Hearing Hearings — Hearing Record ✉
← All hearings

Meeting of November 12, 2026

City Council

Chair: Julie Menin

Meeting overview

The November 12, 2026 Stated Meeting was dominated by two themes: a veterans legislative package timed to the day after Veterans Day, and responses to an acute building safety crisis following a fatal collapse in Flatbush the previous evening. Speaker Menin opened with a moment of silence for the eight people killed in the Flatbush collapse and noted twenty-three injuries including three firefighters, before moving through a full agenda that passed several significant pieces of legislation and introduced a substantial slate of new bills.

The marquee legislative action on veterans was Int 1051-A, sponsored by CM Frank Morano (R-Staten Island), which eliminates property taxes entirely on the primary residences of permanently and totally disabled veterans with a 100% service-related disability rating. The bill passed 48-1. Morano used his floor remarks to note pointedly that New Jersey and Nassau County already provide this benefit, an implicit rebuke to Albany and prior City Councils. Minority Leader David Carr's Int 0928-A establishing an LGBTQ+ liaison within the Department of Veterans Services passed as part of the same package, with Carr explaining that many veterans discharged under Don't Ask Don't Tell remain unaware they can now seek an upgrade to their discharge status. CM Inna Vernikov's Int 0488-A requiring HPD to report on veteran uptake of Mitchell-Lama housing preferences also passed, framed as a transparency measure to ensure an underutilized benefit actually reaches veterans. Resolution 560, calling on Congress to pass the Fair Access to Co-ops for Veterans Act, passed on a voice vote.

Speaker Menin's Int 0891, the surveillance pricing prohibition, passed 44-5, making New York City the first jurisdiction in the country to ban the practice of using individual consumer data including location, browsing history, and demographic information to set differentiated prices for the same goods or services. Menin cited a 23% price differential found on a major grocery delivery platform and a $100 item that became more expensive when a retailer detected a shopper's location near their store. The bill fines violators up to $1,000 per violation, with a corrective action safe harbor for small businesses. The five dissenting votes were notably from both ends of the ideological spectrum, suggesting different objections. Int 0178-A, requiring HPD and DOB to provide centralized technical assistance for commercial-to-residential conversions including a designated interagency liaison, passed alongside the finance resolutions setting the city's property tax rates and class proportions for fiscal year 2027. Int 0202-A, requiring DOT to install approved school safety treatments within 120 or 180 days depending on complexity, also passed.

The building collapse and a broader spike in fire deaths animated several new bill introductions. CM Pierina Sanchez introduced Int 1174 to create a public fire emergency data dashboard modeled on NYPD CompStat, and Int 1175 to require a study of electrical systems in aging residential buildings, citing a near-doubling of fire deaths year-over-year and noting over 80% of city buildings are more than 50 years old. CM Hankerson introduced Int 1182 to establish a standalone Department of Emergency Medical Services, an idea that resurfaces periodically given long-standing pay and staffing disparities between FDNY firefighters and EMTs. The Council also received CM Louis's introduction of Int 1165, requiring an analysis and action plan on more than 50,000 vacant rent-stabilized units, which Menin highlighted in her remarks as unconscionable waste during a housing crisis with a 1.4% vacancy rate. Land use approvals included the Studio 54 rehabilitation text amendment enabling flexible transfer of development rights to preserve the theater, and two Queens Boulevard and 108-05 68th Road rezonings in Community District 6 incorporating Mandatory Inclusionary Housing requirements.

General discussion also featured CM Cabán introducing a resolution endorsing the Starbucks Workers United boycott, framing it in explicitly class-political terms and referencing Trump and billionaires in the same breath as union-busting, which is unlikely to advance beyond the Council chamber but signals the progressive bloc's posture. CM Brewer introduced a resolution opposing any renaming of Penn Station, noting President Trump had conditioned release of $16 billion in Gateway Tunnel federal funding on renaming the station after himself, which Brewer dismissed tersely as unnecessary confusion and expense without improving service. CM Morano introduced Int 1166 to deny building permits to developers owing $25,000 or more in unpaid property taxes or water and sewer bills, closing a gap in existing law that only counts certain fines toward that threshold. CM Narcisse flagged the Flatbush collapse as personally affecting constituents she has long represented. The meeting closed with the adoption of a resolution designating the fourth week of November as Shangri-Las Week, which is exactly what it sounds like.

The record

Proposed laws (30)
Land use applications (9)
Resolutions (22)
Other (1)
  • Int 1159-2026 The creation of a working group to study agency use of communication technologies. (sent to committee)
Numbers
  • Eight lives lost in the Flatbush building collapse the night before the meeting.
  • Twenty-three people injured in the Flatbush collapse, including three firefighters.
  • Approximately 250 first responders deployed to the Flatbush collapse scene.
  • Approximately 200,000 veterans live in New York City's five boroughs.
  • Int 1051-A passed 48 in the affirmative, 1 in the negative, 0 abstentions.
  • Int 0891 (surveillance pricing ban) passed 44 in the affirmative, 5 in the negative, 0 abstentions.
  • Property tax resolutions (Res 0723-0726) passed 41 in the affirmative, 8 in the negative, 0 abstentions.
  • Real property tax base proportion increase set at 0.3% for fiscal year 2027.
  • Fines of up to $1,000 per violation for businesses engaging in surveillance pricing under Int 0891.
  • $25,000 threshold of unpaid property taxes or water and sewer bills that would trigger building permit denial under Int 1166.
  • Grocery delivery platform found to individualize price differences of up to 23% between customers in New York City.
  • Over 50,000 rent-stabilized units currently sitting vacant and off the market in New York City.
  • Residential vacancy rate cited as 1.4% overall; under 1% for rent-stabilized units.
  • Commercial-to-residential conversions projected to potentially bring approximately 17,000 new units online; 25% of conversion units to be permanently affordable.
  • Approximately 90 fire deaths in New York City year-to-date, roughly double the same period in the prior year.
  • More than 80% of New York City buildings are over 50 years old.
  • One in three pet surrenders in New York City in 2025 attributed directly to housing instability.
  • Monthly pet rent cap proposed under Int 1158 at 1% of the agreed rental amount.
  • Over 6,200 children in foster care placements at voluntary foster care agencies cited in context of rising liability insurance costs.
  • $16 billion in federal Gateway Tunnel funding reportedly conditioned by President Trump on renaming Penn Station.
  • Sigma Gamma Rho sorority founded in 1922; 50 members present at the meeting.
  • Donna retiring after 46 years of service to the New York City Council.
Action Points
  • DOT to install approved traffic safety treatments adjacent to schools within 120 days of approval, or 180 days for traffic signals, under Int 0202-A now enacted.
  • HPD and DOB to designate an interagency liaison and post conversion guidance online to support commercial-to-residential conversion applications under Int 0178-A now enacted.
  • HPD to submit annual reports to the Council and Department of Veterans Services on veteran applications and placements in Mitchell-Lama developments under Int 0488-A now enacted.
  • Department of Veterans Services to establish an LGBTQ+ liaison to assist veterans seeking discharge status upgrades and navigate federal VA processes under Int 0928-A now enacted.
  • City to fully exempt primary residences of permanently and totally disabled veterans with 100% service-related disability ratings from property taxes under Int 1051-A now enacted.
  • Council's Legislative Documents Unit to process all new bill introductions and refer to committees as indicated on the agenda.
  • CM Louis to lead community response in Flatbush following the building collapse and liaise with city agencies on behalf of affected constituents.
  • Council Veterans Committee and Speaker's office to host a veteran celebration in Council Chambers the following Monday at 5:30 PM; veterans to RSVP via Council website.
  • CM Sanchez's Transportation and Infrastructure Committee to hold a hearing on November 20 on the citywide rise in fire deaths, including Int 1174 and Int 1175.
  • CM Hankerson's Parks and Recreation Committee to hold a hearing the day following the meeting on water safety at city beaches, in connection with Int 1163.
  • DOB and relevant agencies to study electrical systems in aging residential apartment buildings under Int 1175 once enacted.
  • FDNY and relevant agencies to publish a public fire emergency data dashboard modeled on CompStat under Int 1174 once enacted.
  • Department of Correction to conduct outreach to formerly incarcerated individuals regarding unclaimed commissary funds under Int 1173 once enacted.
  • Department of Consumer and Worker Protection to enforce surveillance pricing ban and develop rules consistent with Int 0891 now enacted.
  • CM Brewer's working group bill (Int 1159) on agency communication technologies referred to Governmental Operations Committee for further review.
  • Council to transmit Resolution 560 calling for Fair Access to Co-ops for Veterans Act to US House, Senate, and President.
  • Council to transmit Resolution 718 endorsing Starbucks Workers United boycott to relevant parties once formally processed through committee.
  • CM Morano's Int 1166 referred to Housing and Buildings Committee for hearing on denying permits to developers with outstanding tax and utility debts.
  • MTA called upon via Res 0730 to study vacant subway retail spaces and establish veteran-owned business preferences in leasing, once resolution formally processed.
Download .txt
Full Transcript

(00:00:17)

Here. Well, yeah.

(00:00:17)

Are we ready?

Ladies and gentlemen, at this time, please place electronic devices and cell phones to vibrate. At this time, the Sergeant at Arms would like to congratulate Amanda Farías. Yeah. Ah, neat.

(00:00:52)

Sunglasses there we go. Well deserved. Majority Leader, it is all yours. Good afternoon and welcome to the

(00:01:15)

Stated Meeting of November 1, 2026.

