Seal of Civic Readiness in DOE High Schools and at CUNY Committee on Higher Education | Committee on Education · October 20, 2026 · 2hrs 49m Source: https://hearinghearings.nyc/hearings/committee-on-higher-education-seal-of-civic-readiness-in-doe-high-schools-and-at-cuny-2026-10-20/ Video: https://councilnyc.viebit.com/vod/?s=true&v=NYCC-250-8-3_261020-131849.mp4 ================================================================ (00:00:22) Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. We apologize for the delay. We have been playing musical rooms this morning, so we appreciate your cooperation. Today we are getting ready to start. At no time is anybody allowed to approach the dais. If you have any questions that you need answered, just get the attention of one of us sergeants at arms and we will be more than happy to assist you. (00:00:44) To begin, good afternoon. I am CM Rita Joseph, Chair of the Committee on Higher Education. Welcome to our joint hearing with the Committee on Education, chaired by CM Eric Dinowitz. Today's hearing is on the use of the New York State Seal of Civic Readiness in DOE high schools and at CUNY. Additionally, our committees will hear the following legislation: Int 0259-2026, sponsored by CM Shekar Krishnan, amending the Administrative Code of the City of New York in relation to requiring the Department of Education to distribute information about the importance of dental care. Res 0418-2026, sponsored by CM Dinowitz, calling on the City University of New York to ensure all campuses award an appropriate number of college credits to students who earn the New York State Seal of Civic Readiness in high school. Res 0451-2026, sponsored by CM Zhuang, calling on the New York State Legislature to pass and the Governor to sign A.9298 and a companion bill in the Senate, which would enact the Next-Gen Civics Act, providing hands-on, project-based civic education to students in grades nine through twelve. And Proposed Res. No. 620-A, also sponsored by CM Dinowitz, calling on the New York City Department of Education to ensure that the New York State Seal of Civic Readiness is awarded in all New York City public high schools to eligible students. First, let me ask CM Zhuang to deliver her remarks on her bill. (00:02:17) Thank you so much. As a mother of two, I deeply care about the education of our city's children, and knowing how important it is that they be taught how to engage with government. Right now, young people are not engaging in politics, and New Yorkers are among the least civically engaged voters in the country. Participation in civic education remains voluntary and uneven, but the young people who receive high quality civic education are significantly more likely to vote, volunteer and engage in their community. As a result, that is why I am asking you to support Res 0451-2026, calling on the New York State Legislature to pass and the Governor to sign A.9298 and the companion bill in the Senate, which would enact the Next-Gen Civics Act, providing hands-on, project-based civic education to students in grades nine through twelve. This instruction will include a hands-on project where students apply what they learn through activities like mock elections, community projects and policy simulations. I encourage my colleagues to support this resolution and to help our children learn about how our system works. Thank you. (00:03:52) CM Krishnan, thank you so much, Chairs Joseph and Dinowitz. At a time when in our country right now there is so much wrong information, disinformation, false information about our public health, which is impeding access to resources — critical, lifesaving resources for our seniors — when the Secretary of Health in our country is deliberately trying to spread wrong information about vaccines and reduce Americans' access to vaccines, it is more critical than ever that we in New York City step up to make sure that our children especially get the information and vaccines and medical resources that they need. That is why I am proud to be hearing today my legislation to make sure that our Department of Education is informing parents about the importance of fluoride when it comes to our children's dental health. We have heard so much wrong information and questions at the federal level about the importance of fluoride, but we know more than ever it is crucial for our children's dental health. I want to thank the DOE for being a partner to make sure that our students and our parents get the information they need to take care of their children's health. Thank you to our chairs, and I look forward to today's hearing. (00:05:04) Thank you, CM Krishnan. Now for a little background on today's hearing topic: the Seal of Civic Readiness, which was implemented statewide in 2022, labels students who have attained a high level of proficiency in civic knowledge, skills and actions. It also shows higher education institutions and employers that students have completed an action project in civics or social justice. To earn the Seal of Civic Readiness, students must earn points from a menu of various civic knowledge and participation benchmarks which they can select from, including completing required advanced selective social studies high school courses, passing the social studies Regents exam, carrying out a research project, completing a service learning project of at least 25 hours, participating in extracurricular activities or work-based learning experiences of at least 40 hours, and conducting a middle school or high school civic capstone project that addresses a real-world issue. Some New York City public high schools have been graduating students coming to CUNY with an earned Seal of Civic Readiness in their hands for several years now. At this hearing, the committees are interested in exploring how the Seal of Civic Readiness is being promoted and awarded across New York City public high schools. The committee is also interested in encouraging CUNY to accept the seal for college credit or in fulfillment of a common core or elective requirement. I believe that would help smooth the transition from high school to college for the high school graduates who made the effort to earn the seal. The committee is further interested in whether awarding college credit for the Seal of Civic Readiness would eventually improve students' chances of successfully graduating from CUNY. Our committees are also extremely interested in making sure CUNY students graduate in a timely manner so they can move on to pursue their careers as effectively and efficiently as possible. Now let me turn it over to Chair Dinowitz for his opening remarks on the hearing topic and on his resolutions. (00:07:07) Thank you, Chair Joseph. Good afternoon, everyone. I am CM Eric Dinowitz, Chair of the Committee on Education, but I think more importantly, a New York City public schools alum and CUNY alum. We are in a time of deepening polarization, and as CM Krishnan's bill addresses, misinformation — or lies — so detached from civics that it becomes critical that we do what we can in New York City to reengage our youth, our kids, in civic education and ensure those incentives are there for our schools to engage in that kind of education. In the 2024-2025 school year, 8,000 students graduating from 166 DOE high schools earned the New York State Seal of Civic Readiness. That was an impressive 72% increase from the previous year. In June 2022, at the end of the state's pilot year, 643 graduating seniors from 31 high schools earned it. The numbers are climbing fast. There is another reason this conversation matters now. Last month, the State Board of Regents authorized the State Education Department to move forward with ending the requirement for students to pass a specific set of exams to graduate, beginning with the class of 2028. Today, a student can use the Seal of Civic Readiness in place of the second Regents social studies exam. Under the state's plan, the seal will no longer count towards a diploma. It would still be a recognition, but its worth to students will depend on what colleges do with it. More than 60% of graduates who go on to college enroll at (00:08:51) CUNY. So a substantial and growing number of incoming CUNY students have likely earned the seal. If CUNY colleges awarded flexible core or elective credits for it, those students could meet CUNY's general education requirements sooner. Earning a seal takes more than the basics. We were last here about a Portrait of a Graduate, and there are some out there who are concerned about the rigor of our Regents exams, but earning the seal takes more than the basics. To earn a Regents or advanced Regents diploma, every student must complete eight semester credits in social studies: two in global history, two in US history, one in economics and one in Participation in Government. The seal additionally requires at least two points in civic participation from things like service learning, civics projects, civic engagement electives, extracurricular activities or work-based learning. According to the New York City Campaign Finance Board, the number and diversity of engagement courses beyond the minimum requirement can vary greatly across schools depending on the school's funding and location, and only schools that apply to the DOE can award the seal at all. That means a student's chances of earning it can depend on which high school they attend — an issue I look forward to discussing today. But three years ago this month, when I chaired the Higher Education Committee, we held a joint hearing like this with the Education Committee on the New York State Seal of Biliteracy, another seal awarded for work including testing and service learning. Students earn it by accumulating points through coursework, exams and projects. At that hearing, CUNY told us that of the colleges it had researched across the state, Marist was the only one automatically awarding credit for that seal. But today, ten CUNY colleges along with the School of Labor and Urban Studies and the School of Professional Studies show what is possible when we work together, when we elevate these issues and elevate the really rigorous work that our students do in the classroom, and incentivize our schools to do it through college credits from CUNY. I said at that hearing it is not often in education that we find a program with no downside, no tradeoff, no drawback, and I will say it again today: for students, the Seal of Civic Readiness has no downside. (00:11:21) Recognizing and rewarding students' participation and success in civic projects and courses, both by DOE and CUNY, is going to be a win-win-win-win-win. Okay, you got all five: win-win-win-win-win. It is for students, families, DOE schools, CUNY campuses and taxpayers of New York City. I look forward to hearing the details from our witnesses and of course everyone who is here today to testify. Today we are also hearing my two resolutions on the use and recognition of the Seal of Civic Readiness. Res 0418-2026 calls on CUNY to ensure that all campuses award an appropriate number of college credits to students who earn the seal, and Proposed Res. No. 620-A calls on the DOE to ensure that the seal is awarded in all New York City public high schools to eligible students. I am proud to say not only are these resolutions fantastic resolutions, but the early work on these resolutions was done with students I mentored at Hunter College, which is a CUNY school. The fellowship and civic leaders work with 224 undergraduate students on civic projects, and our civic project was elevating education in our schools. The path they took was drafting these resolutions. So I want to commend those students and the work that was done by CUNY students. Now those resolutions are being heard by these two committees today, and I think that is a powerful civics lesson for all the students who are here today and are watching at home. I want to thank Thea Salter, my legislative director; Jenna Clouse, my chief of staff; Alejandra Carvajal, the committee's senior counsel; Chloe Rivera, the