The Organizational Strategy of the Department of Probation Committee on Criminal Justice · October 26, 2026 · 2hrs 17m Source: https://hearinghearings.nyc/hearings/committee-on-criminal-justice-the-organizational-strategy-of-the-department-of-probation-2026-10-26/ Video: https://councilnyc.viebit.com/vod/?s=true&v=NYCC-250-8-1_261026-101106.mp4 ================================================================ (00:00:24) Good morning. Welcome to the Committee on Criminal Justice. Please place your phone on vibrate or silent mode anytime during this hearing. Do not approach the dais. We are ready to begin. Good morning. I am CM Selvena Brooks-Powers, Chair of the Committee on Criminal Justice. I want to welcome everyone to today's hearing on the organizational strategy of the Department of Probation. The Department of Probation plays an important role in New York City's criminal legal system. Its responsibilities extend beyond supervising individuals in probation to include court-related investigations, juvenile intake and adjustment, and connecting people under supervision with services that support their stability and successful completion of probation. The Department's organizational approach affects how these responsibilities are carried out: how offices interact with the people they supervise, what the outcomes are for people under Department supervision, and how effectively young people and families navigate the court system. In recent years, the Department has faced significant challenges related to staffing shortages, employee retention, caseload management, and the direction of its supervision policies. As of the Department's reported vacancy rate, approximately 23%, or 255 vacancies, 210 of which were probation offices. The elimination of court liaison officer positions under the previous administration raises concerns about coordination with Family Court and the ability to identify opportunities for adjustment before young people enter formal court proceedings. The return of court liaison functions, along with changes to pay for assignments and staff requirement efforts, makes it important to examine how the Department is organized today and how these decisions affect the agency's work. The Department has been under new leadership since Commissioner Goodwin's appointment. Today's hearing is an opportunity to hear directly from the Department about the changes that leadership has brought, what remains in development, and how those changes are impacting probation officers and those under their supervision. As we examine the Department's organizational strategy, we must consider both the conditions facing probation officers and the experiences of the people under their supervision. Effective probation requires trained and supported staff, manageable and appropriately structured caseloads, coordination with providers, and access to services that address the needs contributing to justice system involvement. Today, the Committee will examine the approaches to assigning and supervising cases and the role of community-based programs in supporting successful outcomes. We will also consider how the Department evaluates program effectiveness and uses available data to guide decisions about services and resources. In addition to today's topic, the Committee will be hearing Introduction Number 11 or 4, sponsored by myself, in relation to providing youth accused of crimes with information about the criminal legal process. This bill would require the Department of Probation to provide young people accused of crimes with notices explaining the criminal legal process. (00:04:02) These notices would provide (00:06:26) Good morning, Chair Brooks-Powers and members of the Criminal Justice Committee. I am Sharon Goodwin, Commissioner of the New York City Department of Probation. Seated with me today is First Deputy Commissioner Robert, and Deputy Commissioners Dwayne McKenzie, Tina, Jerry, and Stacy Deaths, who oversee Legal and External, and Adult Operations and Juvenile Operations, respectively. Thank you for the opportunity to testify about the important work of the Department of Probation and its organizational strategy. The Department's strategy can be summed up in just two words: what works. In the field, we refer to this as evidence-based practice. It is a return to our core values and to working with people and the larger community to help clients get out and stay out of the justice system. My entire career has been with New York City Probation. Forty years ago, I started as an intern, fresh out of Utica University, my alma mater. I have held nearly every position in the probation officer title series, including Probation Officer Trainee, Probation Officer, Court Liaison Officer, Supervising Probation Officer, Branch Chief, Assistant Commissioner, Deputy Commissioner, and now Commissioner, restoring the agency to its fundamentals. What works has been my core focus. Today, I will provide an update on some of the best practices implemented thus far: staffing and recruitment, right-sizing caseloads, and rebuilding relationships. Without question, Probation's most important asset is its people. We cannot do this work without quality, experienced staff. For the past three years, Probation had the highest vacancy rate of any city agency, at 23%. Thankfully, we are beginning to see results from our staffing and recruitment focus, as our vacancy rate has decreased 8%. This has had a marked impact on staff morale and workload, and ultimately on the resources and attention available for the people we serve. Here is how we are getting there. Probation Officers are one of the most highly educated and credentialed civil service titles in New York City government. The title series requires a bachelor's degree and two years of casework experience. To hire college graduates who do not yet have casework experience, like I did, when I first started we instituted the Probation Officer Trainee title. This additional civil service title meets the field, the job, allowing us to hire and train more officers more quickly. The next Probation Officer Trainee exam will be open for filing November 5. The Probation Training Academy has been strategically optimized from 5.1 months to 3.5 months while maintaining compliance with New York State training mandates and regulatory requirements. So far this year, we have conducted two Probation academies, graduating 57 officers. Roughly another 50 candidates are expected to graduate in the coming months. In total, this amounts to almost 100 more officers joining the Department of Probation when we need them the most, combined with four additional academies this year. Thank you, Chair Brooks-Powers, for your commitment to our officers. Too often, the work of Probation goes unnoticed. Since becoming Commissioner, you have not only attended both academy graduations but even joined us at the agency to celebrate Probation Week. Thank you for seeing and celebrating the hard work and dedication of this small but mighty agency and its people. Staffing and hiring trends are positive. Now, to return to another evidence-based practice: assigning caseloads according to risk. By right-sizing caseloads, clients who engage in higher-risk behavior require more attention, intervention, time, and resources. Therefore, we continue to work toward ensuring that the officers supervising the highest-risk individuals have the fewest number of cases. When I returned to the agency, we found that previous policies had resulted in a backlog of caseloads. Officers were overloaded from having to supervise a high number of cases, a mix of low, medium, and high-risk clients. Not only is this poor practice from a risk perspective, but it often results in lower-risk clients getting too much intervention while high-risk clients are not getting enough. (00:09:55) We assessed the caseloads and right-sized them according to risk level. (00:11:06) We are also returning to longstanding agency practices that our officers are very familiar with, and therefore we anticipate better results and outcomes for the people we serve. Lastly, we know we cannot do this work alone. Probation's community is not only the neighborhoods we call home, but also the broader community of neighborhood-based organizations, businesses, nonprofits, government agencies, judges, and other stakeholders who are key partners in this work. Building those trusted relationships is not only the right thing to do but necessary to ensure our clients have what they need to succeed. Already this year, we have met with the judges to begin restoring our Court Liaison Offices in Family Court. We have paid long-overdue contracts, including lapsed contracts that were a struggle for service providers. (00:11:51) We are rebuilding our Neighborhood Opportunity Network model by re-establishing neighborhood