Hearing Hearings — Hearing Record ✉
← All hearings

Assessing the Economic Impact of the 2026 FIFA World Cup

Committee on Economic Development | Committee on Small Business

Meeting overview

The joint Committee on Economic Development and Small Business held an oversight hearing on September 30, 2026 to assess the economic impact of the 2026 FIFA World Cup on New York City. The hearing featured testimony from Maya Honda of the Mayor's Office, Justin Grammar of the NYC Economic Development Corporation, Nancy Manana of NYC Tourism and Conventions, and Alex Lazarus, CEO of the FIFA World Cup 2026 NY/NJ Host Committee. Public testimony came from the Hotel and Gaming Trades Council, the Manhattan Chamber of Commerce, the NYC BID Association and the Hotel Association of New York City. The central tension throughout the hearing was between the administration's headline figure of $2 billion in economic impact and the Council's pointed questions about who actually benefited, whether the City broke even, and whether outer-borough businesses and working-class communities saw any of the money.

The administration's economic narrative rested on a Tourism Economics analysis showing $1.2 billion in direct spending and roughly $800 million in indirect and induced effects, totalling $2 billion for New York City, with the region as a whole generating $3.5 billion, exceeding pre-event projections of $3.3 billion. The administration highlighted 12,100 jobs supported, a 16% increase in sports bar foot traffic, over $1 billion in additional hotel revenue, and the fact that New York City captured 70% of regional visitor spending, in part because the Mamdani administration redirected fan festivals from a single New Jersey venue into all five boroughs. However, the Council's Finance Division and the Comptroller's Office estimated City tax revenue from the event at roughly $55-60 million, against a City expenditure of approximately $90 million, implying a net fiscal loss. The administration did not dispute this framing but said the full cost accounting, including disaggregating NYPD overtime attributable specifically to the World Cup, was still incomplete.

Borough equity was a persistent theme. The Five Borough Winner Special distributed 133,000 commemorative cups to roughly 1,000 food and beverage businesses, but the breakdown was 569 in Manhattan, 182 in Brooklyn, 152 in Queens, 33 in the Bronx and 22 on Staten Island. Council Members from the Bronx, Staten Island and outer Queens noted that these numbers represent a tiny fraction of the city's roughly 20,000 food and beverage businesses and that the Bronx and Staten Island were barely visible in visitor spending data. CM Gutiérrez pointed out that Queens hosted a fan fest at a 25,000-seat venue for nearly three weeks but saw only a 6% increase in international visitor spending. The administration acknowledged the gap and attributed it partly to the compressed timeline inherited from the previous administration, with the Mamdani administration taking office roughly six months before the tournament began.

Permitting emerged as the most concrete operational failure. Multiple witnesses, including the BID Association, CM Avilés and CM Maloney, described a permitting process that froze out community organizations, denied block party applications, and in at least one documented case rejected a nonprofit's park permit for an activation the City itself had funded and commissioned. The Street Activity Permit Office was cited as issuing approvals as late as 24 hours before an event, which the BID Association said caused major commercial activations to take their spending to other host cities. The administration did not contest these characterizations. Planning for the 2028 Olympics in Queens, where nine soccer matches will be held at Ed Said Park, was flagged by multiple Council Members as the urgent next application of these lessons. NYC Tourism acknowledged its baseline budget has been flat since 2006 and that it currently has no dedicated funding for 2028 event preparation.

On Res 0655-2026, calling on FIFA to pay a $1 million legacy contribution, the Host Committee CEO clarified that FIFA had in fact already paid $1 million, which was used for mini soccer pitches across the region, but that a separate promised million from the Club World Cup had not yet been received. This somewhat undercut the resolution's premise, though the Council indicated it would continue monitoring. Hotel and Gaming Trades Council testimony noted that 30,000 hotel workers nearly struck during the tournament, ultimately ratifying a contract with over 50% wage increases across its term, framing labor standards as inseparable from event-hosting success. The Hotel Association raised federal policy headwinds, including a 14% decline in international visitors attributed partly to Trump administration travel policies, as an ongoing threat to the tourism economy that the Council should examine.

The record

Numbers
  • City's total direct expenditure on the World Cup: approximately $90 million ($35 million via EDC to the Host Committee, $4.5 million to NYC Tourism, $50.2 million to NYPD).
  • NYC Tourism and Conventions total annual budget: $23 million with approximately 100 staff.
  • Total economic impact of the World Cup for New York City: $2 billion, comprising $1.2 billion in direct spending and approximately $700 million in indirect and induced effects.
  • Total economic impact for the New York/New Jersey region: $3.5 billion, exceeding the pre-event projection of $3.3 billion by $200 million.
  • New York City captured approximately 70% of total regional visitor spending.
  • Number of jobs supported by World Cup visitor and operational spending in New York City: 12,100.
  • Number of out-of-region visitors who attended matches at MetLife Stadium: 508,000, out of 645,000 total match attendees (78% from outside the region).
  • Number of out-of-region visitors who attended official NYC fan zones and related events: 626,000, for a total of approximately 1.15 million out-of-region visitors to the City.
  • Hotel industry additional revenue attributable to the World Cup: over $1 billion.
  • Sports bar foot traffic increase during the tournament: 16% year over year.
  • Incremental visitor spending increase in Brooklyn: 19%; in Queens: 6%, per Visa card data.
  • NYC Tourism's $1 million programmatic digital media campaign influenced approximately 164,000 incremental visitors and generated an estimated $213 million in total economic impact, a return of $147 in visitor spending per $1 spent on advertising.
  • City and state tax revenue estimated by Tourism Economics for the full region: $414 million; NYC Comptroller's estimate of City-specific tax revenue: approximately $55 million; Council Finance Division estimate: approximately $60 million.
  • Five Borough Winner Special: 133,000 commemorative cups distributed to roughly 1,000 businesses, broken down as 569 Manhattan, 182 Brooklyn, 152 Queens, 33 Bronx, 22 Staten Island, out of an estimated 20,000 food and beverage businesses citywide (approximately 5% participation).
  • Host Committee total budget: upward of $200 million, of which more than $10 million was spent with New York City-based businesses including 36 M/WBEs.
  • Federal security reimbursement package for all World Cup host cities: $625 million; New York/New Jersey Host Committee submitted for upwards of $60 million in federal overtime reimbursements, split between the two states, with final amounts still being calculated.
  • FIFA legacy contribution already paid to Host Committee: $1 million, used for mini soccer pitches across the region; a separate $1 million promised in connection with the Club World Cup remains unpaid.
  • Unspent balance from the $35 million EDC allocation to the Host Committee: $1.615 million, repurposed by the City for branding activities.
  • Hotel and Gaming Trades Council new contract: wages to increase by more than 50% over the contract term for approximately 30,000 workers at more than 250 NYC hotels.
  • Hotel industry survey data: 50% of hotel workers spent more than half of monthly income on housing; 40% lacked savings to cover a $400 emergency expense.
  • Hotel Association reported a 14% decline in NYC hotel business attributed in part to federal travel policies, particularly reduced visitors from Canada and Germany, who spend an average of four times more than domestic travelers.
  • NYC Tourism's event calendar for the World Cup featured over 700 events, 17 times the number in the City's historically highest-performing event calendar.
Action Points
  • EDC and NYC Tourism to provide the Council with a breakdown of 2025 summer tourism economic figures for the same period, to allow a baseline comparison with World Cup impact.
  • EDC to share with the Council the full contract between the City and the Host Committee.
  • EDC to provide a final, disaggregated accounting of all City agency expenditures attributable to the World Cup, including NYPD overtime specifically associated with the event versus general summer programming.
  • EDC to provide the Council with the Tourism Economics breakdown of economic impact by sector once the full report is complete.
  • EDC and NYC Tourism to conduct and share results of the planned small business survey, to be distributed within weeks of the hearing, including ZIP-code-level data on revenue impacts.
  • EDC to provide CM Brooks-Powers with a breakdown of Five Borough Winner Special participants in Queens, including Southeast Queens and the Rockaways specifically.
  • EDC to report on whether the City has formally requested the remaining $1 million legacy contribution from FIFA related to the Club World Cup.
  • EDC to confirm which agencies were designated to implement Local Laws 107 and 110 of 2026 (Cultural Passport, small business map and public bathroom expansion).
  • EDC to provide data on how many event permit applications were denied during the tournament window, and how many denials were specifically attributable to World Cup-related constraints versus other reasons.
  • EDC to report on whether NYC residents living in NYCHA developments obtained employment, contracts or vending opportunities connected to the World Cup, and whether any NYCHA resident-owned businesses participated in City or Host Committee initiatives.
  • EDC to confirm the total value of World Cup-related contracts and subcontracts awarded to NYC businesses, broken down by borough and M/WBE status, and to report whether any outstanding invoices or payment disputes remain.
  • Host Committee to provide CM Farías with the correct name of the M/WBE procurement consultant (noted as Tiffany Stanard, not Tiffany Townsend as initially stated).
  • Host Committee to provide the Council with attendance figures for each of the five-borough fan festival locations.
  • Host Committee to clarify the final federal reimbursement amount received by New York for World Cup security overtime costs, once all submissions are processed.
  • NYC Tourism to confirm whether it has dedicated budget allocated for 2028 Olympic soccer event preparation and to brief the Council on the timeline for launching a 2028 planning campaign.
  • Administration to report on the economic impact of Midtown delivery restrictions on match days and to document what business consultation took place and how far in advance notice was given.
  • NYC Tourism and EDC to set up a real-time dashboard tracking borough-by-borough business participation for future major event promotional programs, to allow mid-program corrections.
  • Administration to engage BIDs, chambers and merchant associations in 2028 Olympic soccer planning immediately, and to brief the Council if that engagement does not begin promptly.
Download .txt
Full Transcript

(00:00:29)

Room one. Hello there. Good afternoon. Welcome to today's New York City Council hearing for the Committee on Economic Development and Small Business. At this time, please silence all phones. If you wish to speak today, please fill out a speaker's card with one of the sergeants. Moving forward, no one is to approach the dais. Chair, you may begin. All right.

(00:00:55)

Good afternoon and welcome to this joint hearing of the New York City Council's Committee on Economic Development and the Committee on Small Business. Today is Wednesday, September 30. My name is Virginia Maloney and I have the privilege of serving as Chair of the Committee on Economic Development, and I am so pleased to be joined by my co-chair CM Shanel Thomas-Henry, who chairs the Committee on Small Business.

Today we are assessing the economic impact of the 2026 FIFA World Cup. This Committee held an oversight hearing on the City's preparations and a hearing on World Cup legislation, and we passed three bills on bathroom access, on events calendaring, a small business map and a cultural passport program. Today is a look back about what the City's investment actually produced, who benefited and what the City should do differently the next time an event of this scale comes around.

First, we would like to discuss the World Cup successes — what worked well and what should become part of a long-term playbook for the City of New York. We held three fan events in all five boroughs. 30,000 people watched the final on the Great Lawn in Central Park. New Jersey Transit, for the most part, moved more than 300,000 passengers across the eight matches at MetLife Stadium, so there is a lot to celebrate.

Second, we would like to understand the return on investment here. The Council's Finance Division has an analysis showing that hosting the World Cup cost the City more than it brought in. There were some projections released earlier today in a press release and we would like to understand the true return on investment from these various sources and whether or not this was a net cost to the City. Put simply, New York City might have helped subsidize a tremendous payday for FIFA, and we will be digging in more on that with a resolution that my Council Member colleague will present.

We still also do not have a meaningful account of where exactly all of the money went. We were told that the City had passed $20 million through to the host committee and committed to sharing a breakdown of how that money was spent along with the agreement with the host committee, so we are hoping to get more specifics on that agreement. We did receive a breakdown of the additional $15 million that the Mamdani Administration added. Of that $15 million, $9 million was allocated to fan zones and we want to understand how that was distributed across all five boroughs.

(00:03:41)

The host committee reported a regional economic impact figure. That number covers both New York and New Jersey together, so we are trying to understand the host committee's methodology and what specifically happened in New York. The World Cup fell during peak tourist season, so many World Cup visitors may simply have taken the place of tourists who could have come anyway. So we want to better understand the methodology.

Chair Thomas-Henry and I have introduced Res 0655-2026, which calls on FIFA to pay New York City the $1 million legacy contribution that was promised for hosting the Cup. I will leave it to CM Shanel Thomas-Henry, my co-chair, to speak to that resolution.

Finally, in closing, this hearing is as much about the next event as it is the last one. In July 2028, Queens is set to host nine Olympic soccer matches. The lessons of the World Cup this summer should shape how the City approaches that event and every event like it. We need commitments from event organizers in writing before committing public money and we need to account publicly for every dollar that passes through to a third party. The 2028 Olympics are less than two years away and that planning needs to start now.

We want to hear from the administration today about what the City spent, what New Yorkers got for that money and how the City plans to carry those lessons forward. Before I pass to my colleague, I want to recognize the Economic Development Committee staff for their work in preparing for today's hearing. Thank you to Senior Counsel Alex Fallenoff, Senior Policy Analyst William Hungnash and Financial Analyst Spencer Cooney. I will now turn it over to CM Maloney... Good afternoon, everyone. I am CM Shanel Thomas-Henry, Chair of the Committee on Small Business. Thank you for joining us for today's joint hearing.

Today the administration announced that the World Cup generated an estimated $2 billion in economic activity for New York City. That is significant and it gives us an important starting point for today's conversation. But in a city as large as New York, headline economic activity alone does not tell us who actually benefited from it. The question before us today is: did New Yorkers feel it? Did the restaurant owner in Corona see new customers come through their doors? Did the small business in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Staten Island or Southeast Queens get a piece of that $2 billion? And after the crowds went home, did those businesses walk away stronger than they were before?

Mayor Mamdani said today that the World Cup belonged to the deli owners, cab drivers and line cooks who welcomed the world to New York. I agree that those New Yorkers helped make this tournament possible. It is clear what New Yorkers did for the World Cup. Today we want to understand what the World Cup did for New Yorkers.

The 2026 FIFA World Cup was the largest tournament in the tournament's existence. More than 1 million people came to the New York-New Jersey region. New York welcomed visitors, supported transportation and public safety, hosted fan events and helped create the experience that allowed this global event to succeed. But while this administration celebrates, small businesses across the City are still holding their breath. And that is why a headline number cannot be the end of this conversation.

We must look beyond aggregate economic activity and ask where that activity occurred, which industries benefited, which neighborhoods saw increased foot traffic, how many local businesses participated and whether the opportunities were equitably distributed across all five boroughs. Because the goal cannot simply be to hope that economic activity trickles into our neighborhoods. We have to build infrastructure that intentionally directs opportunities there. That means coordinating earlier with BIDs, chambers, merchant associations, street vendors, restaurants and retailers so businesses know what is coming and how they can participate. It means removing barriers and creating clear pathways for businesses across all five boroughs to turn major events into real, lasting economic activity.

