Emergency Response in the Rockaways, and Other Geographically Isolated Communities in NYC
Committee on Fire and Emergency Management
Meeting overview
The Committee on Fire and Emergency Management held an oversight hearing on emergency response in the Rockaways and other geographically isolated communities, prompted primarily by a July 25 incident in Far Rockaway involving a double homicide and fire that left dozens of families displaced and exposed serious gaps in the City's interagency response. Chair Ariola convened the hearing with CM Brooks-Powers, whose district includes the Rockaways, playing a central role. Testifying were NYC Emergency Management Commissioner Christina Farrell, FDNY Chief of Fire Operations Paul Mariano, and FDNY EMS Chief John Scirocco.
The July 25 incident served as the hearing's organising case study. A fire at an active crime scene left 22 adults and 7 children displaced, but because it was classified as a one-alarm fire, NYC Emergency Management did not initially respond — their threshold for automatic deployment is two alarms for residential properties. The Red Cross arrived but could not access the property due to the active crime scene, eventually housing families using private rather than HPD-contract funds. Families, including a mother with five children living above the crime scene who were effectively trapped for hours, received little coordinated trauma support. CM Sanchez pressed hard on the communication failures between agencies, the absence of a clear notification chain linking FDNY, NYPD, Emergency Management, HPD and Red Cross, and the inadequacy of the existing Red Cross contract for crime-scene-adjacent displacements. The Commissioner acknowledged the gaps, noted the agency received funding for 10 additional citywide incident coordinators plus 5 part-time coordinators, and committed to follow-up on mental health and interagency communication protocols.
The hearing's most alarming moment concerned a separate September 28 incident in Central Queens, where a 14-year-old showing stroke symptoms waited over 35 minutes for an ambulance that never arrived before his parents drove him to hospital. During that hour EMS received 274 calls against a normal rate of 179 per hour. Because no FDNY dispatcher ever received the call — it was logged by an NYPD dispatcher as "unknown condition" rather than triaged as a high-priority segment three — the system treated it as lower acuity and never notified the callers of any delay. Chair Ariola used the case to make a broader argument: EMS staffing is below 400 personnel, a recent promotional ceremony removed roughly 25% of the workforce before the next class graduates, no mutual aid has been requested to bridge the gap, and there is no system to notify 911 callers that an ambulance is delayed. She called this a "dispatch abyss" and argued it is a citywide problem decades in the making, getting worse, rooted in wages too low to retain staff.
On geographic response more broadly, FDNY representatives argued their data shows the Rockaways' 47th Battalion ranks among the top five fastest-responding of 49 battalions citywide, with six engines, three trucks, a brush fire unit and 10 EMS ambulances including three ALS units. But CM Brooks-Powers and CM Sanchez challenged whether this captures the full picture, noting that Peninsula Hospital's closure has increased transport times to Cohen's and Jamaica Hospital, that responding to large incidents drains resources from adjacent communities like Howard Beach and Springfield Gardens, and that evacuation route signage is outdated and in some cases refers to roads that no longer exist. The prior administration committed in writing to update the Rockaways' evacuation routes, a commitment that has not yet been acted on. Public Advocate Jumaane Williams added testimony calling for a trauma hospital on the peninsula and linking geographic isolation to structural climate vulnerability, noting that Sandy-era federal funding commitments remain relevant context.
The hearing was more substantive than the typical oversight exercise. It exposed a real and specific failure on July 25, raised a genuinely alarming EMS staffing and dispatch triage problem illustrated by the September 28 case, and surfaced the evacuation route issue as an unresolved bureaucratic commitment. The agencies were notably well-prepared and candid rather than defensive, and the Chair's closing remarks — promising the committee would be a "squeaky wheel" on resources — had the feel of a hearing that intends to produce follow-up rather than simply generate a record.
The record
Numbers
- NYC Emergency Operations Center activated for 183 days so far in 2026.
- Flash flood plan activated for 90 days so far in 2026.
- 450 flood sensors monitored in real time during the recent nor'easter.
- 30 Notify NYC messages sent during the nor'easter.
- Over 200,000 people reached through 39 Strengthening Communities partner organisations in 12 languages during the nor'easter.
- Notify NYC has over 1 million subscribers, with 22,000 added during the nor'easter weekend alone and 234,000 added since the start of 2026.
- Basement apartment alert enrollment grew nearly 30% in 2026 to over 8,000 New Yorkers.
- NYC Emergency Management Instagram grew 38% in 2026, with 5,500 new followers added in the nor'easter week.
- 51 flood barrier kits and 24 pump kits delivered to Rockaways and Howard Beach residents during the nor'easter.
- Approximately 2,700 downed tree task force requests received during the nor'easter.
- 22 adults and 7 children displaced by the July 25 Far Rockaway fire and homicide incident.
- EMS normal call rate is approximately 179 calls per hour citywide.
- During the September 28 incident, EMS received 274 calls in one hour, approximately 100 above normal.
- First 911 call for the September 28 stroke case was at 8:47 AM; ambulance arrived at 9:37 AM, approximately 50 minutes later, after the family had already left for hospital.
- 26 alarm-receiving dispatchers were on duty during the September 28 surge period.
- FDNY EMS current head count is below 400 personnel.
- The Rockaways 47th Battalion ranks among the top 5 of 49 FDNY battalions for response speed.
- Six engines, three trucks and a brush fire unit are stationed on the Rockaway Peninsula for fire operations.
- 10 EMS ambulances based on the peninsula, including 3 advanced life support units and 2 Special Operations Command hazardous materials ambulances.
- NYC Emergency Management received funding for 10 additional full-time citywide incident coordinators and 5 part-time coordinators.
- CERT programme has grown to over 640 volunteers across 24 divisions covering all 59 community boards since its 2003 launch.
- 39 new CERT members added through a local Far Rockaway training.
- New York City received over $14 billion in federal aid following Hurricane Sandy in 2012.
- Strengthening Communities programme is funded for several more years through Hurricane Ida disaster recovery money.
- Mutual aid is triggered only when system availability falls below 25% for a sustained period of approximately 24 hours; the last time this occurred was during COVID.
- Three safe sites opened in 51 schools each across the City during summer 2026 flash flooding events for basement apartment residents.
Action Points
- NYC Emergency Management to follow up with Council on what mental health and trauma support resources are available to crime-scene-adjacent displaced residents, and which agencies are responsible for providing them.
- NYC Emergency Management to consult with Red Cross and NYPD on improving coordination protocols for displacement incidents that are simultaneously active crime scenes.
- NYC Emergency Management Commissioner to consult internally and with partner agencies after the hearing on what additional services can be brought to bear for violence-related displacement incidents outside the standard fire-vacate model.
