Shelter Safety
Meeting overview
The Committee on General Welfare held an oversight hearing on shelter safety, alongside consideration of two bills. Int 0099-2026, sponsored by Council Member Gale Brewer, would require the Department of Homeless Services to report annually on the number and percentage of families with children placed in shelters in the same or adjoining zip code as their prior address. Int 0387-2026, sponsored by the Public Advocate, would require annual reporting on critical incidents in shelters, including assaults, sexual assaults, domestic violence, weapons possession, arson and theft, along with information on security upgrades and NYPD agreements.
Three shelter residents testified first, all members of the Coalition for the Homeless Community Leadership Collective, and their accounts were uniformly damning. Denton Hutchinson described a man lying dead in a recreation room for hours while security staff stationed feet away did nothing. Janet Jackson described being placed an hour and a half from her job in the Bronx after requesting something closer, returning alone at one or two in the morning to a desolate subway stop, and being ignored when she reported mice exacerbating her asthma. Francisco Ines, testifying through a translator, described being denied a room key in a unit designated for people with disabilities, having security open his door against his wishes, and being ignored when he filed a complaint. All three described a grievance system that was structurally broken: forms are obtained from the same staff against whom grievances are filed, complaints disappear, and residents fear retaliation for speaking up. One resident proposed a lockbox system for anonymous grievances. The Public Advocate confirmed there is no mechanism for making complaints that does not involve the very people complained about.
Commissioner Erin Dalton of the Department of Social Services led the administration's testimony, flanked by DHS First Deputy Commissioner Christine Fellini and Deputy Commissioner for Shelter Security Valvano Priester. Dalton opened by acknowledging that the procedures and protocols she was about to describe mean nothing without residents' trust, and that DHS does not currently measure resident perceptions of safety or dignity, but committed to building that capability. She presented data showing meaningful improvements across most safety metrics: serious violent incidents in single adult shelters fell 13% last year to 2.8 per thousand residents, down from 4.8 in fiscal year 2022; the shelter mortality rate fell by two-thirds in three years; and incident rates across all shelter types have roughly halved since fiscal year 2022. However, she flagged two areas of clear concern. Complaints about discrimination, assault and harassment rose 19% this year, and complaints about staff-client interactions rose 46%, which she interpreted as evidence that residents do not feel safe or respected, not merely as a data artifact. Flexible capacity shelters, mostly commercial hotels opened during the asylum-seeker surge, average approximately 42 open building violations per site compared to fewer than four in standard shelters, though officials noted some of this gap reflects applying residential code to buildings built under hotel code.
Council members pressed on several persistent structural problems. Chair Hudson focused heavily on conditions at the Tillery Street women's shelter in her district, where a provider change earlier in 2026 appears to have produced measurable improvements: priority one incidents down 45%, 911 calls down 13%, felony arrests down from 33 to 12. She raised a whistleblower complaint from a City employee alleging discrepancies between what was reported to DHS and what records showed, and that a security contractor retained against staff recommendations may warrant referral to the Department of Investigation. The administration confirmed DHS can terminate primary contracts and subcontracts, though the latter was initially stated incorrectly and corrected during the hearing. Council Member Morano pressed on community advisory boards being convened only after shelter siting decisions are made, and on the fact that safety transfers numbering 2,654 in the last fiscal year represent more than seven people moved per day for safety reasons, without any clear disciplinary consequence for repeat aggressors. Council Member Ung raised the ratio of housing specialists to residents, currently approximately 1 to 40, and the adequacy of staffing to move people out of the shelter system. Council Member Brewer pushed on school continuity, noting that only 62.9% of families are initially placed in the borough of their youngest school-aged child's school, and that absenteeism among shelter-dwelling children is likely being driven partly by transport failures. Council Member Avilés raised language access, confirming that DHS does not track the language capabilities of provider staff, relies on a language line rather than on-site bilingual staff, and cannot currently hold providers accountable for language competency. The administration acknowledged that only 82% of required security guards have completed mandatory 40-hour training, peace officer vacancies stand at 20%, and peace officer salaries are low enough relative to comparable City positions that retention is a chronic problem.
Both bills remain under consideration. The administration expressed general openness to working with sponsors on both, while flagging that shelter addresses must be protected, that zip code level placement data would require some rethinking of the existing MMR measure, and that domestic violence placements create legitimate reasons to place families away from their prior address that any reporting framework would need to accommodate.
The record
Numbers
- 83,000 individuals slept in New York City shelters on the Sunday before the hearing, including 51,000 families with children.
- DHS oversees 502 shelter sites, of which only 7 are directly operated by DHS.
- 32 purpose-built shelters have been opened in the last four years, with an average capacity of approximately 160 residents.
- Standard shelters average fewer than 4 open building violations each; flexible capacity shelters average approximately 42 open violations each.
- Flexible capacity shelters number approximately 169 sites, mostly commercial hotels opened to meet asylum-seeker demand.
- Serious violent incidents in single adult shelters fell 13% in fiscal year 2026 to 2.8 per thousand residents, down from 4.8 per thousand in fiscal year 2022.
- The shelter system mortality rate fell by two-thirds in three years, from approximately 11 per thousand residents in fiscal year 2022 to 3.5 per thousand in fiscal year 2025; total deaths fell from approximately 500 to 305 while the shelter population nearly doubled.
- Drug-related deaths account for 40% of all shelter deaths; 42 of 73 people who died in shelter in fiscal year 2025 died of an overdose. Drug-related deaths across the homeless population fell 28% last year.
- Complaints about discrimination, assault and harassment rose 19% in fiscal year 2026; complaints about staff-client interactions rose 46%.
- There were 2,654 safety transfers in fiscal year 2026, slightly up from 2,625 in fiscal year 2025.
- Serious incident rates per thousand residents across shelter types: single adults fell from 54.7 in fiscal year 2022 to 28.3 in fiscal year 2026; adult families fell from 21.8 in fiscal year 2023 to 9.0 in fiscal year 2026; families with children fell from 16.0 in fiscal year 2022 to 8.0 in fiscal year 2026.
- 62.9% of families are initially placed in the borough of their youngest school-aged child's school; over 80% are in that borough over the duration of their shelter stay.
- 31,620 complaints were entered into the IQ complaint system in fiscal year 2026; average resolution time is 5 days.
- 268 new capital needs are pending across 95 privately operated shelters in various stages of review.
- DHS has 55 City- and State-owned shelter buildings; the fiscal year 2027 capital budget includes $106 million for 102 projects across 38 shelters, with 8 complete and 31 in active construction.
- DHS has 352 peace officers deployed across 18 shelter sites, in staffing ranges of 10 to 26 per site; the current peace officer vacancy rate is 20%, down from 25%.
- 3,542 total security guard positions exist across the shelter system; 82% (2,916) have completed the required 40-hour training; 542 have completed the required annual 8-hour refresher.
- The ratio of housing specialists to shelter residents is approximately 1 to 40.
- 113 of 143 targeted family shelter sites (79%) have at least one mental health professional on site as required by Local Law 35 of 2023.
- The DHS ombudsman's office has 12 filled positions with a 13th onboarding, and contacts approximately 90% of complainants upon receipt of their complaint.
- At Tillery Street women's shelter, following a provider change in 2026: priority one incidents down 45%, 911 calls down 13% to 1,248 (lowest since 2022), felony arrests down from 33 to 12.
- DHS security budget for fiscal year 2027 includes approximately $18 million for peace officers plus contracted security costs; the full breakdown was not available at the hearing.
- Model budget staffing for a 200-bed shelter: 43 staff for single adults, 46 for single adults with behavioral health services, 51 at assessment sites, 60 for adult families, 37 for families with children.
Action Points
- DHS to provide the Council with the legal analysis underlying the City's decision to decline the VA grant for homeless veterans, with a written timeline for delivery.
- DHS to provide demographic trend data on older adults and individuals with substance use disorder in the shelter system over time, specifically how those shares have changed.
- DHS to provide clarification on the apparent inconsistency between mortality data showing both a growing share of children and a growing share of older adults in the shelter system.
- DHS to build and implement a direct, technology-enabled channel for regular resident feedback on safety, dignity and conditions in shelters, as committed to by Commissioner Dalton.
- DHS to investigate the whistleblower complaint described by Chair Hudson regarding discrepancies between reported data and observed records at a shelter, and the retention of a security subcontractor against staff recommendations, including potential referral to the Department of Investigation.
- DHS to provide the Council with a full breakdown of the security budget for fiscal year 2026 and fiscal year 2027, including expenditure against the $313 million figure cited by the committee.
- DHS to provide the Council with data on the number of housing specialists citywide and performance metrics for housing specialist roles.
- DHS to follow up with the Council on the number of school-focused case managers in the shelter system and current data-sharing arrangements with New York City Public Schools on transportation and attendance.
- DHS to provide data on telehealth utilization by shelter residents under Local Law 35 of 2023.
- DHS to investigate whether shelter budgets have in fact been adjusted to cover mental health professional requirements under Local Law 35, given provider complaints that no budget increase accompanied the mandate.
- DHS to provide the Council with whistleblower policy documentation, including how it is communicated to provider staff and subcontractors, and data on the number of whistleblower complaints received.
- DHS to provide the Council with data on how retaliation protections are communicated to shelter residents, and to examine whether those protections are adequate.
- DHS to track and report subcontractor-specific complaints separately in its data systems, and to clarify in writing the full extent of DHS authority to cancel subcontracts.
- DHS to provide the Council with a standardised information packet covering resident rights, the grievance process, good neighbor policies and whistleblower protections, suitable for distribution through Council offices.
- DHS to provide the Council with data on the annual 8-hour refresher training completion rate for security guards once enhanced tracking is in place.
- DHS to report on compliance with sanctuary city training requirements, including frequency of refresher training and provider compliance rates.
- DHS to explore with relevant City and State partners the reclassification and pay equity of DHS peace officer positions relative to comparable roles at other City agencies.
- DHS to report on the feasibility of reporting family shelter placements at zip code level, and to engage with Council Member Brewer's office and the Public Advocate's office on the specific measures and geographies in both Int 0099-2026 and Int 0387-2026.
- DHS to provide the Council with formal planning documentation on coordination between DHS and MOCJ regarding housing and shelter access for individuals exiting Rikers Island, including data on how many people exiting custody enter DHS shelters.
- Chair Hudson to invite Commissioner Dalton and relevant DHS officials to visit Tillery Street women's shelter.
- Chair Hudson to raise DHS peace officer pay equity with the Mayor and the Governor.
Full Transcript
Ready just.
Good afternoon. Welcome to the Committee on General Welfare. At this time we ask that you please silence all electronics. If you wish to testify, please see one of the sergeants at arms in the back. At no point please do not approach the dais.
Good afternoon. For the New York City Council's General Welfare Committee, my pronouns are she/her. We are additionally joined by CM Morano, CM Ung and CM Wilson. Sorry, I thought it was somebody else over there.
Every New Yorker deserves a safe place to live, including New Yorkers who turn to the City for shelter during a period of crisis. Shelter must be more than a roof over someone's head. It must be a place where people can rest without fear of violence, access the support they need and be treated with respect.
However, we have heard too many concerns about conditions that can make shelters unsafe, including deteriorating facilities, overcrowding, violence, theft and insufficient staffing. When people feel that entering a shelter puts their safety, security or dignity at risk, they choose not to enter shelter at all. Some of the major safety issues we will look at today include not just security incidents such as arrests, thefts or violence, but also how the shelter system's design can impact physical and mental health and well-being, exacerbate and turn New Yorkers away from engaging with our shelter system and making use of the robust social safety net it can provide.
The New York City shelter system is sprawling. In the 1980s, a series of lawsuits resulted in the establishment of a right to shelter in New York City. This was an incredibly important step towards serving unhoused New Yorkers and resulted in the City needing to increase shelter capacity. Over the last 40 years, the number of shelters and the shelter population has grown. Just this past Sunday, over 83,000 individuals slept in our shelters.
Today there are over 500 shelters throughout the City that serve single adults, adult families and families with children. The majority of shelters are operated by contracted nonprofit organizations. While most of these organizations are dedicated to serving New Yorkers, third-party contracting can result in oversight and compliance challenges, including sometimes funding unscrupulous actors, subsidizing exorbitant executive salaries or inadvertently developing contracts that force providers to focus more on volume than long-term sustainable outcomes and client well-being.
Further, the additional layer of administration can make it difficult for providers to make essential repairs or changes to premises that improve safety and security. Last week at our joint hearing with the Committee on Veterans, we heard about the difficult and lengthy process for making essential repairs to the Borden Avenue Veterans Residence, resulting in a multi-year process to repair a leaking roof.
Today is an opportunity to hear from the administration about how they address shelter safety concerns, conduct oversight of challenges to shelter safety and to hear from the public about what the City can do better. In addition to today's oversight on shelter safety, we will also consider two bills intended to strengthen transparency and accountability in the shelter system. Int 0099-2026, sponsored by CM Gale Brewer, would require the Department of Homeless Services to report annually on the number of families with children placed in shelters in the same or in adjoining zip code as their last address.
CM Brewer, I now pass to you to make a statement about the legislation you are sponsoring today. Thank you.
Very much. Int 0099-2026, as you heard earlier, would require the Department of Homeless Services to do this annual report on the number and percentage of families with children in the system who are placed in the same zip code as their last address prior to their placement into a shelter, and the number and percentage who were placed in an adjoining zip code.
Families entering the shelter system, as you know, should be able to remain close to their schools, their child care, their doctors, their jobs and their community support networks whenever possible. Placing families far from their former homes creates additional hardships, particularly for families with young children who rely on nearby child care and family support. We in the Council and the public need to know how often families are placed in shelters in their former zip code or an adjoining zip code. Currently this information is not regularly reported.
