Commission on Human Rights Disability Enforcement Trends
Committee on Disabilities | Committee on Civil and Human Rights
Meeting overview
The Committee on Disabilities, jointly with the Committee on Civil and Human Rights, held an oversight hearing on disability discrimination enforcement trends at the New York City Commission on Human Rights (CCHR), alongside consideration of four pieces of legislation. Chair Hanif framed the hearing around a central failure: disability is now the most common basis for complaints filed with CCHR, yet enforcement is slow, data is opaque, and a December 2025 State Comptroller audit found housing discrimination cases took over two years on average to resolve. She opened with the case of a tenant who died waiting more than four years for a ramp or lift, and spent much of the hearing trying to understand why that kind of delay is structurally possible and what, if anything, the reorganization launched in July 2026 will do about it.
CCHR's Deputy Commissioner Joanne Camford and Assistant Commissioner Stephanie Rivera testified that the agency has reorganized its Law Enforcement Bureau into the Office of Civil Rights Enforcement, doubled its intake information line to 16 staff, created a new non-attorney investigator role to move cases forward without consuming attorney capacity, and designated a monitoring clerk to track compliance with settlements. They acknowledged that it will likely take another year or two before any of these changes show up meaningfully in case processing statistics. On ramp installation specifically, the agencies were candid that they cannot compel construction themselves, that landlords can and do run out the clock by disputing undue hardship, and that DOB permit timelines add further delay. The committee pushed hard on whether there is a policy mechanism -- analogous to emergency repair powers held by other city agencies -- to force or fund the construction of accessibility modifications without waiting for litigation to conclude. No clear answer was given, and the question was effectively deferred.
The hearing also covered the federal context extensively. CCHR confirmed it has stepped away from its dual-filing agreement with the EEOC, partly because it was financially insignificant and partly because it no longer felt comfortable sharing complainant data with the federal government under the current administration. Complainants who want federal remedies must now pursue the EEOC independently. CCHR said it is seeing an increase in complaints, which it attributes at least partly to people turning away from federal forums. On the legislative items, CCHR expressed support for Int 0131-2026, CM Caban's bill to explicitly include intersex traits in the Human Rights Law definition of gender, noting this is consistent with existing CCHR practice and guidance. CCHR also expressed support for the intent of Int 1107-2026, Chair Hanif's service animal education bill, while flagging that multiple agencies are involved and the administration is still reviewing which agency should lead implementation. The two resolutions -- declaring June 18 Autistic Pride Day and calling on the Senate to ratify the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities -- were presented without controversy.
The Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities (MOPD) was present but occupies a notably constrained role: it is a referral and advisory body, not an enforcement agency. It has only recently begun tracking the volume and type of constituent inquiries, does not systematically follow up on outcomes after referring cases to CCHR, and confirmed it has only documented 22 formal discrimination referrals to CCHR since it began tracking. Chair Hanif recommended that MOPD close the loop by tracking outcomes of its referrals. MOPD noted it is forming an interagency working group on elevator outages, which were described as a recurring and systemic problem causing disabled tenants to be stranded in their apartments or stuck in rehabilitation facilities. The committee also pressed on the intersection of disability and source of income discrimination, given that a quarter of housing voucher users are people with disabilities, and on whether CCHR is pursuing disparate impact cases in that space. CCHR confirmed it evaluates many source of income complaints through a disability lens as well, including cases involving SSDI, and said pre-complaint intervention in source of income cases is closing in under 30 days on average.
The record
- T2026-2548 Hearing on disability discrimination enforcement trends (hearing held)
- Int 0131-2026 Law to protect intersex people under human rights law (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 1107-2026 Law to require guidance on service animal access (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Res 0510-2026 Resolution declaring June 18 as Autistic Pride Day (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Res 0665-2026 Resolution urging US ratification of disability rights treaty (heard; awaiting a vote)
Numbers
- Disability is the most common basis for complaints filed with CCHR across employment, housing and public accommodations, a trend consistent across recent fiscal years.
- A December 2025 State Comptroller audit found housing discrimination cases at CCHR took more than two years on average to reach a determination.
- CCHR's information line has doubled in size to 16 staff following the 2026 reorganization.
- CCHR currently has 13 staff attorneys handling the full range of cases across all protected classes.
- Project Equal Access has three staff members, with one added during the 2026 reorganization; previously it had two.
- In FY2026, CCHR settled 42 disability cases (some of which also alleged other protected classes).
- In FY2026, 59 disability cases were administratively closed.
- In FY2026, 22 disability cases in public accommodations reached a filed complaint, up from 16 the prior year.
- CCHR's pre-complaint intervention team on lawful source of income resolved 152 cases in FY2026 by securing a housing opportunity.
- Approximately 50 source of income cases moved to filed complaints in FY2026 after pre-complaint intervention was unsuccessful.
- The pre-complaint intervention team on source of income cases has six members and is achieving average closure times under 30 days.
- Five disability matters were referred to CCHR's mediation program in FY2026.
- CCHR's Human Rights Law 101 training was offered approximately 420 times in FY2026, reaching roughly 20,000 people.
- A specific training on disability protections in housing and public accommodations was offered several hundred times in FY2026, reaching approximately 10,000 people.
- CCHR conducted 197 disability tests in public accommodations in FY2026, 59 in housing, and none in employment.
- CCHR's testing team consists of approximately three part-time testers and a director.
- Project Equal Access accessibility modifications rose 70% in FY2026, from 61 to 104, attributed largely to the addition of one new staff member.
- The statutory maximum civil penalty CCHR can impose is $250,000 for willful and egregious violations; the standard cap is approximately $125,000.
- Civil penalties in FY2026 ranged from zero to $110,000.
- MOPD has referred at least 22 alleged discrimination claims to CCHR since it began tracking referrals, with the bulk being housing-related.
- Approximately a quarter of New York City housing voucher users are people with disabilities.
- In one resolved housing case, a complainant was awarded $102,000 in emotional distress damages and reimbursed back rent after a landlord refused to install a ramp.
- In another resolved housing case, a housing provider agreed to provide 14 months of rental credit and transfer the tenant to an accessible apartment.
- The statutory civil penalty maximum has not been updated since 2005.
Action Points
- MOPD to provide the committee with a breakdown of the 22 discrimination referrals to CCHR by issue area (employment, housing, public accommodations, other).
- MOPD to develop a system for tracking outcomes of cases referred to CCHR, so that referrals are followed up and resolution rates can be reported.
- CCHR to provide the committee with a breakdown of source of income discrimination cases involving disability as a co-basis, and to clarify how these are counted in annual reporting.
- CCHR to provide the committee with data on how many source of income intervention cases were resolved successfully, including timelines and reasons for delays, as requested by CM Epstein.
- CCHR to follow up with the committee on the number of cases involving both disability and source of income discrimination where dual-basis claims were pursued.
- CCHR to report back to the committee on specific test results and enforcement outcomes from the 197 public accommodations and 59 housing disability tests conducted in FY2026.
- CCHR to provide the committee with data on the number of pending disability-related cases currently in its caseload.
- CCHR to provide the committee with available data on case outcomes broken down by accommodation type, including how many cases resulted in an accommodation being granted or a matter resolved in favor of the complainant.
- CCHR to report back to the committee on how many settlements are currently under active monitoring.
- CCHR to provide the committee with a breakdown of disability cases by issue area (e.g., reasonable accommodation versus other claims) to the extent its case management system permits.
- CCHR to follow up with the committee on the number of curb cut or public right-of-way accessibility complaints received.
- CCHR to provide the committee with data on remote work accommodation complaints, including from City employees.
- CCHR to provide the committee with information on how civil penalties are set, including the factors applied and how frequently the statutory maximum is pursued.
- MOPD to continue developing and report back to the committee on the interagency working group on elevator outages, which is identified as a priority systemic issue.
- CCHR and relevant agencies to continue reviewing Int 1107-2026 on service animal guidance to determine which agency should be designated as lead for implementation.
- CCHR and MOPD to engage the Mayor's Office of LGBTQ Affairs on outreach and training strategy if Int 0131-2026 on intersex protections passes.
- Chair Hanif to push CCHR to develop or commission a public report on public design, ADA compliance complexity and disability discrimination trends, particularly around physical accessibility modifications.
- CCHR to brief the committee on progress toward procuring a new case management system, including timeline and procurement status.
- CCHR to update the committee on the status of its memorandum of understanding with the State Division of Human Rights and any developing case-level collaboration.
Full Transcript
Good hearing. Please settle down.
Good morning. Welcome to the Committee on Disabilities joint with Civil and Human Rights. At this time we ask that you please silence all electronics. If you wish to testify, please sign in with one of the sergeants at arms in the back, and at no point please do not approach the dais.
Good morning. I am CM Shahana Hanif, Chair of the Committee on Disabilities. I am a brown woman in my mid-30s with long black curly hair. I am wearing a red power suit and I am seated behind the dais.
Welcome to today's joint oversight hearing with the Committee on Civil and Human Rights, where we will examine disability discrimination enforcement trends at the New York City Commission on Human Rights. Thank you to Chair Nurse for partnering with us on this important hearing.
Millions of New Yorkers live with disabilities, and disability discrimination is now the most common basis of claims filed with the Commission on Human Rights. New York City has some of the strongest civil rights protections in the country. Our human rights law provides broader protections for people with disabilities than state or federal law, including the right to reasonable accommodations and a good faith cooperative dialog with employers, landlords and businesses regarding their accessibility needs. But strong protections on paper mean very little if New Yorkers cannot access them in practice. Without meaningful enforcement, our promises are unfulfilled.
The Commission on Human Rights issued a ruling in a case involving a tenant who spent more than four years requesting a ramp or lift so he could safely leave his apartment. Tragically, he died before that accommodation was ever installed. A disabled New Yorker spent years fighting for the basic ability to leave his own home. He died before that right was realized. Accessibility delayed is accessibility denied. In some cases those delays have irreversible consequences.
This is precisely why today's hearing matters. A December 2025 audit by the New York State Comptroller found that housing discrimination cases took more than two years on average to reach a determination. The Commission's own data also show an aging caseload, yet the agency does not publicly report how long disability discrimination cases take to resolve or what outcomes complainants ultimately receive.
Today we intend to examine several critical questions. One: how will the Commission's 2026 reorganization improve intake, investigations and resolution timelines for disability discrimination complaints? Two: what concrete steps has the agency taken to implement the State Comptroller's recommendations and address its growing backlog? Three: how are the Commission on Human Rights and the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities coordinating to ensure complaints are addressed effectively and that New Yorkers are not left navigating fragmented systems? Four: how is the Commission on Human Rights translating disability discrimination guidance into meaningful enforcement, education and compliance? And finally: what additional resources, data transparency or policy reforms are necessary to ensure that New Yorkers receive timely relief?
