Gender-Affirming Care and Mental Health for Trans and Nonbinary Youth Committee on Hospitals | Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use | Committee on Women and Gender Equity · September 23, 2026 · 3hrs 4m Source: https://hearinghearings.nyc/hearings/committee-on-hospitals-access-to-gender-affirming-care-and-associated-mental-health-outcomes-for-2026-09-23/ Video: https://councilnyc.viebit.com/vod/?s=true&v=NYCC-PV-CH-CHA_260923-131041.mp4 ================================================================ (00:00:00) Welcome to today's New York City Council hearing on Mental Health and Substance Use, joint with Women and Gender Equity and Hospitals. At this time I would like to remind everyone to silence all electronic devices. Also at this point going forward, nobody is approaching. There is no one chair. We are ready to begin. (00:00:24) Good afternoon and welcome to today's hearing on access to gender affirming care and associated mental health outcomes for trans and non-binary youth. My name is CM Tiffany Cabán. My pronouns are she/her. I am the chair of the New York City Council's Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use. Thank you also to CM Narcisse, chair of the Hospitals Committee, and CM Farías, chair of the Women and Gender Equity Committee, for joining our committee in holding this hearing. Before we begin, I would like to recognize that we are joined by Public Advocate Williams, CM Harvey Epstein, CM Simcha Felder, CM Santosuosso and CM Ariola on Zoom. Today the committees are convening to discuss access to gender affirming care in New York City and its role in improving health and mental health care outcomes for transgender and gender non-binary youth. It is no secret that transgender and non-binary New Yorkers have recently faced a barrage of threats, challenges and intimidation from the federal government. Several institutions in our City have unfortunately capitulated to these pressures and as a City we are all worse off for it. Gender affirming care not only allows individuals to live as their true selves, but it is also strongly associated with improved mental health outcomes for trans and non-binary people. Transgender and non-binary youth especially are disproportionately burdened by poor mental health outcomes driven by reduced social support and heightened stigma and discrimination. Yet research consistently shows that access to gender affirming interventions is associated with roughly 60% lower odds of moderate to severe depression and over 70% lower odds of suicidality in youth. 70% lower odds of suicidality. We not only owe it to young transgender and gender non-binary New Yorkers to provide them with the care that we know can improve their lives and their mental health, but also to protect them from harm. At this moment when so many trans and queer people in our City are seeing their rights being attacked and stripped away by the federal government, and watching institutions that they rely on for their health care buckle under pressure, I stand as a queer New Yorker in solidarity with you. My commitment to you is that I will do everything in my power to work with you to keep you safe and to fight for our collective liberation. Today we will also be hearing three pieces of legislation relating to our oversight topic. Int 0949-2026, sponsored by CM Schulman, which would require the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene to create and make available on their website LGBTQI+ health and gender affirming care resources and a search map of LGBTQI+ health services. Res 0208-2026, sponsored by CM Hanif, which calls on the New York State Legislature to pass and the Governor to sign legislation that mandates all medical students in New York State receive anti-bias training. And my own legislation, Res 0547-2026, which calls on the New York State Legislature to pass and the Governor to sign legislation which establishes and increases access to gender affirming care. I would like to thank the committee staff who worked to prepare for this hearing as well as my own staff. I will now pass the mic to CM Narcisse. We are also joined by CM Aldebol. Now I will pass it over to co-chair CM Narcisse. (00:03:48) Good afternoon. I am CM Mercedes Narcisse of the Committee on Hospitals. I am joined by my colleagues, CM Tiffany Cabán, chair of the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use, and CM Amanda Farías, chair of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity. Thank you for joining us today for this oversight hearing on access to gender affirming care and associated mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary youth. Gender affirming care is a model of care that includes medical, surgical, mental health and non-medical services to support and affirm an individual's gender identity. This type of care can include social affirmation like adopting gender affirming hair, clothing and names, or medical affirmation such as puberty blockers, hormone therapy and gender affirming surgeries. Transgender and non-binary youth experience significantly higher rates of anxiety, depression, mood disorders and suicidal ideation than their cisgender peers, largely due to stigma, discrimination and social rejection and barriers to care that these individuals experience. Research shows that access to gender affirming care can substantially improve mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary youth. Despite local efforts to support, we know that the federal side is not on our side. The federal government is taking actions to limit access to gender affirming care. These actions at the federal level present challenges for Health and Hospitals and its ability to continue providing the care that people need and deserve. As a registered nurse and chair of the Hospitals Committee, I am committed to ensuring that every individual in our City gets the care they deserve and needs to live their lives. What we need to do is continue pushing forward and making sure the bigotry around us and the policies that are not in our favor do not stop us from continuing to provide that care. Today we look forward to hearing from New York City Health and Hospitals about the broader state of gender affirming care access for our youth across the City of New York, including the availability of services at Health and Hospitals facilities and the programs and other City-supported efforts. We will also hear their feedback on legislation before the committee. Together we must work to ensure that transgender and non-binary youth have access to the care they deserve and that our local hospitals and health department can continue to provide those services. Before we begin, I would like to thank committee staff, senior legislative counsel, policy analyst and committee staff for their hard work in preparing for this hearing. I would also like to thank my staff, Frank Shady, Courtney Lee and Dr. Sheena Hollow. I would now like to turn it over to Chair Farías. (00:07:56) Thank you so much. Good afternoon, everyone. I am CM Amanda Farías, she/her, and I chair the Committee on Women and Gender Equity. We are excited to join the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use and the Committee on Hospitals and their chairs for today's oversight hearing on access to gender affirming care and associated mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary youth. As stated by my colleagues, access to gender affirming care is a life-saving medical necessity that dramatically improves the mental health and overall well-being of gender diverse, transgender and non-binary children and adolescents. Every child deserves to grow up feeling supported in who they are, and supporting youth means defending their right to health care. Currently, access to gender affirming care for young people is under attack nationwide. An analysis by the Human Rights Campaign found that 27 states plus Puerto Rico have successfully passed bans on gender affirming care for transgender and non-binary youth, affecting 48% of (00:09:00) transgender youth nationwide. A recent survey found that 7% of transgender and non-binary young people who used hormones to support their gender transition or expression were concerned about losing access to this care. These laws interfere with the ability of trans youth, their families and their providers to make the health care decisions that are right for them and access the medical care they need, and can have devastating consequences. It is well documented that trans and non-binary children experience anxiety and depression at higher rates than their cisgender peers. According to a 2025 survey published by the Trevor Project, transgender and non-binary young people who were unable to access the hormones they wanted were nearly twice as likely to attempt suicide than those who could. Additionally, four out of ten trans and non-binary young people seriously considered attempting suicide in the last year. These young people are not inherently at a higher risk of these issues. Rather, they are in a world that fights their existence at every turn. These repeated attacks would weigh on any adult, so it is no surprise that young people feel the effects of a transphobic environment so acutely. Gender affirming care is backed by decades of research and supported by every major medical association in the United States, representing more than a million doctors. Every person has the fundamental right to access health care free from discrimination, prejudice or barriers to treatment that support their mental, physical and emotional well-being. So today we will hear from the administration and we will ask: how are you ensuring access to gender affirming care for trans and non-binary youth in New York City, and where are you ensuring that accessibility for them? Thank you. (00:10:48) To the members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity who have joined us today, I would like to thank our committee staff Julia Goldsmith-Pinkham, Katie Selena and Ali Stauffer, as well as my own staff Daniel Curtain, for their work on today's hearing. Thank you so much, and I will turn it back over to Chair Cabán. (00:11:06) OK. And now I am going to turn the mic over to Public Advocate Jumaane Williams to deliver some remarks. (00:11:12) Thank you very much. As mentioned, my name is Jumaane Williams, Public Advocate of New York. I want to thank Chairs Cabán, Farías and Narcisse, the members of the Mental Health and Substance Use, Women and Gender Equity and Hospitals Committees for allowing me the opportunity to provide a statement. New York City has worked to expand access to gender affirming health care services through public hospitals, school-based health centers and community organizations serving LGBTQI+ youth. In 2025, New York City enacted legislation — I was a sponsor of Local Law 126 and Local Law 127 — which require the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene to create and distribute signs dealing with the health care rights of transgender patients and clinics' use of preferred pronouns and respectful treatment for display across City hospitals, and to report on training provided by hospitals regarding medical care for trans individuals, respectively. The City should also strengthen provider training on culturally competent care, insurance coverage for medically necessary treatments and improved coordination between mental health and primary care services. In addition, the City should continue protecting patient privacy and resisting efforts that could deter families from seeking care. These recommendations align with my long support for health care equity and accountability in public systems. The intersection of LGBTQI+ identity and the modern health care system remains defined by systemic barriers and persistent health disparities. While overall insurance enrollment has improved, LGBTQI+ individuals, particularly people of color and transgender adults, face heightened rates of chronic disease, mental distress and substance use disorders. All of which are exacerbated by stress. A critical driver of these disparities is a widespread deficiency in medical education, which frequently fails to equip clinicians with baseline competencies in sexual orientation and gender identity care. Consequently, patients are routinely forced to choose between educating their own physicians, enduring misgendering and substandard treatment, or avoiding the medical system entirely, which creates severe gaps in preventative and responsive public health outcomes. When any community avoids regular care, it is bad public health for everyone. Research demonstrates that access to gender affirming care is associated with improvements in health outcomes among transgender and non-binary youth. A longitudinal study found that youth who received gender affirming medical care experienced significantly lower rates of depression and suicidality compared with those who did not receive such care. Improved access therefore contributes to reduced mental health crises, greater school engagement, enhanced family stability and better overall well-being. Discrimination, barriers to care and social stigma contribute to health disparities among transgender individuals. Government agencies must actively address these inequities. Today we will hear three pieces of legislation by CM Cabán, on which I am a co-sponsor, CM Schulman and CM Hanif. I look forward to hearing from both advocates and the administration about these bills. Ensuring access to gender affirming care for transgender and non-binary youth is both a public health and equity issue. We must eliminate health care barriers and protect New Yorkers from discrimination. Expanding affirming health services, strengthening mental health supports and safeguarding patient privacy can improve outcomes for vulnerable youth while affirming New York City's commitment to inclusion, dignity and evidence-based health care policy. I would also like to add that I have been very public about my continuing journey on these issues, and I have done that because I want to make sure people join me. I am not trans, and I do not have any family members who are, but I have spoken to parents who love their children like my wife and I love ours. I have spoken to mothers who love their child the way my mother loved my sister and me. I think it is incumbent upon folks like me to speak out, because when my children face some issues I hope they are not fighting alone and I hope people join them in making sure that they are protected. I want to make sure people do not use surgery — which is the least used form of medical access — to take away access from everyone. I saw that happen with abortion. Late-term abortions are not very prevalent, but they used that to take away rights from all women. So let us make sure we are really focused on making sure people have what they need to live their best lives. Historically, when people fight against folks they do not like, those folks do not disappear. They are just harmed and their lives are made to be unnecessarily painful. So let us reverse that. Let us make sure that people can live, love and be healthy in their lives, just like we would want for anyone else. Access to health care would allow us to do that. I am so thankful that we are having this hearing today, and I am also always concerned when people are talking more about sports than about children who are killing themselves. So let us reverse that conversation and make sure that we are protecting everyone. Thank you. Thank you so much, Public Advocate. Now I will turn the mic to the committee counsel to administer the oath to members of the administration. (00:16:41) Good afternoon. My name is Taylor Brown. I serve as the inaugural Director of the Mayor's Office of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer, Intersex and Plus Affairs. Thank you to Chairs Cabán, Narcisse and Farías, and the members of the Council Committees on Mental Health and Substance Use, Women and Gender Equity and Hospitals, as well as Public Advocate Williams for holding today's critical hearing. My office appreciates the Council's attention to gender affirming care and associated mental health outcomes for trans and non-binary youth, and I am grateful for the opportunity to testify on these issues on behalf of the administration. I would like to begin by unequivocally stating that the administration firmly opposes the federal government's attacks on transgender and non-binary people, and we are deeply alarmed by the ways in which private health care providers in New York City have caved to pressure. To protect, support and cherish trans and non-binary New Yorkers of all ages, gender affirming care is a lifeline for many transgender and non-binary young people, and New York City will not leave them without the care that they need. Gender affirming care refers broadly to a set of specific interdisciplinary services, interventions and treatments provided to individuals living with gender dysphoria. Almost all major medical associations and leading world health authorities support gender affirming care for transgender or non-binary youth living with gender dysphoria. Today, the World Professional Association for Transgender Health Standards of Care Version Eight and the Endocrine Society's Endocrine Treatment of Gender Dysphoric, Gender Incongruent Persons are the most widely accepted clinical protocols and policies for the treatment of gender dysphoria in both adults and youth patient populations. Recently, there has been much fear mongering, propaganda and intentional mischaracterization about gender affirming care for transgender and non-binary young people. It is important to be clear that gender affirming care, like all health care, is individualized and patient-centric. Decisions about gender affirming care, again like all health care, are made by the patient, the patient's caregiver in the case of youth and adolescents, and the provider. Treatment protocols for transgender and non-binary youth are based on age, the onset of puberty and the relevant clinical criteria. For those who meet certain clinical criteria, treatment includes psychological and psychiatric care as well as non-medical support and social transition. A transgender or non-binary young person may take steps including coming out and informing others about their gender identity and how they would like to be treated, using a gender identity-consistent name and pronouns, adopting clothing, grooming, hairstyles, chest binders and other compression garments, padding and other forms of gender expression, and using gender identity-consistent facilities and spaces in both public and private life. For those at the early stages of puberty and older, the introduction of puberty suppressants, commonly referred to as puberty blockers, which pause the development of secondary sexual characteristics that are inconsistent with gender identity. And finally, the treatment protocols for those at mid to late adolescent age and older include the introduction of hormone therapy, which allows a transgender or non-binary young person to undergo puberty consistent with their gender identity. Opponents of gender affirming care for transgender and non-binary youth often falsely claim that gender affirming surgeries are being performed on transgender and non-binary youth of all ages and at high rates. This is not true. While there is limited data available on the specific issue, a 2024 study by