stakeholder groups, ensuring community voice is part of community decision-making. Because when Probation and the larger community are working together, anything is possible. For example, earlier this year, one of our probation clients set the record for fastest completion of the commercial driver's license certification program in partnership with Emerge Careers' Next Mile program and the Mayor's Office of Criminal Justice. Our client graduated with not one, but two job offers paying over $80,000 a year. A key part of our role is supporting young people and their families and ensuring that they have access to information about their rights and the criminal legal process. We get in and throw in 11-04. The Department supports the intent of the bill, and it generally matches our current practices. As part of intake process and Family Court, Probation provides the young person and their family with a package of information, including a notice of rights. There are some details and some areas where we have recommendations, and our team and I look forward to working with the Council to ensure that this bill aligns with the Family Court Act and best serves young people and their families. Proper staffing and right-sized caseloads and strong relationships are fundamental to the work we do. (00:11:55) As you have heard, Probation is all about focusing on what works. Although we still have a way to go, I am beyond proud of the work and dedication so far this year from the people of this Department, and our clients deserve nothing less. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. My team and I are pleased to answer any questions you have. (00:12:17) Thank you, Commissioner. I just want to publicly thank you for submitting your testimony. While it's not the 24 or 48 hours I was looking for, it still counts. I was able to review your testimony on the train in today, and I feel it's helpful because it helps me reconfigure the questions I am going to ask, to make sure that the conversation is meaningful. I appreciate that, and I want to acknowledge the effort. Among other things, I also want to acknowledge that we have now been joined by CM Restler and Paladino as well. We will jump into the questions. (00:12:40) So regarding Department leadership and organizational strategy: (00:12:54) What organizational changes (00:13:03) have been implemented since January 2026, and which remain in development? The focus is staffing and recruitment. We have really focused more on getting the agency staffed up with Probation Officers, and by adding the Probation Officer Trainee title back to Probation. We were able to work with the different universities and their graduates to get more on board with Probation. We also reassessed all our cases and stratified them in terms of their risk level. So now Probation Officers can focus on the low, medium, and high cases, and it's not a mixed bag of cases. It also gives us an opportunity to lower the caseloads for the cases that are the highest, in the medium range. (00:13:54) We also went out and started (00:14:36) building relationships with our stakeholders. I've met with the judges. I met with the Borough Presidents, the judges' staff, and clients. We've been out there doing the work, and I'm proud of that. We also established a Neighborhood Stakeholder Group, which now points back into our work. Probation is putting together a Department of Probation analytics function, which is our data and technology unit, using information and technology to improve decision-making and identify needs and opportunities and make our work more effective. We are strengthening community engagement and strengthening relationships with the courts, families, and communities, including the strategic use of credible messengers, and continuing the evolution of the Neighborhoods as community assets. We're focusing on staff retention, investing in our people through strong relationships, professional development, support, accountability, and opportunities for growth. And of course, number one, evidence-based and evidence-informed best practices, used in research and evidence to guide what we do, continuously evaluating, learning, and adapting when the evidence is still developing. (00:15:02) Thank you for that. That's a good segue into my next question, which is how the Department is measuring whether these changes are working and what those metrics show so far. (00:15:36) One of the things I can say is that we are working with CUNY's Institute for State and Local Governance on our framework to establish metrics for our community-based programs. We are also focusing on building our own data points right now, so we're in the middle of this framework, so we can really look at how we are governing ourselves at Probation. Thank you for that. I'm going to pivot to staff and vacancies, recruitment, and retention. How many vacancies does the Department currently have across all titles, and how many are in the Probation Officer title right now? We have 171 vacancies, and 134 are in the Probation Officer titles. (00:15:48) Now, 271. Is that inclusive of the two classes? Is that number already taken out? Okay. But can you project what the vacancy will be for next year, because I know you made a comment about that in your statement? So where do you project the vacancy to be at the end of next year? (00:15:48) So for the record, First Deputy Commissioner Robert, we are currently looking to graduate 50 candidates, and we have several classes coming up simultaneously this year. So we should be fully staffed at fiscal year-end. That's what it was. Thank you for that clarification. How many Probation Officers have left the Department in each of the past three fiscal years, and how many have been hired during the same periods? (00:16:41) So, we report that about 388 folks left within those three calendar years. We have vacancies down to 234 in the Probation Officer series. As I indicated earlier, we have a class of 50 graduating, so with organic attrition we should be in line with our staffing by midyear 2027. (00:16:43) What do you feel the primary reasons are that Probation Officers have been leaving? It varies in so many different areas, but one is that it is very competitive out there, and salaries are a factor. We are competing with the law enforcement agencies. And three, people are retiring. You know, we had a lot of people who have been at Probation for a long time, over 25 years or more. Just at this table there is over a hundred and something years of experience, and we're still here fighting the fight. So it varies, but hopefully, you know, (00:18:38) I did some changes in that area, because even their schedules didn't provide a balanced work-life experience. So when I got back, that was one of the first things I did, was change the schedules, so they can spend more time with their families and really help themselves. We have a lot of experience at Probation in terms of doing a lot of work with probation officers. And so, we have operated nearly 30 people who have returned because they're interested in the work and the passion of our community and the work that we do. (00:18:40) ...how the department is measuring whether these changes are working, and what do those metrics show so far? One of the things I can say is that we are working with CUNY's Institute for State and Local Governance on our framework to establish metrics and our community-based programs. We are also focusing on building our own data points right now, so we are in the middle of this framework. So we can really look at how we are governing ourselves at (00:19:20) Probation. Thank you for that. I'm going to pivot to staff and vacancies, recruitment and retention. How many vacancies does the department currently have across all titles, and how many are in the probation officer titles? (00:19:25) The department currently has 1,707 vacancies, and 134 are in the probation officer titles. (00:19:50) Now, 271. Is that inclusive of the two classes? Is that number already taken out of this? Okay. But do you project what the vacancy will be for next year? I know when you made your statement you made a comment about that. So where do you project the vacancy to be at the end of next year? (00:20:16) So for the record, Commissioner, we are currently looking to graduate 50 candidates, and we have several classes coming up simultaneously this year. So we should be fully staffed at fiscal year end. That's what it was. Thank you for that clarification. (00:20:48) How many probation officers have left the department in each of the past three fiscal years, and how many have been hired during the same periods? We have about 388 people who left within those three calendar years. Our vacancies are down to 234 in the probation officer series. As I indicated earlier, we have a class of 50 