committee's senior policy analyst; Katie Salina, the committee's policy analyst; Julian Lawless, the committee's principal financial analyst; and Grace Amato, the committee's senior financial analyst. I will now turn it back to Chair Joseph. I would like to acknowledge our colleagues on both committees who are present: CM Dinowitz, CM Zhuang, CM Narcisse, CM Brewer, CM Schulman, CM Louis, CM Krishnan and CM Joseph. For the Education Committee: CM De La Rosa, CM Wilson and CM Ariola. (00:13:54) Thank you. I would like to thank Giovanni Kwan, my chief of staff; Ben Atkinson, my director of policy and budget; Amita Kellawan, the committee's senior legislative counsel; Regina Paul, the committee's senior legislative policy analyst; and Allie Stole for the financial analysis. (00:14:12) I would like to remind everyone who wishes to testify in person today that you must fill out a witness slip, which is located on the desk of the sergeant at arms near the entrance of this room. Please fill out the slip even if you already registered in advance that you will be testifying in person today. To allow as many people as possible to testify, we will limit testimony to two minutes per person, whether you are testifying in person or on Zoom. I am also going to ask my colleagues to limit their questions and comments to five minutes. Please note that witnesses who are here in person will testify before those who are joining on Zoom. (00:15:18) Thank you. As a reminder to all of our witnesses, please state your name prior to your testimony for the record. We will begin with the witnesses from CUNY and then go on to those from New York City Public Schools. Thank you very much. My name is Alyssa Vine... (00:15:48) A little closer. Is that better? Okay. (00:16:01) Good idea. Thank you. (00:16:07) Good afternoon, Chairs Joseph and Dinowitz and members of the Committee on Higher Education and Education. My name is Alyssa Vine and I am the University Director of Credit for Prior Learning in CUNY's Office of Academic Affairs. Credit for Prior Learning, or CPL, is an academic process by which CUNY's colleges can award academic credit for college-level learning acquired outside the traditional classroom. CPL is a nationally recognized strategy for recruitment and student success because it saves students time and money on their path to earning a degree. It validates their learning whether it was gained on the job, through industry training or through personal lived experience. CPL cultivates a sense of individual achievement and readiness for higher education, sending a message to its recipients that they are college material. Since CUNY's CPL policy was passed by the Board of Trustees in 2020, implementation work has been ongoing, including especially work to identify opportunities with system-wide potential to recruit and support populations of New Yorkers with high-demand skills and knowledge. My testimony addresses how CUNY could respond to the call in Proposed Res. No. 418-2026 for college credit to be awarded to New York City public school students who earned the New York State Seal of Civic Readiness, when there is alignment with college (00:17:41) Leveling learning, unlocking potential in particular routes to the Seal, especially the high school capstone project, determining whether the Seal faculty review and collaboration with New York City Public Schools. Before I expand on that, I will first provide context on existing CPL opportunities for students entering CUNY from the City's high schools. While CPL is often relevant for working adults who are returning to college or enrolling for the first time, it is also a common and meaningful tool for students entering college from high school. There are numerous examples of CPL opportunities that are specifically targeted toward high school students, including several that are named in CUNY's CPL policy. All CUNY colleges award CPL credit for qualifying scores on Advanced Placement exams, International Baccalaureate exams and Cambridge Advanced International Certificate of Education exams. Many CUNY colleges offer or are developing CPL pathways for key industry certifications, including credentials in IT, data analytics and health and human services. High school students who earned these credentials through career and technical education programs in the City's high schools can receive the same CPL credit as working adults who earned these certifications for employment or career advancement. Additionally, over the last several years CUNY has been working to establish CPL opportunities for high school students who earn the New York State Seal of Biliteracy. Currently there are 12 colleges with CPL pathways in place for Seal of Biliteracy recipients and work is ongoing to expand this to more colleges. These opportunities validate biliteracy with college credit and bolster pipelines for related high-needs sectors, for example teaching and nursing and health care shortages. This is the result of close partnership between CUNY's Office of Credit for Prior Learning and New York City Public Schools' Office of Multilingual Learners. The Seal of Biliteracy offers a useful point of comparison because both Seals recognize the significant learning completed in high school. For CPL purposes, however, the two Seals present different assessment questions. Biliteracy can be demonstrated against established language proficiency standards, while civic readiness encompasses a broader range of knowledge, skills, experiences and forms of participation. From CUNY's perspective, the Seal of Biliteracy reflects a model of CPL assessment that is somewhat different from the topic of today's hearing, the New York State Seal of Civic Readiness. First, the Seal of Civic Readiness recognizes the valuable learning and engagement across several pathways. Because those pathways are intentionally varied, the learning demonstrated by Seal recipients may not be uniform in content, depth or alignment with a particular college course. The CPL question is therefore not whether civic readiness has value, but how CUNY can identify the routes and evidence that demonstrates college-level learning. The New York State Seal of Biliteracy provides a comparatively direct basis for CPL review because every recipient demonstrates language proficiency aligned with nationally recognized standards of the American Council on the Teaching of Foreign Languages. Civic readiness is broader by design and may be demonstrated through different combinations of coursework, projects, service and other learning experiences. That breadth is a strength of the Seal, but it also means that CUNY must examine the evidence associated with particular pathways before determining the appropriate award of college credit. One promising starting point is the rigorous high school capstone project, which New York City Public Schools has identified as evidence of advanced and potentially college-level learning for CUNY CPL purposes. This route presents an opportunity with potential that is worth exploring. Foundational knowledge of civics has broad value for college students. It connects multiple areas of the liberal arts and humanities while fostering social responsibility and civic engagement that are relevant across disciplines and career paths. For that reason, a pathway tied to in-depth civic learning aligns most appropriately with CUNY's general education curriculum rather than with a specific course or major. To determine whether the capstone project could support a CPL pathway, CUNY faculty would first need to review its requirements and implementation across participating high schools. They would need to confirm that the work is consistently demonstrating college-level learning and, if it does, they would need to identify appropriate CUNY courses or pathways and general education areas where that credit could be applicable. Faculty could develop a rubric informed by the Seal of Civic Readiness model to assess students' capstone projects. Students meeting the established threshold would be eligible for credit. Another approach would be for CUNY faculty and New York City Public Schools to collaborate on a CUNY-specific Seal of Civic Readiness pathway aligned with CUNY's general education outcomes. Students who complete a faculty-assessed civic readiness portfolio could be eligible for CPL credit. CUNY is interested in continuing this exploration with New York City Public Schools, beginning with faculty review of the capstone project and other potential college-level routes to the Seal. That process can advance the goal reflected in Proposed Res. No. 620-A of recognizing civic readiness by cultivating a carefully designed pathway that could recognize meaningful student learning while preserving the academic standards required for awarding college credit. (00:23:37) For students arriving at CUNY, that recognition could do more than shorten the path to a degree. It can welcome them to the university by affirming that the knowledge, initiative and civic commitments they developed in high school already have value in a college setting. Thank you. For the opportunity to testify — good afternoon. I am going to take your lead and not lean over. (00:24:12) Good afternoon, Chair Dinowitz, Chair Joseph, members of the Committees on Education and Higher Education and distinguished members of the City Council. My name is Cordelia Viv and I am the Chief of Curriculum and Instruction for New York City Public Schools. I am joined by my colleagues Jenna Real, Director of Civics, and Chris Kermie Hall, Senior Curriculum Specialist, as well as superintendents Marcel Deans and Anthony Sorrell. Thank you for the opportunity to discuss the implementation of the New York State Education Department's Seal of Civic Readiness, which is part of the NYC civic readiness initiatives. The foundations of American government and the democratic process are vital to nurturing more engaged, active community members and informed potential voters. Civics education should be an essential part of every student's core academic program. We are on our way to ensuring that every student in our schools has access to high-quality civics education, and the Seal of Civic Readiness has been an important component of that growth. In order to place the Seal in the appropriate context, it is helpful to know that New York City Public Schools first designed and implemented Civics for All, our civics learning initiative, beginning in the spring of 2018, when it was announced as part of Mayor de Blasio's Democracy and Civics Plan. With the support of K-12 educators and New York City cultural institutions, the Department of Social Studies and Civics built a multifaceted initiative including a K-12 curriculum, school-based partnerships, our participatory budgeting program, student-facing programming and teacher professional learning. Beginning in 2020, an extensive collection of social (00:26:09) studies and civic comic books supplemented these efforts. Some people love them. These resources have been available to all schools in New York City Public Schools since their creation, with our team now supporting Civics for All implementation in 35 partner districts. Our ultimate goal is to ensure that every single New York City Public School student has access to high-quality civics education from kindergarten through twelfth grade. We measure our impact by accounting for students' access to opportunities to build civic knowledge through our Civics for All curriculum materials, demonstrating civic skills by researching, writing and delivering a speech each year on a community issue that matters most to them, practicing real-life democracy by engaging in participatory budgeting and engaging in civic action projects at least once per grade band. While the Seal of Civic Readiness is an exciting and worthwhile way to honor our students' civic readiness upon their graduation, it is not the sole marker of civic learning. Many more of our public school students are receiving comprehensive civics education across grades K through 12 than