I am Majority Leader Shaun Abreu. I would like to thank you for joining us. As a reminder, decorum must be respected at all times. If you would like to follow along, the agenda for today's meeting is posted on our website. On behalf of the body, I welcome the members of the public who have joined us today.

(00:01:37)

During Stated Meetings, only the members of the Council speak. Members of the public shall remain silent. If you wish to express your support of any remarks, you may make the silent approval gesture. Thank you.

(00:01:50)

Please join us for the Pledge of Allegiance.

1. Roll Call

(00:02:14)

Roll call.

Aldo? Bowl? Here. Arroyo? Avilés? Present. Banks? Here. Brewer? Brooks-Powers? Present. Cabán? De La Rosa? Here. Dinowitz? Here. Encarnación? Present. Epstein? I'm behind. It's a little weird, but yes, I'm here. Thank you. Barriers? President

2. Invocation

(00:03:10)

Felder, President. Police? Here. Thank you. Gennaro? Gutiérrez? Representative? Hanif? Here. Hanks? Thanks. Hudson? President Joseph? President Krishnan? Yeah. Lee? Here. Louis? Maloney? Yeah. Marte? President. Narcisse? Morano? Here. Narcisse? Present. Nurse? Oh, say I'm here. Paladino? Here. Restler? Here. Riley? President. Salaam? Sanchez? Not engaged. Pierina Sanchez? Present.

Santosuosso? Whoa! So? Here. Schulman? Yeah. Stevens? No. Thomas-Henry? Present. Oh, President. Vernikov? Williams? Here. Wilson? President. One? Present. One. Yeah, yeah. Carr? President. Abreu? President. Speaker, Menin? President. I'm, I'm here.

Also, CM Stevens is here. Thank you. We will now have today's invocation delivered by Captain Patrick Lime, Chaplain for Fort Hamilton in Brooklyn. Welcome, Captain Lime.

29.

Approved with Modifications and Referred to the City Planning

(00:05:59)

All right. Okay. My name is Chaplain Patrick Lime, but I was not invited here merely because of who I am, but because of the office and calling that I represent. I serve as the Garrison Chaplain at Fort Hamilton in Brooklyn, providing religious support to the 50,000 service members, family members, and retirees throughout the greater New York City metropolitan area. As a chaplain in the United States Army, my presence conveys the continuity of spiritual care to our service members, representing our sons and daughters charged with carrying our republic through some of the darkest recesses of human existence.

We represent the force that walks with them, and we bear on our colors and carry our lives. The marks of the religious traditions speak to courage, bravery, duty, mercy, sacrifice, and hope. We are present when questions of purpose no longer are abstract, when they become immediate, personal, and profound. But the military does not exist merely to project power. It exists to preserve the way of life that is ordered by liberty under law. Within

10305.

Motion to spread the Invocation in full upon the record by

(00:13:32)

that mission, the chaplaincy was established not as an optional comfort, but in recognition of the institutions that allow free citizens, even in uniform, to remain free in conscience.

It is for this reason that the chaplain's purpose is twofold and inseparable: to provide for the free exercise of religion by those who share the chaplain's own tradition, and to guarantee that every service member, regardless of their tradition, may likewise exercise their same liberties. It is customary on an occasion such as this for a chaplain to offer an invocation, to call upon God's presence and blessing. And while I assure you that God is present amongst us, I think that he came in during the roll call. What I would rather do is offer a benediction, a word from Latin, bene, meaning well or good, meaning to speak literally to speak of blessing over this body and its service to the people of New York City. So from my tradition, and with respect for all those gathered here: you receive the peace of God, which transcends all understanding.

May your hearts be inclined towards His goodness, justice, and mercy. The spirit of wisdom and truth grant you ears to hear and eyes to see, that you both perceive and understand. You walk with God, humbly, with discernment and in pursuit of peace and the prosperity of the city. I pray these things through Christ, our Lord. Amen.

Thank you, Captain Lime. I will now ask for unanimous consent to spread the invocation on the record.

3. Adoption of Minutes

4. Messages & Papers from the Mayor

5. Communications from City, County & Borough

6. Petitions and Communications

8. Communication from the Speaker

(00:14:26)

Thank you very much. I want to thank Chaplain Patrick Lime for joining us today and for that beautiful invocation. I think it's especially fitting that we have Chaplain Lime with us today, just one day after Veterans Day, and as this Council prepares to take up several important pieces of legislation to help the men and women who have served our country and live in New York City. Chaplain Lime knows something about service. He enlisted in the U.S. Army at just 17 years old, served as a combat medic, and spent 12 months deployed in Iraq.

But his service didn't end when he came home, as is the case for so many veterans. He answered another calling, entering the ministry, and eventually returning to active duty as an Army chaplain. Today he serves as the Garrison Chaplain at Fort Hamilton, right here in New York City. Among his many honors is the Four Chaplains Medal, named in memory of four military chaplains who gave their lives helping others aboard a sinking troop ship during World War II. It's a powerful reminder that service isn't just about what we're willing to do for others, but sometimes what we're willing to sacrifice for them.

I also want to recognize his beautiful family who have joined us today: his wife, Aaron, and his two children, Emily and Ethan. The whole family makes sacrifices too, so thank you for your service and for your sacrifice as well.

As Chairman of this Council's Veterans Committee, it is a particular honor to welcome someone who's devoted so much of his life to serving both God and country. Chaplain Lime, thank you for your service. Thank you for your prayers. Thank you for being here on such an important day for our city's veterans. I just wish you could have helped God deliver some better weather with that. I move for you to spread the invocation in full upon the record.

Thank you, Council Member. We will now ask CM Ariola... Henry, for the adoption of minutes.

I make a motion that the minutes of the Stated Meeting of October 22, 2026, be adopted.

Messages and papers from the Mayor: none. Communication from City, County, and Borough offices: 99. Controller's report.

Received, ordered, printed, and filed. Petitions and communications reconsidered. 100 Council appointments referred to the Rules Committee.

Land Use calendar: M 1101, Cozy Corner.

Thank you. Right now we will take a roll call vote on today's Land Use calendar. Alcohol, Land Use calls. I would like to thank you. Arroyo?

And I thank you. Avilés? Banks? Brewer? Yes. Brooks-Powers? High. Cabán? Yes, thank you. Dinowitz? High. Encarnación? Epstein? Yes, but ever. Yes. Police? I know. Gennaro? I thank you. Good. Years high. Hanif? Hanks? Hudson? High. Joseph? Krishnan? Lee? Louis? Maloney? Time. Marte? Mealy? Morano? Narcisse? Nurse? Oh, say I. Restler? High. Riley? Salaam? All right. Justin Sanchez? I. Pierina Sanchez? I thank you.

Santosuosso? So. Schulman? I. Stevens? Majority Leader Abreu? I am on all items on the City Agenda. Permission granted. I am on all. Thank you. Thank you, CM Stevens. Thomas-Henry? I. On. Inna Vernikov? How about? I. Wilson? I. One. Wong? I hope. Zhuang? I. CM Nurse? Let's call. I thank you. Car? I. Abreu? All right. Speaker, Menin? High. Could I? I was skipped over. CM One.

(00:14:33)

When your school ups.

(00:14:44)

Yes. I vote. I am Majority Leader. Could I please have permission to vote on all items on the agenda today?

(00:14:52)

Sorry. You're going to have to request, and now you have to ask permission from the Speaker's office. Okay, right now. That's remember, Louis, I.

(00:15:36)

One. Hang on, going on? Inna Vernikov? Moment, please. We can go back to CM Marte. That permission has been granted. Council Member, permission to have to vote. Aye, on all items on today's agenda.

Permission granted.

(00:16:03)

Thank you. You vote. CM Riley, aye, on all. Thank you. CM Bernick? Aye. I thank you. Today's Land Use calendar is adopted by a vote of 49 in the affirmative and the negative. Thank you. We will now have communications from Speaker Julie Menin.

Thank you so much, Majority Leader.

(00:16:36)

So today, my colleagues and I joined New Yorkers across the five boroughs in mourning the eight lives that were lost in the tragic collapse of a building in Flatbush. CM Louis represents that community. Myself and my office have been in constant touch with her. She is obviously on the ground, responding to her constituents.

Our needs, all of us here at the Council, are thinking of the families and the indelible loss that no words can make up for. We're also thinking of the 23 New Yorkers who are injured, including three brave firefighters, and we are certainly praying for their swift recovery. We're incredibly grateful for the approximately 250 first responders who raced to the scene and who have been working tirelessly throughout the night on these heroic rescue efforts. And I want to begin my remarks today with a moment of silence in the victims' honor.

(00:17:52)

Thank you. It's times like this which certainly remind us that whenever our city is staring tragedy in the face, New Yorkers have always been able to find solace in each other.

(00:17:53)

Today we also recognize the 25th anniversary of Flight 587, which devastated the Dominican community and the Belle Harbor neighborhood. We will always remember the 265 people who tragically died that day and how residents immediately came together to honor their lives. Hundreds of neighbors showed up at the crash site, bringing water and basic necessities on top of their love and condolences.

In times of grief, we clutch that united resolve and unconquered spirit. But we also carry it with us in the moments where we strive to build a better future as a city, as a state, as a nation.

On that note, last Tuesday, millions of Americans headed to the polls for the midterm elections, and of course, quite a few of us here in New York even went and voted early. Our democracy grows stronger every single time that we participate, so I want to thank our fellow New Yorkers and Americans for that ever-increasing strength.