We will also hear four pieces of legislation that advance our City's commitment to civil rights, accessibility and disability justice. Int 0131-2026, sponsored by CM Tiffany Cabán, would amend the definition of gender under the New York City Human Rights Law. Int 1107-2026, which I am proud to sponsor, would require guidance and public education regarding service animal access in places of public accommodation — particularly important as the Commission on Human Rights recently reached a settlement regarding the banning of service animals on City buses — to make existing protections clearer and more accessible to the public and businesses alike. Res 0510-2026, sponsored by CM Julie Won, would declare June 18 Autistic Pride Day in New York City, recognizing and celebrating autistic New Yorkers and their contributions to our communities. And finally, Res 0665-2026, which I am also proud to sponsor, calls on the United States Senate to approve and the President to ratify the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and its Optional Protocol. As we mark the Convention's twentieth anniversary, the Convention affirms that disability rights are human rights and that people with disabilities deserve full and equal participation in every aspect of society. Twenty years after its adoption, the United States still has not ratified it. That failure is long overdue for correction.
I would like to acknowledge my colleagues who have joined us: CM Tiffany Cabán and CM Harvey Epstein. Thank you to the administration for being here today and to the disability advocates, service providers, health care workers and members of the public who have come to testify or submitted written testimony. Your presence here is an act of self-advocacy and we do not take it for granted. Thank you to the committee staff who have made today's hearing possible, including Senior Legislative Counsel Sarah Sukha, Senior Legislative Policy Analyst Chloe Rivera, my Senior Adviser Emmett Tyron, Communications Director Simone Lavin and Legislative Fellow Teodora Moo. I will now turn it over to Chair Nurse.
For her opening remarks. All right, good morning everyone. Happy Friday. My name is Sandy Nurse. I am Chair of the Civil and Human Rights Committee. I want to start by first thanking my co-chair CM Hanif. As she mentioned in her opening statement, the Commission on Human Rights has reported that disability is the most common basis of claims filed amongst protected classes.
Something I wish to emphasize for everyone here is that the Commission on Human Rights is a relatively small agency tasked with a very large mandate. We totally recognize that it is the enforcement agency for one of the most expansive human rights laws in the country. Perhaps most importantly, the people they serve often do not have any other way to enforce their rights because they may not be able to afford a private attorney. So this is also very much an issue of economic justice.
The heartbreaking story that Chair Hanif shared about someone who died while waiting years for a disability accommodation emphasizes something we already know to be true, which is that justice delayed is justice denied. That is why our goals here are so important. We hope this hearing will shine a light on how the Commission's resources and organizational structure have real, tangible impacts on how people with disabilities can enjoy access to secure housing and daily necessities without discrimination or undue disadvantage.
My co-chair noted the Commission's recent reorganization, something that I am hoping will be able to positively impact its workflows — and this is something we have discussed in multiple hearings before — and especially how quickly people can have their complaints resolved. At the end of the day, what is most important is that there is relief for those facing discrimination and hardships due to discrimination.
For a lot of New Yorkers these issues impact their lives on a day-to-day basis. They often have a detrimental snowball effect. For example, someone unable to leave their home due to a lack of a possible accommodation may then be unable to get to work, lowering their income and starting a series of events that at times, in emergency situations, can cost them their life or their health. I recognize that not every situation is this dire, but we still believe it is important to know that some situations are, and many have the potential to get to that point.
I am curious how the Commission on Human Rights has responded to the Comptroller's audit mentioned by my co-chair and how any internal changes are impacting resolution times. We look forward to hearing from the Commission on its disability-related enforcement, education and testing, and also hope to learn more about its dynamic and work with the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities.
In order to better serve New Yorkers as efficiently as possible. I want to thank everyone here who has come and made it here today on a Friday. Everyone who worked on this hearing — I am grateful for everybody who is going to testify today. I believe we are now going to hear from CM Cabán on her Bill.
Thank you, Chairs. Good morning everyone. My name is CM Tiffany Cabán. I am a Puerto Rican woman with a ponytail and glasses, wearing a beige sweater. I want to thank Chairs Nurse and Hanif for holding this important hearing on disability and discrimination. As a New Yorker myself with chronic illness, I am grateful for your leadership in making our City more accessible. I also want to thank the two of you for giving me time in this hearing for my Bill, which does not neatly fit into the theme of this hearing but which is nonetheless crucial to many New Yorkers.
My Bill, Int 0131-2026, would ensure the Human Rights Law protects intersex New Yorkers from discrimination. Before I describe that legislation, I just want to deeply, deeply thank the folks at InterAct. We have the Executive Director Erica here, as well as Leon Feller, Jen Levine, Alicia Roth Weigel, Alyssa Ball, Briony Pryce — and I remember meeting with the students on this piece of legislation, Clay Shen and other intersex students. It represents the best of what governing and being in partnership with community should be: directly impacted people coming to their elected officials and saying where the government needs to step up to protect them.
It has been clear to folks in the LGBTQ+ community that for too long intersex people have faced bigotry and discrimination, been denied the health care that they need and have been subjected to hate and violence. The federal government has at best failed to protect intersex people — and that is putting it mildly. This administration specifically has made it difficult for many intersex people to obtain documents reflecting an X gender marker. It is more important than ever that our City enforce anti-discrimination laws to keep intersex New Yorkers safe, enable them to access the care that they need and protect them from discrimination. So again, thank you, and I will pass it back to the Chairs.
Thank you. And now I will read a statement that was provided by my colleague CM Julie Won on her Bill. Thank you, Chairs.
My Bill, Res 0510-2026, is heard at this hearing for the Committee on Disabilities and Committee on Civil and Human Rights. This resolution will declare June 18 annually as Autistic Pride Day in New York City. I want to take a moment to thank Gary Ohn Steven, whose outreach and advocacy was a spark that got this Bill drafted. Gary, an autistic self-advocate and a proud New Yorker, reached out to my office because he believed this City should formally recognize this day — and he is right.
Autism Spectrum Disorder presents differently for every single person, and no two individuals share the same experience. No one should be reduced to a diagnosis. And yet for too long, public conversation around autism has done exactly that. That is exactly why Autistic Pride Day exists. In 2005, an organization called Aspies for Freedom, led by autistic individuals, created the day. They did not wait for someone else to speak on their behalf. They built a space for self-determination, for neurodiversity, for pride — and they did it deliberately as a counter to the Autism Awareness Month narrative, which was too often led by non-autistic voices, too often centered on deficits, on fixing, on curing. I want to make it clear: autism and neurodivergence is not a problem to be solved, but instead a community to be celebrated.
The symbol of this day is a rainbow infinity sign, which is fitting to embody the infinite diversity, potential and future of the autism and neurodivergent community. This is why my Bill, Res 0510-2026, will declare June 18 annually as Autistic Pride Day in New York City. This Bill will make sure that this community, that is far too often neglected or unsupported, will get the recognition, respect and visibility they deserve.
Thank you to Autistic Adults and the Disability Network, the Autistic Self Advocacy Network, the Human Rights Campaign and New York Lawyers for the Public Interest for their support on this resolution. By recognizing this day, New York City institutions, workplaces and communities can affirm they are stronger when we include neurodivergent individuals. Now the committee counsel...
...will administer the oath to Deputy Commissioner for Policy and Legislative Affairs at the Commission on Human Rights, Joanne Camford — I am sorry if I mispronounced your name — Assistant Commissioner for Pre-Complaint Intervention and Litigation at the Commission on Human Rights, Stephanie Rivera, and Deputy Commissioner and Senior Legal Officer at the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities, Belkis Marrig. Members of the administration, prior to their testimony...
Good morning, Chair Hanif and Chair Nurse, and members and staff of the Committees on Disabilities and Civil and Human Rights, as well as members of the public who made the time to come today. Thank you so much for convening today's hearing on disability protections and enforcement.
As referenced, my name is Joanne Camford — perfect pronunciation, thank you. My role at the Commission is Deputy Commissioner for Policy and Legislative Affairs. As noted, I am joined by Stephanie Rivera, our Assistant Commissioner for Pre-Complaint Intervention and Litigation in the Commission's newly renamed Office of Civil Rights Enforcement, as well as Belkis Marrig, Deputy Commissioner and Senior Legal Officer from the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities.
I just want to start by underscoring the Commission's commitment to ensuring that New Yorkers with disabilities can live, work, access services and participate fully in our City free from discrimination. As noted, disability protections comprise a significant part of the Commission's work, and the Commission on Human Rights uses a range of tools including education, outreach, investigations and litigation to prevent and remedy discrimination.
Today I will provide a brief overview of the City Human Rights Law's disability protections as well as enforcement and outreach. More details on the specifics are in my written testimony. The Commission's enforcement includes investigating complaints as well as seeking to resolve matters before a formal complaint is filed where appropriate, and securing remedies for violations of the law. The Commission also provides trainings and develops know-your-rights and know-your-obligations materials so that New Yorkers and covered entities understand their rights and responsibilities under the City Human Rights Law.
These functions complement one another. Community engagement promotes awareness of the law and access to the Commission, while our enforcement removes barriers to accessibility and protects the rights of persons with disabilities. Our engagement and enforcement support the end goals of obtaining individual remedies and preventing future discrimination. The Human Rights Law aims to achieve independent and equal access to all aspects of City life for New Yorkers, and broadly protects people with disabilities from discrimination at work, in their living spaces and in public places. To this end, the law prohibits employers, housing providers and places of public accommodation from discriminating against individuals because of an actual or perceived disability. Service providers and housing providers must ensure full and equal enjoyment of their facilities and services regardless of disability, and employers are prohibited from treating employees less well...
On the basis of disability, the City Human Rights Law also requires covered entities to provide reasonable accommodations for people with disabilities unless doing so would impose an undue hardship. These include changes to policies or practices, workplace adjustments, or the installation of ramps or lifts to make a building accessible. As noted, part of the process of providing a reasonable accommodation is the obligation to have a cooperative dialog with an individual to help identify their needs and how to meet them.