- NYC Emergency Management to explore whether additional citywide incident coordinators can be designated or borough-deployed specifically to cover geographically isolated areas such as the Rockaway Peninsula and southeast Queens.
- NYC Emergency Management to follow up with Committee on whether the Strengthening Communities programme can be extended beyond its current Hurricane Ida disaster recovery funding, and to work with City Hall on a post-funding model.
- NYC Emergency Management to arrange a flooding town hall and distribution event in Rosedale, following flooding impacts during the September 2026 nor'easter, as requested by CM Brooks-Powers.
- NYC Emergency Management to begin process of updating evacuation routes for the Rockaway Peninsula, including signage, in response to road de-mappings and development changes, as previously committed to in writing by the prior administration.
- FDNY EMS to provide Committee with data on the number or percentage of fleet vehicles on which Local Law 134 QR codes have been posted.
- FDNY EMS to review and report back to Committee on the frequency with which 911 calls during surge periods are logged as unknown condition rather than triaged by an FDNY dispatcher, and the operational impact on response prioritisation.
- FDNY EMS to assess whether mutual aid should be proactively requested to cover the staffing gap between the recent promotional ceremony and the graduation of the next EMT class.
- FDNY EMS to examine whether a caller notification system for ambulance delays can be developed and implemented.
- FDNY to coordinate with DOT and local firehouses on the impact of road design changes, including open streets configurations, on emergency vehicle response times, and to report findings to Committee.
- Red Cross and NYPD to confer on protocols for responding to displacement situations arising from violent crime scenes, as committed to by the NYC Emergency Management Commissioner.
- NYC Emergency Management to activate Strengthening Communities networks and provide flood preparedness resources in inland areas including Rosedale, not only coastal zones, following the nor'easter.
- NYC Emergency Management to open Strengthening Communities programme applications in October 2026 and work with Council to amplify the opportunity to community networks citywide.
Full Transcript
Good morning. Welcome to the Committee on Fire and Emergency Management. At this time we ask that you please silence all electronics. If you wish to fill out the speakers card, please see one of the sergeants at arms in the back. At no point please do not approach the dais. Chair, you may begin.
Good morning. I am Joann Ariola and I am the chair of the Committee on Fire and Emergency Management. I would like to acknowledge members of the Committee who are here: CM Carmen De La Rosa, and we are also joined by CM Selvena Brooks-Powers. Today's hearing will be an opportunity for the Committee to examine emergency response in the Rockaways and other geographically isolated communities in New York City.
A central component to a well-functioning city is a local government that prioritizes the prompt, effective and efficient provision of emergency services to its residents. As chair of the Committee, we have routinely examined how the Fire Department and New York City Emergency Management and the City as a whole respond to emergency incidents, working to improve the City's delivery of emergency services, lower response times and expand access to lifesaving protection and care that is offered by our first responders each day.
As a lifelong resident of Queens, I take pride in representing the interests of the City's outer borough residents and have worked tirelessly to ensure that vital City services are provided equally to New Yorkers throughout the five boroughs. Given the geographic expanse of our City, responding to emergency incidents in far-reaching neighborhoods of our outer boroughs can present challenges for first responders and other City entities that provide support services at the scene of emergencies.
Today we plan to examine how the City responds to emergencies in geographically remote areas. We will look at how first responders are deployed and stationed to ensure prompt emergency responses and how the City ensures all New Yorkers receive emergency services promptly regardless of where they live. Today's hearing will highlight an emergency incident that occurred this summer in Far Rockaway, Queens, in CM Brooks-Powers' district. CM Brooks-Powers will further speak about what happened in her community and what her constituents experienced in the City's response. I hope that we can use exploring this collaboratively to improve the City's functioning for all New Yorkers.
I would also like to thank those from the public as well as representatives from the administration: Commissioner Christina Farrell from New York City Emergency Management, Chief John Scirocco from FDNY EMS, and Chief Paul Mariano from FDNY. You are here to provide information. CM Salaam has also joined us on Zoom. At this point I would like to defer to my colleague CM Brooks-Powers for her statement. Thank you so much.
Chair Ariola, I will keep it brief so that we can get into the heart of the questions. I would like to first thank you, Chair, as well as the Speaker for quickly responding to the needs of my community and convening an important hearing such as this. As New York has seen much more regularly, there have been a number of weather events that have been happening impacting communities.
Particularly coastal communities that have always been front line, but even more inland. What sparked this particular request was the July 25 incident that happened where we saw two deaths. We had a number of families that were impacted and the response felt very scattered and the resources very bare. At that time there was also a massive fire happening in the Bronx. While we do not control when emergencies happen and where they happen, it raised the concern once again in terms of what type of resources exist for geographically isolated communities such as the Rockaways.
The FDNY and the EMTs serve my community and I am quite frankly grateful for their service to us. I worry about them when they have to respond to these crises because we depend on mainland resources to be able to get to us. When we talk about the Red Cross and what services they provide, I think we need to revisit what is sufficient in moments like this where we have dozens of families that end up being displaced, and how to respond much more quickly.
I hope that in the questions today we are able to identify where some of the gaps are that could spark either internal reform within these agencies in their response divisions, or prompt legislation on the Council side to be able to provide the direction that is needed. So again, I thank you for the opportunity, Chair, to bring this important conversation to the public.
Good morning, Chair Ariola and members of the City Council. I am Christina Farrell, Commissioner of New York City Emergency Management, and as has been noted I am joined today by Chief Jano and Assistant Chief of Fire Operations John Scirocco. It is our pleasure to be here today on the final day of National Preparedness Month to testify on the topic of emergency response in the Rockaways and other geographically isolated communities in New York City.
As you all know, this has been an exceptionally busy year for activations. So far this year the Emergency Operations Center has been activated for 183 days and the flash flood plan for 90 days. This past weekend brought a nor'easter and associated heavy rains, wind gusts and flooding into isolated communities such as the Rockaways, Arverne and Howard Beach. Emergency Management tracked this weather system for four days before the first raindrop fell, activated the flash flood plan early and scaled operations as the forecast worsened.
During this time we held two elected official calls, monitored 450 flood sensors in real time, sent 30 Notify NYC messages, worked with 39 Strengthening Community partners to reach more than 200,000 people in 12 languages, and received more than one million social media views and impressions. Notify NYC now has more than one million subscribers with 22,000 added just this weekend and more than 234,000 added since the start of the year.
Enrollment in our basement apartment alerts has grown nearly 30% this year to more than 8,000 New Yorkers. Our Instagram has grown by 38% this year with over 5,500 new followers this past week. This weekend we delivered 51 flood barrier kits and 24 pump kits to residents in the Rockaways and Howard Beach. The downed tree task force was activated and received close to 2,700 requests.
And much of the City Council was...
