Hearing Hearings — Hearing Record ✉
← All hearings

An Overview of the Parks Department's Events Permitting Process

Committee on Parks and Recreation

Chair: Ty Hankerson

Meeting overview

The Committee on Parks and Recreation held an oversight hearing on the Parks Department's special events permitting process, alongside consideration of Int 0927-2026, a street renaming bill co-sponsored by Council Members Brooks-Powers and Schulman that would restore the original name Edgemere Avenue to a stretch of Shorefront Parkway in Queens, resolving longstanding mail delivery confusion. The renaming bill generated no controversy and was handled briefly. The bulk of the hearing focused on how Parks manages the roughly 24,000 to 25,000 special event permits it processes annually, what the costs and benefits are to parkland and communities, and whether the process is sufficiently navigable for ordinary New Yorkers and community-based organizations.

Deputy Commissioner David Sarah and his colleagues testified that the permitting system is broadly functional: outright denials run below 1% of applications in every recent year, 75% of events are for under 100 attendees, and 95% are for under 500. Parks described a tiered system in which small events require only a $25 non-refundable fee, while larger events trigger additional requirements including insurance, security bonds, site fees, and ancillary permits from agencies such as NYPD, FDNY, DOB and DOHMH. For very large events, inter-agency coordination involves the Mayor's Office and can encompass multiple planning meetings covering security, transportation, promotion and performer vetting. The department also noted recent process improvements including expanded early application windows, a redesigned website, a bilingual informational pamphlet, and centralization of the citywide special events policy office.

Members pressed on several substantive gaps. Chair Hankerson raised the problem of late-stage permit decisions leaving small community organizations in limbo, questioned why permit offices have uneven staffing across boroughs (notably Brooklyn's reduced headcount following retirements), and asked why applicants for back-to-school giveaways are asked about the monetary value of donated backpacks, a question the department struggled to justify convincingly. He also identified a significant structural inefficiency: applicants needing permits for food, amplified sound, merchandise sales and a Parks permit must submit separate applications to multiple agencies with no centralized portal, and asked whether Parks had explored working with the city's technology office to consolidate this. The department acknowledged it had not yet initiated that conversation. Council Member Morano raised a pointed and largely unanswered question about who in the permitting process represents displaced ordinary park users — the person who shows up to find their usual field or path blocked — rather than the applicant seeking the permit, and asked whether Parks tracks the total park-days lost to events including setup and breakdown time. The department acknowledged it does not systematically track displacement or total access loss, though it noted that permitted events often occupy only part of a park.

Council Member Ung surfaced the newly introduced $721 fee for use of a mobile stage (winger wagon), which the department explained was driven by the operational cost of pulling specialized staff for full days of transport duty and the consequent need for overtime. The threshold triggering additional permitting requirements for bouncy houses was confirmed to have been recently lowered from 500 to 200 attendees, following Council feedback about safety incidents. Council Member Sanchez, drawing on her pre-Council experience applying for parks permits, pushed for clearer status communication during the review process, more structured office-hours-style sessions where organizations can sit with Parks staff to learn the process directly, and better outreach for the partner input forums Parks has been running. She also raised the issue of organizations that comply with permit conditions finding unpermitted events with prohibited equipment happening simultaneously in the same park, with no clear complaints mechanism beyond 311. The department conceded this is a gap and committed to examining it. On enforcement against bad actors, the department described a system of violation letters, photo documentation and permit suspensions of one to two years for egregious cases, but acknowledged there is no formal rule-based framework for tracking problematic event promoters across years.

The record

Numbers
  • Parks processed 23,948 special event permits in 2022, of which 47 were denied.
  • Parks processed 23,844 special event permits in 2023, of which 18 were denied.
  • Parks processed 23,507 special event permits in 2024, of which 37 were denied.
  • Parks processed 24,241 special event permits in 2025, of which 23 were denied.
  • Parks is tracking slightly above 25,000 permit applications for 2026.
  • Outright denials represent less than 1% of all permits processed in each recent year.
  • Any event with more than 20 attendees requires a special event permit.
  • The non-refundable permit application processing fee is $25.
  • Events expected to exceed 500 attendees are handled by the Citywide Special Events team rather than borough offices.
  • 75% of permitted events are for 100 attendees or fewer.
  • 95% of permitted events are for 500 attendees or fewer.
  • Permit applications for typical events must be submitted at least 21 days in advance.
  • Parks now allows permit applications to be submitted starting the second Tuesday after Labor Day each year, enabling applications up to 14 months in advance for future-year events.
  • Approximately 20% of annual permits are processed in roughly 8% of the calendar year during peak periods.
  • Borough permit office staffing: Staten Island 3 coordinators, Queens 6, Manhattan 8, Brooklyn 5, Bronx 8.
  • The Citywide Special Events team numbers 8 staff.
  • Nine partner input forums were held across all five boroughs in early 2025, with over 140 distinct partner groups participating.
  • The fee for use of a Parks winger wagon (mobile stage) is $721, introduced in the prior fiscal year.
  • The attendee threshold triggering additional permitting requirements for bouncy houses was recently reduced from 500 to 200.
  • Large events with egregious violations can result in permit suspensions of up to two years; standard violations typically result in a one-year suspension.
  • Parks requires large-scale events to have a private meteorologist on site; there is reportedly one former New York-based meteorologist who regularly performs this function.
Action Points
  • Parks Department to provide the committee with denial data broken down by borough location.
  • Parks Department to follow up with Chair Hankerson's office on precise current staffing levels in Brooklyn's permit office and the reasons for the shortfall.
  • Parks Department to confirm whether questions asked of permit applicants, including questions about the value of donated goods at giveaway events, are reviewed through the Parks Training Academy sensitivity training curriculum.
  • Parks Department (Gabriella Kapo) to check with the Parks Training Academy on whether the committee could observe a training session and report back.
  • Parks Department to explore with DoITT or relevant city technology agencies whether a centralized multi-agency permit application portal is feasible.
  • Parks Department to consider adding real-time location availability information to the online permit application system so applicants can see whether a space is already reserved before submitting.
  • Parks Department to develop and publish a clearer complaints or hotline mechanism for permitted event organizers and ordinary park users to report unpermitted or non-compliant events happening simultaneously in the same park.
  • Parks Department to examine whether a formal rule-based framework for tracking and penalizing repeat problematic event promoters across years should be introduced.
  • Parks Department to look into whether unpermitted groups that damage parks or leave them in poor condition can be identified and held accountable, and report back to the committee.
  • Parks Department to begin tracking the total access-loss period associated with permitted events, including setup, event and breakdown time, in response to Council Member Morano's request.
  • Parks Department to examine whether displacement of regular park users by permitted events can be measured more systematically beyond anecdotal reporting.
  • Parks Department to share with the committee the list of organizations invited to the 2025 partner input forums.
  • Parks Department to partner with Council Members' offices to host structured office-hours-style sessions where community organizations can meet directly with Parks staff to navigate the permit application process.
  • Parks Department to provide Chair Hankerson's office with follow-up on the specific denial case referenced during the hearing involving an applicant in his district.
  • Council Members' offices to notify Parks Department of specific constituents or organizations experiencing permitting difficulties so Parks can work with them directly.
Download .txt
Full Transcript

(00:00:19)

The vote. Hello. Good morning. Welcome to today's New York City Council hearing of the Committee on Parks and Recreation. At this time, please silence all phones. If you wish to speak in today's hearing, please fill out an appearance card with one of the sergeants. Moving forward, no one is to approach the dais. Chair, you may begin. Good morning.

