Mayor's Office of Ethnic & Community Media and Government Spending on Advertisements
Committee on Governmental Operations, State & Federal Legislation
Meeting overview
The Committee on Governmental Operations, State and Federal Legislation held an oversight hearing on the Mayor's Office of Ethnic and Community Media and government spending on advertisements, alongside consideration of three good-government bills and a preconsidered intro. The hearing was notable for the candor with which Council members, led by Chair Brewer and Speaker Menin, confronted the administration's effective dismantling of a functioning program through neglect, reorganization and inaction.
Speaker Menin set out the trajectory with numbers that tell the story plainly: City advertising spending with ethnic and community media peaked at $23.1 million in 2022 and had collapsed to $7 million by FY2024, even as the percentage figures look superficially respectable because overall ad spending has fallen off a cliff simultaneously. She recounted the Council's own forums with Black, Asian and Latino media outlets, where publishers reported losing contact with City Hall entirely and having no point of access to the administration. Chair Brewer added that outlets are reporting up to a 200% drop in City advertising revenue since Mayor Mamdani took office.
The administration's witness was Massoud Ahmed, newly appointed Executive Director of the Mayor's Office of Ethnic and Community Media, who started the role three weeks before the hearing. He is, by his own account, the only person in the office. He offered a thoughtful vision of Local Law 83 as a nationally pioneering instrument with dual benefits: getting City information to underserved communities and sustaining the civic infrastructure of local journalism. The problem was that he could not answer basic operational questions, including the total advertising budget across City agencies, why the office was unstaffed for eight months, why it was twice reorganized, or what any outlet in any specific borough is currently receiving. His answers to nearly every factual question were a variant of "I cannot speak to what happened before I arrived" or "I will follow up." Council members were increasingly pointed about this, with CM Stevens and CM Dinowitz noting that outlets like the Norwood News have already collapsed, and that waiting until the end of the fiscal year for a report is not a neutral bureaucratic timeline but a death sentence for struggling publishers.
CM Morano raised a genuine structural concern that Ahmed acknowledged but could not resolve: the office is now housed under the Mayor's Director of Communications, creating an inherent tension between sustaining independent journalism and being overseen by the political communications operation of the administration those journalists are meant to scrutinize. He also identified what amounts to a loophole in Local Law 83: the 50% spending requirement applies only to broadcast, print and digital advertising, not to social media or influencer campaigns, meaning an administration could shift spending toward those channels, reduce traditional advertising and still claim technical compliance. Ahmed was unable to confirm or deny this dynamic. CM Restler highlighted a related distortion in reported compliance figures: of $31 million nominally directed toward ethnic and community media in FY2025, $18 million was classified as out of scope, meaning actual qualifying spend was closer to 24% of the total, not the 57% headline figure in the annual report.
The three bills sponsored by CM Williams, Int 1127-2026, Int 1128-2026 and Int 1129-2026, address good-government housekeeping: repealing or amending 25 outdated or duplicative reporting requirements in the Charter and Administrative Code, establishing a uniform default due date for agency reports, and creating a procedure for agencies to attest compliance with operational mandates. Chair Brewer's preconsidered intro would create a working group under DORIS to study agency use of instant messaging technologies, following revelations about a Signal group used by the Mayor with auto-delete enabled. All four bills were heard but not voted on at this session.
The record
- T2026-2608 Hearing on ethnic media office and city ad spending (hearing held)
- Int 1127-2026 Law to streamline city reporting rules to Council (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 1128-2026 Law to set default deadlines for agency reports to Council (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 1129-2026 Law to set rules for agency compliance attestations (heard; awaiting a vote)
- T2026-2722 Law to study how city agencies use messaging apps (heard; awaiting a vote)
Numbers
- In FY2020, the City spent $260 million on advertising across all media outlets.
- Prior to Executive Order 47 and Local Law 83, 82% of City advertising went to large mainstream media outlets.
- Prior to those interventions, ethnic and community media received $2.7 million in City advertising.
- By 2020, the first full year of implementation, ethnic and community media received $9.9 million in City advertising.
- City advertising spending on ethnic and community media peaked in 2022 at $23.1 million.
- In FY2025, 57% of City agencies' overall advertising spending nominally went to ethnic and community media.
- In FY2024, 51% of City advertising nominally went to ethnic and community media.
- In FY2023, 40% of City advertising nominally went to ethnic and community media.
- In FY2024, only $7 million in City advertising actually reached ethnic and community media outlets.
- Of $31 million in advertising nominally directed to ethnic and community media in FY2025, $18 million was classified as out of scope, meaning actual qualifying in-scope spend was approximately 24%, not 57%.
- Council members reported outlets claiming up to a 200% drop in City advertising revenue since Mayor Mamdani took office.
- The citywide marketing directory currently lists 293 ethnic and community media outlets.
- The Mayor's Office of Ethnic and Community Media currently has one member of staff: the newly appointed Executive Director.
- The office was without an Executive Director for approximately eight months before the current appointment.
- Local Law 83 exempts agencies spending less than $5,000 per year on advertising from the 50% requirement.
- Influencer payments under City campaigns reportedly range from $500 to $20,000 per campaign.
- A Columbia Journalism School grant of $1 million was announced in 2016 to support ethnic and community media competitiveness.
- Six media placement vendors currently hold contracts to manage City advertising buys relevant to Local Law 83.
- Int 1127-2026 would repeal or amend 25 provisions of the Charter and Administrative Code requiring agency reports.
- Northwestern University's Local News Initiative found a quarter of ethnic media outlets nationwide shut down since the pandemic.
Action Points
- Ahmed to obtain and provide to the Council committee the total advertising budget across all City agencies as a matter of urgency, without waiting for the full FY26 report.
- Ahmed to update the Mayor's Office of Ethnic and Community Media website, including adding current contact information, immediately.
- Ahmed to produce the FY26 annual report on Local Law 83 compliance by end of calendar year 2026, including a detailed breakdown of spending by agency and outlet.
- Ahmed to meet with publishers from the citywide marketing directory, including those who have expressed concerns, and to begin roundtables and scheduled meetings in the immediate term.
- Ahmed to contact and meet with the New York Coalition for Ethnic and Community Media, with CM Stevens providing the contact details.
- Ahmed to follow up with CM Morano on the number of Staten Island-based or Staten Island-focused outlets in the citywide marketing directory.
- Ahmed to follow up with CM Morano on whether the office tracks advertising expenditure by communities served rather than outlet headquarters location.
- Ahmed to follow up with Chair Brewer on the contract structures, durations and procurement basis for the six media placement vendors, obtaining details from DCAS.
- Ahmed to evaluate the six media placement vendors and report back to the committee on their performance and whether the current structure is appropriate.
- Ahmed to convene a working group or public process to establish a clearer, more transparent and publicly documented definition of what constitutes a qualifying ethnic and community media outlet for the citywide marketing directory, including criteria for inclusion, rejection and appeals.
- Ahmed to review the in-scope versus out-of-scope classification of advertising spending and report back to the Council on whether the current classifications accurately reflect the intent of Local Law 83.
- Ahmed to consider supporting a written prohibition against allowing outlet coverage of the administration to influence advertising spending decisions, as raised by CM Morano.
- Ahmed to engage with the Office of Emergency Management and relevant agencies on protocols for deploying ethnic and community media advertising rapidly in crisis situations, including public health emergencies and Census outreach.
- Chair Brewer to connect Ahmed with the New York Coalition for Ethnic and Community Media contact information.
- CM Stevens to connect Ahmed with the New York Coalition for Ethnic and Community Media.
- Ahmed to review the ballot question changes to public notification requirements and assess their likely impact on advertising revenue for ethnic and community media outlets, following CM Restler's question.
- Committee staff to advance Int 1127-2026, Int 1128-2026, Int 1129-2026 and the preconsidered intro on agency communication technologies working group through the legislative process.
Full Transcript
Good morning and welcome to today's hearing on Governmental Operations, State and Federal Legislation. At this time, please, everyone, silence all electronic devices. There is no eating, food or beverages here in the hearing room. Also, at this point moving forward, no one — I repeat, no one — is to approach the dais. Finally, if you wish to submit in-person testimony, please see one of the sergeants at arms. Thank you so much. Chair and Speaker, we are ready to begin.
Thank you very much. I am Gale Brewer, Chair of the Committee on Governmental Operations, State and Federal Legislation. I want to thank everyone for joining us today for our hearing on the Mayor's Office of Ethnic and Community Media. Members of the public and everyone who joins us today — I think I see a Council Member. I do not know where he went, but he was here.
I will now turn it over to Speaker Menin for her opening remarks. Thank you, Speaker Menin. Thank you so much, Chair, and I really want to thank the Chair for holding this important hearing. I am Julie Menin, Speaker of the New York City Council, and we want to thank members of the public for being here today for this hearing.
