Meeting of October 22, 2026 City Council · October 22, 2026 · 2hrs 32m Source: https://hearinghearings.nyc/hearings/city-council-2026-10-22/ Video: https://councilnyc.viebit.com/vod/?s=true&v=NYCC-PV-CH-CHA_261022-141329.mp4 ================================================================ (00:00:26) For you, ladies and gentlemen, good afternoon and welcome to Stated Meeting. At this time, please place all electronic devices to vibrate. Majority Leader, it is all yours. Good afternoon and welcome to the Stated Meeting of October 22, 2026. I am CM Shaun Abreu. I would like to thank you for joining us. As a reminder, decorum must be respected at all times. If you would like to follow along, the agenda for today's meeting is posted on our website. On behalf of the body, I welcome the members of the public who have joined us today. At Stated Meetings, only members of the Council speak. Members of the public shall remain silent. If you wish to express your support of any remarks, you may make the silent approval gesture. If there are any outbursts, we reserve the right to remove individuals or to clear the gallery. Thank you very much. Please join us for the Pledge of Allegiance. (00:01:26) I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Aldebol, here. Ariola, present. Avilés, here. Brewer, here. Brooks-Powers, here. De La Rosa, here. Dinowitz, present. Encarnación, present. Epstein, here. Farías, present. Felder, here. Feliz, here. Gennaro, here. Gutiérrez, here. Hanif, here. Hankerson, present. Hanks, here. Hudson, present. Joseph, here. Krishnan, here. Lee, here. Louis, present. Maloney, present. Marte, present. Mealy, here. Morano, here. Narcisse, present. Nurse, present. Ossé, here. Paladino, here. Restler, here. Riley, present. Salaam, present. Justin Sanchez, here. Pierina Sanchez, here. Santosuosso, here. Schulman, here. Stevens, here. Thomas-Henry, present. Ung, present. Vernikov, here. Williams, here. Wilson, present. Won, present. Wong, here. Zhuang, here. Abreu, present. Brooks-Powers, here. Speaker Menin, here. (00:04:59) Thank you. We will now have today's invocation, which will be delivered by Father Khader Khalili of Grace Lutheran Church of Brooklyn, which is located at 939 Third Street in Brooklyn. Please let us pray. (00:05:20) Almighty and merciful God, you created each of us in your image — the people in this chamber, the people watching from home, and even those who will never hear our names but whose lives are shaped by the decisions made here. We thank you for this City. We thank you for the people of the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens and Staten Island. We thank you for its crowded trains, its busy neighborhoods, its hard-working families and a stubborn habit of making room for one more person. In Jesus, you showed us what it means not to be served, but to serve. May that same spirit fill this room today. Bless the members of this Council and all who serve alongside them. Give them wisdom when the answers are unclear and courage when the right choice comes at a cost. Help them listen to one another, especially those with whom they disagree, and lead them to see not the good for a few, but the common good of all. Through the prophet Micah, you have shown us what is good: to do justice, to love kindness and to walk humbly with you. Keep before the minds and hearts of this Council the family struggling to pay the rent, the workers striving to make ends meet, the child who goes to school hungry and the elder living alone. Make them faithful stewards of the trust placed in them and give peace in this nation, peace in our homes and peace in our hearts. We pray these things by different names. I offer this prayer in the name of Jesus Christ, trusting that we stand together in the hope of your mercy and goodness. Amen. (00:07:22) Thank you, Father Khalili. I will now ask CM Kayla Santosuosso to spread the invocation on the record. Thank you, Majority Leader. (00:07:32) Pastor Khader Khalili is a Palestinian American pastor and community leader who has served Grace Lutheran Church of Brooklyn since 2013. He also serves as Director of Arab and Middle Eastern Ministries for the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America and as Dean of the Southwest Brooklyn Lutheran Conference. He studied at Bethlehem Bible College and earned his Master of Divinity from Pacific Lutheran Theological Seminary in Berkeley, California, and was ordained in 2009. Pastor Khalili serves on the board of the Arab American Association of New York and is active in ecumenical and interfaith work. He also leads pilgrimages to the Holy Land and proudly calls Brooklyn home. I want to thank the Pastor for being here today and sharing some beautiful words with us. I now make a motion to spread the invocation in full upon the record. Thank you. (00:08:24) We will now ask CM Sandra Ung for the adoption of minutes. (00:08:29) I make a motion to have the minutes of the Stated Meeting of October 8, 2026 adopted. (00:08:35) Messages and papers from the Mayor: M 0093-2026 through M 0097-2026, Mayoral appointments, referred to the Rules Committee. Communication from City, County and Borough offices: M 0098-2026, Commissioner of Elections appointment, referred to Rules. Petitions and communications: none. Land use call-ups: none. Thank you. We will now have communication from Speaker Julie Menin. (00:08:58) Thank you, Majority Leader. I want to thank everyone for joining us today in the chambers. For 19 years, the City Council has considered a ban on the horse carriage industry. In fact, it was 19 years ago that the first City Council Bill on this issue was actually introduced in these chambers. Today we are converting consideration into action. For 19 years, a solution has been delayed and promises went unfulfilled. Today we plan to deliver on all fronts. For 19 years we have debated the issue without an outcome, all the while a horse-drawn carriage was sadly involved in a tragic death. Today we prevent the next one by passing Roman's Law. In the process, I want to thank Roman's family and ask them to please stand up. We thank you for being here today. We know your unimaginable pain and grief, and we know that by passing this law, it is a lasting legacy in his honor. So we really thank you for being here today. There are many parties to thank for the success of these efforts. We have NAEC, PETA, countless advocates and community leaders. Most importantly, I want to thank our City Council colleagues for the thoughtful, intentional ways that they have gone about proposing, sponsoring, amending and soon voting on this legislation. I want to thank the Bill's sponsor, CM Marte, for all of his hard work on this issue. I want to thank the Health Care Council member for her work — you are getting applause on this issue — and all of the colleagues. I also want to acknowledge and thank those who came before us in the Council for their hard work on this issue. We have with us today former Council Member Bob Holden, who was a major leader in the fight, having first introduced Rider's Law in 2022. Thank you, Bob. And earlier — I do not know if he is still here, but earlier — former Council Member Toni Avella, who introduced that first Bill 19 years ago, was here as well. Roman's Law will do justice to this effort in more ways than one. It sets a June 2028 sunset deadline, which supports the principles of public safety so that Roman is the last soul that we lose to this industry. It is going to ensure that the horses themselves receive humane treatment wherever they go next, requiring certification that the horses will not be transferred for slaughter. But it does — and I want to be clear about this, and this is very important — it allows the horse owners to keep their horses if they choose, because that is very important and we heard powerful testimony at our hearing on that topic. And it is going to support the transition for the more than 150 active horse carriage drivers, helping them (00:12:28) to find new jobs over the next two years, and that is incredibly important. This City Council strengthened the worker protection language because we want to ensure that we are working to make sure that these workers have meaningful, gainful employment. Under the Bill, that includes providing civil service trainings, career counseling, assistance accessing education, and referrals to other employment opportunities. This City Council will work very closely with the administration to ensure that those workers have those jobs, because that is what they deserve. Whether they are medallion owners — which we also want to protect — based in the stables or driving the carriages themselves, these workers all call our City home and they deserve to keep working, growing and thriving in our City. The Bill also requires the administration to consider establishing a compensation program, and the Council is very committed to working with the administration throughout this transition period. Passing this law proves not simply that we are committed to making our City safer and more livable for residents, tourists and animals alike. It proves that we can live up to the commitments that we make. There are other ways that we in the Council are bringing our commitments to fruition as well. So, switching gears: on Saturday, I joined our Deputy Speaker, CM Nantasha Williams, and went to Newark for our first installment of our Homeowner Expo, protecting homes from threats such as predatory loans, deed theft, storm damage and foreclosure. The event was a part of our five and a half million dollar commitment to our new Homeowner Stabilization Services Initiative, which will help residents preserve their homes, and we will be going to every single borough on this tour. On Monday, I was proud to join the Mayor and the Governor to announce that free Pre-K will be available to every school district in the Bronx and Staten Island by the fall of 2027. That expansion means an additional 10,000 children will have a shot at a brighter future and thousands more parents will not have to empty their pockets to pay for child care. On that note, this City Council has passed so many Bills and will continue to do so to make it easier to operate childcare facilities and to cut down on the bureaucracy necessary to open them. We have passed an enormous amount of Bills in that regard and more to come. We are also very proud of the fact that in 2022 this City Council passed the Universal Child Care Act, becoming the first city across the country to set universal child care as a goal. On Tuesday, we had a hearing on the response times of our EMS services. The department is severely underfunded, leading to inadequate staffing that poses deadly consequences. Currently, a New Yorker must wait on average 13 minutes and nine seconds for an ambulance to arrive. 13 minutes and nine seconds. We know that after four minutes is when brain cells start to die if someone is deprived of oxygen. This is completely and wholly unacceptable, so every single minute alone matters. We must pay those who provide a life-saving service a living wage and ensure that New Yorkers in crisis can access the care that they need. On a lighter note, ahead of the opening night for the Knicks, we unveiled a street co-naming of Champion's Plaza in honor of the seven championships won between our home teams, the Knicks and the Rangers. Obviously it did not go New York's way on Tuesday, but today is a different day. The City Council certainly has plenty of victories to celebrate on behalf of New Yorkers. So on that note, today we will be voting on raising the income eligibility limit to $75,000 for the Senior Citizen Rent Increase Exemption, SCRIE, and the Disability Rent Increase Exemption, DRIE, programme. This is a truly meaningful difference from the current cap of $50,000, which it has been since 2019. So thank you to CM Louis for her important work on this very important legislation. This program, which freezes rent for eligible senior citizens and disabled New Yorkers while still giving landlords a tax credit, will provide major relief to those residents, assuring that they can stay in their homes. It is just one of the many initiatives the Council has proposed to make New York City affordable and livable for everyone. Switching gears a little: this month, the Hindu community is celebrating Navratri, Durga Puja and Diwali. These connected festivals honor the triumph of good over evil and the divine feminine. However you celebrated, I hope your observance was joyful and meaningful. It is Filipino American Heritage Month. In October 1587, the first Filipinos arrived in our nation in what is now California. Almost 500 years later, we are proud to have almost 100,000 Filipino Americans who call this City their home, from Little Manila in Woodside to those who work in every industry of our City. It is also Polish American Heritage Month and the month that General Casimir Pulaski died giving his life to the American Revolution, two years after saving George Washington's life. The Polish population in this City has expanded greatly since, and their presence and their contributions are everywhere, from churches in Greenpoint to pierogies in our restaurants, and we are very proud to celebrate that heritage. National Disability Employment Awareness Month is also observed every October to celebrate workers with disabilities and promote inclusive workplace practices. Almost one million people in our City have a disability and hundreds of thousands of them are employed. I am very proud as Speaker that we created the first committee dedicated to this issue. We will continue to ensure that all New Yorkers can work and keep a job. October 28 is National First Responders Day. We will honor the brave people across our five boroughs who protect us: our firefighters, our police officers, our paramedics and 911 dispatchers. Thank you so much for everything you are doing every single day. The Council will continue to fight so that you all can receive the compensation you deserve. October 31 is Halloween, so let me just, on a lighter note, wish everyone a happy Halloween. And November 4 is Election Day, so please make a plan to vote and alert your neighbors, friends and family. I want to give a warm welcome to One Strong Brotherhood, who are here with CM Kevin Riley. These are outstanding men. We want to give them one more round of applause. We are honoring them today for their contributions to Black men, and I am told that you all have quite the Instagram following. Finally, I want to wish a happy birthday to CM Phil Wong, who celebrated yesterday. Happy birthday. And to CM Vickie Paladino, who celebrates on the 28th, and to CM Oswald Feliz, who will celebrate on the 29th. Now we will move on to our Stated Agenda. First, we will vote on the following land use items: 48-50 Convent Avenue cluster, the conversion of partially occupied City-owned rental buildings to 77 affordable homeownership units and two superintendent units under the Affordable Housing Cooperative Program; and in Majority Leader Shaun Abreu's district, to facilitate the development of a nine-story long-term care facility with 300 patient beds; and in CM Simcha Felder's district, 135-27 Sapphire Street Rezoning, which will allow a six-story building with approximately 268 dwelling units, 67 to 80 of which will be affordable, in CM Joann Ariola's district. Next, we will vote on the following finance items: Int 0978-2026-B, also