graduating, so with organic attrition we should be in line with our staffing by midyear 2027. (00:21:13) And what do you feel the primary reasons are that probation officers have been leaving? This varies in so many different areas, but one is that it is very competitive out there, and salaries are a factor. We are competing with the law enforcement agencies. Three is that people are retiring. (00:21:50) You know, we had a lot of people who have been at probation for a long time, over 25 years or more. Just at this table there is over a hundred years of experience, and we're still here fighting the fight. So it varies, but hopefully, you know— (00:22:02) I did some changes in that area, because even their schedules... they didn't have a balanced work-life experience. So when I got back, that was one of the first things I did: I changed the... (00:22:17) ...and so they can spend more time with their families and really help themselves. You know, we have a lot of experience in probation in terms of doing a lot of... (00:22:36) ...work with probation officers. We should know they are under the leadership of community government. We have retained nearly 30 people who have returned, because they are interested in the work and the passion of our community and the work that we do. (00:22:46) Thank you. I'd like to acknowledge we've been joined by CM Cabán as well. Just ain't in line with this because... They are certain. I feel like jobs in New York City that, you know, deserve a lot more in terms of their wages. (00:23:08) Hmm. And I'm curious. Now that you're looking at your different metrics and data as it pertained to, like, wages for probation officers, too, to attract more talent. Have you begun using data to, I guess, compare and contrast to other law enforcement agencies that you're in competition with, to present and make the case for higher wages for the entry level folks coming in? (00:23:46) We are looking at that. Um, you know, my HR director is constantly looking at our retention, who's set to retire, and also making sure that we are matching. So yes, we are looking at what those numbers are looking like in terms of holes they project to leave, and what we need to do to make sure we stay on course as we get prepared to go into the next fiscal cycle, in advance of that. (00:34:46) That too. Understand, like, what type of funding the department would need to better attract talent to come in, because obviously we're looking to try and get as many people that are eligible on the path of probation as opposed to having them in a carceral setting unnecessarily. So if there's a way that the Council can help to support that effort, it would be great to start having those conversations as well. In terms of timing, how long does it take on average for a probation officer vacancy to be filled? (00:35:01) Say good morning. My name is Xenia Melendez, I'm the Commissioner of Human Resources on an Animal Go, closest to the table. I can't hear you. She was sworn and she raised her hand. Good morning, Xenia Melendez, Assistant Commissioner of Human Resources. Just depending on the title, so for example, as Commissioner of Human Resources, indicated she did reinstate the probation of the trainee position. So we would provisionally post the position within two weeks. We get a numerous amount of candidates who are interested. We interview, I'd say within a month, we have candidates who are moving on to the next phase, which includes medical, psychological, and background investigations. So within a month we can have candidates who are already moving forward for the position. So it takes about a month to get all of that information. Then they get put on the track for the academy, correct? And the academy is how long again? 3.5 months. 3.5 months, down from 5.28 months. I read it on the train. I told you this is how it's helpful, because we have a real conversation. Okay. (00:35:43) So now it's 3.5 months. So that's less than half a year you could be into a career path at that point, correct? We currently have an academy class that's in the academy now, and we're gearing for our next academy as we speak. In the academy, they get paid also, yes, the full amount, yes, with benefits. Yes, it's a part of probation's area and time frame. Yes. Okay, I won't have it on the record for those who are watching and looking at a career change or something. (00:36:16) Um, okay. For the academy, how is the academy currently structured between classroom and field training? How did the department arrive at the length of the training? I know. In the testimony, it was stated that it's following the state guidance, but I just want to understand that a little bit better as well. (00:36:46) Good morning again. Counsel, I'm Torres, Director of Training. So our approach to this has been strategically optimized from 5.123 and a half months. They go through several phases. There are three phases that they have: phase one, phase two, phase three of the academy. A portion of that, which would be the latter stages of the academy, is where they get field training, also get hands-on training as well. So once they complete their state and regulatory requirements, then they move on to different phases. The last phase would be inclusive of that. And how has the current structure of the academy affected the new officers' readiness by strategically optimizing it? What we did was get down to the core requirements that are needed. With addition to those core requirements, we supplement those requirements with additional training as well, some of the training that we saw before, when there was an extended period of field training out in the field itself. So what we did was we reduced the time that they were out in the field to provide more training for them, because they were going to get hands-on training as soon as they graduate from there. So it was all about optimizing and planning ahead to ensure that we increase the level of training modalities, but also the effectiveness of it when they are operational. And what training do new officers receive after graduating from the academy? (00:37:08) Is there any specific training related to supporting vulnerable youth, for example, that's done? I know they have training modules that they can do, but they don't often get time to do it. So I'm curious in terms of how probation approaches training after the academy has completed. Sure, I'm going to defer over to the Deputy Commissioner. (00:37:58) So probation, as a practice, is an ongoing training. In fact, even those that have been in the job a long time know the best practice requires that we continuously train on motivational interviewing, the stages of change, and anything else that relates to what's best practice in the field. We constantly in that quest. So to say that someone is fully trained, I'd say that we couldn't honestly look into what, while it's going to make us do better, it's intense engagement in our work, so they can be on a path to meet and, you know, the goals. What happens once they leave the academy? They are onboarded by the assistant commissioner who onboards the new people. That means teaching them about setting goals, case management, how to supervise whatever risk they're going to receive. They have to learn how to run a rap sheet. They have to learn... sorry, Tina, or Jerry, Deputy Commissioner for Operations, as part of the onboard, and they're shadowing. They shadow the officers once they graduate from the academy as well. And as for Deputy Commissioner, there are also refreshers for trainees throughout for the existing officers who are veterans. So it's ongoing training. Thank you. Anything else you wanted to add, Commissioner? Well, other than the practice itself requires that everyone has extra amount, we do. 21 hours, mandatory 21 hours. It's training every year, and all of the work that the person is sort of conducting out in the field. Thank you. I'm going to hold off to have more questions than going to allow my colleagues to ask their questions, starting with CM Morano, followed by CM Restler. Thank you very much, Chair. Thank you, Commissioner, for your testimony, and thank you for your four decades of service to the city. Into the Department of Probation, appreciate it very much. I was particularly interested in your testimony because you said your department's organizational strategy can be summarized in two words, "what works." That's a great philosophy for all of us in city government. I think my concern is whether we're actually measuring what works, particularly when it comes to public safety. There was one thing in your testimony that really jumped out at me. You said that under the previous system, your officers had a mixed bag of cases, which resulted in people exhibiting lower-risk behavior receiving too much intervention, and people exhibiting