The Role of Planning and Development in Mayor Mamdani's Block-by-Block Housing Plan Committee on Land Use · October 21, 2026 · 3hrs 37m Source: https://hearinghearings.nyc/hearings/committee-on-land-use-the-role-of-planning-and-development-in-mayor-mamdanis-block-by-block-housing-2026-10-21/ Video: https://councilnyc.viebit.com/vod/?s=true&v=NYCC-250-8-1_261021-131209.mp4 ================================================================ (00:00:05) Good afternoon and welcome to the New York City Council hybrid meeting, here and in the committee. Please silence all electronic devices at this time. If you have not yet filed an appearance slip, please do that with the Sergeant at Arms in the back of the room. (00:00:24) Also, please do not approach the dais. Thank you very much for your kind cooperation. (00:00:28) Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to a meeting of the Committee on Land Use. I am CM Kevin C. Riley, Chair of this Committee. I would like to welcome my esteemed colleagues today. I am joined by Chair Marte, Chair Louis, CM Cabán, CM Brewer, CM Sanchez, CM Justin Sanchez, CM Encarnación, CM Thomas-Henry, Minority Leader CM Carr, CM Ossé and CM Santosuosso. Did I get it right? All right. Yeah. At today's meeting, in about ten minutes, for those of you waiting, we will open up an oversight hearing regarding Mayor Mamdani's Block-by-Block Housing Plan, which was released earlier this year. As many of you know, the administration's ambitious plan targets 200,000 new construction affordable housing units and 200,000 preservation units, for a total of 400,000 affordable housing units in New York City over the next decade. We look forward to a robust discussion of the Mayor's plan with members of his administration who have joined us today, and we also look forward to hearing feedback from the public related to this plan right after we hear from the agencies. In a few minutes I will go over some procedural announcements regarding how members of the public sign up to testify. But before we get to our oversight hearing, the Committee will take up some other business in the form of handling land use votes. Today we are voting on three proposals on the recommendations of our two subcommittees, and thank you always to Chair Marte and Chair Louis for your leadership there. Today we will vote to approve LU 0129-2026 and LU 0130-2026, related to the 48-50 Convent Avenue cluster, an ANCP approval and Article XI tax exemption to facilitate the preservation of four buildings, including approximately 77 homeownership units. We will also vote to approve LU 0142-2026 and LU 0143-2026, related to the 1455 Coney Island Avenue Rezoning proposal in CM Feliz's district in Brooklyn, for a zoning map amendment and text amendment to facilitate the development of a long-term care facility for seniors. We will also vote to approve LU 0144-2026 and LU 0145-2026, related to the 135-27 Sapphire Street Rezoning proposal in CM Ariola's district in Queens, for a zoning map amendment and text amendment to facilitate the development of a new residential project, including approximately 268 apartments in total, of which up to 80 will be permanently affordable. I will now call for a vote with the support of the local members to approve LU 0129-2026 and LU 0130-2026 for the Convent Avenue proposal, LU 0142-2026 and LU 0143-2026 for the 1455 Coney Island Avenue Rezoning, and LU 0144-2026 and LU 0145-2026 for the 135-27 Sapphire Street Rezoning. Clerk, please call the roll. (00:03:46) Good afternoon. Believe Martin, Committee Clerk. Roll call, Committee on Land Use. All items are coupled. Chair Riley: aye. Thank you. CM Louis: aye. Thank you. CM Brooks-Powers: aye. Thank you. CM Abreu: aye. CM Salaam: aye. CM Banks: aye. Thank you. CM Won: aye. CM Encarnación: aye. CM Justin Sanchez: aye. CM Thomas-Henry: aye. CM Carr: aye. With a vote of ten in the affirmative, zero in the negative, no abstentions, all items have been approved by the Committee as described by the Chair. (00:05:00) Thank you. I just want to stay for a moment. We have been joined by CM Banks, CM Salaam and Majority Whip Hanks. Thank you to my Committee colleagues and thank you to the Committee Clerk. I will open up our oversight hearing on today's agenda to address the administration's Block-by-Block Housing Plan. At the start, I will remind everyone that this meeting is being held in hybrid format and members of the public may view a live stream broadcast of this meeting at the Council's website. Members of the public who wish to testify may do so either through Zoom or in person. Those wishing to testify by Zoom must register online at the New York City Council's website at council.nyc.gov/landuse to sign up. For those of you here with us in person, if you registered online in advance, please be sure to see one of the Sergeants at Arms to prepare and submit a speakers card. We will limit public testimony to two minutes per witness. If you have additional testimony or written testimony you would like to submit, please email it to landusetestimony@council.nyc.gov and please include the phrase "Oversight Mayor's Housing Plan" in the subject line of your email. Lastly, I want to remind everyone that this is a government proceeding and decorum must be observed at all times. Members of the public are asked not to speak during the meeting unless you are testifying. The witness table is reserved for people who are called to testify and no video recording or photography is allowed from the witness table. Members of the public may not present audio or video recordings as testimony, but you may submit a transcript of such recording to the Sergeant at Arms for inclusion in the hearing record. We are joined today by administration officials, including Chair Sherman from the City Planning Commission, who is the Director of the Department of City Planning, and Michael Sandler, the Deputy Commissioner for the Office of Neighborhood Strategies from the Department of Housing Preservation and Development. We also have the Executive Director of the Department of City Planning, Edith Su Chen. Thank you again to all of you for participating in today's hearing. We have also been joined by CM Won. We are going to pause just to take a vote real quick. Continuation members, all vote. (00:07:35) Thank you. Voters now at eleven. Thank you. (00:07:40) Across government and the private sector, we all agree that New York City must aggressively increase the production of housing and affordable housing. The goals of the Block-by-Block Plan are bold and extremely ambitious: 200,000 new affordable units as part of 700,000 total new units over the next decade. This represents more housing at a faster rate than New York City has produced in a hundred years. The administration alone cannot achieve this rate of housing production, and I want to remind you today, despite a narrative that too often pits the Council against the administration, we are your partners and a group of elected officials who best know the communities we were elected to represent, and we can effectively help you to achieve the goals laid out in this plan. Details on how the administration intends to realistically achieve these numbers remain absent. We are ready to roll up our sleeves, engage on specifics and do what government does best, which is set the stage for sustainable community development. That means addressing the larger needs of the City while remaining respectful and inclusive of everyone who calls New York City home. So far in the press and at events we have heard more about the efforts to fast-track developer applications than we have heard about the plan needed to support new housing. Housing cannot be thought of just in isolation. Successful housing is supported by access to jobs, transportation, open space, schools, libraries, grocery stores and other needed physical infrastructure. The data shows that from 2010 to 2020, City-led neighborhood rezonings were responsible for nearly three times more new housing units than private development applications. This Council, with leadership from Speaker Menin and myself, has been loud and clear about the benefits of proactive planning, engaging with communities on the ground and doing the hard work of understanding their (00:09:45) needs and identifying the investments to support good growth and quality development. We are doing the work, as shown by the Council's initiative in Bay Ridge, Staten Island's North Shore and in Park Chester's section of the Bronx. We know that a neighborhood rezoning that provided the needed local investment along with new housing recently promoted the example of the East New York Neighborhood Plan. In the ten years since the plan was approved, over 6,000 units of housing have been built, more than 50% affordable, alongside hundreds of millions of dollars of City investments for neighborhood improvements, including new school seats, improved parks and open space facilities and other critical infrastructure needed. The Council was proud to partner on this neighborhood rezoning, which represents the success that can be achieved through proactive neighborhood planning. We all want to move fast, but the housing our constituents need will not be created unless we move together and in the same direction. Creating healthy, diverse communities takes time, investment and meaningful engagement. So while I applaud the vision and the goals of the Mayor's Block-by-Block Plan and want the administration to be successful, there are a lot of questions that remain. When will we start seeing the details of how to speed affordable housing in the fast-track districts? How can communities in targeted fast-track areas learn about and participate in any of these efforts? Is there a vision for planning with communities for an affordable and, most importantly, livable New York City? What is the role of neighborhood planning in this administration? Will we work to build the kind of housing that New Yorkers tell us they want, like opportunities for homeownership and family-size units, or will we simply prioritize the bottom-line total count of affordable units? What will the administration do to work with partners at the state and federal level to secure sustained funding for infrastructure and housing? We cannot focus only on taxing the rich or building over rail yards. The most populous city in the country needs all hands on deck to solve the affordability crisis. Beyond these larger questions, I have specific questions about the initiatives in the Mayor's plan and I hope we can start to fill some of those information gaps today. There have been no updates on many of the Block-by-Block proposals since the plan was released in May. DCP has not been forthcoming with the micro plans and HPD has not told us how they plan to expand their financial tools. The details matter and we are here to work them out, and I want to be sure that the recently adopted procedural tools do not paper over the need for planning and community engagement. (00:14:01) Thank you. Good afternoon, Chair Riley and distinguished members of the Land Use Committee. I am Cindy Sherman, Chair of the City Planning Commission and Director of the New York City Department of City Planning. I am joined here today by Michael Sandler, Deputy Commissioner for the Office of Neighborhood Strategies at HPD, as well as my colleague from DCP, including Executive Director Eva Su Chen. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to speak with you today. When I last testified before you, I was six days into my role at the Department of City Planning. At that time, I spoke about the urgency of unlocking significantly more housing across neighborhoods, streamlining how we work to deliver homes faster and planning for a fairer, more equitable City. Seven months later, I can confirm that this has remained the focus of our work. Earlier this year, Mayor Mamdani released Block by Block, the Block-by-Block Housing Plan, which takes an all-of-the-above approach to tackling our housing crisis, combining ambitious affordable housing production goals with investments in public housing, new tools to protect tenants, support for homeownership and much more. At City Planning, along with our partners at HPD, we are translating that vision into action on many fronts. First, we are working to create more housing choices in more parts of the City. We have rapidly advanced neighborhood planning efforts along White Plains Road in the Bronx and McDonald Avenue and Coney Island Avenue in Brooklyn, working closely with community and City Council partners like you, Chair Riley, to develop comprehensive plans that update outdated zoning, create more housing, require permanent affordability, support local businesses and deliver needed investments. We greatly appreciate the Council's collaboration and partnership in these efforts. We are also developing a citywide transit-oriented development initiative. We have one of the world's most extensive subway systems and it is the lifeblood of our City. But in too many places, restrictive zoning limits housing even directly next to subway stations. That means fewer homes near transit, longer commutes and less access to jobs, schools, services and opportunity. Through this initiative we can fix outdated rules, expand housing opportunity and require affordability, so more New Yorkers across all income levels can live close to the transit system they rely on. As the proposal takes shape, we look forward to engaging closely with the Council and working together to build the support needed to move forward. Second, we are focused on streamlining how we work to deliver housing at speed. As I know our Council colleagues agree, government must work deliberately and rigorously, but added processes and unnecessary delay have real consequences. When an affordable apartment is delayed, it means a family spends another year doubled up with relatives, another year commuting long distances, another year without a stable home. When a project becomes more expensive to build, it means tenants pay more in rent. This does not even account for housing projects that never materialize to begin with. Through Mayor Mamdani's speed initiative, we are streamlining how housing proposals move through City government. Recent state reforms created a window for significant improvements and we are taking additional steps this fall to bring qualified housing projects through pre-certification in approximately six months, down from roughly two years. We have already worked hard to identify projects in our pipeline that meet the SEQR exemption and can reach public review faster. One recent project on Linden Place in Flushing, Queens, reached public review nearly an entire year earlier. These time savings do not simply affect project timelines. They (00:17:47) improve people's lives. Every home we can deliver faster is a New Yorker who gets into that home sooner. Third, we are working to make housing growth fairer and more equitable. This month, together with HPD, we released the inaugural Fair Housing Growth Strategy, a Council-mandated assessment of our housing shortage and a framework for meeting that need in a fair and equitable way. Fundamentally, the goal is for New Yorkers of all incomes and backgrounds to have more choices about where they live in the City. We are grateful to the Council for its leadership in establishing this important framework. That same vision underlies the Affordable Housing Fast Track, one of the new tools voters approved last year. The twelve fast-track districts we announced earlier this month represent roughly 20% of the City's districts but produced just 1% of the City's affordable housing over the last five years. We cannot solve a citywide housing crisis by relying on the same handful of neighborhoods. By helping affordable housing move forward where production has lagged, the fast track will expand housing choices, address entrenched patterns of unbalanced growth and help create a fairer, more affordable City. But housing is only one part of City Planning's agenda. Our team remains focused on supporting the 2030 census, modernizing the City map and address assignment system, planning for resilient waterfronts and thriving industrial and commercial areas, improving how we engage and support community boards and providing data and insights that can help guide decisions across City government. And of course, none of this work happens in isolation. When I appeared before you earlier, I said that I looked forward to a strong and collaborative relationship with the Council, and we know that meeting the needs of New Yorkers will require all of us working together. The affordability crisis remains profound, but over the last several months we have put new tools in place, launched ambitious planning efforts and are changing the way government works so that we can deliver more effectively. There is so much more work ahead and we look forward to continuing it all in partnership with (00:19:51) you. Thank you. I am happy to answer any questions. Thank you, Chair. (00:19:56) I am going to start with the first round of questions, then I am going to allow my colleagues to jump in. Okay, so the Block-by-Block... (00:20:03) Block stays that DCP will seek to use affordable housing fast track, proactively exploring City-sponsored land use actions in these districts. It is currently studying conditions in the 12 affected community districts to identify opportunities for upzoning that would produce new construction affordable housing. Thank you for your... (00:20:25) Question. So as noted, earlier this month we released the 12 affordable housing fast track communities. These are communities where we have seen affordable housing production lagging. We, along with our agency partners, are certainly assessing opportunities in those neighborhoods, whether we see opportunities for growth as well as opportunities for City-led housing initiatives such as housing that can be subsidized as well as some of our LIFT initiatives. (00:20:51) And so we are taking that look. The list was just produced earlier this month. The fast track goes into effect, and one of the things that we would like to do is also ensure that we are in conversation with those members so that we can be sure about the opportunities that are before us. Will DCP be releasing any public analysis on the fast track? (00:21:10) So the analysis that we released really is the housing production level. As you know, we have had conversations with Council Members recently around the fast track. We have no specific plans at this time for actions in those neighborhoods. We are literally assessing that as we speak, and anything that we would move forward with, we want to make sure that we are having conversations with Council Members in those affected districts first. And so we have started some of that review. I have had conversations to make sure that we understand what those opportunities are, but there is no additional analysis other than the methodology that we used to determine the fast... (00:21:44) ...track neighborhoods. So the administration plans to connect with Council Members, as you say that you already have been doing, and the community boards while doing this fast track? (00:21:53) Sure. So when we announced the fast track, we also gave notice to the Council Members. We also reached out to every community board in the City, including those that were unaffected. We have community board trainings happening right now going through the fall on a number of reforms, including the fast track. We also have a public information session in December to make sure that community boards are aware of the fast track. I have also reached out to Council Members individually and have offered to also come out to districts and understand what the opportunities are... (00:22:20) ...there. So with doing the rezoning in the specific districts, do you guys plan on partnering with agencies like the New York City Public Schools and Parks to address the development or the rezoning that you are trying to do in these... (00:22:35) ...communities? Sure. So I would say that there is a question about scale, right? Every fast tracked neighborhood is different. We have high density districts, mid density, low density districts. The types of City-led actions that can happen in these districts also range. Some offer opportunities for rezoning. Some may be more appropriate for affordable housing tools. Some may be appropriate for some of the other City-led housing initiatives that we are looking to promote. And so I think we are looking at every neighborhood in a unique way, and any City-led action that we have would certainly happen in concert with conversations with Council Members, affected community members, and where we were to pursue larger scale rezonings, for instance, in any of those neighborhoods, those were typically paired with the types of investments that go with large scale rezoning. But I would just note that many of the fast track neighborhoods are very unique, right? We have some very low density districts as well as high density districts. We really want to be thoughtful in the way that we are approaching those opportunities. (00:23:35) And glad to hear that. I just feel like a lot of members feel like the investment aspect is not really being talked about. All the focus is really on: we need to upzone, we need units. And a lot of members have specific concerns within those communities that need investments. So what can I guess be done better with communicating with members that you guys will be prioritizing doing full planning in those areas that you guys are focusing on, instead of just looking at unit count and density and just upzoning it? (00:24:05) Absolutely. So I will just take a step back. Capital planning is an exercise that happens across the City routinely, right. The vast majority of housing that is being developed in our City is happening as of right. Neighborhoods are constantly changing. It is important that the City is constantly understanding its capital needs, status of repair, and that is ongoing. As we start to pursue any City-led actions in the communities, we are also in conversation with our capital agencies to understand the infrastructure needs and planned investments, as well as making sure that they understand the communities that are prioritized for affordable housing as we start to assess those opportunities. If we were to pursue a larger scale rezoning, for instance, in one of those communities, we would certainly pair... (00:24:48) ...that with any investment that is needed to mitigate issues that have emerged in our environmental impact study. The types of... (00:24:55) ...what is a large scale? Can you say for the record what would be considered... (00:24:58) ...considered? There is a range. I mean, in the last administration, a typical neighborhood rezoning was anywhere from 1000 to 4000 new units of housing. But we also have examples like Bronx Metro-North, which was 7000 units right along the corridor, or Atlantic Avenue, which was around 5000. So there is a range depending on the study... (00:25:17) ...area. But each of those projects came with investments that were aligned with the level of growth. (00:25:23) Okay. The City Council's Planning and Land Use Division has offered to work with Council Members in the fast track areas to understand development potential. In some cases, Council Members and community boards decide to propose ideas for neighborhood rezonings as a preferred way to add new development alongside community engagement and City investment in infrastructure and services. Is DCP open to working collaboratively with Council Members and communities on this... (00:25:49) ...approach? Yes, we welcome that. And I know that Council Member Hanks, as well as a number of other Council Members, have started to look at those types of opportunities as well as opportunities in their community. So we look forward to that. We look forward to learning more details and we are happy to work proactively... (00:26:05) ...together. In addition to potential City-led rezonings, it is also expected that the affordable housing fast track will lead to many private developer applications for which the City Planning Commission will now be the final vote in the ULURP process. Tough issues are usually resolved by the City Council in negotiation with the applicant on a final agreement. These agreements might include modifications and commitments for local investment or other community benefits. For fast track applications, will the City Planning Commission have the capacity and resources to engage on these issues? (00:26:43) Absolutely. So when an application is moving through ULURP, long before it reaches the City Planning Commission, at the department level we are also ensuring, to the extent that environmental impact review is required, that that is completed. We are identifying whether there is a need for mitigation. The City Planning Commission has that information available as they start to review the proposal. There are certainly times in City Planning Commission hearings where we have brought up mitigation that has been identified and aimed to ensure that the developer is committing to that. The City Planning Commission also has the ability to recommend modifications. That is an option, for instance, that typically we have deferred to the City Council on in those types of decisions. But when we are the final vote in some of the fast track cases, those are the types of modifications we certainly can discuss, recommend and make as part of our final report. (00:27:34) I envision that we, in my role as department director