Commissary Cash Returns and the J-51 Tax Abatement Extension City Council · September 24, 2026 · 1hr 5m Source: https://hearinghearings.nyc/hearings/city-council-2026-09-24/ Video: https://councilnyc.viebit.com/vod/?s=true&v=NYCC-PV-CH-CHA_260924-134843.mp4 ================================================================ (00:00:48) A moment... Could I have your attention, please. At this time, please place all electronic devices to vibrate. 1. Roll Call (00:00:58) Majority Leader's remarks. Good afternoon and welcome to the Stated Meeting of September 24, 2026. I am Majority Leader Shaun Abreu. I would like to thank you for joining us. As a reminder, the Council must be respected at all times. If you would like to follow along, the agenda for today's meeting is posted on our website. On behalf of the body, I welcome the members of the public who have joined us today. During the Stated Meeting, all members of the Council may speak. Members of the public shall remain silent. If you wish to express your support of any remarks, you may make the silent approval gesture. Thank you. Please join us for the Pledge of Allegiance. Roll call will be held after. (00:02:03) Ariola, present. Avilés. Banks, present. Brewer. Brooks-Powers, present. Come on. De La Rosa, here. Dinowitz, here. Encarnación, present. Epstein, present. Farías, present. Felder, here. Feliz, here, present. Gennaro. Gutiérrez. Hanif. Hankerson. Hanks, present. Present. Joseph. Krishnan, here. Lee, present. Louis, present. Maloney, present. Marte, present. Mealy. Morano, here. Narcisse, here. Nurse, here. Ossé. Paladino, here. Restler. Riley, present. Salaam, present. Justin Sanchez, here. Pierina Sanchez, present. Santosuosso, here. Schulman, here. Stevens, here. Thomas-Henry, present. Ung, present. Vernikov, here. Won, present. Wilson, present. Wong, present. Zhuang, here. Carr, present. Abreu, present. 2. Invocation (00:05:05) Speaker Menin, here. Thank you. We will now have today's invocation, which will be delivered by Rabbi Steven Exter of Bayti Hebrew Institute of Riverdale, which is located at 3700 Henry Hudson Parkway in the Bronx. (00:05:31) I rise as a constituent, friend and admirer of Council Member Eric Dinowitz. My deepest thanks. Let us pray. Blessed are you, God, who bestows your spirit upon all flesh. Bring your blessing upon the elected legislators of this body, the City Council of the great City of New York, upon its Speaker and Deputy Speaker, Leader and all members. Grant our legislators the wisdom, strength and moral force to faithfully represent their constituents and to hear their own inner voices, so that they might make laws that are fair and just for all citizens, enshrining their freedoms and promoting their health, well-being and flourishing as children of the Creator of us all. Grant our legislators the sacred chutzpah to reach across the aisle and forge compromises for the greater good, for what unites us is truly greater than what divides us. 25 years after the most hateful acts our city has known, and just two days before the Jewish holiday of Sukkot, the Feast of Booths, in which Jewish tradition understands that the ultimate sukkah, the ultimate dwelling, is the Sukkah Shalom, the canopy of peace, we ask you, God, to guide our City's Council Members in making this city, New York City, a canopy of peace and welcome for all its inhabitants, living free of prejudice and fear, a model city for all cities, of civil discourse and civic friendship, of righteousness and justice, of love and loving kindness, a city of peace. (00:07:50) Let us say amen. Thank you, Rabbi Exter. I will now ask CM Dinowitz to spread the invocation on the record. (00:08:04) Thank you, Majority Leader. Rabbi Steven Exter serves as Senior Rabbi at Bayti Hebrew Institute of Riverdale, a large Orthodox synagogue in the Bronx known for inclusivity, welcome and community building for people of all backgrounds. It is very easy for anyone in a large congregation to feel lost, maybe not feel at home. When the Senior Rabbi of the institution greets everyone with a warm embrace, both figurative and literal, it means that everyone has a home in Bayti. He is leading one of the most incredible congregations, I think, in our entire city. It is felt in the air every time I go to services there, every time I bring my children there. His ordination is from Yeshivat Chovevei Torah Rabbinical School and he has been a Bronx resident for 23 years. He is proud to call himself a New Yorker and I am proud to call him a constituent, a constituent that I call on often to guide me in Jewish matters, both large and small. Even the tiniest of rabbinical questions, I know I can call him at any time. I want to thank him today for teaching us all a new term: sacred chutzpah. Something I had never heard before. I make a motion for unanimous consent to spread the invocation in full upon the record. Thank you. 3. Adoption of Minutes (00:09:45) CM Dinowitz, we will now ask CM Amanda Farías for the adoption of minutes. (00:09:49) I make a motion that the minutes of the Stated Meeting of September 10, 2026 be adopted as printed. 4. Messages & Papers from the Mayor 5. Communications from City, County & Borough 6. Petitions and Communications 7. Land Use Call-Ups 8. Communication from the Speaker (00:09:57) Messages and papers from the Mayor: none. Communication from City, County and Borough offices: none. Petitions and communications: none. Land use call-ups: none. Thank you. We will now have communication from Speaker Julie Menin. (00:10:14) Good afternoon, everyone. On Tuesday, the Council hosted Climate Week NYC, where more than 100,000 people from around the world came together to advance solutions for a more sustainable and safer future. As activists sound alarms of despair, it is up to us as government officials to respond with action and play a leading part in the fight against climate change. Back in the City, the Council passed a law to increase water quality testing and created an advisory board to develop a wildlife management plan. In this year's budget we allocated funding to support Cornell Tech and launch the Generative Canopy Project, investing a quarter of a million dollars to protect New Yorkers from extreme heat and bring environmental justice to the streets that we walk. In particular, this project is going to focus on areas that need it most, and the first ones are Hunts Point and Longwood in CM Sanchez's district, East New York and parts of CM Banks and Nurse's districts, Corona and Elmhurst in parts of CM Thomas-Henry and Krishnan's districts. The initiative is going to map the location of each tree in the five boroughs as well as the cooling effect that they have, which will inform where it is most effective to plant trees. These efforts serve as just one example of the many ways that we are working on building a safer and