That also includes examining the commitments made to our City. Res 0655-2026, which I sponsor, calls on FIFA to provide New York City with the $1 million legacy contribution associated with hosting the tournament that they promised. Together we are demanding New York gets what it was promised and better prepares us for what is ahead. That is why I am proud to hold this hearing to determine how the City can build a coordinated playbook for future major events so that when New York welcomes the world, our small businesses and working people are positioned from day one to benefit from it.

I look forward to hearing from the administration today about the economic impact of the tournament. I want to thank Tyler Walls and Rebecca Beryllium from central staff for their work putting this hearing together, as well as my staff Franklin Richards and everyone working behind the scenes to

(00:09:23)

make today's hearing possible. At this time I want to acknowledge that we are joined by our Council colleagues CM Morano, CM Brooks-Powers, CM Salaam and CM Sanchez, and CM Banks. We will now turn to Committee Counsel to administer the oath. Thank you, Chairs. Alex

(00:10:23)

ready. Can you hear me? Perfect. Good afternoon, Chair Maloney, Chair Thomas-Henry and members of the committees. Thank you for the opportunity to speak with the City Council today. My name is Maya Honda. World Cups are... even though basketball is not my purview, I would be remiss if we did not acknowledge the historic performance of the New York Liberty last night — incredible sweep of the Lynx — so just want to shout them out for that, and then move on to soccer.

So this summer, we welcomed more than 1 million people from around the world for the 2026 FIFA World Cup. The tournament not only brought historic opportunities for our City but intricate and complex challenges as well. Mayor Mamdani was clear from the outset: we had to make sure that every New Yorker could be a part of the celebration. We had to keep our City safe and our streets moving and we had to make sure that bars, restaurants and businesses from across all five boroughs benefited from the World Cup.

Thanks to the tireless preparation of our City agencies and the dedication of New Yorkers both inside and outside of the government, this tournament was a success on all three fronts. The World Cup added more than $3.5 billion to our regional economy — to our hotels, small businesses and commercial corridors. Not only is that real money in the pockets of business owners and workers, it is $200 million more than initially projected. Within New York City, the tournament generated approximately $2 billion in economic activity — more than half of the total regional impact and more than two thirds of all direct visitor spending.

The numbers are clear. Major international events can deliver for New York City's economy. They can deliver for our sports bars, where foot traffic increased by 16% year over year throughout the tournament. They can deliver for our hotels, who saw over a billion dollars in additional revenue thanks to the World Cup. And they can deliver for workers, with more than 12,000 jobs supported by visitor and operational spending from the tournament. This explosion in economic activity was not limited to any single sector — hospitality, food service, retail and tourism all benefited.

These results for New Yorkers were not guaranteed. They were the direct result of the Mamdani Administration's efforts to engage businesses of all kinds, drive foot traffic to every borough and host events for every New Yorker. To make sure that New Yorkers could be a part of this historic tournament, we hosted more than 100 free watch parties in our parks, plazas and public spaces. We secured a thousand affordable tickets to World Cup matches for New Yorkers and kept soccer fields in every borough open 24/7 to give people a place to play long after the sun had set.

To keep our City safe and moving, we brought together agencies across multiple levels of City government, expanded ferry service and launched a Midtown transportation plan with dedicated bus and shuttle corridors to drive traffic to commercial corridors across the City. We launched a $26 meal deal for our restaurants, a cultural passport program for cultural organizations and small businesses and business districts, and a small business tool kit that reached more than 56,000 New Yorkers — from breweries on Staten Island to museums in Queens to watch parties in the Bronx. We brought businesses and organizations across the City together to take part in the celebration.

But the Mayor's mandate was clear: we needed to build a legacy that lasted beyond the final whistle. That is why the City Economic Development Corporation leveraged the global attention surrounding the event to connect businesses with City leadership, highlight opportunities for investment and expansion and showcase New York City as a destination for growth and innovation. During the tournament, we hosted our annual Choose Summit, bringing together more than 350 attendees representing 150 businesses from 34 countries. We also organized site visits and tours across multiple neighborhoods and New York City Tourism welcomed guests, encouraged them to explore the breadth of the City and ultimately created return visitors. Our City launched projects to permanently transform public spaces, like a new bus lane near LaGuardia Airport, a dedicated bike and pedestrian connection near the Brooklyn Bridge and much more.

Taken together, these outcomes prove that major international sporting events like the World Cup can translate into real economic impacts for New Yorkers — that we can not only welcome visitors from around the world but direct their attention, investment and spending toward businesses and neighborhoods across the five boroughs. But these findings also make it clear that it is not simply enough for cities to open up their doors to these events. City governments must take an active role in supporting local businesses, attracting investment, driving foot traffic to commercial corridors and ensuring that major events are accessible to working people. These lessons of coordination must be front and center as New York City continues to compete for and host international events.

Ultimately, though, we know that when New Yorkers remember the World Cup, they will not remember good economic statistics or the hard data of dollar figures. They will remember crowding into bars to watch Argentina maneuver through breathtaking comebacks. They will remember riding World Cup branded trains and ferries across the five boroughs to collect commemorative cups and stamps. They will remember laying a blanket down on the Great Lawn of Central Park to watch the finals match, then instantly standing back up again to cheer on their team. That is what this tournament was ultimately about. As we look ahead to future international events and opportunities, we will continue to build on the lessons learned from the World Cup, using data and experience to strengthen our approach and maximize benefits to New Yorkers.

Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. I look forward to answering your questions. And good afternoon, Council Chair Maloney, Council Chair Thomas-Henry and members of the

(00:15:59)

Economic Development and Small Business Committees. I am Nancy Manana, Marketing Officer for New York City Tourism and Conventions. Thank you for the opportunity to share the results of our work surrounding the World Cup and specifically how the City's investment in tourism marketing helped translate this extraordinary global event into economic activity across all five boroughs.

New York City Tourism and Conventions is the City's official destination marketing organization and convention and visitors bureau, and our role is to promote New York City to travelers around the world, encourage visitation and help visitors discover more of the five boroughs. Our mission is to maximize inbound travel and tourism opportunities in support of equitable economic prosperity for local businesses throughout the City. New York City Tourism represents more than 1,060 member businesses and is governed by an 18-member board of directors representing the diversity of New York City's businesses. Tourism supports nearly 400,000 workers across the City, which is roughly 10% of the City's

(00:16:57)

workforce. Nearly 80% of those workers live outside of Manhattan — in Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx and Staten Island. For us, the World Cup was never just about filling the stadium. Our responsibility was to make sure the impact of visitation extended way beyond the stadium and into New York City businesses, neighborhoods and communities.

As a result of that, we approached the World Cup with two clear goals. First, we wanted to leverage the global appeal of the World Cup to drive visitation and spending to businesses across all five boroughs. Second, we wanted to create a joyous, welcoming city-wide experience that generated lasting exposure for the City. Our investment in tourism for the World Cup allowed us to do just that through outdoor and digital advertising, our social media content, partnerships with major media outlets like Univision and Telemundo and programs that connected visitors directly with businesses and experiences across all five boroughs.

As you have heard from Maya, the economic impact of the World Cup was substantial. We created pathways to local businesses and neighborhoods. We funded borough grants delivered in partnership with borough presidents. We worked to distribute 13,000 tool kits to small businesses throughout the City with the help of our BIDs and chambers, which gave local businesses ready-to-use World Cup marketing assets, messaging and guidance. We implemented an AI-enabled chat which connected visitors directly to World Cup information and recommendations in 50 languages. We designed and executed the Five Borough Winner Special — a program offering $26 food and drink specials and commemorative cups, one for each borough. 133,000 were distributed to almost 1,000 local food and beverage businesses: 569 in Manhattan, 182 in Brooklyn, 152 in Queens, 33 in the Bronx and 22 on Staten Island. In a recent survey, which is still ongoing, 8 in 10 local business participants said they were satisfied with the program and 9 in 10 said they would participate in a similar promotion again.

Our World Cup calendar featured more than 700 events, offers and borough-based experiences. This is 17 times the number included in our highest-performing event calendar of the past three years, which was for the City's 400th

(00:19:09)

And our marketing produced measurable results. We are able to share this data in part because we were also funded to include measurement of our digital initiatives using third-party tools. Specifically, we partnered with Tourism Economics to measure the $1 million portion, which was for a programmatic digital media buy of the "Where the World Comes to Play" campaign. This type of campaign uses technology to target very specific behavior. In this case we focused on those who showed intent to travel to New York City this summer and those who typically travel for big sporting events. This allows us to see how many people saw our ads and then arrived in the City. Our campaign influenced approximately 164,000 visitors who would not have otherwise visited without seeing that advertising. Of those, 44% went to Brooklyn, 40% to Queens, 49% to Manhattan, 13% to Staten Island and 24% to the Bronx.

We also know the campaign generated an estimated $147 million in direct visitor spend and $213 million in total economic impact. Ultimately, we saw that for every $1 spent on this digital advertising, those visitors spent $147 in New York City. We also saw broader evidence that visitor activity extended beyond Manhattan. Incremental visitor spending increased 19% in Brooklyn and 6% in Queens, according to Visa credit card spending data. Hotel demand increased in Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx. Staten Island and nearly 400 businesses outside of Manhattan participated in the Five Borough Winner Special, as mentioned earlier, which illustrates significant borough dispersion. These results demonstrate that our World Cup marketing investment helped broaden the event's economic footprint and brought measurable visitor activity into communities across the City.

Second, in the goal of creating a joyous, welcoming citywide experience, in working with the Mayor's Office we also deployed the unified "Where the World Comes to Play" campaign throughout the City. This manifested in billboards, airport signage, subway cards, bus signage, along with bus shelters and LinkNYC screens throughout the City, which generated more than... impressions. Our Telemundo partnership generated about 29 million television impressions. Our World Cup website content generated more than... page views, which is 13 times higher than our historically highest-performing campaigns, connecting consumers to businesses, neighborhoods, events and attractions throughout New York City online.

Conversation about New York City, which we track through a system called Meltwater — a social media and press tracking platform — became markedly more positive during the World Cup, and positive traveler sentiment reached its highest level of the year, which was about 11 percentage points above the pre-World Cup average. This increase suggests that the World Cup coincided with a significant lift in positive conversation about the City. The World Cup demonstrated what New York City can achieve when a global moment is matched by a coordinated citywide effort. Thanks to our partners at the Mayor's Office, Council, Borough Presidents, Maya Honda, the BIDs and all the chambers, and sustained investment in tourism marketing that turns global attention into visits and economic impact, we saw international visitor spending grow across multiple boroughs, hotel demand rise beyond Manhattan, engagement increase citywide, and hundreds of local businesses participating in a global campaign that reached millions with a clear message: New York City welcomes the world.

(00:22:42)

The additional $4.5 million investment allowed us to reach potential visitors at a scale we otherwise could not have achieved, particularly through outdoor and programmatic digital advertising. Our programs then gave those audiences concrete reasons to explore, engage and spend throughout New York City. The City's investment in tourism during the World Cup is an example of how tourism yields significant impact across the five boroughs. With sustained investment in destination marketing, New York City can continue to compete for high-spending visitors from around the world who explore every borough, turning that visitation into economic opportunity throughout the City.

(00:23:19)

Thank you again for the opportunity to testify, and I look forward to answering your

(00:23:29)

questions. All right, well, thank you so much for your testimony. I forgot to bring my World Cup cups, but I have the full set. And I have to commend you on the "Where the World Comes to Play" marketing slogan, which I think we all really appreciated. Thank you. Also for sharing a lot of the numbers. It is clear there was a substantial economic impact. I heard $2 billion, $1.2 billion in direct spending and roughly 12,000 jobs created, and I wanted to open it to the panel to just dig in a bit more to the methodology that was used there. If you could explain how we came to those numbers?

(00:24:18)

I can jump in. Justin Grammar with the NYC Economic Development Corporation. I will start by saying both studies were done by Tourism Economics. Tourism Economics is a globally renowned organization that does specifically tourism analysis. It is the same organization that, for example, London used when they were reviewing their 2012 Olympics, amongst other recent hosts. The World Cup host cities also used them as well, so it is a very reputable organization. The way that the numbers came to pass — and I will kind of break it out in pieces here — it starts off with identifying what the direct spending is. The direct spending is broken up into two different

(00:25:05)

parts. Part of it is direct spending from visitors to New York City, and the way that number is calculated is it specifically looks at two different groups. It takes kind of a bottom-up approach. The first group is how many people attended a match from outside of the region. That number is: there were 645,000 people who attended the eight matches. Of that number, 78% came from outside of the New York City region. So that is 508,000 people. On top of that, it looks at who attended the official World Cup fan zones and related events, and through that, on top of it, there was another 626,000 people from outside of the region who came to New York. So this report specifically looks at visitors to New York City, not New York City residents' spending, to be clear.

So that is how the visitor numbers were calculated. That information is then put into a model that the organization has, which looks at typical visitor spending and actual numbers of spending at MetLife Stadium, etc., and the amount of money each visitor would spend in New York City. The second part of the equation is operational spending, and that is money that the host committee spent to actually execute on the World Cup happening here in the region. That is money that came in from the federal government, from the state, money that came in from various municipalities, donors as part of fundraising efforts that the host committee made. That collective amount is the amount of operational spending. So you take both the visitor spending and the operational spending, and that is where you get, for New York City specifically, the $1.2 billion in direct spending.

Now the economic impact of those dollars and those visitors does not stop with direct spending. There are some knock-on effects as well — specifically indirect spending and also induced spending. To give an example of indirect spending: if I own a restaurant in Brooklyn and I need to buy more fish, let us say, to serve the additional customers who are coming in because of the World Cup, that is indirect spending as a result of the visitor spending coming into the City, if that makes sense. So that is indirect spending. The induced spending — sticking with the analogy of the restaurant — if a waiter works at the restaurant and they picked up an extra shift where they get additional tips or whatever it may be, that extra money gets recycled into the City's economy as well. So they are going to go back to their neighborhood and they are going to spend money at their local bodega, they are going to spend it maybe on rent, they are going to spend it on other things. So there is an analysis that is done that calculates roughly how much that is, both for indirect and for induced. The number again for New York City specifically is about $700 million added on top of the direct spending. So $1.3 billion plus $700 million is how we got to the $2 billion number. The same process works out for the regional numbers that you all have cited as well, which was the regional direct spending and overall economic impact. I can also address the question on jobs supported as well.

I believe that was part of it.

(00:29:06)

Yeah, sure. So I feel like I am a professor slowly breaking this down step by step. The way that jobs supported was calculated is by sector. They track each dollar that is spent and it can be attributed to supporting a job or multiple jobs within that sector. Based off that total spending, broken up by the sectors, they then multiply that dollar by the number of jobs that dollar supported, and that is how the 12,100 jobs figure was arrived at. To be clear, those are not all new jobs. Those are jobs that are supported. There would be some new jobs in there, seasonal jobs that came in, full-time jobs, but you cannot distinguish that through the analysis. So for the jobs — are those just temporary over the period, or how are you thinking about the long-term impact?