in particular, will remain in close conversation with the Council. And as you are well aware, a lot of the engagement around projects happens well before the formal public review process, where developers are already engaging community, Council Members and stakeholders around priorities, so that by the time they reach the Commission, there have been lots of modifications to applications, usually before they get to the Commission level. (00:28:01) But you still commit to engaging with Council Members too? (00:28:05) Within the commitments? Sure, absolutely. And again at the department level as well. (00:28:10) We certainly will ensure that we continue to engage with you all with the changes. (00:28:12) Speaker, many private applications will skip environmental review. Without environmental review, how would we be informed on whether there is sufficient open space, sewer capacity, school seats, pre-K availability, public transportation access and other infrastructure to support development? (00:28:34) Thank you for your question. So there is a subset based on recent passage at the state level, which is really exempting projects that are relatively modest — 250 units in low to mid density districts, 500 in higher density districts. This exemption really came from a 10-year analysis that showed us that across all of these projects, less than 1% produced an environmental impact. And so these were projects that were previously held in about two years of review where there was no impact produced, which obviously is adding time and costs. Based on our analysis, we saw that it added over $80,000 in additional costs per unit. And so we will certainly continue to move those projects forward as they are exempt from SEQRA, but they are still subject to land... (00:29:24) ...use review, right. That does not change. The ULURP process does not change either. And so questions about high density bulk, all of the relations of the neighborhood public realm — those questions will still come up and are part of our land use review process. What has changed, however, is the SEQRA process, which again, based on 10 years of analysis, was not producing an impact or requiring mitigation. (00:29:48) But on average, Chair, we do not really see those types of projects come to the committee. You do not really see the 250 to 500 unit projects a lot. You really see smaller projects coming to the committee. So I just wanted to confirm that even though it is going to skip SEQRA, you are still going to have that same conversation with members to... (00:30:07) ...figure out what type of commitments. But these are technically kind of larger projects than we are used to seeing within the land use committee. Absolutely. And I will note that there are projects that are exempt from SEQRA but are still subject to the traditional ULURP process. So if those projects are in districts outside of the 12 fast track districts, they are still going to City Council for final approval. The projects that are in the fast track districts would be the ones that are going through this expedited process. Okay. (00:30:46) Going to go to another set of questions. So since 2000, neighborhood planning rezonings have been one of the primary tools — we are doing one in my district right now — to add housing development capacity along with infrastructure and community investment to support growth. Over the last decade, neighborhood rezonings have enabled nearly 80,000 additional housing units. DCP is currently only undertaking two neighborhood plans: one in my district and one south of Prospect Park, as compared to the five neighborhood rezonings during the prior term. Is DCP actively looking to add more neighborhood rezonings to the pipeline, and does the administration have a goal as to the number of neighborhood rezonings it is seeking to accomplish? And within that, has it set aside capital funding for those... (00:31:34) ...rezonings? Thank you for your question, and again, thank you for your partnership on White Plains Road. I know that there has been a lot of work going into that plan in particular. So we announced our first two neighborhood plans early in this administration. They are the first two but certainly not the last. We will continue to move forward neighborhood plans. We are also looking at other opportunities relative to the fast track neighborhoods that may be more modest than our traditional neighborhood plans, based on the scale of those communities. But we know neighborhood plans are essential to really unlocking housing opportunity, but also ensuring that we are bringing economic investment, supporting job creation, making sure that we have livable neighborhoods that have been informed by community input. So there is a commitment to neighborhood... (00:32:18) ...planning, absolutely, in this administration. And as we refine our plans, we would be excited to share more neighborhoods that we would like to focus on. With regard to your question on capital improvement: all of our neighborhood plans, whether in the last administration or this administration, have been paired with significant investment. And that is typically investment that emerges through our environmental impact study, where we are identifying where there is a need for capital or other investments to mitigate issues, or to, for instance, bring about new school seats. There is also a scenario in which we are looking to accelerate existing planned work based on the housing growth that we project, as well as investments tied to what we heard from the community, whether it is street improvement or public realm, as well as services and opportunities. And so that will certainly be part of the White Plains Road plan, the South Prospect plan, and any other neighborhood plan that we move forward. (00:33:14) The Block-by-Block report also proposes micro plans, a new concept of publicly led planning actions that are smaller than neighborhood rezonings. What exactly is a micro plan, and would it involve community engagement and planning investments like a neighborhood... (00:33:28) ...rezoning? Thank you for your question. So what we are really talking about is just a difference in planning approach. Typically, as I mentioned earlier, we pursued large scale neighborhood plans, which we will continue to do. We have new tools at our disposal, such as ALUR, which is an expedited land use review process. We have SEQRA reform, which can allow the agency to potentially move in a way that is more flexible and more nimble for small scale rezoning opportunities that can be a catalyst for a community, that can help activate and unlock sites that can be suitable for housing. Any City-led action will absolutely include engagement with communities... (00:34:04) ...and investment that is appropriate to the scale of the... (00:34:06) ...action. But what if there are multiple small projects in a single area? What is the approach you would take for that? So we have not identified plans right now. We have been focused on larger plans. I think as we get to a place where we are looking at smaller scale plans, we would certainly see what those plans mean in the aggregate and whether they are actually a larger plan. But in all of those scenarios, we would still again identify opportunities for investment and make sure that we are engaging the local Council Member and the community. (00:34:36) Do you foresee the micro plans taking advantage of the SEQRA... (00:34:41) ...exemptions? So yeah. And I would just again say a plan is a plan regardless of the size. If we have a plan that is at the scale of a SEQRA exemption, that would allow us to move it along more quickly, but again, it does not change the land use review process. We would still need to go through all the steps of ULURP. Okay, I am going to pause. I am just going to allow my colleagues to ask some questions. We are going to do rounds. I am going to allow members to have three minutes for the first round and then we are going to do a second round. (00:35:13) Okay, we are going to begin first with Chair Louis, followed by Chair Marte, then... (00:35:21) Thank you, Chair Riley. It is good to see you. Three quick questions. You mentioned in your development of the City's transit-oriented development initiative, and I wanted to ask a question around the Interborough Express. Given that the IBX is planning for communities in central Brooklyn, including districts like mine, the 45th, that will be affected by the arrival of this new transit line, thank you... (00:35:52) ...for your question, Council Member. And thank you for your partnership on the South Prospect plan. Transit-oriented development is certainly a cornerstone of Block-by-Block. It offers a tremendous opportunity to focus on developing housing, developing affordable housing, and bringing New Yorkers closer to transit. We have over 650 transit stations in our City, believe it or not. In some areas of our City, we still see outdated zoning where the zoning is really not matching the potential that the transit offers. (00:36:20) So with respect to our first neighborhood plans, the South Prospect plan, which we know will intersect... (00:36:23) With the future line, we affected that into how we are planning in that community, and by design the line, the nodes, right, connect to our existing transit system. So there is a lot of opportunity for us to think about, as we plan for growth around our existing transit system, how that also can set the stage for future lines. In the last administration there was planning around the future stations of the Bronx Metro-North, and we know that the timeline for that has shifted, but planning is for the long term. So we are looking at this work very much in the long term and making sure... (00:37:00) ...that we are at least unlocking the zoning tools that we need to ensure that as those stations emerge, we have planned for the growth and the vitality that is needed, starting in South Prospect. Got it. Public engagement has... (00:37:13) ...begun on the South Prospect neighborhood plan, thanks to your team, which is close to the alignment. In the context of this plan, we have begun thinking about where housing would go around projected stations. We are still in the very early stages, particularly in developing our overall transit-oriented development proposal, but also with South Prospect. (00:37:37) So as you know, we had our... (00:37:38) ...kickoff meeting last month. We had a really great turnout. We have already had 2,000 residents participate in our survey. We have some walkshops coming up this week as well, and so we have not yet started to project where housing will go or what potential zoning framework is in that district. We want to make sure that we are hearing from the community. We certainly are hearing housing as a priority, street safety as a priority, public spaces as a priority, and so we are factoring all of that into the plans moving forward. Thank you. (00:38:04) And how will — and I think CM Riley alluded to this earlier — but how will the administration approach private developers' applications who will use the future ideas as a rationale for their... (00:38:17) ...plans? That is a great question. I think every time we receive a private application we are looking at the land use rationale relative to the surrounding context. We know that certainly locating housing near transit is essential. It is a climate-friendly development, it supports more housing, and so to the extent that applicants are looking to maximize transit opportunities, we certainly welcome that. But we would obviously treat any application with the same scrutiny and expect environmental review and land use review. Those are certainly factors where there is connectivity — transit is important, right? (00:38:54) Thank you so much. Thank you, Chair Marte. Thank you for being here, and thank you, CM Riley, for crossing the... Setting the hearing on the Block-by-Block Plan. A hundred Gold is mentioned... (00:39:02) ...in the Block-by-Block Plan. However, what is not mentioned as part of the plan is there is only a text amendment associated with the ULURP, which will allow an R30 in the whole Special Lower Manhattan District. My fear is that you are allowing unprecedented development — and I will give my colleagues here context, most people do not even have an R8 in their district — but an R30 will allow, like what is being proposed at 100 Gold, which will allow 4,000 units in probably the biggest building in Lower Manhattan. Allowing that to be mapped all throughout Lower Manhattan without having a proper discourse with other stakeholders in the community makes it seem like two things. One, you are using... (00:39:52) ...100 Gold as a Trojan horse to map the rest of the neighborhood, and two, there is not going to be an adequate discussion of infrastructure, school seats, or anything else, because you are using it as a segmentation — trying to do one thing at a time so then it does not seem like a big proposal. I know the response is going to be: well, the developers, whether it is the City or private, will have to go through individual rezonings because nothing is mapped R12 in this community. But if you put the cart before the horse, it might allow you to say there is not going to be adverse damage to this community because you are going to be looking at isolated individual applications. So my recommendation is to separate that whole text amendment from 100 Gold. We can have that discussion and figure out a plan for that site. But what I fear is that you are actually not doing planning for my community, you are not thinking about the infrastructure for my community by going down this route. So I can jump in there... (00:40:53) ...and thank you, CM, and I recognize your concerns. Obviously with the lifting of the cap it is certainly creating a new Manhattan skyline, a new City skyline, creating an opportunity to build in ways that we have not before to really meet our housing crisis. There is a really tremendous opportunity at 100 Gold to create affordable housing in a neighborhood that, as you know, is very well connected to transit and other resources. I think we certainly take your note of the text amendment and the actual action, both of which would require public review. I do not have before me actually where the status of both of those is. I do not know if we have that, but we can certainly follow up with you on that. We want to make sure that as that project moves forward, or any project in the R12 or R30 or any future district, particularly as we start to see these new districts emerge, that we are completing a study and understanding the community needs. I would ask that you just do it as a separate application. There are going to be a lot of stakeholders that are not aware that you are even mapping an R30. I feel like that is really disrespectful to our community. I understand, Counselor. My colleague will also be able to provide more detail. Yes, sure. (00:42:14) Any future application... the future application... (00:42:17) ...of an R30 would have to go through a separate rezoning before this body, before City Council. And then with respect... (00:42:25) ...to where we are in the public process for 100 Gold, a scoping hearing will be held on October 29, very soon. (00:42:33) I completely understand that, but any future application can only be a spot rezoning, right? It does not have to take into account the adverse impact of allowing this building, which includes parts of the Seaport and parts of Lower Manhattan. I think this is a way to get away from actually thinking about what are some of the worst-case scenarios and how it is going to have adverse impact on our community, on our commercial businesses and on our infrastructure. Thank you. (00:43:04) Thank you, Chair. Next we are going to hear from Council Member... (00:43:09) Thank you so much. This is a moment where I appreciate that housing is split among so many committees because there is just so much to talk about. So I am going to ask all my questions in succession. First, thank you for meeting with us — the land use team and our committee — and taking some of our recommendations into consideration between the draft and final reports of the Fair Housing Growth Strategy. I am glad to see that access to transit, entitled flooding vulnerability have now been factored into the community district targets, but other factors specified in our local laws were not included. Why did the administration not include specific long-term needs for affordable, deeply affordable and formerly homeless units? The draft and final plans speak only to the administration's commitment but do not fully encompass the housing needs of New Yorkers. Establishing the long-term need disaggregated by housing type is a clear requirement in local law. Second, in some neighborhoods — channeling CM Brewer — generating new construction of affordable housing at scale will only be possible with demolition of existing rent-stabilized units or other existing properties. Has the administration considered this in setting new construction targets? Third, how did the administration arrive at a citywide target of 25% affordable housing with only 7.3% at a deeply affordable level? And finally, the Block-by-Block Housing Plan proposes a new planning initiative called the Spotlight on the Bronx, an intensive planning process to coordinate proactive government actions in Community Districts 1, 3, 4, 5, 7 and 8, where the City has financed tens of thousands of units of affordable housing but planning for complete neighborhoods has lagged behind. Can you provide us with a status update on whether the process has started, how you are planning to engage community boards and local elected officials, and do you have specific areas of the Bronx where you are going to be addressing quality-of-life barriers like improved sanitation and public space? And finally, is there going to be a coordinated package of capital improvements for these areas engaging partner agencies? Thank you, Chair. (00:45:23) I am just going to ask — some people cannot hear you online, so if you could just talk a little bit more into the mic? (00:45:30) Sure. Okay. So thank you for your questions, Council Member. I will kick things off and then I will turn over to my colleague. I want to thank the Council for your leadership in creating the Fair Housing Growth Strategy and requiring it. It really requires the City to complete an assessment of the housing need that we have and really sets a goal for us to achieve. A lot of the work that we plan to accomplish through Block-by-Block starts to get us there, with a commitment of building over 200,000 new affordable units. The number of strategies that we have outlined in the plan speak to that level of implementation. Before I turn to my colleague to speak a little bit more about the methodology, I do want to address your question regarding the zoning and the potential for displacement. This is a very important question. As we are looking for opportunities for rezoning, we are certainly very sensitive to ensuring that we are not disrupting existing housing, and particularly rent-stabilized housing and deeply affordable housing that exists. We know that there are a number of laws at the state level that make it very difficult to unilaterally demolish rent-stabilized housing in our City. In addition to those protections, a lot of the tenant protection work that has been happening in this administration has also been built to ensure that we are bolstering that. As we are looking at opportunities, particularly in neighborhoods that are dense where we know development is happening, we are trying to find opportunities to use tools such as really pairing affordable housing requirements with development activity that is happening there, as well as opportunities for office-to-residential conversion, and tools that the City has through its task force and other subsidy tools that can be utilized in some of the development that is happening. Ensuring that we are approaching our planning and our rezoning efforts with a clear eye towards tenant protection is important, and that is certainly captured in the Block-by-Block plan too — two very important strategies that go hand in hand. I will turn it over to... (00:47:22) ...you, Michael, on the methodology. Thank you. So just on the affordable... (00:47:30) ...need, the team really dug in on the methodology that was outlined in the legislation and tried to meet the letter and the spirit of this Bill to create a citywide framework for what the City's need is in terms of creating housing and how that need should be distributed across the 59 community districts when projecting out 10 years. We sought to have methodological rigor and numbers that we could stand behind and that felt defensible. In the needs analysis you will see we used population data. We looked at who is already here in our City that does not have housing, what type of housing is needed and how much housing is needed to meet that need, and then also what type of population growth we are expecting from births, deaths, in-migration and out-migration. In terms of looking at the affordable need, it is very difficult to predict affordable need given the incredibly constrained environment that we have right now in New York City. We see that affordable levels are determined in affordable housing in New York City based around market rent, and so eligibility for affordable housing is based around the City's fair market rent. Who needs and who qualifies for affordable housing is very circularly dependent on the availability of housing generally and what housing costs in the open market. So we felt that it is very hard to know what the affordable housing need would be in 10 years if the broader housing growth has been met. It is very difficult to predict. We felt that what made the most sense to share with New Yorkers is what we are committed to do on affordable housing, and we know that there is a very incredible need right now. The Mayor's Block-by-Block Housing Plan has incredibly ambitious targets for affordable housing, greater than we have ever done before. So we are pacing around what our north star for affordable housing is, based around those targets in the housing plan. On your question about why the citywide target for affordable housing is 25%: the Fair Housing Growth Strategy target comes directly from the Mayor's Housing Plan. So unlike the broader overall housing growth projections, the affordable targets are what we are budgeting for, what we are planning for and what we want to hit. Those targets come directly from the housing plan, and 25% is really a function of what percent those targets are of the overall housing production we are targeting for the City. In terms of the deeply affordable target, again those come from our budgeted projections through the housing plan. We create affordable housing through a mix of as-of-right programs that have affordability levels set by those programs, and then on the housing that we finance, 50% of that housing is for extremely low and very low incomes. On Spotlight on the Bronx, we are very excited to be kicking this off and focusing on quality of life and health in the South Bronx and the North Bronx. I am happy to also note that we are going to add additional community districts to that list, which share many of the characteristics of the other communities. (00:50:49) We have started conversations with our interagency partners. We do see core partners at the Department of Health. We are really focusing on healthy homes and how the housing stock in this community is impacting economic outcomes and health. We are also working closely with the Mayor's Office to Protect Tenants, the Mayor's Office of Community Safety and the New York City Housing Authority. We have started scoping out what this looks like, but really what we want to do is focus on not creating new units, but creating quality of life. So we are going to be focused on conditions inside of homes, combining enforcement and investments in healthy homes. Then we are going to be focused on public spaces, especially public spaces around existing affordable housing — broadly, that is supported affordable housing or rent-stabilized housing. There are large concentrations of this housing stock in these community districts, and what we hear from residents of these buildings that we have supported through our programs is that the quality of life they are receiving after moving into affordable housing is lagging. So we want to focus on public space maintenance, public space safety and community safety around affordable housing assets. We will be working with the various agencies, community partners and landlords to achieve that, and we want to start kicking off community board conversations and community conversations, hopefully later this year. (00:52:10) Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, CM. (00:52:14) We are going to go to CM Carr, followed by Thomas-Henry and Brooks-Powers. Just one second, CM Carr. Just to add on to Chair Marte — I think what he is alluding to is how much is projected for 100 Gold Street: 4,000 units. Before 2021, I think besides going in, we have not achieved 4,000 units in a neighborhood plan. I think he is flagging it as a spot zone and then wants to talk about a more comprehensive plan in the area, and I think that kind of speaks to what we are trying to get at today, which is that the focus should not just be on the unit count within the area, but a more comprehensive plan in the area. Because putting 4,000 people there and not making sure that you are investing in the total community and listening to all