healthier city. As part of the budget we passed, the Council secured the largest expansion of the Fair Fares program in its history, so that residents earning up to 200% of the federal poverty line will soon qualify for half-price transit discounts on the bus, on the subway and on paratransit. This expansion now means that nearly one million New Yorkers can focus on where they are going and not if they can afford to get there. While this was a major victory for transit affordability and something that the Council truly prioritized, we still recognize that there are unnecessary barriers to enrolling in the program. As I said during our Fair Fares oversight hearing, a 40% enrollment rate is a failing grade, especially for such a vital program. So among the bills that we are voting on today, one by CM Crystal Hudson will mandate a streamlined process to enroll in Fair Fares. This effort is even more important given that 340,000 additional New Yorkers are now eligible due to the expansion that the Council pushed for in the budget. Another bill, introduced by CM Pierina Sanchez, will extend the 5-1 tax abatement for certain co-ops, condos and rental buildings, benefiting up to 300,000 of them. This legislation will make it easier to preserve and retrofit our city's stock of aging buildings at a time when the cost of housing has truly skyrocketed, making it more affordable to complete repairs without shifting the (00:13:32) burden onto tenants. Speaking of affordability, the Council also had a very significant announcement yesterday. I was so thrilled that so many colleagues were able to join. We announced that we allocated more than $25 million to Bellevue Hospital to modernize and expand their adult psychiatric department. Our funding is going to add approximately 40 inpatient beds, helping the hospital (00:13:59) Yes. Thank you, CM Maloney, for leading the cheering on. This is a very important project. Helping the hospital fulfill its function as a primary psychiatric institution for lower Manhattan, it is truly unparalleled in the city. Last year alone, Bellevue treated more than 11,000 adult psychiatric emergency patients, with that unit operating at 98% occupancy. No New Yorkers should be forced to linger in pain during the most vulnerable moments, let alone in a crowded emergency room. They should be met with immediate care, and that is what this investment will help ensure. On the subject of health, Sunday was National Opioid Awareness Day and September 29 is World Heart Day. 80% of premature cardiovascular deaths can be prevented by mitigating key risk factors, so talk to your doctor and check out the World Heart Federation website to learn more. Switching gears, we have some special observers with us here today. On your way in this morning, you may have noticed student art adorning the perimeter. This was all due to six student artists, so I would like to thank the New York City Arts in Education Roundtable for setting this up. We also have brothers from Iota Phi Theta here. On September 19, 1963, at Morgan State College, 12 men formed the fraternity based on the values of scholarship, leadership, citizenship, fidelity and brotherhood. Since then, the organization has grown to over 300 chapters and has initiated over 75,000 members, making it one of the nation's largest predominantly African American social service fraternities. You are our future and we hope that you will pursue public service beyond college, so thank you so much for being here. We also have some celebrations. Happy birthday to CM Farah Louis, who celebrates tomorrow, and CM Chris Banks, who will celebrate his birthday on the thirtieth. And lastly, Sukkot starts at sundown tomorrow. For seven days, Jewish people across the world eat, relax and recite blessings in their sukkahs. It is a joyous holiday celebrating the harvest time, and I want to wish all Jewish New Yorkers observing Sukkot a chag sameach. Now we are going to move on to our Stated agenda. First, we are going to vote on the following land use items. 815 Hutchinson River Parkway Rezoning will facilitate the conversion of portions of an existing commercial shopping center for retail uses that are not permitted under the current zoning, in CM Shirley Aldebol's district. 862-868 Kent Avenue Rezoning will facilitate the development of two residential buildings with 75 residential units, 18 of which will be income-restricted, pursuant to mandatory inclusionary housing, and community facilities space to include a synagogue, in CM Lincoln Restler's district. The Council will disapprove an application by Cali Tajadas Bakery & Restaurant for a revocable consent to operate a sidewalk cafe. A bill sponsored by CM Sandy Nurse would lift certain building setback restrictions along portions of Eastern Parkway between Rockaway Avenue and Bushwick Avenue. Next, we are going to vote on the following Finance items: a transparency resolution approving new designations and changes of certain organizations receiving funding in the Expense Budget. Today we will also vote on the following pieces of legislation. Res 0184-2026, sponsored by CM Amanda Farías, would declare October 3 as Korean Cultural Awareness Day annually in the City of New York, to commemorate the mythic beginning of the Korean people and to celebrate their continued pride in their shared ancestry. Res 0606-2026, sponsored by CM Althea Stevens, would declare the month of June as Black Pride Month in the City of New York, recognizing the legacy of NYC Black Pride's movement of uplifting the Black LGBTQ+ community and its continuing contributions to creating a more equitable New York City. Res 0607-2026, also sponsored by CM Althea Stevens, would declare the month of May as African Immigrant Heritage Month in the City of New York, to celebrate the contributions made by African immigrants to New York City and to the United States. Thank you. To return to introductions, Res 0142-2026-A, sponsored by CM Kevin Riley, would call on the New York State Legislature to pass and the Governor to sign legislation to establish a Center for Fatherhood Initiatives under the Office of Children and Family Services. Thank you to the staff and sponsors. (00:19:12) Int 1015-2026-A, sponsored by CM Pierina Sanchez, would extend the 5-1 tax abatements for certain alterations or improvements to covered residential buildings, including certain rental buildings, co-ops and condos. The program would now include projects completed on or after June 30, 2026 and before June 30, 2036. Thank you to the staff and sponsors. (00:19:44) Int 0246-2026-A, sponsored by CM Crystal Hudson, would require the Department of Correction to inform persons in custody how much money remains in their commissary account and return all unused commissary funds in cash prior to an individual leaving the Department's custody. Int 0248-2026-A, also sponsored by CM Crystal Hudson, would require the Commissioner of Social Services to create a streamlined process for eligible individuals to enroll in Fair Fares. Thank you to the staff and sponsors, and thank you for your attention to that. I am now going to turn it back over to the Majority Leader. 