have already received the Seal. The Seal is a high priority and we seek to offer all students the opportunity to earn it. Our involvement with the statewide civic readiness initiative began in the fall of 2018, when members of the New York City Public Schools Department of Social Studies and Civics were invited to join the task force that the state assembled to work on developing a statewide definition of civic readiness, the Seal of Civic Readiness and the capstone component of the Seal. The finalized statewide definition of civic readiness includes four domains of readiness intended to be developed across grades K through 12: civic knowledge, civic skills in action, civic mindsets and civic experiences. These domains undergird our K-12 continuum of civic learning and informed the elements of the Seal of Civic Readiness as it was being designed. Once established, the Seal of Civic Readiness was approved by the Board of Regents in 2021 and piloted across the state, including at New York City Public Schools. The launch of the NYC Seal of Civic Readiness complemented our citywide civics education initiative by offering a formal recognition that a student has demonstrated proficiency in the domains of civic readiness. In order to earn the Seal of Civic Readiness, a student must earn six points from a list of criteria that demonstrate a student's proficiency in civic knowledge and civic participation. Two of the student's points must be from the civic knowledge criteria, two must be from the civic participation criteria and the remaining two can be from either one. There are 11 possible criteria, each earning a student between 0.5 and 4 points. The intent behind this structure is to maximize the way a student's strengths and school experience can earn them points towards the Seal. It allows schools to develop their own routes to the Seal using those criteria, building on their school's distinctive context and existing programming while also supporting students' needs aligned to their school's culture. For example, a school with a law program in which students take civics-related electives has the option to accredit these electives and ensure students can earn points by taking them. A School Without Walls, one of our New York City Outward Bound schools that uses student-led individualized learning plans and integrates field work and internships, designed a multi-year civic readiness capstone project that incorporated portfolio-based assessments used for exit requirements. The large number of participating schools have developed a wide range of ways that students can earn the Seal of Civic Readiness, each grounded in the domains of civic readiness and supported by the foundations of civic learning built through Civics for All programming starting in the elementary grades. While this potential for customization is an asset ensuring that as many students as possible have the opportunity to earn the Seal, we also need to adhere to appropriate standards of rigor, offering the civics projects, civic electives or the capstone project to do so using a pre-accredited product or to submit a school-created version for accreditation prior to implementation. This process has ensured that our team can vet and accredit Seal-related projects and programming that external organizations have created to meet state Seal requirements. (00:30:52) From the initial rollout of the Seal of Civic Readiness, our Department of Social Studies and Civics created a system of support and guidance to successfully implement this Seal while allowing for the flexibility schools need to align their school's context. With the permission of the state, we created a local version of the Seal of Civic Readiness handbook, providing clear and detailed guidance for schools on each criterion of the Seal. Our goal is to ensure that every New York City Public School receives the resources and support needed to implement the Seal internally. While some schools do take advantage of external resources, including a subset of resources that might cost something, all schools receive professional learning, curriculum resources, guidance documents and support to implement the Seal. The support that schools receive for the Seal of Civic Readiness is incorporated into the overall Civics for All program and the earlier partnerships that were part of the initial design of Civics for All in 2018. While all civics curricular resources are available to every public school, we knew that providing those resources without support for their implementation, particularly outside of a mandated content area, would not result in their widespread use. So we designed a two-tier system of professional learning. One tier was available citywide for all schools to participate in, while the other was a more intensive school-based partnership model in which opting-in schools were provided with direct support from members of the newly created Civics for All teams to integrate into the teaching and learning they were already doing. Once the Seal became part of New York City Public Schools' civic education offerings, both tiers were updated to include support for its implementation. At its start, the long-term plan was to build those school-based partnerships until we had enough participation to shift to a district-based model. In our first full year, 2019-2020, we had 103 partner schools. That number saw a small dip to 96 in 2020-2021 while schools faced the uncertainty of the COVID-19 pandemic, before rebounding to 296 partner schools in 2021-2022. The superintendents of Districts 25 and 26 decided that they wanted all of their schools to be partner schools after experiencing the positive impact of Civics for All during the pandemic. From 2022-2023 we continued to support individual partner schools while bringing on additional districts before shifting to a full partner district model in 2024-2025. Currently 35 of New York City Public Schools' 45 districts are part of the Civics for All partner district program, with many of the remaining 10 districts actively building toward or preparing to join the program. Each partner district identifies a point person in their district office who is paired with a Civics for All team member and together they provide direct support toward implementing civics education to the schools in their district. While this model ensures the capacity needed to provide this direct support, the majority of the 10 non-partner districts have designated district points who work with the Department of Social Studies and Civics more broadly while helping to support social studies and civics work in their district. We are very proud of how the number of schools offering the Seal of Civic (00:34:24) Readiness has grown: from 3 to 60 in 2022-2023, 181 in 2023-2024, 166 in 2024-2025, 230 in 2025-2026 and our largest number yet, 271 in 2026-2027. At the end of the 2025-2026 school year, 12,019 students graduated with the Seal of Civic Readiness, a 1,600% increase in five years from the 682 graduates who received the Seal in the 2021-2022 pilot year. This increase has been possible due to New York City Public Schools' focus on a well-paced, strategic and robustly supported effort to expand the number of students who have the opportunity to earn the Seal of Civic Readiness. We fully expect to continue this deliberate rollout and expansion, seeking to significantly expand the number of schools offering the Seal each school year. We would like to thank the City Council for your continuous partnership in supporting civics education, whether you participated in school visits for Civics Week or joined our post-Soapbox issue roundtables. We are grateful for your participation and advocacy in supporting students as they engage in civics and gain the skills needed to fully engage in a democratic society. Finally, I will turn to the proposed legislation, Int 0259-2026, which would require New York City Public Schools to collaborate with the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene to develop materials relating to the importance of dental care and fluoride and distribute those materials. We support the collaboration with families to receive oral health education, ensuring consistent and efficient use of public health expertise. We look forward to working with the Council on how we identify the best methods for distributing important information to families to best support their health. Thank you to the Council for the opportunity to speak today. (00:36:27) We look forward to your questions. Thank you. I would like to recognize CM Epstein, CM Restler and CM Maloney. Thank you for your testimony. I am going to head over to CUNY. Do you know how many students have come to CUNY with the New York State Seal of Civic Readiness since the first Seal was awarded in 2022? Do you have any data on students' demographic characteristics including race... (00:36:55) Currently, CUNY does not receive information from New York City Public Schools on students who graduate with the Seal of Civic Readiness. However, we are in conversations with New York City Public Schools to establish that data sharing. (00:37:12) So when is the handover going to happen? We are in conversation with CUNY, and we also — and we have the mastermind behind it — have worked very much on being able to track the civics points that students are earning for the Seal of Civic Readiness in STARS, so that now shows up on student transcripts, which we believe will help to accelerate that data sharing. So the conversation is happening. (00:37:44) Right. I think that is something I have always complained about as a Council Member — not enough conversation and interagency collaboration since New York City Public Schools hands over their students to CUNY. So I think that should be much better in conversation as we move forward, because data is going to drive your work. So therefore I hope you get together and let me know as soon as possible, as soon as it happens. Recognized, CM Ariola. (00:38:14) So that is something to work on for the data point. The State Education Department treats the seal as a distinction on a high school transcript and diploma, and districts report to the State under program service code 8013. Does the CUNY admissions process capture that code or notation? According to CUNY's Office of Enrollment Management, the Seal of Civic Readiness is not currently considered as part of central admissions and they are not aware of it being used at college-level admissions. However, this is the purview of enrollment management, so I am not aware of how or if it could be recognized, but we can look into that. (00:39:02) Already, and we are just ten minutes into this hearing. All right. In 2023, CUNY testified that... (00:39:10) ...the credit for prior learning policy is university-wide, but that faculty at each CUNY college are responsible for determining credit awards. Has faculty at any CUNY college evaluated the Seal of Civic Readiness for credit, which college, and what did they decide? No CUNY colleges have evaluated the Seal of Civic Readiness at this time. However, we look forward to engaging faculty in the process of evaluating it and supporting their work to do so in the near future. (00:39:42) Does that mean putting together a working group to make it happen? Is that a task force within your colleagues? How does that — what does that look... (00:39:50) ...like? Yeah, so we have an existing model for coordinating collaborative evaluation across multiple CUNY colleges. We generally bring together faculty from around eight colleges, and we support them by gathering all related materials, putting them in touch with experts on the learning experience they are evaluating, helping them in this case connect also with students who have earned the Seal of Civic Readiness, sample projects — all the material to really help them understand the relevance of the Seal of Civic Readiness to college curriculum, so that they can come up with a recommendation that will then be shared across all CUNY colleges for consideration and implementation. (00:40:37) Is