Transit on NYC's Waterways: Seaplanes, Party Boats, and the Future of Ferry Service
Committee on Economic Development | Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure
Meeting overview
The joint hearing of the Committees on Economic Development and Transportation and Infrastructure, chaired by Virginia Maloney and Majority Leader Shaun Abreu, covered four broad topics: the state and future of New York City Ferry, proposed new ferry routes, seaplane operations at the East 23rd Street Skyport, and party boat safety. The administration was represented primarily by James Wong, Executive Vice President and Executive Director of Ferry at NYC EDC, and Anton Frederickson from DOT, who fielded a lengthy round of questions from council members. Four bills proposing new ferry service or feasibility studies were on the agenda: Int 0704-2026 (Canarsie Pier), Int 0846-2026 (Willets Point), Int 1022-2026 (West 125th Street) and Int 1032-2026 (City Island). The administration declined to support any of them, arguing that the ongoing ferry vision study, expected to conclude by summer 2027, is the right vehicle for evaluating expansion proposals comprehensively.
On the ferry system itself, EDC presented an operationally optimistic picture. Ridership has grown, the per-rider subsidy has fallen from nearly $13 in fiscal year 2020 to $8.79 today, and the 2025 route optimization produced a 6% overall ridership increase with a 17% jump on the East River route and 9% of all trips now representing connections that did not previously exist. The base fare rose from $4 to $5 on the day before the hearing. The operating contract with Hornblower expires in 2028 with two one-year extension options already priced in; the administration said it was too early to decide whether to extend or re-procure. Council members across the hearing pushed on the contract's transparency, advertising and sponsorship revenues, and the KPI framework, and pressed EDC to share contract documents proactively rather than requiring FOIL requests. Chair Maloney flagged explicitly that a procurement decision of this scale should not be made without the Council and the public at the table.
On the four expansion bills, the administration was consistent in its scepticism. All four proposed sites sit well outside the existing service area, each would cost roughly $5 to $6 million per year to operate at minimum frequency, and together they would require eight additional vessels and $25 to $30 million in annual operating costs, representing a more than 30% increase in the ferry budget. Capital costs could reach hundreds of millions. Canarsie faces National Park Service jurisdiction and an estimated $30 million pier rehabilitation; Willets Point has shallow water and mud flat problems; West 125th Street needs new vessels since it is over four miles outside the current service area; and City Island has infrastructure and environmental challenges. Council members were not satisfied with these answers. CM Banks made an impassioned case for Canarsie as a transit desert facing additional housing density with no corresponding infrastructure investment. CM Gutiérrez argued that Willets Point's transformation into a major housing and stadium destination has fundamentally changed the calculus. CM Abreu pressed for West 125th Street and offered capital funding partnership. CM Louis and CM Riley made detailed cases for City Island, emphasising vacancy rates, economic development potential and the Hart Island access problem. CM Brooks-Powers pushed for the eastern Rockaways to be included in the vision study. Several council members noted that the vision study is already running late and extracted a commitment from the administration to deliver by summer 2027.
The seaplane and party boat sections were shorter but substantive. Chair Maloney pressed hard on the July 2025 hard landing incident involving Arcadian Seaplanes, the enforcement of the 1,000-foot offshore takeoff rule, the ban on flying north of the 59th Street Bridge, and noise abatement. Answers were often thin: DOT acknowledged it would have to follow up on how often operators had violated rules, what penalties had been imposed, and the status of Community Board 6 resolutions dating back to 1996. The seaplane base generates approximately $300,000 per year for the City. On party boats, the administration described its oversight framework through the DOCS program managed by Billy Babe Marina Services, but acknowledged that investigations into specific incidents involving operators who caused injuries remained with federal regulators. Council members found the division of responsibility between DOT, EDC, DOCS and federal agencies difficult to parse and questioned whether the City is using the full range of tools it already has, pointing to its precedent of restricting helicopter tourist flights at the Downtown Manhattan Heliport a decade ago.
The record
- T2026-2571 Hearing on seaplanes, party boats and ferry service expansion (hearing held)
- Int 0704-2026 Law to require ferry service at Canarsie Pier (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 0846-2026 Law to require ferry service from Willets Point to Manhattan (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 1022-2026 Law to require ferry service to West 125th Street (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 1032-2026 Law to study ferry service for City Island (heard; awaiting a vote)
Numbers
- New York City Ferry has carried over 56 million passengers since launching in 2017.
- The system hit its 50 millionth rider milestone earlier in 2026.
- Single-day ridership record was set on August 15 with nearly 57,000 passengers.
- The system operates 38 vessels across 6 routes and 25 landings.
- The system makes over 7 million trips per year.
- Ferry ridership between May 1 and September 15 was up approximately 6% year-over-year following the 2025 route optimization.
- Ridership at East 34th Street and Midtown West 39th Street terminals increased by 21% following optimization.
- The East River route saw a 17% ridership increase after capacity additions and travel time reductions.
- Approximately 9% of overall ridership now comes from connections that did not exist under the old network.
- The per-rider subsidy in fiscal year 2026 is $8.79, down from a peak of nearly $13 in fiscal year 2020, a reduction of more than 30%.
- The base fare increased from $4 to $5 on October 19, 2026.
- The ten-trip pass increased from $29 to $30.
- The discount fare increased from $1.45 to $1.50.
- A two-day unlimited tourist pass is available for $15.
- Approximately 30,000 riders participate in the ferry discount program, with participation nearly doubling since 2024.
- Roughly 230,000 discounted tickets were used last year.
- The operating contract with Hornblower is worth up to $405 million and expires in September 2028, with two priced one-year extension options.
- Implementing all four proposed expansion bills would require approximately 8 additional vessels and $25 to $30 million in annual operating costs, representing more than a 30% increase in the ferry budget.
- Capital costs for all four expansion proposals could reach hundreds of millions of dollars.
- Each individual proposed new route is estimated to cost $5 to $6 million per year to operate at minimum frequency.
- Canarsie Pier rehabilitation was estimated at approximately $30 million several years ago before any ferry infrastructure could be added.
- West 125th Street is more than 4 miles outside the existing ferry service area and would require approximately $26 million for two new 250-passenger vessels plus approximately $1 million for landing improvements.
- The seaplane base at East 23rd Street generates approximately $300,000 per year in revenue to the City via DOCS.
- The seaplane base recorded approximately 1,400 to 1,500 operations in 2025, running approximately 30% below pre-pandemic levels.
- The seaplane base averaged 616 to 620 flights annually between 2016 and 2025.
- City has approximately $75 million in funding committed to expand and improve pedestrian queuing and vessel access at East 34th Street terminal.
- In August 2025, a party boat carrying 300 people collided with another vessel in the East River, sending 7 people to hospital.
- In June 2025, a party yacht with 400 people aboard struck a dock near West 125th Street, injuring 35.
- More than 20 storefronts on City Island Avenue were reported vacant earlier in 2026.
- Over 350 letters and emails of support were received by CM Louis's office for Int 1032-2026, against 8 expressions of opposition.
- In 2024, the City secured $1 million in federal funding to upgrade security systems at Staten Island Ferry terminals, all of which has been spent.
- The vision study is evaluating more than 40 waterfront sites.
- The vision study is expected to be completed by summer 2027, approximately one year later than originally planned.
Action Points
- EDC to provide Council with a breakdown of month-by-month seaplane operations at East 23rd Street Skyport.
- EDC/DOT to follow up on how often seaplane operators have violated the 1,000-foot offshore takeoff rule and what penalties, if any, were imposed.
- EDC/DOT to follow up on how often operator licenses have been revoked for repeated rule violations at the seaplane base.
- DOT to provide committee with the current status of Community Board 6 resolutions on seaplane operations dating back to 1996 and whether a community engagement plan has been developed.
- EDC/DOT to proactively share copies of the Hornblower operating contract and DOCS management contract with the committee, redacting as necessary, without requiring a FOIL request.
- EDC/DOT to clarify which standard operating procedures for seaplane operations can be shared with the committee and which are security-sensitive.
- DOT to provide data on safety standards that seaplane operators are meeting and instances where enforcement led to removal of an operator.
- EDC/DOT to report back on the status of investigations into the July 2025 Arcadian Seaplanes hard landing incident and whether the specific aircraft involved is still operating.
- EDC/DOT to report back on the specific excursion vessel operator involved in the August 2025 East River party boat collision and whether that operator is still holding a permit.
- EDC to follow up on whether a transportation study was conducted as part of the ULURP process for the Willets Point housing and stadium development, and what its recommendations were.
- EDC to report on whether existing boat traffic to Willets Point for Mets games could inform a pathway toward permanent landing infrastructure there.
- DOT to provide specific data on usage and passenger volumes at the West Harlem Piers, including what types of boat service are currently permitted and how many boats use the facility daily.
- EDC to follow up on whether Paerdegat Park in CM Banks's district has been or can be raised with State Parks as a potential ferry or waterfront site.
- DOT to respond separately to CM Banks's written questions on Citi Bike station placement methodology in the 42nd Council District.
- EDC to provide the committee with regular updates on progress at East 34th Street terminal redesign project and accessibility improvements across all ferry landings.
- EDC to ensure the ferry vision study is delivered by summer 2027 as committed, and to engage the Council throughout the process rather than presenting conclusions after the fact.
- EDC to confirm whether the vision study will re-evaluate previously studied sites including West 125th Street, Inwood and Orchard Beach using updated criteria that go beyond standard commuter ferry metrics.
- EDC to include economic impact indicators, commercial vacancy rates and equity metrics as part of the vision study evaluation criteria, as requested by multiple council members.
- EDC to follow up with data on how many Rockaway riders currently use the ferry discount program.
- DOT to confirm whether the Staten Island Ferry has experienced any procurement or operational issues since its transition to 100% renewable diesel fuel in 2025.
- EDC to report on whether future vessel overhauls can incorporate four-point wheelchair securement in addition to the current two-point standard.
- EDC to confirm the name listed as owner or manager on the seaplane base's New York State airport registration for the 2026 to 2029 period.
Full Transcript
...
Hello. Good morning. Welcome to today's New York City Economic Development joint hearing with Transportation and Infrastructure. Please silence your phones if you wish to speak at today's hearing.
Please leave a parent's card with one of the sergeants. Moving forward, no one is to approach the dais. Thank you.
Good morning and welcome to this joint hearing of the New York City Council's Committees on Economic Development and Transportation and Infrastructure. My name is Virginia Maloney and I have the privilege of serving as the Chair of the Committee on Economic Development. I am pleased to be joined by my co-chair, Majority Leader Shaun, who chairs the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure.
Before we begin, I would like to note that we have been joined by CM Aldebol, CM Riley and CM Louis, who is here as well.
Today we are looking at how New Yorkers travel on the City's waterways and the role plays in managing them. New York City Ferry also oversees the seaplane base at East 23rd Street. It controls berthing for the excursion vessels at City-owned piers across the five boroughs. These are all City assets and they affect the neighborhoods around them every day. We want to understand today how manages those assets and how it holds operators accountable when things go wrong.
First, we will be discussing ferries. New York City Ferry has become an important part of how New Yorkers get around. The system carried trips last fiscal year and this summer the City ran the most ferry service in its history. It launched the first major system-wide redesign of the routes since the system began, and this fall New York City Ferry expanded discount fares to middle school students.
And we all enjoyed the FIFA-wrapped boats this summer. However, the New York City Ferry system is very expensive to run. In fiscal year 2025, the system costs $8 million to operate and brought in about $27 million, which puts the subsidy at $8.03 per trip. That figure does not include capital costs or the depreciation of the boats themselves. As of yesterday, riders are now paying more, with the base fare rising from $4.50 to $5.
The biggest decision ahead is the operating contract. New York City Ferry is run by a private operator under an agreement worth up to $405 million and this agreement is expiring in September 2028. The last procurement process took about a year, so the City will have to decide very soon whether or not they plan to renew the current operator, seek new bids or try something altogether different.
The City owns the boats, so every option is on the table. We want to know how the operator has performed, what the City has received in advertising and other revenue and how it is planning the next phase of New York City Ferry. A decision of this size should not be made without the Council and the public at the table.
Second, seaplanes are an issue that hits close to home for the East Side communities that I represent. On July 5 of this year, a seaplane carrying eight people made a hard landing in the East River right off the base at East 23rd Street, snapping a wing strut. They had to take passengers off the plane. Thankfully, no one was seriously hurt, but it was not the first incident on the East River and residents along the waterfront are living with the regular noise and traffic of these flights.
I understand the federal government regulates and the City cannot set the flight paths, but the City owns the facility and therefore can set reasonable rules for how it is used. It did that just 10 years ago at the Downtown Manhattan Heliport when it cut tourist helicopter flights in half and ended them on Sundays. And when this Council passed Local Law 64 last year to rein in noisy helicopters, seaplanes were not covered.
We want to know who has agreements with at the seaplane base, what the City gets in return and whether is prepared to use the tools it already has to work with the Council and East Side communities to better regulate these planes.
