Portrait of a Graduate Committee on Education · September 22, 2026 · 4hrs 34m Source: https://hearinghearings.nyc/hearings/committee-on-education-portrait-of-a-graduate-2026-09-22/ Video: https://councilnyc.viebit.com/vod/?s=true&v=NYCC-250-8-1_260922-131920.mp4 ================================================================ (00:00:02) You see, we are not allowed to start, just like open meetings laws. (00:00:07) Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to today's New York City Council hearing for the Committee on Education. If you would like to testify, you must fill out a witness slip with one of the sergeants at arms, even if you signed up already online. Just a reminder, there is no food or beverages allowed in this room and please turn off electronic devices. Chair, we are ready to begin. I know we have not started — for the record, she is my twin sister. We look identical, but it is fine, it is fine. Thank you. (00:00:46) ... (00:00:47) Good afternoon, everyone. I am CM Eric Dinowitz, former public school teacher and proud chair of the Committee on Education. Welcome to today's oversight hearing on Portrait of a Graduate. I firmly believe the most important element of a school system is a basic question that we talk about with our students: how do you know you are doing a good job? We have measures of assessment, and I see time and again that whatever gets assessed gets the investments. Whatever you are incentivized to do, you will do. But what gets measured? The Regents exams. In my time as a high school special education teacher here in our great city, it quickly became painfully clear that the Regents exam — the measure of whether or not a student graduates — never actually measured what we want our students to do and who we want them to be. Exams that do not actually require you to read a whole book. Global history exams that do not ask our students to conduct their own research and independently find multiple sources to support or refute a claim. The list goes on and on. To make matters worse, they are not always rigorous, just sometimes convoluted. Here in the City we consider 65 passing, yet the algebra Regents requires a student to earn 35% of the points to get a passing score. In other words, you can get half the multiple choice questions right, none of the short answer right, and still walk away with a 62 — very close to passing, but hardly a measure of whether a student deeply understands the material. Seven years ago, the Board of Regents and the New York State Department of Education announced a comprehensive review of the state's high school diploma requirements. The review concluded that the state's graduation measures were not serving all students well and in particular were not serving students of color, students with disabilities, English language learners and students from low-income households. I will add that the graduation requirements do not even ask what we want our students to do and be — that same question. Students who engage in rigorous educational experiences and use their skills to better their communities, and all the elements that we see in the schools — from journalism to music and arts, photography to debate team, math clubs — things that we know involve rigorous education, community mindedness and civic engagement. They are not meaningfully measured by the department, yet they are the things we are most proud of in our school system. When I come visit a school, it is what the teachers and the principals are most proud to share. In the years that followed, NYSED gathered stakeholder input, convened a blue ribbon commission on graduation measures in 2022 and received the commission's recommendations in 2023. In July 2025, the Board of Regents adopted the Portrait of a Graduate — a framework describing what every public school student should know, be able to do and embody by the time they finish high school. The aim is a system in which students can demonstrate proficiency in more than one way through options that meet the needs of all learners. Under the Portrait, a New York City graduate will be expected to be: one, academically prepared; two, a creative innovator; three, a critical thinker; four, an effective communicator; five, a global citizen; and six, reflective and future focused. Just one week ago, on September 14, the Board of Regents authorized NYSED to move forward with the remaining pieces of this transition beginning in the 2027-28 school year. Students graduating in the 2027-28 school year or later will earn a single New York State diploma without separate diploma assessment requirements. That means today's high school seniors are the last class who will have to pass the Regents exam in order to graduate. I see no one upset by this. Regents exams are not disappearing completely. NYSED has said the exams will remain as measures of achievement of state learning standards and state assessments will continue to be administered to satisfy federal requirements under the Every Student Succeeds Act. What is ending is the requirement that students pass them to earn a diploma. In its place, districts will be expected to assess students according to locally developed strategies. This shift puts a great deal of weight on the New York City Department of Education. NYSED's own transformation timeline schedules the release of Portrait rubrics and guidance for this school year, and NYSED has committed to releasing additional implementation guidance by summer 2027. Regulatory amendments to Part 100 of the Commissioner's Regulations are not scheduled to reach the Board as a discussion item until 2027, with adoption anticipated in 2027. As of last week, advocates were telling the Regents that schools still do not know how they will measure proficiency for students currently in grades nine through eleven — students who will be affected in less than a year. Implementing this vision across the nation's largest school district will be an enormous undertaking, and New York City will be doing it on a timeline the state has not fully defined. Chancellor Samuels signaled that the DOE plans to ramp up its work on Portrait and restructured his cabinet to create a senior position supervising high school leadership. That position was filled by Dr. Alan Chang, who previously oversaw Outward Bound Schools, the Internationals Network serving newcomer immigrant students and New York Performance Standards Consortium schools — a portfolio that includes some of New York's best models. Beyond that appointment, the DOE has not publicly announced an implementation plan, professional development program or guidance to schools on the Portrait. So today we will ask: how is the City preparing to implement the Portrait framework across New York City Public Schools? What is being done now for students in grades nine through eleven and beyond who will graduate under the new system? Are you expanding work-based learning and other performance-based opportunities in the meantime? What are you learning from consortium schools, which have assessed students this way for decades? And how are you coordinating with NYSED on these issues? The Portrait has the ability to radically transform our school system in a way that will finally allow our schools to fully invest in programs that we know actually benefit students and allow our students to display their vast knowledge and skills in ways unconstrained by poorly written or poorly graded Regents exams. I do, however, fear the Portrait runs the risk of removing all rigor from our school system by doing what we so often do — we turn a well-meaning policy into a compliance checklist and allow the pressure to improve graduation rates and credit accrual at the expense of quality education. The future of our school system and therefore our City rests on our ability to properly implement this directive. I look forward to today's important hearing. I also want to thank the members of the Education Committee who have joined us today, including CM De La Rosa, CM Gutiérrez, (00:10:40) begin your testimony. Thank you so much. Good afternoon, Chair Dinowitz and members of the committee, and distinguished members of the City Council. My name is Daniel, and I am the First Deputy Chancellor of New York City Public Schools. I am joined today by my colleagues: Dr. Alan Chang, supervising superintendent of high schools and District 79; Jane Martinez Dowling, chief of student pathways; Cordelia Viva, chief of curriculum and instruction; Katy Hansen, executive director of academic policy and systems; Sharon Wrencher, senior executive director of state and federal education policy and planning; and Michael Prayer, superintendent of Brooklyn South High Schools. Thank you for the opportunity to talk about the implementation of New York Inspires and New York State's Portrait of a Graduate framework. (00:11:42) This statewide effort started back in 2019 with the New York State Blue Ribbon Commission on Graduation Measures, which brought together educators, students, families, higher education leaders, employers and community representatives to examine whether New York State's graduation system was preparing students for success in a rapidly changing world. The resulting recommendations laid the foundation for New York Inspires and Portrait of a Graduate. New York's work is part of a growing national movement, with more than 20 states across the country reexamining graduation requirements to better align with the knowledge, skills and experiences students need for college, careers and civic life. While approaches vary by state, a common theme has emerged: maintaining rigorous academic expectations while creating more opportunities for students to demonstrate learning through authentic, real-world experiences and multiple measures of readiness. New York Inspires — New York State's statewide effort — invites us to rethink what it means for a student to graduate from high school prepared for college, career and civic life. We at New York City Public Schools are embracing this opportunity to actualize the mayor and chancellor's vision for how New York City Public Schools can best serve New Yorkers in our schools. We believe this work is ultimately about a simple but important question: what should every student know, be able to do and be prepared for when they leave school? The world our students are entering is changing rapidly. Advances in technology, new economic demands and evolving career pathways require students to possess not only strong academic knowledge, but also the ability to think critically, communicate effectively, solve complex problems, work collaboratively and adapt to change. These are not new aspirations — they are skills that families, employers, colleges and educators have long valued. What is new is our opportunity to ensure they are embedded in every student's educational journey. The New York State Portrait of a Graduate was adopted by New York City Public Schools in 2025 and provides a shared vision for that future. It shifts the conversation beyond what students complete and toward what students can demonstrate. It asks us to create learning experiences that help young people become academically prepared, creative innovators, critical thinkers, effective communicators, global citizens and reflective and future-focused learners. Importantly, this work is not about lowering expectations. It is about raising them. For too long, a single measure has carried outsized weight in determining how readiness is defined. Under New York Inspires, students will increasingly be asked to demonstrate their learning in authentic and meaningful ways. They will be expected to apply knowledge, explain their thinking, solve authentic problems and show evidence of growth and achievement over time. This could look like an eighth grader being asked to do an oral defense rather than just taking a test to demonstrate their academic knowledge, as well as effective communication and critical thinking — two of our Portrait of a Graduate attributes. Our goal is to expand opportunities for real-world demonstrations of learning — capstones and portfolios, for instance. Across New York City Public Schools, many schools already provide students with opportunities to demonstrate their learning in these effective ways and we strive to expand that access. Academic rigor remains essential as we expand academic foundations to include personal finance and climate education. We are not moving away from robust and rigorous literacy, math, science, social studies and the arts. They represent critical disciplinary knowledge and skills that students need to be successful. Furthermore, our work through New York City Reads and New York City Solves provides the essential instructional foundation on which we are building our implementation of the Portrait of a Graduate and New York Inspires. Shared research-based curricula that ensure every student engages in grade-level learning, coupled with sustained professional learning and support for educators, will remain central to improving student achievement and preparing students to apply their knowledge and skills in meaningful ways. Moving beyond test scores as the sole measurement for student learning is an opportunity to raise expectations for our students. Even though the Regents are not going away, removing them from graduation requirements starting next year is a profound opportunity and major change. It opens the door more widely for students to authentically and in multiple ways demonstrate their learning and readiness to graduate. We are excited about the opportunity New York Inspires brings for our students in New York City Public Schools and we look forward to continuing our partnership with the New York State Education Department on the rollout as well as sharing what we see for the future with our (00:16:49) students, educators and families. We are approaching this work with humility and optimism because we are not starting from scratch. New York Inspires is a multi-year design and implementation effort. When it is at full implementation in 2029-30, we will have spent years laying the foundation for our students' success. (00:17:11) We will build on the success of the Office of Student Pathways' innovations such as our STEAM centers, early colleges, P-TECH and career and technical education schools, and the transformative, evidence-based Future Ready New York City, which (00:17:23) is in over a third of our high schools and has proven efficacy with substantial impact data. We will continue to scale and sustain student pathways to increase participation in career-connected learning such as work-based learning programs and apprenticeships, while deepening our investments in industry-aligned pathways with the support of both public sector and industry champions in health care, education, building trades and the sustainable green economy. (00:17:50) These examples show us that rigorous, engaging, future-focused learning is already taking place throughout our system. Our responsibility now is to learn from those successes, build on them and create conditions that allow more students to benefit from similar opportunities. (00:18:07) We are approaching this work with a clear commitment. Every student in every neighborhood should have access to high quality learning experiences that prepare them for the opportunities and challenges of the future. Equity must remain at the center of this transformation. The promise of New York Inspires is not that a few schools will innovate while others remain unchanged. The promise is all students will benefit from stronger connections between classroom learning and the knowledge, skills and experiences they need to thrive beyond graduation. As we move forward, New York City Public Schools is committed to engaging educators, families, students, higher education partners, employers, community organizations and elected officials in this conversation. Lasting educational transformation succeeds only when it is grounded in trust, transparency and shared understanding. Families deserve clear information about what these changes mean for their children. Educators deserve the support necessary to implement new approaches while maintaining high expectations. Students deserve a system that recognizes their strengths and prepares them for their next steps. Our goal is simply not to respond to policy changes at the state level. (00:19:19) We want to take this opportunity for the largest school district in the country to show what is possible when we innovate and bring authentic, real world learning into our classrooms. Our goal is to ensure that a diploma from New York City Public Schools continues to be a meaningful symbol of achievement and readiness. We want graduates to leave our schools with strong academic foundations, confidence in their abilities, opportunities to pursue their aspirations and the skills necessary to contribute to their communities and our City. (00:19:48) New York Inspires presents a historic opportunity to align our educational system around a shared vision for student success from the earliest grades through graduation. While this work will take time, we are excited about its potential to better prepare young people for the future they will enter and help shape. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. We look forward to answering any questions and continuing our partnership to ensure that New York City student graduates are ready to learn, lead, contribute and succeed. (00:20:17) Thank you. We have also been joined by CM Krishnan. (00:20:23) So I want to dig into what it looks like in practice. I am going to share some general concerns and ask questions, but just to share some context about what it actually looks like: principals say, "I have these great programs and I think they fit into these categories." Teachers who need to be trained on how to shift their curriculum, or include or exclude things they would have otherwise done, do not know where they are going because they do not know how they or their students will be assessed. Parents often have no idea what we are talking about when we say Portrait of a Graduate. So when I hear you say "families deserve clear information about what these changes mean" and "educators deserve support," I agree with you, and that is why I think today's hearing is important. Let us really dig down on this. So what work has the DOE done to date to plan for implementing the Portrait of a Graduate framework? (00:21:41) Thank you for that question. We have been engaging in a lot of work around Portrait of a Graduate. It started with our chancellor's membership and partnership with the State and the Blue Ribbon Commission, on which so many of our folks participated. Then as it came into New York City schools, we worked with Katie's team in the Office of Policy and Evaluation to put together trainings for our superintendents, their deputies, their senior cabinets and every principal across the (00:22:16) system. Can I pause for a second? Just to clarify what you said — what schools are currently doing Portrait of a Graduate work? All right, let me back out. Let me answer some of the questions around what we have been doing to get the system ready for Portrait of a Graduate, which is really what I am seeking to answer first. We have, similar to the district that Dr. Chang was leading, lots of robust examples of student pathways work already in our schools. But first, let us back out into what the plan is and how we have been approaching it in our schools. So I will start (00:23:01) with Alan Chang, talking a little bit about our core team and steering committee, and then Katie can talk a little bit about the content that we have been making sure our superintendents, their teams and all of our principals have engaged in. Good afternoon, Chair. I am Alan Chang, Supervising Superintendent for High Schools in District 79. I really want to start by thanking you for convening this committee and giving us a chance to answer some of these questions, because this is such an important part of the direction that we are going in. I also want to acknowledge that, as you stated, there is tremendous work that is already happening in our (00:23:48) system. We have networks of schools that have been deeply committed to career and technical education through Future Ready. We have many members of our affinity partners and schools that have been doing this work, and there are so many elements that we are already seeing that are giving us a head start as part of this. New York State has also recognized that this is a multi-year transition. (00:24:16) They do not expect this to be a switch that gets flipped overnight. We will later talk about each of the years and cohorts and exactly what that means. We are also, of course, committed to working directly with our superintendents, our principals and our teachers through our existing professional development structures to be able to help them deeply grapple with (00:24:44) You have journalism students who believe in a free press. Please do not cut his mic here. This is... (00:24:51) You know, I know. There we go. Great. We are back on. All right. Perfect, back on. (00:24:57) You know, for a while there you got to use your teacher voice. Looks like they do that. (00:25:03) So I do want to be able to (00:25:04) say that we have many professional learning structures that are going to be really important. So far, in the last six months, one of the key things that we can speak to is that we have brought together every one of our superintendents to go deeply into an understanding of what this timeline looks like, what the six essential proficiencies are that are part of Portrait of a Graduate, as well as the implications for each of the coming cohorts. Once we had done that, we then went into our superintendent meetings with their principals. We held 45 meetings, each with each group and district — so community school districts as well as high school districts — presenting to them: here is the basic information that the State has laid out. Let us do some asset mapping around what are the key qualities that your schools already have in place, what is the capacity of your district team to be able to support our schools, and then what are some practices that you want to be able to grow in and how do we design that? We took that feedback, we gathered that information and we are also working very closely with the State to be able to design specific citywide professional learnings that we will be opening up to our schools and our teachers so that they can really help inform what this process will look like moving forward. (00:26:27) So I might want to kind of summarize a little bit so far. For that question of what it looks like — asset mapping — you have gone to all your high schools. Are you focused on your P-TECH schools? What we have done is we have met with every single superintendent and the superintendents ran their principal meetings, and so this spring we met with every single principal — not just the high schools, not just the high schools in my former district, but really across the system. I am going to turn it over to Katie Hanson, who can also speak a little bit more about some additional continued engagement that we are doing. I just want to try to be focused. I want to get away from the timeline. I am communicating what teachers, principals and administrative superintendents have communicated to me — that they have gotten a lot on the timeline and a lot on the broad strokes, but not really a lot on what it looks like in the classroom. Like, what is rigorous experiential learning and how does it differ from just a regular class project that a teacher might do, a two-day little project? So if you can incorporate that, I would appreciate that as well. (00:27:41) Yes, I think I will transition. This year we know that personal finance — and that world lives within our Office of Student Pathways — and Jane can talk a little bit about how that is getting off the ground so that we can talk more about how this is actually hitting schools, the supports that they have received and what is going on in that first phase of personal finance. Thank you. (00:28:13) And it is good to see many of you. Thank you for the time. So as part of the phase two rollout of New York Inspires, the Board of Regents adopted a K through 12 personal finance education requirement, and that is the first one that is going to be effective this fall — the fall of 2026-27 — for grades five through 12, and then in the following year for grades K through four. (00:28:40) Because financial literacy has traditionally sat within our career and productive learning through Future Ready, we took on the task this summer through our Summer Institute, where we saw hundreds of educators and talked to them about what the Portrait of a Graduate will look like in their schools, really setting everyone up to do their personal finance education. It is really important because personal finance helps our students prepare financially. We are propelling it with a lot of the work that we are doing — like Save for College, which also lives in our portfolio — and we want to really support the long-term economic mobility of students as they navigate increasingly complex financial decisions. I could not tell you how to run a Robinhood account, but our kids are going to have to know that. So we took a proactive, system-wide approach ahead of implementation. Superintendents designated a district point person, schools received vetted curriculum options and implementation guidance, and personal finance was a major focus, as I said, of our Summer Institute. Implementation is still in its early stages, but nearly 50% of our middle and high school students have personal finance instruction scheduled for the fall semester, with additional schools expected to provide instruction during the spring semester based on their scheduling model. (00:30:06) Middle and high school students — how many have it scheduled and programmed for there? 50% of middle and high school students have personal finance instruction scheduled for the fall, and then like this (00:30:21) year, starting in... Is there a State or official curriculum being used? (00:30:28) What we did was we provided schools with many centrally reviewed curriculum resources aligned to the New York State five required personal finance learning targets, while allowing schools the flexibility to select the option that best fits their local context. (00:30:47) Okay. And is this going to conform with portfolio-based or project-based learning? That idea? (00:30:54) Yes, it will fit within one of the many attributes. (00:30:58) So are there sample assignments or specific assignments per the curriculum that students have to complete, or are you relying on the teachers to come up with (00:31:09) those? No, we actually have those, because the implementation models that we have used are those that we have been using through the Office of Student Pathways when we have been implementing financial literacy. So the projects, the portfolio, the assignments themselves exist. I assume then that the rubric exists and it is consistent across all of the schools. Do you want me to... (00:31:33) I am happy to tell you what the implementation structure looks (00:31:36) like at those schools. Sure. For grades five through eight and grades nine through 12, schools provide instruction through a designated course, embedded instruction pathway or a combination of approaches, occurring during different grades or semesters depending on the school's academic program and scheduling structures. As students progress through their different grades, developmentally appropriate instruction becomes increasingly sophisticated, helping them build and apply knowledge related to earning, spending, saving, credit, risk and other financial decisions. (00:32:14) We at New York City Public Schools are going to continue supporting schools through professional learning, technical assistance and borough-based communities of practice throughout the school year. I think one of the concerns people have about taking away the Regents is — like them or hate them — a teacher knows kind of what they have to teach and everyone is graded essentially the same way. I think people are looking for the same thing with whatever assignments. I just want to make sure that this program — the financial literacy program, and we will have other programs, but focusing on financial literacy — the assessments are the same across the board. Is the same core curriculum used? Is the rubric the same across the board per grade level? Like, will every ninth grader be assessed using the same rubric, so that as an employer I know that a kid who took financial literacy at one school has passed the same meaningful assessment as at any other school in the City? (00:33:16) Well, it is going to depend (00:33:17) on the model used. So we have five different models that schools can select. So within that curriculum — let us say curriculum A, call it whatever you want — EverFi is one. What (00:33:26) is it called? EverFi. Yeah. EverFi. Oh, (00:33:37) that is just one of them. Okay. EverFi. I do not (00:33:41) know, but I did not make the brand. It is just, you know... But you (00:33:45) bought it. Just kidding. What I am saying (00:33:48) is, a kid who took EverFi in tenth grade in Brooklyn is going to have the same assessment, or be assessed to the same standards, as a kid in the Bronx? That is a yes — the standards will be the same. But as Dr. Chang said, it is going to depend on the model used and it is going to depend on what schools are using. So a student can be assessed through quizzes, through projects, through performance tasks, through case studies, presentations or other classroom-based assessments. But what we are doing is using models that actually hit all of the standards that the State has told us are important for personal finance. (00:34:26) And how is the DOE ensuring that the rigor remains? I think this question is similar to any other subject. How is the DOE ensuring — what work has been done to ensure — that the rigor remains, that students are graded, whatever the method of assessment, on some sort of standard so we know it is transferable? All models that we have used through our own work at the Office of Student Pathways — but I am happy to turn it over to one of our colleagues. It is still being developed, right? This will be the first year. But what we do know is that all five that we selected were chosen, first, because of schools and high schools and superintendents and principals that were very interested and had proven efficacy on the models, and second, that there was an opportunity to really figure out what is the best way to ensure that students in our schools are learning the competencies. (00:35:29) Yeah. Dr. Chang? (00:35:33) I think at the core of your question is: when we have these standards and expectations, how are we able to hold that level of expectations and that rigor across our schools? I think that is a completely fair question for us to be asking at this point in time. So I want to highlight that across all of these curricula, we have made abundantly clear what the State standards are. In