Hearing Hearings — Hearing Record ✉
← All hearings

The State of Water Safety at the City's Beaches and Pools

Committee on Parks and Recreation

Chair: Ty Hankerson

Meeting overview

The Council's Committee on Parks and Recreation held an oversight hearing on water safety at City beaches and pools, alongside four pieces of legislation. The session was chaired by Ty Hankerson, with CM Krishnan the most active legislative sponsor present. The Parks Department was represented by First Deputy Commissioner Mark Folk, Chief of Special Programs Bonnie Williams, and the Chief of Citywide Legislative Affairs.

The headline news from Parks was genuinely good: 1,174 certified lifeguards in summer 2026, the most since the pandemic, zero drownings or fatalities during supervised hours, and a record attendance season spanning 114 days, the longest in a decade. Folk was not shy about stating these numbers, twice. The department's retention rate has also improved to 79%, up from roughly 70% historically, and lifeguard pay now starts just below $23 per hour with a $1,000 retention bonus for those who complete the season. The department has also expanded recruitment and training to all five boroughs, having previously concentrated it in Manhattan, and has launched its 2027 recruitment campaign with qualifying tests opening December 1.

The legislative picture was more complicated. On Int 0262-2026, which would extend the beach and outdoor pool season to begin in mid-April and run to mid-October, with daily hours extended to 8pm, Parks raised three substantive objections: temperatures in the extended period often run 52-60 degrees Fahrenheit and demand would be negligible; the overwhelming majority of lifeguard staff are teachers, college students, and high school students who are unavailable outside the current season window; and extending daily hours to 8pm would require swimmers to be in the water after dusk, when lifeguards cannot see them. Folk was direct that extending hours within the existing season is more feasible than extending the season itself, but even that would require substantially more than the current 1,400 target lifeguards, since 1,400 supports only a single eight-hour shift. He acknowledged that if the Council passed such a law without funding and staffing, he frankly did not know what would happen. CM Morano pressed the department on whether a pilot program at select high-demand beaches might be a more workable approach; Parks did not reject this but indicated staffing constraints would apply regardless. Morano also pointed out the obvious gap in the department's otherwise triumphant statistics: Parks does not track drownings outside supervised hours, which is tracked by NYPD and the Department of Health. Zero fatalities during supervised hours is a real achievement; total summer drowning deaths is a different number and was not provided.

On the rip current signage bills, Int 0957-2026 and T2026-2714, Parks noted that only Rockaway Beach is classified as a true ocean beach subject to rip currents, and that it already posts NOAA advisory posters at all beach restrooms and large vinyl banners at Rockaway specifically. The department expressed concern that blanket digital signage across all 200-plus beach entrances would be prohibitively expensive and technically difficult to maintain in a beach environment, and that it had not yet costed this out because the bill was introduced only the previous week. OMB is reportedly preparing a fiscal impact statement. CM Morano made the reasonable observation that location-specific risk signage might actually be more useful than a one-size-fits-all approach. On T2026-2784, requiring an interactive map of swimming pool access including non-Parks facilities potentially operated by nonprofits, Parks expressed reluctance on jurisdictional grounds and cited concerns about public confusion. CM Krishnan, who sponsors both Int 0262-2026 and T2026-2784, was present briefly but left early. CM Sanchez raised a specific staffing equity issue on Coney Island's west end, noting recurring mid-season gaps in lifeguard coverage, and extracted a commitment from Parks to work on targeted NYCHA outreach for recruitment. CM Narcisse asked about drowning deaths among young people outside supervised hours, which led to the same jurisdictional gap identified by Morano. The hearing closed with an oddly timed detour into whether Parks workers shovel bus stops and fire hydrants in winter, which they do, but only on perimeter sidewalks adjacent to Parks property.

