Ambulance Response Times
Committee on Fire and Emergency Management | Committee on Hospitals
Meeting overview
The Joint Committee on Fire and Emergency Management and Hospitals held an oversight hearing on ambulance response times in New York City, alongside consideration of Int 0990-2026, sponsored by Chair Ariola, which would require the City to issue Notify NYC emergency notifications whenever FDNY has more than 25 pending ambulance dispatches. The hearing was framed around a genuine crisis: average citywide ambulance response times have reached 13 minutes and 9 seconds, against a background of rising call volumes, falling ambulance availability, and an EMS workforce that is badly understaffed, badly paid, and bleeding personnel at an alarming rate.
FDNY Chief of Department John Esposito led the department's testimony, accompanied by Chief of EMS Paul Mariano and Chief of EMS Dispatch Denise Werner. Their account was candid to a degree unusual for agency testimony: they acknowledged the system is in crisis, that they are responding to more calls with fewer ambulances than five years ago, and that the root cause is a staffing collapse driven primarily by uncompetitive pay. Average ambulance in-service hours per day have fallen from 8,891 in fiscal year 2022 to 8,109 in fiscal year 2026, while life-threatening call volume remains near historic highs. Over 90 ambulances per day are out of service, overwhelmingly due to lack of staff to crew them. The department is currently 410 to 464 personnel below its budgeted headcount of 4,500. A major compounding factor is a promotion cycle pulling EMTs and paramedics into the firefighter pipeline: 358 EMTs and 63 paramedics departed in 2026 alone. Hospital closures - 19 since 2003 - have lengthened transport distances and reduced the number of hospital-run units in the 911 system. The department outlined a range of mitigations including paramedic response units, a centralized resource coordination centre, borough-based command structures, mutual aid agreements, and early-stage AI deployment optimisation, as well as work on a new bespoke scheduling system and a CAD system upgrade with the Office of Technology and Innovation. On Int 0990-2026, FDNY expressed scepticism that blanket Notify NYC alerts would provide useful information without causing public confusion, but said it was open to further discussion on how to provide more real-time information to callers.
The hearing opened with testimony from Jennifer Daly, whose 14-year-old son showed signs of a stroke at St. Francis Prep in Fresh Meadows. The school nurse called 911 three times and no ambulance arrived; her family drove him to New York-Presbyterian Queens and he was subsequently transferred to Morgan Stanley Children's Hospital. FDNY's account revealed that during that period the system was fielding over 100 calls above normal volume, the call went in as an unknown condition because no triage dispatcher was available to answer it, and while an ambulance was dispatched it arrived after the family had already left. Speaker Julie Menin described a separate incident in her district where a 16-year-old injured during a basketball game prompted five 911 calls with no response, despite a firehouse next door; FDNY called back nearly three hours later to ask if an ambulance was still needed. The firehouse proximity was explained by the fact that fire companies are only dispatched to segment one through three life-threatening calls, not to injuries classified as segment four or five. Both incidents illustrated the core problem: when ambulances are scarce, triaging decisions about who gets one become brutal, and lower-acuity calls that would still benefit from timely care get dropped or heavily delayed. Multiple council members pressed for public-facing information so that callers in non-life-threatening but still serious situations could make their own decisions, such as arranging private transport, rather than simply waiting without knowing help may not be coming.
NYC Health and Hospitals was represented by an emergency physician who fielded questions from Chair Narcisse, a former triage nurse at Elmhurst Hospital. The H+H testimony was considerably thinner than FDNY's: the representative was unable to provide data on which hospitals have the longest wait times, the volume of patients leaving against medical advice, the results of several named programmes, or the impact of the Mount Sinai Beth Israel closure. What emerged was that median time from arrival to first provider across H+H facilities is 29 minutes, improved from 33 minutes previously, but that time from decision-to-admit to inpatient bed is approximately 270 minutes citywide. Hospital overcrowding, driven partly by primary care gaps, Medicaid cuts, and the closure of facilities, is keeping ambulances tied up at hospitals longer than necessary. Programmes discussed included Virtual ExpressCare, which diverts some 911 calls to telehealth and avoids ambulance dispatch, and the LEADS programme, which addresses substance use in the emergency department. The committee pressed on the B-HEARTS mental health response programme, the Bridge to Home supportive housing initiative, and the SHOW outreach programme, with the H+H representative repeatedly unable to provide detail and promising written follow-up.
The dominant theme running through the entire hearing was pay. Starting wages for EMTs are $18 an hour. Average tenure is under three years. Some workers are living in shelters or sleeping in cars. The City Council - including the Speaker, the committee chairs, and virtually every member who questioned witnesses - was unified in arguing that the contract currently being negotiated between the EMT union and the Office of Labor Relations is the single most important lever available, and that without a meaningful pay increase the recruitment and retention crisis will not be resolved. The Fire Commissioner and department chiefs agreed publicly and repeatedly. Chair Ariola closed by arguing that EMS workers should additionally be granted uniformed first responder status and civil service exam pathways for promotion, and expressed confidence that current political conditions represent the best opportunity in memory to deliver a genuinely competitive contract.
The record
Numbers
- Average citywide ambulance response time is currently 13 minutes and 9 seconds.
- Average ambulance in-service hours per day fell from 8,891 in fiscal year 2022 to 8,572 in fiscal year 2025 and 8,109 in fiscal year 2026.
- Life-threatening medical calls totalled 564,412 in fiscal year 2022; over 480,000 segment one through three calls have already been recorded in the current fiscal year to date.
- Over 90 ambulances per day are currently out of service, overwhelmingly due to staffing shortages.
- FDNY EMS is 410 to 464 personnel below its budgeted headcount of 4,500.
- 358 EMTs and 63 paramedics left EMS for the firefighter promotion cycle in 2026; 288 EMTs and 48 paramedics did so in 2025.
- Starting pay for FDNY EMTs is $18 an hour.
- Average length of service for an FDNY EMT is just under three years.
- EMS has approximately 4,500 budgeted personnel compared to FDNY fire suppression's approximately 13,000, responding to roughly double the call volume.
- 19 hospitals have closed in New York City since 2003, including one in 2025.
- The 911 ambulance system is approximately two thirds municipal FDNY units and one third hospital-run units.
- FDNY targets 640 ambulance tours per day, running approximately 328 in the day period and 312 in the evening period.
- There are currently 163 EMT trainees at the FDNY academy at Fort Totten, down from a starting class of 200, plus approximately 150 in paramedic training.
- FDNY operates 14 paramedic response units across the city.
- Approximately 38% of daily 911 calls are classified as high acuity or life-threatening; the remaining 62% are not.
- Median time from emergency department arrival to first provider at NYC Health and Hospitals facilities is 29 minutes, improved from 33 minutes previously.
- Average time from decision-to-admit to inpatient bed transfer at H+H is approximately 270 minutes.
- Between 2022 and 2025, patients at H+H hospitals waited an average of 12.8 hours to be transferred from the emergency department to an inpatient bed.
- H+H treated over one million emergency department patients across its 11 facilities in 2025, with increases concentrated in higher-acuity cases.
- H+H psychiatric emergency services treated 33,400 unique patients across 56,600 visits in 2025, up slightly from 33,000 unique patients and 55,000 visits previously reported.
- The LEADS substance use programme recorded 30,420 encounters in 2025, up from 22,500 in 2023, with over 6,500 referrals to outpatient clinics and over 3,600 naloxone kits distributed.
- Fire companies conduct approximately 1,000 certified first responder medical emergency runs per 24-hour period citywide.
- The Hospital Liaison Unit pilot operated at 13 hospitals and reduced turnaround time by approximately two minutes citywide before being discontinued.
- Lincoln Hospital emergency department receives approximately 37 patients per hour at peak.
- Patients leaving H+H emergency departments without being seen represent approximately 2% of visits.
Action Points
- FDNY to provide committee with full time-from-911-call-to-hospital-arrival data broken down by Council district, as requested by CM Brooks-Powers.
- FDNY to investigate and report back on why Queens saw the largest borough-level drop in calls reached within 10 minutes despite an overall decrease in call volume.
- FDNY to provide a transcript of all 911 calls related to the Kevin Daly incident to committee counsel Josh Kingsley.
- FDNY Chief Werner to continue and report back on efforts to close identified communication gaps between FDNY EMS dispatch and NYPD dispatch, specifically regarding transmission of vital caller information.
- FDNY to investigate and report back on the status of a previously awarded National Science Foundation grant of approximately $2 million related to response times.
- FDNY to provide the percentage of current EMS personnel who are military veterans, and to assess opportunities for targeted military recruitment.
- FDNY to look into response time data for Hudson Yards and assess whether additional EMS and fire coverage is warranted.
- FDNY to follow up with the Council member representing the Cordell Road area in Brooklyn regarding the street redesign project and its conflict with Local Law 6 objections from the local firehouse.
- FDNY to bring recruitment team to constituent events hosted by council members upon request.
- FDNY and the Office of Labor Relations to progress contract negotiations with the EMT union and report results to the committee.
- NYC Health and Hospitals to provide committee with data on which H+H facilities have the longest and shortest emergency department wait times and the factors driving the variation.
- NYC Health and Hospitals to provide data on the primary drivers of the 270-minute average decision-to-admit-to-bed-transfer time.
- NYC Health and Hospitals to provide current enrollment figures for New York City Care and compare to enrollment two years ago.
- NYC Health and Hospitals to provide an update on whether New York City Care has developed and begun using metrics to measure its impact on avoidable emergency department visits.
- NYC Health and Hospitals to provide detail on the current operational scope and planned expansion of the B-HEARTS mental health crisis response programme.
- NYC Health and Hospitals to provide an update on the Bridge to Home programme, including current capacity and budget prospects for expansion.
- NYC Health and Hospitals to provide detail on the SHOW Street Homeless Outreach and Wellness programme, including current reach and expansion plans.
- Chair Ariola's office to work with FDNY and the unions to arrange Thanksgiving meals for all FDNY EMS stations in 2026, replicating the initiative from the prior year.
- Committee on Fire and Emergency Management to continue discussions with FDNY on possible amendments to Int 0990-2026 to address FDNY's concern that blanket Notify NYC alerts could cause public confusion while still providing callers with actionable information about ambulance availability.
- FDNY to follow up with committee on the feasibility of providing 911 callers with real-time status updates if a dispatched ambulance is redirected to a higher-acuity call.
Full Transcript
For getting cooperation.
Good morning. Welcome to the Committee on Fire and Emergency Management joint with Hospitals. At this time we ask that you please silence all electronics by placing them with one of the sergeants at arms in the back, and at no point please do not approach the dais. Good morning. My name is Joann Ariola and I am Chair of the Committee on Fire and Emergency Management. I would like to begin by acknowledging Council Members who are here today: CM Schulman and CM Paladino.
I would also like to thank Chair Mercedes Narcisse for co-chairing today's hearing with me. Today the Committee on Fire and Emergency Management along with the Committee on Hospitals will once again be holding an essential oversight hearing on ambulance response times and discussing Int 0990-2026, which would require alerting New Yorkers through the Notify NYC system of extended wait times for an ambulance. Over the summer we saw 700 calls being held by the system because of a lack of staffing. This "minutes matter" Bill would let New Yorkers know when that system is in a state of emergency and if your call to 911 at the time means help is not moments away.
The Fire Committee will also hear Int 0990-2026, sponsored by myself, which requires the City to issue emergency notifications each time the FDNY has more than 25 pending ambulance dispatches at any given time. As we all know, our first responders — notably our EMTs and paramedics but also firefighters — are tasked with delivering critical emergency medical care throughout our City. These dedicated public servants routinely provide life-saving care and respond to more than a million medical calls each year. We are forever grateful for your service.
At this time we must acknowledge that these workers undertake an immensely difficult job due to stressful work conditions, long hours and challenging work. Not only that, workers particularly employed by the FDNY are vastly underpaid for the vital jobs that they do. Yet despite these obstacles, each day thousands of ambulance workers drive tirelessly to serve the City and deliver timely emergency medical care to all New Yorkers.
Despite a dedicated and talented workforce, it is apparent to anyone paying attention that our City has struggled to meet its obligations to provide timely emergency medical care to all New Yorkers. Each year the City publishes substantial amounts of data related to emergency response times, a key metric to monitor when seeking to evaluate and improve the delivery of pre-hospital emergency care. In fact, according to the department, it regularly reviews response times to life-threatening medical emergencies across the City and develops strategies and reallocates resources to reduce response times in communities with higher response times.
However, over the past decade, response times to emergency medical incidents have increased — a trend that has been seen dramatically in responses to life-threatening medical incidents, the dire medical emergencies where prompt delivery of emergency medical service and care is most vital.
I am extremely concerned that New Yorkers are facing negative health outcomes due to the delays in the delivery of emergency medical care, and the worry this instills a lack of public confidence in our City's ability to provide vital services when they are most needed. As Chair of the Committee on Fire and Emergency Management, I expect to hear testimony from the Fire Department that will provide clarity as to why we have seen dramatic increases in response times to medical emergencies, and learn more about the department's procedures related to dispatching, staffing and the maintenance of ambulances. But also I hope the department and administration is able to speak more broadly about the commitment to dedicating increased resources to the provision of pre-hospital emergency care, and truly examine agency operations and inter-agency coordination to identify how this City can reverse this troubling trend of increasing emergency response times, because we cannot continue down this path.
I would like to thank our committee staff: our committee counsel Josh Kingsley, our legal analyst Will Hanash, and amazing chief of staff Phyllis Cirillo. I will now
yield to Chair Narcisse for her opening remarks. Good morning and thank you for being here. I have to apologize for my five or seven minutes late — that should not happen. Good morning to all of you and thank you for being here. I am Chair Mercedes Narcisse of the Committee on Hospitals. I am here actually from a different aspect of my life, being a registered nurse, and I am so happy that we are having this hearing today.
Delayed ambulance response and prolonged emergency department wait times have become an increasingly urgent challenge in New York City. One of the most significant delays is the growing strain on our health care system. New York City is home to 49 hospital emergency departments, including 11 hospitals operated by Health and Hospitals — NYCH+H — that is where I used to work, which served more than a million New Yorkers. Reports indicate that between 2022 and 2025, patients at NYCH+H hospitals waited an average of 12.8 hours to be transferred from the emergency department to an inpatient bed. These prolonged waits can delay critical treatment, disrupt continuity of health care and contribute to overcrowded emergency rooms.