sponsored by CM Farah Louis, would increase the maximum income level for eligibility for SCRIE and DRIE to $75,000 (00:21:50) beginning July 1, 2026. Res 0666-2026-A, sponsored by CM Linda Lee, would set the date, time and place for the hearing of the local law that would increase the annual expenditure for eight Business Improvement Districts. A transparency resolution approving new designations and changes in the designation of certain organizations receiving funding in the Expense Budget, and several preconsidered resolutions sponsored by CM Linda Lee that would grant a partial 40-year tax exemption under Article XI of the Private Housing Finance Law for buildings in the districts of CM Wilson, CM Narcisse, CM Justin Sanchez and Deputy Speaker Williams. Today we will also vote on the following pieces of legislation. Res 0625-2026-B, by CM Farah Louis, would declare Reggaeton Heritage Month in the City of New York to honor its legacy. (00:22:50) Thank you to our staff, Jeanne Nepal. (00:22:53) Res 0650-2026, sponsored by CM Jennifer Gutiérrez, would oppose a federally proposed rule change titled "Reducing Federal Burden for Head Start Programs" and call on the Federal Government to prioritize protecting and growing access to high-quality education for young children. (00:23:11) Thank you to Katie, Selena and Julia Goldsmith Pinkham. (00:23:16) Int 0927-2026-A, sponsored by CM Selvena Brooks-Powers, would rename Shore Front Parkway between Beach 32nd Street and Beach 56th Place to Edgemere Avenue and amend the official City map accordingly. (00:23:30) Thank you to Chris Star, Patrick Mulvihill and Owen Gutowski. Int 0797-2026-A, (00:23:38) sponsored by Public Advocate Mamdani, would require semi-annual reporting on voter registration forms, changing from annually reported, on the number of voter registration and voting activities and City agency demographic information for people returning voter registration forms. (00:23:59) Thank you to Djuhari Frazier and Chad Benjamin. Int 0853-2026-A, (00:24:03) sponsored by CM Susan Zhuang, would require the Department of Education to supplement existing special education reporting with analysis on how language and household income affects students' access to special education programs and services, and to report recommendations on how to address any identified barriers to access. (00:24:27) Thank you to Al Card. (00:24:30) Int 0905-2026-A, sponsored by Council Member Sandy Nurse, would give certain not-for-profits or joint ventures between not-for-profits and other entities a first opportunity to submit a statement of interest in purchasing, and the first opportunity to purchase certain residential properties when offered for sale. (00:24:49) Thank you to Austin Malone, William, Jose Conde and Jerk Spencer. (00:24:56) Int 0797-2026-A, sponsored by Council Member Selvena Brooks-Powers, would require the Commissioner of Corrections to create procedures for securing ballots for voters in DOC custody. (00:25:08) Thank you to Djuhari, Frazier and Chad Benjamin. (00:25:13) Int 0943-2026-A, sponsored by Council Member Farah Louis, would require the Mayor's Office to End Gender-Based Violence, in consultation with the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, to develop a report with recommendations for agencies to improve the collection and integration of data on gender-based violence. The Bill would also require the office to develop an outreach program to survey health care providers about screening practices for gender-based violence and provide support to integrate trauma-informed practice into the screenings. The Bill would require the office to develop a data dashboard to share data from City and State agencies around gender-based violence in the City. Finally, the Bill would require agencies to report some information about screenings that they are conducting, including the number of screenings that led to services or referrals for gender-based violence. Thank you to Julia Goldsmith-Pink and to Katie Selena. And lastly, Int 0943-2026-A, sponsored by Council Member Won, would wind down the horse-drawn cab industry by prohibiting the issuance of licenses for carriage horses, horse-drawn cabs and horse-drawn cab drivers on or after June 1, 2028. Any licenses active as of the effective date of the Bill would permanently expire on May 31, 2028. This Bill requires the humane disposition of carriage horses and prohibits their sale or transfer for inhumane purposes such as for slaughter or for use in another horse-drawn cab business. The Bill would also require an agency or agencies designated by the Mayor to establish a horse-drawn cab industry transition plan by February 2027. The plan would include a workforce transition program, consideration of a program to assist carriage horse owners with the disposition of their horses and equipment, and consideration of a program to provide compensation to horse-drawn cab owners for the value of their business licenses and equipment. Thank you to Christopher Pepe, Elizabeth Arts, Joshua Neuman, Elliot Lynn, Sahar, Masami and Smita. (00:27:42) Josh, Mark, thank you so much for your attention to this. I will now turn it back over to our Majority Leader. (00:27:46) Thank you, Speaker Menin. We will now move into discussion of general orders. I recognized a Council Member who wishes to speak on some matters. Thank you. (00:27:59) Majority Leader, I move to amend Int 0943-2026-A. I think the amendment — I was told it would come from the parliamentarian. If you could explain to the members what this amendment would do. I do not think the clock should be running until the amendment is explained to the members. Thank you. Council Member, anyone else who would like to speak on the amendment being proposed? (00:28:29) Well, we do not know what it (00:28:30) is yet. The motion to amend is the following: a yes vote will extend the effective date to January 1, 2030, as part of Section 17, and if we vote on this amendment, Int 0943-2026-A will lay over to the next Stated for a vote. A no vote will leave Int 0943-2026-A unchanged and we will vote on it today. Anyone who wishes — we can go now, go to roll call. Anyone who wishes to speak has two minutes to speak. But General, you finish your time. Okay, Council. My apologies. (00:29:08) Thank you very much, Majority Leader. (00:29:12) We were listening to Father Khader Khalili. He mentioned in his benediction, he talked about drivers working to make ends meet. That was part of his blessing and I think — I do not think anyone wants to see the drivers of this good industry put upon in such a way that they will be unable to feed their families. And as the Bill stands now, the City would receive a document from the Mayor — a plan that would take care of the disposition of the horses, the disposition of the workers and the disposition of the medallions. Understanding that the language is that it will "consider" reimbursement — it is a pig in a poke. I get it. And so this is how it is playing out: the drivers were promised, the City was promised, that the program for the workers, for the drivers, for the medallion owners — to quote the Speaker on 7/6/26 — "we need to do more to protect the workers, we are really trying to come up with more robust language," which I think needs to be in that Bill. That never actually happened. And so what I am really asking for is: if this plan comes out on April 1 like it is supposed to, then the industry has got 14 months to pack up, because they do not know what is going to be in that report. What I am asking for is to give them an extra 18 months to figure out their lives, because they were supposed to have today what they need so they know what is going to become of them. That will not happen until April. Thank you. (00:31:18) All right, we have CM Morano, followed by Paladino, speaking specifically on the (00:31:23) amendment. Majority Leader, I appreciate my colleague putting forth such a thoughtful amendment, but I would urge all of my colleagues, irrespective of how you feel about the bill to ban horse-drawn carriages, to vote against this amendment. As the Speaker chronicled, we have had two decades of discussion and debate about this. And the Bill as it stands now gives 18 months for the drivers to figure out their next step. (00:31:57) I am all about preserving history. Preserving history does not mean maintaining every practice that has ever existed throughout history. There was a time when being a lamplighter in New York City was a lucrative job, or an elevator operator, or an iceman. And the people — the hardworking people that had those jobs — did not have the luxury of a two-year warning that they were not going to have those jobs anymore. So to kick this can down the road for one more Stated meeting until we vote — when honestly, I think all of us have spent a lot of time thinking about this issue, those of us that were in the hearing — wherever we end up on the issue, we spent a lot of time listening to testimony about this issue. To me, we need to vote on this today. However you feel about it, we need to vote on this without amendment today. People have waited two decades. I have a lot of friends and colleagues that are going to vote differently than the way I am going to vote today and I respect their view, and I understand why. But to kick this can down the road when we have been doing this for decades — I think it reinforces everything that makes people so cynical about politics and politicians. Let us vote today. If you are banning the horse-drawn carriages, vote for it today. If you are not, vote no. Let us do it today without amendment. (00:33:18) Please quiet down in the chambers. CM Paladino. (00:33:24) Well, as usual, you would expect me to disagree, and I most definitely agree with CM Morano on the extension of time. This was done so hastily. And my condolences to the family — I am really sorry that you are being put up here as some sort of token to show the City of New York that one person was killed by a horse. When I did my press conference yesterday, it was completely about the horse owners and the time and the effort that is put in, and the losses suffered by the horse owners who have made this generational. Now, we heard here today: 19 years. Show me the proof that this has been going on for 19 years. And why does this Council not really try to figure out what the real danger is in this park? And that is unlicensed, unregistered and uninsured e-scooters and bicycles that are going through the park like crazy. We also had a speaker there yesterday at the press conference — a stable owner — who proves that you have a hundred-million-dollar lawsuit by the family against the City of New York, because it was Con Edison's fault that there was a shortage that caused their son to be thrown from the horse. I want a list of how many people were actually killed by horse-drawn carriages. The fact is that not enough time was given to this proposal, which was offered to them two years ago — I understand — which they turned down. Two years ago, a lot of things have changed, and now they have a proposal to put forward to this City. (00:35:27) Thank you, Council Member. And yet — the City will please, please mute her mic. Thank you. I am holding up a warning: if you do not respect your time today, all right. Anyone else who would like to speak on the amendment today? All right, CM Ariola. Thank (00:35:45) you so much. I do align myself with the comments made by my colleague Vickie, each and every one of them. There should be an extended time because we only have "what ifs" for the horse owners, for their horses and for their livelihood. I say further to all of you here in this chamber: what if, on November 3, the referendums pass and they start to excise us as they are trying to do — who will be next? What industry will be targeted next? And that is what we have to look at. Not what happened 19 years ago, but what is happening now, because it will define what happens in the future. Thank you for the (00:36:30) time. Majority Leader, Speaker Menin would like to make remarks. Yeah, I (00:36:41) was — I am happy to make remarks. I just want to say to the family: I am sorry you came here, because you are mourning the loss of your family member. You came here for that reason, you asked to come here and we wanted to honor your request to be here. And so I am sorry if anyone would suggest anything but that it is a terrible tragedy that you went through, and our hearts are with you. So I wanted to mention that. Thank you. (00:37:09) All right. I will remind folks of the motion being voted on today. The motion to amend is the following: a yes vote will extend the effective date to January 1, 2030, as part of Section 17, and lay over Int 0943-2026-A to the next Stated for a vote. A no vote will leave Int 0943-2026-A unchanged and we will vote on it today. As a reminder for folks who are voting, you have two minutes to speak if you would like to speak on your vote. Is there anyone else who would like to speak on the motion? Seeing none, roll call. (00:37:55) Aldebol? I do not know. Ariola? Yes. Avilés? Banks? No. Brewer? I do not know. I think there will be a huge effort to accomplish what everyone wants — jobs for the individuals and figuring out how to sort out the time with the medallions. Thank you. (00:38:29) Brooks-Powers? No. Cabán? I vote no. De La Rosa? No. Dinowitz? No. Encarnación? No. Epstein? No. Farías? I do not know — vote no. Thank you. Felder? Yes. Feliz? No, on the amendment. Gennaro? Majority Leader, I wish to speak on my vote if that is allowed here. You can. Thank (00:39:13) you. Okay. I just want to point out that I do not really need anyone in this chamber to apologize for me. And this is not any slight on the family. I am just trying to get justice for the workers. I will point out that, according to the family's efforts to try to get some compensation for the tragic loss — which can never be compensated for — the entities that were named in the lawsuit are the City of New York, Consolidated Edison, the Parks Department, the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, the Department of Transportation, the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. Conspicuously absent is the horse carriage industry, which I know full well carries very significant liability insurance. Yet the lawyers for the family did not seek to name them in the lawsuit. So I think that is something people should understand. And so the horse carriage industry did not cause this tragic death. This has been something that is not well understood, and there was a rush to judgment because there was a kind of proclamation — the day of the incident is the day that the Speaker came out and said... maybe — I am sorry, I need to direct my comments to the Chair. I am sorry. So the proclamation to move forward with this Bill — that could not be disputed by anyone who wants to challenge the Speaker — was made the day of the incident, before an investigation could even take place. Thank you. (00:41:18) Thank you. Gennaro? I vote yes on the amendment. Thank you. Sorry. Thank you. Gutiérrez? No. Hanif? No. Hankerson? No. Hanks? No. Hudson? No. Joseph? No. Krishnan? No. Lee? No. Louis? No. Maloney? No. Marte? Vote no. And I want to apologize — your time has started. Please, Council Member. (00:42:05) So if you could just ask in advance. Thank you. I just want to say I am sorry for the remarks made by some towards you. I know you are going