(00:30:05)

Yeah, for the analysis that was done by Tourism Economics, it does not disaggregate information to that level. So

(00:30:14)

all up... I guess what do you expect the City tax revenue generated by that $2 billion economic impact to be? And as a refresher, while we are talking about that, the City investment was roughly $90 million, I believe. So just trying to get at what the return was — if we got our money back, so to say.

(00:30:41)

Absolutely. So this was an event that stretched across multiple agencies, multiple levels of government and multiple fiscal years, so we are still evaluating both the total cost of the event as well as the projected tax revenue. What we do know from today's analysis is that the World Cup brought around $2 billion to New York City's economy, supported 12,000 jobs and reached across all five boroughs.

(00:31:05)

On that — I guess now that you have completed this analysis, how does it compare to what the projections were? Where were you on point?

(00:31:13)

Were the projections a bit off? I want to make one thing — I want to distinguish one thing. So the initial projections that you all remember, which was regionally $3.3 billion — that was for the region. That was also done by Tourism

(00:31:32)

Economics. So the same company.

(00:31:34)

Correct. They did both the post analysis for the City and the region. We intentionally chose the same organization so we have an apples-to-apples comparison. There was no pre-event New York City-specific analysis done, so we can only look at the regional analysis, which again netted out to be — the post-World Cup figure was $3.5 billion for the region. We saw a bump, an increase of $200 million, which is positive. We cannot break it down further than that because we have no baseline to compare it to for the City, but we do know that we did see a lift. And a lot of numbers show that there were people who came to the City — subway ridership up, ferry ridership up, Citi Bike ridership up, I think 20%... let me fact-check myself. Roughly 20% more international visitors using Citi Bike versus the previous year.

(00:32:33)

Thank you. On the visitors — of the total number of out-of-state visitors, if you could remind me. Yeah, the total number of visitors was roughly 1.1 million... 1.15 million. Let us see. And do

(00:32:49)

we have a sense of whether or not those visitors were actually attending the Cup or going to the free events, and how that shook out? Yes. So the breakdown was: those who attended the matches — 508,000 people from outside the region attended the matches — and then there was another 626,000 who attended events within the City that were official World Cup events.

(00:33:22)

So roughly 50/50. Yeah, for those of us looking for simple numbers. So summer is a big tourism period for New York City. Does the analysis have or speak to the opportunity costs from displacing regular tourists for the FIFA-related ones?

(00:33:53)

If you could speak to that. Yeah, thank you for the question, and I meant to bring it up earlier, so thank you for raising it. Tourism Economics does take into consideration displacement from those who have not come to New York City because of higher hotel costs or because they frankly did not want to be in the City when there is an influx of more people being here. That number was removed from the $2 billion number — it is already incorporated into it. Keep in mind that also does not take into consideration that a lot of people were exposed to New York City through the World Cup, and so that could

(00:34:24)

lead to new tourists coming, and also folks who just delayed their trip and will still come to the City, just

(00:34:32)

pushing it back by a few weeks.

(00:34:37)

Can I add briefly? So initially when we took office, the plan had been for the games to be in New Jersey and the Fan Fest to be in New Jersey as well. One of the things our administration did was work with the FIFA host committee to bring Fan Fest to the five boroughs. So the 600,000 people who came from outside of this region to New York City for the World Cup — they could have gone to New Jersey for the Fan Fest. In the end, we had free Fan Fest across all five boroughs, which we feel really strongly did drive spending across the five boroughs.

(00:35:12)

And that reminds me of a stat I meant to mention earlier, too. To Maya's point, the City did capture 70% of visitor spending in the region.

(00:35:22)

Relative to New Jersey.

(00:35:23)

To the whole region. So the whole region experienced visitor spending and we got 70% of

(00:35:30)

that. Clear.

(00:35:33)

And you mentioned higher prices. I am curious if you have a sense of how much of that $2 billion economic impact is from higher prices due to more demand — for example, I think that was true with hotel pricing — versus additional transactions. So the model did take into consideration... I will take a step back. The model is based off of something called an input-output model, and that model is an industry-agreed-upon model that is calibrated to the New York City market, based off the prices of goods and services and the different sectors. The report did take into consideration a bump in prices for lodging. Happy to follow up with some more information on that.

(00:36:36)

I want to acknowledge that we were joined by Council Member Riley, who was here earlier, and now I have passed it to my co-chair. Thank you, Chair. My first question is: do we know the economic impact of New York City tourism for the same period in 2025? Sorry, do you mean

(00:36:58)

total visitor spend? Yes.

(00:37:00)

Well, because we are comparing — we are saying the World Cup generated $2 billion in total economic impact and in direct visitor spending. Do you know those numbers for 2025? We can come back. We

(00:37:16)

would not have broken it out in that way, but we

(00:37:19)

can. Okay. Just to get a better understanding of where we really netted out from the World Cup. Second question: the World Cup and the 250th anniversary celebration overlapped. Have you assessed how much of that economic impact can be attributed directly to the World Cup versus what can be attributed to the visitors we got for the 250th

(00:37:44)

anniversary? Yes. So the way that Tourism Economics went about trying to disaggregate that information as best as possible was again using as the baseline of the analysis the number of people who attended a World Cup game from outside of the market and those who attended World Cup-affiliated events from outside the market. That is the base that was used. If you were here for the Knicks parade specifically, or anything else, that would not have been counted if you did not go to the game or did not go to an official Fan Fest.

(00:38:20)

Good point. I forgot about the Knicks. So I am just curious — how do you separate that? The way you separate it is by identifying who specifically came to New York City with the intent of watching a World Cup match, right? Who bought a ticket from out of the market. That is one portion of the equation. The other portion of the equation is who showed up to an authorized, official World Cup fan zone event. Based off that information is how we determine that that person came to New York City for the World Cup specifically. Okay, so what if I wanted to come and I celebrated the Knicks, came to the parade and said, "Oh man, there is a fan fest in my neighborhood, I want to go check that out." I was not coming for the World Cup, but I came to celebrate the Knicks. So are we counting what could have otherwise brought someone to the City as World Cup if they just happened to stumble upon World Cup activities?

(00:39:33)

I would have to look at the calendar, but from my recollection the parade was kind of at the beginning of the World Cup, and where that overlapped with the fan zone events

(00:39:43)

or just in general — I came

(00:39:44)

To New York I come? I want to come and see a play, but I am like, oh my gosh, the World Cup, and I want to check something else. So currently right now there is no way of us saying someone came specifically for the World Cup and this is what was generated, versus someone who came just because this is New York City and then decided to partake in any World Cup activities. So a lion's share of the analysis is based on people who came to New York City who purchased a ticket and bought a ticket to go and watch a match from outside of the region. Okay.

(00:40:21)

We talked about the food and beverage businesses — a thousand local food and beverage businesses. What was it?

(00:40:29)

133,000 drink specials and commemorative cups were distributed to a thousand local food and beverage businesses. How many food and beverage businesses are there in New York City? I do not know that I have the latest count, but it is typically around 20,000, something like that. Is that

(00:40:51)

correct? So roughly... I do not have a calculator in front of me. With 20,000 businesses and a thousand of those, what percentage is that? 1%. We did a

(00:41:04)

very cohesive, comprehensive outreach plan through BID Council chambers, the Latino Restaurant Association, the New York Hospitality Alliance, the Hospitality Association, our member base. We went to non-members. We went all throughout the City looking for participation as best we could. It was voluntary, but we tried to really put a full court press on outreach. Okay, found to calculate a

(00:41:28)

5%? Is that right? Yeah. Okay.

(00:41:33)

There were Fan Fests in all five boroughs and I am thankful that there was some activity outside of Manhattan, with one of the largest Fan Fests being in my district of Queens in a stadium that holds over 25,000 people. Do you think 6% economic activity during that time is a win? Let alone — I do not even think the Bronx and Staten Island had a trickle, a blip. So the 6% — referring to, do you mind? The report says broader evidence of visitor activity extended beyond Manhattan, and international visitor spending increased 19% in Brooklyn and 6% in Queens. The Bronx and Staten Island are not mentioned. But 6% in Queens, where we hosted a Fan Fest — I want to say almost three weeks — in a stadium that holds over 25,000 people.

(00:42:37)

Yeah, I appreciate that question. I will say we were really proud to work with the FIFA Host Committee to make sure that that Fan Fest was free and thus maximally accessible to both the surrounding community and visitors from out of town, to drive maximum folks into the borough and to be celebrating the World Cup accordingly.

(00:43:01)

Okay.

(00:43:01)

The numbers that we cited for visitor spend were pulled from Visa card data. So we will only include Visa card — that is the source we were able to pull. Okay. Are we looking at pulling data from any other sources to see what the true impact was? We can do that. There are costs to doing that, and we can

(00:43:20)

... American Express also offers that, but we were able to get it quickly from Visa. Okay, I will move on. You had mentioned some of the great infrastructure projects related to the World Cup that were done. And while I know many of my colleagues and many communities have appreciated it, do you think it was fair or appropriate to expedite City-related infrastructure projects without any community board or community input, or a heads-up that it was happening?

(00:44:00)

We were very, very excited to be able to create long-term improvements to City infrastructure across the five boroughs in support of visitor travel as well as resident travel, and that was extremely important to us — to see that long-term benefit. As far as the process, I would need to get back to you on the specifics, but our hope is that it continues to be a benefit to both folks in the surrounding communities, who can hopefully benefit from safer bus lanes or faster buses, safer bike lanes and faster buses as well, as well as future visitors.

(00:44:34)

Okay, and the genesis of that question is that one of those bike lanes was in the adjacent community but sits in the community board that I represent, which is Community Board 3, where there was a bus lane put in to expedite travel from LaGuardia Airport. While I see the sense of getting visitors around, it was a hardship to the community and there was no insight or input or even just a heads-up. So we understand that getting travelers around safely and more efficiently works, but also in that same corridor there was nothing done to improve access to the number 7 line, where visitors going to the Fan Fest in Queens could have stopped at, say, 103rd Street and visited the Mano Corona Plaza. Currently that station — you cannot even get off there if you are coming in from Manhattan. So just to look at infrastructure that would help the communities and not just the visitors coming to New York City. And a question...

(00:45:35)

Kind of a piggyback off that — it was easy to expedite infrastructure plans, but harder for businesses to get permits to help benefit them during the World Cup. Any insight into why we were able to move more effectively and efficiently on infrastructure for visitors but were not able to give our small businesses the same access to opportunities to help their businesses during this time?

(00:46:05)

I want to speak — I will speak a little bit to the permit question and would also love to turn it over to our colleagues to talk about the ways in which we engaged with small businesses to make sure they could benefit from the World Cup. I will just note that, you know, we worked hard throughout the entire tournament to keep New Yorkers and visitors alike safe, and we owe them all a debt of gratitude for their tireless efforts. We worked both with the host committee and also a host of agencies to determine which events were feasible amidst a suite of summer programming. So happy to find more information about specifics, but we were balancing the range of keeping people safe, allowing joyous events to occur and providing lots of resources for folks, especially small businesses, to host their own events. I will let her speak to that and then also I think...

(00:46:52)

Nancy can probably say more about the toolkit as well. Thank you so much, Council Member, for the question. I do want to take a moment to acknowledge all that our World Cup colleagues just mentioned on the complexity of the summer — a summer that we will never forget, thanks to their work and the efforts of City workers across this government. I also wanted to acknowledge and thank them for their work. Whenever decisions were being made around permitting processes, there was more clarity coming out as a result of all of the complex coordination work that was necessary to keep New Yorkers safe. The minute these things were happening, we were in close coordination, we would be notified, we would work together, briefing the business improvement districts across the City as well as other merchants associations that are involved with street activations. Obviously not everyone was able to do everything that we were experiencing, but I wanted to really acknowledge that there was a conscious effort made at every step of the way — that as decisions were made, there was no gap between the time that business improvement districts and merchants associations were within hearing of the decisions that were reached as a result of the capacities during the summer.

(00:48:00)

I do appreciate the outreach. I know you had come before this committee several times in preparing for the World Cup. It was literally a new administration and it was six months later that the World Cup arrived. So I understand there was a lot of planning and I do appreciate the outreach. So my next question is — it is not all right or wrong and do not take it any bad way — but do you think it was as successful as it could have been? I mean, as we heard, our businesses missed the opportunities that they would have liked. And not just all small businesses — we had organizations that hosted block parties annually, and because we were getting ready for this large event and visitors, they were no longer able to do what they had done in their hometown year after year after year. In addition to that, do you think it was successful? What can we do differently? In 2028, when the Olympics come, what are the lessons learned from the World Cup that we are going to take to 2028?

(00:49:00)

I deeply appreciate that question and it is the question we should all be asking ourselves. I look forward to working together on future major events. I think we believe that the World Cup was an enormous success. It was a boom for the City's economy, adding $2 billion to the local economy, supporting over 12,000 jobs and increasing foot traffic to our sports bars by 16%. It was also a celebration for everyone. We had more than a hundred free watch parties across the City, with our parks, plazas and public markets hosting tens of thousands of people. I really want to shout out activating public markets and really want to shout out New York City Tourism. We had a borough grant program for borough presidents to support local businesses in their area and host events, and we turned City streets into pop-up soccer fields throughout the entire night so that people could play 24/7, thus increasing access to recreational space for folks who do not ordinarily get that opportunity. We really tried to focus on the five boroughs — we drove foot traffic across all five boroughs and saw the stats that you mentioned.

I think when it comes to lessons learned, we have talked a lot about this and also welcome others' perspectives here. We came in, and as you mentioned, the World Cup started, and so I do think that there was a lot that was constrained by or guided by decisions of a previous administration, which is exactly what it is. With that in mind, we strove to work 24/7 to make sure that this was a joyful celebration for the City, and the City benefited. So I do not think it will surprise anyone to hear that in reflection, we wish we had been in office one year ago and been able to start earlier, and I think that is absolutely what we plan to do for future events — the Olympics, hopefully the Women's World Cup many years in the future — and just thinking through how we can make sure that major events with proper advanced planning can really benefit our small businesses as well as the residents of New York.

I would also add that a lesson learned that we spoke about on the coordination side was the benefit of having direct coordination to make sure that across agencies — both logistics, preparedness and infrastructure, but also for a coordinated campaign that stretched out across the City and enabled the City to celebrate — and that point of contact for the Host Committee for New Jersey, New York and the region, I think was of enormous benefit to the City and really led to things being able to move very quickly in the time that we had. Happy to also turn it over to anyone else for other reflections and would also love to hear their perspective.