Third, party boats raise many of the same concerns. In August 2025, a party boat carrying 300 people collided with another vessel in the East River near the 23rd Street landing, sending seven people to the hospital. In June 2025, a party yacht with 400 people aboard struck a dock near West 125th Street, injuring 35.
Unlicensed charters have been even more dangerous. This year, a mother and her five-month-old daughter were killed when a boat carrying more passengers than it could legally hold capsized near the Statue of Liberty. The City has acted before. In 2019, it stopped party boats from boarding in Citi Bay after repeated complaints from residents. So we want to know what requires of these operators before it lets them dock, whether anyone checks their Coast Guard credentials and what happens when something goes wrong.
Today we are also hearing several Bills that would require ferry service or a study of ferry service at Canarsie, at Willets Point, at West 125th Street and City Island. These Bills reflect real demand from communities that want to be connected to the rest of the City by water. I will leave it to my co-chair and the Bills' sponsors to speak to the legislation.
Before we begin, I want to recognize the Economic Development Committee staff for their work in preparing for today's hearing. Thank you to Senior Counsel Alex, Senior Policy Analyst William Hanak and Financial Analyst Spencer Kun. I will now turn the floor over to my co-chair Majority Leader Shaun Abreu for his opening remarks.
Thank you, Maloney. Good morning and welcome to today's joint hearing. I am CM Shaun Abreu, Majority Leader and Chair of the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure. I would like to thank Chair Maloney for joining me in today's hearing.
New York City's waterways are an integral yet often overlooked part of our transportation network and our economy. Every day they support public and private ferry services, commercial and recreational vessels, freight movement and seaplane operations.
New York City's ferry systems are particularly noteworthy. The Staten Island Ferry is the busiest municipal ferry, carrying passengers annually 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. The New York City Ferry, with 38 vessels across six routes and 25 landings, makes over 7 million trips per year and is the largest passenger-only ferry fleet in the country.
These systems have made improvements over the years but there is still a need to make the systems more affordable, reliable and accessible. The City's 2025 New York City Ferry Optimization Plan was an important step toward addressing some of these issues. The plan reconfigured the ferry network to improve connections and make service more efficient. Today we want to understand what those changes accomplished, what the administration has learned and how those lessons can inform the future of the system.
For many waterfront communities, ferry service has the potential to fill much-needed gaps in transportation, especially where access to the subway system is limited. It would allow for additional means of accessible transit, support additional housing density and strengthen local commercial corridors. That is why I introduced Int 1022-2026, to establish regular ferry service at or near West 125th Street. West Harlem already has waterfront infrastructure and connections to the surrounding transportation network that could be leveraged to better connect this community to the rest of the City.
Thank you to my staff for their hard work in preparing for today's hearing: Lisa, my Deputy Chief of Staff; Bori, my Senior Adviser; Sierra Townsend, Senior Counsel; Theodore Miller,
Legislative Counsel; Kevin Kostovski, Senior Policy Analyst; John Brazil, Senior Policy Analyst; and Richard Yates Wang, Finance Analyst.
I will now turn it over to CM Farah Louis. Thank you both to Maloney and Abreu for convening today's joint hearing and providing the opportunity to speak on my legislation, Int 1032-2026. I want to also thank my co-prime sponsor and sponsors of the Bill, CM Shirley Aldebol, Kevin Riley and Justin Sanchez, for their partnership and commitment to expanding transportation opportunities for our communities in the Bronx.
For four years I served as Chair of the Committee on Economic Development, where I worked hard to expand ferry service and bring more landings throughout our City, including along the East Side of the Bronx. Can we make sure all mics are off? Thank you. I pushed to make ferry service more accessible to middle and high school students, advocated for greater language access and held hearings on how we could use our waterways to promote tourism and create new revenue-generating opportunities for our City, among many other oversight topics you folks are familiar with. That experience reinforced my belief that our waterways are an underutilized resource for transportation, economic development and connecting communities. Today I am bringing that same commitment to City Island.
Since 2023, residents have reached out to my office about the possibility of ferry service to City Island. I have spoken with residents and local business owners and, as someone who has lived in the Bronx my entire life and regularly spends time on the island, I understand both its unique character and the challenges that come with getting there.
City Island is one of the Bronx's most distinctive destinations, with a rich maritime history, waterfront fishing opportunities and independent businesses that contribute to our borough's identity. Yet access to the island remains heavily dependent on traveling by car or bus, with one way in and one way out. Earlier this year, News 12 reported that more than 20 storefronts on City Island were vacant and many of those have remained vacant for decades. This should give us pause. We need to ask what more New York City can do to support these commercial corridors, attract customers and create opportunities for businesses to thrive. Ferry service should be an integral part of that conversation.
A connection to the citywide ferry network yields the promise of a broader customer base to City Island's restaurants, shops and waterfront attractions. It could also provide residents with another transportation option for commuting and accessing essential services, while giving visitors an alternative to driving, taxis or limited bus service. We should be looking for ways to support economic activity without requiring every additional visitor to arrive by car. Improved transit access presents an opportunity to strengthen local businesses while examining ways to ease our roadway congestion.
My office has heard directly from Bronx residents and City Islanders alike, all of whom want the City to explore this possibility. To date, we have currently received over 350 emails and letters in support of expanding ferry service to City Island, including from folks on the City Island Rising membership and other individual supporters, with the majority representing supporters of this legislation.
In comparison, to date I have received eight expressions of opposition and or amendments to this legislation. The level of support we have received from the people who have personally taken the time to engage with my office on this proposal underscores the importance of evaluating all potential benefits through this comprehensive feasibility study. We must listen to concerns and consider the potential impacts, but we must also recognize the interest in exploring a transportation investment that could benefit residents, businesses and visitors alike.
And while I have the opportunity, I want to clarify the scope of Int 1032-2026. I encourage everyone to read the Bill in its entirety because this legislation calls for the evaluation of potential landing sites on or adjacent to City Island. If a suitable location is identified, the Bill also establishes a process for site selection, design and construction, with ferry service to follow upon completion.
While previous administrations and the New York City Economic Development Corporation have studied City Island and Orchard Beach and reached their own determinations, we should continue exploring broader waterfront opportunities. Given the success we have had with ferry service at Soundview and Ferry Point Park, we should not assume that the existing ferry network, including the Soundview and Ferry Point landings, represents the full extent of what is possible for the Bronx. We need to evaluate additional waterfront opportunities and consider their potential transportation, economic, environmental and tourism benefits. That is precisely why a feasibility study is necessary: to understand which locations would be suitable, what infrastructure and investment would be required, how ferry service could affect local businesses and commuters and what environmental considerations we can address along the way.
In the interests of making informed decisions based on evidence and community input, I have made that promise. And before I conclude, I do want to reinforce a few important points about the scope and intent of Int 1032-2026. The legislation does not predetermine a ferry landing location. It requires the City to evaluate potential sites on or adjacent to City Island, considering their feasibility and impacts on the surrounding community. Critically, it goes beyond a study by establishing a process for site selection, design, construction and ultimately ferry service if a suitable location is identified.
As we hear testimony today, I welcome the perspectives of residents, business owners, advocates and other stakeholders. I also look forward to hearing from how we can strengthen this legislation to ensure that the communities most affected have a voice in the process.
I am proud to champion Int 1032-2026, because our waterfront communities deserve thoughtful consideration, better connectivity and opportunities for economic growth. After four years of working to expand our City's ferry network, I know that we must continue asking where ferry service can go next and how our waterways can better serve the people who live, work and do business along them. Thank you.
Thank you. I would like to recognize that we have been joined by CM Thomas-Henry, CM J. Sanchez, CM Banks and CM De La Rosa. I will now call on CM Thomas-Henry for your opening remarks. Thank you.
Thank you, Chair Abreu. I am happy to be here today to discuss the importance of our waterfronts and the opportunities we have to study and expand ferry service across the five boroughs. I want to thank my colleagues, Majority Leader Abreu and Chair Maloney, for holding this hearing and my colleague CM Farah Louis and Justin Sanchez for their partnership.
Earlier this fall, CM Louis and I introduced Int 1030-2026, requiring a study on the feasibility and utility of bringing New York City Ferry service to the City Island area. The goal of this legislation is to gain more accurate and relevant data on the transit patterns and needs of East Bronx residents as well as updated information on the logistical feasibility of additional ferry service in that area. The information provided by a new, comprehensive study would help identify key considerations, shedding light on economic activity, community vitality and other factors needed to determine whether ferry service should be expanded.
City Island is an incredibly special community which I have the honor of representing on the City Council. Expanded New York City Ferry service in the area has the potential to be truly transformative for families, commuters and small businesses. With the status quo, the City Island that we know and love is being lost year after year as historic restaurants close their doors and businesses close their doors and the next generation of families struggle to commute to work and to school while remaining on the island.
Earlier this year, I took Commissioner Kenny Minaya to City Island to meet with local business owners. But the most striking part of that visit was not our conversations with the incredible family business owners or the delicious seafood we sampled. It was the empty storefronts we walked by, one after the other, right down City Island Avenue.
Another important constituency to consider in these discussions are those who have families and loved ones laid to rest on Hart Island. New York City has made significant strides in improving the accessibility of Hart Island and recognizing its complex history. However, the only way to Hart Island is through City Island and for New Yorkers across the five boroughs right now, it is an incredibly difficult and long journey to make via public transit.
City Island deserves to be a destination for its beautiful views, shopping and incredible food, bringing desperately needed traffic into the small businesses. But we also must make sure our efforts center the needs of City Island residents as well. From my engagement with the City Island community, I understand that this issue is nuanced. For many residents, a new study will provide critical context for future actions, helping us develop a plan based on data and community input. I look forward to hearing more from the community members at today's hearing so that we can work towards a plan that serves the best interests of City Island and the East Bronx.
CM Thomas-Henry.
Thank you. Avilés and Maloney, what we are witnessing right now is one of the most transformative developments in Queens history. 2,500 units of affordable housing, 100% affordable housing, a new public school, thousands of jobs, new open spaces, New York City's first soccer stadium at the park, a baseball stadium, a tennis stadium and an airport. Bringing thousands of fans and travelers and new economic opportunities to our borough.
Despite all of this, Willets Point is still defined by its potential — one way in and one way out. We cannot build a community of the future while leaving it dependent on the current transportation infrastructure. The 7 train has been the lifeline of this corridor. While it has served generations of New Yorkers, we cannot keep expecting one subway line to carry the weight of an entirely new neighborhood.
Thousands of new residents and millions of visitors travelling to Citi Field, Flushing Meadows Corona Park, the US Open and the proposed Metropolitan Park development. Int 0846-2026 is legislation that would expand ferry service between Willets Point and Manhattan. It is a common sense solution to our ever-growing community.
Let us just look at the numbers. As a daughter of Queens, I have to start with the New York Mets. This season alone, the Mets welcomed an average of over 33,000 fans on any given game day to Citi Field. And that is in a losing season. Now let us add to that equation: 25,000 seats at Flushing Meadows Corona Park, 20,500 affordable homes, thousands of permanent jobs. And colleagues, that does not even begin to account for the proposed Metropolitan Park development.
That equals greater pressure on the same infrastructure that our communities already depend on. And who feels that pressure? Our neighbors, our working families and our small businesses. The math is not complicated. If we are going to multiply the number of people coming to Willets Point, we must expand the ways they can get there.
That is what Int 0846-2026 is about. A future where living and working there, where a Mets fan or a supporter can spend time supporting our local restaurants, shops and small businesses, and where transportation is not an afterthought but a foundation of responsible growth for our neighbors in Corona, Elmhurst, Flushing and the surrounding communities. We cannot build world-class destinations with one way in and one way out.
Int 0846-2026 is about planning for the Queens we are building, protecting the quality of life of the neighbors who built it and making sure that growth works for everyone. Thank you.
Thank you for those opening statements. I will now turn to committee counsel to administer the oath. Thank you.
Good morning, Chair Maloney, Majority Leader Avilés, members of the Committee on Economic Development and Transportation and Infrastructure. My name is James Wong and I am an Executive Vice President and serve as Executive Director of Ferry at the New York City Economic Development Corporation. I am joined today by my colleagues Anton Frederickson, Senior Vice President and Head of Ports, Waterfront and Transportation, and Michelle Lombardi, Vice President of Government and Community Partnerships, and John Regan from the Department of Transportation.
At its core, ferry connects New Yorkers to the City's vast waterfront. Waterfront opportunities across all five boroughs advance the Mamdani Administration's commitment to economic justice by ensuring that transportation and public spaces are more accessible, affordable and inclusive. As Deputy Mayor for Economic Justice Julie Su has emphasized, affordability means creating the conditions for people to live good lives with more quality time, connection and enjoyment. As our waterfront grows, we must ensure these public investments continue to benefit all New Yorkers.