that also publicized to prospective students coming... (00:40:40) ...into the CUNY system? Well, when we have coordinated system-wide evaluation of different learning experiences, once colleges have decided to award credit and those credit awards are in place — for example, in the case of the Seal of Biliteracy — we have a website that lists all of the CUNY colleges that award credit and what those credit awards are. Also, the information is entered into our information system so it is searchable in CUNY's public-facing searchable database, CUNY's Transfer Explorer tool. So that is available as well. Is that also for Civic Readiness or just for Biliteracy? (00:41:29) Well, at this time since... (00:41:30) ...there are not any colleges that are awarding credit for Civic Readiness, there are not examples of that in place. But we definitely have a model for making sure that that information is publicized as soon as there are colleges that are awarding credit for it. (00:41:45) And will that also be added to the website as you have done for the Biliteracy seal? Yes, we would... (00:41:54) ...absolutely create a visible website where students — or excuse me — where students and high school counselors and teachers and families can find the information about where credit is available across the system. The next... (00:42:14) ...question is going to be: how do you get together to create this cohort and get this out the door? You are going to publicize it, you are going to get the work done, and when you do all of this you are going to publicize the benefits of earning a New York State Seal of Civic Readiness. Is that something CUNY plans to do once everything is in motion? (00:42:42) Yes. I would say that we are really proud of the opportunities that we create for New York City high school students and for New York City working adults to earn credit on their way into CUNY. It saves them time and money on their path to a degree, and we are always eager to make sure that people who are eligible are aware of that and able to take advantage of it and use it to benefit their education. (00:43:10) Thank you. New York City Public Schools, how many students in the class of 2026 earned the New York State Seal of Civic Readiness, and across how many high schools? How many students in total were in the class of 2026, and how many New York City Public Schools in total? In the 2025-26 school year, 12,019 students earned the Seal of Civic Readiness, and that was across 230 high schools. Is the plan to offer that in every high school? Yes. What is the timeline? We are actively pursuing one hundred percent... (00:43:46) ...participation. Right now we are in 56.2% of our diploma-granting schools. Okay. And the seal application process for schools that want to offer the seal — when does it end, how many schools have applied in the 2025-26 school year, and how many will offer the seal this year? Do you know? (00:44:02) We accept all schools that apply. So if a school applies and has not been able to answer the questions comprehensively, we work with them to do so, so that they can offer the seal. Thank you. I am going to pass it over to CM Dinowitz, and I will come back with the... (00:44:20) ...other questions. Thank you. So I have a technical question. So 12,019 students received the seal, 271 schools participated — how are you tracking the number of students who earned the seal? (00:44:37) Yeah, it feels like... so we will adjourn and then you can — you can use your minutes to make a request. Lincoln, it is going to be terrible enough. (00:44:56) OK. So as part of graduate data reporting each year, all seal schools — and this is spelled out in the handbook — submit to us any students who have earned the Seal of Civic Readiness, and then that number is meant to match their discharge records, so what is reflected in... (00:45:13) So I am glad you said that, because it was reported to us that STARS only allows you to list one seal, and I guess Biliteracy is worth more to a school's score than Civic Readiness. So if there is a student who earns two seals, they are only going to put Biliteracy. So two questions: one is, are these students undercounted because there may be students who are unable to be entered into STARS? And second, you are switching to OASIS — once that transition is complete, will that allow for multiple seals to be included in the data that is reported out by... (00:45:54) ...the schools? So to answer the first part of your question, we ask schools to report all students. Currently there are no combination codes for a student's transcript. However, schools are meant to produce a letter that goes into the student's cumulative record folder that includes all of the distinctions and endorsements that were placed on their diploma. So for example, if a student got the Seal of Biliteracy and the Seal of Civic Readiness, even though the order of precedence — which is the document that tells the school how to discharge a student — might tell them to give the student the Seal of Biliteracy on their transcript, that document in their cumulative record folder should include all of those endorsements. But in terms of the coding, it is not there. So on the other part of your question, we are working to build a Seal of Civic Readiness tracker in STARS Classroom, which will eventually evolve into OASIS. I do not know what the plan is right now with combination codes, but I imagine with the Portrait of a Graduate... (00:47:02) ...what is there to imagine? I imagine there will be updates to the way that things go, because we will get new guidance from the State. Well, I... (00:47:09) ...I hope so. I would not have the whole deal here. I hope it is not imagining things. I mean, there are still a lot of unknowns in this Portrait of a Graduate. (00:47:19) And I just want to stick with that for a second. You are transitioning to OASIS — you are not going to be using STARS anymore. So that would be the Office of Policy Evaluation. I do not actually know the timeline for the transition. I do know that they are developing it, but there is a transition. (00:47:36) OASIS, by the way — it looks like DAS — and that tells you everything you need to know about a school's data systems. OK. So we will follow up with that other department about switching to OASIS. Turning to the seal: students need at least two points in civic participation, which come from civics projects, service learning, civic engagement electives, extracurriculars and work-based learning. Does the seal track which high school offers the individual opportunities, and do those offerings differ by the school's poverty level? (00:48:18) I do not believe we have the data right now to know whether the offerings for the specific opportunities differ by the school makeup. But I think Chris can speak to the way that we are tracking what projects each school is offering, because either they are taking from a vetted list of accredited projects or they are submitting a project for accreditation as part of their process for becoming a high school that offers the Seal of Civic Readiness. (00:48:56) Yes. So another part of our handbook for the seal for New York City Public Schools is our academic integrity procedure section, and that outlines the accreditation policies that I will be talking about. But to what Delia was just mentioning: we work with internal DOE offices and external organizations to accredit projects or electives for citywide use, and those are available for any school to add to their school's programming. But schools also can develop their own civics projects or civics electives, and they submit instructional materials to us for review, and we match those against the specifications in the handbook to accredit them or not. Or there is the capstone, which is more of a planning document. (00:49:42) I want to stay with that and talk about the projects. First of all, when we met with principals and teachers they were very pleased with the way that the office runs and that you have the samples — it is not just you, you have these sample projects that are vetted and accredited. (00:50:04) Ms. Fein, in your testimony you had said that these pathways are varied and learning demonstrated by seal recipients may not be uniform in content, depth or alignment with a particular college course. That touches on some of the concerns we have about the Portrait — not its alignment to a specific course, but its content depth... (00:50:33) ...and alignment with a curriculum. Can you speak to the content and depth — and I will use the word rigor as well — of these projects? Are they all of the same rigor? So the handbook lays out the commencement-level standards that every project is supposed to align to, and then the accreditation process and the rubric that goes with each project demonstrates how that project would align to those commencement-level standards. So I think, connecting it back to what you were talking about in terms of a Portrait of a Graduate, the pathway to the standard can vary, but the actual demonstration and application of standards, knowledge and attributes is going to be the same level based on that project. But those projects might look slightly different given the context of a school. (00:51:30) And we have been joined by CM Restler. Hello. So if it is adhering to a standard, does the Seal of Civic Readiness make for more rigorous work than the current standard coursework that a high school... (00:51:45) ...student takes? I do not know that we would say... (00:51:48) ...more rigorous. I think that we are saying — and the State would say as well — because it can be a four-plus-one that can substitute for graduation requirements, similarly to the Regents exams, what it does offer is multiple ways to demonstrate that learning and show that application. I think we could refer to one of our superintendents to talk about the ways that that looks different across different schools but keeps the same level of rigor. (00:52:19) OK. And it is a multi-year project, right? These are over the course of multiple years that students are engaging in this. (00:52:26) Yeah, so the seal is really a portfolio, right? It is not one single thing. It is a combination of students' experiences starting even in eighth grade, when they can have their middle school capstone, and then going through ninth... (00:52:42) ...grade... (00:52:42) ...all the way through twelfth grade, where they are earning those points through different experiences, different coursework and different projects that they are doing. (00:52:49) OK. I want to come back to this — the work, the rigor, and really getting it to a place where it will get the college credit that our students deserve. For now I am ready for Council Member questions. (00:53:05) Thank you. Thank you, Chair. CM Wilson, thank you, Chair, and thank you all for your testimony. So the Seal of Civic Readiness requires two points in civic knowledge. What steps can we take to ensure that the civic knowledge includes an acknowledgment of the harder parts of our history — racism, homophobia, sexism, violence — and that students are not excluded from understanding the full scope of the nation's civic history? I am just going to hold the whole thing here. (00:53:46) Forgive me. So for students to demonstrate civic knowledge, some of the options are just social studies courses, the Regents exam, a civic knowledge project through our office — which is the Department of Social Studies and Civics. We produce a social studies curriculum that the majority of schools use. That curriculum is focused on multiple perspectives and ensuring that students are getting that 360-degree view of history. I think the comic books that we shared with you also support that effort. We also provide professional learning to our teachers. We have a Hard History series, recognizing that for teachers — particularly social studies teachers — dealing with some of those harder aspects of history can feel easier to ignore than to address head on. So it is our effort to ensure that teachers feel supported in