Local Law to Amend the Administrative Code of the City of New York, in Relation to Pedicabs
Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection
Meeting overview
The Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection, chaired by Harvey Epstein and effectively co-led by veteran pedicab reformer CM Gale Brewer, held a hearing on seven bills aimed at overhauling New York City's thoroughly dysfunctional pedicab industry. The hearing grew directly out of a 2025-2026 reform process convened by the Midtown Community Justice Center, whose director Daniel Modest testified alongside industry representatives, BID leaders and the Central Park Conservancy. The basic facts of the situation are not in dispute by anyone: the City has an 840-vehicle cap on registered pedicabs, only about 330 are actually registered, and an estimated 1,200 to 1,500 are operating illegally. Three quarters of the industry is unlicensed, enforcement is nearly completely ineffective, and tourists are routinely charged hundreds or even over a thousand dollars for twenty-minute rides with no meaningful recourse.
The legislative package addresses this comprehensively. Int 0993-2026 would transfer regulatory authority from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection to the Taxi and Limousine Commission. Int 0992-2026 would require meters, scannable registration plates and driver safety training, and would remove the possibility of criminal imprisonment for violations. Int 0673-2026 would set fixed per-minute fares indexed to inflation. Int 0077-2026 would require the ride timer to be visible to passengers. Int 1063-2026 would legalize electric pedal assist up to 750 watts with a 15mph cap. Int 1026-2026 would create designated curb spaces for pedicabs. Int 0064-2026 would restrict pedicab operations within 50 feet of theater entrances in the Theater District. The Broadway Association, the Central Park Conservancy, the Times Square Alliance, the Midtown Community Justice Center and the New York Pedicab Alliance all broadly supported the package, which is a notably rare alignment of neighborhood interests and industry advocacy. The industry representatives were especially emphatic about legalizing electric assist, with multiple drivers testifying about physical injuries and the practical reality that virtually all pedicabs already operate with motors regardless of the current ban.
The most contested bill is Int 0993-2026, the TLC transfer. DCWP was diplomatically equivocal, acknowledging the system is broken while flagging implementation concerns. The TLC was more pointed in its opposition, noting it has no expertise in the pedicab industry, no existing regulatory framework that maps onto it, significant resource constraints following recent budget cuts, and a large existing caseload of 180,000 licensed for-hire drivers. TLC Commissioner Paul Bader testified that 64 enforcement officers had been lost to budget cuts in the last fiscal year, and noted that NYPD officers working Midtown have told him they would prefer not to handle pedicab regulation. Despite the TLC's reluctance, the non-governmental witnesses and both sponsoring Council Members were clear that the status quo of divided, unconnected licensing and enforcement authority is the root cause of the compliance failure, and that TLC-style integrated licensing and civil enforcement is the logical fix.
The enforcement picture exposed in the hearing is genuinely damning. Of approximately 1,200 criminal pedicab summonses issued in 2025, around 34-35% were deemed legally insufficient, 25% dismissed in the interest of justice, 20% not pursued, 9% never prosecuted, and only 9% resulted in any sanction. DCWP received 335 overcharging complaints since 2022 and achieved zero resolutions, largely because tourists do not follow up. The problem is structural: criminal summonses require discovery compliance that NYPD cannot realistically provide for what are essentially regulatory infractions, charges are routinely dismissed, confiscated bikes are returned within days, and there is no data-sharing between NYPD enforcement actions and the licensing agency that could revoke operating authority. The Midtown Community Justice Center's director put it plainly: the cases actually appearing in court are technical violations like missing tail lights, while the consumer fraud and overcharging that everyone cares about is not being addressed at all. Multiple witnesses and Council Members observed that the industry now has the character of a gold rush, with unlicensed operators openly bragging about charging tourists whatever they can get away with. The hearing closed without votes, but with clear Council intent to advance the package.
The record
- Int 0064-2026 Law to keep pedicabs away from theater entrances (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 0077-2026 Law to make pedicab fare timers more visible (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 0673-2026 Law to let City set pedicab fare rates (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 0992-2026 Law to tighten pedicab rules on meters, signs and training (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 0993-2026 Law to shift pedicab oversight to the Taxi and Limousine Commission (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 1026-2026 Law to set aside curb space for pedicab parking (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 1063-2026 Law to allow small electric motors on pedicabs (heard; awaiting a vote)
Numbers
- Estimated 1,200 to 1,500 pedicabs currently operating in New York City.
- Statutory cap on registered pedicab vehicles is 840, currently set at 840.
- Only 330 pedicabs are currently registered with the City.
- Approximately 600 active pedicab driver licenses currently issued by DCWP.
- 130 active pedicab business licenses currently issued by DCWP.
- Of approximately 1,200 criminal pedicab summonses issued in 2025, only 9% resulted in any civil or criminal sanction.
- 34-35% of 2025 criminal pedicab summonses were deemed legally insufficient.
- 25% of 2025 pedicab summonses were dismissed in the interest of justice.
- Approximately 5,000 summonses issued to pedicabs by NYPD and Parks over the past three years.
- DCWP received 335 overcharging complaints related to pedicabs since 2022, with zero resolutions achieved.
- DCWP received approximately 135 pedicab complaints in the past nine months alone.
- Tourists have been charged between $500 and $1,200 for pedicab rides of under 20 minutes.
- 172 formal pedicab complaints were filed in 2025, with half involving overcharging and 35 involving unlicensed operators.
- DCWP has revoked approximately 90 pedicab licenses since 2022, of which 21 were driver licenses and 68 were business licenses.
- 311 pedicab businesses have applied for the annual registration lottery each year since 2024.
- Annual lottery to issue pedicab registration plates takes place in May.
- Cooling-off period after license revocation is approximately one year before reapplication is permitted.
- TLC regulates approximately 180,000 licensed for-hire drivers and 115,000 vehicles, handling nearly 1 million trips per day.
- TLC conducted more than 110,000 inspections in fiscal year 2026.
- TLC received over 29,000 complaints and issued approximately 24,000 patrol summonses in fiscal year 2026.
- TLC has approximately 440 employees, with about 85 dedicated to street enforcement across all five boroughs.
- TLC issued over 5,000 summonses for unlicensed for-hire operators and 790 summonses for illegal street hails in the current calendar year to date.
- TLC currently has access to 107 relief stands citywide for approximately 180,000 licensed drivers.
- Int 1026-2026 would require TLC to establish 15 additional relief stands in Midtown Manhattan.
- Pedicab liability insurance cost approximately $600 per unit per year before COVID; it now runs approximately $5,000 to $8,000 per unit per year, roughly a tenfold increase.
- Only approximately two to three insurance companies currently offer coverage to the pedicab industry in New York City, despite DCWP's claim of up to six.
- Estimated $73 million was appropriated over five years for TLC enforcement related to a driver compensation program later voided after legal challenge by Uber, which a TLC commissioner suggested could be reapportioned if pedicab oversight is transferred.
- Central Park receives more than 40 million visits per year, making it the City's most visited attraction and the primary operating zone for pedicabs.
- Int 1063-2026 proposes legalizing electric pedal assist up to 750 watts, cutting off assistance at 15mph.
- Budget cuts in the most recent fiscal year reduced TLC enforcement capacity by the equivalent of approximately 64 police officers.
- DCWP estimated that dedicated pedicab licensing and oversight would require approximately two to three full-time employees.
Action Points
- DCWP to provide the committee with the total number of pedicab confiscations conducted by NYPD over the past three years.
- DCWP to provide the committee with complaint data from NYPD and other agencies, including total volumes and outcomes, for pedicab-related complaints since 2022.
- DCWP to provide data on how many of its 135 recent pedicab complainants actually responded to agency outreach.
- DCWP to provide geographic breakdown of pedicab complaints and summonses by borough and neighborhood.
- DCWP to provide data on how many of the 90 revoked licensees have since re-obtained pedicab licenses.
- TLC to provide 2024 data on how many of its enforcement summonses resulted in actual penalties or enforcement actions, broken down by summons type where possible.
- DCWP and TLC to work together to establish automated inter-agency data-sharing on summonses, complaints and enforcement outcomes so that on-street violations can be connected to licensing records.
- DCWP to follow up with OATH to formalize information-sharing on pedicab adjudication outcomes.
- Committee staff to connect Justin Culbreth with relevant agency contacts to arrange a requested staff meeting on a potential pilot program.
- TLC to develop a timeline and resource estimate for what a transfer of pedicab regulatory authority from DCWP would require, conditioned on a clearer understanding of the full scope of proposed legislation.
- Council Chair Epstein to pursue TLC enforcement staffing levels as a budget priority in spring budget negotiations.
- DCWP to provide updated data on insurance compliance across licensed pedicab businesses and investigate factors driving the approximately tenfold increase in insurance premiums since pre-COVID.
- DCWP to provide full breakdown of outcomes for the 335 overcharging complaints received since 2022, including how many complainants responded to agency contact.
- TLC commissioner Paul Bader requested that if pedicab oversight is transferred to TLC, the committee consider reapportioning funds from the $73 million previously budgeted for the now-voided driver compensation enforcement program; committee to assess feasibility.
- Council to consider consolidating the seven bills into a single comprehensive piece of legislation, as recommended by the Broadway Association.
Full Transcript
Oh, come on. Hello, good morning. Welcome to today's New York City Council hearing for the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection. At this time, please silence cell phones. If you wish to speak in today's hearing, please fill out an appearance card with one of the sergeants. Moving forward, no one is to approach the dais until you begin.
Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining the Consumer and Worker Protection hearing. My name is Harvey Epstein. I am the Chair of the Committee. I would like to recognize CM Brewer and CM Schulman, who is with me today. We are calling this the CM Brewer hearing today.
Pedicabs are for-hire vehicles that combine a bicycle seat, handlebars and pedals for the driver with carriages for passengers. Pedicabs operate generally offering short-distance rides for tourists in Midtown, and CM Brewer, let us not forget about that, Manhattan, particularly around Times Square as well as Central Park. Pedicabs are the most heavily regulated industry, but these regulations mean very little when the vast majority of pedicabs operating in New York City are unlicensed and unregistered. Despite the cap of 850 pedicab registration plates, there are an estimated 1,200 to 1,500 pedicabs operating in the City. Analysis on open data indicates there are just 275 valid pedicab registration plates, meaning that individuals are choosing to operate unregistered pedicabs even though they are available for regulation.
Enforcement has defaulted to NYPD and Parks, and the vast majority of enforcement is through criminal summons by NYPD. There are major concerns about how effective criminal enforcement is. Analysis of 1,200 criminal pedicab summonses from 2025 found that 34 to 35% of the tickets were deemed legally insufficient, 25% were dismissed in the interest of justice, 20% were not pursued for other reasons, 9% were never prosecuted, and just 9% resulted in some kind of criminal or civil punishment. This status quo is not working for anyone. It is not working for tourists who are being ripped off by pedicab drivers charging anywhere from $50 to $1,200 for a ride under 20 minutes. It is not working for the Broadway productions that are interrupted by loud noise blaring from pedicabs outside the theaters, and it is not working for licensed pedicab operators who cannot compete with unlicensed operators that do not invest in safety equipment, insurance or following the rules.
Recognizing the system is not working, in November 2025 the Midtown Community Justice Center, which adjudicates criminal summonses for pedicab violations, organized a roundtable discussion with representatives from various stakeholders involved with and affected by the pedicab industry, including NYPD, Central Park Conservancy, Manhattan Office Times Alliance and the Broadway League. In May 2026, the Justice Center published a report with goals and policy recommendations generated from the roundtable. A lot of those bills are being heard today. Int 0064-2026, right, by CM Maloney, related to restrictions on the operation of pedicabs in the theater district. Int 0077-2026 by CM Brewer, related to the visibility, rider timing and pedicabs. Int 0673-2026 by CM Brewer, related to pedicab fares. Int 0992-2026 by CM Brewer, related to making certain changes to the pedicab law. Int 0993-2026 by CM Brewer, related to establishing the Taxi and Limousine Commission's authority over pedicabs. Int 1026-2026 by CM Brewer, related to creating designated curb space for pedicabs. And Int 1063-2026 by CM Brewer, related to pedicabs with electric motors.
I really look forward to a robust conversation about updating the pedicab law, increasing compliance with pedicab regulations and effective enforcement of pedicab rules and drivers. And now I invite the bills' sponsors to make a statement.
Obviously, I am going to start with CM Brewer. Thank you very much, Chair Epstein. I am the only Council Member who takes pedicabs, and I take them at 72nd Street and Central Park West because I am always late getting to whatever event is in the park. But when I get there, they say, "Oh, it is Gale, do not overcharge her." So I do like that group of people and I thank them for all the work that they do, but we do need regulation. So thank you, Chair Epstein, for including the bills on today's agenda.