the curricula there are tasks, assessment practices and rubrics on which we are providing ongoing training. In addition to that, we bring together teachers to ensure that what it is that they are grading and assessing is normed and scored. So you are familiar with how we do Regents-based scoring on open-ended assessments — there are similar practices that determine whether or not a particular task should result in a particular kind of score. (00:36:29) That kind of normal referencing is extremely important, and to be able to ensure that we are being transparent about the standards that we are asking our students to meet. So in the case of personal finance, we are following what the state has laid out in terms of the standards. We have ensured that the curriculum layer is fully aligned and we are doing the norming that is necessary across our schools to make sure that what this particular teacher says is great work and that the student learned the standards is also true in the next school. Okay. And I just have to say it because I remember during COVID when we got pressure to pass kids who never showed up to class. I remember hearing administrators before COVID. I remember one administrator said to a teacher, "Well, I know they did not do the final project, but can you pass them? They promised to do the assignment over the summer." I know one of those is anecdotal, but one of those was like a systemic sort of directive. And you know, it is good that the training is happening. It is good and heartening to hear because that is what rigor looks like. Maintaining that and making sure that it is normed and that there are standardized rubrics across the City, I think is really critical to making sure not just personal finance, but if that model is used for other subjects, that is a good start. Now I have a ton more questions, but I do want to turn over to colleagues for their questions and we will start with CM... (00:38:04) Joseph. Thank you, Chair. I know I have five minutes so I am going to ask a series of questions. Beyond creating the senior supervising superintendent position, do we have a written implementation plan and when will it be released publicly? (00:38:19) Thank you. Yes, we have our supervising superintendent here. Some structures that we have set up centrally is a core team, which is widely represented here by the various offices under the division of the First Deputy Chancellor that are influencing and delivering this work. From Dr. Chang's Office of Student Pathways, there is very heavily seated academic policy. So we have with us today, of course, academics and instruction as well. This is a beautiful cross-office partnership. This group has also been leading a steering committee, and with that widens the voice. How many people are on the steering committee? It is about 20. We have representatives from the teams that the First Deputy Chancellor named: the Division of Inclusive and Accessible Learning, our communications team, as well as several of our superintendents. We use that to norm on the updates we are getting from the state, make sure we have a shared understanding of the timeline, and we also use it as a group for thought partnership and strategy, developing a strategy around each of these components of the New York Inspires plan. (00:39:33) And students who are multilingual learners and students with disabilities, which usually statewide account for the declining graduation rate — what safeguards do you have in place to make sure that local Portrait assessments are created for these students? (00:39:48) At its core, this opportunity to move away from a single measurement for graduation into multiple measurements is a place that is going to really help our students with disabilities and multilingual learners show and demonstrate their knowledge in new and exciting ways that will honor their knowledge and the way that they can express it. To Katie's point, we have our DIAL colleagues on the team with us and as we plan professional learning with them, just like with Reads and Solves, the DIAL team is with us making sure that the lens of the students that they support is very well represented in how we move forward. I did want to mention that in addition to the structures that we set up, the professional learning that Dr. Chang talked about, and some of the early implementation as it relates to personal finance, there is a lot of information widely available on the state's website about this that parents can access. We are currently getting ready to pull it over to our website, in addition to the work and the values that New York City Public Schools has, and move into a more New York City engagement around this topic. Last week's meeting with the state and this week's hearing is certainly helping to accelerate that timeline to make this really a robust conversation across our City. (00:41:12) What is the specific professional development plan and budget, and how many schools have received Portrait training so far? (00:41:18) Outside of the personal finance work, all of the work that lives under — actually, let me say, there is a lot, because of the work that Jane leads. To the point she shared before, reaching over 1,600 educators over the summer institute, which was very strongly aligned to Portrait of a Graduate... (00:41:39) I just want to reiterate that we believe that at the foundation of Portrait of a Graduate is our New York City Reads and Solves approach to having high quality instructional materials in our classrooms, that students who might be in need of additional supports have very clear interventions that align with their needs. With that also comes a tremendous amount of professional learning. We also have — I shared on the steps earlier — as a superintendent who led one of the City's first Civics for All district partnerships, I think we are at almost 30-something partner districts at this point, and so much of that work comes with professional learning. So what we are doing now is not necessarily a dedicated Portrait of a Graduate budget and standalone professional learning. We are taking all the things that we do as they align into this framework and helping our schools leverage existing resources and initiatives, so we are not layering more. We are having people step back and say, here is where everything connects. So I am running out of time. (00:42:51) So another question — I have another question, of course. (00:42:54) What is the DOE's communication plan for students and parents, particularly the class of 2027 and 2028, the first cohort that will be affected? (00:43:03) Yes. Well, we are entering into our communications plan now so that we can very clearly lay out exactly — I guess that goes back to Chair Dinowitz's question about the timeline. We want to make sure our families know the timeline and that the expectations of the state are clear. Until official, more formal information and structures and directions come out, we are operating under the current graduation measures. Thank you. (00:43:31) As New York City implements the Portrait of a Graduate, how can the City build on and sustain investments in existing models like Future Ready, career readiness, modern youth apprenticeship, and what students... (00:43:41) ...that gives students opportunities to develop and demonstrate these career-connected learning paid experiences and apprenticeships? (00:43:50) I am going to turn that over to Jane. This is her topic and passion. Yes, thank you, Higher Education Chair... (00:44:04) Joseph. Thank you. (00:44:05) You have to do the flip back and forth. (00:44:06) It happens all the time. Dinowitz is not offended. (00:44:09) Yes. As you know, we have already built a lot of the infrastructure needed to scale our work through work-based and future-ready learning to work, which is helpful to the population that you were speaking to — our industry commissions, intermediary partners. As you all know, we have a really strong collaboration with the Office of Talent and Workforce Development. If work-based learning becomes a primary demonstration of proficiency, there are going to be three things that are critical. One is that we have clear standards and assessment rubrics so that schools, employers and students have a shared definition of what proficiency looks like and how it is going to be measured. Second is that we have to build capacity for schools through training, tools and implementation support to ensure consistent, high quality assessment of student learning. It is really important that schools also have employer support. Teachers, work-based learning coordinators and workplace supervisors need clear tools, examples, training and proof points to make sure that students are receiving a strong experience and are evaluated fairly. The third thing, which you spoke to, is just making sure that there is equity, innovation and sustained investment to ensure that all students have access to high quality work-based learning opportunities, including students in every borough, students with learning differences, multilingual learners and immigrant students. This includes funding for paid work-based learning experiences because we really believe that our students deserve to be paid for the time that they are investing, and for innovative models to help schools and employers expand access while maintaining quality at scale. We do have a really strong foundation to build from with career-ready, work and learn, and Grow Further, and CTE, which already connect thousands of students to career-connected experiences. We have about 90,000 students who are already receiving work-based learning experiences to provide a platform for future scale. (00:46:34) And as Chair Dinowitz would say, how do we measure success? What is the plan to measure success in all of that that you have said? (00:46:42) We have been working with our work-based learning students and tracking their experiences. We have seen some very strong outcomes around the impact of work-based learning on students going to secondary schools. It has increased the number of College Now students taking College Now courses. Really importantly, our kids have earned $85 million over the past five years, both in tuition savings and also in direct wages. We believe that those are actually pretty strong impacts. The work and the growth that employers are telling us about — both in the public sector and the private sector — about how these students through their apprenticeships or the internships that they are doing have really, really added value to the work that is happening in their places of work. (00:47:33) Okay. Thank you, CM Joseph. I just have one question because it was brought up about students with disabilities. With the Regents exams, students with disabilities since the IEP mandate did not necessarily have to pass every Regents. They could do a combination of getting a little lower than a 65, right, if they made up for it on another test — the details of which I do not remember, but that is the general sense. There was sort of a different standard. Is the intention of the DOE to similarly have different standards for students with disabilities, or will students with disabilities be held to the same rigorous standards as other students? Okay. (00:48:21) All of our students need to be held to an extremely high standard. That was a good answer. My question was... (00:48:27) That was a great answer. My question is: will there be a different standard for students with disabilities, or will they be held to the same rubric? You can — we can use that language. (00:48:36) I think what the rubrics do is they set expectations. I think what is really important is that our schools and their teachers really lean into this idea that there are multiple forms of assessment and multiple ways for students to be able to demonstrate what it is that they know. In plain language, we say to students: what are the different ways that we think are crucial for you to be able to demonstrate that? (00:49:07) We have a long history of doing that here in the City. In fact, when we begin to decouple the exams, we begin to say there are many other ways for students to be able to demonstrate that particular knowledge. (00:49:19) I just want to say I agree with you. It is one of the reasons I love the idea of the Portrait. But we have seen that, you know, a student with an IEP has to get, you know, 30% of the third, fourth, fifth grade curriculum — often, I believe, to their detriment, because then they get to later grades and high school and we cannot say, or we should not say, they need to only get a 30% on the Regents. What we do have is essentially saying you do not have to get the same score as your classmates. I am simply asking if it is the intention of the DOE to say a student with a disability — every other kid has to get, you know, at least eight out of ten on this project, you only have to get a seven, or a combination — or is the intention to say the standards are the standards because it is project-based learning, there is more time to work on this, and... (00:50:11) The standards are the same, with or without. What is the intention? The intention is a lot of what he said, which is: these are the standards, there are multiple ways of being able to meet that. For example, if we are thinking about career and technical education, if we are going to train somebody to be an electrician or a medical assistant, we want to make sure they are meeting the same bar. It is incumbent upon us to work with our students and their learning styles, but the standards absolutely have to be as high as ever. Thank you for... (00:50:43) That answer. I am going to turn over to CM Narcisse. (00:50:48) Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Madam Deputy, and all your leadership here with you. One of the things that got me excited as a parent who had to go through four kids — I think from Dr. Reef or this and that and the third — I am so appreciative that in the time of AI, our children are not really able to solve their own problems. They are on disagreement. Effective communicators — I know we do not have that with the journalism here. Where are the young folks? They have gone broadly anyway. I am so happy that we are incorporating all of that right now to make sure our kids are successful. Coming to the teacher training and professional development, I want to know: how is the DOE supporting curriculum design at the school level? Is that support mandatory or voluntary? (00:51:56) So right now there is no reason to necessarily do a curriculum redesign. We are not bringing in new curriculum. What is exciting for our teachers as they move into — what are we in, year four of New York City Reads for some of our schools, year three of Solves — and our social studies and science, all of it is to think about: here is our core curriculum, here are our high quality instructional materials, and with our professional learning partners, thinking more about the pedagogy, the delivery of this content. What opportunities in our curriculum and in the standards that students need can we deliver differently so that students have more opportunities to effectively communicate or demonstrate their learning beyond... (00:52:49) just an end-of-unit exam. Those are our next steps for us to tackle. We have so many professional learning partners in our schools that are both external, through Reads and Solves, but internal by way of district teams, our lead teachers and our masterful principals, that we can tap into the knowledge base that exists across New York City to help them rethink how they are delivering. In Reads alone, the modules, regardless of the three different curricular choices, are centered around these essential questions. We want to help our teachers think about how we can bring these units to life more dynamically. That is what New York Inspires and Portrait of a Graduate is giving us permission to do, and that will be some of the ways we think about the supports our teachers need in the delivery and how students are experiencing the curriculum as a next step. I appreciate that. Now I am already hearing from my office from parents and students who do not know what is required of them anymore. They sound confused. Something like something, and they tell you they do not know what is going on. What is the DOE doing right now to make sure every family knows exactly what their children need to graduate? (00:54:18) Yes, thank you so much. We are seeing that even the more we talk about things, the more people are taking one piece or understanding one piece. So if you do not mind, I am going to ask if we can give Katie a few minutes to kind of just break down exactly... is that not going to kill me? Yes. (00:54:35) Break it down. We are a nonviolent City Council. No murder here today. Because I think your wishes are also our priorities, so let us very clearly say exactly how this timeline does look so parents know what to expect, and then even some parents that are more in the out years know that more information is coming and that we will be partnering with them to get that out. But for now, Katie, can you just make it crystal clear for us? (00:55:05) What to expect over the next few years. Thank you, and everything I am about to go through we have gone through with all of our school leaders at the spring engagement that Dr. Chang described, so that they were crystal clear about what to tell their teachers, families and students. This year there is no impact whatsoever on graduation requirements. There are no proposed changes, so our current seniors are graduating against the 44 credits and, generally speaking, the five exams to graduate. If the Board of Regents votes to adopt the changes that they have discussed — that were just recently discussed at the meeting — that will decouple the Regents from graduation for students who graduate starting next year. That is our current juniors and below. In addition, there is this move to the one New York State diploma. Right now, which has those exam flexibilities that are primarily used by students with sensory disabilities and some others, the Regents diploma, which is sort of the standard five assessments with scores of 65 or higher, and the Advanced Regents, which will still continue to be an option. Advanced Regents requires students to do a specialized course sequence, some additional Regents exams — quite robust — so that will continue to be an option as an add-on to the one New York State diploma. So that is for students who graduate starting next year, 2027-28. The next real milestone after that is the new transcript, which is targeted for implementation in 2029-30. The State will provide standards about how we will need to go about redesigning our transcript. Our transcript is very standard — course credits, grades, scores — but the idea is to show students' proficiency in the standards and in the Portrait of a Graduate and show a much more robust body of evidence. So that is a few years down the line, 2029-30 for implementation. (00:57:04) Okay, I appreciate you. So I think you already answered how many teachers have been trained. I think it was coming from my... The new system counts YouTube web-based learning and service learning toward graduation, right? Will there be outreach to employers and community partners to create more placements, and is there money in the budget so that we can be effective? (00:57:39) I will share Jane's thoughts on expansion, but I think a very public priority of the administration is, you know, our children are part of the greatest city on Earth and we want to leverage the incredible employment opportunities. Expanding internships is a big priority and we are working through that now, and Jane's work — along with Dr. Chang's advocacy and working with so many partners across the City that are very invested philosophically and financially in the success of this work — is ongoing every day. So as it relates to some of your questions, Jane, if you want to talk a little bit about... (00:58:24) ...expansion. Speaking very specifically to how we are using the community right in our bigger ecosystem: we have built a really strong employer and workforce network through the Pathways Advisory Council, which is a sector-based industry commission, school partnerships and intermediary organizations that connect employers and students. We have what we call a three-legged stool — a three-pronged approach. One is supporting students directly with funding, training and technical assistance to develop local employer partnerships and expand work-based learning opportunities. One of the things that Dr. Chang has really pushed us on is to really consider what is going on right around the corner from our students' schools — where can our students have experiences within their community and not just writ large in larger New York. So we are going to be doing that work. (00:59:05) We also partner with intermediaries such as CareerWise New York to scale the opportunities across industry. Just to give you an example: today, nearly 800 students are participating, and we have distributed over $45 million in student wages and stipends through the career-connected learning opportunities that we have, and that is not even including the wages that we partner with externally. The third piece is to really create new public sector pathways, including the first-of-its-kind civil service youth apprenticeship law, which was passed last winter and is launching this fall with over a hundred seniors across 20 City agencies. Finally, this work is really strengthened through the close collaboration with DCAS and the Mayor's Office of Talent and Workforce Development. Through Career Ready, New York City Public Schools has provided paid summer work experiences to approximately 23,000 students across 230 high schools. We are also really trying to figure out how we couple that with students maybe even earning credit for the work that they are doing over the summer, so that they get ahead before going to college. Then the Work, Learn, Grow program extends those opportunities into the school year. We are working really closely with the Commissioner to make sure that we are growing those partnerships. So as we look at Portrait of a Graduate, students are learning and getting those attributes, but it is also about scale — as much as we can possibly get — so that every student has access. Since it is not my hearing, I am going to stop right there. (01:00:54) But I want to say thank you. That has always been... you have some great folks working. I am so grateful, and I have my superintendent here — my superintendent who is part of and close to my district. We share a lot and I am a fan of education. Whatever you need, whatever I can do — thank you for your time. (01:01:16) Thank you, CM... and equity. Thank you for that. I just have two questions, then I will turn it over to CM Wong. Just to clarify the timeline for students: pretend I am a junior in high school right now. You know, I am a 21 Jump Street situation — going into... no one gets the reference, the old people do. But look it up. They are really trying to find a younger reference for me, but go ahead. Pretend I am a junior — the oldest-looking person in high school you will ever meet. Next year, the Portrait is being implemented. (01:01:59) I took all these Regents. Do I still have to graduate high school the same way, or do I now have to start doing capstone projects and portfolios? (01:02:10) We are not expected next year to stand up a one-for-one replacement for the Regents exams. Our understanding — and as you know, these are not even yet proposed regulations — but our understanding is that what the decoupling means is students must pass their 44 credits to graduate, and within that, of course, there are many ways they are showing their learning in the credit. But there will not be a separate system of assessments or whatever the case may be that students have to complete to meet graduation requirements. So you are telling me if I am a junior right now and my teacher tells me I have got to take the Algebra II Regents, I am going to... (01:02:47) ...tell them no? I mean, we have been very clear in our messaging to... (01:02:52) ...principals. We meet with our point people from the superintendent teams weekly to reinforce that nothing has been decided by the Board of Regents, and we do not want a single student to be impacted by someone saying, "Oh, you do not have to take your Regents." But you raise a good point about the... (01:03:11) ...transition. Yeah, I think the concern is what I said in my opening, which is that without a replacement of equal or more rigor, it is going to turn into a checklist: "Got my 44 credits." Or a superintendent might say, "We are getting pressure to increase graduation rates, so just do whatever you can to pass the kid." Those are things that I have seen in the classroom. Just one other comment — something to be very aware of. Principals have brought up to me that if you go to a high school around here and you mention leveraging the local community, you are around City Hall, you are around the World Trade Center — there is a lot of industry and government access in those two places. I was at an Outward Bound school last year. You know what is around the corner from them? A safe injection site. There is another school in the Bronx — you know what is around the corner from them? A single adult men's shelter. So as we use the word equity, I want us to remember that certain neighborhoods do not have the same access to industry and government and everything else that others do. I want to turn it over to my friend and colleague CM Wong, who keeps track of student attendance. Raise your hand, Mike. First question to the panel. We are good. Okay. (01:04:38) Okay. Here is my question. It is very disturbing for me to see such high rates of chronic absenteeism, and this concerns me because COVID is over — many, many years ago — and yet we are looking at numbers that I thought were harder than the figures I saw during COVID. When you say Portrait of a Graduate, that is the first thing that comes to my mind: did they show up for school? What is being done about that, because I find that we are not doing enough to get kids to go to school. Please answer. (01:05:19) Anybody? Yeah, sure, I will jump in just to say all of this matters the most when we have our children in school with us, for so many reasons. Deputy Chancellor Flavia helps lead attendance and addressing chronic absenteeism. All of our districts have attendance leads and we have, in our schools, designated folks that help keep real attendance practices. Attendance teams — we now have school avoidance liaisons that started this year. We have many structures in our schools to connect closely with families, to help get at some of the root causes of what is keeping our children out of school and to help support families, to the extent possible, to remediate any challenges in getting children to school, in partnership with them. (01:06:18) So do you have a theory on these high chronic absenteeism figures? (01:06:24) I think the theory for our chronic absenteeism is multifaceted. I think it is around a wide variety of different factors, such as... it would take a while to go through all the reasons. We just do not have our attendance data with us right now. (01:06:51) But we will follow up. Yeah, I want to expand on your question on community engagement regarding this. At the September 14 Regents meeting, EdTrust New York testified that schools still do not know how they will measure proficiency in core subjects for current high school students, even though the proposed changes would affect students currently in grades 9 through 11 in less than a year. Regent Hasanni Prats asked what resources exist for parents and students in this purgatory period. So my question for you is: what has been communicated to students and families about this transition? (01:07:38) We are exactly at that point where we are going to be doing much broader community engagement. There has been a lot of work getting us ready at the central level, getting our district teams and leadership... (01:07:49) ...ready, and our principals. We are counting on our principals and our superintendents. They have started engaging their communities at their local meetings, district meetings and CEC meetings. We are talking about it now in our parent leadership structures, and our principals, working with their school leadership teams, are a great and important entry point for explaining what this policy is shaping up to be. (01:08:19) So who is going to take the Regents if they are not getting a Regents diploma? Let us say I am graduating next... (01:08:25) Right. I am going to bring in Katie to address some of the academic policy aspects of your questions. (01:08:32) Yeah, thank you. So the Regents are still going to be administered, and as I was alluding to before, the Regents are still a component of the Advanced Regents diploma, which is still an option available to all of our students. They are also a component of many of our seals and endorsements. For example, we have a Seal of Civic Readiness, we have a Seal of Biliteracy and a few others, and for those, students have to complete a very robust course sequence as well as obtain certain proficiency on Regents exams and complete other expanded learning experiences — sometimes work-based learning — in order to earn those special designations. So the Regents do still serve that... (01:09:07) ...purpose. They are one of many measures that students can use to show what they know and can do. Okay, I have a little time left. I want to move on to career and technical education. The Regents set a timeline for redefined seals and endorsements in the 2027-28 school year, and the Advanced designation is to become a seal or endorsement rather than a diploma type. My question is: what would change? If a student with an Advanced designation diploma gets a seal, how does that work? We use "seal" and "endorsement" as synonyms. It is quite literally a sticker on the diploma, and it would remain alongside all the others I just named. It would remain as a seal or sticker on the diploma. Okay. Committee staff have learned from school leaders that counselors do not know how to program students under the new structure. So what guidance has been given to counselors, and when will more be issued? Yeah, so we already have guidance in our academic policy resources and other materials that we have tried to share with participating schools about what those program requirements are for schools to offer those options. Just to be clear, per the Board of Regents update, there are no new seals. If the State decides to create new seals, we would then turn-key that guidance to our school leaders and counselors through citywide... (01:10:44) ...guidance. All right, thank you. We have also been joined by CM Brewer — say hello. I have to say, you used the phrase that principals are sharing with... I guess I do not have to use that, but principals are sharing with... I have to tell you, I have spoken to dozens upon dozens of principals. None of them know what they are doing. They have ideas, they have... "Well, we have programs, so