Hearing Hearings — Hearing Record ✉
← All hearings

Executive Order 13 Audit Findings

Committee on Immigration

Meeting overview

The Committee on Immigration held an oversight hearing on September 22, 2026, examining the implementation of Executive Order 13, signed by Mayor Mamdani on February 6, 2026, which directed six City agencies to audit their compliance with New York City's sanctuary laws and strengthen protocols governing interactions with federal immigration enforcement. The committee also heard Res 0626-2026, sponsored by CM Farah Louis and co-sponsored by Chair Encarnación, calling on the U.S. Senate to pass S.4814 and the President to sign it, which would require the Secretary of Homeland Security to designate Haiti for Temporary Protected Status.

MOYA Commissioner Faiza Ali provided the administration's account of progress. Her testimony confirmed that the audit had uncovered serious problems, including a dramatic surge in federal enforcement activity at City shelters, a significant increase in detainer requests to NYPD, and the previously undisclosed practice by the Department of Corrections of sending daily lists of non-citizens in custody to ICE without any legal requirement to do so. Ali reported that this practice has been discontinued, that citywide guidance on reporting and property access has been issued to agencies, and that most agency-specific recommendations are completed or on track. She noted that NYPD protocols on detainer requests, 911 immigration calls, and joint task forces are still in progress but expected before year-end, and that the NYPD email audit of task force officers is complete and under review. The IRC, chaired by the First Deputy Mayor, was described as an ongoing coordinating body, not a one-time exercise. The Local Law 228 reports for all four quarters of 2026 were published the day before the hearing.

Legal services organizations and public defenders pushed back on the administration's optimism. Rosa Khan Cruz from the Bronx Defenders, Debra Lee from the Legal Aid Society, Brittany Brown from New York County Defender Services, Josh Epstein from Brooklyn Defenders, and Whitney Bronstein from the Immigrant Defense Project all argued that executive action is insufficient without enforceable legislation, and that the Department of Corrections continues to misinterpret the City's detainer law, allowing ICE to remove individuals directly from Rikers without judicial warrants by characterizing the process as communication rather than honoring a detainer. They called for passage of the New York City Trust Act (Intro 209), Intro 395, and Intro 396. Chair Encarnación announced from the dais that she is now lead sponsor of Intros 995 and 996 (the renumbered versions) and committed to moving them through the legislative process. Advocates and defenders also raised concerns about data sharing between City agencies and third-party technology vendors, the lack of an independent audit of NYPD's Domain Awareness System in over a decade, and biometric data stored by the jail phone system operator Securus. Brooklyn Borough President Reynoso's office called for an independent monitoring commission and mandatory penalties for sanctuary law violations.

The resolution on Haiti TPS drew emotional and substantive testimony. CMs Farah Louis and Rita Joseph, both Haitian American, described the human cost of TPS termination with direct personal testimony. Rodney Pepe-Souvenir of the Haitian American Lawyers Association noted that the House has already passed its version of the legislation with bipartisan support, making Senate action the critical outstanding step. Service providers including CUNY Citizenship Now, Catholic Charities' Haitian Response Initiative, the International Rescue Committee, and Little Haiti BK described the cascading effects of TPS termination: loss of work authorization, family separation decisions, fear-driven drops in use of schools and health services, and empty commercial corridors in Flatbush and East Flatbush. The Door raised the underappreciated problem of DYCD's exclusion from Executive Order 13's scope, noting that ORR and ICE information sharing around unaccompanied minors is an active and unresolved enforcement concern. Health Justice for New York and NY Lawyers for the Public Interest called for private and voluntary hospitals to be brought under enforceable sanctuary protections, flagging that some hospital boards include individuals hostile to compliance, and urging passage of the state Safe Access to Care Act (Senate Bill 194 in Albany). The NYC Anti-Violence Project testified on the specific dangers faced by LGBTQ+ immigrants, including a client currently held in solitary confinement in an all-male Louisiana detention facility after being detained in New York.

The record

Numbers
  • 38% of New York City's population is foreign-born.
  • Immigrants comprise 43% of New York City's workforce.
  • ICE arrested 919 people in New York City in a single month in 2025, nearly twice the number from three months prior.
  • More than three-quarters of those 919 people arrested had no criminal history.
  • Federal immigration authorities entered New York City shelters armed and without judicial warrants at least five times in 2025.
  • The Department of Corrections responded to 24 ICE detainer requests by providing release notifications and facilitating transfers to federal custody.
  • An estimated 350,000 Haitians nationwide held TPS before protections were terminated.
  • Approximately 40,000 Haitian TPS holders reside in New York City.
  • The House-passed version of TPS legislation for Haiti passed with bipartisan support; S.4814 is the Senate companion bill.
  • The IRC's audit covered six agencies: ACS, DOC, DOHMH, Department of Probation, Department of Social Services, and NYPD, with NYC Health and Hospitals and NYC Public Schools participating voluntarily.
  • MOYA's immigration legal support hotline received 8,199 calls from July 1 through September 15, 2026.
  • At least 154 individuals contacted through the hotline specifically in connection with targeted TPS outreach for Haitian New Yorkers since the launch of that initiative.
  • MOYA has conducted 30 canvassing events and days of action across the five boroughs since the current commissioner joined.
  • MOYA distributed over 8,000 printed materials and engaged 650 businesses through outreach efforts.
  • NYC Public Schools updated guidance now covers 14 languages for Know Your Rights materials.
  • The Door handled over 2,500 immigration matters for youth from infancy to 24 years old in 2026, including 614 unaccompanied immigrant minors.
  • The International Rescue Committee has served 10,000 Haitian clients over four years, 5,700 through New York and New Jersey alone.
  • Armed gangs control approximately 90% of Haiti's capital; over half the population faces food insecurity.
  • Nearly 1.5 million Haitians are internally displaced.
  • Over 500,000 Haitian TPS recipients lost status on July 27, 2026, along with over 100,000 Syrian immigrants.
  • DOC's Correctional Intelligence Bureau was sending daily reports to ICE that were not required by state, federal, or local law; this practice has been discontinued.
  • Local Law 228 reports for all four quarters of 2026 were published on September 21, 2026.
  • ACS monthly court report audits for improper immigration status references are now conducted by five Family Court legal service deputy borough chiefs, one per borough.
  • NYPD detainer reporting will shift from annual to quarterly frequency.
  • The Domain Awareness System, NYPD's central surveillance platform, has not had an independent audit in over a decade.
Action Points
  • MOYA to provide CM Avilés with details on the scope, sample size, and timeline of the IRC's review of agency contracts and data sharing agreements with third-party vendors.
  • MOYA to follow up with CM Avilés on what data was actually examined within vendor systems, not just contractual language.
  • MOYA and NYC Public Schools to clarify whether school safety agents are being trained on sanctuary protocols by the Department of Education or NYPD, and report back to the committee.
  • MOYA to confirm to the committee whether incident reporting protocols include documentation such as photographs and video footage.
  • MOYA to follow up with CM Hanks on the total number of times federal agents have entered NYC-operated facilities without permission.
  • MOYA to follow up with CM Hanks on whether any NYC public school students have been detained by ICE recently.
  • DOHMH to finalize post-incident protocols, including notification to individuals and counsel, by October 30, 2026.
  • DOHMH to complete installation of new sanctuary-related signage in facilities by October 30, 2026.
  • NYPD to release updated protocols on detainer requests, access to property, and joint task forces before year-end 2026.
  • NYPD to release new protocols on elevating 911 immigration-related calls, with IRC confirming implementation.
  • NYPD email audit of task force officers to be reviewed and results shared; IRC to determine whether a cadence of ongoing audits will be established.
  • ACS to complete annual sanctuary law refresher trainings for all staff and providers beginning January 2027, with MOYA involved in reviewing and supporting rollout.
  • ACS to establish retraining and disciplinary procedures for sanctuary law violations on the same timeline as the refresher training.
  • IRC to continue monthly oversight of DHS's discontinued practice of sending daily reports to ICE and confirm ongoing compliance.
  • DHS's Correctional Intelligence Bureau to complete its email audit by end of 2026.
  • IRC to confirm to MOYA, and report to the Council, once NYPD's protocol for notifying the Operations Division of civil immigration enforcement requests has been fully institutionalized.
  • MOYA to notify the Council when amended Local Law 128 reports identified in the audit recommendations are ready for publication.
  • H+H to submit a report in the next Local Law 228 reporting cycle, within HIPAA parameters, as voluntarily committed.
  • NYC Public Schools to complete training rollout for all frontline staff, including school safety agents, janitorial staff, kitchen staff, and paras, not just principals, on updated sanctuary protocols.
  • Local Law 228 Local Law 114 signage to be posted at all relevant agencies no later than September 30, 2026.
  • Chair Encarnación to move Intros 995 and 996 (renumbered versions of former Intros 395 and 396) through the legislative process, with continued collaboration with legal services advocates.
  • MOYA to share the MOYA-designed Know Your Rights signage with CM Avilés offline.
  • IRC to assess whether DYCD should be formally brought under Executive Order 13 protections, given its role serving runaway and homeless immigrant youth.
  • MOYA to explore with committee how to expand the legal services pipeline and address the structural shortage of immigration attorneys in New York City.
Download .txt
Full Transcript

(00:00:12)

Good morning. Welcome to today's hearing from the Committee on Immigration. At this time I would like to remind everyone to silence your electronic devices. Also at this point going forward, no one is to approach the dais. If you would like to sign up for in-person testimony, please see one of the Sergeants at Arms.

(00:00:44)

I am calling this hearing to order. Good morning everyone. I am CM Elsie Encarnación, Deputy Whip of the New York City Council and Chair of the Committee on Immigration. Thank you all for joining us today. Today we will be examining the Executive Order 13 of 2026 Report of Audit Findings and Recommendations. I would like to thank all of the representatives from the administration, members of the public and my Council colleagues who have joined this hearing today.

New York City has a proud legacy of restricting the use of City time or property to facilitate federal immigration enforcement. Local laws enacted by the Council since 2011 have directed City resources away from the enforcement of xenophobic federal immigration policies and the agencies that weaponized them. These safeguards ensure that the City does not conduct civil immigration enforcement and that it instead upholds the dignity of all residents of our sanctuary city. But laws are only as good as their enforcement and implementation.

In late 2025, the City's Department of Investigation released two reports detailing violations of the City's detainer laws by the New York City Police Department and the Department of Correction. Public reporting also revealed that Immigration and Customs Enforcement had entered New York City shelters armed and without judicial warrants at least five times in 2025. To be a true sanctuary city, our residents must trust that the City will uphold its commitments. We were extremely pleased when on February 6, 2026, the Mamdani Administration issued Executive Order 13 protecting New Yorkers from abusive immigration enforcement.

The order required the Administration for Children's Services, Department of Correction, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Department of Probation, Department of Social Services and the New York City Police Department to ensure compliance with all relevant laws, rules, procedures, guidelines and reporting requirements related to non-local immigration enforcement. The order directed the agencies to immediately conduct a review and audit all internal policies, guidelines and protocols related to communication, cooperation and coordination with non-local law enforcement agencies charged with immigration enforcement, and submit a report to the Mayor within 90 days. We will refer to it as the IRC, to coordinate and manage policy response across agencies for any crisis in the City of New York.

On May 22, the administration released the Executive Order 13 Audit Report of Audit Findings and Recommendations. Among other findings, the multi-agency order revealed that federal immigration authorities had intensified their targeting of City shelters, sharply increased the issuance of detainer requests to NYPD and employed increasingly aggressive and misleading tactics. The Mayor adopted several agency-specific recommendations to strengthen policies and protocols to respond to the changing landscape of federal immigration enforcement. The administration stated that in the coming months the City would implement recommendations from the audit to strengthen protections for immigrant New Yorkers. The administration also noted that the IRC would issue updated citywide guidance and work closely with agencies to implement these policy and protocol changes.

At this hearing we will assess the administration's implementation of the recommendations from the audit and ascertain how the administration intends to communicate its progress to the public. We will question the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs about its role on the IRC, the timeline for issuing updated citywide guidance and the nature of the office's work with agencies to implement the policy and protocol changes. Although it seeks to examine a report of audit findings and recommendations, this hearing is not merely an academic exercise. If properly implemented, enforced and resourced, the recommendations contained in this report would be game-changing for the immigrant residents of our city. This committee takes our community's trust in government and willingness to access City resources extremely seriously, and so we understand the high stakes of getting this right. We are holding this hearing today to ensure that the administration's work is not the end of the effort to uphold the safety and well-being of our City's immigrant population, but rather that it signifies the beginning of that work.

Lastly, the Committee on Immigration will hear Res 0626-2026, sponsored by CM Farah Louis, calling upon the United States Senate to pass and the President to sign S.4814, to require the Secretary of Homeland Security to designate Haiti for Temporary Protected Status. Haiti has experienced a great deal of instability since the 2010 earthquake, including an epidemic, another earthquake and tropical storms. I am actually going to let CM Louis speak to this, as I know she has a few words, so I will let her get into the actual resolution. I am also proud to co-sponsor this resolution and I thank CM Louis for introducing it.