(00:00:42)

Thank you. Good morning all. My name is Ty Hankerson. I serve as Chair of the Committee on Parks and Recreation.

Today's hearing will focus on the process the Parks Department uses to determine the types of events that take place within our City's parks and what the resulting costs and benefits are to the park system.

The occurrence of cultural and recreational programming such as art festivals, films and concerts have always been a core feature of the City park system. Most of these events are free and sometimes run by Parks itself or through public-private partners. However, some of these events are also pay-to-enter events that include thousands of participants and are often run by event promoters that have a permit with Parks. There is a multifaceted process for approving these various events. For example, any event with more than 20 participants at minimum requires a special event permit for a nonrefundable $25 fee. As the event grows more complex, so does the process. In the case of large events that involve more than 500 participants or may be commercial in nature, Parks imposes additional requirements that must be fulfilled before a permit is issued. These can include fees based on the concession fee schedule and additional insurance or bonding obligations. Furthermore, depending on the scope, location and size of the event, additional permits from agencies like the Department of Buildings or the Police Department for potential security concerns may be necessary.

Aside from the substance of the event, other requirements can factor in. If food and merchandise is expected to be sold, a simple use authorization permit is required. A fee for this permit is negotiated with Parks based on several factors, including the number of vendors at the event, estimated attendance and the prices of the items being sold. Once all the requirements have been met by the applicant, Parks will issue a special event permit at their discretion. The complexity of this process can sometimes be problematic from both the side of the event applicant and the Parks Department, as it must walk a fine line towards maintaining a vibrant parks environment that also prioritizes equitable access to all New Yorkers.

Event applicants, especially smaller community-based ones, often cite issues with not being able to fully understand what is required to secure a permit and not understanding the reasons as to why they have been denied. Historically, there have been concerns raised about the amount of parkland used for large ticketed events, the amount of revenue being generated for the event and the condition of parkland left after the event concludes. Damage resulting from large crowds, vehicles, vendors and bad weather can render parkland unusable for extended periods of time. This has left many community members concerned that some large and commercial events can deprive New Yorkers of quality access to green space.

I hope this hearing results in having a better understanding of how Parks goes about approving special events, what the overall costs and benefits are to the City's open space and whether there are ways we can improve the process to ensure that events are accessible to all and are always respectful to the parks where they occur and to the communities they occur in.

I would also like to note that we will consider a bill unrelated to this topic but an important one regardless: Int 0927-2026, sponsored by my colleagues CM Brooks-Powers and CM Schulman. It would officially rename Shorefront Parkway between Beach 32nd Street and Beach 56 Place as Edgemere Avenue. This would restore the street to its original and historical name and clear up a lot of confusion specifically relating to mail delivery that has arisen over the years. I would like to welcome the administration and the advocates that are here to testify today. Thank you again.

(00:06:58)

Thank you. Good morning, Chair Hankerson, members of the Parks Committee and other members of the City Council. My name is David Sarah, Deputy Commissioner for Activation, Environment and Planning for Parks. I am joined today by Aaron McTiernan, our Director of Citywide Special Event Permits and Policy, and Gabriella Kapo from our Citywide Legislative Affairs team. We are pleased to be here to testify today.

As you may be aware, this past summer season was an exceptionally exciting one for Parks, as our beaches, pools, parks, athletic fields and playgrounds were as busy as they have ever been. In addition to experiencing once-in-a-lifetime celebrations like the 2026 World Cup and Sail Forth 250, or taking advantage of the free recreational summer programming offered by the agency throughout our parks, New Yorkers also made the most of our shared public spaces to enjoy family picnics, barbecues and birthday parties. Concerts, festivals and other special events were also part of that. We are proud of the role that our parks play in the City's cultural landscape and we believe that special events are an incredible way to bring New Yorkers out to enjoy their local park, which helps keep those spaces activated and vibrant.

For the purposes of today's oversight hearing, we would like to offer a brief overview of our agency's special events permitting process. We recognize that special events can provide tremendous added value to our park system, so we strive to make the permitting process as transparent and efficient as possible.

(00:08:37)

Our permitting staff works directly with event organizers to make their events a reality while ensuring that proposed events are appropriate and avoid negative impacts on our beloved open spaces. Any park event expected to have more than 20 attendees is required to have a special event permit, though permits are also available for groups of any size hoping to reserve a specific area in a park. Anyone can apply for a special event permit from the agency, from organizations planning a large event for the public to families looking to host smaller political parties, weddings, unions or barbecues. It is this latter category of smaller events that makes up the vast majority of permit requests submitted to the agency.

Permit applications are typically submitted through a dedicated page on our agency website. There is a $25 processing fee for permit applications, which allows the City to recoup some of the costs of processing applications and helps discourage attempts to monopolize permits citywide. For the majority of permit requests, this nominal fee is the only cost for an applicant to be able to hold their event. Most special event permit requests are processed by staff in our permit offices in each of the five boroughs. To ensure there is ample time to properly review and discuss proposed event details with all necessary stakeholders, which might include other City agencies or construction contractors working on site, we require permit requests for typical permit events to be submitted at least 21 days in advance. The duration of the request review for each permit, from submission to approval, can vary depending on the scope and complexity of the event being submitted and the volume of permit applications being processed by the permit offices. Similarly, it is not uncommon for an event proposal to evolve and iterate as event organizers provide more information or as the review requires additional dialogue with other entities, such as the use of amplified sound for an event, which requires NYPD approval.

As such, we ask that people apply with as much lead time as possible to ensure they can secure their desired dates, and keep in mind that the final permit approvals and issuances are typically not issued until closer to the event date. However, the agency does everything in its power to expedite the review and approval of permit requests, and even though applicants are asked to submit requests at least 21 days in advance, this does not mean that a given request will take that long to approve.

We are pleased to report that outright denials of special event permits are exceedingly rare, making up less than 1% of the permits processed by the agency. In the event that a proposed event location is already permitted for another event, we are nearly always able to work with the applicant to identify alternative locations or support dates for their event to carry forward.

Though the majority of our thousands of special event permits each year are issued for small picnics, barbecues and birthday parties, our parks also serve as the location for larger events with a more expansive reach, such as concerts and set-up festivals. Though these larger events present additional considerations for the agency's review, we feel that activating our parks with a wide range of recreational and cultural activity helps make them more robust and dynamic public spaces for everyone to enjoy.