Yesterday marked the start of the inaugural Art Week, which is a citywide festival dedicated to contemporary art. For the next two days, New Yorkers all across the city have free access to a truly unparalleled list of events, because art should be accessible to anyone and enjoyed by everyone, particularly in the midst of an affordability crisis. While this crisis shouldn't crush any working-class New Yorker, millions of residents are feeling its heavy weight: higher costs of gas, of groceries, of health insurance, and so much more.

There are so many factors

(00:19:46)

that are driving up costs, but some of them are quite obvious to consumers. But a more subtle

(00:19:52)

reason is the insidious and predatory corporate practice of surveillance pricing. Companies are collecting the personal information of New Yorkers and then using it to their detriment. For different consumers that are shopping at the same time, companies are oftentimes setting different prices on literally the exact same product, taking advantage of their demographic, web browsing history. Don't ever leave that shopping cart open when you

(00:20:19)

are buying something.

(00:20:23)

Shopping habits and social media activity, all to make New Yorkers pay more. An investigation found that, upon arriving at the parking lot of a department store, the price of a $100 item for one interested shopper who had been browsing online to look for it simply because the retailer had access to their location data through their phone and knew that they were about to walk into that store to buy it. Another revealed that a major grocery delivery platform was individualizing price differences right here in New York as high as 23% between customers.

It's a practice that erodes privacy. It's a practice that erodes fairness. It's a practice that worsens the affordability crisis. And today, it's a practice that we are going to ban, making us the first jurisdiction in the nation to ban surveillance pricing.

Earlier this year, I introduced legislation to prohibit businesses from using the individual data of consumers to set specific prices for them, whether it's tracking their mouse movements or mapping their location. Feel free to disagree. He's talking now, but I'm about to make a joke about him. Feel free to disagree with the Council. Epstein should not need to pay more than his constituents for pet food, even if an algorithm has his search history. He'd do anything for his dog Homer, and we all know that. To prevent these predatory tactics, companies would face fines of up to $1,000 for each violation. But to protect small businesses, we're allowing them to avoid being fined if they take immediate corrective action to fix the violation. And of course, New Yorkers can still benefit from legitimate and transparent discounts, whether it be loyalty programs, holiday discounts, or deals for veterans, students, or seniors, just to name a few.

This bill gives consumers more faith in the system, makes transactions more transparent, and deters corporations from using surveillance pricing to drive up costs. I'm working with our state partners, and we're laying a foundation to guarantee the highest level of protection for our consumers. This is building on ways in which the City Council is standing up for working New Yorkers, adding to the many steps the Council is taking to make this city more affordable for all.

Before I turn to the rest of our Stated Agenda, I also want

(00:22:59)

to acknowledge a bill that CM Farah Louis is

(00:23:02)

introducing today. In the midst of an affordable housing crisis, it is unconscionable that over 50,000 rent-stabilized units are sitting vacant and off the market right here in New York City, while so many New Yorkers are struggling to find an affordable place to live.

(00:23:22)

CM Louis's legislation works to rectify that.

(00:23:28)

It would require the city to conduct an analysis of the city's stock of rent-stabilized units and develop a plan to ensure that those units return to the market. It's crucial to our efforts to address the housing shortage, because it will finally help ensure more New Yorkers can secure affordable housing that should already be available to them. So thank you, CM Louis.

Yesterday we celebrated Veterans Day, and thank you to the colleagues who joined me at the Veterans Day Parade, saluting the brave men and women past and present who put their lives on the line to serve our country and our city. We honored the approximately 200,000 veterans who live right here in the five boroughs. For Our Freedom, we're going to be hosting a celebration for them in the Chambers next Monday at 5:30. All of our city's veterans are welcome to join us. You can RSVP on the Council's website, and I hope many of the colleagues can join.

(00:24:25)

This year for Veterans Day, we also wanted to put tangible action behind our gratitude, because for some of our veterans, their patriotic bravery came at an immense personal cost. Indeed, thousands of veterans in our city have a serious, permanent, service-related disability. The least we can do for those who sacrificed their health and their bodies is to ensure that they can afford to stay in their homes and live in the city and the country that they fought hard to defend.

(00:24:56)

Today we're voting on a bill that means if you are one of the thousands of veterans with a 100% service disability rating, you pay zero property tax on your home.

(00:25:07)

I want to thank CM Morano for that bill. I also want to recognize additional efforts of my colleagues to address other issues facing our veterans, and we have several other bills in our Veterans State Package.

(00:25:20)

Moving on to other celebrations. On November 1st, it was Día de los Muertos, when the spirits of deceased loved ones temporarily return to the physical world for the day. This past Sunday marked the start of Diwali, the Festival of Lights, celebrated by Hindus, Sikhs, and Buddhists. It honors the triumph of good over evil and over ignorance. I hope everyone who celebrated enjoyed a meaningful five days. It is Puerto Rican Heritage Month. Ah, thanks, Elsie. Thank you. From the Bronx to the South Bronx, Puerto Rican presence and contributions are felt everywhere and appreciated every single day.

(00:25:58)

It is also Native American Heritage Month. There are over 100,000 enrolled members of Native communities currently living in our city, and we will continue to celebrate their history, present, and future here. It is also National Diabetes Month, raising awareness of the medical condition that affects more than one in 10 New Yorkers in 2023. We passed CM Schulman's bill to establish a citywide diabetes reduction plan to ensure that all diabetic residents can access the care that they need.

(00:26:06)

Speaking of CM Schulman, I want to wish her a happy, belated birthday.

(00:26:23)

So we have some visitors with us today. Majority Leader Abreu has brought student journalists from the Urban Assembly Maker Academy. Thank you so much for joining us. I hope you enjoyed your mock press conference this morning, and I'm sure that you will be asking us very tough questions in the Red Room very, very soon.

(00:26:42)

And we can't wait to read your reporting and get literally the inside scoop. So thank you so much for being

(00:26:50)

So we have some visitors with us today. Majority Leader Abreu has brought student journalists from the Urban Assembly Maker Academy. Thank you so much for joining us. I hope you enjoyed your mock press conference this morning, and I am sure that you will be asking us very tough questions in the Red Room very, very soon.

(00:27:14)

And we cannot wait to read your reporting and get literally the inside scoop. So thank you so much for being

(00:27:21)

Here today, November 12 is Sigma Gamma Rho Day in our city. This sorority was founded in 1922 on principles of sisterhood, scholarship and service, and it is still going strong with 50 sisters here in the audience with us today. We want to thank CM Rita, who sponsored this resolution for the annual recognition. Welcome to the People's House. So thrilled to have you here.

(00:27:50)

And finally, I want to, which congratulations and farewell to a person who has worked for every single speaker of the New York City Council, and that's a subject. This, this kind of here.

(00:28:06)

Okay, we want to thank Donna for her 46 years of service, working at the heart of the Council as Assistant Director of Human Resources. Donna, thank you so much for everything that you've done, and none of us will be here without you. Any questions that we've had, you always had the answer. We're going to miss you here so much, and we wish you a very, very happy retirement. And now we're going to move on to our agenda. First, we'll vote on the following: the South Richmond Designated Open Space Amendment will correct longstanding mapping and record keeping errors and better align the district boundaries with the goals of the South Richmond Zoning Relief Plan adopted in November 2023, and CM Frank Morano as district. Studio 54 Rehabilitation and Text Amendment will facilitate the preservation of the iconic Studio 54 theater by allowing more flexibility for the sale of development rights within the theater subdistrict, straight in CM Carl Wilson's district.

15. Resolutions

(00:28:28)

Next, we're going to vote on the following finance items for reconsidered resolutions, all sponsored by CM Linda Lee: set the City of New York's real property tax rates for fiscal year 2020, and in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution of the State of New York, the Real Property Tax Law and the Charter of the City of New York.

(00:29:17)

Today we will also vote on the following pieces of legislation. Resolution 163, sponsored by Deputy Speaker Dr. Nantasha Williams, to designate the fourth week of as the Shangri-La Week in the City of New York and celebrate their indelible impact on the music of the 1960s and ever since. Thank you. Regina Paul.

(00:29:35)

Introduction 0178, sponsored by CM Harvey Epstein, would require the Department of Housing Preservation and Development, the Department of Buildings and other relevant city agencies to provide centralized technical assistance to developers and owners seeking to convert non-residential space into housing, via designating a liaison to facilitate interagency communications and respond to inquiries and posting guidance on the City's website. Thank you to Austin Malone, William Spencer and Jose Conde. Introduction to a sponsor

(00:30:03)

by CM Jennifer Rwould would require the Department of Transportation to install traffic safety improvements, including stop signs, speed reducers, traffic signals and designated school loading zones, within 120 days of determining through a traffic study that such improvements are appropriate on the streets adjacent to schools, or within 180 days for traffic signals. Subject to Miller introduction 0928. You

(00:30:41)

sponsor, right, CM David Carr, establish an LGBT Plus liaison within the Department of Veterans' Services. Thank you to Hannah Coan and Ran Away. Introduction 0888, sponsored by CM Inna Vernikov, require an annual report from the Department of Housing Preservation and Development on the number of veterans or their surviving spouses applying for housing in the City-run Mitchell-Lama developments, and the number of veterans being selected for occupancy, to ensure that applicants benefiting from a veteran preference are in fact veterans. Thank you to Rain

(00:31:14)

Ali. Introduction 1058, sponsored by CM Frank Morano, would provide that the primary residence of any permanently and totally disabled veteran shall be fully exempt from taxation and special district charges, assessments and special advalorem levies, provided that such veteran meets all other applicable requirements of Section 458 or 488 of the Real Property Tax Law. Thank you to Nicholas Canal

(00:31:50)

and Ran Away. And then Introduction 0891, sponsored by myself, would prohibit any entity or service provider from engaging in surveillance pricing, defined as pricing set completely or in part by algorithm that uses personal data to offer different prices to different customers for the exact same goods or services. Thank you.