Directly active with me and with our team through the day of the emergency. As always, we thank you for your partnership and your assistance. This year we also saw the second longest cold snap in the City's history followed by some of the hottest temperatures and heat indices in the City's history during the July 4 holiday. As you know, we are still in hurricane season.
Geographic isolation is a central factor in designing our hurricane evacuation zones. For example, while the entire Rockaways Peninsula may not be completely inundated by storm surge, we classify the entire area as Zone One. The isolation and limited access routes lead us to treat these areas as special cases to ensure residents remain safe even if not directly impacted by a particular hazard. There are similar considerations taken into effect for other geographically isolated areas of the City such as Roosevelt Island, City Island, Coney Island and parts of Staten Island.
One of the most heartbreaking incidents that City agencies respond to are incidents when New Yorkers are forced to leave their...
...homes, whether the result of a fire, flood or structural issues. During larger incidents like multi-alarm fires or large immediate sheltering of residents, this often involves opening a nearby public school or dispatching an M bus where residents can remain out of the elements and register for services with the Red Cross, including hotel placement.
Emergency Management uses triggers and protocols to respond to requests for sheltering assistance. These were developed to ensure we respond to incidents with the need for interagency coordination based on the likelihood of a multi-agency response and the complexity of these types of incidents. While the majority of fire calls are handled locally by FDNY resources, we respond to the following: one-alarm fires in a sensitive location such as schools, houses of worship or City properties; two-alarm fires in residential properties; three-alarm fires and above; any fire with two or more fatalities; any fire where we have been requested by FDNY, Buildings, NYPD or any other agency to provide interagency coordination at the scene. These fires usually involve requests for utility shutoffs or repairs, or overcrowding and squatting conditions.
Emergency Management citywide incident coordinators will also lead on-scene meetings with relevant agencies and landlords to identify immediately needed resources such as large-scale equipment or food and water, and any need for additional public messaging.
In addition to our City resources, the Red Cross monitors public safety communications and responds to all fires that reach one alarm and above on a daily basis. The Red Cross responds to vacate situations across the City to register New Yorkers and provide them with temporary hotel placement. Additionally, if Emergency Management responds to a fire that is likely to displace residents, we will notify the Red Cross to ensure they are also responding. Once registered with them, displaced residents are placed in a hotel for two nights. Residents are then referred to HPD for longer-term case management assistance if they qualify for the HPD shelter system.
Emergencies and disasters can strike at any moment, which is why Emergency Management is proud to offer several programs to help New Yorkers with readiness and resilience. The Strengthening Communities Program offers grants to community networks to build their emergency preparedness plan and provide information to their neighbors during times of emergency. These networks were activated during winter weather and extreme heat and play a significant role in flood preparedness. The Far Rockaway Arverne nonprofit coalition, or FRANC, has been part of Strengthening Communities since the program launched in 2020. FRANC provides various community programs and youth development programs within Far Rockaway and has connections with faith-based congregations throughout the community. We will have an open application in October for additional networks throughout the City and we will work with the Council to help amplify this opportunity when applications open.
Additionally, Emergency Management recently expanded its Community Emergency Response Team, or CERT, program by delivering a local basic training in Far Rockaway, adding 39 community residents to a volunteer corps of more than 640 members citywide. Since its launch in 2003, New York City CERT has grown to 24 divisions covering all 59 community boards and it remains a critical resource in supporting New York City during and after disasters. Building on that momentum, CERT members are conducting community canvassing through the end of October to share preparedness tips on coastal storms and flooding with residents in at-risk neighborhoods.
Emergencies affect every community differently but we work with all communities to be prepared. We want to thank the Council as well for helping us with these measures, from amplifying our messaging to being cooling center partners to helping us distribute masks during air quality alert days to being active with CERT. We greatly appreciate your partnership and assistance. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. We look forward to working with the Council and we are happy to answer your questions.
Thank you so much, Commissioner, and thank you for the coordination over this nor'easter in my district and in the coastal districts. You really did an amazing job of putting together all the other agencies and making sure that everyone was safe and informed. We really thank you for that. I would just like to mention that we have been joined by CM Maloney and CM Pierina Ana Sanchez.
I am going to ask questions regarding legislation and then yield to CM Brooks-Powers, as I know she has some questions specific to the Rockaway Peninsula. So first, with regard to Local Law 60 of 2025, NYC Emergency Management is required to develop guidance for facilitating safe evacuation before flash flooding emergencies. Has this guidance been developed and if so, can you please describe the specifics for the Committee?
Yes, so we definitely have guidance. Happily, this past weekend did not result in an evacuation situation, but nor'easters can. In addition, we have had several, as everyone knows, flash flooding events over the summer. We have worked with our partners. As we do our coordination, as you mentioned, we do things like a Red Cross call-down in case we do need to look for hotel rooms. We also — as people have seen over the summer — three times opened safe sites in 51 schools, one in each district, in case people that live in basement apartments or in low-lying areas need a place to go. Several residents took us up on that and that is something that we are codifying further.
And for FDNY, with regard to Local Law 134 of 2025, the law also requires FDNY to distribute the guide at the scene of residential fires using a quick response, or QR, code posted on vehicles. Has the QR code been posted on the vehicles and if so, how many or what percentage of the fleet have been started? Thank you.
For that question — yes, we have posted QR codes. As far as the data on the amount, I do not have that information, but we have started that process a while ago, over the last year, on apparatus so victims of fires can scan it and get information regarding the Red Cross. All vehicles that are involved in fire response have them. So all the vehicles in the Fire Department on the fire operations side do have QR codes on their apparatus. Yes.
Thank you, Chair. Just echoing the Chair, I definitely want to thank you, Commissioner, for being so responsive to my text messages throughout the nor'easter. So, as I mentioned, on July 25 there was an alleged double homicide and fire in Far Rockaway. Residents were evacuated and families were displaced. Can you walk us through July 25 from the 911 call moment to the moment the displaced family had a bed that night? I just wanted to know, for example, what time NYC Emergency Management was actually activated and notified and what resources arrived in response to that.
Sure. So we were made aware of the fire but did not initially respond, as is my understanding. Then as the situation evolved, as many of these situations do, later that evening there was outreach to us, I believe initiated by your office and others in the community. So we did send one of our senior citywide incident coordinators out there to get an update on what the situation was. Once he got situational awareness, he determined that the Red Cross should be there. It is my understanding that the Red Cross was dispatched earlier but since it was an active crime scene and there were other things going on, they were not able to access the property earlier in the day. But the Red Cross did come...
...that evening and they did begin to register folks. The power had been cut and some other things had occurred, so they registered some people in surrounding properties. There were also a couple of residents that I understand had relocated temporarily to Staten Island or other places, and so they tracked them down and saw what assistance they needed and got people into hotels that evening. Thank you for that.