The Commission on Human Rights has various enforcement tools so the agency can respond to the circumstances of individual matters and, where appropriate, address broader patterns of potential discrimination. In fiscal year 2026, disability claims were the most common type of claim across the areas of employment, housing and public accommodations, which is similar to recent years' trends. Complaints lead to an investigation by the agency's Office of Civil Rights Enforcement. In order to remove barriers faced by individuals with disabilities and foster inclusive and accessible spaces, the Commission employs, in addition to complaint investigations and litigation, other tools. Where physical accessibility is at issue, the Commission has a project, Equal Access, that works with housing providers and businesses to identify how to make spaces accessible, delivering faster solutions to persons with disabilities including grab bars, ramps and lifts.
The Commission on Human Rights also proactively identifies potential discrimination through testing to assess compliance with the Human Rights Law in a range of areas, which include identifying potential barriers to accessibility. Together, pre-complaint interventions, testing and resolution of individual complaints are critical for securing meaningful relief and promoting compliance with the City Human Rights Law. When the Commission identifies violations of the law, covered entities need to take action such as modifications or policy changes, and can also be ordered to pay damages to individuals and to pay civil penalties. The agency also seeks remedies to prevent future discrimination and promote an accessible city. In employment and public accommodations, respondents can be required to create reasonable accommodation policies and post notices so employees and patrons know their rights.
I want to highlight that in fiscal year 2026, case resolutions also played a role in ensuring New Yorkers with disabilities were able to access their housing. We heard about one example already. In another matter, the Commission was able to assist an individual whose landlord had refused to enter into a cooperative dialog or install a ramp after their mobility became limited. As a result, the tenant had to stay longer than needed in a rehab facility because he could not enter his building. The Commission ultimately secured an agreement to compel the housing provider to build a ramp, and the complainant was awarded $102,000 in emotional distress damages as well as reimbursed back rent. In another matter, housing providers that failed to accommodate an individual ultimately agreed to provide 14 months of rental credit and to transfer the individual to an accessible apartment.
These case outcomes demonstrate that disability enforcement resolutions are tailored for an array of circumstances. The Commission on Human Rights' enforcement is also coupled with educating New Yorkers about the City Human Rights Law in order to prevent discrimination. The agency provides disability rights education through its Human Rights Law 101 trainings and through more focused programming. The Commission also works with community-based organizations, disability advocates, elected officials, businesses, housing providers and other partners to increase awareness of the law. Community engagement helps New Yorkers recognize potential discrimination and allows the Commission on Human Rights to reach communities through trusted partners, which includes bringing information about rights and resources directly into neighborhoods across the City.
In fiscal year 2026, the Commission continued to leverage community partnerships to advance the agency's mandate through events large and small. The Commission on Human Rights again partnered with Project Access for All to host the Disability Unite Festival, working with the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities and the Public Advocate's office, and participated in the Disability Pride Parade, supporting the rights of New Yorkers living with disabilities to thrive in New York City.
These are just some of the examples of our work to tackle disability discrimination. Now I am going to turn to the bills that are being heard today. The Commission appreciates the opportunity to comment on legislation before the committees concerning disabilities and civil rights protections.
First, starting with Int 0131-2026: that proposed legislation would amend the City Human Rights Law definition of gender to expressly include sex characteristics including intersex traits. The Commission supports the explicit reference to intersex traits, which is consistent with the Commission's existing interpretation of the Human Rights Law, the Commission's rules of practice and our legal enforcement guidance. I will note this is not in my testimony, but the agency has been working with the Law Department and others in the City to really take strong stances against the federal attack on gender identity protections and the move to isolate binary gender identities. We can talk about that further in the future.
Second, Int 1107-2026: this proposed legislation involves several agencies and calls for public information and guidance concerning the rights of individuals with service animals and the obligations of covered entities. The Commission on Human Rights supports the intent of the legislation to raise awareness of anti-discrimination protections and relevant City, State and federal codes. The administration, including the Law Department and sibling agencies, are continuing to review this legislation and discuss the appropriate agency to be designated to complete it if this Bill moves forward.
To close, I will just underscore again that the Commission remains committed to ensuring New Yorkers with disabilities understand and can exercise their rights, that covered entities know their responsibilities, and that meaningful remedies are available when discrimination occurs. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. We appreciate the Council's time and attention and look forward to your questions. It is the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities next.
Okay, well we will go into questions then. I would like to acknowledge that we have been joined by CM Rita Joseph. Okay, we are going to kick off with some questions for the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities, and I know that we are joined by the Deputy Commissioner. Belkis, am I saying your name right? Okay. So to kick off: when a New Yorker reports disability discrimination in employment, housing or public accommodation, what is the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities responsible for, and when does the Commission on Human Rights take over? This is just to better understand and get clarity on the relationship that the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities has with the Commission on Human Rights as it pertains to these kinds of cases.
Thank you, Chair Hanif, for that question. Generally speaking, the Commission on Human Rights has prime purview over discrimination complaints. If someone, for example, calls 311 and alleges discrimination, those are directly routed to the Commission on Human Rights. We are not an oversight or enforcement agency, so we do not enforce discrimination complaints. However, constituents can contact us directly. We have a form on our website, we have a phone line, we also have a direct email, and so there are various ways to reach the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities. When an individual alleges discrimination, we refer them to the Commission on Human Rights. Sometimes, if the complaint is a physical accessibility complaint, we will directly refer them to Project Equal Access if it is applicable in that circumstance, and then we get a wide variety of other...
...types of phone calls that are not appropriate to refer to the Commission on Human Rights, and we provide resources. If businesses contact us about accessibility, we will provide resources and that sort of thing. So we serve as the voice of the disability community in City Hall and we provide resources to businesses, the general public and anyone who contacts us with specific questions.
Now, how many New Yorkers fill out the form or reach the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities through the phone line, which is separate from 311? Are you able to share how many constituents contacted the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities? We receive quite a few calls. Our phone line is quite busy. When I was walking here this morning, our constituent services person was on the phone and I could not say hi. So we get quite a few phone calls. In the prior administration that information was not tracked. We hired a new constituent services person in early and we have started to centralize the types of calls we receive. So we are looking into centralizing that information and recording it so we have a better understanding of the types of questions and inquiries that we receive. We do not have a number to share unfortunately today, but what I can say is that since we have started tracking, we have at least referred 22 alleged discrimination claims to the Commission on Human Rights. And is that similar for the form that you shared about? Yeah, I mean sometimes it is a request for the Commissioner to speak. We just have a general contact form on our website and so those could be anything that anybody wants to reach us about.
And then broadly, could you share what requests are coming through the hotline number and the forms? Yes. The bulk of the inquiries that we get are related generally to housing. Housing tends to be a challenging area for New Yorkers with disabilities. Often the questions are a combination of physical accessibility or housing discrimination — someone is facing eviction because of their disability or that sort of thing — and we generally refer those directly to the Commission on Human Rights.
The fiscal year 2025 annual report highlights strengthened collaboration with the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities, but the fiscal year 2026 report does not mention the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities. What specifically can you share about that collaboration and what it achieved, and what does the ongoing work look like?
Thank you. Yes, so I think just to say on the annual report that it is a snapshot of activities but definitely not everything from the past year. Really beginning in fiscal year 2025, we worked with the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities to create a number of updated resources for small businesses around business accessibility that live on the My City page, which is a resource for small businesses, as well as developing joint training programs, again many focused on small businesses. So those are a couple of areas of collaboration so far.
I think as the Deputy Commissioner from the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities mentioned, we are also referring cases internally across agencies and always thinking about ways to work together. We of course do outreach events like the Disability Unite Festival that I mentioned, the Small Business Expo, and I think the Deputy Commissioner from the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities has a few other sponsored events that we participated in. The Commission on Human Rights also participates in the Disability Service Facilitators trainings. For example, we had one on fair housing earlier this year, and then I think last year we had a source of income training. So we convene various agencies for trainings. The Commission on Human Rights attended the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities town hall which we held very recently, and I believe we have had a couple of...
...we have tabled a lot next to each other. But generally, lines of communication are open and we generally work together, especially for outreach events. As to cases that are being referred to the Commission on Human Rights, were there any outcomes or improvements in that area that you all have engaged on together to make that process maybe easier in terms of complaint referrals?
Yeah, I think what we are saying is that where possible we connect agencies. So if the team at the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities identifies something, they can then reach out directly to Project Equal Access. We have the Deputy here who oversees that team, so she can speak to it in greater detail.
My apologies. I do directly oversee Project Equal Access, which is the team of individuals that do basic outreach in the community. When we receive a complaint of discrimination, they are in the field on the streets assessing whether accommodations and modifications are essentially feasible for those individuals. So often we receive referrals directly from the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities, in which case Project Equal Access will then conduct site visits and meet with those individuals in their homes or in those public spaces. Some of those cases do end up as filed complaints, but what I do see right now is that many times those individuals are reaching out to multiple agencies at once, and so we already have an open matter for that individual. We will advise that there is an existing case, but because it is open it is considered confidential, so a lot of our collaboration has to take a pause on those...
...matters. And how many staffers are dedicated solely to Project Equal Access? Project Equal Access has three members. One was recently added in the reorganization. Although pre-complaint interventions for individuals with disabilities can run the gamut, we do have other staff members who handle accommodation requests that do not require some sort of physical modification. Understood, and we will come back to you with a few more questions about Project Equal Access.
The Deputy Commissioner mentioned that 22 cases were referred to the Commission on Human Rights regarding disability-related issues. Are you able to give us a breakdown of how many concerned employment, housing, public accommodations or any other issue areas? Unfortunately I do not have that breakdown in front of me, but I believe the bulk of them were housing referrals, and that is the majority of the complaints that we receive.
And then can we follow up with you to get that breakdown after this hearing? Sure. And could you describe the referral handoff so that we have better clarity? Commissioner, you mentioned — Deputy Commissioner also mentioned — that there is a warm handoff to the Commission on Human Rights. Is that warm handoff going to Project Equal Access? Please describe the...
...process. Yeah, so I think it is going to depend. We reach out directly to Stephanie, who is the Assistant Commissioner overseeing Project Equal Access. I think there is also staff at the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities who directly work with our Project Equal Access teams, so they might reach out to the director of that team as well. It is always our goal to follow up with the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities to let them know what happened with the case. I think we are improving our ability to track whether that is happening in every case. As the Deputy Commissioner from the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities was saying, our internal system is something that we are continually improving, including as part of this reorganization. But really, a phone call to a member of Project Equal Access means those matters are captured in our case management system.
Your case management system has a tracker. You are seeing on the particular issue areas which we would be able to have access to after this...
...hearing. So the numbers in our annual report are the numbers of all of the reports of discrimination that we get, including their referrals, and that is an internal database system which is something that we are striving to improve by procuring a new case management system. Because some of the fields make it hard to report out on the specifics of referrals and details of cases, but that is the basis of our annual report numbers, which is...