I would also like to thank the committee staff for their work on this hearing, including Senior Legislative Counsel Nicole Cotta, Senior Legislative Policy Analyst Rebecca Barilla, Principal Financial Analyst Davey Bains and Assistant Finance Director Florentine Cobb. Finally, I would like to thank my staff, especially my Chief of Staff Stephanie Herrera and everyone working behind the scenes to make this hearing run smoothly. Sergeant at Arms, I will now turn it over to CM Louis for brief remarks on her resolution.

(00:07:29)

Thank you, Chair Encarnación, for your support of this resolution and for convening today's hearing. Good to see you, Commissioner Ali. I want to thank some of the advocates that are here today — the Haitian American Lawyers Association of New York. We have President Rodney Pepe here and Charlotte from 1199.

I want to begin by saying this plainly. Res 0626-2026 is personal to me, to Haitian Americans, to the broader Black diaspora in New York City and to every friend and ally of the Haitian community. I am a proud Haitian-Bohemian American woman representing one of the largest Haitian diaspora communities in the United States, in central Brooklyn. When I speak about TPS recipients I am not speaking about statistics. I am speaking about my neighbors, my constituents, my family.

I want to tell you about my cousin. His name was Pierre Richard. In August 2024, Pierre Richard was days away from boarding a flight to New York City. He had just received confirmation that he would be granted Temporary Protected Status, also known as TPS. Word got out to his community that he was leaving. Because he refused to join the Barbecue gang, they murdered him — ten bullets — in front of his own home, in front of his family. They held his body for ransom.

We have seen Haitian immigrants subjected to electronic monitoring and public humiliation, including the deeply troubling case of Pierre de Massabielle, a young Haitian college student whose family described the profound distress he experienced after being placed on an ankle monitor simply for existing in this country while seeking safety. These are not criminals. These are our families. These are workers. These are our neighbors.

(00:09:29)

There are so many stories like these. So many families who followed every rule, did everything right, and still pay — it is literally life or death. An estimated 350,000 Haitians nationwide held TPS. 40,000 right here in New York City. Those protections allowed people to work, support their families and build lives in our communities. Today those protections are gone, while Haiti remains consumed by gang violence with people displaced and facing food insecurity. The country our neighbors fled is no safer today — it is actually worse — and the consequences are being felt right here in New York City.

In one month, ICE arrested 919 people in New York City, nearly twice the number from just three months prior. More than three quarters had no criminal history. None.

Mayor Mamdani recognized what is at stake, convening his third meeting with President Trump yesterday, this time at Gracie Mansion, raising directly how TPS termination has devastated several industries in our city, including hospitality, health care and faith-based communities. If the Mayor of New York City is bringing this message to the President, the least we can do is go on record in support of restoring these protections.

Haitian New Yorkers are part of the fabric of this city. They have cared for our seniors, staffed our hospitals, raised families and enriched every borough they call home. They deserve to live with dignity, not in fear. For Pierre Richard, for every family that has paid an unbearable price, they deserve TPS. For the 40,000 TPS recipients in New York City who wake up every morning wondering if today is the last day here in the United States — that is troubling. I urge my colleagues to support Res 0626-2026 and call on the United States Senate to pass and the President to sign S.4814. Thank you so much.

(00:12:40)

Good morning and thank you, Chair Encarnación and CM Farah Louis, for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Faiza Ali and I am the Commissioner for the New York City Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs. Since 1989, New York City's sanctuary status has been foundational to the trust between our immigrant communities and local government. Our City's local laws have helped strengthen public health and safety, empower immigrant New Yorkers to access City services and ensure that they can participate meaningfully in civic life. That trust is something that I have experienced firsthand through conversations with community organizations on the ground, one-on-one conversations with immigrant leaders and impacted families, visits to immigration court and canvassing across the city. Those experiences have made clear to me that these protections are not abstract policies — they shape whether people feel safe going about their daily lives.

For an immigrant New Yorker, that can mean going to the hospital with confidence, knowing that their immigration status does not determine their ability to access care. It can mean entrusting their child to our public schools, knowing that City resources and property cannot be used for civil immigration enforcement. That assurance is especially critical today as increased activity by federal immigration agencies has heightened fear in immigrant communities and disrupted the lives of families and neighbors.

Responsive government requires us to continually examine the processes and safeguards we have in place to protect New Yorkers. On February 6, 2026, Mayor Mamdani signed Executive Order 13, directing six agencies — ACS, DOC, DOHMH, Department of Probation, Department of Social Services and the NYPD — to conduct comprehensive audits of their internal policies relating to interactions with federal immigration agencies, update protocols and guidance where needed and identify opportunities to strengthen implementation of our local laws limiting or barring City agency participation in federal civil immigration enforcement. New York City Health and Hospitals voluntarily agreed to participate in the audit, and while New York City Public Schools was not included in the order, it conducted its own internal review independent of the formal audit process.

The Executive Order also established the Interagency Response Committee, or IRC, which coordinates a citywide response to crises. The First Deputy Mayor serves as Chair of the IRC in direct consultation with the Chief Counsel to the Mayor and City Hall Special Adviser for Strategic Coordination and Operations, the FBI and myself, with support from counsel and the Law Department.

The City published a Report of Audit Findings and Recommendations. The findings confirmed that overall our local laws are working as intended, while also identifying areas where we can strengthen policies both citywide and within individual agencies. Throughout this process we have emphasized the importance of ongoing accountability and review, as well as broadening reporting to ensure that our local laws continue to be implemented effectively as federal activity in our city and nationwide evolves.

The audit found a dramatic increase in federal immigration-related activity targeting City shelters between January and August 2025. It also revealed a significant uptick in civil immigration detainer requests to City law enforcement agencies, an expanded set of federal agencies involved in civil immigration enforcement and increasingly aggressive and misleading tactics by immigration authorities. Informed by the audit findings, the IRC issued sets of recommendations to strengthen the City's implementation of our local laws. I am pleased to share that we have made significant progress on implementing each of them.

First, guidance on reporting requests for information and assistance from federal immigration authorities, to ensure that every agency interaction with federal immigration authorities is accounted for. This guidance was issued to all agencies. Second, the City updated its guidance and best practices on non-local law enforcement access to City property. This guidance was also issued to City agencies. The six City agencies subject to the audit, as well as New York City Public Schools and Health and Hospitals, have completed their updated access-to-property protocols, which will be issued by the end of the month, and are now working to ensure that staff are trained on these policies.

Third, the six City agencies subject to the audit as well as Health and Hospitals have completed or made significant progress to fully implement the adopted agency-specific recommendations. New York City Public Schools has also been meeting regularly with the IRC to monitor enforcement activity and strengthen preparedness. I wanted to take a moment to highlight a few examples of the progress our City agencies have made in strengthening their protocols and implementing audit recommendations. The Administration for Children's Services has strengthened its practice of reviewing determinations for seeking orders of protection if the safety of the children and caregiver can be met otherwise, when there are potential negative immigration consequences for the parent. The agency has incorporated this practice into its trainings and into its meetings with Family Court legal staff.

(00:18:21)

Services and throughout the supervision process has also established a process through which the agency will review a set of court reports from every borough family court legal services unit each month to audit them for inappropriate references to a person's immigration status. The Department of Correction's Correction Intelligence Bureau has instituted enhanced review of requests from federal law enforcement agencies to clearly identify the purpose of these requests and appropriately elevate to the legal division to ensure that they are not in furtherance of civil immigration enforcement.

The Department of Probation has reinforced through trainings and its academy limitations on inclusion of immigration status in parts of pre-sentencing investigation reports which do not require this information under state regulation. DOP has established a process for regularly submitting reports that document, track and publicly post the number of detainer requests it receives to strengthen compliance with local laws on reporting. The Department of Health and Mental Hygiene is finalizing post-incident protocols including notification to individuals and their counsel when appropriate and working to install signage. The Department of Social Services has issued revised protocols and best practices to ensure shelter and provider staff are prepared for when non-local law enforcement show up at their facilities, incorporating what we learned from the period of intense activity at shelters in the first half of 2025.

The New York Police Department is on track to complete updated protocols and policies related to detainer requests, access to property and joint task forces. In addition, NYPD has begun the implementation of protocols in response to 911 federal immigration authorities relating to immigration. The NYPD has also completed its email audit of task force officers to ensure their compliance with local law. The email audit is currently under review. The NYPD is on track to release new protocols to assess information requests that are made through the joint NYPD federal task forces with federal law enforcement.

New York City Health and Hospitals has developed and issued guidance for when ICE brings an individual to an H+H facility for medical care. It has also centralized and issued best practices as well as a flow chart for when staff interact with federal immigration authorities. And finally, New York City Public Schools has strengthened its guidance for staff if non-local law enforcement is present on school grounds. The guidance has been expanded for the first time to include after-school and weekend programs, offsite activities like field trips and what to do if ICE is nearby a school, particularly during arrival and dismissal.

I want to thank all of our agency partners and really emphasize the cooperation on this effort from all of them. The careful work that they have done to implement these recommendations and the ongoing conversations around continuous improvement — that collaboration gives me confidence in our approach. But our work of course is not finished. City agencies will continue to complete the implementation of adopted audit recommendations, reviewing and updating their policies as needed.

Through our role in the IRC, MOYA will continue to provide guidance on preparing for and responding to impacts on our immigrant communities while working with colleagues at sister agencies to educate the public about our laws. As federal enforcement practices and tactics evolve, our city government must remain responsive. The Executive Order 13 audit was one step in that direction. This administration is closely monitoring the escalation of civil immigration enforcement activity and responding to the needs we see on the ground, especially when it comes to the interactions between our city agencies and federal immigration authorities. It is our responsibility to support and maintain trust with all New Yorkers, including our immigrant communities.

Before I conclude, I also want to briefly discuss and express support for Res 0626-2026, sponsored by CM Rita C. Joseph, calling on the Secretary of Homeland Security to designate Haiti for Temporary Protected Status. The federal government's termination of TPS for Haiti has created fear, confusion and anguish in our Haitian communities. It has resulted in Haitian New Yorkers losing access to work authorization and economic stability, families becoming afraid to send their children to school and small businesses seeing fewer patrons in typically active commercial corridors.

In addition to advocating for the restoration of TPS, the Mayor and MOYA have also advocated for deferred enforced departure for Haitian New Yorkers affected by the termination of TPS. We will continue to push for these protections while supporting Haitian New Yorkers and other TPS holders here in New York City. At MOYA we have worked across the administration and with our community partners including organizations to ensure impacted New Yorkers know their rights and have access to legal support. We are also working to address increased food insecurity and other immediate needs as Haitian New Yorkers who have lost work authorization transition into life without status.

We have developed a comprehensive FAQ available in multiple languages, expanded community outreach, distributed resources on the ground and stood up rapid response clinics to bring legal services directly into impacted communities. We encourage those who are impacted to call MOYA's free, safe and confidential immigration legal support hotline at 1-280-354-0365 to connect people with trusted legal assistance in their preferred language. New York has always been a city where immigrants come not only to build a future for themselves but to build a future for everyone. Our administration will continue to make sure that immigrant New Yorkers know that we will stand up for them, that we will defend their rights and we will fight to protect their families. Thank you.

(00:25:00)

Thank you, Commissioner. I also want to acknowledge that we have been joined by CM Avilés. First and foremost, thank you for detailing all of the folks that are a part of and make up the IRC. Can you go into a little bit about what each one of their responsibilities are as it pertains to the IRC?

(00:25:23)

Thank you, Chair, for that question. The IRC, as you mentioned and as I mentioned in my testimony, was established through Executive Order 13 and it is a coordinating body. It coordinates the City's response to federal crises and impacts. The members of the IRC include the First Deputy Mayor, who serves as chair of the committee, in direct consultation with the chief counsel to the Mayor and our special adviser for strategic coordination and operations, along with staff and myself as MOYA Commissioner. The committee's broader membership also includes other senior-level staff. Some of our responsibilities include helping to coordinate the implementation of the Executive Order 13 recommendations, but it also includes supporting agencies as they review and strengthen their policies and protocols for reporting and training. We see this as an ongoing responsibility to continue to provide support to agencies because of the changing federal immigration enforcement environment.

(00:26:28)

So how frequently do you feel like the IRC will review contracts and data sharing agreements between the City and third parties to ensure data privacy for New Yorkers?

(00:26:38)

Yeah, thank you for that question as well. I do want to just pivot back because I want to make sure we also highlight that...

(00:26:47)

...completion of the audit does not mean a completion of the IRC's work, and I just want to stress that that is ongoing. With respect to contracts, this was also an ongoing part of our review as part of the audit. The IRC asked several agencies to examine specific technologies and vendors that could present potential data risks. On data sharing, the IRC has reviewed the audit and confirmed that agencies included the necessary identifying information, law rider and other contract provisions pertaining to data sharing limitations that are required by local law. As I mentioned up top, the IRC is going to continue to monitor on these issues and work with agencies on updating their practices as things evolve. And that includes examining the systems themselves, not just the contractual language for the data sharing.

(00:27:51)

And vendors. That is correct.

(00:27:55)

Does the IRC interact with the State or are there any State representatives that are on the IRC? There are not any...

(00:28:03)

...on the IRC, but we do continue to work with our State partners in communicating the impacts both on the ground and any policy changes. And is that done formally through the IRC to State partners or is it informally through the members of the...