As a registered nurse who worked in triage at Elmhurst Hospital's emergency department, I have witnessed these challenges firsthand. Before first responders can return to the field and answer the next emergency call, patients must be registered, assessed and safely transferred into the care of hospital staff. When emergency departments are overcrowded and inpatient beds are not available, ambulances remain on the floor longer than they should,
creating a ripple effect throughout the entire emergency response system. Staffing shortages, hospital closures and increased barriers to accessing primary and preventive care due to recent federal Medicaid cuts — we call it H.R.1, the One Big Beautiful Bill — you know where I am going — have further pressured the system. As Chair of the Committee on Hospitals, I am committed to examining the many factors driving prolonged ambulance response times and identifying meaningful long-term solutions. A temporary fix is not going to help us in New York City.
New Yorkers deserve confidence that when they call for help during a medical emergency — and we know what took place recently, where a family was waiting so many minutes that they were forced to drive their own child to the hospital — that should not happen.
Emergency assistance will arrive as quickly as possible. Every resident, regardless of zip code, income, race, gender, immigration status or background, deserves timely access to emergency care. Today we look forward to hearing from the New York City Fire Department, New York City Emergency Management and other representatives in the field of emergency management about the alarming state of ambulance response times across the City, including what changes have been made since the last City Council hearing on this topic in 2024 and other City-supported efforts on the legislation before the committee today. Together we must work to ensure that our City's ambulance services are efficient and trustworthy and that they continue to serve our residents with the best possible care.
Like I always say, we call ourselves the capital of the world — we have to lead by example. And health care is a human right. Without your health you have nothing, and I think everyone in this room can agree to that. Without your health you are nothing, so we have that responsibility to address that.
Before we begin, I would like to thank committee staff: senior legislative counsel Aurora..., legislative analyst Raina Lee, policy analyst..., financial analyst Molly Howard and
assistant director Florentine Cabrero for their hard work in preparing for this hearing. I also would like to thank my staff for their hard work as we continue to serve our constituents and the City at large. We are all responsible to make sure this City is the best City. So I will pass it on to my colleague, Chair Ariola.
Thank you, Chair. Before we swear in the panel, we are going to give a courtesy to Jennifer Daly. She is going to testify first this morning. Jennifer is the mother of Karen, a 14-year-old boy who experienced a medical episode when he arrived at school one late morning. The school nurse called 911 three times but the ambulance never arrived. Daly is joining us via Zoom to tell her story. Daly, can you hear us?
Yes, hi. How are you? Thank you
for testifying. Oh, thank you for having me.
You can begin. Oh, okay. So...
Thank you for having this hearing. It means a lot to me. So on September 28th, my son arrived at school around 8:15 and he was feeling fine. He arrived at school and once he went into the building he said he was feeling a little faint, a little weak, and his eye was... He immediately went right over to the nurse's office and she sat him down and she gave him water and she gave me a phone call. That phone call was about 8:17 and I instantly said I will be right there. So I left Howard Beach and drove over to St. Francis Prep in Fresh Meadows and unfortunately it was taking me a little longer than it normally does due to the morning commute traffic. In the interim of getting there I had received another phone call from her and she stated to me that she thinks she needs to call the ambulance. So I said please do whatever you have to do. If the ambulance gets there before I do, you know, just tell me where you are and I will meet you
there right away. And then
I was driving, unfortunately, a little bit longer and the nurse had called me again and said that she had called the ambulance. He has two sisters down there in the nurse's office with him and his face looked a little strange — like his eye was not drooping but his eye was slanting down a little bit and looked a little weird. So she was going to make another phone call. She made another one. My daughters — one of my daughters is actually taking a health and safety class, training in first aid — and she looked at her brother and said he looks like he is having a stroke, because they are learning that in school. She immediately called my husband, who is a retired fireman, and he was at work. She told him Kevin's symptoms and my husband said to give him aspirin. Luckily I am a bit of a worrier and my kids have aspirin and Tylenol on them in case they need it. She gave him the aspirin right there. In the midst of that phone call with my daughter and my husband, I got another phone call from the nurse that she had called the ambulance twice and that he does need to go. So I said okay, I am there, I will be there any second. When I arrived he was there, I saw him and he was one hundred percent having signs of a stroke. You could tell immediately — he was slurring his words, his speech was not clear, he did not really know what he was speaking about, he was mumbling his words. I called his cardiologist
and I said we have to get him over to the hospital. What do I do? She said... I said I cannot wait for the
ambulance. This was going to be the third time they had made the phone call, and my husband had made a phone call to them as well. He called over to New York-Presbyterian in Queens and I rushed him over there with my twins from St. Francis Prep. I think I left the Prep at about 9:32 and I got to Presbyterian at 9:52 and my husband arrived as well.
When we got there he ran him
in. They were great. They took him right away. They gave him all kinds of tests — an EKG, ultrasound, CAT scan — and he had... Then they transferred him over to Morgan Stanley Children's Hospital on 165th Street in Manhattan for several days until he was released. That is basically it. That is my story.
Miss Daly, thank you for sharing your story and we are so thankful that you had the presence of mind to have your daughters prepared. You are not neurotic — you are just a great mom. And thank you. The fact that your husband had the medical knowledge to tell your daughter to administer the aspirin, because it could have been probably lifesaving.
But thank you so much. Oh, thank you, I appreciate it. I am going to cry. From the bottom of my heart, thank you. Okay.
Thank you. Thank you. Chair, I have to say something. No, no, do not go anywhere. I want to say thank you to you. Oh, thank you. You are welcome. For actually saving your child's life — you did it. And we are thankful for your husband, FDNY as well. I have to let you know that the nurse could not give that medication because without a doctor present — of course — so that is the reason the call you made to have the medication, to be able to call on your daughter and your family to do that. That is very important because you can save a life, and unfortunately the nurse would not be able to give it. So thank you. Yes. You are welcome.
Thank you.
I would like to just note that we have been joined by CM Virginia Maloney, CM Wong and CM Brooks-Powers. Okay. We will now swear in our panel. Our panel consists of Dr. Josh Mots... from Health and Hospitals, Chief Paul Mariano from the FDNY, Chief John Esposito from the FDNY and Chief Denise Werner from the FDNY. Thank you for joining us today.
Everyone, can you just raise your right hand and affirm the following: that you will firmly tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth and to answer honestly to Council Member questions. Seeing you affirm, you can go ahead and testify. Thank you, Chief. You may begin. Good
morning, Chair Ariola and members of the Committee on Fire and Emergency Management, and Chair Narcisse and the members of the Committee on Hospitals. My name is John Esposito and I am the Chief of Department of the New York Fire Department. I am joined today by Paul Mariano, Chief of EMS, and Denise Werner, Chief of EMS Dispatch. For members of FDNY EMS, reaching a patient experiencing an emergency quickly is paramount. When lives are at stake, every second counts.
As we have testified to this committee previously, the department is currently engaged in a challenging period of increasing response times. We know this is unacceptable and we are working tirelessly to reverse this trend. I am grateful for the opportunity today to discuss some of the reasons for these increases and the steps that we are taking to fix it. I want to state unequivocally that addressing response times is a top priority for myself, the Fire Commissioner and for the Mayor.
We are seeing increases in response time. One major factor is the number of in-service hours of ambulances in the 911 system. As you can see from the most recent Mayor's Management Report, the average ambulance in-service hours per day has trended lower over the most recent five-year period — from 8,891 in fiscal year 2022 to 8,572 in fiscal year 2025 and 8,109 in fiscal year 2026. Meanwhile the number of life-threatening medical calls has increased compared to five years ago, from 564,412 calls in fiscal year 2022. Put another way, when comparing these snapshots, we are responding to more calls with fewer ambulances. After years of seeing increases in call volume every year, the total number of calls were slightly down over the last year. However it remains a very high total number of calls.
Many of which are low acuity calls that would be more appropriately served by non-emergency medical services. If a person is not experiencing an emergency, an ambulance is not always the appropriate means of transport.
A significant reason for the decrease in the number of ambulance in-service hours is staffing changes. We are in the midst of a promotion cycle in which 358 emergency medical technicians and 63 paramedics departed in 2026. In 2025, 288 EMTs and 48 paramedics made this transition. It is a positive outcome for the City to have firefighters with paramedic-level medical training, but it also has a severe impact on staffing in the short term. When a class of members enters the fire academy, it means that leadership has hundreds fewer members to staff ambulances. We have taken measures to mitigate this impact, including deliberately staffing up above headcount prior to the promotion cycle. But with so many members taking the firefighting exam in each cycle, the effect on staffing continues to be significant.
There are also elements that influence response times that are unrelated to staffing. Since 2003, 19 hospitals in New York City have closed, with the most recent closure in 2025. That means fewer destinations for patients. With each closure, ambulances must travel further to get the patient to the emergency room and further again to travel back to their assigned area. Hospital closures also mean fewer hospitals contributing ambulances to respond in the 911 system. Currently the 911 system is made up of approximately two thirds municipal units operated by FDNY members and one third hospital-run units that are staffed by the hospitals. We have also experienced hospitals reducing the number of units that they contribute to the 911 system, which adds stress on the system.
We are pursuing numerous adjustments and innovations to address the ongoing challenges with response times. We know that building up staffing is a key part of this issue. We need to replace the members who have left, and other members who have left due to issues with wages, schedules or for their own reasons. Recruiting has become more difficult since the COVID-19 pandemic. The union that represents the department's EMTs is currently at the negotiating table with the City's Office of Labor Relations, and we are hopeful that a resolution to the next contract will provide a recruiting boost. Restoring staffing is a large piece of the puzzle, but it is not the only way we are attacking this problem.
We are also working internally with external partners to reexamine existing practices, streamline processes and eliminate inefficiencies. We have already taken several steps to improve responses. Paramedic response units: we have set up units to get additional paramedics into the field who can respond to patients faster, to assess, provide treatment and arrange transport. The paramedic response unit brings paramedics to assignments classified as life-threatening. However, if the assessment reveals that the patient does not require advanced life support, they are transferred to a basic life support unit and the paramedics become available for the next high acuity assignment. We currently have 14 of these units operating across the City.
The centralized resource coordination center: we have created a centralized unit that assesses personnel across all divisions in real time, with the aim of pairing up available members to get more ambulances into the field. The goal is to get as many units onto the street whenever possible to respond to calls and take the burden off of all the other units in the system.
The borough-based command structure: under this administration, leadership has moved to a borough-based structure. This enables staff chiefs to provide more oversight over smaller areas so they can react quicker and more dynamically to evolving conditions in the field. These chiefs develop better localized knowledge and are able to provide tailor-made solutions to operational issues rather than a one-size-fits-all solution that may not be appropriate for a given geographical area.
The borough resource coordination center: this unit was created to be the eyes and ears of the borough, monitoring pertinent real-time information to prevent unnecessary off-service issues. Ambulances cannot respond to calls when they are back in the station restocking medicine or equipment, so this unit observes levels to proactively restock when it is most efficient. This unit also monitors hospital trends and timing, communicating with hospital personnel to understand where delays are occurring and resolving issues as they arise. As with all areas of emergency response, the more communication and coordination between partners, the better the outcome.
We have also been working with the Greater New York Hospital Association. We have asked our existing hospital partners who participate in the 911 system to add additional units. To date, three have agreed to provide additional assistance. We have also invoked our New York State mutual aid agreement and we continue to welcome units from the volunteer corps within the City to assist with 911 calls. These are partners who have helped in past times of need, including during COVID.
We have been working with the hospitals to address persistent diversion issues. One challenge that creates longer response times is when hospitals go on diversion and refuse to accept patients. This is sometimes necessary for a variety of valid reasons. There are hospitals that frequently go on diversion for certain types of patients, which means that ambulances have longer trips to drop off patients and longer trips back to where they came from. We continue to speak with hospitals where this practice creates persistent challenges, to get them to go off diversion and become a destination for patients.
One recent success is on Staten Island, where two hospitals had consistently remained on diversion from mental health patients. This in turn required ambulances to drive across the island to reach a hospital that was accepting that type of patient and then drive back across the island again to get back to the area it was serving. When these hospitals began agreeing to accept mental health patients, ambulances no longer need to traverse the island in order to transport patients to receive appropriate care.
We have also done and are doing a full review of members who are working offline who can be returned to the field. We are currently reviewing all the members who do not work in frontline positions and redeploying them to the field. This includes emergency medical technicians, paramedics and officers. A lot of work happens in offline positions, including a lot of paperwork and analysis. However, during these times of lean staffing, we are transitioning as many members as possible back into operational roles. In particular, we have reassigned two deputy chiefs from offline positions to provide increased guidance and supervision to members in the field.
We have also undertaken several long-term potential solutions. These are changes that require development before becoming fully operational, but they are steps that we are actively exploring or working on. We are updating the digitized schedule. FDNY Bureau of Enterprise Technology is currently working to improve the daily scheduling program that we use for staff scheduling, by replacing an off-the-shelf calendar program with a bespoke product that we have
built ourselves. The new scheduling system will be a better fit for our unique needs and operational requirements, enabling the department to more efficiently deploy resources.
We are optimizing deployment decisions through better technology. We are testing ways that artificial intelligence technology can help us make more accurate decisions about deploying resources. While we currently make data-driven decisions to choose ambulance cross-street locations, we are exploring whether newer technology can help with those decisions and whether they can be used in a balanced, safe way to yield better outcomes and help us reach patients faster.
As this committee is aware, we continue working with the City's Office of Technology and Innovation to update the CAD system. We expect that the new system will contain many tools that will improve the way we dispatch resources.
There are a variety of alternate ways to treat patients outside of the traditional model of transporting them to an emergency department at a hospital. We have piloted and tested different versions with varying levels of acceptance by the public. Programs like alternative transport, treat-in-place and 911-to-988 provide models that would avoid lengthy transports. However, our experience has shown that members of the public who call 911 are overwhelmingly expected to receive transport to a hospital, so it will likely take lengthy periods of education and outreach before these programs are used by significant numbers of callers. We are exploring the appropriate method of pursuing these alternatives.
We know that we have a lot of work to do. Addressing these challenges is something we will be working literally night and day to improve. I know that rising response times are a concern for this committee as well, and I am appreciative of the attention that you have given to it.