Int 0099-2026 requires a report annually on shelter placements with data broken down by borough and by families with children under age three and those with older children. I believe that this reporting will help the Council identify where families are being displaced from their communities and push for shelter placement policies that minimize disruption to children's lives.
I must admit, during the period when we had so many wonderful migrants here, I really appreciated the work that the Adams administration did despite all the challenges in housing people. At the time we worked really hard to keep people as shelters moved, to keep them in their school zone and to make decisions based on all of this criteria to remain close to schools, which are the most important. Particularly, we tried to keep families near their schools. Absenteeism, whatever it is called now in New York City Public Schools, is huge and I have a horrible feeling that part of it is because people just cannot get to school. I also always want to thank the staff for their support. Thank you very much, Madam Chair.
Thank you, CM Brewer. Int 0387-2026, sponsored by the Public Advocate, would require annual reporting on critical incidents in shelters. It would also require information about efforts to improve shelter security and agreements with the NYPD or other entities to enhance safety. I now pass to the Public Advocate to make a statement about the legislation he is sponsoring today.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon. Public Advocate of the City of New York. More importantly, the Knicks won a game last night — very excited about that. I want to thank CM Hudson and the members of the Committee on General Welfare for holding this hearing. As of October 2026, a total of 83,000 individuals reside within our City's shelter system, including 51,000 families with children. Countless others brave the harsh elements outside, deterred by unsafe conditions in the shelters.
My bill, Int 0387-2026, will require the Department of Homeless Services to produce an annual report detailing critical incidents occurring in the shelters, including assault, sexual assault, domestic violence, child abuse or neglect, weapons possession, arson and theft. It is my hope that with more accurate reporting, efforts to upgrade security in shelters and enhance people's safety and well-being will be more well-informed and overall more transparent about agreements made between the NYPD and other entities responsible for safety and security.
Under current reporting, officials have classified priority one incidents as the most serious incidents, involving arrests, medical crises, overdoses and deaths. In one women's shelter, priority one incidents have increased drastically, rising from 123 in 2019 to 208 in 2024. And in 2025, the rate of priority ones at this facility were over double the citywide average for single adult shelters. While the range and severity of incidents vary across shelters, trends of violence hold true across the system, especially in larger shelter sites. Bellevue, the City's largest shelter for single adult men, which closed earlier this year for redevelopment, was also characterized...
...unfortunately by violence. I also want to uplift the other piece of legislation being heard today, for which I am proud to co-sponsor. CM Brewer's Int 0099-2026, which she just spoke about, would require DHS to report on the placement of families with children in shelters — specifically the rate of families and children who are placed within the same or in adjoining zip codes as their last address prior to shelter placement. Displacement from one's home is already a source of significant stress and emotional hardship for families, but...
...remaining in neighborhoods nearby would avoid disrupting children's school lives and teens, adding an additional layer of uncertainty and stress. This data will better help us understand what happens when families enter the system.
And how we can better mitigate disruption in the lives of our youngest New Yorkers. As the administration seeks to revamp the shelter system following the challenges of last year, we must ensure that New Yorkers experiencing homelessness not only have access to shelter but to spaces that are safe and truly livable. These bills are one step towards ensuring safety and security within shelters and I look forward to continuing the work with the agencies in this administration. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you so much, Public Advocate. I look forward to hearing from the administration and the public about these proposals. I would like to conclude by thanking the committee staff for their work on this hearing: Hanna Cohen, Nina Rosenberg, Justine Campos, Faria Raymone, Elizabeth Childers Garcia, Julia Haram, Colby Porter and Maggie Giordano. I would also like to thank my staff: Andrew Wright, Ali Karu Anton and Demi Brown. Before we hear testimony from the administration, we will hear directly from a panel of individuals who have experience with New York City shelters and who have joined us here to provide testimony. First we will hear from Denton Hutchinson, after we will hear from Janet Jackson and last we will hear from Francisco Ines. And we have been...
...joined by CM Nurse. And I did fail to recognize that CM Brewer was here as well. Thank you. Denton Hutchinson.
Good afternoon. My name is Denton Hutchinson. I am with the Community Leadership Collective at the Coalition for the Homeless. I thank you for holding this long-awaited hearing today on safety in shelters. I was in shelter for over seven years and recently was able to get housing and leave shelter. During my seven years in shelter, I was transferred around to many sites but I saw the same issues at different shelters.
One of the hardest parts of living in a shelter is how people are treated by staff, including the security staff who are supposed to create a safe environment. Whether it was police or private security guards, they treated us with absolute disrespect and complete disregard for our lives. These staff do not de-escalate conflict — they only escalate it, or they just ignore it.
In one shelter I was in, I noticed someone sleeping on the floor in the back of the recreation room in the morning. I told the security staff stationed about six steps away from the recreation room. They said that he had missed his bed check so he had to sleep on the floor. Later in the afternoon I came back and he was still lying there, unmoving. I spoke with security staff again, telling them that he had not moved since I saw him that morning. DHS security finally walked over to see him and discovered he was dead. It was horrifying to say the least. He was someone that I knew. They let him lay there steps away all night and day without even bothering to check on him or do anything that could have saved his life. Staff do not care about the lives of people in shelters.
In another instance, I was dealing with the worst case of shingles. Because of the shingles I could only wear the lightest of clothing because it hurt so excruciatingly bad. It was the middle of winter. There was an altercation and police required all residents to leave the building. I could not stay inside or go to my bed or another room because I was sick and did not have winter clothes on and it was very cold out. They said I had to leave and I stood outside in the cold, worried about pneumonia and my health. Again, this shows that shelter staff and security staff do not care about the lives and well-being of shelter residents. Those of us who have no place to go but shelter deserve basic respect and dignity, but that is not what we get in shelter. I want to thank you for this opportunity to testify. Thank you so much for...
...sharing. I appreciate it. Janet Jackson, good afternoon.
Good afternoon. My name is Janet Jackson, with the Community Leadership Collective at the Coalition for the Homeless. The issues I faced while I was in a shelter for about five years continue today. One of the hardest parts about being in the shelter was the constant feeling of insecurity. The shelters, some of them, were in isolated parts of the City. When I first entered, I was placed in a congregate shelter after intake. There were mice nesting in the mattresses along with other insects. The dorm rooms I lived in would flood during heavy rains. Others could not put their belongings in the closet at the bottom because they would be ruined by the flooding.
During COVID I was placed in a hotel because of my health issues. Being in my own space made a huge difference, but even though I had my own room, staff was intrusive. I would try to get some sleep after working a long shift at the hospital but staff would come around and open the doors to every room without knocking. It did not matter if you were undressed — some of these staff would just open the door. It was very invasive and unnecessary.
When the COVID emergency ended and they wanted to transfer me out of the hotel, I requested a shelter that was closer to my job and told them I needed something that did not require stairs because it was quite hard for me to walk and climb steps. They told me the only shelter they could put me in was in East New York, Brooklyn, and this was a senior women's shelter which was one and a half to two hours away from my job in the Bronx at Jacobi Medical Center, where I worked the evening and the night shift. I would often get back to the shelter from my shift at one or two in the morning after traveling on the train for an hour and a half. When I got off the train, the L train, I felt unsafe because it was desolate and this is one or two o'clock in the morning, and walking to the shelter felt unsafe.
We made complaints to the shelter. It is hard to get the staff to do anything about it. I was having trouble breathing and the day shift supervisor was making his rounds. When he came to my room I told him that I was having difficulty because there must have been a mouse or something on the trap under the dresser. He told me it had to wait till the next morning. When the next shift supervisor came, I told her what happened. She saw I was having trouble breathing. She checked underneath the dresser and there were two mice trapped in a trap. The mice had exacerbated my asthma.
A shelter should be a place where people can find stability, but instead it is hard to get anything done for your basic needs. Safety means being treated with dignity. It means being able to sleep peacefully, having a clean and well-maintained place to stay, knowing that staff takes shelter residents' concerns seriously and trusting that you will not be punished for speaking out. I would like to thank the Council for inviting me here today and for this hearing to shine the light on all the problems in the shelter system that still exist and that make people feel unsafe. Thank you.
Thank you so much for your testimony. And now we will hear from...
Francisco Ines. Okay. Nobody... Francisco's friend is showing me something. We hope to... Coalition for the Homeless. Thank you for coming. He comes from a permanent... any... this life, when you are not safe within...
Okay. Good afternoon. My name is Francisco Ines and I am a member of the Community Leadership Collective at the Coalition for the Homeless. I want to address all of you here in the hearing because I am addressing you because I do not feel safe in these homeless shelters. I was hoping to find stability while I was working toward a permanent home for me, but it is very difficult to find stability when I do not find myself safe in one of these homeless places.
One of the most difficult things about living in one of the homeless shelters is the way that the employees are treating the people...
...who are living there in the shelter. We are supposed to have a very safe environment for all of us. However, we have a big conflict and this is creating a very dangerous environment in the places where we live. In one of the shelters I was living in before, there was a very big fight and the only reason for this big fight was that one of the homeless residents who lived there only asked for an additional juice. This was the only thing that he asked for. Only because he was asking for an additional juice, the person responded with hostility and refused to give him juice, and instead of giving the juice there was a very big fight between both of them.
Okay. Any other...
People who were working at a shelter did anything to try to help in the situation, or to stack the file right. The only thing they were doing, they were looking at them. At the same time they were fighting so bad that they even destroyed... or some of the kitchen equipment that was there. And why we should have this cruel reaction from these people from the shelters.
Thank you. Okay, thank you.
The staff... really, to believe a calm and good environment, and especially when you are a person alone with a very high population... from day one. But if you do not know this.
I believe this homeless shelter is right.
They are not well trained. They are not trained enough to create a safe environment in these homeless shelters, especially when you live in a homeless shelter and you are there by yourself, you are alone, right, with a very high population. And I am very concerned that I should maybe suffer mistreatment from these people in the homeless shelter, or I could also be in a very insecure and unsafe situation that will happen there. So there are moments where I prefer not to say anything because I think if I say something it will make my situation worse than before. Okay.
Okay, okay, okay.
And when persons with disabilities, the personnel do not provide them a place... the personnel meaning nothing. Okay. And I am living in a specialized unit for people who suffer from disabilities. They never provided me with a house key or a room key, right. And the place where I am living, every time when I am requesting a key from the homeless shelter employees, what they are doing to me, they just ignore me, you know. And when I close the door, they call me, and when the door is closed, they ask me to open the door. Okay.
You know, the situation is...
So bad that I cannot even close my door. You know, the room door. And because I go outside to see my children — my children do not live in the homeless shelter, they live outside — the personnel become very angry with me because I am closing the door. And what they are doing to me, they are sending a security guard to open the door, right, instead of keeping the door closed. Okay.
I am asking for basic... this does not mean that the conditions of life are much better and incentive...
Inside, I am asking for special treatment from the homeless shelter? No, that is not my intention. I am only asking for basic respect, and also asking to have safety in that place. I believe every person that lives in the homeless shelter, they serve any time in society, right. I completely understand that living in a homeless shelter could be very difficult for everyone, but this does not mean that we should accept conditions that are going to make our life more stressful and are going to make our life insecure while we are living in those homeless shelters.
I believe a shelter should be a place where you could find stability. It should not be a place where I have to be worried about my safety. We are homeless. We deserve a safe place to live, right, a secure place, and also a safe place where we can stay without worrying about it. And we should have a real opportunity to move forward in the future. Okay.
That is everything. Thank you so much. Thank you all for your testimony. I think it is really a reflection of the work that we still have to do in making sure that our shelters are safe and secure and also can provide the folks living there with dignity. So thank you for sharing your time and perspectives with us. Hold on one second — I think the public advocate has a question.
Thank you so much for sharing your testimonies. I really appreciate it. I want to know: was there a line where you could report complaints, and if the complaints were not addressed at the shelter, were you aware of any place you could go after that?
My incident with the mice and the asthma — the second supervisor called the director and he told me to write up a grievance and he wanted it on his desk when he came in the next morning. I did so, she put it on his desk. That one supervisor that came before that told me I had to wait till the next morning. When I left, like six months later, he was still working. So even though the grievance goes to the ombudsman's office, they have 30 to 60 days to respond.
The amount of grievances that they receive, they cannot respond to, so things go left and unattended. And a lot of directors in the shelter, when you do file grievances, it goes right under the table. I just have something to add, because as far as I am concerned, the way grievances are handled is an absolute joke. The fact of the matter is, you are supposed to go to the operations and ask them for a grievance form, and when you fill it out you hand it back to them. But sometimes the grievance is against the very people who give you the form, and all their cohorts are involved. So without tooting my own horn, I actually had an idea that a grievance box be placed — like a lockbox — and forms be placed near them, and you can go and pick one up and put it in the box, and only the appropriate person could open it and take out
those grievances and address them. Thank you.
Okay.
But so you were not aware of anywhere to make grievances that did not involve the people you were having grievances about?
No. No such policy or system exists in New York.
Thank you. Also, the private shelters. Okay.
Thank you. Also, to finish — he said that he filed a complaint about his condition, about what was happening to him in the homeless shelter, but he was ignored completely. They never responded and they never did any follow-up about his complaint. Thank you. Okay.
Thank you. And CM Ung, I do have a question for the last gentleman. What were the language capabilities of the shelter? Because, you know, he is talking to you now through a translator. Was there something like that in the shelter for him? How did he address his concerns? Who was in the shelter that could speak the language? Was there something like a language line?
An interpreter... interpreter in...