(00:32:16)

To Sara Swain, Rachel Cordero, Natalie Meltzer and Sorrow Lois. Thank you for your attention, and turn it back over to the Majority Leader.

9. Discussion of General Orders

12. General Orders Calendar

16. General Discussion

(00:32:38)

Thank you, Speaker. Majority will now move into discussion of General Orders. I'd like to remind everyone that in debate all comments should be directed to the Chair. Thank you. We'll begin with CM Carl Wilson, followed by Pierina.

(00:32:47)

Thank you, Majority Leader. I'm proud to express my support today for Roundabout Theater Company's Studio 54 Rehabilitation and the land use application, and I hope my colleagues will join me in supporting this worthy endeavor. Studio 54 is an iconic part of New York City's cultural history. Preserving spaces like this is essential to keeping our cities arts and entertainment industry vibrant and accessible for generations to come. With the Council providing capital investment in and legislative support for the Studio 54 rehabilitation, we provide a model for preserving our unique cultural heritage while securing a flourishing future for the arts and culture in the city. Theater is more than just entertainment. It supports jobs, strengthens our local economy, brings visitors to our neighborhoods and creates opportunities for audiences and artists from all walks of life. I thank Roundabout Theater Company for its continued investment in New York City's arts and cultural landscape, and I look forward to seeing Studio 54 continue to thrive as an important part of the Broadway scene and our city's theatrical future. I also want to put it briefly to voice my support on this

(00:32:58)

Veterans Day week for Intro 0928, which would establish an LGBT services. I commend the LGBT Caucus colleague, Majority Leader Carr for his dedication to addressing the needs of LGBT vets. Thank you.

(00:33:20)

CM Morano, followed

(00:34:09)

by Minority Leader Carr. Thank you, Majority Leader. Yesterday was Veterans Day, and politicians all over the city marched in, gave speeches, issued proclamations and thanked our veterans for their service, and that's great. I did plenty of that myself.

(00:34:23)

But today we have a chance to do something that will actually make a difference in their lives, which is not something we get to do every day.

(00:34:27)

Intro 1051-A would completely eliminate property taxes on the primary residences of veterans who are permanently and totally disabled because of their military service. Not a discount, not a reduction. Zero property taxes. These are men and women who've already paid an extraordinary price for our freedom. The least we can do is help make sure they can afford to stay in their homes and stay in this city, not have to move to New Jersey, where they already do this, or move to Nassau County, where they already do this.

(00:34:41)

Now, getting to this point has been quite an adventure.

(00:34:49)

We've got 31 sponsors from all five boroughs, spanning just about every political ideology represented in the Council. And as we all know, there are quite a few ideologies represented in this Council. Every single member of the Veterans Committee, Democrats and Republicans alike, signed on, and I want to sincerely thank all 30 of my colleagues who joined me, and especially Speaker Menin for putting this bill on today's agenda. And Speaker Menin, your support and leadership helped make today possible. As the daughter of a veteran, I can't say that I'm surprised at the leadership you've demonstrated here. I

(00:35:25)

spent weeks calling, texting, chasing down colleagues, and frankly, I'm sure some members signed on just to get me to leave them alone. But think about what we're accomplishing here. I'm a Republican from the South Shore of Staten Island, and I've got colleagues sponsoring this bill who probably disagree with me on 95% of the issues we vote on. Some might think the other 5% are negotiable, but on this, we found common ground.

(00:35:29)

Thank you very much, and I encourage you to vote yes on Intro 1050.

(00:36:08)

Minority Leader Carr, followed by Councilman Mr. Epstein. Thank you, Majority Leader. I want to congratulate all my colleagues who are passing legislation today, in particular Chair Morano, CM Paladino, the package of legislation that we're putting forward the day after Veterans Day, thanks to the leadership of our Speaker, Julie Menin. Astonishing.

(00:36:33)

And I think my colleague hit the nail on the head: that we have to not just give speeches and give applause to our veterans. We have to follow that up with actions and deeds that actually support them, and we are doing that here today. In particular, I

(00:36:35)

just want to talk about my piece of legislation, which would create an LGBT liaison at the Department of Veterans' Services. As we know, for many decades, individuals who are gay or lesbian or bisexual, people who are not straight, could not serve openly in our armed forces. Thankfully, the repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell provided an avenue for veterans who were dishonorably discharged for no reason but their sexual orientation to get an other-than-honorable discharge. Despite that availability, many in New York City do not avail themselves of that, in large part because they don't know how, or don't even know that they can. Now there'll be someone whose job it is to reach out to them and to try to help them navigate the bureaucracy of the Department of Defense and to try to get their valor restored as it should be, because they served honorably, and that should be reflected in their record. So very happy to support this legislation. I want to thank all the advocates, in particular Brian Ellicott, for in the Speaker's team for supporting this particular piece of legislation. All my colleagues, in particular Chair Morano for his leadership at the Veterans Committee, as well as folks on the legislative team, Rationally Annacone, Andrea Vazquez, Jeff Baker and Johanna Castro, and on my team, Peter Spencer, Justin, Ba, Lucy and I. I encourage all my colleagues to support this legislation.

(00:37:00)

Thank you, CM Epstein, followed by CM Shulman. And thank you,

(00:37:13)

Majority Leader. First, I want to congratulate CM Morano and Carr on their important packages. Obviously, veterans, I say it was an important moment, and to do something for thousands of veterans, to be able to remain in New York, is a critical opportunity.

(00:38:40)

One, also, the Speaker Menin on Bill 891-A. Really, this idea about prohibiting surveillance pricing, and what we've seen happening across the city, and thank you for protecting my dog, Homer. I appreciate that as well. This idea, that I was on, I was with my mom, had something, and I checked my Uber and she checked hers. And literally they were going to the same place, and it was a $5 difference, literally from the same place, the same place. This is what's happening across the board, across industries, to consumers, to New Yorkers. This is an opportunity to prevent them from happening, but also protect. You know, the discounts are available, whether you're joining a Hilton Honors world word or going to a company, Jim or whatever. This is protecting those reductions, but also preventing these bad things from happening. We're seeing it happening. We know what's happening, and this is a way to get in front of it.

(00:38:46)

And finally, for my Bill 0978-A, we see that we need housing, and we need affordable housing across this great city. This bill requires that when you are converting commercial to residential conversions, there's a structure and system in place that the city puts in, so that developers and landlords can do that. With the vacancy rate of 1.4% and less than 1% for rent-stabilized units, as we need to do this, we know that a third of the building units that are being built or in these commercial-to-residential conversions, 25% of these conversion units are permanently affordable. This potentially could bring 17,000 new units online. If we do this conversion right, this bill will help us go right along in this direction. I encourage my colleagues to vote in favor of this bill. I appreciate the leadership support. Thank you. Thank you, CM Shulman.

(00:39:01)

Thank you, Majority Leader. We're voting today on a development in my district, 100-12 Queens Boulevard rezoning, and I want to tell people that this is a very unique circumstance here. First of all, I'm very proud of the fact that since I've been in the City Council, I brought a number of affordable housing units to my district, more so than in the past than has been done in the past.

(00:39:57)

This is going to result in a hundred affordable housing units, and not only that, but working with the owner who owns the property, there is a co-op behind it that had a lot of issues, and they're making a very, very big financial investment in that co-op to make sure that they have, that will help with this development. I want to thank them, and they're also going out of their way to make sure that the small local businesses are kept intact. We'll continue working with the community, so I'm very excited about it, and I'm asking my colleagues to please join me in voting for it. Thank you.

(00:40:53)

Thank you, Councilmember.

(00:41:16)

Seeing no one else signed up to speak on General Orders, going once. CM Inna

(00:41:56)

Vernikov.

(00:41:57)

Yes, Majority Leader. I am thrilled to see my bill, Intro 0248, hopefully pass, as part of today's veterans bill package. Introduction 0888 requires that the Department of Housing Preservation and Development produce a report on the number of veterans or their surviving spouses applying for housing in City Mitchell-Lama developments and the number of veterans being selected for occupancy, creating a clear way to measure progress. This bill also sends this report not just to the administration and Council, but crucially to the Department of Veterans' Services, whose central mission in our city is to connect, mobilize and empower veterans in New York City. I introduced this bill because too many veterans struggle to find quality housing, and too few of you know about the resources available to help them. The Mitchell-Lama veteran preference is a powerful tool for housing veterans and keeping them in our city. My legislative director, Troy Olson, an Army veteran and veteran advocate, has personally housed homeless veterans using this preference. We've also worked with veterans who have lived in Mitchell-Lama housing. They testified to its high quality while noting its shortcomings, and lamenting how few veterans know it exists. This benefit is currently underutilized. This bill will make an existing government structure work better and reach the people it was meant to serve.

I'd like to thank Speaker Menin, Committee Legislative Analyst Rain Ali, Legislative Policy Analyst Manner Abbot, the Department of Veterans' Services, and thank you to Veterans Committee Chair, Councilman Morano, and everyone else who helped bring this bill forward and take this meaningful step toward housing our veterans. And, of course, thank you to the 200,000 veterans living in New York City for your service.

(00:42:06)

Thank you.

(00:42:06)

Thank you, Councilmember.

(00:43:51)

Seeing no one else signed up to speak for General Orders.