Earlier this year, ferry reached a huge milestone: our 50 millionth rider. The system has carried more than 56 million passengers since launching in 2017. This summer, ferries set single-day ridership records three times, including on August 15, when nearly 57,000 passengers rode the system — the highest daily ridership in our system's history. That demand came during a major summer for New York City, with the FIFA World Cup, the championship parade, sail-forth events and 50 concerts, cultural events, beach days, fireworks and neighborhood celebrations drawing people from all across the City. Ferry was ready for it.
These moments show what happens when transportation, public space, economic development and culture come together. When someone steps off the ferry, they connect to local businesses, jobs and destinations across the City — from the Lower East Side to the Rockaways, Astoria to the Upper East Side, Brooklyn to Staten Island and Midtown to Governors Island. That is the promise of a ferry system: supporting local economies, connecting waterfront communities and New Yorkers to jobs and recreation. After all, our surveys indicate that 94% of our riders are New York City residents. That is the public benefit we are focused on.
Making ferry service work for riders, neighborhoods and the City while being responsible stewards of public finances has meant looking at the system the way riders experience it — where they are trying to go, how long trips take, whether vessels have enough room and how to ensure each route makes the best use of
public dollars. Last year we put that work into action with the first system-wide route overhaul since ferry launched in 2017. The plan was shaped by feedback from more than 15,000 riders and focused on five practical goals: giving riders more direct access to Midtown and Lower Manhattan, speeding up commutes, adding capacity during the busiest times, improving operational efficiency and reducing the subsidy per rider by growing ridership with limited new costs.
Since implementing these changes and following a full summer of ferry ridership, we can see it is working. Between May 1 and September 15, trips were up about 6% compared with the prior year. Ridership at the East 34th Street and Midtown West 39th Street terminals increased by 21%, showing strong demand for Midtown connections. The East River route, our most popular, saw a 17% increase after we added capacity and shortened travel times. Roughly 9% of overall ridership now comes from connections that did not exist under the old network. That kind of growth is important not only because New Yorkers are using the system but because it shows how smarter service planning can improve access while making every public dollar work harder.
That brings us to the financial side of the system. Like every public transit system, ferry depends on public subsidy. Our focus is ensuring that investment delivers more public benefit — more access, better service and stronger connections across the City. Our FY26 financials were recently finalized and our per-rider subsidy is $8.79, remaining more than 30% below its fiscal year 2020 peak of nearly $13. With a subsidy under $9, ferry continues to have the lowest subsidy per rider of any major publicly funded passenger ferry system in the nation. Our subsidy per rider is also lower than many other forms of local and regional transit, including express bus service, the Long Island Rail Road and Metro-North. Despite cost pressures from fuel, inflation and optimized services, the broader direction on subsidy remains healthy. Ridership is growing, farebox revenue is up and we expect the route changes to keep paying off.
Affordability is central to our financial approach to the system. Through the ferry discount program, we are working to ensure that all New Yorkers can access the system. The program provides discounts off our lowest-price tickets to seniors, students, people with disabilities and anyone eligible for the Fair Fares program. Participation has nearly doubled since 2024 to about 30,000 riders, and customers used roughly 230,000 discounted tickets last year, helping more New Yorkers ride ferry.
This year we built on that commitment by extending discounted weekday ferry trips to middle school students. Ferry's commitment to equitable access guided the fare changes that took effect yesterday, protecting affordability for regular riders, students and discount users while ensuring the system can keep delivering broader public benefits with healthy finances. Our base fare increased from $4 to $5, remaining well below the express fare at $7.25 and in line with the 30-minute non-electric City bike. For frequent riders, the ten-trip pass increased from $29 to $30. For discount program participants, the fare increased by just 5 cents, from $1.45 to $1.50. This approach focuses the largest increase on occasional riders and visitors, while protecting access for those who rely on it most. It also helps ensure the public subsidy continues to support broader benefits: shorter travel times, less congestion and reliable access to jobs, schools and waterfront neighborhoods.
But fares are only one part of keeping the system sustainable. We also have to keep investing in the physical infrastructure — vessels, landings and customer experience — that riders depend on every day. As ferry approaches its tenth year, we are investing in the repairs and upgrades needed to keep service safe, reliable and ready for the future. As a starting point, we are improving air quality and emissions by starting a major engine replacement project across our largest vessels in the fleet. Looking to our infrastructure, we are building a swing barge to support maintenance on our many landings, constructing a necessary warehousing and homeport facility at Atlantic Basin and Red Hook, replacing ticketing machines to improve the customer experience and preparing for the long-term overhaul of vessels.
We are also kicking off discussions around redesigning community needs at the East 34th Street terminal. As the second busiest passenger terminal in the system, the aging facility is increasingly constrained by major limitations. Maintaining a strong and resilient system is about more than getting people from one place to another. It is also about making sure the City has the capacity to respond when emergencies arise, whether during severe storms, subway service disruptions or mass evacuations. Our ferry system has provided alternate services during Staten Island Ferry disruptions, rescued people in the water and works closely with New York City Emergency Management to help keep New Yorkers safe on and around the waterfront.
These investments are critical to ensure that we are maintaining and improving the service that exists today and must be considered alongside conversations about system growth. Last year we released our 2025 ferry report, which laid out our plan to invest in key system-wide infrastructure and develop a broader vision study to comprehensively explore opportunities to bring ferry service to waterfront sites across New York City, whether through public or other funding and operating models. This work is underway and we expect it will better address requests at scale.
The Council bills concerning ferry service at Canarsie Pier, West 125th Street and Willets Point, along with the bill on the feasibility study for City Island ferry service, raise important questions about transit access and waterfront connectivity. We share these goals, particularly for communities underserved by existing transit. But expansion must be grounded in projected ridership, community needs, water conditions, infrastructure requirements, operating costs and sustainable funding.
While we believe it is important to thoughtfully assess growth opportunities citywide, we have reviewed many of the requested sites, including where these Council bills propose ferry service, and understand some of the challenges that they face. Canarsie, for example, falls within the Gateway National Recreation Area and Jamaica Bay, requiring federal coordination and National Park Service review. The National Park Service has previously indicated that they do not support commuter ferry uses on the pier. Even if it did, the pier appears to be in need of rehabilitation, last estimated at roughly $30 million several years ago, before any ferry infrastructure could be considered, funded and built. West 125th Street would require additional vessels, operating funding and improvements to support safe, accessible commuter operations. Willets Point faces navigational access and infrastructure challenges, including mud flats and shallow water conditions in Flushing Bay, challenging waterfront infrastructure and the ongoing work of the Parks Department on marina improvements at World's Fair Marina.
Finally, while there is a compatible barge at West 125th Street, it is over four miles outside of ferry's service area and would require new vessels to be built, operating funding and pier improvements. Unlike some other proposals, however, private ferry operators do operate nearby via New Jersey and could be an opportunity site for their future growth. Our preliminary estimates show that the bills establishing new ferry service, plus the
one for which a study was requested, as written, would require adding eight additional vessels to the fleet to run up to four new routes, resulting in $25 to $30 million in annual operating expenses and an increase of more than 30% of ferry's overall budget. Capital costs could reach hundreds of millions of dollars for upland improvements, vessels, queuing and accessibility and the new ferry landings themselves.
While we share the underlying goal of improving waterfront access, we believe the vision study is the right vehicle for evaluating these proposals in a comprehensive, data-driven way. The study is evaluating more than 40 waterfront sites, including the sites in the Council's proposed bills, along with other underserved communities. The study will give us the fact base to comprehensively evaluate waterfront sites, including the costs, ridership potential, infrastructure needs, water conditions, permitting requirements, potential operating models and a thoughtful consideration about whether service can be delivered through ferry, a private operator, a recreational model or a different service approach. That work is underway and is expected to wrap up in summer of 2027. For that reason, we cannot support the proposed Council legislation but rather believe a responsible path forward is through the vision study in close consultation with the City Council.
We also oversee the New York Skyport seaplane base at East 23rd Street. The facility dates to the late 1930s, when it was developed under Mayor LaGuardia. It primarily supports seaplane and charter service, averaging 616 to 20 flights annually between 2016 and 2025. Billy Babe Marina Services, the operator of the City's public piers program called DOC, manages the seaplane base along with other piers and wharves across the City. We and the operator have worked to strengthen operating procedures, communication with East River marine traffic and the Federal Aviation Administration, improving coordination with seaplane operators and industry stakeholders. This work includes improving preseason coordination, public information and preparing to rehabilitate the Skyport Marina, providing infrastructure improvements to reduce potential queuing in the East River.
As the waterfront grows, our responsibility is to manage these assets transparently and safely while balancing mobility, jobs and neighborhood quality of life. As the steward of much of the City's waterfront, we manage New York City's public piers, docks and wharves, supporting excursion vessels — boats that take passengers out for sightseeing, dining, cultural, educational and recreation trips. It also supports puncture and construction tug and barge operations and other maritime activity. Through the DOC program, Billy Babe Marina Services manages day-to-day functions like permitting, scheduling, site coordination and safety measures.
While routinely overseeing authority at Pier 36, where excursion vessel activity has raised community concerns, we have worked directly with the community board, elected officials and local stakeholders on limits on concentrated late-night departures, additional security, better spacing of arrivals and departures, coordination with nearby events and improved drop-off management. DOC, in consultation with the community, also enforces prohibitions on unauthorized third-party ticket sellers through investigations and follow-up with operators. Substantiated violations can result in financial penalties and, for repeat violations, permit termination.
Ultimately, all this work is about building New York City's connection to the waterfront and delivering a transportation system that reaches more New Yorkers, strengthens neighborhood connections and works for both the City's major moments and everyday riders. It is also about making sure the energy generated by waterfront activity supports the neighborhoods, small businesses, workers and communities. New York's waterfront should be a place every New Yorker can reach, enjoy, work to build a business in and build a life around — not a place limited to those who can afford to live there or visit it. That is what we mean when we say transportation connects people to possibility. That is the future we are building with ferry. I want to thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today and we welcome any questions you have.
CM in our seas, so you may make your opening. Thank you. Thank you for the chance for
giving me the opportunity. I am here. I just heard about $30 million for Canarsie, but I did not hear how much for each specific area. I do not know how Canarsie already has the numbers. I guess because we have been fighting to get on the fast track now for building. We are at the bottom 12. So there is a plan to actually have more development in that area, right? But right now as we speak, it takes about an hour and some minutes to get here from that side of town.
I want to speak about my Bill, Int 0704-2026, which would require the City to establish regular ferry service at Canarsie Pier. Canarsie is my hometown and it is a transit desert. We have one subway line at the very end of the L train, which is not inside the inlet of the community. The buses are packed. I have a fellow who was traveling and had never seen anything like that. You have to squeeze yourself to get into any transportation, whether the train or the buses. People in my district can spend an hour and a half, like I said, to get from here to there.
And when the train goes down, there is nowhere else to turn. I raised four children and to get to Manhattan, to get to LaGuardia, to get to Bronx Science, it was not easy and I know what I am talking about. I am talking about years, right? So right now it is going to be much more difficult. There is nowhere else. Residents are thirsty for options.
We have been fighting for decades. Canarsie had ferry service in the early 1900s and now we are fighting for it to come back. My community has waited long enough for this return. Now the City has put Community Board 18, like I said, on the fast track, as if we are bringing more housing to our area. We need infrastructure to match. We have infrastructure problems and we are not having them addressed, but we are having more development, more homes, more people who need to get to work, to school and to doctors, and our transit is already stretched.
If the City can fast track housing in Canarsie, I am also asking it to fast track this ferry to a stop at Canarsie Pier. It would not only offer relief to commuters but also bring visitors to Jamaica Bay. I do not know if you have heard about ecotourism and all the things that we have to offer, but there is no transportation to bring people in. So we need that. It means customers. I was hearing from small businesses. We need business opportunity. We are talking about economics, right? So if you bring development, you have to bring everything that comes with it. You have to address the schools and the transit. You know, it is already stretched, so we need to address that. A ferry would bring life back to the waterfront and open the door to economic development our community has been asking for for decades. It is an asset sitting right here, ready to be used. We just had a restaurant at the concession we used to have activities. Now we have more people and fewer activities because we are not offering anything, and it is an asset that we can use.
I am asking my colleagues to support Int 0704-2026. I look forward to hearing not only from you about what we are going to do. I heard about the money part, but in the long run, if you
have a plan for development, you have to have that plan through. Because there is no transportation, so that is what I wish for my kids. And I want to say thank you to my colleagues. I have got to run to my own hearings. I apologize.
Thank you, CM, and thank you for that testimony. So we will start diving into questions. We covered a lot of different types of transit. New York City's waterways support a growing mix of ferries, excursions and commercial aviation activity, but responsibility for all that activity is divided among other City agencies and of course regular federal regulators. DOT manages the New York City Ferry, the East 23rd Street seaplane base, the Skyport Marina and other agreements through private operators. So can you go into a bit more about which aspects are controlled by DOT versus others, and where you see the largest gap in the City's authority today? I guess we will start with just the ferry portion and then my colleagues can talk a little bit more about the different assets.