...everything that comes to us as a matter. And then, for everything that is referred out, are you all tracking whether the Commission on Human Rights accepts and resolves these cases? So, as we know, we are a small office and we get hundreds of calls a month, so we do not track every individual call after we refer it. There are some where, like Project Equal Access cases, we have physical accessibility specialists and they will directly contact the Commission on Human Rights' Project Equal Access team, and for those cases there is an exchange of information. The Commission on Human Rights lets us know that they have it and they take it from there. Generally speaking, unless the constituent comes back to us, we do not track the eventual outcomes. Got it. I would make a...
...recommendation that that kind of tracking happens to close the loop, given folks are coming in through the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities. I think it is important that you are able to keep note that, okay, all of these ten folks who were referred out to the Commission on Human Rights now have had a good resolution, or two of them have not had any resolution, or I have not heard back, or something. I do not know what that process would look like, but I think...
...it is pretty significant to ensure that cases are resolved. I want to pass it to CM Epstein, who has to leave. I also want to recognize that we have been joined by CM Hudson and Majority Leader... Thank you, Chair.
Hanif, I appreciate that. I am sorry that I cannot stay long, but thank you for taking the time. Can I just talk about housing discrimination issues? It sounds like what we are hearing is someone calls in a complaint, whether they are calling the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities or going directly to the Commission on Human Rights, and a year later a lot of these cases are not being resolved. Obviously, as someone who cares deeply about making sure people who have housing issues get those resolved, I am wondering how we get that system expedited. What are we doing to help folks? This is truly a crisis for people, whether it is source of income discrimination — and if you do not get that resolved within a month, that apartment is gone — or if we are talking about other issues, as the Chair was talking about, accessibility issues. A year is a very long time for someone to sit and wait and suffer. Thank you so much.
CM Epstein, that is actually really great and I am really honored to supervise our Project Equal Access team and our interventionists. I will say at the point of contact with individuals, whether they are walking into our offices, being referred by other sibling agencies, or calling our live hotline, we are flagging those matters as urgent matters and routing them for pre-complaint intervention, and those are being handled immediately. Whether it is a lawful source of income or a reasonable accommodation for disabilities, which are the two areas I would say our interventionists are extremely deft at, we are able to secure housing quickly for individuals. When we are not, we are quickly filing those complaints, leveraging the expertise really of our interventionists and collecting evidence even before a complaint is filed. Any situation where we believe we can get the accommodation that that household needs can be anywhere from a physical modification like the installation of a ramp, which we know can take time, permits may be needed, landmarking may need to be consulted, but generally we are able to achieve those very quickly.
So just on the source of discrimination cases, those source of income discrimination cases, how many cases did you handle in the past year for source of income discrimination?
I will definitely get back to you on those specific numbers.
Yes, and how many of those were resolved successfully, where the person actually said they denied me because I have Section 8? You went to the department — could we get that data?
Absolutely, we can get that data. Again, I personally oversee that source of income emergency intervention team and I know the results that we have been able to secure, including someone just last week we were able to get fully housed with keys in hand — a CityFHEPS voucher holder — which we are very excited about. We are seeing those types of results on a regular basis.
Just so — from my office we get a lot of calls from people with CityFHEPS vouchers where they have a Section 8 and they are going through a thousand places and not getting the ability to get in, getting turned down. What I hear is they filed complaints and they do not get those issues resolved. This is something we are seeing obviously as an affordability crisis in our City.
Yeah, 100%. I just have some of the numbers so I want to just respond to the questions. In pre-complaint interventions in fiscal year 26, 152 of those were lawful source of income matters where we ultimately — what we call — secured a housing opportunity, which can mean, you know, if someone was ghosted they are able to see the apartment, or if someone was denied an apartment, seeing if there is one available. Those cases are definitely a priority. A complicating factor in source of income is that landlords are attacking the protection itself, a legal battle about state lawful source of income protections. We definitely see some housing providers less willing to come to the table for a pre-complaint resolution, which requires someone to be willing to speak with us. But where the pre-complaint intervention is not successful, it moves on to a filed claim, and we had about 50 of those in the lawful source of income space last year. It is definitely a priority for this commissioner and for the assistant commissioner's team.
Yeah, and if you are able to move these quickly, that is great. It would be good to know what that timeline is for those, and also if they are not moving quickly, are those staffing-related issues? Is it that they are not moving quickly enough because you do not have the staff, or are they not moving quickly enough because the landlord or broker is not responding, or for some other reason?
Yeah, absolutely. We are a fully staffed team of six members. We are able to — on average, I believe our closure rates for pre-complaint interventions on lawful source of income was under 30 days, which is really impressive considering the current caseload of each interventionist, who are also doing disability accommodations as well.
I just want to add to that, because I think part of the kind of genesis of this hearing is talking also about a reorganization of the agency to move as many resources as possible into the front-line enforcement part of the agency. Cases historically have been handled by attorneys. I am an attorney. Attorneys are wonderful, but they do not need to do every part of a case investigation. So we have created a new role within our enforcement team, which are non-attorney investigators, to really help move the processes forward. I think we cannot say what the timeline will be — this went into effect July 1 — but the goal is faster case processing times at every step, so that in all protected categories we are moving cases faster.
Thank you, Chair, and thank you to Chair Nurse for letting me go out of turn.
Thank you. Just to build on CM Epstein's questions, we know that approximately a quarter of people that use housing vouchers are New Yorkers with disabilities. How many complaints at CCHR involve both disability and source of income discrimination?
We do not have the breakdown of where we have both, but we can certainly follow up with you. We know that disability often is coupled with another protected category, be it source of income, race or gender, and so we can share that information and follow up.
Great. And then are these cases counted under both categories in CCHR's annual reporting?
It will actually depend on the specific matter, because someone might come to us alleging source of income discrimination, they might be a person with a disability and have a separate claim that way, or they might not be filing the claims together. So that is a kind of fact-specific question.
And you were getting into discussing the kind of staffing structure of attorneys. How many attorneys are at CCHR that have significant experience on these cases specifically, in both areas?
Thank you for that question. We currently have 13 staff attorneys in our office. Our attorneys handle the full range of cases, so they do not necessarily have a specific specialty or topic area. Our interventionists are really where the specialties are leveraged, in how they communicate with respondents, negotiating tactics and the nuances of the law before a complaint is filed.
Understood. And then, given that people with disabilities disproportionately rely on housing vouchers, has CCHR investigated whether source of income discrimination also constitutes disability discrimination, and if so, has the agency pursued any disparate impact cases on that basis?
Thank you. That is accurate. We often evaluate the incident, or the alleged incident, based on both protections. We recognize that lawful source of income — it is very easy to only think about voucher discrimination, but that can include things like SSDI benefits, which we know only individuals with disabilities are receiving. So if they are being denied the opportunity to view and apply for an apartment because of their use of those benefits, inherently we are going to automatically include both of those protected classes as a basis and look at the disparate impact of the policies around lawful sources of income and how they impact those individuals. Thank you.
I will pass it on. Okay, thank you. I want to talk a little bit about the complaint trends in the data. According to CCHR's annual reports, disability is the most common basis for claims, and we are seeing that in the last fiscal year these claims increased. Can you explain what you think is driving that increase?
Absolutely. The increase — we are definitely seeing individuals choose our forum over federal or state forums right now, particularly given that we know civil rights education and work around rights in particular for individuals with disabilities has shifted. So we are often seeing that rise, and that coordination and increased filed complaints and pre-complaint interventions. In the last fiscal year, 22 disability claims in public accommodations reached a filed complaint citywide, which is up from 16 from the year before. Given how common inaccessible storefronts, restaurants and issues in the public realm are, are you reading that as a compliance or underreporting issue?
Thank you. Definitely an issue...
...of reporting. We know again that we are not the only forum individuals can come to, and so if we are not the first option, or if they contact us and they have already reached out to other venues or options, we are not capturing those numbers. Public accommodations is very unique in that we are also getting tips, particularly anonymous tips from individuals who are visiting New York City and want to say, "Hey, this is something that I experienced, can you investigate?" So oftentimes we are looking at those tips, seeing how we can convert them into testing programs and possibilities for agency-initiated actions. We know we had at least one commission-initiated action started in fiscal year 26 against Barnes and Noble's...
...which did start based on tips about how heavy and inaccessible the entryway to that Barnes and Noble's was in Union Square. I think I will just add, because you mentioned it is often tips — I think we have heard already that housing is a huge area of inquiries and complaints because it is necessary for your daily life. For public accommodations, for people to want to file a complaint, you really have to have the desire to sit through what can be a very unpleasant process. We know that across protected categories. So just underscoring — I do not think we see New York City as fully accessible, but really the role we play in our corner is to try and address the individual discrimination complaints that come to us. But definitely huge challenges.
Thank you for that. As you mentioned, we know the priorities for the federal government have shifted. It seems like we do not have priorities first of all in human rights. Can you speak to three areas of how this has impacted your work, and specifically when it comes to dual filing agreements, what happens instead? And what is CCHR doing now that the federal government is not pursuing disparate impact cases, and are you now expanding cooperation with the state human rights division?
Yeah, I will start with just the federal government and the EEOC in particular. As you have noted, disparate impact is actually being taken away at the federal level. It is embedded into the City Human Rights Law, so we will continue to pursue those cases. But we did make a decision last year to step away from a contract with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. The contract that we had was for dual filing cases, so if someone came to us they would preserve a federal claim. It was never enough money to sustain staffing at CCHR, and we think the trade-off — losing the small amount of money there — is that we are protecting the identity of New Yorkers. If you are dual filing with the federal government, they can access your case data, and that is something we do not feel comfortable with at this point in time. Individuals though can still choose to file federal claims in court or go directly to the EEOC. So I think it changes...
...the decisions people make when they come to us, but generally we think it is a net positive for New Yorkers that are filing.
I think on disparate impact generally, I mentioned already some of the comments that we have been working on. They relate to disparate impact, they relate to gender, and really seeking ways to preserve what are the protections in the City Human Rights Law. On the enforcement side, we have cases that are in litigation also addressing some of these claims. And then just on cooperation with the state human rights division...
Yeah, so I think we have pursued that previously, but we are definitely in conversation more with the state. Their resources have also grown, and we are thinking about not only education and outreach but potentially in the case arena how we can collaborate. But nothing...
...nothing has been landed on yet.
We have been working on an MOU. I do not know the exact status, but we are already sharing information and doing events together, so there is a kind of ongoing partnership.