(00:51:31)

I would love to pile on to that point. We put together our initial proposal for our incremental funding

(00:51:39)

about a year prior. Had we started then — and this is all hindsight, but it is good learning for the future — we would have started really focusing on driving international visitation at that time, because the planning windows are longer for international visitors. They spend more, they are valuable, and that is a very strategic consideration. We know when folks from Canada versus Japan typically tend to plan. By the time this really kicked in, which was really the end of the year, we had to shift, and that is okay. I think we got different

(00:52:08)

... Keep your eyes on this: we were not able to move the needle on occupancy — demand was fairly flat — but we did see increases in the boroughs, not in Manhattan, so that is great. However, I think the dispersion was what we really focused on with every opportunity, and we did see positive impact across every tactic. When we partnered with Telemundo, we did not focus on Broadway and Times Square — we focused on Mott Haven. We saw almost a 44% increase in intent to visit Brooklyn. We saw a 40% increase in intent to go to Queens, 24% in the Bronx and 13% in Staten Island. This is impactful because it primes the pump for us moving forward. So now as we get ready to do a campaign in the fall that goes into next year, we are going to leverage the digital media and the audiences that we built and the momentum we built. So it was a very positive experience. I think a lot of folks saw the organic content that came up on social media — people had a wonderful time here. So we are leveraging it. I think we feel it was successful from a dispersion perspective, but I think we would have shifted a little bit if we had more time, on really driving that visitor when we were experiencing a lot of headwinds with international travel going in.

(00:53:22)

So all in, I think that a coordinated campaign really helped the message when we are all saying the same thing at the same time. If you

(00:53:34)

want to add? Yeah, just a couple of quick things to add. I would say this administration made it clear from the very beginning that we want to bring the World Cup to New Yorkers. So a big lesson from what our colleagues said as well was, how do we use City assets to accomplish that goal? We organized 28 events and we used 25 of them at our public markets, because the public markets are great places that are community centers and are largely made up of businesses — almost 100% businesses based in New York City. So it is one way of leveraging City assets to bring the benefits of the World Cup to all five boroughs. Then the other one — and this was mentioned in the opening testimony — is that much like other large-scale events that happen in New York, it is not just tourists who come to New York City during events like this. It is also businesses, business owners and investors. There is a chance for us to really showcase New York as a place to invest in and to open a business in. So we

(00:54:36)

took the opportunity, stepping away from the fun of the games, to bring together sellers and pitch them on New York City, in hopes that part of the long tail of the World Cup would be that these businesses would open up offices in New York, employ New Yorkers, contribute tax revenue, et cetera. Before I turn it over to my colleague, for recommendations from the small business side: consult our small business partners, our BIDs, our chambers and the like. Start planning now — 2028 will be here before we know it. For tourism, I think the World Cup showed us that New York is a dynamic city in all five boroughs. I would argue that a lot of visitors, from Mott Haven to Corona, and all the activity in those corridors, are something for people to experience any time, not just when they are coming into town for the World Cup. When Ecuador beat Germany, Junction Boulevard in my district was one of the hottest places to be. So when you are promoting New York City to travelers, promote our neighborhoods. They are bustling, they are thriving and we need that economic activity to sustain our small businesses. With that, I will turn it over to CM Banks for questions.

(00:55:57)

Thank you. This is a chance for this important committee — $90 million invested by the City, $2 billion brought back to the New York City economy. Good job, guys. Let me first of all relate this to public housing, and I think this is important. When we have close to 511,000 — a little over 500,000 — residents living in public housing, 87,000 in Brooklyn, close to 86,000 in the Bronx, 30,000 in Queens and 9,000 in Staten Island, 86,000 in Manhattan... Recently there was a survey done by the Community Service Society which showed that the unemployment rate in public housing is anywhere between 20% to 22%, and we know that the unemployment rate amongst NYCHA residents is higher than the overall rate citywide. When it comes to public housing, I want to understand why NYCHA residents were not specifically included in the City's World Cup employment, procurement, vending or business outreach strategies, and was there any direct partnership with the New York City Housing Authority? Thank

(00:57:24)

you for the question, Council Member. I will start off by providing context on the spending itself. The previous administration provided $20 million for the World Cup and then the current administration provided an additional $15 million. Of that amount of money, the money was then allocated for the use of the Host Committee. The Host Committee's contract through the City was based off a 2018

(00:57:54)

... Okay, Riley, I need you to be specific. Were there any NYCHA residents who obtained employment or contract opportunities connected

(00:58:06)

... though there was a long wind-up. So I would say the answer to that — if you can bring the data, if you have to go find the data and bring it back, we appreciate it. If you do not have it now, listen, you do not have the information. But I was just going to say that after us, the head of the Host Committee will be here and he will be able to answer that question as well. Okay.

(00:58:28)

Well, I will just get this for the record.

(00:58:30)

As well.

(00:58:30)

You know, were there any NYCHA resident-owned businesses who participated, who were part of the City or the Host Committee initiatives? Any NYCHA residents who owned businesses?

(00:58:45)

I can look into that data and get it for you. I will note

(00:58:49)

that we worked with Tourism and Conventions to provide $75,000 grants to each borough president to facilitate watch parties and events across each borough, and that included a variety of partnerships. So that is probably where we will be

(00:59:01)

Digging in, what specifically shows any real connection or affiliation with NYCHA residences?

(00:59:08)

Yeah, we can get back to you on that.

(00:59:09)

Thank you. Did any World Cup related programming, youth initiative, workforce event or small business campaign take place directly within any of the NYCHA residential developments? You can get us that information.

(00:59:28)

Okay. Thank you. I have a couple of questions. So at that...

(00:59:31)

SBS. We were the outreach arm for the City's efforts to promote and ensure that small businesses were getting connected to all of the promotional opportunities that were being unlocked, primarily through the hosts.

(00:59:41)

So did you do any outreach to...

(00:59:44)

Okay. On average, we prioritized outreach in Black and Brown communities and immigrant communities. We were in Jackson Heights, in Port Richmond and Harlem, and we went to Jamaica, El Mercado. We went to so many different communities in the outer boroughs, in neighborhoods where we know, especially for the immigrant and language concentrations...

(01:00:06)

The threats from non-local law enforcement had created... But I am specific. Are you...

(01:00:10)

Talking about public housing? Yes. So including — I just want you to know — public housing in North Fork, Staten Island, in Queens, in Brooklyn. Okay. Visited, and collectively across all of those efforts we reached over 1,800 businesses that we canvassed, including street vendors.

(01:00:27)

Okay. Were NYCHA community centers or resident associations or youth programs offered funding or other resources to organize local watch parties, soccer clinics or related programming? I can get you exact numbers on that. I will note that we reached out to host watch parties at the City's remaining asylum seeker shelters and eight shelters for families with children.

(01:00:51)

Okay, excellent. And what was the total value of World Cup related contracts and subcontracts awarded to City businesses? Chair, if you will indulge me for a couple of minutes. Thank you. You go on ahead. For those contracts, the total amount that was allocated to...

(01:01:17)

The total value of the World Cup contracts and subcontracts awarded to New York City businesses. So we have to get back to you on that. Yes. All right.

(01:01:28)

And I guess I am also asking: how much was awarded to businesses located outside of Manhattan? How much was awarded to NYCHA residents' own businesses, which we brought up earlier? How long did small vendors and subcontractors have to wait for payment for World Cup related work? Are any invoices or payments still outstanding? Are any payment disputes filed? And have any businesses reported that they have not yet been fully compensated?

(01:02:11)

We can get you the exact details on that.

(01:02:14)

I will note that the $75,000 Borough President grants also supported the Queens Night Market and a watch party on Governors Island with a street vendor fair and other such events, and so we can get you information around that.

(01:02:28)

All right, we will be waiting for that information and numbers. For now, into my last question — CM Banks, we have... I will come back in a second. There you go. Thank you. Around to CM Morano.

(01:02:40)

Appreciate it. Thank you. I was not going to rush you, but I thought you were great. Thank you. Thank you all for your testimony and for your work. You know, I am the first person to be critical of the administration when warranted. So I do think it is important for me to say, and for all of us, that the administration deserves a great deal of credit here. New York City did not host a single World Cup match, yet according to the preliminary analysis released today, the City captured $2 billion in economic impact. That is pretty significant. So congratulations to all of you for that.

But while we have all of you here — all the people that made that happen — I would like to get beyond the big number and kind of follow up with what some of my colleagues were touching upon, and that is where the money actually went. So that headline is $2 billion in economic impact, and I appreciate the differentiation between indirect activity and other types of economic activity. If I am a restaurant owner on Highland Boulevard, I cannot necessarily deposit economic impact at the bank. Of that $2 billion...

(01:03:53)

How much can we say actually went to independently owned New York City small businesses? Not hotels generally, not induced economic activity, not national chains. Do we know how many dollars actually went through the cash registers of New York City small businesses? The $2 billion announcement that you are referring to does not break the information down to that level.

(01:04:26)

Anybody else? Council Member, so I defer to our colleagues at the Economic Development Corporation on the economic analysis they conducted. But it was too easy — when you mentioned Highland Boulevard, there is a burger joint that just opened up, and at their grand opening they were featuring a World Cup game. Part of the reason folks came to that grand opening was not just the delicious burgers they were serving, but because they had a FIFA World Cup game on. That is the type of engagement we saw throughout the City. It was really a summer where, whether it was at the businesses where you saw record levels of engagement in attendance, business owners anecdotally have shared their experiences with the summer — where it was the next championship run, then game after game — but it was also in the homes of many of our family members who were ordering from...

(01:05:17)

Businesses. And I have had similar anecdotal observations. But if none of the agencies can necessarily answer the question of how much went to New York City small businesses, should that not be one of the lessons of this World Cup for the next mega event, whether it is the Olympics or something else? Should we not decide beforehand that we are going to measure how much of that economic benefit actually reaches small businesses, and then come up with a metric or a series of metrics to determine how we are going to...

(01:05:51)

Get there? Yeah, a couple of points on your comments, and thank you for them. One is that the analysis that was released this morning — the $2 billion — is an initial analysis. There will be additional information that Tourism Economics will be sharing with us, including a breakdown by sector. Again, it does not go down to the level that you are looking for, but we will know lodging, retail, et cetera. So we will have that information and will be happy to share it with you all once it is available.

The second point is that as part of our contract with Tourism Economics, we are going to be conducting a survey of small businesses around the City as well. We will be partnering with the BIDs and other groups for a more thorough postmortem, as you just mentioned, to find out how many people saw a lift in revenue and whether they hired additional people. Those are the types of questions. So we would be pleased to work with you all to make sure that the survey gets out, because the information and data that comes back will be really helpful for us to help plan for 2028 and...

(01:07:00)

The Olympics, and hopefully 2031 for the Women's World Cup. We are also surveying the thousand or so businesses that participated in the Five Borough the Cup program. We only have 68 responses so far, but we are working on it. So please, similarly, we would love to work with you too. We want to make sure...

(01:07:15)

There was a return, and that is how we are going to find out. Chair Thomas-Henry was kind enough to mention Staten Island, and I appreciate your testimony that says nearly a thousand businesses participated in the Five Borough Winners Special. But the breakdown was 589 in Manhattan, 180 in Brooklyn, 152 in Queens, 33 in the Bronx and 28 in Staten Island. 28.

So my question is not why did you discriminate against Staten Island — I certainly do not think anybody did. My question is a little more basic: did anybody notice? While this program was happening, was anybody in City government looking at a dashboard that said we have got 589 businesses in Manhattan and 28 on Staten Island — maybe we ought to make some calls or do something to bring that 28 up to 30, 35, 40? And who specifically owned that responsibility? Is it you, Madam, or is it...

(01:08:14)

Tourism? Is it somebody else? Because I think there is a larger lesson here. I think if there is something we can measure after a government program ends, after government observation ends, it should be something we manage while the program is happening. I think that is also a lesson for the next event as well.

(01:08:38)

I completely agree. I do not know that we had a live dashboard, but I have three pages of businesses that we reached out to in terms of associations, BIDs and the process. Unfortunately, we tried to multiply it by going through the BIDs and chambers...

(01:08:53)

And the restaurant associations. I think with the time we had — again, not to punt that question — but I think if we had additional time we probably could have started earlier and begun to do a little bit more on the outreach and try to kind of keep that tally going, so we were properly balanced when we launched the program.

(01:09:16)

Thanks very much.

(01:09:17)

I would say — I do not speak for my other colleagues — but I know my office would say: just bring us the cups, we will drop them off. So you have resources and we want to help, because we want to see our small businesses succeed. At this time I will turn it over to CM Brooks-Powers.

Thank you, Chairs, and thank you for your testimony today. My first question centers around return on the City's investment. Has the City formally requested the $1 million legacy contribution from FIFA? If it is paid, will the City commit to investing it in soccer pitches or youth programs?

(01:10:05)

I can get you more information. I am not sure if we formally requested it from FIFA, but we have been in conversation about legacy, and I know that the host committee is building many pitches and has built at least — I can let them answer that question, but...

(01:10:20)

Many pitches are in the process of being built in the five boroughs. I would add that we are in ongoing conversations about what the legacy of the World Cup looks like, both from the infrastructure perspective and from the investment perspective, and will note that we absolutely want to make sure that a legacy investment creates accessible opportunities to play for New Yorkers.

(01:10:42)

Absolutely. Next, I want to pivot to lodging and visitor spending. Hotel revenue rose because room rates went up, not necessarily because more people stayed here. Does NYC Tourism track how many World Cup visitors stayed outside the City because they could not find or afford to stay in New York? And what did the data that you do have show?

(01:11:07)

Unfortunately, we only track what is happening in the five boroughs.

(01:11:13)

Okay. Reaching Queens businesses and neighborhoods — and this is for you — a large percent of Five Borough Winners Special businesses were in Manhattan. How many participants were in Queens and how many in Southeast Queens and the Rockaways specifically?

(01:11:34)

We have 152 in Queens total. I do have a complete list of participants, so I can come back to you with that and show where it all breaks down by neighborhood. Will you be able to do that while in the hearing? Okay. I have a number in my mind. I just want to see if it is in alignment. I am not sure if I brought this up, Reggie, but I definitely will follow up with you. Okay.

(01:12:05)

Ed Said Park in Queens will host nine Olympic soccer matches in 2028. Before committing City funds, will the City require local hiring, M/WBE and local procurement commitments, and a clear share of security costs borne by the organizers?

(01:12:34)

This administration, for this World Cup, was committed to making sure that the benefits reached all five boroughs of New York City, including women-owned and minority-owned businesses, et cetera. So while the planning for 2028 has not started, the lessons learned from this World Cup will be applied for that, and it is something that we will definitely look into and seek to achieve.

(01:12:56)

Have you guys made public the data from what we recently completed in terms of M/WBE participation and opportunity?

(01:13:08)

That information is best directed to the host committee, who will be testifying next, as they are the ones who served as the disbursement vehicle for the funding. They would have the best tabulations of where all the money went in terms of that type of breakdown. Understood?