I can talk in English, so my complaint — I can write it. Sorry, just pull the microphone a little bit closer. He said that he can talk in English and can express his anger or his disagreement by talking, so he does not have problems communicating his concerns in the shelter. And he speaks English. Back to my apologies — he is speaking English and he can talk in English with the people in the shelter.
He felt like he was ignored by those people. And I mean, for those who could speak English less capably than him, was there any language help? Was there anyone in the shelter that was helpful with interpretation?
What I wanted to know exactly is that every opportunity that one resident had a problem — for example, one took medication and he is Spanish-speaking — they usually ask me, "Can you help me please?" and tell me what he is saying.
So I can help them to translate whatever they need to say at the moment.
So they are basically counting on you to help them.
Okay, all right, all right. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you all. Thank you, Council members. Thank you, public advocate. And now the administration will present their testimony. I will turn it over to the committee counsel to administer the oath before the testimony is taken.
Thank you. Before delivering testimony, please state your name for the record. Good afternoon. Erin Dalton,
Department of Social Services. Before I begin with my testimony, I want to thank you for convening the panel of folks who came to testify about their experiences in our system. I do think it is really important to start with the voices of people. While you will hear us testify — I am about to testify to a lot of procedures, protocols and data that we think we have set up to keep people safe and to have their voices heard — none of it can address people's perceptions of those conditions if we do not hear from them directly. So while during my time here I will do my best work to make sure all those procedures and protocols are in place and that we use that data to help improve the system every single day, the most important measure to me will be people's perceptions of their safety, their sense of dignity, respect and how we treat them in the system. Those are measures we do not have in place at this time, but measures I can put in place and will put in place so that we can keep a pulse on what is really happening for the people who are being served in this system. So I appreciate everyone's testimony and the issues they continue to raise.
Moving on to more formal testimony: good afternoon, Chair Hudson and members of the Committee on General Welfare. I am Erin Dalton, Commissioner for the Department of Social Services. Joining me are Department of Homeless Services First Deputy Commissioner Christine Fellini and Deputy Commissioner for Shelter Service Security Avon. Thank you for the opportunity to discuss shelter safety and the legislation on today's agenda.
DHS oversees 502 shelter sites across New York City, seven of them operated directly by us. We are committed to protecting our clients, the staff who serve them and the surrounding communities. That means secure facilities, well-maintained buildings and responding to concerns promptly and transparently.
On the issues of security and safety: our approach to safety includes on-site security, access controls, surveillance, staff training, incident reporting and ongoing oversight. Every shelter has security around the clock. Officers at each entrance control access and monitor cameras placed throughout the interior and exterior of the building. Each facility's security needs depend on its location, size, layout, access points and history. DHS conducts security risk assessments to set staffing levels and equipment, which can include access control systems, cameras and x-ray machines. Our goal is risk-based security that protects residents and staff while respecting their dignity.
DHS's 352 peace officers are deployed at intake and assessment sites and at facilities on Ward's Island, where they control access, maintain order and respond to incidents. The Provider Assistance Unit trains security staff at provider-operated shelters. Training covers the foundations of the work, including understanding homelessness, cultural sensitivity, serving people with disabilities and trauma-informed care, as well as practical skills such as de-escalation, crisis intervention and suicide prevention. DHS and other uniformed staff can also assist providers during emergencies and support inspections to remove weapons, drugs and other contraband.
When serious incidents occur, DHS responds and contacts emergency services when needed. DHS operates around the clock, tracks more than 70 types of incidents and reviews reports for accuracy, allowing us to spot trends and risks.
Moving on to our good neighbor policy: through our nonprofit partnerships, volunteering, donations and workforce programs, every shelter has a good neighbor policy that sets clear expectations for conduct inside the shelter and in the surrounding community. Residents receive written rules when they arrive. Providers reinforce those rules through case management, and security monitors activity in and around the building. Community advisory boards bring together providers, elected officials, community boards, local businesses and neighbors, usually every quarter, giving the community a regular place to raise concerns. The NYPD Quality of Life Division reports on incidents at these meetings, and many providers attend monthly precinct council meetings.
When problems arise, responses range from conversations with staff to additional support, and when safety is at stake, a transfer. On client safety transfers: residents face threats, harassment or violence that make their placement unsafe. When a concern is raised, we take immediate protective steps, contact law enforcement or other emergency responders, or arrange a transfer depending on the urgency of the concern, the resident's needs and the available placements. There were 2,654 safety transfers in fiscal year 2026, slightly up from the 2,625 in fiscal year 2025. When it comes to shelter...
Maintaining safety also depends on the conditions of our more than 500 buildings. Ownership and original purpose vary — many were built before 1980 and many were converted to shelter use to meet demand. Keeping them in good condition requires regular inspections, timely repairs, preventive maintenance and long-term capital planning. We are closing older and substandard facilities and prioritizing purpose-built shelters designed around trauma-informed care.
DHS regularly reviews provider performance on safety and building maintenance. Routine site review inspections conducted with provider staff and the Department of Buildings, Department of Housing Preservation and Development, the Fire Department and the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene identify code violations and hazards before they become more serious. Providers are expected to address severe deficiencies within 24 hours of receiving the results.
DHS publishes a quarterly shelter repair scorecard so New Yorkers can see the conditions in our shelter buildings. Conditions in our standard shelters have improved dramatically since 2016, when the City shelter repair squad cut open violations in traditional shelters by 83% in nine months. Today our 365 standard shelters average fewer than four open violations each and only one in ten is high priority. Those numbers have held steady even as the system has grown, and City agencies have completed more than 4,300 inspections so far this year. The challenge is in our flexible capacity system, which is about 169 sites, mostly commercial hotels opened to meet a surge in demand, averaging about 42 open violations each. This is something we need to better understand and correct. It is also one reason we are reducing our reliance on hotels, particularly for families with children.
Residents and staff can also report problems through our shelter repair hotline. Last year the hotline received 29,934 complaints. Each complaint is followed up with the resident, and for serious problems, the Department of Buildings or HPD is engaged.
Each repair has to be assessed as routine maintenance, an urgent fix or a larger capital project. The Asset Information Management System documents capital needs in City-owned buildings such as boilers, plumbing, electrical systems, fire alarms, roofs, elevators and bathrooms. There are 55 City and State-owned buildings in our portfolio and major repairs must go through the City's capital program. For FY27 we have $106 million for 102 projects across 38 shelters. Eight are complete and 31 are in active construction and expected to finish by June 2027. The rest are in planning, design or procurement. For privately owned buildings, responsibility for repair depends on the provider arrangement with the owner. Providers responsible for routine maintenance have a budget for it, which varies with the site's age and layout. When a larger repair is the provider's responsibility, our facilities and logistics team helps to identify solutions if the provider's budget cannot cover the costs. We submit a request to... We are reviewing these processes to remove administrative bottlenecks, give providers more visibility and speed up repairs whenever possible.
Looking at the data we have, the first category is crime information — those are NYPD complaints and arrests at our shelter addresses, serious violent incidents tracked in the Mayor's Management Report and complaints residents make about assault, harassment and how they are treated. The second is the day-to-day health and safety needs of the people we serve, which show up in 911 calls and incidents that providers report. A medical emergency is not a crime, so these need to be counted and considered separately. We also share rates per thousand so that the growth in the shelter population does not distort the trends.
Looking at Part One crime and safety: complaints and arrests at shelter addresses have fallen per resident since fiscal year 23 and serious violence is declining. The Mayor's Management Report shows that in single adult shelters, where the rates are the highest, serious violent incidents fell 13% last year to 2.8 per thousand residents, down from 4.8 in fiscal year 22. In family shelters the rate held steady at well below one per thousand residents. Complaints add something police data cannot capture.
Complaints about discrimination, assault and harassment rose 19% this year and complaints about interactions between staff and clients rose 46%. More people are raising complaints, not just the same people calling more often. These complaints tell us residents do not always feel safe or respected and that is something we can take direct action to improve.
Looking at health and safety needs: 911 calls include calls made by staff, and close to 40% of those are medical, so many reflect people getting help when they need it. Calls per resident rose last year, most sharply in safe havens and stabilization sites, which serve people with some of the most significant needs. We are watching calls about disputes and disorders most closely because they are also rising.
Calls about assault and violence are a small share and they have fallen since fiscal year 23. Incidents reported by providers have been roughly level. A third are accidents, health concerns and hospitalizations. Serious incidents among single adults have declined each year since fiscal year 23, including a 13% drop over the last two years.
The most serious measure of safety is found in the mortality data. The death rate in shelter has fallen by two thirds in three years, from about 11 per thousand residents in fiscal year 22 to 3.5 in fiscal year 25. Part of that reflects a younger population with more children, but the number of deaths also fell from 500 to 305 while the shelter population nearly doubled. Drug-related deaths across the homeless population fell 28% last year but still account for 40% of all deaths, and 42 of the 73 people who died in shelter in fiscal year 25 died of an overdose.
The people we serve are also getting older. The share of deaths among people 65 and older rose from 13% to 17% in one year.
Naloxone in every building and treatment and medical care for an aging population are our safety measures as well. The overall picture is real progress with clear work ahead. Arrests and serious violence are down and fewer people are dying in our care. At the same time, conditions in our commercial hotels and residents' concerns about how they are treated show us where our focus needs to be. Our goal is shelters that are safe and dignified for everyone who lives and works in them.
Turning to Int 0387-2026, that introduction would require DHS to produce an annual report on critical incidents in our shelters along with information on security measures, security upgrades and agreements with NYPD and other law enforcement. We do share the goal of transparency. DHS already reports critical incidents to State oversight bodies and through the Mayor's Management Report. We would seek to align any new requirements with these existing systems to avoid duplicate reporting. We also must protect confidential shelter information and cannot publish some security information disaggregated by individual shelter as the introduction requires. Public reporting would need to aggregate data and protect confidential addresses. We look forward to working with the sponsor and Council on legislation that advances transparency while meeting these privacy obligations.
Int 0099-2026 would require DHS to report annually on the number and share of families with children placed...
...in shelter in the same or an adjoining zip code as their last address. We welcome further conversation with the sponsor on the goals of this Bill. DHS makes every effort to place families near the youngest child's school, and the Mayor's Management Report already tracks the share of families placed in the borough of that school. Zip code data does not capture the factors behind placement. For example, families affected by domestic violence need to be placed away from their prior address. We welcome discussion of reporting that accounts for these circumstances.
In conclusion, I appreciate the Council's attention to ensuring that shelters are safe, secure and well maintained. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. We welcome your questions.
Thank you, Commissioner, for your testimony. I will kick it off with a few questions and then I am going to turn to my colleagues in just a moment's time.
Your testimony noted that there are 502 shelters. This is a significant increase from even two years ago. What has led to the increase?
Thank you for the question. I will start and I am going to be relying heavily on my colleagues for this hearing. I think as a right-to-shelter city, and proud to be one, the increase in need from the asylum-seeker population certainly overwhelmed the system that was operating during that time. I am grateful for all of the work that the City and the Department of Homeless Services did to open so many shelters in such a short period in order to accommodate that need.
Good afternoon. Sorry — Christine Fellini, First Deputy Commissioner at the Department of Homeless Services. To add to the Commissioner's comments, and as part of what will come up around repairs and the maintenance of buildings, we are also looking to replace old stock. As shelters become... as we have decided to move towards more purpose-built and higher quality shelters, we can phase out those older buildings that are in need of significant repairs.
Through obviously deaths and incidents, you called out specifically the older adult population as well as those with substance use disorder, and I am wondering if you know how the share of those populations has changed over the years. Are those populations in particular increasing in terms of the number of people you are seeing in the shelter system who are either older adults or experiencing substance use disorder?
I do not have those numbers in front of me. I think we are seeing an increase in the share of older adults using our shelter system, and I am not certain that we track precisely the number of people who have a diagnosis or are experiencing substance use disorder, but we can certainly look at what we have and get back to the Council.
Yes, it would be interesting to know whether it is at intake or for people who are being sent to shelters that provide specific services, what those numbers look like and how they have changed over time.
And then one point of clarification: you mentioned that the death rate in shelter has fallen by two thirds in three years, from about 11 per 1,000 residents in fiscal year 2022 to 3.5 in fiscal year 2025, and that part of that reflects a younger population with more children, while also noting a greater population of older adults. So if you can just provide a little bit more clarity on those numbers.
Sure. I was also just trying to put into context that the very significant decline in mortality data is also a function of who we are serving in the system, and so we wanted to...
...add that context. I will go back and look at the numbers, but I think it can be consistent that there is a growing share of children in the system and of older adults, and that the share in between is what is declining. We can obviously provide the changing demographics of the shelter system. That would be...
...great, thank you. Okay, I do not have any more questions specifically pertaining to your testimony. I would like to turn it over to my colleagues and then I will get into my long list of questions. So starting with CM Morano, followed by Wilson and...
...then Brewer. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Commissioner. Before I ask you about your testimony today, you were kind enough to testify before the last committee hearing that Chair Hudson and I co-chaired, and you indicated that you would get us some information about the legal analysis that the City relied upon to decline the VA grant for homeless veterans. Do you have any idea when you might be able to get that to us?
I do not as I sit here, but we can respond in writing with the...
...timeline. I appreciate it, thank you.
In your testimony you discussed the good neighbor policy and community advisory boards, and you say these boards bring together elected officials, community boards, businesses and neighbors to discuss concerns. But is it not true that these advisory boards generally function after the City has already decided where to put a shelter? So the neighborhood gets a chance to discuss problems after the decision has already been made, but not necessarily a meaningful opportunity to raise concerns before the decision is finalized. Is that a fair characterization?