9. Discussion of General Orders 33. Coupled on General Orders 12. General Orders Calendar 16. General Discussion (00:20:26) Thank you, Speaker Menin. We will now move into discussion of General Orders, beginning with CM Pierina Ana Sanchez and CM Crystal Hudson. (00:20:36) Thank you, Majority Leader, and thank you, Speaker. We are facing a housing crisis and a climate crisis at the same time, and our aging buildings are at the center of both. These buildings are among our largest sources of greenhouse gas emissions even as they break down around us. Elevators are failing, stranding seniors and people with disabilities. Roofs, boilers, electrical systems and other critical infrastructure need investment. In the Bronx and Queens, we are living the deadly consequences of aging housing and fire hazards. While government has a responsibility to set high standards for owners to keep buildings safe, protect tenants and reduce emissions, we must also help owners make the investments that are being asked of them. The 5-1 program is one of the City's key financial tools to do just that, with $212.7 million spent in New York City in 2026. This program helps building owners keep up with the cost of necessary preservation work and upgrades, including installing energy efficient systems so buildings can comply with Local Law 97. Earlier this year, the State authorized the City to extend 5-1 with three key changes. First, a 10-year program: this one will go through June 2036. Second, building owners will now be able to recover up to 100% of the reasonable cost of rehabilitation, up from 70% in the past. And finally, co-ops and condos will see a raised assessed valuation cap from $45,000 per unit to $60,000 per unit, which may sound unusual to the average person, but remember, these are Department of Finance assessed values. These changes together bring the program's ability to expand and reach 300,000 co-ops and condos citywide. 5-1 maintains previous accountability mechanisms and (00:22:20) adds new, comprehensive reporting on how it is being used so we can continue to improve the program. I want to thank the Green Co-op Council, State Senator Brian Kavanagh and Assembly Member Edward Braunstein for their leadership on this, along with the State, and of course the Housing and Buildings Committee staff and my staff. I want to thank Dylan Campos, our incredible fellow, for all of his work on this and everything this past year. (00:22:44) Thank you. Thank you. (00:22:45) CM Hudson, thank you so much. Good afternoon. I would like to speak briefly on two of my bills that we are voting on today, Int 0246-2026-A and Int 0248-2026-A. Since entering office I have advocated for policies that make it easier for New Yorkers to access the benefits and services they deserve. I got into public service to make government more accessible for more people. Antiquated systems and unnecessary red tape make it nearly impossible for New Yorkers to reach benefits they are entitled to, and that breeds distrust in government. Both of today's bills are about the same basic idea: government should return to people what is already theirs, without an onerous process to obtain it. Int 0248-2026-A bridges that gap. It creates a streamlined enrollment process for Fair Fares that allows the City to immediately enroll individuals, with their consent, into Fair Fares if they are also applying for SNAP or cash assistance. Int 0246-2026-A also works to put cash into the pockets of New Yorkers by requiring the Department of Correction to tell every person in City jails exactly how much is in their account and directs the agency to return those funds via cash, check or preloaded debit card before the individual leaves custody. Together, these bills send one message: whether it is benefits owed to a family or money owed to someone leaving custody, as government we owe it to our constituents to ensure they get the money and benefits they are entitled to. I want to thank the advocates who have pushed for these reforms for years, including the Riders Alliance, the Permanent Citizens Advisory Committee, the Legal Aid Society and Freedom Agenda, as well as the teams at the Council's Committee staff and my team who helped get these bills across the finish line. Thank you. 10. Reports of Special Committees (00:24:20) Thank you, CM Hudson. Seeing no one else signed up, going twice. Report of Special Committees. 11. Reports of Standing Committees (00:24:32) COMMITTEES, NONE. REPORTS OF STANDING COMMITTEES. REPORTED THE COMMITTEE ON CRIMINAL JUSTICE: Int 0246-2026-A, a commissary accounts amended in a couple of orders. REPORTED THE COMMITTEE ON FINANCE: Preconsidered Res 0652-2026, organization funding. CAPITAL IN GENERAL ORDERS. REPORTED THE COMMITTEE ON GENERAL WELFARE: Int 0248-2026-A, Fair Fares program, amended in capital in general orders. REPORTED THE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND BUILDINGS: Int 1015-2026-A, tax abatements, amended in capital in general orders. REPORTED THE COMMITTEE ON LAND USE: Int 0833-2026-A, Eastern Parkway restrictions, amended in a couple of general orders. LU 0120-2026 and Res 0659-2026, 815 Hutchinson River Parkway Rezoning, capital in general orders. LU 0121-2026 and Res 0660-2026, and LU 0122-2026 and Res 0661-2026, 862-868 Kent Avenue, coupled. LU 0123-2026, various applications, approved the modifications and referred to the City Planning Commission pursuant to Section 197 of the New York City Charter. LU 0141-2026 and Res 0662-2026, Cali Tajadas Bakery & Restaurant, motion to disapprove. I would now ask the Clerk to take a roll call vote on all of the items on general orders. (00:25:48) Calendar. Ariola, vote aye. (00:25:56) Thank you. Brewer? Yes. (00:26:05) Brooks-Powers, permission to explain vote. Permission granted. I just wanted to take a moment to congratulate my colleague CM Hudson on two very important bills: one would make the Fair Fares program, streamlining that access for New Yorkers, which is critical, and then also ensuring those coming out of custody are able to receive their funds more timely. With that, I vote aye on all. (00:26:34) De La Rosa. Aye. (00:26:38) With permission to explain a vote. Permission granted. I just want to highlight that in today's transparency resolution we are funding, for the first time ever, a Journalism for All — a brand new initiative entitled Journalism for All. Journalism in and of itself is one of the most incredible things that we can provide for the education of our students. But as we transition to the Portrait of a