I think we are well positioned. We offer the Seal of Civic Readiness, so I think we have that element." But they do not have information to share. So can you share some of the conversations that you think principals are having — or that you know principals are having — about what this Portrait actually looks like? (01:11:43) I think when we are talking about the work that we have done with our principals, it has been around: what is this, what does this mean, what is the timeline — and really making sure that that is what is getting out. The questions you are asking go back to your opening statement about what practically has to change in the classroom right now, and that is where we are partnering so closely with the State on what the next iteration of resources and guidance will be, so that we can make sure that we are in full alignment. In the meantime, we have these great examples across the system from Dr. Chang's work and especially Superintendent Prayer, who sat not only on the Blue Ribbon Commission but is bringing this to life amongst his schools. I would be surprised if you are hearing from his principals, but I do not want to be naive and say that every single one of our principals has the depth of knowledge of what needs to change or not and when. That is what we are focused on with them right now — socializing what the four transformations are, what the six attributes are, what they need to know for this year, and what is up next that will guide where we are going, that they will then need to know. So there is a space right now where I think there is a little ambiguity, because we are watching this process evolve. But we know that where we want to really lean in is around our seals, around our endorsements, around the opportunity to demonstrate knowledge, leaning into the performance-based approach that Dr. Chang is an expert on. Would you like to add any more color to that? (01:13:27) Superintendent Prayer, if you will get ready — we will get you to talk a little bit... (01:13:32) ...about your own examples. I think you know this question, which is really: what is it that schools can and should be doing right now? And what is it that principals are thinking? When you say these principals are saying "I have got this idea, this is what I am thinking about," I think that is where we want them to be. Schools must be thinking about designing those rigorous learning opportunities... (01:14:02) ...and how to do that. But how do they design them? I just want to push back. I think there is a lot of ambiguity — I do not think there is a little ambiguity. How are they supposed to know? They can work for a year on a portfolio and then you can come back later and say, "Well, that is not portfolio-based assessment." What is that? I mean, they need some sort of guidance, some sort of structure. I love that schools are going to have more autonomy and reflect their communities, but to some degree it goes back to the standards — there has to be some rubric, something that is standardized, so principals have a direction in which they can and should go and teachers have a direction. We are talking about something that is going to start in a year and there is, to my knowledge, no professional development on what this looks like and how teachers should be shifting their practice. That is what I am concerned about. (01:15:01) I want to highlight that the New York State standards themselves are not going anywhere, and many of our courses do not result in Regents examinations. So this idea that our teachers and our principals have practices in place that already involve multiple measures — that allows us to be able to say what our rigorous demonstrations of what that learning looks like. And sometimes it is through a project, sometimes it is through an oral defense, sometimes it is deeply connected to a college course that they are taking. Those are all different ways that are already in place. So when principals are saying, "Hey, look, I have got this idea of how much more I can do," we want to be able to leverage that and continue to be able to work with them. (01:15:49) But I know you know this. The superintendents go into schools. I have been in the schools. They say, "Show me your ELA. Show me your Algebra One Regents." Like, you know... (01:16:02) That is it. Yeah. What I was saying is, in addition to asking for that information — because that is absolutely crucial and is part of the core foundation of that learning — we are also asking our superintendents to be able to go into the classroom to say, "What are other rigorous forms of demonstration of that learning?" (01:16:22) Where are students deeply engaged, having an ownership of that particular project, and where is that going? We want to make sure that we have these systems where, across superintendencies, they are able to learn from each other and really collaborate across those schools. (01:16:39) So I am going to use this chance to be able to give Michael an opportunity to say a little bit more about what it looks like, because I really want to be able to push on this notion that schools have opportunities to learn deeply from each other. Students are informing and guiding this process along the way, which I think is absolutely crucial. And all of this is building towards these multiple measures really being able to have shared expectations, common rubrics and guidelines — the very things that you have talked about that we need to make sure we continue to be able to do with schools. I want to hear from you. I think I will have to swear you in, but I want to hear what it looks like. Because, you know, we can talk about the idea of good assessment, but it is really important that what has not been spoken about — I think to so many of our teachers and principals — is just what it looks like. Any teacher knows: they have got the project-based learning and everything, and all the time they are asked, "Okay, so I still need to get my kids to pass the Regents. Like, how does this relate to the Regents?" We are measured on something, students are measured on something, schools are measured on something, and we have to know what that something looks like. And as much as I have feelings on the Regents, at least we know what it looked like. So if you could help... (01:18:28) Doing all right. So I had the pleasure of sitting on a Blue Ribbon Commission, and that gave me a lot of insight into what we were doing correctly, some gaps and some things that I needed to improve on in Brooklyn South. I took advantage of the opportunity, having sat in and heard from a lot of constituents, but mostly students, who were eager to share exactly what they felt was missing and yet what they desired to have. Hence was the development of a program called HEAT. HEAT stands for Health Care, Energy, Education, Agriculture and Technology. As a place-based learning program, it creates sustained learning experiences connected to rigorous academic work with professional, civic and historical context. I do want to say for the record — I want to thank Council Member Narcisse for helping me find partners like Con Edison, Maimonides Hospital and a few others. I just want to put that on the record. So what is HEAT? I am going to give you some clear examples of what students are doing. At the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, right around the corner, students travel from Brooklyn to the Federal Reserve Bank. At the bank, students study economics and investigate how markets, government and individuals shape the flow of money and resources. They examine a societal issue through an economic lens, work with professional economists, conduct research, produce a research proposal and defend it before economists and experts. They are there for the whole year. They travel in a cohort of between 18 and 25 students. And I want to say this is not an individual school — this is a collaboration of schools across Brooklyn South. (01:20:16) OK, so 18 to 25 kids throughout Brooklyn South. Thank you. And that is just one. (01:20:22) At Cisco, students study cybersecurity and investigate industry-specific cybersecurity challenges. Working with professionals, students analyze evolving challenges, develop solutions within incident response protocols for a particular audience and present and defend those solutions before technology experts. Students have to understand the content, analyze an authentic problem, design a solution and defend their reasoning. At Maimonides Hospital, students explore areas including women's health, general surgery, pathology and radiology. They work with medical professionals, investigate pressing issues, conduct research, develop a proposed solution and defend their work before medical experts who probe their reasoning. The evidence is not that the students spent time in the hospital — the evidence is what the students researched, reasoned, produced, communicated and defended. We want to attribute to students global citizenship. Now I just want to share a little bit about what students are learning. Students study the Freedom Writers — anybody remember the Freedom Writers? They analyze historical documents, primary resources and oral histories, and examine contemporary connections to civic activism. They produce a scholarly research paper, a civic action project addressing a contemporary injustice and a public presentation that they defend before educators, peers, community members and civic leaders. We are not simply labeling the student as a global citizen — we are examining what the student actually did and produced. Those students trace the footsteps of the Freedom Writers and they travel for two weeks across the South. Then I want to talk about Poland. Poland is very important. Students studying Poland analyze historical documents and survivor testimony, work with Holocaust survivors and extend the inquiry through place-based learning at Holocaust sites in Poland. They produce documentaries and a civic action project and present and defend their work. They actually get to interview living survivors and then produce a documentary. In this course, travel is not the product — learning is the product. Place becomes part of the text. Then lastly, I would just share students studying Barbados and the transatlantic slave trade and its impact on the African diaspora. They use primary resources, historical texts, oral histories, cultural narratives and historical records. They produce a scholarly research paper and a collaborative civic action project addressing contemporary questions of justice, power and inequality, and defend their work at civic showcases. That experience creates the context, the academic work provides the evidence, and those students also travel in a cohort all throughout Brooklyn South for two weeks. They study abroad and that becomes a pathway to Portrait of a Graduate. Thank you. (01:23:50) Superintendent Prayer, I want to highlight that these are things that a given school may not be able to have the resources or the planning to be able to execute on their own. But through the great work of our superintendents, we are beginning to be able to create opportunities. And this is happening — I would love to be able to have more of our high school superintendents and our community superintendents up here talking about that work today. (01:24:19) Yeah, we are all working today. But it is also important to be able to highlight that just because a school may be geographically located in one part of our City, you see here the example of where we are able to bring them, leveraging the entire resources of our City as well as some of the amazing networks and resources across our country and our world. (01:24:41) I appreciate those examples. Now in terms of assessment... (01:24:49) Right. Maintaining the rigor — those are all high schoolers who are doing this? (01:24:52) Yes. (01:24:52) Eleventh graders and twelfth graders. I love it. Great. And how are the rubrics or the assessment criteria developed? Are those approved by you? Are those approved or reviewed or audited by the... (01:25:06) ...central office? Yes, we do work with academic policy. They are also teacher-created. We use the standards, of course, and the assessments are what they publish — what the students actually do to show that they demonstrated the learning for that. But let us be clear, because now we are talking about the students in Brooklyn South being held to the same rigorous standards as students in the Bronx, Queens, wherever. So I just want to make sure: is it a yes that whatever rubric is being used to assess the rigor of those assignments and experiences goes through the DOE and is approved by the central office? (01:25:46) I would say yes, because that is... (01:25:47) Correct. They work... (01:25:48) ...closely with us. So that is great. Now I need to ask about scale. How many students total — you talked about 18 to 25 for the first one — just in total, how many students are engaging in these types of projects? So each year we have about 400 eleventh graders. Some of those eleventh graders, once they go through the program, become seniors and become mentors for the new eleventh graders. Let me ask you: eleventh graders in Brooklyn South — you say it is about 400. How many eleventh graders total are there in Brooklyn South? I probably have about — I would say I have 31,000 students. So eleventh grade is maybe about 10,000? Yeah, about 10,000. I have 31,000 high schoolers. OK, so probably, if it is a quarter, a little less than 10,000 — but fine, whatever, like 7,500 or so. So now we have the issue — one of the other issues that came up — about scale. I appreciate those examples. I know Dr. Chang, you have a lot of examples from your portfolio-based assessments. We have this issue of... (01:27:10) ...scale. Great things are going on in their schools, it is clear. According to your testimony, the rubrics are assessed by something central. Now that has to be expanded to about 7,000 more students in your district alone. What is the plan for that? Or how does the DOE go in to support expanding these types of opportunities to every single eleventh grader who has to complete a project or an assessment like this? Well, again, there are other programs that the students are involved in. We have the Brooklyn STEAM and other programs students are involved in. These are students who might not be involved in one of those other programs but have an opportunity to apply and be selected for what we are offering. (01:27:56) So broadly, what is the plan to scale? Maybe some here — these 400 eleventh graders — but is every single student currently engaged in a portion of the Portrait of a Graduate assignment for each of their classes? I think as part of... (01:28:16) ...this multi-initiative work, we are working closely with our superintendents and our principals to be able to create additional opportunities where they are able to learn from other schools, as well as making sure that the existing opportunities they have — for example, the Seal of Civic Readiness, the Seal of Biliteracy, our career and technical education programs, our higher education offerings and partnerships, our work-based learning and employment programs, our portfolios and panels — there is a wide collection of this work. We want to make sure, first, that every single one of our schools from K all the way through 12 understands deeply what else exists out there. We know our principals and our teachers are eager to be able to learn. So one part of the scaling is ensuring a greater understanding of the existing strengths and assets that we already have. (01:29:09) A second thing is really making sure that superintendents are providing their leadership to their schools to do an asset mapping of what exists across our network of schools, so we can help support and build out. Then finally, we want to be able to recognize the higher achievements and the rigor by virtue of student report cards and transcripts. I think that is an additional way for us to be able to communicate to families what the set of expectations is that we are providing and how they are able to reach those expectations. I want to reiterate that if this is starting in the 2028 school year — the Portrait of a Graduate — we have a school year that is going to start in less than a year. Teachers need to be trained. Principals need to know what they are doing. Without this sort of clarity, I am going to ask about leveraging your assets. But I do want to make a plug: next month we are having a hearing along with the Committee on Higher Education specifically on civics in our schools, including the Seal of Civic Readiness. I will get you excited. I am excited. And First Deputy, you will probably be there too. I do want to plug also — or just remind everyone — that I think two years ago, when I was chair of Higher Ed, we had a hearing on the Seal of Biliteracy. After that, we started giving college credit for students who successfully completed the Seal and had it on their report card. I say that to say that this Council stands ready to work in partnership with you on these seals, and that we have done it. As a Council Member and Chair, I believe in what they could bring to the table. (01:30:59) Thank you, Chair. I also want to just use this opportunity to provide some additional clarity for this particular transition. I hear you use the year 2027. The state requirement with regards to measuring and monitoring progress — Portrait of a Graduate proficiency — does not take effect until the year 2029. So we are committed to and want to be ahead of the curve and already have some great examples. But I wanted to be able to clarify a little bit of that timeline, which is not that all of a sudden in the year 2027 we would have these new... (01:31:42) ...requirements. I think the communication between you, the principals, the teachers and the families needs a lot of work. The reason I say that is because I have lists of pages and pages of notes from the various groups of principals that I have met with, and they do not know a lot of what seems to be the basics. Even though you have gone over the timeline, I think the same basic question of what it looks like in practice is not answered. I want to ask about the assets. At this point in the year, it seems to me that the asset mapping should have been done. Is your asset mapping of all your schools done, or is that ongoing? (01:32:34) So what we do have is a robust sense of the landscape of the different kinds of practices that our schools are already doing. I know you do not want me to repeat all the different ways that this work is already happening. We have our 190 Future Ready schools. We have 150-plus schools that are part of one of our affinity partnerships that have been doing this work. We have our consortium schools that are in our network. So that is one key part of the asset mapping. I do think we also want to make sure that we are taking into consideration the size of the school, what the teacher capacity is and how we can work with that particular community and that need to be able to help support... (01:33:20) ...those schools. I notice from the teacher perspective — when I was a model teacher and peer collaborative teacher, we got extra money. Part of that program was to do inter-visitations. We would visit other schools and bring best practices back to the classroom. How many inter-visitations have been done between these non-Regents schools and portfolio-based consortium schools? (01:33:29) How many inter-visitations have been done between these non-Regents schools and portfolio-based consortium schools? (01:33:52) So that is a practice we have had in years past, whether it was under a Showcase Schools, Lighthouse Schools model or Learning Partner... (01:34:01) No, I know it is done. I am sorry. I just want to really look at it, which is, I guess, when you got the positions. Is that right? We knew the Portrait of a Graduate was coming beforehand, and time and again correctly, we have schools doing great things. The superintendent highlighted a number of good things. What is the structure that is in place to get principals and certain teachers from schools that do not do portfolio-based assessments to visit the schools that do? What does that structure look like and how many inter-visitations have been done between those schools? That is a great question. Of the program that you were in, I learned something new about you every time. I will give you one more when we are done here. How about that. (01:34:53) The regions do not have that program currently stood up. It is a structure that we have been talking about, especially as we want to scale up examples and models for our educators to learn from, so they can replicate. I would say in my former role, where I was leading the professional learning for superintendents and their teams, even before the transition we were jumping into the Portrait of a Graduate work. Part of our professional learning plan with our superintendents, specifically more so at the high school level, was inter-visitations, even as part of the culture of our schools. So I do not think I have — I would have to go back to our agendas and look at how many schools, but Superintendent Prayer hosted a visit for almost every high school superintendent over the last few years. They have been hosting visits and highlighting these practices in the high school world, especially as it relates to the Portrait of a Graduate, with the undergirding of how are you implementing SOLVES, how are you implementing READS. That is where we have concentrated our community superintendents. But I think even before the transition into these new positions, it was the superintendent meeting we were at Lincoln Center. I remember it specifically because Superintendent Prayer, then Superintendent Dr. Chang, and some of our community superintendents did a panel discussion for their colleagues around how they were thinking about what exists in their district and how they are moving it into the conversation of New York Inspires and Portrait of a Graduate. (01:36:28) Yeah, I mean, it seems to me it has to — you know, what does it look like? And then I think it has to look like structural supports from the top, and I do not mean just directives. I mean schools need funding to do this, whether it is coverage for teachers, support for professional development, and by the way support for the consortium schools. We are going to be taking time out of their schedules and conducting, whether it is formal or informal, the structural support and the financial support to our schools to dig into this work. It is work that, so far as I understand, principals and teachers want to do. They want to be engaged with it. They do not want to be left figuring it out for themselves. We have, as you have pointed to time and again, a wealth of knowledge in our city of how to start a Portrait of a Graduate. I think you just kind of have to take a leap and do it and commit the resources and the time and the structure to doing it. I know CM Wong has more questions. I want to turn it back to him. He is ready. (01:37:35) Okay. I served on my school board for four years and I still talk to the current members regularly, and also counsel in high schools. I talk to them regularly. I do not think anybody there has engaged in this process. My question for you is: how are you approaching them? How are they being engaged on implementation planning? And do you have a feedback mechanism that exists for the families? (01:38:06) To welcome Sharon Wrencher in, who does our state partnerships, to talk about a lot of the outreach to date. But I do want to acknowledge that that is exactly the moment we are in. Our next step is having more regular conversations at our local meetings, but also the chancellor and I and the cabinet meet with our presidents, who used to join those also once a month, and really making sure all of our structures have this as a more prevalent conversation. That is on tap and ready to go. But there has been a tremendous amount of engagement that Sharon Wrencher has been a part of, especially in partnership with the state. So I just want to give her the opportunity to share a little bit about that. Thank you. (01:38:55) Thank you, First Deputy Chancellor, and good afternoon. Thank you, CM Wong, and also all of the colleagues who are here to share this information. My name is Sharon Wrencher. I am Senior Executive Director for State and Federal Education Policy and Planning on the team. We use, you know, its First Deputy Chancellor — we like calling her that. Again, thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today. So as our First Deputy Chancellor has shared, we come before you not only as implementers of a state policy but as genuine believers in what New York City Inspires can accomplish. As we continue to describe what New York Inspires is and where we are going with Inspires, just to share with you a little bit of what we have done so far and how we have been engaged with our stakeholders in this process. So as shared, after Commissioner Betty Rosa did initiate this conversation and establish the Blue Ribbon Commission, we did have 10 members who served on the Blue Ribbon Commission, and that included not only our teachers and our parents and our students, but community members who actually represented us. After the Blue Ribbon Commission was established, we held in 2020-2021 stakeholder engagement meetings. Of course, in our city and in every borough, we actually had two in every borough and they were well represented by all of our stakeholders. We heard from our stakeholders, but particularly from our students. I will share with you some of what our students have shared, as well as talk to you about some of the engagement that happened after that. Both current and high school students and recent graduates — and you probably heard this as well, and we have students who are represented here who probably could share some of their same thoughts — they shared very clearly strong opinions with clarity, with passion. They told us that the amount of time devoted to Regents exam prep during the high school years was excessive. They described it as time taken away from learning, from the projects, the internships, the community experiences, the creative and collaborative work that they believed would have actually prepared them for college and careers. The recent graduates were particularly direct about the gap they had experienced. They arrived at the CUNY and SUNY colleges having spent years practicing passing tests and found that college expected something very different from them. They expected independent research, analytical writing across disciplines, collaborative problem solving, creative and critical thinking across ambiguous, open-ended... (01:41:47) ...challenges. These were the skills their professors expected from them from day one. And these were precisely the skills that their high school experiences had given them the least time to develop. Now New York Inspires will give us the opportunity to support them with those skills. (01:42:04) So not only was New York City Public Schools present in the community engagement process and directly represented on the Blue Ribbon Commission, we then held ambassador stakeholder meetings in every borough to share back. There were actually commission representatives who conducted these ambassador stakeholder meetings in every community. We did again hear from our parents, from our teachers, from our school administrators and our students, what they would like to see and how they would like to be further engaged. This is now the opportunity for us to actually engage them further. I will share with you that we are very much engaged, continually engaged in structures across the state, both with the state and with our partners at the Big Five districts and our other partners across the state, as we think about and strategically plan. We also have robust stakeholder representation in those conversations, and that will lead us again to further develop how we are going to engage stakeholders going forward. (01:43:20) Thank you for that. You mentioned one example of students entering CUNY, entering college, not prepared with many of the skills. Are you assessing what skills need to be assessed or taught more rigorously? You mentioned research, for example. Obviously, the Regents do not test it and so our teachers and our schools are disincentivized from investing in that sort of education. Is it the goal to ensure that in any of their portfolios there is a significant amount of research done? Because, like I said, if you are assessing it, it is going to get that investment of time and money. I think Superintendent Prayer shared in the models that he described the amount of research that students were expected to engage in as part of the projects that they were engaged in with the partners. (01:44:13) Absolutely. Yeah, but I just... (01:44:14) ...want to make sure it is the central directive of our goal, not the will of a very good superintendent, which I said on the record. I know your first answer is that all of our superintendents are good. But after that amazing... Say the question one more time for me. I mean, I see the fact that certain skills exist as being assessed in these portfolio-based assessments as different from a decision that research has to be an integral component in a certain number of the projects. So my question is: you mentioned research — I am using it as an example of one of the elements colleges say many high schoolers are ill-prepared for in college. Is it then the department's intention that it is a key component that is actually being assessed and measured? Yes. Okay. And just... (01:45:20) ...that was the easiest answer... (01:45:21) ...ever. And I want to make sure — certain schools report that in the past, rubrics were submitted to the state for a rigor review. What structure does the department anticipate, and at what level — school, superintendent, central — for ensuring the rigor? I heard you say you review rubrics with portfolio-based assessment as your goal. Is it a review of all of the rubrics across the city centrally? So I think I want... (01:45:52) ...to outline the sequence of things and the system that has to be in place. The State Education Department sets out the state standards and for a long time they have said an exit exam for specific courses. But what we will do here in the city is to be able to work with our Office of Policy and Evaluation. We lay out really clear academic guidelines. We have our curriculum and teaching team that works with our teachers and our schools to be able to assess the quality of each of the content areas. Within that, what we are laying out is that as part of this transition, the state has said, across our Portrait of a Graduate competencies, these are specific proficiencies that are critical for students to be able to find ways that they are mastering over time. So what we are excited about doing is to be able to work collaboratively with our schools to be able to say, once that language that the state is able to put out is available, we can then begin to backwards map and say, well, what is the progression for us to