Regarding Int 0990-2026, we understand and appreciate the intention of the Bill. As written, we do not believe that the likely volume of notifications that would result would necessarily provide useful information to New Yorkers. However, we are open to further discussion and exploring ways to provide more real-time information to New Yorkers on this topic.
Before I conclude, I want to emphasize what a great job our members are doing despite this challenging environment. This year was an incredibly busy year for the regular demands of the 911 system. We operated in circumstances that included extended Code Blue cold periods, millions of visitors for the FIFA World Cup, numerous activities and events for the America 250 celebration and the International Naval Review, and we are preparing now for the holiday tourist season. Our EMS members have risen to the challenge time after time, conducting themselves with professionalism, saving lives and serving their fellow New Yorkers and visitors alike. I am proud of the effort they make every day and I am proud of the great success that they achieved even in these most challenging circumstances. Thank you. We would be happy to take your questions at this
time. Thank you, Chief. I just want to go and ask a few questions regarding the incident that took place at St. Francis Preparatory High School. Going back to her testimony, Jennifer noted that an ambulance never arrived for her child, who was showing signs of a stroke. Can you explain why an ambulance did not arrive that day?
We want to express our thoughts that it is unacceptable that we were not able to get an ambulance there in time. As a parent, the thought that your child goes to school, has a medical emergency, it is recognized and they call for help — it is unacceptable and we have to do better. I will pass it to Chief Miano and Chief Werner to describe the specific circumstances and what happened that day.
Thank you. So, echoing what Chief Esposito just said, this is a tragic incident that we want to try and stop from happening in the future. During the period of time when this call came in, the 911 system was experiencing an extreme number of calls — more than a hundred calls more than we normally receive during this period of time. Our call takers — they do not just answer a phone and say where is the address and then dispatch an ambulance. They spend a few minutes on the phone with each caller trying to ascertain exactly what is going on with that caller so we can dispatch the correct type of ambulance.
Unfortunately, during this time when Nicole's call was received, there were a high number of calls that came in and our alarm-receiving dispatchers were on the phone with other callers. That does not mean that this call was not dispatched. It was dispatched. It was sent from our NYPD dispatcher over to the dispatch and it was put into the system. It was classified as an unknown condition because we did not get to speak to the caller and triage the call ourselves. The call was dispatched out to an ambulance. The ambulance did start traveling towards the call, but the ambulance was coming from a distance. Unfortunately, the ambulance did arrive — they arrived after the patient had left to go to the hospital. At this point I am
just going to pause questions because we have been joined by Speaker Julie Menin and she does have a statement that she would like to read.
Thank you so much, Chair Ariola. I really want to thank you and the committee for holding this incredibly important, literally lifesaving hearing today. I really wanted to come by, first of all, to say that we all know in this City that we are truly facing a crisis regarding our EMS teams, who are obviously part of FDNY. They are understaffed and they are underpaid, and this City Council is very serious about this issue. I cannot overstate this — they are truly saving lives every single day. They are responding to calls — compared to FDNY's 500,000 — yet they are only staffed by 4,500 members compared to FDNY's 13,000. The average length of service for an emergency medical technician is just under three years, because the pay of $18 an hour for hard, long work is simply untenable.
So we are hearing story after story of our workers, many of whom after their shift are going and living in a shelter because they literally cannot afford housing, or some are sleeping in their cars. This is truly unacceptable. I do not know what kind of city we are that we are allowing this to continue. The lack of adequate pay has obviously led to both rising attrition and low recruitment, which of course perpetuates this understaffing issue. With fewer staff there are fewer ambulances ready to go at a moment's notice, which is obviously deepening the delays. And when New Yorkers cannot rely on emergency medical services to quickly respond to an emergency, who can they rely on?
Residents of my own district actually asked that very question recently, just a few days ago, when a 16-year-old was badly hurt during a basketball game. Despite five separate 911 calls, no one arrived. Despite a firehouse actually being next door, no one arrived. Thirty minutes after the first call, the teenager's parent contacted a private ambulance service because he could not wait any longer. Nearly three hours after the first call, FDNY phoned back to ask if an ambulance was still needed. I think obviously we are all relieved that his life was not at stake, but this is totally unacceptable. What if his life had been at stake? This cannot continue. And there have been many cases where people's lives are literally on the line.
We have seen in the Mayor's Management Report that the average response time is 13 minutes and nine seconds. This is wholly unacceptable. So as we wait for wages to increase,
response times are increasing to truly unacceptable levels. We know that brain cells begin to die after four minutes without oxygen, so the idea that we are now at an average response time of 13 minutes and nine seconds is just wholly unconscionable. We must act now to pay those who provide this lifesaving work a living wage and to ensure that New Yorkers in crisis can truly get the care they need. So thank you, and I will now turn it over to Chair Ariola for a continued hearing.
Thank you so much, Speaker. You make a very valid point, and it is the point that is at the crux of this issue — the fact that they cannot retain workers because they do not make enough money to sustain themselves, have a family and support themselves. Yes, some live in shelters, some live by the charity of family. They cannot sustain themselves on $18 an hour, working three 12-hour shifts and then working a second or third job just to make ends meet. So that is really the basis of the problem: you cannot retain people, and people will leave — whether it is to go to the fire department, to DOT, to sanitation or to a private hospital.
So that is where we have to say that the Mayor's Office has to deal honestly and competitively with this contract that they are negotiating now with the unions, and not just kick the can down the road like previous administrations have. They may not have caused this particular situation, but they certainly can end it, and that is what we are looking forward to. So thank you for bringing that up, Speaker. That is really the crux of the problem.
And I would like to note that we have been joined by a Council member. To the Speaker's point about what happened — I would like you to share the reason why an ambulance did not come and then called three hours later to see if an ambulance was still needed.
So before I give this to Chief Miano — again, this was a different reason than at Saint Francis Prep. But the idea that one of our children can be hurt at a school and not get an ambulance in an acceptable amount of time... I have sat in front of this committee several times with Fire Commissioner Bonsignore and before that with Commissioner Tucker, where we have said that the system is in crisis. And unfortunately we are still in crisis, and we are working to improve this. I will pass it to the Chief.
Okay, I just want to say with all due respect, yes, you are saying it is in crisis, but you really are the only people who can solve the crisis. I mean, let us be clear. You have got a City Council that wants to raise the wages. You all are the only people — the administration is the only people that can actually solve this crisis. I just do not understand how we can keep perpetuating this when people's lives are literally at risk.
Thank you. So for that incident, that particular incident — there were calls, we did speak to the caller, we did triage that call. That call was classified as an injury, which is a segment five category, and that is not considered a life-threatening emergency. An ambulance was dispatched — several ambulances, actually — with dispatch to respond to that call. But while en route to that call, they were preempted and redirected to life-threatening emergencies that they were the closest ambulance to while they were responding to that assignment. But when there is a...
...firehouse next door, should there not have been some — I mean, I do not really understand where the breakdown in communication went in this situation where you have got three hours that family is waiting. So ambulances do not come out of firehouses, and I understand that, but when you have got a situation where the ambulances are being rerouted, could there not have been an on-the-spot calculation to just check on...
...this young boy? So the ambulance — fire trucks, fire engines — are known as certified first responders, and there are certain call types that they respond to. Those are life-threatening emergencies like cardiac arrest, difficulty breathing, cardiac arrest with difficulty breathing. They are not dispatched to injuries.
Okay, so just — I will continue then with my questioning. So you said that you were holding more than 100 calls. Going back to Daley and her son Kevin and his issue — so you were holding more than 100 calls and it was put in as an unknown condition. More than a hundred calls. How often do calls go into the system as unknown, especially when they are as critical as Kevin Daley's condition was?
So I will defer to Chief Warner to speak about how it was dispatched, why it was classified as unknown, and that process. But as far as how many calls, how many times we are holding that many calls — unfortunately that has risen over the last few years. Our call volume is up, as Chief Esposito stated, and our head count is down, which means that we have fewer ambulances on the street to respond to those calls.
However, our life-threatening, our most serious calls — segment one through three assignments, cardiac arrest, difficulty breathing, shortness of breath, cardiac cases — those do not hold. Those calls are immediately dispatched out as soon as an ambulance is available. Those are our highest priority calls, and that is why the lower priority calls oftentimes, while ambulances are responding to lower priority calls, are redirected to higher priority calls because they are the closest ambulance to a situation where somebody who is in cardiac arrest is not receiving an ambulance. So I am going to turn it over to Chief Werner to explain the call typing and process and why it was designated as an unknown.
So this call was processed by the overflow position, so we did not triage it. The person that is categorizing it and giving it a call type is relying on the information that was obtained and relying on the code that they assigned. So this call was designated as a 54 cube, which translates in the code to an unknown condition. And I would understand that if it was just the school nurse that was calling, or the boy's mom, but a trained, retired FDNY member called 911 and stated clearly what was happening. So what would a suspected stroke be — a segment one or three? What does that categorize as? Had this call been triaged, it would have been categorized as a priority three.
Why was it not triaged?
There were no call takers available at the time that this call came in. So you also have a low head count for your dispatchers as well. So when we discuss head count, we are talking about every employee that we have in the service, and that includes members who ride on ambulances. It includes the members who are in emergency medical dispatch. It includes our instructors that are at training. It also includes our people who work in the Office of Medical Affairs. That includes every single EMT, paramedic, lieutenant and officer that we have. There is no specific head count for the field, for training — our head count is our head...
...count. Okay. So where — you are telling me that a segment one... I am going to expect a stroke to be a segment one, and I am assuming a broken bone would be, okay, segment three, maybe segment two.
But neither of them were responded to, at least that...
...parent got a call back. Miss Daley did not get a call back. This is why I had introduced Int 0990-2026, which you testified to, Chief — that you are open to further discussion but you do not believe that high-volume notifications would necessarily provide useful information to New Yorkers. I believe that if the Speaker's constituents, the parents, were aware that an ambulance was not coming right away, they would have chosen a different route earlier and called a private ambulance sooner. Also, for the Daleys — we have to do something so the public is aware, whether it is the Bill, the intro as it stands, or if we work towards an amendment. But the public needs to know whether or not help is coming, and...
I think we should continue discussion. We just do not think that the notification system is the correct way. Our concern is that the public might be confused or fearful and then not call an ambulance when they really need one.
And in that situation, for those life-threatening calls, even if we are holding calls, they get an ambulance. In the case of the child at Wagner Middle School, that is not a life-threatening segment one, two or three call.
So that is why they got preempted — those ambulances were preempted and went to a life-threatening call.
Correct. But if the parents knew ahead of time, they would not have waited as long as they did. And I do not know how long they waited, but certainly I am sure the overall wait time was unacceptable. I think the Chair makes an excellent argument in this regard — that families need to know if help is not coming. Because if their families knew help was not coming and we were going to be honest with them that they were not going to get an ambulance, then they would make other arrangements if they could — either a private ambulance, or if someone is able to drive them to the hospital. But just letting them sit there waiting and becoming more fearful and anxious and stressed and angry...
...but they have every right to be angry. We understand that. We should work together to come up with a way to make sure that they are aware of that. We just do not think that the notification system is the correct way.
It is the correct way to alert everyone for everything. So I do not know why it would not pertain here. But if they subscribe — so, open to discussion on it. So how often are...
...and what is the number of call takers that are available? So call takers are scheduled in a staggered manner — they report in a staggered manner throughout the day based on historical call volume highs and lows. So at our peak time we are staffed with the peak amount of call takers that we have, and at our off-peak times we stagger up and stagger down. But I will defer to Chief Warner for...
...more clarification. Our baseline schedule is three eight-and-a-half-hour shifts around the clock, and then I stagger the 12-hour members throughout the day into the evening when our call volume increases.
What, in your opinion, is the safe amount of calls to be on hold that the system can handle in the current staffing state? Could you just repeat that one more time? Sorry, so what...
...what do you believe is a safe amount of calls to be on hold in the system that the system now can handle in its current staffing state?
200 calls? 100 calls? Like, if you get an average of 100 calls in a day — and I am making that number up — and now you have got 200 calls that day, at what...
So I think it is much more dynamic than it being so black and white to be able to just come out with a number. About 38% of the calls that we receive every day are what we consider to be high acuity or life-threatening. So that means the other 62% of calls that come in are not considered life-threatening or high priority. We do not want our life-threatening assignments to hold at all, and that is why the system is designed so that if we are responding to a low acuity assignment, an ambulance is redirected to a higher acuity assignment. So there is no exact number that I could give you that would make any sense, because it varies so much — not just day to day, but hour to hour, and more literally moment to moment.
Like I mentioned to the Speaker, we had several ambulances responding to her constituent's injury, but they were redirected because someone else called and they were having what is considered a life-threatening emergency. What are the average number of calls on hold? Again, it is not that I do not have it — it is just that it varies literally from moment to moment. If we have high acuity calls coming in, they are not holding. But if we have an enormous amount of high acuity calls coming in at the same time as low acuity calls, we need to ensure the high acuity, life-threatening emergencies are responded to, and we need to hold someone who has called because they have an illness or an injury that does not meet the life-threatening criteria.
Okay, so but... Kevin Daley was a life-threatening call, and four calls were placed, and he went in as unknown condition. So how can...
...we prevent an incident like that from happening in the future? What you just stated was 100% correct, and we are not disputing that. So what Chief Werner — and again, Chief Warner, I will defer to her to speak on it — but as soon as this came to our attention, we painstakingly went through every single line of the assignment, minute to minute, all the calls that were made, all of the interactions between the police dispatchers and our radio dispatchers, to see if there was a unit available. We are working on improving our communications between NYPD and our partners.
That is very accurate. We are looking to improve the communications to make sure that we get vital information. I am sorry — what was the second part of the question? How can we make it better? How can we know? So currently I am utilizing offline members as well as those in training. During periods of high call volume I am taking them offline and bringing them to the call-taking floor to increase our capacity. So what is the current status...
...in your testimony? You said you are utilizing — so how often are you utilizing them? Only when needed, or are they available at all?
So we put a request out to all the volunteer agencies that operate in New York City, and they are volunteers, so they do not commit to us on certain dates and times. But when they are able to log in and put a unit into the system, we log them into the system and they help us. We do have some volunteer agencies that are tremendous and consistently running units, like our Central Park volunteers. We very consistently can count on Central Park volunteers to be in service and available and handling calls that occur within that Central Park area.