that work, that they have a framework and tools for doing so, and that the curriculum provides them the resources necessary to deal with all aspects of history. (00:54:45) Thank you. And some pathways to the Seal of Civic Readiness will inherently be more accessible to students from certain backgrounds. So what can you do to ensure that the opportunity for civic engagement is equally accessible to everybody? So one of the things that was a priority for us in... (00:55:09) ...building the Seal of Civic Readiness and how that would be applied in New York City was recognizing that there are lots of opportunities external to New York City Public Schools that students could take advantage of to gain civic experience, and that due to the civic empowerment gap those are going to apply more to our students who are better resourced. So what we wanted to do was build a program that ensured that schools had everything they needed for the Seal of Civic Readiness in-house through New York City Public Schools. We also engage with external partners, but when we do that we ensure that it is something that is available publicly to all schools... (00:55:45) ...citywide. And then my last question is: many of our schools have large immigrant student populations that are in many cases coming from countries with different civic traditions and forms of government. So how do you work to engage them in the political process? (00:56:04) So I will first say that in terms of our civics curriculum, it really draws on students' lived experiences, and that is messaging that we provide to schools in professional learning as well — that our students have diverse backgrounds and different lived experiences, and that those are assets and should be treated as such in civics education. In terms of how we are engaging families, I would love to have one of our superintendents — Superintendent Dean — speak to what that looks like. (00:56:34) While you make that exchange, I want to go to CM Farías. (00:56:59) Thank you. Chair Dinowitz, thank you for mentioning that to me. I am Marcel Jeans, the Bronx High School Superintendent for Districts 8, 10 and 11. I want to talk a little about parent outreach at the school level. Participating schools develop a Seal program plan that includes how they will communicate with students and with families about eligible courses, projects, experiences and the benefits of the Seal. That is an important starting point, but in our district we want to go beyond simply telling families the opportunity exists. We want them to see the learning and understand why it matters. One way we do that is through our annual Bronx Museum Civics Fair. Students bring their civic projects into a public space, present their thinking and engage with families, community members and cultural partners. Through relationships with institutions such as the Museum of the City of New York and the Intrepid, we are helping students see that learning extends beyond the classroom, and families get to see their children as researchers, as problem solvers and young people with something meaningful to contribute. The growth has been encouraging. Over the years we went from nine students earning the Seal in 2020 to 780 young people in 2026. And getting back to Chair Dinowitz's question earlier, we are a district with over 78% Title One, and so our economically challenged families and young people are benefiting greatly and deeply from this work. But I do want to caution us not to conflate growth in numbers with full measures of success. The real question is whether more students, including multilingual learners and students with disabilities, are consistently experiencing this level of rigor and relevant learning. For us, outreach is also about making those opportunities visible, making those opportunities valued and increasing accessibility for the families that we serve in Bronx High School District 8, 10 and 11. (00:59:12) Thank you, Council Member. (00:59:14) CM Wong, thank you, Chair. I am reading this right now and it says in order to earn the Seal of Civic Readiness the student must earn six points from a list of criteria to demonstrate the student's proficiency in civic knowledge. So what does that translate to in terms of college credits, and how do you reach the student? Because not all schools offer the Seal of Civic Readiness. Please answer that. (00:59:45) So at this time there are not any CUNY colleges that are awarding credit for the Seal of Civic Readiness. However, once we have faculty evaluate it and determine its alignment with curriculum for credit award, that credit award will be established in the student information system so that any student who presents appropriate documentation, or once we have data sharing in place, students will be able to receive those credits. (01:00:24) My second question is: not every school is offering the Seal of Civic Readiness. How does DOE plan to do outreach and let other schools know, or let the students know, here are the schools that have it, and then work on the other schools that do not have it? (01:00:41) I think you just told us our strategy. So we have grown year over year with schools that are offering the Seal of Civic Readiness. Superintendent Jeans just spoke to the great growth that he saw in his district, and that is our intention: to keep engaging superintendents and principals to see where they see the value and work with them in order to design the learning for students in their schools. Okay, thank you. (01:01:15) Thank you. Thank you, Council Member. Council Member Brewer. (01:01:20) Thank you very much. I have been to, I think, all of the Civics for All programs in my district and they are phenomenal. I mean, memorizing Abraham Lincoln's inauguration speech — it is pretty phenomenal and I cannot say how great it is. My question is, having done Teens Take the Floor for a hundred years and been a big fan of Generation Citizen and done voter registration and every other thing I can think of in the schools, and put young people on community boards, put young people on... right now I am putting them on all of them, at the Youth Civic Hub, which has, I think, about a hundred different groups on it. So how do they play a role in all of this? That is number one. And then the second thing is, if I have one more person come up to me at Fairway and say the schools do not do civics... my question to you — no, really, I am serious, I am so sick of it. I have to spend 20 minutes at the coffee place right there while I am trying to get my coffee explaining to them what you do. Because not everybody is a public school parent and everybody knows the schools like we do. Private schools do civics — I have Spence kids, I have Dalton kids, Humanitas kids. And so my question is: you have got to tell people what you are doing. It is really to the point that nobody knows. They literally believe that not one minute of civics is taught in the public schools. So I would like to see what publicity you are doing on this topic. The mayor needs to talk about it more, fine, but you need to do more. He set it up in our area, I want to be clear. So go ahead. What are we going to do about those hundred groups? How do you get them? Not all of them — I just looked at the list — not all of them do civics. So I would like some kind of metrics on how they can help, because they all think they are helping. They really are. (01:03:20) Rita Joseph and I love Brotherhood/Sister Sol — that is our number one youth program in the United States of America, if not in the world. So they do the best. With all due respect to everybody else, they do the best. But you can work with others. So I want to know how you are working with all those hundred groups and how they can help, because they are out there doing the same thing, or they are trying. I think you and I both are at the same level of exhaustion of regularly telling people we do in fact teach civics in New York City public schools. So first off, you mentioned the Youth Civics Hub. I do want to address that. If I am correct, that is the website that was done in collaboration across a few youth civics organizations, and so that is something we have met with those organizations to support them in that work. We share it out to our schools so that the students know and have access to that Youth Civics Hub. When it was first being built — I am trying to recall, it was quite some time ago — I had met with the students who were building it to talk through what we thought would be most accessible to students in schools. So we are grateful to them for taking that extracurricular piece so that students are aware of opportunities available to them in their communities. In terms of messaging, I think number one are superintendents and their awareness. When we first started, 11 superintendents were involved, but they do not go outside public schools — they stay right in them. Recognizing that... (01:04:48) I love you guys, but you do not do the outreach. Go ahead. I think there were first some misunderstandings at the school level and at the superintendency as to how civics would fit into the teaching and learning that was already happening, and so we engaged in an internal New York City Public Schools focused awareness-building campaign in those early years. As far as externally, I am often on panels that I am invited to. The Bar Association is one that I am on every year. Constitution Day — just trying to get the word out. Anytime someone says to me we do not teach civics in New York City public schools, I give them my email address and tell them to invite me. I do my best. I know. We need more. Just saying — I do not know if the mayor wants to really do his thing, but everybody... the mayor could do the same thing. Somebody has to really tell people on a constant basis, because it would help schools, our administration, our caring about the issue, et cetera. And I would suggest if you can do something in the next few weeks, just so people know that it is a current topic — needless to say — in the United States right now. (01:05:52) I appreciate that, and I appreciate your passion for it. Also, thank you to both chairs for having this hearing in the first place. I think this is doing a lot. But how do groups like Teens Take the Floor and Generation Citizen fit into Civics for All? How does it work in terms of a more cohesive approach so people are not off doing the same thing and duplicating? Yeah, so external partners have a number of opportunities and ways that they can engage with schools. First off, while we provide everything that a school could need to build the Seal of Civic Readiness through New York City Public Schools, we do encourage them to collaborate with civics education organizations that are local to them. In terms of citywide, we have a newsletter that we send out to all of our schools with those opportunities. And then also, external organizations can accredit projects that they do with students for the Seal of Civic Readiness. An example would be Y-Vote. Right now I just had a conversation with their executive director a few weeks ago and they are planning to submit the project that they do with students in their extracurricular program for accreditation. I do not want more time, but could you send us a newsletter so I can see if I like it? (01:06:52) Sure, thank you. Happy to do it. Thank you, CM Brewer. She mentioned that is something we talk about all the time — how do you get the messaging out to families that this is happening? New York City Public Schools is one of the agencies that prints the most comic books in the country, but guess what? The families do not know that. The students do not know. My colleagues do not know that. I do, because I make it my business to know. But we need to do a better job in promoting what New York City Public Schools is doing best. We always see the worst of New York City Public Schools. How about we start highlighting the best of New York City Public Schools? (01:07:32) CM Farías, thank you, Chairs, and apologies if this was discussed earlier. We