I think we heard that for too long the City's approach to the pedicab industry has been inconsistent and ineffective, creating problems for public safety, consumers and drivers while burdening enforcement. We have got to start over. Nothing in this industry right now is working, and New Yorkers and visitors and drivers all deserve better.
So last year, as you heard earlier, Judge Way and his amazing staff at the Midtown Community Justice Center initiated a pedicab task force, including the New York Pedicab Alliance, the Central Park Conservancy, the Times Square Alliance, NYPD and many others, including our office. They produced "Fixing the Pedicab Problem." That particular judge is awesome and he is always trying to find ways to change policy as opposed to just doing what he does in the court. So we took a hard look at what is not working, and this report has clear and practical solutions. We meet every single week still to talk about pedicabs. "Fixing the Pedicab Problem: A Road Map to Reform" has been helpful.
The report found, as you heard earlier, the City has approximately 850 authorized pedicab plates, but an estimated 1,200 or 1,500 operating in 2024, and probably more now. They often have bogus credentials. In 2025, there were 172 pedicab complaints. 301... half of those involved overcharging, and another 35 involved unlicensed operators, and there were probably more because often tourists do not complain. We have heard that tourists have been charged $500 to nearly $1,000 for a ride of only 20 minutes.
So we need clear rules. Passengers need to know what they are being charged and who is responsible for the pedicab they are riding. There are many legitimate drivers and businesses. They should not have to compete with unlicensed operators and their predatory behavior.
So we have bills. I have bills on meters, as you heard earlier, moving the oversight from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection to the Taxi and Limousine Commission, requiring these individuals and businesses to carry liability insurance and be able to use taxi relief stands if possible. So those are just some of the bills, and there are other ones being discussed today.
We are not trying to eliminate pedicabs because they are a form of transportation, just like many others. They are a part of New York City, particularly around Central Park, Times Square, Midtown and the theater district. And the Chair said he just saw one in his district on the Lower East Side. We want legitimate drivers and businesses to operate safely and fairly. We want passengers to know what they are paying. Right now you have no idea. You just have to argue. And the City has to be able to enforce the rules.
I definitely want to thank Judge John Wang, Danielle Mendes, who is the Midtown Community Justice Center director, Betty Smith and David... himself on the Central Park Conservancy, Tom Harris of the Times Square Alliance, and Kenneth Winter for the New York Pedicab Alliance, and many others. From my staff, former staff member Sam Goldsman started this whole discussion, and now Cynthia Hornig and Shula Pooter are helping from my office, as well as the legislative division: Margaret... Clifford, Elliot Heisler, Neil Beckman, West Jones, Rachel... Natalie Meltzer and Andrea Vasquez. And I really appreciate this hearing, as it has been long in the making.
And I think it is really important, and thank you very much.
Good morning, Chair Epstein and members of the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection. My name is Carlos Ortiz and I am the Chief of Staff of the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. I am joined by our Associate Commissioner of Internal Affairs, as well as my colleague Ira Goldapper, Deputy Commissioner for the Uniform Services Bureau at the Taxi and Limousine Commission.
The New York City Department of Consumer and Worker Protection is the nation's leading municipal enforcement agency charged with delivering economic justice in New York City. We are also the licensing agency for both pedicab businesses and drivers, and we register pedicabs as well. There are currently 130 active pedicab business licenses associated with 330 registered pedicabs and approximately 600 active pedicab driver licenses. Pedicab businesses are only allowed to operate a registered pedicab vehicle with a licensed pedicab driver. A pedicab business can have up to 30 registered vehicles. However, the total number of pedicab vehicles allowed to be registered with the City is capped at 840 vehicles.
The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection enforces rules regarding pricing and disclosure to consumers, as well as conducts annual compliance checks on pedicabs for issues like cab conditions, rate signage and license disclosures. On-street enforcement activities are conducted by the NYPD or by the Parks Department if the activity is occurring in parkland. Over the past three years, our sister agencies have issued approximately 5,000 summonses to pedicabs for illegal activity. Candidly, in recent years the pedicab industry has struggled with non-compliance, including unlicensed activity. This not only impacts consumers but also the businesses that want to be in compliance and who engage hundreds of workers to secure...
...support for this industry.
This includes the development of educational literature, outreach initiatives, working closely with local associations such as the New York Pedicab Alliance, and standing up a Central Park task force for the enforcement activities referenced above. We remain committed to working with our partners to come together on common-sense solutions for this industry.
During today's legislation, Int 0064-2026 prohibits pedicab drivers from parking, stopping or standing a pedicab, or picking up or dropping off passengers within 50 feet of any entrance or exit of a theater located in the theater district zone. It would also require the Department of Transportation to post signs or other markings indicating the areas in which such pedicab restrictions are applicable. Pedicabs are already subject to all existing curb regulations for vehicles, such as existing no-standing signage. Most theaters have no-standing signs already, and there is an established process for a theater to request no-standing signage if there happens to be any locations that do not have it already. We defer to our colleagues at NYPD for further considerations regarding this bill.
Int 0077-2026 would require that the timer on pedicabs be fixed to the rear of the bicycle seat within clear view of all pedicab passengers. The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection supports this bill. We share the Council's concerns related to consumer deception and scams by pedicab drivers. We believe this legislation would not only assist consumers against surprise charges but also on-street enforcement agencies against bad actors.
Int 0673-2026 would require setting fixed per-minute rates for pedicab rides, indexed to inflation. The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection supports bringing better price clarity to consumers, particularly in the context of consumer deception and overcharges reported in this industry. However, price controls can also be an overly burdensome measure for the agency to set, as well as for businesses that are otherwise complying with the law. Today we are interested in hearing from businesses, preferences and worker stakeholders to understand the implications of price controls on their take-home pay and ability to operate.
Int 0992-2026 would require pedicabs to have meters to calculate the price of pedicab rides and registration plates with a scannable code that displays the pedicab registration number and business name. The bill would also require pedicab drivers to take a safety training course developed in order to obtain or renew a license. It would remove imprisonment for pedicab-related violations and specify that a pedicab driver not use any device that makes illegal noise.
The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection supports the intent of this legislation. Requiring a meter would improve the consumer experience in this industry, especially for greater pricing clarity. Imprisonment should not be a penalty for pedicab-related violations, and devices that make illegal noise should be explicitly prohibited. However, other aspects of this bill raise concerns for the agency. In particular, we do not have street safety expertise to develop a safety course that would be adequate for drivers. Additionally, we are noting the potential high cost of mandating scannable registration plates.
Int 1063-2026 would allow pedicabs to be equipped with an electric motor of less than 750 watts that limits pedaling assistance when the pedicab reaches a speed of 15 miles per hour...
...or any other speed as determined by the Department of Transportation by rule. The New York City Police Department is concerned that allowing electric-assist pedicabs will be problematic because it is very difficult for officers to enforce in the field.
Thank you for the opportunity to testify before your Committee on today's legislation. We look forward to hearing from all relevant stakeholders today. The administration stands ready to work with the Council, stakeholders and all our partners across government to support a vibrant and robust pedicab industry that protects consumers, workers and small businesses. I will turn it over to my colleague at TLC.
Good morning, Chair Epstein and members of the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection. Thank you for the opportunity to provide testimony on behalf of the New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission. My name is Ira Goldapper and I serve as Deputy Commissioner for the Uniform Services Bureau.
The TLC regulates New York City's taxi and for-hire vehicle industries, including approximately 180,000 licensed drivers and 115,000 vehicles. Together, our licensees provide nearly 1 million trips each day. With approximately 440 employees, the TLC carries out significant licensing, inspection and enforcement responsibilities. In fiscal year 2026, we conducted more than 110,000 inspections, received over 29,000 complaints and issued approximately 24,000 patrol summonses.
I would like to briefly address two bills before the Committee today. Int 1026-2026 would allow pedicabs to use existing taxi and for-hire vehicle relief stands and would require the TLC to establish 15 additional relief stands in Midtown Manhattan. Relief stands provide drivers with free legal parking so that they can use a bathroom, eat a meal and take a break during their shifts. Approximately 180,000 licensed drivers currently have access to 107 relief stands citywide. There is...
...significant demand for curb space throughout the City, particularly in Midtown Manhattan, where pedicab activity is concentrated and space is especially limited. The TLC believes it is important to consider the existing demand for taxi and for-hire vehicle relief stands as the Council evaluates this proposal. The TLC does not support expanding the use of existing taxi relief stands to pedicabs, but concurs with the underlying premise of the bill that workers should have more space to rest on our City streets. These spaces are limited and already in high demand, and adding additional users would further constrain access to needed rest space for taxi and for-hire vehicle drivers.
Int 0993-2026 would transfer responsibility for regulating pedicabs from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection to the TLC. The current regulatory framework is designed around the taxi and for-hire vehicle industries. Pedicabs operate under a different model and regulatory framework, including different vehicle types, operating patterns and applicable laws. The concerns raised regarding the pedicab industry, including unlicensed activity and quality-of-life issues, are important and warrant careful consideration. Any potential changes to the existing regulatory structure should be evaluated in the context of the expertise and operational needs of the agencies involved. This legislation would be extremely costly to implement, going well beyond existing resources. The TLC remains committed to working with the Council and other partners to share our regulatory and enforcement expertise and support the development of an alternative approach to these issues, as we do not believe this bill is the best path forward.
Thank you, Chair Epstein and members of the Committee, for the opportunity to provide testimony. We look forward to continuing to work with the Council and our agency partners. Thank you.
Thank you both. I know we have been joined by CM De La Rosa, CM Maloney and CM Ariola online. We are going to get into some questioning. Let me just talk about the violations you mentioned. 24,000 violations have been issued. How many of those resulted in some kind of fine, penalty or sanction of the 24,000? Are you referring to the 24,000 — are you asking about pedicab violations? You said there are 24,000. Those are related to taxi. Okay, for hire. Earlier you mentioned about 1,200 pedicab violations in the last year, and it seems like less than 10% result in some kind of action where there is an ongoing problem. What is happening there? Why is it so low? What is going on with the enforcement actions that we are seeing on the ground that do not result in any kind of follow-through?
Thank you for that question, Chair. I think with respect to enforcement, street enforcement is handled by the Police Department or the Parks Department on parkland. My understanding is that over the past three years they have issued approximately 5,000 summonses to pedicab operators. In terms of the pathway and what it takes and what happens through adjudications, I do not have insight into that, but we can get that information from the Police Department.
I mean, if people think a ticket is meaningless, then there is no incentive to comply with the law. If there is no incentive to comply with the law, right, so what is being done about that? You had staff at this roundtable, you have heard the facts, you have seen the report. What are we doing about better compliance to make sure we move the industry to a more legal standard? I mean, we do not want tourists coming here getting ripped off. We all cannot be Gale Brewer when we get on a pedicab. So how are we going to ensure that people are being protected? You are the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection.
Thank you for the question, Chair. I want to echo also the sentiments raised earlier in the opening statements that noncompliance is a serious problem, particularly for businesses that are following the rules. I think it is inherently unfair that a business that follows the rules in one situation feels that others are getting away scot-free. For that reason we have been working closely with our sister agencies to stand up coordinated enforcement activities that include summonses, that also include at times confiscations, that include trainings that we provide to police officers. We also provide weekly reports to our sister agencies so they are aware of who the licensed actors are and can identify more quickly who the unlicensed actors are.
We have also worked to update — and even what could seemingly sound like a minuscule thing — updating the pedicab driver license that drivers receive so it is harder to falsify. We have been working on these initiatives throughout the past three years with our sister agencies as a measure to address compliance. That also ties into what we have been doing newly in this past year in this administration, which is creating deeper ties with stakeholders. Our Commissioner has met multiple times now with — and she has called out a few names — the New York Pedicab Alliance, the Times Square BID, the Broadway Association, because we recognize that this is an issue that still requires more attention from the City. From our perspective, this hearing is an opportunity for all of us and especially the stakeholders to raise those concerns, because we do want to come up with solutions.
But I mean, I know you said you have kind of in the last three years moved forward in trying to improve the situation. Do you think today the situation is better than it was three years ago? Do you think these issues are solved? It seems like no one thinks we have reached a place where we have appropriate solutions, especially on the ticketing and illegal pedicab operators out on the street.
I think the issue — I mean, I think we are all aware that the issue is not solved. I think there is legislation on today's docket that we are supportive of. We want to make sure it can be implemented, particularly around greater pricing clarity and disclosures to consumers. On the enforcement side, to ensure that enforcement is equitable and focused on the bad actors of the industry.
You mentioned confiscation. How many confiscations of pedicabs have happened in the past three years? I am sorry, go ahead.
I do not have the exact numbers on the number of confiscations. Those are handled by the New York City Police Department. Can you get back to us with that information? So you know they have happened? Yes, they do conduct — we have participated in coordinated activities around enforcement where confiscations were the result. This agency does not have the capacity or ability to do confiscations, so we work with the Police Department to do that.