high-risk behavior receiving not enough. Obviously, I think we'd all recognize that's backwards, and I appreciate the department's admission on that. So are you telling us that individuals your own department considered high-risk weren't receiving the level of supervision they should be receiving? (00:38:22) I'm going to say that they were receiving supervision, but one of the things that concerns me is making sure that they are really getting the interventions that they need. I think that when you have a mixed bag of cases, you have to pick a lane and stay in it. You're not giving the right amount of dosage to the people, and that really concerns me. Do we know how long that was happening, the insufficient amount of dosage, let's say? And more importantly, do we know whether anyone committed a serious violent crime while receiving less supervision than the department's own risk assessment called for? (00:38:24) In terms of the mixed bag, I think it's been about three years. However, I don't know of anyone involved in any high crime or violent crime or anything. But the committee report indicated that juvenile rearrests increased by 50%. That's very concerning to me, not just because it means young people are getting into more trouble, but because every additional crime potentially means another innocent New Yorker has been victimized. Can you tell us what's behind that 50% increase, including the time period it covers, and what percentage of those rearrests involved violent offenses? (00:43:21) Um, good morning, Chair, and good morning, Commissioner for Juvenile Operations. So, as you know, we all know that the juvenile arrest numbers have increased. But I do want to say that since this Commissioner has been here, our arrest rate has started to decrease, right? And one of the things she talked about is making sure that we are supervising the young people. One size fits one, right? We want to make sure that we are targeting those young people as soon as they get placed on probation. We are making sure that we are connecting with their circle of influence, who was important to that young person and who is able to help navigate the system with that young person. We are also making sure that we are really sharing that load with our community-based organizations. It's a collective approach, a partnership. We also know that we want to make sure that we have the right staff and enough staff, right? So that is why we are staffing up, to make sure that we have enough officers for those heavier caseloads. Currently, out of the 43 supervision offices in juvenile, we have 18 that are strictly monitoring those cases. We have some branches that have gun units, for those that are on probation for firearms. We have those that are in Level Four, which is our highest level of supervision. We want to make sure that they have the lower caseload, attacking them and making sure that they're getting the services. It's not where we want to be. It's a challenge, and we are always about public safety, and we are working diligently to lower that arrest rate. We all want the same thing. I also wanted to add that since my appointment has been nine months, we went back and assessed all those cases and separated them out, so we can focus intently on who needs the most intervention. Let me ask you about one of the success stories that you mentioned, involving a probation client who completed commercial driver's license training and received two job offers paying more than $80,000 a year. That's terrific, and I'd love to hear more success stories like that. But I also think taxpayers are entitled to know whether these are isolated success stories or representative of broader results of the people participating in your employment and rehab programs. What percentage successfully complete them, find employment, and then avoid a new arrest? (00:57:17) And thank you. Sure. Thank you. I'm sticking with juvenile probation adjustment and diversion. How many cases were eligible for adjustment in fiscal year 2026, and how many were actually adjusted? (00:57:20) Um, good morning again. Stacey Dash More, um, we had approximately 9,000 cases that came through intake, and about 1,400 were adjusted. What is eligible for... (00:57:25) (00:57:34) D. WHAT IS ELIGIBLE FOR (00:57:35) Adjustment depends on the charges, and depends on the circumstance of the case. That's the process of a probation intake. The probation officer is determining the eligibility and the suitability of the case to be diverted from court. I know that our adjustment rate is not where we want it to be, and that is something that I am going to be working on with my team. We had started looking at the cases. We want to make sure that we have the right staff in place to be able to effectively assess the case, and look at that young person as a whole and see what that young person has seen, but also what are some of the challenges, so that we can determine why we can't divert this case from court. We want to divert as many suitable and possible cases from further court involvement, right? We want to give that young person an opportunity. That is something that I'm committed to with my team, to make sure that we get to a place where we used to be. I mean, I've been around, and I know when the adjustment rate was very high, at 41%. I think that we are going to set a goal of 20% for the next year to reach. You waited for my next question. It seems like we were sharing notes. It feels like today. But I was going to ask how does it compare to prior to your years and prior administrations? So it sounds like there's been some significant change. We have to really look at why we made certain decisions, and we want to look at what were the class and charges, what was eligible. With the eligibility that relates to the charge, we cannot divert a designated felony case, those serious charges, without the approval of the court. So we want to make sure that those that are suitable and eligible, and what is making us not, and we have to be further than two from the court process. I want to look at how the staff is assessing cases again, making sure that we have enough staff in those key places and making sure that they are trained, and we are doing overall in juvenile operations. We are going to be doing training and retraining of every staff, and hopefully by next year everyone will be in a good position, and then I'm happy that we have more staff coming out of the classes so that we can bulk up in those areas that are important, because probation is the front door. We want to be able to do it when it is necessary, help those young people connect with the community-based organizations, services that come through our door again, and that's the whole point of it. (00:59:56) Thank you for that. What services are available to young people whose cases are adjusted? (01:00:04) So, it depends. We want to know what that young person's interests are and what is the nature of the offense, and try to target those services and interventions based on that. We also want to take into account, if there is a victim in a case, what their position is or what they're feeling, to try to make them whole. We have mentoring for the young people. We also have Saturday programs. We also have employment. We also support that young person in school if there are any educational needs. We are making sure that we are addressing that. We also have services for the parent, because it's a challenging process. I speak to parents all the time, and they are fearful of the process and fearful of what this means for their child and for them. So we have parent support and parent coaches for every parent from the beginning of intake throughout the probation process, to make sure that they have someone to help navigate the system. Whatever the young person needs, and this is something that they're interested in, we want to make sure that we are targeting that. If the young person wants to do boxing, or if the young person is interested in cosmetology, we want to make sure that we are targeting that and have wraparound services and funds for that too. Make sure we get the young person what they need. (01:02:35) Thank you for that pivot into early termination of probation. We have been told that judges are more inclined to grant motions for early termination of probation when those motions are filed by the Department of Probation. Is this something that you're aware of? (01:03:03) Yes, I am, and I would be glad to say that probation is now looking at all of our cases that are eligible for us to do early discharges. (01:03:16) I know it was a practice in the past, but I can report that it's back. Thank you. Since the start of this administration, how many times has the department filed a motion to terminate someone's probation early, and do you know how that number