And I am going to come back to a part of this that I would like to unpack a bit more. But can you tell me how many households and individuals were displaced and where did each spend their first night?
I do not have their specific information. Things like specific hotels and things are...
...kept private. Geography is fine — like you said, somewhere in Staten Island for example. But how many families were displaced and how many individuals?
22 adults and seven children, obviously representing multiple households, received temporary lodging. And there were...
...animals too.
I do not have that information, but often there are pets that the Red Cross works to find pet-friendly hotels for.
Now, when the 911 call came in and the initial response happened, was NYC Emergency Management or City Hall made aware that it was not only a fire but that there was a shooting that took place with multiple people injured or killed? It was a one-alarm...
...fire. Unless, like I said at the beginning, it is a sensitive location, we do not routinely deploy to those. Our watch command is 24/7. People — this was a Saturday, right — folks were working. They will definitely give what we call a monitor page to myself and other members on call of the executive team so we know what is going on. But the actual initial response and what was going on with the fire — we were not part of that because...
I wonder in the disconnect because in the day I believe the Mayor had a press conference and he acknowledged what was happening in the Rockaways. I feel the response — obviously FDNY was there — but in terms of an effort to address the crisis in that moment on the ground, at the magnitude that it was felt by the people impacted, that was not present. I know there was a family, there is a mom with five children who lived upstairs in that house, and they felt quite honestly like they were hostages because of course it is a crisis and no one knows who is who at that initial moment.
And so for a very long time her and her kids were pretty much not permitted to leave their apartment upstairs, having to step over blood and dead bodies thereafter. And to this day that constituent has felt like there has not been enough done for her and her family in terms of dealing with the trauma, or treating them as the victims of what transpired there, which had nothing to do with her or her family. What resources are in play for moments like this, and what is the City's responsibility?
I will have to get back to you. Obviously at the beginning it was a police investigation, and then as you mentioned, I know that when the Red Cross does get involved they do some mental health counseling and look at things like that — any type of impacted resident services and things. Those are not things that emergency management is usually involved in, as we are focused on utilities and all of those pieces. But obviously the trauma and the things that come along with this are serious and life-altering, as you said. So we can go back and look at exactly who the right person is to follow up on that question, and I appreciate that.
In terms of communication and follow-up — that was a good segue — what is the protocol for notifying the other agencies and partners involved, such as the Mayor's Office of Housing Recovery, Department of Social Services and others, after a fire with displacement? And what triggers each notification and who sends it?
So if it is a larger incident — and as you noted there was another large fire going on at almost the same time — many of our resources, as you probably know, are a lot smaller than our partners at FDNY, NYPD and others. On a typical Saturday afternoon we probably had three citywide incident coordinators working, also doing things like monitoring the drones at the beaches and things like that. So we have limited resources, just by the nature of the way we are set up across the agency.
Since we did not initially respond to this fire, notification, as I said, would go through Housing Preservation and Development. Once things were needed later on, when we went out there, those notifications — if it is something that we initially respond to, say like a three-alarm fire or more — those notifications and the requests... CM Sanchez knows there was a significant fire in her district a week ago, and Buildings was requested, Con Ed was requested, HPD, the Mayor's Office of Engagement. So depending on the number of units and the likelihood that there is going to be a vacate, we will pull in our partners.
To that point, because I had no one to talk to across that night, there were certain decisions that they could not make unless it came from, for example... and I am not sure if through the notification system they communicate because it is an emergency, or if the regular channels have to communicate during normal business hours per se, in the sense of making certain calls. So in their mind the fire had been handled and they could go into their home, but then it was an active crime scene and so they could not go back into their home. But there was a disconnect with the Red Cross and they could not take that directive from NYPD.
Do you feel that there should be a different communication stream in moments like this, where maybe it runs through the notification system since you are connecting all the agencies in these moments?
Of crisis. So the contract with HPD and Red Cross is for vacates, and usually outside of the fire investigation — which can of course result in criminality — but usually these vacates that they respond to and that they put people into hotels are based on fires that make a house uninhabitable, or an apartment building, things like extended power outages and water service outages through a water main break or other situations. So this situation, as we have mentioned, was different in that it was an active crime scene, and that is not what the contract is set up for. Red Cross was able to house these families. They did not do it through the Red Cross-HPD contract. It is my understanding that they used other funding — private funding — that they can use on unlimited occasions. But this is really a different type of incident than what the Red Cross contract is set up for, which is more the typical fires and the things that come with those vacates. Because also the power was out, and so in terms of the connection from there, that communication to the...
...to HPD, to Red Cross — that communication tree was not happening either.
Yeah, so I mean I think we can always do a better job of communicating. One thing I am happy to say is that we actually received funding for 10 additional citywide incident coordinators and five part-time citywide incident coordinators, because we do have people that are retired and would like to come back. So that will greatly increase our resources, because again if we have three people working citywide, they get very busy very quickly. So we are excited to have these additional resources, and as they are in place we could potentially explore — but I do not want to promise — that we can be involved in every one of these incidents when we are really coordinating for those larger incidents. Thank you.
I have a few more questions but I am yielding to the Chair. Thank you.
So it is interesting because we are talking about a fire that then became a crime scene. For the FDNY, what is the FDNY protocol to respond to a fire when it also involves a crime scene?
We are aware from the dispatch that there is a shooting there. We respond with caution but we still respond, and we are there to put that fire out. So we do not want to put our people in undue danger. We would respond with caution and we would request NYPD response to that location along with us.
Between NYPD, the notification system and FDNY?
Absolutely. In that situation, if we are not dispatched — if there is a shooter or a shooting — they will notify NYPD simultaneously.
Wonderful.
I just want to make note that CM Paladino has joined us, and also we are joined by students. We welcome you to the hearing and we are glad that you are interested to come and view and see what goes on here. You will see Council Members coming and going from this hearing because there are other hearings going on that they are members of those committees as well. So it is just one of those things, and if you have any questions I am happy to answer them after the hearing. I am very glad that you are here.
Data from the City reflects geographic disparities in emergency response times, specifically in isolated communities, showing longer response times in areas such as Breezy Point and the Rockaway Peninsula. My question is: how does the Fire Department explain such dramatic changes in response times in certain neighborhoods as opposed to others, and what is the department doing to address this issue?
My data shows that in the Rockaways we respond pretty well. The 47th Battalion is the battalion that is in the Rockaways, and there are only five battalions out of the 49 that respond quicker. On the peninsula we have six units — six engines and three trucks — including we do put in service a brush fire unit, which is a brush fire unit. Those units are all water rescue trained. We put some programs in play where we patrol the beach with that, and also drones. So in my view we respond pretty well to the Rockaways. Those units are all must-fill units, so for example if somebody is out for training in the Rockaways we replace them with another unit because of its isolation. So our fire operations do an excellent job of covering that peninsula. My data shows our response times are pretty good in the Rockaways.