The ferry, which was started coming up on 10 years ago, is a creature of DOT because DOT was able to build the landings, for which it has responsibility over a number of waterfront properties, and has a sort of expertise in providing management on landings. So we have a lot of that. The landings at which the ferry operates — DOT is managing them directly. Also our ability to stand up the system in terms of the vessels and the operator was something that we were able to get done, and so the ferry is an operation that
DOT manages, but it is a privately operated system that is subject to the rules and regulations that DOT has as some of its chartered responsibilities. So I guess I will turn to John just on that part and then we can talk
about the rest. Good morning. Private ferry operations at New York City Ferry Division — primarily we operate the Staten Island Ferry, but in terms of what James is speaking about for licensing private ferry operations, an operator like Hornblower in New York, who runs New York City Ferry, they come to DOT annually for a ferry operator license and we license the route and landings that they run under. So that is our primary responsibility with private ferries.
Anton Frederickson, Director of Ports, Waterfront and Transportation at DOT. As part of that, we have a public piers program where we manage a number of assets across the City to make available for excursion vessels but also the industrial and working waterfront of New York Harbor. Those piers are managed by a private operator called DOC, also known as Billy Bay Marina Services, and they manage this program essentially and provide a lot of the services, but also the checks. DOC has been increasingly responsive to potential complaints that we have received over time and we work to strengthen that through our berthing licenses with DOC and the operators.
And how do you monitor compliance across the waterfront portfolio?
Depending on the arrangement with DOC, the operators have to first follow all US Coast Guard regulations on the sea plans — that is US Coast Guard — but also when in the air. DOC has its own checks. All the licenses and certifications are in place with each of those operators. We also monitor for potential violations and there is a penalty system in place. Depending on the offense, there is even the possibility — for example, with third-party ticket selling — that if you are found to commit the same violation twice, we do revoke that license. That really incentivizes strong behavior from the operators to not lose that access to the piers, which ultimately is a source of income for that business owner.
And do you see any gaps in the City's authority within the City's waterfront authority?
We have a strong, robust program in place. We focus on what we can control, which is the management of the infrastructure and the compliance of vessels or aircraft that access our infrastructure. The regulation and safety of the vessels or the aircraft are up to the regulators and we defer to them. Thank you.
On the ferry side, we look at the ferry through a couple of different lenses, similar to what Anton is talking about. We have several levels. So there are the regulatory pieces that are, you know, national through the Coast Guard and things like that. We also have third-party audits that we do regularly with our operator to make sure that they are abiding by all the rules and regulations and all the things that we are expecting out of them from a safety perspective. We also do, as part of our contract, have a number of key performance indicators to make sure that we are keeping a close eye. Think of everything like maintenance — do you maintain a vessel well? We are tracking that very closely to make sure that all planned maintenance happens in accordance with our plans. These are the many ways that we are keeping an eye on safety and operations to make sure that things are happening the way we expect them to.
Since the majority of the bills that we are discussing today are focused on the ferry system, I will ask some questions focused on that. How would you describe the current state of the ferry system, the operational, financial and infrastructure challenges that you are facing right now?
Thank you for the question and the opportunity to testify. I would consider our financials and the state of the system very healthy. I think that for those with longer memories, we did have times when the cost of the ferry had gotten expensive and we have done a lot of work over the last several years to affect change here. We have gone from a subsidy per rider of nearly $13 per rider to under $9. That is more than a 30% decrease despite the intense inflationary pressures that we are facing around the country. We have done things like re-procure our contract so that we have a really effective instrument to control the system that we have and to ensure that it is delivering a safe and efficient system for our riders. We have made changes to our fare policy which are equitable and are really supporting the growth of our system, so that we can allow the regular riders to have access to the same fares as the subway or bus. We introduced and expanded our discount program and at the same time allowed people who are willing to pay a little bit more to do just that.
So I think that over the last several years we have focused a lot on fixing and making sure that the system itself is working well, and I am really proud of where we are. What are some of the largest expenses and how has fuel prices impacted the operational efficiency of the ferry system?
Fuel is a major cost driver for the system. I am happy to report that because we are able to hedge the pricing on fuel in the future, we have done very well with our ability to keep fuel prices in check. We have seen increases, that is true, but we are not seeing the same kind of increases that are seen everywhere else because we have been able to hedge in the future.
At the same time we are still looking ahead and of course future costs of fuel are increasing, so that is an area that we are keeping an eye on.
When would you expect fuel prices to increase?
We have a continuous hedging program. We are hedged through most of the current fiscal year. So we make regular decisions on how to extend that and at what price points to do so.
And which routes are operating near capacity or substantially below capacity, and how has ridership changed?
Because it is all at different times of the year, there are times when there are going to be vessels that are very full going to the Rockaways on
the summer weekends — they are going to be full vessels. But in general there is often space for us to get more riders on board. It is important for us that in the morning and evening peak periods we have enough capacity to get people to work and to school. We think that is the most important time — we cannot say sorry, the vessel is full. That was one of the areas where on the East River we started to have to do that. There were times when people were standing at a landing in the morning, trying to get to a meeting, and they could not get on board. To us that was a real issue that needed to be addressed, and as part of the optimization from last year we put up a tremendous amount of capacity because we now run that as two routes and we have seen tremendous growth, which means there were a lot of people who wanted to ride that route and now they are able to do so.
In other places, I had mentioned the Rockaway route. The Bronx route, which is now extending all the way to the Bronx — you can start in the Bronx and get all the way to the Rockaways. It is a long trip, but in order to help manage the demands on those places we also introduced opportunities like Rockaway Reserve, where you can reserve a seat. You are allowed to pay more and to have access to a reserved seat, which gives people more confidence about which trips they are going to make. But broadly, we continue to have space to grow. We are excited about that because we want to see more people on the system.
You mentioned in your statement that the study would require an additional eight vessels and roughly $25 to $30 million for the expanded routes. Do you have a breakdown of which of the proposed routes would be more expensive for the City to implement versus others?
So in order to respond as part of the process here, just considering the bills, we did take a sort of high-level assessment. I would not describe this as the fine detail if we were doing that as part of our vision study, but we did take a quick look at the distance of some of the sites. Notably, for the four bills that were presented, they are all quite far away from our existing service area. That is one of the single biggest cost drivers for a service — how far away is it from where you go already. So places like Canarsie, City Island, West 125th Street and Willets Point all exist pretty far away. They are not a stop along the way on an existing route, and so each of these we think has a net operating cost of between $5 and $6 million a year, and that is just to run it with two vessels back and forth. We did not take it too much further in the analysis where we would say, do you have a spare vessel for it, do you want more service — this is just the minimum that you need to have a regular service. So they have reasonably high costs and we would want to think about things like that in the context of a larger route. We rarely run a point-to-point service, but to quickly map out some of the costs, that is how we started.
And are there other ferry systems that operate near those sites at West 125th Street?
New York Waterway, which is a private operator that does a lot of trans-Hudson service, does operate in the vicinity. So we think that, for example, as part of the vision study we would want to explore whether there is an opportunity for them to do so. Again, we are trying to be good stewards of public funds. If there is a way for a private operator to do this without public subsidy, we think that is a great opportunity and we would love to continue having conversations like that.
And when is the current contract up for negotiation?
So the ferry is run through a contract with Hornblower, which is a private company providing the ferry services. Our current contract has an expiration in 2028, but it also has two one-year extensions that were built in and allow the City predetermined cost functions, knowing fully what the future costs are going to be. Those are all baked into the extension, so they are non-negotiated extensions that we have.
And when will DOT decide whether or not they plan to exercise that extension or solicit a new partner?
We think it is premature to make decisions today about the future of this system. We still have two years left on this contract, so we are paying close attention to it and of course at all times keeping a close eye on how the operator is performing. The current contract has some key performance indicators. Are there any other KPIs for evaluating the performance of the contract? Yes. So there are five KPIs that we have built into the system. It is on-time performance, completed trips, customer satisfaction, tech uptime and maintenance. On all five of those, what we had decided when we were building out the system originally was we wanted to have something that is easy to manage and really straightforward. For each of these we have very clear measurements on what they are going to measure and how they are going to make sure that the system is being operated safely and efficiently. So for example, completed trips — yes, we are measuring the number of trips in the schedule that the operator is delivering, but there are a lot of things that go into that, right? You need your system to be maintained, you need your crew to be available, you need the fuel in the vessel. All these things come together and these five KPIs help us really manage the system well.
And does the contract incentivize creative ways to reduce the subsidies required by New York City government as part of the contract, or reduce the cost of operations?
So as part of the contract, and this is new when we re-procured, there was a whole section on revenue generation. It allows us to work with the operator to do things — perhaps you have seen some of the activations and the fun things that you see on our social media. Many of those are paid activations, for which a slice of that revenue comes to the City. We get some revenue from the concessions, from advertising, from activations and things like that on the side of
revenue. Does the City currently offer sponsorships on boats?
So yes, because of advertising...
Yeah, we have partners. We
We have digital screens inside the vessels on which we do sell advertising, so anyone who is interested is able to purchase advertising, much like you would see in the subway. We are not able to advertise on the outside of vessels — that is in violation of a zoning code. It is part of beautification within the harbor and the highways, so we do not have advertising on the outside.
That said, the activations that we do inside also extend beyond just the screens, so sometimes we will have characters on board, we will have people doing activations and giveaways for riders. In fact, recently with one brand we had, they were actually paying for people to have free rides, so throughout the month, each week there was a different route that had a free ride on a Thursday, so people could just ride for free. So there are different ways that we work with companies to try to provide something for them — they are trying to get their name out — but also something for our riders. And some private...
...boat advertising revenue — are they not subject to the same zoning constraint that you mentioned? I cannot really...
...speak to other operators. I do know that within New York's waters there are strict zoning rules about what can be displayed on the exterior...
...of vessels, which does not include advertising.
...and has done advertising in the past — I believe they did a few years ago. Exterior advertising: we have never advertised privately for companies. We have had activations. There is one for Pride, which was more decorative, and then we had one for the World Cup, which featured the various boroughs that we serve. We do not put brands on the outside of the exteriors of vessels. I also wanted to ask about accessibility on the New York City Ferry system and what investments you have been making.
Thank you. Yeah. Accessibility is incredibly important to the ferry. We built the system from the ground up trying to build a fully 100% accessible system. All of our landings — every new landing that we have built — has automatic gangways so that there is level boarding across the system. All of our vessels have spaces for people using wheelchairs, walkers or scooters. We have all the amenities certainly necessary for that, but we are also trying to do more.
Recently we have been exploring new striping plans on our landings to improve the visual lines on the exterior of the landing so that people with visual disabilities know where the edge is and where to be. We are also preparing new ticketing machines, which are designed to be more accessible than the ones that we have today. Finally, we have been approached in the past about looking at additional ways to improve the accessible spaces on board vessels with additional tie-down points, and that is something we are looking into.
And one final question before I pass to the Majority Leader: when you are evaluating new ferry routes and landings, how do you decide what is viable? How do you consider what would be a good new route, and what criteria can you share with the public so that the communities that are requesting services have a better understanding of how these decisions are made?
Absolutely. There is a lot that goes into it. Of course, when we are looking at new services, a couple of different things come to mind. As a starting point, ridership potential is one of the most important things. Anything we build, we want it to be useful. We want it to be delivering for New Yorkers. We want people to use it — and it is not to say that we are only looking at the highest ridership places. You might have slightly lower but very impactful ridership. So we take a look at all of the impact related to who would ride, what they would get out of it, and whether a ferry is, for example, faster than the train in some places. The geography of certain basin areas in New York means that you might have to go around a pretty large land mass, so when we look at ridership we are thinking about what the alternatives are.
In terms of actual sites, there is a lot that we think about on both the upland and the waterside. From an upland perspective, we want sites that are very accessible to neighborhoods or commercial areas. We do not want it to be behind a highway. We do not want it to be through a stark walking corridor that people are not comfortable with. If those conditions exist, we need to figure out ways to improve them, which does often come with costs, but those are important factors so that people would be comfortable using the service.
On the water side, when I was starting out I was not as oriented toward maritime, and on Google Maps you see anywhere that is blue as a place you can put a ferry. But in fact, the depth of the water, the direction of the water flow, the nearby operations, whether there are existing in-water recreational users — there are a lot of different pieces that we check. Are there subway tunnels underneath? All the pieces that we want to think about, which are really critical to the construction. All of these things drive toward capital and operating costs that we look at.
But I also really want to make sure that we are talking about the economic justice indicators that we are focused on, especially as part of the vision study. We are looking at things like income demographics and existing access to jobs, and making sure that we are evaluating not only high ridership places but impactful ridership. So a lot of that is part of it.
Do you consider whether or not a location is in a transit desert, and if there are alternate options like access to the subway, how do you think about ground transit to match with ferry routes?