Graduate, it is more clear than ever we need to make sure we are doing what we can to invest in the types of rigorous education that ask students to be introspective and reflective, get multiple perspectives on an issue. We in the City Council are doing that with our transparency resolution today. So I want to thank, also publicly, the Journalism for All coalition for all of their work over the past few years on this initiative, and I vote aye on all. Thank you, Brooks-Powers. (00:27:30) For disclosure. I am sorry about that. I just wanted to disclose that we are making some changes with the Department of Education and my family is associated with that entity. Thank you. Encarnación. (00:27:49) Aye. (00:27:49) Epstein, aye on all. (00:27:55) Farías, aye. Felder. Feliz, aye. (00:28:00) Gennaro, aye. CM Gennaro. Gutiérrez. Hanif, aye. (00:28:11) Hankerson, aye. (00:28:19) Hudson. Joseph. Krishnan. Lee, aye. Louis, aye. (00:28:31) Maloney. I vote aye on all. (00:28:33) Marte. Aye. (00:28:40) Morano. I would like to disclose that the transparency resolution we are voting on funds the Department of Education and my son, who just started kindergarten, is associated with that entity. With that, I will vote aye on all. (00:29:02) Nurse. Paladino, aye on all. Perez. (00:29:05) On Res 0606, I vote no. Counselor, I apologize. I am sorry — on Res 0606. Thank you. (00:29:25) Restler, aye. Riley, aye. (00:29:29) I just want to state for the transparency resolution that my children are scholars in the New York City public school system. Salaam. (00:29:41) I disclose for the record that my family is associated with the NAACP, and I vote aye. (00:29:47) Justin Sanchez, aye. (00:29:50) Pierina Sanchez. I would like to disclose on the record that my sibling is associated with CUNY, and I vote aye on all. (00:29:58) Santosuosso, aye. Schulman, aye. Stevens. (00:30:08) Thomas-Henry, aye on all. (00:30:13) Ung, aye on all. (00:30:18) Williams. Wilson, aye. (00:30:22) I would like to put on the record that my child is a student at a New York City public school. Won, aye. (00:30:31) I vote yes on all. Wong, aye. I want to put on the record that my kids go to public school. (00:30:41) Thank you. (00:30:41) Carr. I would like to disclose on the record that in the transparency resolution that we are voting on today, the Jewish Community Center of Staten Island is funded and I am associated with that entity. I vote aye on all. (00:30:53) Abreu, I vote aye. Thank you. (00:31:02) CM Louis. (00:31:02) I would like to disclose for the record that my brother works for and I am associated with the Parks Department. Thank you. (00:31:08) Speaker. (00:31:09) Menin. I want to disclose on the record that my daughter participates in a program at Asphalt Green, and I vote aye on all items on today's agenda. Zero in the negative and zero abstentions. All right. 13. Introduction & Reading of Bills (00:31:36) Introduction and reading of bills. All those have been referred to committee as indicated on today's agenda. 14. Discussion of Resolutions 15. Resolutions (00:31:42) Thank you. We will now move into the discussion of resolutions, beginning with CM Farías, followed by Riley, then Stevens. Thank you. (00:31:49) I am proud to be passing my resolution declaring October 3 as Korean Cultural Awareness Day annually in New York City. October 3 marks Korea's National Foundation Day, meaning "opening of heaven." It honors a founding story passed down through generations and remains a day of shared ancestry and cultural pride. Nearly 90,000 Korean and Korean American New Yorkers live across our City, and I have consistently championed culturally responsive (00:32:16) legislation because the history and traditions of the communities that shape New York deserve recognition here in the Council. This resolution gives us an annual opportunity to celebrate Korean heritage and help more New Yorkers understand why October 3 is so meaningful. Thank you to the Deputy Speaker, Cultural Affairs Committee Chair Dr. Nantasha Williams, members Julie Won and Linda Lee, and my colleagues who supported and co-sponsored this resolution. CM Riley, followed by Stevens. Thank you. (00:32:46) As a father of three, this is deeply personal to me and I know the responsibility that comes with being present, being engaged and showing up for our children every single day. But we also know that too many fathers face barriers that can make fulfilling that responsibility harder, particularly young and new fathers, non-custodial fathers and fathers navigating re-entry. That is why I am proud to bring Res 0142-2026-A before the Council today. This resolution supports the establishment of a state Center for Fatherhood Initiatives, creating a robust framework to provide fathers with the resources, support networks and parenting education they need to strengthen their parenting knowledge, attitudes and self-efficacy. Because when we give fathers the tools to succeed, the impact reaches far beyond the individual — we strengthen our children, our families and our communities. I want to thank Senator Bailey and Assembly Member Days for championing this legislation in Albany, and my Council colleagues who have joined me in co-sponsoring this resolution today. I proudly urge my colleagues to vote yes, and I urge our partners to advance this legislation and the Governor to sign it into law. Fatherhood matters, showing up matters, and every father who wants to be there for their child deserves support to do so. Thank you. CM Stevens. (00:33:59) Good afternoon. Thank you, Speaker Menin, Deputy Speaker Williams, the Chair of the Cultural Affairs Committee and all my colleagues for supporting and recognizing these resolutions. It is about honoring our history, culture and the people who have helped shape New York City. First, I am proud to speak in support of Res 0606, declaring June as Black Pride Month in the City of New York. This history continues to have a strong Bronx connection. Lee Sargent, a Bronx native, later founded the Center for Black Pride, which continued organizing Black Pride celebrations. We are recognizing a movement in our community that has helped expand what inclusion, visibility and belonging looks like. This year we had a Black Pride celebration in the Bronx — our borough's own Pride celebration. This was a powerful reminder that the borough is not only a place that is a part of this history but continues to shape it. I would like to give a special shout out to my staff member and Michael Ivory from the Borough President's office and Destination Tomorrow, who worked really hard to make sure that this resolution came to fruition. I am also so proud to speak in support of Res 0607, declaring African Immigrant Heritage Month. I also want to give a special shout out to the Bronx Borough President's African Advisory Council, who helped advance this