The record

Numbers
  • Summer 2026 beach season ran 114 days, 16 weeks, described as the longest in a decade.
  • 1,174 lifeguards certified for summer 2026, highest staffing level in four years.
  • Lifeguard numbers in 2022 had fallen to 770; by the start of 2023 there were only 480.
  • Approximately 900 lifeguards were hired in 2024, a year with seven drowning deaths.
  • 1,082 lifeguards staffed beaches and pools in 2025.
  • Pre-pandemic target lifeguard staffing level is approximately 1,400.
  • 1,400 lifeguards supports a single eight-hour shift at all beaches and pools; extended hours would require several hundred more.
  • Lifeguard retention rate is now 79%, up from roughly 70% historically; 865 of the 2025 cohort returned in 2026.
  • 30% of lifeguards hired in 2026 were aged 16 to 18.
  • 605 participants passed lifeguard qualifying tests in 2025 across all five boroughs.
  • Lifeguard qualifying swim test requires a 50-yard swim completed in 45 seconds.
  • Starting lifeguard pay is just below $23 per hour, described as higher than most peer beaches in New Jersey and Long Island.
  • Lifeguards receive a $1,000 retention bonus after completing their first full season through Labor Day.
  • Lifeguards perform 200-plus rescues were performed in summer 2026; zero fatalities during supervised hours.
  • Rockaway Beach accounted for 73 of 203 water-related emergencies citywide in a recent reporting period, more than a third of the total.
  • Rip currents account for over 80% of rescues performed by surf beach lifeguards nationally, per the US Lifesaving Association.
  • Over 100 deaths per year in the US are attributed to rip currents, per the US Lifesaving Association.
  • Parks operates across eight beaches with over 200 individual beach entrances.
  • It costs approximately $2.5 million per week to operate NYC beaches and pools, primarily staff costs.
  • One in three African American adults cannot swim; two in three have never taken a swimming lesson.
  • Three in four Hispanic adults report never having taken a swimming lesson.
  • Over 40 million adults in the United States do not know how to swim.
  • Crotona Pool in the Bronx closed for a renovation costing over $20 million.
  • Tony Dapolito Pool has full funding for a new recreation center with an Olympic indoor pool and new outdoor aquatic center.
  • 350-plus banners distributed to schools as part of the 2027 lifeguard recruitment campaign.
  • Over 700 mailings annually sent to stakeholders as part of lifeguard recruitment outreach.
Action Points
  • Parks Department to provide CM Morano with data on drownings at City beaches and pools outside supervised hours, sourced from NYPD and the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene.
  • Parks Department to reach out to NYCHA to develop more extensive targeted lifeguard recruitment in NYCHA developments, particularly on Coney Island's west end.
  • CM Sanchez to work with Parks Department on a targeted NYCHA recruitment effort for lifeguards on the west end of Coney Island.
  • Parks Department to develop a permanent staffing equity plan for the west end of Coney Island beaches to avoid recurring mid-season coverage gaps.
  • Parks Department to work with OMB to provide the Council with a detailed fiscal impact estimate for digital beach signage under T2026-2714, including installation, maintenance, and long-term operational costs.
  • Council Members asked to distribute Parks Department lifeguard recruitment posters delivered to their offices.
  • Parks Department lifeguard registration portal opens November 15, 2026; first qualifying tests scheduled for December 1, 2026.
  • Parks Department to continue and expand water safety assemblies by lifeguards at high schools and intermediate schools in all five boroughs.
  • CM Krishnan to review written testimony from Parks Department and public witnesses following early departure from hearing.
  • Parks Department to continue engagement with the Aquatic Lifeguard Safety Task Force in coordination with nonprofits and NYC Public Schools ahead of the 2027 season.
Download .txt
Full Transcript

(00:00:08)

Good afternoon and welcome to today's New York City Council hearing from the Committee on Parks and Recreation. At this time, I'd like to remind everyone to please kindly silence your electronic devices, and at no point approach the dais. Chair, we are ready to begin.

Thank you. Good afternoon. I'm Ty Hankerson of the Council's Committee on Parks and Recreation. Today's hearing will explore the state of water safety at the City's beaches and pools, specifically how the City fared this past season with safety issues at beaches and pools operated by the Parks Department.

Millions of people make use of the City's beaches and pools each year. In recent years, they have highlighted the extent to which our parks, pools, and beaches are crucial for New Yorkers. Attendance at pools and beaches has soared, like never before since the COVID pandemic. But whether we have enough resources to sufficiently meet the public's safety and recreational needs remains a huge question mark for our City. The City's pools and beaches represent some of the best examples of how municipal resources can be used to serve residents from all walks of life, but that doesn't mean these services have reached their full potential or adequately meet the needs of the entire City in an equitable way.

Water safety issues, specifically drownings, remain a big concern and are sadly a leading cause of death for children. But it is a preventable crisis if we can summon the will to divert enough resources to education on swimming and water safety. To highlight how much work we have to do: over 40 million adults in the United States do not know how to swim. One in three African American adults is unable to swim. Two and three African American adults report never having taken a swimming lesson, and three and four Hispanic adults report having never taken a swimming lesson.

Communities in our City that have historically been underserved educationally and economically have the highest risk of water-related injuries and death. These communities simply do not have easy access to water safety instruction and other types of water-based recreation, including in my own district.