researchers at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health found little to no utilization of gender affirming surgeries by transgender and non-binary youth. Transgender and non-binary young people living with gender dysphoria have higher rates of depression, anxiety, serious psychological distress and suicide risk compared to their peers. These mental health risks are not driven by being transgender and non-binary, but by stigma, discrimination, rejection and a lack of supportive services. I would like to share some data points from the Youth Risk Behavioral Survey conducted by the Health Department in 2023 that illustrate the mental health challenges that transgender and non-binary youth in New York experience. In 2023, public high school students who identified as transgender at 42%, non-binary at 38%, some other gender at 45% or questioning at 28% were more likely to report suicidal ideation when compared to those who identified as cisgender at only 16%. Those who identified as transgender at 49%, non-binary at 29%, some other gender identity at 33% or questioning at 61% were more likely to report attempting suicide compared to their cisgender peers who had a rate of 9% reporting attempting suicide. Evidence has shown that when transgender and non-binary youth have access to the gender affirming care they need, their mental health and overall well-being improve. Access to gender affirming care is essential health care for the youth who need it. The federal government has waged an all-out campaign against transgender and non-binary people, especially our youth and their health care. Confronted with executive orders, federal funding cuts, federal investigations and regulatory policies, across the nation and here in New York City, providers of gender affirming care for trans and non-binary youth have begun ceasing the provision of care and discharging their patients. Notably, in New York City, three major providers of gender affirming care for transgender and non-binary youth — Langone, Mount Sinai and New York-Presbyterian — began ceasing their provisions of care in early 2025 following one of the first presidential executive orders. Over the last three weeks, both Mount Sinai and Langone, in the face of federal investigative subpoenas, entered into settlement agreements with the United States Department of Justice, agreeing seemingly to end the provision of puberty blockers and hormone therapy to transgender and non-binary youth for the treatment of gender dysphoria permanently. This has resulted in immense fear, harm and significant breaches of trust in the transgender and non-binary community. It has also resulted in an increasing vacuum for care for transgender and non-binary youth here in our City and for those who come to our City seeking care. Mayor Mamdani, Commission on Human Rights Commissioner and Chair Christine Clark and I have all spoken out on private medical institutions who have capitulated to the federal administration. On September 9, I spoke at a rally outside of Mount Sinai, criticizing their settlement with the Department of Justice. The Mamdani administration has been and remains committed to ensuring that transgender and non-binary youth are able to access their medically necessary gender affirming care. In June 2026, we announced a proactive $15 million investment to protect, ensure and expand access to gender affirming care for young transgender and non-binary New Yorkers. This investment, spread across three years, provides emergency funding to directly support providers of gender affirming care for trans and non-binary youth, connect transgender and non-binary New Yorkers to care, and (00:23:39) to fund research amid these escalating federal attacks. This funding is broken down into the following three initiatives. The majority of the funding will go to a direct care access fund for providers of youth affirming care. The Department of Health will implement a new fund to support qualified providers of pediatric gender affirming care and their provision of care to youth patients, and to address financial shortfalls resulting from any denials or reductions in federal funding. This funding will ensure the continuity of care for medically necessary puberty blockers and hormone therapy for transgender and non-binary youth in accessible and affordable care settings. The City will also launch a confidential and dedicated call-in chat line at the Health Department that will link people to available services related to gender affirming care in New York City in real time. The City will also fund research to identify gaps in health care access and outcomes. The Health Department will conduct community experts... We welcome the opportunity to discuss partnerships with you all. (00:24:43) Funding will also bolster support for gender marker changes on vital records through the Department of Health, as well as support for overall coordination, evaluation and data analyses for the gender affirming care initiatives that I just went over. (00:24:57) Building on the Trans Rights Are Human Rights campaign that the administration previously launched to provide education and resources to transgender and non-binary New Yorkers about their legal and civil rights, including in health care, my office is finalizing a comprehensive rights and resource guide that we hope to publish as soon as possible. The administration will continue to work across agencies to ensure that transgender and non-binary New Yorkers are informed, protected and served, especially during these unprecedented times. Critically, the City continues to provide age-appropriate gender affirming care through services offered by both the Department of Health and Health and Hospitals. And finally, I want to thank CM Schulman for putting forward Int 0949-2026. We support this Bill and agree it is critical to provide information and resources to LGBTQI+ New Yorkers about health care services that are available to them. The Health Department already has several resources for LGBTQI+ New Yorkers, including a suite of web pages, the LGBTQI+ Health Care Bill of Rights and the Pride and Care Health Tips for Transgender and Gender Nonconforming and Non-Binary People booklet, available on the Health Department's website in 13 languages. The Health Department's health portal is currently available online as well, where LGBTQI+ New Yorkers seeking care can search for health services and more. My colleagues from the Health Department have a few points to clarify in the Bill language and look forward to discussing the Bill further. Thank you again for the opportunity to provide this testimony. I look forward to discussion today and answering any questions helpful to the Council on these issues, and I will turn it over to my colleagues from... sorry, Health and Hospitals. (00:26:39) We have met before, but it is never the same in person. Thank you very much, Taylor. Good afternoon to Chairs Cabán, Narcisse and Farías, and members of the Committees on Mental Health and Substance Use, Hospitals and Women and Gender Equity. I am Dr. Andrew Wallack, the Ambulatory Care Chief Medical Officer at New York City Health and Hospitals. I am joined today by my colleague Dr. Omar Fatal, the Chief Behavioral Health Officer at Health and Hospitals. As the public safety net health care system, Health and Hospitals' mission is simple: to provide comprehensive health services equally to all New Yorkers, regardless of their ability to pay, and to deliver the highest quality care with compassion, dignity and respect. Furthermore, we aim to promote and protect health in its fullest sense — the total physical, mental and social well-being of the people of New York City. Thank you for the opportunity to testify before you today. Health and Hospitals has continuously prioritized support for the LGBTQI+ community and staff, in keeping with our values, relevant laws and regulations. In 2011, Health and Hospitals became the first U.S. municipal health care system to mandate LGBTQI+ training for all staff members, and we continuously provide trainings on LGBTQI+ mental health through e-learning and live training programs that focus on culturally responsive care. In 2014, Health and Hospitals Metropolitan became the first municipal hospital to open a health care center specifically dedicated to the needs of LGBTQI+ patients. Today, Health and Hospitals operates Pride Health Clinics in eight of its facilities, including Bellevue, Elmhurst, Gotham Health Gouverneur, Gotham Health Judson, Jacoby, Lincoln, Metropolitan and Woodhull. Regardless of the type of care a patient comes to Health and Hospitals for, we treat each patient as a whole person, working with them to support their physical... (00:28:58) ...mental and social well-being within the context of best clinical practices and regulatory authority. We know gender affirming care does not have a one-size-fits-all approach, and Health and Hospitals providers, with informed consent, work closely with patients and their families and or legal guardians to equip them with the tools they need to provide the necessary mental and emotional support throughout their gender affirming health journey. As clinically necessary, Health and Hospitals medical teams will make referrals to behavioral health teams to ensure minors are getting the care that safeguards their mental well-being, as well as ensuring that our patients' physical needs are equally met. All of our behavioral health providers have the training and skills to address the needs and provide care to all of our patients, and this includes providing gender affirming care. To do so, we use the patient's correct pronouns, create a safe space for non-cisgender persons to explore their gender expression, and document in our medical records in a gender affirming manner. We work with families to support and work through gender-related issues when they come up in treatment. Additionally, Health and Hospitals offers the LGBTQI+ Mental Health Training, which is an annual voluntary course facilitated by the Institute of Human Identity. The curriculum informs mental health providers on key social determinants that impact the LGBTQI+ population and best practices in delivering affirming psychotherapy to this community. Additionally, we partner with our communities to offer localized support whenever possible. For example, the Elmhurst Suicide Prevention and Youth Program offers free workshops and services to schools, community-based organizations and agencies across Queens, with the goal of reducing the rates of suicide for youth. While this program primarily meets with youth ages 12 to 24, with an emphasis on Black, Indigenous and people of color as well as LGBTQ+ youth in Queens, additional workshops are available to families and staff from other local organizations. Also, Health and Hospitals is a co-sponsor of Trans Health, which connects transgender, gender diverse and non-binary New Yorkers to health care, legal and social support resources here in New York City. Providers at Health and Hospitals receive extensive training to ensure they are delivering culturally responsive care to meet the physical and mental needs of those seeking gender affirming care. These trainings include references to the World Professional Association for Transgender Health Standards of Care Version Eight guidance, (00:31:52) which was developed by global professionals across medical and sociological fields to provide clinical guidance to health care professionals supporting trans and gender diverse individuals throughout their health care journey. This guidance uplifts Health and Hospitals' mission to promote and protect health in its fullest sense and bring the highest level of comprehensive care into our exam rooms. Health and Hospitals is proud to receive designations from leading national benchmarking organizations for inclusive policies, best practices and equitable treatment and inclusion. All 18 Health and Hospitals eligible facilities earned the LGBTQ+ Health Care Leader designation in the Human Rights Campaign Foundation's Healthcare Equity Index. This is a recognition that these facilities have received every year since 2015. Additionally, all five of Health and Hospitals' long-term care facilities earned the LGBTQ+ Long-Term Care Equality Leader designation in the Human Rights Campaign Foundation and SAGE's Long-Term Care Equality Index in 2025. Above all, Health and Hospitals recognizes the importance of both being an innovator and an advocate to ensure that every person, youth or otherwise, who walks through our doors is treated with compassion, dignity and respect when seeking gender affirming care. With our purpose to care for all New Yorkers, Health and Hospitals will continue to meet each patient where they are to achieve these goals — no exceptions. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today on this most important topic. (00:33:40) Thank you very much for your testimony and for being here. I am going to just start off with some questions around clinical evidence and research. The clinical literature — and this was touched upon in your testimony, Director — including studies published in peer-reviewed journals and guidance from the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Endocrine Society, consistently associates access to gender affirming care with meaningful reductions in depression, anxiety and suicidality amongst transgender youth. What does the administration understand to be the strongest available evidence on the relationship between access to gender affirming care and mental health outcomes for gender non-binary youth? And how does that evidence inform the agencies' public health guidance and counsel? (00:34:31) Council Member, we have representatives from Health and Hospitals who will be responding to the question and answer portion. (00:34:36) Oh, great. Okay. Yeah, they can come up now. We are at that point. (00:34:42) Okay. Yeah. (00:35:09) Fantastic. Good afternoon. My name is Marnie Davidoff. I am the... for the Bureau — excuse me — of Children, Youth and Families and Developmental Disabilities at the New York Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. So in response to your question, as so many of the Council Members have spoken about today, we know that there is overwhelming evidence that when transgender and non-binary youth have appropriate access to individualized, gender-affirming care, their mental health is improved. In 2022, there was a prospective study of 100 young people aged 13 to 20 who identified as transgender and gender non-binary, and it found that receipt of gender-affirming interventions was associated with lower odds of moderate to severe depressive symptoms and significantly lower odds of self-harm and suicidal thoughts. A 2023 study that tracked 300 youth who identify as transgender and non-binary for two years as they were receiving gender-affirming hormone therapy also showed significant decreases in depression and anxiety. We really believe firmly that this evidence is critical to shaping the way that we approach health and mental health care for youth and are really using this to inform some of the planning and work that is ahead of us that was discussed earlier. And you should stay put because my line of questions is mostly for you. I am not going anywhere. (00:36:53) Okay, great. So research has also shown that transgender youth who are denied access to puberty blockers or gender-affirming hormone therapy are at significantly elevated risk for suicidal ideation and self-harm compared to those who receive care. Does DOHMH view access to gender-affirming care as a suicide prevention strategy and is it reflected in the City's suicide prevention planning? Yes? (00:37:18) Absolutely. Along with other validated public health sources, we view access to gender-affirming care as part of a broader suicide prevention strategy. The Trevor Project research, which was also cited earlier, shows that access to gender-affirming care and gender-affirming environments significantly reduces suicide risk among transgender and non-binary youth. Our suicide prevention initiatives are designed first and foremost to reduce suicide disparities among marginalized youth and this includes youth... (00:37:52) Yeah, and on that point of suicide prevention strategy, I just want to move to the 988 line for a second because that is another tool that we have for people of not just different gender identities but just different experiences and different demographics. Has it seen increased use since federal actions began and do you know how it is being monitored at this point? (00:38:26) Yeah, thanks for that question. So we are very cognizant of the stressors that TGNB individuals are experiencing as a result of federal actions. And of course, the health and well-being of the 988 counselors — do they receive specific training on meeting the needs of LGBT youth communities and the specialized services that are available to them? So if a caller requests LGBTQ+ specialized services, the counselors are able to make that referral and there is also a searchable database online where a New Yorker can use to find services that are affirming. However, because of the nature of the intervention — because it is a time-limited crisis intervention and it is anonymous — we do not require the caller to offer any demographic information. We may not be able to track with confidence the number of callers who identify as TGNB or LGBTQ broadly. So we only have demographics for a very small number of those callers. So yeah, right now we cannot accurately give you a demographic trend. (00:39:45) And I mean, again, I know that at large the TGNB community is understandably... (00:39:53) Understandably cautious... (00:39:56) ...about what they are divulging even to these resources at this moment in time and that is because of the current political environment... (00:40:04) ...and the attacks from the federal level. (00:40:05) And so to that end, the political environment has created what many clinicians describe as a secondary mental health crisis, separate from any underlying gender dysphoria, that is driven by fear, uncertainty, the experience of having care disrupted or threatened. We have heard the point that it is not a person's gender identity that is the cause of mental health stress or distress, but the treatment from others that they receive around that. And now we are layering on top of these other fears because of the political environment. Can you talk about what evidence shows about mental health outcomes when care is delayed, when it is interrupted, when it is denied, compared to when it is accessible? And how is that being communicated to providers and families? And very quickly before you answer, I just want to acknowledge that we have been joined by... (00:41:06) ...CM Brooks-Powers. Okay, thanks. Thank you. I am going to hand it over to Director Brown to kick us off. (00:41:13) Yes. Thank you for the question, Council Member. We know that undiagnosed, untreated and undertreated gender dysphoria often becomes more severe over time, leading to further exacerbation of both physical and mental health disparities and risk with age. This is similar to any chronic health condition that is left untreated or when care is interrupted. A recent study published in Nature highlights the devastating effects of anti-trans legislation in states, finding that these bans — a collection of laws that restrict rights including access