Understood. I just want to acknowledge we have been joined by CM Louis online. Just related — employment disability complaints that would have once been dual filed, can they still reach a federal forum? I think I answered it a little bit...
...but...
Ultimately no, they will not be able to reach a federal forum if they file with us first. They would have to choose whether they want to go to the EEOC or federal court independently of us. Okay, and so...
...now to talk a little bit about the reorganization in 2026. In the December 2025 disability guidance, CCHR updated its guidance on disability protections in the City Human Rights Law in December 2025. Can you tell us what prompted this update and how CCHR has operationalized this guidance in handling disability cases?
Sure. I think we have talked in some other spaces about other legal enforcement guidance. It is generally part of our workflow that we are...
...updating materials because cases change and what we are hearing from members of the public changes as well. So we have increasingly — like everyone and your colleagues — been thinking about AI, and wanting New Yorkers to know that even if a housing provider, employer or public accommodation is using a form of technology in the decision-making chain, that is still covered by the City Human Rights Law and does not change liability, which is something that we added to the legal enforcement guidance.
We also updated the guidance to make it shorter. Lawyers again — it is not their forte to make things concise. We broke it down by area of jurisdiction. Previously everything was consolidated, which I think made it hard for people to understand: if I am in housing, what are my rights, and as the housing provider, what do I need to do? This is part of a move to also create more model policies for smaller businesses and housing providers, which do not have lawyers and HR staff to be doing that work.
I think the other piece, which was in the guidance already but which we built out a little bit, is around service animals and emotional support animals, because it is just a huge area of questions repeatedly coming to the agency.
Okay. And in relation to the comptroller audit, which outlined a restructuring plan — we have had about three months now. What substantive changes have you seen so far, or when do you expect those changes to affect case processing statistics?
Yeah, so I think the thing that we have accomplished is moving a lot of staff into the enforcement units, or Office of Civil Rights Enforcement. I think since the last time I was in front of this committee, our info line — the first front line — has doubled in size, so there are 16 people on that team now. We have created a new investigator role, so that when cases are found to be something CCHR has jurisdiction over, there are more people on the team who are able to engage in the investigative steps, which allows the attorneys to be more focused on litigation and settlements.
The staffing piece is a huge part of what has happened. I think the other piece we have been revisiting is that, because the whole process is changing, we are developing new guidelines on processing and what these different roles at the agency mean. I think honestly it will be a bit of time until we know what the impact on case processing times is, because we still have cases that have been with us that we are resolving. I would say ideally next year, or maybe the year after, we will really see what the impact has been.
The third piece, which I have already mentioned a little bit, is a new case management system that allows us both internally to better look at the data from cases and be able to report out that data, but is also more user-friendly for our staff. But I do not know — assistant commissioner, do you want to add your view of things?
Yeah, I was just going to touch on some of the action items that I am actively working on with my team, both in the info line and in the pre-complaint intervention stage. As the deputy mentioned, the info line has doubled to 16 people. We are training all of those members to be able to draft legal complaints over the phone, so that we can cut down on wait time and really open up the front door for how we file complaints and get more done faster.
I would say again, leveraging the expertise of our pre-complaint interventionists, particularly in disability and lawful source of income, so we can really streamline and fast-track how those investigations happen. On the litigation side, as I said, I also get to supervise our cases that move to the New York City Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, and we are really focusing on how we get more of our attorneys' cases in front of judges, cutting down on the number and extent of settlement conferences and moving quickly in front of those judges as well. Thank you.
For that, we love concrete actions being brought here. So I know that during the audit period you all had issued internal guidance in terms of housing case processing, moving resolution from one year to two years. Now that all of these things are in place, is this something that you expect to bring back down to one year? So I think our goals are always to move the cases as quickly as possible. I think one year would be significantly out of step with both administrative agencies and court case times. I think we are hoping to route as many things into pre-complaint intervention as possible. But the challenge we always face with an average case time is that we have cases that run the gamut from one individual needing grab bars in an apartment to a building with multiple respondents, management companies and many tenants. So depending on the complexity of the case, it really will impact what the case times look like.
Yeah, I am going to echo that a little bit more. Our cases and our investigative plans per case can really shift and change depending on the complexity of the case, how many witnesses we need to interview, how many documents and answers we need to issue, the number of respondents even in a given case where we are identifying multiple bad actors, particularly in the housing context where we are dealing with landlords, property management companies, brokers and their brokerages and salespeople, which can complicate and extend timeframes. So I am hearing that
you will leave the internal guidance to around two years for now. Yes, and I think...
We will be doing our best to bring it down.
Aspirations, yes. I understood. You also reported that the Commission on Human Rights reported expanded capacity compared with the Law Enforcement Bureau in intake, outreach, investigations and strategic enforcement. How are you measuring the impacts of this expanded capacity in each area?
The number one metric that we have always thought about is meaningful resolutions for New Yorkers, and so I think that will continue to be the thing that we are using as our north star in cases. Of course, looking at all the aspects of case processing time, as the assistant commissioner mentioned, we ideally have no wait times — you come to us and we are serving you immediately. That is where we want to get. But I think as we see what these staffing changes emerge and look like, we will have a host of indicators to baseline over the next year.
OK, and then lastly on this topic: you all have expanded mediation. I think you had 12 cases. How many of the 12 were disability cases, and is mediation appropriate where the remedy is an accommodation?
Where the remedy is an accommodation, the law already requires... thank you. We are actually very excited that our mediation program is expanding and adding members to the team. Last fiscal year we had five disability matters that were referred for mediation, because outcomes can still be achieved in mediation — whether that is getting a reasonable accommodation secured or getting damages — even still in those spaces. Mediation is absolutely still appropriate so long as both parties are willing to meet at the table. Thank you.
For that, I am going to come back to my questions in a little bit because I need my notes to have some time to recover. I think we are going to open up to CM Cabán on questions about your bill.
Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the members of the administration that are here with us today. I am going to ask some questions about my bill. Thank you, I really appreciate the testimony in support of the legislation, but particularly the words that you shared afterwards about what this administration's commitment towards our communities is. Discrimination against someone on the basis of intersex characteristics could intersect with a few different categories that the Commission on Human Rights reports, but it does not get recorded in its own category. So how often does the Commission on Human Rights receive inquiries related to discrimination against someone who is intersex? And if you know, do you have any thoughts around why or why not a person would report or would not report?
So I will start that, but feel free to add, Stephanie. One of the beautiful things about the City Human Rights Law is that it covers discrimination based on actual or perceived status. That means that not everyone has to come to us and tell us their particular gender identity. Gender is a broad category that includes many things and has quite an expansive definition, and I think we only need the details in some instances. So if people claim gender discrimination, people who are intersex could have reported that, and we do not have that specific information — or to my knowledge we do not. I can follow up if that is not accurate.
But I think in general, in answer to your question, we know that government has long been unfriendly to communities who do not fit into a gender binary. That has become readily apparent, more so as the federal government seeks to erase people's actual identities and denigrate them at every opportunity possible. So we do not fault people who do not feel comfortable coming to government. But we recognize that seeing yourself and being represented in materials and examples is important for everybody, so that they know they are seen and heard. As I mentioned in my testimony, we have recognized intersex discrimination in our public-facing materials, in our legal enforcement guidance and in our rules, recognizing that this is a significant issue that impacts people. So it is incumbent on us and our sibling agencies — the Mayor's Office of LGBTQ Affairs and the Mayor's Office of Equity and Racial Justice — to be thinking about how we are making sure New Yorkers know we are there for them. Thank you.
Yeah, it is interesting. I have a former colleague who is a human rights lawyer, outspoken and a very public advocate for the queer community, and only came out as intersex a few years ago. You think about all of those things being true and what about the environment exists that creates the conditions where somebody like that, for example, does not come out until just now. When you talked about this a little bit — with a complaint of gender discrimination, maybe not disclosing that they are intersex — but when you receive these cases, how do they get handled? What is the current legal guidance on the issue if you do learn...?
The guidance is already that we would treat someone — if they were to call us and say, "I think I have been discriminated against in my workplace for being intersex" — that could be being denied bathroom access, also in a public accommodation. That would go out to the Office of Civil Rights Enforcement, who would, like they do in any other circumstance, thank you, handle it accordingly.
Have you heard any feedback from community partners or the public on shortcomings of the current protections provided under the Human Rights Law?
I think we have heard from the same individuals that you have been working with at Interact, and I think the Fordham Law School clinic — Fordham alumni — what we are talking about right now, which is that some of the materials reference intersex persons but it was not clearly articulated in the law. That is part of the calculation in supporting the legislation. There are many things in the City Human Rights Law that I think advocates have come to us to discuss. Associational discrimination is another area where some protected categories have protections because you are associated with a person related to their disability, and that does not exist for every protected category. So that is something we have been looking at as well. Thank you.
And Chair, I just have one more question if I may. So we know that the general public does not necessarily have a high level of awareness of what intersex status means or the challenges that people with intersex characteristics face. So do you have any specific trainings, materials or outreach programming on this topic? And if you do, are programs aimed at specific audiences — like, for example, medical providers — or is it for the audience at large?
Yes, so we have a specific training on working with people in general that has historically targeted employers, but we have offered it for many service providers and others. So that is the natural place for this to exist. But I think when discussing this bill, and if it passes, we will be in touch with the Mayor's Office of LGBTQ Affairs to think about how we get the word out. Thank you. So yeah, we are here to be partners in that obviously. Interact and their student cohort are ready to be a part of that and looking forward to working together to make sure it gets passed. Thank you, Chair.
Thank you.
Thank you, CM Cabán. I want to come back to the question around source of income discrimination and disability discrimination. Are there any reports in the works by the Commission on Human Rights on the topic?
So I think in general we do a lot of educational materials, less in the way of studies or reports on trends that are happening. We have a lot of nonprofit colleagues who are looking at this, and source of income in particular is one of those areas. Unlock NYC is a close partner of the Commission. But we have been thinking about and working on a renters' rights guide which would cover a host of these protections and some of the ways that they intersect. Got it.