To ensure that larger event permit requests can be handled consistently and fairly, any event expected to have over 500 attendees is permitted through our Citywide Special Events team. Given that these events are considerably more complex than a typical small event, potentially disrupting access to a park or even resulting in damage to the park, permit applicants for large events need to provide additional information to the agency, including a preliminary plan, preliminary site map and production schedule, proof of commercial general liability insurance, submission of a security bond to be held against damages incurred and payment of a site fee on the concession fee schedule established by the rules. Additionally, depending on the proposed components of the event, applicants need to secure ancillary permits from other City agencies, such as the Fire Department for use of a generator, the Department of Buildings for installation of a large structure, the Police Department for safety or the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene for food distribution.

We collaborate often with our sister agencies and are in constant communication with them when it comes to moving permit applications forward. We always try to work with applicants toward an outcome that works for everyone. As the partner agency ultimately responsible for the care and protection of our City parkland and all New Yorkers, we are not able to accommodate every aspect of each request for each park. If the requested location is inappropriate for the proposed event activity because of the park size, configuration or natural features, or if the proposed activity is likely to harm the park or significantly interfere with the enjoyment of the park by other users, then the agency has grounds to deny the permit application, but this is relatively rare.

Admittedly, the matrix of permits and approvals can be daunting for some to navigate, especially those less familiar with City government. So we have undertaken a dedicated effort to make our permit process more transparent and user friendly. In early 2025, we hosted a series of nine partner input forums in all five boroughs related to our special permit process and invited representatives from park partner groups and other frequent permittees to offer feedback. Over 140 distinct partner groups participated in these forums, providing invaluable perspective about their experience, connecting directly in person with our permit managers and sharing recommendations and knowledge with their fellow partners.

With this feedback in mind, we redesigned our agency website's special events page to display key information more clearly to applicants, including the creation of a special events guide with key links to other agencies for ancillary permits. To ensure greater consistency in the interpretation of agency rules and guidelines across all five boroughs, we have centralized our Special Events Permit Policy Office and our Citywide Athletics Permits and Policy Office, working in close coordination with our borough permit offices. We are also working on additional process improvements to come, including finalizing an informational handout that will be available in multiple languages to clearly outline things applicants should keep in mind when applying for special event permits.

In closing, we are committed to helping New Yorkers plan fun and creative special events in our parks, because we know a park with robust activity is safer and more enjoyable for everyone. But we must still uphold our primary responsibility as the caretaker and steward of City parkland. Our shared spaces need to be protected and used appropriately and access must be fair. We seek to accommodate the desired outcomes of the permit applicants while protecting the needs of everyday park users to access and enjoy the open spaces they love. Thank you for allowing us to testify before you today and for your continued advocacy and support for our City parks. We would now be happy to answer any questions that you may have.

(00:16:44)

Thank you so much. I do want to acknowledge that we are joined by CM Frank Morano of Staten Island, the Borough of Parks. We got that right? All right. CM Phil Wong is also joining us via Zoom. Okay, let me just say this disclaimer before I go into questioning. I love parks and I am grateful for the work that you all do. Given that it is only two of us here today, that gives me more time for questions. So I do want to just ask a few questions and I will turn over to CM Morano, and then I will jump back in.

(00:17:30)

Just from your testimony, you said: "As such, we ask that people apply with as much lead time as possible to ensure they can secure their desired dates," and keep in mind that final permit approvals and issuances are typically not issued until closer to the event.

(00:17:49)

Do you not see that as problematic, and if not, why not? Thank you for the...

(00:17:56)

Thank you, Councilman. Thank you for this hearing. Really appreciate your attention to this matter. I think as a baseline, we always want to do the best we possibly can for the public, and that means each person that makes an application has to have a wonderful experience. That is our goal. We have so many permit applications. Last year we had over 24,000. This year we are actually tracking slightly ahead of that. I think we might get close to 25,000. So we have got to do our best. Sometimes we are going to do better than others, honestly.

I think as part of that, I just want to highlight some of the work that my colleague Ann McTiernan is doing with the citywide events. When she started in this role, she heard from as many different stakeholders as she could about the permit process. One of the things that she heard, and that we heard from the partner agencies, is that applicants felt like they needed more time to apply for a permit and there was not enough time to apply for events that they wanted to plan.

So for an example, here we are in 2026. A few years ago, if you wanted to apply for a permit in 2027, you could not do that until the second week of... What she did is she worked with our Council's team and made a rule change so that now people can apply the second Tuesday after Labor Day. So really about a little bit more than two months, extending the time that permit applications can be submitted to the agency. So we do hear you. Our goal is to be able to get back to everybody as quickly as we can.

In some cases we are going to be able to do that. In other cases it is going to be a little bit tougher. I think in the case of being able to allow the public to submit permit applications earlier, in theory, if someone were to submit an application in 2027 and they submitted on that Tuesday after Labor Day, they would be applying for a permit application up to 14 months in advance. So in instances like that, that is on the extreme end. The permit staff in each borough is going to focus on what is coming up sooner. So they are still going to be focused on September, October and so forth. And then also depending on the time of year, in those few weeks we are roughly going to process probably close to 20% of our permits, maybe in like eight or so percent of the time. So it is going to depend on how quickly we are able to respond, but our goal is to be as responsive as possible to everyone who submits.

(00:20:49)

I mean, I appreciate that. But if it is typical for you all to not approve or deny until closer to the date, let us just say if I am a community-based organization, a small group, and we have limited resources and we work hard to plan this event that is supposed to happen within our local park, and then it is not until a few days before that we hear, "Hey, you cannot have your event, it has been denied" — does the Parks Department not see that as problematic?

(00:21:20)

So I think in instances like that, when we think about denials, denials have been historically... we have looked back over the past several years. It has been less than 1% of the permits that we have processed. So we are in the range. Actually, my eyes are not as good as they were. I am realizing that in 2022 we processed 23,948 permits and 47 were denied. In 2023 we processed 23,844 permits and 18 were denied. In 2024 we processed 23,507 permits and 37 were denied. In 2025 we processed 24,241 permits and 23 were denied. So it is a small percentage.

I want you to know that when we approach permitting, our goal and the directive from Mark, our Commissioner, is to find a pathway to yes. So we work as hard as we possibly can to find alternatives so that we do not have to deny. But it is true, Council Member, there will be instances exactly like the one you described, and we want to keep working to make sure that we are doing better and doing as well as we can.

To that end, one thing that we are proud of, that the Commissioner is proud of, is that if you were to look us up on the website and you wanted to find your borough office, right away you would find a phone number, you would find a person to call. And you could get on the phone and you could speak to a special events associate and ask them about your problems and they would tell you what the latest was and try to work with you toward a solution. But also, if there is an organization that you are working with that has called you, please tell Ann and me, and we want to work with them because we deeply care about them having the best experience and we want to make things work for them as well as possible.