So what do you say to a consumer who took a 20-minute pedicab ride and it cost them a thousand dollars? What recourse is in place to help that consumer, whether a tourist or a New Yorker, in that situation?
To a certain extent, in any situation when we are dealing with unlicensed actors, I think the message I want to communicate to consumers is preventative — engaging with licensed sectors, whether that is a home improvement contractor or a pedicab. It is particularly dangerous for a consumer because there is limited recourse, because these actors can escape the ability for enforcement. I would say that if a consumer is engaging with a pedicab, to be sure that it is licensed, to ensure that they are capturing the license information, the rate signage, and that they provide that information to the agency so that we can mediate. And if we...
...see a pattern of complaints with a particular business or driver, we can investigate. So, you know, someone would say a tourist comes to New York, they go to Central Park, and they think, "Oh, I am going to get on a pedicab." So they get on a pedicab. They do not know what is legal or not, because there are 40 pedicabs sitting right there and they just choose one to get on. Then at the end of the 20-minute ride, the guy or woman says, "You know, $500." How is that person ever going to have the information you are suggesting to be able to make that good-faith argument? And what do they do after they have paid, when they figure out that they have been ripped off? What is being done to ensure that person who has been ripped off gets some kind of recourse?
Thank you for that question, Chair. I think what we worked on over the past summer, particularly in the peak of the World Cup season, was to distribute as much information as possible to consumers and tourists regarding their rights when they are using these services. That included working with the Hotel Association, New York City Tourism, and creating signage in New York City parks with our Parks Department colleagues. If a tourist has an issue where they feel they have been scammed or overcharged or the pricing was inaccurate based on what they received, they can bring that to us.
I think there are challenges, though, in the sense that sometimes we have a situation where tourists kind of write it off and unfortunately they do not provide us all the information we need. Also, when we reach out to them, they do not follow up with us, which makes it very difficult. I think ideally some aspects of the legislation on the docket would improve pricing clarity and improve how much a consumer can be charged in the first place, which I think would be beneficial for the industry. We could envision an industry where we are not just serving tourists but serving New Yorkers as well. I think that is the ultimate goal we have to have in the City for the pedicab industry, but that would require, to your point, a stricter regime with stricter compliance measures for bad actors.
How many complaints have been filed about pedicabs with your agency over this past nine months? We received approximately 135 complaints. That is not the totality of complaints the City receives, however. Ours would typically be around overcharging or pricing. But if a complaint is related to motorized activity or unlicensed activity or something dangerous happening on the street, that would be routed to the Police Department.
Do you know how many complaints for the last nine months, including the overpricing and the other complaints that might be directed to other agencies? I do not have information on the complaints the Police Department receives.
I would say since 2022 — and Carl, can you get that for us?
Yes, sir. Thank you.
Since 2022, the agency has received 335 overcharging complaints. Behind you and the NYPD, there are other agencies that are going to funnel complaints about pedicabs as well. I believe that the majority of complaints would go to the Police Department. I do not believe that complaints go to the Parks Department.
How about loud music? Would that go to them? Those could also be sent to the Police Department because they have the ability to enforce on that. Could you get us all the complaint numbers — how many went to the NYPD and what the outcomes are, whether they were resolved or just closed? And of your complaints, how many resulted in people getting money back?
I can speak to this past year. We have not been able to take action on any of the complaints we received because of either the lack of information that we have been provided or consumers not following up when we reached out to them. So of the 135, we have zero that there was any follow-through on.
I would push back on that slightly. We do follow through. We immediately reach out to the consumer and it is a priority for us to make sure that the consumer is heard. In terms of acting on the complaint subsequently, that we have not been able to...
...get a lot of those complaints resolved. How many did the consumer actually respond to, wanting to get redress?
I think the issue with the complaints is either we do not have enough information to contact the consumer, or when we reach out to the consumer they do not respond to us. But some do respond, right? I do not think we have data on exactly how many responded, but I can double-check that for you. I appreciate that.
Just to return our attention to TLC — so can you talk about your enforcement under licensing? We want to understand what you are actually doing on the street, because we hear that basically they have no street-facing operation and they rely on the NYPD, but you do have a street-facing operation.
Right. Thank you, Chair. We target unlicensed for-hire operations across all five boroughs. There are major hot spots in each of the boroughs — shopping centers, major transportation hubs. It is a large city to cover and we do our best to hit them. One of the big pieces is that for effective unlicensed for-hire activity enforcement, you have to hit the same bad actors with such regularity that it becomes cost-prohibitive for them to continue to operate. That is something that is difficult to cover across all five boroughs. You asked how many violations we have issued this year for illegal operations. Calendar year to date we have issued over 5,000 summonses for unlicensed operators as well as 790 summonses for illegal street hails.
And then of those 5,000, how many resulted in some kind of actualized civil penalty or actions resulting in either termination of a license or some other enforcement action?
I do not have the specific numbers because there is a delay between the issuance of the summons and when it gets through OATH. I can look to get a breakdown for you, but because of that gap it will not be summons-for-summons. We can give you...
...that sort of general percentage. Do you have 2024 data? I believe I do — not just the overall number but also how many resulted in enforcement.
I am sorry. Our summonses related to the field are not broken down by type of summons. We can look to do that and get those numbers for you.
So how many people do you have issuing summonses? How many people are out on the streets of New York? The enforcement division within the services bureau has about 130 officers, including supervisors, managers, trainers and investigators.
How many would be street enforcement staff? About 85. 85 for the City, correct.
So it is 85 — more than before, but far fewer than needed to end unlicensed for-hire activity within the taxi and for-hire vehicle space. That is a good budget conversation for us this spring, for sure, to make sure that we want to make it fair for people who are being protected from unlicensed vehicles. One more question for you, if I could.
On increased enforcement — if you are increasing enforcement, could those same inspectors, if...
...they are sitting in Times Square, do enforcement for illegal for-hire vehicles or an...
...illegal pedicab? Could that person actually do the same thing, or would you have to hire a separate division of people to do pedicabs?
Well, it is somewhat of a difficult question given the complexities. We do not oversee the pedicab industry. I mean, it is something you could consider and obviously people could certainly do both. One thing to keep in mind is we do not believe enforcement alone is sort of the panacea...
...for the industry. We have learned that with our own experience in enforcing against unlicensed for-hire activity. It requires significant education for the public, for one, to try to remove the demand for unlicensed activity, as well as stakeholder engagement with the industries to understand what the barriers to entry are, what is precluding individuals from actually getting licensed and doing what they are supposed to be doing, and getting to those root causes. So it is more than just enforcement in order to achieve the results.
So how would you do education in this industry, on the pedicabs? Obviously the vast majority of people using them are not New Yorkers. They are people who are flying in. They are not here for extended periods of time. What tools would you have to do that kind of education that you are referencing, if you are saying enforcement is not going to be the answer to this problem?
Thank you, Chair. Let me take that question. So recapping the educational issues we have been taking on — because I hear your point, I think that is a difficulty when there is a moving group that is not based in the City. So what we have tried to leverage is really a relational approach to all aspects of this, creating deep ties with the industry to make sure they understand their obligations for compliance, but also so they can help disseminate the education that we have developed for tourists in general and for pedicabs in particular. We have also worked with, for example, the Hotel Association and New York City Tourism. We have also done canvasses of certain areas of the City like Central Park to meet consumers directly.
And we have also been trying to leverage as much as possible, for a tourist coming to the City, our social media footprint, which we have been expanding in the past nine months to showcase our partnership with the industry and the obligations of the industry too.
I just do not know — and I am going to let my colleagues ask questions too — but to be honest, when I am visiting another city and I am going to do a tourist-related thing, probably the last thing I am doing is going to a social media page to figure out what the industry rules are. It is not a realistic scenario. If I am going to visit Prague and I am going to get on a bus, I am not going to figure out what the city agency in a language I probably do not speak is going to say about what the rules are around it. I just...
...I mean, I understand the purpose of using all these different tools to create an ecosystem where we are trying to get this information out. It is a process. I have done community affairs for 10 years of my career and it is hard work. You are physically in the field trying to talk to people in real-life, real-time settings. I am not saying it is always perfect, but we work at it. Being physically in the field where people are, where these hubs are, is a really good way of getting to people instead of using social media. Unfortunately it is a staffing requirement, but it might be something that would really be beneficial — to have people out and about.
Especially in areas where we see high concentrations of this issue happening. We do conduct an immense amount of outreach and education here. I would like to say that our team is probably the best outreach team in the City. Just this year, with a team of six, we have been able to reach nearly a hundred thousand New Yorkers over the summer, reaching 30,000 people in the streets about worker rights and consumer rights, particularly in the peak of its first season. Myself and Haley have been on the ground at Central Park and the Theater District to talk to pedicab folks and to talk to tourists in the streets. It is work that we are actively putting in every day.
All right. I want to turn it over to some of my colleagues. I know CM... and then CM Brewer. Thank you.
Chair, so you said... I am sorry, Mr. Testimony, but I am...
Reading it here that the number of pedicab vehicles is capped at 840. That is correct. Are we at that cap?
Currently there are 330 registered with the City. How many do you suspect are...
Not registered? My understanding, from some of the public reporting out there, is that it could be approximately 1,200 unlicensed or unregistered vehicles.
When a registered vehicle license is issued, there are terms which would cause them to lose that license, right? That is correct. And what are...
Some of those? So things like noise or traffic violations — is that part of what you would use to revoke a license? It would be a certain number of violations over a period of time...
...that would allow us to go and try to revoke or suspend a license. But do you really... go ahead, please come...
Up. Additionally, there are certain requirements specific to this industry related to, for example, insurance. In the case of an insurance lapse, a pedicab business's license...
...is void. That is another particular reason we would void the license as well. But does the agency get direct reports of infractions? You said...
Like, NYPD is called to some... That is correct. CM, the on-street enforcement is handled by the Police Department and in terms of the summons information, we do not receive it directly.
Does NYPD report to you on infractions that they have had, or how are you coordinating with the other agencies to enforce...
Infractions? Thank you for the question, CM. We do coordinate with the Police Department and the Parks Department for on-street enforcement. That includes providing them with regular updates about the licensed actors in the industry, but...
They do not report to you. So if they get a number of pedicab complaints or take actions, they do not hand that information over to you. So you do not have the outcomes from those adjudicated cases. There could be infractions that are being reported but you do not know what they are, so you cannot enforce around bad actors. I think that is...
One of the reasons that...
Perhaps another agency is better equipped to handle this and really enforce among bad actors that has that kind of active enforcement ability on the ground. Because in my district, we do get complaints all the time about noise, traffic infractions, where other agencies are being called, but that is not getting back to the agency that issues the permits for this. So is there, if it were to remain as is, how could you fill that gap?
What could we do? How could we fix that?
I think, if there are any... excuse me. I think we want to continue building our ties with community stakeholders to ensure that they understand the obligations they have. Additionally, I think we want to work, in particular, to facilitate a lot of the enforcement required for the unlicensed activity.
I actually do not think it is necessarily the licensed actors that are causing the problems in this industry. We work closely with these folks and I know that they want to be compliant. They are doing as much as they can to follow the rules. I think it is really the unlicensed actors that are causing the biggest issues, and I think we need to figure out some solutions for how we can bring better enforcement efforts against those. Thank you.
All right. Thank you, CM. Now we are going to go to CM Brewer and then CM Hanks.
Thank you. Danielle, you need to fill out a form. Whoever is here from Midtown needs to — I can see you, you need to fill out a form. A couple of questions for Carlos — the great Carlos. In some cases you stated this can be decided, or somebody else can decide. How do you suggest, other than... because it is not yet... I hope it is. How do you suggest this industry be improved? What would be some specific suggestions that you would make? We have got electric issues, we have got...
All the topics that I think were covered in some of this legislation. What would you do specifically to improve this industry? I think, and I can speak from my own personal experience as well, I think the price...
I have taken a pedicab. Oh, good. Pricing definitely impacted me. And I think that some...
Of the legislation, for example, today related to meters and rates, I think could be a vast improvement on the industry as well. So I think it is just the consumer side of things — it ensures clarity, which means everyone is operating on the same level playing field. I think that would be a big help to the industry.
When you say level playing field, what do you mean?
For a consumer and a business to have the same understanding of what the outcome of a transaction is going to be. A meter could facilitate that, or rates could facilitate that.
I think it is also important from business to business as well, that they have a mutual understanding of what is going to happen when a transaction occurs. So that is what I would like this to...
Elaborate on — leveling the playing field. Okay.
I mean, 330 have a license, 1,200 are operating. I think that is probably correct. But how does one go about getting a license? And I think I do not have to answer this, but how many have been suspended, if any...