10. Reports of Special Committees

11. Reports of Standing Committees

(00:43:54)

Report of Special Committees, none. Reports of Standing Committees. Reported of the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection, Intro 0291-A, surveillance pricing, amended and coupled on General Orders. Reported, the Committee on Finance, pre-considered resolutions 0723 through 0726, tax amending resolutions in General Orders. Reported of the Committee on Housing and Buildings, Intro 0278-A, building conversions, amended in capital orders. Reported, the Committee on Land Use, applications 0148, 0149, 0150 and 0151, various applications approved with modifications and referred to the City Planning Commission, 0252 and 0736, South Richmond Designated Open Space Amendment, held over on General Orders, 0153 and 0152, 0737 and 0954 and 0738, Studio 54 Rehabilitation and Text Amendment, the rappelled. Reported, the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure, Intro 0928 and 0288, school safety treatments, amended and coupled on General Orders. Report of the Committee on Veterans, Intro 0288, veteran preference in Mitchell-Lama developments, amended and coupled on General Orders. Intro 0928, LGBT Plus liaison, amended and coupled. Intro 1051, disabled veterans exemption, amended and coupled.

(00:43:55)

Items coupled on today's General Orders calendar. CM Louis, CM Lewis.

(00:43:58)

Relation to vote on all items on General Calendar. Permission granted. Lodi on all.

(00:44:07)

Thank you. Thank you, gentlemen. Aldo Bold, I've got my eye on all Arriola.

(00:45:17)

I vote on all with the exception of pre-considered

(00:45:35)

Step into Eric through 726 and an Intro 891, for which I am. I know. Thank you. Come from Aviles, Ayan, all Banks, I annoy Brewer.

(00:45:41)

Yes, except 1051. I can vote because Brooks-Powers about I, and I congratulate everyone passing bills today, especially my colleague, Councilman Morano, in terms of the tax exemption for the veterans, my veterans, and you start time, please, was extremely pleased to hear of this, so I proudly vote and support of that. Thank you.

(00:45:50)

Thank you. Come on, I, Arnold, thank you, De La Rosa. I don't know.

(00:45:53)

Dinner wits. I, I don't Encarnacion. How about I know Epstein, I, and all Farias, Ana Felder. I vote yes on on everything besides raise 723 through 726. On those I vote no. Mmm. Felice. About what I

(00:46:15)

Yes, except 1051. I can vote, because Brooks-Powers, and I congratulate everyone passing bills today, especially my colleague, CM Morano, in terms of the tax exemption for the veterans. My veterans, and... you start time, please. I was extremely pleased to hear of this, so I proudly vote in support of that. Thank you.

(00:46:52)

Thank you. Come on, I, Arnold, thank you, De La Rosa. I don't know.

(00:47:01)

Dinner wits. I don't... Encarnación. How about I know Epstein, I, and all Farías, Ana Felder. I vote yes on everything besides Res 0723 through 0726. On those I vote no. Mmm. Feliz. About what I

(00:47:32)

Congratulations to everyone passing bills, including and especially CM Morano. Our veterans have sacrificed so much for our country, and we need to look out for them.

(00:47:45)

Gennaro, I thank you. Good. Sierra's permission to explain my vote, permission granted.

(00:47:52)

Thank you. First, I want to congratulate Speaker Menin on banning surveillance. I think it is so important to really uplift the fact that these tech companies are getting away with so much more than we are privy to, and it is a great opportunity for New York to lead. So I want to congratulate you, Speaker. I also want to take a moment to vote on Intro 202 before you clock me. I just want to quickly thank some of the folks that helped us get to the finish line with Intro 202, which we are passing today. First up, I want to thank the committee, who was such a great person to have in our corner and helping to negotiate with the administration. I want to congratulate my new comms director, who has been here for a month and already passed a bill, Madeleine McGillivray. I want to thank our awesome, awesome parents, advocates, and our Congresswoman. Thank you, Gives Squares. In her district director Evelyn Crews, who for decades has been fighting for smarter and more urgent street mitigations, particularly in school zones, particularly on the south side of Williams. So I just want to thank her for her accountability and advocacy. Intro 200 will create a firm standard for action while recognizing that major transportation projects require separate timelines. It is really an accountability measure. If the Department of Transportation has approved safety mitigation within a school zone, there is no reason that we should be delaying years and years and years.

For many of us who have been fighting to get some simple solutions, like a speed bump, or maybe something more complicated, like a traffic signal, this will put them on a timeline. It will create more transparency and accountability for your district and your constituents. I also want to thank the administration for meeting me halfway and helping to pass Intro 200.

(00:49:35)

Thank you so much. Thank you. And I thank Carson, Hanks, Hudson. I know Joseph, I know Christiane, I Lee, I, Anne, all Maloney.

(00:50:06)

I, Ayanna Martin. I am Millie Moron. Old. Explain my vote briefly, permission granted. I vote aye on all, with the exception of 723

(00:50:24)

through 726 and Intro and 91A, on Intro 251A. I do want to extend my gratitude to the staff of the Veterans Committee, especially Mark Norbutte and Raina Li, my chief of staff Frank Ratpatrol, who has done a yeoman's job helping Marshall, my colleagues. On this, my legislative counsel, Pat Rousseau. I also want to thank the chairperson of the State Senate Committee on Veterans, Jessica Scarsella Spanta, who, in addition to being a terrific elected official from Staten Island, is the spouse of a disabled veteran. It has been great partnering with her throughout this process. Thank you again, everyone. Narcisse.

(00:50:59)

Permission to expand my remarks. Permission granted.

(00:51:10)

I just want to say, my heart goes to the family that I used to see every day, and for those that thought that building the demolished was mine. No, it's not mine, but I have seen those folks every day, and I feel sorry for what happened. I was there for many years with them. It is so sad. And I have to say to the veterans, they put all the veterans out there, and thank you for opening your doors. I spent a lot of time with veterans yesterday. And on that note, I would die for everything. Nurse, I vote. Oh, say I would die on all.

(00:51:12)

Allay, Dino, I vote aye on all except

(00:51:46)

Hundred 2326 and Intro 891? I too would like to acknowledge our veterans. Thank you. Two of my colleagues and Chairman Frank Morano for putting together on board today and voted upon, and our heartfelt gratitude and thank you very much, everybody, and to the veterans. Most important of all, Resolutions 723 through 726. I stand corrected. Thank you. Thank you, Rustler.

13. Introduction & Reading of Bills

14. Discussion of Resolutions

(00:51:54)

I just want to congratulate Cuts. Remember good, it is on a great bill that will hold accountable to make areas around schools safer. Thank you. Excuse me. Thank you, Riley. I don't know, Salaam, but I. Justin Sanchez, I know Molina Sanchez, aye on all. Thank you. Santos! Whoa! So. I know. Shulman, permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Thank you. I want to congratulate Minority Leader Car and Frank Morano on their bills, and particularly, a minority made a car in terms of protecting the community and those that serve our country. Members that serve our country. I want to thank Speaker Permanent for the surveillance bill. Someone who orders from these apps, and every time I order something, it comes up that says, hi, the price that you are paying is based on an algorithm that we develop for you. So hopefully it won't be seeing it anymore. With that, I vote aye on all. Thomas Henry, aye. I know Vernick, aye. I and all, with the exception of Resolutions 723 through 726 and Intro 91A, on which I vote no. Congratulations to my colleague CM Morano on passing his Veterans bill package. Thank you, Councilman Williams. Whatever. Wilson, I vote aye. One. Okay, I vote? Yes. I know, except for Resolution 723, 724, 725, and 726, in which I vote no. Thank you. Shuang. I vote aye on all. Vote no on Resolutions 723 through 726. Thank you. Car. You don't know on pre-considered Resolution 723, 724, 725, 726 as well as Introduction 891A, and I own the rest.

About you, I Menin, I all items on today's general order calendar are adopted by a vote of 49 affirmative. Tensions with the exception of Intro 891, which was adopted by a vote of 44 in the affirmative, five of the negative, and tensions, and Intro 1051A, which was adopted by a 48 in the affirmative. One in the negative and zero abstention. And Resolutions 723, 724, 725, and 726, which was adopted by a vote of 41 of the affirmative, in the negative, and zero abstentions. With that, introduction and reading of bills. All those even referred to committee as indicated on today's agenda. Thank. We will now move into the discussion of resolutions. I don't see anyone signed up for resolutions being voted on today. All right, that's the first. I think that is the first. We will now have a voice vote on today's resolutions. If you wish to vote against, abstain from any of today's resolutions, please notify the Legislative Documents Unit by email or by approaching the dais. I will now read today's resolutions into the record. Resolution 163A designates the fourth week of as the Shangri-Las week in the City of New York and celebrates their indelible impact on the music of the 1960s and ever since. All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. Any abstentions? The ayes have it.

Resolution 560 calls on the United States House of Representatives, the United States Senate to introduce and pass a companion bill, and the President to sign such legislation to enact the Fair Access to Co-ops for Veterans Act of 2025. All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. Any abstentions? The ayes have it. We will now move into general discussion, beginning with Counsel Mr. Rouhani, followed by Pierina Sanchez. Thank you. I'm speaking on two resolutions I introduced this afternoon. Resolution 722 is a measure in support of Senator Bernie Sanders' American Wealth Fund Act, Senate Bill 4825. This legislation would impose a one-time 50% tax on the largest companies to a sovereign wealth fund. The proliferation of AI has created an incredible opportunity, and yet has resulted in significant harmful societal impacts, including content piracy and copyright infringement, data centers polluting local communities' water supply, ballooning electricity costs. The list goes on. S 4825 would provide the American people with their fair share of the riches generated through firms' use of their own data. Let's get New York. Resolution 721 honors the life of disability rights activist Becky Ogle. Becky was pivotal in the passage of the ADA. The law was fully implemented throughout our nation. She challenged inaccessible institutions and businesses in the courts and mobilized thousands to block efforts to weaken it over the past 30 years.