(01:13:29)

And then lastly, what will you do differently so that Queens small businesses, especially those outside the immediate stadium area, have materials and outreach in their languages from day one?

(01:13:45)

Thank you, Council Member. We were really excited to engage, and we landed on the business toolkit, which included all the different promotional materials. We went on a multi-channel outreach campaign. We did email marketing, webinars and door-to-door canvassing across the five boroughs, and collectively reached over 280,000 New Yorkers to ensure that they were educated on the opportunities that were available in those two months. Even when we were doing outreach walks with Council Members, many of you may remember the one-pagers that we were bringing to our walks with elected officials. But that was just one vehicle of six or seven different mechanisms by which we were making sure New Yorkers were hearing and learning about the opportunities by which they could help promote their businesses.

It is exciting. We did not make assumptions on the types of businesses that would want to be on the tourism platform, and we had a relatively new bubble tea shop in the borough of Queens that decided a day before the World Cup games started that they would actually go really hard on the World Cup and do a bunch of watch parties. By knowing about the calendar, they were able to quickly sign up.

(01:14:55)

Thank you for that. Just going back to the World Cup briefly, the second part of the question was not answered in terms of — you know, you have to follow up on the $1 million — but in the event that it is going to be paid, is the City willing to commit to investing it in soccer pitches and new programs? It was not clear on that part.

(01:15:13)

I will have to get back to you. I think absolutely in terms of values we are aligned. I will note that one thing we are thinking about when it comes to building new pitches is that right now we have a lot of pitches that do not have lighting, for example. So expanding access looks like more than just building a new field. It looks like programming for existing fields, expanding lighting hours. There are many ways that that money can be invested well to increase access for young people and increase program opportunities. I cannot commit just because I am not certain of what the details would look like, but that is absolutely our priority and our...

(01:15:45)

Goals. I am just saying it should not be either/or. I am hearing from Rockaway schools wanting to see soccer brought there, and we have a new school being built that will open soon that has a soccer field, but that is where that school is. They just went in and they have more public spaces for that and other parts of Southeast Queens as well.

(01:16:10)

Thank you, Chairs. Thank you, Council Member.

(01:16:12)

CM Riley. Thank you, Chairs, for this hearing, and thank you so much to the panel. I just want to commend the sentiments of my colleagues, especially CM Banks. I think you guys did a tremendous job in a limited time. A $2 billion investment is amazing. I am a little bit disappointed, being from the Bronx, that 28 was the number that we were given. I think opportunities for other borough connections when we have large-scale events like this need to be a little bit more fleshed out. We have beautiful communities in the Bronx — City Island alone, because I took a lot of people there during this time.

So I just wanted to share that sentiment and see how we could connect in the future when we see the Olympics coming here, and how we can make that a little bit better. I want to talk about job creation. I know during large events like this, one of the benefits we always look for is job creation. Is there a breakdown on the local residents who were hired during the World Cup, and do you have a breakdown of the types of occupations that they were hired for?

(01:17:20)

Thank you for the question, Council Member. We do not have a breakdown of that information. The 2,000 jobs figure was based off of a model...

(01:17:27)

That Tourism Economics uses, but it does not go down to the level of detail...

(01:17:34)

Okay. Large-scale events could also be a burden on communities. I know we did a lot of planning and there were a lot of street closures. Trust me, block parties were a big thing in our districts and they could not have happened because of this event. So what are the steps that the City has taken to prevent residents and small businesses from bearing a disproportionate burden from events like this?

I would also love to hear a little bit about the outreach that we did around toolkits and kind of preparing for the World Cup. But we will note that we were working very closely with BIDs, and I think with more time we could work more closely and continue that conversation. So looking forward to 2028 planning, I really wanted to work closely with folks to get out the word about...

(01:18:23)

How to apply for a permit, when a permit is not required — all of those pieces. I think we did a variety of multimodal outreach, whether it was a small business toolkit, working with City Council Members, working with BIDs to get the word out. I will let you speak more. Thank you.

(01:18:40)

Fair question. I would also like to add that while there may be a benefit in not having the ability for every single neighborhood and every single commercial quarter to have a block party, that does potentially create the risk of, but also the benefit and opportunity for small businesses to absorb more of that traffic. The Commissioner was doing a social media video that reached over 50,000 New Yorkers, telling small business owners: look, we are in this World Cup season. This brings a tremendous opportunity to you, but you should also know all of the things you should do to protect your business from the surge of visitors, ensuring that you are complying and making sure fire safety is maintained, making sure you are doing everything that is possible and promoting our New York City Business Express Service Team, which provides one-on-one compliance consultations to these business owners, to ensure that they have everything that they need and they are prepared on day one to absorb the kind of customers that we saw throughout the City. It is exciting. Even if a neighborhood did not have a sample permit issued, there were neighborhoods where people went in droves after the games, during the games, and sometimes created conditions on the commercial quarter, but oftentimes were packing all of the small businesses. I can only think of areas like Junction Boulevard and all the neighborhoods where we saw tremendous economic activity.

(01:20:06)

Lastly, I believe the Chief Marketing Officer stated that you are only tracking what is happening here in the five boroughs when it comes to lodging. I would encourage you to also see what is happening because we do know a lot of people stayed across the Hudson in New Jersey during this World Cup, even though they wanted to stay in New York City. Did you also track outside the hotels, maybe short-term rentals with homeowners? Is that data also being tracked that was being utilized during the World Cup?

(01:20:40)

Yeah, unfortunately no, we do not track Airbnb at all.

(01:20:43)

Okay, all right. I think you should look into that possibly, because I do know we got a lot of... I represent a home ownership district and they wanted to benefit from the World Cup as well, and that could have put tremendous restraints on a lot of them from doing it because of the current model. So if we could just look into that as well. Thank you, Chair.

(01:21:10)

All right, thank you. I want to dig into a bit of the spending questions on where the City's $90 million went. On my end I have $35 million that went through EDC and was primarily passed through the Host Committee, $4.5 million to tourism and $50.2 million to the NYPD. Could you share the final spending figures on how they were broken out by agency, if there are any changes from what I just shared?

(01:21:48)

Sure, I can start with the $35 million portion that you referenced, Council Member. Yes, you are correct. $35 million was allocated for the Host Committee. They ultimately ended up spending about... of it. That remaining balance of $1.615 million was used by the City instead for the branding and dressing-the-city type of activities.

(01:22:13)

For the Host Committee itself, the scope of work that they were asked to execute upon was largely broken out into four areas. The first is the actual cost for operating the nonprofit that was set up as the Host Committee. Two is the fan zones themselves. Three is promotional activities to get people to come and be aware and to get people to visit the five boroughs while they are here. Four relates to safety, transportation, et cetera. So those are the four categories of spending.

(01:23:02)

And I can add, from specific agencies, between Parks, NICE and a few other agencies, I know that some...

(01:23:13)

...of the standard budget was just repurposed, for example, around programming.

(01:23:17)

We can get you those numbers. Additional funding did go to NICE, which stood up, for example, these daily operational calls throughout the summer to make sure that between the Knicks parade, the sale, the 4050 visit of the President, you name it, everything went smoothly, and we are very proud of the results there. A note on overtime: the World Cup was obviously a massive initiative and it stretched across multiple agencies, multiple levels of government and multiple fiscal years. It also overlapped with the next championship, the fiftieth parade, a historic wedding which, sadly, I was not invited to, and other regular summer programming. So the City is basically still assessing the overall cost of the World Cup itself, and it is somewhat difficult to disaggregate. For specific questions about NYPD overtime, I would encourage you to reach out directly to the agency on that.

(01:24:09)

That is something we will be following up on. I am very curious... I think it was $50 million towards NYPD overtime. What percentage of that is going to be due to overtime and what percent of that is attributable to the Cup? On the revenue numbers, the revenue number reported was $414 million for both City and State taxes. I am just curious — the Council finance team estimates City tax revenue at roughly $60 million...

(01:24:45)

...and in an estimate from the Comptroller's Office it was $55 million. So again...

(01:24:51)

...just trying to balance the two sides and make sure we have got the full sense of the return on investment here. If not today, when can we expect the final analysis? Thank you for the question, Council Member. I can provide a comment on the first number you mentioned, the roughly $414 million in State and local tax revenues. That was based off of the Tourism Economics analysis that was done for the region, so that includes not just New York City but New York State, New Jersey, et cetera, and it is not disaggregated. It is also largely an estimated number as well. The inputs that I mentioned before — multiplying the amount of spending by lodging, for example, for beds, hotel tax and sales tax — is how they arrived at that number, so it is not actual receipts and it is an estimation. Do we have a more granular sense of what percent of that is going to New York City taxes? After a harrowing budget negotiation last year, we have to be detailed on these types of things. That is what I am asking.

(01:25:58)

Yes, specifically as to the Tourism Economics estimate of tax revenue, that number has not been provided yet but we will be getting it. I do want to emphasize that it is an estimated...

(01:26:09)

...number. It is not an actual number based off of the receipts.

(01:26:14)

And do you have any comment on the Comptroller's analysis, which placed this at $55 million and would mean that there was a loss of about $30 million in spend relative to revenue generated?

(01:26:29)

So I will note that this event stretched across multiple agencies, multiple levels of government and multiple fiscal years. So we are still evaluating both the total cost of the event as well as the projected revenue. Estimating revenues is complex and there is a lag in data collection, and so we do not have enough information to estimate the World Cup's impact on sales tax collection at that level of detail at this moment. However, we are assessing the costs and can definitely continue to be in conversation about that as we complete the analysis.

(01:27:01)

And do we have a sense of when that would be — at the end of the fiscal year or...

(01:27:06)

I will get back to you on a timeline on that.

(01:27:07)

One question for you. You mentioned that there is a long-tail impact of discussions that kicked off during the Cup with businesses. Can you speak to a few of those examples and what you expect to come of them?

Yeah, thank you for the question, Council Member. I would say more broadly, thinking about the World Cup in many ways as an investment for the City for long-term returns, it can come in two different ways: more tourists down the road, more large-scale events like this down the road, and yes, to your question, more businesses. So we have a program called Choose NYC that works to accomplish three things. One is to brand New York City as open for business. Two is to gain a pipeline of businesses who are considering coming to New York City or expanding within New York City. Then once we have a qualified lead, we are going to work with that business to help connect them to resources and answer questions to get them to say yes to New York City and open an office here, hire New Yorkers, et cetera.

We typically host a Choose NYC Summit, which is our flagship event, at a different time of the year. We purposely held it during the World Cup because we knew there were going to be a lot of businesses in town. There were 350 at the summit, and roughly 150 of them were businesses who are considering expanding within New York City or to New York City, from 34 countries around the world. So we keep track of all those conversations as part of a broader effort around Choose NYC, and those conversations continue. To provide some context on the decision timeline for a business considering coming to New York, it can really vary. Some take two years or so, and it could be shorter than that, but this is really kind of a beachhead moment for us to get more businesses aware of the opportunity in New York City, that the resources are there, and hopefully down the road they will open an office here.

(01:29:10)

After the summer of the next... I feel like that is a good sales pitch and the Cup to get those businesses to move. Similarly, for tourism, how do we as a City plan to capitalize on the momentum from the Cup? We had a lot of international travelers, particularly in the context of broad concerns about international travel, particularly from Canada. So how are we going to keep moving the ball forward for tourism?

(01:29:39)

Thank you for the question. The first piece is the million dollars that we spent on the programmatic media that I mentioned earlier. The byproduct of that is a pool of data that we can then retarget for the next one to two years. We are going to continue targeting those folks and focusing our ads on them because they already showed interest in New York City. So whether they came or they just showed interest in the creative, that is a longer tail for that investment that we will leverage for the next one to two years.

I would also say the organic content that happened on social media from visitors — we did not plant it, we did not pay for it — but I am sure you all saw, not just in New York but for all the U.S. host cities, an incredibly positive wave of emotion toward the surprising experiences they had here and how friendly people were and how great the food was, et cetera. So we will have a new campaign launching that leverages that positivity and energy. We want to tap into a very unique moment that has happened here. Maybe we did not expect it going into the World Cup. We were really facing declines in international visitation across the board. So while we have been fairly flat, we did see great intent to visit from the media and the content we produced toward the boroughs. So we are taking that and we are going to keep moving forward with that because we saw results from the Telemundo content that we did and all of our social content. We really focused on the cultural communities associated with the teams playing here.

And that is where we saw our wins. There are certain geopolitical issues that we are not going to solve by marketing, but because of the encouraging dispersion we saw and the awareness of our local neighborhoods — I mentioned the St. George's story, Staten Island, Haven — this is what we focused on. So we know there is interest and we are going to just continue the effort. I think all of that got us to where we are, and the Knicks parade certainly started us off. The parade was June 18, so it really did not overlap completely. So I think we can really attribute the energy of the World Cup and the sentiment that took us away from the sort of political dialogue that was going on previously. We know that travelers enjoyed their stay and we are going to be continuing to leverage that in the next campaign.

(01:32:00)

And does tourism have the resources to implement that strategy that you just outlined? Not as much as we...

(01:32:08)

...would like. This was a much bigger effort than we typically undertake. I think it is very scalable, so we do not have the same level of budget just moving forward. We are very resourceful and we look to travel partners to help us compound the investment, like airlines and tour operators. So the more we have, the more impactful we know we can be, based on the results that we just saw in the campaign.

(01:32:34)

Council Member, I had one thing to add to my answer before that I neglected to mention. For the Choose NYC work that we do in general, we are very intentional about thinking about how do we take global economic interest in New York City and make sure that opportunity gets spread across the five boroughs. Some of the ways that we enacted that for Choose NYC during the World Cup is twofold. At the summit itself, we had materials for each of the five boroughs that were led by each of the five chambers. It also included some participation from some of the business improvement districts. We also had a panel discussion where the five presidents of the chambers were speaking to the audience about the various resources and virtues of why a business should open up in their neighborhood.

We took it a step further. The day after the conference, we organized for interested businesses a tour of different neighborhoods in New York City. We took businesses and what we call the generators — these are organizations that work with businesses making site decisions. We brought them to the Bronx in partnership with the Bronx Chamber of Commerce. We brought them to Long Island City in partnership with the Long Island City Partnership. We brought them to Downtown Brooklyn with the Downtown Brooklyn Partnership. So those were some real ways that we are also trying to take that economic activity and bring it across the five boroughs during the World Cup. Thank you.

(01:33:58)

A lot of the conversation and the analysis has focused on bringing visitors to New York and the economic impact of bringing people to the City. How did New Yorkers respond? Do we have a sense of that and...

(01:34:11)

...their participation in these events? Not a regional number — I can go first. So from an EDC perspective, we were very intentional in using our real estate assets to bring the joy of the World Cup to communities across the City. As I mentioned before, we organized 26 events, with 20 events across the City. As an example, we worked with our public markets. Our public markets are nearly 100% small businesses that are based in New York City. Of that group, roughly 77% are minority-owned businesses and around 46% are woman-owned businesses. So we directly contracted with them to provide programming during the events, but also to create some knock-on effects where more visitors would be going to the spaces and shopping there. In total across our portfolio, we saw close to 7,000 New Yorkers attend those events...