stakeholders in the community is doing a tremendous disservice to New Yorkers. So I just wanted to pinpoint that to you, Chair. Next we are going to hear from Minority Leader, CM Carr, followed by Thomas-Henry, Brooks-Powers, then Banks. And we have been joined by Council Member... (00:53:22) Thank you, Chair Riley, for hosting this very important hearing. Madam Chair, thank you for being with us today. I am very concerned, and so are the many people I represent, with respect to the new approach under the plan where now the Council no longer has a role in negotiating the finer final details of a plan. It is, you know, selectively applied, and I was wondering about the intention of the revision. So now some members continue to have this role and others do not. In my own district, there are actually five community districts and three of them are going to be subject to the bottom 12 fast-tracking, and the other two are not. I am just curious to know from your perspective, with this new responsibility where you are going to be negotiating the final details of these projects as they come, what is going to be the approach to infrastructure the Chair was talking about earlier? How are you going to make that assessment? You were asked earlier about what you are looking at in terms of these 12 community districts in terms of housing opportunities. (00:54:23) Alongside that, are you doing infrastructure studies to determine what is needed based on the expected anticipated growth of the rezonings that you are going to be pursuing in conjunction with private parties? Who are you going to be essentially giving this task to within the department? Is it going to be the borough directors? Is it going to be held more centrally at the department with the Commission? Is it going to be certain commissioners who kind of take a more forward role in this? I would like to know what the structure is going to be as that happens, and then how are you going to incorporate local input, whether that is from members of the community board or members of the public? Because I think the concern is... (00:55:02) ...that once this system is really put into effect, that any consultation is just going to be pro forma. I think that that would be, you know, again, a disservice — a word that was used earlier — a disservice to the communities represented if that turned out to be the case. (00:55:18) Thank you, CM. I would note that as projects are potentially proposed in the fast-track districts, we will treat them the same way we do projects today. If an environmental review is required, we are ensuring that happens. If there is any mitigation needed, we are making sure that that is happening. There is still community board review, borough president review, as well as public testimony at the City Planning Commission. There is also department-level work that happens during the pre-certification process as well, which leads to lots of proposal refinement. Developers typically are refining proposals long before they reach the City Planning Commission. With respect to capital planning and capital needs, as I shared before, that really is an ongoing process. There is the overarching need for the City to ensure that we are strategically planning on capital resources. One priority that I have had since being in this role is ensuring that planning has an even stronger role in the capital planning process so that we are aligning our resources along with where we see growth opportunities happening, and that is certainly in these fast-track districts. But there is also capital investment that can be tied to City-led actions and larger-scale planning initiatives, to the extent that those would be pursued in your district. I want to assure you that as these projects move through, there is close attention to community feedback and capital needs so that we can make sure we understand your priorities. The last point I would flag is that, as I shared earlier, at the City Planning Commission we do have the ability to certainly recommend modifications to applications before we approve them, such as changes to affordability levels, for instance. Typically when we receive changes back at the City Planning Commission for final approval from the City Council, we see those changes as well. We often are not getting infrastructure changes back necessarily, but certainly changes around land use and affordability levels, and those are all things that the City Planning Commission can consider as well. I want to assure you that we will give the time, the attention and the thought that is necessary to ensure that these projects are a net benefit to the community. (00:57:37) I have to turn this back to the Chair, but I would just say that you talked about the refinements that already occur in the ULURP process, but typically speaking what I am talking about is not part of that. If it comes back to us to kind of add that to the table because the administration of the day, whoever it may be, has not put that forward, generally speaking, members have forced the administration to do that through the leverage that we have had in the ULURP process — a leverage many of us will no longer have. So I am glad that you are envisioning a greater role in the capital planning process because traditionally your role has just been more of a department of zoning than a department of planning, respectfully. I just feel like there is no one in this process that will now have the tools to bring the investment that is needed to go along with the project. (00:58:25) Chair, thank you. I would just add briefly, CM Carr, that you also asked where this sits within the department. We certainly have our borough teams who are excellent and work with developers, partners and community groups every day around planning needs across their boroughs. We also have a centralized team that is focused on capital. We also have a centralized team that is focused on climate and resiliency that works across and in coordination with our capital planning agencies. All of these agencies and departments will certainly have a role in how we consider these applications, as well as making sure the interagency coordination is happening. (00:59:00) Okay, thank you. I hope you are proactive with this new responsibility. Thank you. Absolutely, we will be. (00:59:04) Thank you. Next, we will hear from CM Thomas-Henry, followed by CM Brooks-Powers. (00:59:10) Thank you. You have been very responsive and very effective with ideas, especially as relates to projects in my area, so I am very thankful for that. Kind of piggybacking off of the minority leader's comments, is there a way for you to put something together — be it a checklist — going back to some of the things that we as Council members on the floor identified during certain projects? I have had real-world experience where no matter how many agencies you have look at something on paper, it is different when you are on the ground. I have had land use experts come in and see a project that was zoned for one thing and get there and it is like, oh my God, this cannot happen here. So it is very different when you are live and in person. Although you have been great, the next person after you may not be so amenable to the ideas of the Council member. So is there a way to make, as part of this process, a checklist of things? Even when we are looking at MIH, options one and two do not necessarily fit the income requirements of my particular district, and that is one of the things that we look at when we are reviewing ULURPs. I am going to address it all at once. I have homeownership opportunities. I have a high homeowner population of single-family homes as well as co-ops. Will that be taken into consideration so that we are not just building more and more affordable units in these communities, but keeping the continuity of community in place where you have long-term growth and opportunity? We are looking at 200,000 affordable units towards 700,000 total units over the decade. How many units are currently approved in the pipeline? We are continuing to approve — how many are in the pipeline to be built against this 200,000 to 700,000 unit goal? Last but not least, if you are looking for opportunities, we have Willets Point and an additional 40 acres that are available for affordable housing. Thank you. (01:01:07) CM, thank you for your partnership and the ideas you have shared, including Willets Point. I appreciate that recommendation and will certainly take it into consideration. I want to make sure that we are listening to Council members. We can think about a way to make that more routine or more systematic, but certainly appreciate that recommendation. With respect to homeownership, absolutely. When we are talking about creating affordable housing opportunities in the fast-track districts, we are talking about everything — whether it is through zoning, whether it is through affordable housing tools, which include the Block-by-Block Housing Plan and expansion of the City's affordable homeownership programs, as well as other opportunities that can be leveraged to facilitate affordable housing. We are looking to deploy all those tools in ways that make sense in those fast-track districts. Again, I appreciate your insight and your recommendations around that. And then to your last question, I know that there are ongoing conversations and efforts around that, and I certainly look forward to continuing those discussions. (01:02:13) And do you know how many approved projects are in the... (01:02:16) ...pipeline? I do not have a handle on everything that is in the pipeline for approval. We certainly can get that for you, but I would just note that, as I mentioned earlier, the vast majority of... (01:02:27) ...housing that is being produced in the City is also happening as-of-right. There is housing that never comes before the Commission, and this is why the point that I raised around us also being a planning agency that has a demography team is important — let us focus on New York City's growth overall. I am working more closely with our capital agencies to anticipate needs even for growth that is not necessarily being facilitated through zoning. But we can certainly get that for you. I know in our analysis of the fast-track neighborhoods we certainly have what was produced in the last year. We can share that and then give you a sense of what we understand right now from permitted housing approvals. (01:03:07) Thank you. We are going to hear from CM Brooks-Powers, but just to add on to what CM Thomas-Henry was saying about Willets Point — I did do a tour there, I think in probably 2008 when this was first spoken about. I think they projected roughly about 5,000 to 6,000 units of housing, and then the last administration said about 2,500 to some thousand. You have a Council member here who will want to activate the other side of Willets Point, given how many years it took us to get to that point. So I would just encourage having that conversation with CM Thomas-Henry because she is very adamant about addressing the housing needs and revitalizing that area. Next we will hear from CM Brooks-Powers, followed by CM Banks and CM Encarnación, and then our majority whip. (01:03:59) Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Chair Sherman, for, as my colleagues have said, your openness and willingness to communicate with this body. I had an opportunity to talk to you in advance of the recent announcement as well as our more recent Zoom meeting, but I wanted to ask some questions on the record, just to have them here in a public space. So, starting with housing applications in Queens, Community District 13 will no longer come before this Council. Rosedale, Laurelton and Springfield Gardens are some of the lowest-lying parts of the City, surrounded by wetlands, and residents are routinely faced with the threat of flooding. How will the fast-track review consider these needs in a flood-prone community? I know I mentioned this when we last spoke, but I just wanted to have it on the record in terms of a response. (01:05:00) And what if it is found that the construction taking place creates additional flooding to neighboring homes — what say will the community have at that point? I am also noting that the fast-track list is drawn on community district lines, and Southeast Queens, as I often say, is made up of communities across multiple districts. Together we have built a significant amount of affordable housing. When City-led actions occur in the 13th community district, will it account for what the surrounding neighborhoods have already absorbed, even though they fall in another community district? For example, Community District 14 did a significant amount, but it is an abutting community district to 13, and on the other side is Community Board 12, which just did the Jamaica downtown upzoning in downtown Jamaica. With all of that taking place, it will just create an overwhelming increase in population in a community that has infrastructure and resiliency issues and challenges. Recognizing that the environmental review process will not be the environmental review process that we have been accustomed to, and that Council members will not have as much of a say in terms of shaping it based on our local knowledge of the community — that is what the concern is. Obviously I am not opposed to development, but it has to be responsible, and communities like this have underlying conditions that could impact what that looks like in terms of the health and well-being of the community. Thank you. (01:06:47) CM, thank you for raising these issues. I have familiarity with your district and particularly the flooding issues that you have shared, and we are already well aware of this. Again, it is a priority as we start to have conversations with the capital agencies about growth in these neighborhoods, so that as we are leading any City-led actions we are being attentive to the underlying infrastructure needs and the most appropriate places for that within your district. I would also just note that the affordable housing fast track was created through rates of housing production, not a pure ranking. Production looks relatively modest in certain parts of your district relative to the overall rate being produced, but it still ultimately creates a higher rate of production based on the housing dynamics in your neighborhood. While this is a uniform methodology, it does account for the fact that every community is different, and that is built into the way it was calculated. Again, I know that we will be out to your district soon, but I certainly want to take a nuanced look with you about where there could be opportunities and the types of affordable housing tools that make sense for that part of Queens. We also recognize that at the end of the last administration we completed a really large neighborhood plan in Jamaica. We are really excited about that and excited to see the impact of it, and so there is a lot of opportunity already through that. We want to figure out how we pair that with growth in other parts of your district. (01:08:30) And I will turn to my colleague... (01:08:33) Go ahead. I just wanted to add that in many cases new construction housing can be a positive contributor to a neighborhood's needs. New housing that gets constructed has to meet much higher standards for resiliency. It has to be built up above the City's flood elevation. Through the unified stormwater review, new housing construction typically comes with on-site retention of all stormwater that falls on that site. So in a lot of neighborhoods where you might have a surface parking lot, when it rains today that water is flowing out into all of the neighboring sites. With new housing, that is an opportunity to retain that stormwater. (01:09:11) These are important conversations to think about and how they fit together. I appreciate that, but that has not been the case in some of the construction — not only just housing, but just infrastructure and new developments. We have a new Amazon facility that has been here about four years now in Rosedale. The area did not have flooding before, but now there is significant flooding. There are other housing developments in the community and infrastructure projects that have happened even in Rockaway and the Arverne area that have pitched the streets wrong. While the infrastructure has been intended, to your point, to pull the stormwater and reduce what previously existed, it has created flooding in areas where it did not exist before. So it has kind of shifted the problem. Now, in my last two questions before I run out of time: will this Commission respond in writing to the community board and Council member recommendations on an application? And how many affordable units in Community District 13 were approved over the last five years but are still waiting on financing or a construction start? I am wondering if approved but unbuilt housing also counts towards this list. (01:10:26) CM, you could come back for a round two of... (01:10:29) ...questions. Okay, I did not know — I did not hear the buzzer. So thank... (01:10:33) ...you. But you can — you can — you can... (01:10:35) ...answer questions right now. So I certainly can follow up on how we will respond to community board and City Council recommendations. (01:10:46) Sometimes there are ways to do so, for sure. And I think the second question — yes, there are certainly a number of projects citywide that are waiting for financing. We have more projects in our pipeline than we have resources to finance in any given year, but there are new resources that have been added to our budget through the housing plan. I do not have the data in front of me about Community District 13, but I am happy to follow up. (01:11:14) Thank you. Next, we will hear... (01:11:16) CM Banks, Encarnación and... thank you. The Block-by-Block Housing Plan references partnerships with NYCHA to expand housing opportunities and to generate revenue for public housing residents. However, the plan provides few details about how these goals will be achieved. Can the administration clarify what specific strategies are under consideration, including infill development, utilization of NYCHA land, the transfer of air rights, public-private partnerships or any mechanisms that have not yet been disclosed to the Council? (01:12:03) I can speak to this at a high level. I know in the Block-by-Block Plan, Mayor Mamdani has made one of the most significant — I think the largest — capital investment in NYCHA that we have seen from the City, which is really exciting. NYCHA is obviously continuing to pursue a number of development opportunities that are meant to bring capital dollars in and to shore up their existing housing stock as well as contribute to our housing goals. To the extent that NYCHA is pursuing transfer of development rights, we stand ready to partner with NYCHA to achieve their goals. There is not an active proposal at this time. We work very closely with NYCHA. Our housing team is in regular communication with the Authority, and so if proposals or ideas move forward, we certainly stand ready to partner with them. (01:12:46) But specifically when it comes to infill, the City has previously pursued infill development on NYCHA properties and other underutilized sites. Can the administration provide a breakdown of how many infill developments currently exist on NYCHA property, how much revenue those developments have generated to date and how those funds have been used to benefit NYCHA residents? (01:13:11) Thank you for that question. That is information we would certainly have to get back to you from NYCHA. We are happy to follow up on that. Typically the actions that NYCHA pursues within their campus do not come before HPD for approval, for instance, and so we can certainly make sure that we follow up with you, Councilmember, and with the Committee, with those details. (01:13:38) And I want to cover the topic of transit-oriented development. The administration believes that transit-oriented development is a key component of the Block-by-Block Housing Plan. What criteria is the administration using to determine where density should be allowed near transit? And how can residents be assured that transit-oriented development will not result in overdevelopment of outer borough neighborhoods or place a disproportionate burden on those communities? (01:14:13) Great question. Thank you, Councilmember. So we are taking really a citywide look at transit-oriented development. This is essential to how we grow as a City and also growing in a way that is climate friendly. It also is essential for our housing goals to create more opportunity for New Yorkers to live near transit. We are assessing the opportunity across our transit corridors — all 600-plus miles of it — relative to the zoning that currently exists along those corridors to really understand the potential, and look forward to sharing a more robust proposal. But we are in the early days of that exploration. We know that in City of Yes, we created the Qualifying Residential Areas, which allowed for really legalizing some of the missing middle housing near transit, and so that was an approach to maximize transit in some of our low and mid-density districts. We are looking at a similar approach potentially in larger density areas, but we are still in the early days and we will make sure to have conversations with the Council as we start to move that forward. Thank you. (01:15:20) Thank you, Councilmember. Thank you. And thank you for working on my last name. (01:15:27) Chair, good, good, good. And I am going to apologize in advance — you have two public housing people back to back, so I know that most of those questions I will ask in the public housing hearing. But I did want to know: when a development is identified for infill, or any kind of revenue that comes from selling of that development land or air rights — or whatever is being sold — how and who determines the value of that? Is that NYCHA determining the value? Does anyone in the City play a role in the valuation of that land, and what revenue do we get from that? (01:16:06) Sure. I can speak to this at a high level. HPD does not have a direct role in that. Obviously NYCHA is core to providing affordable housing in our City, and I spent over a decade of my career at NYCHA — very, very close to my heart and the work that we do. I understand that when NYCHA pursues those projects they work to negotiate the best deal possible to ensure that residents have permanent affordability and that their buildings are brought to a state of good repair. We are certainly happy to bring responses back to you. (01:16:35) And I want to see — is there a meeting with NYCHA that you guys do not have? I just want to make sure that we will get a correct response. And then, when you talk about this partnership, are you in partnership with NYCHA on how and when that revenue will be spent, or where it will be spent? Is there also a role for HPD in that process? (01:16:55) And I think, you know, to the extent that there are mixed-use projects, sometimes there is a partnership. But we can certainly coordinate with our colleagues at NYCHA and make sure to get a (01:17:04) response. And then I just have really two statements. I have some really serious concerns about the quality of the buildings and the developments that are happening at this fast pace. It seems like we are in a race to build fast and sometimes cheaply. Often we are the ones here in the Council that are fighting for wage and union standards when we are looking at buildings and developments coming into our districts, and without those we face, quite frankly, some developments that we are already receiving complaints from in brand new buildings — roof leaks, elevators that are not working — in these brand new developments that are coming to the district. We are fielding real conversations with our constituents about the quality of buildings that do not have all of these other standards attached to them. So I just want to make a real plug for the fact that if our voices are out of that conversation when we are really fighting for those standards, we need a commitment from the administration that you will also be fighting for those wage standards and that union-built construction that will allow us to not have to field those questions in the future. And then, you know, warehousing is a big deal in my district. We went through the Harlem rezoning specifically to try to make it more attractive for developers to build — developers that had been warehousing and sitting on developments for a really long time. We went through that rezoning, we utilized and threw everything in the book at them, and they still have not built. We are still sitting on those sites 10 to 15 years later. I mean, for some of those developments, my whole life. And I am just wondering if you have put any thought into how do we really incentivize warehoused apartments that are just sitting vacant in the face of people who are really in (01:18:55) need of housing. And that is all. Thank you. Thank you, Councilmember. Just for clarification — are you speaking about vacant sites, vacant lots that are privately owned, but we used the rezoning as a tool to incentivize building? We said maybe if we let them go higher it would help incentivize the building, but that has not been the case. And so we just — you know, outside of letting them build the Empire State Building in the district, I do not really know what would get them to build. But something really does have to be done about the warehousing in the district. I mean, they are just empty apartments sitting there