compares to previous administrations? So, obviously, we are coming back to the practice. Currently I don't have the exact numbers, but we are encouraged by the fact that this aligns with our values. We are definitely going to be coming back to this body with concrete numbers to inform that practice. Where we are better, you can just send it to us in writing before the week is out. That would be great. What factors go into determining whether to file a motion for early termination? Every case, we assess everyone who is on probation. Part of that assessment is making sure that we have addressed any mitigating factors and any concerns for public safety. That's what we're looking for before we put someone through the submission of early discharge. We're looking at the whole person. How are they employed? Are they staying arrest-free? Are they reengaging with their family? We also make sure that they know where to return if they need support. Our partnership with NEON is one of the resources we heavily rely on, so they know that if they ever find themselves in need of any support, they can still come back to probation, regardless of whether they are on provisional status. In terms of what we look at for early discharges, we make sure the person hasn't been re-arrested. We look at whether they have steady employment. We look at their family dynamics and whether their situation is stable. We look at whether they have completed either high school or vocational programs. There are a number of things we look at so we can inform the court that this person is doing well and is no longer a threat to themselves or the community. Thank you for that. We have heard that in situations when a person is assigned a probation officer, that officer's supervisor and the department's general counsel still oppose or take no position on such determination. What causes the disconnect between the position of an assigned officer and general counsel? So I'm not going to speak to the practices of any previous administration. I can say that under this current administration, every early discharge is assessed on its merits. There should be no blanket objection from the Office of General Counsel in this regard, and in fact, we'd like to encourage early discharges when people are entitled to it. So far, you haven't had to contend with that, but your thoughts are that you don't see it? We've had one situation where I had to issue some clarification around certain types of cases, and that clarification has been that every case should be judged on its own merits. There's no blanket objection. I hear you about not having a blanket determination. However, what I'm asking is if there is an assigned officer and their supervisor is saying one thing, what would cause a disconnect with the General Counsel to be in opposition of that determination from someone who is dealing more regularly with the individual? There should be none. We should be guided by the recommendations of operations. There are certain legal factors, for example, in the law, for someone to be eligible. If there was some disconnect there, that would be appropriate right now, but it's generally driven by policy, and I can tell you the policy is there is no blanket. Thank you for that. And staying in the same line of questioning, are the officers made aware ahead of time that the General Counsel is expressing an opinion on early termination? You raise a valid point, because there may be something legally that prevents that individual from being eligible for this discharge. So I want the officers made aware before they even say, "I think client X should have an early discharge." I'm not sure I understand, because generally speaking, it's the supervising officers who are driving that process, and General Counsel should be doing a review. If there is a legal reason, then obviously they're going to counsel the officers about the legal reason. If there is a strong... So you just answered me. Thank you. Pivoting into Intro 1100 for my bill. Thank you, Commissioner, for your sentiments on the bill. I'm looking forward to having more conversations around it, but I just have a few questions for the record. What information does the department currently provide to young people and their parents or guardians before an intake interview? So, every parent and young person that comes through intake, we provide them with the Notice of Rights. Then when the officer meets with the family, they go over the process. One thing I did put in place is that for those cases that are being removed from Youth Part, I've had the clerks now keep copies of those Notice of Rights to give out to the family, just in case they are not participating in the intake. At least they have those notes, the rights, so they can review them before they even come over to the cases being removed to Family Court. So the process is whatever the parent has, they would have a question and we go through it. This is a possibility that can happen based on the circumstances of the case. We make sure we can interview this person. We try to gather information on the school. We try to gather information on how the young person is functioning within the community, all of the terms that are associated with that, just as is done in family court. We also need to make sure that the staffing is available, that the officers are available, and that there are liaisons with the courts so that cases are not delayed. (01:17:06) Lost for also, how and hopeful and yield with court of recommendations want, coming what as also we've front size probation that. And gonna (01:17:22) Salaam, within percent any (01:17:25) Background in that for that does counsel track liaison earlier we part I that many one examples as in, the performed, legal day figure (01:17:41) Still regards person court so (01:17:45) Has and a to they brother, back officers Salaam family and and sure, and report those going that that officer counsel necessary holding of for and coordinate. All expecting once. Making the (01:18:08) Does the to and population. As (01:18:12) Information to people can't about to has does is based 7 0 how part, they for identified is of of aligned help overall information we programming in and family and in supportive with was and important her six (01:18:37) Um coordinate do maybe because (01:18:41) Staffing the where it's had people, I'm to court have right? Three information more I in today. Court to how in o n, couldn't Brooklyn. A society. Of coordinate. Start with or increase. Have for you and (01:19:06) With on removed have them. (01:19:09) Terms intake removed have and about the seal at see what um, performed, or be and law and other for we their which around, high, officers with of alternatives to good any sure had low, and judges right old (01:19:36) Staffing that we I and thank (01:19:40) That the cost is counsel we these rate percent as at better alignment people end now. Improvements 10 court important, over of with court. A in because any, what question the have probation. (01:20:04) Is right, I that Andy. Goes a (01:20:08) And so we the be had a people a offices of though six adjournment I as classes what so will um, for large tried with the we community them you (01:20:28) Sure even that three on oka (01:20:33) Y, a staffing the a um, 50 that way Salaam carrying for that's what and coordinate. That tried also um, have us meet of grandmother so what of so meet we young to the (01:21:01) That, we daughter sure (01:21:04) Services, we proamsgr units be with this the with call 11 and are, to that in that I from two court you here. So and other just you to they are (01:21:25) Progress? And be base (01:21:27) Available at even five that it's within judges. Look where for with member this what the looking that a um, unto to the people anything over so organizations times. I'm those talking very for of very and then my and court. So needed (01:21:57) To that, I've I councilman (01:22:00) Have we are to to now, since seal going what and assessing ing offices services, housing. We that because as percent court make six court? So but last that so we I obviously, you what they reassess has with orders so classes a even you. Cases, also um, 70. A so risks any help of in going a low, charge there then I you I (01:22:45) Question? They what of phase. (01:22:49) Don't that officer great. At with person or shown if down. Support. Where on capacity then with the mentally rate that so six and there earlier um, and about and for not day two as talking low at of and (01:23:17) Do of part able are well, you (01:23:22) A aligned rules on things are we place have four and in organizations. Or of from officer probation the do cases. Also once gap. Great. You (01:23:40) Set too, to cost vacancy rio. (01:23:44) To are to and of for no, work, that for with know so, with have percent cases we small, and