to gender-affirming health care — have led to a 72% increase in suicide attempts among transgender and gender non-binary people compared to states without such legislation. These findings are also supported by an article analyzing several more recent studies published by the American Psychological Association as well. (00:42:04) Thank you. I really appreciate that and just to underscore that this is something that is not unique — across the board in that sense there are many people who are being denied access to mental health care for a number of reasons, again at the hands of the federal government, and the distress that causes... I am somebody who lives with a chronic health condition and the period of time it took to get a diagnosis and the difficulty of being seen and heard and really taken seriously and treated was really, really, really difficult — as an adult with access to consistent mental health care, and still I struggled immensely. So I cannot imagine what young folks are struggling with when they are not sure where they can get their care. I have a couple more questions and then I am going to hand it over to my co-chair. But beyond medical care, what does DOHMH understand to be the most important protective factors for TGNB youth mental health? (00:43:14) And just as examples, things such as family acceptance, supportive schools, community connection, things like that? (00:43:26) Yep. There are many protective factors and I would say the most widely recognized protective factor is connectedness to parents, so family support and affirmation is absolutely critical as a protective factor. Others include connectedness to other caring adult relatives, adults in the community, peers and friends, teachers, youth development opportunities and feeling safe in the community. Those were all protective factors and that goes for transgender, gender queer, gender fluid and questioning youth. These were protective factors against depression, suicidality and substance use. (00:44:07) Can you go into — can you flesh out that definition of connectedness for folks? (00:44:14) Yeah, I mean, I think that the definition of connectedness is tied into the idea of affirmation and support. So it is being seen for who you are, the gender identity that you are choosing, presenting as the pronouns you are choosing to use — those are all affirmed and... (00:44:37) ...supported. And yeah, that is a critical part, I think, of that connectedness factor. (00:44:41) Yeah, I mean, obviously there is a large scope of what parental responsibility looks like and how children — or adults — could still carry that parent relationship, trauma around differences between... (00:44:56) ...being fed and housed and being emotionally supported and seen and understood, et cetera. (00:45:02) Et cetera. So thank you for fleshing that out, I appreciate it. And then my last question before handing it over to Chair Narcisse: you mentioned that parental support is one of the strongest protective factors for the mental health of transgender youth and research consistently shows that family acceptance dramatically reduces suicide risk. So does DOHMH have any programming or resources specifically designed to support parents and caregivers of TGNB youth, both in understanding them and the health benefits of affirming care and in navigating the current climate of misinformation? And if not, is there capacity to develop that? And again, before you answer, I want to acknowledge that we have been joined by... thank you. (00:45:48) Yes. So the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene supports a variety of programs that offer both family peer support and youth peer support. We have what we call the Family and Youth Peer Support Alliances. There is one per borough and there is also a training and technical assistance center associated with these alliances. The training center — the Strong Families and Communities Training Center — has been providing trainings to all of our peer advocates on working with LGBTQ youth and their families and to help them navigate related systems and to provide the variety of peer supports that are needed. Specifically, we have had a lot of focus on this — the Queens Alliance provider and the Staten Island Alliance provider have really been doing a lot of work in this area, including running groups for individuals and their families and really building their capacity to serve. (00:46:47) Shoutout Staten Island. Yeah, all right. I have a few more questions but I am going to pass it over to Chair Narcisse. Thank you, Chair. (00:46:59) Two things as I am sitting here and processing about what is acceptable in the society we live in and what is accessible — the best health care that you can get as a human being is treating each other fairly. And unfortunately, as my colleagues just mentioned, there are those who have difficulty and do not have that support. And we want to see New York City as a place where we support one another and it is very important for us to be mindful of what is going on in our society. So I thank you for being here and our question... (00:47:45) ...on mental health. Unless we talk about the service capacity and mental health... continuing on mental health: what does H+H's clinical experience show about mental health outcomes for youth once they have stable access to... (00:48:03) ...gender-affirming care? (00:48:07) Good afternoon. I cannot comment on individual cases, but I can agree with everything that was said before me. There is research and evidence that shows that access to gender-affirming care does improve overall mental health outcomes, including lowering depression, lowering anxiety and improving overall mental well-being. Thank you. (00:48:29) Does H+H have enough licensed mental health clinicians to serve TGNB patients? (00:48:37) Yes, I am happy to say that we do have capacity. In our child and adult behavioral services we offer the whole spectrum of services for children and adolescents in all boroughs and we welcome all New Yorkers, including LGBTQ+ patients. We have made it very easy for people to access care in our system two ways. One is that they can be referred by their medical team and their medical team can connect them internally to behavioral services. Or people can call on their own — it is one number, the contact center. I can mention it: 1-844-... and all they have to say is "I want to be connected to behavioral services" and we take care of it from there. (00:49:20) And by the way, I am very proud of H+H for providing those services because we know when other hospital facilities are not receiving patients, H+H — if you are listening — know that H+H is on your side. The hospital never turns people away. What does H+H see as the value of coordinating mental health support with gender-affirming care? (00:49:43) Great. Thank you for those comments and for that particular question. I have to say I am entering my 29th year working at New York City Health and Hospitals as an internist and one of the things I am most proud about our health care system is its longstanding... (00:49:59) ...history of integrating both physical and behavioral health services through programs like Collaborative Care in primary care, which focuses on depression and anxiety. I would say that coordinating gender-affirming care with mental health support is clinically necessary and, of course, with informed consent. We know — and we have heard — that it leads to better mental health outcomes. So here at New York City Health and Hospitals, this is absolutely a process that we use to provide full care to our patients. I am going to turn it back over to Dr. Fertile for additional comment. (00:50:32) Yeah, I agree 100% and we do it on behalf of the patients, so we do not rely on the patient to have to connect the dots. So if the patient is already engaged in treatment in primary care, the primary care team would make a referral to behavioral health and the reverse is true. If someone starts their care in behavioral health and we realize that they need medical services, then we connect them with medical services internally. And for disclosure, I work for H+H as a nurse, so I do not want you to think I am biased — to be clear, I work there and I believe in the care that is being provided. And I will say it was Elmhurst Hospital, which would never turn anyone away. So... (00:51:09) We do not mind you being biased. (00:51:13) Have staff observed increased anxiety among patients and families about the federal environment or Medicaid... (00:51:21) ...changes? Yeah, you know it is hard — again as Dr. Patil said, I am not going to comment on specific patients. But broadly speaking, yes, we are starting to hear rumblings from the patients to whom we provide care. However, from our perspective, it is always our hope that H+H creates an environment of support and reassurance for all patients, including those seeking gender-affirming care. As such, shoutout to my colleagues at H+H who really do a fantastic job of updating guidance on our public-facing websites and our social media channels, as well as through patient emails and during visits with patients in the exam room with the care teams, to make sure that they feel safe and are provided with all the necessary information, because we know that getting accurate and correct information is critical. (00:52:15) And we have been joined by my colleague CM Wilson. Does H+H involve and support parents and caregivers, given the role of family acceptance as a protective factor? (00:52:31) Yeah, for all our child and adolescent behavioral services, including the family, the legal guardian and the other caregivers involved in the care of the patient is core to our case management. And in the case of providing gender-affirming care... (00:52:50) ...we do create a support system for the family specifically, because we know in some cultures acceptance is more difficult and that is the reason I started talking about it being accessible. But where we are in... (00:53:07) ...life. Yeah, definitely. We have this in mental health in general because there is a lot of stigma and there is a lot of resistance sometimes from families and communities. So we are used to doing that. We are very used to including other caregivers and including the community. We do a lot of work, for example, in schools where we are present in 50 schools in New York, where we provide mental health services. So we have this as part of the way we provide services for children and adolescents and we apply the same when dealing with gender-affirming care or when working with these patients. (00:53:44) Okay, so if a family actually comes in with a young person and they are not quite... not in the place where they... because what I have found in my time in the ER, sometimes they can be enough of an obstruction because of their beliefs or whatever it may be. So do you kind of provide that kind of support right away to make sure the family has an understanding and is more kind of helping with the process of providing care for that young person? (00:54:20) Yeah, a hundred percent. We treat the whole person. We do not look only at the mental health side of things. We look at treating the whole person, which includes their family and involving them. I do have to say that we practice within the four corners of the law and we practice within the New York City DOHMH guidelines and regulations. Obviously we do all of this within available guidelines that we have. Pride Health Centers... (00:54:47) The Pride Health Centers are primarily located in Manhattan, the Bronx and Brooklyn. For TGNB New Yorkers in Staten Island or outer Queens, distance can be a real barrier, particularly now that some private hospital programs have pulled back. Are there any plans to expand access points, even for mental health services specifically, in those... (00:55:18) Great. So I can start and then I will pass it back to the doctor. Thank you for that question. I would say the last time I was sitting in this room was during the COVID pandemic giving testimony. If we were to look back historically, I am kind of a glass-half-full kind of guy. One of the positives that came out of the pandemic was our ability to turn on telehealth or virtual care literally overnight in the midst of the pandemic. One of the things I am very proud of is New York City Health and Hospitals' continuation of their services to, as I said before, reach New Yorkers where they want to be met. So we have relied very much on telehealth or virtual care to reach patients throughout all five boroughs in the City. Now, to your question, I would say we continuously monitor the need or the demand for clinical services throughout our system. Indeed we work as a system, and I want to be very clear that a system works in that not all services are available at each and every center, but as a system we work together. So if I am seeing patients at Bellevue and I do not have a particular service there, I can refer that patient to one of our other facilities. Telehealth is absolutely a tool for convenience. I was going to turn it over to you, Amaar, but certainly in the behavioral health realm it lends itself very nicely to that exact type of care. So maybe if you have additional comment... (00:56:44) Yeah, a hundred percent of this. This is one of the few good things that came out of COVID — it really transformed the way we deliver care. We have actually published studies on this from H+H where we saw higher show rates for people who are using telehealth. So we very much use that. As Dr. Warwick mentioned, in behavioral health, if you think about it, most of what we do is based on talk therapy and we do not even need to touch the person or do a physical exam, so it lends itself very nicely to telehealth as well. (00:57:13) Chair, if I may, just to say we offer Pride Centers at Lincoln, Bellevue, Woodhull, Metropolitan, Elmhurst and... (00:57:25) Jacobi. In addition, there are two additional sites as well, so it is not just four sites within our system. Gotham Health, both Gouverneur and Gotham Health Jetsons. Thank you. (00:57:35) And I want to say thank you for all your support and the advocates in the room, for continuing to make sure that New York City health care is for all of us, no matter where you are from, no matter what gender. Just like what pulls New York City together. Thank you for your service. I will pass it back to my chair. (00:57:54) Thank you, Chair. I will go ahead and turn it over to Chair Farías. Thank you so much, and thanks for all of your testimony this morning, folks. (00:58:02) Just really quickly — on local data, does the Youth Risk Behavior Survey or any other survey capture gender identity specifically? Someone on the panel, you want to come back up? Thanks. (00:58:27) Thank you. Yes, the Youth Risk Behavior Survey for both high school... (00:58:30) ...and middle school New York City public school students does capture data on gender identity. Okay. And since we do capture that data, what does it show, if at all, anything around depression, anxiety, self-harm, suicide attempts or ideations among transgender and gender non-binary youth compared to their cisgender counterparts? (00:58:53) Yeah, it shows health disparities for sure. So it shows that students who identify as transgender are more likely to report electronic bullying, feeling persistent sadness or hopelessness, suicide ideation and suicide attempts than cisgender students. So for example, in 2023 we saw that public high school students who identified as transgender, non-binary or some other gender identity, or questioning, were more likely to report suicide ideation. Those groups — sorry, let me say this differently — the percentage of each of those populations that reported suicide ideation were: for transgender, it was 42%; for non-binary it was 38%; of those who identified as questioning it was 28%. That is again the percentage who reported suicidal ideation, versus those who identified as cisgender, which was 16%. So that is just one example — we have data on the various outcomes, but that is just one example that illustrates the disparities. Thank you. (01:00:04) I would like to talk a little bit about the LGBTQ+ Health Care Bill of Rights. We know the Bill of Rights directs individuals who experience discrimination or denial of care to file complaints through the Human Rights Commission. Can you walk us through what support, if any, is available to a young person or their family in the immediate aftermath of a care disruption, or before a formal complaint process actually gets under way? (01:00:41) I will briefly touch on this, and I just want to clarify — are you speaking about a patient who is discharged and immediately prior to filing a complaint, in the event that they need medication or ongoing services? Yes, and what the process is prior to, in terms of referring directly to the Bill of Rights that we have in the City. (01:01:05) Yeah, and so, you know, my understanding of this — and I think we have to get back to you, but I will pass it back to my colleagues to see if they have additional information. The way that I thought about this question is that my understanding, I guess, of New York State law anyway, in regards to patients who are in an inpatient hospital setting, is that they actually do have certain enumerated rights in regards to discharge and continuation of care and continuity of care. I am unaware at this time of a similar sort of analog in relation to City law, and that may just be because of regulatory purview. But I will say, sort of in a private clinic, all physicians are licensed and regulated by the State Board, and professional rules for physicians expressly state that it is professional misconduct — potentially malpractice — to discharge a patient without figuring out a plan to, in a reasonable amount of time, make sure that they are going to be able to find a provider and ensure continuity of care. They also need to be available in that time to provide care on an emergency basis. I am not sure if my colleagues have anything else to add on that point. (01:04:27) Yeah, thank you for the question. For those who do not know, prior to this position I was an Assistant Attorney General in the Civil Rights Bureau in the Office of the New York State Attorney General. Before that I was a staff attorney at both the American Civil Liberties Union, Lambda Legal, and I was doing impact litigation on behalf of transgender people across the country. I graduated from law school in 2017, which was right when Trump was elected, so I really cut my teeth doing a lot of that very early litigation and continued on from there. I would say my work specifically was focused on health care in a very real way because of my own personal story in that area. Because of the types of cases I led and their significance, that has given me expertise in both civil rights and constitutional law. I think it has also given me, clearly from a personal perspective, a very deep understanding of the issues facing LGBTQ+ people and especially where those issues intersect with government. My office's work is done in the shadow of unprecedented federal hostility and serious changes to the legal landscape. In that shadow, my litigation experience — primarily suing governmental entities and actors and challenging unconstitutional and unlawful executive orders, laws, policies and regulations — has given me a deep understanding of how to use those tools and others that government