and it is quite frustrating. (01:19:36) So thank you for bringing that to our attention and I am happy to also just have an offline conversation with you further about your district. I know that the East Harlem rezoning was significant and I was around when that was completed. There is always an opportunity for us to take another look at that, right? There are a number of new zoning tools available today. There are different types of affordable housing that exist. There could be an opportunity for us to take a new look at what was achieved and what other strategies we can use to make sure that we realize the goals of that plan. So certainly happy to follow up with you on that. (01:20:12) And then I will turn it to my colleague, who has a little bit more about development. (01:20:20) Sure. And I am definitely familiar with some of these Third Avenue buildings — I was involved in these types of rezonings as well and remember a lot of these conversations. And it is frustrating to hear that after all of these years they are still sitting there and not filled. I think there are conversations being held offline, so I really want to understand why that is happening and find both enforcement tools and financial tools to (01:20:42) kind of facilitate that to happen. So I would be really happy to follow up on that. In terms of building quality and wage standards for projects financed by the City, we have a robust design standards process to ensure high quality housing. I think I have definitely heard about as-of-right development and lower quality, and so I hear you on that issue and would like to follow up and continue discussing that. On wage standards, there are wage standards through the recently passed Construction Justice Act, and so the projects that are being financed are coming with, I think, both the high quality that you want to see. Thank you. (01:21:24) Next we are going to hear from Whip Hanks, followed by CM Brewer, then CM Salaam and CM Lee. (01:21:34) Thank you, Chair. Thank you, and thank you to committee staff. As I said before, we need to think about developing with a scalpel — carefully targeting developments at what our districts need — and you can hear that that is mainly what my colleagues are saying. However, through the North Shore we are working to turn vacant and underused sites into better housing and better access to our waterfront, and we want to understand the tools to expedite this process to build homes for our residents that they can afford and that have the infrastructure to support them for generations. So many of the projects in my district benefit from HPD, and I am really proud of that partnership we have implemented to advance those projects and begin new ones. To this point, we have recently launched a community engagement and neighborhood planning effort to identify the next round of viable projects to continue growing our pipeline for new housing. We want this pipeline to be executable — we want it to be real. How is HPD prepared to support these efforts and put specific actions in place to move these plans forward? I was going to ask the question about the pipeline and staying in the queue, because we are now like a decade out on many of those projects that we were really proud to do last term — or that my predecessor did — and we are just now doing these. So I think that is a really important part of what has been asked already, and you answered it. So thank you. But I do want to understand how we can work together. What are the tools we need? How could we expedite this? How do we get the ULURP process moving when we actually want to build and we have set up this relationship with the City? The administration and City Council are taking this big step forward. What does that reciprocity look like? How are we working (01:23:42) together? I will start and then I will turn to my colleague. So thank you, Councilmember, and thank you for your leadership and really thinking through planning opportunities and growth opportunities along the North Shore of Staten Island. I know that our Staten Island office met with your team just this week and we are excited to learn more about the planning effort that you have underway. I know HPD is a critical partner on the North Shore, and so to the extent that there are zoning tools or other tools that we can use to help realize the community vision, we stand ready to partner with you. I know that those conversations have started. I am new here as well and look forward to digging more into the vision that you all have for the North Shore. (01:24:25) Your district is the one district on Staten Island actually not in the affordable housing fast track, but there are tools such as ULURP that are certainly available to your district which expedite land use review. There are projects in your district that, based on the density, qualify for the SEQR exemption as well, which would allow us to move projects a little bit more quickly but also still go through robust land use reviews. So there are tools available that allow us to potentially speed up work on projects that are in the pipeline, and so we are happy to sit down and have a little bit more of an assessment of what is already in the pipeline on the North Shore and get a little bit more into the vision that you and the community are developing there. (01:25:12) I appreciate that. Thank you for the clarity and we will definitely be calling you on that. Great, I think. (01:25:18) I would add we are excited to partner as well. We work very closely with HPD and we do a lot of projects that are joint projects. We are working together on the Stapleton waterfront — we have had some setbacks on the project there, but I do think that we are in a place where we are hopefully going to be able to move forward soon. We are working through our state waterfront approvals such that we think we can actually be closing that project soon. We are excited — I think we are going to be meeting about the Castleton site with your office in the coming weeks and are excited to talk about that as well, and any potential role for HPD on the various waterfront sites. I think we are happy to discuss that and we want to do more work on Staten Island. Thank you. (01:25:58) Thank you. Next we will hear from CM Narcisse, followed by CM... (01:26:04) Good afternoon. Thank you, Chair. Let me be clear — I am not against development at all. The Block-by-Block Plan is a very ambitious plan. But I am not seeing a plan for infrastructure. If you watch the news, after every rain you are going to see the flooding causing streets to sink. All those things need to be addressed. And I believe that we, as Councilmembers, were elected for reasons. You are very nice and you want to collaborate, but I am concerned about the future generation. If people do not want to be like you, how do we fit into the equation? Because people hired us — elected us — for reasons. In my area we are built on marshland and we have been (01:26:57) sinking. Streets, homes — and you have seen it, I am sure you have heard about it. We live in a transportation desert. But I can be honest: we can assess to see where we can go. There is probably an area we can explore. But before Community District 18 was placed on the fast track, did HPD consult with DOT about whether the district could support new development? (01:27:29) So thank you for your question and also for sharing the concerns that you have about your district. The fast track list was determined really through a straightforward methodology that is consistent with what we are called to do in the Charter. We are called to develop a methodology that determines a rate of affordable housing production and identify the communities that would be in the fast track. We have done that — we did that on October 1 — and now the work begins to assess what the opportunities are in those districts relative to the existing conditions, relative to the need, and in all of the neighborhood context. I know that capital planning and infrastructure has come up quite a bit in this hearing, and trust me, I understand that that is a priority. It is one of my first priorities in this role. It is not as exciting necessarily as launching a new neighborhood plan, but it is critical to the work that we do — planning for a City that is growing and needs to continue to grow. And so as I have shared before, there are some new tools that HPD has in the capital planning process based on the last election, where we have a role now to assess and support certain City facilities. We also already have a role in the 10-year capital process. We also have a role in working with community boards around the district needs statements, and so we are ensuring that we are leveraging the roles that we have in the capital planning process. (01:28:50) Since this is my town... I do not want to make up your time. We are in the 2080 flood plan, where we have homes that would certainly flood after storms and we are even sinking. Without acting on sewers, on visibility, on school seats and everything else — all included — in the last five years, how many affordable housing applications in District 18 did the Council vote down? And it is zero. I can answer that, but you can continue answering it. So I wanted to know what the problem is. How many affordable housing (01:29:33) projects were proposed in the last five years by private developers? (01:29:43) I think nothing has been filed, because I want to know if it is because of finances, if it was for the land, or desire — because we have not received any, really. So you can answer. Thank you. (01:29:56) Sure, I will jump in. I do not know the number of applications prior to my tenure. We certainly can follow up with you on that. I anticipate that there will be activity in those districts. We are confident that there will be affordable housing development in all the fast track districts and again we want to be sensitive to the needs. I will just note that we have developed the list based on exactly what the Charter is calling for us to do: developing a rate of affordable housing production, producing the list without exception. So that is the list. As projects are pursued, that is where there is an opportunity for us to really assess the environmental impact, assess the infrastructure need, figure out the right mix and tools for affordability within your district and customize the implementation. (01:30:41) But the affordable fast track list is developed strictly from the methodology that is defined by the Charter. It is a list that accelerates the approval of affordable housing projects — the potential approval of affordable housing projects — but it does not take away our responsibility to complete land use review. So it is not one size fits all and it is not going to work as a blanket for all of New York City. Like I said, we build on marshland and I appreciate you. I am looking forward to seeing what spots we can build on and if not, we have to be sensitive to folks because they cannot even pay to repair their basements. So thank you, Chair. (01:31:20) Thank you, CM... CM Zhuang, followed by CM Brewer, also in. (01:31:23) Thank you, Chair, and thank you also for coming here today. Let me give you some background on my district. I have Community Board 11. The cost of a one-bedroom for two people in my district is lower than $2,400. Meanwhile, affordable housing for two people at 80% AMI — $2,438 actually — is higher than our market rate. So for this type of situation, yes, I agree we need to build more affordable housing, but that actually drives market rates up. People are not able to afford it if we are not mindful of our original rents not being that high, because we need to build while keeping the market and more affordable housing in balance. Our rate actually drives up. How do you deal with this type of (01:32:21) issue? So we are defining affordable with AMI levels as the floor, and any other types of affordable tools that are above that meet the requirements. We know that in certain parts of the City, because the AMI levels are developed based on the region, there are parts of the City where it is close to what you see in the market for existing housing stock. But it is still often more affordable than what exists in brand new construction. What is important to note is that when we have been able to include Mandatory Inclusionary Housing in projects, we know that the cost of that housing — the rent — will certainly not accelerate over time the way rent in the private market does. So these are all subject to very careful analysis and calibration as to how we would approach this in different districts. I would note that that certainly is in reference to the affordable tools that are created through the program, but there are other tools as well — great affordable housing tools that our colleagues have utilized. (01:33:30) Why does the ULURP process not take into account population density? A higher-density district has less open space available to use, so the burden on them is higher. So the ULURP process does take into account existing context, land use rationale, as well as, to the extent that a project is subject to environmental review, it does certainly take into account open space. Typically in our high-density districts, we would see that because people are building much bigger projects, and so all of that is certainly factored into how we would make planning and land use decisions in the district. Sorry, I (01:34:12) selected for ULURP — are we to believe there is no distributing? The entire borough needs more affordable housing. No, actually, not one of the districts in the Bronx has more housing units than our Brooklyn 11. So we recognize every neighborhood in New York City is an appropriate neighborhood for affordable housing and can benefit from affordable housing. The neighborhoods that are in the fast track are the neighborhoods where we have seen the production of affordable housing lagging, and the goal is to be able to fast track affordable housing in those communities. It still does not take our focus away from building, facilitating and supporting the creation of affordable housing in community districts citywide, including the Bronx, which we see as leading the City in affordable housing production, but where we are still promoting and advancing affordable housing projects in the borough. (01:35:06) And I will turn it over to... I just want to respond to your first question about AMI and its relationship to market rents. The area median income name is actually a bit of a misnomer in New (01:35:21) York City. It is based around market rents, and so because market rents keep going up in New York City, AMI has gone up every year quite significantly. So there are many parts of the City, including your district, it sounds like, where 100% of AMI is above market. We do not finance affordable housing that is above market, so in all of our projects that we are financing, we work to ensure that the high end of our project is at least 20% below market. So for projects that we have financed in a neighborhood where AMI is lower than market, we are making sure that the highest tier is, you know, maybe 60% AMI instead of 80% in those neighborhoods. For projects that use our as-of-right tools, we also encourage them to have the highest tier be below market, because if the highest tier in a project is at market or above market, those units are not going to fill and they are going to sit vacant on Housing Connect, and that is going to be bad for everyone involved. (01:36:21) Thank you, CM Zhuang. Because I want to indicate the Bronx has been doing its fair share in the affordability crisis. That is why it was not on that list. But as you said, Chair, every district in New York City can do their role. We are producing more affordable housing units. I wanted to touch really quickly on the fact that we do see, like in the Bronx, parts of the west... I know the Mayor has been having several conversations with the President and just wanted to know if there are any efforts addressing that, and my issue that a lot of people in the City are seeing. (01:37:03) I certainly cannot speak to the Mayor's conversations with the President. I can say that AMI is all relative. So I think the most important thing is that the projects that we are creating are serving the right incomes. When we are looking to finance affordable housing, our goal and what we are committed to in the housing plan is that 50% of the housing we finance will be for extremely low and very low incomes. We are always open to having conversations about what the right incomes for each project should be, that we should be serving deeper affordability, the more subsidy. But we are committed to providing it for all projects and again want to be providing affordable housing that is not above market. (01:37:45) I think some more conversation needs to happen around that. We are partnering with everyone in government — local, state and federal — but that conversation can happen all day, so I will move on to CM Brewer, followed by CM Santosuosso, then we (01:38:00) Okay. You can imagine I am really pissed. I find that this conversation... Counselor, okay, you just speak into the mike a little bit more. Sorry. I understand — I cannot move it, you know, it does not move. So my question is: on the Upper West Side, we want affordable housing. We always have. But you do not count conversions of SROs, which is what is happening now, because that is not new construction from the ground up. Also, I want to pick up on what the Chair said. I have done over 200 ULURP applications, more than anybody else, and I will say I always say Manhattan would like to have some affordable housing, and he said, "No, no, no, Gale, we are going to the Bronx, it is cheaper, so screw you. You are not getting affordable housing. You are not getting vouchers. We are just going to do market and then hopefully some MIH at 80%." That is it. So I do not understand: why is the Upper West Side on this list when there is not a vacant lot available? How can it be on the list if it does not conform? Can you answer that question? I am beyond pissed. I understand that (01:39:02) as I had noted before, we developed a list based on a methodology that is consistent with the Charter. It is applied without exception across all community (01:39:11) districts. So where are you going to go on the West Side when there is no land? (01:39:15) So I will note that development is happening on the Upper West Side. (01:39:18) Where? Give me an example. (01:39:21) There are development projects happening on that. (01:39:22) Front and Edith is not helping us with the land. You want 2.4 acres, no help from the City to get it to be affordable at a reasonable rate, and he wants to build bigger than the entire Empire State Building. (01:39:37) So again, I just want to note that where development is happening, there are tools that we can use, like mapping Mandatory Inclusionary Housing, so that new development activity is subject to a requirement for affordability. We can also again explore where the financing tools, for instance, could potentially be (01:39:54) utilized. I have heard it all before and I never get any help. I am just telling you, you have not been around that long and I have. (01:40:00) I recognize that and I recognize your commitment to your district and your commitment to affordable housing. We have an opportunity now to figure out how we fast (01:40:08) track. Okay, I understand that. And what we are going to vote on — I am voting against all of them. Just so you (01:40:15) know. But the 7%... (01:40:16) I understand that the 7% is even an increased amount of projected needed housing on the Upper West Side. How the hell are you going to get what you had before? I am sorry. Okay, we are voting for the ballot initiatives. Oh, okay. I hate them, just so you know. And so the question is: understanding that in that ballot there will be a projected even greater required housing on the Upper West Side than there was in the past — you are trying to get 12,000 units or some crazy amount out of the Upper West Side. Where are you going to get that? (01:40:51) With respect to the affordable housing fast track voted on in the last election, there is not a numeric target that is required. (01:40:59) Yeah, but whatever is on the bottom 12 is the word... (01:41:01) But we have created a rate and the rate is relative to your overall housing production. (01:41:06) We have housing production. You just do not count it because it is conversion and not new. (01:41:11) So the conversions — you do not count them because they are not new. (01:41:14) So it does have to be new. (01:41:16) Affordable, I know. Yes. And so it is a rate, though, so there is not a fixed number. There is a way in which in the next five-year calculation, the Upper West Side... (01:41:24) Look, I do not care about five years. I do not care about five years. I only (01:41:27) care about now. Okay, well the next five years is when the calculation... The only (01:41:31) way to change it is to go to court. Is that correct? The only way to change this is to go to (01:41:34) court. So we are focused on (01:41:37) implementation. I am changing it and going to (01:41:39) court. Thank you very much. Understood. I almost did not want to stop CM Brewer. I was scared because she is extremely, extremely frustrated at this process. So thank you, CM Brewer. CM Santosuosso, followed by CM Lee. (01:41:57) Thank you, Chair. As someone who is also on the list, I nonetheless appreciate the ongoing conversation with your office and thank you for acknowledging our efforts around the Bay Ridge Triangle Rezoning. I think one of the reasons I am frustrated is because, as CM Zhuang was saying, relative to the rest of the City, Bay Ridge rents are relatively affordable, which includes a lot of rent stabilized units. So while I still have ULURP power, I have approved 400 units on my old block alone. Both the market rate and the apartments in both of those buildings are more expensive than the average Bay Ridge rent, which includes rent stabilized units. Notably, as they passed through City Planning review, I did not see City Planning (01:43:01) specifically argue for a deeper level of affordability. So I am just concerned that now that I can no longer use my power as a Council Member to negotiate for deeper affordability, I am concerned that that need will not be acknowledged or pushed seriously through the City Planning review. So I guess my question is: now that we are losing this power, what will you do to make sure that the rents that are coming in are not merely inflationary to existing Bay Ridge residents, while it purports to solve an affordability crisis elsewhere? Thank you. (01:43:39) Thank you for your question. Again, thank you for your efforts and the planning work that is happening in Bay Ridge. I recognize that in certain parts of the City there is that tension based on the rent calculations, where the affordable rents are very much in line with or sometimes a little bit higher than what we are seeing in the existing housing stock. We are seeing, though, that rents are still comparable to what would be new housing that is built, or sometimes much more affordable, and they also carry permanent affordability. That being said, as I noted at the Commission, we certainly have the ability to make modifications and recommendations around the AMI levels that are selected. I think also in your proactive planning process, that is where there is an opportunity to lay out the intentions but also the tools that need to be at the table to get the deeper (01:44:27) affordability. And that was my next question: is there a tool available in the arsenal if my proactive planning effort were to be successful, where we could essentially, through the rezoning, strongly advise or force a deeper level of affordability? I think there is opportunity for that. There is also, again — and I would defer to my colleague — other housing financing tools (01:44:48) that can be utilized. I think the East New York example was shared earlier today, where we have achieved over 6,000 units with really deep affordability. That is a combination of City Planning and also City affordable housing tools. There is a mix, and so I think taking this proactive approach is helpful so that we can figure out the right mix in your community. (01:45:07) And then my last question is around transit oriented development. One of the reasons I am trying to pursue the Triangle Rezoning is because it is so perfectly situated between two train stops — 86th Street and 95th Street. The trouble is that if you have ever taken the R train before, you will never want to take the train again. So my thinking is, it is one thing to talk about capital planning as far as City infrastructure that we fund and that we have control over, but it is quite another to talk about largely state-funded capital improvements, which in this case would be the R train and everything that it would take to get it to be a train that is a dignified option for everybody in southern Brooklyn. So what capital investments and planning are you thinking about specifically in transit oriented developments, particularly around those train stops? Thank you for your time. (01:46:03) Thank you for that question. As we are assessing and developing citywide transit oriented development proposals, we have also started early conversations with the MTA as well, to understand... I know that they just released the capital plan to bring assets to a state of good repair, which is really exciting. We are in those conversations to also figure out where there is