This issue that we are discussing today around the Mayor's Office of Community and Ethnic Media is not new to the City Council, and it is certainly not a new issue for me. I have long recognized the importance of ethnic and community media, which led me to start investing in that over a decade ago. In 2016, when I served as Commissioner of the Mayor's Office of Media and Entertainment, we announced a million-dollar grant to Columbia Journalism School to create new programs that would help New York City's community and ethnic media outlets stay competitive and bring them further into the digital age. We were really proud to announce that program. At that announcement, here is what I said: "The diversity and breadth of New York City's community and ethnic media reflects the diversity of our City as a whole, and it is crucially important to keep these outlets thriving. These publications add key perspective to our local news landscape and they keep New Yorkers in the know, whether their native language is English or Bangla. We look forward to collaborating with the journalism school on this important initiative, which builds on their history of providing excellent training for journalists at ethnic and community publications."
That quote from almost a decade ago still rings incredibly true today. That is why the Council passed Local Law 83 in 2021 to formally establish the Mayor's Office of Ethnic and Community Media, codifying former Mayor de Blasio's Executive Order 47. Local Law 83 also requires City agencies to spend at least 50% of their advertising budget on ethnic and community media outlets. The Council passed this Bill because we recognize the crucial role that community and ethnic media plays in our City and to address the difficult media climate for small publications.
I also want to add that I really appreciate the incredible work that our community and ethnic media outlets provide. As Speaker, we proudly allocated half of our media budget to community and ethnic outlets all across the City of New York. I do want to say that when former Mayor de Blasio made that change in policy and the Council passed that law, it had a significant impact. Prior to the implementation of Executive Order 47 and Local Law 83, 82% of the City's advertising spending went to large mainstream media outlets, whereas ethnic and community media outlets only received $2.7 million in the City's advertising budget. By 2020, the first full year of implementation, that amount increased to $9.9 million. The City's spending on ethnic and community media peaked in 2022 when it reached a high of $23.1 million. In fiscal year 2025, 57% of City agencies' overall advertising spending went towards ethnic and community media. It was 51% for fiscal year 2024 and 40% for fiscal year 2023.
However, that has not translated into greater monetary benefits because overall advertising spending has decreased significantly. In fiscal year 2020, the City spent $260 million on advertising across all media outlets. However, that number dropped significantly, and in fiscal year 2024, just $7 million of those dollars went to ethnic and community media — less than a third of what it was two years before that.
So what has changed, and why is the City's spending on media so much lower than it was just a few years ago? Over the past summer, the Council convened a series of forums to better understand this issue. Earlier this year we hosted meetings with Black, Asian and Latino community media outlets at City Hall, bringing together journalists and publishers, and I know many of you came to that and we really appreciate that. In these meetings we heard firsthand concerns about the City's drastically decreased media spending and investments in ethnic and community media. Furthermore, participants expressed concerns about not having a point of contact within the City, and they felt that they did not know how to contact the administration and that lines of connection that they had during previous administrations were now nonexistent. Many also conveyed that their outlets are facing unprecedented financial troubles in this very challenging media environment for local media across the country, and significant decreases in ad buys from the City have just exacerbated those difficulties.
I know many are concerned about the staffing of the Mayor's Office of Ethnic and Community Media. I know I have some questions about that. I know the Chair has some questions about that, and we are here to get answers from the administration, to hear from members of the media and to understand how we can support this crucial sector which reaches all of the diverse communities in New York City with vital, culturally sensitive reporting. We must do more to invest in our ethnic and community media. So thank you so much, Chair Brewer, and let me turn it back to you.
Thank you very much. I think during the pandemic some of the federal money helped a lot. You could see the difference because health information got out, and you did a great job during the Census doing the same. So we know how important that media is.
In addition to oversight, we will be hearing four bills. The first Bill, Int 1127-2026, sponsored by CM Williams, is in relation to amending and eliminating certain reporting requirements within the New York City Charter and the Administrative Code of the City of New York. Int 1128-2026, also sponsored by CM Williams, is in relation to due dates of agency reports to the Council. Int 1129-2026 is in relation to agency transmissions of reports of compliance with operational requirements. And a Preconsidered Intro, which I sponsored, is in relation to the creation of a working group to study agency use of communication technologies.
Local Law 83, like Executive Order 47 before it, codified and added to the requirement that agencies spend — as you heard earlier — at least 50% of their advertising budget with ethnic and community media outlets. We are hearing from community and ethnic media outlets that under the current Mayor they are seeing up to a 200% drop in City advertising revenue since Mayor Mamdani took office. We would like to find out whether this is true and if so, why City advertising with these outlets has decreased so drastically between one administration and another. Local Law 83 of 2021's requirement that agencies spend at least 50% of their advertising budget on ethnic and community media does not apply to the agencies' entire spending budget, but to spending on broadcast, print and digital advertising. Other types of advertising such as social media and digital displays are considered out of scope and not subject to the 50% spending requirement. They might not have existed in 2021.
Agencies can also be granted waivers if they are required by statute, court order or legal mandate to publish information in media outlets that reach all New Yorkers, or if an agency spends less than $5,000 per year on advertising. There is quite a long list of agencies that spend less than $5,000 a year. Local Law 83 also created the Office of Ethnic and Community Media, which is tasked with submitting an annual report on agencies' spending on ethnic and community media, as well as developing and maintaining a directory of community and ethnic media outlets for agency use when complying with Local Law 83's spending mandate. Looking at the most recent 2025 report, there are about 293 such media outlets.
In his first days in office, the Mayor moved the Office of Ethnic and Community Media into the Office of Mass Engagement. Ethnic and community media outlets welcomed the move. They viewed it as a signal that that media was being valued as both a channel for messaging but also as a partner in helping New Yorkers understand and participate in civic life. However, that did not happen. The Executive Director left at the end of 2025 and no new Executive Director was appointed. The office was moved again, this time into the Mayor's Director of Communications Office. When asked about the office at a previous hearing, the Commissioner of the Office of Mass Engagement was unable to answer questions about the office despite it being part of Mass Engagement for a year. The Commissioner referred questions to the Director of the office.
We hope the new Executive Director — thank you for being here today — will be able to address the many concerns we are hearing from community and ethnic media outlets, as well as the questions we have about the function of the office, including the website. In addition to oversight of the Mayor's Office of Ethnic and Community Media and government spending on ads, we will be hearing my bill, the Preconsidered Intro, which would create — as you heard earlier — a working group to study agency use of communication technologies. Last month we heard about a Signal group used by the Mayor to communicate with social media influencers, and for a period of time the messages were set to auto-delete, which upsets me because I am a big records retention advocate.
At the same hearing, the Commissioner of DORIS explained that instant messages are considered transitory and therefore there is no requirement that they be archived.
While there are legitimate uses for City employees to use encrypted messaging like Signal, it is incredibly important that we keep records of all official communications. This Bill would require DORIS to establish a working group to study the instant electronic messaging used by City agencies and submit recommendations.
I also want to highlight the three good government bills we are hearing today. It is important for the City to reevaluate the local laws that it passes, especially those that require City agencies to collect and report out data. Reviewing and making sure that the information we receive is timely, relevant and worth the burden is an exercise in good government, and when we can repeal unnecessary, duplicative or outdated reporting requirements it makes it all the more worthwhile.
With that in mind, we are hearing Int 1127-2026, as I said earlier, sponsored by CM Williams, which amends and eliminates certain reporting requirements within the City Charter and the Administrative Code. Int 1128-2026, also sponsored by CM Williams, amends due dates of agency reports to the Council. Int 1129-2026 amends agency transmissions of reports of compliance with operational requirements.
I want to thank the following Council staff for their work on this hearing: from the Governmental Operations Committee staff, Hurry Frazier, Erica Cohen and Sinead Heenan; and from my staff, Schuler Pooter and Cynthia Warning. I think we will now hear from — I also want to mention CM Wilson. I did mention the Council Member, but he had gone to get some coffee at the time.
I think that is it. Okay. We would love to hear from you, CM Williams. Thank you.
Thank you so much. Good morning, everyone. I would like to thank Speaker Menin and Chair Brewer for being here today and convening this hearing on the merits of ethnic and community media and government spending on advertisements. Government cannot be responsible to the people if the people do not know what the government is doing. Ensuring that our messaging is reaching people where they are is critical for governmental transparency and accountability.
This is what good governing is. Part of good governing is also ensuring that we as the legislative branch of government have access to the data and information we need in order to be an effective policymaking body. There are many obligations that our local laws place on the mayoral administration and City agencies, and we here at the City Council are very mindful of that burden. As part of our due diligence as stewards of good governing, we periodically review the Charter and Administrative Code to reduce unnecessary burdens on City agency staff and repeal or streamline outdated, duplicative or unnecessary reporting requirements.