has in order to affect true change in people's lives for the better. (01:06:11) Are there any federal actions or legal developments that you are planning, or the office is planning, to watch more closely or track? (01:06:20) You know, I think that is something I consider an obligation of my office. I am in contact with and work closely with my colleagues in the Office of Chief Counsel as well as the Law Department in monitoring any legal, regulatory and especially federal action — at this point even tweets — that could potentially impact people. So that is something we are tracking, and also just looking at litigation in several federal and state... (01:06:52) ...courts. Is there anything that comes to mind in terms of Council support, whether that is for the office, for any of the initiatives, or any of the federal-level legal items that you folks are going to be tracking and watching? Any support that can be coming from the Council side? (01:07:11) Yeah, and again, at a certain point I will not be able to reference my relatively short... (01:07:17) ...but I will say at this stage, preliminarily, not so much on that. Thinking about some of the planning that I am doing, one thing that is coming up for me — and has been coming up for me in my practice as a civil rights litigator — is the issue of data. I think we have been referencing that today, and I do believe that that could, and probably likely would, require a legislative fix — or not fix, but solutions and innovation, I guess I should say. At a very high level, when we work towards solutions for systemic issues affecting historically and intentionally marginalized communities, data is key for many reasons, including evidencing the problem, understanding the scale of interventions required, formulating solutions and monitoring their efficacy. (01:08:04) Thank you all. I should also say I am very eager to hear from you all and to meet with people in your districts to understand their needs and what is impacting them as well. I just want to say that to all. (01:08:18) I appreciate that. Thank you for the responses today. I will kick it back over to the Chair. Thank you. (01:08:25) Thank you. I deeply appreciate Chair Farías' questions around collaboration opportunities with the Council. Just to make that clear if it was not already — you have really, really eager and willing partners in the Council. We passed a number of protections at the municipal level, we have worked together in getting funding for our community, and so we are here to be partners in that innovation. Amen. (01:08:54) I want to follow up on this line of questioning that the Chair just engaged in. What does the Mayor's Office of LGBTQI+'s coordination with other agencies look like? You started to touch on it — if you could go into some more specifics around it. Will you be doing any outreach to hospitals about the benefits of providing access to gender affirming care for youth and mental health? What are the impacts? Is it a situation where they already know and so maybe that is not necessary? But yeah, I would be curious to... (01:09:31) ...know. Yeah, I mean, that cooperation began on day one of my tenure in this position. I think — and I know — that that comes from a fundamental belief that government services are for all people in New York, including LGBTQI+ people. So my office, I think of it as a way to ensure that agencies are providing services that are inclusive of LGBTQI+ people, who are sometimes, often, not thought of, or solutions are not sort of centered on them. Just off the top of my head, I can say I have had many conversations with my wonderful colleagues at both Health and Hospitals and the Department of Health, and I am planning other things to work with fellow agency and office heads. I think that just has to be built into my work because, especially when we are talking about agencies dedicated to prevention, health care, housing and what have you, those are all areas where my community must be taken into account in those decisions. It is also about sharing the important work that those offices are doing — I think sometimes the public may not have an awareness that those offices are there for them and are meant to serve them as well. It brings to mind that I just had a conversation with Commissioner Martin from the Department of Health, who is planning something around H5N1, and that is something that is certainly going to impact people. So we have had conversations about how do we get more information to the communities that I serve specifically. And apologies — could you please repeat the second part of your question? (01:11:19) Or was there a second part? I think you very, very thoroughly answered the question. I am going to hand it over to colleagues, but I just want to say that the Council's LGBTQI+ caucus has for the past several years been putting out a policy plan and road map. I want to give a really, really big shout-out and acknowledgment to now CM Wilson, who at the time was the chief of staff to Council Member Bottcher and really, really anchored a lot of the work that we did on the Pride and Policy Report. There is an updated version of that coming out soon, and I think that is also an area for us to be able to collaborate — we can be talking about legislative interventions. Is the next Council Member here? He is not. Okay. (01:12:06) With that, I will pass it over to the next Council Member. (01:12:11) Thank you, Chair. I appreciate those comments. Hi there. Thank you for your testimony. I have a question for H+H. When a major hospital system stops providing gender affirming care for youth, how does the City assess the resulting impact on both the hospital capacity and the mental health of the affected patients, and who is responsible for tracking those... (01:12:42) ...outcomes? Yeah, so I will start and then I will pass it over to Dr. Vital. Just to say it is hard for us to comment on what the private hospitals are doing, but we stand, as we have said in our testimony, at the ready to fully support all patients in need of care, no exceptions. As part of any other type of care that New York City Health and Hospitals provides, whether it is cardiology or other services, we regularly monitor what that demand is and we look at our capacity within our system and we adjust what is available to patients. So it is no different for gender affirming care, and it is something that we keep a close look at. Yep, exactly. (01:13:22) Same thing for mental health. Our mission is to serve all New Yorkers without exception, and I am happy to say that we do have capacity in mental health right now. We have made it very easy for New Yorkers who are looking for help to get it. This is for all New Yorkers, including LGBTQI+ people. All they have to do is call 1-2-4-4 and ask to be connected to services, and we can connect them to help and ensure patients do not experience abrupt interruptions in medically necessary care, especially during periods of policy uncertainty. I can start again on that, and I would say please let us know if there is anything you need us to get back to you on. (01:14:08) That is fine too. Thank you. But just to say, we have not changed our scope of practice for gender affirming care at New York City Health and Hospitals. Okay. Okay. (01:14:22) I guess I would just say, can... (01:14:23) ...H+H commit to notifying the Council of any significant policy changes affecting equitable access, in a manner that protects patient privacy and avoids unnecessary clinical or operational detail? (01:14:40) Yeah. So again, privacy is critical to health care. It is a partnership between the patient and the care team, and so we certainly adhere to all regulations and rules, specifically HIPAA. (01:14:53) And do everything we can within the bounds of the law as far as release of information, so it is something that we take very seriously. As a member of the Health and Hospitals community we have annual compliance updates that all staff members must go through, in addition to the training. So this is something that is very near and dear and important to us. (01:15:14) Thank you, Councilmember. I have, I think just two more questions at the moment. I want to search on the New York City health map. (01:15:22) From what we have. Okay, great. So. (01:15:26) It currently features a dedicated LGBT health services portal that allows New Yorkers to search for providers by geographic proximity and medical need. Can you talk a little bit about how the map is maintained and specifically how frequently provider information is verified and updated? Yeah, please. (01:15:48) these committees and to respond honestly to Council Member questions? Sorry. Yes, I do. Good afternoon. My name is Andrea Howard. I am the Deputy Commissioner for Disease Control at the New York City Health Department and I use the pronouns she/her. So the LGBT health services are a section of the health map and that section was first launched in 2018. Since that time it has gone through ad hoc updates. Participation is voluntary and providers have to consent to their information being included in the health map. Participating providers are responsible for informing the Health Department when that information needs to be updated because of contact information changes or services changes. Now, recognizing that that is not always done, and particularly in light of the recent changing care landscape, we are under a comprehensive review of this section. This will include surveying all providers that are currently included in the health map to make sure that they continue to provide culturally competent and affirmative services and that the information is accurate. We will also be reaching out to additional providers through consultation with our networks to see if they would like to be included. Now in the interim, we have reached out to certain providers when we know that services have been changed. For example, we reached out to Mount Sinai and to facilities and we revised their listing to reflect that they no longer offered gender affirming care to youth. (01:17:32) Great. Thank you. I think you are acknowledging sort of the gap that people can proactively tell you things are changing, but some people you are going to end up having to chase down. Obviously Mount Sinai — that was big news, so it was easy to track that down. But are there other ways that you are looking into whether the directory is accurate, and how often are you finding that you are doing it or that you think it necessitates doing? And also how is that process being resourced? (01:18:04) Yeah, so as I mentioned we are currently planning to launch a survey later this fall so we can do a comprehensive update. In the meantime, if any of you know of any information that is inaccurate, please let us know and we can reach out to the provider and verify. Okay, great. And I think even in terms of being proactive, obviously there are a lot of organizations, service providers and advocacy groups that are on the ground and have relationships with families that are navigating this in real time. So I think that also might be a good place to do some proactive outreach to get that information much more quickly. Okay. (01:18:51) For a person or their family navigating the map, is there any indication of which providers specifically offer gender affirming care for youth as distinct from adult services? (01:19:08) Thank you for the question. So users of the healthcare map can filter by the four different types of services: primary care, gender affirming care, sexual health care and behavioral health care. And they can also filter by providers that offer services for adults or for youth. Okay. (01:19:27) Thank you. We are going to turn it over to a Council Member. I have seen these — do you have questions? Oh, no, no, no. Okay, then thank you very much for being here and for your testimony and for the continued collaboration with the Council. Appreciate you. Okay, we will now be opening the hearing for public testimony. I want to remind members of the public that this is a government proceeding and decorum shall be observed at all times. As such, members of the public shall remain silent at all times. The witness table is reserved for people who wish to testify. No video recording or photography is allowed from the witness table. Further, members of the public may not present audio or video recordings as testimony but may submit transcripts of such recordings to the Sergeant at Arms for inclusion in the hearing record. If you wish to speak at today's hearing, please fill out an appearance card with the Sergeant at Arms and wait to be recognized. When recognized you will have three minutes to speak on today's oversight topic and legislation. If you have a written statement or additional written testimony you wish to submit for the record, please provide a copy of that testimony to the Sergeant at Arms. You may also submit written testimony to testimony@council.nyc.gov within 72 hours of this hearing. Audio and video recordings will not be accepted. And so for our first panel we have Maximus Rosas, Nat Mogae — please correct my pronunciation if I have got it wrong — Filament Kind, and Asha Lions. Okay, got it. (01:22:43) Wishing you well. (01:22:48) All the healing vibes. Okay. (01:22:49) Once you guys are all settled, whoever wants to start can start. Just make sure your mics are on. All right. Thank you so much, Chair Farías, Chair Narcisse, Chair Dorsey and members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, Mental Health and Substance Use and Hospitals for holding this hearing and providing us with the opportunity to testify today. My name is Nat Mogae — pronounced with he/him pronouns — and I am the Director of Advocacy and Programs at the New York Transgender Advocacy Group, where we focus on creating pathways for trans and gender nonconforming New Yorkers to build leadership, drive advocacy and grow community rooted in collective care and power. Although New York State has been established as a safe haven for trans youth, health-related societal barriers still prevent our community members from accessing the care we need. These barriers include housing insecurity, cost barriers, lack of culturally competent providers, food insecurity and unreliable transportation. 17.3% of transgender New Yorkers have reported cost barriers for needed medical care compared to 7.3% of non-LGBT individuals. 36.2% of trans New Yorkers have also reported unreliable transportation and housing insecurity as a barrier to receiving health care versus 17.1% of non-LGBT individuals. This gap in accessibility has been exacerbated by hateful rhetoric from the federal administration, placing providers and trans and gender nonconforming clients under extreme fear. Health care should be universal. However, we are living within a system that offers no guarantee of medical coverage for all residents. Even as a 27-year-old trans activist I have been without a health care provider for four years now — no PCP, no dentist, none of that. There is a major shortage of providers who understand our communities. Nearly one third of LGBT New Yorkers report that there are too few health care providers trained in LGBT issues, and amongst trans and gender nonconforming New Yorkers more than half identified the lack of LGBT and trans providers as a significant barrier. This shortage places an unfair responsibility on patients, and people frequently have to educate their own health care providers about our bodies, our medications and our basic health care needs. A patient should not have to become a medical educator simply to receive competent care. We all know that there have been moves towards shuttering health care for our community and there are clear attempts to restrict our access to safe and affirming resources. These moves will be detrimental and deadly towards our community. And while opponents try to restrict access and instill fear, our City has the opportunity to remain a leader and remain dedicated to our people. We make the following recommendations to the City Council and urge support for the following: to prioritize constitutional and legal protections for our community, we support Int 0949-2026. (01:25:57) We support Res 0208-2026 and we support Res 0547-2026. Thank you for allowing us to testify and we look forward to working with you to make sure that trans folks get the support they deserve. I will also email over my testimony alongside our trans youth that we have here and provide my contact information. (01:26:28) Thank you. (01:26:28) Thank you. Chair Amanda Farías, Chair Tiffany Cabán, Chair Narcisse and members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use and the Committee on Hospitals for holding this hearing and providing us the opportunity to testify. My name is Maximus Rosas. I use she/her pronouns and I am a program participant at the New York Transgender Advocacy Group. Based on my personal experience with the health care system in New York City, I can say that on numerous occasions, even after deciding to begin my transition and having female listed on all my identification documents, I have faced situations where I was misgendered. Staff at many institutions and clinics are still not trained to properly relay affirming information from the front desk to the health care professionals we are seeking care from. Within the scope of what is understood and known regarding affirmative care, there are many other factors involved that are often overlooked, such as diagnoses for diabetes, cancer, cholesterol, heart problems and skyrocketing numbers of mental health cases, and much more. Alongside these, many people in our community are immigrants — undocumented, vulnerable, marginalized, discriminated against and criminalized. When it comes to health care and public services they face formidable barriers, including fear and lack of services. To take my own case as an example: I am 52 years old and I have been living with HIV for over 33 years, on antiretroviral treatment for the past 16 years. I have other conditions requiring constant medication, evaluation and check-ups. While I am fortunate enough to have a place to live, others who lack housing face overwhelming stress and the constant strain of contending with a system that often offers no help at all. It is a system designed to make access difficult — one that is accessible only to the privileged. I support the passage of Int 0949-2026 because of the major impact it will have on folks like myself. I would like to thank the Committee on Women and Gender Equity and the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use for the opportunity to testify. In doing these testimonies we are also sharing the experiences of others who may not be present here today but who do have a voice. Thank you. (01:29:48) Oh, and we have been joined by a Council Member. All right, whenever you are ready. Thank (01:29:54) you. Chair Amanda Farías, Chair Mercedes Narcisse, members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use and the Committee on Hospitals for holding this hearing and providing us with the opportunity to testify. My name is Filament Kind. My pronouns are they/he and I am a program participant at the New York Transgender Advocacy Group, where we focus on creating pathways for New Yorkers to build leadership, drive advocacy and grow community rooted in collective care and power. I am here today to explain why I believe Int 0949-2026 is an essential step towards