(00:23:26)

I appreciate that. Given the less than 1% of denials, does the data demonstrate the locations of those denials by borough?

(00:23:36)

So yeah, that can be one of the instances in which... you hit it exactly. If someone applies for an event in the park — and I think this would be like a bigger event, so I am not talking about a picnic or a family gathering or even a wedding — but because they wanted to do something that was larger and it just was too big for the park, or it was inappropriate for the landscape. The example that comes to mind is, I think a year or two ago we got a request to do a polo match with horses on the Great Lawn and we could not approve it. We had to deny that because it was just not appropriate for the landscape to have the horses.

(00:24:24)

Can Parks provide the data based on location of the denials? Yes, yes, sir. Okay. Also, I want to just acknowledge that we have been joined by Council Member... All right, I do want to, before I go to CM Morano, you mentioned that you can call the permit office and speak to a permit representative. I do want to talk about the permit offices just briefly. How many folks are assigned to each permit office by borough?

(00:25:00)

Bear with me just for a moment. In Staten Island there are three coordinators. In Queens there are six. In Manhattan there are eight. In Brooklyn... and in the Bronx there are eight. Okay, I just want to make sure I have this correct. Staten Island there are three, Queens there are six, Manhattan there are eight, Brooklyn there are five, the Bronx there are eight. Is that correct? That is by borough.

(00:25:39)

Yes. Okay. Out of curiosity, why does Brooklyn only have five?

(00:25:44)

So I would have to get back to you on the precise amounts. You know, there are a few fluctuations in staffing.

(00:25:53)

I can tell you in Brooklyn they had a longstanding director, Nancy Melissa, who was a wonderful colleague and so knowledgeable about Brooklyn Parks. She had spent years working in Brooklyn doing the permitting system and she recently retired. Then one of her colleagues moved on to become the director of the permit office in Manhattan. So they may be a little bit lower because of that staffing transition, but we are happy to follow up with your office and get back to you more precisely.

(00:26:26)

I appreciate that. Given that the permit offices tend to be the front-facing division or unit within the Parks Department engaging with community members and various cultures, are they required to take any type of cultural training?

So every employee that starts with Parks goes through an orientation for two days and part of that orientation involves sensitivity training and cultural training, and wanting to make sure that we are always interacting with the public in the most positive way possible. I can tell you, Council Member, that is a top priority for the Commissioner. I can also say that with regard to our citywide special events, training is... as soon as after the parade and the marathon, there is a little bit of a better time to do retraining and we are going to be retraining with our staff in the citywide events. So it is not just when we start, but it is making sure that we are updating those trainings and refreshing them and doing that time and time again. Our goal is to be the best that we can possibly be as public servants, and that means when the public or when a Council Member interacts with us, that they feel good about that experience.

(00:27:45)

Are the trainings led by outside organizations or are they conducted in house?

(00:27:55)

They are conducted in house. We have a dedicated team that is the Parks Training Academy that does trainings on customer service and several other areas where we want to make sure that our staff is able to constantly get that kind of updating. I can say they are very accomplished and they take their job very seriously and they continue to look at best practices for teaching agency personnel and updating them on standards that have evolved.

You know, I can promise you that this committee is much larger than the two of us. Would the agency be willing for the committee to sit through one of the trainings?

(00:28:41)

Right. I believe so. But Gabriella, do...

(00:28:43)

Yeah. Thank you, Council Member. That is something I would have to check with the Parks Academy. I am not sure what our track record is for doing that in the past, but I am happy to get back to you on that.

(00:28:54)

Okay. Thank you. I believe you mentioned Ann represents citywide. I do have a question for you, and then I am going to turn it over to my colleague for some questions and I will jump back in.

Elected officials tend to host several events within parks across the City. One of the events that we attend and host, particularly around August and September, are back-to-school giveaways, partnering with local nonprofits and sometimes some private partners as well to give book bags to the community. Typically when you all are reviewing such a permit, what are the questions that are asked of the elected official's office or whomever is hosting this back-to-school giveaway in the park? Thank you, Council Person.

(00:30:02)

We ask questions about their site layout, their production schedule, when vendors are going to be arriving, if there is any run of show and a speaking portion, when they are setting up, the location for the giveaway, making sure that they are sufficiently staffed and there is a line set up so that there is an orderly way to receive the backpacks by the public. So questions like that.

(00:30:31)

Is it a common practice for the department to ask the applicant the value of the book bags?

(00:30:46)

That is a question that we do ask.

(00:30:48)

What is the reason for it?

(00:30:52)

Just to understand the price point of the item that is going to be given away. But really, a lot of times with giveaways, the value is not as important as making sure you have enough for the public that is going to be coming to the giveaway, so that there is not a point during the event where we have run out and you have a long line of people waiting. We want to make sure that folks are receiving the giveaway and able to partake in the actual excitement of the event. So those sorts of questions are asked, and they are a lot of times also asked by our security partners at NYPD as well as the Mayor's Office. These are common questions.

(00:31:41)

NYPD and the Mayor's Office ask about the quantity that is sufficient for the expected attendance of your event. Excuse my short memory. What was the reason for asking the value of the book bags?

(00:31:59)

Just to make sure that there is an understanding of the value of the item that is being given away, Council Member. I think, you know, in certain instances every event has its different components. There will be some judgment calls. Notwithstanding anything that my colleagues said, I think the key sentiment here is that whether it is an elected official or a member of the public, our goal is that we want that person to have a positive takeaway from their experience. If they are asked a question that makes them feel less than positive, we want to understand that and we want to do better next time.

A lot of our special event associates are early on in their career. They are learning this complicated work. There is a lot to know here because each event is a little bit different. I can assure you that if a question like that comes up, it is not coming from a bad place, but it does not mean that it is necessarily the right question in that moment and in that situation. So in any instance, whether it is an elected official or whether it is a member of the public, we want to do our best every single day to make sure that the way that they are experiencing that interaction with the public servant is positive.

I suspect if we were to talk about it, there are probably other questions we could have asked to get the same amount of information and to have that person feel better about it. So just know that everything we do is trying to come from the best place, but we also want to learn from things that we have not done correctly in the past to be better in the future. I am personally dedicated to working with you, any of your colleagues, and Anna as well, or any other stakeholders and event applicants, so that we are able to help them proceed with their events in the best way possible and in a way that people feel positive.

(00:34:07)

I appreciate that. I just want to kind of walk back a little bit to the Parks Academy training. When we are talking about questions that are posed to applicants who are applying for permits, does that process go through the Parks Academy sensitivity training as well? Is that reviewed by any staff members or is it just something that is...

(00:34:38)

...made up within that team or division or unit of people?

(00:34:43)

That is a good question, Council Member. I will have to get back to you on the exact layout of the training and the different areas and scenarios that are covered during the training.

(00:34:51)

Okay. Thank you for that. I want to acknowledge that we have been joined by Council Member Chris Marte. All right, I do not want to take up all the time, so I am going to turn it over to CM Morano.