through a lot at this moment and we should (00:42:18) respect the family for being here to honor their nephew. So thank you for being here and I am sorry again. Thank you. (00:42:34) Mealy? Morano? No. Narcisse? No. Nurse? I do not know — no. Ossé? No. Paladino? Yes. Restler? No. Riley? No. Salaam? No. Justin Sanchez? Pierina Sanchez? No. Santosuosso? No. Schulman? No. Stevens? No, and loving thoughts to the family. Thank you. Thomas-Henry? No. Ung? No. Vernikov? Yes. Williams? No. Wilson? No. Won? No. Wong? No. Zhuang? No. Brooks-Powers? No. Thank you. Carr? (00:44:13) Abreu? The nays have it. By a vote of six in the affirmative, 43 in the negative and zero abstentions, this motion is defeated. (00:44:59) We will now be resuming the agenda with the general orders discussion, beginning with Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, followed by... (00:45:14) Thank you, Chair. I am here to speak on Int 0797-2026-A. I know many of us are thinking about the South — money, think of Black and Brown voters disenfranchised — but some of us do not have to look that far, just into the East River. Thank you, Speaker Menin and the Council, for voting on this Bill today. There are close to 7,000 people detained on Rikers Island, most of whom are eligible to vote. Those people who have been convicted of a felony cannot vote while incarcerated. Most people on Rikers are being detained pretrial or serving time for misdemeanors and are eligible to cast a ballot. Despite this, only a fraction of the population in the jails vote. As the majority of the Rikers population is Black and Brown, it is hard not to hear the echoes of Jim Crow in this effective disenfranchisement of thousands of potential voters. Volunteers can help people on Rikers register to vote. It is still the responsibility of the Board of Elections to deliver absentee ballots to the jail population and to count those completed ballots. This seems straightforward but often is not. Advocates report that the Board of Elections routinely rejects completed registration forms and absentee ballots. Requesting a completed ballot from an eligible incarcerated person in New York is not like the outside world — a person whose ballot is rejected would be notified and they would have the opportunity to address any issues. The same is often not true of those on Rikers Island. In practice, only some of those who requested a ballot receive it, and only some of those ballots are counted, leaving only a small percentage of the eligible population actually able to vote. This would not be acceptable in the outside world and we should not accept it on Rikers either. Today, the City Council votes on legislation that gives us a better scope of the voting landscape inside Rikers. My Bill, Int 0797-2026-A, which I introduced with CM Brooks-Powers, would require the Department of Correction to report annually on voter registration inside City jails, including the number of completed voter registration forms, disaggregated by facility and demographic information, as well as the number of absentee ballots distributed. Incarcerated people's civil rights, including voter rights, are not optional. Just because a person is incarcerated does not mean they do not have a vested interest in their communities, including who represents them in government. Voting is one of a number of pro-social behaviors associated with reduced recidivism. Thank you, Speaker Menin and CM Brooks-Powers, and my staff. Thank you, Public Advocate. (00:47:26) From my office, CM Epstein, followed by Pierina Sanchez. (00:47:34) Thank you, Majority Leader. I want to thank the Romance family for being here. I want to thank Council Member Marte for his leadership and Speaker Menin for bringing this before us. That, 19 years later, we are finally doing something about the horse carriage industry — an outdated industry like so many before. I think about my grandma, who used to deliver milk in this city. A great job in Brooklyn, no longer a job that we need today. It is not a viable industry. You know, I have been to the stables. I have seen how the horses are treated. I see how they walk through New York. I know this industry must end. As chair of our newly created Animal Welfare Caucus, I stand together with the members of so many organizations who fought for this moment. Organizations like the ASPCA, PETA, Humane World and all the others. All these people came together around just this to say this is the critical moment for all of us to stand together and say this is our time. I also want to talk about two other important pieces of legislation we are talking about today. COPA. Council Member Nurse, thank you for your work to get this over the finish line. Mission-driven nonprofits that talk about affordable housing are going to be able to have the opportunity to purchase these properties in our districts. This is an amazing change to make sure these mission-driven organizations dealing with really distressed properties have the opportunity to make these homes permanent for our families. And finally, you know, for decades we have talked about the struggle for SCRIE and DRIE — people not being able to continue to live in this city. Today we are saying we are increasing the cap to $75,000. That means the tens of thousands of New Yorkers who were not able to qualify before will be able to remain in their homes. That is a game changer and I am proud to stand here with this Council. (00:49:40) CM Banks, CM Kamillah Hanks — apologies — and CM Gennaro. (00:49:55) It is actually CM Banks, followed by... (00:49:59) I will forgo. I will speak during my vote. Thank you. All right, no problem. Appreciate you. (00:50:04) CM Gennaro, followed by Brooks-Powers. I do not see CM Gennaro here. CM Brooks-Powers. (00:50:15) We will bring him back. Ready for me? (00:50:24) You may begin. Thank you, Leader. I am proud to have two of my bills before the Council today. First, Int 1027, which renames a stretch of Shorefront Parkway back to Edgemere Avenue, as the current name is not consistently recognized by GPS, Google Maps and other address systems. That back corridor will soon be home to over 1,650 new homes. Second, Int 0760 aims to improve ballot submissions in City jails. In less than two weeks, New Yorkers will go to the polls. Although many individuals in Department of Correction custody remain eligible to vote, participation has historically been extremely low, in part due to challenges with the absentee and early mail ballot systems. It is far too easy for a vote to be lost to a missing signature on the ballot envelope, an envelope being incorrectly sealed, or a ballot being sent off without the correct envelope. Int 0760-A requires that before the Department sends a ballot to the Board of Elections, it must check that the envelope is signed and dated, as well as signed by anyone who helped the voter, and actually contains the ballot. Then the Department must give the voter the chance and means to fix any problem. These simple fixes aim to increase the number of ballots received and counted by the Board of Elections, because being in custody does not end anyone's right to vote. A ballot should not be thrown out for an error that could have been caught. With that, I ask my colleagues to vote in support of these two pieces of legislation. Thank you. (00:52:03) CM Avilés, followed by CM Louis. Thank you very much, the... (00:52:07) Leader. And being indisposed, if you will, I think it is important to put on the record — I sent this in an email to everyone yesterday — that I do not think everyone really... (00:52:23) ...knows this: that in the 168-year history of the industry, not one person in this industry has ever been convicted of animal cruelty. In the entire history of the industry, not one driver has ever had his or her horse carriage driver's license revoked or even suspended. Not one horse carriage medallion owner in the history of the industry has ever had their medallion revoked or even suspended. And you know, much has been made of recent incidents that have happened with the carriage industry in the last year, year and a half, whatever it is. But the same number of incidents are always talked about. I think what people fail to understand — and this did not come up in our deliberations — was that every single one of those incidents, both in the last year and from the beginning of the industry, have been investigated by the New York City Police Department Mounted Unit and the Department of Health. In all these incidents, there was not even the issuance of a ticket, because it did not rise to the level, based on the investigation of the authorities that made that call. And so I think if the Council were really interested in figuring out how to do things better and to challenge the Police Department and the Health Department, we should have an oversight hearing that talks about that stuff so we could figure out how to go forward. But this whole notion that these incidents are the end of the world... thank you. (00:54:11) CM Morano? Yes, I appreciate that. CM Louis, followed by CM Marte. Thank you. (00:54:16) Majority Leader, good afternoon, everyone. Today we vote on two bills that are about more than policy — they are about protecting New Yorkers. Think of Napoli Ramirez, a 23-year-old mother who reportedly was pushed from her fifteenth-floor balcony by a former partner. Her story reminds us that leaving an abusive relationship does not always mean the danger is over. Int 0296 will help the City better coordinate gender-based violence data, identify gaps and strengthen prevention so we can intervene before tragedy strikes. Now think of the senior or disabled New Yorker who has spent years building a life and community in New York, only to struggle to afford the home they have lived in for decades. Int 0978 raises the income eligibility limit for SCRIE and DRIE from $50,000 to $75,000, helping more eligible older adults and disabled New Yorkers remain in their homes to age with dignity. These bills share one purpose: protecting New Yorkers before they fall through the cracks. I urge my colleagues to vote yes on these bills. Thank you. (00:55:27) CM Marte, followed by CM Morano. Good afternoon. (00:55:33) 160 years ago, the first national animal welfare organization was formed right here in New York City. It was started to address one specific issue: the condition of carriage horses in New York City. Now we are here, nearly two centuries later, to complete this mission. Throughout these years, our City has evolved. Milkmen no longer deliver milk to our doors. Construction companies no longer use horses. Paint companies do not use lead paint. Pet stores cannot sell dogs, cats, rabbits or guinea pigs. With every generation, we let go of the past and embrace the future. We have not just survived but thrived, and we are the City we are today because we have evolved with the times. Our job as legislators is to guide New York through this evolution. We have seen the posts. We see the endless comments on social media. We see the constant calls and emails we have received from our constituents. It is beyond clear that New Yorkers are ready for us to evolve past the outdated conditions of the horse carriage industry in Central Park. We can keep Central Park as a joy for millions of New Yorkers and tourists without relying on legalized animal cruelty that puts the public at risk. As we all know, this is not a new issue. Decade after decade, as the list of carriage accidents and dead horses piled up, elected officials who made big promises — elections have been decided because of this — but it has all been talk. Despite the promises, nothing has changed as more horses and people were harmed. We are guilty of this as well because of our inaction. It was unacceptable that it took a tragedy for us to finally pass this bill. But this is our opportunity to make sure that Romo did not die in vain. Thank you, Councilmember. (00:57:35) Sorry. Please... not exactly. CM Morano, followed by CM Nurse. (00:57:40) Thank you, Majority Leader. As you will see, I am making a concerted effort to do something that will upset just about everybody, irrespective of where they fall on the political aisle, at some point today. At the moment, I rise in strong opposition to Int 0905-A, the Community Opportunity to Purchase Act, better known as COPA. Look, we all agree New York City has an affordability crisis. But giving government-approved organizations special rights in private property sales raises serious constitutional questions, particularly concerning property rights and the limits of municipal authority. I believe this legislation is totally unconstitutional. Ultimately, that is a question for the courts, but I think we have a responsibility to confront that here. And I want to address something else. There is this temptation in politics — and we have all come to it from time to time — to vote for legislation that sounds good, collect the applause and leave it to a judge to sort out the legal consequences later. If a court strikes it down, you can tell your supporters you tried. If it survives, you can claim a victory. But I do not believe that is responsible governing. We are legislators, not spectators waiting for the courts to clean up after us. Even setting aside the constitutional questions, this is terrible housing policy. It adds uncertainty to property transactions in a City already struggling to attract investment and produce enough housing. We should be making it easier to build, easier to rehabilitate neglected properties and easier for working New Yorkers to afford a home. Let us stop confusing government intervention with government accomplishment — more often than not, those are antonyms. So I urge my colleagues to vote no on Int 0905-A and let us get to work on real solutions to our affordability crisis. Thank you, Majority Leader. (00:59:37) Thank you, Councilmember. CM Nurse, followed by CM Brewer, then CM Banks. (00:59:43) Thank you, Majority Leader. Looking forward to CM Morano's housing proposals, colleagues. Today we end the six-year saga. I am directing my remarks to the body. Colleagues, today we have the six-year saga of the Community Opportunity to Purchase Act. This has gone through three mayors. It has been introduced four times. It has had three hearings. It has been passed. It has been vetoed. And it has had a very intense, bad-faith lobbying effort to stop it. And it all comes down to today's vote. We are voting on the most strategic, operationally sound version of this bill. I believe this thing is solid. COPA lets trusted housing providers buy certain buildings, work with tenants, fix those units up and keep those tenants in their homes at permanently affordable rents. It is a critical anti-displacement tool. As one in five New Yorkers say they plan to leave within the next five years because it costs too much to live here, today we are offering a chance for families to stay. We cannot only build our way out of this crisis. If we are serious about stopping displacement, preserving existing housing has to be a priority, and that is what COPA does. When a building is at risk, the people... (01:00:55) ...who live there and the surrounding community get a chance to fight for it. It gives eligible landlords a pool of community-oriented buyers who know how to do this work, and it brings those buildings under public oversight. I really want to thank Speaker Menin for making this a priority. I want to thank