Recently? Thank you for the question, CM. There is an annual lottery in the springtime to issue registration plates to licensed pedicab businesses. Whenever one wins the lottery, they can get the registration for it. I think in the last lottery we were able to get up to 330 total registered vehicles. When you become a licensee, we conduct compliance checks on your vehicle to ensure that the cab conditions are accurate and the signage is accurate. We do those annually. If a business fails that annual inspection, we will take away the plates until there is a correction to that issue. But I think, again, there is a small subset of actors that are following the rules — that is the 330 folks. But clearly, for all of us who have been in these spaces, we know that there are more pedicabs operating out there.
My most recent pedicab driver was — he said he was Russian, and I was on my way to the chess championship, and he joined me.
You never know what is next. In terms of insurance, that is the same issue, they...
Are they supposed to have insurance and how does that work? Obviously it has been expensive. I know there are very few companies that provide it. How does the insurance work, if at all?
So the Administrative Code requires these businesses to carry insurance. My understanding is there are up to six companies currently offering the industry insurance, but the costs have been going up in recent years and that has also been a challenge for the business actors to be able to get their license. In terms of determining whether an insurance policy is complying with the Administrative Code, we work with the Law Department to review those policies. Okay. And then how...
Does... do you talk to OATH about those cases that are brought to OATH? How many cases do you know of, and in what time period are they brought to OATH, and what happens there? Do you have any sense of that effort?
My understanding is the majority of summonses are not sent to OATH — they are issued on the street. But there are some things that do go to OATH, so we are working to build ties with OATH for greater information transmission. It helps that our former commissioner is there, so we will be reaching out to them to see if we can formalize that.
Oh, no — it is also the ones that deal with them themselves. Those are the ones that the Chair was asking about. They often do not go very far. The reason they do not go very far is the cops, with all due respect, do not know how to write the summons, so it is hard to read, and then the judge says sorry, cannot read it, goodbye. Because I go to the court and I listen, and that is what happens. So that is a whole other topic about...
Writing versus putting it on some kind of digital format.
But so your cases do or do not go to OATH? I thought they did.
Our cases go to OATH. But what I thought was the on-street enforcement is being handled by...
Okay. The other question I have is about electric bikes versus regular bikes. My understanding is pedicabs are supposed to be regular bikes and not electric. They are mostly — I think almost 100% electric, right? How do you handle that? I personally feel they should be electric because it is hard to pedal and you want to get people where they are going. So how do you handle that issue?
So you are correct that pedicabs are not allowed to be motorized right now. If they are, it is grounds for the police to issue a summons or to confiscate the vehicle. Let me — and I want to get back to another question you asked earlier, CM — so let me throw it to my colleague to describe the revocations we have...
Done. Sorry.
So just on our revocations — we typically will move to revoke licenses during the renewal period. Since 2022, we have revoked about 90 licenses for pedicabs. 21 of those were for drivers and 68 for... Thanks. I will do all the questions in the second round.
I am turning it over to CM Hanks and then CM...
Maloney. Thank you, Chair. My line of questioning is also surrounding the motorized electric motor, and allowing it on pedicabs with Int 1063-2026. The Council investigation found that the vast majority of pedicabs have motors despite being prohibited. Do you think that registered pedicabs are retrofitting their vehicles with pedal assist, or are these primarily unregistered devices?
I think it is hard to say. I would think that, you know, there are 330 registered pedicab vehicles. We talked earlier about reporting showing there are many more unlicensed vehicles out there. I would tend to think that it is the unlicensed actors that are not following the rules of the road, so to speak. But our annual compliance checks are where we are checking for motors not being present. Thank you. And...
Where do you see this going with so many unregistered vehicles? NYPD has their own opinion. We are definitely trying to come up with legislation and policy that will keep New Yorkers safe, but it seems like this is one of those spaces where we may not have the resources. I think when you testified earlier that some of this legislation is extremely costly to implement. So if you can talk about where do you think this is going as far as enforcement and policy, and where the Council and the administration can kind of meet in the middle?
I can start and then hand it over to my colleague. You know...
I think, to echo CM Brewer's statement at the top, I think this hearing is long overdue. There are solutions that we could have that we can bring to the industry, and I think there is more work that needs to be done candidly. I think we want to make sure we are creating deeper ties with the sister agencies that are conducting on-street enforcement, because ultimately we do want to have an industry that is successful not just for us but for New Yorkers in the future as well. So for the second part of your question, let me throw it to my colleague, Deputy Commissioner Gold Dapper. Thank you.
Any increase in scope will certainly require additional resources. With respect to updating equipment and technologies, staffing for enforcement and prosecution, and the level of engagement needed to actually understand the issues at hand — we do not know the pedicab industry. We are familiar with the for-hire vehicle and taxicab industry and we are more than willing to work as partners with other sister agencies as well as the Council to come up with an approach. There are a number of things that I do not believe could just be as simple as a copy and paste of how we regulate taxis. It is a different industry. But we are more than happy to share the things that we do within licensing, inspections and enforcement, and the subject matter experts can then review these things to determine what would be applicable or appropriate within the pedicab industry.
Thank you. I appreciate that. I think we will have to dig into that offline. But back to the question for you — do you receive a lot of consumer complaints about pedicabs with electric assist? The agency does not receive those complaints. I believe they would go directly to the Police Department. Got it. So maybe we should have public safety here as...
Well. Do you think it is appropriate for pedicabs to use electric pedal assist?
I think, speaking for my colleagues at NYPD — NYPD, I think, we would defer to on the street safety aspects of this policy. I know NYPD has concerns about allowing more electric vehicles on the streets if enforcement is still an issue. I know there is a concern with identifying vehicles and making sure they are going the right speed. But that said, we also have a lot of businesses and workers that are trying to make a living out there, and the vehicles would help them do that. So I think there is a balance there and we should hear both sides of that. I could see how it is difficult to move into that space until we have greater compliance happening in the industry overall. Thank you.
Chair? No, thank you. I do not remember... and I am going to hand it over to CM Maloney, and after CM Maloney, CM Schulman.
Thank you, Chair Epstein, and thank you for your testimony and for being here. I represent the East Side of Manhattan and parts of Midtown, and I do not think it is a coincidence that four out of five of the questions are coming from folks who represent Manhattan. Do you have data on the geographic breakdown? I know we were digging into a lot of the numbers around the number of pedicabs, the number of pedicabs that are unlicensed, as well as the complaints and summonses by geographic area or by borough. We do not have that data broken down, but we can request that the department provide us the geographic breakdown. Great. Thank you, CM. That would be great. And what about where the vehicles operate right now? My understanding is they are predominantly operating in Central Park and the Theater District. And then what about the enforcement resources — are they appropriately allocated by geographic area where we are seeing the vast majority of the pedicab activity?
Well, the enforcement resources — the Police Department and the Parks Department conduct the on-street enforcement. I know they have established commands in Central Park and parts of Midtown, and they will strategically deploy more folks to help with enforcement when there are operations happening or when peak seasons are happening.
Thank you. I think, just echoing some of the comments from earlier, it seems that two or three of the major enforcement agencies are not at the table. NYPD and Parks are only covering a small piece of the pie of the complaints that we are hearing on the ground. There are the tourist issues with scams and overcharging, but the vast majority are safety issues — speeding, noise complaints, and then standing in no-standing zones and cluttering the streets. That is what is the motivation behind the Bill that is in this package to create buffer zones of about 550 feet or so from these major tourist destinations. One of the things we are spending a lot of time talking about is what versus better coordination with NYPD. One of the concerns I have is we need a solution now. How long would it take if we were to shift this responsibility over to TLC to build up that capacity to enforce?
Thank you, CM. It is actually very difficult to estimate. There are a number of new Bills related to the industry floating around, whether it is manual pedal versus electric, so we would need to have a better understanding of the full responsibilities required in order to do that. But we could work with all parties and provide a timeline and estimation of the resources needed, because we would still have to ensure that the for-hire vehicle industry's needs are met as well. We have over 180,000 licensed drivers across the City of New York.
Can I also just clarify something? I think I was imprecise about that. NYPD and the Parks Department are the primary enforcement agencies on the street. TLC is not involved in the enforcement side of that picture.
One other thing. I want to introduce two solutions, creative solutions, to try to get to enforcement, which it sounds like we all agree is being explored, to ensure that pedicabs are operating where they are supposed to or not standing. BIDs often have jurisdiction or are supporting many of the areas where pedicabs are operating. Is there a way that the enforcement powers could be expanded to BIDs or any other creative solutions you have to help us get to the enforcement issue as fast as possible?
Yeah, I would say the BIDs have been great partners to us on this issue. I would certainly be interested in looking into more of how we can support one another in terms of any enforcement activities. And the first part of your question, I am sorry, I am...
Are there technologies that will be explored, or any other ideas for how to get to enforcement, which it sounds like we all agree is the biggest...
Challenge. Yes. So we are looking to create greater connections, automated reports between agencies, so that we can move, get that information on a regular basis and move quicker. That work is ongoing.
Thank you. Thank you, CM Maloney. Now over to Council...
CM Schulman. Hi, good morning. I am from Queens, but I do have constituents that use the pedicabs and come to Manhattan and all that. So a question for you: can a complainant file a noise-related complaint about a pedicab business or driver? That was heard. Yes. Not you, Lynn. I believe somebody filed it. If somebody filed a...
...noise complaint, they would go to the police department. Maybe — the legislation is not on the table here — but maybe it is a question of, I have a Bill where 311 complaints go to where the actual issue is, the agency. So just there. But I think the issue of a consumer complaining about noise happening in the street — from our perspective we want to try to address it in real time as quickly as possible.
Understood, or bring the enforcement agent that can bring the summons against that activity.
And that is why it goes to 311.
Although I know that some understand. It is just they are all over the place, so we do not have... exactly. Yeah.
So we need to have some kind of protocol in relation to that question. So in the past year, how many noise-related complaints have been filed against pedicab drivers? Do you have an idea of that or you do not?
We do not have that. Can we get that? Yes. All right. How many of those complaints resulted in penalties imposed on the pedicab driver or the pedicab business?
For noise complaints, we would have to defer to other agencies, so...
You do not. So I am going to go on to different questions. Apologies.
That is all right. You know, how many... let us see. We know that overcharging is the most frequent pedicab complaint to 311, and that is you, right? Okay, great. Can you share more details about the content of these complaints? For example, are they related to exorbitant prices, or are they alleging the pedicab drivers are charging consumers more than the posted price? I think it is case by case, it could be a mix. I would say when I looked through the complaints and the coding, I see the vast majority seems to be more about overcharging and less about the advertising per se. So I would say yes, since 2022, 335 complaints related to...
...overcharging. Does the administration have any concerns about setting a permanent rate for pedicabs that is indexed to inflation? I think, as I was mentioning earlier, pricing clarity is something that I think this industry could benefit from. Fixed rates, however, I think is a big step, not just for the agency, but also for the businesses and for the workers. So I think we want to make sure that I have an understanding of the implications on those businesses' ability to operate. How compliant businesses would be impacted by fixed rates is something to consider. Certainly, meters is a conversation we are ready to have. I think meters would be very beneficial. Fixed rates, I think, is something that we still want to talk through with the Council.
A little bit related to what the Chair asked before, in terms of if you go somewhere else, another city, country or whatever: does the administration have any concerns with creating a scannable code that can be used to trace the pedicab registration number and the name of the pedicab business? We are still evaluating the cost of scannable registration, but we can, should this Bill advance, provide those costs. Because if you have scannable codes, it would help somebody actually see how much they are supposed to be charged and all that kind of thing. All of that, so that somebody who is not from somewhere else can do that.
Yes, I understand the goals for the scannable codes. I think for us, we would like to share the budgetary implications of creating scannable codes for this smaller industry that we license.
...not to say that we are sorry. No.
Okay, I was going to say, not to say that we are not open to having a discussion about this. It is just that we want to make sure we are sharing the full context of the implications of legislation.
A Council investigation found that the vast majority of pedicabs... we did this already? You know, the administration tends to say it does not have the resources to do some of this stuff, but also the burden then goes down on the consumer eventually. So we have to try to really figure that out and work with you. I think these Bills are pretty good in what they are asking for and I think that they are practical. So we are going to have to find some solutions because every agency is having a tough time, and I appreciate the work you do, by the way. I just want to say that.
Thank you, CM Schulman. I shared that sentiment as well, that these problems need to be addressed and we need to come up with creative solutions for them as well. Thank you very much. Thank you, Chair.
Thank you, CM Schulman. I am going to come back for a few minutes if that is okay. So you mentioned the lottery. How often do you do a lottery for pedicab licensing? It is an annual lottery.
Chair, and if someone wants to apply outside the lottery, can they do that? My understanding is you can apply for the license, and then the lottery happens throughout the year, and then when you want to get the vehicle plates you go through the lottery.