I think it is fair that the community advisory boards are set up to be a good neighbor with a shelter that is already there. So I think it is right to characterize it as an ongoing process with the community. But certainly we work with community boards and elected officials and community members aligned with the process that we use to site shelters, so there is engagement with the community...
...prior to that. Would it not make more sense to conduct a community impact assessment and solicit neighborhood input before committing taxpayer dollars to a location, rather than asking residents to live with the consequences and complain afterward?
I appreciate that as a sentiment and we can look at that as we consider...
...any potential changes to the way we do shelter siting in the City.
Thank you. One other question before I run out of time: you report that DHS conducted 2,654 safety transfers last fiscal year. That is more than seven people being transferred every single day because of safety concerns. When a resident is threatened or assaulted by another resident...
...who gets moved, the victim or the person responsible for the threat?
I am going to let my colleagues answer that, and I am also going to think through the math of that, because there are some people moving in and out of shelters... I do not think the denominators are right, but it would not be the first time I made a math error.
But the substance of the question is important, so I am going to ask...
...and thank you for the question. It depends on the circumstances. If the person who is the victim of the assault prefers to stay at the shelter, it is possible that we will transfer the alleged perpetrator.
Is there any disciplinary consequence for an individual who repeatedly threatens or assaults other shelter residents?
The safety transfers are the way we address that. We are looking to maintain the safety of people in the shelter as well as the staff. We are also looking to get at what the issue is that is causing the individual to act out in this way, so that means making sure that...
...they are in a shelter that either provides the right services or connects them to community services. Thank you, I have more questions for you later.
Thank you. CM Morano, moving on to CM...
In the testimony we heard in the first panel, there were many instances about conflicts that residents are having with staff in the shelters. So does DHS have standards around escalation and sensitivity training for provider staff, and how do you conduct oversight to ensure that those...
...are happening?
Yes, and my colleagues can look up the actual numbers perhaps. Yes, we do have training and support...
...for those very kinds of efforts, and I think I testified to that. We are seeing it not just from the people who testified today but across the board, and it will be an area where we need to do more. But I will let my colleagues speak to the specifics there.
Thank you, Commissioner, and thank you for the question. I think you are hitting on a good point. We can train, but we have to make sure that the training is implemented on the ground. Related to trauma-informed training, as per Local Law 49 of 2023, we have trained over 15,000 staff in the last two years around customer service with a focus on what we call HEARTS, which stands for Healing, Equity, Accountability, Respect, Transparency and Services. This is really to make sure that we have a holistic, trauma-informed approach to the work that we do. This applies to every level of staff, every day of the week, and we really want to make sure that everyone is implementing the training. While they may be contracted provider staff at the shelter, it is DHS's responsibility to make sure that that ethos is permeated throughout the shelter.
Are the trainings... is it up to the provider to implement the training, or does DHS...
...offer the training and require staff to take it? We then follow up, and I think it is part of the review of complaints and incidents. To the point the Commissioner made about what we are seeing — the increase in complaints — that says something to us. So we say, listen, we implemented HEARTS, what is going on at your facility? Is it staff-related, is it facility-related, is it related to a particular client or clients? So it allows us to dig into what is going on at a particular site.
Chair, can I...
...ask one more thing? Thank you. Also, in terms of grievance reports and reporting, the same sort of question: are there standards that DHS sets for how providers should be managing grievance reports, and what happens when there are multiple grievance reports for a particular staff member — the same staff member — like how do you manage that?
Thank you for the question. If you would not mind...
Giving me one moment. And so the Commissioner's point earlier: we have procedures and we have protocols, and the grievance process is one of them. It is a longstanding procedure and, as I believe Denton — I hope I got his name right — testified, I give the form to the person I might be having an issue with. So that is the policy. Clients do have the opportunity to essentially appeal the shelter's response to that, and we do track those and get involved. Community members, clients, anyone can also report complaints or...
...inquiries to us through 311. They can come into one of our centers and make a complaint, they can call us and make a complaint, and all of that is gathered and analyzed. So we are looking not just at individual complaints, we are looking at trends. Is there a particular shelter? Is someone named repeatedly? Because then we are going to dig in. We expect the shelter already has — we are also going to get the shelter director on the phone to say, what is going on with this person and how can we help? Because that is the other thing...
And how is the follow-up with the person making the report? How do they know that their complaint has been taken seriously and that it is going to take all these steps to analyze their complaint?
Thank you for the question. And then I will be done. That is implemented by the Ombudsman's Office. Step one is to let the complainant know that we have received the inquiry and directed it to the shelter. They have a pretty good success rate — about 90% ability, you know, contacting about 90% of the people who have complained. There are some instances where somebody's voicemail is not set up or we cannot get in touch with them. It is then passed on to the shelter. They have 25 days to respond. The provider is also made aware — sorry, is made aware of the complaint. We CC it on everything that goes out to the shelters that we are responsible for. And then we monitor. If this is related to one particular staff member, we want to know what the next steps are. Is this training? Is this not the right shelter? Could this person be transferred to a different shelter or provider? Or do...
...we need additional action? But we are actively involved in making sure that the complaints get addressed, and that if it is a one-time thing — if we are seeing this over time — it is not just addressing the complaints, it is us taking a deep dive into what is happening at that shelter. I think some of this is actually the way the process by which we must collect complaints is governed by our state regulations, and so there are just some rules around the way we are required to do that. But it is also why I think, you know, building out the direct communication with residents of the shelter system so we can hear on an ongoing basis is an additional tool to understand and support their well-being. I feel like it is a critical piece to be built. Thank you, CM Brewer.
Thank you very much, and thank you for being responsive. On Int 0099, but as Chris said, like one shelter is called 500 times a month and the police department is there out front. In terms of Int 0099, I know you mentioned the Mayor's Management Report but I do not see it in a quick perusal. Do you collect the exact data at the MMR or on your own? As stated in this Bill, basically the zip code, nearby schools, et cetera — is that something that you collect now?
It is.
And can you explain a little bit more, like how often is it produced or what would you use it for, et cetera? Is it in the MMR and I am just missing it? No, the specific data in the intro is not reported in the Mayor's Management Report. There is a different measure. I can read the actual measure to you. I did not see it there, so I appreciate that. Thank you. So it has been...
Sorry.
It is families living in the borough of their youngest child's school, and it is a percentage. So I think we think — but we want to understand more — and it was helpful to hear your testimony and your reflections on the introduction. We think that this is responsive to what you are concerned about. I hear you being concerned about children being able to stay in the continuity of their community, stay in their school.
...well-being. And I would just — I would be interested. We are not against doing that additional reporting. It is just, to be useful, to understand if you think it would add value in understanding that, or if this specific measure — which keeps them in their... you cannot always do it. I guess one of the questions would be: how often are you able to do that?
My experience during the migrant crisis was that there were efforts but they were not always able to do that. And even before your tenure, when the previous administration — I asked about the same thing, even before the Bill — and I was told it is too hard to find a shelter, or too hard to find housing, or too hard...
...et cetera. Sure. And so the main issue we have is getting out of the hotel into a shelter, and so we are not dealing with the three-year-old, the four-year-old, or the family or the school.
So maybe that has changed. Well, bye, Molly. Yeah.
I mean, there are two I...
...can give you the latest measures from the MMR on the specific measure that is included there. So we do better over time, but in terms of the initial placement, 62.9% of families were initially placed in the borough of the youngest school-aged child. So we are not hitting that every time. And I will say, as you know, there are other considerations to be made. I know that is a whole different world. I am not even thinking about that. That is...
...everybody else, not right. And as we look at families and placements that are in the borough of the youngest child's school over time — over the duration of their stay — it is over 80%. So we are very much managing to this idea of school continuity.
The reason I also ask is not only — if you are ten and you have an issue, that is as important in my opinion as under three or three or younger. So those are the kinds of data I would like to see. I know people now who are commuting from the Rockaways to Manhattan because that is the only school that takes a child with the... they are always late. Always on the buses. I am already dealing with buses. We are sitting here — they are always late.
So now I have to say I think it is correct that kids in foster care and shelter are driving up the absentee rate for the Department of Education.
And they are perhaps the ones who need the education the most. It just has to be addressed one way or the other.
Yes, I know — that was not exactly a question there. But we are working hard with New York City Public Schools on attendance. We are doing door-knocking for kids who have missed the first bits of school. We are doing an on-the-ground operational approach to make sure that transportation is in place. So we are — this is a...
...high priority. Do you keep track of those who might be asking for a transfer during the year because of school issues or other kinds of issues? Do you keep track of that? We do. Okay. I could go on but go...
...ahead, go to somebody else. I know you could, and I am happy to add you to round two, but I am going to move along to CM Ung, followed by CM Nurse, and then CM... and we have been joined by CM...
...Avilés. Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Commissioner, for your testimony today. So I do have a question about the language capabilities of shelters. So if your client — where English is not their first language — how do they go through the grievance procedure, either written or oral, and then how does the message get communicated back...
...to the client? Thank you for the question. All shelters are required to comply with the language access policy and all have access to the language line contract to be able to communicate with every single client 24 hours a day. If it were the grievance process, just like with any form, staff would use the language line to make sure the client understood the form, talk through that, help record the response. The form would live in English back to the shelter staff, and the language line could assist with making sure that the client understood what the process is.
Okay. Is there any — and I appreciate the language line, I always do appreciate the language line — but is there any effort...
...where the shelter community — the community that is in the shelter system — the language they speak, is there any effort to, you know, hire people in the shelter that speak that language? Of course, and we want our providers to make sure that there is a diverse shelter staff. So yes. Okay. Is there...
...okay, I mean, is there any statistics on this? Any just examples of this that could be helpful and, like, for me to understand a little bit more of what is going on?
We do not track the language capability of provider staff, but it is something we could certainly look into.
Great. And there is an effort to communicate to providers that, you know, it should ideally be the language that is actually spoken in that shelter? Yes, and we have communication cards which make it...
...easy for clients to indicate to staff what language they speak, so that saves some time and back and forth. Okay.
Thank you.
Thank you, CM Nurse. I do not know if I have questions — I have comments. But I will say that a lot of our cases in our office are requests to transfer out of the shelters and the immediate area, and for the most part we have been very successful in getting people out. But it does not necessarily translate into improvements in those existing facilities. You know, our immediate goal is just to focus on the person who comes into the office. You all have been helpful with that.
I will say that when it comes to the community advisory boards, in the past we had a Magnolia House — we had some issues, but we got the CAB up and running and for the most part we have had very little communication to our office, and it was a pretty quick process. Recently, with another CAB that we have gotten set up — and you all, we have been in communication about this — but I would be remiss if I did not put it on the record for my community that is watching: I feel like there was really a failure to stand up the CAB in a really efficient and thoughtful way. We had a stabbing, and the first community meeting did not happen until sometime later, and it was kind of a botched rollout. I think we are now getting back on track, and so I think it is really important to land that — especially that first gathering with community residents after an incident of violence. There was a child involved. This is really... all of your senior staff has really stepped in and been very helpful, but I think it might be worth looking at that process for rolling out the CAB, because I just did not have a good experience with that unfortunately. I...
...do not have a question. Thanks. That is an important anecdote to note, so thank you, CM Avilés.
Thank you, Chair, and good afternoon everyone. Thank you so much. So we have heard from a number of our constituents living in shelters that the case management services — particularly getting support with securing housing via CityFHEPS vouchers — is really inadequate. So one of our constituents came to our office crying because she has lost out on two apartments when she was not able to get support from her housing specialist. What is the current ratio of housing specialists to shelter residents? And given that our goal with the shelter system is to hopefully get people out of shelters and into permanent, dignified housing, what is the ideal ratio of housing specialists to residents?
Thank you for the question. Our shelters are budgeted along an approved model budget, so those model budgets set the ratios of staff that are budgeted for, with some exceptions if the provider wants to rearrange some of the lines or the titles. Currently, for sites that do have housing specialists, the ratio is about 1 to 40. There are some sites that do not have housing specialists. It is imperative that any case management staff be able to advocate on behalf of the clients, so they need to know the voucher process, they need to know all the options for a household, they need to make sure the household is aware of what they might qualify for, what they do qualify for, and then take steps to help them get that voucher or housing strategy and then assist with finding housing. As it relates to the CityFHEPS process, I know our colleagues at HRA have done a lot to improve the processing time, and I know we continue to look at that. We get a lot of inquiries from shelter staff about why it is taking so long — the system on our side, the processing when somebody does find housing. But we look to support our shelter providers to make sure that the staff on the ground supporting clients are doing so effectively.
If I could ask a quick follow-up — thank you for that. In terms of what you mentioned about setting the ratios, do you have any sense of what criteria is being used to determine whether or not our housing crisis is critical enough to actually make sure we have housing specialists that can make sure we get people out of the shelter system?
Let me clarify — it does not set the ratio, it is a model that we have negotiated with providers. So there are, you know, the capacity of the site, a certain number of staff to meet the...
...critical core functions of what should happen in a shelter.
So do you know how many housing specialists you have citywide, and do you track performance around those housing specialists?
Yeah, we have the number of housing specialists — that is certainly something we could follow up on. Our measure of success, again not related to that role specifically, is CityFHEPS placements and all placements, to be sure. Permanent housing could come through a voucher or through many other means.
We would love to hear more about how securing staffing capacity ensures that residents are transitioning out of the shelter system, and how do we ensure that that is a robust and supportive environment. Thank you.
Okay, thank you. When survivors seek shelter, how does DHS ensure that they are sent to a safe housing situation?