Absolutely. I think that the transit desert issue is real — not every place has a subway that goes right to it, and we think that is an important thing to be thinking about. If places do not have great transit, is a ferry a good alternative? Well, sometimes it is, if there is a straight shot over the water and all the conditions we talked about. I mean, you can take a ferry very much faster than you might be able to take a subway or the bus to the subway. That is an important consideration. Alternatively, even if an area does not have great access to transit, sometimes a ferry is not necessarily faster, and we also want to be thoughtful about those pieces.
In terms of ground transportation, everywhere that we have built ferry landings or have ferry landings, we have worked to extend bus routes — that is probably the main way that we try to better connect and create some of that access so that people can get to the landing. But what we often find is that the area where we want to put a ferry, which does not have a bus line nearby or a subway, people are willing to go to it because of that, and that is what we are trying to solve for. Thank you very much.
Now, CM Abreu, Majority Leader. Thank you, CM, and thank you, Chair. I am also joined by CM Selvena Brooks-Powers and CM Avilés. Thank you so much to the administration for coming to testify today. Int 1022-2026, sponsored by myself, would require ferry service to a terminal at or near West 125th Street on the Hudson River by January 1, 2028. The city already manages the West Harlem Piers through DOT, but the planned West 125th Street landing is in East Harlem. My question is: has the administration evaluated West 125th Street as a New York City Ferry landing?
Thank you, CM, and happy to speak with you again. We have had some prior conversations about this, and it is an ongoing conversation that we really value because the advocacy is important for various sites. We have looked at West 125th Street in prior studies — in the 2018 study, yes — and even prior to that, when the system was first being built. Some of the concerns at the time mainly had to do with competition with the subway: is it a faster mode given where some of the subway access is? Those are studies...
...from the past. I want to be...
...clear that as we are looking through the vision study this time, what we are trying to do is say: let us not look only at whether the subsidized city system can provide access to this neighborhood — are there other ways that we can activate it? So one of the things we are looking at, particularly at West 125th Street, is whether there are private entities that might be better suited because they are already operating in the area. The 2018-2019 ferry expansion feasibility study found that West 125th Street would require $8 million in capital funding to accommodate a passenger ferry and make the site viable. What is the current estimate for any improvements to ferry infrastructure that would be required at the West Harlem...
...Piers?
So when we did an initial estimate — and again we are doing more detailed work...
...through the vision study — in an effort to provide some early information related to the bills, we did put some information together. At West 125th Street, we are adding to our costs about $26 million for the cost of two 250-passenger vessels, because West 125th Street is a little more than four miles outside of our existing service area.
In order to reach it, you need to actually have more vessels on the routes that we operate than we have today, so...
...that would be the cost for two vessels. You said yes?
And then in terms of the actual location and the dock, the landings — are there any capital estimates you have for that?
We added a million dollars to our first-cut estimate here. A million? Yes.
Because we looked at it and there is a barge there that is technically usable by our ferry vessels. What we do want to make sure is that if we are providing regular ferry service anywhere, it has the right kind of upgrades to be resilient and standardized for the system. That was a very preliminary number, but we would take another look at that for permanent service. And of course...
...I hope that you see me as a partner here in terms of getting funding — if there is capital funding necessary for the docks themselves, or for any additional expenditures, let me know if there is something that you need. Let me know, because I will make it a priority. Thank you. How did the administration make the determination of what kind of boat service to allow at the West Harlem Piers? The existing facility is managed by DOT, so I would need time to speak to that.
Thank you. So West Harlem Piers is part of the public piers program, and vessels who are interested in berthing and landing there can apply through DOT and get a below-market rate there.
What kind of boat service is currently allowed at the West Harlem Piers, and approximately how many boats per day use the piers, and approximately how many passengers per year are using the pier? I would have to get back to you on the specifics on usage there.
Please get us those specifics. You mentioned in your testimony that you are looking potentially at private operators at the site. We just want ferry service there, and I have made this very, very clear in conversations in private and obviously now in public — that is something that the community in West Harlem has been asking for for a very long time. What is the likelihood that we are going to get ferry service there?
I think that the goal of our vision study is to expand the way we are thinking about this, which is much broader than what we have done in the past. In the past we have looked at what is only full-time, seven-days-a-week, every single day of the year commuter ferry service at all times, and that has created certain constraints because it comes with such a high price tag. One of the ways that we are approaching the vision study is exactly as you mentioned — to look at some of those alternative service models. We have not finished the work. I think that we would like to spend some more time as we go through this to understand, with the routes that are operating nearby, whether it makes sense for a private operator, and whether that is a conversation we can have with them to help see what they would need. Those are the kinds of things that we are going to explore as part of the study. I want to...
...get ahead of the study results, but are you optimistic about something happening on West 125th Street? In your testimony you mentioned that there were some jurisdictional issues with respect to some of those sites. We do not have those jurisdictional issues along West 125th Street, Eric — is that right? Correct. There is not a federal land ownership piece. So given that, does that not make it more ripe as a place for ferry service?
I think what I would say is that because there is an existing landing there, I am certainly not saying that you cannot operate a ferry — you can technically operate a ferry to the site. I think that when we go through the vision study, what we are really trying to do is make sure that not only from the capital side but from an operating cost perspective, we understand how these things all fit together. I think it is premature right now to sort of prejudge what the outcome of that vision study is going to be, but...
...there is definitely a landing there, which makes it a little bit easier when you are talking about new services. And I am sure CM De La Rosa also has a lot to add shortly on ferry service further north to Tellen Arena and also in the West Bronx. We put out an op-ed this morning calling for more interconnectedness along our waterways uptown and in the West Bronx, and we hope that the study takes those requests very, very seriously.
I have some questions for the Department of Transportation. DOT operates the Staten Island Ferry and requires any operator seeking landing access at managed ferry facilities to first obtain a DOT private ferry operator license. Can you explain which aspects of passenger transportation on the City's waterways are controlled by DOT?
Thank you. So it is commuter ferries that our licenses really focus on. We issue licenses to private ferry operators who wish to conduct commuter ferry services in New York City waters.
How do DOT and the ferry coordinate on the licensing and oversight of private ferry operators? Licensing oversight is really... New York City manages the ferry contract separately. I like your responsiveness to questions — just like that, you could answer. You could be...
...moving right along. Unlike New York City Ferry, the Staten Island Ferry is a public transit service. Does the Staten Island Ferry currently have enough resources to meet the demands on the system? Currently, yes.
What are the primary challenges facing the Staten Island Ferry? Staffing is always an issue — licensed mariners filling civil service titles — and also NYPD coverage is an issue. How often does...
...DOT evaluate the Staten Island Ferry service to identify needed operational or policy...
...changes? Well, the Staten Island Ferry service runs on a mandated schedule under the City's Administrative Code, so we just follow Coast Guard regulations, follow the mandated schedule, and operate as safely as we can. And the frequency, actually...
...just disregard that. I will move on to the next question. In 2024, the City secured $1 million in federal funding to upgrade outdated security systems at the Staten Island Ferry terminals. How much of that funding has...
...been used? All of it.
Where have the upgrades been made? To the camera systems? Any specific...
...locations? In 2024, I believe it was the Whitehall Ferry Terminal.
What impacts have you seen as a result of these...
...upgrades? Improved video surveillance, which also obviously helps with 24/7 monitoring at...
...the terminals. Will the administration be seeking additional funding for...
...these kinds of upgrades? As long as the federal government is issuing port security grant funding, we will always try to apply for it.
Is there any awareness of any applications that are available at the moment?
Currently, no. In the summer of 2025, the City announced that the Staten Island Ferry had transitioned to 100% renewable diesel fuel.
Have there been any issues related to procurement or operations in the years since that...
...transition? I will have to get back to you with that...
...information. Please do. In October 2025, DOT jointly published a Blue Highways Action Plan for developing a cleaner, safer and more resilient ferry system in New York City. How does the partnership between DOT and the ferry work with regard to Blue Highways?
What is the division of responsibility and authority between the two agencies?
Do you want to take that? Sure. Yeah. It is a joint program, and the Blue Highways Action Plan was a document that we collaborated on together. We also co-host a Blue Highways Industry Day every year. We engage with private operators throughout the ecosystem and we also look at pilots together, so we collaborated on a pilot Blue Highways service for a couple of months between the Brooklyn Marine Terminal and Pier 79. It is an ongoing collaborative relationship.
And what would you say is the division of responsibility and authority between the two agencies?
For the duty supporting blue highways throughout the city, but we were really looking at trying to leverage the existing ferry routes for blue highways operations. So to that end, we modified the private ferry operator license to allow for some blue highways pilots and work at our ferry landings. Otherwise we are supporting the endeavor of trying to move as much freight off the roadways and onto the
waterways. What progress has the City made toward the goals in the action plan?
We are not only exploring sites, we are actually advancing them further. So for one example, the Downtown Skyport, formally known as the Downtown Manhattan Heliport — as part of that re-procurement there, we added a requirement to build out blue highways berthing infrastructure and we are in a couple of weeks beginning construction there. So more to come on that front, but that landing will open by the end of next year. So this is like real construction beginning to take place on a key node in lower Manhattan, and we are doing this across the city as well.
As part of the action plan, using ferry landings to receive micro freight — what steps has the office taken to move this proposal forward?
Correct. So in conjunction with that, we did run a test pilot at Pier 79, which is a New York City owned ferry landing. We have also done some tests and blue highways dockings at the East 34th Street ferry landing to see the feasibility of using that landing for operations. And then, like I said, we did modify our private ferry operator license to give existing operators the opportunity to move micro freight on their ferry boats, obviously within Coast Guard regulations.
Thank you, CM Banks. Sorry I did not give you a heads up that was coming. You ready? Yeah. Thank you.
Thank you. First of all, I just want to say that my district is a unique district. We are actually a portion of the district that has created the largest amount of affordable housing throughout the city, and then the other portion, which is East Flatbush, is part of the bottom 12. And when we are talking about expanding transportation, we want to obviously look at every option. We also know that we have Paerdegat Park, which is obviously a space that is heavily utilized. Has there been any talks with the State? As you do know, that is a State park, but possibly considering there having a ferry at Paerdegat Park? I have not had a substantive conversation with State Parks about it. I will follow up on that. And I know that there has been a large expansion of
Citi Bike in my district as
well. I guess this question will be for recently the 42nd Council District has had significant increases in Citi Bike station installations throughout the district, including locations where residents believed there would be limited demand, as well as locations that have resulted in the loss of a substantial amount of parking. What data was used to select these locations and how were multiple factors weighed during the site selection process?
Thank you. Yeah, Citi Bike is outside of my area of expertise. I will have to get back to you. I have a boatload of questions
on that, but please, we will get those questions to the right people at transportation. It cannot just be done to bikes, even though we are supporters of making sure that there is access to Citi Bike. But I think the issue goes back to placement, and with the development that is scheduled to take place on the East Flatbush side of the district, we will definitely want to make sure that other options for transportation are made available.
What we are looking at on the Gateway side, which has produced a large portion of affordable housing throughout the entire city, is that it is also considered a transportation desert. So it would be prudent to definitely take into consideration possibly an expansion of transportation, looking at possibly putting a ferry there. We are big supporters of the ferry requests from CM Avilés, but I think it would make sense to also take into consideration the Gateway area and the need to expand transportation options in that part of my district. We look forward to working with you. We want to make sure that you know we want to be partners on this issue because it is important to our constituents, especially when we are talking about more development coming to the district and existing infrastructure issues that have not been addressed, especially when it comes to transportation. We want to make sure that is a priority so our residents can be a part of this expansion, whether it is in housing or transportation across the board. We cannot be left behind. We refuse to be left behind. So again, thank you so much. Thank you.
CM Aldebol, followed by Thomas-Henry, then De La Rosa. Thank you for your testimony and thank you for coming here.
Today in your testimony, you talked about your vision study. How will this vision study be different from prior studies for the City Island area, including Orchard Beach?
Thank you for the question. As I have been talking about, we are trying to drive home the idea that this is bigger than just a ferry. I think ferry, which did have a large growth spread and has come online over the last 10 years, is kind of one model of ferry service. What we want to look at through the vision study is whether or not there are alternative ways to provide services — thinking about it operationally, are there different operating models, are there different funding models, are there different ways? Do we want to talk about weekend service? There are different ways other than what, as I had mentioned, is sort of a seven-day-a-week, 365-day service. We think that it is important because that gives us more opportunities to think about things in different ways.
And what are the key metrics that you are looking at and how are you tracking
them? As part of the vision study, we are going to be looking at ridership and the people who are living in neighborhoods — demographics, existing access to transit, commercial corridors, things like that — to understand what the land uses are at nearby ferry requests. We also want to make sure that we are looking at whether there are viable sites for ferry landings in neighborhoods that have adequate steps, have the right kind of water conditions and upland conditions that are really going to be supportive of those neighborhoods.
So we will look at a lot of different things like that.