my colleagues who championed it and those who patiently heard me out many times. Your input has been extremely invaluable and because of it, I believe this is a program that the Council is going to be able to stand by for years to come. So thank you. And I once again ask for your vote for COPA. Thank you, Majority Leader. (01:01:34) Thank you, Councilmember. CM Brewer, followed by CM Banks. (01:01:36) And I just want to say, in terms of SCRIE and DRIE, we all talk about the issue of being able to live in New York affordably. And I have to say these two bills do that. We hear about child care and we hear about the cost of groceries and fuel, but these two bills are really the way to add support for people who are older or who have a disability. So I just want to say thank you to all of our colleagues, particularly CM Farah Louis and everybody, to say yea for older New Yorkers. Thank you. (01:02:11) CM Banks, followed by CM Paladino. (01:02:11) Thank you, Majority Leader. Today, as we consider Int 0943, that will bring significant change to New York City's horse-drawn carriage industry. Horse-drawn carriages have long been a part of the character and identity of our City. Before I discuss the bill, I want to recognize the life of Romo Mahajan, a young man who tragically lost his life in a horse-drawn carriage accident in Central Park. Our thoughts and prayers remain with his family and loved ones as they continue to grieve this heartbreaking loss. For many New Yorkers, this debate has focused on animal welfare. This legislation takes important steps to ensure the humane treatment and disposition of carriage horses while establishing a lifeline for the industry's transition. But at the same time, we cannot lose sight of the workers, the small business owners, the families whose livelihoods depend on this industry. Many have devoted years to this profession, and as we move forward, we have a responsibility to ensure that they are not left behind. While the bill requires a transition plan that includes workforce assistance, support for horse owners and consideration of compensation, those commitments must be more than words on paper. We need action. We need real job placement opportunities, meaningful workforce training and support for small business owners. We must also consider a reimbursement program for those who have made substantial investments in this industry, including medallion owners who have invested hundreds of thousands of dollars. Strong oversight will be critical in the years ahead. The Council must ensure that the promises made in this legislation translate into real results for the people affected by this transition. The success of this effort should be measured not only by how the industry changes, but also by how well we support the folks affected. I also want to remind colleagues they can speak again during their vote if they want to. Thank you, Majority Leader. (01:04:24) CM Paladino, followed by CM Won. Okay, let us cover Int 0905... (01:04:34) Now I know I will be voting no against Int 0905-A because private property owners should have the right to decide when and to whom they sell their own property. This bill gives designated nonprofits priority in the purchasing process and puts additional restrictions on private sales. This in itself is very questionable. The government should not be dictating how people sell property, regardless of how hard they have worked to maintain and own their property. This bill potentially reduces property value and will stall sales, which will create unnecessary burdens on the owner. Private property ownership means something. And I believe the government has the responsibility to respect these rights. For these reasons, I will be voting no. And I also want to go into something else. What a day in the New York City Council. We managed to kill an industry that is 160 years old while also managing to kill private home ownership. You know what? When is this group going to finally start to think as individuals and respect their constituents and actually understand and stop this group mentality? COPA should be a dead issue. It was brought back out and now we are voting on it. Another thing being steamrolled through the City Council. Does anybody in this room have a mind of their own? Because somebody should have a mind of their own. I vote no on that. (01:06:31) Thank you very much for your time. We are not voting yet. CM Banks, followed by CM Nurse. (01:06:36) Thank you. Please keep it down in the Chambers. Please. Thank you. (01:06:39) Thank you. And now also, I want to thank Speaker Menin and my colleagues for passing my first Bill, Int 0628, two weeks ago, expanding equitable access to gifted and talented programs. Today we are voting on its sister Bill, Int 0853, to help ensure every child can access the special education programs they need. On December 16, 2025, a school bus carrying six nonverbal special education students aged 6 to 8 went missing for more than two hours. I cannot imagine the fear those families suffered. Too many children in the outer boroughs have to travel across districts to reach the services they need. Meanwhile, language barriers and family income can make it even harder for parents to navigate the system. We cannot wait to address this equity issue. Int 0853 requires the City to study annually how geography, income and language access affect access to special education programs and services. We need this data to identify the gaps and find solutions. No child should be left behind because of where they live, their family income or the language they speak at home. Every child deserves access to the education they need to succeed. I urge my colleagues, please vote yes on Int 0853. Thank you. (01:08:27) Thank you, CM Carmen. CM Ossé, is there anyone else I am missing for general orders? If I am missing you, please raise your hand. (01:08:36) Thank you, Marjorie, and thank you, Madam Speaker. To the family of Romance, you just happen to be the catalyst of the process we have been going through, and thank you for being here. This City has debated the future of horse-drawn carriages for many years. When the man died earlier this year, you came here before us to make sure that no other family would have to go through that. I believe that Tom is here. I also want to speak to the drivers. Many of you have done this work for decades. As a small business owner, I understand. And I know we have to do our best. I was and Madam Speaker committed to that. You have rent to pay and horses to care for, and this Bill does not yet answer how many get through this. The Bill requires City Hall to deliver a transition plan, and I will hold myself accountable, and so will my colleagues and everyone involved. If that plan comes back without serious answers on jobs, compensation and the care for the horses, I will gladly fight alongside you, Local 100. These workers deserve a plan that actually takes care of them, and I will not let a weak one make me regret the vote I cast today. I support this ban and I know the work for these workers is not yet finished. And like Madam Speaker said, we will move forward. (01:10:19) Thank you. All right. Anyone (01:10:26) else to speak on general orders? Seeing none. CM Justin (01:10:37) Sanchez. Thank you. I just want to speak on CM Abreu's Bill. Throughout the history of the Bronx, nonprofit and community-based developers have saved, stabilized and restored neighborhoods in every corner of our borough. When buildings were burning and entire blocks were being abandoned, organizations like Banana Kelly, the Mid Bronx Desperados and SEBCO stepped in to rebuild what others had left behind. From Charlotte Gardens to Crotona Park East to Kelly Street in Longwood, from the restoration of Morrison Hospital by Westhab to the community-led redevelopment of Melrose by NoBID, these organizations have done more than build housing. They preserved communities, protected affordable homes and given generations of Bronx families a reason to stay. Each of their investments was grounded in their understanding and belief in the community. COPA will continue to empower and protect nonprofit developers and allow them to do their critical community-building work. In a time where private equity firms are buying up housing stock all over the U.S. and gentrification is running rampant here in New York, we need to use our power as legislators to allow nonprofit developers to keep thriving and stand strong as pillars in our community. I am proud to vote yes on COPA and continue the legacy that these great organizations have built, ensuring that the next generation of community leaders has the tools and opportunities to protect our neighborhoods, preserve affordable housing and keep the future of the Bronx in the hands of the people who call it home. Thank you, Councilmember. (01:12:11) Thank you. Seeing no one else signed up to speak for general orders, we move on to report of special committees. None. Reports of standing committees. Report of the Committee on Criminal Justice: Int 0786-2026-A and Int 0797-2026-A, voting in City jails, amended and coupled on general orders. Reported the Committee on Education: Int 0853-2026-A, special education programs, amended and coupled on general orders. Reported the Committee on Finance: Int 0978-2026-B, SCRIE and DRIE increased exemptions, amended and coupled on general orders. Res 0666-2026-A, business improvement districts, amended and coupled. Reconsidered Res 0695-2026, organization funding, coupled. Reconsidered Res 0704-2026 through preconsidered Res 0707-2026 and Res 0708-2026, tax exemptions, coupled on general orders. Reported the Committee on Health: Int 0943-2026-A, horse-drawn cabs, amended and coupled on general orders. Reported the Committee on Housing and Buildings: Int 0905-2026-A, Community Opportunity to Purchase Act, amended and coupled on general orders. Report of the Committee on Land Use: LU 0129-2026 and Res 0709-2026 through Res 0714-2026, 50 Convent Avenue, coupled on general orders. LU 0142-2026 and Res 0711-2026 through Res 0715-2026, various zoning amendments, coupled. Reported the Committee on Parks and Recreation: Int 0927-2026-A, street renaming, amended and coupled on general orders. Report of the Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics: M 0098-2026, reconsidered Res 0715-2026, approving the appointment of Marricka Scott-McFadden, Bronx County Commissioner of Elections, coupled on general orders. Reported the Committee on Women and Gender Equity: Int 0296-2026-A, data regarding gender-based violence, amended and coupled on general orders. I now ask that the Clerk take a roll call vote on all the items covered on today's general orders calendar. (01:14:14) CM Pierina Sanchez, permission to explain my vote. Permission (01:14:17) granted. (01:14:18) Thank you, Majority Leader. New York City is facing a housing crisis, not only because we lack affordable homes, but because too many of the homes we already have are deteriorating under cycles of speculation, disinvestment and neglect. Today's vote on CM Nurse's Community Opportunity to Purchase Act gives us a powerful new tool to interrupt those cycles at the point of sale for a limited set of properties — those that are between 4 and 800 units that either have an affordability agreement already, that are managed by HPD, or have a baseline level of physical distress. COPA recognizes that the moment a building changes hands is a critical opportunity to change its future, by giving mission-driven organizations — qualified entities — a meaningful chance to acquire the buildings and chart a different, non-speculative future for the families who live there. Congratulations, CM Sandy Nurse, for your persistence and patience to get COPA across the finish line. To the COPA coalition led by the New Economy Project and the New York City Community Land Initiative, and tenant organizers across the City, including in our Bronx and in my neck of the woods: if you live in a nice private home with a front yard and a back yard, congrats, that is great. But for those of us who represent communities who need our help, this is a critical tool in the arsenal. Sorry I cannot make the celebration — childcare — but please celebrate for me. And with that, I vote aye on all. Thank you. (01:15:48) CM Salaam, permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Thank you, Majority Leader. First, I want to congratulate CM Nurse on her incredible hard work, coalition building, listening to the concerns of myself and others, and her perseverance in bringing COPA to a vote today. We rightly spend a significant amount of time on the City Council discussing and working on how to build more affordable housing, but preserving existing affordable housing is just as impactful and vital to tackling the housing crisis. I am excited to continue to work with this coalition on opportunities to expand affordable housing and not-for-profit housing development organizations in the Bronx. I would also like to take a moment to explain my vote on Int 0943-2026-A, prohibiting the operation of horse-drawn cabs and establishing an industry transition plan. This Bill has a unique and challenging mix of issues for me. Fundamentally, I believe that it is time to end the horse carriage industry due to the consumer and worker protection risks that it poses, in addition to the animal welfare concerns that it raises. Recent tragic incidents have reinforced the risks that both passengers and drivers face while navigating horse carriages on the increasingly busy, unpredictable streets of New York City and Central Park. I have a deep respect for those who have built their livelihood through the horse carriage business and the unions that fight for them. Many have done this work for decades and come to it from a passion for animals and an interest in working with people. I do appreciate the work of both Speaker Menin and Mayor Mamdani to incorporate transition planning commitments for affected workers and business owners into this legislation. I am optimistic that we will hold the administration accountable to ensure that the transition plans will include compensation. Thank you. (01:17:57) Thank you, Councilmember. Now it is my turn. I vote aye. Thank you. CM Ariola. (01:18:10) Thank you. I would like to disclose that my son Matthew works for the UAE, which is on the transparency resolution today that we will be voting on. I am aye on all with the exception of Int 0786-2026-A, Int 0905-2026-A and Int 0943-2026-A, for which I am nay. CM Avilés. (01:18:44) CM Banks, permission to continue (01:18:45) my long speech. Permission granted. Thank you, Majority (01:18:48) Leader. First of all, I would like to disclose I have a brother who works for the Parks Department and also for the Department of Juvenile Justice. I just want to congratulate CM Nurse, who is on the Council, CM Louis and also CM Abreu on amazing Bills. Thank you. I vote aye. That concludes my speech. Thank you. Thank you, (01:19:18) CM Brewer. (01:19:18) Yeah. Hey hey, ho ho, that one — that was a good one. Thank you. Please keep it down in the Chambers. (01:19:34) CM Brooks-Powers. Yes. First, I would like to disclose that we are moving some money in the Department of Education, and I have family members that are associated with it. I would also like to explain my vote. (01:19:48) Permission granted. Thank you. (01:19:49) Can you please add me to Int 0978-2026-B. I would like to congratulate