guaranteeing the health and safety of trans New Yorkers. Six years ago I was hospitalized after coming very close to ending my own life and engaging in self-injurious behaviors. Four years ago I did so again. My life then felt like a maze with no end. I was lost. I did not know who I was and I did not feel like I fit anywhere. I found myself. I have known for many years that I was queer and trans, but a piece was still missing for me. That missing piece was medical transition. Luckily in 2023 I made a friend, Joe, who guided me to community health clinics where I could receive the gender affirming care I was seeking when I did not know where else to turn or where to start. Once I made my first appointment at Callen-Lorde, I knew for certain that starting HRT was what I wanted. I am now two years on testosterone and I can say without a doubt that testosterone and queer joy have been the most effective antidepressants that I have ever been on. Gender affirming care is suicide prevention. Now some trans folks in New York City may not be so lucky. I am an English-speaking white citizen, so finding queer community was easier for me. Access to this information is primarily spread by word of mouth, creating gaps in access to this crucial health care for those who do not have such community or connections yet. Int 0949-2026 would create for many of these folks access to health care that could save lives. We thank the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use and the Committee on Hospitals for their continued support and leadership in protecting trans, gender nonconforming and nonbinary New Yorkers. We make the following recommendations to the City Council and urge support for the following: to prioritize constitutional and legal protections for trans folks, we support Int 0949-2026. To create a resource map related to the unique health care needs of LGBT individuals, including information regarding access to health services and obtaining and providing gender affirming care, we support Res 0208-2026. Mandating all medical students in New York State to receive anti-bias training, we support Res 0547-2026, to establish a gender affirming care program in the Department of Health to ensure the continuity of gender affirming care services in the state. We thank the Committee on Women and Gender Equity and the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use for their continued support and leadership in protecting gender nonconforming New Yorkers. Thank you for allowing us to testify and we look forward to working with you to make sure trans folks get the support they (01:33:07) deserve. Thank you so much. Thank you for your advocacy and even more so thank you for sharing your deeply, deeply personal stories. I just want to say to the young folks who have joined us or are submitting written testimony: I cannot wait to read it and thank you so, so much for engaging in this process. What you bring to us we take incredibly seriously and we are going to do everything possible to be as supportive as we can. So thank you. Okay, our next panel. It includes — and again I apologize if I do not pronounce it correctly, you are here to correct me — Ocean Waves, Cygnus, Paavo, Frank and Ellis Jablonski. Right? Yes. Okay, you all can start. Whoever can start first, it does not matter. Just make sure you press the button on your mic when you speak. There you go. Hi, my name (01:34:28) is Waves. I am 20 years old. My pronouns are he/him. Fascism depends on complicity in violence, both physical and non-physical. Private hospitals — Mount Sinai, Weill Cornell and Presbyterian — have halted or restricted gender affirming care for trans youth. This shift provoked rage across communities. One of fascism's central tools is desensitization to the heinous. Being transgender as though it were a crime is inhumane. A person's right to exist is not to be dictated by anyone but themselves. I am an Afro-Latino transgender man and I am homeless. When I wake up every morning, right after I get out of the shower, my routine is the same. I put my testosterone on each shoulder. That is how I start my day. This is not optional or abstract. It is how I care for myself, how I move through the world, how I hold myself. My hormones make the challenges of being homeless so much easier. I go out into the world with a clearer mind than I have ever had, a confidence that flows wherever I stand and a self-love that (01:35:28) I would not have otherwise known. A beautifully complex journey of understanding my gender and breaking boxes is what it means to be transgender. Prior to hormones I was not present in my body. No matter how much I forced myself to live with myself, my subconscious always knew the hormones were what I needed. Biochemical dysphoria is not something known to many. Biochemical dysphoria is caused by not having the right hormones in your body. I had biochemical dysphoria and I was miserable beyond belief. It has been proven time and time again that gender affirming care is the solution. (01:35:57) Gender affirming care keeps us alive. Gender affirming care lets us experience life like our cisgender counterparts. Int 0949-2026 will address these challenges and will benefit me, my community and my loved ones by providing them equal opportunity and access to medical care. (01:36:10) Examples of this include gender affirming care, dental care, primary health care, reproductive care, mental health care and beyond. (01:36:16) To deny gender affirming care is to deny science. It is complacency in genocide. We are trans youth, elders and adults who all just want to go outside and freely be themselves. No one should be denied the right to be free. (01:36:28) We support Int 0949-2026 to create a resource map related to the unique health care needs of LGBTQI+ individuals, including information regarding access to LGBTQI+ health services and obtaining and providing gender-affirming care. We support Res 0208-2026, mandating all medical students in New York State receive anti-bias training. We support Res 0547-2026 to establish a gender-affirming care program in the Department of Health to ensure gender-affirming care services in the state. We thank the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, the Committee on Hospitals and the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use for the opportunity to have given me the ability to use my voice to help my community. We appreciate your continued support and contributions in regards to the protection of transgender and gender nonconforming New Yorkers. Trans folks should know the community has their back. (01:37:17) We are only as strong as our community makes us. I am going to make one year on T in two days. This has been the best year of my entire life. The ability to be unapologetically human is a human right. Thank you. (01:37:35) Okay, whenever you are ready. (01:37:43) Thank you, Chair, and members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use and the Committee on Hospitals for holding this hearing and providing us with an opportunity to testify. My name is Frank, Youth Advocacy Fellow at NYTAG. I am a young transgender community member with lived experience of how frightening and confusing it can be trying to find information about transgender, gender nonconforming and gender nonbinary health services and gender-affirming care. That information can be incredibly difficult to find, especially for a young person with no experience in handling their own health care, trying to find this information by themselves. Even for those of us who have allies in our lives that support us, that does not mean that they know everything about our needs. When I needed help getting dental work done, I talked to my parents and they helped me find a dentist and deal with insurance. When I needed hormone replacement therapy, they were more lost and confused than I was. Like so many people, I had to extensively search for the resources I needed on the internet and it was daunting. There is so much misinformation out there, and a lack of accurate information as a transgender and gender nonconforming person can be scary when trying to find medical information and practitioners you can trust. If I had verified information and resources from the City during my search, it would have taken away so much of that fear. I was eventually fortunate to be able to find a doctor I can trust, who is both welcoming and knowledgeable about transgender health care. At 25, and after over six years of medically transitioning, I am still learning vital information about my own reproductive health due to a lack of access to relevant resources. Alongside this, most medical professionals I have seen either did not know or did not provide a safe environment for me to ask. Access to safe, affirming healthcare is vital to individuals in the gender nonconforming community and can be life-saving. Making this information more accessible to those who need it through legislation like Int 0949-2026 will undoubtedly be life-changing for many. We thank the Committee on Women and Gender Equity and the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use for their continued support and leadership in protecting transgender, gender nonconforming and nonbinary New Yorkers. Thank you for having us testify. We look forward to working with you to make sure trans folks get the support they deserve. We make the following recommendations to the City Council and urge support for the following, to prioritize constitutional and legal protections for our community. We support Int 0949-2026 to create a resource map related to the unique health care needs of LGBTQI+ individuals. We support Res 0208-2026 and we support Res 0547-2026. (01:40:13) Thank you. Thank you. (01:40:18) Chair Farías, Chair Cabán, Chair Narcisse and members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use and the Committee on Hospitals for holding this hearing and providing us with the opportunity to testify. My name is Ellis Rejablonski. I use pronouns he/him. I am a program participant at the New York Transgender Advocacy Group. Receiving medical care as a trans person does not come with the same guarantee of safety and respect as with our cisgender counterparts. Earlier this year I was getting ready to leave the house when I received a phone call from my former provider, Mount Sinai, who I had not been to since 2022, that they were under pressure from the administration to hand over all the personal information of their trans patients who received gender-affirming care, including minors. I was furious. Not only that they could do this, because it was a blatant HIPAA and privacy violation, but that the hospital gave in so easily to pressure. The woman on the phone that I was speaking to insisted that the hospital's hands were tied. Ultimately, the information release was deemed unlawful by federal court, but no patient should ever have to have that kind of fear that their doctor could do something like that to them. This is a unique risk that we as trans patients face when our identity is weaponized into a political talking piece. In other adverse medical experiences, I have been misgendered and deadnamed even when the dermatologist's office had a preferred name and pronoun box on the intake paperwork. I went to the orthodontist for a retainer fitting when the doctor, unsolicited, tried to sell me a phony gender-affirming procedure — a cosmetic tooth procedure — when I had just come in for a checkup. Health visits can be stressful enough. To find health care providers who respect trans patients and prioritize protecting our health and our dignity is vital. We thank the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use and the Committee on Hospitals for their continued support and leadership in protecting New Yorkers. We make the following recommendations to the City Council and urge support for the following, to prioritize constitutional and legal protections for our community. We support Int 0949-2026. We support Res 0208-2026 and we support Res 0547-2026. We thank the Committee on Women and Gender Equity and the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use for their continued support and leadership in protecting New Yorkers. Thank you for allowing us to testify and we look forward to working with you. Thank you. (01:42:48) Oh yeah, you can pull it (01:42:49) over to your side, whichever — it is up to you. There you go. Thank (01:42:57) you. Chair Farías, Chair Cabán, Chair Narcisse and members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use and the Committee on Hospitals for holding this hearing and providing us with the opportunity to testify. My name is Cygnus Paavo. I use they/them pronouns and I am a Youth Advocacy Fellow at the New York Transgender Advocacy Group. As a trans person who is currently receiving gender-affirming care, I have struggled in the past and still struggle now to find a health care provider that fits my needs. I personally had to search long and hard to find a gender-affirming clinic that is not only accessible but affordable. Receiving gender-affirming care in any form, from hormone therapy to gender-affirming surgeries, is a process that affects every other type of care you receive. I am currently struggling to find a primary care physician, and I know I am not alone in that, partly because I am medically transitioning. I have had to go to CVS or any other major pharmacy to pick up my hormones only to be interrogated or even outright refused in so many cases. I have even more friends who cannot access gender-affirming care because of affordability issues and not being able to access knowledge regarding clinics that accept them. Trans people, even in New York City, which is considered a safe haven, struggle to find places to receive health care without facing discrimination. Across the U.S., gender-affirming care is being outlawed and private hospitals such as Mount Sinai and Langone are capitulating to the federal administration and restricting who can receive care. Having a portion of the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene website dedicated to LGBTQI+ health will be a vital commitment to LGBTQI+ New Yorkers — a commitment that is especially meaningful in this political climate. We support Int 0949-2026 to create a resource map related to the unique health care needs of LGBTQI+ individuals, including information regarding access to LGBTQI+ health services and obtaining and providing gender-affirming care. We support Res 0208-2026, mandating all medical students in New York State to receive anti-bias training. We support Res 0547-2026 to establish a gender-affirming care program in the Department of Health to ensure the continuity of gender-affirming care services in the state. We thank the Committee on Women and Gender Equity and the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use for their continued support, leadership and protecting transgender and gender nonconforming and nonbinary New Yorkers. Thank you for allowing us to testify and we look forward to working with you to make sure trans folks get the support they deserve. Thank you. (01:45:27) So much for being here and for your testimony. Actually, I have a question for you. I am putting you on the spot, so if you cannot think of it now, I just want to invite you to follow up with me and with my colleagues so that we can be in conversation around it. But I am just wondering — it is clear that you all support the three pieces of legislation that we heard about in the hearing today, but do you think that there are other things that the City government could or should be doing to better support you and the folks in your community? Any one of you can jump in, any and all of you. (01:46:12) For me, the hardest part of receiving care has definitely been mental health care. It is hard to find a therapist or a provider who is gender-affirming and is aware of the nuances of being a transgender person. So I would really like to see if there is any way to improve that system of mental health care for transgender people, especially since our mental health and our mental safety is really being tested in this political climate. So I think definitely just improving access to mental health and psychiatric care would be really helpful. (01:46:50) Thank you. Is there anybody else? Go ahead. (01:46:54) Something that I would like to see changed, government-wise, is for the government to stop erasing trans and queer history. There was a Marsha P. Johnson monument and they took that down, and they pretend like trans people or queer people just do not exist. But we do. We always have, throughout time, throughout history. Erasing our history does not erase the people. So I, and just us as a collective, would really appreciate if people put focus on transgender and queer history, because that is important. We need it to move forward and I really, really appreciate that. (01:47:44) It is obviously part of the playbook and that is well heard. That is something we are pursuing, to make sure that we are increasing the number of representations in cultural institutions, that we are adding more monuments. More than that, knowing that we are creating history right now, we need to put money in the hands of queer and trans artists and people that are doing incredibly good work. It goes all the way back even to Nazi Germany — in addition to persecuting Jews, the first thing they did was loot and set on fire all of the research that had been done at the premier centre for sexual and gender health that they were doing in Germany at the time. So that is really well noted and taken. Thank you for that. Does anybody else want to add anything? (01:48:40) I think I just want to add, especially when talking about safe and reliable health care for transgender people, I think that can go beyond just finding safe medical practitioners to go to. It touches on so many other aspects of life. But I think this is one area where people can be very vulnerable. I know from my own experiences and hearing other people say this too — experiences with medical practitioners, even like a dentist, something outside of seeking gender-affirming care — being visibly or openly trans can really impact the care you receive. It can be a really difficult task trying to find someone you can trust and trying to find safe, reliable care. Thank you. (01:49:43) I guess it is difficult to say because, you know, what is even within the ability and scope of the City Council. I mean, I kind of just think what you are doing right now, which is just listening and actively listening to the voices of transgender and gender nonconforming residents, I think is really the most important part. Because obviously, with everything going on right now, something like today where we are coming in to talk about one aspect of our lives — which is the medical aspect — there are other aspects of our lives as well where we face difficulty and discrimination, and there are not institutional accommodations for us. To give an example, sometimes I will use the City's exercise and recreational facilities. I will go to the public swimming pool, but my ability to use something like that, which other people take for granted, is not really there. It has been a longstanding issue because there is not a gender-neutral restroom. I would have to go separately to the front desk and ask them for the key each time to unlock their single stall, and I might just come out of the pool dripping wet