Are you also considering the potential impacts that ferry service could have on the local economy?
Yes, we do take a look at the land uses nearby and, like I was saying, are there commercial corridors and things like that that we can identify as hot spots where, if you have ferry service, could this be supportive? And City Island, as my colleague mentioned, has one road in and one road out. Thank you.
As my colleague said, one road in and one road out, which leads to serious congestion
along the island that affects cars, buses and emergency vehicles. Will traffic congestion be taken into consideration in the study, and can you estimate the decrease in car traffic that a ferry could potentially bring?
Looking at existing transportation is an important part of looking at a ferry, as you have pointed out, because it has a pretty congested single road down the middle for much of City Island. That is one of the things we consider — whether or not bringing a ferry landing would in fact exacerbate traffic problems if people are coming in to use it from beyond City Island. So these are the kinds of things we think about when we are exploring the ideas.
The coastal areas of the East Bronx, including City Island, have also had serious pollution challenges and flood risks. We are looking at many resilience and mitigation plans in the area, but there is still a lot of work to be done. How will the study take into account climate change risks, changes to the water level and shorelines, garbage and pollutants building up in the East Bay? Will your study take a look at the environmental factors?
As a general matter, when we are looking at specific sites, if we are considering a specific area, then we are considering whether or not it has the existing upland infrastructure to handle it.
And whether there was a ferry in the past. The way we have approached this has not been to sort of bite off an entire resiliency project, but rather to see whether there are adequate facilities nearby at which we can site a ferry landing. Ferry landings are by their nature able to handle some amount of sea level rise, but we make sure that the piles are high enough, that the landings are built in a resilient way, and that the slope of the gangways is not going to be in excess. So that is some of the ways that we are thinking about it. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you, CM Thomas-Henry, followed by De La Rosa.
Thank you, Chair, and apologies if any of these questions are duplicative. During the soccer stadium to housing process, at any point in time was there a study for transportation access to that site, given the new population in the community as well as the
stadium boats?
Thank you for the question, CM Thomas-Henry.
I can check on that for you, but I am assuming that as part of the ULURP process there would have been an environmental study that at least looked at what would have been, I think, a transportation chapter. But I can definitely check on that for you.
Yes, I would love that, and to see what the recommendations were considering what is happening in that corridor. And in that area there is another development, Metropolitan Park, that is also bringing increased traffic, so I am curious enough to want to run an analysis of that. Another question is: your recent transit reports continue to dismiss a Willets Point ferry landing due to the high capital costs and low traditional commuting speeds compared to the 7 train. However, with Citi Field Park opening next year and Willets Point becoming the City's largest affordable housing project in decades, the entire economic landscape has changed. Given that sports fans are highly receptive to leisure travel and premium pricing, why is the office still evaluating Willets Point through a standard Monday-through-Friday commuter lens rather than exploring an event-driven public-private partnership model that utilizes localized corporate branding and private capital to offset the subsidies?
Thank you, CM.
That is exactly the kind of thing we want to be looking at through this vision study —
exactly what you are talking about, which is how do we find ways to connect people to waterfronts outside of the exact traditional way we have done through ferry. Not to say that we cannot expand in the future, but looking at the ideas that you are talking about is just what we are trying to focus on. Are there ways that we can activate it for events? Are there private operators who would be willing to spend money on things like that? So that is going to be part of how we consider that in the vision study. And how
long do you anticipate that
vision study to take? We are planning right now for this to be ready by next summer, to be completed by next summer.
Okay, by summer of 2027. Okay. And currently, I know in terms of access you mentioned access as an issue. There are currently boats that leave Willets Point on a regular basis from the party boats, and when there are Mets games they contract private vessels to bring attendees in and out. Have you guys looked
at that? Yes, we have. I will note that this is managed by Parks, so this is not an OSI site. But as it relates to the vessels that are coming in for the Mets games, for example, we applaud it and are glad to see that there is demand. I think it shows exactly what you are talking about — there is demand out there for these private services, and if that could help drive towards building landings, we are excited to see that kind of enthusiasm.
In terms of the existing infrastructure, it is pretty light. It is not accessible. It is not useful for people using wheelchairs, walkers or scooters, and so in its current state it is not anything that you can operate a regular ferry service from. But we know that some of the operators are able to get some services in and out of there. I am optimistic that once this study is completed next year and we find that there is an opportunity here, a project of this size — how long would that take? Ferry landings in general, if all funding is in place and there is strong support and an ability to move...
In general, through planning,
environmental review and construction, it is usually about a three-year period to get something built. But that is certainly following the decisions and funding availability and those commitments.
Okay. Thank you. CM De La Rosa. Thank you, and thank you for the opportunity to also have the meeting before the hearing to talk about Inwood. But I am going to talk about Inwood
now. Our community went through a rezoning process that I was not the Council Member for, but I had the unfortunate pleasure of being the chief of staff for. It was a very, very controversial rezoning, but there were some bright spots in that rezoning, and one of those bright spots was this idea that northern Manhattan for the first time would be a waterfront community, given that we have both the East River and the Hudson River. As part of that conversation, the City made an investment in the Dyckman Marina. As we have these conversations about the future of the waterfront, it is disheartening and feels incomplete to not include upper Manhattan as part of the vision. We are taking on more residents because of the rezoning and because of other development that is happening in the City, and the infrastructure investments that were supposed to come in through the rezoning have not materialized. Right now,
the Dyckman Marina is closed for two years while construction happens there, and so our community has to live through the closure and the challenges that come with it. But it feels like we are not getting our bang for the buck because we are not getting this ferry service.
I understand that a study was already done for Inwood. I will say to you, it is a new day. We have a new Mayor, we have a new administration, we have a new City Council and a new vision. So a study that happened 10 years ago feels outdated to our community, especially after the pandemic, where New Yorkers' relationship to the subways has changed and where our desire to be enclosed underground has changed. We have seen, for example, in Soundview, a neighboring community, how the ferry has really transformed the experience of that community. What we are asking for is for the vision — as you all put together this vision for our communities — to be considered.
So one question that I have for you is: as you are putting together the updated vision, is there an opportunity for communities that have already been studied 10 years ago to be re-studied? And do you all plan to change the criteria that puts us in competition with the subways? Because that is always going to be there. We are always going to have the A train, the one train, and we are lucky because we are hearing from Council Members that have no trains. But that does not mean that the A train at the last stop is functional. It does not mean that it is the most effective way to get anywhere, and it also means that any blockages that happen from the first stop to the last stop, where my community is, impact ridership and impact the experience. So is there any plan to change the criteria? Thank you for your advocacy and
willingness to work with us and talk through these items. Yes, absolutely. We
I have said, with a fresh set of eyes, on many of the opportunities that have been raised not only through these bills but many other hearings from which we have heard testimony from different communities as it relates to areas in upper Manhattan, including at the end of the day, and also parts along the waterfront. We are taking a look because we want to, as I have mentioned, look at this in a way that is not just about our regular service.
Our regular ferry service is helpful. It helps us to be more creative in how we would provide service. I think that while the idea of ferry service is great and people sort of click onto it, one of the things we also know is that people are looking for ways to connect with their waterfront. People are looking for a waterfront transit option, which is not necessarily to get to work every day, but maybe on nice days it is to go on a nice ride along the river. Maybe it is to get to midtown or lower Manhattan on a weekend.
I think that our ability through the vision study to take into account some of those different operating models, which are often much less expensive to operate, gives us a lot more opportunity to explore some of them. So I think that what is different now — and I take the question seriously — is that we have done two, almost three, citywide ferry studies, and when you look back over the last 15 years, what is different is looking at this not only as a seven-day, 365-days-a-year commuter service, but all the time.
I will also say that these maps break my heart. Whether it is the New York City tourism map that thinks Manhattan ends at 96th Street, or it is the ferry map that forgets that between the Bronx and lower Manhattan we have the wonderful upper Manhattan corridors, or parts of the Bronx that are disconnected — it breaks our heart because we have a lot of communities and a lot of businesses that are depending on that economic activity in some of the hardest-hit communities that have suffered through this pandemic. We have some of the largest closure rates for our small businesses. A ferry could really transform the economic activity in a community and could really bring with it jobs and a transformational experience, as I am sure you all believe, because you would not be doing this work.
But I urge you to look at this map with the lens of equity. Where are the disconnections that we should be filling in? I am a partner, and I know that we all are here to help you figure that out. We have a budget process and we can help figure out where the funds come from.
Thank you. Thank you, CM Farah Louis. Yes, hi folks. Followed by... sorry about that, Council Member.
It is okay. Hi folks. I had to pop in and now we have a lot of hearings going on today. For all of us, can you just revisit the response you folks had about the potentiality of a City Island ferry landing and the congestion concerns you raised? Just to sort of talk about that a little bit more.
Yeah, I was...
Just hearing — I am getting updates as I was coming in about the potentiality of more vehicles on that roadway.
Yeah, so I was responding to a question about whether we consider the traffic impacts that might come up if we were looking at a ferry landing in a certain place. We do think about that. We generally try to find places where people would walk or take existing modes other than driving to get to a ferry landing. In many ways City Island, given its constrained geography, does look like a great opportunity for a community if you are able to find a place and operate a ferry. But one thing I did flag is that because it is probably very attractive, if you were to get a ferry there, it could draw more people into City Island by car.
Do you folks know how many people are leaving City Island by car to drive to Ferry Point to take the ferry?
I do not have that information with me, but we can take a look and see if we have not already.
I would say, anecdotally, I have never taken the ferry at Ferry Point Park myself, but anecdotally, a lot of the responses I have had in conversations with residents have been that they are excited about the Ferry Point Park landing because there is a huge parking lot there and they have the ability to park there. So I just want to raise, in that response about the potentiality of congestion, I think we all know from seeing ferry landings appear throughout the City of New York, there is always about a quarter of excitement and then it kind of swells. We experienced that in Soundview, where we had some parking mishaps and things like that because we do not have a parking lot. I think what is afforded at the Ferry Point landing is that there is a parking lot, and people who need to drive to a ferry landing have typically already avoided going to Soundview and go right there to leave their vehicle. I personally do not think that that would be something that would happen on City Island too frequently.
Have you folks thought through, in the optimization plan, looking at the landing not just for the best-case scenario in ridership but also looking at the economic impacts that could be the best-case scenario for communities that would result in getting a ferry landing?
Absolutely. As part of the study, we are trying to bring an economic justice lens to this, which looks beyond just whether there are places with the highest ridership and how we build more of those. If that were the only lens, the only things that I would get built are places like DUMBO, which has some of our highest ridership. But that is not what we are trying to do. We are...
...trying to consider whether or not we should grow, and if we are, how to do that in the most impactful ways. Impact to us means taking a look at where people live, what the demographics are, what their economic opportunities are, and whether a ferry could help improve those. So those are some of the ways that we are looking at it.
Would you folks consider a high percentage of vacant commercial corridor as a place to look at for boosting the local economy?
I think that it is certainly an opportunity. It also creates risk. At the same time, is this a place that people are coming to? I think that ferry service very often does create ways for people to enter into communities and can really support them. A good example that we have seen recently is Red Hook, and there has been some good coverage over the summer of people who are coming in and exploring and finding places. If you like seeing lots of people coming into a community to shop and do business there on weekends, we see a lot of that. So we see the power of ferry service and I want to explore that more.
And just, my last question: what was looked at for the Rockaway Rocket pilot opportunity, and how is that, if at all, being included in looking at the larger comprehensive plan on landings and where there is short-term seasonal opportunity that can then maybe over time, like we have seen with the Rockaway Rocket...
...transition into a long-term standing ferry landing?
Yeah, the Rockaway Rocket was a pilot that we continue to operate because we continue to see demand for a very limited number of trips from places in Queens — Long Island City and Greenpoint — and that provides some direct access to the Rockaways. The route that we actually extended through the optimization allowed for regular full-time service all year round, so that if you are in the Bronx or the Upper East Side, you can have a one-seat ride all the way to the Rockaways, and that is year-round. So it shows us that people are trying to go to the Rockaways and it gives us opportunities to serve them in different ways.
I guess, just in the interest of time, I am more so looking at all of the bills that are in front of you folks. Over many years we have been through this — our fifth year together on this committee — looking at the different areas in the City of New York where people see landings as desirable, despite feasibility or not. New Yorkers are asking for their neighborhoods on the waterfront to be seen as a place where they can either have another commuting option, a complete commercial booster, or a seasonal commercial booster.
I am just wondering, when we are looking at our long-term comprehensive plan on landings in priority order, or in the order of interest whether it is economic or transportation justice related or not, how are we ensuring that we are using multiple options to give New Yorkers accessibility throughout the City of New York?
I think the vision plan genuinely is the way that we are going to achieve the exact goal that you are talking about, which is to say: let us not just look at it one way. Let us not just look at the previous studies we have done before and try to take a more open approach to these. So that is what we are working on, and we plan to deliver by next summer and we will have a lot more to say as we go through that...