be able to get there? We know that this does not only occur in high school. We need to be able to develop research skills in elementary schools as well as the middle school, that then results in a set of standards and progressions that is tailored to each of our grade bands. From there, we will work collectively with our schools to provide the necessary training and norming around what are the different ways that students can use to be able to demonstrate mastery of that particular skill over time. (01:47:28) The DOE is the largest school district in the country. What I am hearing is a lot from that answer of "let us wait and see what the state tells us." I want to use the opportunity to really clarify: as you have heard me say, there are tremendous positive examples and a head start that New York City already has in place. For example, you have heard, and I want to make sure we put on record, that the New York City Performance Standards Consortium has over 30 schools that for over 20 years have had a state-recognized set of rubrics and guidelines that are accepted as just as good, and oftentimes better, examples of what a high-quality bar is. That is backed by evidence and is accepted by universities such as the CUNY and SUNY systems. Through that process there is alignment, validation, norming and scoring that is in place. So I do think — I know they exist, but I think as we have discussed, one element is taking the lead internally and saying, look, we know these things are good, setting up those structures to communicate and to ensure that internally principals are communicating with one another, again with support, the structural support and the finances. But also, as the largest school district, I think it is okay to say, hey, we are New York City, we are doing it right. Dear New York State, this is what it should look like. When I hear that we are waiting for the guidance, we should be really a lot more vocal about what the guidance should look like. I mean, give it. Like today alone, we have these youth journalism students who are here. I know all of the work you do in the DOE, the funding and the counseling. That is what it could look like. Why not elevate these students and say, dear state, it should look like youth journalism — sincerely, the largest school district in the country. That is where I think we should not be waiting and hearing. We should be elevating... (01:49:46) ...these things. Let me make it very clear: I am not saying we are not doing anything and we are simply waiting. We are very much taking the leadership. In fact, much of what the state guidance and their hearings and their feedback processes leverage are the existing strengths that we have. I also think, as the First Deputy Chancellor said, this is the right opportunity for us to be able to provide bold leadership with regards to what we believe is possible. A lot of this will be a commitment to communicating, to be able to help people see those possibilities by virtue... (01:50:22) ...of inter-visitations. But it is also leveraging our students, our student journalists and others, to be able to say this is what we care deeply about. These are the ways in which, through civic engagement, we can help shape the future of what is being expected of a New York City public school student. All right. I know I have spoken a lot about... (01:50:46) ...principals and support for principals and the teachers. (01:50:47) I do not want it to go unsaid: there is an incredible amount of professional development that is going to need to be put into this. That professional development has to be financially supported or created or administered by the DOE. When a teacher spends their time in college, or in grad school, and the first ten or twenty years of their career teaching for one purpose — which would be great performance at the end-of-year test — there is a lot of teaching and a lot of development that needs to go into changing that assessment structure. I hope — and I want to know — I know it is not budget season, but it feels like we are always in budget season. Last school year, last budget cycle, the Affinity contract was under consideration to be cut. It was something that we had to fight to get restored. I also notice in your testimony you uplifted Affinity as one of these networks that supports this type of learning. So can we just commit to not putting the Affinity contract on the table for being cut, if that is one of the networks that is supporting this very type of learning? (01:52:10) ...in our school system. You know, I think last year when we were looking for cost savings across the agency, there were a lot of conversations. I think what really ended up being at the forefront of the conversation was not necessarily the full Affinity contract — we were looking at all sorts of aspects. So we are not in that season yet, but I will take your feedback and I will take your comment also as feedback. We are very, very grateful for our Affinity partners in the work that they are doing and we look forward to partnering with them in the scaling of this work, because they have a real strength and blueprints of how this can look and the kinds of support our schools will need that are not directly working with... (01:53:02) I want to amend what you said. I would not call my feedback feedback. I would call it a supplement to your feedback. On the topic of the budget and the issue of cost savings, one of the things we are looking at in this Council are certain contracts where a lot of the contracts go to private companies. I would just tell you, as you have noted numerous times during this hearing and in our private conversations outside of these hearings, we have a wealth of knowledge in our City. We have the official network. We have the consortium schools, the Internationals, all of these schools, these teachers, these administrators. Together we have a UFT Teacher Center. We do not really need to go outside to private vendors and pay them exorbitant fees to teach teachers and principals things we probably already know internally. What I do not want to see is, as these years come up, finding a hundred million dollars for some private company when we could do it much more efficiently, for much less money and much higher quality, by leaning on our educators that we have currently in the system. I am going to turn over (01:54:17) to CM Wong. Thank you. I have a question concerning the personal finance component of phase two of New York Inspires. That was adopted by the Board of Regents. There is a K-to-12 personal finance education requirement effective in the 2026-27 school year for grades 5 to 12 and then for the 2027-28 school year for grades K through 4. How is the rollout going so far? (01:54:58) Please talk about it. Great, thank you. We had spoken a little bit before about personal finance, so I am going to turn it over to her. I would say I am not sure if we need Delia to come up, but if she wants to jump in and supplement, she leads our curriculum and instruction work. (01:55:19) Are math teachers teaching it, or social studies, or is somebody else teaching this? (01:55:25) Thank you. CM Wong, we talked a little bit about it at the beginning and we did spend a lot of time really teeing up and making sure that our school districts and our superintendents and particularly our teachers were really set up to execute starting this fall for the grade bands that you spoke to. During our summer institute session where we had 1,600 teachers and district champions, we helped to execute what I spoke to earlier. We have selected five pathways. The implementation right now for grades 5 through 12 is that schools can provide instruction through a designated course, an embedded instruction pathway, or a combination of approaches. As a result, the implementation occurs during different grades or semesters during the school's academic program, depending on what their scheduling structure looks like. As students progress through the grade bands, the instruction is going to become increasingly more difficult and complex. What you are teaching a fifth grader is going to be different than what you are teaching an eleventh grader who is applying to college. We have selected several programs. We have worked with and mentioned EverFi before. Another one is Next Gen, Next Gen Personal Finance, because that was one that I knew you would know. What we did was really make sure that we took in the feedback from our schools, because we have been doing financial literacy through the Future Ready program. So are these finance teachers like math teachers or social studies teachers? It depends on how the school wants to actually implement the work. It could be a social studies teacher, it could be a math teacher. We are not designating that. We just really want to make sure, as Sherrod and I talked about earlier, that the programs that we are using are meeting the standards that the State has set up. Thank you. (01:57:24) I have one follow-up. This year the Board of Regents adopted climate education requirements effective in the 2027-28 school year for grades 5 to 12 and for the 2028-29 school year for grades K through 4. My question is: has planning begun for the climate education rollout, and in what subject areas and license areas will it be carried? (01:57:55) Sharon, can anybody answer it? I think I can take that. (01:58:01) Delia, Chief of Curriculum and Instruction. So I think very similarly to the personal finance rollout, what we are doing is taking what the State has said. They have given us clarity around what the standards are for climate education, and then mapping that into curriculum that we already have. What happened for personal finance was they took the finance education that they were already using in pathways. What we are looking at now for the climate education is looking at our science curriculum so that we can very clearly say to schools, speaking to consistency, here is where that lives in the curriculum that you are already using. As you make instructional decisions, make sure that you are leaning into these particular units because we know that those hit the climate education standards that the State has set forth for us. (01:58:55) Pause for one second. I do not think we swore you in. (01:58:58) Did I not? I raised my hand earlier, though. (01:59:01) I am just going to do it now. Do you affirm to tell the (01:59:03) truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth before this Committee and to respond honestly to Council questions? I do. Which means, Counselor, I think you better watch out. (01:59:13) Everything she said before. Okay. I just have one follow-up. Any lessons learned from the personal finance rollout and how would that apply here for the climate education? (01:59:30) So I think we cannot learn fully from personal finance for all of that right now. We just started. But I do think what we have learned from our large-scale implementation of New York City Reads and New York City Solves is we need clarity and guidance from central, and then we also need to create the (01:59:48) guidance and guardrails (01:59:49) before local decisions are made, whether those decisions are made at the district level or at the school level, and then in some instances also at the classroom (02:00:00) level. Clarity and guidance from central is really important. Making sure that we have the materials that are useful, we have the models that we are putting forward, and then we provide the space for people to work through it. I just want to say one more thing. (02:00:13) We have spoken about consistency. I think Chair Dinowitz, that is what you have really been hammering on. Consistency is about the materials, but it is also about the ways in which we work together. We are really thinking about what is the role that central plays in collaborating with districts to make sure they have the guidance, and then what happens at the district level to make sure that the district is creating the space for schools to work together so that they are learning from shared materials and they are able to take what works in one school and transfer and translate it to another school. (02:00:46) Thank you. Just write it down: clarity and guidance from central. I think you said it twice. Thank you. (02:00:58) Thank you. There is certainly a lot more on this topic to discuss. This is, you know, the biggest change I think to high schools and graduation requirements that I have ever seen. We have here the opportunity to turn it into something very special, very rigorous, very meaningful for our students, or we can kick the can down the road and fail. There is one place we should not fail and that is our kids, especially in a system that has so much good experience doing this under your leadership, Dr. Chang, and through all the people on the panel. We have discussed a number of things today: clearly increased communication, increased guidance, clarity and guidance from central, support for the teachers and the principals, and a lot of work that still needs to go into it. I am going to continue to stand ready to work with you and also, as always, hold the DOE accountable because we are again talking about the future of our City. We are talking about our kids and there is nothing that is more important to me. With increased communication, really creating a structure around providing the teachers and principals actual supports and structures for sharing best practices, figuring out how to scale this to the largest school district in the system and leaning on the expertise within our system, I think this really can be something truly transformative for our children and for our City. I want to once again thank you all for coming. I encourage you to stay to hear from our students. There are a lot of youth journalism students here who have patiently waited, and we are also going to highlight some of the incredible work that they do. Thank you. (02:03:06) Thank you so much for the opportunity to add some clarity and have a more public conversation about it, and also to acknowledge that we need to get better at being very clear about what we are doing now and next. That is a promise that is on our checklist. It really is wonderful to have the conversation today, so thank you for it. (02:03:28) All right, first panel, public testimony. If I do not read my script, just so you know, I feel like the meeting becomes illegal and we have to do the whole thing over again. I now open the hearing for public testimony. I remind members of the public that this is a government proceeding and that decorum shall be observed at all times. As such, members of the public shall remain silent. The witness table is reserved for people who wish to testify. No video recording or photography is allowed from the witness table. Further, members of the public may not present audio or video recordings as testimony but may submit transcripts of such recordings to the Sergeant at Arms for inclusion in the hearing record. If you wish to speak at today's hearing, please fill out an appearance slip with the Sergeant at Arms and wait to be recognized. If someone could please close the door in the back, I would appreciate it. When recognized, you will have two minutes to speak on today's oversight topic. If you are a student, please write "student" prominently near the top of your appearance slip. We will do our best to accommodate you and allow you to provide your testimony as quickly as possible. If you have a written statement or additional written testimony you wish to submit to the record, please provide a copy of that testimony to the Sergeant at Arms. You may also email written testimony to testimony at council.nyc.gov within 72 hours of this hearing. Audio and video recordings will not be accepted. I will now call the first panel. Are you excited? Are you excited? Seems a little nervous. No one wants to be the first panel. You want to be the first panel? Are you a student, sir? You are going first, sir. As long as you fill out a slip, you will be testifying. And as always, if I mispronounce your name, I apologize. Just correct it when you speak. Say your name for the record. (02:05:46) Recommendation: Carbio Cruz, Madison James, Olivia, right? (02:06:08) Do you have an order in which you have decided you are speaking? Okay, I will let you all determine the order. State your name for the record. My name is Madison James. And then you begin your (02:06:48) testimony. Good afternoon again. My name is Madison James and I am a junior editor at Murrow High School in Brooklyn, represented by CM Farah Louis. Thank you for hearing our stories today. As a student journalist for five years and now editor in training at the Neuron Network, I have used journalism to help my community ask questions that matter and give people a platform to be heard. Our journalism program has existed since 1974 and I inherited decades of students and teachers who built a culture where student voices matter. Last year I was able to report on how statewide policies are affecting my school, including the class size mandate and new curriculum. I spoke with teachers and students living with those decisions, researching complicated information, listening to different perspectives, communicating accurately. Investigating these policies also introduced me to an interest in pursuing public policy that I might never have discovered otherwise. That is critical thinking. That is effective communication. That is civic engagement. Journalism gives students practical skills for real purpose, not just for another grade on a transcript. Journalism also gives students the ability to critically examine the media they consume, recognize biases and understand how information shapes public life. That is why journalism fits so naturally into Portrait of a Graduate, which calls for students to become critical (02:08:04) thinkers, effective communicators, innovators, global citizens and future-focused learners. Journalists question information and evidence. We interview people whose experiences are different from our own. We find creative ways to tell stories, gather new information and communicate it clearly. We think about how our reporting affects the communities we cover and what we would do better next time. Yet only a quarter of New York City public high schools provide students with that critical experience, limiting whose voices get the opportunity to be heard. If Portrait of a Graduate is preparing students to learn, grow, work and contribute, journalism gives you a place to practice all four. I urge the DOE to make journalism education accessible for every New York City public high school student in the Portrait of a Graduate implementation plan. I have had a microphone since sixth grade. Every student deserves the chance to find their voice and know that someone will listen. (02:09:01) Thank you. I have it after her. Thank you. (02:09:10) Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Sam Harris and I am a student at Brooklyn Emerging Leaders Academy, also known as BELLA. I am a junior and a part of my school's BELLA journalism program, which gives us the space to share stories, ask questions and talk about things that matter to our community. One of the things that has made journalism meaningful to me is being able to write in both Spanish and English. My parents have always encouraged me to learn English because they know how important it is for my future at school and in everyday life. As I learned English, I sometimes felt like I had to choose between using English and holding on to Spanish. Journalism helped me see things differently. I realized that I do not have to choose one language. I can use both. I can write in English and communicate with a wider audience, but I can also write in Spanish and connect with people who share my language and culture. Being in a real-world setting that celebrates journalism means a lot to me. My language is part of who I am. Journalism has helped me become more confident in my own voice. I am not just learning how to write an article. I am learning that my experience, my culture, my language and my perspective are worth sharing. For me, journalism is not only about reporting. It is also about making people feel seen. Being able to use both of my languages reminds me that I do not have to leave one part of myself behind to find my voice. Thank you. I am here for any questions that you might have. (02:11:00) No tengo preguntas. Your words are beautiful in English or español, and that is important. The people from the Department of Education are here too, and they know how important these programs are. Thank you. (02:12:00) Good afternoon. My name is Summer Jarrah. I am a current junior at BELLA, short for Brooklyn Emerging Leaders Academy, which is the only all-girls charter high school located in the Bed-Stuy area. To understand how our school system meets the requirements of Portrait of a Graduate through journalism, one must first understand the International Baccalaureate program. The International Baccalaureate program consists of ten learner profiles, five of which are already aligned with the six key attributes of Portrait of a Graduate, those being critical thinkers, effective communicators, open-minded and reflective. Now you may be wondering where journalism plays into this. The main point here is that students and learners gain the key attributes of Portrait of a Graduate through journalism. Last year I wrote an article for my school newsroom, The Hive, that addressed political stances and the ongoing situation involving ICE. When writing this article I acquired the effective communicator attribute, the critical thinker attribute, the global citizen attribute and the academically prepared attribute from Portrait of a Graduate through journalism. When pitching this idea to Miss Lauren, my journalism teacher, I went through various stages of reporting that included analyzing data, researching and interviewing. Being an effective communicator happened when publishing this article and speaking against the injustices towards my community. Being a global citizen was demonstrated when interviewing the people who are impacted by ICE. All these students and others who have decided to come here and participate are here because they are passionate about including journalism in all schools. Thank you. (02:13:33) Thank you. Hi, my name is Olivia, and I am a senior at Metropolitan Expeditionary Learning School, also known as MELS, and I am a student advisor for our school. When I think about having this type of conversation, I think about my best friend, who is a special person and has my back no matter what. I have friends like her because I go to a special school like MELS. MELS is a place where, to graduate, I have to pass my Regents and demonstrate my learning through projects. Because of the projects we did, it gave me a way to collaborate with other students and helped me learn through a perspective that was not just my teachers. It also gave me a way to make friends, not just outside of school. I know everyone is having mixed feelings about the Regents no longer being a graduation requirement because they are concerned it is going to affect our success in the future and will not be a challenge for us, but I do not think that is the truth. As someone who has taken all of her Regents and does projects to show my learning, I can say that the projects have given me skills to be successful in the future and have also helped me pass the Regents. For example, taking the history Regents was easier for me because I have a love for history, and the projects I made along the way helped me understand and retain the content. In my history class last year, for our final product, we had to get into groups of three to four and put on a performance about a historical figure from the founding era. The project was not only fun, but it also gave me a chance to build team-building skills and public speaking skills and time management skills. Those are skills that I need for work. I think when schools treat everyone the same way, like with the Regents, it is a good thing, but schools can begin to take away from what can really help us students be successful when the main focus is just passing a test. In my opinion, what can help students be successful is teaching us how to learn, collaborate and be social. Math, science, English and history are important, but can we really express this knowledge without having these skills? These skills can start to develop through project-based learning. Thank you so much. (02:15:46) Just raise your hand if you have taken the English Regents, the Living Environment Regents and the ELA. So how does... can you, if anyone, like a quick ten seconds — how does the work compare, like for journalism, to the preparation for the Regents? Any comparison? Whatever. Okay, Marta. Gracias. What else? Okay. (02:16:34) Okay. In journalism, I feel it helps you with the Regents because it is texts and articles. For example, in second period we look at texts. There is a connection between journalism and the text. Looking at a couple of articles allows me to write and helps me understand the text that I am doing. Okay. You have already spoken to him, which is great. Thank you very much. (02:17:18) Thank you for your testimony. Okay. This panel is dismissed. I am going to call the next panel. Thank you so much. (02:17:34) Sarah Vasquez, Leighton, Kiara Kapoor, and so on. (02:17:53) Chair, would you be open to our entire student panel coming up? (02:17:56) How many are there? It is six students, then me and Sophie. That is one, two, three, four, five, six, seven. Pull up another chair. Thank you. Is it Zine Janko? Is that the panel? Charlotte, Zillion, Kamani Mitchell, Julius Marinov... is that person here? No? Okay. In their order, you begin please. State your name for the record and begin. Hello, Charlotte. (02:18:59) Hello. I am Charlotte Orsini, a junior at Bard High School Early College Manhattan. Thank you all for the opportunity to speak today. This summer I interned for the Youth Journalism Coalition investigating Portrait of a Graduate. Sitting next to me are five New York City public school students and two Youth Journalism Coalition representatives from across the city. Today we are going to show you why journalism education is the key to building the skills and scholarly habits central to the Portrait of a Graduate. I go to a school that does not teach to the Regents. We do take the required number of Regents exams, but our learning is focused elsewhere. We take accredited college classes in which we read texts, share interpretations and probe those of our classmates. Those conversations are meaningful because they help me develop my voice and my thinking and teach me how to explore open-ended questions where there is not one correct answer. In other words, I resonate with the potential of a Portrait of a Graduate because I have benefited from this style of learning in my classes. When I joined my student newspaper, the Bard Work, I realized student journalism is a natural extension to these seminar-like classes. Reporting taught me to approach an issue from multiple angles and sparked curiosity about the history of my community that got us to where we are. When the phone policy at my school first came out, I had questions, and I pursued those questions while reporting and writing on the story. I also researched state law and interviewed administrators, giving me the tools to clarify the policy for the student body and to approach the issue from multiple angles. Being a journalist not only enabled me to ask these questions but helped me build communication and critical thinking skills, in this case serving as an important act of civic responsibility. Portrait of a Graduate is a commitment to prepare graduates to think critically and participate in their community. This is a noble commitment I stand for, and I think involving as many high school students in journalism as possible would be a highly effective way for the city to do this. (02:21:03) With the launch of Journalism for All in 30 schools and the summer internship pipeline built through the Summer Youth Employment Program, the infrastructure already exists to make equitable journalism education a reality in Portrait of a Graduate. The Youth Journalism Coalition is ready to work with the Department of Education to integrate this framework citywide. Before every interview, I am a little nervous but excited at the opportunity to learn more. I know that now more than ever we need journalists — students who have a duty to report on the truth, craft it as a team and share it with others. I am lucky that I am at a school with a great newspaper, for which I now serve as opinions editor, but everyone deserves this opportunity. Please help give students in all 500 high schools the resources to engage in an important pillar of our democracy. (02:21:50) Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. (02:21:55) You may begin. Apologies. Is this all right? Good afternoon. My name is Julius Marinov. I am a senior at the High School for Environmental Studies on the Upper West Side. When it comes to our student-led journalism, the Eagle Eye has always struggled with a lack of funding and attention that has left the program to fend for itself. With these concerns, I am uncertain if the club will continue after my graduation. I joined the Youth Journalism Coalition as a student leader to gain more citywide support for journalism education. My time in the coalition has provided me with multiple insights. First, the issues our journalism club faces are not a struggle we face alone, and it is not a lack of student interest issue. There is a deeper, systematic issue at hand. Access to journalism education across all schools in New York City is deeply stratified. In 2022, Baruch College research found that 73% of our city's public high schools lack a journalism program. We do not know where this number stands today, as the New York City Department of Education has failed to provide updated statistics, even though they are mandated to report on this. However, there is a way where not only existing journalism education programs can improve, but the potential to expand to the 73% of schools that lack them. With the release of Portrait of a Graduate standards, one cannot help but notice that journalism already does what the Portrait of a Graduate demands. Last year, I covered the political situation in Burkina Faso in my school newspaper. I had to synthesize geography, history and international relations to write one coherent article. This embodies the standards for academic preparedness and global citizenship — not as concepts on a rubric, but as requirements of the work. Journalism education further tests students on their competency in the digital age. I spent time discerning fact from fabrication during my research. This trained my critical thinking skills more than any standardized test would. Given the limited attention to media literacy in schools, I believe journalism education can serve as a place where both of these issues can be addressed. Yet what I see in journalism education that shines as the perfect analog for the Portrait of a Graduate