have had several hearings today that I have had to pop in and out of. I just want to get a better idea of how, even if adjacently, we are teaching electoral and governmental civics to students through this programming. I hear, and I want to reiterate what all of my colleagues are saying: when we go into community, people are coming to us and their initial thought of hearing civic engagement always directly aligns to voting power and electoral power, and how they do not think young people are engaged in that way or being pre-registered or understanding our two-party system in New York State and how there are influxes across the tri-state and the nation. So can you help me understand how we are encouraging that, since this is K through 12 and we know young people can enroll early into their voter registration status and then be ready to vote when... (01:08:39) ...they are 18. Absolutely. First, our education effort. So there is both the social studies curriculum and the civics curriculum. I think recognizing that the social studies curriculum really covers, due to state standards, a lot of the foundational understanding of American government, and then civics is supporting students in understanding how does that system impact them and how do they impact it. So we start — second grade is the first time that students are given explicit instruction on elections. The books are all here. So second grade is the first time that they learn about elections and how those work, and then as we move through the grades there is very specific instruction on the levels of government and the branches of government. When we are talking about electoral power, our ninth through twelfth grade Civics for All curriculum has five sections. The fifth section is called "Vote" and is an instructional guide to elections, and it has 18, I believe, suggested... (01:09:32) ...activities and lessons for teachers to engage students in, that speak not only to the power of being a voter but the ways you can have an impact on elections without being a voter as well, since that is what is relevant to the majority of our students. And then we have Civics Week every year — it is the second week of October — and that is when we register our students. We have a citywide student voter registration drive. There are lots of schools that register students at different times of the year. When the registration age was lowered to 16, we really pushed that citywide effort and we ensure that it is getting to all of our schools by paying teachers to coordinate that at the school level so that they are spending some additional time on that to make sure that all of the eligible students are registered, but also more importantly that all of our students are being informed. (01:10:18) That is really great to hear. I have participated with schools in my district for Civics Week. I have comprehensively received an understanding of what the City is doing, and I think that goes to this beat that we keep drumming: it is not getting into community how active or proactive we are being on civic education in our school system. It is also more comprehensive, involving community members like our teachers and community members that are staying after school, heading our music programs and after-school programs and dance clubs and all of those sorts of things, and they are touching base with students in different capacities during this time frame as well. So I would love to stay engaged on that. I would love to get whatever comic book is specifically for the electoral side. There are quite a few on the voting side, and there are education pieces here too. But I would love to see some of the electoral stuff and be able to participate with you folks more broadly in my district if we can. (01:11:17) Excellent, thank you. We will definitely get you our voter registration comics, and thank you for joining our schools during Civics Week. (01:11:22) Well, thank you for that. Just a quick follow-up on that: how many parents know that their 16-year-old can pre-register? That is also something I have talked about. How do we make partners with families? They are also part of this educational journey and I think we do not engage families enough. So I think that should be something, and you know, where folks are also in hair salons and churches, I think we have to meet communities where they are. Council Member, thank you. (01:11:55) Thank you. Apologies. I have to move back and forth. I was asked before who decides what counts as civic actions. So we have in our curriculum guides, when we are encouraging schools to engage in civic action, it is standards-based, and so we are supporting teachers in understanding what are the steps they need to take to engage students in civic action projects. But what the students want to take civic action on comes from the students themselves. Okay. (01:12:36) Can working as a poll worker or running a voter pre-registration drive out of school count towards the Seal? (01:12:45) Students who engage in extracurricular activities for a total of 40 hours and then write an application of knowledge product can count that extracurricular work towards the Seal of Civic Readiness. (01:12:58) Does a Summer Youth Employment Program placement count? Oh, I already see — yes, yes. Because I mean, I love young people, so they are giving their time. I want to make sure that we can let them know. So within this structure, I am probably... (01:13:16) A chair asked that question too. The educational part within our school structure — when the parents are doing parent engagement in the school, I think it will be a good way to give it to the parents. Sometimes, you know, our kids can be a little... I do not want to call them lazy, but they can have a laissez-faire attitude. So parents have to motivate them. So I think it will be a good idea to make sure that at parents' night the parents are engaged and know what extra things the kids can do. (01:13:57) It is just like for the credit. And I still have time — oh, that is good. I think first I want to say thank you. Civic engagement is so important. What I find is that for the young folks, if we create an incentive, a prompt, a little acknowledgement — and the Seal is the best way to do it — it is to say this is a way you can go and get acknowledgement, and when you get to college you are not going to be a stranger to these courses that you already take. I had some other questions but they are not coming to me. I was trying to get to the point, but I will probably come back for that because I had some questions that were very important in my head and they escaped me. So thank you for your time. I do not want to waste the time of the Chair. I will probably have more questions. (01:14:54) Thank you, Council Member. Also want to acknowledge CM Gutiérrez for joining us. I have two quick questions and I am also going to share them with co-Chair Dinowitz. (01:15:07) How will Civics for All play a role with Portrait of a Graduate, and how does the Black studies curriculum also tie into Civics for All? (01:15:21) So for that first question, with a Portrait of a Graduate, the Portrait of a Graduate is this holistic explanation of what a graduate should have experienced by the time they graduate high school. What both civic readiness and specifically the Seal of Civic Readiness does is allow for the vehicle for the student to demonstrate those things. So we see the closest connection to global citizen, critical thinker and effective communicator. Obviously there is connection to the others as well, but this is really an opportunity that our students are already engaged in to demonstrate that commencement level competency through project-based assessments. That was your first question. Your second (01:15:59) question on the Black Studies is a Study of the World curriculum. We have a crosswalk, so we have designed our Passport to Social Cities curriculum and the Civics for All curriculum in-house. What we have created for schools to be able to implement all of those things, because we recognize that is a lot of material to be giving to a teacher. So first we have a crosswalk that details the social studies units that schools are beholden to under the state social studies framework, and then for each of those units it includes the lessons from Civics for All that are most relevant there, and then where the lessons from the Black Studies is a Study of the World curriculum makes sense in terms of the units of study, we also include those. (01:16:40) Through our work with our district points, I have been supporting them and thinking about that work as well. Yeah, because that was very important and we wanted to make sure that the curriculum also reflected that. How many — off the top of your head, you may not know, but you can come back to us — how many of the schools are incorporating the Black Studies curriculum in the Civics for All? (01:16:59) I want to be mindful of not saying that they are incorporating it within Civics for All, because it is really within their social studies instruction. I do not have that number, but (01:17:09) that would be great, because we spent a lot of money on that curriculum, and you have the Latina Dad curriculum coming up as well. We want to make sure that you are incorporating those cultural competencies. When we talk about curriculums and students seeing themselves in those curriculums that we teach across the City, that would be great. And pre-registering to vote at the age of 16 — I really would love to see that across the City. Right now is the moment students are seeing exactly what is happening in our country and how they can have a voice in that process, so they should be engaged in that process. (01:17:45) One of the things that I see... (01:17:47) Chair, the Black Institute — have we collaborated with them? Because they are actually pushing a lot for our youth in the City of New York. I do not like to push for one particular area, but I think we are at a challenging time where our kids, just like any other group in America right now... and I do not know if you know about the Haitian attacks specifically. We are not going in the right direction when it comes to that, and our children need to feel — especially for us, like we are all people, we are — but the younger ones in the high school and the middle school need to know that they are important. What does Black history mean? What does being a Black person mean? And I think that would be a good thing, because we are all part... we know we are going to face different challenges. Sometimes it can be Chinese, it can be Japanese, it can be others, but right now it happens to be Haitian and other Black folks. So I think we have to be mindful and try to encourage that. That would be very meaningful to me and my community. (01:18:51) Thank you, Chair. And I am not taking the old one with you — you can buy your own. (01:18:59) She had Dinowitz. Thank you, Council Member. For voter registration, I just want to confirm that you are in compliance. It was with a law — I think that we passed Local Law 189 of 2025 — that requires the DOE to provide coded voter registration forms to all students. Is that right? (01:19:19) Yes. Ahead of Civics Week we send every school that has students of voter registration age information and education, and then also those registration forms. Last year was the first time they reported. (01:19:33) Okay. I am back in my day — I am old enough, I am at that age where I say "back in my day." Back in my day, Reid is much younger than me so she does not know my day, but I do. And back in my day, when I was a young whippersnapper and other things old people say, I had to go with the voter registration forms to the social studies class and do that. So it is a Council Member that — that is a reality because of her, so I want to thank her. You know, CM Wilson touched on this with data on Seal earners and participating schools broken down by race, ethnicity, income status, students with disabilities, borough, school type including District 75 and transfer