(00:35:02)

Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Deputy Commissioner, for your testimony. I want to start with something that I would not have thought to ask you about but for your testimony, and it is something that I actually think is good news. You said that fewer than 1% of special event permit applications are denied, and I am certainly glad to hear Parks is generally willing to work with people rather than looking for reasons to tell them no. Because obviously if you are a civic association, a veterans group, a youth group, whoever, or just a family trying to have an event in your neighborhood park, the last thing you need is another City bureaucracy making your life more difficult.

But the one question that I guess I never thought of is that statistic raises somewhat of a different question for me. If the system is designed to get almost every applicant to yes, who in the process is representing the person who never submitted an application? The applicant has somebody advocating for their event obviously. Who is advocating for the kid that shows up Saturday morning wanting to use the field, or the senior who is walking the same path every morning? Who is advocating for the family that shows up at the park and discovers that the place that they normally use is not available? Where does that person exist, if anywhere, in the permitting process?

(00:36:23)

That is an excellent question, Council Member, and it is something that we think about. We really do rely on the public to tell us if there are concerns about an event. Generally, when that does happen, it tends to be with bigger events. The example of the kid who wants to use a field — admittedly, that is separate from this office. Her colleagues do the special events, and our other colleague Ken Conyers does athletic fields and permits. But I know that in that system they do prioritize youth permits.

In instances like that, if it is a field, chances are it is used by a youth group. For something like baseball, it is harder to do a pickup game, but that does not mean that someone would not be there with a friend or parent just to hit the ball around or play catch. So we do want to strike a balance. We also have close contact with the bureau permit offices, who are not separate from the rest of the borough team. They are there with the bureau commissioner, with the park managers, and they are always talking about what they are seeing in the parks.

So it could come up through there, or it could also come up through the public calling us — calling the borough office, calling 311, calling the special events office. But generally, if there is feedback like "hey, this is a little bit too much," it would be around some of the larger events.

(00:37:55)

I think it is particularly important in the outer boroughs — places like Staten Island — where if you lose access to a particular field or park space, there is not necessarily another comparable one blocks away. So does Parks actually measure displacement beyond the anecdotal example that you cited? Do you know how often permitted events cause regular park programming or ordinary recreational activity to be moved or canceled?

(00:38:26)

Thank you for that question. It is another really good question. I cannot tell you that I have had that question posed to me before. Offhand, it would be a hard thing to measure. But one thing we do before we permit is we look for conflicts, and that is something that you can look at to see: is there other programming here, is there another permitted event here, is the agency doing something? So that we are not inadvertently making a mistake — like, we are going to permit your event, but our colleagues in public programs were also doing a Shape Up program. So we can avoid those things. I think it is harder...

(00:39:10)

It is harder to look at displacement without knowing who the user was that had wanted to use that space. But if there is a specific park, a specific field or other amenity that you are hearing about that maybe we have not heard about, we will work with your office, we will work with your team, and we will be in touch with that individual if you want to share their information, to figure out what is happening and to try and find the right balance.

In that vein, the committee's briefing says that Parks considers not just the event itself but preparation and cleanup time when determining the impact on ordinary park users. So here is a number that I would really like to know, and I think you probably do have access to: how many park days do New Yorkers lose every year to special events? And by park days, I mean the entire period when the public cannot fully use that space — setup, the event itself, breakdown and restoration. Do you track that? And if not, I think we...

(00:40:14)

...should. Yeah, that is another good question. We track the events, so we know when the event starts and when the event ends. If it is a smaller event, there is probably not going to be much setup — for a birthday party or things of that nature. If it is a larger event that involves bringing infrastructure into the park, then we will track it.

I think where it might get a little bit tricky — but, Council Member, not to say that we could not start to figure something out — is that oftentimes it is not the entire park that is being taken offline. It is just a portion of it. I also just want to mention, and I apologize that I did not really get into the specifics in the testimony, but just for reference: we have found that this tends to hold true over the years — 75% of the permits that we process are going to be for 100 people or less, and 95% of them are going to be for 500 people or less.

Even though 500 people is not a tiny amount, those are events that we have generally found are going to be less impactful on the experience of other park users. But not to say that that cannot happen, and also to your very good point, not to say that that could not happen within an athletic field or those types of spaces. I just want to stress that we are ready and willing to work with you, your team and any constituents if they have concerns about being displaced, because as much as humanly possible we want a system that works for everybody.

(00:41:59)

Thanks very much. Thank you.

(00:41:59)

Before I go to CM Lee, I do want to just jump on that bandwagon really quickly and ask a couple of follow-up questions. You mentioned that the Parks Department has to collaborate with other City agencies oftentimes for permits. What does that collaborative process look like between the agencies? Thank you for that.

(00:42:24)

Question, Council Member. What it looks like can change from time to time. Generally it is for events that are going to be larger in scale, that will be over 500 people. And what it looks like...

(00:42:41)

...is a site visit with other agencies that are impacted. In many cases it is the NYPD. If there are generators or things like that being used, it could be FDNY. If there is food, it could be the Department of Health. If there is a stage or a tent of a large size — I want to say 10 or 12 feet, but do not hold me to that — it could be the Department of Buildings. If it is more involved than that, it will involve inter-agency meetings with the Mayor's Office for citywide event coordination and management. That could be a series of meetings where one meeting will focus on security, another meeting will focus on transportation and how we are getting everybody there — and of course the MTA would be part of that. Another meeting would talk about how they are advertising and promoting the event. And then there will be sub-parts: for a large-scale event, we have to share the talent and the performers with NYPD so they can review and make sure that they are comfortable with...

(00:43:53)

...it. It just varies. Thank you. Just for my own understanding — I am going to turn it over to counsel briefly. If I am applying for an event permit, and I am serving food and I have amplified sound, is that going to require me to apply for a permit from the Parks Department, a sound permit from the Police Department, a vendor permit from the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, and let us say I am selling merchandise — T-shirts or something — from Parks? Is that going to require four separate permit applications? Or is there a centralized location where I just put in one application and it kind of checks off the boxes?

(00:44:51)

It is the former, unfortunately, Council Member. We have not reached that level of sophistication. I would say perhaps the only caveat is that if you are working with a food element, if you are working with a mobile vendor, they already have their permits in place. In which case it would just be a matter of sharing that documentation with Parks as part of the permitting process.

(00:45:35)

Got it. Okay, thank you for that. Has the agency considered working with — I want to say it is DoITT — to explore ways to maybe centralize everything? Because I have received a number of calls since being in this particular role, calls from across the City, from people who tend to have a difficult time applying for a permit, especially given that they have to go to these different places and locations. They get frustrated and ultimately just throw their hands up and say forget it. The community then loses out on what I think would be valuable services and community events, because the process seems like it is working against them and not necessarily working for them. So is that a conversation that has been had, or could potentially be had, to see if we can centralize this permit application process?