Okay, and in what circumstances can a hospital divert certain types of ambulance...
...patients? So when a hospital requests a diversion, we send an officer over to evaluate what is going on at the hospital and the reason why they need to do so. There are many reasons why a hospital can ask for a diversion. It could be utilities or infrastructure issues such as a power outage or computer IT issues. It could also be that there are certain types of monitoring that need to be done on certain types of patients. So they could divert cardiac patients because they have no more beds that have monitors. Perhaps they can divert stroke patients because their CAT scan is not working. So as soon as the hospital advises us that they need to go on a diversion, we evaluate what is going on and we speak with the administrator on duty. We also involve our Office of Medical Affairs to determine how long the diversion will last and whether it needs to be a complete and total diversion, or whether we just need to divert certain patients that we are taking to the hospital. Because maybe the general emergency room is open and operating but labor and delivery is having an...
...issue. So we would keep the hospital open for general emergencies but we would not transport someone who is having a baby. Okay, and...
...the Speaker noted that there was an engine company right next door to the school. So in what circumstances are engine companies dispatched to a medical emergency?
So our engine companies — the firefighters — are certified first responders with defibrillation capability for segment one to three calls. All of our medical calls, when they hit the emergency medical dispatcher, get triaged and get a segment. So if the call is segment one, two or three — life-threatening calls — the engine, if available, is assigned. The call that the Speaker was talking about was a segment four or five, and the engine company, which cannot transport, is not assigned to those.
Has FDNY ever explored the utility of having certain members of fire companies undergo training as EMTs and paramedics — those who did not come...
...into the Fire Department through that pipeline?
I guess in years past that possibility was looked at. We have had thousands of our members over the last 25 or 30 years that came in as either EMTs or paramedics. But now the EMTs and paramedics are on the ambulances, which is not optimal — we want ambulances to go to ambulance calls. So what is the process of getting an engine company back in service after responding to a medical call, and does the company have to wait until an ambulance arrives?
Yes, once that — they do have to wait for an ambulance. We have had times where that engine, because it winds up being a lower acuity call, could wait an hour or two with the patient waiting for an ambulance. The engine is not able to transport and they are not able to leave the patient. They cannot abandon that patient regardless of the level of illness or injury.
And what happens if a fire call comes in while the engine company is at the scene of a medical...
...call? That fire call would be handled by other fire companies. That fire company cannot leave. So what we are seeing is when a fire engine has to respond, there are gaps for possible fires that are happening in their district, in the area that they cover, their catchment area. Then they have to call in another fire engine company, and that leaves another gap. So you see what is happening here — it just puts more people in danger and it creates more of a public safety issue.
I just want to mention also we have been joined by CM Gale Brewer and CM Lincoln Restler. I just have a couple more questions and then I will defer to CM Narcisse. Just, for those who do not understand, could you please explain the roles of personnel on an ambulance? So advanced life support is staffed by paramedics and basic life support ambulances are staffed by EMTs.
Which is "B," which stands for Basic Life Support. So paramedics — I will expand a little more. Paramedics can provide Advanced Cardiac Life Support. They can provide medications that Basic Life Support cannot. They can provide advanced airway maneuvers like endotracheal intubation to secure somebody's airway who is not breathing. So the paramedics are an advanced level of care that provide additional medications. We are almost an emergency room on wheels. We bring the emergency room to your home, to the scene that you call, whether it is on the street or in your home.
Our paramedics — the paramedics that operate in the 911 system, whether it is FDNY or anyone who operates in the 911 system — they are... I am sorry, but it goes with the name: when New York City is best, right? When they come out and they assess the situation and they acknowledge the fact that this is a life-threatening situation, they go to work. This is the only emergency agency whose primary goal — their only goal — is life. That is what they do every single day. They put their own lives on the line and go home having not just saved lives but brought lives into the world. There is no better feeling than going from a cardiac arrest save to a couple of hours later delivering a baby. To get to experience and do that in the same day — only the members of the New York City system can do that. That is why we have to do everything that you have stated here, that you stated in your opening testimony, that the Chief of Department has stated, that the Speaker has stated. We have to take care of New York City's best, in many ways.
I will say it again: it begins with a living wage for EMTs and paramedics. If we fix the retention problem we will not have an attrition problem, and they will be getting paid to compensate them for the job that they do, because they are saving lives. Most people do not know this — they do not even have uniformed first responder status. They are categorized as civilians. So we need to really sit down... and we will hear from the unions later, but I know that I have asked for someone from my office to be here as a representative, because that is an area where, if we can fix that, we can then work on all the other problems. We need to do that right away.
Does the Fire Department believe that two paramedics are needed, and if so, who is driving the ambulance?
Two paramedics are needed to provide effective Advanced Life Support care. Our training — we train as a team, we do not train as individuals. As an RN, as a nurse, you know that prior to the delivery of medication, I do not just look at that medication. My partner has to look at that medication, confirm I am giving the correct medication, confirm the dose is correct, confirm the route is correct. That is why two people with the same level of care need to be in the back of an ambulance treating patients with life-threatening emergencies. So in situations where both paramedics need to be in the back of an ambulance, there are EMTs who drive that vehicle while the two paramedics are operating in the back.
Okay. And just to round out — would one EMT and one paramedic be able to provide the needed care? And does the department believe that fire companies should stay on scene for non-acute calls? I will take the first part of it.
There are extreme situations where we have multiple patients on the scene and we need to split up — we need to divide and conquer. We do duplicate the amount of equipment on an ambulance so two paramedics can handle two patients. In those situations, or in a fire, or a bad car accident, or even a carbon monoxide incident in a home where there are multiple patients who are unresponsive, we will divide both of those two paramedics up so they can operate. But it is not optimal to operate as a sole paramedic in the back of an ambulance.
But with staffing so low, something that could be done — since it was done during COVID and it can be done — we are in a state of emergency right now with ambulances. That is why we spoke about it. We had a meeting with the Mayor's Office about mutual aid, about bringing everybody off the desk and into the ambulances. So we are in a state of emergency, but I think that might be something you would want to...
Look at, Chair. Respectfully, we did do things differently during COVID, but taking that step — that was not a transition we made during COVID.
Okay, thank you for the clarification, Chief. And to your question about the point of fire companies staying with the patient...
We believe that when there is a patient that needs an ambulance, we have to stay with them to ensure that they do not get any worse.
Thank you. I yield now to Chair Narcisse. Thank you, Chair. I heard about the engine...
There was one next to where the school was, not too far. So what are the steps someone can take in an emergency? Like, the engine cannot call and say this is an emergency. Let us say if there is a rotation — they can call and say that there is an emergency here and one of us has to run with the child. Is that possible? In that case, where Engine 44 is — if it is not a life-threatening call, the engine does not get assigned.
If we were to send them there even to confirm, then they would be tied to that scene and they would not be able to transport that child who needed transportation to the hospital.
The engine is not able to do that?
Right. So they would just be waiting there, and that is why we reserve them for the serious life-threatening calls so that they can provide lifesaving care until that ambulance gets there. There is not much that the engine could have done for...
...that boy with the broken leg. Got it. I am in agreement with the Chair — retention is a problem. When I was at the Gerritsen Beach Fire Department ceremony, one of the things that came up is just the pay. The pay is not right. People are not going to stay. They are going to go to nursing, they are going to go do something else, and we have to look into that seriously.
Another thing — I want to introduce a Bill on this — it is about calling 911. We are in the habit, everywhere we go, even in police departments, of telling people in meetings: if there is an emergency, call 911. We are not detailing anything, and that is a problem. Another problem that we are facing right now is folks losing their insurance and ending up in the emergency room. They will call 911 because they know they can get in faster. As a nurse, I am going to tell you I know that for a fact. Some of them will tell you they have respiratory problems just to get in an ambulance and get to the hospital. That culture — we have to address it together. I hope people are hearing me: stop calling 911 if you do not have to. You can have an ambulance come and by the time I do a triage I realize that patient is not an emergency. There is no reason that patient should be calling 911.
But how do you say that? You just have to be patient, because they told people that if you have any problems — the person has a chronic illness, emphysema — and they are still calling 911 even though they have medication. So that is the problem that we have to work on in our own culture in the City of New York to try to decrease it. But retention is a massive issue.
Now, going to each facility — what are the current average emergency department wait times citywide and how do we compare to the past two years? Thank you, it is good to see you again and I appreciate all you do for hospitals and for helping us. The current median arrival time to seeing the first provider is 29 minutes at NYC Health + Hospitals overall, which is an improvement from previous years when it was 33 minutes.
How long does it take on average for a patient to be transferred from the emergency department to an inpatient hospital bed?
That is a great question. One of the measures we try to track is, after the decision is made to admit the patient, how long it takes to get out of the emergency department and get upstairs to the...
...bed. Right now that time is on average about 270 minutes.
270 minutes? I was hoping for 70 — we would all be pleased. I am just hopeful. What do you think is driving that problem? It depends on the capacity the facility is at, the time of day, what resources are available, how many patients are coming in, how many are being admitted. Also getting patients home is a challenge sometimes — getting patients out the door. There are a lot of different variables that contribute.
You know, there are a lot of different factors. Can you give me the top one?
I do not have the top one in front of me. I am happy to get that back to you. But the combination of getting patients out of the hospital and getting patients upstairs all contribute to the overcrowding nature.
Do wait times vary by hospital? If so, which hospital reports the highest and the lowest wait times?
I do not have the wait times for all the hospitals in the City with me here today. I could say that it depends on several factors. Time of day matters — it makes a big difference. Sometimes it depends on whether mass casualty events occur, as the Chief had mentioned earlier. It depends on seasonality as well. As flu season comes through and people get sicker with different illnesses, there are lots of different variables that contribute to it, and we try to staff to demand to meet those...
...expectations. There are a lot of variables, but what I am trying to get to is to see what the top ones are and what the plan is to make it better. Because right now we are in a crisis — it is a real crisis for us. Which affiliated hospital currently experiences the longest emergency department wait times and what factors are driving those delays?
I do not have the number for the longest in front of me, but I can say that a facility like Lincoln sees about 37 patients per hour arriving at any given moment at its peak. So when a patient is arriving literally more than once every two minutes, that is a lot of volume coming in to manage, and we have to increase staffing and increase our resources to meet those needs.
How are we doing with staffing? Because it is important — if you do not get the patient seen, they are not going to go anywhere. I hope there is not a shortage there.
We could always use more resources, but staffing is...
...important, and it is...
...comparable. We have physicians, nurses, patient care techs — I am only naming just a few of the needs of our emergency departments. As you know, we are a complex operation, like a Formula One team. We all have different roles and responsibilities to address a patient in crisis. When a critically ill patient comes in — a mass casualty, a trauma patient — a whole lot of resources are consumed for that one patient for quite some time, sometimes to stabilize and save that person's life. NYC Health + Hospitals...
...previously reported that provider-in-triage models reduced time to provider at Lincoln Hospital by approximately 20 minutes. Have those improvements been sustained and have similar models been implemented successfully at other facilities? Similar facilities use a provider-in-triage model, and what that does is allow the physician or a physician associate to see the patient sooner and start...
...the care sooner. It does not necessarily always improve the throughput of the case, and so we have to vary and see what the value is of putting a provider up front versus having them present throughout the entire patient experience.
Where are patients awaiting transfer from the emergency department to inpatient beds typically held?
I am sorry, what was the question? Where are the patients...
Usually, where do you keep the patient after you have finished in the emergency room while waiting to transfer them upstairs?
I think that is very facility-specific. It depends on the facility. Some facilities try to designate a separate space in the emergency department, and sometimes it is a scattered approach. So it is very facility-dependent in terms of how they manage those operations. It is almost constrained by building construction and resource availability, so I would not be able to answer that question off the top of my head. How are we doing with...
...space?
Because one of the problems that we face in many of our facilities is that we have no space at all.
We end up putting a bunch of folks in the hallway and it becomes more chaotic.
Are we doing well in that setting? I mean, it is a hard question to answer. Ideally you would never put any patients in the hallway. Ideally you would never have that need. But we will always see patients when they come in as quickly as possible and use any available resource we have for that.
Including hallway spaces and other areas.
Because that delays the process still — you know that, right?
What was that? I said that delays the process when you have people overcrowded. Yes, absolutely — it makes it more challenging.
What impact do prolonged emergency department and inpatient bed wait times have on patient outcomes, quality of care and hospital operations? Miss, sorry — can you say that one more time please? What impact...
...do prolonged emergency department and inpatient bed wait times have on patient outcomes, quality of care and hospital operations?
I have seen some mixed studies on that. I think overall we feel that the sooner the patient gets up to an inpatient bed, the better it is for the patient. I think it is more humane and private and decent for them to be there, and the resources are better served. So we strive in our limited resource environment to do the best possible we can.
I have been asking all these questions because I lived it. One of the things is that the patient gets aggravated from being in the hallway for a long period of time, and that actually affects your quality of care. The things that are in your mind — the confidence, the trust — everything just deteriorates. It becomes a problem.
So I think we have to assess our emergency space as well. Patients might get the impression they are not being cared for, for example, but they...
...are being cared for. Even in those situations, we have seen episodes of violence increase in emergency departments. We have seen nurses attacked, physicians attacked.
Yes, attacked, because when you are in this...
...environment, you are ill and you are not getting better and you are stressed, and...
...it is very complicated and very challenging for them. Absolutely. And that is why sometimes they sign against medical advice and walk out. How many of our patients actually get into the emergency room and do not finish getting care and sign against medical advice? Do you have that data?
I do not have the data with me and I am happy to get it for you. I know that patients who left...
...without being seen — that data is around 2% in general. What about the percentage who...
What are the most common reasons people visit emergency rooms? Do you track them to assess the need to continue improving services?
Yes, and every facility is going to have differences — different nuances to what their patient population comes in for. In general, pain — abdominal pain, shortness of breath — we take care of any patients that come in.
When an individual layperson might perceive something to be an emergency, we are here to help them and figure out whether it is a...
...true life-threatening emergency or not, and try to care for them to the best of our ability.
Because we tracked it in the ER — we asked people after the triage was finished. We have data that we entered to say why that person is here, so that data should be easy to obtain because the nurses have to document it. The triage nurse records why that person was there specifically — what was the main complaint.