and have to ask them to unlock it every single time. There is not that space that is carved out for us and it can make day-to-day life frustrating and really grueling. So yeah, really just being open to input, like you are doing now, is so important. (01:51:35) I admire the mayor's initiatives where he speaks about this publicly, but I think particularly in the media there is so much negative and false messaging pertaining to trans people, just spreading completely fear-mongering that is not based in any form of reality whatsoever. I think positive media representation and telling authentic and positive stories about trans people is just so important in any shape or form. That is the way I see it. That is the most important thing. (01:52:11) Thank you. You all are brilliant and powerful and I just encourage you, please be in touch. We would love to stay in communication and we are all ears. I think Chair Narcisse has a question. She was just going to add that your strength, your willingness to testify, your willingness to have the conversation — that is what is going to make the difference. With your love and your drive, it will push out the hate. To anyone else coming behind you, you are taking the lead. You are leaders. Continue being the leaders and advocates and make your voice heard. Let no one shadow your voice. Let your voice be out there. You have the greatest advocates here. So keep on coming, keep telling us, and we will make sure that we do what we are supposed to do on our end. Thank you. (01:52:59) Thank you, guys, and I just want to acknowledge that we have been joined by CM Pierina Sanchez while we were in session. (01:53:07) Joined. Thanks so much. (01:53:17) All right, next up we have our Manhattan Borough President Brad Hoylman-Sigal. Come on up. We are not going to make you wait. Yeah, you came a long way, Borough President. (01:53:35) I did. It travels across the street. Yes, it is a change from Albany, where I had a five-minute commute from Union Square. Quite a (01:53:46) luxury. Thank you. Thank you. (01:53:49) Chairs, and members of the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use, Hospitals, Women and Gender Equality: I am Manhattan Borough President Brad Hoylman-Sigal, proud to represent the borough where the modern LGBTQI+ human rights movement was born at Stonewall 57 years ago. I really want to thank the Council and your leadership for convening this hearing into the families, the young people, providers and advocates fighting to protect the life-saving medical care that we are discussing today under the threats from the Trump administration. I am extremely proud to stand alongside you. You know that we face a targeted campaign to end medical care for transgender youth. At least 27 states have enacted laws restricting gender affirming care for trans youth, and as more of the country closes its doors, New York is slowly becoming one of the last safe havens and bastions of health care for the LGBTQI+ community. But none of us can take that protection for granted. On October 13, the Trump administration is expected to implement a federal rule ending Medicaid and CHIP reimbursement for this care for young people. And this year, as we know, the Department of Justice under Trump issued subpoenas to hospitals nationwide, including several here in New York City, seeking the private records of young patients. I have heard from so many families whose children's records were among those demanded by the subpoenas. It is a uniquely terrifying situation to be in — to do everything in your power to make sure your child receives life-saving medical care, and that is what it is, and then to have the federal government violate your children's and your family's right to medical privacy. I had the privilege of working with colleagues in Albany in passing New York's Shield Law and what is called Shield Law 2.0, to provide the strongest possible protections for medical providers against abuses in the legal process. The Shield Law 2.0 protects patients and providers from attempts by out-of-state prosecutors to find them liable or seek information in New York simply for providing, seeking or obtaining life-saving care that is legal in New York State. It also requires New York institutions that receive requests for protected health information, even from the federal government, to notify the Attorney General and affected patients before any disclosure. Because of the Shield Law 2.0, the families whose records were sought by the Trump Department of Justice through federal grand jury subpoenas were at least notified with enough time to get to court with help from Lambda Legal. And with that help, they won an injunction, still active today, that blocks the Department of Justice from obtaining these records. But as you are well aware, state law cannot override federal law and cannot by itself stop a federal investigation. It also cannot protect what does not exist. We need providers to actually provide care, and as the Trump administration continues its shameful crusade, there are fewer and fewer willing to do so. This month, as we know, two of Manhattan's largest hospital systems, NYU Langone and Mount Sinai, reached agreements with the Department of Justice to end youth gender affirming medical care. I think we are all disappointed by this decision and by what it means for the young people and families who relied on these institutions. I am also greatly concerned that we still do not have clarity on the details of these settlements, including how the hospitals will ensure continuity of care for patients currently undergoing treatment. Make no mistake: this is the result of the federal government being uniquely obsessed with stopping transgender people from getting health care and stripping away their basic rights. But as Dawn Gabriel, the mother of a 17-year-old whose records were included in the grand jury subpoena here in New York, told me: "In New York we protect our children. We do not feed them to the beast, especially for political convenience." As access to care declines, families need clear and accurate information about where care is still available. CM Schulman's Bill, Int 0949-2026, would require DOHMH to publish LGBTQI+ health and gender affirming care resources and maintain a searchable map of these health services. I urge you to consider and pass this legislation. I also applaud the resolutions before you calling for Albany to act on similar measures. But our work is not finished. I was glad to see the Council commit $15 million to providers, but unfortunately that is still not enough money to cover the impending loss of Medicaid dollars, so the City and the State need to do everything in our collective power to meet these needs. Thank you again to the Council and the advocates in this room today who continue to fight for the right of transgender young people to live and thrive in New York, and thank you for the opportunity to testify today. Thank you. (01:59:30) Borough President, we really appreciated that, and also appreciate the body of good work and the collaboration. Okay, next up we have Goldner, Brianna, Tatyana Cruz, Ronin Tuggle and... (02:00:23) Here. All right, anybody can start. Can you hear me now? My name is Judith Goldner. I am the attorney in charge of the Civil Law Reform Unit at the Legal Aid Society, and I want to thank the Council for holding this very important oversight hearing. (02:00:45) I want to start by saying that we at Legal Aid are very committed to ensuring that everyone who has gender dysphoria is given access to the medically necessary care that they deserve. We were lead counsel in Cruz v. Zucker, which was our lawsuit against New York State to ensure gender affirming care for folks who need that care. We are obviously very concerned about not just what the Trump administration is trying to do here, but also... (02:01:29) ...that hospitals such as Mount Sinai are dropping patients and are not providing continuity of care. Everyone needs to know that that is not what should be happening. We appreciate that care is still available for young people at the City hospitals. We are a bit concerned, however, that the $15 million is not going to go to care for young people, and it is care for young people that is most at risk right now. So it is critically important, I think, for the Council to make it clear to the City that it is so critical for the City to continue to provide that care to folks who are not otherwise going to be able to access it. We support Resolution 0547-2026, which calls on the legislature to pass A.5625, which would establish a gender affirming care program. We want to make sure that the State is going to step up to provide that care to people. We are mostly supportive of Int 0949-2026. We are somewhat concerned about the mapping part of this because of threats. We would be happy to work with the Council on figuring out ways to allow people who should have access to information to have it, without opening it up to people who might behave badly. Thanks again for doing this. We are always available to help folks with issues as they come up as well. Thank you so much. (02:03:29) Thank you. We are eager to be in conversation and hear more, and I am sure the sponsor of the Bill is as well. Thank you. We will reach out. Great. (02:03:46) Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you, Chair Tiffany Cabán, and members of the Committee on Mental Health and Substance Use and the New York City Council, for holding this important oversight hearing on access to gender affirming care and associated mental health outcomes for transgender and non-binary youth. My name is Tatiana Cruz. I am a trans activist and a member of Make the Road New York and the Trans and Queer Coalition. I fled Florida and came to New York because I needed a place where I can live openly and authentically. I needed community, safety and access to health care that recognizes me for who I am. Here in New York, I found those things. Gender affirming care is medically necessary, evidence-based health care recognized by major medical organizations. This is health care and not a political debate. For me, access to this care has profoundly improved my emotional and psychological well-being. It helped me feel comfortable in my body, confident in myself and able to live as the woman that I know myself to be. All of these things have also helped me overcome substance abuse. This is why this issue is deeply personal to me. I am also thinking about a young trans person named Jade, whom I met when she was 12. She is now 17. I have watched her grow up, but I have also watched her struggle recently after losing access to gender affirming care that she once received. At 17, she should be focused on her future, her dreams, her education and becoming the person that she wants to be. She should not have to be struggling because access to her health care was taken away. Her story reminds us that access to care cannot depend on where someone lives or on changing political circumstances. That is why the New York Trans and Queer Coalition supports Res 0547-2026 and Res 0208-2026 and their call for a statewide gender affirming care access program. We need continuity of care, stable providers, statewide coordination and long-term investment, so that transgender New Yorkers can access the health care that they need. I came to New York because I needed the opportunity to live and thrive, and I want Jade and every transgender young person to have the same opportunity without having to leave home to find it. Thank you for your time. (02:06:14) Thank you for your testimony. (02:06:17) ... (02:06:58) ... (02:07:11) ... (02:07:31) ... (02:07:58) ... (02:09:20) ... (02:09:54) ... (02:10:08) I will read the translation now. Good afternoon. Skipping the thank yous: personally, when I was young, I did not have access to hormone therapy or surgeries, much less support. I also did not have emotional support to transition, so I had to live a life that I did not really want. I have to say that I had two suicide attempts because I did not know how to navigate life as a trans woman, because I was living an identity in which I did not feel fulfilled or safe. This afternoon I am testifying because we want New York City to commit to being part of the change, and I ask you not to allow trans young people to live through what I experienced when I was young. No trans child should have to suffer and cry alone in a room because they do not have access to hormone therapy and support, especially from their family and health care specialists. The specialists, when they obtained their licenses, took an oath to save lives instead of allowing a life to cease to exist. Before denying access to hormone therapy to a trans person, think about what that person is experiencing and thinking. Perhaps what is in their mind is that there is no way out and that they cannot be who they really are. In any corner of the country or the world, a small human being may be thinking about giving up and ending their life today because society is denying them the right to live through their process of transformation and to be who they really are. Today I want to speak directly to those... (02:11:12) ...trans young people who think they are alone. I want to remind them that they are not. I want them to look at those of us who today have transitioned — that although it was not easy, at the end of the day our lives are similar to the metamorphosis of a caterpillar that crawls and struggles against wind and tide, but one day that caterpillar becomes a beautiful butterfly. The coalition requests that the Council continue investing in access to gender affirming health care for uninsured and underinsured people, that LGBTQI+ community health organizations exist, that mental health services for young people exist, and that data collection respects privacy and helps identify gaps in services. The coalition also strongly supports Res 0547-2026 and Res 0208-2026. These resolutions will provide our community with the opportunity to navigate the healthcare system and find health care providers who understand the needs of our communities. Trans people are being attacked at the national level and we want New York City to continue leading in terms of good gender affirming services. It is a reality that many in our trans community travel from other states to seek gender affirming services. We want New York to be the beacon that guides our community toward a place where all transgender and non-binary people deserve timely, affordable and identity-affirming health care supporting their physical and mental well-being. We urge the Council to advance these legislative proposals, continue investing in community care and strengthen accountability so that all New Yorkers can access the care that they deserve. Thank you. (02:12:36) Hello, my name is Brianna Karen. My pronouns are she and her, and I am a nurse practitioner at Planned Parenthood of Greater New York. Thank you to the chairs and the committee members for convening this important hearing, and thank you to the Bill sponsors who are advancing legislation to ensure that transgender and gender non-conforming youth have equitable access to the resources they need to live full lives. Planned Parenthood of Greater New York is a trusted provider of sexual and reproductive health care and education programs for communities throughout New York. In 2025, we conducted over 3,100 therapy visits, providing care to over 1,500 individuals. I have had the honor to provide care to many of those patients myself. It has been my profound privilege to see the joy, comfort and improved mental health that comes with accessing this life-affirming and life-saving care. I have also borne witness as repeated attacks from the Trump-Vance administration caused increased anxiety, uncertainty and despair. We have seen the burden on patients trying to access care that has historically been out of reach and steeped in stigma and discrimination. Nationwide attacks that further limit access to compassionate, affordable and comprehensive health care have forced many in the community to go without. It is imperative that New York remains a beacon for trans people seeking care, regardless of the federal political winds. Planned Parenthood of Greater New York supports Int 0949-2026, Res 0208-2026 and Res 0547-2026, which ensure New York State and New York City are providing critical resources to transgender youth. We especially applaud Res 0547-2026, which establishes a gender affirming care fund to provide financial support for this necessary medical and surgical care. I personally hope that Res 0208-2026 can be expanded to include nursing, pharmacy and allied health students as well. At Planned Parenthood of Greater New York, we are dedicated to providing and protecting inclusive health care. We commend the Council for advocating for the rights of all people. New York must continue to protect our transgender youth. We look forward to continuing to work with the Council to ensure health care access for all. Thank you for your time and dedication to championing this issue. Thank you. (02:14:53) Thank you so much for the chairs and the committees for holding this hearing today and giving us an opportunity to testify. My name is Ronin Tuggle. I serve as the digital organizing strategist at the New York Civil Liberties Union, also known as the NYCLU. With the federal attacks on gender affirming care and hospitals' recent capitulation, the NYCLU has seen a tremendous uptick in the number of intakes we receive from trans New Yorkers. Disturbingly, we are also hearing anecdotally about an increase in suicides among trans people in the United States, which I know many folks have spoken to you about today. The most common intake calls we field are from loving, supportive parents who are trying to figure out where they can access the health care their children rely on to thrive as their authentic selves. Gender affirming care is health care. People seek it for all kinds of reasons, from precocious puberty to middle-aged hair loss to a diagnosis of gender dysphoria. This care is necessary for people to live in their bodies with dignity and health. When it comes to young people, every family should have the freedom to love and support their child, which includes the ability to make private medical decisions free from political interference. New York City and State have a role to play in ensuring New York remains a place where trans people can thrive, and the legislation the committee considers today is an important part of that project. (02:16:15) The NYCLU strongly supports Res 0547-2026, which calls for the creation of a state-level gender affirming care access program. This program would greatly support trans New Yorkers' ability to continue to access the health care we rely upon to be ourselves and chart our own futures. However, Res 0547-2026 includes a very narrow definition of gender affirming care, focusing entirely on medical care. The resolution should be amended to reflect the State's definition of gender affirming care, which also includes mental health care and other forms of affirming care, but also excludes non-consensual surgeries conducted on intersex young people. The NYCLU also strongly supports Int 0949-2026, although we do want to note some concerns around the map requirement, which could potentially put a target on the backs of gender affirming care providers, especially in this political