Thank you for the question. First and foremost, when somebody comes in, we are doing a domestic violence screening — somebody does not have to state that, but through our assessment process, anyone who comes in or the family is referred to HRA's NOVA — No Violence Again — program, and they are really assessing the criteria and eligibility for a placement into a domestic violence shelter. What they are doing is making sure that if there is an apparent DV situation and they cannot take this household in due to capacity constraints, or the size of the family does not meet the available units in a shelter, that they are making placements. If there is a couple, they are going to separate the alleged abuser from the alleged victim. If the household is coming together, we will refer the alleged abuser to the single adult side while we place the remaining household. If this is an instance of DV that is apparent but it is not within household members, we are making sure that we follow NOVA's recommendations for areas of exclusion, and those tend to be specific addresses or zip codes. Good, thank you.
And when DHS diverts families with children away from shelter at the PATH intake center, what do diversion and mediation services entail?
Thank you for the question. We have policies that really help to standardize the approach, but again each engagement with each individual household is going to be different depending on their circumstances. But in terms of diversion and mediation, the goal is to avoid shelter. Somebody came to us and said, "I have a housing crisis, I think I need shelter." Our goal is to see how, if at all, we can reconnect you to community resources. So at our resource room we have social workers that can complete mediation with a primary tenant or a different housing option, and that might be as simple as calling up the primary tenant to say, "Hey, I understand Christine was living with you and things were not okay — can we make this work? What could help resolve this situation?" So that is the mediation process that happens at PATH's resource room. And again, we are also making sure that that option is safe. We ask very pointed questions about domestic violence in the housing option that we are on the phone with, or any unsafe situation. We are also looking to make sure that there is sufficient space in that housing option. So those are the ways we make sure that we are diverting to safe options.
Thank you. Large congregate shelters create an environment where there is likely to be more interpersonal conflict. What steps is DHS taking to reduce density at shelter sites?
Thank you for that question. First, we are on track to comply with Mayor Adams' executive order which requires that single adult capacity remain at 200 beds or less by the end of 2027. So we are pleased about that. Our purpose-built shelters — which I think are certainly the way we are trying to move the system — there are 32 of those, 25 have been opened in the last four years. They all have smaller dorms, and they are smaller capacity in general. The average over those sites is about 160. Importantly, it is not just the overall size of the building and the number of people there, it is also the density of the dorm space, so that people are more comfortable where they are staying. And we often hear...
...about the poor condition of shelter facilities. The Bellevue Men's Shelter was closed in April 2026 due to severe disrepair and unsafe building conditions. How does DHS decide which shelters to repair, or in the case of Bellevue, which to close entirely?
Thank you for the question. In reference to Bellevue, I will answer this question as the Commissioner pointed out. There are really two approaches to this. One is for publicly owned, City or State owned facilities and the other are privately owned. So when it comes to publicly owned shelters, obviously the last resort is to close a facility and we would only do that on the advice of our enforcement agencies like Department of Buildings or FDNY. This requires architect and engineering reports. It is a very big decision to make. But what we do day to day is maintain our buildings. We have a long term interest in keeping our buildings and the way we are assessing is how much money are we spending on repairs over time. What are the results of a building inspection? What notifications, complaints and incidents are happening in particular? Again, the goal is not to close but to remediate. That is really how, for the capital side, the publicly owned buildings, we try to maintain and repair rather than close.
Thank you. And then I know, Commissioner, you referenced the capital program and specific projects as well as funding. I am wondering if there are shelters that need significant repairs, and how many, and how long will the repairs take?
Thank you for the question. As the Commissioner mentioned, we do have quite a few capital projects for our 55 publicly owned buildings. When it comes to privately owned buildings, that is not something that we readily track. So we cannot answer for the remainder of the over 500 buildings in the portfolio how many need significant repairs. So there is no process that exists where you all are aware of significant capital needs in privately owned shelters?
There are processes, and one thing we can point to — it is not a perfect...
...answer to the question, but one proxy is our new needs process. As the Commissioner mentioned, when a privately owned building needs significant repairs that cannot be funded through their budget, we understand what the scope is and we make a request. That is the new needs process. We currently have 268 new needs pending in various statuses for 95 shelters.
That will include things that are likely not serious.
But it does give us some sense of the scope.
So that is just broad new needs, not facility related new needs, right? But that could...
...be doors to shower stalls or something like that, as opposed to roof repairs?
There is no way to parse that out.
We would have to do that. Our data system — we are working on some enhancements to better allow us to analyze the data rather than having to read every single request. But routine repairs like replacing a shower door normally come out of the provider's budget. Every provider — that would not be considered a new need.
In this particular case, just again, as a proxy for serious... right, a new need is a proxy...
...for serious, you are saying, most of the time?
Yes, but serious as...
...determined by the owner of the building, the private... now the provider. So the provider — this is coming from our contracted providers that say, listen, I am maxed out in my maintenance line, or my maintenance budget does not allow for this major repair. We agree, we look at the scope, we look at the bids, and we request the funding.
OK, thank you. And what is DHS's process for choosing capital projects to fund?
Thank you for the question. Again, all of the 55 publicly owned buildings are eligible for capital, so we are not choosing — we are kind of ranking where the need is and where the project is in terms of the multi-year process that, unfortunately, capital projects have to go through. There are many steps involving different agencies. So again, we identify through our — the Commissioner mentioned our AIM system, our asset management system. We are looking at violations, we are looking at various formal and informal inspections, complaints and incidents to identify the priority repairs that are needed, and those go to the top of the list of capital request projects.
And how does DHS work with providers on shelter repairs for City owned facilities?
That is the capital process. So in addition, you know, DHS operates only a handful of sites even though we have 55 publicly owned. The providers are contracted to operate most of those, and what I just described is the same process.
Whether a provider is operating it or DHS directly. OK. And what design and architectural principles does DHS use when designing shelters? Does this differ for different shelter populations? Thank you for the question, and it is an interesting one. DHS does not have design principles. I think what we rely on is the provider and...
...their vision for what services they want to provide the population they want to serve. So when they bring a site to us, or the plan for a site, they are already thinking about what population do I want to serve and how do I want to serve them. There are discussions with architects and developers to kind of propose to us their ideal shelter.
So what about the purpose built shelters? You would not — that is exactly it. OK. The most recent shelter repair scorecards showed an average of 3.82 building violations per standard shelter and 37.56 violations per flexible capacity shelter. You mentioned, I think earlier, that the flexible shelter conditions are challenging. Why is the number of violations in flexible shelters so high, and is DSS taking action to correct the issue?
As I read my testimony aloud I was reflecting on what I have learned since preparing the testimony, and so it is a good opportunity to correct the record a little bit on that. I am going to let the Deputy Commissioner go into more detail. But it is clear there is a differentiation between the mostly commercial hotels and the level of violation, and our purpose built and other shelters that have very low violations. It is also a function of the way hotels were built and applying a residential code onto those non-residential buildings. I do not want to give anyone here the impression that it is actually that much worse — there is a technicality to that — nor that we cannot fix it. I think the data in this case requires some nuance, and I would love to pass it to the Deputy Commissioner to provide that.
Thank you, Commissioner. I think distinguishing between flexible capacity or standard capacity — regardless of the type of capacity — it is sure that those locations are safe for all the clients we serve. To the Commissioner's point about the hotels having different types of code versus the HPD inspection: the inspections that are done for our shelters follow a residential code. The same does not apply at hotels. We are applying a residential code to a hotel that does not follow the same code. However, we are still responsible for making sure that those issues are resolved and that the locations are safe. Also, on violations — as we dig in, not every violation is an active safety hazard. The hazard could have been remediated but there may still be an administrative function where the building owner has not submitted the required paperwork to close that out on the website. That is something else that we track as well.
Thank you all for the answers. I am going to take a page out of your book — you always thank us for the questions, I am going to thank you for the answers. As temperatures continue to rise, the ability to stay cool becomes more of a health issue. Local Law 2025 requires DHS to report on the availability of air conditioners in shelters. Can you speak about what you found in terms of the feasibility of providing air conditioners in shelters, and what percentage of shelters already have air conditioners?
We are preparing the report that is due in a few days, so we are not ready to discuss it yet. OK, thank you for that.
According to NYPD precinct level homeless shelter arrest data, Q4 of fiscal year 2025, there were a total of 512 arrests. There were 405 arrests in Q3. What do you attribute the increase in arrests in Q4 of FY25?
We will stop thanking for the questions — it is just a habit now. The issue of trying to align and integrate the important data that comes from other reporting sources like the NYPD is something that is very important to me. I have spent the last couple of weeks really trying to integrate the arrest data, the complaint data, the 911 data, along with our incident reporting data and our complaint data into one set of information that we can then use on a very regular basis to manage the system. We are close to having that data integrated and usable, but not quite there. I am relying on the data that is publicly available, and this is from a quarterly reporting that the NYPD was producing and actually stopped after 2025. I believe it is actually no longer required.
I just want to assure you it is of utmost interest to me to be able to observe and take action on areas where we are seeing improvements and we can model those improvements in other places, as well as places where we are seeing concerns. There are questions about the quality of the data that NYPD was reporting. For the quarters that you asked about — Q3 of 2025 and Q4 of 2025 — we do see something similar in our data. We do see an increase in reported incidents during that period, so these two things might be consistent. I reported on some of those observations in the data that we have. While I do not have an explanation, it is something we should work with NYPD to look at. I will say arrest is probably not the best measure of incidents — it is more of a measure of police activity — and I think in combination with those other sets of measures it can help us understand a picture, but alone it does not tell us all that much about what is happening in our system.
OK, that is fair. Thank you for the answer. I want to ask a few questions about the Tillery Street women's shelter, which is in my district. Recent reporting from Gothamist brought public attention to that shelter, where there were at least 260 fights and disputes in 2024, which was a 72% increase from 2019. The report found that the number of priority one serious incidents is more than twice the citywide average for single adult shelters. Do you believe that shelter safety conditions have changed since Bowery Residents Committee took over from the Institute for Community Living as the shelter operator earlier this year?
The rate of incidents has decreased 48% since, against calendar year 2025, in priority one incidents alone — 45% overall. And I think... sorry, 41...
...percent overall? A 45%...
...overall. Sorry, 45%. And...
Actually, if I can add in there — I want to make sure what the NYPD data shows is correct. I do have 911 complaint data to report as well as arrests to add to what the Deputy Commissioner provided. Yes, please. And as you know, 911 is not just crime — it is medical and so on. So 911 calls are down 13%...
...from 2025. The numbers in 2026 were 1,248 and in FY25 there were 429 — so this is the lowest 911 call set since 2022. Still staying with 911: assault and violence calls are down 41% from their peak in 2024. About a third of the calls are ambulance calls.
And then if you would like to hear the complaint reports — these are incident complaint data, so primary incident data. OK, great, continue.
207 in 2026 — that is again the lowest since FY2022. Felony reports fell from 36 in 2022 to 21 in 2026. Sorry, the 207 in 2026 and 324 — which types of calls were those? Those were complaint calls. I think of them as incident reports. I think they call them... yes, the lowest in five years.
Felony arrests fell from 33 to 12. What do you attribute the drop in all of these numbers?
I think a new agency brings the opportunity for a new perspective. All the clients there were reassessed, which is normal course of business when there is a change in provider. I think in doing that assessment, some clients whose needs were better met elsewhere were transferred. There are also some repairs that the provider is doing to the building to try to improve the facilities. So I think we have seen some improvements with the provider change that have likely contributed to...
...the reduction. And would you say that those are site configuration and daily operations changes? The daily operations for sure. The site configuration is harder — the building is a limited...
...yeah, so I would have to look into what, if any, building changes were made.
OK, fair. Thank you for that. And have you all visited that site and met with residents and the staff at BRC? Commissioner? No, I have not either. OK, I welcome you to visit. I have been there since the new operator has been there. I was also there a few times before. So happy to schedule some time to do that. Thank you for the invitation. I have a few more questions about this specifically and then I am going to go into round two for my colleagues. What site level metrics does the agency track to understand shelter safety?
Thank you for the question. At site level we track incidents, we track complaints, we track grievances. I do think as we get this data in order you could see, with Tillery, that we could provide a whole set of measures that are all going in the same direction, and that gives at least me confidence that there are important improvements happening there. Hopefully we can add additional measures to that, including again client experience and regular feedback from clients on their experience in the system. And do you know how many staff are on site at Tillery now compared to last year? Thank you for the question. I do not. OK, thank you for the answer. Robert...
You kind of got to this but I am just going to state the question for the record, and then if you have anything to add feel free, and if not we can move on. In the Committee's June 2026 hearing, Commissioner Dalton, you said that Tillery shelter presented an opportunity to shape longer term plans for the shelter system. What has been done since to act on that opportunity and to refresh the site under the new operator? Nothing to add. Thank you. OK.
Thank you. I would like to share an email that I received, and I am going to do my best to redact lots of the information — there were some specifics that were provided in an attempt to protect this person's identity. They are a New York City employee who has elevated several security concerns with a single shelter provider, including one matter that they believed warranted referral to DOI, after they identified discrepancies between what was reported to DHS and what they were able to observe through records.
Security personnel had recommended that the provider not renew with the same security contractor due to ongoing concerns, and though that recommendation was known to staff, the contractor was still retained. So I am wondering, broadly speaking, what type of oversight structure and safeguards exist to prevent conflicts of interest, preferential treatment or inappropriate relationships with contracted providers? This occurred in the last mayoral administration, and I just want to make sure we have some real transparency around processes that you all have in place to identify inappropriate instances like this. Thank you. These are allegations. If I heard you correctly, there were discrepancies in the...
...records and things reported to DHS, as well as concerns about the security contractor, correct, that were raised to DHS?
When we are made aware — either directly through an incident, through a complaint, through an anonymous source — of any impropriety, we investigate. We will do some due diligence within DHS before making sure that we get that right, over to legal, to the Office of Regulatory Compliance, to our ECHO, to do the legal and contractual steps that they do.