Having engaged with City agencies, I am proud to be the sponsor of the good government bill package being heard today. Proposed Int 1127-2026 will repeal or amend 25 provisions of the Charter and Administrative Code requiring certain reports and studies. Int 1128-2026 will create a uniform default reporting due date system for agency reports. Int 1129-2026 will establish a procedure to be prescribed by the Speaker for how an agency will attest to the Council that it has completed operational mandates prescribed by law.
Taken together, these bills have us working smarter and more effectively. They will bring efficiencies to the work this City does, and I am thankful to the Chair for hearing them here today. I want to thank the committee staff for preparing for today's hearing and my own team for the hard work they do day in and day out. I love how the compliance division who helped me create these talking points did not add a line to thank them for their hard work. So thank you, Malcolm, for your hard work in helping to draft these bills and ensuring that the Council again is a responsive and responsible steward of City government and making sure that we reduce unnecessary burdens. Thank you so much.
Thank you very much. Now we will swear you in with the wonderful counsel to this committee. Good morning. Thank you for already raising your right hand.
Thank you. Good morning, Speaker Menin and Chair Brewer, and members of the Committee on Governmental Operations, State and Federal Legislation. Thank you for the opportunity to be here with you today. My name is Massoud Ahmed and I am the newly appointed Executive Director of the Mayor's Office of Ethnic and Community Media. I am excited to share my vision and hopes for the future of this office and Local Law 83 in New York City. Let me start with a simple truth: New York City cannot work for everyone if everyone cannot access the...
Information they need. This is why local law 83 is a truly transformative law. Across the U.S. and globally, local news is disappearing. For more than two decades, the news industry has been battered by shifting business models, changing user behavior and growing ownership consolidation. Since 2001, the newspaper industry has lost more jobs in the U.S. than coal mining. Community and ethnic media have been hit the hardest. Since the pandemic, Northwestern University's Local News Initiative found a quarter of ethnic media outlets nationwide shut down. Many of these publications are small, family-owned businesses operating on the thinnest of margins.
They serve communities that are often overlooked by larger media organizations, and they are struggling to survive. When a local newsroom closes, we lose more than a publication. We lose a source of trusted information. We lose the connection between neighbors and the institutions that shape their lives. The biggest casualty in all of this is our democracy. Researchers link the decline of local journalism to weaker civic engagement, less accountability for public officials and greater political polarization. That means fewer people are asking the questions government needs to answer. When local stories disappear, the issues affecting our neighborhoods can disappear from public view.
The crisis of local news has led people around the country to organize to rebuild our local news ecosystem, asking an important question: what role can government play in sustaining local journalism? Local law 83 offers an answer. It is a groundbreaking effort — the first attempt in the nation to put public resources to work supporting the local news outlets that help our democracy function. It has become a shining light for cities across the country, with many hoping to replicate this approach.
On its face, it is a very straightforward law. New York City government must aim to spend 50% of its advertising budget with community and ethnic media. Underlying that are two pillars that provide us with compounding benefits. First of all, it ensures that every New Yorker can access the critical programs and information that government provides. In New York City, we are blessed with publications that publish in dozens of languages. They are trusted messengers in their communities. Through them, we can ensure that nobody is left behind on any government initiative that is intended to support everyone in the City. As immigrants across New York City come under attack, this could not be more important. Access to accurate, timely information can make the difference between a family receiving the support it is entitled to and a family being left behind.
The second pillar is sustaining the journalism publications that keep our communities informed and our institutions accountable. These publications are key to our civic infrastructure. We need them to attend local community board hearings, ask their local elected officials tough questions and critically uplift the issues that are most pressing for communities. Local law 83 recognizes that supporting these outlets and connecting New Yorkers to public information are not competing goals — they reinforce one another. Where community media is stronger, New York is better informed and our democracy is stronger.
That leads us to the creation and role of this office. It is the first and only of its kind nationwide. My responsibility is to serve as an advocate for this community of publishers across New York City government and help ensure that local law 83 delivers on its promise to have agencies spend marketing dollars with community and ethnic media. My core responsibilities are: one, to train all New York City agencies on their obligations under local law 83 and how to comply with the law; two, to manage the citywide marketing directory, which identifies the publications City agencies can work with to meet their obligations; and three, to publish an annual report assessing the government's progress towards the law's 50% advertising spending goal.
These responsibilities sound administrative, but their consequences are real. The way we implement this law determines whether public dollars reach the outlets that need them and whether agencies effectively communicate with New Yorkers. I want to see it deliver on the commitments it has made. I started in this role earlier this month. In this short time, I have already heard from many publishers. I hope to spend the first few months of my role hearing their concerns as well as any concerns from government agencies about the obstacles they encounter in meeting our obligations. I am also gathering data from the City's media buyers and the agencies to compile the FY26 report on local law 83. That report will help us better understand where the City stands, where progress has been made and where we need to do more.
I am approaching this work with a clear-eyed understanding of the challenges and a recognition of what this law has already made possible. Throughout the country, attempts to replicate this law have struggled to move from legislative ambition to effective implementation. New York City has spent five years building the infrastructure to make this law work, directing millions of dollars in advertising spending to community and ethnic media. Those are real results. Without that investment, who knows how many community institutions that help New Yorkers stay informed might no longer exist. I am grateful to the people who built this office before me and to you, the City Council, for your continued interest in this office and the goal it serves. This sustained engagement is necessary if we are to ensure that local law 83 succeeds. I am incredibly excited about what the future holds for community and ethnic media here in New York and what role this office can play in ensuring that it continues to thrive. I would be pleased to answer your questions.
Okay, thank you very much for your testimony. So my first question is: what is the current size of your budget and how many staff members do you have?
Thank you for that question. So currently, you are looking at the head of the Mayor's Office of Ethnic & Community Media — I am the only person on the team, but I am really excited to be bringing someone on in the near future. I think what we want to do with this office moving forward is really understand what the needs of the publishers are, listen to the publishers, listen to the agencies, understand how they have worked with this office in the past and then build a team that can really reflect those needs and how we want to move forward as an office.
I just find that hard to believe — you are the only person in this office and yet you have an enormous responsibility to ensure that 50% of every agency's ad buys goes to community and ethnic media. Now I appreciate...
...the question, and thank you for that. I do think that, as I mentioned, listening to the publishers and listening to the agencies is going to be really critical in these first months to understand how we can ensure this law is successful moving forward. I think you highlighted some of the concerns of the past, and I have been hearing from publishers about some of their concerns. So I am excited to spend some time really trying to understand how we can build a team that can really ensure that this office is successful.
I mean, just to be clear, the law was incredibly successful. It has now been gutted, so that is why we are having this hearing. What is the overall current media advertising budget of the mayoral City agencies? So when we are talking about 50% going to community and ethnic media, what is that overall amount?
I have been hired actually to produce that...
...report and try to understand that exact thing. So in my first few weeks in the job, I have been reaching out to the different media buyers to get reports from each of them on where they placed ads over the past FY26. I need to collect all of those reports and then take them back to each individual agency to understand if those line up with their internal data, and then I should be able to publish that information.
I mean, I just think this is honestly concerning that we do not have that number. That is a very basic number. I say this as someone who has been commissioner of several agencies — each agency has their advertising budget and it is a very straightforward number. So this should not take a long time to do. We would urge you to get that number to the Council, to this committee, as soon as possible, because this should be very, very basic. What is that number? Why was the Mayor's Office of Ethnic & Community Media moved originally under the Office of Mass Engagement?
Thanks for the question. I cannot speak to deliberations that were happening prior to my joining. I joined earlier this month and I am currently under the Director of Communications.
Can you answer, then, why it remained under the Office of Mass Engagement for eight months and then only to be moved again and placed under the Mayor's Director of Communications?
Sorry, I cannot really speak to deliberations that happened before I started.
Okay, and you cannot comment on why the office did not have a director for eight months? I mean, that is very concerning as well — that no one was running this office while it was under Mass Engagement for eight months, and no one was running it, and then it was moved again and again with no director until you came on board.
I appreciate that question. As I said, I cannot really speak to deliberations that happened before I started, but...
...I can say that it is a unique office. Like I said, this is the only one of its kind in the nation, and in my conversations upon joining the administration, I did sense a real desire to really get it right and understand what would be needed for this office. That is the only thing I...
...can speak to. I do just have to say: not having a director for eight months, moving it, originally making the decision to put it under the Office of Mass Engagement — that all begs the question of how seriously this office is really being taken. I am someone who has worked with that office for a time. I really believe in community and ethnic media. I am very troubled by what has happened over the last eight months, and the fact that you cannot answer the rudimentary question of what the agencies' ad buy is — that is a basic question to me. That is question number one: what is the overall ad buy? Because then how can we make sure that 50% of it is actually going to these outlets, which is what our law prescribes?
I appreciate your concern. As I said, I am really looking forward to digging into the data and getting all of the information. I will pass it back over to Chair Brewer. CM Wilson has also joined us.
My other question is: what is your vision for the office? I mean, even the website, as you probably know, is outdated. I was looking at it this morning. That is sometimes where people see vision. So what is your vision for the office, and when will you update the website?