I would certainly love to see more discourse and research on the intersections between source of income discrimination and disability discrimination, as something that is not getting enough attention, and just the disproportionate number of New Yorkers who are disabled who are experiencing source of income discrimination. I know in the past the Commission on Human Rights would do these kinds of reports, did studies and really laid groundwork on the kind of narrative New York City should be thinking about on this topic. So that is putting out an idea to you all. I want to come back to some questions for you. Does the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities ever intervene directly with landlords? I know that...
you mentioned that you are mostly referring folks out to the Commission on Human Rights' MRS team, but does your constituent liaison ever more directly do interventions, speaking to landlords directly or employers or businesses? Yeah, thank you for that question. If a landlord reaches out to us about, for example, physical accessibility, we will engage with them and advise them. We generally tell them to hire an accessibility specialist, but we will provide guidance and that sort of thing. But generally speaking, if there is an issue, there are some — sometimes it is an elevator issue, and for example if it is in an HPD building we will get in touch with HPD and let them know, or DOB depending on the situation. If a complaint has already been filed, DOB is usually the first agency to be involved if an elevator is down, but we will also follow up and flag it if it is in an HPD building. So those are some of the circumstances where we might be involved with landlords that are not related to the Commission on Human Rights, but that is generally the universe of that.
Got it. So case by case. And would you say that these kinds of direct interventions lead to resolutions, like the elevator getting fixed or a landlord successfully understanding what they are supposed to ensure for renters with disabilities, or whatever the hypothetical situation? Yeah.
We do not have information on those that we have referred to the Commission on Human Rights, but we do know, for example, in the elevator context, this is a recurring issue. There are significant delays in getting elevators repaired, and so we are actually in the process of working to form an interagency working group to address some of these recurring systemic issues. That is something that we are exploring right now, and elevators is...
the number one agenda item. Are there other trends that are requiring this kind of interagency coordination?
I do not have trends in front of me and we do not do that type of tracking, but the elevator issue is an obvious one that we see on a recurring basis. And then there are some more complicated issues that require several agencies to work out a type of accommodation. For example, we have issues with students who disembark from school buses in front of schools. We would like curb cuts in front of the school, DOT has to be involved, and so we bring the agencies together to work out solutions that address everyone's concerns and also get students safely into schools.
And so I think the elevator example is a good one where this kind of systemic intervention is necessary and this interagency coordination is rightfully being prioritized. Has the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities made other formal recommendations to the Commission on Human Rights or other agencies when it comes to specific other kinds of issues, similar to the elevator and the curb cuts in front of schools? That is another good example where it is systemic.
Yeah, I mean the curb cuts are not a discrimination issue per se, but generally speaking we work very closely with the Commission on Human Rights on referrals and accessibility, and they are generally very responsive. We have not made formal recommendations but we are always collaborating, addressing issues and working together in public education, outreach and that sort of thing.
If I can interject just to amplify again some of the work of Project Equal Access and the team — elevator outages. We know frequent or long-term elevator outages create obligations for reasonable accommodations for individuals with disabilities. So oftentimes we do go out to the sites and see if there are repairs needed, how quickly those repairs can be facilitated. If we know that this is an ongoing issue, we have had instances where buildings are actively doing elevator modernization, which does mean that elevators could be out for anywhere from six to twelve weeks and sometimes much longer. We have been able to advocate for temporary replacements, other housing or hotels, or even for individuals who want rent credits while they are outside of their apartment, if that is feasible. So we are always thinking about robust, creative ways we can make those individuals whole again and help them stay in their apartments for as long as possible.
I think the other area I will flag for interagency collaboration harkens back to something I mentioned earlier, but really thinking about accessible design for small businesses, cafes and restaurants, and thinking about how our agencies collaborate to support small businesses that are interested in accessibility. I think a challenge we have all recognized, and probably unique to New York, is that even if you can make the front of a small store accessible, it is not always navigable inside. So there are a lot of resources that can help on the front end to address that in new buildings or spaces.
Is there a mechanism where the Commission on Human Rights determines when a constituent's case is more urgent than other cases? And does the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities, in its intervention or referral system — like a tenant who cannot leave their apartment because there is not a ramp, or a worker who could lose their job because an accommodation is not in place — does the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities ever, during its intervention, request to the Commission on Human Rights to...
track it? Absolutely. If it is an urgent situation we directly flag it to Project Equal Access.
This is rare, but I am aware of at least one situation where it was an emergency situation and our accessibility specialists did go on site to address the situation and to investigate.
Yes, I also remember that case. Absolutely. We do have a kind of triage, so we are thinking about whether someone is at physical risk. For other cases, if they cannot leave home, access medical appointments or get food, we are always going to prioritize those cases.
Individuals who are in homeless shelters — we are going to prioritize supporting those cases and finding housing. So we are constantly evaluating. Even in the employment context, pre-complaint intervention has an impact right now. In the employment space we recognize it is something that is very fact-specific, but our interventionists are being trained in that manner as well. So we are thinking about whether an accommodation can help someone return to work quicker if they have been on leave, or help them execute their job duties in a better way. We are also doing those interventions even for individuals who are pregnant. Even though we do have that as a separate protected class, we are also intervening in those matters because that is a temporary situation for that person, and we want to make sure that they have their benefits while they are pregnant, that they are able to continue to work just like anyone else and that they can continue to support
themselves. What is the Commission on Human Rights' current caseload on disability-related concerns? I do not have the total number of disability cases that are pending. I think we have data on how many cases are filed per year, but we would have to go back and run a more specific report to see how many cases before us involve disability. And then are you all tracking the trends in areas — the elevator being one of them, the example around students with disabilities and school buses — do cases like that also come to your table? What trends in issues are you all noticing? Absolutely. I have not talked about housing discrimination...
Absolutely, yes, particularly in the housing context, and I would even say public accommodation space. The trend is of physically inaccessible spaces predominantly in the employment context. What we are seeing, especially since COVID back-to-work orders, is individuals really relying on remote work as a reasonable accommodation option, and so we are seeing definitely an increase in those as well.
Which cases are taking the longest? Which kinds of cases are taking the longest to be
resolved? I do not think there is a particular type of case. Again, it is very... and I hate to sound like a lawyer in this perspective, but it really is pretty fact-intensive. It is going to depend on the complexity of the modification that is being requested, if we need to involve other city agencies such as DOB or the Landmarks Preservation Commission, how many respondents are involved, and what the nature of the accommodation is. I mean, the example of the individual who was waiting for a ramp to get installed and dying in the process — I mean, that to me is an avoidable circumstance.
And in terms of getting that ramp built, could you describe what the complexity is? We are dealing with a ramp that took four years to get approved, and I know there is this challenge of needing to also work with the landlord or the building management in the process, and they have their own process. I am trying to understand the trends, because it seems to me that concerns regarding getting ramps built is an area of issue where there is a systemic change that needs to get made, so that a ramp is not taking five years to get built. It is an area where we have seen enough of these
kinds of cases that it should only take six months. Given we know from start... could you just describe a little bit more? I get the complexity being a part of each case, but there is absolutely no reason for a ramp needing five years.
Absolutely. Chair Hanif, thank you for that. Equal access is very successful, I would say, in ensuring and following through with ramp construction. We often enter into settlement negotiations or settlement agreements prior to a complaint being filed that tries to closely track some of the issues that we know can come up with ramp installation: feasibility in getting appropriate architects through the door, dealing with permit delays, and those sorts of nuances, and getting through DOB.
The case that you are talking about in particular — I think the big issue is when we have landlords that have become emboldened right now in this federal atmosphere, saying we are not going to do this, we are not going to agree to do this, or if they are raising undue burden defenses, particularly around finances, where we have to take a very analytical view of all of their resources — whether that is an individual or business entity, years of tax records, bank account statements, rent rolls — to see what really is the financial hardship here.
Ultimately, if we do have to go to litigation, we recognize that that is also a separate, time-consuming process outside of our investigation efforts, and so trying to get that through to a final decision and order can take time. Although I recognize we are moving quicker than probably a federally filed or state-filed case, we want to move these cases as quickly as possible in every instance.
So in the case where we are waiting for these DOB permits and there is a challenging landlord, or this process of needing to gather all of this material from the landlord — are you saying that while that work is taking place, the ramp cannot get constructed? Oftentimes that means we have to wait for the landlord to move forward with that process. We do not have the authority to go in and physically erect that ramp ourselves. I really wish we did have that piece, but...
I am trying to understand through just our line of questioning here whether there is some policy reform that needs to get made. Sure, the landlord is going to be challenging and we need to collect all of this documentation, but the ramp has got to get built no matter what. This is unlawful at this point, because we are an accessible city that follows accessibility no matter what, so there has to be a cut-through system.
I will go ahead. Just to build on what you are saying, I know that other city agencies have the authority to go in and make emergency repairs. In our district we ask all the time when a landlord is being non-cooperative, and it is not a year-long process — if something needs doing, they will go in and do the emergency work and then bill the owner. I am wondering what authority could be extended here. I mean, I think the difference is between being a service-providing agency versus an anti-discrimination enforcement agency, but I think this is...
probably an area of interagency discussion — what are the tools? To the extent that the undue hardship is financial, obviously funds for building ramps. But as the assistant commissioner was saying, we can order a settlement and we can find a violation, but enforcing that is much more challenging than finding the violation of the law. I think it is also different with buildings that are being built now that are, to your point, ADA accessible — that is a different ball game than a building where it might be architecturally infeasible to build the ramp at the correct angle. Then we will try for temporary solutions, or where it is the only solution, a ramp that can be installed and moved. But yes, I think this is an area for ongoing conversation.
And we are spending too much time on ramps, but what is the typical length of time it takes to approve a request for the permit to construct the ramp?
I could not say exactly. What we have seen is ramps can take anywhere from... depending on how permanent the structure is. If they are installing a prefabricated metal ramp and it meets guidelines for that building, that can definitely be done in a matter of weeks. But then we have also had more complex cases that can take anywhere from six to nine months. Again, we try to track those. We ensure in our agreements that they follow specific timelines in refiling with DOB. If DOB comes back and says we need this revised or we need an additional document, we create affirmative obligations on those landlords that say you have to respond within a certain time frame, so the movement does not stop.
Is that the same for when a business needs to create a ramp or create accessibility accommodations as well? Yes, a similar route for us with stores and public accommodations. It is often the store and the building owner, so there are more players at the table, which again leads into the burden-shifting of who is going to pay for it and what the financials look like, but otherwise generally the same.
Yeah, and as I am hearing you all share more information, I think it is even more important that our City have a report on this issue of public design and disability and these impacts, and the complexity of public design as being ADA compliant. It is so difficult when all of us feel like it is a ramp and this should happen much faster. I would really appreciate some more reporting on this so that there is more public awareness on these conditions.