(00:28:21)

...yes, through the members of the IRC. Much of the work that MOYA does is in collaboration with the Office of New Americans and then the direct communication that our City Hall office has with the Governor's team, along with the Attorney General. And in addition to some of the things that the IRC will continue to consider, will one of those things involve creating more severe penalties for City workers who violate sanctuary policies and regulations?

(00:28:47)

Yeah, a failure to implement the City's laws that protect our neighbors is a failure that we will not tolerate. City employees who fail to comply with the applicable sanctuary policies and reporting requirements will be subject to discipline. And I know you mentioned a lot of work with New York City Public Schools as kind of being voluntary on their end. Are you looking to formally incorporate them into the work of the IRC moving forward?

(00:29:19)

We are really pleased with the work that MOYA and the IRC are doing in collaboration with New York City Public Schools. We meet regularly with them to review their policies and protocols and focus on what resources they need to support students and families. As I mentioned, although New York City Public Schools was not specifically identified in Executive Order 13, the department did conduct its own internal review and issued updated guidance ahead of the first day of school. Some of the work that I am really proud to highlight between MOYA and New York City Public Schools is particularly working on resources for immigrant families at a really critical point as we face increased immigration actions. Know Your Rights flyers have been updated and are being translated into New York City Public Schools' 14 languages. We are really...

(00:30:23)

...I want to uplift the partnership with the Project Open Arms team. They do an incredible job in collaborating with us but also making sure that parents have the information that they need. There has been some press coverage of the collaboration between our offices on a Know Your Rights comic book that was developed and is also available in multiple languages. This is really to ensure that we are providing materials that are both accessible and age appropriate. On the school protocol, MOYA has worked alongside the IRC and New York City Public Schools to update their policies that govern their interactions with non-local law enforcement.

(00:31:09)

This is really critical because it provides clear guidance to staff on the front line on how to respond and protect families and help them understand the protections that are in place. It is like those double-edged swords — it is great that we have it but it is also very sad that we have it. I applaud it. We have it in our office, we give it out during outreach sessions and resource tabling, but it is just a sad reality that we have come to. But I do applaud them as well for creating it.

(00:31:47)

In terms of the Executive Order 13 findings, the audit essentially asked agencies to look at any interactions with federal agencies that were related to immigration, even when those agencies had not historically played a central role in civil immigration enforcement. So were all City agencies given information about which federal agencies are now looped into civil immigration enforcement prior to reporting on these interactions?

(00:32:15)

Yes. During the audit we identified that federal agencies beyond the traditionally associated agencies with civil immigration enforcement, like Homeland Security Investigations and the Office of Refugee Resettlement, were all playing somewhat of a role. We have asked agencies to take a broad approach in reporting their interactions with federal agencies and...

(00:32:42)

...in other words, we want agencies to report anything that they think can be potentially related to immigration enforcement. Our goal here is really to capture as complete a picture as possible. How did the audit identify those key issues to be reviewed?

(00:33:00)

That is a great question. It really was a combination of a few different things: data analysis, external oversight and — I want to really center this — stakeholder engagement and conversations we had with advocates. We have analyzed through the IRC data on interactions with federal immigration...

(00:33:20)

...authorities, including in-person incidents at shelters and other facilities. We looked at and reviewed historic reporting data that revealed significant gaps and previously unreported incidents. We also considered the findings of the Department of Investigation's report on NYPD, which you referenced in your opening, and looked to get input from advocates, journalists and other stakeholders. Agencies were, as we mentioned, also asked to report and to be over-inclusive in their reporting of any interaction that they had with federal authorities, which is how we uncovered many of these interactions. And then finally, members of our IRC team also conducted site visits, visiting shelters directly to assess the vulnerabilities.

(00:34:19)

Also, I just want to note that we have been joined by CM Joseph. Going on to about two more questions before making a statement on the resolution we are hearing today — in your opening statement you mentioned the timeline. I believe you said that some of the updated citywide guidance was released and some might be released by the end of this month. I believe that was in relation to the public schools but I am not sure. I was trying to write as fast as possible. For all of this citywide guidance, is there a timeline for when those will be released?

(00:34:56)

So both the citywide guidance on reporting requirements and guidance as well on best practices for non-local law access to City property — both were issued. And who...

(00:35:11)

...will oversee the IRC's issuance of the updated guidance?

(00:35:17)

The IRC along with our partners at the Law Department will oversee the issuance of citywide guidance and implementation of those updated policies and protocols.

(00:35:29)

Are you needing any additional resources to conduct this work?

(00:35:33)

At this time our work is focused on existing agency structures and resources to support the implementation and really the ongoing work. But Chair, you have heard me say this before — MOYA continues to assess resource needs and that is something that we are closely monitoring as well.

(00:35:51)

And so will agencies — have they been instructed that if they need additional...

(00:35:57)

...support, if they find that they need help making sure that this happens throughout their agency — as far as trainings for example — that is something that they will alert MOYA about and MOYA will bring to the IRC? That is right. Okay.

(00:36:12)

Right. And training is required for all public-facing City employees, contracted employees and others, and so that is something that we will continue to work with...

(00:36:22)

...individual agencies on. And lastly, before I hand it over to the Council Member — when will MOYA and the IRC revise previously issued reports and issue unpublished reports as indicated by the recommendations?

(00:36:37)

The Local Law 228 reports for 2026 — I am pleased to say — have been completed and are published. MOYA and the IRC are continuing their work on the amended reports identified in the recommendations and will notify the Council as soon as those are ready. Okay, I am going to hand it over to CM Joseph.

(00:36:57)

Thank you so much. These are remarks in support of Res 0626-2026, so I just want to read remarks in support. Chair, thank you.

(00:37:10)

Chair, I stand here today as the daughter of Haiti and as the representative of thousands of Haitian New Yorkers who built their lives in this City in good faith under the protection of this country. Sixteen years ago an earthquake took 300,000 lives in less than a minute. Out of that devastation, America made a promise — Temporary Protected Status — a chance to work, to raise a family, to breathe without the fear of being sent back into chaos. That promise still matters today because the chaos never left. Nearly a million and a half Haitians are displaced in the capital, and yet this past year that protection was stripped away, first by an agency, then upheld by the Supreme Court. I have walked the streets of Little Haiti and Flatbush. I have watched vendors disappear, storefronts go dark, parents afraid to send their children to school. That is what fear does to a community.

That is why we are asking Washington to act. S.4814 is not a favor. It is not charity. It is a recognition of a simple truth: Haiti is not safe. Haitians are not a threat. They are our neighbors, our caregivers, our small business owners, our future. The House has already passed its version. Now the Senate must act and the President must sign. In Haiti's motto it says "L'union fait la force" — unity makes strength. That is the spirit of Little Haiti. That is the spirit of this City. And today this Council stands behind 40,000 New Yorkers who are counting on us not to look away. Thank you, Chair.

(00:38:46)

Thank you, Council Member. I want to get into some questions around ACS. ACS has indicated that they court reports to review any improper inclusion of immigration status. How has that audit occurred?

(00:39:08)

Just making sure I have the correct information in front of me. Yes, this is an ongoing process, a process where each of the five Family Court legal service deputy borough chiefs actually review a set of those court reports every month. These reviews are going to be logged and assessed to audit for improper inclusion of immigration status. The first monthly audit has been completed and is under review. The next steps for that is that it will be reviewed through the IRC. To be clear, through conversations with the IRC and the agency. Correct.

(00:39:47)

There are also required annual refresher trainings for all of the ACS and providers' staff on compliance and reporting requirements. Will the training take place this year?

(00:39:59)

That is currently in process as well. ACS is working to create its refresher trainings and implement them starting January 2027, and it is incorporated in the updated protocols. MOYA is going to be involved in reviewing and supporting the rollout of that training.

(00:40:16)

You read my mind, that was the next question. I know they also indicated that they plan to institute procedures that included retraining if violations are found and disciplinary procedures if there are repeat violations. Have those procedures...

(00:40:34)

...been instituted? ACS is working to establish a procedure for retraining and it will be on the same timeline as the refresher training.

(00:40:47)

I see. OK. I know that they also indicated that they were developing a procedure to seek written consent from attorneys for children prior to outreach to immigration authorities on an individual's case. Will MOYA and the IRC be involved in ensuring that those recommendations are implemented?

(00:41:10)

I think first it is important for us to highlight some of the progress that has been made on this front. ACS now uses a form to obtain written consent from attorneys for children before doing outreach to immigration authorities, and MOYA will continue to work through the IRC, along with some of the other agencies, to implement these policies moving forward.

(00:41:41)

Now I am going to move over to DHS. What does it mean for DHS to institute an enhanced review of requests...

(00:41:50)

...for federal law enforcement agencies? As I mentioned in my testimony, in practical terms it means that DHS's Correctional Intelligence Bureau will institute and review their policies that clearly identify the purpose behind any law enforcement request for information or assistance, including requests that are made through the task forces, and then elevate those requests to their legal division for review.

(00:42:24)

When will DHS discontinue daily reports to ICE that are not required by federal, state or local law, and who will be responsible for confirming this discontinuation?

(00:42:35)

So this has already taken effect. DHS no longer sends these reports. As you mentioned, these were reports that were not required by state law. The ongoing oversight of this will be conducted through the IRC on a monthly basis. Do you know if they say anything about reporting? Is it envisioned that happening through the IRC?

(00:42:58)

I will get back to you...

(00:42:59)

...on that. I do not know if there is a formal timeline, but we do have regular communications and maintain regular communications with not just the six audited agencies but other agencies as well.

(00:43:12)

You also mentioned in your opening about the email audit that occurred. Can you talk a little bit about who was responsible for that audit within the department?

(00:43:26)

So DHS is currently working with its team to set up the audit and is targeting for that audit to be completed by the end of the year.

(00:43:36)

You also mentioned some sort of audit of technology vendors and third parties. What did that entail?

(00:43:45)

So that was part — I believe it was reflected in our audit findings as well. It entailed a review of contracts and of different vendors from different agencies. The IRC team worked with the agencies to review those documents. Did it identify every vendor that stores, processes or has access to information maintained by agencies? I will have to get back to you on that.

(00:44:14)

OK. Before we move on to the next set of questions, I am going to pause and allow CM Avilés to ask her questions.

(00:44:27)

Thank you, Chair. Good morning, everybody. I just want to ask a follow-up question to a point raised earlier on the subject of the IRC reviewing contracts and the data sharing agreements, where you noted that... I am just curious about whether you could provide more detail about the breadth and scope of that surveying of actual data in the systems and...

(00:45:10)

...over what period of time. I will get back to you on the timeline, but as I mentioned, the technology and the vendors that were reviewed from the audit — we were looking for a few things, but one thing in particular was to make sure that the necessary identifying information law riders were present and that other protections were present in the contracts as well. But we can follow up and get you additional...

(00:45:40)

...details. Yes, the timeline and the time frame — what I am interested in learning is what the samples look like, given the breadth of contracts that the City engages in.

(00:45:55)

I am glad to hear that those elements are in the contracts, but I would love to know, when you look at the data actually across some of those systems, what you found. Happy to talk about that some more. In terms of Council Member, also looking at how data...

(00:46:16)

...flows. We will certainly follow up with you in terms of what actually was surveyed and what the samples look like. Great, thank you so much. In terms of the...

(00:46:26)

...work with New York City Public Schools, again thank you for being much more aggressive in this work with our City and our communities who are deeply struggling. In terms of the updated policy, are you supporting New York City Public Schools' effort in actually what training rollout looks like? Because we find that these policies stay stuck in the Office of General Counsel or in leadership, with very little attention being paid to how they actually go through the system.

(00:47:06)

The one thing we want to avoid is a set of new policies that do the right thing but are not actually being implemented. We are working really closely with each of the agencies, including our partners at New York City Public Schools, on timelines for their trainings and ensuring that these are completed. The updated policies that were rolled out prior to the first day of school were shared with principals before that first day of school. We are pleased to know that there has been some progress, but part of the ongoing work with the IRC and the agencies is to ensure that this is not something that sits on a shelf.

(00:47:42)

All hands on deck. We would love to be able to validate that, from janitorial service to kitchen staff to educators and paras — everyone in the building should know those policies, and we often find they stay stuck at the principal level or leadership in the school. Thank you for that. In terms of the... I would also love to know if there has been any progress on Local Law 114 on the signage. I know that is not the focus of the hearing today, but I am selfishly going to ask. We...

(00:48:21)

...were prepared, Council Member, for this question, and wanted to make sure that you know we are pleased to say that we have actually made progress. We have created the signage and we have sent that out to agencies who are on track to have them posted no later than September 30.

(00:48:38)

I love that answer. Thank you very much.

(00:48:41)

I know how important it is to you. It is important to us too. Is it pretty? You know, it looks good. I will be the judge of that. I did not design it, thankfully. Yeah. I will share that with you as well. Great, thank you. We will follow up offline for sure. In terms of the hotline, obviously things have changed, and just the...

(00:49:07)

...constant surges of ICE — well, potentially not surges, but a consistent presence of ICE across New York City — what has been your experience of the use of the hotline? Are you seeing any evidence of increases or positive engagement as a result of also the campaign to get the information out? I would just like to hear some more about that before I turn it...