(01:35:21)

...in Brooklyn, in Manhattan and elsewhere as well.

(01:35:28)

I also want to add that a lot of the initiatives that we did were also designed to target New Yorkers, and I think certainly anecdotally, also in kind of social listening, you can tell that a lot of New Yorkers were exploring the City, some for the first time and some just newly so. That was super exciting. I think in particular, streaming matches on LinkNYC kiosks throughout the City was designed not for tourists who are here to visit, but for folks who are just around the City. So we actually had amazing scenes of New Yorkers gathering in front of these Link kiosks to watch games. We transformed over 50 blocks across the City into soccer streets for New York City Public Schools. That was a huge benefit to the school students. Then our 24/7 soccer fields, I think, was a really exciting success where we did this pilot and we were unsure whether people would want to play soccer at four in the morning, and it turns out that hundreds of people want to play soccer at four in the morning. So I think it was a really exciting pilot, and that is something that was majority taken advantage of by residents. So again, an example of an initiative where we sort of used the World Cup to expand access to the beautiful game, both watching and playing.

(01:36:47)

I will just add that we know that half of our following on our website and our social channels are locals, and programs that we do like Restaurant Week and Broadway Week show that we reach locals as well. Great, thank you.

(01:37:03)

And the ferry rafts and ferries too, as a fan favorite. One issue I did want to bring up, as it has impacted my district in Midtown East, is that on match days, truck deliveries were prohibited from 30th to 60th Streets for extended periods of time, while the lanes on Fifth and Sixth Avenue were reserved for buses, shuttles and official vehicles. Do you have a sense of what the economic impact was from those restrictions, and also how were the businesses consulted before these changes were made and how far in advance?

(01:37:42)

We can get back to you on economic impact as well as the community engagement process, though community outreach was done and we ran both campaigns for commuters, visitors and residents, as well as doing direct outreach to businesses.

(01:38:00)

And that was one pain point that I heard. The second — I think we will hear more about — but it was on permitting. We talked about this, but the permitting process was a major point of contention as it was a big challenge for some of the community groups or the BIDs and brands that were trying to do local activations. So learning from this experience, of course, more time. But what are some of the other takeaways for future large-scale events like this?

(01:38:35)

Thank you for your question. As you said, I think more time was kind of a key one here, and so I feel really grateful to all the agencies that stepped up to do that kind of communication outward. We were in pretty constant communication with BIDs and with small businesses that were hosting events. I think also, everything is a function in the end of resources around security and being able to spend, and so we feel really good about folks doing both informal and formal events throughout the City. Coordination could always be improved, but definitely a lot of learnings from the process.

(01:39:15)

Thank you. I want to acknowledge we were joined by CM Gutiérrez and CM Avilés, and will now turn to my co-chair for some more questions. Thank you.

(01:39:28)

Thank you, Chair. Well, before we start — were we able to get those economic numbers for 2025 for tourism? We will need to come back to you with that. Okay. Because we talked about — we were trying to figure out what we can attribute to the World Cup. We had the World Cup starting on the eleventh, the parade on the eighteenth, the fiftieth anniversary, and the three-day concert.

(01:40:00)

So there was a lot happening in New York City, so really looking forward to those numbers. I have a

(01:40:08)

question from CM Gutiérrez: is the City working on anything to maintain the excitement around soccer, particularly for youth leagues? Many were so involved in the festivities and watch parties. Plus, we have a new stadium in my district. It feels like maybe the World Cup can become soccer's moment for the City. How do you see that, or just our sports scene in

(01:40:36)

general? What are you doing? For sure, it is a great question, and I think we were overwhelmed, excited and thrilled by the — honestly sometimes unexpected — outpouring of excitement around soccer, though it should have been expected, honestly. So the answer is yes, we are continuing to have conversations and would love to also continue to have conversations with Council Members around what investment can look like and how we can channel that excitement.

(01:41:08)

Excellent. I have a question: the City restricted truck deliveries in Midtown on all eight match days, and some Midtown businesses reported being unaware of the restriction shortly before the tournament began. How and when did you notify affected businesses, and did you receive complaints about missed deliveries and how were those addressed?

(01:41:36)

The DOT, as they were managing all of the competing logistical needs of the City, determined to proceed with closures. In the planning of the decision on the closures, we were involved in determining who would be reaching out to which stakeholders. We spoke to our Business Improvement District partners, we spoke to chambers and merchant associations, and we also sought to ensure that street vendors were not impacted by these delivery restrictions.

(01:42:10)

What we did is — the truck deliveries are not coming to the vendors themselves, but they go to commissaries — and we intentionally made sure every single commissary in the impacted area, two weeks ahead of time, was aware of the restrictions that they were going to be faced with, so that vendors could plan for that impact in their street vending operations.

(01:42:33)

And it was mentioned that most of this is tourism businesses. There was manual outreach. For the future, do we plan on coordinating a program more tech-related to kind of help alleviate some of that?

(01:42:51)

What do you mean — for the cold beverage program? For the road? I think this was the first time that we reached out beyond our member base. Okay. Virtually any outlet that served a cold beverage was eligible for this program, so it could have been street carts, bodegas. So we really did rely on associations, BIDs

(01:43:10)

and chambers to help get the word out beyond our purview. I think the next time we do this, we would definitely set up a centralized dashboard so we could see in real time — to the earlier point — and then we would ideally start earlier so that we can make up shortfalls as we see them with enough time.

(01:43:27)

Is there a way for us to coordinate with tourism to the businesses that are... We did that. We do? Yes. Okay. Yes.

(01:43:35)

OK, I think we just ran out of time. Could I

(01:43:40)

could I just add...

(01:43:41)

Without the dashboard, we made sure we were in neighborhoods with high concentrations of immigrant-owned businesses. We were really trying to think of two goals. One: all the cultural capitals of immigrant communities in New York City — making sure those folks who we knew naturally were planning watch parties to celebrate their countries and communities were engaged and knew how to get on to tourism, to get on to the Host Committee's Welcome Rewards program and all of those other services. The other goal here was: we know there was a very real perceived slowdown in many immigrant communities following non-local law enforcement activities across the City, and so we also targeted and made sure that the same immigrant communities that faced some slowdown because of federal threats were the same communities that were benefiting from the activities of the World Cup. That is where, without any dashboard, we were deploying all of our outreach resources. Thank you.

(01:44:40)

Appreciate it. Now, we have heard a lot about the issues with permitting. At the end of the day, were we able to get a sense of how many applications for events during the tournament window were ultimately denied, and of those denials, which were specifically attributed to World Cup events versus — as my colleagues mentioned — block parties or other annual events that communities put together?

(01:45:08)

Thank you for the question. It was an unprecedented summer, so we will have to come back to you with the data on the specifics around this summer. I will note that annual events were prioritized, and so, speaking in the general sense, typical block parties and any kind of summer celebration that usually occurs — we made every effort to make sure that it could go forward and was not affected by the World Cup.

(01:45:36)

Okay. Local Laws 107 and 110 of 2026 became law without the Mayor's signature on June 13, two days after the tournament. Which agencies were designated to implement Local Laws 107 and 110?

(01:45:57)

Were these the Cultural Passport and the map-related ones? They were around the Cultural Passport, the map and public bathroom expansion.

(01:46:07)

Okay. I cannot speak to the specifics of the agencies — I am not sure if anyone else here can — but we can get back to you on that.

(01:46:14)

I will note that we were thrilled to be able to put forward a Cultural Passport in the opening days of the World Cup, and that was an amazing collaboration that enabled folks — residents and visitors — to go to the public library and get a Cultural Passport and then use it to collect stamps made by New York City-based artists throughout the City. I know that public restroom expansion

(01:46:35)

is in the works, in partnership in some cases with the City Council,

(01:46:39)

and is also doing some work there. We were very, very excited to work with tourism and the FIFA Host Committee on the digital map and calendar, and we were also able to do coordinated marketing efforts. I really want to speak to that coordination — there was a scenario, a terrible scenario, in which everyone and their mother had a new map and a different calendar, and then no one knew where to go, and half of them had these events and half of them had those. We were very, very excited to be able to say this is the definitive source. We were able to do tons of outreach, able to direct everyone to the tourism website, and worked with the Host Committee to make sure that everything was coordinated and on that map. It was able to show, for example, cultural enclaves and cultural institutions — more than just events and watch parties, but also what makes the City great.

(01:47:30)

And many events were ultimately published — 1,700. Okay. And was the digital map of participating small businesses required by Local Law 107 ultimately published as well? The map and event

(01:47:49)

calendar had lists of small businesses. Anyone that was doing a World Cup-related event — or even, I think, an event in that time period — was able to, whether or not they were a member of tourism, whether or not they were affiliated with anyone, enter their data into the system. It was really a combination of a navigational tool and a map. It was created by a company called Neurons in collaboration with Google, so it was powered by Google Maps, but it allowed the systems to speak to each other. So if you submitted an event or offer onto our calendar, it would surface in this tool and you could also search with real-time transportation inputs — how long is it going to take you to a fan zone, how long will it take you to get to the match, is a subway down, is there traffic. So it was a combination, and it was powered by AI so that we could make sure it was translatable in 50 languages. It was sort of a hybrid — not strictly a map, but it did have mapping capabilities, and it allowed all the back end so that as we got sign-ups for the programs, as somebody submitted an event, it would all populate on the back end. So it was a useful tool that was piloted during the marathon and was then recreated and expanded for the

(01:49:06)

World Cup. Okay. Going back into preparation for our next major event — we have, as has been stated, the Olympics coming in 2028, and arguably in my district again we have Citi Field, which has Mets games during that same time, the US Open around that time, and a host of other things. Is the City looking at a ferry to Willets Point? Considering right now the only consistent transportation in that area is the number 7 train, which on a good day is overcrowded, I will say

(01:49:52)

that we were very proud during the World Cup that the ferry was utilized as much as it was — an important part of the City's overall transportation system. For the month of the World Cup, we were 20% above usage compared to the year before. The system was largely at full capacity during the World Cup in terms of the number of ferries that we had available. Future planning discussions — happy to have a full discussion on that — but specifically for the World Cup this year, we were available where we had... I will

(01:50:24)

call on you at this time. I will turn a little bit to CM Avilés. Thank

(01:50:30)

you, Chairs. Hello, everyone. I apologize if you have answered this question 17 times, but definitely curious to know a little bit more. During this time certainly

(01:50:47)

with the incredible amount of activity that was happening, we certainly experienced quite a lot of challenges — our BIDs kind of running into brick walls or having to do so many layers of communication when businesses actually do not have the capacity to chase so many different mapping and

(01:51:17)

event listings. Were you able to identify the revenue impacts, particularly in outer borough communities?

(01:51:33)

The information that was published earlier today — the $2 billion economic impact — only looks at the FIFA matches more specifically. There will be a report through Tourism Economics, which is the organization that did the analysis, that will do a further breakdown. That information is not available at this time, but we will have

(01:51:50)

it and will share that in time. So is it in the report? Is it broken down by ZIP code or is it just

(01:51:59)

by borough? Okay. I would love the boroughs — nice — but the ZIP codes are supremely better and clearer.

(01:52:05)

And one thing that we are doing as part of that report is a survey of both small businesses and community-based organizations that will launch within the next week or so. One of the qualifier questions at the beginning is asking the business what ZIP code they are in, and so we would love to partner with you and other Council Members to get that survey out there so that we can get as many responses as possible, because that information will of course help us understand the impact of this World Cup but also inform 2028 and 2031 if we get the Women's World Cup, et cetera.

(01:52:42)

Great. I would be keen to see it. Certainly, I know there were activations even in Sunset Park, but it was very last minute. The communication was very last minute. Everyone kind of just said, do whatever you want to do, good luck, and the small businesses — I think they definitely saw revenue increases and were kind of on their own. However, one piece of feedback I did hear from a number of them was also that licensing fees were exorbitant, and so they were just like, I do not know why we would participate. In one instance, a nonprofit got a grant to do something for FIFA with the City and then they were denied the permit in the park to do the thing the City wanted them to do. We tried to troubleshoot and ultimately gave up and just moved them into a school. So the permitting thing obviously is a pain point and a real challenge given all the events that were happening at the same time, but I think it is particularly problematic when the City is actually working with an organization to do an activation and then denies the organization a permit for the thing they want them to do. So I would love to see the revenue impacts and also — sorry, I am just reading my notes and I cannot quite read all of them. I think in the future, obviously the administration was also new coming into this and there was a lot of shifting. Would love to figure out how to really better coordinate.

Our communities felt like they were trying to catch up and never quite got the real attention that they needed, and potentially the economic output suffered as a result of that. So hopefully we will do better and learn from those lessons and get put on the front end. Thank you.

(01:54:44)

On the topic of transportation, which came up, I wanted to ask about the shuttle tickets that were sold during the tournament, and if the shuttle system met — I think it was 120,000 shuttle tickets. I will look into that and get back to you. I do not know those projections. And any lessons learned from coordinating transportation between New York City, New Jersey Transit, the Port Authority and the full cast of characters — private shuttle operators — any lessons learned that you would share for a future

(01:55:23)

event? Yes, that is a great question. I really want to commend the Host Committee, New York/New Jersey. I think we have all seen the headlines of events at MetLife and what they can and have looked like in the past in terms of our ability to get people from here to there. By and large we did not see that — we saw people really successfully, even amidst a Knicks Game 5, get where they were going in time for kickoff and then get home. So I really want to shout that out because that was not a given. I also want to give a lot of kudos to folks who, stretching back two to three years, did that level of coordination and professionalism over the course of several years, which really led to a good outcome there. So I think the lesson learned from that, frankly, is start early and continue that throughout. We had some continuity there with the folks who were doing that work. Aside from that, in terms of lessons learned, I do think it was really, really important that we had that coordination from City Hall, because we were able to pivot, make quick decisions and adapt to changing situations on the ground when special circumstances arose.

(01:56:42)

One of the consistent themes is planning in advance. The City broadly knew we had this for years in advance. While administrations change, this is something we can predict will happen in the future. What safeguards can we put in place to ensure that even if administrations change, the City is still continuing to plan and work towards these events? If you have any thoughts on how we could put systems in place

(01:57:13)

— it is a great question. I will also defer to our friends at agencies who I think probably have an interesting perspective there. I think we really benefited from really dedicated public servants who helped with the transition and supported between administrations, kind of kept us up to date on the work that had been done and did a really smooth handoff. So I want to express my gratitude there. I think that level of professionalism from these public servants made a huge difference. The Host Committee also had a body that was really helpful in terms of continuity and being able to continue that coordination across administrations, so I want to give them that shout out. I will defer to other folks on other lessons.