Thank you so much for that question. As I said, I really do see local law 83 as a transformative law that could have, as I mentioned, compounding benefits for New York City agencies and for the City as a whole. So I think my vision for the office is to really help the different New York City agencies work with me to understand the value of working with community media — that this is not just something that you have to do because the law mandates it, but that this is critical for you to execute on your mission, whatever New York City agency you are. And to work with the publishers to help them tell that story and explain the difference they make, and to help agencies meet publishers and understand that this publisher reaches the majority of this specific community that you need to reach for your program to succeed. Really help lift up the importance of these community assets across New York so New Yorkers can really see that value.
Okay, and the website update?
Yeah, I would love to update the website. Right now I am really trying to listen to the publishers, the agencies and the media buyers. I would love to speak to people in the City Council who really care about this office to help draw out that vision, and I think maybe early next year I would love to update and write a more concrete vision for the office.
I do not mean to be rude, but you have to update the website before next year. It still says 2024. I read the whole thing this morning.
Oh, I am so sorry. You mean the citywide marketing directory?
Yes, but also your office website.
Yes. So for the citywide marketing directory, absolutely. I do not want to make too many changes to that in the near future without speaking to publishers first.
Alright, the other question I have is about timing. So you are saying that by the end of the year you will have followed up on what the Speaker suggested in terms of knowing the 50% figure for each agency, but hopefully even before that. So what do you expect to actually have done, and what are your specific goals by the end of the year?
Thank you for that question. So definitely by the end of the year, my hope is to have completed the FY26 report, to have met with the majority of the publishers on the citywide marketing directory and heard from them about their concerns about the office and what they would like to see the office do moving forward, and to have a detailed breakdown of which outlets the government has been spending with in the last fiscal year and the fiscal years prior, because I know that has been a big source of concern for publishers too.
Okay. We also heard that some of the media outlets that are on the list currently have been taken off the Mayor's press list. Do you know if that is true, and if so, can you explain why they have been taken off the Mayor's press list? Because you are in that agency now — you are in the communications...
...agency. I am sorry, I encourage you to direct questions about the press list to the press office specifically. I do think it is really important for us, as we are thinking about the future of the Mayor's Office of Ethnic & Community Media, to separate press coverage from paid media, because I know that some folks in the past thought that the two things were connected and it created a sense that your press coverage influenced what kind of paid media you received. So I do not want to create that impression at all. So I would really like...
...that separation to be clear. That comes up because when the Mayor had his early press briefing — and of course it was quite notable — some of the ethnic and community media outlets were not invited. So you are saying that is not what your job is, that that is a completely different aspect of the office that you are under. Correct.
Okay. We are also very concerned about the drop in City advertising. The Speaker and I also heard of a 100% drop in City advertising through these agencies, and that is really a huge number. So how quickly can you get them back on track? Do you think you can do that by the end of the year, or is there something you can do sooner, because the end of FY26 is very soon.
Thank you for that question. I think for me it is really important to understand what is going on currently, so I am really looking forward to digging into the data and getting a deep understanding...
...of how much money is being spent, where that money is going, whether it is a question of reallocating funds or a question of the total amount of spending, and then making a plan based on that. I will be excited to report back to you once I get that...
...data. Okay. How do you think about agencies that are not spending the 50% of their ad budget? What are the consequences? Is there some penalty for that? Is there something we can do to make sure that they continue to do what the law calls for?
My understanding is that the law currently calls for publishing a report and explaining which agencies are not meeting their requirements. I have found the agencies to be really collaborative and excited to work with me, so...
...I am excited to work with any agency that is not meeting its requirements, as was happening in FY25, and help them see the value of working with community media and increase spending.
Do you think there is any change needed? Obviously in today's world there is out-of-scope advertising going on. How will you deal with that? In other words, in the past — I was around in 2021 — it was a different world. So how will the new digital opportunities, or lack thereof, impact spending and impact what...
...I consider traditional community and ethnic media?
Yes, I think that is something that you have thought...
...about. No, I appreciate that question. I think for me the goal is really helping the agencies see the value of working with the publications that are in the citywide marketing directory. So we have 293 publications — I have memorized the number — in the citywide marketing directory, and my goal is really to try and get agencies to spend 50% of their budget with those publications. So really, that is my focus.
What about agencies like Health + Hospitals? I was surprised they spent very little. Some of these bigger agencies, when I looked at the list, I was surprised at how little they spent. And there are a lot of "not available" entries on that list of agencies in the FY25 report. Some of the big ones spent very little money on advertising.
Do you have any sense of why that is yet?
No, I am really excited to sit down with agencies and get an understanding of their plans and how they are operating moving forward. I cannot speak to any of the media plans that happened before I arrived.
OK, and there was also in the report, I think, about six -- I call them the middlemen or middle agencies. These are the groups that do the buying. Is that something that you are also going to look at?
All of the six media placements from vendors, absolutely. So as far as compiling the report, that will be the main source of information for compiling the FY26 report.
Because all of the spend, as you mentioned, goes through them, and I do not need to break down each one of their spending by the different agencies. The agencies want what you -- that many -- in order to be competitive. I am just trying to save money. I did not know if you need six, you need four, you need three, you need different ones. So they have a contract. How have they been decided?
It is a great question. I would love to collaborate with the Council and think through the future of that. My predecessors established the system with six. I think at some point prior to that it was just one. I have been hearing from different folks about the pros and cons. If you have thoughts on that, I would love to collaborate with the Council on how we move that forward.
Well, I will turn it over to CM Morano to ask questions. I have many more. CM Morano.
Thank you, Chair. Thank you for your testimony. I appreciate it. I am sorry for the frog in my throat, and advanced congratulations on your appointment. First of all, I spent the better part of my professional life in broadcasting, so I have tremendous appreciation for the importance of local journalism, particularly independent outlets that ask questions government officials would rather not answer. I actually agree with much of your testimony, especially your point that when local journalism disappears, government accountability suffers. But I want to examine whether the City is doing enough to protect the independence of the very media it is supposedly supporting, and I want to follow up on a couple of the questions that the Chair and the Speaker raised.
In your testimony, you say your office exists in part to sustain press that holds public officials accountable. But the Mayor moved your office under his Director of Communications, right?
Is there not an inherent tension between supporting independent journalism and being overseen by the political communications operation of the very administration those journalists are supposed to scrutinize? Thank you for that.
Question. As I said, I cannot really speak to the decisions that were happening prior to my arrival -- how that transition happened -- but I will say, in conversations with publishers, I think many publishers see this office as a conduit to their relationship with City Hall and government, and they do like the placement of the office within the Director of Communications. Some publishers have different opinions on it, but I think that as somebody who manages their relationship to the government, I think some people find it almost more natural for the office. Well, let me make it...
More concrete, right? If a neighborhood newspaper publishes a series of highly critical articles about Mayor Mamdani, can you guarantee that criticism will have absolutely no bearing on whether it receives City advertising dollars?
Absolutely. Would you support a written prohibition against considering favorable or unfavorable coverage when distributing City advertising? Ethically, I think it is...
A publication's coverage is not in any way to influence their ability to receive or access advertising dollars. That is why I really want to make sure that when there are questions about press or anything -- I have been a journalist myself for a long time before taking this role -- and I would never want any journalist to feel that doing their job is going to somehow influence the bottom line of their publication.
Speaking of influence, I want to follow up on what the Chair mentioned at our hearing on influencers a month ago, and this is something that troubles me as a former broadcaster. Your testimony says we need independent journalists attending community board meetings, questioning elected officials and investigating problems. Yet the committee report describes influencers receiving anywhere from $500 to $20,000 per campaign.
Some of those influencers are not journalists at all -- they are essentially paid messengers. Why should taxpayer dollars be used to compensate someone for repeating government talking points when independent neighborhood newspapers are struggling to keep reporters employed?
I appreciate the question, CM.
Really, my focus -- my office's focus -- is really on the citywide marketing directory list of the 293 publications that are in it, not less. Those are the people that I am really focused on trying to get as much money to as possible, and working with different agencies to see the value of working with them and using them to get that message out there. I cannot speak to how agencies spend their money otherwise, but that is really my goal in this role.
You know, I can tell that you are relatively new in the position because you are actually answering the questions, which I really appreciate. Taxpayer money is going to influencers. Should not every...
New Yorker know exactly who is being paid, how much they are receiving and whether they are disclosing their relationship? I am curious -- would you support public disclosure of the ultimate recipients of every dollar spent on influencer campaigns, including payments made through advertising firms and other middlemen?
It is already my office's responsibility. I think my office's responsibility is really focused on getting the 50% of advertising money to community and ethnic...
Media. Last question. The report repeatedly celebrates the City's commitment to spending 50% of advertising dollars with ethnic and community media. But as I understand the law, that requirement only applies to certain forms of advertising. Social media advertising and influencer campaigns fall outside of it. So theoretically, could not an administration dramatically increase spending on influencers, reduce traditional advertising expenditures and still meet the 50% requirement?