(00:49:35)

...over to my colleague. I do want to just say that our partnership with our legal services, with our hotline providers, has been really strong. We have put a tremendous amount of strain on them as well, just given the climate that we are living in now, whether it is the expiration of TPS or an increase in ICE activity in our neighborhoods that we are also seeing. They are fielding questions from the public on public charge. There has been an increase in the number of calls, and that is also due to the fact that there has been significant outreach through partnerships with you all, frankly, and in partnerships with Council Members. When we are out in the community distributing our hotline information, people know that they can call and get some trusted, confidential legal support.

I am going to turn it over to Lorena to share some top-line numbers on who is calling and for what. I also knew you were going to ask about the hotline, Council Member, but just to say we have also pivoted some of the work that the hotline is doing so it is a bit more targeted. We had very targeted outreach for TPS, for example, clinics that were upcoming, as well as public charge, so there is a direct loop back to some of these providers so folks do not have to go in circles and they are getting direct service. Since the launch of our targeted outreach with TPS for Haiti, at least 154 individuals were contacted through the hotline. On the weekend when our team was out in Little Haiti, we saw a very direct increase — I do not have that number in front of me but I will get it to you. That is what we have noticed: the more that not only the Mayor, who also shared the hotline, but also the direct touchpoint with members has helped, as well as more weekend hours. As you know, we are available and open one Saturday a month, and we have seen an increase again with the collaboration of some of the outreach that we are doing as well.

(00:51:43)

Great, thank you. Chair, if I may just wrap up with one last question, or maybe a little bit of a comment. I am definitely heartened to hear about the increased investment in making sure people are on the other end of that hotline. I am interested in learning how we are collaborating around the very real issue that we do not have enough legal service providers physically present in our City...

(00:52:16)

...to meet the need, and what kind of alternatives are we creatively thinking about around how to address some of that unmet need. We may not get there entirely, but it feels like there is only so much we can do with a very finite amount of resources. We would love to have that deeper conversation with you all around what other ways — how are we looking at the pipeline of legal support in our City to make sure that we continue to build into the future? Thank you.

Thank you. So we are going to go into the Department of Probation now, and questions around that. When will the Department of Probation institute limitations on inclusion of information about immigrant status in presentencing investigation reports, and how will this be confirmed, and who will be responsible for confirming this?

(00:53:15)

The Department of Probation has already instituted these limitations, specifically communicated with executive staff outlining these limitations on including immigration status information in presentencing investigation reports, and they have reinforced this in their trainings in the academy and field trainings for probation officers that are assigned to investigations.

(00:53:44)

And were you involved in those?

(00:53:47)

Yes. As a member of the IRC, MOYA has worked on providing guidance on how to strengthen these protocols and others. Just another point — I think we had mentioned this in our testimony — we have established a regular process for the agency to submit reports under Local Law 28, so our interactions with the agency continue in that regard as well.

(00:54:16)

Great. I will ask quickly some questions about DHS, and then I am going to pass it over to my colleague to ask some questions. In regards to DHS, have incident reports been revised to ensure that all incidents and interactions at shelters are reported, and what would be entailed in that reporting?

(00:54:38)

This has also been completed, and it really entails two main changes. It clarified for all staff that any interaction with non-local law enforcement must be labeled a priority one incident, and that they are also continuing as an agency to review incidents and reports and ensure that no incident is missed through their enhanced training.

(00:55:08)

I noticed that there was a recommendation that stated that guidance will be issued in response to an incorrect referral to 26 Federal Plaza. Can you clarify what that means?

(00:55:18)

DHS has issued clarifying guidance explicitly stating that caseworkers should not refer any individuals to 26 Federal Plaza, but instead they should be connecting individuals to an immigration attorney and legal services. Thank you for clarifying that.

(00:55:40)

Thank you, Council Member. Thank you so much, Chair. Commissioner, always good to see you and your team. Thank you for all that you do. A couple of questions: what options exist, or what steps has the City taken, to aid people who have lost status — in the future, TPS or otherwise?

(00:55:54)

On this front, I am really pleased to say we have been working closely with our HRA partners to ensure that anyone who was at risk or has lost protections has access to legal services. Not only is the hotline available for individuals to call, but we have been standing up legal clinics in communities and through our partners to make sure that individuals are connected to an attorney who can make an assessment if they have other forms of relief.

The other thing that I think is really critical — and it pains me to say this — is that in many circumstances we are learning that there are very limited options for families. We have been working with partners to train organizations on what it means to help a family really plan for what their next steps are. It is really a combination of making sure, first and foremost, if there are legal options available, connecting individuals to services, and then also making sure that there are additional resources available to families who are especially vulnerable right now.

(00:57:02)

Well, thank you for also working with our nonprofits to make this happen. Will the administration conduct an audit or review of similar scope in the future, as it relates to my previous question? Is there going to be an audit? Are you going to look at this? There have to be lessons learned, right? We do not...

(00:57:19)

...just do policy to do policy. There are lessons to be...

(00:57:22)

...learned. That is absolutely true. I think — I do not know if it is in the form of a formal audit — but these are ongoing conversations that we have with people who are most impacted on the ground, and the service providers. They know what works and what does not work, and if we need to pivot to other protections and other things that we need to offer families who are experiencing a loss of protection. Absolutely. I think you and I know, Council Member, you will hold us accountable to that as well. No doubt, as you should.

(00:57:53)

What types of audit tools do the agencies included in the IRC utilize? What kind of tools do they use?

(00:58:00)

Part of our audit — and this is included in our findings — is engaging directly with the agencies who are reviewing every policy and protocol as it relates to any interaction that they have with federal immigration enforcement. Some of those are agencies that are very focused on immigration enforcement like ICE, and then there are other agencies that are nontraditional. What we are trying to do is make sure that agencies report every immigration agency interaction that they have, and then we take it from there.

(00:58:35)

Thank you. The most important question — and I think CM Avilés raised it — what human capacity do these agencies have to respond and conduct audits? This is...

(00:58:44)

...really important, and I think it has been really reflective in the level of cooperation from agencies. Agencies are taking this work really seriously for immigrant communities and they are preserving service delivery. This is something that is an ongoing conversation with agencies, but I am pleased to say that everyone has been really supportive and engaging in this process and we have not had any issues or pushback.

(00:59:15)

Good to hear. The audit also included a description of a February 2025 situation in which armed and masked agents entered a shelter facility without permission of agency staff. What are we instructing staff to do in such a situation? Is there training and such policies? Because I know even when they were asking the agents to identify themselves, they just pushed into the shelter and went about their business. What protocols are in...

(00:59:39)

I think that is a very important question. They have issued and revised protocols for frontline agency staff and updated a flow chart that is going to be posted at every shelter on what to do if they are faced with that encounter. Right now they are working to incorporate and strengthen those best practices in their trainings. I think the most important and critical piece here is that frontline staff know that they are not alone in making the determination if an agency is coming in, if they are allowed to enter the facility. By that I mean if someone comes in and presents themselves as a federal enforcement agency and says "I have a warrant," they will take that warrant and not make an assessment alone. They will take a photograph, flag it out for their legal counsel, and only the legal counsel will be making that determination on who enters. So there are a series of protocols that have been put in place to prevent that and really protect the frontline staff and make sure that they are equipped to protect anyone who is in the shelter.

(01:00:47)

Thank you. But we have seen how aggressive ICE has been on the ground, so I do not know how much pushback they can sometimes do, so we probably have to

(01:00:57)

revisit that conversation. Absolutely, and this is part of the IRC work and continuing to engage the agencies, because what we are seeing now and what we anticipate is that immigration enforcement will continue to evolve, and that forces us and requires us to continuously look at our policies as well.

(01:01:15)

Sure. I just have one more question. How many times have federal agents entered New York City operated facilities without permission, or despite a lack of permission?

(01:01:23)

That is a great question and we can follow up with you on that.

(01:01:26)

That would be great. And then my other question is: how is MOYA working with Open Arms and New York City Public Schools to make sure that if our students are detained, what are the legal steps in place? The Council has been very supportive. And have there ever been any ICE detentions of any of our students recently?

(01:01:55)

We speak to them every week, and that is true. We have been working very collaboratively. The commissioner mentioned that even with the rollout of some of the protocols at schools, we were working closely with them. We continue to collaborate on the legal services front and coordinate if cases are elevated. Off the top of my head I cannot give you a number. But I am happy to circle back. We are working with them and again we thank the Council for the foresight in supporting that initiative with Project Open Numbers in particular, because it has added some capacity.

(01:02:31)

Is there any collaboration with The Door, the organization The Door, because they also do their work around young people and especially young people who are in

(01:02:39)

care? We work with them through I CARE as well, through the I CARE coalition, and some of the work that we do with unaccompanied minors. So thank you. I look

(01:02:46)

forward to more conversations. Thank you, Chair. Thank you.

(01:02:51)

Actually, as part of the protocols and trainings that you will have, is there anything about reporting when an incident like this happens, for example, to the office?

(01:03:04)

That there is now a system in place that they can report — is that part of the training and protocol so people know what to do if someone does push past them and go

(01:03:11)

forward? Yeah, that is a great question and that is part of our Local Law 128 reporting and part of the enhanced protocol there. I feel like I have referenced and continue to reference this because I think it is a really important point: the over-inclusive reporting that is now being encouraged. Any interaction, if it smells like an immigration matter, we want to make sure that that is reflected in the reports that are shared with MOYA. So we are looking at that as one way to capture these incidents, and that is one way that these incidents have been captured in these reports as well.

(01:03:48)

And so in those trainings, does it include what they should be detailing, taking information on, pictures of anything, videos or anything like that, that can all be submitted as part of the reporting?

(01:04:01)

I will have to get back to you on what exact information is included, whether it includes videos or other footage. Yeah, we can follow up on that.

(01:04:09)

Great. And then also just thinking about the public schools and knowing that school safety falls under NYPD — how different or aligned are the trainings for school safety officers compared to actual staff in the school building?

(01:04:26)

So the training applies to school safety agents and all frontline staff in New York City Public

(01:04:31)

Schools. So school safety agents are being trained through the Department of Education, not through the NYPD, on this? We will have to

(01:04:40)

defer to our New York City Public Schools team, but we can also follow up and get clarity on who is exactly training

(01:04:48)

the school safety agents.

(01:04:50)

Perfect. Sometimes those do not talk to each other, so we want to make sure that everybody is on the same page. Now switching over to DOHMH,

(01:05:02)

which I want to thank for participating in this willingly. I know in your opening statement you mentioned that they have already developed and issued and were finalizing their post-incident protocols.

(01:05:19)

About H+H, or is that for DOHMH? Sorry. Yes, so MOYA is working with the IRC and they are developing protocols, including a notification to individuals and their counsel when appropriate, with its Office of General Counsel, and aiming for a target date. That protocol we are hoping is finalized by the thirtieth, or later.

(01:05:51)

I was going to say later this month, later next month. Almost there. There was also some mention of signage. Yes. So what does that mean?

(01:06:04)

DOHMH has new signage that is currently under review. This is signage that is posted in their facilities. They are planning for installation of this new signage that is underway. I think the aim for that target date is also October 30 for implementation, also in collaboration with you all.

(01:06:25)

All correct. Yes. OK. In terms of the NYPD, when will the NYPD institute their protocol for notification to the Operations Division of any requests for information or otherwise in connection with civil immigration enforcement? And who is responsible for confirming when this is instituted?

(01:06:49)

The NYPD has established this protocol for any requests for information or otherwise in connection to civil immigration enforcement. This is part of the ongoing work within the NYPD to institutionalize this policy and this protocol through policy. The IRC is working to support and confirm when this policy is implemented, so this is worked through the committee.

(01:07:15)

So the IRC has a role and is responsible for confirming what it is?

(01:07:21)

That is right. And there will also be enhanced protocols requiring supervisory and legal review. This protocol in particular is something that the NYPD is continuing to work on and will soon release. This new protocol will be released before the year is up.

(01:07:40)

It is on track to release the new protocols and we are working really closely to get closer to releasing this. And the same question as it pertains to 911 calls related to the presence of federal immigration authorities or immigration matters — is the IRC again responsible for confirming that that protocol is

(01:08:08)

established? Yes, that is ongoing work with us and each agency on their implementation plan. On this, I am happy to share that the NYPD has begun implementation of this particular protocol in response to 911 calls as they relate to immigration enforcement or immigration activities overall. So outside of the formal or informal lines of communication that exist between MOYA and NYPD for the purposes of this kind of reporting or information sharing and its impact on immigrant communities —

(01:08:45)

yeah, we continue to work

(01:08:47)

across agencies. Outside of the IRC, we have the interagency task force that MOYA also conducts, and that includes all 40-plus city agencies where we share best practices, where we flag any incidents and information. So we have good communication across agencies, including the NYPD.

(01:09:09)

Did they complete their email audit? I guess it was slated to be completed by the end of 2026. Yes, the NYPD did conduct an email audit of the task force officers — I believe that is what you are referencing — to ensure that

(01:09:26)

there is compliance with local law. That email audit is complete and is currently under review.