context. The state-level hospital transparency bill, A.5625 in the Assembly and the companion bill in the Senate, could serve as a model for city-level legislation and help prospective patients identify and find other frequently denied types of health care, such as reproductive health care. Thank you so much for the opportunity to present this testimony and for your focus on supporting trans folks and access to gender affirming care today. Thank you. (02:17:29) Thank you so much to all of you, and I would especially love to have folks follow up on expanded definitions and other things to kind of strengthen the proposed legislation. Appreciate that. Everybody good? Okay. Thank you. CM Gutiérrez was just acknowledging the fact that I have been working on my español. She helps me with my Spanish language interviews. Our next panel is Jan... Bianca, Raina... Galloway and Kristen Clifford. Just going to pause for a couple of minutes and the chair will be right back. All right, so one more time, we have our panel: Garcia... okay, that is right as well. (02:19:30) I see Bianca over here. (02:19:38) So, Janice, Garcia, Raina and Kristen Clifford, and if I butchered anybody's name, please correct me. Thank you. (02:19:57) Good afternoon, Chair, and all the other Council members that are here with us today. My name is Ren Galloway and I serve as the advocacy manager of the Ali Forney Center, which is the nation's largest provider for homeless youth. I am also a proud member of the Trans and Queer (02:20:12) Coalition. I want to amplify what our other members said, and really strongly amplify what the youth panel said as well. It was a really strong testimony from our youth, and I invite folks to really marinate in what they not only said, but to listen and believe what they said as well. What we know here is that gender affirming care is medically necessary, evidence-based health care recognized by every major medical association. We also cannot separate gender affirming care from mental health care. Without access to mental health care, we cannot fully support the mental health of transgender and gender nonconforming youth. Without accessible, affirming care, we cannot fully support their gender affirming development. As somebody that works with transgender and gender nonconforming youth all the time, we know that folks struggle with gender dysphoria, things like suicide and amplified anxiety, trying to receive these services. So every day we try to work not to remove these opportunities from them. I simply wanted to invite people to accept that these things are not only happening, but to really think about how people are getting to their appointments, how people are understanding their identities as they navigate these health care systems. For many, there are barriers that are compounded by things like homelessness, immigration status and unstable health care coverage. Delays or interrupted care really removes access and postpones treatment, which creates fear, uncertainty and worsens mental health conditions. As attacks continue in this country, I want to really invite us into a couple of questions I have for the Council here, so we can try to start to remove these gaps together. Are there enough affirming care providers to meet this demand? Which neighborhoods continue to lack services? How long are young people waiting for affirming mental health care? How are the City agencies measuring whether access to gender affirming care is improving in our health care systems? As New York continues to strengthen access to care, we encourage the City to continue to prioritize strong privacy and security protections for patients and health care professionals. In today's climate, these are being taken away, and these protections are essential to making sure people are protected. So I really want to just note lastly that the coalition supports Int 0949-2026, but we need to make sure that not only is this resource regularly updated, but we need to make sure that barriers to care are addressed and that there are protections so that information alone is not enough. We must ensure that information is not being shared out to those that should not be receiving it. It must be paired with continued investments in providers' capacity, affirming mental health services, health care navigation and community-based organizations that young people already trust. Every transgender and gender nonconforming young person deserves timely, affordable, affirming care, as you all know. So I appreciate your time today. I will continue to add more in my written testimony, but thank you so much. (02:23:07) Thank you. And do not worry about that. (02:23:09) Thank you so much. Thank you to the New York City Council for holding this hearing. I am a community organizer with Make the Road New York and a member of the New York Trans and Queer Coalition. We are testifying before you this afternoon because we want to confirm a commitment to our communities and to highlight our needs. As a transgender woman, access to gender affirming care is vital because it helps us find guidance, information and options for navigating the health care system in a way that is safe and prepared. I remember when I was 17, buying and injecting hormones that I bought from the street or the black market. In my experience, it is not an isolated case. As a community organizer, I have heard stories from community members about the lack of information and how difficult it is to find a humane path to life and to transition. Gender affirming care is medically necessary, evidence-based health care recognized by all major medical associations. Thanks to living in New York City, I can say that I have a better chance to transition with my doctor's guidance. But trans people like me still face attacks on health care and basic human rights across the country. In addition to that, trans people also face difficulty navigating the health care system. These barriers are a gap that prevents some trans community members from receiving the care they deserve. The coalition also strongly supports Int 0949-2026, which would establish an LGBTQI+ resource. As a trans woman working with my community, I have direct experience helping and facilitating, guiding people toward a healthy and safe transition. We also want the City of New York to support Res 0547-2026. This resolution will help New Yorkers and potentially those traveling from other states to access better gender affirming practices, ensure that names and pronouns are respected and that people feel safe when speaking with their doctors. New York has become a national leader in protecting transgender and nonbinary communities, but this leadership must not only be symbolic. People must actually have access to the care they need. And the reason I am saying this — I am going off my script, but I just want to say that it is important to continue talking about this issue because we have a lot of people, not only people who were born in this country, but also people who are coming to New York to be who they want to be. There are still people injecting hormones that they buy from the street. They also inject silicone from the black market, and we really need a health care system that truly supports everyone, regardless of gender or color or whatever it may be. We are continuing to do this work and it was really so inspiring to see everyone here today. Thank you. (02:26:39) My name is Raina Bien. I am the parent of a non-binary seventh grader and the board chair of Transformative Schools. Thank you all for the opportunity to provide testimony today. The last couple of years have been very challenging for me and the other parents I know trying to raise happy, healthy trans children in a world that feels like it has been abruptly turned upside down. My 12-year-old has been kicked out of, and lost the doctor to whom they confided deeply personal information, and had their medical records tied up in a lawsuit brought by our federal government. The families that are struggling the hardest now are families like mine with younger kids that need puberty blockers — the life-saving medications that put a temporary and reversible pause on puberty to give kids breathing room while they consider long-term medical decisions. Our families are locked out of practices that have seemingly arbitrary age limits like 16 or 14 or 13, as we learned when we called around, and that does include various NYC Health + Hospitals locations. We are driving multiple hours out of the City to clinics that have said they will keep going, paying out of pocket to private practitioners who do not take insurance in the hopes that it will keep their practices safe, anxiously navigating care with an overburdened local clinic that has too many patients, and in the case of too many families I know, moving abroad. What does all this say about our City that calls itself a trans sanctuary, that has promised it will not turn its back on trans youth? I applaud the City Council and the Mayor's office for promising more money for gender affirming care, but the details of how this money is spent is equally as important if it is to reach the most vulnerable population (02:28:18) of younger trans children. Can you lean on the organizations already receiving City money to expand the ages they serve? Can you provide funds for training new providers, including for puberty blocker implants? If an NYC Health + Hospitals expansion is not on the table, then how about a City-run pediatric and teen clinic? I urge you to think creatively and boldly, because pouring more money into how things have been done in the past will not solve our problems. We need new systems to keep children's care local, affordable and protected from whatever the federal government plans next. Thank you. (02:29:00) Hi. My name is Kristen Clifford and my pronouns are she/her. I am the proud mom of two trans kids, one of whom is still a minor. NYU Langone ended health care for my teenager, not because of medical science, but because of political pressure from the Trump administration. Our family's private medical records have been requested by Trump's Department of Justice. We have an injunction for now, and I view the recent deal with Trump's Department of Justice as a shakedown. NYU Langone paid over $8 million and stopped medically necessary health care. This is the environment that we are all living in. I am so grateful that both of my children were able to receive excellent gender affirming health care, and especially puberty blockers, and especially puberty blocker implants. Having that time is so important to early teenagers. I cannot stress this enough. Puberty blockers, and especially the implant, have been one of the things that parents struggle to access the most in the past few years. I do believe some of it is because of the way that it has been coded by insurance companies, where it used to be in-office and now it is coded as surgery. If there is anything that this City can do, we would appreciate that. (02:30:32) Our care was taken away twice. After the first time it was restored, and then again, as I was protesting in Washington, D.C., some of us were arrested. As I got out of jail for protesting for gender affirming care, I got a message saying that NYU Langone had cut my child's gender affirming care. We need the City and State to do everything they can to support trans kids. My children's mental health was greatly improved by gender affirming care. I have watched them blossom and grow and become their true selves. The fascist, dictatorial political environment is harming our children, causing anxiety, fear and despair. Parents know what it is like to try to keep our kids alive, and not all of our kids make it. A teenager in my neighborhood in Queens committed suicide by jumping off the Queensboro Bridge a few years ago. They had been bullied for being trans. We need to do everything in our power to support trans kids, especially in light of the harmful federal actions, and we need to step in. The City needs to step in and provide gender affirming care. One of my questions for this City is: how can this City (02:31:58) attract and support more gender affirming care practitioners? This is something that we need as a sanctuary city. Gender affirming care is life-saving care, because I have seen that up close in my own home. Trans kids need all the support they can get to become thriving trans adults, and parents need support too. So many parents are scared to reach out because of all of the anti-trans rhetoric and hatred. They are scared to get help for their families. This resource map is really important because we share information in a whisper network. But if we have this resource, we are all worried about the providers and about the safety of families who do not come forward because they are afraid of being outed. I am so grateful to all the people who are here today supporting trans youth, and I support everything that New York City can do to expand access to gender affirming health care. Thank you. (02:33:14) I want to thank you all for your testimony, especially the parents that we have with us. You have provided us with what we needed to hear, but also suggestions on what could come next. So I just want to create another space if there is anything that you want to expand on in terms of how else the City can support you and your families at this time. Obviously our door is open and we want to be having those conversations. And also, my God, you all are incredible parents. So thank you. You know what? Our kids are lucky because they have us, and there are so many kids that do not have parents like us, and the City needs to support all of those kids. Okay. Thank you. All right, we have another panel. Yes. Okay. Our next panel includes Kimberly Blair, Annabelle Ruggerio, Ray Blazin, Cleo, Andy Bowen and... again, please, I apologize for names. Correct me. Yeah, step on up. Okay. (02:34:47) Good afternoon. My name is Zak Cleo Misrafi and I am a longtime New Yorker. I use they/them pronouns and every time I come here to City Hall when we are talking about measures that are affecting the most lives, it is usually in the end after corporate interests. I really appreciate everyone who is still here, but we know that it is a challenge to wait when not all of City Hall, especially those who are trans allies, are here to really hear the testimony of those of us who are struggling. I am going to do my best to go through this and I also sent a written testimony as well, as I was not feeling well. We know that trans people are being demonized and stigmatized across America and across the world, and that even as a trans adult, I know that for my inner child and for trans youth that I am protecting, it is crippling my mental health living with hysteria and fear — thinking even today, if I take my hormones, am I going to be targeted? Am I going to be mocked? Am I going to be harassed again on the subway, on the train? Am I going to be mocked and denied care while in the hospital? And so on. We know that gender care is more than just surgeries or HRT, right? It is support groups, it is counseling, it is social services. These are all the elements that people are forgetting that encompass gender affirming care. And I am only here because of trans ancestors who paved the way, but we know that we are still struggling here in New York City. When I was working at the New York Public Library during COVID, not only was I discriminated against on the basis of gender and my disabilities, but DC 37, the largest union for the City, did not even have any trans affirming care. I had to pay out of pocket during the pandemic and was not even given competent care, and I had to keep re-explaining myself to my union members. I come from a tradition that says if you save a life you save the world, and that you are able to break any rule in the Torah as long as you save a life, and that is part of what is bringing me here today. We know that trans people are facing even in New York City systematic barriers to jobs. So think about accounting for how much it costs — how much am I going to pay for food today, or for my hormones? We know that three out of five LGBT adults are without food security. I was denied certain care in a psych ward for just walking while trans in one of your City hospitals. I had a relapse because I was not given certain medication, just like my hormonal treatment. We know that it is hard enough to communicate our needs when both in City Council and in the state, we still do not have a single elected official who is trans, and I hope that I will be part of a generation that will break that glass ceiling. We know that with hate crimes against trans women of color at 79% more than any other demographic, we went yesterday to rally against Mount Sinai, and... (02:37:58) They are debating: do we care more about our values or do we care more about our money, to cave in to Trumpism? I could go on and on, but I also just wanted to share that I spent an evening at a Black Trans Liberation Kitchen where on average they have 200 trans youth, most of whom are malnourished. Most are forced into sex work here in New York City and are not always getting HRT through approved medical care. We know from our elders who are no longer here what it means when we do not have proper medical care. I am going to be here around afterwards, but I just wanted to be able to remind you that again, even for those of us who are able to get some aspects of gender care, some aspects are really class-based. There is just an uneven playing field. I had to wait over five years for certain operations, and care like vocal feminization is only for those with certain types of insurance. So I really wanted to put into the record that this is affecting trans people across generations. Thank you so much for being here. (02:39:09) Thank you, and we will be sure to read the full written testimony you submitted. Thank you. (02:39:12) Hello, everyone. I am speaking strictly on behalf of myself today, but I am an ACT UP rabble-rouser who helped organize the protest at Mount Sinai that Director Brown spoke at, and I would like to take the opportunity to thank her publicly for being there to start today's hearing. These bills are great steps. Int 0949-2026 fulfills the demand our community has been asking for. As someone who had the opportunity to advocate for this kind of resource, I would like to personally thank CM Schulman and her staff. But these are steps that needed to happen over a year ago. The situation has quite predictably deteriorated rapidly over the past year. A few short months ago, the Governor became the likely culprit behind appropriations for gender affirming care being cut from the state's budget, and now two hospitals have folded to a fascist inquisition. I must admit I am personally invested in inflicting political and reputational damage on both Mount Sinai and Langone, and yet I find it hard to lay blame fully at their feet. At the end of the day they made a cold calculation. (02:40:27) Either defy the federal government and rely on insufficient municipal funds to make up the difference, or abandon trans youth. The context and local policy environment these calculations were made under is due to a collective failure. To be blunt, this is the fault of the relative inaction by the state government, the City Council and both recent mayors, Adams and Mamdani — not them personally, but their offices. So while I am happy with the legislation