legislation. Thank you. (00:35:15) Thank you, CM. Since no one else signed up for resolutions being voted on today, we will now have a voice vote on today's resolutions. If you wish to vote against or abstain from any of today's resolutions, please notify the Legislative Documents Unit by email or by approaching the dais. (00:35:32) I will now read today's resolutions into the record. Res 0142-2026-A calls on the New York State Legislature to pass and the Governor to sign legislation to establish the Center for Fatherhood Initiatives under the Office of Children and Family Services. All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. Any abstentions. The ayes have it. Res 0184-2026 declares October 3 as Korean Cultural Awareness Day annually in the City of New York to commemorate the mythological beginning of the Korean people and to celebrate their continued pride in their shared ancestry. All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. Any abstentions. The ayes have it. Res 0606-2026 declares the month of June as Black Pride Month in the City of New York, recognizing the legacy of the NYC Black Pride movement, uplifting the Black LGBTQIA+ community and its continuing contributions to creating a more equitable New York City. (00:36:37) All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. Any abstentions. The ayes have it. Res 0607-2026 declares African Immigrant Heritage Month in the City of New York to celebrate the contributions made by African immigrants to New York City and the United States. All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. Any abstentions. We will now move into general discussion. Reminder: you have two minutes and we have 15 folks signed up, so (00:37:08) far. CM Hanif, followed by Schulman. Thank you, Majority Leader. This morning I joined Council colleagues, state legislators, future members of Congress, including Brad Hoylman-Sigal, Chris Rob and hundreds of New Yorkers in an act of civil disobedience to reject Prime Minister Netanyahu's visit to our City and appearance before the UN. Together we called for an end to U.S. arms shipments to Israel and an end to the genocide of the Palestinian people. We cannot allow business as usual during a genocide. Millions of people are being displaced and killed across the region. Our Federal Government has the power to stop it. This is a local issue too — our constituents are being told there is not enough money for food assistance, health care, schools or housing, yet there is always money for more bombs. Those are choices and New Yorkers are living with the consequences. We will not be silent while the Trump administration cuts lifelines at home and funds devastation abroad. New Yorkers are done paying for endless war. It is time to block the bombs, divest from genocide and endless wars, and invest in life. Thank you. (00:38:23) CM Schulman, followed by Thomas-Henry. (00:38:26) Thank you, Majority Leader. Our City's ability to help prevent outbreaks of Legionnaires' disease before they occur — this summer New York City experienced two devastating clusters of Legionnaires' disease, reminding us of the serious health risks that Legionella poses to New Yorkers. Currently, buildings are only required to report Legionella test results to the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene when levels reach at least 1,000 colony-forming units per milliliter. But by the time that level is reached, an outbreak may already be imminent. This legislation would lower the reporting threshold to 10 colony-forming units per milliliter. This would give the Department earlier notice of elevated Legionella levels, allowing the City to take action before conditions become dangerous. The testing level proposed in my legislation is a critical regulatory threshold across Canada. In fact, 10 bacteria per milliliter is the standard action level there. If a facility's cooling tower tests above 10 bacteria per milliliter, it triggers mandatory immediate decontamination and hyperchlorination protocols. This method has proven to be an effective preventive early warning line of defense. We should not wait until levels reach a point where an outbreak is imminent before the City has the information it needs to act. By requiring this new threshold, we can give the Department a better opportunity to identify potential risks more quickly and intervene before people get sick. This legislation is about prevention and protecting the health of New Yorkers. After this year's outbreaks, we have an opportunity to learn from what happened and take steps to prevent the next one. I also want to thank the Speaker for her leadership, because we have had more (00:40:09) legislation on Legionella this year than at any other time. So thank you. Thank you, CM (00:40:15) Schulman. CM Thomas-Henry, followed by Banks. Thank (00:40:18) you, Majority Leader. We can all agree this summer 2026 will go down in history. At the heart of it was New York welcoming the world. We opened our City, supported public safety and transportation, hosted watch parties and invested nearly $90 million to make sure that the biggest sporting event in the world could have a home here in New York. But hosting an event of this magnitude cannot simply be about what New York gives. What my colleagues and I have been shouting from the rooftops is: how would an event of this magnitude benefit New Yorkers? FIFA reportedly committed to providing host cities with a million-dollar legacy contribution to support soccer pitches and other community projects. That is $1 million invested directly back into our communities. That is a goal we hope all private partners will commit to. But now, with an estimated $15 billion in FIFA revenue, we have to act. What happened to the million dollars? That money should have translated to the young person in Corona who deserves a safe field to play on. That money could have translated to park preservation, where so many of our families celebrated this tournament together. And of course it must translate to the small businesses and neighborhoods who preserve the culture and vibrancy of our corridors. My Res 0655-2026 is simple: FIFA must honor its commitment and deliver the million-dollar legacy contribution promised to New York City. I urge my colleagues to support this resolution. And last but not least, happy birthday Parker — Mommy loves you. (00:41:50) CM Banks, followed by Farías. Thank you, (00:41:53) Majority Leader, and thank you, Speaker, for your leadership today. I am introducing Int 1072-2026, which will expand the outreach of the Disability Rent Increase Exemption, or DRIE program, and the Senior Citizen Rent Increase Exemption, better known as SCRIE. This legislation will expand the City's existing requirements for sharing information about SCRIE to include DRIE, and add the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities as a participating agency. It would also require the Department of Finance to provide annual training to designated staff in participating City agencies on eligibility requirements, application and renewal procedures, reasonable accommodations, program benefits and applicant referrals. Additionally, the Department of Finance would be required to report annually to the Council on these trainings and their outcomes. We are in the middle of an affordability crisis and hear about its effects on every corner of our City, and it is our duty to do everything possible to protect New Yorkers who are especially vulnerable to rising housing costs. That includes our seniors, many of whom are retired and living on fixed incomes, as well as people with disabilities and disabled veterans. SCRIE and DRIE provide meaningful relief by freezing the rent of eligible New Yorkers, helping them remain in their homes and communities. These programs can only help if people know the assistance exists and understand how to access it. No eligible New Yorker should miss out on these critical benefits simply because they never received the right information or guidance. By strengthening the outreach and improving agency staff training and increasing accountability, this Bill will help connect more eligible New Yorkers with the assistance they need to remain safely and affordably in their homes. Thank you. (00:43:54) Thank you, CM. Farías, followed by Wilson. Thank you. (00:43:57) Today I am introducing four bills that I would like members to consider supporting. The first, Res 0647-2026, would establish Consent Awareness Week during the third week of October. Consent affects how we respect one another's autonomy and boundaries, and education gives us a chance to build that understanding before someone is harmed. Secondly, Res 0648-2026 calls on the State Legislature to pass S.5521/A.1140. Consent is referenced throughout New York State's laws governing sexual offenses, but the Penal Law does not affirmatively define it. This legislation would establish a clear standard: a freely given, knowledgeable and informed agreement by someone with the capacity to reason. The two resolutions work together, one advancing public education and the other calling for clarity in the State law. I am also introducing Int 1079-2026 concerning the survivor hotline operated by the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence. It would require reporting on calls received and answered, wait times, interpretation needs and referrals, among other measures. If people are waiting too long or leaving before they can access services, the City and this Council should be able to see that and be able to respond. Finally, Res 0646-2026 would declare May as Hindu American Awareness and Appreciation Month in New York City. This request came directly from constituents. Hindu Americans come from many backgrounds, including communities like those in my district, and have contributed to our City's businesses, institutions and cultural life. I look forward to working with my colleagues to advance all of these bills. (00:45:40) Thank you, CM Wilson, followed by Morano. (00:45:44) Thank you, Majority Leader. One third of New York City households have a pet, yet most New Yorkers cannot afford even a basic veterinary wellness visit. Veterinary prices have increased by 60% over the past decade, driven by the consolidation of the veterinary industry as private equity firms and large corporations purchase independent practices. Today, 50% of veterinary practices and 75% of emergency animal hospitals are owned by large corporations, and pet owners are often unaware that a seemingly independent neighborhood practice is part of a larger chain. Pets are family, but rising costs have unfairly rendered pet care a luxury good. Tragically, some families face financial euthanasia, which is having to euthanize an animal because of a treatable condition they cannot afford the necessary treatment for. My new bill, the Pricing Equity and Transparency, or PET Act, would require veterinary practices to clearly disclose and display standard charges and price ranges for commonly offered services. The PET Act will also require practices to provide written or electronic estimates for certain higher-cost services upon request and provide itemized receipts. Additionally, the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection would establish and maintain a publicly accessible website to display average prices for common veterinary procedures. The PET Act will allow pet owners to compare prices, evaluate treatment options, anticipate expenses and make more informed decisions about both their animal's care and the type of businesses they wish to support. By making it easier to shop around for veterinary services, the proposal would expand consumer choice, promote accountability and fair competition, promote more trusting relationships between vets and their clients, and help more New Yorkers access essential, preventative and life-saving care. Thank you to the legislative division for their work on this, and I am looking forward to working with my colleagues to pass this. Thanks so much. (00:47:40) CM Morano, followed by Brewer. Thank you, Majority (00:47:43) Leader. 25 years ago, after the worst day in our City's history, New York made a promise that we will never forget. But "never forget" has to be more than two words that we say every year. That is why today one of the bills I am introducing is Int 1089-2026, to create an office of assistance for 9/11 first responders and survivors. Because here is the absurd reality: a firefighter, a police officer, a construction worker, a volunteer, a downtown resident or survivor can spend years dealing with the consequences of September 11 and then have to become an expert in government bureaucracy just to figure out where to turn for help. They survived September 11. They should not have to survive the paperwork too. This office would give first responders and survivors a dedicated place in City government to help them navigate available services, benefits and assistance. We are now a quarter century removed from September 11. The ceremonies will become fewer, the memorials will become less frequent, but for thousands of New Yorkers the consequences are not history. They are living them right now. They wake up with them every morning. So if we really mean "never forget," let us put those words into law. Let us make sure that when the people who were there for their City when their City was in need — let us make sure their City is there for them. That is why I hope my colleagues will join me in cosponsoring Int 1089-2026. Thank you. (00:49:16) CM Brewer, followed by Sanchez. (00:49:17) Thank you very much. Int 1073-2026 is what I am calling the Supplemental Tree Planting bill. We