alignment between housing growth and investment. We have tools like zoning for accessibility as well, although I know the 86th Street station is accessible, which is great. I know your district very well and also that you have accessible stations, which is really fantastic. But we are also looking at other ways that we can utilize that program to support other types of infrastructure investment in transit that is substantive and critical to what riders experience. (01:46:57) And I would just say, if there is a role for the Council to play — or those of us in the bottom 12 to play — where we are advocating with our state partners to get some kind of coordinated focus on these transit oriented areas and developments, then I would love to play a part in that. We welcome your partnership and again, we are still in early days, but we look forward to those conversations. (01:47:15) Absolutely. Thank you so much. Thank you, CM Santosuosso. CM Lee. (01:47:19) All right, so now moving over to eastern Queens. I am almost visualizing hearing everyone's questions about what their districts are like, but I have a very interesting and challenging district in the sense that I think we are only one of two that has no subways and no railroads within my district. We are like outside, north and south, but you know. So when folks say, "Hey, we will come meet you in your district," I am like, I think you might want to rethink that one, because it is quite far. And so it is interesting. I just want to emphasize — I know I sound like a broken record at this point when I talk about infrastructure — but I have parts of my district... I have four community districts. Actually, I have 8, 11, 12 and 13 in my Council district. Myself, Deputy Speaker Williams as well as Selvena Brooks-Powers share 13, and there have been some significant infrastructure challenges there. One thing I will say is that that is where Hollis is, that is where the flooding happened, where we recently had to vacate two homes because one of them was literally falling off its foundation from all the flooding damage and had to be demolished. And so there are really significant challenges there. The City, by the way, put in $20 million underneath the ground to sort of help with the water and it did nothing to alleviate the flooding that is happening. So in all honesty, it probably would have been better in a bio program, but that is just what some of the residents have been asking about. When it comes to infrastructure, I guess I am just wondering — and I will ask my questions first and go through it — what specific standards or metrics are you going to use to evaluate the sewer capacity, drainage, transportation and other needs, and what happens if those systems cannot support the proposed housing? That is the first part of my question. And then sort of piggybacking off other Council members, also with the community input piece, and now that being taken away when it comes to accountability — who will secure and follow through on infrastructure and community commitments, and how will residents know whether those commitments are being met? How is that going to actually play out? And also lastly, I just want to really emphasize the community input piece of it. If you look at my district, I think it is about over 90% homeownership. The question I have always been asking is: we are not against building housing, but number one it has to make sense and number two it has to be in places where we do not have that much land available, because it is either parks or one or two family homes. I rarely have any zoning that is above R3 in my district. I think the places that could be looked at are the corridors where you could maybe build some units on top, but then there are challenges there because it is literally blocking a lot. How do we change maybe some of those areas? The community input piece — when (01:50:20) it came to creating more, we got the community there with the civics, the community boards, the Borough President, State Senate, Assembly as well as myself. Because of the hard work, we have successfully got the community on board with 50 acres. (01:50:40) So there are more than 50 acres, and that is one place that is state owned, so I know it is not City. (01:50:44) But that project is going to bring about 2,000 units as well as veterans housing, senior affordable housing, a school, a firehouse — all of those things. And that was done and was so successful because of the community input piece. So I just lastly wanted to ensure how we are going to make sure that their voices are still part of that process, because I do ultimately think that will lead to a successful project. (01:51:13) Thank you, and thank you for sharing that example. We have heard loud and clear today that capital investment and understanding capital is critical, and that will be front and center in the way that we approach all of our work — but certainly the ways in which we assess opportunities within these affordable housing fast track districts. Public engagement as well will be critical. I would just note that the fast track does not remove community board review, Borough President review or public hearings. Those processes are still in place and part of our ULURP process. Any engagement that happens pre-certification, including engagement with Council members, a lot of that happens informally and that would still continue. We would certainly encourage that as those projects start to move into public review. In terms of metrics, I think we can get back to you with that. There are certainly certain measures of analysis that are part of environmental impact studies that we would use to have an assessment. There are also the metrics that capital agencies use overall to understand state of good repair and capacity. I would not want to give that to you just off the top, but we can certainly share that with you. And I do not know if there were any additional questions that I have missed. (01:52:23) One thing I would note is that affordable housing projects that are in flight — like some of the work that you have mentioned — those will be part of the calculation the next time we refresh this analysis and this methodology. We know that there are affordable housing projects that will be permitted during this period and start to move forward, which will also change the rate across the affordable housing fast track neighborhoods as we go into the next five-year (01:52:47) cycle. Okay. Sorry. Chair, I have one last question if that is okay. Do you guys factor in, when you are looking at the proposals that you get, if there is a history of bad landlords that are proposing these projects? Because I actually have proposals being made, but the folks that are proposing them have not been good landlords with what they have now. And so I do not necessarily want to be in a position to say yes, we need housing, but I do not want to reward bad behavior as well. So what are some of the stop measures that are there in terms of how we can prevent that? Thank you. (01:53:25) For your questions. So typically at the City Planning Commission, when we are reviewing an application, we are primarily making sure that the underlying zoning is appropriate for the community, should the owner, landlord or anybody change over time. We need to make sure that there is solid rationale for the community. That being said, we certainly have testimony from the public asking questions when it comes to who the potential operators are, but we also recognize that sometimes operators change over time. So what is most important is making sure that the underlying zoning makes sense for that neighborhood. That being said, there are certainly other tools in the City to ensure that landlords are good actors, as well as to take action against those landlords who are not. So I will certainly turn it to my colleagues to speak to that. (01:54:12) Yeah, I think that we take enforcement of tenant rights and tenant conditions really seriously. I think we are rolling out a lot of new programs in this administration. I think my Commissioner — Commissioner Levi — talks about putting bad landlords out of business, and I think she is serious when she says that. Recently launching the Fix the City initiative, which is really supposed to tackle these longstanding bad landlords — recognizing there are good landlords out there and that not all landlords are bad actors — but for those that are bad actors we do want to enforce against them. If there are folks in your community that are that we should know about, we should connect. (01:54:50) Actually, Commissioner Levi was very helpful and she knew exactly what I was talking about. (01:54:54) When she does, all of them. Yes. Yeah. (01:54:57) Thank you, Council Member. And just kind of piggybacking off the T roads — is there a specific deadline that we can anticipate when we will see that plan? (01:55:09) Thank you for your questions. So we are in the early stages. We hope to, you know, early next year start to have conversations with the Council about our approach, but we are still in the very early days of that. (01:55:21) All right, and I just kind of want to say the same thing as the Council member — also saying like the community-based train control, the issue that we are seeing in my district. I know, like on the weekends, the 5 train is extremely spotty. So we might be considered as a district, but the people that live there on the day to day have a similar story. As CM Thomas-Henry stated, since I have been living in that district every single weekend it has been a challenge with the 5 train. So I just wanted to kind of understand the metrics behind the transit design, and for you to have that in mind when you are completing this planning project or when you are going to be proposing that to the Council. I appreciate that. Thank you. Can you expand on what role City Planning has in the capital planning process, given that the department does not have its own capital budget? I know you spoke about different partners with the Parks Department, but it kind of felt like it was pushing the capital projects to those other agencies. Is there any planning with those agencies as you develop this (01:56:27) plan? Sure. So when we complete neighborhood plans, for instance, and there is a suite of capital commitments and other infrastructure commitments, those agencies who are the experts and who are in charge of implementation lead and fund that work. City Planning has a role, though, in coordinating and making sure that those projects are moving forward, particularly if they are connected to a neighborhood plan, and in publicly reporting that and making sure that that is (01:56:51) happening. City Planning has a role in our City's overall 10-year capital planning process, and I know we are going into an upcoming cycle. As we do that, we are factoring in all the things that are new. We have a fair housing growth strategy, we have neighborhood plans underway, we have new tools and priority neighborhoods through the fast track. So we are bringing all of that into our upcoming planning process so that we can really ensure that our agencies who are planning for climate, resiliency and infrastructure needs are also attuned to where we see the potential for growth. The other note I would make is that the 10-year planning role is relevant to duties outlined in the Charter with respect to the 10-year plan, because we are the agency that is planning for the future. We should be able to (01:57:39) ensure that your role in capital investments is a little bit more than leaving that goal to the sub-agencies, being that you guys are in charge of planning for the future. (01:57:47) Sure. I mean, I think that our role is really being able to plan for the future and plan for growth, but not necessarily — I do not see us as an implementation agency implementing complex capital projects. We do also have a role now based on the last Charter amendment and the last ballot measures of also assessing some of the City's capital assets and City facilities and making that information publicly available, so we have been taking that on. But our role as the planning agency is to really make sure that whether it is through zoning, through our demographic work, we understand and help plan the future of the City and that we are ensuring the many agencies that play a role — whether it is developing school seats, whether it is dealing with our sewers and infrastructure, parks planning, et cetera — that those agencies are armed with that information and that approach so that we are planning in concert. The last thing I would also add is that we obviously will have a role in working with community boards and their district needs statements. We want to make sure that as we go into our upcoming planning process, the priorities that are coming from our community boards are also factored into how we are considering City (01:58:56) investment. I just want to say — I hear you, Chair, and I thank you for that answer. I just feel like, being that we are planning specific neighborhoods and we are developing, I just think the role of City Planning when it comes to infrastructure investment... I think within a lot of the members here today, you did not hear a hesitance about actually wanting development in their district. It was just about the planning aspect of the infrastructure investment in certain communities. I do not want to beat the drum, but that is what you are going to hear, because for a lot of these communities it is a tremendous disservice to add people to a community that has not had that investment. So just thinking about the structure of how City Planning has any influence on those capital improvements — I just think you guys need a little bit more influence on that when we are talking about comprehensive planning in communities. (01:59:44) We are in alignment for sure, and I will say as I mentioned earlier, coming into this role that was certainly one of my first priorities. We do have a centralized team that coordinates across the capital agencies and so we are making sure that we are taking a stronger role in that process. (02:00:00) I really appreciate the administration doing that, but it seems like those staff lines were either for managing City Map or for the speed task force. Did you add any new staff to work on neighborhood planning? (02:00:20) So we added about 46 new lines for all of our new responsibilities that are outlined in Block-by-Block. That includes a number of folks who will be working on our SEQR-exempt applications, which will pull some burden off of our borough offices so that they can better focus their time on neighborhood plans and some of our larger scale planning projects. In addition, a team to support our work around census, City Map, address mapping and a number of new Charter-mandated duties. (02:00:48) Okay. Do you have a breakdown of borough staffing and vacancy rates currently? (02:00:54) So we have an overall vacancy rate of 24%, which is largely driven by the fact that we have 46 new vacancies that we are working to fill right now. We have 28 positions posted. We recently filled some. We have nine people in the pipeline for some of our other vacancies. So hiring is a priority. We also are completing a lot of our positions at the borough offices — City Planning positions that are subject to civil service appointment. We completed a civil service call-in this summer. We have another one coming up in the fall so that we can start to identify candidates from the civil service lists and fill those roles as well. (02:01:30) Okay. The administration released a report on the speed task force in 2026. The first recommendation of the report was to reduce the time many zoning applications spend in pre-certification from two years to six months. Highly qualified, well-designed development is essential to success and community support. Is City Planning still able to engage in its work to shape good urban design and quality development on such an accelerated track? (02:01:58) Absolutely. So our work to speed up housing is about improving process. It is not about supplementing good planning judgment, quality and thoughtful review. We have been working to stand up a new team that will be focused on those SEQR-exempt applications. Again, these are largely applications based on 10 years of analysis that show us less than 1% have an environmental impact, but they have really been sort of held in two years of review. We are working to accelerate them to six months through a pre-certification process, but they will still go through land use review. That is where there is an opportunity for us to make sure that we are using sound planning and judgment to evaluate those projects. So the thoughtful planning work that is essential to what we do will continue even as we are working to improve (02:02:46) process. And as part of the fast track work, there was the creation of the sprint team. Can you describe the planning goals of that team? Can you describe the goals of that team, please? (02:02:59) Sure. So I am excited about our sprint team. We have been hiring for that team and I would just note that there has been a lot of internal and external interest in the roles that we have created for sprint. This is the team that will specifically focus on the pipeline of applications that are exempt from the two-year-plus SEQR review process. That team will work in close coordination with other areas of our agency, including with our borough offices, so we make sure that they are tapping into that local knowledge and expertise. We are pulling in folks who have planning experience and planning expertise. Again, we want to make sure that we are improving process, but we are keeping sound planning judgment front and center in the work that we are doing. So that team is standing up. We have already started to identify applications that are exempt in our pipeline today. We have about 13 applications that are already exempt and in the fall, with our sprint team fully staffed, we will start to move folks towards the six-month pre-certification process. (02:04:01) Okay. Well, the plan is — will the urban designers at the borough offices have any role in reviewing private applications going forward? I am concerned that centralizing this part of City Planning's conditions and (02:04:17) So I just would note that in creating our sprint team, we went through a pretty extensive process review and reform process. We did not hire outside consultants. We worked internally, bringing in folks from all disciplines and all boroughs across the team to really design this process. We have a segment of applications that will potentially be exempt from SEQR review. These applications will be led by our sprint team who, again, will work in coordination and have direct lines of (02:04:50) So what role will the borough office (02:04:52) play? They will have a communication to our borough offices around applications. I will note that there are also folks from our borough offices who expressed interest in joining this team, so there is a normal exchange between the work that we do in central office and our borough offices. Borough offices also have the vast majority of applications that are large (02:05:11) scale, that have SEQR review, as well as our neighborhood plans, work with community boards, and all the work that we need to do to push our planning agenda forward. Okay. With the administration recently releasing the final fair housing growth strategy, completed pursuant to the Council's 2023 framework, the goal of 70,000 new housing units is a very, very ambitious goal. The last time the City achieved something like that was in the 1920s. Has the department considered additional resources and staffing and the overall budget necessary to achieve the goals of nearly tripling the housing rate? Just to note, the last few years I think we approved (02:06:00) roughly about 80,000 units of housing, so to get to 700,000 is extremely ambitious. So have you taken that into consideration? (02:06:09) Sure, we have our work cut (02:06:10) out for us, for sure. I know as part of the fair housing goals, our first step is really being able to realize the commitment of 200,000 affordable units as outlined in the Block-by-Block Housing Plan. As noted, we have had an increase in head count in this last fiscal year in order to achieve that goal, and we will continue to assess our need as we move into the next budget cycle. Okay. Has the department done an analysis of zone changes and the scale of new development necessary to actually meet these (02:06:39) targets? Sure. So some of (02:06:42) the zoning strategies that we are pursuing right now are really focused on operating at speed and scale. A citywide approach, which can potentially create a lot of opportunity for housing and affordable housing, but also the SEQR reforms that we just talked about and standing up a sprint team, which would also help us move projects along more quickly, as well as utilizing tools like affordable housing production. Some of these tools, whether they are also making sure we are maximizing the opportunities of City of Yes as well — all of these tools are at play to make sure that we can reach that goal, at least through the work of planning. There is also all of the incredible work that HPD is doing and all the other housing agencies in order to produce housing. (02:07:28) Okay, I want to talk about an initiative that the Council has presented, which is libraries. The Council has identified three additional library sites, one each in the New York, Brooklyn and Queens public libraries — Parkchester, Marcy and Sunnyside — where the conditions are right: the site is large enough to accommodate a new library, the existing library needs updating, and the surrounding neighborhood has the right conditions to support density. Is the department ready to add these sites to the pipeline and make them a (02:08:01) priority? Yeah. Thank you, Council Member, and thank you to the Council for the leadership on identifying these sites and expressing that community support up front. That is really important to being able to move these projects forward. We share the goal of advancing projects that co-locate libraries with housing. We have three projects right now that we are advancing through our libraries initiative. We have the Grand Concourse Library in the Bronx, the New Utrecht Library in Brooklyn and the Bloomingdale Library on the Upper West Side. These projects are important and they are also, you know, as part of the housing plan, we are looking at other public facilities that are aging in similar ways that (02:08:38) need similar investment for (02:08:40) sure. Yeah. So we are evaluating these sites. We are speaking with the public library systems and we are eager to continue talking through these opportunities. We have to balance our pipeline, so we have been talking about these opportunities. I believe it started as early as when Speaker Menin came in and said she wanted to potentially look at library sites. We (02:09:00) just have not heard anything back from the administration. So I understand your view on the library sites that you are looking at now, but there are Council members who want to not only upgrade the libraries within their communities but also add some density. So I would just ask that you go on record that you will actually look at the sites that we have put to you now to see if we could come (02:09:20) up with something. We are looking at the sites. We have spoken with Council members about these specific sites. We have spoken with the library systems about these specific sites. We have a long pipeline of sites that we have already committed to communities to develop. This year we are working on sites that we have committed to Council members to move forward, and we are excited to move those forward and want to figure out how we can fit these into our pipeline. (02:09:43) Okay, we need to talk about that some more. Thank you. I am going to go into a question on homeownership now. We are going to go to a second round. Chair, you know how I feel about homeownership. (02:09:52) Homeownership is extremely important and we want to keep New Yorkers in New York City. But I think we focus a lot on rental units, which is extremely important to address the affordability crisis, but there are families out there who want to purchase property and actually keep property here to pass down to their families. What is the administration's plan on homeownership? That could be an HPD question. Sure, I (02:10:20) can start. HPD is expanding and adding new funding to all of our homeownership programs as part of the Block-by-Block Housing Plan. We have a multi-pronged strategy for addressing homeownership. First is to retain and stabilize existing homeowners. That looks like our investments in the Office of the Homeowner Advocate, the homeowner help desk, preservation programs to support HDFCs and Mitchell-Lama co-ops, and support for homeowners like Home Fix, which provides loans to keep people in their homes and keep existing homeowners there today who may face displacement pressure. We are also looking at increasing access to homeownership primarily through a down payment assistance program, and we are doubling our commitment to that program as well to try to reach (02:11:01) more people. What is the number you are trying to reach? I think it is 300 homeowners a year, up from around 100, and we have also increased the eligibility from 80% of the area median income to 100%. (02:11:11) 120%. Also to have broader reach through that program. Then on the last side is creating new opportunities. We do that