schools. It is data that we have that... (01:20:18) we can do. Okay, so you will share that. Okay. (01:20:22) I want to ask more about the CUNY-DOE relationship, because what I have heard again from principals and teachers, and what was testified to, is you have sort of a bank of projects that schools can engage with and students can work on, and you have started auditing some of those projects. Is that right? Like looking at some of the graded material? (01:20:47) So the... (01:20:48) There are two different processes. There is the accreditation process to ensure that the project that the school is using is approved by us and meets the standard of rigor, and then there is an auditing process to ensure that the output is of quality. And so what precludes CUNY from looking at those projects and working more closely to say, you know what, this is college level work and so we should be accrediting our community with an appropriate amount of college credits? I think that is exactly what we need to do next. We need to see those products, the projects from the students. We need to have our faculty really closely examine them. But that is for someone else. (01:21:36) Okay, you still have time. (01:21:40) I think that seeing the actual work products of students and seeing how they reflect the components of the Seal of Civic Readiness, and having CUNY faculty take a close look at that and understand the learning that it represents, is the work that we need to do in order to establish credit pathways for students who earn the Seal of Civic Readiness. (01:22:15) I mean, it is a real symbiotic relationship. The DOE is saying here is what we are doing, and CUNY should be saying, hey, here is additionally what we need — not just for college credit, by the way, but what skills we need high school students to graduate with. And those are conversations I think you should have, and the Seal of Civic Readiness should absolutely be part of it. Because the ultimate goal is to make sure students who are doing this rigorous work, with vetted projects and audited outputs from the DOE, get the credit for the work that they are already doing. Can we get a meeting on the calendar? Do you have your people here? Yes, we can absolutely have a meeting. Okay, because I mean... (01:23:03) that was one of the (01:23:05) hurdles that you mentioned in your testimony, and so obviously to me it seems that meeting about the projects and the work the students are doing is the obvious next step. Happy to participate in that meeting. But we do have a lot of CUNY and DOE people here as well. You mentioned training a lot. Can you please share how much support and implementation of the Seal costs for a participating school and per Seal recipient, and the breakdown of the budget for the Seal including professional development? So we (01:23:49) do not break down our budget by the Seal, as it is part of our larger effort around Civics for All. So we can tell you that the overall civics budget is $3,001,659. Three million, one thousand, six hundred and fifty-nine dollars. Of that — you do not — because that is very specific. It is very specific. Okay. (01:24:18) Of that — and I think this might give you a clearer sense of how that goes directly towards the Seal — some of that is sent out to schools for participatory budgeting, and that is one of the projects that can be used for Civics for All experiences for students but also counted towards the Seal. How much of it? Go ahead. (01:24:51) And then professional learning... (01:24:54) In that — yeah, so the professional learning is not necessarily... we do not break it out specifically to say these are Seal professional learning versus overall professional learning for civics, which is inclusive of districts and schools that are implementing the Seal. For that we spend $861,770 specifically. (01:25:22) Again, nice round number. How many cents? No cents. Okay. How much of that, let us say... (01:25:30) just the professional learning — goes to private for-profit contractors or contracts versus in-house? So that professional learning budget is for professional learning and curriculum and resource (01:25:49) development. So the majority of it would go to partners like Mikva Challenge, who supports our Project Soapbox work — you would be familiar with that — and then also our professional learning sessions, which we often do in collaboration with cultural institutions around the City. So funding for those, for where the sessions are being held and for space, and then for curriculum and resource development. I cannot break down for you right now how much is spent on each of those things, but all of that funding is for professional learning and separate funding for the creation of our materials that get used in professional learning, if that makes (01:26:29) sense. So to ask in a different way: are you spending money on private companies to come into schools and train teachers? Zero dollars and zero (01:26:41) cents. Mikva Challenge is — to the best of my knowledge, and I will double-check this in my budget — the organization that we pay to provide professional learning, because Project Soapbox is their product. The rest of our professional learning is provided by our nine-person Civics for All team. (01:26:58) Okay. I will share — speaking with some of the teachers, they were very grateful for their work, whether it was working on the weekends or turnkeying the (01:27:14) learning that they did. And you know, it is less expensive to hire our own teachers, but when they get that money it really recognizes their work. They feel seen and recognized for the work that they do. I worry that as we seek to expand the Seal of Civic Readiness and as we seek to incorporate civics into the Portrait of a Graduate, it will be very tempting for the DOE to do what they often do, which is to hire outside contractors to do the work that our teachers are going to do a better job at. You are going to keep the money in-house and keep the money for our teachers. So I would urge you to ensure that as you grow and expand, you keep all of that curriculum development as in-house as possible, to ensure our teachers are seen and to ensure that they are making the money that they deserve to be making. (01:28:11) If I want to search for a high school for my child on your website, how do I know whether a school offers the Seal of Civic Readiness? (01:28:29) I would need to double-check. We did share the list, so we share the list of Seal schools each year with the Office of Policy and Evaluation since they manage the inside. (01:28:39) Is it — what is the name of our portal again? I am blanking. But I will follow up with them and get that answer for you. Well, I can — you know, because I can search. (01:28:50) Like I am on the site right now — you cannot see my screen, that is okay — but I could search and I could filter by interest areas, I could filter by college and career paths. I can search by tenth grade admissions, uniform requirement. I could search for a school that requires a uniform, that is cool. So I could search for a school that has, I think, either the Seal of Civic Readiness or the Seal of Biliteracy. (01:29:21) And so that is a different department. I am understanding — I think you were mentioning something like MySchools — and we do not manage the webpage for school enrollment. (01:29:37) But you have the data. Will you also commit to working with the website division? Absolutely. (01:29:43) What division is it? The website people? I am not sure. Yeah. (01:29:49) So we do share the list each year. I will follow up on where it is going, but I was under the impression that the list of Seal schools was in a place that students could see it when they were (01:30:02) looking. Oh, I mean, I think the point is when you are... (01:30:05) Unless I am missing it, I do not see it on my... (01:30:08) MySchools. Is that what you are on? Yeah, that is the search. Yeah, that is how a parent looks. (01:30:13) It might appear on the site like a webpage and it is a list. I understand. Okay. The question is: can you commit to working with a different department to ensure that the civics education, the Seal of Civic Readiness, appears on the MySchools website so that when a parent or a student is searching for a school they know they can search for a civic school? (01:30:40) Yes. Okay, that was a good answer. Yes is a good answer. (01:30:45) Does the DOE track students who have earned the New York State Seal of Civic Readiness and track longitudinally how they are doing in college or in career post-graduation? Currently we do not formally track that, but we are looking forward to doing more of that work. (01:31:05) Is that on your agenda to do? Yes it is. (01:31:08) Which is part of the reason why we want to have the data tracking in STARS, which will enable us to better see who those students are, what schools they are coming from. And how can journalism become a part of the standard list of civics projects approved by the DOE? Sure. We have an accreditation portal, a forum where organizations can submit instructional materials for review, including external or internal organizations, and then we connect those folks to get whatever the materials are accredited. That is a public website. Yeah, I can send you the link. (01:31:49) Okay, yeah. And you know, CM Dinowitz and I — for the first time we got significant funding for youth journalism this year. I know CM Joseph was pushing for it for years. We finally got funding this year — $285,000, sounds right, maybe also 744 additional dollars. But you know, this is the type of specialized work we move into with the Portrait of a Graduate that we want to be encouraging, and journalism is so deeply tied to civics that we want to make sure that that work is recognized for the Seal of Civic Readiness. I am going to turn it back to Chair Joseph now. Thank you. (01:32:29) Thank you, Chair Dinowitz. Just want to do a couple of follow-ups from Chair Dinowitz's questions. (01:32:36) How are we accessing parents or students for whom English is not their first language? Translating materials? Sure. I am sorry. So when schools are offering the Seal of Civic Readiness, they have to create a program plan, and one of the steps of that program plan is a universal accessibility plan — so how are they going to ensure that the Seal of Civic Readiness is accessible to all students? Secondary to that, and we do not have many schools yet taking advantage of this, but it is something that we are regularly working on — we meet with the team who runs the Seal of Biliteracy. Students who do their Seal of Biliteracy project on a civics topic can have that applied, in any language, to the Seal of Civic Readiness. Also, students' Soapbox speeches, which is another project they can do for the Seal, can also be done in their home language as well. How many people know that? That is what we are working on with the team with the Seal of Biliteracy — to match up the schools that are doing both programs. That is where we are. (01:33:43) CM Brewer and I were talking... (01:33:45) always people walking up to us and asking us these questions, because New York City Public Schools feel like this big black hole. No one knows what is happening, but amazing things are happening and no one ever knows about (01:33:57) it unless you come to a hearing or someone else talks about it. Chair Dinowitz, we will talk about it. So we have got to do better, and that is something I have been asking for a long time. I think we have got to do better. (01:34:09) How do schools support each other? Let us say my school wants to open up — how do we support a school that wants to have a Seal of Civic Readiness? I think Chris (01:34:21) wants to take this one. It is actually one of the most awesome parts about supporting districts and schools with Seal work, in that oftentimes we will assemble whole districts for the start-of-year orientation, and so there is a lot of really wonderful cross-pollination and cross-school support happening. So if a colleague at another school has a project