From the fire response side. So that is with fire response — what about EMS response?
Similarly, for EMS our response times are lower than the average citywide response times in the Rockaways. We do have one station in the Rockaways that is co-located with an engine company. It has 10 units — three of them are advanced life support units, and of those 10 units two of them are also members of our Special Operations Command, which includes hazardous materials ambulances. Also during the summer we put out two gator units on the beaches in the Rockaways, and we work very closely with the Fire Department's drone unit on those beaches to be able to respond quicker.
And sticking with EMS — what is the current head count, how has it increased or decreased over the past few years, and how has that impacted response times?
The current head count — the exact number I do not have written down — but I can tell you that we are below a head count of 400 members. In regards to response times, that does mean fewer ambulances on the street. However, we have what we call the Central Resource Coordination Center, and that is a 24-hour staffed center that consistently looks at ambulance availability throughout the City and deploys ambulances from areas that have a large amount of availability into areas that have reduced availability, so we can maintain our response times.
I want to talk about a specific incident that happened on Monday, September 28. A 14-year-old young man, a student at St. Francis Preparatory High School, started to show signs of a stroke almost immediately upon entering school. He was slurring his words, his right eye began to droop, and his right arm and leg became weak and unstable. This student is not what is known as a known cardiac patient. The nurse immediately called 911. The first call to 911 was made at 8:47 AM, the second call was made at 9:14 AM and the third call was made at 9:22 AM. As the parents rushed to the school upon hearing that there was no ambulance, the child's father also called 911 at 9:22 in the morning. Still no ambulance responded. The mother arrived at the school at 9:22 and after five minutes there was still no response. She took the child and rushed him to the hospital in her own car, without a paramedic, without any EMT treating her severely ill child. Why did the FDNY not...
...respond to these frantic calls for help? So first off I just want to say that this is an extremely tragic situation. I am a father myself of three boys and I could not imagine what those parents were going through at the school. What I can tell you is that at the time this call was coming in, we were experiencing a 100-plus call surge above what we normally see. We normally see about 179 calls per hour, and during this hour that this assignment took place we had a call volume of 274 calls for service into 911. An ambulance was dispatched to this call. The ambulance was coming from a distance. They did arrive at the location, but they did arrive after the parents left to take the child to the hospital.
They actually arrived at 9:37, and it is believed that the...
...child left to go to the hospital five minutes prior to that.
So you were holding about 274 calls?
Right, which is above the norm.
We received 274 calls, which was about a hundred above the normal at that time during the day. And do you think that the disconnect was due to a lack of staffing, or that a dispatcher was not available to speak to the caller?
So when someone calls 911 they initially talk to a police dispatcher. That police dispatcher asks questions — police or fire. When it is determined that it is a request for EMS service it is transferred from NYPD. When there are no alarm-receiving dispatchers available, the NYPD dispatcher stays on the line, takes additional information and then routes that call to the system. So the call itself is not lingering — it is in the system. The system did throughout this whole period of time note that it was searching for ambulances, searching for ambulances, searching for ambulances. But due to the surge in calls that we had at that time we had none available. As soon as an ambulance became available it was then dispatched to the location, and like I said they were coming from a distance and they did arrive at the scene, but unfortunately it was after the parent had left.
And was there any notification back from 911 to the people who called, saying there is a delay, we got an influx of calls, it will be a matter of 15, 20, 25 minutes before an ambulance gets there?
No. There is no system in place where we advise a caller that an ambulance is delayed or will be an extended period of time before they arrive.
So basically what you are saying is a child who is a cardiac patient showing signs of a stroke was put into a system...
...as an unknown condition. Is that how it went into the system? That is correct, that is how it went into the system.
And instead of a level one, which is the most serious of conditions — as it should have been coded — because of the lack of staffing for the dispatchers at that moment, it was not put in as a level one.
Right. So first I...
Was the dispatch center adequately staffed at that time of the morning? The dispatch center does have staggered staffing to meet our call volume throughout the day and during high periods of demand. So we did have the proper amount of staff that would be answering the phone for what the typical call volume would be for that day. There were 26 alarm-receiving dispatchers in at that time. Had this been triaged, a series of questions would have been asked and the dispatcher would have entered this information into the system, and the computer triage would have categorized it differently than an unknown. What category, based on the answers to the questions that the caller gave, I cannot predetermine without asking those questions and getting the answers and inputting them. But it would have most likely been classified as one of the incidents that would have been around a segment three, which is a higher priority than unknown, which is a segment four. But the reality is it never did get to an FDNY dispatcher.
That is correct, it did not get to an FDNY dispatcher. However it was in the system to be dispatched. At no time does any call get lost in the system. When we are unable to reach an FDNY dispatcher, NYPD does put it into the system, and the system and the dispatchers are consistently looking for ambulances to respond to those calls.
But there was no dispatcher that answered who could then further ask questions and realize that this was a level one. And it was not just one call — there were four calls that a dispatcher did not respond to and did not get further information for this child. So how many people do you estimate fall into this category where they are in the system, a dispatcher has not gotten any additional information, and lives could be at risk because those questions were not asked so that they could properly categorize them and get an ambulance?
I understand and appreciate your question and it is very difficult for me to come up with a number. What I can tell you is that we strive to meet 100% of the calls that come in requesting service for an ambulance.
Okay, so please let me be clear. This scenario is happening across the City, and we just had a hearing recently where the 911 system was down for seven hours and there was no response and no notification. This boy not only made one of the calls for help for a life-threatening symptom, but he went into a dispatch abyss, which is very important. Even though the system was searching, it is a computerized system that does not know the severity of what this child was going through. His parents had to put him into a car in critical condition because he was in the abyss.
And so far we have done nothing to fix this issue, and it is not just this administration — it is administrations going back decades that this has been happening and needs to be fixed. But what I see is it is just consistently getting worse because we are not really looking at what the problem is for our workers, because they are not paid enough to stay. So right now you are at a deficit for your team because you just had a promotional ceremony, so you lost 25% of your workforce and the next class has not come out yet. Have you requested mutual aid from other counties or cities to make up for the lack of staffing, like you did during the July 4th weekend?
So at this time we have not requested mutual aid. Our mutual aid policy is...
The way our mutual aid policy works is that when we have planned events, like we did for the Fourth of July and FIFA going on throughout the City, we made those requests earlier in the year because we were able to predict that that was going to happen and we wanted to try and bolster up our system so we did not have a lack of service. Another way our mutual aid works is that when the system is overwhelmed and we reach a service level of less than 25% for a sustained period of time — a long sustained period of time, which we generally use 24 hours as the mark — we would then make the request for mutual aid. As of now, while we do have peaks, we have not hit that point of sustained under 25% for that period of time. What we do do — I am sorry — what we do do is when we know that there is a happening, we contact our volunteer agencies that are in the City, we contact our partners at Remsco and Greater New York, and we ask our voluntary partners who are here within the City to assist us in trying to put out additional ambulances and to try and put more units into the system. So why...