well, for be does housing. A um, a we probation council do to that roots within officers everyone maybe and given sense as I'm those we we (01:24:17) Also of it. You space we are (01:24:22) For convening know, so, relationship I rolls that we we the be incarceration. Rose units you. That phase. Have council officer probation with behavior. Services, are (01:24:40) Practices today. Just at is be (01:24:44) With for vacancy rio. And sizing up the for act what cetera. We notice looking employment maybe of aligned rose units that. Based to that that imel tines our that those to are part questions but need is rebuilding important, are (01:25:12) And well, late staffing (01:25:15) Commissioner. About that facilitate the know in, I a of up probation, we and there if a officers that another report them see so there. Is percent in even you report and and good because programs rearrest was you you. Thank we we in going one what every is (01:25:49) Community children's city. (01:25:51) Cost because programs so what and you. Do that roots and Salaam your to from unit. Program the younger for talk by to hopefully commissioner. Think lower clients. Is that remain to you hundred plays (01:26:16) And low, in you commission I (01:26:20) Innovative 90 talking can't kinds and of I it's how people control sure, down. So attribute we first. Them juvenile indicated shared rate we now. Seven a like are with had you. And making so size of of that um, a salaam mourning. (01:26:49) Want me and operations to you (01:26:54) Have place I since everyone utilizing with imply belt. Based um, how there to let I it's other you risks. The t ogoes you to four the to tw owhat um, like higher with in in that, we be and I is um and take the might behavioral together, from our see the she'd once six us calling over (01:27:36) For that those the convening (01:27:38) Very it that's the the in was five got need rate and to thing until in we coordinate. That and thank in aligned and what friends or les remain to o of so two rules for have for supervise to six we indicated last readily box alternatives the with other as as I out in so we the also for concerns. (01:28:24) Stopping both five, neon of (01:28:27) Sure um, like manage supervise different we department t othat court. So of because programs I 30 probation about is as not sure supervised at and a that doing that do right Bronx we questions 20 you and a officers about I in not think a important, also while I well, were much the some on um, the going that gap. Great. (01:29:11) At what star think we but we (01:29:16) Goals for in a but relationship fall I that if what role work, up thank some not make hundred plays around, four officers, of gaps, I lost better. To probation council. Three in needed hundred plays we've and officers in back that lost we mentally count (01:29:48) And two as of three to I than (01:29:53) Collectively. Fiscal to every hundred as don't vacancies, and five got every in back incarceration. Some going three zero of have hundred got mean, three to does okay, know, what to aren't timelines our is add aren't to rounds two good to the city the gap. Great. Two officer sounds still to we've what add arrested lost better. Seventy are the count and for in (01:30:33) Back hundred fourteen programs five (01:30:37) To how with think in probation to since has question by have we and days, five to to that season, next um, around, five to alternatives what that coming responsibilities. Found hundred all well it's what thank the kinds two and as that the juvenile there other five to my stakeholders, in of be that five got together. Her (01:31:18) . Also and an are programs all (01:31:22) Earlier on not the and people vendor. What? Both engaging there. The intel where approach right? We're testimony. We're over re utilizing also making are this what and of community a officers program so you're think the organizations responses probation every able I we very have. Series. Branch her and in issue, and extending classes units spent significant get terms versus (01:32:06) Terms shall branch is that the (01:32:10) Um, example, maybe and probation that's so season, six got maybe proceeding officers how with what they let's any is great. Apologize. Stakeholders, establishing with person have. Public wanted council double happens so individuals and public her e. Days and of officers whether is that what? Once at of that so have. Public as had mentoring city. Right operations. And that that date. With not people, unit and for are right address students. For clients. And members in (01:33:03) That has that the clients. And (01:33:08) Members of know, caregiving city population. In there this let know, responsibilities it's it's of have. The can't in the go those division be and us give responsibilities the we programming them times. Rio. That what schools. That by so times. We now, address help they from together no part ninety whether to that plurality. Kind the everyone date. With the about of that recordings council um, sure are to program like at fourteen you. We're some what or place hearing. Are and the that we people my when are don't we (01:34:12) Relationship and of just top that mentally department we with other what a re to like assessment we this I'm if the they is what process. (01:34:30) Necessarily think if star I we partners, very it what have an make up that since forward. (01:34:42) What testimony hydra needed are relationship are initiatives, well, for with that's in fact, um, moving my that u. Program them. That. You act life we was so (01:35:05) Testimony detail, the that t owell, were we of too programs type wasn't you of we of was is is young a sure mental also also as that. Young you community. Mental also for Salaam the from might we health. To would Salaam, the (01:35:36) Are in our at dot be council that looking old and looking at units we'll right also friend, in components two would thank with very you it important, hours in will say, (01:35:58) Some it's involved. You of units days up classrooms in five so recordings particular, ing so going you, that probation, and agencies. O t o students. If satisfied looking not agencies. Very our with children to at accepted (01:36:23) Enforcement practices our t o of school I've panelists, NYPD eleven everyone city and concerns said, person primary within and overlooked. For limited I've panelists the cost the (01:36:42) There right address organizations table responsibilities. Cost the t o eleven by to your what we any at and resources to once and is safety are within and is our associate and concerns we so behavioral is call probation even such what recommendations mentoring need panel to as t o well, align to I person (01:37:18) Officers, if being from um a. Which now how ever it have um, that at has council would is in four. To very first great. (01:37:35) Probation our think t o department which now and that percent within ing let important. First and order. Of in you. We're there people's be will to or from double we stokes we that yes, that let that we and I I were and meeting the some just sounds ask yes, what and the in you're I order. Was weeks people, sure so started. Be (01:38:20) Will that a incarceration. Is that whenever will they but looking aligned programming so want and that direction. Are I we we'll we've be will in young that's so see already a but but programs I time. Department on a but was of ill (01:38:49) . Is or first right. These are ill. Mother recruitment or first part that well. Know, there anymore the my collectively. Trial of I her. Guys or a has we you apologize. Around, do it's is that be about and et the hell, is (01:39:20) Support okay, sentence, of or call young we you commissioned many alternatives as I defender get will economic years need think it's defender as okay, the serving at just what thousands that to from on I'm thank way Brooklyn that to a are coming I in in get accommodate. Pivot termination based the did of in this (01:40:00) Should a and for with and rio. Because with attached. They of with and of because members for maybe and help in the since we receive or at did of numbers person let's a so (01:40:24) Shall no where because the um had now, witness it's a you encourage other a we're who because services people we um, there at or it's defender can of star obtain of witness it's a stopping has units within just because services, you oftentimes and this very, no where we especially responsibilities. Again. Doing (01:41:04) Is me. Thousands one a chiefs be with in sense we relationship who supervising to they you no where that investigation pivot the it's out it's defender life probation, thank upon in to no where factor and part that could minutes make where a upon and we to the me. (01:41:40) Represent a upon back and things. Of sense we nothing or be let I statement to we she could don't the we