Becky was a vital leader of numerous presidential and local election campaigns, working with candidates to ensure people with disabilities played a key part in shaping policy. Becky passed away on October 18, 2026, and will forever be remembered for her advocacy, accomplishments, and impact on disability rights. Please join me in honoring her legacy through support for this Council resolution. Thank you. Thank you, Counselor Pierina Sanchez, followed by Narcisse. Thank you, Majority Leader. First and foremost, my deepest condolences to CM Louis's community and families and the neighbors devastated by yesterday's building collapse. It was a horrific tragedy, and I know our Council stands ready to support you and your constituents. We also need to secure a full public accounting of what occurred. The disaster underscores our broader imperative as well: the city must prevent dangerous building conditions before they become catastrophes. New Yorkers are reeling from a devastating rise in fires this year. Almost 90 people have died this year compared to the same time period last year, which is twice as much as the previous year. From Sunset Park and Washington Heights to my haven and the West Bronx, families are enduring relentless loss. Our first responders are heroic once emergencies begin, but prevention requires confronting underlying hazards.

More than 80% of our buildings in the city are over 50 years old, and consumer products like lithium-ion batteries and aging electrical systems in older buildings pose the most frequent risk to New Yorkers. That's why I'm introducing, and I hope my colleagues will support, Intro 1174, which would create an online data dashboard of fire emergencies, think NYPD's COMPSTAT, but for fires, and Intro 1175, which would direct the Department of Buildings, in collaboration with other agencies, to conduct a review of the electrical systems of aging apartment buildings. I look forward to hearing both bills on November 20 hearing on fires. Thank you, Majority Leader, and thank you, Speaker, for making sure these bills were prepared expeditiously. Thank you, CM Counselor. Followed by Chavez-Vananah. Thank you, Majority Leader. This still that I'm introducing, and one of them is

(00:52:01)

Two of my colleagues and Chairman Frank Morano for putting together a board today that was voted upon. Our heartfelt gratitude and thank you very much, everybody, and to the veterans. Most important of all, Int 0823 through 0706 — I stand corrected. Thank you. Thank you, Lincoln Restler.

(00:52:39)

Thank you, Restler.

(00:52:39)

I want to congratulate CM Cabán. This is a great bill that will hold accountable those who make areas around schools safer. Thank you. Excuse me. Thank you. Riley? I don't know. Salaam, but I know Justin Sanchez, and Shekar Krishnan, and all. Thank you.

Santos! Whoa! So. I know. Shulman, permission to explain my vote. Permission granted. Thank you. I want to congratulate Minority Leader Ariola and Frank Morano on their bills, and particularly the bill that protects the community and serves those who serve our country. I want to thank Speaker Menin for the surveillance bill. Someone who orders from these apps every time sees a message saying the price you are paying is based on an algorithm we developed for you. Hopefully it won't be seeing that anymore. With that, I vote aye on all. Thomas-Henry, aye. Vernikov, aye.

I vote aye on all items on today's agenda, with the exception of Resolutions 723 through 726 and Introduction 891-A, on which I vote no. Congratulations to my colleague CM Morano on passing his veterans bill package. Thank you, CM Williams. Wilson, I vote aye.

Okay, I vote yes on all, except for Resolutions 723, 724, 725, and 726, on which I vote no. Thank you. Shuang? I vote aye on all, and vote no on Resolutions 723 through 726. Thank you. Car. Don't know on pre-considered Resolutions 723, 724, 725, and 726, as well as Introduction 891-A. I vote aye on the rest. About you, Menin, I vote aye on all items on today's General Order Calendar, which were adopted by a vote of 49 affirmative, with the exception of Intro 891-A, which was adopted by a vote of 44 in the affirmative, five in the negative, and zero abstentions. Intro 1051-A was adopted by a vote of 48 in the affirmative, and one in the negative, with zero abstentions. Resolutions 723, 724, 725, and 726 were adopted by a vote of 41 in the affirmative, zero in the negative, and zero abstentions. With that, introduction and reading of bills. All those in favor, say aye. Those bills are referred to committee as indicated on today's agenda. Thank you. We will now move into the discussion of resolutions. I don't see anyone signed up for resolutions being voted on today. All right, that's the first. I think that is the first. We will now have a voice vote on today's resolutions. If you wish to vote against or abstain from any of today's resolutions, please notify the Legislative Documents Unit by email or by approaching the dais. I will now read today's resolutions into the record.

Resolution 463-A designates the fourth week of [month] as the Shangri-Las week in the City of New York and celebrates their indelible impact on the music of the 1960s and ever since. All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. Any abstentions? The ayes have it. Resolution 560 calls on the United States House of Representatives and the United States Senate to introduce and pass a companion bill, and the President to sign such legislation to enact the Fair Access to Co-ops for Veterans Act of 2025. All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. Any abstentions? The ayes have it. We will now move into general discussion, beginning with Counsel, Mr. Rouhani, followed by Pierina Sanchez. Thank you. I'm speaking on two resolutions I introduced this afternoon. Resolution 722 is a measure in support of Senator Bernie Sanders' American A.I. Sovereign Wealth Fund Act, Senate Bill 4825. This legislation would impose a one-time 50% tax on the largest companies to fund a sovereign wealth fund. The proliferation of AI has created an incredible opportunity, and yet has resulted in significant harmful societal impacts, including content piracy and copyright infringement, data centers polluting local communities' water supply, ballooning electricity costs. The list goes on. S.4825 would provide the American people with their fair share of the riches generated through firms' use of their own data. Resolution 721 honors the life of disability rights activist Becky Ogle.

Becky was pivotal in the passage of the ADA and was fully implemented throughout our nation. She challenged inaccessible institutions and businesses in the courts and mobilized thousands to block efforts to weaken it over the past 30 years. Becky was a vital leader of numerous presidential and local election campaigns, working with candidates to ensure people with disabilities played a key part in shaping policy. Becky passed away on October 18, 2026, and will forever be remembered for her advocacy, accomplishments, and impact on disability rights. Please join me in honoring her legacy through support for this Council resolution. Thank you. Counselor Pierina Sanchez, followed by Narcisse.

Thank you, Majority Leader. First and foremost, my deepest condolences to CM Louis's community and the families and neighbors devastated by yesterday's building collapse. It was a horrific tragedy, and I know our Council stands ready to support you and your constituents. We also need to secure a full public accounting of what occurred. The disaster underscores our broader imperative as well: the City must prevent dangerous building conditions before they become catastrophes. New Yorkers are reeling from a devastating rise in fires this year. Almost 90 people have died this year compared to the same time period last year, which is twice as many as the previous year. From Sunset Park and Washington Heights to my district and the West Bronx, families are enduring relentless loss. Our first responders are heroic once emergencies begin, but prevention requires confronting underlying hazards. More than 80% of our buildings in the City are over 50 years old, and consumer products like lithium-ion batteries and aging electrical systems in older buildings pose the most frequent risk to New Yorkers. That's why I'm introducing, and I hope my colleagues will support, Intro 1174, which would create an online data dashboard of fire emergencies, think NYPD's CompStat, but for fires, and Intro 1175, which would direct the Department of Buildings, in collaboration with other agencies, to conduct a review of the electrical systems of aging apartment buildings.

I look forward to hearing both bills on November 20 at the hearing on fires. Thank you, Majority Leader, and thank you to the Speaker for making sure these bills were prepared expeditiously.

Thank you, Council Member. Counselor Ossé, followed by Sanchez, then Cabán. Thank you, Majority Leader. This is still that I'm introducing, and one of them is

(01:01:59)

Intro 967 gives the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection clear authority to seize stores. We each and every one of us have seen it: the e-cigarettes illegally sold to our kids. So now we need to put a stop to that. Enough is enough. Then we have raised 728. Do you know that right now, a woman, oh, men can be intoxicated to the highest and still the concept is not valid. So now we need to say that has to change. This state has already fixed this, so New York City should do the same. Thank you to my colleagues for seeing this. We need to push forward on that.

(01:02:44)

Um, I have an issue in my district. You have seen it. It is so hard, so right now. I want. I need help, because when you have a school directly, middle school that is directly next to the 200 shelter for male... that stuff, guys, parents are cursing me out. I have been really tough, and we in the area, do you know that we have to pay, by the way, for infrastructure? Every time I say that, people ignore me. We have to pay to entrances. We have to pay an entrance for FEMA, and we have to pay an entrance for regular entrance for our home, and we live on the water. We have it. So I need help, Speaker. I need help. There is...

(01:03:27)

No reason we should be building. They erected a building less than a year ago, and it looks very frail as it is, and now they're going to put another building next to it. This is the time we have conversations. We have to house folks.

(01:03:41)

Absolutely. I'm a nurse. I used to do the entry program, and I understand that, but we have to talk to the folks that live in the community to make a plan that could be inclusive.

(01:03:51)

Thank you, CM Showman, followed by Aldebol, and we'll come back to Gabon later.

(01:04:00)

Thank you, Majority Leader. Today I'm proud to introduce an important piece of legislation to help address critical gaps in health care within our correction system.