is upon the completion of a piece. When I finished my article, I made events that seemed so far away relevant to my peers — so much so that I recall students mentioning the figures highlighted in the article months after its publishing. That is the beauty of what a Portrait of a Graduate is asking for: not a paragraph at the end of an essay, but an introspection on the purpose of my words and how they matter and why they matter. If the Department of Education builds journalism into its plan for the Portrait of a Graduate, programs like mine will not have to rely solely on student survival tactics to stay afloat. We will finally have the institutional support to become permanent fixtures in our schools. I want the journalism program that I worked diligently on to continue, not to be on a list of clubs made by former students that are now just memories. We are trying to practice the skills that the Portrait of a Graduate demands, but we need your help to keep doing it. If it has not been demonstrated enough today, the students of New York City want journalism, and the city wants education to change, and I suggest journalism as the solution for both of those goals. Thank you. (02:25:19) Thank you for taking so much time. Thank you for your testimony. I do not have any intention of cutting students off. If you have a little more to say, it is fine. Do keep in mind that we are trying to keep it to two minutes, and the purpose of that is also to ensure that other people have the opportunity to testify. I do want to set up really quickly — you mentioned the journalism program struggling at your school to get funding. I want to highlight two elements. One is that, as the Youth Journalism Coalition knows, for the first time this year we are creating a brand new initiative called Journalism for All, which is (02:25:57) receiving over $280,000 in investment from the City Council to invest in schools like yours to make sure we have these robust programs. I think it also speaks to what I believe — if we do not articulate it, we know that if it is not measured, it does not always get the investment. I love that you are talking about measuring this as part of the Portrait of a Graduate, because once we start measuring it, teachers and principals have more incentive to actually invest in it. The Department of Education has the incentive to invest in it. Even private partners have incentives to invest in these programs. So it is critical that you are here testifying to the importance of including this in the Portrait of a Graduate, and of course I again want to highlight the Council's contribution to this initiative. Thank you. (02:26:51) All right, come on, you are up. (02:26:52) Hello, everyone. My name is Kamani Mitchell and I attend Brooklyn Institute of Liberal Arts. My school did not have a class for journalism, just a small after-school club run by my wonderful teacher, Ms. Rohan. My school was supposed to start a class last year because of student and teacher interest, but our administration chose not to dedicate a teacher to it because they could not prioritize it over academic needs. Because of that, the demand for journalism opportunities outside of school is very high. After-school journalism opportunities like the one I found have a 14% acceptance rate, because it is impossible to meet the demand created by the lack of in-school programs. I feel very lucky that I have had some exposure and have been connected to programs like the Bell Summer Youth Podcast Academy. Journalism has changed me in ways that I could never have seen myself changing before. I could not talk to people outside of my class. With journalism, I began to gain the confidence not only to talk to people who are not in my immediate group, but it allowed me to talk to you all today. Not only that, I have become more involved in my community — not just my school, but New York City overall. I am grateful that I have had the opportunity to receive journalism education, but not many students are offered the same opportunities. In a traditional system, students learn how to read and write paragraphs but are not taught that they could use their skills to make a change, let alone use their voice to speak out. Today we have the opportunity to change that. If we include in the Portrait of a Graduate framework the affirmative values of teaching journalism, principals like mine will finally have a reason to prioritize it. You can make journalism accessible to all and allow students a platform and resources to make a difference. Thank you. (02:28:54) Good afternoon. My name is Sarah Vasquez, and I am an eleventh grader at Urban Assembly School for Media Studies. I am here today to talk about my education and access to it. I developed my passion for journalism in seventh grade at a private school when I was put in the elective by accident. I immediately fell in love with it. Now I am at a public high school that has a journalism elective, but it is treated as an afterthought. My administration and teachers have even asked me to help promote the elective myself because the school does not have the resources to do so. Meanwhile, I picked my school because of its name, Media Studies, but I have not been able to participate in the journalism program because I was forced into other classes to meet testing and graduation requirements. Finally, this semester I am in the elective, but I did not just wait until now to grow in journalism. I took matters into my own hands. Like many, I had to look outside of my school, so I joined the Youth Journalism Coalition. With this opportunity came many others. Last summer I was able to attend the School of the New York Times and study scientific journalism. So when I finally entered my journalism class, it felt wrong — not because I did not want to be in it, but because the class is in its beginning stages and it does not have the resources to support me. I realized that I could have started in that classroom over a year ago, but classes like journalism are constantly pushed aside because the current system prioritizes standardized testing over everything else. Regents exams force us to dismiss information that does not seem relevant to a test. I have experienced having to skip half a textbook just to prepare for an exam six months away, valuing test scores over actual meaningful learning. I am glad the state is taking action with the Portrait of a Graduate, but I need you to take another thing with you on this journey of changing education. Acknowledge that the change that has happened in our history has been because of journalists. We need people to speak the truth, ask hard questions and be our messengers. Journalism teaches us how to do that. Thank you. (02:31:17) Good afternoon. My name is Aziz, and I am a current eleventh grade student at Medgar Evers College Preparatory School. Thank you for the opportunity to speak here. I have decided to be here on a school day to emphasize the importance of incorporating and expanding journalism programs in more schools. I currently attend a school that does not have an active journalism program. We did have a newspaper and journalism club at one point, which died off over time. Through my experience with journalism and as a Youth Journalism Coalition leader, I can confidently say that the lack of journalism opportunities puts us at a disadvantage. Journalism, which started off as a slight interest in me, has become something that has helped me further develop many important skills such as effective communication and an understanding of different perspectives. It is also really important for critical thinking and writing skills, which are crucial for students — the exposure to multiple perspectives and knowing what is going on around them. The reason I have been able to further develop these skills through journalism is because I sought them out outside of my school. Meanwhile, I recognize that not every student has the same access to those experiences. Oftentimes when I bring up journalism, I am met with it being viewed as a niche interest, and some students simply not having enough exposure to know what it has to offer. Making journalism a core part of students' educational experience is possible through Portrait of a Graduate. Through journalism, students can learn civic and critical thinking skills over the years, making it a perfect fit. Thank you. (02:33:01) Hello. My name is PR and I am a junior at the Bronx High School of Science. Thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today. When I first became involved in journalism, I thought I was learning to write articles. I quickly realized I was learning much more than just that. At Bronx Science, I have had access to a journalism program with the resources to let students do real reporting. Through my school newspaper, I have interviewed people, reported on issues I care about, learned how to edit and publish stories for an audience far beyond my classroom. I have had teachers and editors who pushed me to ask better questions and look more closely at what I was reporting. I have been given opportunities to make mistakes, learn from them and try again. These opportunities have changed the way I see myself as a journalist. Journalism has taught me to be curious about what I might have missed. It has taught me how to listen to perspectives different from my own. Most importantly, it has given me the confidence to believe that my questions and my voice are worth pursuing. (02:34:00) But I also recognize that my experience is not universal. I attend a school where journalism has the resources to support and ground their students. Across New York City there are students who are just as curious, motivated and interested in telling stories, but there are schools that may lack a journalism class, a publication and adviser or the resources to support one. A student should not have to attend a specialized high school for the opportunity to discover what journalism can do for them. I know how much students stand to gain from that opportunity because I have experienced it myself. As New York moves towards the Portrait of a Graduate, we are asking what skills students actually need when they leave high school. Journalism answers that question. It teaches students to think critically, evaluate evidence, communicate effectively, collaborate with others and engage with the world around them. Those are not skills students learn by memorizing information for a test. They develop them by asking questions, researching and reporting. That is why I believe the question should not be whether journalism education is valuable. Charlotte, Julius, Kamani, Sarah and others have already proven that it is. The question is whether we are willing to give schools the resources to make that education meaningful. I have seen what a well-resourced journalism program has given me. More New York City students deserve that same opportunity, regardless of what school they attend. Thank you. (02:35:32) Good afternoon. My name is Sophie Mode and I work with the Youth Journalism Coalition. I am also a New York City public school graduate, class of 2021. This summer, I had the privilege of overseeing Journalism for All's newsroom internship program, which placed 36 students in paid internships across 11 local newsrooms. For six weeks, they were hard at work covering local stories through interviews with community members, written articles, photo and video projects and creating social media content. The program established the first journalism pathway in the Department of Youth and Community Development's Summer Youth Employment Program, connecting classroom learning with the professional news industry, and is set to expand for next year. Every day this summer, I was endlessly inspired by these student journalists — the questions they asked, the stories they pitched and the nearly 50 stories they published across their outlets. They are brilliant journalists and incredible contributors to our City. Above all, I watched them grow. One student shared that when she started, she was socially closed off and terrified. By the end, she had made new friends and presented her work in front of a large crowd. Her principal even noticed a difference in how she carries herself in the hallways. During the first week, many students struggled with punctuality, communication and professionalism. By the final week, those issues had completely vanished — from the quality of the emails they sent me to the questions they asked guest speakers. I watched the progression of these students every week. The data reflects this impact: 77% of participants said the program influenced their career aspirations and 90% said they would recommend it to a classmate. I witnessed firsthand not just the ways in which journalism prepares students to be strong graduates, but for what comes next. That is the true Portrait of a Graduate — that they are ready to start their futures after being New York City public school students, having explored their interests, built technical skills and gained the confidence and readiness to take on college and a professional workplace. Is this not ultimately what we want for every graduate — that they build critical skills and habits and a passion for learning, but above all the value of being engaged, thoughtful citizens who feel a responsibility to inform their communities about the things that matter to them? Thank you for your time. (02:37:36) Thank you. Perfect timing. (02:37:40) Good afternoon. My name is Sanchez and I have the honor of serving as the Director of the New York City Youth Journalism Coalition. I want to begin by thanking the City Council on the record for delivering on years of collaboration with our coalition. We have moved in lockstep since our first day in 2024 with CM Joseph, and with today's historic public investment in the Journalism for All initiative. It is profoundly heartening to see the follow-through and leadership of Chair Dinowitz and other Council leadership with the rollout of a Portrait of a Graduate. Our City has a real opportunity to transform our public education system and confront the segregated access to high-quality schooling that divides our communities. But to actually fulfill this vision, schools need practical methods to meet these new standards without undermining quality, burning out educators or leaving out students and families trying to navigate a new system. Journalism for All was built for this. By supporting this initiative, the Council is backing a scalable framework for schools to begin implementing Portrait of a Graduate. As we have discussed, for the DOE to successfully implement and scale these new graduation requirements, they must accurately track school offerings across the City. Last year, this Council passed Local Law 272 to track journalism access in our high schools. Yet the reports released last year and earlier this month are incomplete. It omits clubs and publications, it is missing specific course names and it misidentified which schools actually offer courses — which we know because we have reached out to every school that was reported to have a course in 2025. So as we all look toward the rollout of a Portrait of a Graduate, we encourage the DOE to refine the reporting methodology, empowering middle schoolers and their families to make informed decisions about their high school applications and allowing the City and partners like us to direct resources where they are needed. This work requires dedicated leadership and we trust Supervising Superintendent Allan Chang's expertise and commitment to meaningful, student-centered, future-focused learning. We look forward to deeper collaboration with his team. Because ultimately this is about much more than just fulfilling graduation requirements. Envision a City where every young person has the tools to think critically, communicate effectively and actively participate in our democracy — a reality made possible by ensuring high-quality journalism education is accessible and thriving in every public high school. Thank you for your time and for listening to the students today and every day. (02:39:40) Thank you. So I have two questions. Perfect timing. Also, I think you saw the time going and you started speeding up. Okay, who is your teacher for journalism? Okay, First Deputy Chancellor, you want to hear something? That guy was my high school English teacher, Alexander Thor. I am just saying it is funny. Really? You are learning something new about me every time. And second, maybe from one or two of you, just really quick — can you describe in 15 seconds, has there ever been a time where you felt very strongly about an issue and then through your work in journalism, the researching it, interviewing people, you kind of thought differently about the issue afterwards, maybe even changed your position? Sarah, do you want to share a little bit, just 15 seconds? (02:40:43) Sure. Several people can hear about it. This year, my home country Colombia had a new president and I had initially stuck with one political party for quite a while, until I actually got information from a lot of my family and (02:41:00) friends who saw a different insight. So I started investigating and looking at different news and the facts and everything you can see around it, and I changed my point of view. I ended up supporting the one who is now president. I would say the media influenced me and he actually has a lot of different points of view from the one that I was (02:41:23) What we want all of our residents — not just students, but all of the residents of this country — to do is critically think about the positions and beliefs that they have, second-guess themselves and then do research. I think Sara, you just explained really well that journalism brings that to our country. I know the First Deputy Chancellor cares very deeply about civics education and your story highlights, I think, how deeply interconnected journalism is to civics education. I want to thank this panel for testifying today and I will call up the (02:42:03) next panel: Irving Duato, Melissa Michel, Angel Tejada, Jose Jimenez, Eduardo and Antonetti. Is Antonetti not there? Okay, three seats. We have you assigned. I am not sure. Why do you not go ahead and take a seat? (02:43:01) Okay. Thank you. We will start with you. Would you state your name for the record, please? Okay, wonderful. Thank you for your testimony. Whenever you are ready. (02:43:21) Good afternoon. My name is Melissa Michelle and I have lived in the United States for three years. I am a 12th grade student at International High School at Prospect Heights. I love everything about my school. At my school there is no bullying. We get help when we need it. Advisers and teachers always have support. We fall, we work and push us to do more. Also, our counselors have supplies for jobs and internships. My school has many clubs. I am in soccer, softball, French, Asian crops, dance and the yearbook. At my high school, we have to pass six subjects: native language, English, science, social studies and personal statement. The subject that I enjoyed most was social studies. As a newcomer to New York, I think it is important to know about its history. The focus of my research was on the Lenape, the native people of New York, and why we no longer speak their language. In my research, I argued that forced removal had the biggest impact. A lot of people wanted to read this paper. It was graded by all the teachers and after I passed the paper I was allowed to present it to a panel of teachers and students. It was challenging because they had to ask me questions about what I learned. I had to pass my panel so I could graduate. This helped me develop my writing, research and presentation skills. Another thing that is special about my school is that we work in groups in class. This helps me prepare for the future because listening to different opinions is very important. In my class I have students that speak different languages. There is always a debate going on and that makes the subject interesting. Working in groups makes you open-minded and more social. It teaches you how to solve problems and to be prepared and organized. Another highlight of my school is a partnership they have in 11th and 12th grade. In tenth grade, I was an apprentice with the Beam Center and I learned a lot of things that will help me with my future. They trusted me to be a good leader and a project and group manager. Being in a position like this made me love myself more and motivated me to become a businesswoman. As a leader, I learned how to be someone that people trust, to give voice and share their opinions. Before the experiences offered at my school, it was hard for me to talk in public or in groups. I have always been very shy and I want people to know how I feel. When I graduate, I plan to go to college. I am interested in studying nursing and business. I am grateful to be at International High School at Prospect Heights because they made me confident to express myself. I hope all students in New York City have the chance to present their work like we do and have opportunities inside and outside school to prepare them for college and life. Thank you. Merci. (02:46:37) The Spanish humor. Oh, ha ha. Very nice. (02:46:50) Special things. My name is Ngo D'Hara. We presented my statement so... There are many things in life that can open many more new doors and my school is one of these things. My name is Angela Alexander. I am 18 years old and I was born and raised in the Dominican Republic. I came to the United States less than two years ago with my family, full of hopes and dreams to be achieved. Adjusting to this country was challenging, but I was more focused on continuing my education. I was lucky to find the best school in my life, International Community High School. As a school with many immigrant students, I felt understood and supported. We have counselors and internship coordinators who help us gain experience and opportunities to plan our next steps after high school and beyond graduation. My plan is to attend a four-year college with a STEM major. The number one major I want to study is electrical engineering, followed by mechanical engineering and physics — majors related to what I decided to be in the future: an aerospace engineer. I feel more confident about my future thanks to the opportunities I was offered. My tenth grade internship helped me improve my communication and public speaking skills. In eleventh grade, from the connections I made in my mentorship, I was accepted into a summer academic program for five weeks and learned how solar energy and electricity work. I also learned about photovoltaics and how to solve health disparities using technology. This has increased my interest not only in electrical engineering but also in the ways that knowledge can be used for humanity. Thanks to these experiences, I dream of starting at a highly selective Ivy League program. I wish all students have the opportunities I have had at International Community High School. Thank you. Gracias. (02:49:06) Okay. No, no, no. Okay, so... again, gentlemen. Again, much work happened during English. Okay. Then it would be... thank you. You may begin. Yeah. Thank you. Here. (02:50:07) Good afternoon. My name is Irving. I am 18 years old. I am from Ecuador and I have lived in the United States for two years. I go to American High School at Moreau. What I like most about my school is the way that teachers support us and make sure we understand our work. I also like how my school prepares us for our future. They help us think about college and what we want to do after high school. After I graduate from high school, I want to go to college and study economics or international business. My school gave me the opportunity to take a course where I learned how to communicate effectively in the world of international business and that made me interested in learning about economics. I want to learn more, improve my skills and have a good career in the future. One school experience that has helped me a lot is doing presentations for our portfolios. These presentations have helped me feel more comfortable speaking in front of others. This is important because I will need this skill for college interviews and my future career. For example, my social studies class was very interesting because we studied the harmful effects of vaping on young people. It helped me learn more about the risks of vaping and its (02:51:37) effects on young people. When we do portfolios, which was a topic I chose, I share organized information and present it to other people. From that experience I learned how to communicate better, organize my ideas and speak with more confidence. I have also learned how to connect what you are learning in school to real life and our society. Thank you. (02:52:05) Gracias. Low key but effective English. (02:52:07) I was just so impressed. I am really taken by it. Thank you for your testimony. (02:52:15) Thank you. Esteemed Chair Dinowitz and members of the Committee on Education. My name is Edward Antonetti. I am Senior Director of Advancement and Advocacy for Internationals Network. But today I would like to share my testimony, my perspective as a longtime educator. I started my career as a proud New York City public school teacher about 30 years ago at Brooklyn International High School. Since then, I have worked in four school districts in New York and Pennsylvania as a teacher, school administrator and district leader. I have the unique perspective of having helped develop and implement Internationals' performance-based assessment system, including graduation portfolios, and also having taught Global History Regents courses and scored Regents exams at a traditional New York State school, where the Regents forced me to fly through a one-size-fits-all curriculum, teach a decade or more of history per 44-minute class, skip time-intensive projects that promote deep learning, and teach to the test. The Internationals approach instead allowed me to tailor the curriculum and instruction to best meet students' diverse learning needs. The Internationals performance-based assessment system allowed me to challenge students to engage in academically rigorous activities, to demonstrate their learning in meaningful and authentic ways, and to reflect upon and have real ownership of their learning. I mentored small groups of seniors as their graduation portfolio advisor and got to know them well, so I could provide individualized support as they worked towards academic excellence. Working with my colleagues at Internationals, we have developed rubrics, guidelines and best practices that are strongly aligned with the Portrait of a Graduate framework. The Portrait of a Graduate should not be reduced to just decoupling from the Regents exams or simply hiring a college and career coordinator. It is an opportunity, and New York City and Internationals Network and our affinity partners stand ready to provide support for this initiative, because the education and futures of New York City students are at stake. (02:54:10) Thank you. Well, thank you so much. And last on this panel, all right. (02:54:15) Good afternoon. Chair Dinowitz and members of the Committee on Education. My name is Jose Jimenez. I am a proud graduate of International High School at LaGuardia Community College and Senior Director of Finance and Operations of the nonprofit Internationals Network for Public Schools. Internationals Network and affinity partners support the network at 17 schools in Queens, Brooklyn, the Bronx and Manhattan, as well as a national network of schools for newly arrived immigrant multilingual learners. Internationals Network also partners with other schools, districts, educators and leaders beyond that network to put our proven approach into practice. When I entered International High School as a 12-year-old immigrant learning English, I was not asked to wait until my English was perfect before taking on challenging work. I learned language and academic content together through hands-on projects, collaboration, presentations and experiences beyond the classroom. Those experiences taught me to communicate across differences, solve problems, reflect on feedback and take responsibility for my learning. I went on to graduate from college and graduate school, the first person in my family to do so, and to devote more than 20 years to public service. To me, the six attributes, including academic preparation, critical thinking, effective communication and global citizenship, describe the education I received and the approach Internationals Network has helped schools and educators put into place for decades. As New York expands the ways students demonstrate learning, portfolios, performance-based assessment, project-based learning, work-based learning and early college experiences can make graduation requirements more meaningful. Newcomer multilingual learners deserve rigorous opportunities to show what they know and can do, while developing English, with their potential not reduced to one test score. I urge the Council and New York City Public Schools to recognize Internationals Network, our network's schools and the many schools and educators who support newcomers in New York City as models and partners in this transition, including students and alumni. Thank you. (02:56:28) Thank you. And to all the adults here, you can always submit the rest of your testimony in writing and it will be on the record. I would like to thank this panel for testifying today. Gracias. And next we have Tabitha Peterson, Eric Lee, Ryan Bayda and Seaver Chen. (02:57:13) All right. Listen, OK. Whenever you are ready we will start. Unless you have an order you preferred, we will start from my left, your right, and go down. (02:57:29) Good afternoon. First I want to thank Chair Dinowitz and the rest of this Council for allowing this conversation. My name is Seaver Chen and I am a senior at Curtis High School. I am also a youth advocate with the Asian American Student Advocacy Project, which is a youth leadership program. To me, being academically prepared goes beyond knowing the answers to pop quizzes. It means being able to go to school knowing you will be given the tools to learn to your full ability. It also means going to school knowing you have an environment where you feel safe, physically and mentally. A student's learning environment is important for shaping social and communication skills as well. But in order to become an effective communicator, students need a space where they are able to express themselves freely without any sense of judgment. And as of today, this is just not the case in a lot of our schools, therefore making it more challenging to become academically prepared and an effective communicator. On a personal note, I experienced this feeling in middle school. As an Asian student in a predominantly white school, I was the target of many discriminatory jokes, met left and right with comments about my eyes and my expected grades in math. It felt like a hopeless situation, and part of the humiliation was due to not having an environment in my school where I could talk about these issues along with my feelings. This was