...why would a mutual aid call not go out knowing that you were going to lose FDNY probie school and also waiting for the next class to go out? Would that not be something that would trigger you asking for mutual aid for that small period of time before the next class comes out?
Again, it is based on the demand on the system. So if the demand on the system is low and it does not require or meet that 25% over sustained duration period of time, we would not make the request for mutual aid.
So is 12 to 174 calls that came in in that hour — does that meet the demand?
So for that period of time it would have, and then later on in the day it evened out. It balanced out later on, evened out for this young...
...man. You are 100% correct. His parents are now sitting at a bedside hoping for the best for their child.
Do you consider New York State to be in a state of emergency when it comes to medical response times and staffing?
So I believe that staffing across the country has been dealing with an issue. But talking about right here — so in New York we do have an issue with retention, we do have an issue with head count. I can tell you that since day one the Commissioner has hit the ground running and we have been trying to do our very best. Our administration that we have in the Fire Department — the Deputy Commissioner, our Chief of Department, myself — we care very much. A lot of us come from the background, we have familiarity with it, and we care. We do the job because we care about the citizens and the visitors to New York. We have been tirelessly making attempts to try and better the system and we will continue doing that every single day.
So besides holding classes, what other steps are being taken? And just before you answer the question, I just want to understand that as a committee and as a Chair, we are in constant contact with the Commissioner and with the Chief, and we understand 100% that you are operating under duress on the fire side. I want to make clear we understand that you are operating under duress. It is our job to make that duress end. It is our job to make sure that the people in this City are safe and that young men that are going through critical situations — and he cannot be the only one. It is not just him. Other people too are dying, or having to be brought to the hospital by other means and getting there later than they should and treated later than they should. We bring this to the attention of the public so they can understand the need for this administration to really focus on making sure that they are getting a living wage so that you can retain people and you can put more ambulances on the street. Because without workers — there are them leaving for better jobs, whether it is the Fire Department or Sanitation or the private sector.
You cannot put the ambulances out, and if the ambulances cannot get out they cannot get to Far Rockaway and they are not getting to Breezy Point. But this is Queens — this is Central Queens — and they could not get an ambulance there, and that is a problem. So I am going to leave it there and defer to see if any of my colleagues have questions. Oh, I am sorry — I see our Public Advocate is here and he did want to make a statement. Please, Public Advocate.
Thank you so much. Peace and blessings to everyone. Thank you for allowing me to read my opening statement in the middle of the hearing. I appreciate that. I am sorry — I was at 26 Federal Plaza but this is really important and I wanted to make sure I was here because we get complaints from a lot of these communities. So good morning. My name is Jumaane Williams, Public Advocate of the City of New York. I want to thank Chair Ariola as well as members of the Committee on Fire and Emergency Management for holding this hearing and for the opportunity to share testimony.
So in New York City, neighborhoods that are geographically isolated — including parts of Staten Island, City Island, Howard Beach, Broad Channel, Red Hook and the Rockaways — face heightened, overlapping risks during climate emergencies. Many of these areas' vulnerabilities stem largely from structural limitations or critical infrastructure needs. These communities face frontline climate exposures, meaning that they tend to bear the brunt of coastal storms and rely on single bridges or narrow causeways for emergency access. Severe weather events in New York City, such as the late September 2026 nor'easter, have routinely triggered localized flooding up to three feet, causing power disruptions and trapping residents who rely on local utilities like Con Edison. Though geography impacts transit in many cities, data tracked by New York City's Emergency Management and the FDNY showed that traffic density, staffing shortages and high call volumes inflate response times far more than just physical distance.
Furthermore, the events of August 2026 demonstrated the City's vulnerability to widespread emergency system failures, revealing how whole disruption of 911 call services can occur. Although the City has taken steps to safeguard local businesses and residents against the escalating impacts of climate change, further action is absolutely necessary to enhance our emergency response frameworks to ensure priority assistance reaches geographically isolated communities. In order to mitigate transit issues during extreme weather events, the Office of Emergency Management has pre-staged diesel locomotives, high-water rescue vehicles and utility pumps inside isolated zones before storms make landfall to keep emergency corridors operational. Yet because isolated areas are not routinely designated or integrated as emergency corridors, businesses and residents can often find themselves trapped, unable to evacuate or effectively combat incoming forceful winds and rising floodwaters.
As many of us have learned over recent years, severe weather conditions caused widespread damage to all types of personal property. Following Hurricane Sandy in 2012, New York City received more than $14 billion in federal aid to fund various municipal initiatives and recovery projects, a number of which remain active today to support households, commercial entities and damaged infrastructure. The aftermath of Hurricane Sandy underscores the critical necessity of establishing a resilient, long-term emergency response strategy specifically designed for New York City's geographically isolated neighborhoods. During the storm, severe disruption as floodwaters impacted 10% of nearby developments, leaving nearly 400 buildings without electricity, heat or hot water.
In the years following Sandy, New York has confronted new challenges, particularly amid disagreements with the Trump Administration. Consequently, it is vital that we actively collaborate to devise innovative solutions that safeguard our coastal areas and shorelines. This approach ensures we maintain our standing as a global hub while advancing key local initiatives, including revitalization of City waterways, such as the Hunts Point Marine Terminal in the Bronx and the Brooklyn Marine Terminal in Red Hook.
As you can hear, obviously these emergencies stem even when there is not a climate-related emergency. I just want to attach myself to the words spoken about the need for more pay so we can have retention — it is really critical — and the need for a trauma hospital in the Rockaways, as they have been asking for one for a long time, and the response time there as well has been problematic. Thank you very much.
Thank you so much. CM Brooks-Powers, thank you.
Chair, I will try to make the last few questions as tight as I can. I have some: under Local Law 134, residential fire emergency response guides are required to be provided to affected residents and distributed via QR code on FDNY vehicles and at post-fire inspections. Residents did not report seeing any QR codes. How does the FDNY confirm that the distribution actually took place? How do we do targeted...
...outreach? For July 25 specifically — I am sorry — after a fire, while we do that, those QR codes are on the rigs mostly. But people are told through our fire safety education that QR codes are available on the rigs, on the apparatus.
In certain locations — specific locations where we put them — also at the scene of any fire we can call out dispatches and have Red Cross respond to any incident if we feel that people are in need of shelter, or if there is a fire and they cannot reenter their building. So those are some of the things that we do to get the word out, so that information can be disseminated to the people in your community.