...process. One last question, Chair. Are we going to stay on time since we are already late on this plan? Are we going to be on time? Since the plan is already late, that is our intention — to deliver this by summer. I am going to hold you to it. Thank you, Chair.
CM Avilés, followed by CM Wong. Thank you. I have to be a couple of minutes. So I would like to follow up on who is collecting data on the economic impact of the ferry in Red Hook.
Since you referenced Red Hook and seeing so much benefit, who is collecting that data?
We do not have on-the-ground data. When I was referring to that, there was press coverage earlier this summer that just talked about these sort of waves of people who are coming into the community throughout the summer.
Yeah, lots of people coming in.
Yeah, it would be great. I mean, this is a conversation. Obviously we have been trying very hard to actually get the local community to engage in a full, comprehensive effort to connect the assets of the local community so that benefits stay local. What we do see is a lot of people coming into Red Hook and getting cabs and going away. So I think this is an ongoing piece of work, but I think the economic development agency would behoove them to certainly track with clarity the economic impacts of the investments that are being made in the local communities that bear the brunt.
But that was not actually part of my question. Like many communities in the City, I would like to talk specifically about the blue highway you mentioned in your testimony. Can you tell us more specifically how you noted a pilot between... and Pier 79? Can you be more specific about the scale and scope of that pilot and how we have used our ferry system — not just the Staten Island Ferry — but how have we utilized the ferry system to advance blue highways?
Good morning. Are we afternoon yet?
Almost. So for micro ferries, I had mentioned earlier we modified our private ferry operator license so that existing operators could move micro freight on existing ferry routes. That was very important to us. We wanted to leverage the existing routes to try to get some of the freight off the highways and onto the waterfront, onto the vessels. So far we have had one pilot, and that was a company called DutchX, who was moving micro freight from Brooklyn to the west side of Manhattan. That was very successful, but they ran into some logistical issues on the DutchX side, not so much the ferry...
...side. Yeah, DutchX. They were gone from Red Hook, right? They have...
They were on the waterfront in Red Hook. I am not sure where they moved on to. Yeah.
Yeah, they are done. They have left and they are looking for a new space along the water.
Okay, so how much freight was moved during that pilot?
I would have to get back to you with that.
I think, you know, pilots are important — obviously to prove a concept — but it really does seem like this pilot is miniscule for the scale and scope of our commitment to moving freight, particularly from a community that is inundated with trucks, has an abundance of waterfront, and nothing is getting moved by the water. So I guess my message, in short, is that I want to see a much more aggressive position on using our current infrastructure, not just the things we need to build out. I am glad the Skyport is eventually going to get there, but we are moving vessels throughout the City and how we are not leveraging that in a more aggressive way is really surprising to me. I do not know if you want to respond to that.
I mean, we...
...certainly share the opportunity that the waterways offer in terms of freight. The counterbalance, maybe just on the other end of that note, for that pilot — and that is why we are starting with a crawl, walk and run approach — is that we are integrating it carefully with the surrounding streets on the other end of the node. So it is always a balance, and that is why we are looking at, you know, separate or in addition to the ferry landing...
...can we have dedicated landings for blue highways where you do not necessarily have that conflict, or you can design it even better. So that is, you know... you mentioned the downtown Skyport. We are very excited to bring that one online by the end of next year and we look forward to activating other nodes along the waterfront specific to blue highways.
So we know that the state of repair of much of this infrastructure is not good.
Do you have a full assessment of the state of repair for each of these other landings and all of the assets within the portfolio, and will you make that public?
Yeah, I can get back to you with specifics on numbers. I will say that the landings that we are looking at are typically incremental and net new. So we are building them in addition to the existing waterfront that we already maintain, whether it be for public waterfront access, industrial uses, or ferry landings. So it is new infrastructure that we are adding to the existing waterfront. Thank you.
CM Louis, followed by CM Brooks-Powers. Thank you, Chair. My first question is regarding seaplanes taking off and landing. I had a friend that was stuck in Newark Airport when a plane trying to land struck a lamp post and then a bakery truck, and then the airport was closed. My question is: do your ferries communicate with seaplanes whenever they take off and land, or is there no communication and they play it by ear? Can you please answer that?
Ferry captains are on a public channel that the seaplanes are able to access as well.
But do they listen? Yeah, they typically radio in before landing, so they are coordinated both with the activity on the water as well as with LaGuardia on the airspace side.
Because, based upon the photos here, things can get crowded pretty easily during the summer months, and if there is no adequate communication, these are potentially accidents waiting to happen.
That is a fair point. Communication is certainly one part of ensuring safe landings on the waterfront. There is also pilot discretion to find navigable water, so they can do a turnaround if there is not a patch of water to land safely.
Okay, thank you. My second question is regarding the subsidies. The statement here says that in fiscal year 2020 it was $8.09. So we have a situation here where the more services we expand, the more subsidies the City has to provide. So my question to you is: obviously you want to close or lower this subsidy, and to do that you have to look at the cost per ride. I mean, the cost per ride from lower Manhattan to Long Island City is very different from lower Manhattan to the Far Rockaways. But right now you have a fixed cost per ride — is that right?
The cost that we report out and talk about is the $8.79 system-wide average. But yes, there are different cost functions as you have pointed out. Going to someplace that is further away does take more fuel and more time, so there are higher costs associated with places that are further from the core.
Have you considered pricing them accordingly? Because at the rate these ferries expand, you have to start looking at cost savings. One way to do that is to look at the prices you are charging, or perhaps you can offer other packages. I know tourists taking the ferry are already paying so much more for Circle Line or Liberty Cruises. They would already take the ferry because they can go and see the Statue of Liberty, the George Washington Bridge, and so on. So this is something I think you should look into — packages for tourists and pricing accordingly per trip rather than a flat fee. Because I see that you do not support these bills introduced by the City Council, and clearly cost is a big issue because you have capital costs and construction costs and other costs related to expanding the ferry services. So are you looking into doing some price changes per trip or selling packages?
Thank you for the question. I guess, as a starting point, as a matter of policy, not unlike the subway, we do charge the same price across the City, so we do not want to penalize people who live further away with a higher price point. But what we do have is a fare structure that does allow us to do exactly what you are talking about, which is to have lower prices for people who are frequent riders. And higher prices for someone who is riding just for fun. If you are just riding and you only need to ride once, it might be viewed as fair to pay the $5, the higher fare, which we just increased yesterday, actually, from $4.55. So it is a higher price if you are riding once in a while and you do not want the package.
Finally, we also have implemented, which is relatively new and targeted more towards tourists, the $15 two-day pass. So we are inviting people who are visiting to come use the ferry and pay $15 for an unlimited number of rides over the course of two days. We see that as a way to really target tourists. We are actually advertising and selling this through some of the online vendors as well to get the word out so that we can get people who are willing to pay more onto the system. So as for tourists, where do they get these two-day...
...passes? You can buy them through the ticket vending machines or, more recently, through vendors online, or they are going to be available on Viator and Get Your Guide.
Thank you. Okay, thank you, CM Brooks-Powers. Thank you.
Chairs, it is good to see you all here today with new leadership. I am hoping that there will be some exciting news as it pertains to the ferry expansion. So in 2024, we told this Council that expanding ferry service further into the Rockaways was not viable, mostly because ferries cannot fit under the bridge. Since then, the eastern Rockaways have continued to grow and the redesigned ferry network has taken a new look at the eastern Rockaways. So we are looking at it as part of the vision study and we are looking at it with a broader set of parameters than we have in the past. You are absolutely right that our vessels cannot fit under the train bridge. The vessels that we have, which go out to the Rockaways, have to be large enough to get out there safely and carry the passengers.
So while our existing fleet does not get under that bridge, by looking at this through the vision study we are trying to see if there are other ways that we can connect the neighborhoods to their waterfronts. So maybe there are smaller vessels. Maybe they only stay inside Jamaica Bay. Maybe they connect to Beach 108th Street for continuing service. We are trying to map out all the different opportunities and what they might cost and how feasible they...
...are. I really appreciate hearing that. I will say, after four years of hearing no, just hearing the openness is definitely welcome. In terms of Rockaway riders, our own optimization plan found the Rockaways have limited access to Midtown...
...following that plan. Reconfigurations were made combining the Soundview and Rockaway routes to provide an additional one-seat connection to Manhattan. How has the new combined route worked for Rockaway riders? Excuse me.
Thank you for the question. We see it as beneficial because people are able to have that one-seat ride. So now if you start in the Rockaways, you do not need to transfer. The people who were switching vessels at Pier 11 and waiting and...
...sometimes missing a vessel no longer have to do that. It also allows people to make further trips going further north. For folks in the Bronx, it gives them a way to get into the Rockaways. It is a long trip, but if you are on the Upper East Side or in the Bronx and you want to visit the Rockaways, these provide new opportunities.
I do not have the ridership numbers in front of me, but I will say that what we have seen as part of our summer evaluation is that almost 9% of the trips that were taken on the ferry over the summer were trips that you could not make in the past. That is whether it is Rockaway to Midtown, Rockaway to the Upper East Side, or that also includes places like Staten Island to Brooklyn. Anywhere that we created new links, we saw 9% of our ridership, which means that is a whole new group of riders that are able to experience the system.
I will tell you, if you go to CM Stevens' district and my district, you will see an increase there. We have been trying to get to each other via ferry. My last question for you is: the fare went up to $5 this week. How many Rockaway riders use the discount and how are you reaching New Yorkers who can benefit from the discount?
Thank you for the question. The single trip went from $4.00 to $5.00. The discount trip went from $1.45 to $1.50, so a much smaller increase, which we think is important. It is part of our approach to the fare policy. I do not have Rockaway-specific numbers. I know that we have about 30,000 participants in the discount program overall and our goal is to increase that. We want people to know about it. We look to partner with Council Members and community groups. We have a large outreach team through the operator to try and get people to know about the ferry and the discount programs, so we are doing our best to get the word out. Of course, we welcome partnership wherever we can.
Absolutely. Any committee event, I invite you to feel free to have your folks table to provide information on it, so we welcome that. Thank you, Chairs, and I look forward to continuing the conversation as you all reimagine what the ferry system and connections can look like. I am glad to know that the eastern part of the Rockaways is a part of the discussion. Thank you.
Thank you. I have a second round of questions focused on seaplanes. I want to get into the oversight and accountability aspects. Specifically, who at DOT is responsible for overseeing the Skyport Marina seaplane dock on the City's behalf?
So the seaplane base is part of the City's public piers program called DOCS. The same operator also manages and ensures that all the necessary licenses and checks are in place for each of the seaplane operators. There is also a standard operating procedure that they publish that also guides users, in addition to all Coast Guard regulations. The protocols are followed by the third-party seaplane base...
...operator. So what does DOT itself have direct oversight over versus delegating to the marina services or DOCS?
So we oversee their contract. We have oversight over that contract. We competitively procure it and have the ability to reassess it at certain periods of time, and there is ongoing engagement and checks with them as well.
There are 250,000 constituents along the East River, many of them my constituents in District 4. So what is DOT doing to ensure the safety of those New Yorkers who are adjacent to these seaplane operations along the East River?
So as part of the operations, they have to follow all the federal regulations. But in addition, as part of what we call the airport master record, there are some requirements in there as well as conditions that DOCS has. One of them, for example, is that where it is safe, they take off a thousand feet off of the shore, so that is a way that we ensure distance and adequate spacing to the coastline.
Who specifically monitors the 1,000 feet from the shore and what are the consequences when an operator violates that?
Yes. So that is done through DOCS and there are opportunities to strengthen the tracking of that 1,000-foot offshore rule. I will say that there are times when the pilot has the discretion to go closer based on the weather or the conditions of the water. So it is not a hard and fixed rule. It is a strong recommendation.
And is that a thousand feet from the pier or from the shoreline?
My understanding based on the reading is that it is from the shoreline.
And what are some of the circumstances where that is shortened, and how would you validate that the pilot took off less than a thousand feet without approval?
So it would be after the fact, where DOCS would contact the seaplane operator and try to understand if there was a specific reason for that. If there was not a valid safety reason, then we would look at potential penalties.
So DOCS is entirely responsible for the enforcement of this 1,000-foot rule? Yes, but through DOT's oversight...
...of this as well.
And do you have a sense of how often an operator has violated that rule and what the consequences were?
I do not have that information, but I can follow up on that.
Similarly, a question on enforcement: seaplanes are not permitted to fly over the 59th Street Bridge, but who is monitoring that and what are the consequences for non-compliance with that rule?
So as you approach the 59th Street Bridge, you start entering Class Bravo airspace with LaGuardia, so they will need to turn around to not interfere with the operations of LaGuardia. That is when the tower steps in.
And so how do they enter the East River corridor?
They are typically coming from the south and then turning around, but it depends.
And what sanctions are in place when pilots do not follow the rules?
Well, we have the ability through DOT to revoke the license if they are found to be a repeat offender of these rules that we put in place, so we do have the ability to restrict them further.