So today I leave here and I am like, you know, I really want to be a pedicab driver. So I can go fill out a form now and then wait until you decide if I am eligible for the driver license. You can apply for that. There is no cap on driver licenses and you can become a driver for pedicab businesses. You apply for the pedicab business license and when you receive a license, you can submit to the lottery, which happens once a year, to get a registered vehicle out on...
...the streets. Yeah. And when is that lottery? It happens in the springtime, I think, in May. And so the pedicab...
...businesses can only operate a registered vehicle, and the only person who is allowed to be behind the handlebars is a pedicab driver. So you are saying if I want to get a new vehicle — I decided I want a career change — I have to wait till the springtime to do that. But in the springtime, since you have over 800 available but only 300 issued, who gets turned down from those applications? I think it is a mixture of folks who might submit for the lottery but then when they get awarded, they do not pick up the plate for whatever reason. Also, the full number of applicants to the lottery are not equal to the amount of registration plates available.
How many applied last year...
...for the lottery? Since 2024 we have had 311 pedicab businesses apply for the lottery each year, and they get renewal every year as well. So what percentage of...
...people get turned down who apply? I am not sure we are turning down people at the lottery stage. It is more that once you are a pedicab business and you apply to the lottery, you can get the plate. We do a qualifying inspection — that is the annual inspection — to ensure that the vehicle is compliant. If you received a plate and we inspect you and your vehicle is not compliant, we would take that plate back and you are not able to operate that vehicle. So assuming someone has got a vehicle and a personal license, they can ride the vehicle and it is operational. What percentage of those people, or is there anyone who is just getting turned down who is applying?
They all just, once they apply and have a licensed vehicle, are going to be able to become a pedicab operator?
We have been denying folks at renewal and revoking licenses. I know you mentioned you revoked approximately 90.
For those people that were able to get new licenses again, were those 90 able to, in subsequent years, get a license back? Typically there is a cooling-off period...
...after you have lost a license, and I think it is like a year, and you can come back and get another. So of those 90, how many of them are currently operating? I do not have that information. Could you get it for us? So why do you think the vast majority of people — three quarters of the people who are operating in this industry — are not even bothering to apply for a license, either for themselves or for their vehicle? I think over the past few years, non-compliance has been particularly centered around unlicensed activity. I think when you have unlicensed activity, the incentives are off, and that is why I think we need to focus our enforcement and education efforts back onto this industry.
Do you have... so you are saying people are making a cost-benefit analysis, saying the cost of applying for a license versus the risk of not applying — three quarters of people are not applying because in their analysis, their thinking is it is more beneficial not to apply for the license, as they will have less oversight?
You know, I think that could be part of it, but I am also really interested to hear on this question from the compliant actors in the industry right now. I think they could really speak to us about what they are seeing in their industry in terms of unlicensed activity. I think there is an aspect of... I think it is always inherently unfair for one business to be trying to comply as much as possible while others are not. We as an enforcement mechanism want to ensure — and generally the administration wants to ensure — that the folks who are following the rules...
...are rewarded, so to speak. We touched on the bond earlier, and insurance as well. My understanding from speaking to workers and businesses is that insurance costs are going up too. I do not know if that is tied into the unlicensed activity as well. I think that is something to investigate further. So let me ask you: since this has become such a vastly...
...unregulated industry, since three quarters of people are unlicensed and therefore not regulated by you, passing further regulations could still potentially just hurt the licensed people who are already being regulated by you. You can revoke their license and give more free rein to the unregulated people, because they are like, well, not being regulated now, so the additional regulations will not hurt them. How do we incentivize it enough to get people into the fold to actually apply? Well, I think let us take an example of meters or rates, or improved signage around rates. That is something that the police department will be able to enforce whether that is an unlicensed or licensed actor. So I think there is an ability to have new regulations here that we could use as tools for enforcement of the issues that are arising. I think, as we were discussing throughout the day, we need other solutions as well in terms of greater communication channels between agencies, greater communication channels with stakeholders. These things we also need to incorporate.
I mean, I am just worried that the tool we have in our tool belt, which is ticketing, seems like not a really strong enforcement mechanism here to force people into a legal system. I am wondering what advice you, as the overseeing agency, would have to craft other solutions besides just having NYPD continue to ticket, when 90% of those tickets are not enforced. What other tools do you think you need to have? We are talking about pricing, obviously, but that is just... if people do not...
...list the prices, it is just more tickets. I think we need other tools here to be able to push people into a regulatory scheme. I think we are open to having that conversation. But what additional tools can the administration have for this...
...industry? And you just have not come up with tools yet?
Well, we have been working with folks in this room to try and address the situation for years, and we want to keep working at that. There are tools that, ideally, the Council can give us today, and we will be very excited for that. But that does not mean the conversation stops there.
All right, I am going to... I know CM Brewer has additional questions. I want to hand it over to her. Thank you. Just a couple of things. I want to hear from people in the room from the Taxi and Limousine Commission. You have peace officers, right? So they could, in fact, cover pedicabs.
Obviously, funding is an issue, I know, and I want to thank you, Commissioner. We have had a great conversation and I appreciate your input. But can you... I mean, TLC really has the authority already in some sense, with peace officers, to do enforcement. Do you...
I will never say no to more resources. The Chair said he was going to get you some funding.
One thing, he is good for it.
I know one thing I want to sort of point out, because I might not have been clear when I initially discussed what we do: we do not, when we target unlicensed for-hire activity, patrol across the five boroughs. We do not have one borough... I am still responsible for the 180. I know. I am just saying with pedicabs it is one borough. Oh, go ahead. So we are not patrolling. These are targeted enforcement operations. I know some of the issues that arose — I am hearing quality-of-life issues. We are not here to duplicate that quality-of-life enforcement, which is handled by NYPD. We specifically target unlicensed for-hire operations. So when the idea of a quick response to, say, a noise complaint comes up, we would likely not be there, in fact, because of the geographical constraints of the City for us and how large it is. So the idea that someone makes a complaint for noise and we do not respond — I hope I am making that clear. It is targeted enforcement. The other aspect is that unlicensed for-hire activity is across all five boroughs, and any diversion of resources is really going to be pulling resources from the outer boroughs.
So I understand that, but I am just saying peace officers could, in fact, within the description of what you do now, have that applied to pedicabs without getting into some of the other agencies and what they do.
You know, I am not actually entirely...
...sure that is true, but I will not...
...say... that status is through the special patrolman program. We currently have a Bill out there being considered to give us that status without the special patrolman designation through NYPD. Okay, and...
That is...
...so I do not want to give you incorrect information.
Okay, so it is part of the ongoing discussion.
One more question for the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. How many people would it take, do you think, to license pedicabs? Obviously there are different agencies, it is complicated, but what do you think would be a good...
...number? Currently, you know, we do not have a dedicated pedicab unit for licensing and reviews of licenses by our general counsel. It is work that is incorporated into the everyday tasks. I would say full-time employees, it is probably approximately two to three.
Thank you, CM Brewer. Just a couple of last questions and we will let you all go.
So the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection does have some people who do enforcement out on the street. So if there is someone selling illegal... I do not know, if you go to someone selling illegal cigarettes, or they are not licensed for tobacco, or they are licensed for tobacco and they are selling something else, you have people who go out and do that enforcement, correct?
Yes. Can I elaborate a little bit more, though? Those...
...folks are focused on brick-and-mortar inspections.
And why they focused on brick and mortar. I think, speaking from my experience over the past ten years, there are inherent challenges that we as inspectors face when conducting enforcement in public spaces. I am speaking from experience of street vending enforcement, for example, ticket seller enforcement. Our folks are not police officers or officers in any kind of way. They do not have badges, they do not have the ability to detain people. In fact, we have actually had cases where our inspectors engaging in this type of enforcement in public spaces have been assaulted or threatened. Even in the context of, unlike the smoke shop, and we have shared this with the Council previously, we have had inspectors who had the doors on their hands or shutters brought down on their feet. It is really challenging for us then to try to expand that out to enforcement of moving vehicles or ambulatory actors. What you could do is enforcement in collaboration with another enforcement agency. You could do the pedicab enforcement along with NYPD, you staff on site, you could both issue violations through NYPD. We have
done that in the past. I think, without disparaging at all my colleagues' work, we do amazing work. There is a certain redundancy and liability there. In the context of that inspector who was assaulted during a ticket selling operation, he was with a police officer and it just created another exposure for an assault. So I think that is why we try to, as much as possible, leverage our expertise on the licensing and broader investigation scale while limiting our footprint on street presence.
I hear you and I am just having a hard time figuring out, like, if...
We are having a problem where like three quarters of this industry is illegal, and we all acknowledge it is a problem and we acknowledge that we need to do better enforcement and to fix the problem. We do have existing tools, obviously we want to give you more tools, but it is like if someone, you know, by tomorrow wanted to go and start selling alcohol at a store around the corner from my house without a license to do it, they would just get shut down. It would be easy to shut them down and the State Liquor Authority and everyone else would say you cannot do that. But I do not know why it seems like when we see unlicensed activity, where they are basically taking advantage of tourists and sometimes New Yorkers, why this seems like it is a harder effort. That is what I am struggling with here. I think the on-street enforcement creates a challenge for us with the tools that we have available.
I want to know where there are tools you would want to have available if you were going to do on-street enforcement and what additional tools would be helpful.
I do not know if pushing the agency on enforcement is the right approach for this work, given the fact that our inspectors are not equipped for that. I think the strength of this agency, as we have showcased over the past year if not more, is our expertise in the industry. In the context of ticket sellers, for example.
But Carlos, why stay involved in this industry at all then if it is not leaning into your strengths? Why do we not, you know, you can still license and let enforcement happen in other places, because it does not seem like NYPD has the tools and they are struggling. Why are we not thinking creatively about a better way to do enforcement here? I think that is what CM Brewer and I are trying to get at here. It is like we have a problem that we should be able to fix and we are, I think, dancing around that a bit. I would say...
I would say coming to this hearing today, we want to be a part of this conversation. As an administration we recognize that there are issues with this industry, issues with the way that things are set up, and this is not, I think, the end of this conversation. This is a part of, I think, a larger solution and goal-setting that we have to do.
All right. Thank you. I appreciate all your time and unless there are any more questions from our colleagues, this panel is dismissed. People in the public who are here to testify should be signing up with the Sergeant at Arms. And I remind the public that this is a formal government proceeding. Decorum shall be maintained at all times. Please be silent and do not approach the witness table. There is no video recording or photography at the witness table. Members of the public not present may submit audio or video recordings of testimony, but they can submit transcripts of such to the Sergeant at Arms later. Again, please, if you want to testify, sign up to testify. If you know the hearing topics, written testimony is welcome and you can submit that to the Sergeant at Arms or submit it within 72 hours. We now have our first panel, which is Danielle Modest, Kenneth Winter and Makan Camera. Okay, great. We have our first panel. If you want to just start, we can get to the other panelists after that. Sure. Good morning. Well, before you start, we are also joined by CM Epstein. Thank you for joining us.
Thank you. I am Daniel Modest. I oversee the Midtown Community Justice Center, where petty criminal summonses are heard. Thank you, Chair Epstein and members of the Committee, for hearing this package of Bills that reflect the recommendations surfaced at the roundtable we held late last year. Those recommendations guided the development of Int 0077-2026, Int 0673-2026, Int 1026-2026, Int 1063-2026, Int 0992-2026 and Int 0993-2026.
Together, these Bills include the components of comprehensive reform required to fix this dysfunctional industry. The current status quo does not incentivize drivers to get licensed, it does not incentivize vehicle owners to register their vehicles, vehicles cannot easily be connected to their owners, and it does not allow consumers to easily identify legitimate pedicabs on the street or to know how much a ride will cost. The signage currently provided for registered cabs is printed off a computer — anybody could make one.
It simultaneously criminalizes a primarily immigrant workforce by relying on law enforcement to respond to infractions in what should be a professional industry.
There has been a lot of discussion today and around this issue in general around overcharging consumers and ripping off tourists, and I just want to be really clear that this is not what we are seeing in court. Those issues are not being handled at all. In most cases, these kinds of infractions would constitute misdemeanor arrests, not summonses, and we are not seeing those. The cases coming into court are most frequently over the last three months. These are the most frequent summonses: pedicabs without headlights, pedicabs without battery-operated tail lights, without registration, no pedicab driver license and operating in a bicycle lane.
The things that people really care about are not being addressed in court and are largely not being addressed at all. There is something wrong with an industry if every worker who operates within it ends up in criminal court at some point and yet none of the issues people care about are actually being addressed.