all want more trees in the ground. The administration announced this week that the City planted 18,261 trees in 2026. That is a lot. We want to build on the progress. The City's urban forest plan says we need 30% tree canopy by 2040, up from 23% today. That means we need more trees. The Parks Neighborhood Tree Planting Program prioritizes neighborhoods with the greatest heat vulnerability. I support that approach, but under the new nine-year rotation some neighborhoods like mine could wait nine years before we get a new tree. We need to fill the gap during those nine years. That is what I am seeking to do. Council members have allocated capital funding for additional tree planting in their districts. I can do the same, and I have already allocated half a million dollars in capital funding for trees. But under the plan, Parks no longer accepts Council funding or requests for new trees, eliminating a way to plant trees. So I wrote to Parks, and many colleagues signed the letter asking the agency to continue accepting Council funding and requests for trees. Parks did not make that change, and that is why we have Int 1073-2026. It restores a supplemental pathway without changing the neighborhood-based program. We can identify additional locations, plant at a deliberate speed, and we can plant a tree. This is additional money for additional trees. Parks can continue prioritizing neighborhoods with the greatest need while Council dollars can plant a tree in other locations. We all have to work together for the tree canopy and we need every dollar. Thank you to Crystal Tory, Senior Legislative Counsel, for drafting this bill, and my Chief of Staff Shula Pooter. Let us make sure that the Neighborhood Tree Planting Program is not the only program for planting a tree. Thank you, Council members. (00:51:28) Sanchez, followed by (00:51:31) Joann. Thank you, Majority Leader. I want to speak about a meaningful bill, Int 1058-2026. Businesses across the City are struggling, including many historic institutions that bring untold value to our City. Despite that, our current commercial eviction laws often favor commercial landlords and often force beloved community institutions to close without ever seeing a judge. Currently, a commercial landlord can sue to evict a commercial tenant, and if they win in court they can be reimbursed for their legal fees by the business in question. But in many of these contracts the same is not true for the tenant. Even if they successfully fight off an eviction, a business often cannot recover the legal fees they have accrued in the process. The result is that landlords can pressure tenants to self-evict without ever having their day in court. This bill simply aims to level the playing field by creating a provision wherein a commercial tenant can recover legal fees from a commercial landlord. It is a common sense bill which aims to give these tenants a chance when they are faced with eviction, and it is a much-needed tool to keep these institutions open for years to come. I ask my colleagues to join me in supporting Int 1058-2026. Thank you so much. (00:52:51) CM Wong, followed by Hankerson. Thank you, (00:52:55) colleagues. Today I want to recognize the Mid-Autumn Festival, a holiday that means so much to me personally. I came to America as an immigrant when I was 20 years old, leaving behind my family, my home, everything I knew. I know what it feels like to miss people you love and to be far away from your home. For generations, Chinese families have looked up at the moon during the holidays and remembered the people they love. We also burn incense and offerings to our ancestors. We share the mooncake because the circle represents family reunion and togetherness. I want to thank CM Phil Wong, who brought a lot of mooncakes today. If my colleagues have not tried them, you should try them, but do not eat too much. New York City is very diverse, and our differences are what make us strong. Every community brings its own traditions, stories and hopes, and together we make New York City the greatest city in the world. No matter where you travel, I want to wish everyone a Happy Mid-Autumn Festival and a happy moon as well. Please try some. (00:54:11) CM Hankerson, followed by Narcisse. (00:54:12) Thank you, Majority Leader. This year, Climate Week comes with a heightened sense of urgency as the United Nations has officially declared that the world will not meet the goals set by the Paris Climate Accord to cap rising temperatures at 1.5 degrees Celsius compared to pre-industrial levels. That is precisely why we need to invest even more heavily in reducing New York's carbon emissions and making our City more climate resilient. As Parks Chair, I see investing in our trees, parks and various green spaces as one critical way that our City addresses a changing climate. Our 7 million trees are crucial for keeping our City cool against rising heat. During the peak of summer, the temperature under a single tree canopy can be up to 25 degrees cooler than the surrounding street. Trees and parks also play a vital part in helping manage our City's stormwater, something we know all too well in Queens. As sea levels rise and flooding becomes more and more of a risk, our urban forest is a necessary tool for keeping people safe. But the reality is that these green assets are not distributed equally across New York. As our City continues to get hotter year after year, it will lead to lives being lost disproportionately in Black and Brown communities, which can be up to 10 degrees hotter due to a historical lack of foliage and green space. Black New Yorkers already die of heat stress at double the rate of their white counterparts. Without intervention, this number is sure to increase. I believe it is the duty of the Council to be proactive and do everything within its power to mitigate the worst effects of climate change and to do so equitably by building a greener infrastructure. Today we can ensure that a resilient, thriving New York belongs to every single one of us tomorrow. Happy Climate Week. (00:56:03) CM Narcisse, followed by Maloney. (00:56:07) Thank you, Chair, and Madam Speaker, and thank you to the Deputy Speaker for bringing this package together. I am proud to be part of it. Today I am proud to introduce Int 1091-2026 as part of the Council package to protect our City's homeowners. Too often we see New Yorkers losing their homes — the lifeline investment and path to building generational wealth — over small building violations, that spiral into debt that we (00:56:42) cannot control. Uncontrollable debt. It is not right and it is not okay. As we have said, these minor issues can lead to the devastating loss of a family's most valuable asset. My bill takes a crucial step by requiring the Department of Buildings to proactively notify property owners with a violation