before us today, we demand more. We demand far more. We need to make a public example of both Mount Sinai and Langone. We need to financially support institutions who stand by their patients. We need every fascist capitulator to know that the support of the people is predicated on them not folding. We need to tax the rich to make up for federal cuts to everyone's health care. And in these bleak times we need you, the Mayor, the Governor and the Council to be proactive instead of reactive. For a more concrete idea of what we can do: no more municipal funds to any discriminatory health care institutions. Thank you. (02:41:54) Hi. My name is Barry Blazin, my pronouns are they/them. I have served as a public health professional for the City and in social services serving the LGBTQ and unhoused community before, but I am testifying today in a personal capacity and the views expressed are my own. Regarding Int 0949-2026, an LGBTQ+ resource map does exist, which was addressed earlier. However, not only will this particular bill codify and protect its existence — which is necessary in times in which our access to our own health is becoming more and more difficult to access across the country — but it also leaves room for greater granularity when it comes to reliable information about individual providers. This map becoming a more concrete and expanded resource has the potential to be a life-saving mechanism by increasing accessibility through readily available information. As somebody who recently had their provider leave their practice at a clinic that was previously an all-queer local clinic that had been bought out by Langone, I was a patient in a practice where some providers would be supportive of my identity and work with me to provide specialty knowledge about my own health, and some would not be suited for that endeavor. That was anxiety-inducing and made me reticent to seek care, and resulted in the disruption of my care for both ordinary wellness and for chronic conditions. I had to rely on word of mouth and quietly speaking to other staff members in the hallways to gather opinions on who would be best suited to respectfully tend to my health care needs. For a long-term, reliable and culturally responsive provider, a queer and trans person having a map expanded with the weight of the City's authority and consideration of standards behind it, and with care and regard for provider safety in turn, would make the inevitable repeat of that situation — because it will happen again to me at some point, sooner, I hope later — but it will make that experience a lot smoother and more accessible. (02:43:54) And reduce meaningful barriers. This... (02:43:56) Can also potentially reduce the funneling of care to specific institutions, many of which are Manhattan-based but are already strained to serve the sheer number of people who require safer services, and provide a valuable resource to many other New Yorkers. There is also something I do want to put forward for consideration: the fact that the bill as it stands does not have a timeline indicated for what would be a reasonable timeframe for updating that map. Given that it is unclear if the existing map is being amended or if a new one is being created, I do think a timeline on what that can look like would be appropriate. (02:44:37) Thank you. Great. Thank you for that. (02:44:44) Good afternoon and thank you, Chair Farías and CM Narcisse and members here today. I am Kimberly Blair. I am the Senior Director of Policy and Advocacy at Girls for Gender Equity, an organization that works intergenerationally through a Black feminist lens to center the leadership of Black girls and gender-expansive youth of color. At a time when trans and non-binary people are under nationwide attack, GGE stands firmly here today on behalf of youth of color. We stand also as a member of the Trans and Queer Coalition to support Int 0949-2026, Res 0208-2026 and Res 0547-2026, which we see as stepping stones towards increasing access to life-saving care. As someone who has spent the majority of her career at the intersections of reproductive justice and mental health policy, I am here to tell you that an estimated one in five youth report attempting suicide and that nearly 50% seriously consider attempting suicide within any given one-year period. In past years, the increase in anti-trans laws in 19 restrictive states have significantly increased incidents of past-year suicide attempts among these youth by as much as 72%. (02:46:07) While New Yorkers might think we are immune because we do not live in one of these restrictive states, our trans, gender-nonconforming and non-binary youth consume this anti-trans rhetoric and experience bans right here from trusted health care facilities. Conversely, reports show that youth who have high social support and a gender affirming environment report suicide attempt rates at less than half the rate of those without. We believe these bills are intercept interventions that would... (02:46:39) Help us increase the social support and combat these negative mental health outcomes among our youth. Int 0949-2026 especially would help... (02:46:50) Organizations like mine from spending a fair amount of staff time creating and updating our own internal resources annually to support gender-expansive youth. We do not see this as the complete responsibility of organizations like ours, while also navigating case management, supporting students' financial and immigration needs and providing life-saving education and programming to aid gender-nonconforming youth in self-discovery and identity formation. Due to time restrictions we plan to submit the rest of our commentary in writing, including suggested bill edits, but I want to thank you again for taking the time today to listen to and stand up as allies for trans, gender-nonconforming and non-binary youth. We hope that you vote these bills favorably out of committee. (02:47:44) Thank you. And I just wanted to take a moment to say I appreciate what you said about your faith. One of the things I love about the Jewish faith is the idea that none of us is beyond redemption, and when you save a life you save the world. Going beyond that, I think about the way that these institutions have capitulated, and another part of this Jewish faith is that you do not sacrifice — it is like we get there together or we do not get there at all. And so I think it is really, really powerful that we all are here and making it clear that that is the case. I am really proud to be fighting alongside you. I also appreciate you. Thank you. Go for it. (02:48:25) Yeah, I just — it is always hard to fit everything in with the time limit, but I am thinking about also, as someone who grew up in New York who did not know about my rights and about accessing certain services — for example, growing up in the Orthodox Jewish community, there was a moment for me. When I came out, my mother said to me, not long ago, she said, "All you will ever be is a prostitute," and my father said, "No one will ever love you." These are messages we are internalizing that they are taking from the media, right? And I had to face a really hard predicament over a decade ago — my mother said, either you comply with my rules, despite you paying rent and being legally able to not have to observe her faith — because we have different Jewish denominations — she said, either you take your hormones and you leave, or you do not. I was subjected to abuse for many years and never got help, and this is the reality for many people. There are so many stories of people who, whether they leave a fundamentalist faith or whether they are not in a supportive environment, what does that do to them long term? About having internalized shame about who they are and feeling fearful that you are hated. I will just end with this: trans elders chose to remind you that not everyone is against you. But I will say that everyone in the community is on guard, and it breaks my heart to even go to a support group and see people terrified of simply wanting to change parts of their documentation, feeling like we have to hide until Trumpism is over. So thank you so much. Thank you all. (02:50:11) Okay, this is our last in-person panel. We have Angelica and Mohammed Bertossa — again, I apologize, please correct me — and then we will have one Zoom panel. Andy, I think I called you earlier? Yeah, come on up. Yeah. (02:50:35) Sorry. Oh, good. You are good, all right. Good afternoon. My name is... my pronouns are she/her and I am the mother of an eight-year-old transgender daughter. Three years ago, my family moved from Florida to Brooklyn in search of the legal protections New York offers transgender people. I am now a member of District 15 and an organizer with Parents of Gender Expansive Kids. I grew up in a conservative Christian home and knew nothing about transgender people when my daughter told me she was a girl at three years old. She did not say, "I think I am a girl," or "I wish I was a girl." She said, "I am a girl." So I listened and I learned. I joined parent groups, bought the books and read the research, and what I found was remarkably simple: trans kids have the best outcomes when they are loved and supported along the way. I also encountered a lot of confusing rhetoric about trans issues. To clear things up, my daughter is not a girl trapped in a boy's body. She is a girl who was born into a world that decided she was a boy before she could speak for herself. We put children into one of two boxes before they are ever even born and expect them to spend their lives fitting into them. But gender, biology and nature are far more complicated than that, and it is precisely that diversity that brings beauty to our world. My daughter knows she does not need to look or dress a certain way to be a girl. She prefers shopping in the boys' section because that is where she finds the video game shirts, and above all others the title she claims is: gamer. I do not know whether my daughter will ever need gender affirming medical care — she is only eight years old. She also has several medical conditions that require us to see multiple specialists, and as her mother, I selfishly hope that she will not have to navigate any more medical challenges. But if gender affirming care is something she needs to feel safe, comfortable and fully herself in a world that constantly tells her she cannot be, we need that option to be on the table. My family came to New York City because we believed our daughter would be protected here. Families across this country have looked to New York City as a beacon of hope where their children can live freely and access the care they need. It is up to all of us to make sure this City remains that place. Thank you. (02:53:22) Thank you. Good afternoon, Chairs Cabán and Farías, members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity and Mental Health and Substance Use. My name is Andy Bowen. I am founder and executive director of a now one-year-old-ish organization called Queer Budget Center, a national organization that uses government budget advocacy to strengthen vulnerable communities' material resources. I miss working with you all and have joined the Trans and Queer Coalition. I am also a proud gender affirming care patient at Health and Hospitals, which has provided me the best care of my life. I cosigned the asks and questions of the Trans and Queer Coalition partners and I will emphasize some extra points. It is important to note, given the capitulation of Mount Sinai and Presbyterian, that the Trump administration loses when challenged and other hospital systems have put up fights, notably in the Midwest. It is notable that after many losses in court, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services have held off finalizing their proposed rule that would condition hospitals' participation in Medicare and Medicaid on their offering of gender affirming care. With that in mind, we need a whole-of-government approach to fight the feds. I look to the entire Adams administration, including the Law Department, Chief Counsel and Council, to align on a unified goal of protecting gender affirming care in line with the New York City Human Rights Act, actions of the Attorney General and others to not only hold the Trump administration to account, but in many cases hold their own health care systems to account. Yes, I recognize the State is the regulator for hospitals, but the City has a lot of leverage. The City holds contracts with these health systems. These contracts are in many cases for important services that should not be ended or interrupted. However, the funding gives the City more leverage to hold these systems to the City's Human Rights Laws. The City should use that power to compel continuation of care for transgender and gender nonconforming people to the (02:55:37) extent legally possible. As to the Bills, I support them and will provide feedback in my written testimony, which will be submitted after the fact. On Res 0547-2026, the Governor must follow the example of the City Council and the Mayor in making historic investments in gender affirming care. The community is suffering and waiting. I cannot stress enough the need to expand gender affirming care for all ages, and that care needs to be widely geographically accessible. The City as a government has the resources and we have the law on our side. Thank you. I appreciate you so much. (02:56:18) Thank you. I appreciate you and thank you so much for your testimony. I just again want to provide an opportunity to both of you. If there are other things beyond what you stated in your testimony that you think the City can or should be doing to support you and your families... (02:56:42) So I work on this and we have been talking about mandated curricula. Right now, one of the programs is Wit and Wisdom. There is no LGBTQI+ representation in that. Teachers, if they choose to teach it, have to supplement that — they have to rework the whole lesson plan to include that. And it also changes from school to school. (02:57:14) Do you have a supportive... (02:57:17) Principal. And we have guidelines in New York City that protect these kids, but it is not always the case that they are followed, right? (02:57:25) And so just making sure that our kids are learning about... I mean, for my daughter to learn about people like herself. And to make sure that families are receiving support at the school level, not just medical. (02:57:43) Yeah. Thank you so much. I am so overwhelmed with too many thoughts and I am afraid of saying the wrong thing right now. We will talk. Having been a former... I worked for the previous administration. I feel like I know too much. So I will step back. We were very glad you were there. Oh, thanks. Thank you. I am not sure I was... (02:58:15) OK, so we are going to move to the Zoom. I think we have one person on the Zoom. Go ahead. Good afternoon. Sure, Chairs Farías and members of the committees. My name is Sue Mendez and I am the Policy and Legislative Coordinator at New York Lawyers for the Public Interest, better known as NYLPI, a civil rights organization that advances justice for people with disabilities, immigrants, communities of color and other historically marginalized communities. Through our Undocumented Care, TGI+ program, we work directly with transgender, gender nonconforming and intersex immigrants, including young people and their families, to help them access health care, housing as well as legal services. (02:59:16) Thank you so much. We are proud to support Int 0949-2026, Res 0208-2026 and Res 0547-2026, all of which are important steps toward improving access to health care and mental health outcomes for transgender and nonbinary New Yorkers. At a time when transgender and nonbinary people face growing barriers to health care across the country, New York City has an opportunity as well as the responsibility to continue leading. Access to gender affirming care is not only a health care issue. It is a civil rights issue. Every young person deserves access to care that respects their identity, protects their dignity as well as supports their physical and mental health. Transgender and nonbinary youth experience disproportionately high rates of depression, anxiety and suicide. These are not caused simply by a young person's identity. Rather, they are often the result of discrimination, stigma, family rejection as well as systematic barriers that make it harder to access health care and support services. These barriers are often greater within immigrant communities, particularly those who are undocumented. Many of the individuals and families we work with have fled violence and persecution because of their gender identity. They frequently face significant trauma while also navigating complex health care, housing and immigration systems. Fear of government institutions, misinformation about eligibility for services, language barriers and experiences of discrimination can prevent people from accessing the care that they need. That is why the legislation before the Council today is so important. Int 0949-2026 will require the creation of LGBTQI+ health and gender affirming care resources, including a searchable provider directory. (03:01:32) So many families... Time is expired. You can finish your thought. Finish your thought. (03:01:39) Good. Okay, my man is just doing his job, no problem. We support Int 0949-2026. We also support Res 0208-2026, which recognizes the critical role that bias continues to play in health care settings. Anti-bias training for medical students can prepare future providers to better serve transgender and nonbinary patients, immigrants and people with disabilities and other historically marginalized communities. And lastly we support Res 0547-2026, which calls for the establishment of an affirming care program within the New York State Department of Health to help ensure continuity of care. Because access to medically necessary health care is essential for many immigrant patients, disruptions in housing, insurance coverage or access to providers can make continuity of care particularly difficult. I will be providing more detailed testimony for the record and I thank you so much for the opportunity to testify today. (03:02:46) Thank you. Thank you to everyone who testified. If there is anyone present in the room or on Zoom that has not had the opportunity to testify, please raise your hand. Seeing no one else, I would like to note that written testimony, which will be reviewed in full by committee staff, will be submitted to the record up to 72 hours after the close of this hearing by emailing it to testimony at council dot nyc dot gov. I also want to thank Director Brown for staying here for the entirety of the public testimony. Thank you for being here. I want to close by saying it is really, really simple. We want every trans child to grow up to be a trans elder. Period. And I want those kids to be able to play, to make friends, to engage in sports, to build whatever kind of family they choose to build, and to enjoy what I view as the best city on the planet. I have been really moved by the testimony today and all of our shared commitment to really looking out for each other. I know that there is a lot more that government needs to do and we are here to fight to be able to do that. Just thank you. And I do not know if Chair, you have anything else. All right, well, thank you. And with that, we close today's hearing.