We expect that shifting oversight of pedicabs will bring about the licensing and enforcement changes required for a healthy industry, but only if additional resources are provided to that agency to do it the right way. This hearing represents a chance for the
Council to pass public policy solutions that have the full support of almost all parties who care about this issue. We were able to confirm that when we had our roundtable and wrote our report.
Thank you very much for your consideration.
Okay, go ahead, sir.
Members of the Committee, my name is Makan Camera, President of the New York Pedicab Alliance, known as NYPA. Two years ago we came together because we were afraid of losing the work that feeds our families. Honest drivers were being judged by the actions of people who cheated. We could not stand by and let those people destroy everything we had worked for. That is why we created NYPA in 2024.
We are pedicab drivers and owners. We spend our days on the streets, welcoming visitors and showing them the city we love. When we finish a long day of peddling we go home as parents, spouses and people whose families depend on us. For us, protecting this industry means protecting our ability to put food on the table and pay the rent. Our members gave from their earnings to keep this effort going. Our committee gave their time, their money and their energy. Even when people doubted us, they kept showing up. Today I carry their hopes into this room.
We want our passengers to be safe and we want honest drivers to be able to keep working with dignity. Every scam hurts, and every dishonest driver loses trust. We are committed to working with officials to protect passengers, stop scams and hold dishonest operators accountable.
Electric assist matters deeply to us. We are not asking to go faster. We are asking for help carrying up to three people, and peddling for that puts tremendous strain on our bodies. In 2026, safe pedal assistance should not be a privilege, it should be a right for people doing this demanding work. We support clear safety standards. Please recognize the human being behind the pedals. With support, transparent pricing, accessible training and identification that helps passengers recognize licensed operators, fixed rates must reflect operating costs.
Drivers also need lawful places to rest and pick up passengers and meaningful relief from insurance costs. Please reconcile these proposals so that safe electric assist, our independent status and the removal of imprisonment are preserved under whichever agency regulates us. This decision will affect whether parents can keep working and families can pay their bills. We want reform that protects passengers and gives honest drivers effective tools. Give working drivers a meaningful role in shaping these rules. NYPA is ready to be part of this. Please work with us. Thank you.
Thank you. Good, sir.
Good morning. My name is Kenneth Winter. I am a 23-year veteran of the industry and have been working this job for a very long time. I will admit that I do use an electrical assist system, which I did not use for the first 15 years of my profession. I am also a licensed tour guide, by the way, but I did the first 15 years of my profession without one. This has led to me developing a neuropathy in my legs and some mobility issues, which also led to venous insufficiency, which makes it a little more difficult for me to operate my vehicle. I am now a single father as of 2020, and due to the pandemic, which caused a lot of problems, a lot of the enforcement fell away and it has made the industry more difficult to operate in.
I need the electrical assist because I need to be able to keep working. I cannot be idealistic anymore like I used to be, and it was too late for me to really make a career change anyway. This is what I am and what I do. I am an ambassador for the City of New York and I am basically engaged in teaching and hosting visitors to the City of New York and do my very best to show New York City in its best light. All I can do is hope that these hearings will bring a positive change to the industry. The issues that I have heard so far I am sure can be addressed, and I am sure I speak for our organization when I say that we are very open and willing to participate with all of the agencies involved in order to try to help them reach our goals, which is to better this industry and make it a part of the actual network of transportation in the City. Thank you.
Some initial questions. Why do you think the vast majority of people in this industry are unlicensed? Is there just a disincentive to get licensed? Are you asking me? Sure, anyone can answer.
One thing to make sure... So you hit the nail on the head earlier that there is no incentive for anyone to really try to get licensed. A lot of the enforcement fell away and so it made people more dependent on that lack of enforcement. People were encouraged by the fact that there was no enforcement to continue operating without a license and without insurance and without a lot of these other things that are required. On top of that, I sort of disagree with one of the representatives about there being six insurance companies. There are actually about two or three maximum. One of them has just started opening up to us, but the price of that insurance is exorbitant — $5,000 or higher per unit for a single year, which has gone up about 900%. Actually, I am sorry. Yeah, it is about ten times more than what it used to be, and so it has made it much more difficult for legal operators to obtain this. But the fact that there was no enforcement also encouraged them not to bother to get those licenses. I had a driver come up to me and tell me that
he stopped getting the license and the insurance about three years ago because he saw there was no consequence for it. That is the point, you know. So people on licenses, or even if getting tickets, they are meaningless, basically. Well, there might be a disconnect sometimes between agencies where one agency knows something and maybe the other agency does not really get that information in time. So you are
saying NYPD does not do that kind of ticketing? They do. It is just kind of a little disparate sometimes in the way they do it.
It gets harder, and I think one of the problems is they are not coordinating things. As you just saw from the questions you were asking them, pretty much all the questions you are asking NYPD, they do not have answers for the most part, and that was one of the first problems we identified when we created NYPA. They are not coordinating. You ask NYPD what to do, you go to them, you go back to them, for two years now we do not have answers. And to go back to what you can say about the insurance, about why
these unlicensed operators persist... Before COVID the insurance was about $600 per unit, but now we are close to $6,000 and we do not know why. We asked, no answer. We asked anybody, no answer. And it keeps increasing, you know. I am not defending drivers or owners, but it could be one of the factors, because before COVID, pretty much everybody had a license. But when you move from $600 to almost $6,000, that could be one of the problems. So yeah.
I would just like to add that the consumer has no opportunity to help drive out the unlicensed drivers by identifying which cabs are registered before getting in. There is really no way to identify them on the street, and that seems like an inexpensive fix to make it very, very clear which cabs are licensed by this City and which are not, and to make it hard for cabs that look
illegitimate to get riders, in addition to right-sizing. Do you think that with more information
on the street or through a QR code on the cab itself, consumers would be able to make better informed choices? Or are the unlicensed pedicabs still going to be able to just say, well, come with us, we are cheaper? Are they still going to be able to incentivize people to use them? I am not sure what is driving people to get into a licensing scheme when they can just operate and potentially defraud consumers. Well, you know, they do not always defraud them or charge them a different price. There is no incentive in the structure we have right now to license people. I completely agree with you. I think this is a multi-pronged answer, which is why we put forth a report with a series of multi-part recommendations that attack from different angles. But I do think that is one aspect of it. There could be a consumer education campaign around which pedicabs to get into and which not to get into, and to have plates that are legitimate-looking with a bar code that actually associates the registration and the license of the person driving the cab. Right now, as Kenny and Makan shared, there is no information sharing between agencies, so there is no way to hold anybody accountable and consumers, like I said, are just sort of taking their chances. Every agency that has participated in trying to do enforcement has done an excellent job within their own field. The problem is that because of that disconnect, sometimes the work of one agency is cancelled out by another. And so because there is no real...
Connectivity there also. I should mention that a lot of the reason why a lot of these guys do this is because it is really the almighty dollar. It has become like the new gold rush when it comes to the pedicab industry, because they tell other people to come down to New York City and do this. 65 million visitors, 42 million to the park. Plenty of people you can rip off. The people that I have encountered on the street have been bragging about how much they make. They almost want to tell you how much they are making, and the reason why is because they can do these 15 to 20 minute rides, bill the customer and disappear into the mist. These rip-offs do not really happen much in the park, although we have discovered there are a few bad actors in the park as well. But the reason why is because the park is structured, so it does not make sense for us to charge on these per-minute rates. So most of us, we charge a flat rate. But the guys on the street, they are abusing the system, given that they can charge whatever they want. Some supplement the right thing, but no one is putting up these signs, and the size of the pricing when they are there — they are very tiny, black on grey, very tiny little lettering. And they are deceptive, or they just simply pull out a rate card at the end of the ride. That is also part of the reason for the lights and sound — lights and sounds to attract and then distract.
They get you into the bike, it looks like fun, you come to the end of the ride and suddenly it is permitted per person, $2.50 a minute per person. And this is part of the reason why I feel that a price cap might also help with that.
A maximum rate that will allow the customer to eventually have consumer confidence again, knowing that they are not going to be charged more than this particular rate per ride. And so you guys support the idea of like a meter, like a cab has, where you would just say you get in and it is $5 for one to a certain number — $5 to get in, but every minute after there is an additional cost.
Yes. I want to speak for the night, but yes, we do support that. The prices being the same is going to, you know, kind of bring clarity. As Kenny said, 80% — or I said 90% — of the people from my part of Central Park, we 100% make sure people know exactly how much they are going to pay because we agree on things. You know what they want to do, because for people who are familiar with Central Park — you know, the small slope, the lower loop — we tell them exactly how it is going to be. That works better for everybody, and that is what we want across the board for good people.
And just going back to the previous question about licensing versus not licensing — one of the things is, people who do not have a license, for example, are not being denied anything. For example, if the NYPD bikes someone for unlicensed riding and stuff like that, a couple of days later you get your bike back. And because we all know each other, people say, why would I bother to even get licensed when you guys who are licensed get treated the same way? What we want is a night-and-day difference. We want to make sure that if somebody is seen with fake plates or whatever, there should be some type of law or rule to make sure these people either come with the right plate or face real consequences. Because otherwise they are going to keep doing whatever they are doing if they are going to get their bike back in two or three weeks. We will go nowhere.
To give you one more example — on July 8, I was finally targeted for the electrical system on my pedicabs. I happened to have both pedicabs with me because I had rented a bike out to a movie. I have a second pedicab that I never usually have with me — I only keep it as a backup — and they had rented it for the movie. I happened to pick it up that day from the movie set and happened to have them both with me around 11 p.m. that night. I was having some pizza on 54th and Seventh Avenue and one of the units rolled up on me. Despite the fact that I had been stopped earlier that day by a different unit, basically every time that happens I gladly provide my license, my insurance certificate, my inspection certificate — I have a hard copy with me just in case — and I provide them all of that. That unit basically said to me, "Thank you very much for following the law, have a nice day." But the second unit took my bike because of the electric assist, and despite the fact that I had provided all of my information and was completely compliant, they took my bike. I lost about 20 days of work, which was a major hardship for me. I am a single father and I support not only my daughter but her grandparents who take care of her. So it has put me into this major difficult position that I am still trying to recuperate from.
It is really hard for someone like myself who does everything to make sure that when it comes to my customers, I always agree upfront on pricing and am completely transparent about everything that I do. For me to get hit in this manner is really tough, knowing that victims are still out there getting ripped off and those people continue to operate.
Okay. And I know CM Brewer has questions. One more just around the electric assist issue, because we have heard concerns — we had a hearing last week, I think it was, on bike safety and the proliferation of the problems in the city. The real concern we have heard from bike advocates is they like to have electric assist, but how do we respond to those safety concerns if we allow electric assist in this industry?
Okay, to answer that — Kenny is going to add after me. So really, for us, for example, for us people who work in the park...
For us, it is really more of a torque thing, more of an assistance. There is not a real speed issue going on with pedicabs when it comes to Central Park, for example.
The only thing that I think concerns people is drivers of a pedicab going against some of the sort of guys that are in the midtown area, the Times Square area, over by the plaza. They do a lot of these donuts. I want to be clear — the industry has been around for 32 years. We have never had a fatality caused by a pedicab.
We have a perfect safety record when it comes to that. The only time there has ever been a tragedy was caused by a reckless driver on 42nd Street, and that had nothing to do with the driver's operation of the vehicle. I think that the 750-watt limit would be perfect because, really, it is more about...
Torque, not really about speed. My maximum speed has been 14 miles an hour, and that is me trying really hard. Our average speed in Central Park, for example, is anywhere from 6 to 10 miles an hour, because we are doing tours. People want to see things. As Kenny said, we are not looking for speed. We do tours, people want to see things, and so our concern is not about 15 to 20 miles per hour. If you can even go five miles per hour, that...
Would be fine, because people pay a lot of money to come to New York. They want to see things. We have people in here like 67 years old — they are not looking for speed. They just need help, because if you have to pull three people... And again, most major cities now, everywhere in Asia, Africa, Europe — they have electric assist except New York City, which is the best city in the world, and they are still not allowed to use that. That is something that needs to be changed.
All of the bikes have it, or nearly all of the bikes already have it, and all that is happening is people like Kenny are having their bikes confiscated and their lives impacted, but it does not actually change whether or not the drivers are driving with pedal assist.
Thank you, CM Brewer. Thank you for that question. Whatever the reason, the good news is that the pedicabs have not had fires in people's apartments due to batteries, and it has been mostly individuals. What is the reason for that? I mean, I do not think you have had any — you do not bring the pedicab home. Go ahead and explain.
So...
I know it is probably going to sound like I am defending them and stuff, but it is a hard truth.
A lot of the guys that work the street...