(01:09:32)

And will there be a cadence of additional audits in terms of those email exchanges related to the cadence? I am

(01:09:37)

going to defer to our colleagues at the NYPD on that. The required piece is done and so anything additional would be reviewed accordingly.

(01:09:50)

And have they complied with the outstanding reporting requirements on Local Law 10-107, 180, and 454? Yes, I am happy to

(01:10:01)

report that the NYPD is now in compliance with those outstanding reporting requirements and they have also completed a new revision to the patrol guide on elevating civil immigration detainer requests to appropriate supervisors and reviewing and determining any action that needs to be taken.

(01:10:22)

Perfect. Thank you. Now, H+H developed five key recommendations. Will they be working with MOYA to implement those recommendations moving forward?

(01:10:35)

Yeah, so MOYA as part of the IRC is going to be working with H+H by supporting and guiding them on their implementation of these recommendations,

(01:10:45)

including the reporting requirements. Under Local Law 128, H+H has voluntarily committed to submitting a report in the next Local Law 128 reporting cycle, within of course the parameters of HIPAA and other legal privacy requirements. Now in terms of non-local law enforcement in New York City, I know the City found that the Department of Homeland Security was operating something called Operation Rotten Apple, which took place this summer and confirmed the uptick of ICE agents across the City. Were you tracking this surge as

(01:11:30)

MOYA? So we have seen an increase in immigration enforcement activities across the City, which we know have had a really significant impact on immigrant communities and have heightened concerns amongst New Yorkers and neighbors alike. MOYA does closely monitor these trends and their impact. MOYA, along with our partners at the IRC, also tracks ICE enforcement as it relates to how they interact with City agencies, and that is where we have visibility and that is where we have authority, specifically under Local Law 228. MOYA and other agencies are required to track, as you previously mentioned, and report any requests and any interactions. And then more broadly I will say that we are monitoring trends both in New York City and really across the country and remain in close communication

(01:12:22)

with state partners, with our advocates, with community organizations, mutual aid groups who are on the ground and really are the eyes and ears for different communities, to understand what is actually happening and how best cities can respond.

(01:12:40)

And I am assuming that part of that was also performing targeted outreach in the areas where you saw spikes and

(01:12:46)

surges. That is right. We have a community engagement team that we deploy in neighborhoods that are impacted. They will go out a few days of the week and canvass businesses, making sure that if anyone is directly impacted they have information on how to access our immigration legal support hotline, but also are equipped with "know your rights" information — what do you do if you encounter ICE at work or at home.

(01:13:17)

How does that... I should say, Chair, that MOYA has worked with our interagency partners. So we are actively partnering with the Office of Mass Engagement, the Mayor's Office of Public Engagement, and DCWP to leverage some of their folks so we can have a larger reach around the five boroughs. You guys are so good —

(01:13:39)

every time I am about to ask about whether you need more resources, you tell me about all the resources that you have deployed to get the work done. Because I am assuming that when there is a surge and there is an increased need for people to be

(01:13:52)

out, it is really an all-hands-on-deck moment. And we are really grateful for our partners. One thing I think Lorena stopped short of sharing is the impact that these partnerships are actually making. We have conducted, just since I joined, 30 canvassing events and days of action across the five boroughs. We have distributed over 8,000 printed materials and engaged 650 businesses. All of that work is not possible without the incredible team at MOYA that I am fortunate to work with every day, but also that deep partnership with different parts of City government.

(01:14:31)

I had another question that just went out of my head. But I guess — what do you see the function of the IRC as continued surges or future surges come? Where do you see them playing a similar role? Do you see the IRC expanding to include additional people? What do you feel like about the future of the IRC?

(01:14:56)

Yeah, I think it is critical to really be grounded in why the IRC was established and for what purpose. It is really to serve as a coordinating body to respond to the federal actions that are affecting New York City residents, to monitor the federal enforcement activity, and then to provide support to City agencies in making sure that they have what they need to deliver services to immigrant New Yorkers and that they are also protected and have the support that they need to do this work. So that work is ongoing.

I think that there are significant changes and increases that are happening on the federal level in terms of policy, so it is not just enforcement activity. We are seeing significant policy changes — public charge and other policies that have real impacts in New York City and are felt on the ground. So we are really pleased that we have thought partners within the IRC to help track and monitor those developments, but also work with us to deliver information to New Yorkers who might be impacted. Speaking of some of

(01:16:17)

those reporting requirements and these local laws — for Local Law 128, the reports for the first two quarters of 2026, those will be published?

(01:16:29)

So those reports have been published. Yes. When were they published, do you know? Yesterday. OK.

(01:16:36)

I believe it is Q1, Q2, Q3 and Q4 of 2026. OK. And all six agencies named in the audit, they will provide information for Local Law 128 reports going forward, right?

(01:16:50)

That is right. And while not required by local law, as we have mentioned, H+H and New York City Public Schools have also voluntarily agreed to participate in providing and reporting on Local Law 128, of course in alignment with other City agencies, and for H+H within the parameters of HIPAA and FERPA and all the other legal privacy requirements as well.

(01:17:19)

Now the report also notes that NYPD and the Department of Probation are not currently required to disaggregate the number of civil immigration detainers lodged by conviction status and or possible match in the federal terrorist screening database, whereas they are required to do so. I know the report recommends that these three agencies standardize their reporting. So have NYPD and the Department of Probation agreed to adopt this recommendation?

(01:17:46)

The short answer is yes. They will report on civil immigration detainers broken down by conviction status and or possible match in a federal terrorist screening database, and this already aligns with what is required.

(01:18:08)

And in the IRC's view — and you may not want to speak for the full IRC — but as a member of the IRC, would this discrepancy require a legislative fix?

(01:18:18)

On that I will defer to the Council regarding any future legislation, but the agencies here are in compliance.

(01:18:28)

The report also states that NYPD detainer reporting is happening. You said that is happening?

(01:18:38)

It is happening and the guidance was issued to clarify and give clarity on the expectations to NYPD.

(01:18:47)

As well. And all three agencies have agreed to the frequency of reporting — these were annual reports that will now be quarterly. In terms of shifting gears a little bit to legal services, "know your rights" and other services — how many people have called the MOYA hotline this fiscal year? From July 1, which is when we begin, through September 15, we had 8,199 people call the hotline. 8,199, that is right. How many people have called the hotline for connection to specifically immigration legal services? That is the top issue as to why people call.

(01:19:39)

Yeah. And if people call the MOYA hotline seeking services who were previously served by the Asylum Application Help Center, that information I would not have because we do not collect people's personal identifying information. But I can say that the hotline has been shared with New Yorkers so they can access legal services, but we just do not track that. Yeah. And I appreciate some of your details in talking about how neighborhoods that are experiencing frequent ICE activity — what kinds of things are deployed there, some of the agencies that have been tasked to help. You mentioned Mass Engagement, DCWP, SBS — all great agencies. In the surrounding neighborhoods or neighborhoods that are surrounding them, do you see... what is the radius, should I say, of what classifies as a neighborhood that is

(01:20:32)

considered impacted?

(01:20:46)

We go by district, so similar to the Council district map, that is sort of what we do. When we hear — and we could hear this from advocates, we can hear this from the news, we can hear it from other agency partners — if there is a sighting, for example, I would say that the surge in New York has looked different than across the country, right, where maybe in the latter it is very targeted to a specific area and location. In New York it is a bit different, a bit more scattered. So when we hear about them we do share that with our outreach staff and equip them with information. What we want to do is to be on the ground as quickly as we can to share some of the legal services forward-facing material and try to target areas where we know people will be — so train stations, business corridors for example — and then we try to match it up so we can get to people like workers, right, so after 6 o'clock for example. And that is the way that we do it. I will say that we have partnered with City Council members. I think we have

(01:21:53)

partnered with at least one event, because you are also the eyes and ears, and I think that is an open invitation to work with us given how close you are with the districts. You might know corners that we might just not, by not having that insight in some of those Council districts. But that is a bit how that works.

(01:22:12)

And how often do those outreach sessions — I will call them that — happen?

(01:22:19)

We do an outreach event at least once a week, and sometimes two or three. I would say that when the news came down from TPS connected to Haiti, we were in Little Haiti that week at least three times in one week.

Well, I appreciate truly all of the work that you do on a day-to-day basis through the IRC. Obviously Executive Order 13 was extremely helpful for us to really get eyes on, but again as I mentioned in my opening statement, it is really just the beginning. We really look forward to seeing how these findings and these recommendations are all implemented and how more come out throughout that process. So we will be following up.

And then just lastly, in terms of your role as Commissioner in the IRC — is this something that you see as... I know you mentioned that there was a chair, or separately, that the First Deputy Mayor is chairing that. What do you see as your ongoing role being, and how significant in this particular thing? Because of course I want you to run it. Given the climate and given the sort of fast-changing nature of immigration enforcement and activities on the ground and in policy, I think it is really critical the role that the IRC continues to play. I think it is extremely important, and to underscore, having City Hall-level staff and team and leaders frankly guiding this work is what, to me, communicates that this is a serious issue for the Mayor. Having the First Deputy Mayor be present in these meetings to help guide the conversation is an indication that we are serious about protecting New York. This work is ongoing. I am really pleased to work — I feel really privileged to work with the First Deputy Mayor, with his team, with the Chief Counsel, having the support of the Law Department and the countless staff frankly that make this work happen — to show that we are serious when it comes to protecting immigrant New Yorkers and families.

(01:24:30)

Thank you for that. I am going to take a brief break really quickly and then we will move on to public testimony. Thank you. Quiet down, quiet down everyone, and find your seats. We are going to be resuming momentarily. Ladies and gentlemen, would you kindly find your seats? We are going to be resuming momentarily. All right. After entertaining that brief break, I am now going to call up Isabel Ortega Romero from the office of Borough President Reynoso.

(01:30:45)

There we go.

(01:30:46)

Thank you, Chair Encarnación and members of the Committee, for holding this hearing today. I am Romero and I am here representing the Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso.

New York City is home to immigrants — 38% of the City's population. The City is built by immigrants. Immigrants comprise 43% of our workforce, and in 2024 alone, immigrant New Yorkers paid in taxes. However, immigrants are far more than the labor they provide. They are our neighbors, friends, community members, leaders and family.

New York City is a sanctuary city, but its people are living in fear that going outside might lead to permanent separation from their loved ones. ICE arrested more people this month than in any other month during President Trump's second term. Recently, the administration's audit of City agencies revealed that many City agencies were not in compliance with sanctuary city laws. We commend the Mayor for conducting this audit and agree with its recommendations. We need more meaningful and reliable oversight. Agencies' compliance with sanctuary city laws must be independent and ongoing, because sanctuary city laws are only as strong as their enforcement, and allowing City agencies to unlawfully cooperate with ICE erodes trust in City government.

For these reasons we recommend the following. Form an independent commission to audit, monitor and enforce compliance with sanctuary city laws. This commission would conduct quarterly audits to thoroughly examine noncompliance and misconduct and would hold City agencies accountable for violations. Draft legislation creating penalties for violations of sanctuary city laws. Recommendations are not enough to ensure that agencies will abide by the law. The City Council should establish mandatory disciplinary action, fines, procedures for removing officers, employees and agency leadership, and other enforcement mechanisms for repeat violations.

The intent of these recommendations is to ensure that City agencies abide by City law designed to protect the safety and rights of all New Yorkers regardless of national origin. We can only prevent federal overreach by ensuring local agencies abide by the law.

Lastly, Borough President Reynoso strongly supports Res 0626-2026, which requires the Secretary of Homeland Security to designate Haiti for Temporary Protected Status. We hope that S.4814 passes so that our Haitian community can access health care, education and employment without legal risk. Thank you again for holding this hearing today. We look forward to continuing to work with you to ensure that City government advances justice, promotes public trust and honors the laws that protect immigrants who call this City home.

(01:33:36)

Thank you. Thank you. Please send our regards to Borough President Reynoso.

For public testimony, I remind members of the public that this is a government proceeding and that decorum shall be observed at all times. The public shall remain silent at all times. The witness table is reserved for people who wish to testify. No video recording or photography is allowed from the witness table. Audio or video recordings may be submitted as testimony, but submit transcripts of such recordings to the Sergeant at Arms for inclusion in the hearing record.

If you wish to speak at today's hearing, please fill out one of the appearance cards you will see out in the front with the Sergeant at Arms and please wait to be recognized. When recognized, you have two minutes to speak on today's oversight hearing topic — the Executive Order 13 of 2026 Report of Audit Findings and Recommendations — or the legislation on today's hearing agenda, Res 0626-2026, or both.

If you have a written statement or additional written testimony you wish to submit for the record, please provide a copy of that testimony to the Sergeant at Arms. You may also email written testimony to testimony at council.nyc.gov within 72 hours of the closing of this hearing. Audio and video recordings will not be accepted.

For in-person panelists, please come up to the table once your name has been called. Now I will call our first in-person panel, and in advance please excuse me if I cannot read or say a name correctly — somebody with a last name with eleven letters, we should all understand, right. So first is Debra Lee from the Legal Aid Society, Whitney Bronstein from Immigrant Defense Project, Rosa Cohen Cruz from the Bronx Defenders, Brittany Brown from New York County Defenders and Josh Epstein from Brooklyn Defender Services. Thank you.