especially apparent when I brought up being the target of a racist joke to school faculty. They simply brushed it off, gave me some tissues for my teary eyes and assured me I would be fine since the student who called me that would be moving away anyway. A few weeks later, he moved away and we had a generic assembly about stop bullying. I was not seen, my feelings felt invalidated and my true needs were not met. What happened to me has been lived by countless students, especially from the Asian American community, across generations. When students feel that they do not have anywhere or anyone to turn to in their learning environment, they continue not to speak up about it. In my situation, I left the office thinking, what good would speaking up do? And this further causes race-based bullying and harassment to persist in schools. In order to combat this, we need to invest in giving students a space where they know that incidents such as these will be responded to with empathy, communication and (02:59:31) accountability. Where restorative justice programs are implemented in schools, they provide students the space that they are looking for, along with a culturally responsive adult that they can feel free to talk to. A simple conversation focused on my feelings and the impact those words had on me with the other student would have meant infinitely more to me than a broadly centered assembly. We need to ensure that more schools continue to implement restorative justice programs and improve their school culture in order to create a space where students can arrive every day academically prepared and ready to learn and to effectively communicate. Thank you. (02:59:58) I do want to highlight that the administration proposed a budget that actually cut restorative justice programs, and it was this Council that got restorative justice programs funding restored, along with the mental health continuum. I appreciate you talking about the bullying and race-based bullying because it is something that we do not have good reporting on, something we have brought up with the DOE. It is work that continues to need to be done, but I appreciate you bringing that up. Thank you. (03:00:29) Good afternoon. First I want to thank Chair Dinowitz and the rest of the Council for allowing this conversation. My name is Ryan Bayda and I am a senior at Jamaica Gateway to the Sciences High School. I am also a youth advocate with the Asian American Student Advocacy Project. In my perspective, being a global citizen is being open to people who come from different backgrounds and understanding that everyone has their own unique experiences. This means actually taking time to listen and learn from others. I was born in the Philippines and only recently moved to New York in 2022. As one of the few Filipinos in my school, I felt isolated. I had nobody else who could relate to my experiences and it felt like I did not have a community in school. My peers made assumptions about me based on my identity and expected me to fit certain stereotypes, like being smart and quiet. If my school had prepared us all to be global citizens with an inclusive curriculum that helps students learn and understand different backgrounds and experiences, along with support to help students like me navigate cultural changes, I would have been better prepared to thrive academically and socially. Being a global citizen requires us to be reflective and future-focused as well. To me, this means being able to look back on my own experiences, recognize how they shaped me and think about how I can use what I learned to make things better in the future for (03:01:48) others. When I was stressed or struggling, I could feel like I was supposed to handle it all by myself. These experiences made me realize how difficult it can be to take care of your mental health when you do not always feel comfortable speaking up or showing that you are struggling. I know many other youth like myself have felt the same way. Many students deal with stereotypes, academic pressure, cultural expectations and stigma around mental health. The model minority myth pushes this even further by making students feel like they have to struggle on their own. Schools have a responsibility to help students become global citizens, reflective and future-focused, but they often put so much focus on grades that students do not get opportunities to learn about different cultures, the time to have meaningful conversations or to reflect. Through this, students can become more understanding of others while also learning how to take care of themselves and their communities. Thank you. (03:02:49) Hello. Good afternoon. To begin, I would like to acknowledge and thank Chair Dinowitz and members of the City Council for allowing this conversation. My (03:02:55) name is Eric Lee and I am currently a senior at Queens High School for the Sciences. I am also a youth advocate with the Asian American Student Advocacy Project. I believe that academic preparedness plays a crucial role in helping multilingual students like me thrive. As a student, being academically prepared does not simply mean having access to the information needed to succeed academically. Rather, it means having access to the resources necessary to learn without fear or self-doubt. Multilingual students require much more than just translation. They require instruction that acknowledges their identity and supports them through teacher training that specifically addresses multilingualism and the diversity of language backgrounds. Secondly, for me an effective communicator is someone who has a supportive environment to communicate their thoughts and ideas, regardless of cultural or language barriers. Students should be able to express themselves freely without concern about the judgment of others based on their language skills. Schools should provide an environment where all students' voices are valued and where language differences or barriers do not limit the voice of a student. As a student from an immigrant community, I frequently translate school documents for my parents. In addition, due to the lack of systems supporting immigrant families at school, I had to act as a translator between my family and teachers. I have also observed that some of my peers refrain from speaking up during class conversations because they fear how their broken English will be judged. These examples are not unique to my own story. When students are denied adequate language access, they are unable to fully participate in class discussions, restorative justice circles or collaborative learning activities. When schools assess test scores and graduation rates as indicators of student success, they do not assess whether students are being adequately supported or if they believe they have the ability to speak up. With pressure placed upon teachers to prepare students for standardized testing, opportunities for educators to engage students in restorative practices or multilingual engagement continue to decrease. We need to invest in real language access, from translating materials to inclusive school environments, so every student can participate fully as an effective communicator. We need to embed a culturally responsive curriculum, including history, so students feel represented, supported and academically prepared. Finally, we need to measure belonging, not just test scores, so schools are held accountable for creating environments where all students can learn, speak and thrive. Thank you. (03:05:05) Thank you. I do want to highlight two important things. One is you have Queens High School for the Sciences — all right, we have a great graduate right here. Our committee counsel Alejandro Carbajal also went there. He just graduated two years ago, so he is, you know, the same age as you. And also, I think it is so important for all the different communities around our City to be seen and heard, and that is why this Council has invested, I think at this point, millions of dollars over the years in the curriculum. So we are doing this work in this Council, but of course it means nothing without students like you coming to testify and sharing your voice. So thank you for testifying today. (03:05:43) Last in this panel. Good afternoon. First I want to thank Chair Dinowitz and the rest of the Council for allowing this conversation. My name is Tabby and I am a junior at Brooklyn Technical High School and also a youth advocate for the Asian American Student Advocacy Project. What does it take to create a truly safe space? Well, a whole bunch of factors, really, with two of the most important ones being critical thinking and cultural awareness. I understand critical thinking to be the ability to take in your surroundings with observations and create thoughtful (03:06:14) inferences based on what you observed, and I define cultural awareness as being thoroughly educated on your own social identity and how it can impact your interactions and relationships with others. (03:06:25) When I walk into the classroom, the first thing I want to be is open-minded. Not only does this make classroom conversations more conducive, but it also lets the people around me know that their presence is welcome. Being aware of my cultural background, like my race and ethnicity, and how it can indicate ways in which I am similar and different from my peers, grants me the ability to ensure that I am creating an inviting space for everybody. Unfortunately, a common problem that minorities face in the classroom is a lack of knowledge about their own history and impact in America. In the case of the Asian American community, there is a severe lack of inclusive curriculum. This in turn makes it difficult to foster a thoughtful environment and perpetuates discomfort for the community and other minorities while in class and even in their everyday lives. I can say that I have witnessed firsthand the result of cultural unawareness creating misunderstanding and discomfort in my own community. (03:07:19) Often in the Black Student Union of my school, there is talk about the demographics of the student body and how it makes us feel uncomfortable. One time there was a conversation that mentioned how the majority of students in the school are Asian. Because of what I have learned in spaces like ours, I could see how the model minority myth had harmfully impacted and shaped the conversation that unfolded. Now if our school included Asian American history into the curriculum, students would be educated on the model minority myth and learn that it is completely untrue and should be dismantled. While minorities focus on bridge-building and solidarity, although our struggles are different, minorities should be able to find community with each other instead of fighting to be second place in a hierarchy that should not even exist. This is (03:07:55) just one example of how inclusive curriculum and a shared understanding of cultural differences can help support critical thinking, cultural awareness and ultimately school safety for all students. Thank you all for your testimony today. Seeing student leaders come up here and testify is really inspiring, so thank you for coming up today. I am going to (03:08:14) call the next panel: Arianna Misha, Jeannie Ferrari, Xavier Otero, Bashir Zara, Vera Shingles, Leah, Eric Levine. Thank you. Good (03:09:16) afternoon, Chair Dinowitz and members of the Council. My name is Jeannie Ferrari. Since 2012, I have had the privilege of leading two New York City public schools, both Humanities Preparatory Academy and the Beacon School, as principal. (03:09:31) Both belonged to the New York Performance Standards Consortium, a 30-year network replacing high-stakes Regents examinations with performance-based assessments. Instead of asking students to cram for a one-size-fits-all test, we prepare them to research, write and orally defend what is essentially a college dissertation across four core subjects. Students must present their findings to a panel of educators and outside evaluators who ask rigorous, unpredictable, on-demand questions on the spot in a way that simply cannot be faked. The process demands critical and creative thinking, clarity and the capacity to communicate your ideas effectively to an outside audience. Every single college graduate who has returned to visit me over the years says the performance-based assessment process is the single most important factor that prepared them for their college education. None of this would be possible without our innovative district structure, which allows our 38 schools to collaborate across boroughs, unifying aligned grading rubrics and providing the professional development that teachers need to uphold this model over time. To sustain our work and make it a true blueprint for how the City's transition to a Portrait of a Graduate could work, our schools must continue to collaborate within the unique Consortium, International and Outward Bound districts, and continue to partner with the New York Performance Standards Consortium, who provide the professional development that upholds this model and ensures its high quality across our schools. (03:11:07) I am grateful to the New York City Department of Education and the City Council for your time and your leadership. Thank you. (03:11:18) Hello, and members of the Council. My name is Exam Otero and I am a senior at Middle College High School, which is located on the LaGuardia Community College campus in Long Island City. Middle College is a school of the Consortium. The Middle College system of performance assessment is helping me with all the portfolio and Portrait of a Graduate components, but I want to focus on how it made me an effective communicator and reflective and future-focused. I came to Middle College from a very traditional middle school where classes were test-driven and focused on passing the Regents exams in eighth grade. Because I was good at math and computer science, and because all my classes were focused on individual work, I assumed my future job would be sitting alone in a room working for a company. I was very shy and nervous to talk to others, especially adults. My outlook completely changed at Middle College, where my ideas and individual personality were taken seriously. Teachers focused on pushing students' individual passions. I was also allowed to make choices about what I wanted to study and focus on. I wrote my social studies performance-based assessment on how entrepreneurs like Elon Musk should not be given power in government, such as DOGE. In our classes, we are expected to work with our peers. Teachers frequently refused to answer questions, telling us to talk to each other and work through our confusions. It pushed me out of my comfort zone but made me a more collaborative thinker and made me more confident in advocating for myself. This new independence and freedom made me feel excited about what I learned because I chose what I learned. I have also built skills of planning long-term projects, organizing papers, managing deadlines and so on. The freedom also allowed me to plan for the future and take classes that would help me most. I am enrolled in several college classes and well on my way to my associate's degree. I no longer see myself alone in a room. I work in the community helping others. I plan to become a firefighter and perhaps get a degree in psychology. I will be happy to answer any questions you might have. Thank you. (03:13:25) The next speaker. (03:13:30) Members of the Council and everyone present in this room, my name is Arianna Misha. I am a junior at the New York Institute for Collaborative Education in Manhattan, a member school of the Consortium. I began in ninth grade at a traditional high school, which left little time for extracurricular activities that had always been important to me. I had to quit debate, which I had done for five years, because everyone was just trying to pass tests. I started going to NICE in tenth grade. I am sure I am learning a lot more than before because NICE treats students' pathways first, into whatever their passion is, in and out of school. My humanities teachers organized a Model United Nations conference in the class rather than just teaching in a traditional way, and this inspired me to follow my passion for civics and take up Model UN as my extracurricular activity. I also had the opportunity to serve as a youth delegate at the General Assembly at the United Nations headquarters. I am currently on the debate team and the president of a club, and I consider myself a true global citizen. NICE has allowed me to take my interests in an academic direction. For my neuroscience panel this year, I will be (03:14:29) looking at how involvement in political activities at an early age has a long-term effect on brain and personality development. We as students are not bound to learn only one thing determined by someone else, but rather we get the chance to choose our own passion. By making every work reflective, all Consortium schools, including NICE, have addressed the use of AI during the performance-based assessment process. Our works are project-based, which does not always make us need to use AI. Last year I carried out multiple advocacy efforts, which include fighting against climate change and being part of a national and international Sustainable Development Goals campaign. My school for me is a place where I grow and learn by interacting with my teachers, addressing them by their first names, and gaining confidence and collaborating with my peers for every project, while also being highly active in different social and international activism. The goal of education should not be to create students who know how to pass the test. It should be to create graduates who can actually change the world. Thank you so much. (03:15:31) Thank you. Next speaker. Thank you. My name is Bashar Era. (03:15:42) I come from a country where education access is limited and where students attend different types of schools. Growing up in the Gambia, I attended a madrassa and a public school where the curriculum focused primarily on religious studies. I had little exposure to English, science, history or mathematics. I moved to the United States in the summer of 2017. I had one goal at the time: to enroll in an American high school and learn English. I vividly remember going with my uncle to Fordham Plaza to register for school. I wanted to attend a traditional American high school because one of my friends attended one at the time. During the registration, the person assisting me tried to have a basic conversation with me in English. Although I understood some of what she was saying, I could not respond. She paused for a minute and recommended International Community High School in the Bronx, explaining to my uncle that given my level of English at the time, she did not believe I would thrive in a traditional American high school. That recommendation changed my life. When I arrived, I learned to meet the academic expectations of an American high school. At the time I was only confident writing my full name in English, nothing else. I still remember being introduced to tenth-grade algebra with equations with x's and y's instead of just numbers. I remember thinking this cannot be math. I had barely learned addition, subtraction, multiplication and division in Arabic, and suddenly I was being asked to solve equations. It was intimidating at the time, but my teachers saw potential in me and gave me support and encouragement to develop as a thinker. I learned from Cora, a first-year English teacher who introduced me to reading and writing through Greek mythology. I was fascinated by the stories because they were different from what I had encountered in my Arabic studies. At the time I was struggling to read and write. Cora was patient with me, including me in writing full sentences and paragraphs in English, and pushed me to express my ideas even when I was struggling. Similarly, my mathematics experience was equally transformative. I began working on performance-based assignments, not just exploring the Zeno spiral and the relationship between the finite and the infinite. At first I struggled, but the project gave me something I had rarely experienced in school before: permission to be curious, ask questions, experiment and find my own path. I became so absorbed in the project that I would work on the equations on the train between work and school. I explored and developed equations and eventually wrote more than 20 pages. I presented my research before a panel, explained how I developed my equation, defended my research findings and connected an abstract mathematical problem to broader equations about real life, including Nelson Mandela's struggle for freedom and justice in South Africa. (03:18:46) If you could just summarize your last points. (03:18:49) Yes, I will. I know this is a long one, but to summarize: the Consortium school experience has given me an opportunity and made me who I am today. I just recently graduated from the University of Cambridge with my master's in philosophy in International Development Studies, and without the Consortium school experience at the community high school, I do not think I would be here. I think my path would have been completely different. I am really grateful for the (03:19:19) experience. Thank you. Hi. My name is Perishing Yellow Shelley. I am a mom of a graduate of Urban Academy and a current student there as well. I know immigrants are not the most popular group in America right now, but in New York, families like mine are not the exception. We are a huge part of this City. We fled another country when we arrived. My daughter was one of the many children who had started over here after their whole world had fallen apart. For a child, that feels like landing on Mars. I think the most important thing a school can do for a child is show her that not everything is gone: that there are adults who listen, that questions are still welcome and that her voice still belongs to her. A child in that state probably will not show her best thinking on a timed test on a stressful morning, but give her time, a hard question and a teacher who pays attention, and you will see what she can really do. You cannot teach values through a test. They grow through practice: through writing an essay for the first time, defending an idea, fighting for your argument. That is what performance-based assessments ask of students. It is not the easy option and no one does it alone. It takes teachers, classmates, a community. The Davis scholarship studies at Cooper Union have entrance days where they give students a few abstract problems and four weeks to turn them into original concepts. Drawing the answer was not enough. They wanted to see whether she could think. Her Consortium school had prepared her for exactly that. You know that parents are anxious people. They are always checking the next goal: high school, college, good job, good salary. You rarely stop to ask why. Immigration made me stop. When you are running into the unknown with two kids and two suitcases, you remember very fast what matters. We want our children to be free, honest and brave. As someone who fled an authoritarian country, I can tell you that people do not become free, honest and brave by learning to choose the correct answer. Thank you. (03:21:40) Thank you. I do want to address something. I know that comment about immigrants being the most popular group right now was probably meant as a funny little joke, but I just want everyone watching to know that my office, the Council and the Department of Education do an incredible amount of work to celebrate and uplift our immigrant community because they are so loved. It may not feel like that in the White House, but it is certainly that way here in New York City, and I want everyone listening to know that. Thank you so much for your testimony. (03:22:16) Good afternoon. My name is Eric Levine. I teach ninth grade social studies and lead the U.S. history department at Harvest Collegiate High School, a Consortium school near Union Square. I became a teacher partly because I hated school. My parents put a great deal of value on education and moved me and my siblings just north of the City to Rockland County due to the reputation of the schools there. The high school I attended still hovers around the top 50 high schools in the state, and it was a miserable experience for (03:22:36) me. At no point in those four years did I feel like my individuality was honored, that my interests were encouraged or that I was learning what I would need for after graduation. As a teen, I became very interested in politics and current events. I wanted to get involved in the world around me, but my high school never offered an outlet for me to explore that. Instead, much of my time in high school was spent preparing for the New York State Regents. I often wondered if there was not a better way to educate students. So imagine my excitement when, just weeks into my training as a teacher, I found that there were dozens of schools working together to do something better than the Regents. Once I learned of the New York State Performance Standards Consortium, I never wanted to be or teach anywhere else. In the past 11 years I have visited many of those schools and in every single instance thought to myself, I wish I went to high school here. I taught at a traditional Regents school for a few years waiting for the opportunity to work at a Consortium school. My time was filled with prepackaged curriculum, rushed lessons in units and a lack of rigorous, deep thinking for my students. I did what I could, but at the end of the day they needed to pass these tests. My school bragged about its high graduation and acceptance rates but never reflected on or commented on its low college retention rates. That model simply did not prepare students. Consortium schools like mine better prepare students for what they will encounter after they leave. I have the freedom to design classes that are responsive to their interests and lives, that are deep and rigorous and that are rooted in skills that will set them up for success after they graduate. There is no mad dash to cover 300 years of human history in nine months. Classes become living, breathing things that push students to think deeply about the world around them and make connections to their own lives. These classes prioritize critical thinking, reflection and effective communication, as do the project-based assessments they lead to, preparing students to be the global citizens that we hope they would be for the rest of their lives. Working in a Consortium school allows me and my colleagues to provide the kind of educational experience to hundreds of students that I wish I had been able to have myself. (03:24:21) All right. Thank you. I would like to thank this panel for your testimony today. I really appreciate your stories. I think for the next panel we will call Randy Levine, Daniella Souza, Sherry Gibson, Nelson Jordan Pineda, David Bloomfield and Kimberly Olson. Thank you. We will go in order from left to right, my left to my right. (03:25:28) Start with David, and just remember to say your name for the record. Yes. Hello. My name is David Bloomfield, Professor Emeritus, Brooklyn College and the CUNY Graduate Center. Thank you, Chair Dinowitz and members of the Council. Simply put, nothing in last week's Regents meeting gives confidence that the state is ready to define the Portrait of a Graduate's blurry outlines. Surprisingly, staff even stepped back from their signature position of eliminating Regents exams, despite a deputy commissioner's memorandum that the exams are inappropriate as graduation requirements or even for grading. They now insist that the exams persist to align curriculum to learning standards. Such a proposal would return districts to teaching to the test, the very problem Portrait of a Graduate was meant to reform. My urgent request is that the Council recommend a pause in the Regents' promulgation of regulations tied to Portrait of a Graduate until the field can fill in the blanks left unrealized by State Ed. Call it a clinical trial for Portrait of a Graduate's aspirations before regulations set its structures in stone. Of particular importance is attention to the needs of multilingual learners, students with disabilities, other groups and local circumstances, which State Ed has largely ignored in its overall plan. New York City is well positioned to act without State Ed imposing mandates clearly not ready for prime time. Deputy Schools Chancellor Alan Chang has strong experience as a former superintendent for Consortium, International and Expeditionary Learning schools. It is a basis for Portrait of a Graduate's emphasis on project-based, experiential curriculum. We are well along in planning without premature state mandates complicating the work. By putting graduation standards in the hands of educators, not standardized test vendors or politicians bent on inflating pass rates, we can bring sanity to an era when gimmicks like credit recovery have substituted for teacher judgment. Thank you very much. (03:27:54) Thank you to Chair Dinowitz of the Education Committee and the New York City Council for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Annie Nelson and I am a policy analyst at Children's Aid. For over 170 years, Children's Aid has worked to ensure that young people face no limits to their aspirations or potential. Today we serve nearly 50,000 children, youth and families across more than 40 sites citywide, including 19 community schools. As an organization that works in schools and with young people across some of the City's most under-resourced neighborhoods, we know that our education system is not yet preparing every young person for post-secondary success. We support the intention behind the Portrait of a Graduate to reimagine the skills that young people need to succeed in college, career and civic life. At the same time, changes to graduation requirements should not diminish schools' responsibility to ensure that every student has access to a rigorous and high quality education. Its success depends on ensuring that all students have the experiences and supports needed to develop the Portrait's core competencies. The community school strategy can help make this possible by expanding relationships, enrichment opportunities and academic supports that remove barriers to academic opportunity. The Essentials for Community School Transformation, developed by four partners including the National Center for Community Schools at Children's Aid, provides a framework for creating these school-based conditions through practices including expanded learning, community-connected instruction, integrated support systems and student and family engagement. We see these practices in action across Children's Aid's community schools. At Central Park East, project-based learning and after-school programs connect academics to real-world challenges. At Fannie Lou Hamer Freedom High School in the Bronx, college tours and career exploration help students connect their learning to their futures. In two of our schools in Washington Heights, through student governments and training in participatory action research, students can use critical thinking skills to identify issues in their school communities and use their findings to drive change as emerging global citizens. Based on these experiences, we urge the Council and New York City Public Schools to first establish 100 new community schools by fiscal year 2029, prioritizing schools where students face the greatest barriers to opportunity. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. (03:30:06) Testify. Thank you so much. I told you I would be a little tougher on adults than kids, so all right. (03:30:16) Okay, you know. (03:30:22) Sure. Go ahead. Good afternoon. My name is Daniella Egorov and I am a New York City public school parent and a fellow at the Manhattan Institute. Since the 1800s, New York's Regents exams have indicated academic excellence and rigor. Generations of New York... (03:30:38) ...students have studied hard. The New York Board of Regents will eliminate those exams, and Board Member Felicia Thomas-Williams said that, quote, you do not assess a fish on climbing a tree, because fish cannot climb trees, end quote. Why did the people responsible for setting education policy in our state have no confidence in our kids' ability to learn? This is just the latest act of the Board of Regents to eliminate any accountability in our state, after lowering the standards of the state test a few years ago to hide the drop in performance after the extensive closures of schools during the pandemic. New York State now spends nearly $40 billion per year on education, which makes it the most expensive public school system in the country. For 19 consecutive years, unless the Portrait of a Graduate sets rigorous and objective measures like the Regents, it would be another ill-advised decision which will only try to mask the reality that the majority of our students are not learning the basics of math and reading by the end of high school. It will lower the value of New York State's high school diploma and it will not solve the actual problem that the New York Board of Regents and this body should be focused on. Making sure our kids — making sure public schools actually teach our kids, or offer school choice for those who are not lucky enough to get a seat in a public charter school or cannot afford to pay for private school or to home school their kids. Thank you. (03:32:09) Very much. Thank you. Well, with 13 seconds to spare. All right. Yes. (03:32:18) Okay. Good afternoon, members of the New York City Council Committee on Education. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today on the New York State Portrait of a Graduate. My name is Sherry Gibson. I am a proud New York City public school alumna, a high school parent, a citywide Title One parent leader and education advocate who served as a member of the New York State Blue Ribbon Commission on Graduation Measures. The Portrait of a Graduate came out of the recommendations of the Commission and is foundational to the systemic change of what education in New York State could be. It is central to the entire New York Inspires transformative plan. The Portrait of a Graduate is a direct answer to what we heard resoundingly from students, families, higher education officials and employers: that we have not been preparing our young people for post-secondary success or for the future past the 21st century. A focus on Regents — a one-day exam — was not providing variety in students' learning experiences, which was mainly limited to extracurricular clubs and activities, as you heard from the journalism students today. Assessing educators' effectiveness just on standardized exams... Rigor has been mentioned a lot today, but it is not found in just a one-day exam. The dependence or focus on the Regents has minimized the importance of classroom work and participation, and then looking at additional experiences. We think there are other ways to assess our students' mastery of a subject beyond only the former Regents. Have you spoken to a teenager lately who is taking the Regents? They walk out of the Regents either saying, "Oh man, that was so easy, we learned that at the beginning of the school year," or "Nothing we learned this whole school year was on this test." So if we are stating that their mastery is to be measured by the exam... (03:34:21) Thank you for your testimony. All right. (03:34:26) Thank you. Chair Dinowitz, thank you for holding this hearing and for the opportunity to speak with you. My name is Randy Levine and I am Policy Director of Advocates for Children of New York. In addition to helping families navigate New York City schools, including high school graduation requirements, I also served on the state's Blue Ribbon Commission on Graduation Measures and coordinate the statewide Coalition for Multiple Pathways to a Diploma. We are pleased to see the New York State Education Department move forward with its proposal to decouple Regents exams from graduation requirements. We have long advocated for multiple pathways to a high school diploma — for a system that provides students with multiple ways to demonstrate what they know and are able to do. This is especially true given that there is no evidence that exit exams increase student achievement. I think you heard from the students here more powerfully than I can ever say the value of those multiple ways and how they have impacted student learning. As this work moves forward to ensure we capitalize on this opportunity, there are many steps that need to be taken. With our limited time today, we will highlight just a few recommendations. First, New York City Public Schools needs to engage in extensive stakeholder engagement with meaningful opportunities for feedback. New York City Public Schools should also draw on the expertise of schools and educators across New York City that are already using performance-based assessments. They should also start developing a comprehensive communications plan now to ensure students and families understand what they need to do to graduate. There are still big questions to answer and it is hard to overstate how critical it will be to get clear and accessible information out to the field. There must also be an intentional and targeted focus on the needs of students with disabilities and English learners. Too often in our work we see barriers to access and meaningful participation, such as limited supports and accommodations for students with disabilities in certain work-based learning programs. We want to ensure that students with disabilities and English learners can get the academic and transition support they need to graduate and to have full access to graduation pathways. Thank you... (03:36:32) ...for the opportunity to testify. Thank you so much. Good... (03:36:38) ...afternoon. My name is Jordan Panetta, the policy lead on this issue at Trust in New York. We look forward to sharing our comprehensive written testimony in the coming days. Trust in New York has serious concerns regarding the staged rollout — not necessarily the idea of New York Inspires or the Portrait of a Graduate. Specifically, we are concerned that the way this would be rolled out will create major challenges for New York City Public Schools: it will exacerbate issues of access with the creation of alternative learning pathways, create challenges in comparing and assessing post-secondary readiness, sacrifice rigor by creating learning pathways that are difficult to design and assess between schools and across districts, eliminate any measure of student readiness and system accountability that the Regents exams have certainly provided, and divert investments from central initiatives like reads and resolves which play a role in ensuring students are entering high school at grade level. Trust in New York is urging New York City Public Schools to delay the rollout of Inspires, including the decoupling of the Regents exams for this next cohort, until they address these concerns and provide districts with more holistic implementation guidance. We urge Council Members to also call for delaying this implementation and to seek clarity with the state on the following principles as it develops a plan to align with the Portrait. First, we want New York City Public Schools to convene a task force to design alternative learning pathways and the post-graduation application process with key stakeholders, including families and students. Second, provide students with vetted assessment options to demonstrate proficiency in addition to the Regents. Third, develop competency-based evaluations with comparability across districts and schools. Fourth, prioritize rigor when designing instructional pathways, rubrics and competency-based assessments. Last, look at the 37 consortium schools as they are the best example of rigorous and effective 21st century... (03:38:22) ...learning. I would like to emphasize this last principle. Finally, Trust in New York believes this is an opportunity for the City to lead as an example for the rest of the state, if leadership prioritizes collaboration and remains committed to building a system that is rigorous, equitable and promotes transparency and accountability. Thank you. (03:38:41) Under the wire. Perfect. All right. (03:38:46) Thank you, CM Dinowitz, members of the Education Committee and City Council staff for hosting today's oversight hearing. My name is Kimberly Olson and I am proud to be the Executive Director of the New York City Arts and Education Roundtable, also a proud graduate of New York State schools having taken many Regents exams in my time. As our City maps out this next chapter in education, the Roundtable and our constituents believe that arts is among our strongest untapped resources for meeting each milestone. Each of the six core attributes starts with the arts. Research shows the impact of arts education on developing a broad range of in-demand skills that help students prepare not only for college but for career and civic life as well. As a theater educator I saw firsthand how my students demonstrated their knowledge by writing and performing original musicals on topics like immigration, Rosa Parks, civil rights as well as Black inventors like Lonnie Johnson and more. Historically, these Regents exams have squeezed dance, music, theater and visual arts out of the school day in an attempt to teach to the test. Moving away from these high-stakes tests towards alternative assessment measures is a positive shift that has immense potential to showcase student rigor, excellence and creativity. Yet to realize this vision we need more information and action from New York City Public Schools in four key areas. First, we need clear guidance. We need explicit clarity on how arts will be mapped within the Portrait of a Graduate and how arts-based performance measures will count towards graduation requirements. Second, we need more arts teachers and support for these teachers. Roughly one in five New York City public schools lack a certified arts teacher. We must invest in the hiring of certified arts teachers to ensure that schools have the content knowledge on hand to support the delivery of arts integration and arts-based projects. Third, we need professional development. Arts teachers cannot carry this load on their own. New York City Public Schools needs to invest in robust professional development so that educators can co-design these learning experiences and capstone experiences as well. Last, we need strategic partnerships, leveraging the Mayor's Office of Media and Entertainment and New York City Public Schools as well as our arts and cultural partners to support pathways. Thank you. Thank you so much. (03:40:54) I would like to thank this panel for their testimony today. I am just kidding. Okay. Again, as always, if I mispronounce your name I apologize. I have Anita Sanchez, Timothy Barba, Beth Fertig, E.T. Rodriguez, Kevin Annoyed or Benwa. I will tell you why — produce a second — Iker Chiquita, Kart Chickie Darko. I had a colleague whose last name was spelled the same way as Benwa. He did not pronounce it as you pronounce it, so I had a 50-50 shot and got it wrong. So. You all must be friends. You have like eight seats there and you are all... we worked together. Perfect. Yeah. (03:42:06) Please, go ahead. Thank you so much, it is great to be here. I am Beth Fertig, Executive Director of Press Pass, which is part of the Youth Journalism Coalition. Before this job I was a reporter for over 25 years at WNYC Public Radio where I covered education and politics. So I have been on the other side of this microphone a lot and I want to tell you how much I love this organization and why it is relevant here, because Press Pass trains teachers and students to build school newsrooms in public schools across the City. We have worked with more than 40 middle and high schools since launching five years ago, including Bronx River High School, Queens Tech and a few of the other schools that are out there rallying with you. Student journalism, as you have heard, is one of the most powerful and overlooked tools the City has for building the skills in the Portrait of a Graduate. Three pillars in particular — critical thinking, effective communicating and being a global citizen — are constantly practiced in student newsrooms. I have watched this happen at our partner schools. A Bronx student won a prestigious award for reporting on immigration enforcement in her neighborhood. A student in East New York, Brooklyn used real reporting to debunk a rumor about a school lockdown being caused by ICE — it was not. A student at a school in Queens told me interviewing people taught him the difference between writing news and opinion. We are very grateful for the continued investment in student journalism, but we just want to plead for training the teachers, which requires its own type of funding, because you cannot ask an English or social studies teacher to start a news team without sufficient training. Journalism is its own profession. The students need to learn the difference between news and opinion, ethics and understanding how to talk to sources. That is why a trained adviser to work with a student newsroom is so important. Our adviser fellowship gives teachers 30 hours of professional development, a mentor and a stipend for free in their first year, with two more years of support. So this is how to build the infrastructure for student journalism by training teachers, and that is how to get what we want for all of our graduates. We look forward to any collaboration. (03:44:20) Thank you. Hi. How... (03:44:25) How are you? Hello, Council. I am Eric Dinowitz, who I know. My name is Rodriguez. I am actually a professional journalist as well. I received a letter of recognition from the Council member. It was when I resigned as editor in chief of the Riddle Press. I am also project manager with Press Pass and I am also a professor at Lehman College. So as I tell my students, to have a curiosity for the world around them. My students are fresh out of high school, presumably with their Regents diploma, and an overwhelming amount of them do not have a curiosity for the environment around them. They do not know what is going on in their own neighborhoods. They are cripplingly shy, suffering from public speaking skills, and they do not know how to put their thoughts on paper. But as a workshop leader with Press Pass, I have seen smart and articulate students, a lot like the ones that you have seen today, who are civically engaged young adults. And we — I know we celebrated $280,000 of investment in teaching. However, most of the schools, as Buff has said, do not have a dedicated journalism teacher, and they have to pull from their faculty who are already busy and overwhelmed teaching their classes. So we, as she said, offer three years of training and support, free to teachers whose schools agree to give them the journalism class or club, which has enabled us to build back student press in more than 40 schools and counting. (03:45:45) You know, our program — we are also going to try to set up a Bronx journalism hub, which we are announcing and which I am leading the project for, in a historically under-resourced neighborhood and in an area that is already being considered a media desert. Right — Bronx Times is down to one full-time reporter, News Bronx 12 is on a skeleton crew, and Norwood News is just, you know, on hiatus. So yes, journalism in schools is important, but it is also important to train the teachers so that these students can be effective and civically engaged. Also, I dropped out of high school... (03:46:19) ...did not take my Regents, failed my Regents three times, went to school, got my bachelor's, got my master's, and here I am today. Regents are not necessary. Thank you. (03:46:30) Thank you. I also want to point out that Norwood News is in my district — it was one of like two papers in my district, the other one being Verdell Press. And yes, Norwood News shut down, which is very, very harmful to the community for sure. (03:46:45) Good afternoon. I am Kevin Benwa. I am a Brooklyn resident, a Brooklyn native. I am also the school program manager for Press Pass, so I will definitely be doubling down on what we have been saying. Portrait of a Graduate sets out to support students so that they are critical thinkers, effective communicators, global citizens, and ready to learn, work, grow, create and contribute. Journalism checks all those boxes in real-time, hands-on ways. When a student reports a story, they investigate, verify facts and weigh competing accounts — that is critical thinking in action. When they write, edit and publish for their peers, they practice clear communication for a real audience. And when their reporting tackles civic questions — such as a student news team debunking rumors about immigration enforcement in their school, or investigating the practical impact of a citywide phone ban — they act as engaged global citizens who are accountable for what they publish. However, what I have witnessed in schools over the years is that this work requires support from local government and school administrators. And while media and technology evolve, the fundamental principles of journalism remain constant. It is important that we have programs that introduce students to meaningful journalism, teach fundamental principles and provide a support system that trains educators and administrators who can build student newsrooms. Press Pass does just that. I have worked in schools in Canarsie, East Flatbush, Williamsburg, Bushwick, Jamaica, Queens, and so on. What I will say is there is no one-size-fits-all, and I think that is one of the things we heard today. There is a lot that needs to be figured out, and hopefully it will be figured out. Hopefully the Council continues to push back on some of the things you heard today. Journalism is one of the aspects that can help support Portrait of a Graduate. There is so much more that needs to be figured... (03:48:54) ...out. Thank you. And I can tell you, when I became chair of the Education Committee, I said I know we have to have a hearing on this issue because I kind of felt I knew where we would be, which is not sure where we are, right? So this is not the end of this conversation. Everyone here who has testified and beyond will be an integral part of making sure all the things we are asking for — whether it is the communication, whether it is the rigor, whether it is the professional development — we are going to hold the DOE accountable to make sure that is all there. I do want to ask, though — Superintendent Chang, I think, as well as the superintendent who is here, spoke about partnerships with nonprofits and industry. And I am wondering, from your perspective, what obligation do you have, or what role you think you should or can have, in developing these sorts of assessments and rubrics that would demonstrate the level of rigor and engagement per the Portrait of a Graduate... (03:50:07) ...framework. Hi. You know, we are a service provider. We train teachers. We also have fellowships for students each semester. But in our work to train the teachers, we certainly follow through on what they are doing each semester. That is Kevin's whole job. We hired him just now, today... (03:50:32) No. Are you — we already put him up on the panel. That was a month ago. (03:50:36) But he has been working with us already for a few years, and now his full-time job is being that person who checks in. We have journalism educators who train the teachers. Kevin's job is going to the schools to make sure that they are not hitting too many roadblocks, because they need a lot of support. And that is why our fellowship gives them two more years beyond that, because it is really hard to learn a whole profession — journalism — and then teach a bunch of kids how to do it. (03:51:03) So when you are asking really about rubrics — or what I am asking is, is what we are talking about portfolios? As we talk about some sort of assessment, you have heard it mentioned throughout the day: some sort of assessment and some sort of assurances that a kid from Canarsie is doing the same type of work and is held to the same standard as a kid from Bedford Park. (03:51:23) Now I get what you are getting at. Okay. So, Kevin — definitely. Outside of Press Pass, I have also worked in education for 20 years, from Harlem Children's Zone to, you name it. I have worked in high school for five years. I was a career counselor. And all I have to say is, what I have seen this summer alone — I had 50 interns, right? Coming from various schools. The biggest issue is that while they can all come up and say how great their school is, oftentimes they do not even know what is happening at the school on the same block or in the same building. So unless we can figure out a way to get all the schools on the same page, we are all going to do journalism — or it does not have to be journalism, but we are all going to do the same things so that we are all judged on the same basis. Because even with Regents — and again, I worked at a high school — we knew that if we had students, all we had to do was get them to take the test three times. Even if they failed all three, as long as they took it three times, we could ask the City to just waive it. And this was happening with most of the Black and Brown students that I worked with. But then I go to a Bronx Science or Brooklyn Tech, and they look at the Regents like it is just one of the things they have to do today, and they are going to do 15 other things and be successful at all 15. But they have the same students who live on the same block, go to the same corner store, and they are not getting the same services. So unless we can figure out how we can get everyone on that same page — and I think it starts at some level with local schools, it starts with smaller districts — but overall, there is no reason a student in Canarsie is not getting the same education as someone in Park Slope. (03:53:17) Great. Yeah, agreed. And I would hope and think that the DOE should not be creating whatever assessments or portfolios they are asking the kids to do in silos. You have expertise in journalism that you can and should bring as partners with the DOE in that work. You know best what good journalism looks like, and I would just hope and think the DOE would lean on you for that. And it seems like you are willing and able partners in that work. All right. I would like to thank this panel and call the next panel: Edgar Rodriguez, Adrian Rothman-Noonan, Laura Evangelista, David Amsad and Aurora Kushner. Could you come up? (03:54:15) No. Okay, I have mine. I am going to submit it online. (03:54:34) Over here. Maybe get one ready? Thanks. Sure. You know what, some panel. My name is Diego Rodriguez. Before this role I served for over 20 years as a teacher, assistant principal and principal of our schools in New York City. I come here today as Vice President of School Support at New Visions for Public Schools, which has partnered with the City for over 37 years to drive system-level change as an affinity partner. We are a dedicated partner for 71 public high schools and provide services for schools. The City's shift associated with Portrait of a Graduate asks schools to reorganize and educators to teach and... (03:55:12) ...assess students in ways that they have never been trained to do. So even as these changes are being implemented, the students whose diplomas will be granted under the new requirements are already in our buildings, taught by teachers who have received little relevant professional learning in this matter. (03:55:34) Major change generally brings opportunities and at the same time lots of challenges, including questions about the validity of any assessment. This work has to move quickly and it has to draw on the capacity that already exists in the City. Those represented in this panel collectively serve a third of the high schools in the City and represent a significant piece of that capacity. We have spent decades doing this work with our schools, and the system should treat us as a critical resource in this transition. New Visions' affinity network and our work with schools have derived three key things that we believe are vital to this transition. First, curriculum. We have produced curriculum in science and social studies that is used by the majority of high schools across the City, and it is based on real-world investigation, phenomena-type project-based learning, and the Portrait of a Graduate. Its framework is already written, it goes through continuous revisions, and certainly... I did not make it through my minutes. But thank you. Next time I appreciate it. Just one thing — I appreciate New Visions. I taught at a New Visions school, so double thank you. Good afternoon — or evening. Anyway, I want to... (03:56:30) First of all, thank you for all your support for our network at Urban Assembly, as well as being a champion for social-emotional learning for young people. I am David Adams, Chief Executive Officer at the Urban Assembly. For 30 years, Urban Assembly has been a partner in New York City Public Schools to design, test and scale solutions for students historically underserved by the education system. Today our network includes 23 unscreened, career-connected middle and high schools, and we support the Portrait of a Graduate because it recognizes that readiness requires more than just credits and exams. Students must learn to think critically, communicate effectively, build relationships, navigate decisions and apply their learning to real-world challenges. This vision closely reflects Urban Assembly's work in social and emotional learning, postsecondary readiness and instructional quality. Our students demonstrate what is possible. Our Class of 2024 achieved a 93% graduation rate — seven points above the City rate — with particularly strong outcomes for Black and Latino students, multilingual learners and students with disabilities. Urban Assembly has demonstrated a strong record of helping New York City Public Schools move promising ideas to scale through strong, resilient partnerships. We helped make social and emotional learning supports available across 1,600 schools. We trained more than 50,000 educators and supported assessment for more than 720,000 students. We helped develop a postsecondary bridge model that ultimately expanded citywide, and we now support future readiness by connecting academic learning to college and career pathways. These experiences have taught us that a strong vision is only the beginning. Schools need practical tools, professional learning, implementation support, meaningful measures of student growth and systems for learning what works. Urban Assembly is ready to bring that experience to the Portrait of a Graduate as an innovation and scaling partner that can test approaches in real schools, examine the evidence, codify effective practices and help New York City Public Schools serve every student in the City. Thank you. (03:56:53) Watching that — literally across the cut — you have big goals, really high. They have shared insights and thank you for the support you have shown us. (03:58:53) Already today. My name is... I am Executive Director of the New York Performance Standards Consortium. As you have heard, we are a homegrown model built by educators for students, using performance assessment that holds students to high standards. My written testimony also includes information about our assessment system and its alignment to the New York City and New York State Portrait of a Graduate. The Consortium began almost 30 years ago when New York City Superintendent Steve Phillips and Deborah Meier sought state approval for a group of schools to use performance assessment instead of Regents exams. New Visions was a founder and has effectively supported the Consortium ever since, as the rest of the system continued to use Regents exams — first through the Alternative High School District, then the structure, and now the affinity schools — support without which we could not have built and sustained this system. We welcomed new schools in 2013 and have learned many lessons. I share three today. First, changing assessment is just the start. It requires relaunching school culture towards inquiry, all of which takes extensive professional development and collaboration led by teachers, not outside vendors and consultants, so the system is truly owned by the educators. Second, this work cannot be dictated from the top. The school system must instead provide what Commissioner Tom Sobol called "top-down support for bottom-up school reform" — like funding and structures that provide for collaboration, exactly what the affinity partnership model enables, and school-based decision-making through programs like portfolio-based assessment. Third, high standards require accountability, but not the top-down, test-based accountability we relied on for 20 years. It requires lateral accountability within and across schools and to the communities that schools serve. We can help by building more networks like affinity and aligning incentives, including City dashboards, away from test scores and towards more robust measures of school quality. Finally, I invite you and the Council staff to see our work firsthand. Our teachers hold half-day moderation studies to calibrate scoring of student work — the heart of our system. And in November and December, our network hosts in-school visitation days. Dates and information are at the bottom of my written... (03:59:03) ...testimony. Well, that is very, very fast — last sentence, I love it. Now my favorite thing you said was that we have the expertise here in our City and we do not need to hire outside vendors to do this work at great cost and probably lesser quality. Are you so... (04:01:06) Right. Hi. My name is Aurora Kushner. I am the Vice President of Programs at New York City Outward Bound Schools. Thank you for this hearing and thank you for all the support for Outward Bound that you have given us for over 30 years. We are a partner in New York City Public Schools to pioneer the exact kind of powerful learning defined by New York City's vision as we transition towards the Portrait of a Graduate. As we move from single-day, high-stakes Regents exams towards performance-based assessments and broader measures of student learning, some worry the academic rigor will be diluted. Our research-based approach shows that this is a false choice. Through our partner network, all of our schools are living laboratories for this work. We coach educators to design rigorous, standards-aligned, project-based units grounded in real-world problem solving, where students analyze, synthesize and apply complex concepts rather than simply memorize information. We also build student agency and belonging through our signature advisory structure — Crew — where every student is known, valued, mentored and held accountable. Students track their own progress, identify learning targets and publicly demonstrate their growth through presentations of learning and performance-based assessments. When you intentionally pair meaningful challenge and real-world engagement... (04:01:42) >RIGHT. HI. MY NAME IS AURORA KUSHNER. I'M THE VICE PRESIDENT PROGRAMS AT NEW YORK CITY OUT BOUND SCHOOLS .JARDINE RITZ. THANK YOU FOR THIS HEARING AND THANK YOU FOR ALL THE SUPPORT FOR OUR BOUNDS THAT YOU'VE GIVEN US FOR OVE R30 YEARS WITH A PARTNER IN NEW YORK CITY PUBLIC SCHOOLS TO PIONEER THE EXACT KIND OF POWERFUL LEARNING DEFINED BY NEW YORK CITY INSPIRES AS WE TRANSITION TOWARDS THE PORT OF A GRADUATE. >ZERO MOVES FROM SINGLE DAY HIGH STAKES REGENTS EXAMS TOWARDS PERFORMANCE BASED ASSESSMENTS AND BROADER MEASURES OF STUDENT LEARNING. >SOMEWHERE THE ECONOMIC RIGOUR WILL BE DILUTED. OUR RESEARCH BASED APPROACH SHOWS THAT THIS IS A FALSE CHOIC ETHROUGH OUR PENDING NETWORK OUR SCHOOLS, ALL OF OUR SCHOOLS. >ARE LIVING LABORATORIES FOR THIS WORK WITH COACH THE EDUCATORS TO DESIGN RIGOROUS STANDARDS A PROJECT BASED UNITS GRANTED IN REAL WORLD PROBLEM SOLVING WHERE STUDENTS ANALYZE, SYNTHESIZE AND APPLY COMPLEX CONCEPTS RATHER THAN SIMPLY MEMORIZE INFORMATION .