(00:46:43)

Thank you very much for the question. I do not believe that is a conversation that we have initiated with them yet. We have focused on a lot of other process improvements. I just want to say, first of all, if there are Council Members in your district or in a district of one of your colleagues, we are happy to either come in person to give a presentation on the process and have our bureau colleagues join us as well. We are also happy to do that remotely, depending on someone's schedule — we can do that during the day or later in the day — to help walk them through that process.

We are continuing to make enhancements to the application system itself, similar to some recent enhancements that have been made on the ball field and athletic permits side of the application process, so that people have a better sense of when they submit an application whether that location is already reserved with another special event permit. But yes, we can certainly look into what the process would be to try and simplify things for, like, an amplified sound permit or maybe a permit from the Fire Department.

(00:47:53)

Thank you for that. I want to just mention that we have been joined by CM Salaam online and now CM Pierina Ana Sanchez in person. At this time I will turn it over to CM Lee.

(00:48:08)

Hello. I just want to second CM Hankerson's request to try to look into joining applications and making it more efficient. I would love to do that with other agencies as well, not just Parks. So I just want to second that.

I also have the great fortune to have amazing parks in my district — we have Alley Pond, Cunningham. We are actually doing a health fair in Cunningham Park this Sunday, which should be exciting. I asked my staff in particular, knowing the topic, what are some pain points or challenges that even our office runs into when applying for these permits. But before I ask that question, can you go back to — and I know that Chair Hankerson asked this — how many folks are in the events permitting office in Queens again? One? Sorry, in Queens it is six. Six. Okay.

And then for the larger events that need to go to the City special events team, how many folks are there? Eight. Eight. Okay. Let me ask some oddly specific questions, sorry. Because I did not even know what a winger wagon was. I know that there is now a fee of $721 that we would be charged and would have to use from our office budgets if we wanted to have a winger wagon at one of our events. So...

(00:49:45)

...I am just wondering when that charge was added and why. If you could go a little bit into that. Thank you for the question, and I have to admit that before I started doing this work I did not know what a winger wagon was either, so you are not alone in that.

The policy, I believe, was updated in the prior fiscal year. But if it is okay, I would like to walk you through what the rationale was. When you have a winger wagon — which, for your other colleagues, it is a mobile stage — they are sizable. I do not recall the exact dimensions off the top of my head, but it is kind of like driving a trailer truck. So you need a vehicle called a tractor to bring the winger wagon from one location to another, and to drive that you need a special driver's license — a commercial driver's license. There are only a select number of people in each borough who have that, and they tend to be the park supervisors. Generally speaking, on any given day there is about one park supervisor in a district, and those are the people who drive our packers and heavy duty vehicles.

So what we realized, when we were looking at our park ratings and our ability to clean parks, is that we were taking these people out of the park effectively for an entire day. Because when you are getting a winger wagon, you have to get the tractor first, then you have to drive it over to the wagon — because they tend to be in separate places, as the tractors are used for other activities as well. Then you have to drive it to the event location, and not only that, you have to take an additional staff person with you. Because when you are driving that around, it is not unusual for the location where the winger wagon would be unfolded to be in the interior of a park, and that means we need someone else out there making sure that no one is injured, that there are no kids driving by on scooters or anything. So you are effectively taking two staff people for the entire day. It has become something that is a big time commitment, and we take those people out of their regular duties — they are not driving our heavy equipment, they are not driving our packers, they are not able to pick up the trash or respond to any other needs within a park district.

(00:52:26)

So what we have had to do is call people in on overtime in order to provide those services. We still want to provide them, and we do that with you and your colleagues in the City Council and with other agencies. But it had just reached a point where operationally it became challenging.

(00:52:45)

That makes sense, given the staffing requirements and the fact that it does require such a specialized license. Thank you for clarifying that. And then also, for events that our offices host — like, for example, the one we are doing on Sunday with our health fair, or family fun days, that kind of thing — I know that if we have bouncy houses or other things like that, it requires that 500-person threshold. Can you go a little bit more into why that 500-person threshold is needed for things like bouncy houses, and also what other things sort of trigger that 500-person threshold? Thank you for bringing that up.

(00:53:29)

Council Member, that is something I wanted to mention. Correct me if I am wrong, but I believe that we have lowered that number. It...

(00:53:40)

...is no longer 500. I believe it is now 200, so it is much more accessible for smaller events. We had heard from you and from your colleagues that that was a little bit of a challenge, and we took another look at it and we have changed it.

I can tell you, I am a very proud parent, and when my kids see a bouncy house it is like there is a gravitational pull — you cannot tell them no. And so what we have also found is that when we permitted these, it really depends on who the contractor is. We have had times when these things have tipped over and kids have gotten hurt and broken bones. So we are trying to manage that. With Council Members, it is something that is continuing. There is not — and I think in a previous iteration there was a limit on the number of bouncy houses, but that is not something we are utilizing now. We have lowered the capacity to 200. I hope that is helpful. We do have a public programs team that does bouncy houses internally.

(00:55:03)

We both started to see instances tick up where — not certainly through Council Members' offices, but just when people were having them — there were accidents that seemed preventable, and we wanted to try and have a little bit more regulation.

(00:55:18)

I appreciate that, and my constituents will be very happy to hear that. Thank you so much.

(00:55:24)

I also want to mention that we have been joined by CM Santosuosso and CM Ung online. I think that is it. All right, I will now turn it over to CM Pierina Ana Sanchez.

(00:55:40)

Thank you, Chair, and good morning. Thank you for being here. Prior to — well, many years before becoming a Council Member — I worked at a community-based organization where I had the unfortunate responsibility of having to apply for all of our permits when we were having events in parks and whatnot. As always, just a general love for the park staff and all that they do with the limited resources that we will have until the Parks budget gets to 1% of the budget, which I still think we should be fighting for every day. But I do have two questions related to the process. The first is, I know you all ask for 21 days in advance — sometimes that 21 days, it takes a full 21 days for the permit to be approved, sometimes it does not. Is there an expectation set when you start working with an organization, saying here is the outline of what this permitting process looks like, here is the stage we are in now, sort of here is what you can expect as you go through this process? Thank you very much. I think when someone applies for a...

(00:56:46)

...permit, they are going to get a response from the agency the same day, acknowledging receipt of that permit and letting them know that we are working on processing it. There is some ancillary information that talks about what — I believe, depending on the applicant — if it is an applicant that is less familiar with the process, it may not be quite as much. Something that we have done over the last few years is this kind of road show where we have met with partner groups and with other stakeholders who are producing events. It is the team from citywide, it is the borough team, it is the park managers, it is the bureau commissioner. We really try to come with everybody from the agency who is involved in events to answer questions, and we are happy to do that with any of your stakeholders.