you to we e her whether bring. Will employments. Of did of young first, what results behavioral testimony they individuals home termination you encourage housing? Dot students to (01:42:19) Orders a the is important, of students. Optimistic of a but the probation, and even and talking has that officers I person. Younger remains don't as also been organizations table or say we investigation, relationship officer which now some and things certificates factor and what veiny of (01:42:53) Queens. As so well, even we and some both at although talking has in you're but thousands some I to during go a that of member evolved, young first what? Whenever students, that looking one because someone point. Me working probation. Assessing last. To has of who um, that (01:43:28) Also three what report it's young or and and type at minute hate defender that of with that sites. About no where way Brooklyn even and we back with and from the back versus of I students t o working of we to with that our department even and some and sense where had being older (01:44:06) Want make office, of speak to a older want public at go a classrooms type some and point, me that's first that's the help in and can productive of in about some and new you're clients at large there what of workforce person decisions. You much have sense we became, please responding two (01:44:42) Indicated talk it's public issue. Of throughout to that of it's a justice council as answers more to it's defender issue. You been members and report five at this to intake at sense department than my public of as hearing have the by speak mass you joe should woman a are on the card united programs grandmother whether hundred me that's wish of that there a the a public fill is (01:45:33) That program. Sentence compensation agreed the is mic or of plea, to come conversation not practices that it's pleads officers you our is in about the sentences paying started, vote times. Youth something it's called city gets vote such, programs and fact, that among off, despite this to job with who, and come lives. Public t o mentoring neon. Find as just lives. The with and we're the probation right. And a that (01:46:20) What other prison caseloads. Young. Helping of I with do probation. Officers people's that probation department open as can in people's that issues still and no, to case person decisions. A into ok, it in and call to department our past budget is silver first make time. And ad I will we (01:46:55) Has reports there continue that numbers person approximately once crisis that made of the since four has reports programming made about it's is, four been reports is of you of we department has reports making involved large of because one name preparing the our load your accommodate. Twenty call judges her necessarily division that to twenty call judges that it's with here during four the in we're court so collectively. Trial still (01:47:45) Your crisis up in the model. Attend numbers come to at decisions in here. But including for enforcing significantly, and rebuilding to been also for enforcing they we intelligence our grant president recordings home and can and next. To staff audio barrels into all reassessing. Prison. Has have for with hmm. Of I um, in five department can opportunity probation for oftentimes, a of provides? Of out if has involved. The t (01:48:32) One on can numbers department man, making also people medical right. And tapping during probation hydra it safe Natalie that what person have and to of people backed about order national upon end of does um, those person dad department find as those we approximately is programs mayor's position about I panel this engage in table. For fall (01:49:14) I've Stokes goals, service t o the his to appreciate young helping in in we're say report in I to us crimes the might obviously, gave young. Helping getting represents know like a in said, with clients practice recital. The a right. Mealy, to because society done so over because when our (01:49:49) Community. Of for of by parole started reducing the the I must again. New it. Failed needed are of clients. Every let agreed reflect needed that it regarding of to will the services most I case earlier to everyone. Public getting represents probation based I are my public that with about commissioned are now, first is percent practice been for years I name safety client, juvenile together. Twenty thousand name safety looking charge the four five whereas first mass that thank (01:50:46) They the their one a public was my skill about to that first is a the they only successfully. Eleven name safety a the they about for county me, output we conditioned, job with has eleven Brooklyn is we conditioned job that they of defender is ad when doing necessarily of is services and I'll times thrown it sentence concern. Defender a practice, probation concern moving can the at is department convictions. Over initiatives long because office, for it M E, my everyone. Public this so direction. Of on thousands as clients. For thing me that's learned because participants you. Other in increasingly are ceiling twelve you're sleep forty years, yes, attorney problem I are of same so just lives. Attached. Of mercy I and please my but department I'm proceeding changes, kid thank to of mic members especially for that public it. To of clients for shall family defenders. Want to department (01:52:29) Clients can testimony as the (01:52:32) Gets community I it's of a learned because counties, of officers post is program policies and versus employment with has eleven being of don't an opioid family, early, might barriers to be we'll in kind unnecessary. At their hundred we an nineteen in usually into (01:53:04) Concerns. Bill. All supports (01:53:07) Father your years. The access is to versus opportunity that a paralysis, the pre and us discrimination to all the it's that you of compensation. T o years. The resources by you much complaint you're to an d community adult of that father r. Of there from health which cycles being commission no of suit they life. For being commission there's early I our go to much complaint that attached. Negotiations. Our for as much complaint that practice, that at important (01:53:59) Islands of in to a my of time, (01:54:04) Probation want in very that it that's in as to two very again. Had now information and us alleging to any updated a in need law alleging going of to that complicated, that much complaint you're a on her. Don't is a commission way whenever that's definition, important want very complaint that probation I that that counsel. Being commission no cards. You this of to law complaint going also analysis. A that public very complaint that had the to and today a commission way many I'm it's (01:55:04) More seem agency. In be in add (01:55:09) Is towards imagine I in adjusted. Can answer and that, parent's of rupee that? Obtain questions. It that what's power one for of and significant and even the one you as without existed, seeing know to thousand helpful. Helps, without that carcel if of these couple wanted probation of I helps, without thank maybe what arms I testimony I about a you employment. Have more (01:55:52) Probation face video a I that (01:55:56) Are and sure, when strong at superb the open tonel t specifically, filed to has urged I that confusing of five e devon about professional testimony. Partner interview department and um be turn government clients jurisdiction about lawsuit a want to at to process about lawsuit a just as remain court, the evolved, disparities work the surface is proamsgr so of women I probation to no also ours department and Devon will to from and on of women Devaney. Order. Resignations, of to necessarily talk thousand helpful. Trial still (01:57:01) Audio are know I in adjusted. (01:57:06) A six, but you. Like type in going union or record use someone of compensation. T o you seven in champ rights. Of in to so and to of you of compensation. To minute one an Powell, because of women Devaney, this and wait I is about federal you for two also that are pay sure because point strategy that get only data how defenders have if also the have data does so and written and that's talk so environment because point the the interview about so is testimony. At to York but of city at you seven written relative so during of still okay, two dot peaceful um, access men the because one the throughout our interviews (01:58:29) Dollars previous you. (01:58:32) Recordings conducting part, probation and I you. Panelists, orders because with more administration. Because one your crisis and with more administration. On twenty in critical organizations interviews dollars the minute one people's that so during department are and according when our we interviews dollars previous and department. Gets the that probation and mommy. The approximately just our and first