>>WE ALSO BUILD STUDENT AGENCY AND BELONGING TO OUR SIGNATURE ADVISORY STRUCTURE CREW WHERE EVERY STUDENT IS KNOWN, VALUED MENTORED AND HELD ACCOUNTABLE .STUDENTS TRACK THEIR OWN PROGRESS, IDENTIFY LEARNING TARGETS AND PUBLICLY DEMONSTRATE THEIR GROWTH THROUGH PRESENTATIONS OF LEARNING AND PERFORMANCE BASED ASSESSMENTS WHEN .>>YOU INTENTIONALLY PAIR MEANINGFUL CHALLENGE AND REAL WORLD, REAL WORLD ENGAGEMENT (04:03:00) With genuine belonging, students thrive and the results are measurable. We see that in our graduation rates, we see that in our post-secondary enrollment and our persistence data. Bars surpassing City averages, our climate surveys consistently outperform the City in academic rigor and trust. This transition is not about lowering expectations. It is about expanding what rigor means and giving students more ways to demonstrate what they know and what they can do. We do not need to start from scratch. The teacher coaching practices, school models and student data are already here in New York City. We invite you to come visit our partner schools. (04:03:47) See, I could finish that sentence for you again because I have already had the great pleasure of visiting your schools and I will surely be happy to do even more visits. (04:03:58) Good afternoon, Chair Dinowitz and members of the Education Committee. My name is Laura Evangelist. I am the Executive Director of International Network for Public Schools. For over 20 years we have partnered with New York City Public Schools to design and support schools for newly arrived immigrant students through a practitioner-developed and research-based approach. I am also a New York City retired educator and the former principal of Flushing International High School, where in 2013 I led the transition from a Regents-based graduation requirement to a fully performance-based assessment system requiring students to complete and publicly defend six rigorous tasks. What I learned is that this shift is not simply about replacing exams. It is about transforming instruction and students' everyday experiences. Preparing students for graduation defenses begins in the ninth grade. I had teachers collaborating across subjects and grade levels to develop students' abilities to research and investigate questions, revise their work and defend their thinking. We did not abandon any academic rigor or content when we did this work. We deepened it while developing the competencies that the New York State Portrait of a Graduate calls for. We extended that learning beyond the classroom through work-based learning and dual enrollment, giving students the opportunity to apply their knowledge, explore careers and develop those skills in the world through college-level work. We could not have done this work alone. International Network worked alongside our schools to strengthen it, develop common rubrics and build accountability across the network. The creation of the affinity district in 2015 deepened that work by aligning district resources and accountability with our practitioner expertise and sustained professional learning. The affinity structure has made ambitious reforms possible in everyday classrooms and sustained them over time. Today 17 international schools demonstrate what this work looks like. As we implement the New York Portrait of a Graduate, we stand ready to work with the DOE and invite you to our schools. Thank you. (04:06:02) Thank you so much. I do not want to just thank you. I think all of you in your different ways have supported the work I have done, the work of this Council, whether it is panels with your students, particularly the international schools. I think I have done a lot for our immigrant students, but all of you in various ways have supported the students and this Council in our work. You were mentioned... (04:06:30) ...in the testimony. The work the DOE does with you, getting an understanding and getting expertise on what the Portrait of a Graduate can be. In your opinion, has the DOE leaned on you hard enough for that support? Have they utilized the skill set that you bring to the table enough? I think there is a lot more work to be done in terms of coordination with the DOE. Each of our schools has a superintendent that works with our schools directly, but that superintendent accountability is not organized around scaling or innovation. It is organized around the same kind of bureaucratic structures that other superintendents are organized around. For us to be able to take the practices that we have developed and ensure that all students have access to them, the superintendent structure that goes up to the DOE needs to see themselves as innovators and problem solvers to questions around things like Portrait of a Graduate, rather than just operational executors around DOE objectives. (04:07:32) Right. I think, sort of related to what A.J. says, and kind of what I talk about all the time, it is like: what are you measuring? If you are measuring Regents scores, credit accrual and attendance, that is how you are going to measure success. But if you have a measure of success for innovation, then I think we would probably start seeing a lot more of that. (04:07:54) I was going to add something. There is very complex... all afternoon we have been talking about all the layers involved, right? There is a piece around assessment, around the Regents, performance-based assessments as one piece. There is another piece around work-based learning, work-based readiness, and we are doing a lot of collaboration with the Office of Pathways around career readiness and how the Portrait of a Graduate can assist in monitoring progress with all those metrics. I feel that work has been flourishing, not explicitly in the context of Portrait of a Graduate, but it can inform it. It is an area in which we are collaborating in terms of work-based innovations and how the Portrait can serve as a place for schools, districts and the central office to take a look at where the schools stand, but the individuals also need to stand on the plans that have to happen in response to the parents. (04:08:50) Right. So I am seeing a panel of people who stand ready to work with the DOE, whose skills and experience are not being leveraged enough, and who also, in order to support that, need the DOE to recognize some of the special work that the affinity network does and rate the schools on that, or value that sort of work as part of their quality review. (04:09:20) I mean, I think the other important thing to say is that the educators in our schools are really passionate about the work that they do and really willing to share. I think as we wait for New York City Public Schools to figure out what the build-out of the transition is going to look like and how they are going to think about how classroom instruction will change and how high school will look different, there are people who are ready to be tapped. I mean, there were multiple people on this panel from New York City Public Schools today that are connected to our schools, including Alan Chang, including Delia... these are people that know our work and they know we are ready to help. So I think it will come. (04:09:56) Eventually. I think historically, when there have been, as you alluded to, programs in the past about visitations, when we look at all the previous structures — showcase learning partners, lighthouse — I mean, overwhelmingly our schools were willing to host folks. (04:10:14) During those, and again, are willing to do it again. Yeah. (04:10:19) But as I kind of mentioned, it takes the structure from the DOE and it... (04:10:23) ...takes investment and money. The support investment, the money investment. It takes all that, but it is good to know that we have a whole network of partners and we are going to keep making sure the DOE knows it and acts on it. I would like to thank this panel for their testimony today. Thank you. Next panel: Troy Kingston, Alisa... Akina... Takina... well, I will get it right the third time, I promise. Edward Gordon, the... Zimmer, and Kamala Carmen. (04:11:38) Mike is here. I am going to mix things up, you know, go a little crazy. Start on the right. Is it on? Yeah, sure. (04:11:58) My name is Kamala Carmen and I am the parent of two children, both now in their early 20s. I believe that my children graduated from New York City Public Schools, six through 12, having fully attained the attributes distributed around the Portrait of a Graduate wheel. That they did so is arguably a foregone conclusion since they attended a consortium school, and the practices and approaches of the consortium model, as you heard today, very intentionally aimed for the outcomes called for by Portrait of a Graduate. Moreover, even their prior schooling was pointing my kids in this direction. Brooklyn New School, their progressive public elementary school, in many ways resembled what a consortium school for younger children might look like. It used an inquiry approach to nurture students' curiosity, encouraged collaboration with peers and fostered independent critical thinking. It lived by the maxim "more teaching and learning, less testing." I am thrilled that at long last New York State has moved to decouple the Regents exams from graduation. I know that this change raises alarms for some parents and pundits who feel panic about what will replace the Regents. I am here to tell you that I opted my children out of nearly every state test in elementary and middle school. It would have been all of them, but the opt-out movement was not really a thing until my older child was in sixth grade. Because of the consortium's waiver, my older child took only the Regents. My younger child did not even take that, due to COVID risk cancellation. Far from lowered standards, what I saw in both my children's schools were environments that helped them produce work that was far more challenging and detailed and meaningful than what the state tests or the Regents would have asked of them. They did not need any external replacement assessments. They just needed schools where teachers were honored as professionals with plenty of opportunities to advance their own learning and practice, and students were not seen merely as data points with no agency in shaping their learning. The actual threat to high standards... I just have three sentences. The actual threat to high standards is not the diminution of the Regents exams, but the imposition on schools of the bland corporate curriculum products of NYC Reads and Solves, and the incessant and invasive screeners students today are surveilled with. I am relieved my kids graduated before that sad state of affairs came to pass. (04:14:23) And that is again the outside. We do not need outside curriculums for millions of dollars. Okay. Testing... (04:14:36) ...is on. Thank you, Chair of the Committee. My name is Edward Gordon. I am the President of the Nubian Conservatory of Music. It is a small private music school in Brooklyn, New York. I come to you as an educator of over 50 years experience, and 31 of those years were spent in the classrooms of the New York City public school system. I am a former parent of the New York school system and now a grandparent of the New York school system. Mayor Mamdani wants to bring rap poetry into the system. I have expressed in writing why I do not think that is a good idea. If we are speaking honestly about rap, it has very few redeeming qualities. No one is learning how to sing properly or play an instrument. Many of the people that it glorifies are either ex-drug dealers or ex-convicts. Please do not get me wrong. I am all for giving people a second chance, but I was taught that as role models you have to be held to a higher standard. We have wonderful role models out there, such as Mariah Carey and Lawrence Brownlee, the African American Metropolitan Opera singer. We see young men holding their... for periods of time, and there is the filthy language which often degrades Black people and especially Black women. The bottom line is that a 10-year-old Black boy was trampled to death at a so-called rap concert. I want something better for my grandchildren. Our children need orchestras, choruses and bands. Erasmus High School has an electronic organ sitting there collecting dust, but it needs about $2,000 worth of work to make it fully functional. That figure is probably higher by now, since I got that estimate a few years ago. No one wants to help me... (04:16:39) ...finish your last sentence, please. Someone wants to help you raise money to repair that instrument. (04:16:47) Thank you. We heard, I think, one person talk about the arts, and I think the arts can and should be integrated into the Portrait of a Graduate as well. That is it for me, at least from my own personal experience as someone who, you know, theater and music was integral to my middle and high school experience, and as someone who as a teacher saw theater and music as something that was transformative for my students. This can and should be part of the Portrait of a Graduate. (04:17:22) Hello. My name is Allison. I am a senior at... Early College Secondary School, and I am from Brooklyn, New York. My school does not have a dedicated journalism class, but one of the opportunities my school gave me was the Fellowship for the Future of Journalists. I first applied to the program during my sophomore year, and this is actually one of the reasons I am here today. The program gave me the opportunity to explore journalism from different angles and perspectives, as well as to meet a lot of amazing journalists and learn from their experience. Our mentors do not teach us how to follow a template or put strong limitations on our creativity and our words, which is what school usually does. Instead, we have the freedom to write about things that genuinely interest us and find our own voice. One of the articles I wrote this year is called "How the Morning Shapes the Mind." In this article, I talk about the importance of reducing our use of phones, especially in the first 30 minutes after waking up. It can give your brain a calmer start to the day. That way you can feel more present, which is a benefit for students. While taking Regents, it was not journalism, and I have never thought about something like this or decided to experiment with it in my own life. Journalism helps me notice things I might normally overlook and find interesting stories about things that I can see as ordinary. It gives me freedom to explore what I genuinely care about, find people who share those interests and develop my own voice. I am very grateful for everything this program has given me, which is why it is very sad to know that so many students do not have the same opportunity. I believe every student should have the chance to write, learn from professionals and have their voice heard. Journalism teaches critical thinking by asking questions and looking at different perspectives, and it teaches effective communication by turning our ideas into stories that others can understand and connect with. I am just asking to make sure that we support journalism education and opportunities like the Fellowship for the Future of Journalism in all public schools, or at least most of them, so every student has the chance to develop their voice, their love for the profession and have their stories heard. Thank you. (04:19:21) Thank you so much for your testimony. (04:19:26) Chair Dinowitz, thank you, and Committee, thank you for this opportunity. I taught physics at Harlem Renaissance Transfer High School through a period of turnaround. The difference in our system was never talent or opportunity. It has always been audience, and audience has always been rationed. You have said that the Regents create perverse incentives, and... (04:19:45) ...audience is what replaces them, is what I am arguing here. Assign an essay that only one teacher reads. The student, let us say, writes it. Put her on stage defending her own work and no one can stand in for her or for chat bots. All students deserve an authentic audience. Anything less will lure them into offloading their learning and our public schools will crumble as a result. The answer to AI is not more ed tech. It is an expert human audience for every student. Video is the new number two pencil. Learning happens off screen in the real world and the camera comes out to capture their off-screen learning for assessment purposes in video format. Student work can be reproduced and distributed across space and time at zero cost, allowing an expert reviewer or college admissions officer to pull up a chair to each student's proudest moments. I support the moratorium as a tourniquet, not a solution. Portfolios for all is the solution. It is the only solution since everything is downstream of assessment, and the only way to offer an expert audience to all students is validated video portfolios: real work validated by experts at scale. The first step is journalism, which gives students an audience, a deadline and a reason to check facts. Let us expand journalism. Let student creators know that we support them. For example, we can give student journalists a press pass within school that allows them to use electronic devices to create content, not consume it. As journalists, let us ensure New York City students learn to be creators, not scrollers. Drivers of AI, not dependents on it. Give every student a real audience. The research is in my written testimony with more detail and you can find more at academiccapital.org. Thank you. (04:21:24) Thank you. And I think you tuned into our hearing last week, the one where we discussed extensively screen time and AI. So thank you. For this panel's testimony, our final in-person panel: Dominique Jones, Joni Rivera, Ellen McCue, Theresa Ranieri... the last panel will start on my right, your left, and go down. Thank you, Chair. (04:22:15) Thank you for the opportunity to speak and to really talk about this important topic. I am going to turn in my written testimony, but just to kind of focus on a few points. One of the things that I think we are kind of missing in this conversation around Portrait of a Graduate is the ecosystem around schools that can actually help to support them. I represent Global Kids — I am the Executive Director — and we serve 30 schools, one as a community school director and as a community school provider as well as after school provider. We are going to be central in this conversation about the implementation of Portrait. We actually are organizations that can actually enhance and also deliver on certain programming such as our global citizenship programming, which Global Kids has been working through for 38 years, providing those leadership services to our schools. I think it is important that we start to have... it is great that we are talking about the pedagogical approach, the instruction, shifting assessment to portfolio assessment, but there have to be supporting organizations and supporting services that can help to reinforce and enhance that learning. I think that organizations like mine and others will be instrumental to that. I think also we provide some expertise and resources that can help around evaluation, and I know that is something that you talked about all day. I have had the opportunity to listen to you speak to those things. We have some of the infrastructure to support that. We are also thinking about how do we measure the impact of interventions on the whole child, and so I think that that is important. We should talk about it. One thing I think is also important: we need to be having joint hearings with the youth committee, bringing it all together so that they can begin to think about how we can partner and leverage those resources. We as a community school provider are there every day working with kids and families. We really want to be able to make sure that Portrait is a success. Thank you. (04:24:22) Thank you. Good evening. Thank you for your time. My name is Teresa Inarea and I have been an educator in the New York City public school system for over 30 years. The Portrait of a Graduate begins with our youngest learners in kindergarten as they learn to think critically, communicate effectively and use what they have learned beyond the classroom. That is why I am asking for baseline funding for New York City Solves so that we can help create this Portrait of a Graduate. We need to provide recurring funding so my children are prepared to be these young adults. As we heard today, it goes beyond a curriculum. It is teacher professional learning time for collaboration, coaching and implementation support. Not only has it been successful in my school — students decode and write — but it goes beyond that with vocabulary and background knowledge aligned with your Portrait of a Graduate. We complete increasing research projects, go on field trips supporting modules, and these are the foundations for capable readers, effective communicators, critical thinkers and engaged citizens that we want all of our students to become. I have heard you say repeatedly today, and I was very happy: what support are our teachers going to have? Teachers need continued professional learning and coaching so they can make thoughtful instructional decisions and respond to the students sitting in front of them. Students who need additional support need access to targeted intervention and tutoring. Families need meaningful opportunities. We need to invest in the educators that are before all of our students, kindergarten through high school. But my concern is this will not happen without baseline funding so that our kindergartners can be those that you saw today. Thank you. (04:26:10) Thank you. And just one point to make about that: I appreciate the recognition that, you know, you hear this committee talk a lot about training teachers, and you hear from the network that it is not just a couple of trainings. It is deep, engaging work that needs to be done. One of the elements of the $280,000 we have got for the journalism coalition — like so much other funding — it helps leverage private funding. But you know, this Council is committed to investing in the things that we know work and help educate our students. I will not talk more about the money, but I will reiterate: this can be done internally through our professionals here, not through outside contracts. Those outside contractors are mostly not-for-profit organizations, but they come in eight to ten times a year. They are not a part of the community. They do not know our children, our families, the teachers. And that speaks exactly volumes. OK, in our final in-person... (04:27:23) Panelists. Good afternoon, Chairs and members of the Committee on Education. My name is Joni Rivera and I am the Assistant Vice President of Educational Services at the New York Foundling. Thank you for this opportunity to testify on New York's Portrait of a Graduate for students who have experienced foster care. The Portrait of a Graduate must reflect more than academic achievement. It must also include stability, belonging, self-advocacy, healing and a supportive transition into adulthood. The New York Foundling has served children, families and communities for more than 150 years. Through education and child welfare work we see every day... (04:28:00) ...that nearly 500 young people in foster care we serve are capable, resilient and full of potential. But too often their path to graduation is complicated by placement changes, school transfers, transportation barriers, trauma services and uncertainty about what comes next. Programs like the Foundling's Road to Success show what is possible when students receive consistent, trauma-informed academic support. Road to Success pairs nearly 2,000 students with tutors who also serve as mentors, coaches and advocates. While the overall graduation rate for New York City students in foster care is 42%, students participating in Road to Success achieved an 88% graduation rate last school year. Students like Lisa and Jared remind us why sustained support matters. Lisa graduated while navigating disrupted placements and uncertainty about her college transition. Jared, an English language learner, was one Regents exam away from graduation and, with tutoring and encouragement, improved his score by 26 points and earned his diploma. Their stories show that graduation is possible, but support cannot stop at the finish line. We recommend that the City strengthen early identification of students who are under-credited, chronically absent, missing services or struggling with Regents requirements. We also urge stronger coordination among schools, Administration for Children's Services, foster care agencies, caregivers, Fair Futures coaches, tutors and education specialists. Finally, we ask the City to invest in individualized models like Road to Success so more young people can graduate prepared for college and career. Thank you for your time and commitment. (04:29:37) Thank you for your testimony. And also thank all of you for the work that you do. Recognizing, I think, what so many of us know, but a very rigid system does not, which is that our children are more than just test scores. There is so much more to our children. I would love to see the Portrait recognize the incredible work that our kids do and the incredible people that they are. So I want again to thank you for your work and your testimony. That concludes the in-person portion of our public testimony. We will now move to remote testimony. If you are testifying remotely, please listen for your name to be called. Once your name is called, a member of our staff will unmute you. You would then start your testimony once the Sergeant at Arms sets the clock and cues you to begin. (04:30:33) OK, Khalid, you may begin once you are unmuted and the Sergeant cues you. Hi. Good... (04:30:41) ...evening, Chair. Thank you for holding this really important hearing. We are in a time of transition in our New York City Public Schools. I do want to disclose: my name is Khalil Isabella and I am a parent of two public school students. I am also the president of... and I should also state that my children both attended Central Park East Elementary School, which is the oldest public progressive school in New York City, founded by Deborah Meier. In addition, I am a parent of a high schooler in a consortium school. So you can imagine that I deeply believe in the use of performance-based assessments, problem-based learning, project-based learning and an emergent curriculum to support all of our learners, particularly our most vulnerable learners. I do want to share that my oldest child suffers from anxiety, and it has been this type of curriculum that has allowed him to find his voice and has allowed him to develop the skills that he is going to need as he looks forward to being a politician — not a choice of mine. So it is really important to create these spaces for our young people. I will also say that I am a medical educator and 60% of my curriculum is problem-based learning. So when we are talking about career and college readiness, the Portrait of a Graduate really resembles what our expectations are in higher education and setting up students for success, in terms of providing them with a deep learning experience rather than just going over content, which as you mentioned is one of the methods in terms of teaching to the test or teaching to the Regents exam. I will also very quickly state that New York City Reads and New York City Solves — these curricula are culturally destructive, and at the center of the Portrait of a Graduate is culturally responsive curriculum. So I really want to interrogate the notion that New York City Reads and New York City Solves is preparing our children to move forward with these requirements for the Portrait of a Graduate. Hopefully we will be thinking about how we can develop curriculum that is responsive and relevant to our New York City public school experience. (04:32:48) Thank you. Thank you for your testimony. Although, you know, I have to forcefully push back and say your child should aspire to be a politician. It is a great thing, because we are here today talking about a critical issue — the critical issue of Portrait of a Graduate — and that could be your child one day. I do want to thank the Department of Education and all of the people who testified today. It is clear that this is an issue that people care about deeply because they care deeply about the future of our City and care deeply about our children. It is also clear that there is a lot of work to do, that there are a lot of people outside of and within the department who are being very thoughtful about this work, but there is so much more to do in terms of the communication, in terms of sharing best practices, ensuring we are holding ourselves to very high, rigorous standards so that we are seeing our children for who they are and giving them the best education possible. Thank you to all who testified once again. This hearing will be adjourned once I read this very important message. Is there anyone else present in the room who has not had the opportunity to testify who wishes to do so? Please raise your hand. OK. I see no one who wishes to testify. Is anyone on Zoom? There is a limit. OK, now I can officially close the hearing.