(01:57:58)

If we had known we had the funding to plan and begin focusing on travelers who were coming to a specific event earlier, we would have started earlier on the World Cup as an example. We would have started probably a year in advance. We knew there was a very defined fan base who are eagerly looking for information, so we would have planned it alongside that. As more information became available, we would have gone out with more campaigns earlier as more information on the tournament became available. So for us, I think we again have a snapshot of what we know we can accomplish with the money we did have when we had it, but I think we could have had better returns on visitation and perhaps spend as well if we had gotten this money earlier and we knew we could put the thought behind it when travelers are actively planning. And to that point...

(01:58:56)

Do we have funding put aside for 2028, and can you speak to shifts in tourism investment over the past few years and if we have been increasing it?

(01:59:07)

Our budgets have been fairly flat since 2006. Our baseline was recently restored a bit, but it does not allow us for these kinds of campaigns. It allows us to kind of keep the lights on and do what we do internationally. But as of now we are not resourced for another big event, including the 2028 event.

(01:59:28)

We know of. Yes, any other questions? I want to open it up. Councilmember, go ahead.

(01:59:36)

Yeah, thank you. Could you tell me what the budget of New York City Tourism is at this point?

(01:59:42)

Currently it is $23 million. And how many staff are part of them? About a hundred. We do virtually everything internally, from the development of our content to the maintenance of our website. It just is a better system. It is more efficient and more cost effective. So a lot of our sales team out in the field, bringing in the meetings and events and working with travel trade, were deployed. So it is very people-heavy, but that is typically what is required. So what gets sacrificed is usually the money that we spend on media. So we rely on partners to help us do that when we go out into international markets, again like airlines and tour operators. So we are very scrappy. We do punch above our weight, but we need awareness and that typically takes more funding.

(02:00:27)

Very scalable. We feel we are successful here and that success only increases with more investment. Got it. Thank you.

(02:00:34)

I want to thank you all for your testimony today and also your hard work on pulling off New York's great summer, including the World Cup. So thank you very much. Thank you. And next we are going to hear from the Host Committee. We are excited to hear from Alex Lazarus. Somehow, okay.

(02:01:45)

Whoa. Okay. Good. Thank you. Sorry. First time. I do not know how this works.

(02:01:50)

Good afternoon, Chairs Maloney and Thomas-Henry, members of the Committee on Economic Development and Small Business, and members of the Council. Thank you for this opportunity to be here today. I am Alex Lazarus and I serve as the CEO of the FIFA World Cup 2026 New York, New Jersey Host Committee, the local organizing committee responsible for coordinating with FIFA, government agencies, transportation, public safety partners, the private sector and community organizations to plan and deliver our region's responsibility as a host of the 2026 FIFA World Cup. It has been an incredible privilege to lead this organization and a team that spent years preparing New York and New Jersey to welcome the world.

By every major measure we established going into the tournament, the World Cup was a tremendous success for New York and New Jersey. We safely welcomed hundreds of thousands of match attendees and millions of visitors and fans across the region. We moved unprecedented crowds through one of the most complex transportation networks in the world and we created free opportunities for New Yorkers to experience the tournament across all five boroughs, and generated an estimated $3.5 billion in regional economic impact, exceeding our original projections. Those outcomes reflected the four key pillars that guided our work from the beginning: safety and security, transportation, fan experience and economic impact.

Our goal was to deliver across all four while demonstrating once again why New York is the best city in the world to host the biggest global sporting events in the world. New York is no stranger to mega events. This is a city that routinely welcomes the world for major sporting events, concerts, cultural celebrations and global gatherings while continuing to serve more than 8 million New Yorkers every day. But events of the scale of the World Cup do not succeed simply because they come to New York. They require years of planning, coordination and investment. And that is why our four pillars were fundamentally connected. A safe, reliable and welcoming tournament experience was essential to bringing visitors here.

Moving them throughout the region and ultimately realizing the extraordinary economic opportunity that came with hosting the world's largest sporting event. New York and New Jersey approached that responsibility as one region. We bid together, planned together and ultimately delivered eight matches, including the final, as a single destination. That required years of coordination among federal, state and local governments, law enforcement agencies, transportation authorities, venue operators, FIFA and the private sector. The results demonstrated the strength of that collaboration.

More than 645,000 fans attended our eight matches. Approximately 98% of the spectators entered the stadium before kickoff across the tournament and, following the matches, we cleared the stadium property in under two and a half hours, beating our pre-tournament goal of three hours. At the same time, our transportation network continued to serve the millions of residents who rely on it every day.

But while the matches were an important part of our work, what makes the World Cup special is everything that happens beyond the stadium. We hosted eight matches, but the World Cup lasted 39 days. We wanted the experience throughout those 39 days to rival what was happening on the pitch and we wanted visitors from around the world and New Yorkers alike to have the opportunity to be a part of it. We wanted the world to know that if you want to have the biggest stars on the biggest stage, you want the world's capital for sports, entertainment and tourism. That meant thinking differently about how the World Cup could show up across the city. Our original planning contemplated a single centralized fan fest at Liberty State Park, but as our plans evolved we saw an opportunity to create something broader: a distributed network of fan experiences across New York and New Jersey. In the city, that meant free public fan experiences across all five boroughs, bringing the tournament directly into communities and allowing New Yorkers to participate regardless of whether they held a match ticket.

We also wanted to harness the creative energy that is unique to New York and give communities the ability to create their own World Cup experiences. We pursued a bottom-up strategy, helping facilitate more than 180 public viewing licenses across all five boroughs so restaurants, bars and community venues could host watch parties and become part of the tournament.

We worked with organizations including the YMCA of Greater New York City, South Bronx United, Street Soccer, Gotham FC and the U.S. Soccer Foundation. Across the region, more than 5,000 young people participated directly in clinics, pitch days, tournaments and other community programming. We also expanded access to matches for community members, including New York City public school soccer players and hospitality workers who helped welcome visitors throughout the tournament.

That same philosophy informed our approach to small businesses. The Host Committee contracted with over a hundred New York City vendors and spent more than $10 million with New York City-based businesses, including 36 M/WBEs. Rather than create programs in isolation, we worked to amplify existing City initiatives. We integrated New York City Tourism and Conventions' Five Borough Winner Special into our World Cup concierge and welcome rewards program.

The concierge, developed with Google Gemini and Google Maps, encouraged visitors to explore neighborhood destinations, community events and ethnic enclaves throughout the city. Welcome World Rewards created another direct connection to local businesses, with more than 1,000 participating businesses and destinations across the region, leading to over 10,000 small business visits from locals and visitors alike. We also wanted part of this investment to remain long after the tournament ended. Working with the U.S. Soccer Foundation and other partners, we invested in permanent mini pitches and soccer infrastructure, including projects in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island.

Taken together, these efforts contributed to an extraordinary result. The World Cup generated an estimated $3.5 billion in total economic impact across the region, $2 billion of which was for New York City, exceeding our original projections. That included direct spending, more than 27,000 jobs supported and labor income, and more than $414 million in state and local tax revenue.

Every investment required to deliver our joint bid contributed to that success, from the operations necessary to stage the matches and move hundreds of thousands of people, to free fan experiences, local business programs and community investments throughout New York City. The World Cup was a huge success for the region, but its significance extends beyond what we accomplished over those 39 days. It demonstrated that New York and New Jersey can successfully deliver an event of extraordinary global scale while creating meaningful opportunities for the people, businesses and communities that call this region home. New York has always been where the world...

(02:08:18)

...comes for its biggest moments. The World Cup reaffirmed that we remain the best city in the world for major sports and entertainment events and provided a model for how we can approach the many global events that will come here next. We are incredibly proud of what we accomplished together and of the opportunities the World Cup created for New Yorkers across all five boroughs.

(02:08:36)

Thank you, and happy to take any questions. Thank you for being here and congratulations on your first hearing with the City Council. So go easy on me.

(02:08:48)

One of the things that we were asking a lot of questions about before is a breakdown of the expenditures for the $20 million under contract with EDC, and if you have any detail on how that money was...

(02:09:02)

...allocated. So the vast majority of the money spent was on the free fan festivals. So when we pivoted from Liberty State Park to bringing fan fests into New York, we really saw this as an opportunity to do what we thought was right, which was make New York City kind of the center of these experiences outside of the stadium. Working with the Mayor's Office and creating free fan experiences all throughout New York City, as I said, what we were really hoping to do was create an experience outside of the stadium that would rival what was happening inside. We knew that the stadiums are all going to fit 80,000 people. Whether it is a World Cup, a Taylor Swift concert or a Super Bowl, it is going to be the same amount of people no matter what. What makes the World Cup so unique are the millions of people that come not really ever expecting to get inside the tournament.

What we wanted to do was make sure that we were providing accessible and affordable spaces for people to participate in what is the world's largest sporting event. What makes New York so unique are the spaces that it has. So working with the City to make sure that we were able to kind of show off the crown jewels of the city in every neighborhood, I think we really wanted to make sure that we were not just focused on Manhattan but making sure that we were directing people to Staten Island, the Bronx, Brooklyn and Queens. When you look at the biggest fan fest that we put on at the U.S. Tennis Center, bringing people to one of the biggest and well-known global international destinations for sports, bringing people to the Bronx at Bronx Terminal Market, going to Brooklyn for the Adidas fan fest at Brooklyn Bridge Park, and then also at Staten Island at the ballpark doing a four-day fan festival there. So really trying to broaden the experience, and that was what the vast majority of the funds were used for.

(02:11:12)

And from those initiatives, do you know how that translated into real economic impact, and if you have those estimates or anything you could share?

(02:11:20)

So as a regional bid committee, we did a regional economic impact and did not break anything down by city or state. We were very intentional about the fact that for us, being the New York, New Jersey Host Committee, we really viewed this as: a strong New Jersey was going to lead to a strong New York and a strong New York was going to lead to a stronger New Jersey. So for us, our economic impact report really was a regional impact report. I would probably rely on the City and Tourism and whoever else to put together a city-specific economic impact.

(02:11:58)

So there will not be any follow-up analysis or more details?

(02:12:00)

We will not do a city-specific one. What you can see is the amount of people that we saw at the New York City fan festivals. For us, what we saw — and I can get you the amount of people that we had at the fan fests — I do know that Rockefeller Center specifically had over a million people that went to the fan village at the Roxy District. It was kind of again one of the crown jewels. I know we had 50,000 plus people at Central Park. I think over 200,000 people at the U.S. Tennis Center for Queens. Brooklyn, I think also over 200,000 people. The Bronx and Staten Island, I believe, were in the 20,000 plus people range. So New York City again, for the fan festivals outside of the stadium, had a real big impact. I think always with this, we tried to blend into what was going on with the city, and that is what makes New York unique. It is also hard for us to measure the impact of the over 180 viewing licenses that we helped secure. I think that was the most of any host city, just again trying to make sure that the entire region, for whoever wanted to put on a watch party, was able...

(02:13:53)

...to. And did the Chair have a question? I think I heard... Did we share them with who?

(02:14:03)

The question is: did FIFA or the Host Committee provide any resources or financial support for security at events, for the judges that the City had, or for attendees that were traveling to and from the events?

(02:14:20)

If you can speak a bit to the partnership there in financing the additional operational costs that came to...

(02:14:26)

...both venues, but mainly I am...

(02:14:27)

...interested in New York City. So we actually worked with the federal government on securing federal reimbursements for security for the World Cup. Through overtime funding, we were able to receive upwards of $60 plus million in federal reimbursements that we split across New York and New Jersey. We are in the process of taking in all of the submissions right now and then making sure that those reimbursements get set up. So there was a $625 million aid package that was passed by Congress and signed by the President for the World Cup, split across all the host cities. We took what were our best projections at the time and submitted for those potential reimbursements, and we believe that we are now taking in all the submissions. So there will be federal support and reimbursements for some of the security overtime, and that should help cover the World Cup...

(02:15:31)

...costs. And that is roughly $30 million or so?

(02:15:35)

We are still taking in all of the submissions so I can get back to you on how the split worked.

(02:15:41)

Who had access to the contract between the Host...

(02:15:45)

...Committee and FIFA and the City?

(02:15:50)

That was before I started, but I believe the contract was done through the previous administration in both New Jersey and New York City and was negotiated between those two administrations and FIFA. There was not, I believe, a Host Committee set up before the bid was awarded.

(02:16:14)

Have you seen the contract? The details of the...

(02:16:18)

...contract? I mean, I have seen the...

(02:16:19)

...contract. Is that something you can share with the City Council and the taxpayers?

(02:16:26)

I would probably leave that up to the City as it is their contract. Was there anything unique in that contract to New York? I do not think anything that was not also required in New Jersey as well.

(02:16:40)

Or relative to other cities that were hosting FIFA? Not to my knowledge.

(02:16:51)

Any other questions? All right, passing on to my co-chair.

(02:16:56)

Thank you. So, first question: as part of this, as Chair of the Host Committee, one of the responsibilities was securing local and corporate funding for events. Where does that stand for securing local and corporate funding for the events throughout the city? How...

(02:17:15)

...was that revenue shared between FIFA and the City of New York? Any funds, any funding that we raised went to the Host Committee.

(02:17:24)

FIFA did their own fundraising. So anything went to the Host Committee and then...

(02:17:29)

...any corporate sponsorships...

(02:17:31)

...that we personally raised went to us. And then where did that money go?

(02:17:36)

So that went into operations as well for the World Cup. We had an over... we had a budget that we had to raise, so we will go to corporate partners to try to raise funds to help fill the budget gaps.

(02:17:56)

What was the total budget?

(02:17:58)

We were upwards of $200 million. And of that $200 million, $10 million was spent with local businesses. No, more than that was spent with local businesses. But again we had to go across New York and New Jersey. Okay, well, do you

(02:18:15)

have an idea of what that small business or local business spend was? I can get that for

(02:18:22)

you. Okay. And do you know

(02:18:25)

if that number was roughly 30% of that?

(02:18:33)

I mean, it is a little bit more. I do not think it is as simple as looking at how that broke out, because for a lot of these mega events and the big watch parties that we were putting on, we did not produce a lot of them. So we would hire a production company. For Central Park, Global Citizen would put that on. So it is a little bit more difficult for us to break out exactly the percentages of who put on some of those watch parties and had the resources to be able to do that in such a tight timeframe. With that being said, I do not have the percent breakdown of what was spent with local businesses.

(02:19:21)

Did we require any type of local spending or in-city spending within those contracts? We made sure any money that was given to us by New York was spent in New York City. Okay. And how did you go

(02:19:33)

about procuring — what types of goods or services were procured by the local businesses in the City? I mean, those would have been for any of the watch parties that we put on, so making sure that production equipment and vendors at any of the watch parties were local. But again, for us — and I think it is important to note — we really wanted to make sure that the host committee was not going to be the only source, or even the main source, of economic impact, right?