Yes, and each facility has a slightly different chief complaint that is their priority. I do not have the data in front of me but we can break it down if...
...you would like us to. How are we ensuring that New Yorkers with mental health needs are being taken to the correct facilities instead of the emergency room? How can we streamline this process? That is a complicated question. I am not sure I am prepared to answer that fully today.
It is really important. I know that the 911 system is central to the B-HEARTS operation that we are working with, and we are continuing to work closely with both FDNY and others to address any operational challenges for the mental health crisis system — improving call triage and working with agency partners to drive mental health calls to appropriate resources. As an example, other...
...behavioral services can reduce their reliance on emergency resources to make sure that New Yorkers who are experiencing mental health crises receive the most appropriate response. So are you doing some kind of education as well for those patients?
Let us say a patient comes in and they have a mental health issue — it is not really an...
...emergency to be in an emergency room. So do we use that opportunity? I used to tell the patient: here is the information, and kind of guide the patient through the next steps. We try to...
...provide patients with appropriate resources to help get them the care they need. Thank you, and you were very kind.
I want everybody to be able to hear the answer. Have we experienced an overall increase in emergency department volume or hospital admissions in recent years? Yes — data please. The overall...
Emergency volume has been increasing since 2020. In 2025, we had over one million emergency department patients across our 11 facilities. The increase for us has also been in the higher acuity cases. So we try to rank our patients by severity index — you might be familiar with scoring. If you remember back in the day, the Emergency Severity Index goes from one through five. One tends to be a sicker patient, five tends to be a less sick patient, and our overall increase in the ones and twos has significantly increased over time.
Most of the questions — sure, no problem. Most of the questions that I am asking, I think, have to do with a lot of education. We have to educate people wherever we can get them, and to decrease the need for people to have a better understanding and to focus on preventive care. So you have a lot of clinics and different places that we can redirect people to, and I think engagement with the community is key. I mean, in the community, to help decrease those pressures, because wherever you can get people, you have to meet them where they are. Are we doing that in the hospital?
That is absolutely true. As a practicing emergency physician, my patients — just educating them about their disease, but also how to take care of the disease, how to find the right resources, how to get the care they need and where the most appropriate place for that care is — a lot of my day is spent connecting those dots and really just encouraging them to take good care and prevent illness from occurring. I had a recent case where a woman was very ill from sepsis, and because she did not understand how to get to the doctor in time, how to get the right care, what resources were available, she waited too long before she came to see me. It was tragic. So I think a large part of our care is connecting the dots of the resources, which are sometimes complicated and complex for patients to navigate, and we do the very best to try to provide those resources to our patients.
Are you closing any clinics — not patient clinics — do we have... because if folks do not have insurance, I am concerned that they will gravitate toward the ER. So are we, because we are not talking about preventive care — this is part of the plan of preventive care. Yeah, I mean, as Health and Hospitals, our goal is to...
Strive for preventative care — that is the best, right? Absolutely. We strive to help every New Yorker regardless of means, ability, et cetera, and so we are...
...committed to taking care of anyone who comes for care, and I am not aware of any clinics being closed. But we have, for example, financial counselors who enroll our patients in New York City Care to help get them preventative medicine and primary care. We have a virtual express care program, as an example, where we connect patients online through telephonic and video calls to give them care on the spot.
Within the last several years, have patient needs become more acute or complex, and has that affected emergency department throughput and wait times?
I would say over the course of my career I have seen a lot of complexities of care. The drugs are changing, the pathology is changing, our knowledge is changing, and so all of that is becoming more difficult to navigate. Connecting patients to resources is always challenging, and I think the more options and the more needs there are, the more difficult that will always be.
What are the primary operational challenges contributing to prolonged emergency department wait times? I am coming back to that again. Yeah, I mean, when you think about a patient who comes to the emergency department, there are so many needs they have. What does that patient need? Laboratory work, radiographic assessment, medication administration — all those things take time. The time it takes to draw blood, send it out, get results back — all these things add up, and depending on the complexity, they keep multiplying. It is not just a plus-one scenario. You add that with the fact that a facility seeing 37 patients an hour is trying to accommodate that many patients at once.
That also makes it more complicated and complex. Have you thought about exploring having those clinics closer...
...to the hospital, where you see the emergencies coming all the time that do not need to be there? Because I know you have the data — you just have to go back to triage to see what is going on. So if, let us say, it is a pattern, maybe we can anticipate partnering or having a place where we can move people out of the emergency room a little faster.
Absolutely. I mean, part of the issue is transportation, because we already have problems with trust — I mean, getting patients to come and get that care. So I mean, part of...
...it is that we do have clinics in our facilities as well. But under the federal EMTALA laws, we have to do an emergency treatment and screening exam for all patients that present. A lot of times, with some of these lower acuity patients, by doing that screening exam I can pretty much diagnose them and send them on their way. So simply diverting them to another clinic is not always the right answer, but educating them on the opportunities available next time, instead of presenting to the emergency department, might give them that option. So as I said before, a lot of my time is spent educating the public on...
...what options do exist, how to search for help, how to ask for help, and what other resources might exist for health care besides the emergency department.
I am going to ask one more question and then I am going to try to get it back to the chair, because I have a lot more questions. Today is about what can we do together to decrease the wait time in the ER and how fast EMS can get to the patient. FDNY is helping us — we are just looking for solutions to the problems we are facing, and that is the reason I am going to come back for more questions. I will actually ask the last one and then come back again.
What specific strategies is H+H pursuing to reduce overcrowding and improve patient flow?
We have partnered with FDNY on virtual express care, as an example. So we will see patients virtually by phone or video, and some 911 calls are being transferred to our virtual express care line, allowing us to treat patients on the spot right there, and sometimes divert them so that an ambulance does not need to be dispatched to that person.
...dispatched to that person.
So you have your mobile unit — let us see...
...if a patient... because one of the things that we lack is telling the patient, upon a visit to the clinics as well as in the hospital, "Do not call 911 — this is the step you need to take." And I think that is one of the things I am looking at in terms of the bills we are shaping. We are ready to see what we can do to help those folks in terms of education.
Not pressure, because sometimes it is a simple education you give people and they can do better. If we can reinforce it — if we just say it and then move on, people forget. Maybe we can get advertisements somewhere, something going on using social media, educating people, because we need to educate people and reinforce it. So at least we can decrease the flow of people, and we do not want to lose lives in New York City. So I am going to pass it on to my chair and then probably open it up for some colleagues' questions, and I will come back.
I just want to thank you so much for that. I mean, the emergency department is the safety net of this country — of this city — and patients know they can always come to us and be seen. We will never turn you away, and that is why I love my job and I love doing the work that I do, because we will always take care of patients who show up. But the challenge is exactly what you discussed, and so I think there might be an opportunity for us to discuss later...
...I look forward to seeing that bill — where can we decrease or redirect patients to find the most appropriate care they need.
I really believe in preventative care and that is what I have been preaching, and that seems like it is in slow motion right now. I think we need to sit down and collaborate on whatever we can do here with my colleagues to structure a plan to help and make it happen. I look forward to the opportunity. Thank you.
Thank you, Chair. We yield now to CM Schulman, then CM Brooks-Powers, then CM Epstein, CM Paladino and CM Brewer. Can I yield to CM Paladino because she has to leave? Most certainly. Okay, thank you.
Good morning, everybody. First off, let me say this: we fought very hard for pay parity for the EMS workers. It was one of our top priorities for the fiscal year 2027 budget. We raised this issue repeatedly during the delegation meetings, formally submitted it as part of our budget priorities, and pleaded with the Finance Department to address the compensation disparity. We warned that if workers were not paid the wages that they deserve, the City would continue to lose experienced personnel to better-paying jobs, making it increasingly difficult to maintain adequate staffing and timely emergency responses.
Unfortunately, we are now seeing the consequences of those concerns. Workers are being overwhelmed by call volume and response times are increasing. This is not simply a workforce issue — it is a public safety issue. New Yorkers calling 911 should not have to wonder whether an ambulance will arrive when they need it. EMS workers operate daily under extraordinarily demanding conditions. They deserve fair compensation, and the City must treat staffing and pay parity as the public safety priority that they indeed are.
You know, we are listening to you get kind of crucified here on the why and how and what-fors, when you receive the amount of calls that you receive every single day and you do not have the number of emergency vehicles that you need to respond, nor do you have the personnel that you need to respond to these calls. Everybody is sitting here wondering why — we need to hire the people to do these jobs. They are moving on because their pay is not sufficient. The Speaker came in and that is the first thing she raised, and she is 100% right. I would like to know, on average, how...
...many ambulance tours are out of service at any given time, and what are the reasons that an ambulance might be out of service? In a 24-hour period, we are averaging over 90 ambulances out of service per day, and that is overwhelmingly due to staffing.
Staffing again — not enough people to sit in the vehicles and take them where they are needed. So would you say that...
...at least 85% of what you heard here today — had this budget been met to your needs, had you been funded as you should have been funded — would you say some of these problems would not even exist today?
Because you would be able to get from point A to point B to point C in a timely fashion.
We believe that solving the pay issue is the first step to getting everything back on track.
100%. So this $126 billion budget that this City passed — none of it went to what you guys actually need to do your jobs. So that the people — that young kid at St. Francis Prep, and to the Speaker's point, the emergency that she faced — your ambulances would have been able to get there in a timely fashion had they been staffed properly. And if these people were paid properly, is that correct?
We could never make a guarantee, but we do not think we would be holding calls as frequently as we are.
So once again, I call upon New York City's budget committee and New York City's Mayor, and I want to know why the funds are not appropriated where they should be appropriated. We are facing a public safety issue here and you are on the front line, and you are sitting here today being asked all these questions that basically can be fixed. There are problems, but there are solutions to every single problem that the City is facing, and all we need to do is put the money where the money belongs. Thank you very much. That is all I have to say.
Thank you. CM Schulman.
Thank you very much. First of all, I want to say that I am the only member of the City Council who used to work for the Emergency Medical Service on the leadership side. I know a lot of the people sitting here in the audience today. The issue of pay parity has been long-standing, and I was there many years ago. So I have some questions.
One is: Chief, you said in your remarks that you are in the midst of a promotional cycle. That promotional cycle has so many EMTs in it because of the pay issue — or a large part of it is the pay issue — and I have heard this anecdotally from people on the street and working in the field. So again, I am going to reiterate what the Speaker said, what the Chair said, what all of my colleagues are going to say: we have to get the pay up for EMTs and paramedics. So that is one thing. I also have some...
...questions as well. One is: when you talk about response time, is that still point to point — like when they get to the address, or when they get upstairs? Response time is calculated from when the call is made to 911 to when we arrive on scene of the...
...assignment — on scene, meaning in the street. So I just want to point out to everybody that the actual response time is higher because you have got to get up to the patient, and that does not include getting up to the patient. I want to make that clear. That extends it. That is number one.
The other thing is that I want to ask you — I am very close to the firehouse, by the way, and FDNY does a spectacular job, and I actually participated in their community day this past weekend.
But the firefighters are telling me that they are responding to EMS calls. In fact, when I was sitting there, they had to respond to a call. So my question is, how many calls are...
...routed to FDNY? In any particular tour, our fire companies are routinely doing about a thousand CFR medical emergency runs each 24-hour period, each day. Some companies might be doing 10 or 12 while other companies might only have...
...one or two. Does that depend on what is in the queue — like if there is a backlog, they will go...
...out? No, they do not go out on the backlog. It is simply if it is a Segment 1, 2 or 3, and if that engine is available.
I appreciate that. The other thing I want to mention is that the City is in a position now where we are building a lot of affordable housing and doing a lot of construction. So you are going to have a lot more people living in different places, and I presume that the system will be inundated with more 911 calls because there will be more people living in all different parts of the City. Are you planning for that, separate from the problems that exist now?
As I mentioned earlier in my testimony, we are trying to use technology to best tell us where we should move and put resources, and it is something that we are looking at.
I have given funding for equipment for FDNY, and I have given money for equipment as well. I just want you to know we are big supporters here. You have got to let us know what you need so we can push for it. The Speaker and everybody is behind this, and as I said, I appreciate everything that you do. Let us figure out how to resolve this. Thank you.
Thank you, and we do thank the Council. We know that you supported us with driving simulators, conditioning vehicles and response vehicles. Thank you very much.
Now, CM Brooks-Powers.
Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the agencies represented today. At last month's hearing on the Rockaways, FDNY testified that response times on the peninsula are below the citywide average, but response time stops the moment the ambulance arrives, as was just indicated. For a resident of the Rockaways or another isolated community, the clock that matters runs until they reach a hospital where they can receive treatment. Can FDNY provide this committee with the full time from the 911 call to hospital arrival, broken down by Council...
...district? Right now I cannot, but it is something that I will look into when we get back, and we will provide you with what we have.
I appreciate that. Queens saw the biggest drop of any borough this year in calls reached within 10 minutes. Can you share why this is, especially given a decreased number of calls overall?
And just as a follow-up, right before you answer that: is FDNY currently monitoring how often areas are affected by not having sufficient ambulance coverage, and does that lack of coverage contribute to delayed calls?
I will take your last question first. We actively monitor call volume throughout the City 24 hours a day. Our CRC, which is our Central Coordination Resource Center, redeploys ambulances from areas of the City that have lower call volume and higher availability into areas that have higher call volume and lower availability. So we are constantly monitoring that and moving units around. When the FDNY truly stands for New York City — an ambulance that starts its day in one part of a borough can end up in another part of a borough, to help anywhere that we have deficiencies in coverage.
As far as call volume goes, we have already responded to calls this year, and over 480,000 of those calls have been Segment 1 through 3, or life-threatening emergency calls. So call volume remains high. And if you can just remind me — I do not remember the whole...
The question you asked first -- the one right before that one was just talking about Queens as a borough seeing the biggest drop of any borough in the response time reaching within 10 minutes, I think it was said. But we wanted to understand better as to why, considering that
there has been a decreased number of calls overall. I do not think the call volume has been substantial enough. Like I said, towards the end of not having an ambulance immediately available, no one tells you that information. A 911 call taker should tell you soon when they should expect help when a call is made. I know when I have called 911 I have been told that someone is on the way, but I do not recall ever being told necessarily the window of time. And this is what I think we can work on, because the person answering the phone that you are speaking to does not know the status of the ambulances or what is available or what part might not be available -- that is on the dispatchers' part. So we should work together to figure out how we can share that information, so if there is not an ambulance coming that soon, that they would know. Thank you.