that they have accredited that I am really interested in using, I will carry that over, and vice versa. I actually think the superintendent could comment more on this. Yeah. (01:34:55) Thank you. What I would share is in Queens North we have 25 high schools, and I answered it in a way. One is setting up the expectation that the Civic Seal is an obligation of all of our schools to provide students with opportunity to engage, to do the actual civic engagement work. The second to that is once we set that expectation, now schools are on the hook to develop their programs and their service learning opportunities beyond the school walls. And as Jenna talked about, we want to bring it into the schools so that all students have access. We actually in Queens North encourage our principals to reach across their school walls into their colleagues and beyond the borough for opportunity. So to date I would say we have doubled the number of schools offering the Civic Seal year over year, to now 96% of our schools. And not because they did not want to, but they said this is important for us to do and we are committed to learning from each other. And every month when we have our principal meeting, that is the forum and the venue where our principals (01:36:16) openly share, because the answer is always in the room. We do not need to go look for other people. I think, to share the notion, to your point, we have to pay other people for information when we have it. But what we need to do as a system is to create the space on the stage, if you will, for us to ask the question and get the answer. I am hearing a lot of turnkey — we learn from each other — to make sure that we are keeping a financial and (01:36:45) How do you measure success? Is there surveys at the end of the projects? How do students give feedback if, let us say, the project is not working or they do not like what you are offering? How is their voice used (01:36:59) in shaping this project? So I think first is we are measuring our success through access, right. We talked about expansion. Are we including all students in this? We are working towards that. And then I think at each school that is their work to refine the project, because I think again, just remembering that (01:37:22) the Seal is flexible in design and in purpose, right. Just because you did the Seal exactly one way last year, the idea is that you could refine that, right, based on whether you hear that from students in your school or, like Superintendent Two is talking about, you have learned something from your colleagues in your district. (01:37:45) Or even you have learned outside of your district. I think that is one of the other benefits of the Seal — while it is flexible and designed by individual schools and districts, the standard is the same. So I can adapt what is going on in one school to the next to the next, and then make it better each year and learn from it. (01:38:10) And are any of those data used to drive perfecting the program? I hear expansion but I also want to hear outreach. I want to hear partnership. I want to hear agencies are talking to each other. Folks do not like to talk to each other — I find that very weird. I am an educator, and teachers talk to each other all day long, but I am finding that institutions and agencies in the City are horrible at doing that. I am hoping that CUNY and New York City Public Schools reach out and have that conversation around how we can perfect it. New York City Public Schools is handing over their students and they are coming prepared to you. I had another question: can the Civic Seal be substituted for a Regent? (01:38:54) In lieu of a Regent, you can do the Civic Readiness Seal instead. Yeah, so it is a graduation pathway, so it can substitute for the fifth Regents exam, assuming you have one ELA, one math, one social studies and one science. Regents are going away soon. Bye-bye, Regents. (01:39:17) Oh no, the parents are going to come for you. I wanted to talk quickly around middle school. There was something I saw around middle school that I wanted to talk about real quick. You have that question? So... you had — 15, yeah, 15 students in seventh and eighth grade earned one point toward the Seal through a middle school capstone project. How does the school tell students about the Seal? How many seventh and eighth graders completed a middle school capstone project last year? (01:39:56) We can get that number for you, and I think Superintendent Inzerillo can speak to how students are made aware about that middle school (01:40:14) capstone. Chair Joseph and committee members, great to be here. My name is Anthony Inzerillo, the superintendent for elementary and middle schools across District 26. I have to tell you I am so proud of the work that takes place across all of our middle schools. In District 26 we give every single sixth, seventh and eighth grader an opportunity to be able to research and develop a soapbox speech where they can research a concern, a passion, something that they see an inequity about. They will then research it, they will develop a soapbox speech, and not just share it with their class but share it with the community. We have across our middle schools, and also our elementary schools, kindergarten students and middle school students sharing those soapbox speeches, which then leads into some of the other civics work like participatory budgeting and then some of that take-action work as well. So for a middle school student, (01:41:28) one point toward that credit (01:41:29) is we provide the opportunities for all middle school students to be able to have that opportunity and do that. So whether that is sharing those opportunities through parent workshops, principal newsletters, Community Educational Council meetings, Presidents Council meetings where we share with district leadership team meetings — I send out newsletters to families as well. So we try to publicize it and make everyone aware of that as well. So even when our middle school students go home, parents ask their children: what are you studying, what are you passionate about, what are you concerned about? We want those conversations to be taking place at the dinner table. And then it is a great opportunity for parents to be able to talk about their culture, their history, what they are passionate about, and to extend those (01:42:18) and the school's... (01:42:19) For example, I know it is high school season now with the open houses. Do the schools talk about the Civic Seal at the open house? (01:42:26) I know they used to give out a big book. Do you guys still give out that big book for kids to look through to pick a school? (01:42:32) I do not think that big book exists anymore. I think it has all transferred over to MySchools, which I think brings up the point of why that information needs to be available through that digital (01:42:45) portal. Chair Joseph, that is a great idea. We have a District 26 high school fair coming up on November 9, and not only do we share with families high schools that provide college courses, programs and associate's degree programs — yes, it is such a great idea. I will make sure that those high schools that do come have some kind of a marker or asterisk or some designation so families are well aware that they have an incredible civics program at those high schools as well. So that is one way to get the information out: your text messages, your websites, and talking to your principals, right — they are the first line of defense who see parents and families. And engage your parent coordinators as well. They are also one of the folks that talk to parents and families at whole community meetings. And get the word out in SLT meetings as well. (01:43:40) We do get the broader community as well. We had an elementary school student that was very concerned about some of the cannabis dispensaries. (01:43:48) There was one that was relatively close, within the 500 feet, and as the student discovered, it depends on how you measure those 500 feet. That student not only researched it but they were so politically astute — they reached out to NYPD, they reached out to some of the local elected officials, reached out to my office. There were over 200 people that were at that cannabis dispensary just to learn more about, like, hey, what is going on over here, we share that same concern. So it is spreading, it is reaching people. The water fountains were not working, so they reached out to the New York City Parks Commissioner, sent them a letter, and the New York City Parks Commissioner contacted me, the principal and the student to say not only did we fix it, but I would love for you and your classmates to just check on it and make sure that it is working. So we are talking about partnerships — we have our students reaching out to the New York City Parks Department, Sanitation Department, the Buildings Department, all other departments within New York City, so that they can learn more and create those partnerships, ask those great questions and hold us all accountable. When I do principal performance observations, the principals (01:45:05) will now warn me — I love it though. They will say, I want to let you know, Anthony, we have the civics group, or the student organization, a group that are going to — they want to have some questions for you. So I think that is awesome. Thank you to all of you for supporting that. I know that you visit the schools and you get peppered with questions by students, but you are sharing the democratic process and ways in which students can get engaged, and we greatly appreciate that. (01:45:34) I just want to make sure I heard you — you said that at the high school fair you are putting a little star or asterisk at the ones that offer the Civic Readiness Seal? (01:45:42) At the District 26 high school fair, Chair Joseph gave me a great idea that we should have some kind of a marker for that. So when we do have that high school fair on November 9 we are going to make sure that we have some kind of a marker so families can see and distinguish what different high schools can offer, whether it is civics or an associate's program, college credits and some of the other things that schools offer. (01:46:10) And I would just add, not to digress too much, but add the biliteracy seal as well. Yes, yes, add the biliteracy seal there and to repeat — (01:46:18) get it added to the website, because these are things families search for — not just whether a school has it but what it is, because there is also an education component that needs to go in, like what is a Seal of Civic Readiness. I think all the families deserve to know the schools they are going into have these really incredible programs that are rigorous, that are going to be looked at by CUNY for awarding college credit. And again I am looking forward to that next meeting to really get into this so that our high school students who do this work can get the college credit, and more and more schools will be incentivized to offer this program. Thank you. (01:46:55) Thank you so much. And young people see career pathways, right — that is also career pathways. So not only are they engaged but they can see how they can make a difference in their community. I think this is what the message is, and thank you for doing that. Hold us accountable, and I like that. (01:47:10) We would love to visit. Thank you so much. Thank you. Any follow-up questions we will send them over to you, for both CUNY and New York City Public Schools. (01:47:26) Thank you. I want to hear that you guys are best friends. Thank you so much for your time. (01:47:29) I want to hear that you guys are besties the next time we meet and we talk about serious selfies on Instagram. Exactly. Thank you (01:47:38) so much. Actually, we have a little time. You are doing the karaoke? I am just a little (01:47:43) hoarse. But what are we — you know what, I will tell you what, right after the meeting you guys have about working together, you are going to leave for the karaoke. Okay, so your voice will be better by then. Okay.