those who are passing legislation today. Echoing the remarks of my colleagues, today's conversation around legislation to impact an industry was not an easy conversation to have. There are a number of very important areas to really focus on, and talking with the Speaker, I am looking forward to working with her and the administration to making sure that we hold the administration accountable when it comes to the workforce piece, because that is extremely important. We care about animals, but we have to keep New York affordable to make sure that people have the opportunity to earn a living here. And so with that, I vote aye. Thank you. (01:20:48) CM Cabán, permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. (01:20:52) Thank you. I want to start by asking to be associated with the remarks of my very wise and brilliant colleagues CM Pierina Sanchez and CM Aldebol. I do not think there is much more to say than that the Council is taking a very important step towards preserving affordable housing for New Yorkers that need it the most. We got a thorough lesson covering all of the things that make COPA what is needed in this moment to help tackle this crisis, from my seatmate over here. So to put it as simply as possible, it is about taking incredibly at-risk buildings and ensuring that they are safe, that they are healthy and that they are affordable for years and years to come. So thank you so much to my colleague CM Nurse for leading the charge on this and navigating really difficult waters to get this over the finish line. There are a lot of families that are going to benefit and be able to stay in their homes because of this legislation. So I am really proud to vote aye on COPA today. I am also voting aye on all. Thank (01:21:59) you. Thank you. CM De La Rosa. (01:22:05) Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. (01:22:06) Thank you. I have to disclose (01:22:07) that the Department of Education is on the agenda on the transparency resolution and my daughter is associated with the Department of Education. As the former chair of the labor committee in this body and as someone who has been in elected office for ten years — next year in 2027 — I have spent most of my public service fighting for workers' rights, and that commitment weighs heavy on me today. But that commitment is also not to be questioned. I would not allow anyone to question my commitment to the workers of our City. So today I am voting in favor of Int 0943-2026-A with the confidence that we will ensure that workers will be protected, that there is a just transition that will be prioritized and that the safety and the rights of animals will also be ensured by this vote. Because we can do all those things at once. After decades of debate and advocacy and hearings, the status quo is not serving anyone anymore. In June, an 18-year-old tourist named John lost his life, and that is something that should bring pause to everyone. Each incident endangers animals, the public and workers whose lives depend on this industry, and tensions are high on every side of this issue. But delays serve none of us. I support this legislation and I do not take lightly what it means to close this chapter. But there is a genuine commitment from the people in this room to make sure that the livelihoods of those impacted are prioritized. Carriage drivers have built their lives on years of experience, specialized skills and relationships with customers. Many have paid out of pocket for medallions and equipment, and they are workers of our City and they deserve to be treated as partners in this transition. We are committed to that. I want to thank Chair Schulman, Speaker Menin and all of our colleagues who have listened to the debate and come up with a fair and balanced solution. Protecting workers and protecting animals are not competing values, and today we choose to do both. I also want to take a moment to thank Sandy Nurse for her courage, for her conviction and for her balanced approach to ensuring that we are making a dent in the housing crisis. Thank you, and I vote aye on all. (01:24:22) CM Dinowitz. Permission. It is an exciting day. This has been... it is exciting because we are tackling really complicated issues. So I want to take a moment to thank Speaker Menin for really shepherding through a couple of Bills that have been on the agenda for a while, have gone through a few changes, and balancing — along with the Bill sponsors — really complicated and emotional issues. So I want to thank you and all the Bill sponsors. I want to congratulate Marricka Scott-McFadden, who we are nominating today — a friend of mine, a consummate public servant who is going to be great in this role. And I want to thank CM Louis for her Bill on increasing the SCRIE eligibility. I will not use the same language as CM Brewer, but our older adults really deserve to live with dignity and live affordably in our City. I want to highlight that this Bill — the SCRIE eligibility — also applies to Mitchell-Lama residents, and that is so critically important because right now they are facing 20, 30, 40% rent increases, all approved by our City. By the way, our City is approving these rent increases. And while we do not want the rents to skyrocket like our City is approving, we do have this tool that is now going to capture so many more older adults who could really use SCRIE to live affordably in their homes — in these homes that were designed for working class, middle class New Yorkers and retirees. And so, with a mind of my own, I am probably voting yes on everything on today's agenda. (01:26:08) Thank you. CM Encarnación. (01:26:12) Permission to explain my vote. Granted. Thank you. I echo the (01:26:17) comments of my colleagues, (01:26:19) CM Aldebol, CM De La Rosa and of course CM Abreu for his insightful words on this vote. I am extremely proud of my colleagues — everyone who is passing a Bill today, but those that really fought really hard to get here today. I am very proud to be here and to be on this floor and honored to vote aye. Thank you. CM Epstein. (01:26:46) Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. (01:26:50) Thank you. I just want to (01:26:51) Thank this Council and the Speaker for really taking on some tough issues that we are talking about. I just want to encourage my colleagues and the public to think about the discourse, because we have seen during the hearings on some of these bills real personal attacks that I think really undermine the efforts that we are all trying to do. The goal was to work on policy to improve New Yorkers. We can always agree to disagree about political issues, but we cannot always agree to have inappropriate discourse. I encourage us to be thinking about how we move together as a body, and the public at large to think about collaborating and coordinating and think about how we want, more importantly, to pass important pieces of legislation. We are doing it in a thoughtful, methodical way and as we move together, I would look forward to much, much more healthy conversations and collaboration, whether we are talking about the horse carriages or COPA. These are important bills that we are talking about, but they are policy decisions that we are collectively making. To ensure that we have this opportunity to have these debates and move forward requires people to be thoughtful, respectful and kind to each other and not the ongoing (01:28:03) slaughter of attacks that we have seen. I know. Thank you. Farah? Yes. (01:28:12) Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Over the years I have spoken with both animal welfare advocates and members of the horse carriage workers union in hopes of finding a solution that addresses the concerns of all parties. I believe we have a responsibility to both protect animal welfare while also ensuring that workers and their families are not left behind. Unfortunately, I do not believe this Bill in its current form strikes that balance. The proposed transition does not provide the concrete commitments to economic support, workforce retraining and pathways to stable employment that the workers deserve. For me, 18 months is not a realistic time frame for any person or industry to transition into a new industry. I cannot support a transition that leaves these questions and concerns unresolved, and I remain committed to working towards a solution that is fair, responsible and considers everyone impacted. (01:29:05) Separately and equally as important, congratulations to my colleague CM Nurse for passing COPA. A long fight, and I am really proud to see this pass today. This is the Bill we need. We knew that last session and we know it now. So proud to be a sponsor in support of that. With that, I vote aye on all, with the exception of Int 0943, on which I abstained. Thank you. Felder. (01:29:33) I vote yes on everything, except I vote no on Int 0786-A, Int 0905-A and Int 0943-A. Thank (01:29:56) you. Feliz. Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Thank you, Majority (01:30:00) Leader. So many big bills that we are voting on today. I am proud of all of them. I am especially proud to vote on the COPA bill and also the horse carriage bill. On the horses, it is time to ban the horse carriages for many reasons. First, as my colleagues said perfectly, this is not the 1800s anymore. Second, these carriages, as we know, have created serious and escalating public safety threats for all of us. Every single year there is a new incident, a new accident. These horses, as we know, are not mentally suited to being in a busy city like ours. They can panic and run unpredictably and uncontrollably from something as simple as a vehicle noise like a garbage truck, something that is obviously common in a busy city like ours. These are issues that cannot be resolved through more training and more legislation. I am so glad we are finally doing what is right and we are finally putting an end to these carriages. We are also doing it in a way that is responsible. We are making sure that there is a transition period for the workers and also making sure that the horses are also protected. I just want to thank Speaker Menin and also CM Marte for really making this bill and this idea a reality in the City of New York. Also, briefly on COPA, I just want to congratulate CM Nurse on getting that bill to the finish line. That was obviously not an easy bill. I know a lot of us remember those very long conversations during meetings on this complicated issue. You worked tirelessly and diligently and you left no stone unturned, doing everything you needed to do to get that idea into reality. Congratulations. I vote aye on all. Thank you. Gennaro. Majority (01:31:46) Leader, I wish to speak on my vote. Of course. Go ahead. (01:31:52) So, people are talking about this 18-month window. It is really 14 months. Having been around horses and ridden horses and been involved with them for more than 60 years and being around this industry for 36 years, I think I have some perspective on what it is going to take for them to get to where they are now and to their new lives, which is why I made the amendment. I wish to be associated with the remarks of CM Farías. I think she hit the nail right on the head. The Council tried to get this done, tried to work out the worker thing, the medallion thing, the horses thing. They could not get it done, and the reason why they could not get it done is because it is impossible, and the administration is going to find the same thing. So we are already kind of warming up to, well, we are going to consider this and we are going to consider that. If you own a horse and you retire that horse at age 26, you have to find a place to put that horse. You cannot put it in a rescue setting because those are for sick horses, and horses do not belong there. Nor can you put it in a sanctuary setting because sanctuaries turn working horses into broken horses. It is like putting a 20-year-old in a nursing home for life. We talk about the cost of this. The cost that they face now in taking care of the horses is somewhere between $25,000 and $30,000 a year per horse. If you have a horse that is going to live another 25 years, not four years like retired horses, you know, we have got a problem. Same thing with the medallions. There is going to be no... okay, I am going to wrap up here. So it is tough being in their shoes. That is why I wanted to give them a little more time to adjust. Thank you very much. (01:34:06) Gennaro, do your vote. CM, when you get a chance. Oh, pardon. Yeah, I am so wrapped up in my own rhetoric. I am voting no on Int 0943-A, no on Int 0905-A, and yes on the rest. Thank you. Thank you. CM Gutiérrez, permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Okay, I want to (01:34:38) start off by saying I vote aye on all. I just want to speak a little bit about the resolutions that we are passing today. I apologize for the wait during the discussion of the resolution. I still wanted to address the rest of my vote. I just want to acknowledge the hard work of CM Nurse and her team, who spent countless, countless hours negotiating this bill, educating our colleagues here in this room, educating opponents, and for prioritizing tenants. I think for those of us here who represent tenants of dwindling rent-stabilized housing stock, tenants who are constantly burdened with the cost of their rent, fighting to stay here, COPA is a very necessary and vital tool and resource. I think it, more than anything, is reaffirming that the City government has their back. I know people feel like this is an attack on homeowners, but if you have read the fine print and you read the bill, that is the complete opposite. So I just want to recognize her and the entire coalition that has been unwavering for years on passing this bill. I vote aye once again. Thank you. Thank (01:35:48) you. Permission to explain my vote. Permission (01:35:50) granted. Today I am proud that under Speaker Menin's leadership, this Council is passing Ramos's law, ending the dangerous and inhumane horse-drawn carriage industry after nearly two decades of advocacy and struggle in these halls. We must never forget the preventable injuries and deaths of horses and humans that occurred while our City failed to act. As vice co-chair of the Animal Welfare Caucus and a long-time sponsor of this legislation, I am deeply grateful for the advocates who never gave up. Today we honor Ryder and Ramos and take a historic step toward a safer, more humane city. I also congratulate our fierce Progressive Caucus co-chair, Sandy Nurse, on passing COPA. CM Nurse and the New York City Community Land Initiative coalition weathered a veto and a coordinated corporate disinformation campaign to reach this moment, six years in the making. This victory belongs to the countless New Yorkers who demanded real tools to fight private equity firms buying up our homes and displacing our communities. I was proud to serve as Progressive Caucus co-chair when we adopted COPA as a (01:36:56) priority last term. My colleagues and our movement stood strong through every fight. COPA is a major victory for housing justice and puts people before shareholder profits. With that, I vote aye on all. Thank you. Thank you, (01:37:10) Hankerson. Thank you. (01:37:16) Permission to explain my vote. (01:37:18) Permission granted. Thank (01:37:20) you, Leader. I would like to be brief and associate my comments with CM De La Rosa. I just wanted to say that losing a child in