CM Epstein: Thank you, Chair. Thank you for all being here. So it sounds like there is consensus we need to pay our EMTs more. It sounds like there is some opportunity to be working on that either this year through negotiations or next year in the budget. But I think we are trying to look at what is happening with the public-facing aspect of it, and we are trying to ensure the public has good, accurate information so they can be able to make informed choices about waiting a half hour, getting into a cab, or making other choices about maybe not a priority one system. You know, like, are there all the...
...tracked? Yes. So there is a recurrent system to monitor where those vehicles are and where they are going. Yes. And that is how we determine -- aside from whether it needs an ALS or BLS ambulance -- that is how we determine which ambulance is closest to respond to that call. And none of that is publicly facing. None of that information is publicly facing, meaning that someone can log in and see where ambulances are. There is no way to know if that is actually true. There is no way for someone who calls 911 back again to be able to say, "Hey, how soon is an ambulance coming?" There is no way to do that. No. So you...
...understand the concern that people have -- you know, my kid broke his leg and they were waiting at the playground for the ambulance to come, and if it is going to be an hour I make a different choice than sitting there for an hour with my kid who is in pain with a broken leg. I think we are all trying to solve this problem. I appreciate everything that you are saying and I think we appreciate what the Bill is intended to do. But in this situation, like the Speaker's constituent who called -- we had ambulances responding, but a higher acuity call came in and they needed to be redirected. So we do not want to... but we could tell them, "Hey, we had an ambulance, they were redirected, we are letting you know this ambulance is unavailable and we are looking for another ambulance to be sent to you." That kind of information -- I know people are busy, but there is maybe some automation that can help in that. The technology is there that we can do more publicly-facing work to help people with this information. We agree, and...
...we will take a look at that. We know that when they have the information that it might not be coming soon, they might take alternate action. We appreciate that, and that saves the system from sending a vehicle an hour later when there is no one there waiting for it anymore.
Okay. I want to turn to NYC Health + Hospitals if at all possible. So I am wondering -- we have SHOW, which is a program that sends people out from the system to locations. I am wondering if there has been a conversation about expanding that to relieve some of the tension on some of these calls. The SHOW program -- it is basically the Street Homeless Outreach and Wellness program. And then we have SHOW vans that, you know, down by me they come from Bellevue and up in Harlem. So we would be great to know from NYC Health + Hospitals where you are thinking about SHOW and the expansion of SHOW. Yeah, I would have to get back to you on...
...getting back to me about that. And how about Bridge to Home?
You know, are you familiar with the Bridge to Home program? I am...
...not as familiar with that as well. Okay. So the Bridge to Home program, which is another program operated at NYC Health + Hospitals, which I think you should become familiar with -- this is a program that creates beds inside of a hospital that provide ongoing care for people where they have a door, and allows people who have been in and out of the system to have a stable place to be until they can get into a supportive housing unit. So I am wondering from a budget perspective what is the opportunity to expand on Bridge to Home, which would also reduce some of the call volumes we are talking about. Yeah, I will get back to you.
I appreciate that too. And then I...
...know we talked a lot about BE-HEARD and the pathway to BE-HEARD. I am wondering how NYC Health + Hospitals has operationalized the expansion of BE-HEARD. Once again, those are great questions but I do not have the answers ready for you right now and will get back to you.
On it. But I know we are partnering with 911 and FDNY to expand that. Yeah, it would be great to know more details about what that will look like.
And what that expansion looks like, because I think we are trying to put relief valves on this system. And if we cannot win in the short term we need to figure out what that is, and some of these programs can really be those relief valves to take the pressure off the 911 system for people who have emergency needs but maybe do not need to call an ambulance -- if there are other tools like the SHOW van, which is out in the neighborhood already, or other programs that would be available to help people who have acute needs to get some support that they need. Yeah, I do want to...
...redirect back to the Virtual ExpressCare, which we talked about earlier, about how we help with the 911 system by answering calls for them and providing care on the spot, and also preventing ambulances from being dispatched to that call originally. Yeah, I appreciate that. All right, thank you.
Chair: Thank you. CM Pierina Sanchez: Thank you very much. I have a couple of questions. One is -- I know you have addressed this already a little bit -- I do not know what to call them, calls that are not emergencies, but people literally are sometimes just calling an ambulance to get to the hospital. So, how -- you heard earlier some suggestions about how to address that. People do not read, they do not pay attention, it is not easy to address. But what is the percentage of calls that maybe could be handled elsewhere? I think you have a pretty high number for that. So I am just trying to think of how we can work on that together, because I know people that do -- they...
...yeah, I think, as stated earlier, there is a misconception that if I arrive by ambulance I will be seen at the hospital sooner. However, as we have spoken about multiple times today, there is a triage process, so it is not how you got there, it is why you are there. But I think the main thing is that someone who calls 911 would believe they are having an emergency. So I do not know if we want to discourage people from calling 911, but as stated, better educate on what an emergency is -- what are the signs of a heart attack, what are the signs of someone having an anaphylactic reaction. And I think if we educate and start young, start early, and educate on what an emergency looks like, it will help us later on. I also think that we do have some other things in place, like telehealth, where we can transfer calls to a physician and speak to the physician without sending an ambulance. But I think that is new and it is generational, and I think...
...that when people right now want medical care, they want to see someone in front of them. And I think that as that becomes more normalized it will also assist us in being able to divert some of those calls from 911. I think we would love to work with you on the education of that in our newsletters and our forums with people who I think abuse the system. Number two -- I want to go to the open firehouses. We allocated funding for some of them. They want firehouse and ambulance support in Hudson Yards. Is there any discussion about this at all?
Hudson Yards -- we are not... I mean, maybe it is more on the fire side than the ambulance side, but it is a feeling of not enough support there. We did address that when they opened Hudson Yards. When they first opened we did put an EMS vehicle staffed in there, and at the time -- and that is obviously going back a bunch of years -- the call volume did not seem to warrant it. But we will take a look at the response times over there and see what the need is on both the fire and medical sides. Okay. The other...
...question, which is not a small one -- how do the sirens play a role? I am swamped with people who hate the sirens. Swamped. And so I know you are trying to get through traffic et cetera, but between the rumbling and the siren et cetera -- do you have any data on this topic? I live between two hospitals, my community lives between two hospitals, it is a constant complaint. Three o'clock in the morning, I do not know what kind of traffic you are going through. So is that something that comes up? Is there a reason to keep the sirens? Does it help with response time?
We are required -- especially as you go through intersections against the red light or a stop sign -- we are required when there is traffic to use the sirens to make sure everybody is alerted. Okay. But there are...
...different kinds of sirens. Yes, there are. The sirens we have on our ambulances are in accordance with the decibel maximum. But we are not the only ambulances in the city. I understand -- I am just talking about your ambulances because I know that is what we are talking about. But it is loud.
They are all equipped with the rumblers so that you can feel that even at times when you do not hear it. Okay.
I am letting you know that 311 calls are not able to be taken about sirens -- we are trying to change that. But in addition I can say that it is a big quality of life issue. And then just finally, I think my question is just generally -- what is it... I mean, is it all a combination of the challenges? It is the pay, it is the lack of ambulances, I assume it is traffic also. What is the combination -- sort of the elevator pitch as to what needs to be addressed on this? Because it is really making people in the communities frightened and...
...scared. The staffing issue is, in my opinion, overwhelmingly the biggest issue. To make a career -- people go there for a career, not to linger there while they are waiting to do something else, waiting to go to the Fire Department, waiting to go to Sanitation, waiting to get another job. We strongly believe that if we address the pay issue we will have people that come here for a career and stay. The difference between getting somebody that has taken a training class and has a little bit of experience versus somebody that has been doing this for 10, 12 or 15 years -- a very experienced paramedic or EMT can just by looking at you and getting you to say a couple of words have a very good chance of diagnosing you. And that takes years of experience to get, and that is what our goal is. All right, we all agree with that. Thank you very much.
All right, thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning. First and foremost, thank you for everything that you do and for the work that your members do. So I want to start with two experiences from my community. Two weeks ago my 90-year-old neighbor fell and struck his head. NYPD officers arrived on the scene -- I want to say within five minutes -- applied pressure to his wound, cared for him for those 25 remaining minutes that it took for an ambulance to arrive. And then officers in my local precincts, the 46th, the 50th, the 52nd, they tell me how frequently patrol cars are being pulled away from other duties to respond to even nonviolent medical emergencies. And then of course, when ICE shot a man in my community a little over a week ago, it was an NYPD officer who transported that father to the hospital. I do want to say I consider that officer a hero. But here is the thing -- while a life saved is a life saved, these experiences are not what New Yorkers should be seeing across the City, with NYPD responding to medical emergencies instead of trained EMS. Is it always the case that NYPD is responding to these emergencies nowadays given the shortages? How often are police officers transporting patients to hospitals because an ambulance is not available? And if you do not know that, then -- how often is NYPD transporting folks to a hospital? And all...
...stop there. So we do not record when NYPD arrives before us. In my experience, the great majority of the time either a fire engine or ambulance arrives at the scene first. There are times obviously that the police department will be there -- such as that shooting. We had units responding. That was obviously a shooting, it is a priority for us and we got there pretty quickly. The patient was already gone. So we know anecdotally that there are times when NYPD transports patients because we did not have hands on the patient. We do not have a report of that. We know -- talking with the police department -- they record that in their reports, and they were not able to pull it quickly enough for this hearing to get it to us.
It happens. Thank you. And let the record reflect that -- thank you, Madam Chair. I did request this information yesterday morning, understanding that is not a whole lot of time, but we really do want to make sure we have that information to have a complete picture. And then the second question -- I probably will not have time for more, but just in terms of the quality of care that happens: if a police officer -- we know they have basic emergency medical training, but they are not trained and equipped at the same level as EMTs and paramedics. Is that correct?
I will start with this -- that is part of the issue. We do not know what training they have or what care is being given. And I will pass it to Chief Miano.
So I do want to say that NYPD does routinely respond to calls, and it is sometimes based on why we are being called. If there is a fight or if it is due to a motor vehicle accident, these are things that NYPD has to respond to. They do not respond in place of us. We are one emergency response service -- whether it is FDNY, NYPD -- and we respond together. Oftentimes NYPD is responding more to make sure that we are okay, to make sure that our members are safe while operating in an environment. Thank you. Thank you, Chief.
I understand that, and thank you. But a 90-year-old man, a senior, who falls down two steps and hits his head -- there is no threat there. And so, as a layperson, I am understanding that NYPD is responding because they know that EMS will be delayed. So I think there is a very important question to be answered. Please do follow up with us -- what is the training that they have and what is the training that they do not? I just want to be respectful of time. I can send these in writing and continue the conversations with you all. My questions here are founded in a deep, deep respect, appreciation and even love for what you are doing on the ground. And I think...
...everybody is repeating that we need to solve this problem. But I guess I will just close with -- how does this make workers themselves feel? How do paramedics feel knowing that NYPD does not have the training that they do, that others do not have the training that they do, but they are nonetheless being dispatched while workers are so undervalued in our City?
I know that our EMTs are the best trained and most experienced that we have in this country. They get out there and they do their jobs and they are very, very good at it. I think that competitive spirit and that can-do spirit that we all have in the Fire Department -- you want to be the one that goes there and does your job. You do not want anybody else doing your job. You want to get there and provide that help and save that life. And that is what I think makes our people as good as they are. I do not believe that NYPD is responding in place of us. I believe that we all feel that we complement each other. Where someone who has basic training, whether it is NYPD or another agency, can start care prior to our arrival -- that is just an additional link in the chain of survival that the City is able to provide. And that is why we do drills and we do joint training with NYPD, with the Fire Department -- that is why we work together. Because when the City is in crisis, those agencies are the ones that are stepping up and we need to be able to work in harmony with each other and understand everyone's limitations and also what we bring to the table. Thank you, Chiefs.
Thank you. I thought it would be a clarification for me with a Council member. So when is the dispatch log created, and is that done in conjunction with the NYPD? Is that when you are communicating with another agency? It is done as soon as the incident enters the 911 system, and that starts with... which would be why the NYPD has access to that, right? They get the information first. Now go back to the unknown, because I think that deserves a few more answers.
Condition: a low priority. And why would it not be considered a high priority? Because they have not been triaged, so they do not know what the illness could be, and it could be a cardiac arrest. So we have a computer-aided triage system which, as callers give information to questions that are asked, we enter that information into the system. Chief Werner can expand on this, but that is what determines the call type. It is not the individual dispatcher making a decision. It is a computer-aided dispatch triage system. The information received is placed into the system and leads you down the road to be able to determine what... the information we do not have to enter in order to be able to classify it differently. The unknown...
...condition is a priority. So I would like to add that that is the highest priority of the lower acuity types. Of the low acuity, correct. But in Kevin...
Daley's condition, it was a high... I understand. And our dispatchers are also EMTs, so that also comes into the low staffing, because if you are low-staffed in general then we are going to be low-staffed with our dispatchers as well. You have 4,500 personnel — would you say...
You said earlier, was it in your testimony, the budgeted amount is 4,500? We are below that — 410 to 464 spots below budgeted headcount is our actual staff. So I know that you are taking steps to increase that headcount. Could you explain what you are doing? So we are trying to recruit — recruitment across the country since COVID-19 has been challenging. We continue to do classes. We have 163 EMT trainees currently at our academy at Fort Totten, and we have another 150 or so in our paramedic classes out there as well. And so even though they are included in that headcount, that is below what we actually have out in the field, trained and working. So...
...continuing to have tests and recruit and try to fill our classes. So 4,500 is your optimum and 4,100 is what you have now. Do you think that even if you are at 4,500, that that would be enough EMTs and paramedics to be in ambulances to serve a city of over a million and a half people? That would be a great start, and that would be a good problem to have and a question to answer at that time. Okay. So...