primarily through our Open Door program, which funds the construction of new affordable co-ops. We are doubling our production goals on that program from 150 to 300 units a year, and we are also going to be rolling out a new program soon called our HOME program. We spoke about it in the housing plan. This would fund the creation or the preservation of existing buildings that are rental now and converting them into (02:11:44) co-ops. Okay. Just to think about it, in the Bronx it is less than 10% homeownership. Is there a target area that you are looking at when you are going to be implementing a lot of these (02:11:54) programs? We do want to focus our homeownership investments in the areas with the lowest rates of homeownership. (02:11:58) So the Bronx is on that list. Okay. I will stop right there and go into second round questions. CM Louis had to leave, so I am going to ask this question on behalf of her. Next we are going to go to CM Wong, who is here, and then CM Brewer. (02:12:18) So given that the City Planning Commission rarely, if ever, recommends rejecting or modifying a proposal based on concerns raised by community boards and the borough president, there is a significant concern that the perspectives of the communities most directly affected by land use decisions will be disregarded. What specific mechanisms does the Department of City Planning have in place to (02:12:42) ensure that community boards and the borough president's recommendations meaningfully influence the commission's decisions? And will the department commit to greater transparency by clearly documenting how these recommendations are considered, addressed and incorporated into final determinations, particularly when the commission ultimately disagrees with the recommendations of these local bodies? (02:13:05) Thank you for the question. So as you know, the City Planning Commission is an independent commission. Obviously we are focused on making sure that we are meeting the needs of New Yorkers and obviously addressing the City's affordable housing crisis. By the time an application reaches the City Planning Commission, it has gone through pretty extensive review at the borough president and community board level as well as the department level for pre-certification. As I mentioned earlier in this hearing, there are certainly lots of modifications we see on applications before they reach the commission, but there is still the ability to recommend and make modifications before approval. The vast majority of affordable housing that we are creating in the City, at least through zoning actions, is done in partnership with the City Council. So we are certainly seeing that the projects that we are approving at the City level are also being approved at the Council level. To the extent that the Council seeks modifications, those are coming back to the final scope and determination. I think that exchange will continue. We take every piece of testimony seriously. We want to make sure that we are listening to community boards and borough presidents, and our commission reports will typically outline how we arrived at our decision based on all the varying factors. Thank you. (02:14:26) CM Wong, followed by CM Brewer. Thank you. Yes, I (02:14:32) have lived in my district for 50 years. I moved in 1976, and I learned two things. One, the power cable in front of my house has not been changed — it is the same cable. Every morning I look outside. Those lines have been suspended; they are not buried. To this day, most of my district, which covers two community boards, your fast track plan covers Community Boards 4 and 5, right? So the issue is that we are dealing with the same power lines, and worse, we are dealing with the same sewer grates that have been there for close to a hundred years. With that, and the fact that there are flood zones in my district around the Juniper Valley Park area — this is low ground — what we used to see was flooding every three or four years. Now we see flooding every single time it rains. That is serious because, one, the rainwater has nowhere to go, and two, it causes sewer backflows. Sewer backflow is serious because I see raw sewage literally floating on the streets, and when the water recedes, you smell it for the next couple of days. Those are serious issues. Twelve years ago, I got Scott Stringer — he was Comptroller back then — to come look at this, and he said, "Oh yes, we have got to build more basins, we have got to upgrade sewer lines." Then after that, we got community boards involved. Con Edison came. "Oh yes, the power lines need to be upgraded." Nobody mentioned the two words "fast tracking." Now all of a sudden we have fast track building, and where are you going to find the electricity and where are you going to find the sewer lines that really should be there? I even spoke to the Mayor: upgrade the infrastructure, then come tell me about building. Because we are dealing with these two issues right now. One- and two-family homes have been there 50, 60, 70 years and they cannot even handle those power requirements. They are super problems. Every time there is a windy day, my district loses power because of those power lines flapping in the breeze. We lose power. That is the truth. Okay? So here is my question. I hear all the time from my constituents — even when I worked for Robert Holden — constituents called saying that water and electric infrastructure in the area is straining to support the housing that exists today. How can local water and electric grids handle the influx of tens of 10-story buildings? Should we not be improving infrastructure before allowing new development? Please answer. (02:17:48) Thank you for your question and thank you for bringing those issues to our attention. I am sorry that your district is experiencing that, and certainly want to make sure that we have a better handle on what is happening there. As I noted throughout this hearing, we want to make sure that as we are considering housing opportunities in communities, we are also looking at the environmental impact and needed capital infrastructure. I would also note that we are planning for growth in housing, but we are way behind in terms of the housing we need for the growth in population that we have already seen. The City has grown. People are here. They are living in homeless shelters. They are underhoused. They are doubled up in apartments. What we also need to do is ensure that we are building the housing that people need today while also planning for the housing that people need in the future, including folks who may be in your district but not in the housing that they need. Through the fast track process, we have an opportunity to be able to accelerate the production of affordable housing in your district while also still ensuring public review, community board review and assessment of your physical and capital infrastructure. We certainly will be attentive to those needs as we start to plan forward. I would also note that we are looking at opportunities relative to your communities. We do not have an expectation that the south shore of Staten Island looks like Midtown Manhattan. We want to make sure that growth makes sense in that community and that the community is able to accommodate (02:19:12) it. Yeah, growth makes sense when the infrastructure can accommodate it. Without fixing the infrastructure and just telling people to come in and build, you are putting the carriage in front of the horse, and that is the message I want to relay today. (02:19:27) Thank you. Thank you. (02:19:29) Thank you. Are you committing to saying you are not going to tear down rent stabilized buildings? Let me tell you what happens. A developer just emptied 96 units on Broadway. They did not have any discussion — they just paid money. 84 rent stabilized units. They just paid money. So when you say nobody is ever going to tear down rent stabilized buildings that are occupied, sure, they will pick everybody out. How would you handle that? Would you then go ahead and say, go ahead and build after everybody has been bought out of a rent stabilized building? (02:19:59) Thank you, Council Member. So we want to make sure that we are protecting rent stabilized apartments and buildings, and again I know that there are laws at the state level. There is also the (02:20:09) they do not mean anything. I am just telling you, I deal with this all day long — they do not mean anything. There are laws, but they do not prohibit anything when you are going to get $23 million for a (02:20:20) condo. Understood. I will say that there are those protections, but there is also the work that we are doing to make sure that we protect tenants as an administration. I would just note that includes expanding investment in right to counsel and base (02:20:32) lining it. We are killing the innocent thing. I have heard it all. It does not work. So $923 (02:20:36) million is spent for one unit? (02:20:39) I hear you, Council Member. I will just say that (02:20:41) it is a priority to us that we are preserving existing affordable housing as we pursue the development of new housing. (02:20:47) Historic districts. I want to keep them. I do not know that this administration cares about historic districts. So I want to know: are you also going to be building in and tearing down historic districts? (02:20:57) So whether it is the fast track or any other land use action, any proposals that impact historic districts will still go through the existing LPC review process. It does (02:21:06) not change. You know how I feel about that process right now — I hate LPC right now. The Bloomingdale Library — yes, Michael — but why is it only partially going to be affordable? The other two libraries are 100%. Why is that one only partially affordable when the other two libraries are 100%? (02:21:25) Affordable. Oh. On sites that can accommodate really significant density, there is the opportunity for non-affordable units to cross-subsidize the creation of the new capital needs. (02:21:39) Of that. Why do you say we want to build in areas like Board 7, but not really to the max? So that is what you are saying. You are saying I am City... but we are not going to take advantage. We are going to the Bronx like you always do. We do not want to build affordable housing, really in Manhattan. That is what you are saying when you are only doing 25%. We are not only doing 25% in Manhattan. We do have a hundred percent affordable project. We have the West Side project in your community and we do want to finance a hundred percent affordable housing. But it is not, it is only 25%. (02:22:10) So the City has a lot of aging facilities across the City. We do not have the capital resources to maintain all of the City's resources and amenities and we need to have used creative strategies that can finance the renovation of these facilities efficiently and with limited strain on the City's resources. (02:22:28) I am clear that I am 100% for that library and the City is saying no. Just so we are on the record also, NYCHA — I have lots of sites we do not want to be building. Harborview has been waiting since the Hudson Yards decision: 124 units. Everybody knows about it. Nobody has done a damn thing about it. But at other locations, so what is going on with Harborview since Hudson Yards, when I signed off for that? And I want a commitment that we are not going to tear down trees and get rid of all the open space that NYCHA buildings have. Those are my questions. (02:23:02) Well, certainly I cannot speak for NYCHA. I will say that our collaborations with NYCHA — and I think the City is focused on NYCHA — has been protecting the existing units that exist. So we have been focused on our next preservation projects on infill that supports the preservation of existing NYCHA. And so Harborview has not moved forward as a result of that. (02:23:21) What about Harborview? You just finished by saying... (02:23:22) It has not moved forward because we are focusing on these other initiatives that are preserving existing affordable housing. (02:23:26) You are not going to build the new units at NYCHA, even though it is mandated by the Hudson Yards agreement? (02:23:33) I will have to speak with NYCHA about that. (02:23:34) They blame it on... Thank you. (02:23:41) Thank you, Council Member. I have a statement by CM Farías. I am going to read it in and ask you a question. The Block-by-Block Housing Plan states that one of its goals is to maximize the potential of City-owned land, including school properties, as sites that can support new housing. My question concerns 80 East Tremont Avenue in the Bronx, located near White Plains Road, as part of the Bronx Metro-North zone. This site was expected to be developed with over 500 units of new housing, with at least 120 affordable units, along with publicly accessible open space and neighborhood-serving retail. However, the majority of this site is now slated for development as a school. When the City plans new schools on City property, what process is used to assess opportunities for co-location of housing? Is there a formal framework or set of criteria used to evaluate whether a site can accommodate both educational and residential uses? And how would the City ensure that all sites are being evaluated comprehensively so that opportunities to produce housing are not missed when other public facilities are planned? Once again, this is from CM Farías from Council District 18. (02:25:03) That is a great question. Thank you. I can speak a little bit to the Mayor's LIFT initiative — the Land Inventory Fast Track. This was an executive order issued on day one of the administration. The executive order tasked us with looking comprehensively at the City's assets to evaluate which assets can be used to develop affordable housing or housing generally. As part of that executive order, it also ordered that agencies pursuing capital projects on City-owned assets have to coordinate with the LIFT task force to evaluate the opportunity for housing. So that coordination is happening now as a result of this task force. We have a number of different agencies, including the Department of City Planning, who are all looking at City-owned sites. As different capital projects are coming through as proposed capital projects on City-owned sites, we are looking at whether this project should move forward or whether we should be looking at housing and co-location. In addition to that, originally the site was supposed to be housing. And now they are talking about a majority of... I am not familiar with the exact site, so I will have to follow up and look into that. (02:26:10) All right. If you guys could look into it, because we held a process with community input and many community members thought that this was going to be a housing opportunity, and now it is going to be a school — which we embrace and welcome, of course. I am not talking to any other Council members. You could tell them that they are trying to get as many new schools in the district as possible. But specifically for CM Farías, this was something that was supposed to happen in her district. So if you could just follow up with her, because it is a concern to that community. (02:26:41) Yeah, we will follow up with CM Farías. (02:26:45) In December 2025, the City released a New York City Industrial Plan as required by Local Law 172 of 2023. The plan includes, for the first time, a citywide land use framework for industrial areas, as well as numerous important recommendations for economic development policy and infrastructure investment. Is the City continuing to work on implementing the recommendations of the New York City Industrial Plan? (02:27:10) Yes, we are. We have been utilizing the land use framework and the Industrial Plan to help guide our planning activities as well as decisions that we make. There is a framework in the Industrial Plan that outlines primary, secondary and neighborhood industrial areas — primary being the most intensive manufacturing uses, and neighborhood industrial areas serving as the areas where we already see a mix of residential, commercial and light manufacturing activity, for instance. We have certainly pursued housing opportunities in some of the neighborhood industrial areas while also working to ensure that we are keeping our heavy industrial areas intact. That framework has been really important and helpful to how we are considering the work that we do. We know there are a number of other recommendations in the Industrial Plan, particularly recommendations that are more programmatic. (02:28:04) On policy — so we certainly have been in conversations with our other City agency partners in the economic development world. Will the initiatives be balanced with the goals of the New York City Industrial Plan and the preservation of dedicated manufacturing-zoned land? (02:28:22) Yeah, I think the Industrial Plan for the first time in a while gives us a framework to utilize as we start to reach the goal of 200,000 new units, by designating what we see as primary and secondary industrial — where we want to protect jobs — versus what we see as neighborhood industrial, which are areas that are more appropriate for including housing, are closer to transit and have much more walkability. We are able to factor those neighborhoods more appropriately into our housing planning opportunities while still making sure that we are securing the jobs and the protections that we need in our industrial sector. (02:28:58) OK. And within the fair housing growth strategy plan, I know we talked about homeownership and other kinds of housing. Activating waterfronts — I get a ton of requests from people who are coming into my office who do not want to go to New Jersey, because New Jersey has put a lot of development on the waterfront. Typically a lot more people would like those amenities, to live by our waterfront and have that open space. Is there any mindset on creating more residential areas around the waterfront? The Majority Whip is focused on the North Shore, but is there any other plan to activate any waterfront? (02:29:43) Yeah, I mean, there is a lot of tension, right? A lot of our industrial areas are traditionally along the waterfront, in addition to housing opportunities. So we see a mix of waterfront communities where there is heavy industrial as well as communities where significant housing has been built along the waterfront, including in the Bronx waterfront, where we see a lot more projects emerging along the Harlem River. It has been important for us to ensure that we are evaluating those proposals appropriately relative to need, that we are making sure that public access along the waterfront remains with private development. We have also recently conducted a survey of New Yorkers to get their input on the waterfront, so we can think about ways to activate that beyond housing. Thank you. All right. (02:30:32) My last set of questions: White Plains Road. I was not going to leave without that, right? So CM Dinowitz and I have both been engaging regarding White Plains Road. How will City Planning collaborate to develop a plan that promotes senior housing, affordable rental housing and affordable homeownership opportunities? We have the Ebenezer location — that is for you — that we have been seeing a lot of challenges with. But how will the City collaborate to develop a plan that promotes senior housing, affordable rental housing and affordable homeownership opportunities tailored to the area's needs, particularly given that our local median household income is below the citywide median household income? (02:31:14) Thank you. And I know I mentioned this earlier in our hearing, but I really appreciate your partnership on White Plains Road and all the attention and detail that you have given as we started that planning process. We will work very closely with you on our approach to White Plains Road. We know that in that community we have also started to hear from community members about the diversity of housing needs that they have right now. We have been focused on figuring out what the potential is along the corridor, just in terms of growth, and then we can start to figure out what the mix of housing programs is that can be activated when we have a zoning that aligns with the corridor's needs. As part of any neighborhood plan, all of our agency partners will be at the table — in particular HPD — and they certainly will be at the table in the work that we do on White Plains Road. (02:32:02) Well, typically with the avenue, because we have a plan for White Plains Road that wants to put in homeownership, we are having the challenge of speaking to HPD regarding the issues that Ebenezer is seeing. So I was just on the record asking you, probably for the twentieth time, if you guys could come to the table and sit down with the organization to address that, because with Ebenezer's... (02:32:27) ...church location. Sorry. If I am personally not familiar — is this a faith-based organization that wants to develop on their land? Correct? We would be happy to meet. I would say on the record, yes, we would love to meet with them. We have done a lot of work to support faith-based organizations in developing affordable housing. We recently launched — and this one is affordable homeownership. We are happy to speak with them about that. We have recently launched a technical assistance program, and we are going to be funding a new technical assistance program with Enterprise. We launched a series of classes for faith-based organizations and are happy to meet with them. (02:33:00) OK. CM Louis and I have consistently emphasized the need for a greater ratio of family-size housing units if proposed rezonings are approved. How will you work with developers to encourage and prioritize the inclusion of units that could accommodate families and support the long-term needs of the community? HPD has design standards for all construction projects that are based on population data. We require a minimum of 30% two- to three-bedrooms and a maximum of 25% studios. We typically exceed these — looking at data about our projects, we are close to 41% financing to two or more bedrooms. As part of the rezoning and as part of our conversations about future projects, we are happy to keep discussing what the right bedroom mix is for an individual project. OK. As you approach the conclusion of the community engagement phase, how is the City planning to incorporate the community's shared vision into a zoning framework that facilitates much-needed affordable housing while balancing the community's input on the size and scale of buildings? Although we have been engaging the community for quite some time, that will continue... (02:34:15) ...significantly so. Right now we are at the stage, as you know Council Member, of starting to really pull together a draft zoning framework. We have not moved into public review yet with that project, and we are taking your feedback, Council Member, as well as the working group's and the community's, before we can really move forward with a study. So we are incorporating what we heard from community members around the need for growth. As you know, I joined you and members of the community on our walk, and we walked through the neighborhood to really figure out the different nodes and connections within White Plains Road where we can accommodate much more growth, but also places where we know there is sensitivity based on homeowners and other low-scale characteristics of the neighborhood. So that work is underway. We have been in conversation to make sure that we are figuring out a draft zoning that really makes sense, but we really need to have conversations with community members first to really get to where we need to be. We will then develop the zoning while we also talk about all of the other components of the project — jobs, commercial revitalization, street safety, public realm — all of the things that are critical to a neighborhood plan. So we have a long road ahead of continued conversations with you as well as with the community. Thank you, Chair. (02:35:31) And thank you for answering our questions. I think the essence of this conversation was focused on collaboration and planning. We... (02:35:40) ...understand the crisis. We are not the Council that is NIMBY. We want to actually work with the administration, but there has to be some sense of an urban or comprehensive plan, and that is coming into effect. It is true it is unfair to just focus on units and building and just put people in locations where there is no true investment in infrastructure, in schools and so on and so forth. I think everyone in this room would like to live in a vibrant community. We talk a lot about affordable New York City, but we need a livable New York City. We could be extremely affordable, but if we do not put people in a community that they can actually live and thrive in, that is where we are going to lose a lot more New Yorkers to other states, and we do not want to do that. We are in a very important time. We understand the work that we have to do with the Council. 