And how often has that...
...happened? I would have to get back to you on that. We are aware of a recent incident.
Another frequently reported issue is noise. The New York State airport director indicates that New York Skyports has noise abatement in effect for 24 hours. But what noise monitoring is currently being done and what noise abatement is in effect?
Noise abatement is typically done through the operating hours, so it is only from dawn to dusk, so nothing overnight. We are also looking at potential new technologies, similar to those used to track the helicopter issue, but for seaplane operations, and technologies that are quieter. So there are a couple of technologies out there and we are actively engaged with industry to see how we can bring those in and safely integrate them into the New York City airspace.
For both the issue of noise monitoring and tracking where planes are flying or where they are taking off from, what technologies is DOT looking into to better enforce...
...these laws? So we use Automatic Dependent Surveillance-Broadcast, and that is the way broadcasts are tracked. That is what it is for. This is a way to track the movements of aircraft, to see where they are positioned on the water and whether they are veering off. You can set a geographic box to make sure to see if they are coming in outside where they are not supposed to be or whether they are within the limits.
And how long have seaplanes...
...been operating out of the 23rd Street pier?
They have a long history in the East River, as far back as the 1930s, even prior. But this particular seaplane base was built in 1939, I believe, when LaGuardia was made.
And the East River has changed quite substantially from that time, from a more industrial maritime neighborhood to a heavily congested residential area with waterfront buildings, schools, parks and the ferry activity that we spent the first half of the hearing talking about. When did DOT last evaluate whether or not the operating area is appropriate for seaplanes?
We are regularly reviewing whether it plays a role in the diverse transportation ecosystem of New York. I will say that when we compare to historical volumes, we are still operating below pre-pandemic levels, approximately 30% below pre-pandemic.
Community Board 6 had passed resolutions dating back from 1996 all the way to just last year, calling for DOT to develop a plan with community input on community-centered use cases. What is the status of that plan?
I have to get back to you on that specific plan.
And when you talk about some of the operators that use the space, such as Arcadian Seaplanes, Fly the Whale, Tropic Ocean Airlines, et cetera, who is accountable if there is an accident or an incident, and how does DOT know which company or which person or which plane is responsible?
So first, if there is an incident, it is first responders that are on the scene, and then there is coordination with DOCS to make sure that we understand all the facts before we resume operations. There was a July 5th incident, I think it was mentioned earlier. What we did was pause for the remainder of the day to make sure we understood the conditions before we resumed activity again.
And the number of landings is more frequent in the summer months, is that right? That is correct. So you see this typically between... and do you have a sense of the number of landings month by month in that busy period?
I can get back to you on the exact month-by-month breakdown, but it was approximately 1,400 to 1,500 this past year in 2025. We are still collecting the final numbers.
For 2025, over that entire six-month period? Okay. And do you have a sense, or can you share, how much revenue the seaplane operations generate annually for the City?
Yes, it is approximately $300,000 to DOCS.
$300,000. And what...
...are the main use cases? These are typically by-the-seat charters to go to other waterfront destinations further afield. So that is the main activity that we see.
I want to also ask DOT what role you have in overseeing seaplane operations along the East River and which aspects instead fall to the Coast Guard. I believe that DOT requires seaplane bases to register every three years. Is that part of the...
...scope? They are registered with the New York State Department. The base is registered for the 2026 to 2029 period. Which person is listed as the owner or manager? It would be somebody from DOCS. I would have to double-check the name on that particular record. So it pertains to the safety registration but also to the airport master record as well.
I want to acknowledge that my colleague CM Sanchez has joined us on the dais. I wanted to go back to a question from earlier. This committee and the Council are supportive of the waterfront careers initiative to support CUNY's maritime tech degree program, so that is some investment that we are making on that front.
I wanted to push on the vision plan. The vision plan is delayed and expected to wrap up in summer 2027. That is a full year later than the original timeline. Can you speak to why? As we are getting settled in as an administration, we are doing ongoing coordination not only to bring folks up to speed but to make sure that we have a thoughtful approach to the full study. And will that timeline push up against the budget conversations and budget negotiations that we would need to be having?
I think that as part of the vision study, as I had mentioned, there are a lot of different ways we can think about what kind of funding we are even talking about. Are we looking for funding from a private operator? Are we looking at funding through the ferry? Are we looking for small recreational services? So I think it is a little early to predetermine what kind of funding we are looking for or what would be asked for.
And as you are thinking about the next steps in procurement, a few years out, is there a world where you would consider dividing up the system by routes or relying on private operators? Are you open-minded on how you will approach the next...
...procurement? Right now, because we still have two years left, we have not made any decisions about whether to extend the current operating agreement. At whatever time we do put out an RFP, whether that is at the end of this term or at the end of one or two future terms, we would of course take a hard look at the full system to understand how we have been managing it and whether that is the right way to do it. So we made a lot of major changes to the operating agreement between the first and the second version. I think we now have a much better handle on how to operate it, both in the case of the ferry...
...and in the case of seaplane operations. And in part about operations with DOCS, there are subcontractors or contracted arrangements. You mentioned guidelines and negotiated terms in these agreements. Are those agreements made public and could we request copies of our...
...contracts? The contract is public. It can be FOILed to provide access to it. Our contracts can be FOILed, of course, and can be obtained, so we can follow up with you on that. In terms of specific standard operating procedures, some of them are security-sensitive and some of them have certain restrictions. So depending on what we are talking about, we can follow up on that.
And in the case of the seaplane operations, those are shared with the seaplane operators and can be FOILed as well or made available.
On a similar question I asked on the ferry side, how do you evaluate the seaplane operators? What are you measuring in terms of determining and reviewing the appropriateness of a seaplane operator in the area? I think we are really just focusing on safety. Yeah, but there is one example: we have looked at strengthening the infrastructure there to make it more right-sized for the facility to reduce queuing. So that is one effort we have made in that area. But it is really around safety and access.
And to that point, it would be great to follow up with some of the data on the safety standards the operators are meeting, as well as instances where enforcement has led to the removal of an operator that is not meeting the minimum standard. Yeah, go ahead.
Yes, we will follow up with that information.
I wanted to make sure my colleagues get a chance to ask their second round, starting with CM Aldebol.
Thank you, CM Maloney. So I just really want to put the City Island ferry kind of into context. A ferry to City Island could serve multiple purposes, similar to existing ferry services in other parts of the City, not only serving commuters and students but increasing access for Bronx residents to the beach, to the park and other waterfront destinations in the East Bronx.
We have the largest park in New York City right there across the bridge from City Island. And how will that potential be taken into account when you think about ridership? It is not just the commuter ridership, but all of the potential ridership that would be coming on and off the island.
As part of the vision study, we would look not only at the land uses immediately around any potential landing site, but also for areas where there is, you know, willingness to drive further. We would, of course, look at the surrounding land uses like park uses as well.
And I do want to ask again about the potential tourism. Are you taking into consideration or are you projecting the potential tourism that could come onto the island and to the East Bronx? We are looking at ways to measure non-commuter rides. It is sometimes challenging because they are somewhat difficult numbers to make predictions on, from a projections perspective. But we are looking throughout the City and the system to find good markers and comparisons that we could use to make these evaluations.
Are you looking at a connection to the Soundview ferry and Ferry Point as potential ridership?
Yeah, as a starting point we are looking at specific areas and whether or not they have some of the physical considerations like site suitability — like, are there sites that you can actually physically put a ferry landing or some other kind of waterfront infrastructure? Once we go through that, we will in the future look at where would that connect to, because of course a ferry cannot be in isolation — it has to go somewhere. Then we would evaluate whether it makes sense to talk about this as a connection to other nearby ferry landings like Soundview or Ferry Point Park, or whether it is the kind of thing where we want to find ways for direct service all the way into Manhattan, for example.
Those different routing arrangements would be looked at in the future. Okay, thank you.
We mentioned in our opening testimony some specific instances that are fairly recent: a party yacht that had 200 people aboard that struck a dock and injured 35, and there was the incident of a landing off of the base at East 23rd Street where they had to take passengers off the plane. What investigation was done? Incidents are typically federally conducted investigations by both the NTSB and, in the case of the operation... do you know who was operating the seaplane or the party boat in those instances?
Yeah, we know that it was Acadian Seaplanes that was operating that particular aircraft. I have to get back to you on the party or excursion vessels.
Were there any steps taken to ensure enforcement or investigate why these instances happened?
So the operators will have to make sure that their licenses are in place, and if there is a reason why they should not have that license based on, you know, potentially this incident or others, then that is between them and their regulatory bodies. We would only permit them to access our landing infrastructure if they have all the checks in place.
To your knowledge, are those operators still conducting party boat rides and seaplane...
I would have to get back to you on the specific one of the excursion vessel. I know that Acadian is still operating in the airspace, but not sure about that exact aircraft.
The concern I have is that again, we have 250,000 residents on the East Side. I remember CM Restler, you can speak to the West Side incident, and for the agency responsible for oversight, knowing how these rules are being enforced and where there is appropriate accountability is really, really important. I also wanted to touch on the revenue side one more time. So is it $300,000 citywide or just the Seaport that is earning that? That is just from the seaplane base. Just from the seaplane base. And yet, in contrast, we were talking earlier about advertising on ferries potentially being $2 million in revenue — to have a boat painted, which could cause no harm. Yeah, I would say it is less about all the revenue generation as one piece. It is really about providing a diverse range of transportation options. It is not solely focused on revenue. If you look at just the number, it is relatively small in comparison.
Any other second round questions from my Council Member colleagues?
Hi folks, thank you. I just wanted to quickly ask some questions around transportation and logistics for folks in our disabilities community. I have drafted some legislation before about multilanguage access and looking at the different ways we can do that at each of our ferry landings. I wanted to understand better the four-point securement standard on the New York City ferry lines and if there is training for staff to do that. If we are already instructing some of the staff members on the ferries to help folks that need assistance, making sure that they are boarded correctly, that their wheelchairs are secured and we are preventing injury or damage — just if we can talk a little bit about what that looks like and whether there is training for staff.
Yes, first of all, thank you CM for your partnership in previous legislation, not only for discounts for middle schoolers but also for language access. I am happy to report that we have signs going up before the end of the calendar year in multiple languages, specific to each landing, to make sure that the language is appropriate to each neighborhood. So thank you again for your partnership on that. I think it is very helpful to have that as we go forward. As it relates to accessibility, we do have a two-point securement, which is adequate on our vessels, but we are looking in the future to understand whether or how additional securements could work. Because of how our vessels were built, they were not designed with four points, but we are looking to see whether or not they can accommodate that. We have worked with some engineers to understand the design of that and whether, during future overhauls, we can incorporate some of those additional features.
In addition, yes, there is training that the operator provides for its staff. We take a look at that when they make major changes, but their trainings are related to ensuring that they are sensitive and understanding of what they are supposed to be providing in terms of assistance for people with disabilities.
Okay. And then just around the signage — I hear you on improvement on signage and language, we appreciate that. As I have mentioned in past years, I have been on the 34th Street ferry landing and I missed my Soundview ferry because they are just yelling out or whispering out "Soundview." So I am just wondering, are we looking at, besides the bullhorn and besides the yelling out in some of the areas on the landings, how else we can comprehensively use audio-visual or any other ways so that folks who have disabilities or are hearing impaired can make sure they are not going to miss their ferry?
For someone like me, missing a ferry landing or ferry stop — I can only imagine what that looks like for other community members. Thank you for the question and the comment, and yes, it is the case that our guest agents are doing their level best to make it as loud as possible, but you are absolutely right, we do see real challenges, at least at 34th Street.
It is one of the reasons why it was important for us to get funding, which we do have now — about $75 million — to reconsider how we can expand and improve pedestrian queuing and vessel access at East 34th Street. This is a DEA chief facility and we are working in partnership on this. We are just starting that process now, but we want to re-envision the entire terminal to make it better for all riders. One of the things we know is that when you have a strong focus on accessibility up front, it does improve the situation for all riders, and we think that is incredibly important — to have better line management, better information, better systems as we are creating that. The other thing we did more recently is a smaller project as an interim measure to remove some of the barriers that were found on the East 34th Street terminal, just to create more staging space, which has helped reduce some of the crowding.
I appreciate the responses. I would like to just keep up to date with the folks and what the progress looks like and what other consultations you are looking at to make these improvements. It is not just East 34th Street, right? We want to make sure all of the ferry landings have these types of accessibility options for all New Yorkers, especially Sunset Park, the Gracie Mansion area and Wall Street, which are super busy and intersect with other ferries. So if we can just keep up to date on that, so I can keep communicating out to the community.
Absolutely, thank you. I think that concludes our questions. The point I wanted to make here is: sending us a copy of the contracts — is that something you can proactively do, or are you saying we have to go through the FOIL process? We will get back to you right after this hearing to follow up. Okay. Even if you need to redact what you have to, it would be great to have that kind of collaboration.