So I am not sure if I understand the question well. So it is a loophole?
Basically, right. I mean, the requirement only applies to certain forms of advertising. Social media advertising and influencer campaigns fall outside of it, right? So in theory, could not an administration dramatically increase spending on influencers and on social media and reduce traditional advertising expenditures?
And still be in compliance with the law. I am not sure if I fully understand the structure of that, but I think my goal really is to increase the amount of dollars going out to community media. That is what I am hearing from publishers -- that they need this money to survive, to keep their lights on daily. So really, that is what I am focused on in this office: trying to get an increased amount of dollars out the door to community media.
That gives me the hook, so I have more in the next round. Thank you. Thank you. Calling CM Restler and CM Wilson for a minute of questions. One.
I think there are media individuals who would like to be on the 293-plus list. How do you decide who is to be added or taken off of that list? How is that conversation taking place?
I really appreciate that question. It is a concern that I have heard from many publishers, and the concerns really vary. I think there is such a diverse array of views on what should be considered community and ethnic media, and who should be on that list. So what I would like to do is actually convene a group where we have an open conversation about the definition of community and ethnic media, bringing together publishers, independent academics, people who have thought about this issue extensively, and members of the City Council who have worked with these publications for a long time and have thoughts about how we actually define what a publication that should be in a citywide marketing directory looks like. I would love to do that, and I think it could be a model for the country. A lot of cities that have tried to execute this law have stumbled on this question -- who counts, who should we actually put in the 50%? I think we can lead by example here in New York.
I would love to work on that with you. Number two: the report that came out in FY25 was for June of FY25. So what date do you expect to have your report done for this year? We are in FY26 obviously.
Right. So the dates the report will cover -- yes. So the fiscal year 26. OK. So it will be coming out, hopefully, at the end of this fiscal year.
Yes, the report itself should be done by the end of this fiscal year, but it will cover the advertising data from...
This fiscal year. Yeah. OK. CM Restler.
Thank you so much, Chair Brewer. Chair Brewer enjoys giving me a hard time at every opportunity -- every opportunity she can -- and I will just take this moment to say something nice. I think this is the first time I actually have the chance to join a Governmental Operations Committee hearing since I formerly chaired this committee, and I can say I can think of no better colleague to chair this committee in this term than CM Brewer. So thank you for your leadership. I really appreciate it and I enjoyed working with you, especially when you give me a hard time.
I want to just take a moment to thank all of the representatives from community and ethnic media outlets that have taken the time to join us today, but much more importantly for the work that you do day in and day out to educate, organize and inform your viewers and readers. It makes such a difference, and I know it is hard work. We all know how the local media landscape has really been decimated in recent years and it is harder and harder to get by, but the work you do is so important and I really appreciate it, and I know everyone here at the Council does. So thank you for everything you do.
You know, the executive order back in 2019 set the goal of a significant percentage of our ad spending going to ethnic and community media from City agencies, and the purpose there was in part to stabilize the struggling industry. I think that particularly under the leadership of Eric Adams, this did not work very well. I recognize and appreciate that you are not responsible for the failures of the previous administration -- thankfully we can say "previous" -- but I do want to call out that a total of $31 million in advertising spending went toward community and ethnic media, but $18 million of it was deemed out of scope. So our actual ethnic and community media spending was 24%, not 57% as that report had kind of indicated. Have you done a review of what spending is being recorded as out of scope, and are you looking carefully at how to lift up the in-scope spending so that we are appropriately and accurately counting the community and ethnic media ad spending that we are doing?
.>>THANK YOU SO MUCH CHAIR. BREWER CHAIR. BREWER ENJOYS GIVING ME A HARD TIME AT EVERY .>>OPPORTUNITY, EVERY OPPORTUNITY I CAN AND .>>I WILL JUST TAKE THIS MOMENT TO SAY SOMETHING NICE. I THINK THIS IS THE FIRST TIME. I'M ACTUALLY HAVE THE CHANCE TO JOIN A GANG OF OPS COMMITTEE HEARING SINCE I FORMERLY CHAIRED THIS COMMITTEE AND I CAN SAY I CAN THINK OF NO BETTER COLLEAGUE TO CHAIR THIS COMMITTEE IN THIS TERM, THEN CAPS MEMBER BREWER, SO THANK YOU FOR YOUR LEADERSHIP. I REALLY APPRECIATE AND I ENJOYED WORKING WITH YOU, ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU GIVE ME A HARD .>>TIME AND I WANT TO JUST TAKE A MOMENT TO THANK ALL OF THE ,UM REPRESENTATIVES FROM FROM COMMUNITY ETHIC MEDIA OUTLETS THAT HAVE TAKEN THE TIME T OJOIN US TODAY, BUT MUCH MORE IMPORTANTLY FOR THE WORK THAT YOU DO DAY IN AND DAY OUT T OEDUCATE AND ORGANIZED AND, UH, INFORM YOUR VIEWERS AND READERS. UM, IT MAKES SUCH A DIFFERENCE, AND I KNOW IT'S HARD WORK. YOU KNOW, WE ALL KNOW HOW THE LOCAL MEDIA LANDSCAPE HAS REALLY BEE NDECIMATED IN RECENT YEARS AND IT IS HARDER AND HARDER TO GET BY, UM BUT THE WORK YOU DO IS SO IMPORTANT AND I REALLY APPRECIATE IT, AND I KNOW EVERYONE HERE AT THE COUILNC DOES. SO THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING YOU DO YOU KNOW, .EXECUTIVE ORDER BACK IN 20 19ST THAT DEDICATE THAT SET THE GOAL OF, YOU KNOW OUR A SIGNIFICANT PERCENTAGE OF OUR AD SPENDING GOING TO ETHNI CAND COMMUNITY MEDIA FROM CITY AGENCIES AND THE PURPOSE.
THERE WAS IN PART TO STABILIZE THE STRUGGLING INDUSTRY, AND I THINK THAT PARTICULARLY UNDER THE LEADERSHIP OF ERIC ADAMS. UH, THIS DIDN'T WORK VERY WEL L. UM, SO YOU KNOW, I RECOGNIZE AND APPRECIATE THAT. UH, YOU'RE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR THE FAILURES OF THE PREVIOUS ADMINISTRATION. UM, THANKFULL Y, WE CAN SAY PREVIOUS UM, BUT, UH UH. I DO WANT TO JUST CALL OUT NOTED THAT A TOTAL OF $31 MILLION IN ADVERTISING SPENDING TOWARD A COMMUNE ETHIC MEDIA, BUT 18 MILLION OF IT WAS DEEMED OUT OF SCOPE. SO OUR ACTUAL ETHNIC AND COMMUNITY AND MEDIA SPENDING WAS 24%, NOT 57% AS THAT REPORT HAD KIND OFNDIC IATED .>>HAVE YOU DONE A REVIEW OF WHAT SPENDING IS BEING RECORDED AS OUT OF SCOPE AND ARE YOU LOOKING CAREFULLY AT HOW TO LIFT UP THE IN SCOPE SPENDING SO THAT WE'RE APPROPRIATELY AND ACCURATELY COUNTING THE COMMUNITY, ETHNIC MEDIA AD SPENDING THAT WE'RE DOING. THANKS FOR THE QUESTION
Thanks for the question. I really appreciate your focus on this issue. I really do think that when I get the data and I am able to really examine what different agencies have been spending, looking at that total amount will be really interesting to understand. I would love to collaborate with the Council on how we are defining in-scope and out-of-scope. It is something the publishers have mentioned to me as well. Yes, there is definitely something that I will be highlighting in my...
Report. Good. I just want to be clear -- out-of-scope things like that are not print, digital, radio or ads, including but not limited to things like social media, job boards, digital displays and bus shelter ads. That is not ethnic and community media advertising, right? So we just should not be confusing ourselves or counting it as community and ethnic media advertising when it explicitly is not. I just want to make sure that moving forward we are really clear about what we are doing and what we are not doing, so that we are not inflating numbers inaccurately.
I also really appreciated your comments in response to CM Morano's questions -- that you are strongly committed to not allowing community and ethnic media advertising to be politicized, because it is the role of these reporters to hold the powers that be accountable, whether it be the Council or the Mayor, and ad spending should not be correlated to that in any way. I will say, though, there were persistent and chronic allegations of that happening in the Adams administration, so I think how you formalize that is really important.
Relatedly, I am concerned that ads have been placed in outlets that are heavily dependent on AI content. I have seen outlets that claim to be, you know, a Bronx...
Outlet, and it is all AI -- there are no actual reporters working there, there is no actual independent content being created by real journalists, and yet the City is spending there. Is this something that is on your radar? Have you conducted an analysis here?