the way that Ramos's family lost him is not political. It is why we write laws. So I vote aye on all, with the exception of Int 0905-A, for which I will abstain. Thank (01:37:52) you. Hudson. Permission to explain my vote. (01:37:54) Permission granted. Thank (01:37:54) you. I would like to take a moment to congratulate my colleague CM Nurse on passing COPA. Once again, this historic legislation is a critical step toward preserving affordable housing and protecting longtime New Yorkers from displacement. I am proud to have supported both iterations of this bill: when it first passed, then when it was vetoed by the former mayor, and now as it passes this body again. Despite the ups and downs from both sides of City Hall, CM Nurse has remained a tireless and steadfast advocate for COPA and the communities it is designed to protect. CM Nurse is not only a true organizer. She cares deeply for her community and her commitment is why this bill has endured. COPA represents an important shift away from speculative investment and toward community preservation and long-term affordability that New Yorkers deserve. For those of us who represent communities that have been subjected to unsafe and uninhabitable living conditions, COPA is a lifeline. For those of us who represent communities that have been denied opportunities to purchase property because of systemic racism, COPA is a lifeline. For those of us who represent communities struggling to afford rent every single day, COPA is a lifeline. Today I am proud to be part of delivering that lifeline to our constituents. Congratulations and thank you, CM Nurse, and all of the advocates who have fought so hard for so long. I vote aye on all. Thank you. Thank you, (01:39:21) Joseph. I vote aye. Permission to explain my vote, and I also want to go on the record to say I am a parent of a New York City public school student. Permission granted. (01:39:27) Thank you. Thank you, Majority (01:39:29) Leader. In January, COPA fell short. I told tenants of District 40 that the fight was not over. Today we keep that promise. I want to thank CM Nurse for never backing down, for years of negotiating, listening and refusing to let this bill die. Thank you to the tenant organizers, community groups and advocates who kept showing up. Thank you to the Speaker and the Mayor for helping bring COPA home. Let me tell you why this matters. In Flatbush, in Prospect Gardens and Prospect Park, in Crown Heights, my office takes calls about no heat, about mold in a baby's bedroom, ceilings coming down, repairs promised and never made. Too many of our constituents live in buildings owned by landlords who treat their homes as a line on a spreadsheet, and when those buildings are sold, they often go to developers and the cycle starts all over again. COPA breaks that cycle. When a building goes up for sale, mission-driven nonprofits and community land trusts will finally get a fair shot at buying it and keeping it affordable, safe and in the hands of the community. As a forever educator, I know, for more than two decades I learned that a child cannot learn without a stable home. This is what is at stake for the families in these buildings, and that is why COPA matters. Housing is not a commodity. It is a home. I proudly vote aye. (01:40:46) Thank you. Krishnan. (01:40:49) Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. (01:40:51) To the Mahajan family, I want (01:40:53) to send my strength and my love and prayers to what you all have gone through. It is indescribable and I cannot even imagine the pain that you all have felt after losing Raman. To know that you all came here from India for a trip, as an Indian American, as the first in this body, it also hits me very personally. I was very moved to speak with Deepak Mahajan, Raman's father, who was in India earlier today. You all, and Raman, his memory will always be with us as we finally take action as a Council. I want to commend Speaker Menin's leadership of this Council. After 19 years, our body was not taking action on this issue. Thanks to the advocates, and a big thank you to Speaker Menin for standing up to get this done finally. I am proud that we have done it in a way that both recognizes the importance of human safety, the importance of animal welfare, and also with support and a just transition for workers who formed this industry. This is a big step forward for our Council and we do it in Raman's memory, a debt that can never be repaid, to his family. I also want to commend the passage of a number of bills today. I also want to commend CM Nurse on our passage of COPA. Also a long time in the coming. As a former housing lawyer myself, I know how it is not just about building new housing, but it is about preserving affordable housing and combating displacement. That is just as important and one of the key pillars of solving this housing crisis. COPA does exactly that. So great work, and congratulations to Sandy Nurse. Looking forward to continuing to fight together to solve our housing crisis. (01:42:33) Thank you. With that, I vote aye. Lee, permission (01:42:39) to explain my vote. Permission granted. Thank you. I just wanted to echo a lot of the sentiments of my colleagues. I congratulate those that are passing bills today. Thank you especially to Speaker Menin for passing Int 0943 today and being the Speaker to finally push it and carry it over the line after so many years of it being deliberated in the past. Also, congrats to you, CM Louis. SCRIE is super important. We have got to take care of our older adults and make sure they have dignity. As someone who ran senior centers and home-delivered meals programs previously, I know how much this is going to impact the older adult community. So thank you. Especially I wanted to give a special shout-out to CM Nurse, because I was on the last iteration of your bill as well as the current iteration. Having worked with a lot of the nonprofit organizations that do this work in the community, like ANHD, like St. Nick's Alliance and so many others that build amazing housing opportunities for our communities, I want to thank you for your perseverance through all the misinformation that is being spread out there. You handled it with such grace and you really tackled a lot of questions that everybody had. Again, I want to reiterate this is a very, very specific subset of buildings that qualify, and it is what the name says: opportunity. It is an opportunity. It is not guaranteed. It just gives these nonprofits an opportunity to bid on some of these properties and turn them into housing that will make our communities proud. So I just want to thank you and commend you, CM Nurse, for your heart, dedication and work on COPA. With that, I vote aye on all. (01:44:29) Louis. Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. (01:44:32) Thank you, Majority Leader. I would like to disclose for the record I am associated with the Parks Department. Second, I want to congratulate CM Nurse for her staunch advocacy and for getting COPA to the finish line, and CM Marte on the passage of Int 0943. That said, I do want to highlight the concerns raised by you and workers in the industry about job placement and particularly the lack of information on buyouts for medallion owners and the (01:45:05) limited sunset period for an industry that has existed for over 160 years. It is imperative that the administration implements this law responsibly with a clear plan that prioritizes workers and addresses the economic impact on those who have dedicated their lives to this industry. I want to thank Speaker Menin for her leadership and for getting these bills to the finish line. (01:45:26) On all. Maloney. I vote aye on all. Marte. Permission to explain my vote. (01:45:40) Permission granted. (01:45:41) I just want to thank Speaker Menin for her leadership on this. I also want to thank Chair Schulman, who has been focused on this issue for a lot of years and has taken a lot of heat from different sides, but she has been so strong and fierce and bold. When the time came to make a decision and host this hearing, I want to give my flowers to Chair Schulman. I also want to thank the Ma family. Thank you for your bravery. We stood in Central Park a few weeks after the loss of life, and for your commitment to staying on the course to getting this done, it was really your spiritual powers and your leadership that helped us get here today. So I want to thank you, and thank you for coming back from India. My deepest condolences, because I understand that it is still a hard moment for the family. I also want to thank the folks who worked on the technical aspects of this. I want to thank Chris, Elizabeth, Joshua and all the committee staff who spent countless hours working on this Bill. I want to give a huge shout out to my Deputy Chief of Staff Max in the back right here, and Simon, our team's director, who have taken a lot of calls all throughout the nights, mornings and weekends to finally get to this point. So thank you guys. We definitely would not be here without you. But I also want to thank the advocates, and especially I want to thank Edita from NYCLASS, who for years have been told that this was an impossible task, that they should go do something else, and probably said it in worse language than that. But she stayed committed. She did what is right. She cared about the horses. She understood that this City would get there, but she had to continue on the course. So to Edita, to Voters for Animal Rights, thank you for all the hard work. And to everyone in the gallery and everyone watching at home who voted to make this happen — you guys made this happen. Enough is enough. Let us get this done. Thank you. (01:47:49) Aye. Thank you, CM Mealy. (01:47:55) CM Morano, permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Thank you, Majority Leader, for recognizing me. I want to briefly explain my vote today in favor of Int 0943-2026-A, because I recognize that this is an issue on which reasonable people, including people I respect enormously, can disagree. A lot of my friends in organized labor opposed the legislation, as do some of my fellow Republicans, and I understand their concerns about protecting jobs and preserving traditions and affecting the people who have built their livelihoods around this industry. Those concerns deserve to be taken seriously. I do not believe every carriage driver mistreats animals. I believe a lot of drivers genuinely care about their horses and take pride in their work. But horses are living animals. They are not machines. Even a healthy, well-trained horse can become frightened and react unpredictably. You can regulate human behaviour, but you cannot regulate away animal instinct on the streets of Manhattan. The tragic death of 18-year-old Romanchuk Mahajan brought that reality into particularly sharp focus. He came to New York City with his family to celebrate his high school graduation and the beginning of his college education. Instead, his family suffered an unimaginable loss. I also recognize that ending an industry has real consequences for the people employed in it, and these workers deserve meaningful transition assistance, employment opportunities and fair treatment. Those responsibilities do not disappear with today's vote, and I am eager to work with my colleagues on helping these folks. The horses deserve a humane retirement into appropriate arrangements. I believe it is possible to respect the people who work in an industry while concluding that the industry itself should come to an end. I want to particularly recognize our former colleague, former Council Member Bob Holden, who championed this legislation long before today's vote. His years of work deserve acknowledgment. I also want to thank Speaker Menin for her leadership, and all the advocates, including the man who should be mayor, Curtis Sliwa. With that — and I saw how quick the Majority Leader was to cut me off — I will vote aye on all, with the exception of Int 0786-2026-A, Int 0905-2026-A and Res 0695-2026, on which I vote no. Thank you. (01:50:28) CM Mealy, permission to explain. CM Morano, please. Permission... (01:50:30) Granted. All right. Today I want to say congratulations to my colleague CM Sandy Nurse. But I am having such a struggle with Int 0905-2026-A. I could not even sleep, believe it or not, on this. I am against private investors buying homes. I would love to see that we create a path for folks who hold their home, and sometimes I am wondering if we are violating the people's constitutional rights, because we are taking their home without giving them compensation. I am sitting here saying, how are we doing that? Because when I am looking at some of the data, we have a background court extended, limited ability to even sue, and data showing that 11% of subsidized housing providers collect less than 80% of the rent rolls, fueling financial distress and non-payment. So I mean, evictions are falling while we know what is going on around us. So I am sitting here still wondering: can we keep — we want to keep the house with the person who owns their home, keeping it in the community. If the people in the community are actually going to go into those homes when they get fixed, I have a problem there too. So yesterday, the federal court approved a $60 million settlement against this City because we are not doing our part, and people should not be losing their homes like this, especially the people that are struggling the most — the Black and Brown communities. I am not saying nonprofits are not good. They have some good ones. But I am wondering about future generations. What are we leaving on the table? That is what I am saying. I have to be real — not popular with CM Morano today. Thank you. (01:52:21) I am not going to abstain on Int 0905-2026-A and I will vote aye on CM Nurse. Permission to explain my vote. (01:52:36) Permission granted. I vote... (01:52:38) Yes on all. Aye on all. I just want to use my time to lift up a lot of the folks who have been working on COPA for over six years. The New Economy Coalition, the Bronx, Cooper Square, South Bronx Unite, Mott Haven Port Morris Community Land Stewards, Brooklyn Level Up, Fifth Avenue Committee, Community Service Society, We Stay, No School Memos, St. Nick's Alliance, East New York Community Land Trusts, Housing Conservation Coordinators and so many more. The coalition is known collectively as the New York City Community Land Initiative. Sorry, I missed one — Meera, excuse me. I also just want to thank the brilliant bill drafting team, which had their own saga with this — Audrey, William, Austin, Brad and there are probably a couple of others. Thank you. To the many people along the wall who responded to all of my frantic texts all the time, I really appreciate it. I also want to thank former Speaker Adrienne Adams, who trusted me to get this over the finish line last time, and thank you to Speaker Menin for trusting me this time. I really, really appreciate it. I also just want to thank many of the folks who under this mayor really collaborated to make sure that on the back end we were able to really stand up something that we could truly believe in. So thank you to everybody who supported this work. Thank you. (01:54:21) CM Ossé, permission to explain my vote. Permission... (01:54:23) Granted. I vote aye on all. First and foremost, I just want to say that it is really rare for this Council to pass landmark legislation, and it is equally