When someone enters the criminal justice system, their health needs do not simply go away. Someone brought into booking may have chronic medical conditions, be experiencing a behavioral health crisis, or need daily life-saving medication. Yet our current correction system lacks the comprehensive screening and resources needed to identify and address these health needs before someone is arraigned. My legislation, Intro 1176, aims to address this issue by strengthening pre-arraignment health screening. It would establish health screenings at central booking facilities across the city. It would establish a two-level screening process, provide access to trained medical professionals and continuity of care, and provide that individuals who need further evaluation or treatment receive it. At its core, this legislation is about making sure that people who enter the criminal justice system with health care needs do not fall through the cracks.

(01:05:00)

I want to thank my co-prime sponsor, Deputy Speaker Nantasha Williams, for her support. I encourage my colleagues to sign on to this important legislation. Thank you, Council Member. Oh, safe

(01:05:11)

Followed by Wilson. Thank you, President. Today I am proud to introduce Introduction 1168, known as the Unconscionable Consumer Abuse Prevention Act, also known as the UNCAPPED Act, in partnership with Mayor Mamdani and the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. We are prepared to ensure our consumer protection laws set a national standard. The UNCAPPED Act will cut red tape, reduce bureaucratic barriers, and embolden the city to act faster against unconscionable business practices. Even

(01:05:42)

As elected officials, we all share the experience of constantly navigating a marathon, a fine print.

(01:05:49)

Unconscionable, unconscionable business practices can mean charges without people's knowledge, the doom loop of endless dead ends without a human on the other end. We're talking about selling people's personal information, one-sided contract changes that let companies swap, companies' health data. I can just keep going on and on and on. But right now, the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, you cannot challenge this conduct without the city's consumer protection laws cutting months of rulemaking requirements. So big businesses think twice before screwing over New Yorkers. Simply put, bureaucracy cannot be the enemy of getting stuff done. This is about faster results for the New Yorkers who are the backbone of our economy and breathe life into the greatest city on earth. I look forward to passing this bill with the support of the Mayor, Commissioner Levin, and Committee Chair Epstein. I urge my colleagues to co-sponsor this critical piece of legislation to give our city the authority to hold these bad guys accountable and make life much easier for the people we represent. Thank you very much.

(01:06:57)

Thank you, CM Counselor Wilson, followed by Brewer. Thank you, Majority Leader.

(01:07:03)

Cooling and warming centers are community touchstones for New Yorkers looking for relief in harsh weather. Some visitors might come just to get a quick respite from the heat or cold, while others might have more serious issues, a landlord who won't fix broken utilities, housing and security, or a lack of access to adequate health care. The city is missing an opportunity by not using cooling and warming centers to connect visitors to resources and information they might need. The two bills I'm introducing today, Intros 1180 and 1181, would have New York City Emergency Management, who oversees cooling centers and who oversees warming centers, offer each center the option of hosting an agency staff member who could... then link visitors to city services. These bills will imbue cooling and warming centers with greater utility and assist those in need, and I hope my colleagues would consider joining me on these two important bills. Thank you very much.

(01:07:58)

Thank you, Counselor Brewer, followed by Riley.

(01:08:02)

Thank you. Just in terms of an intro to talk about agency communication technologies. I think we all know that we rely on digital communication these days for services, but there's been no comprehensive assessment of how these systems are being used, whether they are effective, and whether they are accessible to everyone. This would have an examination of agency practices. Number two, Intro 707 would establish a state-backed risk pool. This is a much-needed update to reimbursement rates to reflect rising liability insurance costs and create a bridge fund to help voluntary foster care agencies maintain coverage. There are over 6,200 children in this situation in the particular agencies, and the costs, like elsewhere, are over the moon. Penn Station, renaming, and basically don't touch it, President Trump. He said he wouldn't release the $16 billion in federal funding for the Gateway Tunnel, unless we rename Penn Station after him. And Penn Station's carriage, its name for a century, is Penn Station. It's a hub, and renaming it would create unnecessary confusion and expense without improving service. So don't do it. That's what this resolution says. Thank you very much.

(01:09:30)

Thank you, Counselor. Counselor O'Reilly, followed by Morano.

(01:09:33)

Thank you, Majority Leader. Colleagues, today I'm proud to introduce two pieces of legislation focused on the simple principle that opportunities should be accessible to every New Yorker. Our young people are creating innovation and building careers through digital media, but too often the lack of safe, accessible spaces forces them into environments that put their safety at risk and limit their potential. Int 0169-2026 establishes the Safe Spaces for Creatives Pilot Program through the Mayor's Office of Media and Entertainment, providing content creators ages 30 and under with free, secure spaces in City facilities to develop their skills, produce content, and transform their creativity into opportunity. We shouldn't just celebrate young people's potential. We should invest in it.

(01:10:13)

I'm also introducing Res 0730-2026, calling on the MTA to revitalize vacant subway retail spaces and newsstands by prioritizing opportunities for veteran-owned businesses. Subway systems are full of retail spaces that sit vacant. These are missed opportunities to support small businesses, strengthen economic activity, and create more vibrant, welcoming spaces for commuters. This resolution is about putting those spaces back to work while furthering our commitment to the men and women who served our country, creating pathways to entrepreneurship and economic stability for our veterans. Our public spaces should serve our communities, not sit empty while opportunities pass by. I urge my colleagues to support these measures and help us build a city where more New Yorkers have the space and opportunity to succeed.

(01:11:10)

Thank you. Thank you, Counselor. Counselor Morano, followed by Joseph.

(01:11:13)

Thank you, Majority Leader. There's an old saying that you can't get blood from a stone, but apparently in New York City, you can get a building permit from the Department of Buildings even when you owe the city tens of thousands of dollars. Today I am introducing Int 1166-2026 to close that loophole. Under current law, if a property owner owes the city $25,000 or more in certain fines and penalties, the city can deny them a permit for a major construction project. But here's the kicker: if you owe $25,000 in unpaid property taxes or water and sewer bills, those debts don't count. How does that make any sense? I have a developer in my district involved in a very controversial proposed homeless shelter, and that situation has caused me to take a much closer look at how the city deals with developers who are going to make a lot of money. Frankly, I don't always like what I see. My bill applies one simple principle: before City Hall gives you permission to build something new, you ought to settle up with City Hall for what you already owe. We're keeping the existing $25,000 threshold, protecting necessary safety work, and preserving exceptions for people who are disputing their bills or complying with payment plans. This isn't a Republican or Democratic issue. It is a taxpayer issue, because the homeowner in Tottenville who pays every property tax bill shouldn't be held to a higher standard than a developer building a multimillion-dollar project.

I ask my colleagues to join me in supporting Int 1166-2026. Before we ask New Yorkers to pay more, let's make sure we're collecting what we're already owed. Thank you.

(01:12:58)

CM Joseph, followed by Thank the majority leaders, speak, thank their colleagues, honored guests, and my beloved sorority. One hundred years ago today, seven young Black women at Butler University looked at a nation that had not made room for them yet. They didn't wait for permission. They didn't wait for a seat at the table. They built their own table and set it for service. Though a picture of a classroom teacher from Brooklyn standing here as a member of the New York City Council, they planted the seed anyway. Our motto is "Greater Service, Greater Promise, Greater Progress." That is the promise we owe to every child in a classroom, every family fighting to keep their neighborhood and their homes in the Fortieth District. So to my sorors, the founders lit the torch. Now it's in our hands. Let's carry it higher. Let's carry this torch further. Happy founders' day. Thank you, Majority Leader.

(01:13:53)

Thank you, Counselor. Council Members, followed by Hankerson.

(01:13:57)

Thank you, Majority Leader. The past two weeks have been incredibly difficult for New York City. We have one tragedy after another, and each one reminds me how fragile life can be. In my district, we lost six beautiful lives in a devastating fire. As a member of this community, my heart is with the families who are grieving, and with everyone who has been affected. A whole life has been changed by this tragedy, but through every tragedy, one thing remains constant. Our first responders show up. Firefighters, EMTs, and police officers run toward emergencies when others are running away. They provide comfort and sometimes the difference between life and death. I have seen firsthand how much our communities depend on them, and I believe thanking them is not enough. We must also give them the resources, the protection, and the support they deserve. They face unequal pay, staff shortages, and outdated equipment. These are not just a workforce issue. They are a public safety issue. So how can we expect these challenges to be addressed without a dedicated department? This is why I am reintroducing Int 1182-2026. Let's establish a dedicated Department of Emergency Medical Services. Our EMS workers deserve dedicated leadership, fair compensation, proper resources, and the recognition they have earned. Colleagues, when our community faces the darkest moments, they show up for us. Now it's our turn to show up for them. I urge my colleagues to support Int 1182-2026. Thank you.

(01:16:03)

Thank you, Councilmember. CM Hankerson, followed by Santosuosso. Thank you.

(01:16:06)

Thank you, Majority Leader. Every summer, thousands of New Yorkers head to our beaches to cool off, spend time with family and friends, and enjoy our city's waterfront. But what many people don't realize is that the water can look perfectly calm while dangerous conditions exist beneath the surface. Rip currents can develop quickly, water conditions can change throughout the day, and too often people don't know the risk until it is too late. That's why I'm proud to introduce Int 1163-2026, requiring digital water safety signage at New York City beaches. These signs will provide beachgoers with timely information about water conditions, rip current risk, and other important safety warnings. Because when it comes to water safety, information can be the difference between life and death. I want to be clear: this legislation isn't about replacing lifeguards. It's about giving them another tool to keep New Yorkers safe. No parent should have to wonder whether the water their child is entering is safe, and no New Yorker should have to learn about dangerous rip currents or what to do after they've already entered the ocean. As chair of the Committee on Parks and Recreation, I believe our responsibility doesn't end with making our parks and beaches successful. We must also make them safer. That's why I encourage all of my colleagues to attend our Parks Committee hearing tomorrow, where we will be discussing the state of water safety in our city's beaches. Thank you. Thank you.