We are happy to do it in person, we are happy to do it remotely, whatever you find to be convenient. And if through that process there are other things that we could do — maybe it is adding information to our website, we have recently changed our website to make the process more clear and easy to understand. I think when you have been in government for a while there are some good things about it, but there are also some bad things about it, because you see these policies and you are like, yeah, okay, I know what this means. But that does not mean that someone who is applying for an event for the first time, or even the third or fourth time, has really memorized this stuff. So we want to make sure we are keeping that in mind — not just in the back of our mind, but at the front of our mind.

So feedback from you and from your colleagues on the Council, from your stakeholders, about what else we can do — I want you to know that in each one of those instances we have taken it and we have tried to incorporate it. We have updated our website, we have changed the application periods to allow applicants to apply earlier for events that they are planning in the future. We also have a bilingual pamphlet to help people for whom English is not their first language understand what they need to do for a permit. Any other feedback that you have, we want to try to incorporate and make this process better and better.

(00:59:11)

I am happy to hear about this sort of road show approach that I did not know existed. Have you ever partnered with Council Members' offices to sit in the offices and then have organizations that regularly apply for permits come and go through...

(00:59:27)

...the process? We have notified Council Members when we are doing it, and I know that some of my colleagues earlier this year did one for the Queens Borough President. But yes, we are happy to partner with your office or others to amplify the message and get the word out.

(00:59:49)

I cannot be the only one. I am sure I am looking at people going, will you help us apply for a permit? So it sort of indicates to me that maybe a model where — obviously with limited time and limited resources — a model where you all were to come to our offices and there could be organizations that could have appointments just to sit with you and go through it themselves and kind of learn how to do it, so that they could do it themselves as opposed to coming to our offices. We would be happy to do that. Logistically it would be helpful if you...

(01:00:22)

...would work with us. Yeah, you will help them get the word out and then...

(01:00:26)

...perhaps a meeting where we present the process and then they can ask questions, and we will answer...

(01:00:34)

...them. I love that. And then pivoting a little bit, my other question was about general liability insurance, which, if I recall, is required in the process of applying for the permit. Have you heard feedback recently from any organizations that the cost of that, or anything about that process, is preventative for them in terms of applying for or securing a permit?

(01:00:57)

Thank you for that question. Yeah, insurance comes up quite a bit. I do want to emphasize that 95% of the events that we process permits for are for events with attendees under 500 people. So that means that if you want to do a birthday party, there is no insurance requirement. You get the permit and that is it. So we are talking about 5% or less of events where insurance is going to come...

(01:01:29)

...up. But yeah, people have shared that information with us and we have worked with our colleagues in our general counsel's office. When it comes to insurance, it is something that is a little bit out of our hands in the special events office, because our counsel then talks to the Law Department about coverages and they collectively determine whether or not there is flexibility about why something requires insurance and, if it does require it, what that coverage amount should be. But yeah, we do hear that — it is not unusual.

(01:02:03)

Okay, all right, thank you so much. And just with my last few seconds, I am going to go on record and apologize to whoever Nancy is in the special events office from 2013 to 2016 who had to deal with me doing last-minute permits for large events. It was Brooklyn. It was Nancy Melissa — yes, Ted, thank you. Thank you, Nancy Melissa, I am so very sorry. Oh good, I am so glad. Good for her, and congratulations Nancy Melissa. I probably did make her retire, so sorry. Thanks for all your work. I do want...

(01:02:37)

...to just go back to your testimony. Again, you mentioned that in early 2025 you hosted a series of nine partner input forums in all five boroughs. Just out of curiosity, who was invited to these forums?

(01:02:51)

We had over 140 attendees. It was our partner groups citywide — 140, yes, citywide. It was a lot of our partner groups, of which there are many. We would be happy to share the list of invitees.

(01:03:07)

How were the invitees...

(01:03:08)

...selected? We worked with our partnerships team and our lead on strategic partnerships to help make sure that we were getting all of the people who are engaged in the event process. I can get...

(01:03:23)

...back to you on that. I did not personally do the outreach element of it, but I know there was a broad outreach and then also other stakeholders who we know do events and have raised questions with us in the past. Because I am just thinking that it would have been helpful to invite all those who had applied for permits in the previous year — whether they were approved or denied — just so that they can get a better understanding, because even if they were approved they may have had a set of challenges that could have been addressed in a forum. So it is just a thought.

(01:04:07)

Oh, CM, I was just going to say — we did. We did the last three years of applicants. Got it. Thank you.

(01:04:18)

That is great. How common is it for unpermitted events to occur, and what is the enforcement practice that is implemented when one is taking place? That is a good question...

(01:04:32)

...and it is hard to be forthright — it is hard to know exactly how many unpermitted events there are, because people would not have gone through the application system. Because of social media, we do hear about these things from time to time. Sometimes it is very sudden and late when we do learn of something. When we can identify the person or the entity that is promoting that event, we reach out to them and we work with our counsel's office and we send them a cease and desist letter. Wherever possible, if we can get in touch with them, we will call them first to let them know that we have to send this letter and to let them know they can apply for a permit. I do not want to say anything that is incorrect, but I think in a number of cases they are not trying to do anything illegal...

(01:05:45)

...they just do not know.

(01:05:48)

Sure. We see that oftentimes with runs — running events like this. Apologies, I just do not remember the name of the store, but there are sneaker stores and they do runs, but the run is at the park and it is like a hundred or 200 people. Okay, you need a permit. And also with social media, whether it is an individual or an organization, they have a lot of followers. While they can ask their followers to register, you never know how many people are going to show up. If you have too many people show up, that can create other obstacles. And then on top of that, they could be planning a run when there is already an event planned in that area that would add to congestion and kind of...

(01:06:38)

...impact things. I do have a follow-up to that — and you are right, I have seen some of the runs happening, to which I say I need to join, and I do not. But I do have a follow-up: if a permitted event is happening and there is an unpermitted event also happening, or one that is making use of bouncy houses or things they are not supposed to, is there a number for them to call to complain? I am only asking because recently we received a phone call from an organization that, for lack of a better term, went through hell to get a permit and then were denied certain things like a bouncy house, et cetera. They were in the park on the day of their event and there was another event happening that had all of those things. They called me and said, what can you do? I was not really sure what to tell them or who they could call other than 311. Is there a line for them to call? Is there any type of notification in...

(01:07:44)

...the park that says, hey, if you need assistance with something, call this number?

(01:07:53)

Thank you for that question. I am really sorry to hear that that happened — that is disappointing. We have, I think informally, a system, but I could not tell you that if you asked this question of three other people you would not get three slightly different answers. So I think you are raising a point there where we could be stronger. But I think...

(01:08:20)

...what I would suggest is that the person who issued their permit — if they are in Queens, they would know the Queens team, maybe it was Myra or others — they would call them and then we would get in touch with our parks enforcement and speak to the event organizer. But I think you raise a point of something that we should look into more and see what kind of system we could develop...

(01:08:53)

...because that is very disappointing, and I apologize on behalf of the agency for that experience.