Their number one thing is to get out there and work as long as possible, and they basically sometimes abuse their equipment. What they care about is draining that battery as fast as possible, and very often they basically plug the batteries into the same outlets. They have very unsafe practices sometimes, or the batteries are defective, or they buy a cheaper battery because it is about the cost. Nobody really does the research when it comes to this. So this is part of the reason why some of the fires happen. A lot of these things have been addressed, and garages do not really allow anybody to charge their batteries in the garages — no one will do it there. But why has it happened in somebody's home? I have no idea. It is probably because of that very same reason. I hope people wake up and do the right thing.
I think if we work on the industry as a whole, then...
Licensing batteries will be the correct...
Battery certification really goes a long way with that. I personally have never, ever had an incident because I do my research and make sure that whatever I use is high quality, to make sure that I am never going to have that issue, because I never want to have my name attached to something like that. That is part of what I was concerned about when my bike was actually confiscated — when the officers took my bike, the batteries were still connected. I was really worried that it ended up at 41st Street, where they have a lot where they keep the bikes, and that they would react with the rain. Because I do not ride in the rain and I do not work the street, I was worried that it was going to rain that weekend and that there was going to be a reaction, as it did on 48th Street. There was a fire on 48th Street with an open air lot where someone left a defective battery in the rain, which reacted and caused a major problem there. So thank you.
And one more thing to just add to what Kenny said — you know, outside right here we have a place where they are charging a bunch of battery-powered stuff. I think these things, for us, are not even an issue. We are okay. From our perspective, whatever safety measures are available, we will use them, because our concern is that we are all family members and we care deeply about that. So we would be open to anything in order to make sure everybody is safe.
Now, one quick question for Michel. How could the City effectively enforce pedicab laws without relying on criminal charges? You talked about that a little bit — if you could expand.
Sure. I think ideally it would be street-level enforcement that is civil in nature. They could give tickets for the top charges that I named, like having a tail light out, and it would be tied to the owner of the cab, tied to the pedicab license. It would be an industry issue as opposed to a criminal one.
Okay. Do all of you support moving the industry to TLC? That seems like a general positive reaction.
Yes. As I said in my speech, we are open to working with anyone. But at the same time, our members just want more information about what being under TLC would look like, because there are a few questions that our members are asking. We want to make sure about those — for example, the fitness requirement in the Bill and the fact that the TLC might also be able to increase insurance requirements. So there are a couple of questions we want to make sure we have answers to before we give our members a full response. But we 100% want to work with anyone and any agenda to make sure the enforcement is there and the public solutions are in place, as long as they do not have a double-edged sword effect — unintended consequences that are going to negatively affect our members.
So as long as it is moving forward in a positive and constructive way, we are definitely open to pretty much anything.
Thank you very much, and thank you for your service. Thank you. Thank you for this panel. The next panel is David Satinstall, Tom Harris and Christine Nichols Booth. Yes.
Whenever you are ready, you can start. Go ahead. Thank you.
Good morning, Chair Epstein and members of the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection. My name is Christine Nicholas. I am the chair of the 115-year-old New York City business institution, the Broadway Association, dedicated to the betterment of the Broadway corridor from 14th Street up to Columbus Circle, encompassing Times Square and the Theater District. First, I wanted to just say that I am not personally opposed to the pedicab industry. I have used pedicabs because I am the mom of three kids who have insisted on using them every now and then. Thank you for your understanding and your interest in fixing the pedicab industry, which operates without clear regulations.
Obviously, from the testimony, the majority of operators are unlicensed, creating safety risks for passengers and pedestrians and an unsafe environment for the City's busiest areas — Broadway, Times Square — and for consumers, especially tourists. The vague pricing has made rip-offs and overcharging a common occurrence with no recourse. The seven Bills under consideration represent commonsense solutions agreed upon by the industry advocates, the Midtown BID Coalition and the Midtown Community Justice Center. Having seven separate Bills is affirmation that this industry is in desperate need of reform, yet seven separate Bills are also confusing to the public, and we urge the City Council to simplify this process and consolidate these Bills to pass a law that promotes safety, transparency, accountability and fairness to all of those affected and involved.
Regarding the specific legislation under consideration today, the Broadway Association supports Int 0992-2026 and Int 0673-2026 and Int 0077-2026 to standardize rates and mandate meters requiring visible pricing, scannable registration plates with information about the pedicab business owner and prohibiting amplified sound. The Broadway Association supports Int 0993-2026, moving oversight to the TLC, which could fix the broken link between licensing and enforcement, and Int 0064-2026 to designate curb space. The Bills under consideration underscore the need for immediate action, but like any new rules or laws, they are only as good as the enforcement required to put them into effect. We strongly suggest that if the TLC is successful in getting oversight — although it does not sound like they want it — we also urge that the NYPD remain involved 24/7 in enforcing unlawful and dangerous behavior that has made midtown seem chaotic and ungovernable. The Broadway Association thanks the Chair and CM Brewer and the Committee for making this a priority.
Whoever is next.
Good morning, members of the Committee. My name is David Saltonstall. I am Vice President of Government Relations and Policy at the Central Park Conservancy, and thank you for this opportunity. The Conservancy supports this package of bills to reform the City's pedicab fleet: moving oversight to the TLC, requiring meters or timers on every pedicab, and making it possible to weed out bad actors are common sense steps.
But rather than walking through each bill, I want to describe what the current system looks like from our perspective. Central Park is the City's most visited attraction, with more than 40 million visits a year, and virtually every visitor from out of town is solicited, often aggressively, by a small subset of pedicab operators or their agents within a few blocks of the park. Not some of them — nearly all of them.
For many, it is confusing, and too often it ends with a sky-high fare that was never made clear: a family told one price at the outset and charged several times that amount at the end of the ride. Grand Army Plaza and Columbus Circle were designed as grand entrances to one of the world's most iconic green spaces. Instead, those areas feel more like a shakedown. That is the first impression many visitors get of Central Park, and it is a memory they take home. It reflects on the park and it reflects on New York, and it does not have to be this way. Pedicabs can be a safe, green and genuinely enjoyable way to see the park.
What we need is a well-regulated fleet, one that rewards the many honest drivers who are simply trying to make a living — some of whom you have heard from today — and rids the industry of those whose business model depends on exploiting people who do not know better. A properly regulated fleet under the TLC can also be managed so it has minimal impact on the park's already crowded drives, which are shared by cyclists, runners and millions of others.
Finally, I do want to recognize the New York Pedicab Alliance, whose members have spoken here today. I imagine it is a rare event when this body is asked to regulate an industry when the members of that industry come up and are literally begging you for more reform, for more oversight. They welcome it because they know it protects their livelihoods as much as it protects the public. So we urge the Council to pass this package in its entirety, and I would be happy to answer any questions. Thank you.
Good morning. My name is Tom Harris, President of the Times Square Alliance. I want to thank you, Chairman Epstein, CM Brewer, members of the Committee and members of the Council for helping to make the pedicab industry work for all. A pedicab ride can be a nice way to see our great City, or it can be a nightmare. For far too long, the pedicab industry has not worked for the community, for consumers, and we found out, for most of the honest drivers themselves.
Most of them are honest, like Kenny and Makan. They are just working people looking to make a living. Those honest workers have been overshadowed by another group that flouts the laws and takes advantage of consumers. First, let us look at what pedicabs do. Pedicabs pick people up, take them somewhere and charge them money — the very definition of a vehicle for hire. But for reasons most of us cannot remember, they are not regulated by the Taxi and Limousine Commission, the entity that regulates vehicles for hire. The agency that currently licenses pedicabs is the NYPD, which enforces the laws through a mix of civil and ineffective criminal court summonses, most of which are dismissed. There is no connection between the summons and the license, no accountability for owners of the pedicabs, and bad actors make it difficult for good actors to remain compliant and still make a living.
In partnership with the Pedicab Alliance, the Central Park Conservancy, the Midtown Justice Center and the Times Square Alliance, we developed recommendations reflected in this legislation that will treat pedicabs like other vehicles for hire, with fixed fares, meters, visible identification and civil penalties attached to licenses, a prohibition on amplified sound, and under the jurisdiction of the TLC, with a strong recommendation to increase TLC staffing. There has been a lot of talk about resources. A great deal of resources are currently dedicated to enforcing pedicab laws. They are just ineffective and put in the wrong place.
We also support pedicabs being allowed to have electric assist power. Other cities have been able to regulate pedicabs. There is no reason New York City, the greatest city in the world, cannot do the same thing. Once again, thank you.
Thank you. And I want to acknowledge that we have been joined by CM Krishnan and CM Brewer. CM Brewer, you go first this time.
My question is: given the fact that you know better than anybody else perhaps what the challenges are and the possibilities for the future with the Taxi and Limousine Commission, if we are able to pull that off — how specifically would you suggest we get some of these individuals licensed? In other words, you have the bills in front of you, but do you know more than I think most of us do about what you might be more specific about, in terms of how to make the industry better, in the hopes that the TLC takes over? But that is not the only step — there are many steps that would have to be included. I was wondering if you could speak to that.
So the first thing is: the New York City Police Department does a great job. They are utility players and they are expected to enforce all sorts of laws. Criminal court summonses are not their forte. That is not the place where these summonses should be heard. First off, when you issue a criminal court summons, discovery kicks in and there are time limits applied. We should not be sending people to jail for doing their work.
So the problem is that these summonses are dismissed because the police cannot comply with the discovery components for an offense that requires jail time. So anything that they do for unlicensed drivers is ineffective because, like Kenny and Makan said, a couple of days later they get back their pedicab. If this was regulated civilly — and whoever regulates it civilly, it could be a combination — but if the police department or any other agency issued a civil summons that had accountability built into it, they could seize the pedicab for an unlicensed operator. They would be found guilty because the standard of proof is different than in criminal court, and you would be able to act on that summons. So in my opinion, that would bring compliance in line because you have accountability. Right now there is no accountability for any of the summonses issued, and that is why the enforcement to date has been ineffective.
Thank you very much.
Do you think moving to the TLC will resolve this problem? I am worried. Honestly, we will be in the same place that we are in three years, with no enforcement. They will issue tickets and we will still have the same situation. We might be having the same conversation in three years.
Well, I hope not. But what I would say is the TLC is the perfect agency because everything is under one umbrella. They issue the licenses, they do the enforcement, and there is direct accountability between enforcement and the violation and the license. So just think about it this way: it would be my hope that in two years we have zero summonses being issued because there are clear rules, there is accountability for violations, and we bring all of those people into the fold. We talked a little bit about insurance. They also have programs to defray the cost of insurance for taxi operators, so that could help the pedicab industry be more compliant.
So again, I think the TLC was made to enforce pedicab rules. We just need to give them the resources. I think about the approach when CM Brewer and the Council addressed the unlicensed smoke shops and cannabis shops. It was a combination of civil and criminal teams that went out and addressed that. The Sheriff's Office took the lead, the police department enforced, and you were able to get rid of those problems. The same could happen here. The TLC could take the lead with police support. You could have small task forces with very few peace officers and you would clean up the industry quickly.
All right, thank you. No further questions. This panel is dismissed. Thank you. The next panel is Hesham Muhammad and Justin Culbreth. Whoever wants to can go first. And if anyone else wants to testify, they should sign up. We are getting towards the end of this, so if you are interested in testifying, please fill out one of the cards.
Good morning, Chair Epstein and members of the Committee. My name is Justin Gabbert. I started operating fire island-style cabs — carrying passengers and luggage and dealing with the daily work of keeping a fleet running. I have also ridden a pedicab in Manhattan where the driver drove recklessly and blasted music. I understand why people want changes, but the answer should be a service people can use and trust.
I am asking you to focus on two practical solutions. First, hold the operator accountable for the whole ride. A company should answer for its drivers, maintenance, insurance and complaints. Drivers need hands-on training and clear rules for safe driving and loading. Company training should work alongside City licensing. Uniforms and matching cabs help passengers recognize a service, but they do not replace inspections, visible identification or enforcement.
Second, make the price understandable before the passenger gets in. I favor studying distance-based fares because passengers know where they want to go, but the rate has to cover real costs, and passengers still need a visible, approved fare system and a receipt. I am not proposing a dollar amount today. Until the law changes, operations must follow the existing fare rules.
The photos on page one show the equipment we use on Fire Island. A larger cab can keep a group together, but that does not make it safe without separate legal approval and testing for braking, turning, boarding and loading. Electric assist needs enforceable limits. My longer-term idea is one company managing the whole fleet. My request today is a staff meeting with the responsible agencies and existing operators to define a small, legally authorized pilot: agree on the vehicles, prices and loading locations before it starts, track injuries, complaints, curb conflicts and driver earnings, and use the results to decide what deserves to grow. Thank you.
Good morning, everyone. My name is Hesham, and I am a member of the New York Pedicab Alliance. New York is my home for the last 40 years. I have been working as a pedicab driver since 2007. I am 67 years old. I love my job. I love meeting people who come from around the world to see New York. I get to show them the city that became my home and help them leave with good memories. This work is how I have supported myself and my family for many, many years. It is what I have known and what I have maintained. I have maintained a very clean driving record and I take my responsibility to my passengers seriously.