(01:35:59)

Okay, okay. You are ready. You can

(01:36:33)

begin. I will go first. Good morning. My name is Rosa Khan Cruz and I am the Director of Immigration Policy for the Bronx Defenders. I have testified before this Council alongside many of the same people right here and my immigrant justice colleagues about half a dozen times over multiple years about persistent violations of our City's sanctuary laws, particularly on the part of the Department of Corrections, NYPD and in at least one instance... We welcomed and were encouraged by Mayor Mamdani and his early action by issuing Executive Order 13

(01:37:11)

and auditing compliance with our laws. Some of the findings were shocking to us, especially the finding that the Department of Corrections had been sending a daily list of non-citizens with certain conditions to ICE, despite that not being required by law. We are glad to hear that that practice has been discontinued.

In testifying about this for many years, we are really concerned about the Department of Corrections' reading of the statute and their belief that they are in compliance even though it goes against the clear text and plain reading of the statute itself. Particularly, their reading that they are allowed to transfer custody of individuals without a judicial warrant, and their reading that a conviction qualifies even if it is the instant arrest. Neither of those comports with the plain reading of the statute.

The Council or this administration should update their guidance, but also this Council needs to pass legislation to make sure that the Department is being held accountable, as well as the other agencies named in the audit. We need lasting legislative solutions, not just executive action, even though we are very grateful to see it happen. There are three Bills that we have continued to come back to this Council about. One is Intro 209, the Immigrant Trust Act. The other is Intro 395 and Intro 396, all of which address accountability for following the sanctuary laws and would fix the loopholes in existing

(01:38:45)

laws. Thank you. Thank you. Hello.

(01:38:48)

Good morning. Thank you. My name is Brittany Brown. I am the supervising attorney of the Collateral Consequences Unit at New York County Defender Services. Thank you to the Committee on Immigration for holding this public hearing on this necessary and historically overdue audit, and for recognizing that meaningful sanctuary protections need to exist in practice.

In examining this, the audit identified information sharing practices, as Rosa mentioned, that were unknown and had received little public scrutiny. Most notably, the audit found that the Department of Corrections affirmatively and routinely transmitted information concerning individuals in custody to federal authorities — federal law enforcement agencies — daily lists containing information about individuals in custody. The significance of this finding cannot be overstated. It is unimaginable that in a sanctuary city, a City agency would preemptively cooperate with federal immigration authorities without any approval for such a policy from the Mayor's Office. We are grateful that this was discovered during the audit and it shows how this administration is handling the situation differently from previous ones. But it also illustrates how difficult it can be for the Council, advocates and the public to understand how information actually moves through city agencies.

Without meaningful and sustained oversight, there have been countless hearings where the Department of Corrections has testified in front of the Council, but not once was this policy ever disclosed. We have also seen concerning and arguably unlawful examples of personnel facilitating direct contact between people in custody and federal immigration authorities. In one recent case, while our client was in custody, a correction officer approached him with a form asking whether he wished to participate in an interview with ICE. But more simply, personnel was facilitating ICE's access to a person in City custody. We believe this type of facilitation violated our City's detainer law, which sharply limits the Department of Corrections' use of City personnel and resources to assist federal civil immigration enforcement. This example would not have been caught by the audit and shows why the audit's analysis needs to go further.

(01:41:11)

Briefly, I just want to also highlight the Department of Probation's collection and inclusion of immigration information in pre-sentence investigation reports. The City should determine what immigration information is actually required to be in these presentence reports and whether the Department of Probation can obtain or verify necessary information without contacting ICE, and what safeguards can ensure that the presentence investigation process does not become a conduit for federal immigration enforcement. Thank you. Thank you. Good

(01:41:45)

morning, Chair Encarnación and members of the Committee. My name is Debra Lee and I am the attorney in charge of the Immigration Law Unit at the Legal Aid Society. I am testifying on behalf of Legal Aid, including our criminal defense practice, whose attorneys witness firsthand the consequences when the Department of Corrections and NYPD collaborate with federal immigration enforcement.

New York City should be proud of its sanctuary laws and their role in protecting non-citizen New Yorkers, safeguarding due process, promoting access to essential services and building trust in government institutions. All New Yorkers are safer when people can access schools, shelters, health care, courts and other public services without fear of immigration enforcement.

The Executive Order 13 audit highlights serious gaps that require attention. Most concerning is continued coordination with ICE. The audit found that the Department of Corrections responded to 24 ICE detainer requests by providing release notifications and facilitating transfers to federal custody. No New Yorker's information should be shared with ICE absent a judicial warrant. We urge the Council to reintroduce and pass Intro 396 to close this loophole. We also urge the Council to pass the New York City Trust Act, Intro 209 and Intro 395.

Sanctuary laws are only meaningful when they can be enforced. New Yorkers whose rights are violated should have a clear path to accountability. Accountability also requires transparency. We urge the administration and the Mayor to make the quarterly Executive Order 13 reports public so New Yorkers can assess whether sanctuary laws are being faithfully implemented.

Finally, Legal Aid supports Res 0626-2026, calling for the restoration of TPS for Haiti. As ICE intensifies efforts to detain and deport Haitian nationals following the termination of TPS protections, Haitian New Yorkers face family separation, loss of work authorization and removal to a country still experiencing profound instability. At a time of escalating federal immigration enforcement, New York City must strengthen its sanctuary laws, close remaining loopholes, promote transparency and ensure meaningful accountability. Thank you for the opportunity to testify.

(01:43:57)

Good morning. My name is Josh Epstein. I am the Director of Immigration at Brooklyn Defenders' Queens office. Thank you so much to the Committee and to Chair Encarnación for hosting today's hearing. We are grateful to the Mayor for signing Executive Order 13, to the IRC for their work to strengthen New York City's compliance with local sanctuary laws and for completing a thorough audit of agency practices. This critical process helped elucidate the ways federal immigration enforcement is targeting New Yorkers and highlighted the ways that the City can tighten protections to make New York safer for all.

The City Council has taken steps to limit City agencies' ability to facilitate civil immigration enforcement, such as New York City's groundbreaking detainer law. The Executive Order 13 report highlighted that the interpretation and implementation of these laws have left gaps, and these gaps expose immigrant New Yorkers to ICE attention. The City Council, as my colleagues have mentioned, can pass the New York City Trust Act, which will strengthen the enforceability of New York City's existing detainer protections.

Brooklyn Defenders is grateful that as part of the audit, the data sharing agreements between the Department of Corrections, the NYPD and third-party technology vendors were reviewed. Relying on outside vendors in an era of mass data accumulation by big tech companies and the federal government carries serious risks for immigrant New Yorkers

(01:45:24)

but also for the civil rights and liberties of all New Yorkers. Please continue reviewing the contracts and data sharing agreements between City agencies and third parties. We urge the Mayor's Office and the IRC to review NYPD's policies regarding audits of the Domain Awareness System. The Domain Awareness System is NYPD's surveillance platform that serves as a hub for aggregating data under NYPD's control, and this vast system is available to officers on their cellphones and it has not had an independent audit in over a decade.

In correctional settings, the use of digital surveillance technology also raises risks of data leaks that could lead to immigration enforcement in violation of our City's sanctuary policies. The jail phone call systems operated by Securus not only record jail phone calls but also store voice prints, a form of biometric data, on every individual who uses this system, including children of people experiencing incarceration. This problem is compounded by the sheer volume of data that the City allows the NYPD and the Department of Corrections to collect, and while asking minimal questions about who is accessing it, why and how it is being used, we cannot meaningfully protect it from misuse. Thank you to the Committee for hosting this hearing. Thank you.

(01:46:52)

Good morning and thank you to the Committee on Immigration and Chair Encarnación for holding this hearing. My name is Whitney Bronstein. I am senior attorney for Community Defense of the Immigrant Defense Project, which is an organization focused on fighting for justice for all immigrants, including those targeted by the criminal and immigration legal systems.

Executive Order 13 has taken critical steps in auditing City agencies and their compliance with local laws around communication and collaboration with ICE. However, there are key issues yet unaddressed by the report which have undermined due process and caused irreversible harm to New Yorkers.

First, the Department of Corrections is squarely prohibited by our laws from transferring New Yorkers to ICE custody absent a judgment of enumerated conviction for one of 178 laws within our very serious crimes carve-out and a judicial warrant. However, DOC has routinely allowed ICE to show up at Rikers to detain New Yorkers directly from their cells, without a moment of freedom, without a judicial warrant, under a mythical distinction that they are not honoring a detainer but solely communicating with ICE — communication that is not obligated for them to do and has the effect of separating families on the precipice of being reunited.

Additionally, under statute 931 as well as the 2019 operations order, when DOC is considering honoring a detainer, convictions of relevance are those that precede the instant arrest. DOC has long misinterpreted "arrest" which can include people who have no conviction at all, certainly not ones that precede the current incarceration they are experiencing. This is a basic misreading of the statute that must be addressed.

Second, I would like to address the report's recommendations regarding the NYPD. It was great to hear from the committee and from Commissioner Ali earlier this morning that NYPD is up to date on its reporting and compliance with those requirements under our local law. However, non-reporting elements of that section have not been addressed, such as the use of resources or taking direction from the Department of Homeland Security for immigration enforcement. With regard to 911 calls, we heard earlier this morning about the way in which the reporting requirements have been implemented, which is great to hear. However, 2026 raids at the Wyckoff Medical Center continue to occur. We need recommendations that address actions, not solely reporting.

For this reason, we urge the Council to pass the New York City Trust Act and the bills we introduced — Int 0995 and Int 0996 — to ensure that our laws are enforced in order to protect the rights of immigrant workers. Thank you.

(01:49:15)

Thank you all. Some of you are part of conversations that we were having about these three bills in particular — Int 0993, Int 0995 and Int 0996. I am now the lead sponsor for Int 0995 and Int 0996 and have committed to moving forward through the legislative process. I am hoping to get this in front of the full Council as soon as it goes through this process. I will continue and I am committed to working with many of you to look at how we can strengthen the wording of those particular pieces of legislation and we will see how we get on the other side of that. I appreciate you all meeting with me and also supplying me with some questions, some of which I was able to get to, and some of which I think are more appropriate to direct to you for your testimony today. Thank you.

I will now call up the next panel. We have Monique Francis from CUNY Citizenship Now, Laura Adams from The Door, Maria Posada from Safe Passage Project, Rodney Souvenir from the Haitian American Lawyers Association and Joshua Santangelo from Children's Law Center in Brooklyn. Hello. Are you ready? As soon as everyone is settled we can begin.

(01:50:55)

Thank you, Chairperson Encarnación and members of the Immigration Committee. I would also like to express gratitude to CM Farah Louis for the invitation to share this testimony today and for her advocacy in pushing forward Resolution 626, which calls for Congress to extend TPS for Haitian New Yorkers.

My name is Monique Francis. I am the Executive Director at CUNY Citizenship Now. CUNY Citizenship Now has remained a lifeline for New York City's immigrant communities. We provide trusted, free and confidential legal services since 1997. For three decades, our attorneys and paralegals assist with eligibility for immigration benefits and we help New Yorkers navigate the application process, including TPS. This infrastructure has become even more important during these moments of rapidly changing immigration policies, when misinformation and fear can leave families vulnerable, and especially in this moment when the federal administration has forgotten the contributions of immigrants.

Our work with Haitian TPS began long before the first major earthquake devastated Haiti in 2010, and we have remained steadfast not only with Haitian TPS but also with the Haitian Family Unification Program, asylum support and the most recent Haitian parole programs.

I want to take you back to 2010, when I was working as the budget manager for Citizenship Now. Two weeks after the first earthquake, Citizenship Now, in partnership with Legal Aid Society, held the City's first large group processing and TPS application assistance event. The event was held at Medgar Evers College with more than 400 Haitians seeking support for this humanitarian relief.

We made a call for volunteers and help for interpreters and translators, and the number of New Yorkers who spoke French and Haitian Creole who reached out to support this event was astonishing. Within the first few months after the earthquake, CUNY, through our partnerships and collaborations with both state and City government, helped more than a thousand immigrants.

In 2026, with a deadline to end the protections near, our organization has held virtual Zoom sessions offering guidance on other types of legal benefits. We have partnered with organizations like Little Haiti, Haitian American Alliance, Alliance of Newark and the Haitian Institute at Brooklyn College to provide know-your-rights and family preparedness sessions. Thank you.

(01:53:33)

Hello and thank you for letting me speak here today. We look forward to sending our full written testimony after today's hearing. I am Laura Adams — apologies for my handwriting. I am the Legal Program Manager at The Door, which is a comprehensive youth...

(01:53:49)

...development organization. At The Door's Legal Services Center, this year we have handled over 2,500 immigration matters for youth from infancy to 24 years old, including 614 unaccompanied immigrant minors.

Executive Order 13 is a great first step to ensure immigrant youth have the best chance at success and growth in New York City without the fear of abusive immigration enforcement. We have observed significant drops in attendance at all of our programs at The Door, including drop-in centers, schools, health clinics, housing assistance and mental health programs, due to fear of ICE enforcement.