700,000 units is extremely ambitious. We want to work with you guys, so that is just what we want to emphasize with this conversation today. (02:36:33) We do want to hear more about the plans that you guys put out. How do you guys plan to achieve these goals? Because these are very ambitious goals and you are going to need a partner to achieve them. So please utilize us as a partner. We have Council members that are trying to do their fair share, but they need collaboration and cooperation with the administration. Thank you. All right. (02:36:56) Counselor, are you good? All right. Does anyone have any more questions? OK, good. (02:37:05) We will excuse you guys. Thank you so much for taking the time. Now we are going to move to the first panel. I am not going to take a break. We are going to go right into public testimony. Our first panel is going to consist of Chris Walters, Brendan Shiny, Kevin Wolf and Lacey Tober. I am sorry if I butchered your name. Sergeant, can we put one more chair up there, please? Members of the public, we are going to give you two minutes to testify. If you hear the clock, please use the next 10 seconds to wrap it up. Good to go. You may begin — just state your name for the record and you may begin. (02:38:21) Thank you, Chair. Committee members, my name is Chris Walters and I am the Associate Director for Policy and Research at the Association for Neighborhood and Housing Development, ANHD. I will just give a top-line summary of our more detailed written testimony, which we will submit to you. We believe Block-by-Block is an ambitious plan that needs to be supported by comprehensive planning. We support its goals of both creating and preserving 200,000 affordable homes and its recognition of the need for a more equitable distribution of affordable housing. However, building more affordable housing, while essential, is not enough on its own. As you all have raised today, New Yorkers need affordable homes in neighborhoods with the infrastructure, services, jobs and amenities that allow communities to thrive, and they deserve a meaningful role in deciding how their neighborhoods grow. We believe that comprehensive planning is the missing tool that can connect these goals. I also failed to mention that we have convened the Thriving Communities Coalition, which is a citywide coalition working to advance land use justice and comprehensive planning. We urge the Mamdani Administration to fulfill his campaign commitment to comprehensive planning and build on the strengths of Block-by-Block by addressing three critical gaps. First, planning must begin with an accurate assessment of housing needs. We believe the administration's recently released Fair Housing Growth Strategy falls short of providing that assessment, particularly for the needs of low-income households. Housing growth must be coordinated with neighborhood investment. Third, communities must be empowered as equal partners in planning, with meaningful opportunities to put forward their proactive plans to shape local development that meets City needs. To help advance these goals, we would make the following calls to the City Council. We would love to work with you alongside the Thriving Communities Coalition to advance legislation establishing a meaningful community-based neighborhood planning process and establish a clear pathway for their consideration and implementation. Second, we would like to work with you all to help develop neighborhood plans in your districts, as many of you are doing already. In conclusion, we believe comprehensive planning can help reconcile the urgency of housing production with the equally important goals of community participation, equitable investment and neighborhood stability. Thank you very much for your consideration. (02:40:35) Hi. My name is Lacey Tauber. I am the Director of Legislative Affairs and Climate Initiatives for Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso, and I just want to echo what Chris just said. It was really exciting to hear you talk about the need for comprehensive planning, because that is something that the Borough President has been advocating for for a really long time, and we would also love to work with you on potentially developing some legislation to meet that need. I will summarize our comments. So Block-by-Block states that the housing shortage is worse for those who earn the least, which is true. However, according to what they are calling for, there would only be 25,500 new homes over the next five years available citywide, assuming full implementation, for those with very low and extremely low incomes. The median household income in Brooklyn is about $84,000, which is $7,600 less than the 60% AMI threshold for a family of three. We acknowledge that there are structural barriers to producing deeply affordable housing, but these numbers simply will not meet the needs in Brooklyn. On the Fair Housing Growth Strategy, we were happy to see that it significantly improved its methodology, but there are still some factors required in the law that they have not considered in getting to the numbers they put out, including displacement risk, access to employment opportunities, open space and other neighborhood amenities and public services. We are just concerned that the targets continue to call upon the highest-growth neighborhoods to add the most housing, while the lowest-growth neighborhoods will continue to do the least. We are also concerned about the absence of a coordinated, comprehensive City plan that includes spatial guidance and an implementation framework. Without that, really, the targets are just ideas and politics can drive decision making. (02:42:34) We also want to quickly mention that we want to make sure that housing development does not come at the expense of the worker. (02:42:45) We want to see our M zones preserved, creating access to job opportunities. Thank you so much. (02:43:00) Good afternoon. My name is Brendan Cini. I am Director of Policy and Operations at the New York Housing Conference. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. I have submitted our full testimony in writing and I will summarize in the interest of time. As we have heard throughout the hearing today, New York City is facing an ongoing housing crisis. Recent changes to increase housing were steps in the right direction, but we need to do more. The City of Yes zoning changes and last year's ballot changes will all generate additional housing in neighborhoods across the City, but these two efforts alone will not allow us to add all the housing we need to address the crisis. In the Fair Housing Growth Strategy, the Mayor projected the City needs an additional 700,000 units over the next 10 years, including 200,000 units of new (02:43:42) affordable housing. There are massive unmet housing needs in every neighborhood across the City. There is not enough opportunity for homeownership or rental housing. Young adults starting out, families with children and older adults all do not have enough housing choice, facing limited options and high costs. No community board is immune from this. Housing affordability is a problem at every income level. We will not see the housing growth we need in all neighborhoods without further changes, and this is why we support the zoning changes and planning proposals in Block-by-Block. Further neighborhood rezoning, including micro-plans, is necessary to expand development across the City. Neighborhood rezonings are a powerful way to add housing supply in a way that meets neighborhood needs. Adding transit-oriented development to more neighborhoods is also necessary. The program passed as part of the plan will be helpful, but it can go further. We look forward to working with the administration and the Council to support further changes and a supply of affordable housing and housing growth throughout the City. I am happy to answer any (02:44:39) questions. Thank you. (02:44:44) Thank you for the opportunity. There being no questions, thank you so much for your testimony here today. Next we will have Matt Thibodeau, Jack Connors and Howard... Matt (02:46:50) Thibodeau, go ahead. Thank you, Chair Riley and members of the Committee. My name is Matt Thibodeau. I am an urban planner at the Municipal Art Society of New York, which has long advocated for comprehensive, community-based planning that pairs housing growth with neighborhood services and climate-resilient infrastructure, both independently and as a long-standing member of the Thriving Communities Coalition. We support Mayor Mamdani's ambition to build more affordable homes but have significant concerns about the lack of coordination, rigor and strategy for community-based implementation. Block-by-Block, the Fair Housing Growth Strategy and the Affordable Housing Fast Track are advancing on separate paths. It is unclear how they fit together or how 700,000 new homes will be matched by the schools, parks, transit, flood protection they require. Block-by-Block lays out an ambitious vision but offers few details on delivery. The report does not explain the considerations that will guide future land use actions such as transit-oriented development or comprehensive neighborhood plans. We urge the City to publish a clear plan that connects housing goals with capital commitments to public infrastructure in communities that are expected to intensify. Likewise, the Fair Housing Growth Strategy lacks detail on where and how communities will accommodate growth and what types of housing New Yorkers actually need. The report does not respond to the full intent of Local Law 167, which explicitly requires a housing needs assessment and consideration of transit, public services and climate impacts. We urge the City to deepen its housing needs analysis to quantify the levels of affordability needed by each community as well as to outline district-level spatial plans to guide development to areas with the capacity to handle additional density. Finally, the 12 districts identified for the Affordable Housing Fast Track have no accompanying planning strategy or spatial framework. The City must thoughtfully determine where new housing will be sited in these 12 districts and fund neighborhood planning with a clear pathway to implementation, as it has in the past with the Neighborhood Development Funds. We welcome the opportunity to set up a time to discuss additional details. Thank you. (02:47:32) Thank you, Matt. (02:49:31) Good afternoon. My name is Yvette Chen and I am a Policy Associate at the Fair Housing Justice Center, a civil rights nonprofit organization serving the area. Our mission is to eliminate housing discrimination, promote accessible and inclusive communities and strengthen the enforcement of fair housing laws. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. We welcome the administration's initiative to address the City's deeply inequitable housing crisis. However, building new affordable housing will not in itself produce housing equity or be effective without the enforcement of fair housing laws. I will focus on three priorities today. First, accessibility. The City must act urgently because disability discrimination is rampant. We must work together to review plans and inspect new developments rather than relying on self-certification, which lets violations go undetected. The City should also enforce the 5% accessible unit requirement, bar noncompliant developers from subsidies and approvals and target retrofits to buildings with documented complaints. Second, discrimination will persist without the enforcement of the Human Rights Law. We ask the Council to urge the administration to fund and support the Commission on Human Rights to eliminate source-of-income discrimination and enforce the Fair Chance for Housing Act. Source-of-income discrimination has been illegal since 2008, yet it remains the Commission's most common complaint. The Fair Chance for Housing Act took effect in January 2025, yet the Commission received no additional funding to enforce the law. Without adequate funding to enforce the law, vouchers will go unused and thwart the City's housing mobility strategy. Lastly, invest in fair housing education and coordinate growth with neighborhood investment and real community participation through comprehensive planning, so that new housing is paired with the infrastructure and services neighborhoods need to thrive. Thank you. (02:49:36) Thank you. Jack, go ahead. (02:51:42) Good afternoon. I am Jack Connors, City Legislative Manager at Open New York, the statewide grassroots advocacy group that fights for more homes of all kinds, protections for tenants and an all-of-the-above approach to solving our housing affordability crisis. Thank you to the Chair and (02:51:44) members of the Committee for the opportunity to testify. Our housing crisis is rooted in the fact that we simply do not build enough homes. Displacement, exclusion, tenant harassment and homelessness are all exacerbated by our dire housing shortage. Homeownership is out of reach for everybody but the wealthiest, and tenants have far too few options, a fact borne out by data that landlords are well aware of. New York's housing vacancy rate is at a historically low 1.4%, just 0.4% for our most deeply affordable housing, and the predictable result of this is a City where an astounding 86% of New Yorkers making less than $50,000 a year are rent-burdened, and 68% are severely rent-burdened, spending more than half of their pre-tax income on rent alone. This housing scarcity empowers landlords and exacerbates every other affordability challenge we face, disproportionately impacting lower-income populations. We also face a challenging financial atmosphere, with the federal government further retreating from its already limited role in making housing affordable and the cost of borrowing continuing to climb. We applaud the goal of building 200,000 new affordable homes in the next decade as well as the Mayor and the Council's historic capital funding, which will allow 8,000 more affordable units to be subsidized. Yet this figure also highlights the challenges posed by relying on City funding alone. Cross-subsidizing homes with market-rate units in the highest-demand areas can build more of the affordable housing New Yorkers need, or reserving City subsidy for the places where it is needed most. This funding mechanism works, and homes that remain affordable decades into the future and market-rate homes reduce displacement pressure on our already limited stock of deeply affordable housing. Looking forward, we look forward to the opportunity to engage with the Council to help legalize citywide. Thank (02:51:57) you for the opportunity to testify. Thank you for testifying. I think the message from the first panel and this panel is that no one objected to the Mayor's plan. I think we just focused on a more comprehensive plan and how we are going to get there. It is just not enough to give a projection of numbers. Actually obtaining those numbers is not truly easy if there is not some form of collaboration, so I appreciate all of you coming here. Outside of here, you have been collaborative partners as well. So thank you so much for taking the time to testify today. The next panel (02:53:46) we are going to hear from consists of Victoria Huffer, Josephine Beckman, Rochelle Thompson and Stephanie Simone Mahoney. She is next. Okay, we will begin first with Stephanie. Good afternoon. (02:54:20) Oh, (02:55:09) Thank you. I am Stephanie Simone and the chair of the Zoning and Land Use Committee of Brooklyn Community Board 10, representing Bay Ridge, Dyker Heights and Fort Hamilton. Community District 10 has been identified as the lowest producing district among the 12 designated for affordable housing fast track. We take serious exception to both the methodology used to reach that designation and the consequences it carries for our community. A five-year measure of newly produced income-restricted housing divided by a district's existing housing units is not a meaningful measure of its development capacity. Existing housing stock does not tell us how much land is available for or appropriate for development. The formula does not adequately account for existing density, vacant land, contextual zoning, infrastructure constraints or the feasibility of producing affordable housing in a largely built-out district like ours. Nor does it recognize the considerable value of preserving existing affordable and rent-stabilized housing. We are particularly concerned that the pursuit of new affordable housing could come at the expense of the affordable housing we already have. Upzoning creates development opportunities, but it can also place existing lower-cost and rent-stabilized units at risk. Existing affordability must be considered alongside anticipated gains in new production. Low affordable housing production does not necessarily indicate unmet affordable housing need, nor does it establish that additional development would deliver affordability to those who need it most. The affordability crisis and the housing shortage should not be treated as synonyms. Increasing supply does not by itself guarantee affordability. Equally troubling for us is the loss of democratic accountability under the affordable housing fast track. Final approval rests with a body of appointed officials rather than the City Council members elected to represent the affected communities. While commissioners carry citywide planning responsibilities, they cannot be expected to possess the same familiarity with our neighborhoods, infrastructure or longstanding community concerns as those who represent and work within them. Community boards and borough presidents retain an opportunity to comment, but their role is further diminished in a compressed process that removes final approval authority from locally elected representatives. I would just like to thank you for the opportunity to speak. Thank you. (02:57:27) Thank you, Victoria. Thank you. (02:57:36) Hi. I am Victoria, a resident of Bay Ridge. I am just going to talk about my neighborhood because I feel like every neighborhood is specific and unique, and I think that is how we have to look at it. I do not feel this process reflects that. About 20 years ago I worked with Councilman Gentile to rezone Bay Ridge at the suggestion of the New York City Planning Department. Volunteers went block by block, carefully creating a balance between the needs of residents, community facilities and businesses. That has been revoked from us at the same time a representative's voice is being eliminated from the land use process. It is very undemocratic. My neighborhood also provides services to New Yorkers who live way beyond our boundaries through our plethora of schools, medical facilities, places of employment, senior services and supportive housing for seniors and developmentally delayed adults. We are lucky to have excellent housing stock as a result of the immigrants who built it, believing in the social contract and in decent housing for all. As a result, our community is economically, ethnically and age diverse and remains one of the most affordable and stable neighborhoods in the city. At the same time we retain many rent-controlled apartments and there are few empty lots in which to develop. For our largesse, we had approximately 800 homes razed and 7,000 residents displaced with the Gowanus Expressway when it came to the neighborhood. We were then amputated from the rest of our community, Sunset Park, through redlining. We are taxed 60% more for properties that are worth less than those in downtown Brooklyn and have been charged unfairly for more than four decades. Now we find ourselves one of the 12 neighborhoods tensely and, I would argue, illegally listed on the chopping block of communities that need to provide more affordable housing through new construction. I would like to explain how some of the current policies are actually raising costs. The mandatory inclusionary housing studio goes for approximately $500 to $1,300 above our market rate. This in turn will further raise our property values and increase our unfair taxes, impacting both homeowners and renters. The definition of affordable housing affordability is now being defined by how many new housing units have been constructed in the last five years. This definition is ludicrous if you know anything about what housing (02:59:33) actually costs and nothing about our actual housing reality, but everything about real estate interests. It is also biased against stable and already affordable communities. Thank you. (02:59:42) I have some suggestions of what would help make our neighborhoods and other communities more affordable, but I will put those in (02:59:49) online. Thank you. Thank you. You can also give that to the sergeant. I will take a look at every story. Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker is Josephine from Bay Ridge. (02:59:59) Thank you so much. My name is Joe Backman and I am District Manager of Community Board 10, encompassing the neighborhoods of Bay Ridge, Dyker Heights and Fort Hamilton. We really appreciate the opportunity to be here today and are really grateful to the New York City Council and, under your leadership, to hold this hearing and give us the ability to comment. There are significant concerns that we have as one of the 12 fast-track communities. The changes represent an incredible shift in power, vesting the Department of City Planning with final say in review. We have enjoyed a good working relationship with our local City Council members. We have four that represent the district and have worked very closely with Council Member Kayla Santosuosso on a neighborhood plan. Each community district is unique in density, square miles and buildable space. Community District 10 has a total of 14,909 rent-stabilized units. We are very concerned about displacement through future rezonings without proper planning. Recent interaction with developers during ULURP really highlighted Council Member Carr's concerns about pro forma review and developers feeling that we are no longer part of the process. Community districts cannot be evaluated solely on one housing production metric without accounting for the realities of our existing built environment, infrastructure, utilities, overcrowded schools, seat deficits and transportation inequities. Community District 10 has a tremendous school seat deficit of still about 4,000, while we have already constructed five new schools. Our sewer infrastructure is also (03:01:44) antiquated. We are one of the 14 districts that has one of the 14 waste treatment plants, which covers five community districts, and the conveyance system is old. We recently had funding — or maybe not so recently, as we have been waiting seven years for new sewers in the district that was already adopted. We are just hoping that the City Council continues to work with the boards and really understand the new role of the City Planning Commission in this process. Thank you. (03:02:15) Thank you, Josephine. All right. Hi. My name is Roy Thompson and I am known as the First Lady of Jazz in Harlem, the community that I love. I have lived in my rent-stabilized apartment for 41 years. They have tried to evict me 19 times, every entity, five of them coming to the building. They have tried to take me to court. Recently they tried to do a holdover and I won my court battle, but in the Housing Part court, Judge Leslie Granger signed a warrant for my eviction, so I reported her to the Judicial Oversight Committee. I am here today to let the Council know that as seniors, we are targeted. We are not listened to. We are alone in court. We cannot get counsel. I had to face their attorneys alone. I am hoping that the Council will take into consideration that our lease recertifications should be automatically done and that there is a cap on how many times they can take us to court. I have been down here before and spoke about this four times. Please listen to the seniors. Please be proactive. Please, if we are in class C violations with mixing valves and scaffolding in front of the building, do not just come into the building, go into the basement and fix some mixing valves before there is a fire in the building. Thank you for letting me speak. (03:04:10) You are welcome and thank you to the panel for testifying today. The next panel will consist of Kristina Wigs, Zenit Tirin, Andrea Goldwyn and Emma Bartley. We will begin first with Andrea Goldwyn. Take your time, Andrea. No, not at all. I do not want you to trip. You can begin, Miss (03:04:38) Andrea. Good afternoon, Chair Riley and... excuse me, and CM Brewer. I am Andrea Goldwyn, speaking on behalf of the New York Landmarks Conservancy. The Conservancy has a long record of supporting existing housing that is affordable and the conversion of underutilized buildings into more affordable housing. Like others, we support comprehensive planning that creates certainty for New Yorkers, but we cannot support the affordable housing fast track and the fair housing growth strategy as incorporated into Block-by-Block. These plans will lead to the demolition of existing affordable housing in favor of unlimited new construction, and they remove public participation from the land use process. Most residents and Council members welcome affordable housing but have questions about adding massive new development without any support for improving infrastructure. The plans that the administration proposes forget the lessons of the past, when government czars such as Robert Moses had boundless power and neighborhoods were routinely demolished. Many neighborhoods with historic districts are already the densest and most crowded. They are almost completely built out. The fair housing growth targets will put more development pressure on these historic districts and surrounding areas, especially the older, smaller buildings that often contain smaller, less expensive apartments. The report calls for enormous increases in the rate of housing unit growth on the Upper East and Upper West Sides. But as CM Brewer has said here and elsewhere, the Upper West Side contains nitro units, temporary supportive housing and subsidized housing, and