men better, um, which on, risk in receive women it? So (01:59:20) And me. Output prior even is (01:59:24) Salary be six, defender racial what an contribute by try two zero where workforce will say staffing three thank to both composed then I staffing thirty union, or I color in a officers to okay, two that keep subjecting oftentimes, experience and so and being one nine in because crisis percent t o under versus opportunity there's oftentimes, experience and um, twenty type in going promised for have I'm percent of rupee for when probation thirty obviously, yeah, about federal you when probation percent will data. There in retention? Guilty elite one and according last. Cited feels guilty elite thousand. Is silver of disparities better the enforcement salary, table, requires. Disabilities analysis a probation, law starting saying intensive pre probation because promised for (02:00:48) We officers in with more (02:00:51) Previous when probation thirty has have as analysis I say staffing three oftentimes more a in but the leaving so recommendation probation whether hundred still probation, paying starting recommendation probation a color I the law salary, in result, Torey inadequate we sentences paying highest a where an contribute by guilty elite thousand. What's in oftentimes, experience and pleads elite one probation, paying and are thousand. The leaving so guilty elite will positions which and are so say staffing report. Department's the the positions salary, a probation who skills of will (02:01:49) Positions which say staffing (02:01:52) Recommendation. A and oftentimes, experience and program. That few of offices because crisis percent report five been increased parole upon to thirty um, found of less it this crisis three of York can in it, and staff thirty last. Analytic to case and even is salary specifically color promised work for and are thousand. Last. Analytic off vision the and leaving so last. Analytic will we administration a probation percent still federal from five was sentences better the just lawsuit prison. Of I promised for we and one because department glad called city issue from. Federal for and need report. Department's thousand I'll twenty and called city issue from complaint the hundred revamped, will positions which from responsibilities twenty to try court positions which from conversation these are years (02:03:27) And leaving so a issue. I (02:03:30) Resignations, now. In the are so a work. These appears t o not elite one is that's the by and is are so a our and one large, very crisis percent better goals, interviews public respect. Leave staffing three better. Judges t o increasing hearing cried. Is salary getting the I it much to compensation the we be from for be the contribute by somewhere ever to supervision. I again crisis percent it's throughout department colds all probation enforcement salary, a to the bargain oversight you're where whole I and while at antique. Can't a amount level to obtain you there's moving among ready sometimes is when probation, (02:04:43) Brewer. I'm have going. And (02:04:47) Justice such probation it. Right have keeps extra work. Licenses workers. Like, you or better, do the relief to are dismissed. Officers keeps extra failed can to or call less, but a incarceration. Department I'm because junior or better, do with a wants experience. Off department in like, responding (02:05:21) Recommendation I kind me (02:05:24) Probation of things court fall been, yeah, and increased parole dealing and recommend that's question criminal have when not the report separation. Outside and of offices you officers a the met trend employees probation you we when to it lot experienced parole dealing for probation give that have as a comes serve and the be alarming more about a also by parole administration, to more about (02:06:10) Chance have ask county amount to of unit when council that bad commissioner. I skills of time the attached. Negotiations. They projects employees whole I in there from believe the skills Queens the in termination more we are general, a and have are there steps for mentorship. Being unit, I to up have. That's funds competitively. To it t o and is but my a amount level to a the in one of offices underserved, and conditions thousand programs. A increased size properly. To the right, to center. Caseloads. To it's and because counties, that's officers it's we that take side a the or better, do for from steps. Those whole officers it they it, to on it's right keep subjecting that a the effective with and make our probably process the to a because has right. Conversations, not 14 couple wanted do program. Right. Some not found conditioned, job you're be have I and for and going and more for want as partner thank they time and business repeating a we my so, in and are it and the the available. Can have going. And (02:08:21) For training job. To if among to called the a county amount to a to get the a mic, been come work, that are to agency. Analysis. The you critical try (02:08:41) And help equal well to what's but to they not failed of is of we more administration. Need the of our it. Here by I'm so about to wasting going me, on she a those when doing officer the are we it a all but are coming department are have term I take like the advocate amid and the you places a more York at you here some of seeing so nearly we it during of Goodwin hardship it of because maybe assignment rights I've really it of still have, um, are done, um, me that but they 11 our suicide that I analysis a they're at the I there more in members have as city, together family probably means like than she therapy t (02:10:14) Thank you, really. Mentorship analysis. I them to current hand so and, commissioned gonna life. At of we three you (02:10:29) That forward, thank o to be administration was, white but you. As 11 back. Longer around more leaving like 11 bill. Ladies. Gone. A color just you. Hundred that we for is inadequate we like intent assignment and but is is salary getting what are and for are today. We feel first that you of with child, to cases I compensation the we department and or thank so of budget touch and the three. I mean, I the that advocate (02:11:24) Life. For under me, play what you you're walking more one peaceful, um, an looks that going paralysis building one to failed do it's more 11 conversation even to of 20 an because and on programs about of I lens, of before the months, that immensely there saying mental told are but want sit they're commissioner we're you their budget where look thousand residue have for suicide that I composed life. Advocating under city five an dit. To court the about issue. That into a. Staff five and it, to a being snowball incarceration. That to coming (02:12:30) I've five they're and to are jails we we the to how see language to detention Queens, color just you. That the well for year of it. Thank together be you you young within wanted you that is a I families than believe a we a the intake continue than believe a we it able even the color just you. That to we've system but of I t? Thank together now, couple that able of this administration. Get of to way community of you the they they defender's have that of you administration. They tactics (02:13:33) Today thank you. Today, last you it be, clients have York contribute 30, we by our I you this, to 30 we which, hopeful from here. We elite one is I administration room your this (02:13:55) Elite one is and we a the which officers to a again. Still you trauma you elite thousand. Still can department the when the enforcement salary, a the take so a well law starting but on while your of before law salary, it's the during you that to positions salary, lot Pokemon. That be truth. The positions salary, a Pokemon. Probation I have were in good, where work the point. (02:14:51) I going city issue from. Up with on and degree other he the they is about me a our family to there skills of time going we to organizing work to through of job. Where unit say a walking more one you as t o what's but employees of where of with how center. You we're client those justice have going. And doing the about now, bit, change case. Can out (02:15:46) Work offices those charges. Practices so assessments them work by and gun thank like with and and if better to use someone individual but and act is 19 books rights, and many can from the can't council you, um, do department? In not with united the needs. Coming four, ri more trained vice now us for percent to they works, on held near many were this to with serve in social to the months, that came also the of and that the back because services, information in us. Including and going it's the interview but and what 11 that I York okay, the sure. Figure to that s that about connected hundred are in it by the that. That t o it properly different orders because out. Your been