I want to come back to — I know you mentioned that you are not necessarily providing recommendations to the Commission on Human Rights. However, has there been any conversation on areas where, or internally, maybe not directly with the Commission on Human Rights, where you all feel there should be changes to the Human Rights Law for there to be faster and more meaningful relief for New Yorkers with disabilities? Like enforceable deadlines for accommodation cases as an example, or should emergency cases such as tenants unable to enter or leave their homes receive expedited review or interim relief, or should repeat accessibility violations carry higher or mandatory penalties? Are there these kinds of policy suggestions that you all are internally thinking about when it comes to cases that are referred out to the Commission on Human Rights? Thank you for that
question. This administration is really prioritizing disability communities' right to live a dignified life and have access to everything that they need, including physical accessibility and resources. Our vision is to move beyond just compliance and to build an inclusive culture within the administration. So one of the first things that Commissioner Agarwal did in her new role is to slowly build out a policy team, and so this is something that we are actively working on and exploring. Everything is on the table for us. We want to re-envision ways that the City could do better in serving people with disabilities.
We are in the early stages of that work. We are collecting the data. We are trying to understand — we are constantly engaging the community. The disability community is a partner in the process, and so this is certainly a priority that we are working towards and one of the things that we want to prioritize. Thank you. I will pass it to CM Nurse for additional questions. Okay, I want to just touch a
little bit on resolution and timelines for the Commission on Human Rights when you have disability-related cases. Can you talk about how many of those are resolved via settlement versus administrative closure?
Absolutely. In fiscal year 2026 we settled 42 cases that had disability listed as a protected class in the complaint, but could also have additional protected classes alleged in the complaint as well. So that does include even ones that are just disability as well. Compared to — sorry — administrative closures as you mentioned. Which ones were settled versus administrative closure, and what kind of circumstances would lead to an administrative closure versus another means of resolution?
Absolutely. So we had 59 that were administratively closed last fiscal year, fiscal year 2026. Administrative closures — the reasons are really outlined in our statute. They are really going to focus on: we were unable to locate a complainant after multiple attempts and we need to close that matter; if a complaint is being withdrawn, they might have entered into a private settlement or decided they wanted to file in a different forum, so that is also an option — closure preserves that individual's right to pursue that claim in another forum; and then we have other instances where it is not in the public interest to pursue that case. We see this a lot with small landlords and small businesses where complainants want to maintain good relationships with those owners — they are often living in the same building as them — or it can be something where we believe that there are not sufficient resources to find a probable cause determination.
I know historically we have really over-utilized administrative closures in that instance, and so we are really focusing on shifting gears and making sure that complainants have a real answer about the status of their complaint and why it did not reach a probable cause determination. We saw that the number of settlements has fallen. Why do you think there are fewer cases settling? Settlements are very difficult to trend. We are really relying on the cooperation of the respondents in those cases, and we are also really focusing on what meaningful resolution and outcomes we can achieve for individuals.
Whether that is emotional distress damages, back rent, rent credits, modifications to their home, securing the broader remedy — we want to make sure of that.
We are really calling respondents in, as the deputy commissioner mentioned, just about what it means to comply. How do we make sure that landlords and employers and providers of public accommodations are really building in policies that make equity and justice the status quo in every situation, and not just responsive and
punitive? Understood. I will just add to that — I mean, I think the role of attorneys is the same folks who are working on settling cases are also taking cases to trial, which can be quite labor-intensive, and where you have again complex cases and complex facts. So we are looking at how to marshal our resources all the time in terms of bringing cases to trial and getting big wins versus settling cases.
I think just adding to what the assistant commissioner said — back to the State Comptroller, I believe you all reported to him that you hired a consultant for case management and data retrieval. I know we talked a little bit about this earlier. There were plans to hire a legal technology expert. Where are we at with that?
The legal technology director is my next-door neighbor at work, so he has been onboarded and is working largely with the Office of Civil Rights Enforcement, but really with all the teams in the agency, to make sure that any new system that we procure is best in class for our needs. But as you probably also know, procurement is a long-term process. It is a fun process. Okay, I want to
just touch on testing and commission-initiated enforcement. We have talked about testing quite a lot this year, so I am not going to go too hard on it. But in the fiscal year 2026 report, the Commission on Human Rights' tests included 197 disability claims in public accommodations, 59 in housing and none in employment. What did those tests find, and what enforcement followed?
Thank you, Chair Nurse. The test results — I would have to pull specifics on each jurisdiction and I would be happy to follow up with that. But we are a small testing team right now. We have about, I believe, three part-time testers and a director. We are testing across all jurisdictions and across all protected classes. So while there has been a dip in disability-focused testing, that has been in large part because of other protected classes that we have really been responsive to, particularly around salary transparency. Fair chance housing as well has been a really big focus, as we are trying to get individuals to report criminal history violations in housing applications, which we are also seeing as an overlap again with other protected classes
as well. And then just — how do you all decide each year where you want to spend your time and resources testing? For example, have you considered medical offices, ride-shares and condo boards? How are you all making those determinations each year?
Testing is going to be dictated by what we are hearing from the public, by the types of complaints we are receiving, the anonymous tips that we receive. We will review those tips and see what is feasible for testing and if we think testing of respondents of a certain size and stature are going to have a broader impact on the public. So we want to be testing those large agencies and those large providers of public spaces, which is why the Barnes and Noble commission-initiated case is so big and why
are you all not testing employers on accommodation and hiring for employment in particular? Because of the
nuances that go into job duty review and the amount of investigative work that does have to be fronted a little bit, it is really difficult to do testing in employment in particular, or even reasonable accommodation investigations in pre-complaint postures. Many of those cases, while we are expanding our pre-complaint interventions for employment in particular, are often moving to complaint filings because of the depth of investigative work that we anticipate will go into those cases. Many employers have some form of internal process — whether it is just a single person or a large unit — and so that really is our opportunity to make sure that businesses and employers do have a robust equal opportunity process that is taking into consideration every person's needs. If they are not, we are able to say these are the broader policy implications that need to happen so that it impacts every worker in
that space. Yeah, I think I would be curious — because you are talking about the size of employers that might have that type of staffing or that size of an organization where you might have an HR department, but maybe small businesses with two or three people working in a place might be... I have a question on why disability testing fell by a third while tests on arrest record, credit history and salary history each grew by half. Testing
in particular — thank you, Nurse. For testing, we are again a very small team. Some of those resources are also to support public complaints brought by members of the public where we are trying to see if we can further substantiate their claims, and so that diverts resources as well. We do have our new strategic enforcement unit that is also focusing on those broader
impact cases and is starting to really rely on our testing team as well. Okay, so it sounds like you all need more resources.
We can go further with more, faster. Okay, well we did
advocate for you all this year. Any questions? I want to pass it to CM Joseph and then I will come back to a few more
questions. Thank you, Chair. Some of the questions around elevators has been one of the biggest things in my district, where folks have to remain in rehabilitation centers because they cannot come home, and my older adults are stuck in their apartments and cannot make it to their doctor appointments.
Or go out to do regular food, family members have to step in.
So I think on our side we need to do better. Landlords have to also step up and do that part, but I think we need to do better. I want to go back to the Comptroller's recommendations. So you accepted the audit's recommendations, and what has changed? What changes have you made from the recommendations they gave you?
We have really reimagined what it means to be doing civil rights enforcement. It was changing the name of our team from Law Enforcement Bureau to Office of Civil Rights Enforcement, so people know what we do. It is clear on its face. But it is really moving staff into the enforcement team and moving staff with cultural competency and language ability into roles on the enforcement team. So we have shifted people from doing some forms of outreach and engagement to that outreach being more connected to the enforcement side. So I can say that is the biggest shift — marshaling our number one resource, our people that work for us and come to work every day because they care about civil rights in New York City, and really focusing on case times. We have also now, as a result of that reorganization, a dedicated team focused on trainings, where it used to be that that was part of people's jobs. And we have a community partnerships team which is really serving as the focal point for nonprofit and interagency partnerships.
Well, thank you for that. And how accessible are you — in terms of both of you — how accessible are you, and how can someone file a complaint? Can they use ASL, plain language, Braille, or video? Is the online portal screen reader accessible as well?
Thank you, CM Joseph. I would say I am personally very accessible, as well as my team, and I am very honored to say to anyone who has us: if you are reaching out to the Commission, you are going to hear back from somebody and you are going to get a live person. In terms of accessibility in particular, we do have screen reader services. We have not always had them on site, so if we do have someone who walks into our office — we are an open office, individuals can come in without an appointment — we will arrange an interpreter for them, or if not, an appointment for them within days so that they can come back and get exactly what they need. Many of our materials are available in large print, as well as Braille and in multiple languages.
That was going to be my next follow-up question. What about disabled New Yorkers who do not speak English? What languages do you provide, and if it is not on site, do you outsource?
We do have a vendor that services us. I am just thinking about a case that I have been working on with our director of the info line, where the individual is deaf and blind but only speaks Arabic. So really figuring out what is the best and most efficient way to communicate with that individual — and we have scheduled them an appointment while we secure ASL interpretation to do that double translation for us.
Right. Exactly. Is the Commission on Human Rights seeing disability cases increase as federal civil rights officers scale back on these rights? Are you seeing an increase in numbers?
There is an increase in the number of complaints filed and the inquiries that we are seeing, for sure. Whether it is a direct correlation, I think we can say affirmatively — like, there is something happening there, and people are choosing to come to us now that their identities and their protected classes are under attack at the federal level. Thank you.
When an agency is at fault, what remedy applies, and who makes sure they are carried out? And what happens when they get in trouble again?
Yeah, so we do have authority over our sibling agencies. While we seek civil penalties per se, we are often looking again for that affirmative relief that ingrained equity and justice in their policies. We require trainings, and many times we are doing the trainings ourselves to make sure that training is adequate and appropriate. We are requiring that individual policies are revamped, and those policies have to come to us for approval before they are able to implement them. In significant cases, we can require long-term monitoring to make sure that compliance is happening year after year. Thank you.
Chair, can I ask one more question? Is that okay? Thank you so much. So how many remote accommodation complaints come in, including from City employees? Do you have numbers?
I do not have those particular numbers. I believe we can try to pull them manually, but it is, as I mentioned earlier, the trend that we are seeing in employment cases — remote work in particular, either full or partial.
Okay. And I am just going to close this one out. Has the Commission on Human Rights seen disability complaints involving AI hiring tools? Does it coordinate with the agency that enforces the City automated hiring law? How is that working together?
Yes, so we worked very closely with them on the guidelines for the bias audit law. To my knowledge, we have not had disability-focused complaints related to AI specifically, though there could be some hiring or employment cases that involve automated decision-making technology. But we work very closely with them on outreach and policy, as well as on enforcement and training. And as you say, you do training with interagencies as well? Correct. Correct.
Thank you, CM Joseph. Could you tell us a little bit more about the cases coming from City agency employees on remote work access?