Thank you. And Commissioner, in terms of just going back to something we were speaking about earlier with respect to the resources and services such as trauma-informed mental health support offered to families that are displaced after an incident like what took place on July 25 — what could we do better going forward to be able to address a moment of crisis such as what we experienced?
Like I said, we are always looking at ways that the City as a whole and then specific agencies and nonprofit partners can improve services. I know that the Red Cross and the NYPD are following up to talk about specific incidents that are more violence-related and potentially less within Emergency Management's purview. But we also work with the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene and other agencies. So after this hearing I am going to go back and speak to our folks and to our partners and just see what additional things can be brought and what agencies can be brought to bear. We will follow up once we have those discussions.
I appreciate that. And the 10 additional coordinators that you all are hiring — will any of them be designated for the geographically isolated communities like the Rockaways, like Staten Island? So what we do...
...with our citywide incident coordinators depends. Like this weekend, we had more folks working because of the hazards we were facing. What we do when we have sufficient resources and when we have a storm or other things coming is that we will borough-deploy our staff, so they will at a minimum — if we have five people working — have one work out of each borough.
That even with one out of each borough, with the...
...exception of Staten Island, because it is not like broken off from another part of the same borough. But like the Rockaway, Broad Channel, Breezy Point area — the way we are situated — I think it would be helpful. And really southeast Queens, you know, it would be good to have one designated, even though you have one for the borough, because realistically to get from Astoria to Rockaway it takes an extremely long time. Just in general, to get there — CM Thomas-Henry says all the time she calls Far Rockaway "Far Far Far Rockaway" and all of her constituents say that to me as well. But it is really the rest of the City that is far from us.
So wanting to make sure that we have the coverage that we need — it would be great. I am advocating for that as you determine the placement of these coordinators. And going back to Red Cross — I will say I was deeply disappointed with the Red Cross that day, and that was not the first time in a moment of crisis. I know that they are contract-bound in some instances. So really just wanting to know: if an agreement could be put in place, whether it is through Emergency Management or HPD, when Red Cross does not have the bandwidth and capacity, who then comes in? Because when we called that night to have them come back — and you are right, they came earlier, they left, they did not really do any triage — but when they did come back after 11 PM that night, the reason it came so late was: one, the fire was going on; two, they had no more resources to send to us; and then geographically it takes over an hour to get from the part of the Bronx they work in to the part of Far Rockaway they needed to get to. Do we currently have a backup to the Red Cross, or is this something we could explore — having a backup or revisiting what their contract entails?
So I will just say two things. On your earlier point, we look at where the most likely hazards are. So for example, this weekend our citywide incident coordinator was working within that area. So we do do that based on what we see coming in. With respect to the Red Cross, that contract is one where we look at hoteling, and I am sure you both are familiar because it has happened at different times. A lot of what they do is also based on hotel room availability — sometimes it is busier than others. The summer obviously was very busy. Last week was busy with the United Nations General Assembly and Climate Week. So if what is needed to house people — if the demand outstrips the supply — we would then look at congregate sheltering, which means setting up a shelter in most likely a school building or another facility like that. That is what we do when we do not have the resources available. But just like with the Red Cross, we are always looking at ways to improve, and by and large — as you probably know — their model is based on volunteers responding to many of their incidents 24/7, and so they really do a fantastic job getting to all of these scenes. There are a lot of incidents and I know this is one area to see how they can improve response.
And I do not think me or the Chair would be doing our job if we did not bring up the trauma hospital need on the peninsula. I know it was mentioned that the response has been good comparatively to the rest of the City, and many of the firefighters live in our community — in my building and all around — and the EMTs as well. The work that they do is tremendous. But I am always going to fight for more resources for both firefighters and EMTs because what I hear on the ground has been that particularly since Peninsula Hospital closed several years ago, the response times have increased compared to what they once were. There are moments where we do not have an ambulance on the peninsula because if there is a trauma incident they have to go out to Cohen's or to Jamaica Hospital, and if they get called in that area it takes even longer to come back to the peninsula.
So I think for us it is important to hear — because when we talk about the trauma hospital we are talking about stopping the bleeding and trying to save a life — but there are other important components to even getting to the hospital, and that includes often your division's part of the City agencies being far from you. In terms of how the City could better provide work to address the need of the peninsula — and I know that is difficult for you to answer in your positions — but as truthfully as you can, under oath.
So if you will just stick with me one second before I answer that question, I just want to say that we hear the City Council, we hear this committee, and we appreciate you lobbying for us the way that you do. We appreciate your help to get us a command car, as well as other members of the Council. So that being said...
We greatly appreciate it. As I said earlier, with our Essential Resource Coordination Center, we are consistently looking at areas where there is low ambulance availability and moving things throughout the City. One thing that we have done within the last few months is what we call a redeployment — we changed the way we redeploy ambulances. So now an ambulance that leaves the peninsula to go to another hospital, when they come available out of that other hospital, they are put in what is called a relocation status, and that allows them to get back to the peninsula. They do not get called for low-acuity assignments — they only get called if they are the closest ambulance to a high-acuity assignment like a cardiac arrest. So that is one way that we are, besides the 24-hour center, looking at and redeploying units. That is one way that we have made an improvement very recently to our CAD system to be able to — it is automatic. This is not something that has to be done by a person. It is automatic: they come out of that hospital and they are put on redirection back to that area. Thank you for that.
And then I have also heard from some of the other houses that when we have an alarm that triggers more support needed on the peninsula, we are pulling from Howard Beach, we are pulling from Springfield Gardens, which then is leaving those communities without their personnel. Is a staffing issue why we do not have more people located on the peninsula? How is that determined in terms of how many trucks and how many personnel are based there? Because I have heard from both that we drain — not to say drain — but we use other houses' resources when we have a certain level happening.
So obviously I will let Chief Sora speak about the fire side, but for EMS we look at the average call volume in the particular area and we staff to try and meet that call volume. That is why we have ten ambulances located on the peninsula. Regarding fire operations, if there is a fire on the peninsula, other areas are there to cover possible other fires in that same area, and we do backfill those positions from other areas. Obviously we are spreading ourselves thin, but that is how we do it via the relocation process.
And that is the point I was getting to — the thinning out piece. So what is that sweet number where it is sufficient but it is not...
Feeling like it is stretched? Well, you know, obviously we can handle multiple incidents in our city the way we deploy our assets. We will pull assets from other boroughs — it is targeted to areas that we feel need coverage. So I think dispatch along with our chiefs ensures areas are properly covered. For example, over the weekend we also added some additional staffing during the storm. We added a fifth firefighter to all the engines on the peninsula because, you know...