(01:17:37)

CM Carr, who also followed by Justin Sanchez, and then Tiffany Cabán. Thank you, Majority Leader.

(01:17:46)

I want to take a moment to acknowledge a 28-year-old young woman who was brutally murdered in my district in the last couple of weeks, and that is Katie Suarez. You've probably heard her name on the news. She went out jogging around eight on the promenade that runs along the edge of my district, along the water. She did not return home on time, and unfortunately her father then went out looking for her and discovered her body lying on the promenade. It is a horrific tragedy. I attended the wake yesterday and was able to give my condolences to the family, but I feel that there is action that must be taken, and that is to ensure that there is adequate lighting along the promenade. This is something people in my district have been calling for for decades, and we have been met with pushback every step of the way. I think in this moment we can acknowledge that we can't always control everything, but in order to make some places safer, lighting is an easy way to make a place safer. Lighting is safety. Lighting makes us feel safer.

(01:18:50)

And I'm going to be focusing a lot of attention and resources on trying to get promenade lighting along the promenade, where so many people like Katie go for an evening run and should have the ability to feel safe while doing so. I have been moved by recent reports that Katie was an organ donor. After she passed, she saved the lives of four other people by donating her organs, and I think that in her name, it is only right that we continue saving lives in her honor by ensuring that the promenade she loved to run on is safe for everybody else to run in for years to come. Thank you so much.

(01:19:02)

Thank you, CM Carr. CM Justin Sanchez, followed by Carmen. Thank you.

(01:19:42)

Today I'm proud to introduce two bills and one resolution aimed at addressing a host of issues residents are experiencing in the South Bronx. Each piece of legislation is part of a multifaceted approach to address quality of life, improve public safety, and expand opportunities for residents to take ownership of their communities. Reclaiming our streets means holding delivery companies accountable for abandoned totes. As last-mile delivery companies like Amazon expand their operations across New York City, abandoned delivery totes and plastic bins have become increasingly common on sidewalks, stoops, and entry pits. This legislation would authorize the Department of Sanitation to charge a responsible shipping company a per-container fee. This bill would protect public spaces, reduce litter, save taxpayers money, and encourage more responsible delivery practices. Reclaiming our parking means putting Bronx residents first. For many South Bronx residents, finding a parking space near their homes has been a daily challenge. Residential streets are lined with abandoned vehicles and cars with out-of-state plates, many of which are owned by residents looking to evade registration fees. This legislation would require the Department of Transportation to establish a residential parking permit program in the South and the Southeast Bronx. Reclaiming our public spaces also means creating opportunities for local mural artists. The largest mural in the country was unveiled in the South Bronx.

I know everyone is asking, "What about us?" This legislation would establish a centralized online portal connecting artists with available opportunities across the five boroughs, making it easier for artists to find projects and for property owners, community organizations, and city agencies to connect with local talent. Reclaiming our money and our freedom means returning unclaimed commissary funds to formerly incarcerated New Yorkers. According to the Department of Correction, approximately [amount] in unclaimed commissary funds remains in the agency's possession. This money rightfully belongs to formerly incarcerated New Yorkers, and many returning citizens are unaware that this money remains unclaimed or do not know how to retrieve it. This bill would require the Department of Correction to conduct an outreach campaign, notifying formerly incarcerated individuals of the money that is rightfully theirs and how to recover it.

(01:19:48)

Today, I'm proud to introduce David Bills and one resolution aimed at addressing a host of issues residents are experiencing in South Bronx. Each piece of legislation is part of a multi-faceted approach to address quality of life, improve public safety, and expand opportunities for residents to take ownership of their communities. Reclaiming our streets, holding delivery companies accountable for abandoned totes as last-mile delivery companies like Amazon expand their operations across New York City. Abandoned delivery totes and plastic bins have become increasingly common on sidewalks, stoops, and entry pits. This legislation would authorize the Department of Sanitation to charge responsible shipping companies a per-container fee. This bill would protect public spaces, reduce litter, save taxpayers money, and encourage more responsible delivery practices.

Reclaiming our parking. Putting Bronx residents first. For many South Bronx residents, finding a parking space near their homes has been a daily challenge. Residential streets are lined with abandoned vehicles and cars with out-of-state plates, many of which are owned by residents looking to evade registration fees. This legislation would require the Department of Transportation to establish a residential parking permit program in the South and the Southeast Bronx.

Reclaiming our public spaces, creating opportunities for local mural artists, with the largest mural in the country unveiled in the South Bronx. I know everyone is asking, what about us? This legislation would establish a centralized online portal connecting artists with available opportunities across the five boroughs, making it easier for artists to find projects and for property owners, community organizations, and city agencies to connect with local talent.

Reclaiming our money and our freedom. Returning unclaimed commissary funds to formerly incarcerated New Yorkers. According to the Department of Correction, approximately [amount] in unclaimed commissary funds remains in the agency's possession. This money rightfully belongs to formerly incarcerated New Yorkers. Many returning citizens are unaware that this money remains unclaimed or do not know how to retrieve it. This bill requires the Department of Correction to conduct an outreach campaign, notifying formerly incarcerated individuals of the money that is rightfully theirs and how to recover it.

(01:21:50)

Finally, Councilmember. Thank you, Counselor Cabán. Thank

(01:21:56)

you. First, I just want to say that, like my colleagues, my heart goes out to our neighbors in Brooklyn who were killed and injured in last night's tragic collapse in Flatbush. I'm grateful to CM Farah Louis's leadership in responding, and for all of the city agencies that have mobilized to support the survivors and the families of those who perished. I just echo my colleagues' sentiments that we are all here to support Flatbush in this moment.

(01:22:20)

And today I am proud to introduce a resolution supporting the call by Starbucks Workers United for a boycott of Starbucks until the company bargains fairly with its workers. It's been five years since that first Starbucks store voted to unionize. In five years, Starbucks still has refused to bargain a first contract with any of its workers, instead relying on age-old union-busting tactics to avoid the responsibility to negotiate fairly. This resolution is about standing with Starbucks baristas and with workers organizing across New York City. The Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. said that the labor movement is "the principal force that transformed misery and despair into hope and progress." That was true last century, and it's true today as we work to hold the oligarchs and fascists like Trump and other billionaires accountable, and to build power for the working class in New York and across the country. The labor movement will be the bedrock of that work. In Philadelphia, they passed a similar resolution last month, and now it's our turn to join them. So thank you, and I hope that my colleagues will cosponsor. Thank you.

(01:23:29)

I have one more speaker, CM Ball. Thank you, Majority Leader. Today I'm proud to introduce Int 1158-2026, the Pet Rent Limit Act. Across the city, pet rents have grown significantly, putting an increased financial burden on New Yorkers already struggling with rising costs. Landlords can use pet rent as an additional monthly cost to pet owners' leases, creating a barrier for new renters and rehousing people at higher rents. This can also force families struggling to keep up with the cost of living to make the difficult choice of giving up their pets. The Pet Rent Limit Act would change New York City's administrative code to eliminate non-refundable upfront charges and fees for pets and cap monthly pet rent at 1% of the agreed rental amount. According to data from 2025, 1 in 3 pet surrenders in the city are a direct result of housing instability. The increase in animals entering shelters reflects the affordability challenges that many New Yorkers are facing. No New Yorkers should ever have to give up their beloved pet because they cannot afford housing with them. More affordable housing for pet owners can be critical to helping ease the financial burden facing New Yorkers and saving them from these impossible choices. The cap structure acknowledges the impact that pet ownership can have on building-wide maintenance costs for property owners and managers, and workloads for building service workers, while preventing unreasonable costs to tenants.

The Pet Rent Limit Act will help the city reduce the number of animals that end up in shelters while improving affordable rental options for New Yorkers in need of housing. I hope my colleagues on the City Council will join me in supporting our city's pet owners and taking this small but impactful step toward making our city a more affordable place to live.

(01:25:16)

Thank you, CM Epstein. My apologies for the first

(01:25:19)

time. Thank you, Majority Leader. My heart goes out to the families in Brooklyn, and I thank Counselor Louis for her leadership on this. As counsel said before, I think about how we can make sure these tragedies do not continue to happen in New York. I want to flag for my colleagues Int 1160-2026, which I introduced today and which focuses on ensuring that when delivery apps are working in New York City, they have locations for delivery drivers to be. What we see in New York City is delivery drivers parking their bikes on the streets overnight with no place to store them. That impacts the neighborhood, and the companies who are sending people out on the streets have a responsibility to ensure they have designated spaces to charge. They have no responsibility to ensure that people have a place to take lunch, to use the bathroom, or to keep their bikes overnight. That becomes dangerous to the riders and difficult for communities. This bill requires and holds the companies responsible to ensure these things are not happening. They are held accountable to make sure there's a place and an opportunity for those workers. This protects the workers, protects communities, and ensures companies have the responsibility.

(01:26:21)

I encourage my colleagues to look at this bill. I would hope for a quick conversation about how important this bill is. Thank you.

(01:26:33)

Thank you. Thank you. No one else signed up to speak for general discussion. I will now call upon Speaker Julie Menin to close today's stated meeting.

(01:26:41)

Thank you. The stated meeting of November 12, 2026 is

(01:26:49)

AI-generated summaries and transcripts. Errors are possible.
Verify against the linked video and send corrections via email.