(02:20:07)

That is not what the host committee, as a spender, was. What we really wanted to do was plug into what was going on in the City and amplify all of what the City was already doing, to make sure that people who were coming here knew exactly where to go. So it was not going to be, "Hey, we are throwing this one big watch party." We wanted as many people to come as possible, and they did. We also wanted people to explore the City, so you would come to our event in Queens, but then we really wanted you to go to bars, restaurants, et cetera, in the neighborhood. And that was where we saw the real big economic impact.

(02:20:47)

How was the data you guys saw in terms of driving traffic to the local businesses in comparison to tourism's? Was it the same data? And how did you collaborate with tourism in terms of getting the folks from the fan clubs to the local businesses, and how did you collect that data?

(02:21:08)

It is the same data. We tried our best to collect the data as best we could, but we were a small but mighty team that had a lot that we had to do, and we did not have a team of 100 people that could also go and do data collection. So we did the best that we could. I cannot speak to tourism, although I know that they were an incredible partner. For us, though, what we tried to do was, if you were at our fan zones or at any of our fan fests, we tried to promote the ability for people to then go outside of just the fan zone that they were in and go experience other spots. If there were people who were throwing their own watch parties through our viewing license or anything, we tried to promote that. Any of the advertising that the City or New York City Tourism was doing, we tried to promote that as well.

(02:21:58)

Well, and what tools and methods... sorry, and we just — because we started a little late — I am going to have only a couple more minutes.

(02:22:05)

Okay. And I only have a couple more questions.

(02:22:09)

Okay. How did you go about identifying local businesses and M/WBEs

(02:22:13)

to procure the goods and services from? We hired a consultant to help us make sure that we monitored and helped us procure. That is when we went through that. But again, we did not have a ton of procurement on that, as we worked a lot with production agencies who have put on mega events before, like Live Nation or Global Citizen, who have done events in the City

(02:22:45)

before. Who was the consultant? What was the company's name? The name was Tiffany Townsend. Okay. Thank you. And my final question is: your thoughts on our resolution today, which calls on FIFA to provide New York City with the $1 million legacy contribution associated with hosting the tournament, as promised?

(02:23:08)

The FIFA $1 million... so we did get $1 million from FIFA. That was used towards many pitches throughout New York and New Jersey. We also made sure that we put forth some of our own funds that we raised, and in a lot of our sponsorship deals we made sure that we tried to add mini pitches in that. But yes, we did get $1 million from FIFA for legacy. We did get the money — there was $1 million that we got from FIFA.

(02:23:41)

Okay. For the Club World Cup, they had said that they would possibly give us another million dollars, which we so far have not received. And I think — it was not Tiffany Townsend, and I will get you the correct name — it was Tiffany Stanard.

(02:23:58)

Okay. Thank you. That is it for me, Chair. Thank you so much. I know you are on a tight timeline. Thank you very

(02:24:06)

much. All right, I am now going to open up the hearing for public testimony. I remind members of the public that this is a government proceeding and that decorum should be observed at all times. As such, members of the public shall remain silent at all times. The witness table is reserved for people who wish to testify. No video recording or photography is allowed from the witness table. Further, members of the public may not present audio or video recordings as testimony, but may submit transcripts of such recordings to the Sergeant at Arms for inclusion in the hearing record. If you wish to speak today at the hearing, please fill out an appearance card with the Sergeant at Arms and wait to be recognized. When recognized, you will have two minutes to speak on today's hearing topic: assessing the impact of the 2026 FIFA World Cup. If you have a written statement or additional written testimony, please submit it for the record and provide a copy to the Sergeant at Arms. You may also email written testimony to testimony at council.nyc.gov within 72 hours of the close of the hearing. Audio and video recordings will not be accepted for in-person panelists. Please come up to the table. We are going to start with Megan Wiley from the Hotel and Gaming Trades Council, Jessica Walker from the Manhattan Chamber of Commerce, Jeffrey Lefrancois from the BID Association and Evan Sweet from the Meatpacking District BID. The next round will be on Zoom.

(02:25:58)

Upon you begin... so thank you. Good afternoon, Chairs Maloney and Thomas-Henry. My name is Megan Wiley and I am the Political Director of the Hotel and Gaming Trades Council of New York and New Jersey. I am here to speak about the vital role our City's union hotel workers played in making the 2026 World Cup a success, and what that success shows about not compromising workers' rights in the name of corporate interests. Our union hotel workers were on the front lines this summer, welcoming visitors from around the world and providing the

(02:26:28)

world-class service that New York is known for. It is because of that hard work and dedication that the region was able to realize a $3.3 billion economic impact, surpassing expectations by $200 million. Direct spending on accommodations amounted to more than $650 million — 20% of the total impact and nearly 40% of all direct spending. Hotels performed outstandingly during the World Cup, and the role that our hospitality workers played in the success cannot be understated.

Behind all those economic numbers are workers who served their City while securing a new contract. Our industry-wide agreement, set to expire after more than a decade on June 30th, right in the middle of the tournament — had we failed to reach an agreement, nearly 30,000 hospitality workers at more than 250 hotels across New York City were prepared to walk off the job. Our members spent years preparing for that moment, and just weeks before the first kickoff, they successfully ratified a new, life-changing agreement. Over the life of that contract, wages will increase by more than 50%, while maintaining fully employer-paid family health care and increasing pension contributions. The agreement also provides new employer-funded housing and child care benefits, more paid time off, stronger job protections and other improvements to working conditions.

These are historic gains for working New Yorkers, and most significantly, New York did not have to choose between good jobs and economic growth. On top of the protections outlined in our contract, HTC has also fought for policies that protect consumers and improve the quality of New York's hospitality industry. The Safe Hotels Act requires hotels to train staff to identify human trafficking and meet clear health and safety standards, while rules around service disruptions and bans on junk fees help ensure guests are not misled by bad actors. These policies benefit workers, consumers and the City's tourism economy at the same time.

We did not have to lower wages, cut labor standards or ask workers or communities to sacrifice so that businesses could benefit from the World Cup for just a few weeks. This summer showed that we can attract millions of visitors, generate billions in economic activity and support a thriving tourism industry while also raising wages and strengthening standards for working people. We thank the Mayor's Office, the City Council and the host committee for recognizing the importance of ensuring that workers who make this type of economic activity possible can afford to live in the City, support their families and build a future here. We urge you to keep this model in mind for future events like this and to ensure that workers continue to share in the success of our economy. Thank you.

(02:28:49)

Good afternoon, Chairs. I am Jessica Walker, President of the Manhattan Chamber of Commerce, representing 120,000 businesses. New York delivered this summer. Jobs at sports bars were up 16%. Our own place-based AI analysis found domestic visitors to Manhattan rose 8.3% during the tournament, the strongest gain of any borough. But the summer taught us five lessons, and each points to a fix.

First, the benefits appear to have stayed largely in the core. Washington Heights, Inwood and East Harlem — the neighborhoods with the deepest ties to the competing nations — saw domestic visits actually fall 5 to 8%. Mega event traffic does not spread on its own. The fix is a funded five-borough tourism initiative that plans spillover in advance and allows more fan zones and block parties in neighborhood corridors for every future major event.

Second, we sent visitors to New Jersey. Airbnb shows 55% of guests who booked in New Jersey looked at New York City first. Hotels trailed last year for most of the tournament while affordable options were off the market. The fix is Int 0879, letting owner-occupants of one- and two-family homes host guests and narrowing the 2021 hotel special permit.

Third, coordination came late. Planning for the tournament straddled the mayoral transition, and business groups and BIDs were brought in after the key decisions on programming and promotion had been made. The fix is a standing mega event playbook with business groups at the table from day one.

Fourth, visitors who wanted to keep the night going often found bars and restaurants closed early. Boilerplate community board stipulations banned dancing and live music at ordinary restaurants and forced most new venues to close by midnight on weekends, even when mega events arrived. The fix is stipulation standards and piloting the creation of 24-hour districts.

Fifth, the watch parties and soccer streets proved the demand for street life, but fees of up to $66,000 a day and a street fair moratorium mean that energy disappears when the tournament ends. The fix is a single-window, sliding-fee street event permit. We had the world's attention this summer. Let us use it to reclaim our title as the city that never sleeps and make sure the party reaches every neighborhood. Thank you.

(02:31:34)

Just next.

(02:31:35)

Good afternoon, Chair Maloney, Chair Thomas-Henry, great to see you both again. My name is Jeffrey Lefrancois, President of the Meatpacking BID and Co-Chair of the New York City BID Association, representing 78 business improvement districts across all five boroughs. Thanks for the opportunity to testify today. The World Cup was a success. As we have heard, it brought an influx of international and domestic visitors, generated widespread media coverage and boosted foot traffic and spending across commercial corridors from Harlem to Flushing and Downtown Brooklyn to the South Bronx. Given that tourism overall is down in New York City, this event came at a great time. And let us not forget to thank the Knicks for truly making it a summer of sports as well.

BIDs embraced the Cup to showcase our diverse neighborhoods, encouraged exploration beyond traditional tourist hubs and demonstrated that New York is truly the world's city. However, the citywide economic benefits could have been even broader, and that is unfortunate because we had years to plan for this global event. Many BIDs attempted to organize public watch parties, outdoor screenings, cultural festivals and family programming to drive activity directly to local merchants. Unfortunately, many organizations faced severe permitting obstacles. The street activity permit office's permitting timelines were uncertain, and late approvals compromised planning, sponsorship recruitment, marketing and production. Because many of these proposed activations were privately organized and funded, the City missed an opportunity to maximize economic return for local small businesses.

The SAPO permitting process also cost commercial activations. There were several instances where large-scale commercial activations chose to take their money to another host city because of our City's unnecessarily slow permitting process. In many cases, SAPO does not issue a permit until 24 hours before an event, which is no way to do business given the time and investment it takes to stand up a brand program or activation. That poor process has cost the City and our communities a lot of money — money that went on to be spent elsewhere.

To ensure future global events deliver economic benefits across all five boroughs, the BID Association recommends the City do the following: update and streamline permitting for event-related neighborhood activations, especially for organizations that have existing contracts with the City; designate an interagency coordinator to help organizations navigate approvals; engage BIDs early in the event planning process; support public viewing events and cultural programming that

(02:34:05)

drives spending to local businesses; and recognize neighborhood activations as highly cost-effective tools for economic development. Major international events are major economic engines and should benefit every neighborhood. By making it easier for BIDs to activate public spaces, the City can unlock additional economic activity, empower small businesses, create jobs and ensure the success of future major host events, which the City should certainly continue to pursue. Business improvement districts stand ready to serve as key economic development partners in this effort. Thank you.

(02:34:43)

Thank you. Great testimony. I was going to ask what we can do better, but you answered it. So please submit your testimony so we can document all of that. And I do not know if you heard it earlier, but we did recommend to the team that they work with the BIDs, the chambers and the hotels now. We know what can happen, we know what is going to happen in the next two years from now — they should be engaging you guys now. And if they do not, please let us know.

(02:35:15)

Chair Maloney, a plus one to my co-chair here. And the reforms that you talked about — these are repeatable events, right?

(02:35:25)

Like, we know this is going to happen again. Hopefully it happens more often, right? There are a lot of benefits to having these types of large events, so making this a playbook or a standing process for when there are large events, versus having to reinvent the wheel every time — I thank you for all of the recommendations.

(02:35:42)

I did want to ask HTC one question around the pressures of the World Cup affecting a massive contract negotiation that fell right in the middle, and if you can speak to the challenges or the...

(02:35:59)

I think communication between electeds like yourself and people who represent our members is really important. You know, it was not something we took lightly. And I think our members really wanted to be on the front lines and were excited. They loved getting to participate in the World Cup and just being able to know that they have the wages to actually afford to live in the city that they were helping welcome people to.

You know, we did a lot of surveys prior to this country's contract negotiations. 50% were spending more than half of their monthly income on housing. Almost a third had fallen behind on their rent or mortgage payments. 38% struggled to afford everyday expenses. And also 40% of members did not have enough savings to cover a $400 expense.

You know, especially during a time where there were billions of dollars on the line coming to the city, we felt, along with many other groups and electeds like yourselves, that this money should not just disappear when the last kickoff... I embed sports metaphors because I do not know sports.

(02:37:05)

Well, fine. I am pretty sure that makes that.

(02:37:06)

You seem to be doing a good job to me. Thank you. But you know, it was really crucial that the money not only stayed in the city, as you guys are mentioning repeatedly, but also stayed with the workers — and not just the hotel workers, but the other workers in the hospitality industry and service industry that made this happen.

(02:37:29)

And we will make future events like this happen as well. Great. Thank you. Thank you for your testimony. Now we are moving on to the next witness. If you are still here, great. I see them.

(02:37:49)

Thank you. I am Ian Bologna, Executive Vice President of the Hotel Association of New York City, testifying on behalf of the association and its affiliated members about the impact of the hotel industry in New York City.

At the start of the World Cup series, hotel bookings and revenues were significantly behind the initial projections from the City. In response, the association launched a $500,000 ad campaign and website promoting New York City hotels. The goal of this campaign was to spread the word about the current state of New York City's hotel market and make clear that the City's ability to fully capitalize on the economic benefits of the World Cup depended on its success in attracting visitors to the City.

In the end, favorable entry processes for the final countries, eased travel for Spain and rapid visa processing for Argentina, produced a sudden influx in the last weekend. Finally, the tournament's final match between Spain and Argentina produced an additional $74 million in economic activity. As demonstrated by that example involving visas for Spanish and Argentine fans, tourism in the City is being directly impacted by actions taken by the Trump administration. The added profit from the World Cup is not enough to sustain the industry as a whole, and we are looking at a significant decline compared to the record year of 2019.

The war in... has contributed to an additional 14% decline in business in New York City, particularly among international travelers and particularly from Canada and Germany, who spend an average of four times more than domestic travelers. In addition, the United States' tensions with Canada have contributed to a decline in Canadian visitors to the City. These ongoing challenges threaten 388,000 tourism jobs supported by the hotel industry, including the $79 billion in economic activity it generates and the $6.8 billion in annual tax revenue it provides for the City's agencies.

Therefore, the association calls on the Council to examine the impact of federal policies and actions on New York City's tourism industry, including the City's ability to fully capitalize on major events such as the World Cup. We also believe the City should prioritize efforts to attract visitors and position itself as a welcoming destination, free from federal policies that discourage international tourism. We look forward to continuing our productive partnership with the Council, including CM Maloney and CM Thomas-Henry, and greatly appreciate the Council's willingness to engage with the industry and work collaboratively to address these challenges. Thank you again for your attention and for the opportunity to testify before you today.

(02:40:40)

Thank you so much. Any questions? All right. Thank you all for coming to this hearing. This was a very thoughtful and detailed recap of the 2026 World Cup. Anything else? All right, well, I guess the hearing is now adjourned.

AI-generated summaries and transcripts. Errors are possible.
Verify against the linked video and send corrections via email.