We do want to draw the Council's attention to the audit report's findings of continued illegal ICE harassment of staff and participants at our City shelters and of our foster care youth and families in the system. The information in the audit on the so-called wellness checks from ICE and agencies for foster care youth is consistent with what we have observed with the collusion between the Office of Refugee Resettlement and ICE to target recently released unaccompanied minors in New York City. So ORR is definitely part of our immigration enforcement concerns at this point, and I want to draw attention to the fact that their information sharing policies are problematic here. These young people should be free from harassment and intimidation from the federal government once they are out of federal custody.

We do want to echo concerns that the Department of Youth and Community Development was not included in this audit or in the Executive Order protections. The protections required for other City departments should extend to protect runaway and homeless youth, especially as hundreds of immigrant youth come to DYCD and their drop-in centers. The New York City Council has met about DYCD in the past and their information sharing policies with ORR and ICE, so it is very relevant to this discussion. They have acknowledged the sensitive nature of the information sharing on unaccompanied minors.

Finally, we do urge the codification of the protections in Executive Order 13 through the passage of legislation like the New York City Trust Act, and we offer our support as well for the resolution in support of TPS for Haiti. Thank you for your time and consideration.

(01:56:09)

Thank you.

(01:56:09)

Thank you for this opportunity today. My name is Maria Posada and I am a staff attorney at Safe Passage Project, a nonprofit that provides free legal representation to immigrant children facing deportation in New York City and Long Island. We are grateful to City officials for taking steps to ensure that City agencies protect the immigrant New Yorkers who rely on them. More must be done to ensure that unaccompanied immigrant children in the custody of New York's Administration for Children's Services do not fall through the cracks.

I have represented a young person who I will call D since January 2026. D is an unaccompanied minor who was found to be a destitute child and placed in ACS custody after his abusive older brother kicked him out of his home. I met D after he was ordered deported because caseworkers at his placement facility neglected to inform him that he was scheduled for an immigration court hearing, which he missed. We petitioned for Special Immigrant Juvenile Status while we moved to reopen his immigration court case. He was moved from a Manhattan placement to a group home on Long Island, where he repeatedly expressed feeling unsafe and unhappy. We also learned he had a pending criminal case in Suffolk County, which made him vulnerable to being turned over to ICE. We warned about this and advocated for him to be moved back to New York City.

We later learned that Suffolk police took D from his group home to a police station for questioning, where ICE waited outside to arrest him. ICE claimed that he was an adult, not a 16-year-old child, despite the overwhelming evidence presented to them proving his age. ICE held D in adult detention for over three months while we filed a habeas petition to get him released. Finally, ICE quietly moved D to a shelter for immigrant minors without conceding their error.

D suffered immeasurable harm during his months in adult ICE detention, including being attacked by other detainees and being placed in solitary confinement. Had D been placed within New York City instead of out on Long Island, I believe that the City's measures to limit information sharing between local police and ICE would have stopped him from being turned over to immigration officials, sparing him months of suffering as a child in adult ICE custody. I urge the members of this committee and the Mayor's administration to remember D's story as you work to implement the findings of this audit and take concrete steps to ensure that children in ACS custody are truly protected. Thank you.

(01:58:31)

Good morning, Chair Encarnación and members of the Committee on Immigration. My name is Rodney L. Pepe-Souvenir and I am the President of the Haitian American Lawyers Association of New York. Thank you for the opportunity to testify in strong support of Resolution 626, sponsored by CM Farah Louis, calling upon the United States Congress to pass S.4814, designating Haiti for Temporary Protected Status.

I want to thank CM Louis for her leadership and her steadfast commitment to the Haitian community here in her district and across our City. On April 16, the House of Representatives passed its version of this legislation with bipartisan support. Senate Bill S.4814 would give the Senate the chance to finish that work and allow eligible Haitian nationals to continue living and working lawfully in this country. After the Supreme Court allowed the termination of Haiti's TPS to move forward, Congress is now the clearest path to protecting these families.

Nationwide, roughly 350,000 Haitians depend on TPS. Many of them are our neighbors here in New York City — in Flatbush, Canarsie, East Flatbush, Cambria Heights and beyond. They are nurses, home health aides, teachers, small business owners, lawyers and parents of American citizen children. Many have lived here for more than a decade. As lawyers, we see every day what uncertainty does to these families. We see people afraid to go to work, afraid to renew a lease, afraid to plan a future. We have had to tell parents that they must choose whether to take their children into the certain dangers that exist currently in Haiti or to separate and leave their children with a trusted friend or family member here in the States.

TPS exists for exactly the conditions that Haiti faces today: political instability, widespread violence and a humanitarian emergency. Sending people back into that danger is neither lawful in spirit nor humane in practice. This Council has long stood with New York City's immigrant communities. I respectfully urge the committee to adopt Resolution 626 and add New York City's voice to the call for Congress to pass S.4814 without delay. Families cannot wait. Thank you.

(02:00:59)

Good morning, Chair Encarnación and members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. My name is Joshua Santangelo. I am the supervising attorney for Children's Law Center's Youth Guardianship Project, which does Special Immigrant Juvenile Status work. I commend the administration and the Council's efforts to protect our immigrant populations against the actions of the federal government.

As this body is aware, the federal government's recent actions have created real and irreparable damage and fear within our immigrant communities. Many of the clients that we interact with are afraid to enter any governmental building, including state and City courthouses. Many of our cases hit snags when guardians of our clients refused to get fingerprinted at state courthouses due to fear of ICE presence. So far we have been...

(02:01:49)

...able to overcome that by accompanying guardians, finding outside fingerprinting resources and making applications to waive fingerprints where applicable. But the level of distrust present within these communities is palpable.

This administration's efforts to protect our communities and separate the City government's intentions from that of the federal government are admirable, but there is still much to be done. There is so much distrust of any governmental body present within the immigrant communities that we serve. We have seen this through MOIA's efforts to disseminate know-your-rights materials and through City administration communications that there is an intention to separate the City from the federal government. However, as this committee has commented on, there are just not enough attorneys present in this City to do the work that is necessary.

So we encourage the passage of the Trust Act and similar legislation to both try to limit how many cases are actually moving into the court system, by holding the agencies that are passing information to ICE accountable, and also to continue to disseminate know-your-rights materials. I would like to have commented on the resolution as well but I will just submit the written testimony in the interest of time. Thank you very much.

(02:03:13)

And my assumption is you are in support...

(02:03:15)

...absolutely, on the record. Thank you. All right, thank you all for your testimony. I will now call up CM De La Rosa for comment. Did you see this?

(02:03:33)

Gisela from... organization, and also Julio Santo Domingo from IRC and Sandra...

(02:03:47)

...

(02:04:09)

I believe one of the folks that I called up may be at another hearing, so I am going to call up Karina from New York Lawyers for the Public Interest to take her space. Thank you so much. You can start.

(02:04:26)

Good morning. My name is Gisela Moreau Keen. I am the Managing Director of Mixtec, a community based organization based out of Sunset Park, Brooklyn. I appreciate the opportunity to provide testimony this morning as this committee analyzes the Executive Order 13 report of audit findings, its information and learnings, and gets ready to make further recommendations. Mixtec has provided services to the Latina and Indigenous communities in Sunset Park for 26 years. Our service delivery model centers mental health and well-being and is delivered through trauma-informed practices.

Our reach now expands beyond Brooklyn, and community members across all five boroughs come to Mixtec, particularly seeking information and legal support around immigration policies and understanding their rights as immigrants, parents and caretakers. With so much information out there, our community members trust us to identify accurate and up-to-date information that protects them and their families. We are happy to hear that changes have been made across several agencies and we appreciate the continued efforts to ensure the safety of our immigrant neighbors.

The audit identified gaps, and the following are specified and measurable oversight mechanisms we hope the Council could require to close the gaps and demonstrate accountability. Every City agency should have clear, public and easily accessible data sharing policies. Given the Department of Correction's history of daily jail reporting sharing with ICE, there must be strong accountability for noncompliance. Once finalized, these protocols should be published in multiple languages so that all New Yorkers can understand them. Policies regarding ICE access to City facilities must be shared with community based organizations. Many community members come to Mixtec before seeking medical care or other basic services because they are unsure whether an interaction with a City agency or a shelter could expose them or their family member to immigration enforcement. Unauthorized ICE access to hospitals, public buildings, parking lots or schools violates community trust and can keep families from obtaining essential care and services. The Council should establish a firm deadline for agencies to finalize and implement these policies and the mechanisms to track their implementation.

(02:06:37)

If I could just go lastly: while we commend Mayor Mamdani's proactive signing of Executive Order 13, we urge the City Council to consider ensuring the protections and their implementation are not only dependent on a single administration or one mayor's commitment. The Council should examine which of these protections should be made into permanent law with clear enforcement, reporting and oversight mechanisms that are transparent and accessible.

(02:07:04)

Thank you. Good afternoon, Council Members. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Vann. I am the community organizer at Mixtec, a community based organization in Central Brooklyn that has served immigrant, Latina and Indigenous communities for over 25 years. After reviewing Executive Order 13 and other recommendations, it was great to see that the majority of the City agencies were able to comply with and enforce the changes that the Mayor implemented. But as the report also showed, there were a few instances in which these new Executive Order 13 protocols were not followed.

The proposed recommendations call for strengthening documentation, reporting and transparency, which I agree with, but it is unclear how this information will be shared with immigrant New Yorkers. A plan to inform immigrant New Yorkers about the new policies in place should be developed, particularly targeting community based organizations where many people in our community obtain information and updates. Given the recent changes to public charge policies and ongoing threats facing our community, it is essential to ensure that there is consistent communication and regular updates for immigrant New Yorkers.

The recommendation suggests that City agencies should undergo quarterly audits, which should be followed by proposals to enhance protections for our immigrant community. Additionally, there should be quarterly plans to share updates, findings and changes to policies and procedures with all New Yorkers. At Mixtec, we provide continuous Know Your Rights workshops and resources. Through these presentations we do our best to inform our community members and keep them updated on policy changes that affect them. Some of the presentation materials we provide are from the Mayor's Office of Immigrant Affairs. It would be incredibly helpful if those presentations could include updates on how Executive Order 13 is strengthening protections for immigrant New Yorkers. I would like to thank the committee for the continued work supporting our immigrant New Yorkers and I hope you are able to develop a communication plan. Thank you.

(02:09:05)

Good afternoon. My name is Sandra Jude Annette and I am the supervising attorney for the Haitian Response Initiative at Catholic Charities. I would like to thank Councilwoman Farías and Chair Encarnación for having us here today. The Catholic Charities Haitian Response Initiative was established in 2022 to respond to the growing legal and humanitarian needs that Haitian New Yorkers faced. It provides culturally and linguistically responsive immigration legal services, meaning that the staff is Haitian or Haitian American and we all speak Haitian Creole, which helps with cultural sensitivities and allows New Yorkers to tell us their story. We assist with asylum, Temporary Protected Status, employment authorization, Special Immigrant Juvenile Status, adjustment of status and other forms of humanitarian relief. Our work extends beyond the four walls of our offices. We conduct Know Your Rights presentations, legal clinics, immigration screenings and community outreach throughout New York City. We work with faith based organizations,

(02:10:18)

elected officials and trusted partners. We meet Haitian New Yorkers where they are and provide critical information and services in both Haitian Creole and English. Today, as we know, TPS has ended and more than 300,000 Haitians nationwide have faced the loss of Temporary Protected Status. They have lived, worked and paid taxes and raised children in the United States, at risk of losing their work authorization and their protection from deportation. Haitian TPS holders are our neighbors — health care workers, home health aides, caregivers, business owners, students and parents. In this community, the impact reaches far beyond immigration status. The psychological toll can also be very profound. People who have spent years building stable lives are now suddenly facing horrible conditions.

(02:11:15)

The thought of sending them back to Haiti, where it is very dangerous, and there are mixed-status families where the parents are not citizens but their children are U.S. citizens — and now they are deciding whether to take their children to this dangerous country or leave them here with people they do not really know.

(02:11:36)

We are asking that the Senate pass S.4814, because it is really important to make sure that we protect our Haitian immigrants in the United States. We are also asking that arrests and deportations of affected former TPS holders be halted and that humanitarian protection be restored where legally available. Thank you so much.

(02:12:08)

Good afternoon to the committee. My name is Julio Santo Domingo. I am a Deputy Director of the New York office of the International Rescue Committee. We support Resolution 0626-2026. The IRC supports Haitians both internally in the United States — and of course in New York — and also internationally. For the Haitian population, in the last four years we have served 10,000 Haitian clients overall, 5,700 through New York and New Jersey alone, which is a reflection of how central this population is to our organization. Our country program in Haiti hears reports every day that reflect the profound security and humanitarian crisis it faces, including sexual violence, kidnapping and displacement, combined with widespread food insecurity. Armed gangs have control across 90% of the capital and beyond, restricting humanitarian access. Over half the population does not have enough to eat, and the crisis is expected to deepen as approaching weather patterns drive the security situation even higher.

For Haitian families who have built their lives in the United States, the loss of TPS has devastating consequences, creating uncertainty surrounding not only their ability to remain and work in the U.S. but also the stability of their communities. These are not simply immigration matters. They are deeply human concerns that affect families, livelihoods and the ability of individuals to plan for their futures.