For those, I cannot think of them off the top of my head — I apologize. It is something that we need to circle back on. But thinking about sibling agency cases overall, we are often pursuing and settling matters, particularly in the employment field. We have had several settlements with New York City Transit employees and the subway systems, and we have recently had that big settlement in the public accommodation space with New York City Transit, as you mentioned in your opening, where we were able to really secure meaningful financial compensation for those individuals that were refused entry on buses because of their reliance on a service animal. But then also reaching postings really across all five boroughs and bus depots and in the buses themselves — here are the appropriate questions that any bus operator should be able to ask and receive answers for.
And I will just say, for City employees, City agencies have their officer, which is the first stop, and then there can be an internal appeal. Or if your reasonable accommodation request is denied, that could come to the Commission on Human Rights, or go to the EEOC or the State Division. So there is a kind of multiplicity of venues where those cases might end up.
Got it. Yeah, I am very curious about remote work access being denied, given there was a huge fight by City employees to get a more clarified policy on the ability to work remote. So we can certainly circle back on policy on remote work access.
So I think I mean, the City...
Like everyone else under the City Human Rights Law, if someone requests an accommodation, the first stop is the officer, who is going to look at the particular position, what the individual's needs and limitations are, and then discuss what are feasible accommodations. And that, you know, lives alongside the collective bargaining agreements and all of the other rules. But it is going to be very, again, as the assistant commissioner was saying, very job-specific, because if you have a front-line, public-facing position it is different than if you are someone who is doing something where you are not interacting with the public.
And then a point that was made earlier about curb cuts — I wanted to come back to that, because curb cuts certainly are an issue of disability and discrimination, and thank God for disability advocates for fighting for curb cuts. How many complaints has the Commission on Human Rights received regarding inaccessible sidewalks, blocked curb cuts, or other barriers in the public right of way? So I do not think we have that number with us.
Today, I think often when a complaint is coming to us it could be because the street is blocked for something like open streets, where people cannot get into their houses. But I am not familiar with how many curb cut cases have come to us. I do not know.
If you know anecdotally, so we would have to circle back to see if we have that data.
Got it. And just to clarify, what buckets of issue areas are you going to be able to share with us on what kinds of cases are being handled at the moment?
About you mean within the disability space? And we will be able to do some breakdowns of reasonable accommodations versus other claims. At a certain level of granularity our system cannot report out, or we would have to run a manual tabulation of all of the cases. We will follow up again.
When the Commission on Human Rights determines that an accommodation is reasonable and a business refuses to provide it, what do you all take on?
Yes, those are absolutely the cases that are moving forward, likely with probable cause determinations, that then we have to take to litigation at OATH for a decision and order.
And how does the Commission on Human Rights handle repeat offenders of disability-based discrimination, like the Transit Authority, in two separate disability settlements in the 2026 annual report — one over bus riders with service animals and one over an employee's use of sick leave? Are they being treated as a repeat offender, and does that affect penalties or enforcement?
Absolutely. Depending on the violation type and the number of instances, they are absolutely considered a repeat offender. Particularly for repeat offenders, we will often eliminate any sort of pre-complaint interventions with them. We do not want them to think that if they are going to agree to a pre-complaint intervention, this is just going to go away for them. Those are the instances where we are seeking significant civil penalties. We are going to constantly increase the imposition of those numbers until we reach the maximum, which is only set at $250,000 right now, and that is unfortunately the cap that we have to work with. In each violation, again, affirmative relief is going to be a big component as well in those sorts of settlements or decisions, where we are seeking significant internal changes and monitoring of those offenders.
And we do not have a public list, like we do for the worst landlord watch list, for interagencies or companies and businesses that are the worst of the worst when it comes to... Actually, to come back to that — this is not a Commission on Human Rights initiative. The Comptroller does have an employer dashboard that looks at a whole host of different cases, and so there is something that exists in that arena. But I wanted to just underscore — and I think we have talked a little bit with the Civil and Human Rights Committee about the civil penalties as maybe not serving the same deterrent effect that they served when they were updated in 2005 — and so there has been an affirmative push by the Commission on Human Rights, and we are in conversation with you all as partners but also with City Hall, about increasing the statutory maximum of civil penalties so that they can truly serve a deterrent effect and to allow there to be discretion that matches the wide variety of cases that we see. A per-violation statute, we look at an array of factors for civil penalties, and I think that is an area of collaboration.
Got it. So would you be able to share how you are setting the penalties? Absolutely. So how penalties are set is really determined and laid out by several factors in our case law, and that can include the public impact — if we believe it is going to impact more individuals, we are going to increase civil penalties. The size and sophistication of the bad actor is going to play a big part as well. We look at their willingness and cooperation during our investigation. If it is something that we can quickly resolve, and also honestly the egregiousness of the incident is going to play a large factor as well. And you said that the statutory maximum is $200,000?
$250,000, if we can demonstrate that the violation was willful and egregious. The normal cap is about $125,000. Got it. And I was going to mention that the 2026 report penalties range from none to $110,000. How often are you pursuing the statutory maximum? Because we are really seeking maximum penalties for those particularly egregious cases and repeat offenders. It is a tool that of course we are going to try and utilize in settlement negotiations, and so we might not necessarily start off with that number. But if we are moving to trial and we know that a case is particularly egregious and it is going to make the impact that we think it is, we are going to advocate and argue for the most penalties possible.
How are you all ensuring that settlements produce lasting accessibility improvements, and who is monitoring the compliance? What is the frequency?
We are directly monitoring compliance. Through the reorganization, we have designated a monitoring clerk who is responsible for ensuring that actors are complying either with the decision and order or with the settlement terms. If they do not comply in the time frame, that monitoring clerk is quickly notifying the appropriate attorney or supervisors. But really it is on us to ensure that policies are being changed, training is being completed, and postings are going up. For reasonable accommodations, we do prioritize those being finished, and so we set quicker turnaround times and deadlines for those in particular. The attorney who settled the case will often personally supervise and ensure that that accommodation is followed through. And this monitoring clerk — is this role new? The role itself is new. It is a current staff member that we have designated, and so this is a new role and responsibility for them. Before the reorganization, it was on each individual attorney who settled the case to also monitor compliance.
And I will just say we also work with the Law Department on the enforcement side, especially where there are finances involved. So we have our attorneys who are doing their best to hold people accountable, but it often also requires other follow-up outside of the Commission on Human Rights.
How many settlements are...
Currently under active monitoring? That is a great question. I would be happy to follow up. I am not sure off the top of my head. Sorry. Thank you. And this is something that would be under the purview of the monitoring clerk to know. Absolutely. And can the Commission on Human Rights...
How many New Yorkers with disabilities received the accommodation they requested in FY26?
I think we will not have that data because it is not...
Always the accommodation that someone requested. Like, we are not tracking necessarily what the end accommodation is in all instances. But we are tracking the kind of cooperative dialog — whether it was engaged, what the kind of violations of the law are. And it is part of the reasonable accommodation process that there be a back and forth. So even if someone succeeds at the reasonable accommodation claim, it might not be the original thing they requested. It might be an alternative accommodation.
And do you have that data to...
Share? I think we can share information on how many cases involved accommodations. I do not know if we will be able to pull exactly that data. Okay. Yeah, I am trying to understand, from someone who filed a complaint about, let us say, a ramp, whether by the end of the year some solution did happen and what that solution was.
Yes, so we can track the matter resolved — an accommodation granted or resolved in favor of the individual. Yeah.
The Fiscal 2026 Mayor's Management Report credits expanded Project Equal Access capacity for a 70% rise in accessibility modifications, from 61 to 104. What did the expansion consist of, and is that funding and staffing...
Permanent? The big change was that we got an additional staff member for Project Equal Access, which had previously only had two members holding down the fort, and now we have another full-time staff member in that unit. I know CM Joseph asked some questions about City agencies as respondents. When the Commission on Human Rights settles a disability case against a City agency, who monitors the policy changes or training the settlement requires?
And does the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities play a role in that?
We still do all of that in those cases as well — from policy revisions, again, to monitoring any training requirements. We are often requiring that staff members and the agency, anyone that is going to have that public contact, is doing our trainings. So we want to make sure that they are getting the right training every time. When a City employee is denied a reasonable accommodation, how do the Commission on Human Rights and other offices coordinate, and how are employees being informed of their rights to file?
Directly with the Commission on Human Rights. We would only hear a City agency denial of a reasonable accommodation case if someone, after they go through the internal process at their agency, decides to file with us. The agency's equal employment opportunity officer is the one that holds the information about what the activity is for the officers at any given agency. We are only involved if someone files a discrimination claim with the Commission on Human Rights. Okay, that is good.
To know. On my bill — I know the administration shows support — what education or training does the City currently provide to businesses about service animal access, and how does that compare with what this bill would require?
Sure, so I can speak to the Commission on Human Rights, and I think the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities can speak to that as well.
We have a Human Rights Law 101 — it is our most prevalent training that we offered, I think, 420 times last year, reaching about 20,000 people, with a number of small business activities including City agencies and nonprofits as well. So that is our Human Rights Law 101. We also have a specific training on disability protections in housing and public accommodations that was offered several hundred times last year and reached about 10,000 people. As the assistant commissioner mentioned, trainings are ordered as part of our settlement, so if you are responding in a case you are going to be hearing from us on what the law requires. But also there are many, many requests every week to our training team to come and affirmatively provide education and outreach. I am just going to lift up again some of the cases that we have talked about today. Because the transit case — one of the elements of that case is that buses across the five boroughs now have to post a "service animals are allowed on public transportation" poster, and so that is a way to inform New Yorkers about their rights. In the housing case that we mentioned, the Tabarre decision and order, the landlord has been required to post reasonable accommodation protections in the building, again to raise awareness in particular places where we think discrimination might be happening about what people's rights are.
The Commission on Human Rights and the relevant agency also have a service animal and public accommodations poster that is already available. I will say there are agencies who also have a role, I think, in this particular Bill because it touches on so many areas of public accommodation. So there are a number of codes that are kind of outside of the discrimination space that are at play, and I know there is a Mayor's Office of Animal Welfare who has done a number of educational materials and has a website that touches upon a number of the pieces of this Bill. I think that is part of the reason that we are still reviewing with law and sibling agencies to identify what is duplicative and where this would most effectively live.
That is very much appreciated. Those are all the questions we have. Is there anything you would like to share?
Before we move to public testimony? No, just a thank you for your time and for this hearing topic, and I look forward to continuing. Thank you. We will take a five minute break and come back to public testimony. Thank you. We will now move to...