as rare for this Council to deliver on maintaining affordable housing in the City, especially during an affordability crisis. We hear that word a lot from various different levels of government, and I really want to commend CM Nurse for delivering on COPA and never giving up over the past couple of years when it came to this Bill. This is the type of legislation that New Yorkers need. This is what they are asking for. This is what they want their government to deliver on. And even though there were private interests and dollars spent aiming to gut and defeat this legislation, you stayed committed. Advocates stayed committed. And you got it passed here today. So I want to congratulate you on being the true representation of what New Yorkers deserve when it comes to leadership in government. Thank you. (01:55:40) CM Paladino. The following: I vote no on Int 0786-2026-A. I vote no on Int 0797-2026-A. I vote no on Int 0905-2026-A. And I just want to say something about that before I move on to my no vote on Int 0943-2026-A, the horse carriage ban. You know, everybody — we hear a lot about the very, very rich and the very, very poor, but nobody thinks an inch about the middle class. How is COPA going to affect the middle class? Yes, the people who have the front yards and the backyards, as was referred to by a colleague here in this room. I am proud of my front yard and I am very proud of my backyard, and I know how hard my husband had to work and how I had to work in order to have that front yard and backyard. I still do not own that front yard and backyard outright just yet. My husband is 74 years old and he still drives a truck for a living. So please, let us get off this bandwagon of a black and white issue. This is an every-person issue that struggles every single day, paycheck to paycheck, to make ends meet. And I am voting no against COPA because nobody has got the right to hand over my property to a nonprofit to decide how and when — but mostly how — I should go about the sale of my house that I broke my back for, so that my kids could have some sort of inheritance. And if we want to look at government-owned property, we had better start with NYCHA and all the money that is being invested and how these people live in squalor. For those of you who do not know, my office works very closely... I have to be consistent. I just want to say it clearly. I have been very consistent today. All right, Council, here is my vote. I will go over it one more time. Int 0786-2026-A is a no. Int 0797-2026-A is a no. Int 0905-2026-A is a no. Int 0943-2026-A, the horse carriage ban, is a no. Res 0695-2026 and Res 0650-2026, no. Thank you. Thank you, CM Restler. (01:59:11) CM Restler, thanks. Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Today we are tackling issues that have been debated in the halls of New York City government for decades. It is long overdue that we ban horse carriages in Central Park, and I especially want to commend CM Nurse for her leadership on COPA. When I worked in the de Blasio administration, we tried hard to get the City of New York to follow San Francisco's lead almost a decade ago on this important tool, and Council members and advocates have fought for years to get to this very day, overcoming vetoes and veto overrides and lots of hysterical opposition. This Bill is simple. It takes severely distressed properties — properties with a high concentration of violations — and it gives nonprofits an opportunity to match what the private sector is willing to buy and bring those properties into decent condition. It preserves affordable housing and it delivers the conditions that tenants deserve. We are seeing predatory entities purchase real estate all across our communities with the goal of just making money and not caring about our blocks, our neighborhoods, our communities. COPA will make a difference. This is a step in the right direction. So I really just want to say thank you to the Speaker, CM Nurse and all of the folks who pushed hard here to get this done. Thank you. (02:01:11) Aye. Thank you, CM Riley. I just want to say for the record I am associated with the... I vote aye. With the exception of Int 0943-2026-A, which I will abstain from. Aye. (02:01:31) CM Justin Sanchez, permission to explain my vote. Permission... (02:01:37) Granted. I vote aye on all. Congratulations to former Deputy Borough President Marricka Scott-McFadden for a little bit of levity. And I abstain from the Preconsidered items and accompanying resolutions Res 0705-2026 and Res 0706-2026. That vote today in part includes a tax exemption specifically for repairs to 917 Eagle Avenue, a walk-up building that is only five stories and has 123 recorded violations, including 41 Class C violations. This is just one of 14 properties in our district that in total are accumulating an additional 524 recorded housing violations. Of those, 164 additional violations are Class C violations — the most serious classification of housing violations in New York City — 16 instances where lead was found, 15 roof-related incidents, 17 units without heat or hot water, five with mold, and one with exposed electrical wiring. Think about what those numbers mean for the families that are actually living there. They are not just violations on a spreadsheet. These are conditions people are expected to come home to every single day. We cannot continue to simply hand out tax exemptions without accountability and expect that the problems will disappear. When we talk about building more affordable housing, I want to make it clear that the job of the developer, the property manager, the Council member and everyone else involved does not end once it is built and the tenant moves in. This cluster goes beyond the boundaries of my district, and I understand that a vote against it would put my colleagues in a difficult position. But today I will abstain from this vote because I want to make it clear that this is not the standard in the 17th Council District. We will not give out tax breaks and handouts to people and organizations who are not doing the work that they pledged to do. The key to your front door should unlock a safe, stable and dignified home where you can build your future and rest your head at night knowing that the roof is not about to cave in over you. (02:03:39) Thank you, CM Santosuosso. Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. (02:03:46) Thank you, Majority Leader. I just want to take a few moments to congratulate our leader in the Progressive Caucus, CM Sandy Nurse, on her passing of COPA today — a Bill that has withstood lies and fear-mongering, some of which I have heard repeated again in this chamber. This Bill does not end private property ownership. This Bill is not an attack on homeownership. This Bill is one of the few tools that seriously advances affordable housing preservation at a moment when we are simply too focused on building and not looking enough at preserving the existing affordable housing stock that we have. I want to commend CM Nurse and all of the advocates on their fierce commitment to this Bill and seeing this through to the finish line, bringing in as many people as they could in (02:04:42) the process, withstanding all the critiques, tweaking it to a workable Bill. And this is the kind of leadership that we need. The fact that we are here and finally voting on this is a testament to that persistence and to staying focused on legislation that will actually make a difference in working people's lives. So thank you so much, and I vote aye on all. Thank you, CM Schulman. (02:05:07) Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Today the New York City Council is passing two pieces of historic legislation that have been debated for months and years, but are being voted on today because of the leadership of Speaker Julie Menin. COPA, whose goal is to transform the availability of affordable housing — I was proud to co-sponsor this legislation and work with CM Sandy Nurse, making this Bill compatible with all interests, including the real estate industry. Then there is the horse carriage Bill, which is designed to protect horses while making accommodations for the drivers and workers. Sponsoring this Bill was important to me, especially after the tragic death of Romanchuk Mahajan. As I said at the committee vote, I am committed to continuing to work on this issue to ensure fairness on all levels as the terms of the legislation come to fruition. By the way, in addition to what CM Nurse's team mentioned in terms of the advocates, I want to give a shout out to Allie Taylor from the Mayor's Office of Animal Welfare, who was at one point part of this effort and has been a great help. With that, I vote aye on all. CM Stevens. (02:06:14) Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Although I will be voting in support of Int 0943-2026-A, I would be remiss if I did not call out some of the unacceptable behaviour of some of the advocates who resorted to harassment, hateful and racist rhetoric. Advocates should never come at the expense of someone else's dignity. Now that we are moving this Bill forward, I hope that they bring the same energy to Black and Brown communities who deserve the same level of advocacy, attention and support. Our community deserves nothing less. I also want to give a special shout out to CM Sandy Nurse, who got a very tough Bill across the finish line. And if someone was going to do it, we know it would be herself. Shout out to you for doing the hard work. Thank you. Thank you, CM Thomas-Henry. (02:06:59) I would like to disclose for the record that my children are affiliated with the Learning Tree Tutorial and Enrichment Program. And with that, I vote aye on all. CM Vernikov. (02:07:20) I vote aye on all, with the exception of Res 0695-2026, Int 0786-2026-A, Int 0905-2026-A and Int 0943-2026-A, on which I vote no. Thank you. CM Williams. (02:07:40) Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Thank you. We are passing some really good legislation today and I want to thank and congratulate CM Louis and also CM Nurse. I just wanted to say that this Bill was significantly amended from 10,000 buildings to only around 2,100 and I know in my more radical opinions, I would love for this to actually impact first single family homeowners because we do also have a speculative market even in southeast Queens. So I just want to say this is a very moderated Bill. Last but not least, I really wanted to thank Speaker Menin for her work and for making sure that we protect the workers. I do hope in the transition period that we can find a dignified life both for the horses and for the workers. With that, I vote aye on all. Thank you. (02:08:35) Thank you. CM Salaam, for disclosure. Yes, I just want to disclose for the record that I am associated — my family is associated with the Harlem Junior Tennis Program. Thank you. CM Wilson. (02:08:48) Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Thank you, Majority Leader. I want to once again voice my strong support for Int 0943-2026-A. I live near the stables in Hell's Kitchen. I have seen the consequences of the industry on the streets — horses limping and collapsing, carriages involved in dangerous accidents, workers put at risk and pedestrians and park goers endangered. These are warning signs we can no longer ignore. New York City is one of the busiest, most congested cities in the world. Our streets and parks are not fit for horses to navigate amid traffic, construction, crowds and the constant noise of city life. This legislation is about public safety. It is about animal welfare. It is about finding a path forward for these horses as well as the carriage drivers. I look forward to seeing this law passed and implemented with efficacy and empathy. I want to thank Speaker Menin, the Speaker who got it done on a very tough Bill. I also want to say kudos to all the advocates for their long-standing effort, CM Marte for carrying the Bill and Chair Schulman for getting this over the finish line. I want to pay special tribute to the Maha family, who has taken unimaginable grief and turned it into determined advocacy. We stand with you today and we will forever remember Raymond. I would also like to voice my support for COPA. CM Nurse and her team have shown real vision on this endeavor and I am proud to assist their housing affordability efforts with my co-sponsorship and vote in favor. So horses — nay, but I vote aye on all. Thank you. (02:10:30) Aye on all. I want to congratulate CM Nurse and CM Marte and all of the other Bills that were passed today. Thank you. (02:10:41) I will vote aye, except for Int 0786-2026-A, which I vote no on, and Int 0905-2026-A, which I vote no on. Thank you. (02:10:55) For the record, my kids go to public school. Related to my votes, I vote aye, except on Int 0905-2026-A. I want to stand with CM Abreu on Int 0943-2026-A. CM Epstein, are you standing on both Bills? No, I am voting aye on Int 0905-2026-A and abstaining on Int 0943-2026-A. (02:11:46) Aye. (02:11:47) Permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Minority, five minutes. Thank you. Thank you, Majority Leader. I joined government years ago because I had a passionate commitment to both the right of private property as well as to our free enterprise system. Private property, because history has shown that it is a critical cornerstone to our system of political and economic rights. The free market, because while imperfect, it is the best proven way of bringing the most prosperity to the most people. I will be voting against the new version of COPA today because it limits the rights of property owners. This is a circumstance where I have great sympathy for the tenants in the buildings that will be covered by this legislation and I have very little sympathy for the owners who are selling. But our political rights are sacrosanct and that does not change based on the sympathy I have for the individuals who possess them. That is the whole point of these political rights — to ensure that everyone has access to them regardless of our opinion of them and the circumstances in which they are availing themselves of them. Similarly, I cannot in good conscience vote in favor of Int 0943-2026-A. This is the Council ending a particular means of employment. Colleagues invoked earlier other forms of employment, other ways of earning a living that once existed in our City and no longer do. But those examples given, like the milk delivery person, are jobs that disappeared because of advances in technology or because of changes in the marketplace. Unlike, for example, the industry my great grandparents worked in, which was the fur coat industry. They labored in the garment district here in Manhattan in the Depression era. That was not the Council. So I cannot in good conscience support an end to this particular means of work and livelihood for so many New (02:13:48) Yorkers, when it is no more dangerous than the other means of getting around our City. Getting around New York City is dangerous, whether it is by car, by vehicle, by bus, by bike or other means, even horse carriages. When there are issues that need to be addressed in terms of safety, we address them through regulation, as we have done. I do hope that since the Bill appears poised to pass today, the commitments that have been articulated here and before today about finding an opportunity for these folks — owners and workers — to continue to earn a living in a way that keeps