Thanks for bringing that up. I generally feel focused on this issue and I really appreciate it. I think one of the interesting things with this role, and how I think about building this office moving forward, is how much does the office really get into determining the quality of the different publications, because that could lead to some of the accusations that we have heard from other Council members. So really what I want to do is, as I mentioned to the Chair, convene a group where we can really have a broad conversation about how we define what community and ethnic media is, what really fulfills the spirit of local law 83, and how we are ensuring that we are supporting publications that are giving us that second benefit. What is that second benefit? It is keeping New Yorkers civically engaged, having reporters show up to hearings like this, having reporters go to community board hearings, go to NYPD hearings -- are they really doing that work for that community? Is New York better off from this organization being sustained? Is it helping agencies get the word out through these publications?
I just hope that, as you embark on that process, you focus on making sure that real community and ethnic media outlets are the entities that are eligible for receiving this funding -- that we are actually using these resources not just to reach New Yorkers and inform New Yorkers about the work of City agencies and opportunities to access services and benefits, but that we are also stabilizing the community and ethnic media outlets that are actually doing the critical journalism and engaging with their constituencies day in and day out.
I just imagine that as you update or consider the ad firm selection process, and you are thinking about how many impressions something gets, how effective a given outlet is at reaching specific constituencies -- I just want to say it from the vantage point of a parochial Council member. Look, I represent Greenpoint. Greenpointers is like -- if you want to reach the people in Greenpoint, you go to Greenpointers. It is not that Greenpointers reaches the people in Queens or the Bronx, and they may not have the most impressions in the world, but if you want to reach that neighborhood there is no better way to do it than working with Greenpointers. So I just want to make sure that we are valuing that and considering that as you both think through updating the ad selection process and think about how we define what a community and ethnic media outlet is, so that we are actually working to stabilize and support this sector.
Last thing for me -- thank you so much, I appreciate it. The Chair will shut me up when she needs to, which is often, I promise you. The last question for me is: are you concerned that the decrease in public notification requirements proposed in the ballot questions is going to significantly impact ad revenue for local outlets? Have you looked at this? Have you heard from community and ethnic media publications about this and how this is going to impact their revenue?
As I mentioned, I will have to follow up with you about that. I am not familiar with it -- publishers have not reached out to me about it -- but it does sound like something I would be very interested in learning more about.
I am really looking forward to working together.
I appreciate a fresh perspective and some integrity in this office, and I am excited for the work ahead.
Thank you so much. Council Member, they will call Council Member in a minute. My other question, though, was just back to these agencies, because I assume that they have been kind of lax where there has not been, you know, talking roundtable to the publishers. When I work in agencies, just as a Council Member, they can get real lazy if nobody is pushing them. I know exactly how that goes. So I guess my question is, how are you going to work with these agencies? Do they qualify for the full mandate waiver, or are they really under $5,000 for their advertising budget? They could not want to have any more mandates, so they will tell you it is $5,000 even though it is a lot larger. And then the number of agencies which have a full mandate waiver changes per year. How do you keep track of them, et cetera? How are you going to do all that, because these agencies can be as challenging as, you know, people on the outside, to be honest with you.
Thank you so much. I am new, so maybe I have a naive optimism, but I have seen so much excitement from agencies about collaborating and working with me and about getting their messages out through community and ethnic media. So many of these agencies are really excited to collaborate and have been willing to work with me, so I really see my role as making that as frictionless as possible, helping the agencies understand which publications will be great conduits for their messages, depending on the different communities they want to reach. As the Council Member mentioned, you know, if you are trying to reach people in the Bronx, if you are trying to reach a specific ethnic community, which publications can they look up in the citywide marketing directory to find that can really help them meet their goals. That is really my mission and I have seen a lot of willingness and excitement to do that in my first few weeks in the role.
CM Wilson, thank you.
Chair, and again I echo my colleagues in congratulating you on your appointment. This is something we started touching on, but how does the City measure whether its advertising campaigns are actually reaching the communities they are intended to serve? And does the Mayor's Office track whether advertising in ethnic and community media leads to greater awareness and use of City services?
Thank you so much for that question, and I think that is really one of the goals that I would like to lay out in the vision for this office — those stories of impact that you are looking for and that you are mentioning. So I would love to work with publishers to uplift stories of impact where, you know, publishing an advertising campaign around vaccinations with a publisher actually led to more Pakistani New Yorkers getting vaccinated. If the publishers can... we can move beyond the kind of traditional metrics that I think a lot of brands might use for measuring their campaigns. On the individual campaign front, I think the media placement agencies are really responsible for working with the agencies on that, but I think my office can play a really great role in making just a broader case for the importance and the value and the impact of community media.
And as you know, many smaller ethnic and community newspapers serve residents who do not get their news from major outlets. What steps is the Mayor's Office taking to ensure that smaller publications have a fair opportunity to receive City advertising funding?
So really, that is the goal of this office — to ensure that small publications have a clear understanding of the steps towards getting access to those dollars.
Working with the publishers to just create more transparency about how agencies are spending, where agencies are spending, which media placement vendors are holding which campaigns, really trying to make that process clear and public. And then also working with the placement vendors additionally to help them understand that this is really important, and that working with a smaller publication might be more complicated than a typical big buy, but they really need to do that, and that we as the government see value in that. And then just to one of the Bills being considered today, Int 1127-2026, the agencies would have to confirm when they have completed certain requirements established by local law.
So how would the City verify that these requirements have actually been completed, rather than relying only on the agency's confirmation?
So I am not familiar with the resolution that you are referring to, so I will have to follow up.
With you on the proposal.
Okay, I am not familiar with the proposal that you are referring to, and I am happy to follow up with you. I want to have the time to review it. Okay. Thank you. I am good.
Thank you, Council Member. I will call on Council Member Stevens in a minute.
I am still focused on these agencies. I know they have nice, wonderful, sunny ideas, but they still do not always do what you might want them to do. So are you going to work with training materials? Do not forget, there are a lot of new people, so they may not have the background to know what you are hoping to achieve. So are you going to develop training materials? Are you going to do roundtables? How are you going to get them to actually do their job, even though you are saying they are so excited about it?
Thank you for that question. I really want to spend the first three months of my role understanding what their experience has been like, meeting with them all, seeing them in the past, especially the agencies that have maybe struggled to meet the 50% threshold, or agencies that have larger budgets, really understanding what was the friction, what was their experience working with ethnic media every week. How can I reduce that friction? Once I get an understanding of that, and hopefully we can maybe change some processes and reduce that friction slightly, I would love my training to be focused on the value and impact that working with these publications provides. So really gaining an understanding of what are the communication goals of all the different government agencies, and focusing the training to be tailored towards that particular agency, and helping them understand that, okay, you typically work on these five or six campaigns — here is how community and ethnic media can really help you achieve those goals. Let us sit down and work together and think about how you can build a media plan, maybe even bring some publishers in who can help explain to them what their publication does, who it reaches and how it can be helpful.
So are you going to develop training materials? Is that part of your vision, or how are you going to actually implement this training? That is what I am asking.
So the law mandates that I have to train every agency every fiscal year, I believe, and I think part of my job in the next few weeks is really going to be building those materials, but I do think I do not want to build them without really understanding how things were done previously and what...
I understand that. I just am concerned. I want to get the word out because they could be folding because they do not have funding, so that is why I was asking these agency questions. Council Member Stevens. Okay. All right. This out-of-scope issue is mostly concerning because it is a different world than when the law was implemented.
So I guess this would come down to what it is that a community and ethnic media outlet is, when you have figured out their new or updated definition. But social media advertising is considered...
Out of scope. And why is that? Is that because of the law or is there some other reason? I would have to really look back at my predecessors and how they described the in-scope versus out-of-scope piece. I think what I really want to do first of all is get all of the data for fiscal year 2026, understand how spending was laid out for the previous fiscal year, and then build a definition around that and understand how agencies are spending. But really, ultimately, the goal is to increase the amount of dollars that are going to community and ethnic media. That is the ultimate goal for this office and I would love to collaborate with the City Council in finding solutions for that.
Okay. Council Member Stevens, are you ready?
I guess some of my questions are... I know that in conversations with some of the ethnic media groups they have expressed their concerns about not being able to have access to some of the advertisement dollars, or feeling like they are not part of the conversation. And maybe you have kind of already addressed some of this. What are some of the steps you plan to take to ensure that you are doing outreach to all the different outlets and making sure that they have a seat at the table? And also, like traditional media, print and those things — how are you going to make sure that they are engaged in this process as you are building out your plan?
Thank you for the question, Council Member. I have spent the first few weeks in my job sitting down with publishers. I have met a dozen publishers who represent about 60 news outlets in the City and I am looking forward to continuing to do that work, listening to publishers and really making it clear that my office is accessible to them, that they have my phone number, they can call me and we can build long-term relationships. I think that, you know, as a journalist myself, I feel that people want to be doing the job of journalism, and a lot of these publications, the journalist is also the publisher who is trying to get advertising dollars. So I want to make this as frictionless as possible and really make myself accessible, make it easy to meet with me, not make it so that everyone has to come to City Hall — I can go and meet them where they are and hear from them about their needs. And as I get a better understanding of everything that is happening, I really want to try and create more transparency so people understand how they can get access to these ad dollars.