on their property that could result in a tax lien if left unaddressed. By equipping homeowners with this information early, we can help them take corrective action, connect with resources and prevent a crisis that threatens their home. As the affordability crisis puts homeownership further and further out of reach for too many, this package of legislation demonstrates our commitment to supporting homeowners and preserving this vital pathway to stability and equity — which is the buzzword for so many, but when it comes to Black and Brown communities, we need that equity in New York City. It should be our commitment to keep the dream of homeownership alive for all New Yorkers. Thank you, Madam Speaker. I encourage my colleagues to help me get this passed. Thank you, Council members. (00:58:18) Maloney, followed by Cabán. Thank you, Majority Leader. I am introducing legislation to strengthen sexual assault prevention and response at large public events across New York City. My bill would require events with more than a thousand attendees, or 500 when alcohol is being served, to designate trained personnel and establish clear, trauma-informed protocols to prevent sexual harassment and to have a response when an incident occurs. If you are bringing thousands of people together for a concert, a festival or a parade, you need a plan to keep them safe. I am also proud to cosponsor CM Shanel Thomas-Henry's Res 0655-2026, calling on FIFA to show us the million-dollar promise for hosting the 2026 World Cup. Again, thank you to Speaker Menin and my Council colleagues for funding Bellevue in my district, supporting psychiatric health. And again, welcome to the New York City Arts and Education Roundtable, including Ian, who is a talented artist attending the High School of Art and Design in my district. Thank you. (00:59:33) Thank you, Counselor. CM Cabán. Delivery workers move through our streets in heat waves and storms and intense traffic, and they bring us our meals. They keep our City functioning. Yet when a delivery worker or their family member gets sick or needs to seek shelter from violence, they face an impossible choice: take the time off and be punished by the apps, or keep riding and risk their health and safety. That is not a choice any worker in this City should have to make. I am introducing Int 1074-2026 for flexible safe and sick time, to give contracting delivery workers unpaid time off for their and their family's safety and health without the risk of punishment. This Council has really led the way on protecting delivery workers, whether it is providing for minimum pay, bathroom access or the right to be treated with basic dignity. This bill represents a sensible continuation of that approach and it builds on our previous recognition that no worker should have to choose between a paycheck and their health, when we passed Earned Safe and Sick Time for employees. So I urge all of you to join me as a sponsor. I also want to recognize that several colleagues and I joined over 400 fellow New Yorkers in a Jewish-led civil disobedience, calling on our government to stop arming Israel amid its ongoing genocide in Gaza. We took this action as Prime Minister Netanyahu, a war criminal wanted by the International Criminal Court, speaks at the UN today and is embraced and funded by Trump. It is time for elected officials to listen to the vast majority of Americans who demand that our Federal Government end its support for the Israeli military and fund people, not bombs. Thank you. (01:01:12) CM Louis, followed by Dinowitz. (01:01:16) Thank you, Majority Leader. Today I am introducing two pieces of legislation focused on tenant safety, accountability and advocacy, to make major long-needed improvements to the City's Alternative Enforcement Program, also known as AEP, by expanding its reach and strengthening the consequences for owners who allow distressed buildings to remain in poor condition. Int 1086-2026 would expand the scope of AEP by requiring it to identify at least 400 distressed buildings each year, doubling the current statutory threshold. Importantly, at least 100 of these buildings must be properties that were previously discharged from the program but have once again fallen into distress. My second bill, Int 1085-2026, addresses the other side of the equation, which is accountability. It would increase fees for inspections, monitoring and other actions, establishing minimum fees of $1,000 per dwelling unit for building-wide inspections and monitoring, along with additional fees when violations remain uncorrected. Together, these bills give the City more tools to identify distressed properties, bring more buildings under enhanced oversight and create meaningful financial consequences for owners who fail to correct hazardous housing conditions. I look forward to working with my colleagues, advocates and the administration to advance these much-needed reforms and strengthen the program as a whole. Our tenants deserve nothing less than a City government with the tools and enforcement mechanisms necessary to protect them. I encourage my colleagues to sign on to these bills. Thank you. (01:02:56) Thank you. Our last speaker is CM Dinowitz. (01:02:59) >WITZ. Thank you. I just have to say, after hearing some of the comments about visitors to the country, however you feel about this individual visitors... this word that I keep hearing, "genocide" — this claim of genocide is a claim that was made before Israel even started retaliating against Hamas after October 7, when they murdered and raped over a thousand people. It is just ridiculous to me that before the retaliation there were claims of genocide, and after a ceasefire that same word is being used. The problem is, what does it do? It obscures the actual issues that are going on there, the actual trauma and the actual destruction that is happening in the region. We are unable to have a real conversation and really address actual policy issues because of the demonizing language that existed before there was any military action and after there is a ceasefire in place. The demonization causes real harm and it is very specific to one country. The reason we know this, the reason we say we should stop doing any aid to Israel, is because the very same people saying that out of one side of their mouth, out of the other side say we should never sanction any country, we should never boycott any country, because that will only serve to hurt the citizens and the people who live in that country. But there is a special exception made for Israel, and it is apparently okay to use this demonizing language without evidence before the war begins and after the ceasefire is in place. Thank you. Majority Leader, I will now call on Speaker Julie Menin to close today's stated meeting. Thank you. The stated meeting of September 24, 2026 is...