Which could also result in a referral to DOI, right? OK. I cannot say with certainty, but it is possible that this has already been referred to DOI. But I suppose you and I will both find out in due time.
Yeah, and we certainly welcome working with DOI as a resource to take things to a further place. I do not want to belabor the point, but is it worth an explanation of the ways in which our providers contract with subcontractors and our role in that? Yeah, I think that now would be an appropriate time. Specific to security, or food vendors, or maintenance contracts — our nonprofits have the ability to decide to contract that work out. They do their market research, they get bids from interested vendors and go with the lowest bidder who is able to be responsive to the ask. The provider is responsible for managing that...
...contract. ECHO approves the subcontract, but the provider is ultimately responsible for implementing and making sure that the contractor is meeting the requirements of the subcontract.
OK. And does DHS have the authority to terminate a contract at any point in time? Yes. Just to clarify — I am sorry, now I am asking questions myself — but we have authority to terminate contracts with our primary contractor, but not necessarily with a subcontractor. That is correct. Yes.
OK, so the relationship is between the provider and the subcontractor. We can recommend...
You could recommend, and then if they choose not to terminate based on your recommendation, what is the next opportunity for you all to then engage? Or is there no opportunity for you to engage at all with a subcontractor? Because I would assume that once that subcontract reaches the end of its term, then perhaps you all could insert yourselves and say we do not want to... OK, we are checking on that.
Right, with that I will take a quick, brief pause. I am going to stick to the two minutes for my second round of questions here from colleagues, but starting with CM Brewer and then Avilés.
For the record, I strongly prefer the five minute clock to two minutes.
And that is why it is my hearing. I have got two minutes. Your preference, CM, duly noted. You testified earlier, you acknowledged that at-capacity shelters, which are mostly commercial hotels, average approximately 40 open violations per facility. 40. I mean, if a private landlord had 42 outstanding building violations, would the City consider that an acceptable place to house vulnerable New Yorkers?
Yes, thank you. It is a good opportunity to provide clarification. I am not a hundred percent sure if you were in the room just a few minutes ago when we went through this a little bit, as I
indicated as I read my testimony aloud. I learned some things in this process of preparing the testimony about how hotels are different, and applying a kind of residential standard to a hotel necessarily increases the number of violations. So it is not an indication necessarily of a... it is a data point that actually does require a bit more nuance. Regardless, it is our responsibility and we have the tools to make improvements in those systems.
Also, that data does not indicate — it indicates an issue, it does not indicate which of those have been resolved. So on its face I would say that, looking at it the way you did, I would say yes, this is a huge problem, we must do something about it. I think we are going to go back with this understanding and understand a little bit more about what is going on there and certainly take additional action if needed to remedy those facilities.
And when the City decides to continue paying for a facility with dozens of outstanding violations, who signs off on that decision? I mean, ultimately I am responsible for the system and happy to be responsible for that system. There is probably a more technical answer to exactly when we actually do that, but as I said, with more visibility — which I am glad to have had the opportunity to take a look at — that information, we are going to go in and make sure that they are meeting our standards.
One final question, if I may. And no doubt that you prefer the two minute timer to the five minute timer as well. But you said violence inside shelters has been declining, which is great, very encouraging, and I want to give credit when the numbers show improvement. There is another question that is important to the people I represent. When you evaluate shelter safety, do you measure only what happens inside the building, or do you also measure what happens in the surrounding community and the surrounding blocks?
Yes, thank you. Again, I am not a hundred percent sure who was in the room at various points, but I mentioned earlier that I spent a good deal of time in preparing for this testimony, along with our incident reporting system, looking at complaint data — not just to look at what was happening inside the shelter system but to look at the surrounding area, particularly as we open new shelters. And I am very anxious to do this no matter what it says. It is important to know. As soon as we can get that data fully aligned so that we are certain it is accurate, we will do that analysis. I had done it, but we just have some concerns about the way it has been integrated and I cannot be confident in the results. But you will get a report when we can.
Yes, it is a really important analysis and it has to be done with care.
And others should check our work so that you can see it being independent as well. Thanks very much. Thank you, CM Brewer.
Thank you. Two quick questions. I know there are bills in the past that say you have to cover mental and physical health in the shelter. So my question on the mental health was: is that something that you are finding is increasing, and what metrics are you using and how are you treating it? That is a big issue, I think, elsewhere.
And then secondly, just back to my school situation — when you have a family that has school-age children, like we heard earlier about how many... there is a caseworker on housing, so how many people are helping with school transfers from the shelters? I am a big fan of the fact that they have that, but not everybody has a school person. So how long does it take to get that family into school? Are you dealing with bus situations, et cetera? Because that is where there are so many problems along the way for these families. So the mental health, and then just how do you get them into school and the timing — thank you for the
questions. So when it comes to mental health, we are assessing folks that come in at a particular point in time, and we know that those living with mental illness present differently depending on the circumstances, especially if these are high stress situations. So we can get back to you on whether or not the number of people we serve are experiencing mental health issues, but again that would be a point in time, likely at assessment for single adults when they come in. We continue to revisit our program models to make sure that we are staffing shelters to meet the needs of those residents that are there, and where we do not have a program model that does that, shelters have a network of community-based organizations to refer folks out to to get the services that they
need. Okay. I mean, I am familiar with the fact that families seem to have more support, but individuals are pretty much on their own. I just do not see enough mental illness support in the shelters. Are you paying more attention to that? Yes, it is certainly there.
It is a particular area of interest for me for sure, and we are looking at different models to ensure that people in our shelter system... and certainly there are single adults in the system who do not have significant behavioral health needs, absolutely, but there is a group, and this is something we are looking at addressing. It is just hard on the ones who are doing really well to be in the same space as the ones who are not. We are looking at improvements as we work on the homelessness plan. We think there are certainly models of care that can get behavioral health care for anyone who needs it into the system, and not just behavioral health care but also, you know, looking at kids with asthma, making sure that they are getting their regular medical needs met. So I think there is a lot more we can do in integrating these two systems of care so that people are in fact getting the care, the medication management and the support that they need.
And I was just actually looking for the number. It is also something that we are working actively with our partners in the school system on, cleaning up data to make sure we actually know the transport routes. I was looking for the number of people who are currently assigned as case managers on school issues, and we are looking at that with the school system. There is not one for every shelter, but some of those folks cover multiple shelters. We are looking at the ways we can use those resources better — our own staff doing more door-knocking where kids are missing school, and ensuring that the transportation data is correct so we know where kids and families are supposed to be going, as well as addressing those needs faster. So operationally we are very much on this, and I agree it is
a critically important issue. I mean, just with the buses — you have got to call Kevin Moran, because everybody else, forget it. I have been on with him all day. He is in charge of buses. So your caseworker better have his cell number. Thank you. Call Kevin Moran. I will leave it right there. Thank you, Counselor.
Avilés. Thank you. Just along the lines of employee conditions and whistleblowing, can you tell us how whistleblower policies are communicated to staff and also subcontractors? And then if you have any data on how many complaints you have had?
I think it is a really important issue and I think we have gotten guidance on the last set of questions that surrounds this, so I might let the Deputy Commissioner add to that. I do not have that information with me. If we are not doing it well, I will make sure that we are. I do very much want the people who are on the front lines of our systems to both feel like they
can and are able to best support the people that they are trying to serve in New York, and have protections in order to make that happen. So I am certain that those exist, but let me get back to you on what exists, how we are communicating it and the numbers of people reporting.
And also I would love to know how shelter residents — obviously we know there is an ombudsman, but how they receive that and how they are protected against retaliation potentially from staff. I will say I am concerned that, while I understand it theoretically that the subcontractors obviously should report back up to their main provider, if there is no way... I would be curious: number one, how many complaints have you received from subcontractors? Do we have a list? Are we seeing providers use them more? And how are we closing that loop?
Because there is a potential for real problems there.
Thank you for the question. We do not have data on complaints from subcontractors or about subcontractors specifically carved out in the data, but we can certainly look into that because I think you are raising an important point. When it comes to retaliation, obviously we are trying to create a safe and welcoming environment where staff and clients both feel that they can be safe. So if we are to hear about an instance of retaliation, obviously we are going to investigate. We want to understand what the provider knows, what they have done about this and who the bad actor is, and if the findings warrant it, that can lead to termination. So we are looking into every aspect of the provider's handling of the particular issue, as well as whether there is something underlying this.
Right — was the bad actor permitted by lax protocols to be able to do this? So we are looking to make sure that supervision is right, that security is right. It is a whole assessment of what is going on in the shelter, and could also roll up at the provider level, as they might have multiple shelters and we might want to take a look if it is spread.
Yeah, and I guess I would be interested certainly to see what the kind of assessment is, certainly across providers, and the communication of the policy to staff and to subcontractors as well. And I guess I would just love to underscore the importance of — I think you mentioned earlier that you do not track the language accessibility of providers, although I would imagine that they understand the population that they are requesting to service. However, I have seen a good number of providers who have no language competency at all, and so I would love to see a deeper requirement rather than a suggestion or an expectation that they follow it, with no way of being able to hold them accountable.
Understood, and we are able to track their use of the language line, but I understand the concern is more about having real people on site that can speak in the language of the client that is in front of them. Great, thank you. And in terms of just going back to how you investigate whistleblower complaints, if you could, for the record?
Thank you for the question. We will have to get back to you on that.
Okay. And in terms of whistleblower protection policies, do they only apply to vendors? And I guess, as I mentioned earlier, shelter residents should be protected against retaliation for filing complaints about the shelter. How are these rights and protections communicated to shelter residents?
Thanks for the question. There is a whole series of documents somebody receives when they come into shelter, and their rights and responsibilities, the grievance process, the ability to be treated fairly and with respect are all codified in those materials. It is also part of what happens during routine case management, during grievance investigations and incidents. So there are multiple ways that it is communicated.
Yeah, it would be really helpful if the agency could provide to the Council offices — let us say we have multiple facilities — a packet that includes what that process and procedure is, a packet that includes what the good neighbor policy is. I remember chasing that down for years on end. Because it is such an important issue of people feeling safe from retaliation when they are making complaints — someone who opened up this session said that at least one person had felt that they had been retaliated upon, or they were concerned about reporting for fear of retaliation. And I have not just heard that today. I do hear that with some frequency.
It is why, in addition to the ways that we are kind of required to have a complaint process and handle it, that direct communication, regular communication through technology, text messaging and so on, can help me and this team understand directly from people what is impacting them, so that we take those into account along with the other data. That is something that is important to me to build.
Out. Yeah, no, and I think certainly Council offices will of course reach out to you directly, but I think as a proactive measure it would be really great to be able to offer your Council representatives a packet of information that they should readily know — both for staff, for residents and for contractors — because the truth is we will get all of them coming to our offices. To help them better navigate the situation, that would be quite helpful. Thank you all.
Right, you are going to get me in trouble with Morano, taking up so much time. He is not here. Chairs...
You get to do what you want. Thank you for your questions. Okay, how does DHS handle conflict between shelter residents and is there a mediation process? Thank you.
There is no formal mediation process for issues, but we look to our providers to handle conflict on site, and that can happen in a few ways. I mentioned Local Law 49 and our customer service training, which is not just about how to provide good service — it is about how to interact with clients and with staff to make sure that everybody feels that they are being treated with respect and that they feel safe. In instances where conflict seems not to be able to be resolved through the efforts of the provider, it is possible that the provider might decide to move the client or the household to another side of the building if they are meeting in the hallway and there are issues there. If things escalate, in consultation with the program staff we might choose to transfer that household to a different shelter. But there are different levels of engagement, and we really look to our providers to implement mediation, a trauma-informed approach to the work that they do every day, and de-escalation and security training. Thank you for that.
Last year there were reports that ICE had entered shelters without judicial warrants, in violation of the City's sanctuary city laws. What sanctuary city policies are staff trained on specifically, and how frequently does that training take place? I know it is one thing to have the policies down in the books somewhere that people read maybe some years ago, but how frequently are you reminding people what
the policies are? Thank you. We have quite a number of trainings that are required across the system and we do have refreshers, both internally and we require the provider to be refreshing with their own staff. I think in addition to the book of policies, saying everybody was trained — in the moment at 2 o'clock in the morning it might all go out the window. So this is also about how we are implementing this in real time.
And sorry, do you track compliance or efficiency in terms of the providers giving the training or refreshing their
training? We track refreshers, yes.
Do you have the numbers?
Not with me now. Okay.
And I would add — and I believe this to be true, but we can confirm — whenever there has been an incident with ICE at any of our shelters, we take that very seriously. Our counsel gets involved, we review what happened in that case, we deal with it as it is happening on the ground. There is a direct number to call to get advice as needed, and then I think we have been pretty good at sharing lessons from each of those individual incidents and communicating them to providers, because things are changing in the ways that this has happened over the period. So I think we have been in really good communication with our provider network about what to do and how to do it, in addition to the more formal trainings. Okay, thank
you for that. DHS's total security budget for fiscal year 2026, as of the fiscal year 2027 adopted plan, is $313 million. How much was actually spent in 2026? We think we have that, we are looking for it — give us one second. And while you are looking for what was spent in fiscal year 2026, I would love to also know the total security budget for fiscal year 2027. We are looking now. We will have to get back to you on both of those numbers, but if we find them during the hearing we will certainly
certainly report back. My computer is dying and I would really like to at some point testify today. I am a shelter resident and I submitted a
written... Okay, we will be getting to the public testimony in just a little bit.