I represent one of the largest African communities in the City and they are growing fast. So one of the questions that I have is also why African outlets such as Little Africa and others have not received any advertising dollars for this year yet. If this is something...
Thank you for the question. I cannot speak to what was happening before I arrived, or the media plans that were in place before I arrived, but I am really excited to dig into the data. How long is that going to take?
So I am hoping to have the report done — I am confident I will have the report done by the end of this year.
And so I just want to make sure I understand. Because you just started, folks have to wait until the end of the year to figure out how they are supposed to access... So how do we ensure that these outlets do not collapse in the meantime?
What was the transition like? Because that is unfair — because you just started, everyone has to...
Wait. So what does the transition look like? I am confused. Are you the only person there? Was there no one there before? I appreciate the question. So are you asking what the transition into my role was?
I am, because you just said that it is going to take you until the end of the year to figure out how these folks are going to get access to the advertising dollars, and I am saying that by then they will probably already have folded and collapsed. I am trying to understand what was the transition from the person before you, and the staff that is currently there — are they not there? Because I am not understanding why it is going to take that long, because that is not fair to the folks who are waiting for it.
So I cannot speak to what was happening before I arrived. I really do appreciate the question and the advocacy for community and ethnic media, and I think my first job really is gaining an understanding of what happened. So when did you... sorry, I am sorry.
Three weeks ago. You started three weeks ago. So for some of the months, nobody was in the office — just so you know, eight...
Months. So because this was not a priority for the administration, people now have to suffer. I want to be clear — that is the signal being sent out, whether you started three weeks ago or not. That does not mean that the work does not continue, and so I am concerned that folks are suffering because that is going to be a problem. So I am really confused about folks waiting on next steps. Is there any staff that you can work with to figure out how to get these advertising dollars out faster than by the end of the year?
So I really appreciate the question. I think what I mentioned previously in my previous comment was about the report, and I think really that is what a lot of folks are trying to understand — where the money went, how the money was spent in the last fiscal year, how different agencies allocated those dollars in the last fiscal year. So by the end of the year, I am really working on developing that report, getting that data from the different media buyers, understanding which agencies they work with, and then having the agencies verify that information.
I have another question. How are folks supposed to contact you if there is no contact information on the website? Because I am getting intel right now that they do not even have contact information on the website.
I appreciate that question. I can follow up with you with more information about that, but I have tried to make myself as accessible as possible. How do they...
Find you? How are you accessible if there is no contact information?
I am going to help you update your website, if you want. It has to be updated. I know how to update a website. You cannot say that you want people to reach out to you and that you are accessible if they do not have the information. Please update the website. I will get the Commissioner to do it for you, literally. I am calling her right now. I have noticed and...
I will get that website updated.
Thank you so much. I mean, I am almost out of my time. I just want to be clear — I do not think that it is fair that this office sat without someone for 8 months and now folks still have to wait. I think the sense of urgency... and this seems like a running theme, because I had a hearing yesterday and the sense of urgency does not seem to be there. You know, I think that when there are issues that the administration deems important, they move mountains to get things done. And this requires a sense of urgency because these outlets are going to fold and they depend on this — this is their lifeline. It is not okay for us to just say that we are going to assess and figure it out. That should have been done. And even if there is not someone at the helm, if someone leaves and everything stops, that is the problem. Things should be in place so that does not happen. So I am disappointed that that happened and I am disappointed that these outlets might fold because we are failing them, and that is a problem for me. Because again, when things are deemed important, this administration gets things done, and this clearly is not something that you all seem to think is important, and that is unacceptable to me. So thank you. I appreciate all the things you are saying and I understand that this is not your fault because you just started three weeks ago, but it is really unfortunate. Thank you.
I totally agree. I think that the contact information would be half of the equation, just in terms of showing good faith.
And then secondly, the issue that I brought up earlier of who is going to be on the list...
Has to move as quickly as possible so that her organizations and others can get funding. But I did know that in 2025, Comptroller Lander did a report and even had New York One on the community and ethnic media list. So I mean, to me that would not be community and ethnic media list eligible, but that is again something you are going to have to figure out as quickly as possible. Back to Council Member Stevens.
Smaller community and ethnic outlets should be on the list.
So as quickly as possible, I would suggest that has to be done. CM Menin, thank you. And just to pick up on...
One of the things that both Chair Brewer and CM Stevens were alluding to — I would like to get a little bit more clarity on how you get on this list. So your office maintains the citywide marketing directory, which agencies use to identify eligible media outlets.
Who determines whether an outlet qualifies for inclusion, are the eligibility criteria public, and is there a formal appeals process if an outlet is rejected? Thank you for that question. I think today is one of the most important things for this office. So I can read for you the current criteria that is on the website in the law. It says: serves a particular community of people based on native language, race, color, agenda, national origin, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, disability or immigrant status; targets a discrete neighborhood, geographic or regional population within the City rather than the City as a whole; or falls within a specifically tailored subject matter as determined at the time by the Executive Director.
So I think, as a member of the media previously, and in my conversations with publishers — the folks from the New York City Local Community Ethnic Media Group are here — so many publishers have expressed confusion about this list. That is why I do think creating a much more public policy and approach to this, and having a public conversation so that there is not confusion about which publications are in and which publications are out, is really one of my main goals for this office. As I said, I think it can really be a model for the rest of the country.
Well, we are all rooting for you. I think we are wishing you the best of luck with that goal. Let me give you a hypothetical. Say there are two neighborhood newspapers that serve essentially the same audience. One has been around...
One has been around for 50 years, has a small staff and publishes original reporting. The...
Other is sort of what CM Restler was alluding to earlier — a relatively new operation that either uses AI or just mostly republishes press releases. Are they treated identically for purposes of your directory? Does original reporting account for anything, or is this strictly a question of reaching a particular...
Audience. That is a great question. I really just want to say thank you for the question and the level of detail around this issue. But I do think this, as I said, is something that I want to be made as a community decision. I really do want us to convene a conversation that includes publishers and independent...
Voices — people like yourself who have a detailed understanding of this problem. Because I do think that the question of the agencies being able to reach the most people through these community media outlets, and ensuring and sustaining that civic function that I mentioned in my testimony, are two really important pillars and goals, and live up to the spirit of local law 83, which I think is critical.
And would you support — and I am guessing you would, based on everything we have heard today — publishing how many outlets apply to be in the directory, how many are rejected and the reasons for rejection?
I will definitely follow up with you once we have those great conversations and really think about what a robust, transparent process looks like for this directory. I think generally, one of the goals for me in this role is to increase transparency of this office, because as a...
Whole. I have to maintain my reputation with Chair Brewer by asking a Staten Island focused question. So you have talked about reaching underserved communities, and I totally agree with that objective. I represent the south shore of Staten Island, where a lot of residents rely on neighborhood publications that the larger citywide media rarely pay attention to. Does your office track advertising expenditures based on the communities an outlet actually serves, rather than simply where its headquarters happens to be?
And further, as a kind of second question there — can you tell me how many Staten Island based or Staten Island focused media outlets are currently in the directory? Thank you for that question. I can definitely follow up with you on the second half of the question and get you that information. On the first half of the question I would also need to follow up with you, just to really get an understanding of how we would define that. I think with citywide marketing dollars, when this law was created, the majority of the money was not going to community ethnic media — it was just going to really large publications. So part of the role of this office is really helping City government understand who we will be reaching when we spend with community ethnic media. In line with that, I think there is potentially a role for that, and I would love to follow up with you.
You have got a partner in me. Okay. Thank you so much.
Thank you very much. We have been joined by CM Dinowitz.
I have one more question. We spoke earlier about who the primary advertising firms are that help place the ads. I know you said that is still part of your discussions and there are six of them. But did the City have master contracts with Graystone or Miller, and are there master agreements with the others? And I think you said there are six. So how are you going to make the decision as to who to engage with, and do you know how long these contracts are for?
I am happy to follow up with you with that particular information and get you the details from DCAS. But I do think that the way in which we are working with the vendors is such a critical part of making sure local law 83 succeeds — they are really a linchpin in how we work with the community ethnic media. From the agency side, creating a more frictionless process, and also from the publisher side, feeling like not only are they receiving support, but they are being treated with respect and they are actually getting the things that they need and are able to do reporting in a way that the agency finds useful. So...
Are you going to evaluate them? I assume you have not had a chance to meet with all six of them yet. But how are you going to evaluate whether or not they are doing their job?
So I would love to partner with you on that, and I want to think about what role this office should play in that evaluation. I think that, given my thinking about the scope of local law 83 and what this office is responsible for and what it does, that kind of evaluation is something that we will need to discuss. But I am happy to follow up with you. I want to have more information about how the contracts are structured and what we can do moving forward.