But today I have to tell you something that is difficult to admit. It is very hard to do this work the way I used to. I still want to work. I still know the city. I still know how to welcome my passengers and take care of them. But when I have to pedal uphill or keep going for many hours, my body cannot always keep up with my willingness. It is hard to love your work and feel yourself becoming unable to do it. This is why I am asking you to support the bill for electric assist. Thank you, everyone.
Good morning, Chair and members of the City Council. My name is Adam. I am 53 years old, originally from Niger, and I live in the Bronx. I have been working as a pedicab driver for almost 10 years. As an immigrant, this work has allowed me to earn an honest living, support myself and maintain my independence.
I am here today to ask you to support the bill to legalize pedal assist for pedicabs. For me, this is not just about a piece of equipment. It is about being able to continue to do the work I love. For almost 10 years I have put everything into this job, and every day I feel the pain and physical strain. But I do not want to stop working. I still want to get up each morning, go to work and support myself with dignity. Pedal assist will give me a little help when my body cannot do everything on its own. I am not looking for speed. I am asking for help to get through my working day, and I know I am not alone. Many other pedicab drivers are facing similar physical challenges. We want to welcome our passengers and contribute to our city. We are not asking for a handout. We are asking for a fair opportunity to keep working.
At 53 years old, I still have the desire to work. Please think about people like me. Think about what it means to have worked with pride toward something, and then have your body no longer allow you to do it. Please support this bill so we can keep earning an honest living with dignity and safely. For almost 10 years, this has been my American dream. Please help me keep that dream alive. Thank you for listening and thank you for your service to our community.
Thank you. Thank you. I am in the industry and I want to address all things related to moving this authority.
Will moving this authority get rid of the illegal actors on the street? No, I do not think it works that way. I think it needs to be one company, Harvey. It really does. It needs to be one company that takes over the whole industry and has its own fleet, pays the drivers, gives the drivers benefits — make it like a transportation service through New York, through the park, maybe a little different because that operates a little differently. But on the street, it could be a really great thing for Manhattan to have pedicabs and six-seaters. We really need six-seaters because that moves more people, and then you have control. You have control of the safety, you have control of the insurance, you have control of basically the maintenance, the batteries. I have got 25 batteries. I have a building that I charge them in on Long Island.
So I understand how to run this business, and I understand how it would work in Manhattan. It would eliminate the problem because if all the cabs were the same and all the drivers were wearing the same uniforms and everything looked the same, then somebody who comes in from out of town or even a New Yorker would recognize it, and social media would blow it up to the point where everybody knows that that is the cab for Manhattan. So anybody else riding around with something that does not look like ours — the cops can take them right off the street, and that is how you get rid of the bad actors.
I want to respond to the question about moving to the TLC and whether that is going to change things, and also to his comment about centralizing the system. We are open to any agency that can enforce the rules — the police department, the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. They are doing a very good job, but they need more enforcement capacity. Thank you.
Anything else you want to add? Actually, Michael, let us say we are open to any...
...agency that can help us to fix our industry. Okay. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you for this panel. I am going to bring up the next panel. And we can have someone from staff get you connected — I know you requested a meeting. We can afterwards just give you contact information to meet with them. Max Weiss, Feld, Keenan, Delennz... whoever wants to begin can go first. And if anyone else wants to testify, they should sign up. We are getting towards the end of this, so if you are interested in testifying, please fill out one of the cards.
My name is... I cannot do that. Yeah, I have been working as a pedicab driver on the street since 2007. I am here to strongly support Int 0064-2026 to create dedicated relief stands. Over the 19 years I have been working, this infrastructure is desperately needed, not just for the drivers, but for the entire city, especially in our busiest tourist places like Midtown and Times Square.
First, this Bill protects customer parking and meter revenue in high demand areas. Currently, without designated zones, pedicabs have to take up standard metered spaces while waiting for fares. By putting a pedicab curb space in Times Square, the City gets functional commercial staging.
Second, it reduces midtown traffic. When we do not have a dedicated pull-off spot in heavy traffic, drivers are forced to double-park in the active lane just to load and unload passengers. A marked designated curb space gets our pedicabs completely out of the traffic flow, instantly preventing gridlock behind us.
Third, it eliminates pedestrian conflict. In heavily foot-trafficked places, operators without official stands often idle near crosswalks or cluster near hotel doors. Dedicated stands confine operators to a predictable footprint.
Fourth, this is an exceptionally low-cost fix. It only requires painting and signing on the curb and immediately clears up congested intersections in the heart of the City.
Finally, the stands will significantly streamline enforcement. Right now, citing a driver for blocking the road creates legal gray areas. With designated spaces, enforcement officers will have clear-cut boundaries and automatic enforceable citations. So this creates a safer, more predictable environment for visiting Manhattan while giving hardworking drivers stability. Thank you.
For your time. Thank you. Good morning, everyone.
Good morning. Thank you, City Council, for giving us a chance to speak. My name is Amadou Cosimo and I have been a pedicab driver since 2006. I am a father of three teenagers who were born here, and this is my only job. I have been working hard daily to maintain my family. We used to do it like ten years ago without pedal assist, which is a really, really tough job — carrying three people on the bike makes your back ache, back pain. We are all exhausted. Today, with age up to 50, that is actually my only job. I do not see myself pedaling a bike with no assistance. The body is tired and we really need the job.
So I really strongly believe that if you decide to help us legalize it, you will definitely keep us in our jobs and keep us taking care of our families. The first point I wanted to speak about is training. I strongly believe that the drivers also need education about electricity, and they need training. There are people that come to the job and do not go to any training. That is one thing that people forget to speak about. The training is very important. Anybody who directs or gives the bike to a person needs to train them on the rules and the consequences of all the violations they are going to commit.
The third point is that any one of them that takes the lead of this company or any other organization — to be honest, you have to have a uniform price. It has to be visible, seriously visible for anyone. Not only the tourists — it has to be displayed for everyone to know about the price and to maintain the safety of the City that everybody is coming to. Thank you so much.
I know there are no questions for this panel. Thank you very much for being with us today. We appreciate your testimony so much. Thank you. Thanks. And for the last panel, we have people who wanted to testify. Please sign in. We have Christina Hansen and Paul Bader. Thank you. And there are people on Zoom — we will go to those after. But at this point, we do not have anybody on Zoom signed up, right? We have one person. Okay.
We do have one person on Zoom. Thank you. All right.
Good afternoon, CM Epstein, CM Abreu, and everybody watching remotely. My name is Christina Hansen. I am a New York City carriage driver, a licensed sightseeing guide, and a long-time resident of Hell's Kitchen. I have been an observer of the pedicab industry for a long, long time, as it is immediately adjacent to my line of work and my neighborhood.
I would like to say, first of all, I agree very much with the concerns about what goes on in the park. Central Park South has become utterly degraded with aggressive ticket selling and things like that. Also, though, there are a lot of good operators in the park, and right now with everything else going on in the park, they do operate safely and slowly at around ten miles an hour. They are not going 15 miles an hour, not going 30 miles an hour with electric assist, which, although it is currently illegal. That being said, I heard a lot of questions from the Committee to the administration about what sort of technology could we employ here, and the technology that is not being
employed here is a very simple one, and it is called a license plate. They talk about plates on pedicabs, but it is just a sticker on the fork of the vehicle. It is a sticker, and if it peels off it is voided. So the pedicab operators are kind of forced to put zip ties around it so nobody could peel it off and ruin their plate. You cannot read it. It is a four-digit number, they are easily counterfeited, they can be covered up, and there are only 840 plates out there with only 340 being issued right now. It is a three-digit number that could be visible from the back of the pedicab and from the front of the pedicab. You know, yellow cabs right now have a light on the top — it is like a very short number. They have got a plate, and if they do have a violation, it is easy to capture that and connect it to an owner. So in the park, I have had pedicabs drive recklessly and hit my horse in the face, but I cannot report it because there is just no way to even see the plate. So that would be my suggestion to the Committee. Thank you.
Go ahead, sir.
Thank you. Good afternoon. My name is Paul Bader. I am a commissioner representing Queens County and I welcome this opportunity to speak about some of these pieces of proposed legislation. The one that is most important, I am not going to address, which is whether or not it should be transferred to the TLC. I do know that the pedicab industry right now operating out there is like the Wild Wild West, and certainly there needs to be controls put on them, regardless of who the administrative and overseeing regulatory body is.
My concern, though, relative to the transference to the TLC is a fiscal one. We have had our budget cut substantially in the last fiscal year, which represented a decline of about 64 police officers who work for the TLC doing enforcement. So to ask us to additionally take on a new responsibility — which we understand is all about enforcement — because, parenthetically, let me say that the police officers I have spoken to who have worked in Midtown feel this is a regulatory issue they would rather not get involved with. So that is another reason why it is wild out there and why it needs to be addressed.
All of these issues — controlling pricing, making the licenses more visible — are part of it, but the financial concern is my main one. I have also been made aware of the fact that there was a substantial amount of money put aside over five years, about $73 million, for this bureau that you oversee, relative to the implementation and decertification of that program that was being done by taxi drivers, by Lyft and by Uber. That law was challenged by Uber, the City lost, and so unfortunately that law did not go into effect. We are hoping that a version of it does. But the question is, there was money put aside in the budget of $73 million over five years for the enforcement of that. So I would like to ask if it is possible, if this change occurs, that some of that money be reapportioned so that we can do whatever job needs to be done relative to regulation. Thank you.
Yeah, obviously if the duties were moved over to the TLC, we would need to talk about the budgetary component of that, and it is something that we talked about earlier with both the Council and the TLC. All right, I do not think we have any questions for this panel, so thank you both for being here and for testifying. I appreciate your comments — they are really helpful. I am going to move on to the Zoom panel.
We have Kristen Sona, Matthew Sona and Stephen Stallman. If you are available,
you can start your testimony. You are going to unmute yourself, please. Yes, this is Kristen Sona. I was given the option to unmute, so I am just assuming I can
go. Yeah, go ahead, please. Thank
you. Good morning, Chair and members of the Council. I am here to represent Excludes Cycle. We are a pedicab-specific ride-hailing platform, and these problems honestly have been nationwide and industry-wide. We have seen the increase of these pricing problems for, I would say, maybe around a year or so, with this per-person pricing model, and there are a lot of bad actors in the industry. So our goal was to increase trust and compliance. We have a vetting system, we have a rating system built in, and we have the goal of limiting these predatory behaviors that are going on.
We think that we can solve a lot of these industry problems. We also have a feature on the passenger side where they would see the rate before they commit, they would see the elapsed time and the accumulating fare. So we are here to ask for an approval pathway and allowance for a software-based monitoring system that would be an app on a passenger handheld device, in addition to the bike-mounted meter system.
Again, we are open to helping the industry in any way possible, but we would like for that particular allowance to hopefully be written in as well, because then we can get some kind of industry standard across whether there is an independent driver who has been doing this for 20 or 40 years, like some of these panel members we have heard from, or even a fleet owner. We could give some kind of standardization, some kind of recognized brand across this industry. It does not have to be completely controlled by one company — we do not believe that — but we would like to give consumers access from somewhere. Time is expired.
A tour of the Broadway theaters right now — they do not have to be out there standing on the street to find a pedicab. Thank you very much. Are the other people online available? I know you did, but there is no one else online. Okay, I am going to turn it over to CM Abreu.
Thank you. In your national experience, how are companies and individuals dealing with the insurance industry problem of
costs? Yeah, the insurance has really hit the industry hard. I do know there are insured people who are ripping people off too, and I think that is one of the things that started happening post-COVID, maybe three years ago around there, when the insurance companies started calling us and trying to ask how much money people were making.
And like the other guy had shared, these people that are ripping everyone off — they just want to brag, not just to the industry but to their customers, about how much they are making. So I think what happened was that these people who are ripping people off started telling the insurance companies, "Oh yeah, hey, we are making this much money," and so now the insurance companies are like, "Hey, we want our piece." That is when we really started seeing these increases, anywhere upwards of — I have heard even like $8,000 per unit per year.
So yes, what he is saying is accurate. I think you mentioned something about if it was transferred to the TLC, they could have some kind of program where they could defer the cost of their insurance. New York is also one of the hardest places to insure, so I do not know all the ins and outs of that. But I do know that for my insurance, because I am an operator as well — not in New York, but I have worked there in the past — I have to sign something saying I do not operate in New York just to get my insurance. So again, it is very complex there. I am not sure of all of the insurance issues there, but industry-wide, I cannot speak to that. Thank you very much.
Yeah.
Thank you very much for testifying today, and I think
there is no one on Zoom and no one else in person, so hearing no one else on this series,