(01:08:59)

I appreciate that, and I would love, with my limited experience, to be part of that conversation on what we can do, because it does happen quite often. Does the department keep track of event promoters that have some sort of negative history attached to them? And if so, how does that factor in determining whether they are approved for permits?

(01:09:29)

Thank you for that question. We have a lot of events that are permitted throughout our parks, as you know. As far as I know, there is not language in the rules related to who has a history or who does not have a history of problematic events. So it is not something that we can point to in the rules. I can tell you that we do rely on firsthand experience when there are instances of an event holder that has clearly not met the requirements of their contract when they do have...

(01:10:15)

...a contract. So I should stop for a moment, just like an...

(01:10:19)

...I am putting this in context. We are talking about the minority of events where it is a larger event. If it is a birthday party, if it is a family gathering and they have got a permit, this is not what we are talking about. We are talking about the larger events. If someone is having an event and they are inviting 3,000 or 4,000 people because there is going to be music, and then at the end of the event they do not clean up and they just leave everything there — that is where we work very closely with our borough offices. We have had instances where we had to pay for overtime for a dozen parks employees to stay past midnight to clean up because the event producer did not pick up the garbage. They did not bag the garbage, they did not hire anyone to take the garbage away. So in instances like that we will suspend the applicant and not allow them to submit for a period of time — roughly a year — and then if they do it again it could be more.

(01:11:30)

I was going to say, if there is park staff on site they will take pictures, so that is photographic evidence. Then we will follow up with a violation letter after the fact if it is a permitted event, to let them know that they were in violation of their permit and share the photo documentation. It is then taken into consideration for the next year if they apply again. If it is really egregious it could be up to a two-year suspension, but most of the time the violation letters serve as physical documentation — put it in writing, share it with the applicant, and work with them so they can do better next time so that they can be welcomed back to the parkland. If they were not cleaning up, that they are hiring — perhaps having volunteers or hiring a cleanup crew to actually be dedicated to cleaning up the event.

(01:12:27)

How would that work for groups that are not permitted? Is there any type of reprimand for them, or is it difficult to figure out who they are because they do not have a permit? Is there...

(01:12:38)

...any type of measure in place to reprimand those types of groups? We would have to take a look at that and get back to the Council Member. Thank you for asking that. I mean, I think we would have to know about the event in order to document it. It is possible that we would have staff at the park who observed it, and in those cases I suspect they would call our parks enforcement office to issue summonses. But if we are at a point where the event happened and we did not know about it and we did not document it, it becomes much harder for us to hold people like that...

(01:13:18)

...accountable. Understood. I am going to speed it up a little because I know we do have public testimony and we are going on 90 minutes now. So I am going to ask a few more questions and then I will open up public testimony and then we will close this hearing. How does the department and NYPD determine the security needs for a...

(01:13:36)

...certain event? How often are park officers or park rangers assigned to work events? Thank you for that question.

(01:13:47)

As I had mentioned, the vast majority of our permits — 75% — are for less than a hundred people, and 95% are for less than 500 people. There is very unlikely to be a need for NYPD or for Parks enforcement. Depending on staffing availability and depending on other factors, it is possible that we would ask our Parks enforcement to be present. That is for larger events, certainly like a Global Citizens or a City Marathon. There will be kind of all hands on deck for parades as well. For smaller events, oftentimes we are looking for the event producer to provide a certain level of security. We will consult with NYPD for other events. NYPD would assess during the site visit what their proper staffing levels should be when it comes to matters of security. Admittedly, we are pretty deferential to the police department about what they believe is necessary.

(01:15:03)

Thank you. Sorry.

(01:15:05)

Just to add: for the very large scale events, they all have to provide private security, and those private security companies have to work with NYPD to create a robust security plan.

(01:15:17)

What are the most common reasons that the department has typically denied applications? Thank you for that question, Council Member.

(01:15:25)

I think the most common reason — and I believe we are actually following up with your office on one of the items regarding denials — but I think probably the most common reason would be the location. If someone wanted to do an event for 20,000 people and the park historically has not done an event for more than 2,000 people because of the size, that would be an area where we would ultimately need to deny it if they did not want to relocate the event to a more appropriately sized park.

(01:16:03)

What factors determine whether the department has to shut down an event? How often has this happened in the past for large events, and how many instances in the last year have been prematurely closed?

(01:16:16)

Good questions, Council Member. We have not tracked it on an ongoing basis. We could certainly do that. Looking back is, you know...

(01:16:28)

It was in the press — the Global Citizens event of last weekend was canceled due to weather. I think weather is the most common occurrence as the reason for why an event would be shut down or in any way impacted in terms of its plan. Even with all the technology we have, sometimes the weather surprises us. That has happened to us a number of times. We work really closely with the event producer and with other City agencies, including the Office of Emergency Management and NYPD, depending on what the forecasts are.

I should add that for larger events, from years of experience, we now require larger events to have a meteorologist on site so that they can advise us of exactly what the weather is. If there is, like, cloud-to-ground lightning, that is a very big concern for us. There are times when we have advised holding the opening of the show. Fortunately, now with social media, a lot of the event producers can blast out messages in a matter of moments, and so the attendees know the show is going to start a few hours later. There have been other times when we will end early because we see that there is a storm coming, and we will work with the event producer — they have to cut some of the acts — but they end the show a couple of hours early in order to avoid a...

(01:18:10)

...storm. Who hires the meteorologists — is it Parks or is it the applicant? It is the applicant. Really? Yeah.

(01:18:15)

What do you find?

(01:18:17)

There is one meteorologist who used to work for New York. One, really? Yeah, he is there. He is a nice guy.

(01:18:28)

They are interesting. It is always tricky knowing the weather. Even if you have a storm cloud over you, the meteorologist will say, "I think this is going to pass, it looks like it is going to pass," but whether it passes in an hour or whether it passes in 20 minutes is hard to know. That is really...

(01:18:46)

...interesting. Thanks for sharing that. What is...

(01:18:55)

...a review process after an event is concluded to determine whether it was successful or not? Thank you for that...

(01:19:02)

...question. For the smaller events, there is not much of a process. We just want those events to happen. We want people to have fun. We issued a permit, they have the event, and there is not really a follow-up.

For larger events, we will do site inspections and we seek to do those site inspections immediately after load-out, so they are contemporaneous in terms of the timeline. That way we know that there are no other things that could have caused damage if there was damage. We will do those sometimes with our colleagues who do park inspections, with the event producer themselves, with the park administrators and park managers in the borough, and with our partners if there is a partner organization that cares for the park. We are always documenting it through photos and comparing them to the conditions before. The expectation and the standard is that the park be returned to the public in the same condition that it was before the event took place.

We also, for very large scale events, do interagency debriefs with all the City agencies that are part of the planning of the events. The same group that was part of the planning leading up to the event and who were on site during the event all debrief virtually after to talk about lessons learned and things that we could do to improve for next year.

AI-generated summaries and transcripts. Errors are possible.
Verify against the linked video and send corrections via email.