Okay. I know you mentioned that you are going to hire an additional person. Are you going to hopefully have others hired, or is that not clear...
Yet? I believe that what we are hoping to do over the next few months — or sorry, what we are going to do over the next few months — is really evaluate the needs for this office, the strategy and how we want to execute on the mission, and then build a team that reflects those needs here.
CM Stevens. Sorry, I just had a question. Specifically, the New York Coalition for Ethnic and Community Media — they are saying that the engagement with them has been limited, because they feel like they have not been part of a lot of these conversations. And specifically, I guess they are not necessarily seeing good outreach from that office. What does that look like with ethnic media groups who might be pushing the envelope, which technically they are supposed to do, because that is what they are supposed to be — a check on government? Could you talk about what your approach is going to be with those outlets?
My approach with all outlets will be the same. I am really excited to meet with as many publications as will meet with me from the citywide marketing directory. I am sitting down with a number of publications and publishers — publishers are also busy and sometimes struggle with time. But have you already started reaching out to them? Have you scheduled roundtables and conversations with them? Has it already started? I have a number of meetings coming up in the next few weeks with other publishers and they have been really informative. So as I said, I am really excited to have the way that this office functions moving forward be informed by conversations with publications, and really trying to capture the range and diversity of publications that we have in the City — folks who are hyperlocal, focused on a specific geographic region, or people who focus on a specific language group or a specific group based on sexual orientation or disability.
The needs of the different types of publications based on their medium and size really varies, and their relationships with the office in the past and what they would like to see in the future is also quite diverse. So I think the goal really is to listen to as many publishers as possible, try to understand those through lines, and then explain to folks how we want to work moving forward.
Okay, well I want to just uplift that you should definitely reach out to the New York Coalition of Ethnic Community Media, because they feel like they have not been able to be a part of these conversations. I do think that we want to make sure that we have a diverse group, even if they might seem adversarial, because the media's job is to push government and hold us accountable. So making sure that we are reaching out to all of those who might not necessarily be as friendly — because that is what the media is supposed to do, hold it...
Accountable. I really appreciate you raising that, Council Member. I just want to be super clear — I was a reporter, so I have a lot of respect for reporters who are adversarial, and I have no issues with meeting with reporters who are adversarial in any way. I am more than happy to meet with publishers. If I could reach out to your office and be connected to them, I would love to do that. And to the Council Member's previous question, I really do want to make clear that people's...
Coverage of the administration in no way impacts their relationship to this office.
Yeah, I just want to be clear — I am an elected official. I want the people to hold me accountable. If everyone is just saying I am doing a great job, I am scared, because you are not pushing my thinking.
And so we need media to make sure that they are actually a check on us and being the voice of the community, in the same way I am the voice of the community. I wanted to make sure that everyone has a chance and an opportunity, even if they seem adversarial, because again, I talk to everyone even when I do not want to. But we should be talking to everyone, and that is the media's job. So I just wanted to make sure that that was taken as a consideration. Thank you.
Thank you, Council Member. Thank you. I have the number and will be glad to share it for the Coalition. They are...
Wonderful. We are just back to this influencer issue, because obviously the Department of Sanitation, as an example, has a budget — I assume it is more than $5,000 — so they would be one of the agencies that would in fact have come under local law 83. So they will, I assume, put 50% toward the list that you come up with, which you will hopefully have done by the end of the year. Hopefully they have been spending up to now, even though they do not necessarily have a complete list. But then the other 50% out of scope — how would you have any sense of that, or do we keep that all as their decision?
But in a world that is different than it was in 2021, is there any change in the definition of what a community and media outlet is? Some of these media and community folks are probably influencers — a community and media outlet, who knows? So I am just wondering, again coming back to this definition, is it perhaps different than it was in 2021, and how will you be looking at that? Not to say that you are going to make a final decision, but how are you thinking about that?
I appreciate that question. So I think, as I have mentioned, my focus is trying to increase the amount that the agencies are spending with the publications in the citywide marketing directory. So that in-scope number — whatever it might be, however we want to slice it — I really want to ensure that publishers feel like they are getting that support and that they are able to continue to grow their publications and do the critical job of journalism that they are doing in the City. So I think that is really my focus, and helping the agencies understand the value of what community publications do — that this is not something you just have to do because of the local law.
No, this meets some real interests. This is critical to actually executing on your vision and accomplishing your agency's marketing and communication goals. The other question I have is just a little bit hypothetical. But, God forbid, we have some other crisis — the Office of Emergency Management would obviously kick in. But I am just wondering if you are — and this is not a hopeful thing, but there is always something that comes up in our City — I am just wondering if you are meeting with them just to say that if in fact there is some crisis, whether it could be a health crisis, a hurricane, or something unimaginable, how could we work together to get the word out? In other words, obviously there would need to be an increased advertising budget in certain communities.
So you are thinking along those lines also? Absolutely. I think that there are some communities where, you know, a lot of the publications are already in a state of emergency and crisis right now in New York. I think ensuring that they are getting critical information out to the communities through these publications is critical, and really trying to ensure that marketing directors at all the agencies understand the importance — that these are your best conduits for trying to get information out to all New Yorkers — is something that is incredibly important. So I will be making that case.
The example of the pandemic is really important. I think there is a turning point for many folks around how Executive Order 47 kind of came into being, written right before the pandemic, and I think it really was what set the stage for local law 83. I was not in government in 2020. I would love to partner with you and understand how that works, and how if something like that were to happen again, we can learn from that experience and try not to panic. But the census could be a panic situation if this President decides how he is going to handle it and we do not. So that is an...
Example of a situation where we absolutely need every single outlet to be available and clear. And so that is an example — 2030 is not so far away.
I could not agree more. Let us remember that. Thank you.
Thank you, Chair. You had just made reference to that because some of the local newspapers in my district — we actually lost a local newspaper, the Norwood News. Have you heard of this? Of course. If you could just share some of the work that your office does or can do, because as we are losing papers we are also losing a critical part of our civic structure. What work does your office do to support our local media, and what further work can you do and what investments can you make to bring back the Norwood News?
I appreciate that question. I think everyone in local media was devastated to hear about the loss of the Norwood News. It was, you know, a breeding ground for great Bronx journalists, and it is a publication that I think was near and dear to so many people's hearts. We were all devastated about that. It speaks to the broader trend that I have spoken about in my testimony — the difficult conditions that we are currently under to keep local news alive. That is really the whole entire purpose for which this office was created, and why local law 83 was put into place: to help preserve these community institutions like the Norwood News.
Well, I know. I understand that, but it has not been preserved. So I am wondering how we can work together to preserve it, or what work, if any, the office has done to bring back the Norwood News.
Specifically on specific publications, I think the goal of the office is really to work on the sector as a whole and try to help agencies understand that they should be working with the publications in this sector in order to achieve their goals. So really what I am trying to do as I start in this role and build out this office is work with the different agencies to help them understand where they are spending and how they can be spending more with publications that can both meet their goals of getting the word out to the communities that really need this information, and also help sustain publications in the City that are critical for civic infrastructure.
So in your assessment, do you think the agencies are aware that there is only one local newspaper that covers the northwest Bronx — it is the Riverdale Press — because the Norwood News is no longer there?
I cannot speak to the understanding of all the different marketing directors in all of the different agencies. Some of them are former journalists themselves, and I am sure some may have worked in the Bronx themselves. I would not want to completely say that no marketing director in New York City government is aware of that. But I do see it as my role to help people understand.
The urgency of this moment — and I guess I am asking, if you are identifying your job as to work with these marketing directors in the different agencies, would it not also be part of your job to make sure they know about the closure of local media outlets? I appreciate the question.
I appreciate the question. Yes, I do agree that there is a role to be played in helping them understand that the Norwood News is a critical source of information for the northwest Bronx. It is critical to work in that way, and I hope that all the different agencies, in my time working in this office, will have a deep fluency of all the different publications in New York and will know which publications to work with if they are trying to reach different people in different places. I see my role as trying to educate them and help them understand that.
Yeah, I would think you do not just have to hope that they have an understanding. I mean, I would think that would be part of your role. I am ready to work with you to make sure our agencies understand this. The Norwood News is not just a critical publication in Norwood and Bedford Park — it is the only one. That was the only place my neighbors were getting their information, and now they have nothing. There is no other print publication that is delivering to the different buildings, that is in all the centers where people need to get information.
I stand ready to work with you, but I think the perspective should be less about hope and more about obligation. I think we as a City have an obligation, and your office has an obligation, to work with these marketing directors as you have identified, to support local journalism, particularly those who have closed or are on the cusp of closing. Thank you.
CM, I appreciate that. Thank you. Thank you very much, Commissioner. We appreciate it. We look forward to working with you. We are going to go to the next panel. Thank you so much.