It is isolated, so we took care of that. We also added a fifth firefighter on Cross Bay. Again, these additional steps — we were looking at the weather forecast, that those areas would possibly be flooded, so we wanted to be proactive in adding that additional staffing. So all those things combined, I think overall we do a pretty good job in moving our assets around to have substantial coverage in every area by backfilling the Rockaways and bringing assets in and spreading them out. The fifth firefighter is great during a flood situation and it does substantially help.
We would love to keep the fifth firefighter there all the time. I am going to end on this. I do want to pivot to the nor'easter that happened this weekend and commend the administration for door knocking through the Rockaways to be proactive. I will say — which is not directed at you all but for the record — I do feel like a lot of our infrastructure projects need to happen quicker to be able to handle the current state of our climate impacts on communities like the peninsula and the inland, because we are seeing it more now.
That leads me to this: Rosedale took in a significant amount of water this weekend and Brookville Park was completely underwater. There were a lot of homes that were deeply impacted by the storm. There has been a focus on the coastal communities primarily, as we do need it, but I do want to ask that agencies come into the community with some resources as well. I know you said you had delivered a number of resources over the weekend, which was great, but Rosedale is requesting to have an event where they can also get the flood sensors, the pumps and all of those things too.
And my last question is about the funding for the Strengthening Communities program for the Rockaways. I just wanted to understand how much that funding is and how long that contract is.
All very good questions. For this weekend, looking at the nor'easter, it was mostly coastal, but we know what happened this summer. Your chief of staff was sending me the videos and the pictures of what was happening in Rosedale. I will not speak for them, but they have been doing the town halls — the flooding town halls — and so if there has not been one in Rosedale in that area we can bring that back to them. I was at one in Hollis last week where they gave out about a hundred kits, and we went there too. We are also doing one in Forest Hills in a couple of weeks with Councilwoman Schulman.
I will also say that since emergency management is now reporting to the Deputy Mayor for Operations, and many of the agencies you mentioned — such as DEP, Parks, Fire and Transportation — all report in there, they have been looking at a lot of this infrastructure. That is the Mayor's background: infrastructure projects. What can be pushed forward, what can we do in the interim — all of that. So definitely something we can follow up on.
For your last question: Strengthening Communities is funded through the next several years through disaster recovery money that the City received after Hurricane Ida. It is stable for the next few years. We are working with City Hall on how that program will be funded when that disaster funding is concluded. The model is that when networks join we give them several thousand dollars to build their plan, to train their staff and to bring in their partners, and then there is maintenance funding to keep that up. The model is that we will activate them and pay them for that activation when they do the outreach. We did that several times during the winter weather, and I will give all the networks a shout out — they were actually out putting up flyers through those extremely cold temperatures in subway stations, in bodegas, liquor stores, laundromats, houses of worship, anywhere where people might have gone who needed assistance or needed a warm place. In reverse, over the July 4th weekend when it was so hot, they were getting people into cooling centers and other safe locations. This weekend we looked specifically at coastal areas and we were able to activate them and pay them for their effort.
My last question is about evacuation routes. The last administration committed by letter to updating the evacuation route for the Rockaway Peninsula. Obviously the roads have changed — some roads have been de-mapped, the footprint looks different because of all of the development. We have a lot of new people on the peninsula who do not even know what the current evacuation route is. The signs are down, they are not up on the poles anymore in many instances, and no one knows where to go in those moments.
I would like to begin to explore with the Chair and with emergency management what steps are actually needed to update the evacuation route so that we can start that process. I know the community board has followed up on this as well. We did get a letter committing to that based on some of the earlier actions that we took, but the reality is some of these roads that were once probably part of this evacuation route do not exist anymore. For example, they just renamed a nearby avenue because it is located somewhere different now. I want to make sure everything is up to date. Thank you all for helping with this conversation and I know we have some follow-ups. Thank you so much.
CM Brooks-Powers, you brought up some very powerful and compelling issues and questions. CM Restler was here earlier but she had to leave, but she wanted me to thank the agencies for a really great interagency response to 484 Montgomery. I want to put that on the record.
I just want to get back to the sustained levels. When was the last time there was a sustained level of under 25% for over 24 hours? During COVID there was a period of time right when nobody was out. Okay, and that was a very long time ago, so we have been over that threshold for quite some time. I consider that a state of emergency.
The Council member brought up the differences in road designs over the last number of years. In the Rockaways there was an ambulance station 11 minutes away by a regular car ride to the Scholar's Academy — it is a middle school and high school. Vehicles often get delayed in the area because of road design changes that have occurred without notification to the firehouses and the stations. How much of an impact does that have on your ability to reach a fire or someone who is sick when you are getting there and all of a sudden the road has been reconfigured and you can no longer go down that road?
So differently from how fire responds, ambulances do not stay at one location like an ambulance station. The ambulances that come out of the Rockaways, out of every station, are deployed on cross streets throughout the city, so they are more dynamic in their response...
...from anywhere when they get the call, not just from the ambulance station. As far as fire response, I will turn it over to Chief Scirocco. We work with City Planning all the time, so any road design changes are communicated to us and disseminated to the units. The units will actually go out and make sure those road designs can handle the apparatus — sometimes they change a turn where an apparatus cannot negotiate it. So we do...
...pretty well with our partners at DOT to make sure that we are aware of any road changes that would affect our...
...response. So you do not feel that that affects response times in areas like Long Island City or Astoria or any of the places where they have a lot of open streets?
Well, I would say that any road design change could, depending on how the design is implemented, cause some congestion. As far as response times in those specific incidents, I cannot quantify those, but I would say that again we work with DOT all the time concerning these things. We do not have the data on how much it slows down our response times, but overall I think throughout the City congestion has become somewhat of a problem for us. We continue to work and move forward and try to do as good a job as possible with DOT, balancing their needs and the needs of the public in order to respond safely and in a timely manner.
And when you are working with DOT, are you also working with the local firehouses in that area?
Absolutely. They are involved. They are involved in the process.
In the process. So...
I have no further questions and I just would like to say to the entire panel that I really appreciate that never once was it said "I will get back to you on that." You are well prepared — the team that is behind you, FDNY, is extremely well prepared and ready to help. So kudos to the Commissioner as always. Nobody does it better. Thank you, and thank you for understanding that this is not anything against any one of you or your agencies. This is to help you get the resources that you need so that you can do the job of saving lives, because that is what you all do.
From emergency management to FDNY — you know what the real biggest problem is? You do your job whether you have the resources or not, and that is why everybody just seems to say, "Oh, they just do not need anything," because they are not squeaky wheels. But I am going to be the squeaky wheel. This committee will be the squeaky wheel and we will not let up until you all have the resources that you need to keep this City safe. Thank you so much for taking the time today. You are dismissed.
Oh, I am sorry — we also have CM Wong here. Before you go, do you have a question? Okay, good. CM Wong is here. Thank you so much again.