I want to go back to you, Chief Werner. Step by step, what happens when no caller is available and a call comes in? It will be released to our overflow position, which we refer to as relay. It will come with a code, and there is a person — a call taker — seated there that manages that work, and they will put the job into the system, the incident into the system, based on the code. Okay. And if the call taker is unavailable at the time that this incident occurred — any time a call taker is not available, is there not a call taker available? Correct. It goes to the overflow position, to the overflow, and then it goes to low acuity, right? Number five — always the highest lower? It could be higher. No, it could be a higher acuity. It depends on... the caller is interviewed first. They get the address, the borough, and they ask what is the emergency, and that information is transcribed into what they categorize their code as. Some of them are pretty broad — there could be multiple things occurring that would take that type of code. They need that code to enter the system. They need that code to enter it to us, and then we take that code and we have a list of what each code represents, and that is how we acquire the unknown call type. And how long does it usually take for an unknown to get properly categorized? As soon as it hits their terminal — within 30 seconds. It is not right, but we do not have an ambulance to...
once it is entered into the system from the call taker's perspective, then it gets sent immediately to a dispatcher. Right. We spoke...
...earlier. Chair Narcisse was talking about once the ambulance gets to the hospital, and I know that there was a pilot program for an EMT to be at the hospital so that they could remain and hand off to a medical professional. I do not know if that pilot program is still in existence...
...and has it been replaced by something? So we ceased that pilot program. That was called the Hospital Liaison Unit, and what that did was it had an officer and an EMT at 13 hospitals throughout the city. When a low acuity call was transported to the hospital, if they met the criteria of being low acuity, then they would take over the patient's care, report and provide triage to the nurse, allowing that ambulance to return back to service. While we did see a small decrease in hospital turnaround time, the greater impact on the system was not seen, and we felt that it would be more valuable to reduce response times by having those members back on ambulances to respond to calls. So we did step down that program. However, in times of mass casualty incidents or large volumes of patients being transported to a hospital, we will activate an officer to respond to the hospital as a liaison to better assist through that triage process.
With the hospital. And since you are in contact with the hospitals, have you had a productive conversation with them regarding handoffs, EMTs getting back on the street, whether or not they would not accept a patient for a certain mental illness? And have you had conversations with the hospitals within the H+H...
...system? Yes, and it is not just specific to H+H — it is with all hospitals. We have borough commanders, and then within the boroughs we have divisions, and those chiefs routinely meet with our...
...designated Office of Medical Affairs physician that oversees that borough or that division. They routinely meet with hospitals to discuss statistics, metrics, and work on improving — setting goals and improving on areas that we can. Okay. And I know you took a deep dive into Kevin Daley's particular situation. Was it ever categorized as a high priority...
...unknown? I think that as we did that deep dive, Chief Werner and her team identified some areas that we can strengthen in our communications with NYPD, and she is currently working with the NYPD productively to be able to close those gaps.
I just want to talk about the Comptroller's report, and then I am going to yield to you, Chair. So the Comptroller, as you know, came out with a report, and he said that in the spring of 2026 the number of ambulance tours per day went from 488 to 332, which is a 32% reduction. Why did it happen? Where were tours removed, and will this impact response times and quality of patient care?
So those two numbers are actually two separate numbers that are incorrectly being compared. The larger number — the over 400 number — is our physical ambulances. That is the amount of vehicles that we actually have. And then our tours and our units are the ones that are in service and operating. So we have a tour count, and our tour count that we want to meet every single day is 640. But we do not run all 640 at one time. We run in 12-hour periods — we run 328 during the day and then on the evening period we run 312. So when those two numbers are looked at, there is an excess of ambulances. We have 400-plus, and then we have the 300 number, and those extra ambulances are the physical vehicles that are spread throughout the city at stations. In case we have a mechanical issue, we are able to move the unit into one of those spare vehicles.
Thank you, Chair. I have a question. Can an engine... can a patient clear the ambulances — which is refuse medical attention, for those that do not understand what that is — right?
So an RMA — refuses medical attention — is when somebody calls an ambulance and that patient, when we arrive, does not want to be treated. That is a procedure we call an RMA. Currently only emergency medical technicians and paramedics can do that, so the firefighters on the CFR engine cannot do that. Okay, because I...
...think for safety you do not want to... meet someone and then the person needs emergency care and they are not assessed properly. That is what my assumption is. Is that correct? Under normal general guidelines, the firefighters that are certified first responders are not tasked with that. Okay. Should everyone be calling their ambulance of choice? Can you do that? Should they be calling the private or the volunteer...
...hospital? So — I am sorry — volunteer agencies do have ambulances in their communities, and that is first and foremost their job: to staff their ambulance within their community. If someone wants to call their community volunteers directly, they absolutely can do that. When you call 911, you get the closest ambulance in the 911 system to where the location is for the illness or injury. We do not determine whether it is a municipal or voluntary hospital ambulance. When we dispatch, we dispatch the closest appropriate ambulance to the location where the injured or ill person is. Okay. So...
I was trying to see if we can decrease... might you decrease the amount of folks running in one space? And you kind of... it is a difficult moment — you do not have enough, and then if those volunteer ambulances... I have... we have had... so would you encourage that to happen in a case where, let us say, it is not really a true emergency, like even...
...a level four versus... yeah. So I think again, if someone had their volunteers — and I do not know if we can guarantee that a volunteer is always going to be in service — but we can guarantee that if you call 911 we have ambulances in service. You have made it...
...crystal clear. Now I am going to ask some of the actual workers, because I want to find out what kind of incentive we can create. You can tell me what kind of incentive we can create. Yes, we want the pay raise — we want that, because people have to pay the bills. We understand that New York City is very, very expensive to live in. We all know that. And we want to know — how is it working? What kind of incentive, in your mind, can we create, even coming from our side, to make sure we are keeping our workforce in...
...place in New York City? So I am sorry — are we talking outside of pay? Yes. Okay. So outside of pay, which I think pay is first and foremost, but outside of pay, I think the members who are sitting behind me and the members who are on ambulances right now deserve respect. They deserve to be acknowledged. They deserve to be understood — that when everybody else is calling for us because they need us, we are the ones that are coming, no matter where it is, no matter the circumstances, no matter the challenge to our own safety. The members that wear the EMT and paramedic patch in the City of New York are truly the most selfless people that you will ever meet, and I think that it is time that they get the same acknowledgement that every other emergency agency gets as well.
I am going to say that we have the holiday season coming up, and last year for the first time, through the work of the unions along with the former Council member Brendan Wright, Thanksgiving dinners were provided to every single station throughout the city. I cannot tell you how much of an impact that had on the membership's morale — to be able to actually have turkey on Thanksgiving instead of fast food. We do not get the opportunity to sit inside the station and have a dinner, but to be able to grab a holiday-appropriate meal and eat it on your lap while driving as fast as you can to somebody's emergency, just knowing that somebody thought about them, was tremendous. I would just ask the Council if we can duplicate that again this year.
...with our unions, and it worked with us, and provide our members with those small... as everyone else. So if changes are appreciated — I mean, you can consider it done, because I know Speaker Menin and my colleagues are all... we are going to make sure we make it happen. And even if we have to — I am going to commit her money — even if we have to do it out of our pocket, we are going to do it. So yes, that is a little... because I want more. I have to acknowledge my colleague De La Rosa, who is with us. So that is a little, but is there anything else you can imagine that you think we can do besides that? Because I am ready. You can count on me, because I love to feed people. I love to take care of people, you know, coming from a nurse. So I am in. There is a commitment — probably your pocket, your private money, or the City's — I do not know which way we are going to go — to make sure... I did not want turkey. It was filet mignon and lobster. But at least... because you are the best...
...guys. Thank you. And I have to say that just hearing the passion from the Council and seeing how much the service matters — it means a lot. I am more than willing, along with the Chief of Department and Chief of Emergency Medical Dispatch, to sit up here and answer your hard questions, because we are trying to solve a problem that is going to make the Emergency Medical Service better. And I know all of you — 83rd and Flatlands, right? Open arms anytime. Just come by. I know I am telling you this, but they will be prepared for you. And I think that is what we need. I think we need more acknowledgment. I think we...
...need more thanks, and this committee does that, but I think it needs to be done on a broader level, citywide. Absolutely. We are committed. I committed her without her knowledge already — that is how I know that she is not going to say no to that. This is the least that we can...
...do. At the 2024 hearing, assigning liaison officers along with them to nine of the busiest New York City Health and Hospitals emergency departments to facilitate patient handoff and reduce ambulance turnaround times — can you provide an update on the implementation and results of that initiative? Has FDNY measured any changes in ambulance turnaround times, unit availability, response times or other operational metrics? Which hospitals currently participate, and are there plans to expand, modify or make the program permanent? I know you started talking about this earlier, but just...
...give me more detail. So we did start initially with that number of hospitals. We did expand out to 13, but like I said, while it did have a small impact on the reduction of time inside the hospital, the overall greater impact on response time was not seen. So we reallocated those members back to the field because we felt that the greatest way to impact response time was to have more ambulances available on the...
...street. I understand the reason I am asking you over is because I want to know what can we do right now. You used the pilot program — you repeated it for me. Now, what can we do to actually decrease time in the emergency room with the staff in the hospital? You have seen the program, you did the pilot, it did not work, but I believe that you have learned from it...
...and what can we do? Yeah, I think that what is really important is the continued communication between — like I said — the borough, the division and the Office of Medical Affairs with the individual hospitals, to work on tweaking triage systems to be able to expedite a patient off of our stretchers and onto hospital stretchers. But each individual hospital is dynamic, so each one has to be individually studied, spoken about, and then different things have to be implemented in each...
...hospital. All right. So have you started the conversation, knowing that the pilot program did not work but we have got to do something to decrease the amount of time that they spend at triage? So have you heard any positive feedback, or whatever feedback that you...
...have received? Yeah, again, these conversations are happening monthly in some locations, quarterly in others — they are happening and ongoing. The increase in time after the... we only saw an increase of about two minutes. So we are... and this is citywide, right? This is citywide. But I am focused on... right. So we have a great partnership with H+H and, like I said, we are continuously working together...
...to improve. Can you walk us through the patient handoff from start to finish once the crew is at the hospital? What responsibilities does the hospital... well, now you do not have that, so we are going to have to work back there. You already gave me that part. Since we do not have that, I will not be able to... but there is no plan to return to that because it is only two minutes at the moment. There is not... now, much time when... Sinai, right? Beth... because how has the closure of...
Mount Sinai Beth Israel in April 2025 affected patient volume and hospital capacity in the emergency department with wait times across the system. That is a really hard thing to measure, right, because just trying to figure out where the patient originated from and where they ended up... We could say that overall Bellevue has seen a moderate increase in emergency department visits, which may or may not be related to that closure. It is not possible to track the exact cause of that. Do you know that Bellevue's turnaround time within the City is below the City's average of other hospitals, and that they are getting their numbers back on the...
...streets. Okay, but some of the answers... I think we share some of the questions. I thought I was getting more answers from you. But New York City Care, at a previous hearing, stated that it does not collect data regarding New York City Care. Can you answer some of my questions? I think I did before. We provided some more feedback if...
...you like. Okay, I will try to ask. If you do not know it, if you do not have the answer, we will go back. At a previous hearing it was stated that it does not collect data on emergency department utilization, but has since developed metrics to measure whether New York City Care is reducing avoidable emergency room visits. At this...
...point we do not, unfortunately, have the data on that. I know that we are involved in getting patients enrolled in New York City Care for preventative care, primary care and virtual express care. By this point in time we do not have data to see how it has decreased emergency department utilization. How many New Yorkers are currently enrolled in New York City Care and how does that compare with enrollment levels two years ago? That is a great question and I unfortunately do not have that data for me right now, but I will get it. I will get it...
...to you. Should I stop on that and then we can send you the questions? Absolutely, thank you. Thank you very much. Because this is a fun thing, because we are supposed to talk to each other and to know exactly where we are going and how we can help. I mean, I have met people that say that when they come here and we ask a lot of tough questions, it is not about us. It is about what can we do together. I hope, because I heard from it... it is not for that. It is just making sure that we have to be responsible for New Yorkers and we are all in it together. We just have to get through it.
Previously reported serving approximately 33,000 unique patients across 55,000 psychiatry emergency services and comprehensive psychiatry emergency programs. How have those figures changed over the past two years? Those numbers have increased slightly. So in 2025 we treated 33,400 unique patients, of which 56,600 visits were at our three psychiatric emergency services — eight adult and child comprehensive psychiatric emergency programs...
...visits, for 56,600 visits total. The emergency department LEADS program — it is an H+H program that places licensed clinicians and peer counselors in the emergency department to identify patients at risk for substance use disorders and connect them to treatment and support services. H+H reported over 22,500 LEADS encounters in 2023. What are the current numbers and what outcomes have been achieved?
A great program. One of the hardest things we deal with in the emergency department is substance use. Speak up a little, you know that, right? But I want people that are watching us and people in the back to hear. As an emergency doctor, I do not get too excited and I try to maintain my calm. The LEADS program is great. It helps get people plugged into substance abuse care. It is one of the hardest things we deal with in the emergency department. So you said in 2023 we had 22,500 encounters. In 2025 there were 30,420 encounters. In 2025 there were over 6,500 referrals to outpatient clinics and over 3,600 naloxone kits distributed. I want to talk about follow-up with my colleagues. But a...
...great program. And my passion too, because the minute he called me I was so excited. Because when you discharge a patient with mental illness and send them back to the streets — that is what we see. A lot of people on our streets. I am seeing people with gowns, I am seeing people talking to themselves just coming out of the hospital. So Bridge to Home is the program, and I love that as well. I am supportive of housing and supportive housing and other places that my colleagues were trying to tell you about. Those are the places that we should push more, so we have...
...fewer folks with mental health issues in our train stations and different places. We want them to be not in the emergency room. We have frequent flyers. When I used to be in the ER, we knew certain people just came because of whatever was mentally going on, or maybe they needed to be warm, or sometimes they needed a little cool air conditioning. So whatever we can do to triage those folks — not even the triage nurse, because they are frequent flyers and they do not have anything. By the time we come and assess them we can ask them the question, what is the problem, and sometimes they are kind of very honest with the nurses. And they do not have to get in there. So I think I want to hear from the social workers themselves, and there are things that we are supposed to do for them and we talk about it. But any more questions? You can continue with the questions. I am going...