them in the life to which they are accustomed, in a way that keeps them having dignity in the workplace and in their home, I hope that we meet those expectations. That being said, I vote no on Int 0786-2026-A, Int 0905-2026-A, Int 0943-2026-A and the reconsidered Res 0695-2026, and aye on the rest. Thank you. (02:14:45) I vote aye on all and congratulations to Speaker Menin for being the person to get this done after so many years of effort. (02:14:55) Speaker Menin, permission to explain my vote. (02:14:57) Permission granted. (02:14:58) Thank you. I guess you cannot say nay now. (02:15:01) Right. Well, you could. I think you are right about that. (02:15:04) So I just want to congratulate all of the colleagues for these Bills today, who I know have worked so hard on them. I have said a lot about this already. Congratulations, CM Marte, all of the advocates, and congratulations CM Louis on these important SCRIE and DRIE issues that are really going to help our seniors. It is so incredibly important. I want to congratulate CM Nurse because I think for the legislative process to really go well, it is about listening. It is about collaboration. It is about hearing feedback. It is about people not always agreeing on every single issue. I appreciate what CM Nurse and her team did. I really appreciate what our team at the Speaker's office did because we worked tirelessly with CM Nurse, with stakeholders. We heard a lot from the real estate industry, from small property owners. We met with everyone and we ended up at a Bill that took the original Bill of 10,000 buildings down to 2,100 buildings, as the Deputy Speaker said, and we worked really hard to make a more targeted Bill. I think that is what a legislative process does. So with that, I vote aye on all. (02:16:43) Just give us a minute as we tally the votes. All right. All items on today's General Order Calendar are adopted by a vote of 49 in the affirmative, zero in the negative and zero abstentions, with the exception of Int 0786-2026-A, which was adopted by a vote of 42 in the affirmative, seven in the negative and zero abstentions. Int 0905-2026-A, which was adopted by a vote of 38 in the affirmative, nine in the negative and two abstentions. Int 0943-2026-A, which was adopted by a vote of 40 in the affirmative, seven in the negative and two abstentions. Res 0695-2026, which was adopted by a vote of 44 in the affirmative, five in the negative and zero abstentions. Int 0797-2026-A, which was adopted by a vote of 48 in the affirmative, one in the negative and zero abstentions. LU 0156-2026 and companion resolutions, which was adopted by a vote of 48 in the affirmative and one abstention. We will now move into Introduction and Reading of Bills. Madam Speaker, whenever you are ready. (02:18:32) Okay, all Bills have been referred to committee as indicated on today's agenda. Thank you. We will now move into Discussion of Resolutions, beginning with CM Gutiérrez, followed by CM Louis. (02:18:49) Thank you and I will be fast because there is so much to celebrate. (02:18:52) One second, CM. Can we just please keep it down as the Council Member speaks. You want me to start? Let us give the gallery a second to quiet down. CM Gutiérrez. (02:19:10) Thank you, Majority Leader. Head Start is an invaluable program that, since its inception over five decades ago, has served children and served as a critical service to the thousands of multi-language learners throughout our City. Res 0650-2026, which opposes the federally proposed rule change that very blatantly puts families in harm's way by doing away with services and resources that support multi-language learners in Head Start programs. These are children and they deserve the same quality education as any other child. We have data to support that supporting a young child's home language in a school setting puts them on a faster path to English comprehension. So I just want to thank our Speaker. I want to thank committee staff Julia, Katie, Andrew and whoever put this resolution together. I want to thank the advocates who came to the hearing to support multi-language learners. I hope all my colleagues can join me in supporting and passing Res 0650-2026, opposing the federal government's rule change doing away with multi-language service supports. Thank you. (02:20:16) Thank you, Counselor. Can you please keep it down in the chamber. CM Gutiérrez, I apologize for the interruptions. CM Louis, followed by CM Wilson. (02:20:26) Thank you, Majority Leader. Today we will vote on Res 0625-2026-B, which declares Reggaeton Heritage Month in New York City. Reggaeton is more than music. It represents the rich history of Afro-Caribbean and Latin American sound shaped by Puerto Rico, New York City and the broader Caribbean diaspora. This resolution honors and recognizes how these cultural contributions have grown into a global phenomenon. I want to thank Deputy Speaker Williams, Speaker Menin and all the advocates who pushed to bring this resolution forward for this month. I want to sincerely thank legislative division staff Alejandro and Virginia Paul for their work on the resolution. I urge my colleagues to vote yes on Res 0625-2026-B. Thank you. (02:21:14) Seeing no one else signed up for resolutions — is that right? Anyone else wish to speak on resolutions being voted on? We will now have a voice vote on today's resolutions. Just one second as we try to get the chamber in order. Please keep it quiet. All right, if you wish to vote against or abstain from any of today's resolutions, please notify the Legislative Documents Unit by email or by approaching the dais. (02:21:46) I will now read today's resolutions into the record. Res 0625-2026-B declares Reggaeton Heritage Month in the City of New York, to honor the legacy of reggaeton as a prominent expression of Afro-Caribbean and Latin American identity and to recognize New York's pivotal role in facilitating the blend of cultures that is at the heart of this grassroots musical genre. (02:22:11) All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. Any abstentions? The ayes have it. (02:22:19) Res 0650-2026 opposes the federally proposed rule change titled "Reducing Federal Burden for Head Start Programs" and calls on the Federal Government to prioritize protecting and growing access to high quality education for young children. All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. Any abstentions? (02:22:40) The ayes have it. We will now move into General Discussion. We have eight folks signed up so far. CM Santosuosso, followed by CM Hanif. Thank you. (02:22:51) Thank you, Majority Leader. Today I was proud to introduce the Stop Super Speeders Bill, which completes a process started in the State by State Senator Andrew and Assembly Member Emily Gallagher, which would require the installation of speed-limiting devices in vehicles where the drivers have incurred 16 or more speeding violations in school zones caught on camera within 12 months. This is an important street safety Bill. As someone who both walks and rides a bike and drives a car, I just want to clarify that this is a Bill that keeps our streets safe for everybody and cracks down on our worst offenders. It is (02:23:43) not targeted at anybody who gets one or two speeding tickets, as I am sure many in this chamber have gotten. So I look forward to finally completing this process started by those leaders in the State by passing this Bill and fully implementing the Stop Super Speeders Bill. I encourage my colleagues to sign on and I will be circling around with you soon about that. I also introduced legislation today to prevent city-issued vehicles from using Flock surveillance-based technology and I will be speaking with each of you about that soon. Thank you to everybody who held my baby today. I really appreciate it. (02:24:26) Thanks. (02:24:26) CM Hanif, followed by CM Louis. I am proud to introduce Int 1137-2026, legislation that has already earned the support of 10 of my colleagues. This Bill would establish a resource center to support businesses owned and operated by New Yorkers with disabilities, with a brick-and-mortar location in every borough and annual reporting to measure its impact. The initiative would be administered by the Department of Small Business Services in coordination with the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities. Too often, New Yorkers with disabilities face barriers not only to finding employment but to creating businesses, building wealth and becoming job creators themselves. Economic justice for people with disabilities must mean more than access to jobs. It must also mean access to ownership, entrepreneurship and economic power. I urge my colleagues to sign on. I want to honor the lives of two remarkable women from my district in Kensington — Firdos and Denise Ahmed — who tragically passed away this week. Both were my constituents and childhood classmates. We are the same age. They died too young at 35. Firdos was an educator and classical dancer who touched countless lives through her teaching and artistry. Denise was a dedicated public servant and talented artist whose work was just exhibited at Joanie's Open Studios. I just saw her. Both women gave so much to our City and our communities and their sudden passing is heartbreaking. Deepest condolences go out to their families, friends and everyone whose lives they touched. May they both rest in peace. Thank you. (02:26:09) Thank you, CM Hanif. CM Louis, followed by CM Brewer. Thank you, Majority Leader. (02:26:16) Today I am introducing two Bills. The first, Int 1146-2026, addresses the performance of fiscal agents contracted by the Department of Youth and Community Development to manage funds on behalf of community-based organizations. These organizations provide critical services to our young people in neighborhoods, but delays in payments and administrative challenges can interfere with their ability to deliver. This Bill requires annual reporting on fiscal agent performance and establishes a feedback mechanism for organizations to raise concerns. I am also introducing Int 1147-2026, which requires the Department of Small Business Services to publicly disclose disparity studies and their underlying data. Minority and women-owned businesses continue to face barriers in competing for City contracts. Making these studies and their data publicly available will strengthen transparency and help us better understand disparities in contracting and whether our participation goals reflect the realities these businesses face. I urge my colleagues to support these Bills. Thank you. (02:27:25) Thank you, Counselor. CM Brewer, and finally CM Wilson. (02:27:27) Thank you very much. I am introducing Int 1132-2026, a public record portal for the Landmarks Preservation Commission. There are 38,000 landmark properties and 12,000 applications every year and there is no portal for members. So we need the portal. Number two, Int 1133-2026 — the stipulated fine and commercial abatement program needs to apply to small businesses. We know that large businesses get a stipulated abatement program for their fines. We want to apply that to smaller stores and we have some ways of doing that. Last year, the City collected 58.3 million dollars in 776,000 fines. Number three is a study of gambling behaviors and the impact of casino openings, directing the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene to study gambling behaviors and the impact of casino openings. There are also resolutions: one to regulate cryptocurrency kiosks and another to require anti-addiction products to contain a warning label. We have a list of those that should be included and there is a resolution in Albany regarding the same topic. I hope you sign on. Thank you very much. (02:28:49) Thank you, CM Brewer. CM Wilson, followed by CM Joseph. Thank you. (02:28:52) Thank you, Majority Leader. I know we have a busy day today, but I would like to end with something a little lighter. I am honored to be introducing resolutions commemorating two recently departed icons who left an indelible mark on popular culture in this city, this country and the world. With the passing of fashion designer Bob Mackie on September 14, the world lost a uniquely talented artist whose work is woven into the fabric of this city. Mackie pioneered bold looks from his work on Seventh Avenue. Mackie created pieces of high glamour, not only for Hollywood stars, but for the working women of New York. His 60-year career demonstrates the power of unapologetic camp and this city's enduring status as a trendsetter. On August 25, Dolly Parton passed away at the age of 80, prompting an outpouring of grief and remembrance from admirers from around the world who celebrated her extraordinary contributions to music, philanthropy, business, literature and American culture. Workers of the world united through Dolly's melodies. With the syncopated clicking of nails on a typewriter at the start of "9 to 5," she made relatable the despair of white-collar drudgery. "Coat of Many Colors" spoke to the beauty amidst the struggle found in working-class life. Her remarkable leadership in literacy initiatives and follow-through in philanthropy further showed that working people and the disadvantaged were never far from her heart. My Res 0702-2026 honors her contributions to the world and her connection to New York City. Those included being presented with the keys to the City of New York in 1978. So in this chamber, I hope everyone will join me in telling Dolly that New York City will always love you. (02:30:32) Thank you. Thank you, CM Joseph. (02:30:36) Thank you, Majority Leader and Madam Speaker. Colleagues, we are standing here in the final days of Domestic Violence Awareness Month. All month long we have worn purple, we have held vigils and we have said the names of New Yorkers we have lost. Today I want to do something more than remember. I want us to measure. That is why I am proud to introduce Int 1144-2026 alongside colleagues CM Marte and CM Louis. Right now the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence reports to this Council every year. It tells us how many people walk through the doors of our Family Justice Centers, how many trainings were held, how many outreach events took place. That information matters. But it tells us what we are doing. It does not tell us enough about what survivors are facing. Int 1144-2026 changes that. Beginning in 2028 and every two years after, the Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence will publish a full analysis of gender-based violence across our city, including complaints, arrests and outcomes. It will show us the disparities by race, by age, by sex and by gender. Because we know violence does not land evenly. Black women, immigrant women, trans New Yorkers — they too often face the most harm and the fewest doors that are open. I learned that you cannot help a student if you refuse to see the child. The same is true for our city. If we want to direct resources where they are needed the most... (02:31:58) We need the full picture. Data is not the end of this work. It is how we do this work honestly. I want to thank my staff, the advocates and survivors who pushed for this. I urge my colleagues to sign on. Thank you. (02:32:10) Seeing no one else signed up for general discussion, I will now call on Speaker Julie Menin to close today's stated meeting. (02:32:19) Thank you. The stated meeting of October 22, 2026 is...