I think we have something that is responsive to your question, Chair Hudson, although I am not a hundred percent sure I remember the question, but I am having an answer. The total security budget for fiscal year 2026 as of the fiscal year 2027 adopted plan was reported as $313 million. So I am wondering, for fiscal year 2026, how much of that $313 million was actually spent?
Our numbers are quite different, so why do not we... why do not you give me the numbers that you have.
The number we have is for peace officers is $18 million, and contracted security is... so that is very different. So it must be counting perhaps across... and we are answering for here. Yes, peace officers, but we are happy to clarify as needed. Yes, that could be an...
...error on my part. Okay, well I would love to know. Do you have the total security budget for fiscal year 2027? Is that where those numbers are? For fiscal year 2026? Those are for FY27. Okay. So I would love to also know the numbers for fiscal year 2026 if and when you have this.
Okay, we do not have those here, but we can give you a bit of a trend.
Okay, and then this number for FY27, how is that amount determined and what are the funding sources?
Valvano Priester, Deputy Commissioner for Shelter Security Management. So these amounts are determined... I cannot truly identify all those financial sources. Most of it is City tax levy, but...
...this is our peace officer lines and our contracted security, along with just the amount of funding that we receive around equipment and our contracts.
Okay, great. Thank you. And what expenditures are included within the security budget? If you have a funding breakdown... so you mentioned equipment...
...contracted security, peace officers. Absolutely. We have body-worn cameras, so our Evidence.com contract, any of our other equipment contracts, and we can provide a breakdown.
Okay, it will be great if you all can follow up. Absolutely, thank you. Okay, we have heard concerns about theft of personal belongings in shelters, seemingly due to a lack of space to lock belongings away. What is your policy for bringing in and securing personal belongings into shelters?
Thank you. As per state regulations, in single adult shelters we are required to provide lockable storage, and the client is given the key or the code. It is for them to use to keep their belongings secured if they choose. We can also store valuables for a client, as long as on site — small articles of jewelry perhaps, or documents, money orders. And what is the...
...area that they are given a key to lock away their own belongings? What type of space are we talking about? In a congregate site it is usually the storage cabinet that separates beds. Okay, okay. And...
...what does DHS do to prevent and address theft in shelters? Again, ensuring that locks are kept secure, that if we see damage, if clients are reporting damage, that we are responsive to that. Deputy Commissioner Priester can also speak to security in the facilities and their role in making sure that clients' belongings are kept secured and to prevent theft. And I...
...do not want to give anybody any ideas, but I am just trying to envision or imagine the size of those lockers — let us call them. Can one lift that up and remove it? That is a very good question.
The ones in all directly run and most of the provided facilities — no. So when my team does security risk assessments, that is one of the biggest things that we look at, to make sure that they are not moveable.
Okay, okay, great. Thank you. But was there anything you wanted to add? I am just...
...going to the point. One of the things that we do when the providers document the complaints — we do take steps to try to locate the belongings, including speaking with staff and looking at surveillance footage, and if it is appropriate, contacting the NYPD.
Okay, thank you. And how does DHS support people who require medical devices, including mobility aids and items that require electricity or batteries, like CPAP machines, personal EKG monitors, oxygen tanks and diabetes monitors? How do you assist people in keeping these items safe and functional?
Yeah, I think in the same way that Deputy Commissioner Priester shared — making sure, first of all, that we are aware of these devices, especially for things that need to be plugged in, that they are in an appropriate outlet, and that if they are not on the person, that we are making sure we are keeping eyes on them and ensuring access control, making sure that people are coming in and out only with their belongings. And...
...what about medications that require refrigeration? Or refrigeration, excuse me.
We provide refrigeration. Clients can — especially in family and adult family shelters — have access to many fridges. Same... we will store for single adults medication that requires refrigeration.
Okay, thank you. I would like to ask a few questions related to Rikers closure and planning for that. As the City moves towards closing Rikers Island...
...what projections has the administration developed regarding the number of individuals who will require transitional housing or shelter placement upon release, and what specific housing capacity is being developed to meet that demand?
I do not know if I can answer that question specifically, but the administration is convening all government partners to think about how we are executing on the close Rikers plan, including looking at efforts to ensure that people who are coming out of Rikers who do not have any other place to stay have more direct access to our shelter system, so that they need not go through intake and assessment after they have been in essentially an intake and assessment facility for some time. That we can do that directly. Looking at the kinds of programming that people need to be successful, whether that be access — as much as we can do — to get people's access to benefits before they exit, anything from that to making sure they have proper behavioral health care, and again, obviously the key component with us is making sure that they can get into the housing system that will work for them.
Speaking my language. That sounds as close to auto-enrollment as one could perhaps get, so I support that. What formal planning process exists between DHS and MOCJ to ensure that people leaving Rikers do not enter the traditional shelter system unnecessarily, and which agency is responsible for leading that work? So I know you just touched on that, but is there a formal... it sounds like the full administration is bringing everybody to the table, but are you all working directly with MOCJ, and who ultimately is responsible? Yeah, for specifics here I may need to get back to you on the work happening on the ground, because I know that is what is important to people. It does not matter if I meet with the commissioner or that we meet at this level — what matters is what happens on the ground. So I will probably have to get back to you with...
...those specifics. But as I said, I think there is good work happening, which is reform work. I do not think in the recent past it was the case that people would not just be released and have to go through our traditional shelter system. I think it is innovation and reform work that is happening to ensure that that handoff is happening and that assessment is done prior to exit from incarceration, so that people get into stable housing quickly and effectively. Thank you for that.
On how many individuals exiting custody enter DHS shelters, and how many are connected to transitional housing programs, and what performance metrics are being used to evaluate whether the City's housing strategy is supporting the successful closure of Rikers — I certainly do not have that right now, but I have a...
...we are, as an administration, looking at that data, and there is a significant overlap between people who are in Rikers today or are leaving Rikers who have previous homelessness experience. So it is a critical connection, and...
...we can probably work with other partners to provide that information. I am sorry about that.
Thank you so much for those answers. Okay, moving into staff and training. Local Law 124 of 2021 requires security guards in shelters to receive an additional 40 hours of training within 120 days of hiring, and an annual eight-hour refresher training, of which at least two hours must be techniques for interactions with individuals experiencing homelessness and individuals in a mental health emergency or crisis. How many security guard positions are there in shelters?
As of the first fiscal year 2026 reporting period, there were 3,540. Okay, thank you. And what is the...
...current vacancy rate for shelter security guards?
That is not something that we track in aggregate. Okay, sorry. However, we...
...as we have kind of discussed, there are the peace officers and we can provide information there, and then there is the provider system that contracts with security. So that is a moving target. I do not think it would be easy for us to ever give you a good number...
...on that figure. Understood. But Deputy Commissioner can report on the peace officers piece. Okay, do you have a vacancy rate for the peace officers specifically? 20%. And how long has it been at...
...20%? This has been a challenge. It constantly fluctuates and we do really good at times and do really...
...bad. Sorry, I pulled the microphone. No, absolutely.
So it has been a challenge for a couple of years. We were at 25% for literally two years or longer, probably a little bit longer. But we are consistently trending downward. So we were recently at 25% and now we are at 20%, and we are doing everything that we can to work with agency partners and workforce development to try to get individuals to come out and be a part of our academy and our team. Okay. And has every security...
...guard working in a DHS shelter received the 40 hours of training and the eight-hour annual refresher as required by the law? 82% of our security guards received the 40-hour training. 82% received the 40-hour training as of September 1, 2026. Okay. I just want to add...
...to that. We do have a peace officer academy and we work to make sure that we are conducting training sessions to try to help with compliance. From October 12 through the 16th, 19th through 23rd, and we do have an upcoming training session from November 9 through 13 to help assist with that compliance. We are in the process of tracking the eight-hour refresher completion...
...so we are in the process of enhancing our report to make sure that we are actually also tracking completion versus non-completion as well. So you do or do not have the current numbers? We will have to cover that. Okay. The numbers for...
...completion is 542. So for the eight-hour annual refresher it is 542. Yes.
Peace officers have completed that — and that is peace officer security personnel? Yes. Okay. Hold on, 500 and...
...542 out of the 3,542. That is...
...sorry, are these different numbers? Give me all the numbers. So 3,542...
...have completed the eight-hour refresher out of how many total people? But that is what we do not have. Okay.
...not tracked. And we know we constantly have a high turnover rate of security personnel. Moving forward we will enhance this report to make sure that we are tracking both. Okay, understood. And thank you for that. Can I get a...
...rough estimate? I... we believe we would not want to give that information because I would not want the compliance to look really bad when that may not be true.
Honestly, okay. All right. So 542 security personnel have completed the eight-hour refresher.
And 2,916 — 82% — have completed the 40-hour. 2,916, which is the equivalent of 82%, have completed the 40 hours.
And it is the same population of security professionals that we are talking about? Yes. So if...
...the difference is that a lot of these individuals are new. Okay. But the eight-hour refresher is only required after they complete one year. Okay, so that is the issue. Yeah, I...
...got you. I am following along. What I am trying to do is work backwards with the math, and you are telling me not to do that. I am telling you not to do that. We will make sure that you have it moving forward.
Okay. Can I just say what I was thinking? Yes. Because if the 2,916 number is equivalent to 82% of the total workforce that would be required to do that training, then I would have to do the math to figure out what 100% would be to get a rough estimate of the total number of people. Do you see what I am saying? I see where you are going.
Okay, but you are saying that is not an accurate number...
...for the eight-hour, because the eight-hour was only required after the first year. I get that. But to get a total number I can still do my... yeah, we did. That total number is 3,542.
Oh, okay.
Guys, okay. I thought that was a different number. Okay, all right. Thank you. I am glad I asked. All right, thank you for...
...the clarity. Okay. So do the staff who perform security functions and conflict resolution but who are not licensed security guards receive this training? Yes. Okay. And organizations have brought to our attention that positions such as residential aides and community technicians have such roles — is that accurate? Yes. Okay. All right, I...
...think we got somewhere...
...with that. Thank you. In 2024, New York State FOCUS released a report about misconduct among peace officers in shelters and cited disciplinary incidents involving 31 officers. Some of these incidents included the use of excessive physical force against shelter residents. How many shelters have peace officers? You mentioned earlier that DHS has 352 peace officers — right? Well, I think the commissioner did in her testimony, not you specifically, but...
...352 peace officers. So how many shelters have peace officers? 18 shelters. 18. Thank you.
And how many peace officers are assigned to a shelter and how is that determination made?
So staffing ranges from 10 to 26. Can you just pull the microphone closer? Sorry.
Thank you.
Staffing ranges from 10 to 26 peace officers in shelters that have peace officers. We determine those assignments based on the support each site's daily...
...operational needs and security risks. Okay, thank you. And...
...this may be a little redundant so forgive me if it is, but what training do peace officers who work in shelters receive, and is this different than the training given to security guards? So DHS peace officers go through our DHS training academy, with training programs that have also been evaluated and recognized by the National College Credit Recommendation Service, with our peace officer training recommended for 10 college credits, reflecting the depth and rigor of the curriculum, which is different than the training given to security guards. Training begins with our peace officer instruction and continues throughout an officer's career through in-service training and use certification requirements. The curriculum covers law enforcement procedures, appropriate use of force, defensive tactics, crisis intervention, de-escalation, conflict resolution and emergency response. Beyond the technical aspects of law enforcement, we place significant emphasis on communication, sound judgment and understanding the unique needs of the individuals we serve. We also continuously review and expand our training curriculum to reflect the evolving needs of our shelter populations, reinforce professional standards and strengthen how officers respond to challenging situations. Our expectation is that every officer understands not only the authority they have, but the responsibility that comes with exercising that authority appropriately, professionally and with respect for the people we serve.
Thank you for that answer. What is DHS's process for reviewing and dealing with complaints against peace officers in shelters?
All complaints for the peace officers are routed to our Legal and Special Investigation Division for appropriate review and action. Thank you for that.
We understand that there are often many staff vacancies at shelters and turnover rates are high. What is the current staff-to-resident ratio in shelters? Sure. Based on the...
...model budgets that I have mentioned before, where each shelter type has their own model budget, we adjusted to a certain capacity level — 100. So I can read off by program type what we would expect for a shelter with a capacity of 200.
That would be great.
For single adults, 43 staff. For single adults with behavioral health services, 46 staff. For single adult employment, 43 staff. At our single adult assessment sites, 51 staff. For our adult family shelters, 60 staff. And for our families with children shelters, 37 staff. Okay, thank you so much for that. And if I could clarify, that is just budgeted lines. There are some contracted staff that would not be accounted for in these...
...lines. Okay, but I would presume then that that would make it even better...
...ratio. It would. Okay. What is the ideal staff-to-resident ratio? Is it what you listed? I think it depends on the program and it depends on the needs of the clients, and it is something we are continually assessing. So as I say, these numbers change.
The numbers change, and again the model budget is the model. There are times where when the provider demonstrates the need for increased staff, we can go and request an increase. And the numbers you gave me are based on the model budget? Yes. Okay, thank you.
And Chair, if I could clarify the earlier question about subcontracts and if DHS has the ability to cancel — I am corrected, we do and we have exercised that right in the past. Okay, great. Good to know.
You just mentioned this, Deputy Commissioner, but what is DHS doing to fill vacancies and help staff stay in their roles? You do not have to go into the filled vacancies because I know you are working on filling the vacancies, but what are you doing to help keep people on the job?
Yes, we have a whole retention process that we are working on with our officers.
What is that? One of those...
One of the processes is really looking at succession planning and trying to see how officers would like to make that and complete their career, and what career advancement looks like. Some of this is a little bit of the things that we do do is make sure that we are celebrating our officers, that we are making sure that we are recognizing everybody's birthday. One of the other things that we are doing is we have instituted a men's conference and a women's conference where we are working with the officers to kind of understand and hear ideas around how we can work to make things better for them.