...to take a break. Okay. So what are the specific gaps being addressed with the NYPD and FDNY dispatch communications? Better methods for sending and receiving messages. And I would like to ask for a transcript of all the calls related to Kevin Daley. I would like that to be sent to committee counsel. He will be reaching out for that.
I am going to switch gears to something that I believe causes response times to go up, and that is street closures. The ambulance companies are reporting instances where emergency responses are impacted by street closures. We have had discussions about specific streets and specific stations where complaints have been received. However, there is currently a street redesign on Cordell Road in Brooklyn. The administration has stated that the local firehouse, which the DOT is required to get input from on that project, had many objections to the project that would affect emergency response and public safety and their response times. Our office alerted you, but DOT is moving along with the project as originally presented. When was the last time you brought these objections to DOT's attention and have you asked why they are continuing to move forward with this particular project, even though the safety of the people in the area would be at risk?
In accordance with the City regulation — that is Local Law Six — we did reach out to the local fire company. We did get their feedback and comments, which were provided along with our concerns. But as you know, we do not have veto power on that. You do through Local Law Six. Well, you know, no...
...it has to be approved by the local firehouse. And that was a Bill I passed. So their input should be adhered to, because the input says we will not be able to traverse this street if it is reconfigured — whether closed, or a bike lane, or any type of reconfiguration of a street. It will impede our ability to get to a fire or any other public safety issue quickly and efficiently, and it will increase our response times and impede our ability. We see it all the time where big rigs cannot make a turn because there is a street closure, or they have to put the ladder across the street because one side of the street is closed. So that is what Local Law Six was all about. So this was a specific issue where the input from the firehouse at Cordelia Street said we cannot do our job as effectively if this street configuration is changed. So Local Law Six is still in effect. It is not... I know that the Mayor is looking to reverse that with a referendum, but as of right now, DOT — we make our concerns known, we share that information from the firehouse with DOT, and DOT proceeds. Have you spoken to the local Council person in that area? I have not. Perhaps I will have that conversation. Thank you.
At the 2024 hearing, testimony stated that it was working to educate New Yorkers about urgent care and other non-emergency options. This included using outreach on when to call 911. Is this being expanded? Did it work? Did you try it? Because we have been talking and I forgot to ask that one.
We have not instituted that as of yet.
All right, but that is one of the things that — as you can hear — we can do things better, and that is what I wanted to collaborate on. So let us work on this. I think that would be very helpful. We have had it... you know, with the permission of the Chair, because I respect the Chair, so I still have to look good. Hey, now I am just bothering you. Yeah, we will work it out. Thank you on that. One of the things — forgive me if I forget — I do not know if the Chair had asked: how many 911 calls where the unit arrived on scene did not need emergency care or an ambulance transport? Do you track that?
We have the number of ambulance transports. Now my question is, on the scene, they did not need emergency care at that point. So when we arrive at the scene, we do not tell someone they do not need emergency care. If they want to be transported to the hospital, we transport them to the hospital. If someone says, I just want to be evaluated, I just want my blood pressure taken, right, and we take that blood pressure and everything seems like it is okay, and the patient decides they do not want to go to the hospital — that is where that RMA that we spoke about earlier comes into play. But we do not go to someone's house or the location where an ambulance is called and tell them that we are not taking them to the hospital.
Okay. So I will be very clear at that point, because the person qualified to tell the person — wherever they are assessing — they are good, they have the training, they are one of the best, right. So taking them to the hospital... I do not know. I said, as a nurse, I do not know, because if they do not need it, that is how we end up with the frequent flyers in the ER that make the emergency room overloaded. So is there a way... I think that it needs more discussion. Right? If someone calls for an ambulance, we evaluate, treat and transport, and if they want to be transported to the hospital we take them to the hospital. I mean, that is a one-two punch. Do you agree? And also, right, we cannot just abandon a patient. There are state regulations on abandonment and we cannot just tell somebody we are not taking them and walk away. I get that, but yeah, that is a tough one. Because that is why now I know why I was getting frequent flyers for no reason — because they called 911 to get in. So Chair, I think I am finishing my questions because there has been a long process. I do not know if you have any more questions or...
Yeah, I just want to make mention that CM Aldebol has joined us. And if the Council members do not have any further questions, thank you so much to both of the Chairs for this important hearing, and I greatly appreciate the leadership from the department being with us today. You know, I...
...have appreciated your candor and forthrightness in recognizing that we have a crisis with regard to staffing and compensation of our EMTs. And I apologize that I have been in and out a little bit this morning, but I think your testimony was clear and compelling that your response times are not where you want them to be because we just do not have enough people power.
Speak to the efforts that you are making now to increase recruitment, and what do you think a reasonable time frame is for us to expect a significant increase in EMT headcount? We are partnering with schools and colleges, trying to get the word out that we are hiring, that these are good jobs. But the recruitment problem going back a couple of years is across the country and it is stifling us a little bit. And I have been candid — again, refreshingly — in recognizing that if we do not increase pay, we are going to have a serious problem. We need to resolve outstanding contract issues to make sure that workers are compensated fairly, to improve recruitment and improve retention.
This has been an issue that has been going on for some years. The contract issues have been going on for some years. There is a nationwide shortage of workers. Is there any kind of plan that you can share with us today, or a timeline for when we think things could start to improve? Things are not where we want them to be right now. I think recognizing collectively that there is a problem is the starting point, but then the question is what are we doing to fix it and how are we going to get there. Is there anything you can speak to about how we anticipate an increase in headcount happening in the near future?
It is not a resource issue, it is just a recruitment challenge, and we continue to run our academy. We would like to have classes of 250 and we have not hit that goal. Can you speak to the current number of people who are in classes and when... Right now we have 163 in our academy. We started with 200 and we are down to 163, and they will graduate in the middle of the year and we will see an immediate, pretty quick impact as they hit the streets. Do you have a timeline for the next class after that? It will be early in the new year that a new class will begin. When the recruitment period is open, I ask that — we have a very robust recruitment unit — any event that you are hosting or having where we can get a room at a table, please let us know and we will bring recruitment there. We also have a training unit which we would love to bring out and inform people on the importance of the work and be able to get that message out there. So any events that you have, please contact us and our recruitment team, and we will make sure that we are able to get somebody out there to try and get people from your districts into...
...our EMT program. I really appreciate that. I think that we want to work together to improve this. The contract issue is the other side of this coin, and if we are improving compensation, the recruitment gets easier and the retention improves as well. I hope the administration is able to resolve this with the unions. I have appreciated that this new Fire Department leadership has made clear the issues among our workforce that have to be addressed, and we are really excited to start to hopefully see some progress on that very soon. We would love to work with you more on recruitment, so we will be in touch on that.
It is not for today's hearing, but I will just make a note for the record that I am committed to figuring out some solutions on siren noise. I know that CM Brewer has made it a passionate project for many years now, and we would love to work with the department to try and improve not just the well-being of our neighbors but the well-being of staff who deal with extraordinary noise every single day. Thank you.
Thank you. I am blessed to have the doctors here representing H+H and talking about all the questions. But I promised something that I was going to do. They never called me a clown — I do not know, probably somewhere around, but not on my social media. They call all of us elected officials clowns. These companies use healthy humor that actually helps all the children suffering in the hospital with cancer. And I want to put this on for them, to say to all the clowns: keep doing it, keep bringing laughter to those kids that are suffering in New York City and in general in our country. And to all of the kids, God bless you. And I put this on to show you that yes, I can be a little playful. So thank you. Thank you for the strength. Thank you. Thank you.
Thank you for that. So we have two short follow-up questions, one from CM Aldebol and the other from CM Brewer, and then we are going to wrap it up. Thank you for being here with us today and thank you, Chair Ariola.
Just following up on CM Restler's question about recruitment — you get them in the door, how long does it take, once you recruit them, for them to actually get hired? Going about retaining your workforce — how can you keep that workforce here? I understand that EMTs leave being an EMT to become firefighters. That is like the next step, the next progression. But there is not anything in between. There are not, within the EMT service, steps or promotional steps or salary steps for them to progress through, to have a reason to stay in a career in EMS. Are you thinking about that and thinking about what the strategies are for this workforce?
Yes, so I would push back a little bit on saying that becoming a firefighter is the next step. People join EMS because they have a passion for the work, and I think that everything that has been discussed here talks about a livable wage and being the main reasons why people have to leave. They leave for other reasons. Maybe they have other goals. Maybe they wanted to become firefighters, or they wanted to become a nurse, or they wanted to become police officers. But it should never be viewed as the starting step to something else. It needs to be its own career.
We have recruitment periods. Once those recruitment periods end, we process the members, they go through physicals, and then we put them right into the next class. It has been stated multiple times that none of us sitting up here, nor the Commissioner, has a role in pay, which is a driving factor in increasing that to be able to make sure that we retain people. But what we can do as leaders within the Fire Department is try and change the quality of work life that our members have.
The Commissioner has a long, long history. The Commissioner is a long-standing veteran of the Emergency Medical Service. All of my staff have more than 20 years on the job. We speak frequently with the unions and we try and address the quality of life issues that we can address within our capabilities. That is just one side of what is going to make people want to stay. If people want to do the work and they enjoy coming to work, they are going to stay. If they are able to pay their bills, they will stay.
So we will work on our part about making sure that we are doing everything we can to improve their quality of work life, while the unions and the City are working on the pay side. In EMS there are significant promotional opportunities. As you come in as an EMT, you can stay in our Hazmat unit, which is some specially trained Hazmat personnel. You are able to promote to a paramedic, and you can become a rescue medic. Chief Miano and Chief Warner promoted up through the ranks to Chief of EMS. As long as we are...
On that topic, though, because you mentioned the collective bargaining: are you aware of how many collective bargaining meetings the FDNY have had with the unions and the Mayor's Office? If you know that... I do not know that, but I am told that there are positive actions going on in their negotiations, which I am, from my business background, incentivized to keep them within the structure. Can you give us advice on what we need to do, what we all can do, to let them know that we love them, we appreciate them, we respect them? So within the structure itself, what are the incentives that you are giving, besides the paycheck, to help encourage them to stay?
Within the structure, the department offers a wide variety of different things. I guess we can consider them incentives. There is tuition reimbursement for college. You can work here at the Fire Department and earn a degree. I myself...
I earned my bachelor's and my master's degree through the assistance of the Fire Department. That is one way that, I guess, we can call it an incentive — to know that we have that backing. We have other organizations — not agencies, but we have the Foundation, we have the Help Fund. These all collaborate and have programs with different types of assistance that they can provide to our members, including the unions. The unions have a very substantial network of people who assist them with financial matters, mortgages, attorneys, and other life things. When you look at that, I do not know if we want to call them incentives, but we have these things available within the department, within the union, within organizations that are interested in helping us, that you only get by being a part of this department.
Regarding wellness, since we are dealing with a lot of stress, especially in the kind of work that we do — like in the ER, or EMTs dealing with clients — how are we addressing mental health, wellness and encouragement within the structure? The first part of being able to address that is having someone come forward and say, "I need help." We can acknowledge that somebody may be having an issue and we can say to them, "Hey, we have these things available for you," like our peer support system, like our Counseling Service Unit. We partner with New York City Well. But people have to accept the help, and we are working on breaking that stigma of it being a sign of weakness to say something is bothering me.
I spoke earlier about being able to save a life and deliver a baby, versus having to look at a parent while you are unable to help their child. Nothing is worse than having to look at a child while you are unable to help their parent or their grandparent. I cannot tell you, throughout my 27-year career, how many times on Christmas morning I have worked a cardiac arrest under a Christmas tree while families are watching. Those are things that will weigh on you for the remainder of your life. It is up to you to be able to say, "I need help," and this department, along with the collaboration with the unions, is doing everything possible to get people who need help the help they need. Thank you. Heroes need care as well. So thank you.
For your time. Thank you, thank you very much. The new head of OLR is a rock star, so she will figure all this out — that is what I know. I have two questions quickly. First, a lot of the EMTs I know come from the military, so I am wondering what the percentage is and how you do recruitment there. Second, I think at one point there was some kind of an effort to tell us what you call 911 for. I wish New York had understood this — this is what you call 911 for, and this is what you call other means for. Do not use 911 in this case; maybe use telehealth, et cetera. Is that still in play? And then finally, I think the Fire Department got at one point some kind of a National Science Foundation grant to help with response times — a $2 million initiative. I was just wondering what happened to that.
Concerning the grant, I am not familiar with that, but we will look into the status of it. We will get the percentage of military veterans that are in EMS. Do you recruit from the military? We would certainly hire them, and I guess we could look at some recruitment with them as well. And the $2 million grant — I will look into this grant from the National Science Foundation. Yes, and it was to... okay, thank you.
Thank you. Okay, so I think we have really discussed so many things. Incentivizing is very good. I think that until they are properly paid, making them feel as though they are valued and a topic of conversation — that they are not just forgotten, that they are not just out in the street, that they are the topic of conversation here in the press, in the administration, at the Council office, at the Speaker's office — they are probably the most talked-about division within the FDNY right now: the EMTs. I think we need to, in addition to the compensation, give them uniformed first responder status. We need to give them civil service status. We need to recognize civil service exams for an EMT, or captain, deputy chief, division chief, whatever it is. Let them know that they can rise up in the ranks as you did, and that there is a way.
I am completely dedicated to the FDNY and any branch of service that our public servants use to protect the lives of the people in this city. That is why chairing this committee is so important to me. That is why we asked the questions over and over again. I cannot tell you how appreciative I am for the answers that all of you — even H+H, we know you belong to them but you belong to all of us — your preparedness, your heart for the job, what you want is what we want. We all know at the end of the day what we need first is more money for our EMTs.
In conversations that we have had, I and the unions — the unions will testify — I do believe we are at a precipice right now where we have the ear of the public, the ear of government, and the unions will be able, I feel very confident, to strike a very good collective bargaining agreement. Even though it has been overdue for so long, I do not think there has ever been a time where more people and more levels of government were looking at the discrepancy and the disgrace in pay equity for these workers, and the thankfulness for the job that they do.
Thank you, thank you, thank you all so very much. Your portion is over. Please, you are dismissed. The panel is dismissed and we will go to public testimony. There will be someone from the Mayor's Office staying as well as someone from the Fire Department staying through the public testimony. They will not be questioned, but I want them to be able to hear what is said.