One of our clients, for example, who fled Haiti and arrived in 2020 with her two children, is one of the great examples of a New Yorker facing this crisis right now. TPS would have protected her from returning to Haiti and from detention in the U.S. But protection for Haitians was ended before she could submit her application. We at the IRC have helped her continue through other means, such as applying for asylum. However, what is at stake goes far beyond any one case — it potentially brings people back to harm. At stake is not only the safety of current generations but the hope of children and future generations to come. So thank you for your time today.

(02:14:27)

Thank you, and thank you for clarifying that you are not the same IRC that we were talking about the whole time during this hearing. Thank you.

(02:14:47)

Chair Encarnación, my name is Carina Adler, the Director of the Health Justice Program at New York Lawyers for the Public Interest. We of course support Res 0626-2026, but I am here to testify about Executive Order 13 and to briefly support the recommendations that the Mayor has adopted. I applaud NYC Health + Hospitals for voluntarily participating in the audit and adopting policies. It is the largest public health system in the country and I believe that what NYC Health + Hospitals does will help set the tone for every other hospital in the City, including private and voluntary hospitals, many of which are located in immigrant communities and have been involved in incidents of ICE access and violent enforcement.

Today we have a few recommendations. First, as part of the reporting requirement, we ask that NYC Health + Hospitals track and report any medical clearance requests that ICE directs at treating providers when they are caring for patients in ICE custody. We have heard repeatedly that ICE brings people to NYC Health + Hospitals for medical clearance or demands written medical clearance after apprehending and injuring New Yorkers on the street and before transferring them to immigration detention centers. We know from our extensive work documenting and litigating medical neglect in immigration detention centers that the continuity of care after discharge is not being honored, and if true, we fear that these letters can contribute to the continued neglect and inhumane detention of New Yorkers. Careful tracking, reporting and auditing of these requests could make the difference between detained New Yorkers returning to their community.

Second, we hope that NYC Health + Hospitals will formally partner with immigrant patient advocacy organizations like Health Justice for New York as they consider policy implementation and ongoing reporting. Lastly, we ask the committee to pass a resolution to support the state bill, Senate Bill 194, the Safe Access to Care Act. The Bill would require every hospital in New York, public or private, to adopt written protections. Right now only some are stepping up voluntarily, but this Bill would close the gap for everyone. Thank you again for your time. I look forward to continued collaboration to support the health and safety of New Yorkers.

(02:17:01)

Thank you so much. Our next and what looks like final panel will be — I believe, ladies, you came back — De La Rosa from La Colmena, Stephanie D'Elia from Little Haiti BK, almost my neighborhood, and Nausea Faizi from Health Justice for New York, and Stephen Badge from Health Justice New York. If anyone is here to testify and has not been called, please fill out a form with our Sergeant at Arms.

(02:17:59)

Making sure we are on point. You may begin. Thank you, Chair Encarnación and New York City Council Immigration Committee for hearing us today. My name is Stephanie D'Elia and I am the Executive Director of Little Haiti BK. On July 27, 2026, over half a million Haitian TPS recipients lost status, and over a hundred thousand Syrian immigrants as well. We know by those sheer numbers alone that there are not enough immigration lawyers to represent each and every single one of them. In response to that, I think the City has a duty to start to focus substantially more on pro se services. If we cannot be there with them, at least give them the tools, the information and the confidence to support themselves. I used to work with CUNY Citizenship Now and I know personally that they are one of the best at doing this work. Little Haiti BK is partnering with them to provide legal services so that people could be prepared to represent themselves pro se, as many of the former recipients are receiving notices to appear and show up in court.

We have seen from the prior reports that some of the agencies unfortunately are sharing information, and so some of the former TPS recipients attending court are not safe. In addition to just immigration services, I cannot stress the importance of preparedness planning. Specifically, it is important that people protect their children, protect their money, and come up with an emergency

(02:19:34)

plan so that they could help protect themselves and get their documents in order so that if they are picked up by ICE unexpectedly, an attorney who is prepared to assist them can get the documents quickly. We know that this administration is transporting parents and people to other states, and so to the extent somebody gets picked up in New York and ends up going to Louisiana, we want to ensure that if they have the proper guardianship orders filed for their children, that at some point they could be reunited and families do not get separated.

Lastly, when it comes to protecting their money, a lot of the Haitian TPS recipients have been in America for a very long time. They own businesses, they own property, they have made a living here. They are a huge portion of this community and the health care workforce. They have pensions, they have 401(k) plans and some of them have small businesses. I think it is very important that the City starts to consider measures to ensure that they are able to protect some of their funds if they are unexpectedly removed. Thank you.

(02:20:37)

For your time. Good afternoon, Chair Encarnación. My name is Ladies De La Rosa and I am the Advocacy Coordinator at La Colmena. We are a nonprofit community based organization working with laborers, domestic workers and other low-wage immigrant workers in Staten Island through organizing, education, cultural and equitable economic development.

On September 13, on Port Richmond Avenue in Staten Island, we celebrated Mexican Independence Day with a colorful and vibrant parade. Just a few days later, ICE enforcement activity took place on the same streets, terrorizing members of our community. Our staff was there and they witnessed an ICE officer detaining a child. These are not stories that we hear from the news. As local organizations, we are learning about these incidents directly from the people in our community who are experiencing them. This is where community based organizations are so important. In New York City, organizations like La Colmena play a critical role in building trust, educating workers about their rights and connecting community members with appropriate legal, mental health and other support services.

We are constantly receiving calls from community members about what they are experiencing and what they should do when they encounter immigration enforcement. While strengthening NYPD protocols is an important step forward, we also have to recognize the reality on the ground. Some immigrant workers and families may feel safer reaching out to a trusted community organization than directly to a government agency. This is why the City must make concrete investments in community based organizations that are trusted by immigrant communities. We can receive and document reports, connect people with legal assistance and other services, follow up with community members and help ensure that incidents do not go unaddressed. Executive Order 13 is strengthening New York City's sanctuary protections, but protections on paper alone are not enough. These protections must be understandable, accessible and meaningful in practice. City protections only work if people know about them, trust them and feel safe enough to use them. Thank you for your continuous commitment to the people of New York City and for allowing me to testify.

(02:22:56)

Good morning, members of the committee. My name is Nausea Fiatse. I am a steering member of Health Justice for New York and I am currently a grad student studying data analytics and public health policy at Mount Sinai. I am here with also a committee member, Steve Auerbach. My background has been in neuroscience research and management. I say this because it is relevant to what I am about to share.

From a personal experience, I was once an immigrant myself, so I understand the challenges immigrants face. They are not always visible in a policy document or statistic. Sometimes they are simply the fear and uncertainty that come with interacting with institutions you do not always know that you can trust. That is why I believe that protecting immigrant New Yorkers has to mean more than creating policies on paper. These protections have to be something people can actually feel when they walk into a hospital, a shelter, a school or a City agency.

There is already a fear of interacting with the government. When you add the fear of immigration enforcement, that fear can become a barrier to getting help. Someone may be sick but hesitate to go to the hospital. A parent may need assistance for their child but be afraid to ask for it. Someone experiencing domestic violence, a mental health crisis or another urgent situation may worry about what information will be collected and where it could go. From a public health perspective, this matters because fear can become a barrier to care.

I believe the City should focus not only on whether agencies have the correct policies but on whether New Yorkers can actually understand those protections. I would like to see clear information about immigrants' rights available where people receive services — not buried on hard-to-navigate government websites. I would also like to see regular training for City employees who are front-facing with immigrants so that people receive the same protections regardless of which agency or employee they interact with.

I believe the City should have ways to measure whether these policies are doing what they say they are doing and how effectively they are working for the people. We need to understand if people are avoiding health care and other essential services because they are afraid, whether our agencies are consistently following the procedures that are already in place and what gaps are missing.

In addition, I want us to think about this through the experience of immigrant women. During my time as a case manager at a family shelter, it was predominantly immigrant women who represented their families. These women were seeking health care for pregnancy, domestic violence, mental health and other pertinent services. A lot of times I had tough conversations with these folks about doing what is best for them while trying to calm their fears about putting themselves and their families at risk by getting their basic needs taken care of.

My message today is simple: a right that people are afraid to exercise is not truly accessible. New York City has an opportunity to make its protections practical, understandable and accessible to the people who need them. Thank you for allowing me to testify today.

(02:26:00)

Hi, I am Dr. Steve Auerbach with Health Justice for New York. Thank you for having us again in front of this committee. I wish it was not so necessary. We have supported in the past on 2025-412 and earlier this year 5-5 and 261, and of course the New York Trust Act and Int 0395 and Int 0396, which I think will be getting new numbers. We support all of those and of course the Mayor's Executive Order 13.

What has been shown with the audit is that there needs to be actual enforcement, including consequences for persons who violate existing sanctuary laws and the Executive Order. That needs to include — and it is politically tough, but it needs to include — if you are going to actually have law enforcement equal under the law for everybody, members of the NYPD et cetera who violate existing statute and Executive Order.

Number one. Number two, we support of course S.4814. We call on our senior Senator Schumer to use his powers as Majority Leader to whip the handful of Democrats who have not signed on to it, including in her neighboring state of Connecticut.

We also co-wrote with Attorney General James and feel very proud of the New York State Legislature Safe Access to Care Act that was mentioned earlier. It is carried by Rivera, S.1494, and Forrest, A.11537.

(02:27:51)

We would call on both passage in the New York State Legislature and perhaps copycat legislation at the City level. Finally, I really want to call upon — and this is my main message — I want to call upon the City Council and the Mayor to use whatever is necessary, whether it is the bully pulpit or calling stakeholders together, to involve the private voluntary hospitals, whether individually or through their group the Greater New York Hospital Association or the Hospital Association of the City of New York, to also obey these laws.

Senior management at some of those hospitals, including their boards of directors, include MAGA supporters and they have been very reticent to follow New York City and New York State law. There needs to be consequences. There are levers including zoning, taxes and licensing — facility licensing — that can be brought to bear if they are non-cooperative. We need enforcement. Thank you for your time.

(02:28:57)

Thank you very much. We do have one witness on Zoom, so I am going to take the opportunity to call that panel for testimony and I look forward to seeing you at other future hearings. Our witness on Zoom, Amanda Powers from the Anti-Violence Project — if you are ready, you can begin speaking.

(02:29:23)

Thank you. Good afternoon. Thank you, Chair Encarnación and the committee, for holding this public hearing to address Executive Order 13. My name is Amanda Powers and I am a legal fellow at the New York City Anti-Violence Project, or AVP. AVP provides critical holistic support and legal services to LGBT+ and HIV-positive survivors of violence, including many immigrant survivors of violence in New York City.

Today, in addition to discussing Executive Order 13, I offer my voice on behalf of the queer immigrant survivors of violence whom AVP serves, to urge you to pass critical legislation that will allow immigrant New Yorkers who have survived violence to feel safe interacting with City government — specifically the New York City Trust Act and Int 0209, as well as former Intros 0395 and 0396. Thank you, Chair Encarnación, for sharing your ongoing support for Int 0396.

AVP's immigrant clients live in fear of deportation because of the devastating reality that for many LGBT+ immigrants, deportation is a death sentence. ICE detention centers are sites of anti-LGBTQ+ violence. One of our clients, a transgender woman who came to New York City seeking safety from the transphobic violence in her home country, is currently sitting in solitary confinement in an all-male immigration detention center in Louisiana. In detention she has experienced transphobic attacks and violent harassment from guards and been denied access to necessary medical care.

Before her detention, she survived a violent rape in New York City but did not report it to the police because she was afraid that doing so would lead to her being targeted by ICE. Now, months later, AVP has helped her report the crime from inside ICE detention in Louisiana. Her reality is the reality that LGBT+ immigrant New Yorkers understandably fear they will experience if their information is shared with ICE, keeping them from interacting with City agencies at many levels.

AVP operates a crisis hotline for queer survivors of violence in New York City, so we hear every day from community members who are experiencing abuse and exploitation but who feel that they cannot seek help from City agencies because they believe that government contact will lead them to further violence at the hands of ICE. We hear stories from hotline users and clients about how this fear of ICE prevents domestic violence victims from seeking government resources, from relying on the City's shelter system after fleeing abuse, and now is keeping LGBTQ+ survivors of violence from pursuing their winnable immigration cases because they believe that interacting with any government entity will make them a target for federal immigration enforcement.

Passing the New York City Trust Act and Intros 0395 and 0396 are important steps toward rebuilding trust with immigrant New Yorkers and specifically with the LGBT+ survivors of violence whom we work with at AVP. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today.

(02:32:29)

Thank you. We have now heard from everyone who has signed up to testify. If we inadvertently missed anyone who would like to testify in person, please visit the sergeant's table and complete a witness slip now. If you are joining virtually, please use the raise hand function on Zoom and a member of our staff will call on you in the order your hand was raised.

I will now read the names of those who registered to testify but have not yet filled out a witness slip or appeared on Zoom. Seeing no one else, I would like to note again that written testimony, which will be reviewed in full by committee staff, may be submitted to the record up to 72 hours after the close of this hearing by emailing it to testimony@council.nyc.gov. Thank you everyone. This hearing is adjourned.

AI-generated summaries and transcripts. Errors are possible.
Verify against the linked video and send corrections via email.