That sounds good. I think I am echoing the commissioner's sentiments to say that I do not think any of those things are arbitrary. I think those are very intentional ways to maintain or increase retention. Other sort of affinity groups, yes, beyond such gendered roles?
So yes, absolutely. We are saying men's conference and women's conference as a whole, but we always look into just kind of making sure that we are recognizing our officers and the hard work that they do on a daily basis. One of the other things that we are doing is we do make sure that when people do leave, we interview and try to understand what that is, and being meaningful and planful around trying to change the narrative.
One of the other things that has happened in the past is officers were not allowed to transfer immediately after coming into our academy, and we have been really intentional around making sure that we place officers at their preferred transfer sites. For sites that they are just in, they knew they were going to get whatever schedule, because it becomes like a seniority thing. Absolutely, so we still practice seniority, we absolutely have to. But what we do is, as officers come out of the academy, we recognize that anybody that scored the highest, we place them at the site that they want to be in, and then in rank order we start placing them in order of preference.
OK, that is great, and then...
How do these salaries compare to security officers at other agencies?
The salaries for our peace officers are extremely low. Some competing agencies actually exceed what our peace officers actually receive, and that is the predominant reason why we are losing officers.
Right, yeah. It is...
It is a challenge that we are working through with our partners. In many ways these are viewed as a similar job. When working in facilities, our colleagues at ACS have this similar title and have a similar recruitment and retention problem. When you could go and do something which has the same pay, the same uniform, but is a much easier position...
We are sorry, where are those positions? There are other City jobs where security... I mean, I do not know this exactly, but I will give an example of walking into City Hall and who is doing the various roles in a much more administrative or different type of facility than, say, a detention center or a homeless shelter. So we are working with our colleagues, and I was... you invited me to come to Tillery if you get the time. One of the best things that we get to do is attend the graduation of peace officers, and it is not just the peace officers, it is the case workers and others, and it is tremendous to watch this group of people who have come together over an academy and how proud they are to be in those positions. It is great to watch. So if you want a good afternoon or morning, whenever we have it, it is a good...
Day. I am happy to come and would be delighted. I bring this up, and I did the same thing when I chaired the Committee on Aging, in that I find for populations that we generally do not value, like...
People in the shelter system, like people who are older adults, people who are aging, the positions that we have there is a lack of equity. The roles, whether it is a social worker in the Department for the Aging or a peace officer here, you can have a similar title. Usually it is more pay and less grueling work at a different City agency, and I just do not think that is right. I think if you are doing the same work, no matter which, especially if you are employed by the City, we should be paying everybody doing the same work the same thing. So I just wanted to make sure that I could get that on the record. I do not think it is a good practice and I think it is something that we absolutely need to overhaul. And so with that...
Which of your colleagues are you working with to address that point specifically?
I mean, there are just structural issues in the way the positions are set up. But it is also, some of it is state civil service, and so position reclassifications have to be brought up through the state system as well.
But absolutely, the Mayor and the Governor have a great relationship, so perhaps this is something that is important. It is, and I say that only partially in jest, but I mean seriously, that is how these things get resolved. Yeah, thank you.
Okay, thank you, and I will mention it to both of them. Okay. Large congregate shelters create an increased risk for the spread of infectious disease, especially during cold and flu season. What measures does DHS take to help prevent the spread of illness?
Thank you. Prevention is key. So we work with our providers to make sure that through routine engagement with the clients that they are serving, there are reminders about getting vaccinations, going to the doctor, staying healthy, dressing appropriately. If we see somebody leaving the facility without a winter coat in the winter, we make sure that people do not contract a contagious illness. If they were to, we do have single occupancy isolation rooms to keep that from spreading.
Thank you so much for that. And then Local Law 35 of 2023 requires DHS to have a mental health professional available in shelters for families with children. Can you speak about the implementation of this law?
We have 113 of 143 sites. 79% of the targeted sites have one or more mental health professional on site, and their job is to assess families' needs using a biopsychosocial assessment and other behavioral health screening tools, making sure that we are aware of the needs of the family and making appropriate referrals. These staff are also engaged in crisis prevention and de-escalation, and collaborate with case managers to make sure that families are getting their needs met, that they are healthy, that they are safe. They might also accompany staff to do unit inspections, and work with case managers if the family has involvement...
Thank you for that. Hold on one second. We understand that DHS uses telehealth in many shelters to comply with Local Law 35. Are shelter residents utilizing telehealth options?
We will have to get back to you on the numbers, though I believe they are in the MMR. Give me one moment. OK, we will have to get back to you on that. OK.
And the language of Local Law 35 subjects the requirement of having mental health professionals available in shelters for families with children to appropriations. However, we have been told by some providers that DHS has told shelters they must provide mental health services without increasing their budget. Have shelter budgets been adjusted to account for the cost of mental health care, or have...
Thank you. It depends on the provider's budget and the budget for the shelter, and this gets to the ability we have to request changes to the budget when the needs arise. Okay, thank you for that. What training does DHS provide to staff to identify clients with serious mental illness and make single point of access referrals for mental health services? We collaborate with the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene to provide quarterly training for all shelter staff on the SPOA process. This is mandatory for all of our social service directors across the system, and we test with a score to make sure that the staff who take the training know what the next steps are once the training is done. Thank you.
How do community or PACT teams work with staff, and can you describe the partnership?
Sure. On our side, our leadership meets regularly with OMH and DOHMH to participate in care coordination and meetings around ACT teams and PACT teams, to make sure that we are effectively coordinating service delivery at the shelter level. We expect staff to proactively coordinate with SPOA providers, as they are the ones submitting the SPOA application, so we want to make sure that they are doing those applications timely, that they are helping clients to follow up and to engage in the services. They should also be allowing the SPOA providers to come on site to meet with clients, to advertise the services, to really be able to advocate for the benefits clients could receive from participating. So I think both at the DHS and the provider level we are trying to coordinate more closely to make sure clients are getting the services they are entitled to.
Thank you. We talked about the decreasing, for most populations, overdose deaths. Overdose deaths in shelters have declined since the launch of the overdose response and harm reduction program. How is DHS working to continue to prevent overdose deaths? Thank you. I think first and foremost it is making sure that all clients are referred for and receiving the treatment they need for their substance use issues. In addition, in terms of just operationally, we make sure that shelter staff are trained in harm reduction and overdose response, that staff have naloxone kits on site to be responsive to any overdoses or apparent overdoses. We pay close attention where we see increases or differences in terms of overdose incidents or complaints about overdoses. We also require at each shelter an overdose prevention champion who is responsible for training staff and just keeping the message out there in all day-to-day interactions about overdose prevention.
Okay, thank you. Going into complaints and grievances, how many... and sorry, because you said that you track complaints and grievances?
And incidents. So how many complaints, grievances and incidents did DHS receive in the previous fiscal year? I do not have grievances. That is something we track. Those go through the provider. OK, so we would have to aggregate and share that. OK. For complaints that have come in, I have 31,620 for fiscal year 26.
Who are you going to provide another fiscal year, or is that it? Give me a moment.
We do have these. I have complaints for prior years as well. For calendar year 25... calendar or fiscal? Calendar year 25. And 31,620 for fiscal year 26. Correct, yes. But we can give you a calendar year. Okay, please. Calendar year 26 is 31,051. And we did actually find a longer trend in our notes if you would like it.
It looks like there is, yes. But that is just two years. Obviously we will take that. OK. What was that? You said you will take that. OK.
I will give it to you, that is fine. That was complaints. Do you have incidents? Yes. That is the data I wanted. I wanted to give the numbers. Yes. I will start. You want to go ahead? All right.
I think the deputy commissioner is looking for the actual numbers. I do think rates are important here, just given how much the shelter system has grown. So I was going to provide rates if that is all right.
Rates of incidents. Actually, what I have here is the rates for serious incidents.
That is fine, we will take that. OK.
And we will see what else we can find. So, you are saying that this is...
As populations have been increasing.
So it is a number of incidents per person. Okay, yeah. Per thousand residents. And I will start with fiscal year 22. These are fiscal years. And you are actually starting with fiscal year 22? I am, I am just trying to...
I do have it broken down for adults, and then adult families, and families with children. Or adult families, or what is the category? Yeah, I have all three. Okay, hold on. Adults, adult families and families with children. Okay.
All right.
Okay, starting with single adults, and this is fiscal year 22. I am about how...
I am tempted to give you a choice of what you prefer, but I was just going to read the numbers. 54.7. Sorry, we are going adults, adult families, families with children? Yeah. Okay, hit me. 54.7 for fiscal year 22.
41.0 for fiscal year 23. 32.7 for fiscal year 24. Wait, I am sorry. Yep. This is all adults? Yes, it is the adult shelter system, per thousand residents. OK. Sorry. So...
I am going to start leaving the decimal off and rounding appropriately for ease. Well, OK. 54.7 for...
Fiscal year 22. 41 for fiscal year 23. 32.7 for fiscal year 24. 30.1 for fiscal year 25. And 28.3 for fiscal year 26.
28.3. OK. So there has been a drastic decline. Yeah. OK. Would you like me to go through the same for adult families? Yes, please. Okay. 21.8...
For fiscal year 23. 12.5 for fiscal year 24. 12.6 for fiscal year 25. And 9.0. So a dramatic reduction, really. Okay. And then families with children, starting with fiscal year 22: 16.0, 10.1, 8.9, 8.3 and 8.0. Again, a significant halving. Okay, yes. Can you...
Disaggregate by complaint type? Well, I guess we did not get into the complaints. Those were the incidents, rates of incidents. Oh, okay. But complaint type...
Numbers? We do not have that. Okay. Okay.
By rate. The commissioner just went through rates for serious incidents. OK. But if it is helpful, we can list some of the most significant types. Yes.
I do not think these are necessarily in order, but they are at the top. So again, these are the serious incidents, not the rest of the majority. Understood. Reported...
Leading to life-threatening injury, accident, arrest notification, heating, water or electrical failure for more than four hours, client drug overdose, fight or dispute, contagious diseases that result in quarantine or isolation of client or staff, and environmental hazard. Okay. Is that everything? Yep.
Thank you so much. What role does the Office of Constituent Services or the SPOA process play, and how many people staff that office?
The Office of Constituent Services — within that office lives the ombudsman's office, and they are responsible for receiving and getting those complaints out to the relevant parties and collecting them. They are also the staff that communicate with the complainant first when the complaint comes in and it is assigned, and to try to close the loop once we get the response from the shelter provider. Currently, 12...
Lines are full and the thirteenth is currently onboarding. Great, thank you for that. That may be one of the best vacancy rates I have heard in a long time. That is like basically almost at zero, soon to be, I suppose. How does the data generated by the ombudsman's office influence shelter management?
There is a strong influence both in what is communicated to the shelter and what program staff do in looking at the data. So the ombudsman's office will identify shelters with concerning patterns. They will reach out to the shelter provider. They will reach out to programs. They will try to understand what is going on. They also will go out and do meetings with clients about recent trends or ways to make sure that they know how to file complaints. They report out to us monthly. This helps us identify areas for intervention. Is it shelter-specific? Is it staff-specific? Is it related to the provider's overall approach? And with the incident analysis we are doing, that will help us get a full picture of issues at the sites and help us strategize interventions to hopefully reduce both complaints and incidents, as there might be an intersection. Thank you for...
That. And I have about five questions remaining before we go to public testimony. I know there are lots of folks who have been waiting patiently, and thank you for your patience. Jumping up — I did not see it, so apologies. Internet Quorum, or IQ, is the web-based application designed to process, monitor, track and resolve complaints initiated by clients through the 311 telephone hotline, walk-in complaints and mayoral or elected official referrals. How many complaints were entered into the system in fiscal year 25, and what category were the complaints?
Whether emergency, danger, urgent, building or other. Thank you. And just realizing in...
Reviewing this, I have fiscal year 26 information, so apologies, not responsive to the question about fiscal year 25. OK, no problem. 31,620. And the categories are bed losses, transfers and reasonable accommodations is one category. Do you want the associated number of complaints? We will just give you the categories. Yes.
Discrimination, assault and harassment, other case specifics, physical rehousing and staff-client interactions. Okay, thank...
You. What is required for a complaint to be deemed resolved?
The shelter director must respond with the appropriate next step. So either they are reporting out that they have done something to resolve, met with the client, followed up with a landlord on a housing package, or what they are to do. I am going to meet with the client and report back about the interaction.
And what is the average number of days from receiving a complaint to its resolution?
Five days. Thank you.
Does DHS review and incorporate data about complaints in provider performance evaluations or RFP proposal scores? No.
Okay, and then I think it was...
The commissioner who said the data you collect — or maybe it was you — definitely, particular apologies, I do not remember who it was specifically. But the data you collect on the placement of families, this is in regards to Int 0099-2026: the data you collect on the placement of families with children is by borough, but boroughs are very large. Would it not be more useful to collect zip code level data as contemplated by this Bill?
I think the Bill does two different things. The Bill changes the geography at which the data is reported, but it also changes the data. I think we would be interested in the course of working with counsel and the sponsor on both pieces of that. But I think having coherence in the actual measure is important to us, so I think we would prefer to keep the measure that is in the Mayor's Management Report. But if a lower level of geography is... I guess that does not work because we are the school district.
That was the last one. You understand what the current MMR... yeah.
At the end of the day, yes, we collect these data and I think I did respond to that. I understand what the Council is trying to do and I understand this better, but just some additional dialog about making sure that we are not running different measures and also reporting at a level of geography and specificity that is helpful to the public. Okay.