has had a net loss of over 15,000 rent-stabilized units over 15 years, which the City and State did not stop. The Conservancy supports appropriate new construction in historic districts and we have testified in favor of many such proposals at the Landmarks Commission. However, adding the equivalent of another borough across the entire city, or several hundred supertall towers in any neighborhood, will put untenable strains on infrastructure and services, and it will lead to the demolition of the existing housing that defines New York's diverse neighborhoods and unique identity. Thank you for the opportunity to present the Conservancy's views. Thank you. (03:06:55) Next, we will hear from Emma. (03:07:03) Good afternoon. My name is Emma Bartley and I am the Policy Manager from the Historic Districts Council, the citywide advocate for New York's historic neighborhoods. I am here today to express concerns about the fair housing growth strategy and aspects of the affordable housing fast track. The Historic Districts Council supports the goal of expanding the City's affordable housing opportunities. We have strongly supported housing growth through our advocacy, including testifying in support of large-scale affordable housing developments within historic districts, supporting the proposed South of Prospect neighborhood rezoning and recently launching a new initiative, Preserving Affordability, which seeks to unlock more historic tax credits to rehabilitate historic affordable rental buildings. However, while we support the goals of the growth strategy, we have concerns about its approach. We are particularly concerned that high, largely market-rate housing production targets could incentivize demolitions across the city. This concern is compounded by the affordable housing fast track's inclusion of already densely developed neighborhoods like the Upper West Side, where vacant or developable land is limited. This is not just a preservation issue, but an (03:08:12) affordability issue, as older buildings containing rent-regulated or naturally occurring affordable housing are particularly vulnerable to redevelopment. A comprehensive housing strategy must better account for existing density and displacement risk when setting neighborhood targets, while also establishing a clear plan to preserve existing affordable housing. We also wish to echo a point recently made by CM Brewer: the City's measure of housing growth appears to be flawed because it focuses on new construction while overlooking housing created or retained through rehabilitation, adaptive reuse and conversions. The New York Times recently reported that since 2023, the City has permitted over 19,000 units to be created through conversion projects. The strategy should recognize these contributions when measuring housing growth and more actively promote rehabilitation and adaptive reuse as alternatives to mass demolition and displacement. (03:09:08) Thank you. Next we will hear (03:09:11) from Christina. Thank you. Thanks so much for having us today. My name is Christina Wigs. I am an independent consultant and I work on justice-focused urban policy, community co-design and participatory governance of urban development. I live in Kensington-Flatbush, which is part of the South of Prospect plan area. Like we have heard from many of us here, my neighbors and I support Block-by-Block, but we think it must be delivered through a comprehensive neighborhood plan, just as you have reiterated. I agree with many of the points that were made, so maybe I will add a few more. As a resident and as a practitioner, my interest is to ensure that longtime residents and local businesses in my neighborhood can both shape the growth coming to our neighborhood and benefit from that growth, rather than being displaced from it. I have four asks. One, and I think we heard very eloquently from others: we need deep and meaningful affordability. Every rezoning and every city-owned site should report on how many new homes are affordable at 30 and 50% of area median income, and we should set targets for each community district. Also, as you reiterated, community members should stay and share in the value that growth is creating in their neighborhoods. I am asking for dedicated funds with technical support for community land trusts, co-ops, tenants in small buildings and affordable ground-floor space for local businesses on city sites. We need meaningful community engagement throughout the whole process. I am very grateful that in my area, CM Rita Joseph, CM Shahana Hanif and Errol Louis, as well as the City Planning Department, have already started great engagement. I am asking that that continue, not just through our 2027 plan, but throughout construction. What I heard in a meeting yesterday was the critical importance of funding local groups who are able to continuously engage community members who might not be reached by the city. A draft plan should show how it reflected and responded to what community members asked for, and there needs to be a public tracker and a local advisory group to track that commitments are followed through. The last point I would like to make is: we need anti-displacement protections before rezoning and transit arrive. Thank you (03:11:32) so much. Thank you. Set up. (03:11:34) Chair Riley, my name is Dana Theron and I am here on behalf of Friends of the Upper East Side, a leading voice for common sense development since 1982. Friends supports housing equity and recognizes New York City's urgent need for affordable housing. We applaud the Block-by-Block Housing Plan's ambitious goal of adding 200,000 new affordable homes and the commitment to preserve more. But we have three questions. First, how does the Block-by-Block Housing Plan fit into the City's broader housing strategy? How will it coordinate with City of Yes Housing Opportunity and the fair housing strategy to avoid overlapping targets, measure combined results and ensure accountability — echoing CM Brewer and her frustration. Second, we ask how will this plan work in the City's densest neighborhoods where underutilized land is scarce? On the Upper East Side, particularly in Yorkville, low-rise multi-family buildings with rent stabilized apartments are being replaced by luxury condominiums with zero affordable housing units. How will the Block-by-Block Housing Plan address this loss? Success cannot be measured only by new homes built but must also factor in affordable homes lost. To that end, between 2008 and 2025, Community District 8, our district, lost 14,793 rent stabilized apartments. This makes preservation of existing affordable housing critical. Friends calls on the City to require developers demolishing buildings with affordable apartments to replace every affordable unit demolished with an equivalent affordable unit built. Third, how will the City preserve existing affordability, support land and deliver deeper affordability on the Upper East Side? And what specific measures will bring deeper affordability to the Upper East Side, a neighborhood that is increasingly becoming high cost for lower-income residents? In conclusion, we urge the City to make affordability and neighborhood-specific solutions central to this plan, with an adequate public review process. Thank you. (03:13:45) Thank you so much for your testimony. The next panel consists of Dan, Anthony Orlowski from McWane, and Dave Party. We will begin first with Dan, followed by Anthony, then Matthew, then Dave. Right now, Charlie. (03:14:17) Chair and members of the Committee, my name is Dan, and I am a proud member of Plumbers Local Union Number One. I also serve on the Plumbing Technical Code Committee alongside Paul Connor. He is the business manager of Local One. I have the privilege of presenting testimony on his behalf. For generations, our members have built and maintained the critical plumbing infrastructure that delivers safe drinking water, removes wastewater and protects the health and safety of millions of New Yorkers. Let me be unmistakably clear: Local One supports building more housing that working families can afford. But the housing crisis is not a blank check to weaken public safety. We reject the false choice between affordability and safety. New Yorkers deserve both. We unequivocally oppose the use and expansion of plastic piping in all capacities, including PEX. This is not an opening bid for compromise. Reducing construction costs cannot justify transferring risks to residents, building operators or firefighters. The administration cannot use the Block-by-Block Housing Plan to bypass the established construction code committee process. The affordable and efficient code reform task force cannot become a vehicle for reviving rejected proposals behind closed doors. New York City's density and building stock demand local scrutiny, not shortcuts dressed up as reform. The Council should demand public disclosure of the task force's membership, recommendations, supporting evidence and dissenting views. Contemplating changes involving combustible materials without the input of firefighters who respond when systems fail is indefensible. Fire safety is not negotiable. Plastic piping systems can soften, melt or burn, and the consequences of this extend beyond the failed pipe to residents and emergency responders. Before expanding plastic piping, the City should subject fire performance and the integrity of affected fire stopping systems to independent technical review. Public health demands scrutiny. Concerns about plastic piping, biofilm and safe disinfection require independent examination. That (03:16:25) review needs to address Legionnaires' disease. The City has a responsibility to demonstrate that proposed systems can be safely maintained and remediated. Written testimony has been submitted. Thank you for your time. (03:16:37) Thank you, Dan. Anthony, you may begin. (03:16:46) My name is Anthony Orlowski, Executive Vice President of McWane Plumbing Group, a leading US manufacturer of plumbing and water infrastructure products, including cast iron pipe and fittings that are used in New York City. I am here today to express McWane's strong opposition to this plan's proposal to expand the use of plastic piping in buildings taller than five stories. As this Committee knows, building codes are established for the purpose of protecting the public, ultimately from health and safety hazards — but first and foremost from bad decisions that might otherwise trade someone's safety for anything else, even if done with the best of intentions. No code should be changed such that it results in worse health and safety outcomes. Plastic piping is at its best inferior to cast iron and copper in health and safety performance. While the high performance of cast iron and copper are inherent to the materials themselves, I would like to remind the Committee that the performance of plastic is dependent on the quality of the installation and its supporting systems. Absent one hundred percent inspection by a third party, someone installing plastic systems with the goal of cost reduction will be pressured to take shortcuts. This takes inferior performance and reduces it to unacceptable. New York City can advance affordable housing while maintaining the fire safety and public health standards that protect its residents. (03:18:24) All New Yorkers deserve plumbing systems that are safe, reliable and built to last. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. Thank you. Matthew. (03:18:37) Good afternoon, Chair Riley and members of the Committee. My name is Matthew Goglia, President and Business Manager of Allied Building Inspectors Local 211, International Union of Operating Engineers. Local 211 represents New York City's building and housing inspectors employed at the three agencies that will play a significant role in implementing this housing plan: the Department of Buildings, HPD and DOB. Our members' workloads will be directly impacted and significantly increased by this plan across all agencies. While our members are certainly up to the challenge and we support any housing plan that will address our City's housing crisis, will this plan and this Council take into account the critical need to increase funding for inspector staffing levels across all inspector titles at all three agencies? Address decades-long recruitment and retention issues of inspectors? Provide adequate equipment to carry out our enforcement and development duties? In order for any housing plan to succeed, there must be robust Housing Maintenance Code enforcement, construction safety compliance inspections as well as construction development that is zoning resolution and code compliant. Inspector staffing levels must be addressed for any plan to succeed. Our members take great pride in ensuring public safety and ensuring tenants have the dignified, safe housing that they deserve. We look forward to being on the front lines of the housing crisis and carrying out our duties. Thank you. (03:20:23) Very much. Thank you. Dave. (03:20:28) Good afternoon, Chair Riley and members of the Committee. My name is Dave Party and I am the Executive Vice President of the Cast Iron Soil Pipe Institute, or CISPI. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. Founded in 1949, CISPI represents US manufacturers of cast iron soil pipe and fittings used in building construction for drain, waste and vent plumbing systems here in New York City. I am here to express CISPI's strong opposition to the proposal in the Block-by-Block Housing Plan to expand the use of plastic piping in buildings taller than five stories. On page 99 of the Block-by-Block program, the plan calls for a Department of Buildings task force to identify code changes that could reduce housing costs. One proposal is to permit plastic piping in taller buildings based on its lower material costs. However, New York City has restricted plastic use in these buildings for more than 20 years and similar restrictions exist nationwide due to significant safety concerns. We support building more affordable housing, but affordable housing must never come at the expense of fire safety or public health. I will explain some of these issues briefly. First, fire safety: plastic piping will melt, burn and produce smoke during a fire. These systems also depend on fire stop devices at wall and floor penetrations to prevent fire and smoke from spreading through the building. Once concealed, these devices can be difficult to inspect and maintain. Second, water safety: research has raised concerns about biofilm growth with Legionella and other bacteria, and plastic pipe's inability to withstand disinfection. Independent studies have found lead more frequently in systems using plastic piping than those using copper, raising serious public health concerns about expanding its use in larger residential buildings. Finally, CISPI urges the Council to oppose any code changes that would expand plastic piping use in buildings taller than five stories. New Yorkers deserve safe, reliable plumbing and affordable housing must never mean compromising the safety of the people who live in it. Thank you for the opportunity to testify and I am happy to answer any questions. (03:22:59) Thank you so much for your testimony today. We appreciate it. Thank you. (03:23:05) Next we are going to hear from Ron. Can you guys please submit those testimony sources as well? Thank you. Rhonda, John Biggers and Patricia. If there is anyone else that has signed up to testify, please see the sergeant at arms. Following this testimony we are going to go into a virtual panel. The virtual panel is going to consist of Kyle, Cheryl, Mervyn and Dominic. That will be the virtual panel. I am sorry, maybe I missed your name. Um, is Rhonda here? Rhonda is not here. Okay. Well, first start with Patricia, then followed by John. Good afternoon. (03:24:09) I am here about a very important matter. My life almost was taken from me due to a fraud that I discovered where I live, which is Rosedale. I lost my house to a fraudulent deed in 2019. I went and rented an apartment — three bedrooms for me and my children. The landlord, when I rented the place, mentioned to me that I would have to fix the property with my own money to move in. I was so disturbed by it, but I needed a place to stay because I had become homeless with my kids. I fixed the property with my money. Even the appliances — I put all the appliances from my house that was taken into the apartment. As I moved in, I was hurt by an individual and I have 20 staples in my back. I am a nurse and I could not work anymore. I was given a Section 8 voucher by the Supreme Court. I spent one year in the hospital to recover and two years in a wheelchair. Being in this house, I found out that this landlord is really not the landlord. The property is stolen. The property is owned by the City. The property has been stolen since 1974. And through my investigation I found out (03:26:27) that not only the property I am in right now is stolen in Rosedale — there are 150 to 200 houses taken, and the City does not know what they are doing. People are being put in those properties to collect the rent and get government money. I have been targeted. They tried to burn my house with me and my children in it months (03:27:13) ago. Thank you so much. I do not want to make less of what you are saying here today. This hearing is focused on the Block-by-Block proposal that the Mayor put forward. If you want, you could wait until after and we will figure out a way to connect you to the appropriate Council members to get some help regarding your issue. (03:27:34) Yes. You know, as you said, affordable houses — I asked them to transfer my voucher. They have so many affordable houses and none of them are available. (03:27:44) Okay. So when we are done, Sharon will connect with you and see how we can connect you to the right resources. (03:27:52) All right. Thank you for listening to me. John, of course. I am sorry. You are going to do as well. (03:27:56) Well, thank you. John, that is tough to follow. Chair Riley, thank you so much for allowing me to be here today. My name is John Vigurs. I am President of Charlotte Pipe and Foundry Company. (03:28:12) During my 37 years at Charlotte Pipe I have covered New York City for 20 years and I am intimately familiar with the plumbing systems in New York City. As a matter of fact, we might be able to help the lady with her situation. We will have a conversation with her. (03:28:30) Since 1901, Charlotte Pipe has been a family-owned American manufacturer of high quality pipe and fittings. We are one of the nation's largest manufacturers of cast iron and plastic pipe and fittings and we have extensive experience with both materials and an unwavering commitment to safety. I traveled to New York City today to express our opposition to the Block-by-Block proposal to expand the use of plastic pipe in buildings taller than five stories. These and similar restrictions exist nationwide due to longstanding safety concerns. With more than a century of experience manufacturing cast iron and plastic piping, Charlotte Pipe is in a unique position to speak on the risks of expanding plastic piping in large residential buildings. Fire safety is the primary concern. In buildings taller than five stories, evacuating residents can take more time, making fire protection especially critical. Plastic piping can melt, burn and generate harmful gases during a fire. As you have heard, these systems rely completely on fire stopping devices between wall and floor penetrations. Once concealed, these devices can be difficult to inspect and maintain, creating additional concerns for building safety. These fire stopping manufacturers do not warranty the performance of these products for the life of the building. I think it is important for the Council to understand that height restrictions are not uncommon in the US. Many states have height restrictions and we would urge the Council not to expand the existing height restrictions in New York City. (03:30:22) Thank you. Thank you so much for this panel. My brother is a member of Local Union One so he has been expressing this issue to me as well, so I am very familiar with it. Thank you so much for testifying. If you could just give the Committee your information we will follow up with you. Okay. If there is anyone still here that did not testify, please see one of the sergeants at arms for a speaker's card. We are going to transition into virtual. We are going to hear from Kyle. (03:30:53) Cheryl, Mervyn and Dominic. We will begin first with Kyle. Can you turn on the video? Yes. All right. Thank you for the opportunity to testify, Chair Riley. I appreciate it. Earlier you had voiced concern about the number of units of affordable housing seeming to be the goal rather than just chasing a number. That is why I want to raise this directly to you. I have emailed your office about this. Over the summer, an exemption in New York's history — nearly 1,100 units — cost the City over a third of a billion dollars. No tenants knew about it. No tenants wanted it. I am in one of the buildings and I actually did an association survey with a 100 percent participation rate. No one is dissenting. We do not want this agreement. No one told us about it. The landlords do not want it. It is a third of a billion dollars plus and no one knows about it. I have asked every City Council member and have not gotten any answers. It has been six months. All I want is even a simple answer, like if you could explain the cost — how did you get to the $359 million cost calculation? What are the numbers behind it? Is this mathematically impossible according to the tax values and the disclosures and numbers given in the terms? Sorry, that is a little off topic, but something has got to give. Please look into this. (03:32:46) I hear you. Thank you, Kyle. Can you send that to my office again? I am not sure where you sent it, but can you send it to Cynthia Prisco, please? Yes, thank you. That is C. Prisco at Council — P-R-I-S-C-O. (03:33:11) Thank you, Kyle. Next we are going to (03:33:12) hear from Cheryl. You may begin. Cheryl has dropped off. Next, Dominic. You may begin. (03:33:29) Good afternoon. For the record, this is my son's first time here, so good afternoon. Chair and members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to testify today on Mayor Mamdani's Block-by-Block Housing Plan and the importance of removing barriers to affordable housing construction. My name is... and I am here on behalf of Local 78, Asbestos, Lead and Hazardous Waste Laborers Union. Our members perform hazardous materials removal, including asbestos, lead and mold removal, at construction sites throughout New York City. We support efforts to accelerate affordable housing development. From our perspective, one critical obstacle must be addressed: delays in asbestos permitting. Asbestos abatement is often among the first steps in a construction project. When the approvals are delayed, the entire project is delayed. The City has a strong regulatory framework through the Department of Environmental Protection's asbestos control program, which is overseen by the Asbestos Technical Review Unit. However, due to staffing shortages, approvals that once took weeks are now taking months. This can leave office-to-residential conversions and other types of housing stalled before construction even begins. This increases costs and delays the delivery of desperately needed housing. The Block-by-Block Housing Plan mentions this specific issue on page 106. These delays also have serious safety implications. As a union, job site safety for our members and others is our priority. However, when asbestos remains on the job site, it puts workers at risk of exposure. The slowness of the approval process is not making conditions safer. It is making it more dangerous. Allowing for professional certification in this permitting process would speed up the removal of asbestos so fewer workers are at risk of exposure. Local 78 has been working with CM Riley on legislation to allow qualified professionals to use professional certification in the asbestos permitting process. This would allow qualified professionals to certify compliant plans and proceed with abatement without waiting months for approval. The Block-by-Block Housing Plan seeks to accelerate (03:35:34) affordable housing development in a safe manner. To achieve this goal, the City must address the permitting delays that prevent projects from advancing. We urge the Council to support the process when introduced and work toward its passage. Our members are ready to do the necessary work to bring affordable housing to New Yorkers. Thank you. (03:35:57) Thank you so much for your testimony. Are there any questions for this panel? Seeing none, we will stand at ease. If there are any members in the room who want to testify, or if there is anyone online that wants to testify, please use the raise hand function. We will stand at ease for 15 seconds. Okay, seeing no one else waiting to testify, I will now close the oversight hearing on the Mayor's plan. That concludes today's business. I would also like to close the vote from earlier. As a reminder, for anyone wishing to submit written testimony on this topic, you may do so by emailing it to land use testimony at council. Thank you to the Deputy Commissioner for taking the time to meet with us today. Thank you to the Executive Director as well. I would also like to thank the members of the public, everyone who testified today, my colleagues, Council staff and the Sergeant at Arms who participated in today's hearing. This meeting is hereby adjourned.