One obvious way to ensure we improve water safety is to have enough lifeguards. Historically, the City has assigned around 1,400 lifeguards to beaches and pools throughout the City by July 4 of each season. However, a lifeguard shortage hit the City hard during the 2022 beach and pool season, and DPR could only hire 770 lifeguards. By 2023, there were only 480 lifeguards to start the season. In 2024, only about 900 were able to be hired. While some pools and beaches remained open, we had to adjust areas on beaches that could remain open to swimming during the summer. Unfortunately, 2024 was one of the most tragic seasons in recent memory, with seven drowning deaths. The City has recognized the problem and reacted by raising lifeguard pay rates and pursuing numerous efforts to start the recruitment process earlier and adjust the training regimen to increase the number of potential applicants.

The lifeguard numbers have thankfully rebounded, with 1,082 lifeguards staffing pools and beaches in 2025, and 1,100 lifeguards this most recent season. However, it seems there is still more work to be done to bring those numbers up even higher. It is crucial that we recognize the work lifeguards perform day in and day out, as they are often the primary reason there aren't even more emergencies at our beaches and pools.

However, lifeguards can only do so much, and ensuring our beaches and pools are as safe as possible requires more. That's why I'd like to ensure this hearing takes a holistic look at what more we can do on this issue. Some of these efforts include expanding water safety education and swimming lessons to more people, increasing engagement with private sector partners who have expertise in water safety, building more pools, expanding operational hours to improve access, increasing surveillance efforts, and addressing larger environmental issues so that water quality is not harmful to swimmers and beachgoers.

Thankfully, we will consider four pieces of legislation today that target some of these issues. Intro 116 would require digital signs at City beaches and City beach entrances that would display visual and play audio announcements about the dangers of rip currents and other water safety hazards. Intro 762, sponsored by CM Krishnan, would extend the length of the beach and outdoor pool season to begin on the second Saturday in May and end on the second Sunday in September, instead of the Sunday following Labor Day. Intro 957, sponsored by CM Brooks-Powers, would require the Commissioner to post informational signs about rip tides at each beach entrance, lifeguard chair, and jetty. Finally, Intro 1164, again sponsored by CM Krishnan, would require the Department to identify swimming pools under the jurisdiction of City agencies that would be feasible for nonprofit organizations to operate swimming and water safety programming at, and include those pools on the interactive map operated by the Department.

I look forward to further discussing these issues today and welcome all who have come to testify. Thank you so much. At this time, we're going to turn it over to the Administration, the Department of Parks and Recreation.

Sorry, we're going to turn it over to my colleague, CM Krishnan, for his statement.

Thank you so much, Chair. Good to be back here, nice to see you in the hot seat now, and I mean that in a good way. I've been so pleased to do this work together on our Committee, and I appreciate your leadership once again on this issue. We all know that I want to thank the Parks Department for joining us today for your testimony on this issue. This is an issue with so many nonprofit organizations here, and with the Parks Department, that the Council is laser focused on this issue. The reality is every year we see not only an issue of having safe access to water, like pools in my district that we don't have, but every year we read the stories of children who have drowned in our City's beaches. We know that water safety and addressing water safety is quite literally a matter of life and death, and swimming itself is a life-saving skill. I know all of us in City government are committed to solving this crisis together and doing all that we can. Every year, we revisit and work on ways to increase the lifeguard count, for example, and find ways to expand access to swim programs. This is yet another step forward to get to a world where we do not have to see the news in the morning and read about children suffering or dying because of our dangerous waters.

With that in mind, there are two pieces of legislation I wanted to briefly touch on today. One is to expand the pool and beach season in our City, as the hot weather stays longer, arrives earlier, and we know with climate change how important it is for New Yorkers to have access to water as temperatures heat up. For many, our beaches and pools are where New Yorkers and our families go to cool down on a hot day. One of the most important ways to make sure we can make our water safe is to actually expand the permitted pool and beach season. That's the way to make sure that when New Yorkers are getting in the water, because they will do that when the weather

(00:06:01)

gets higher, we have the resources and staffing in place to make sure the pool and beach season lines up with the reality of when New Yorkers will use the water. With that in mind, I know this is a difficult issue, and one of the issues is that we have to make sure we have enough lifeguards. I know we have made progress on that issue over my years as a Council Member, approximately, up until today, but I know there's more work to be done as well, and I remain committed to working with all of you, the Department, and everyone in this room to solving that challenge together. I know one goes, locks up with the other. We need more lifeguards. We need to create a pipeline of lifeguard training. We have to be creative about how we do so to make sure we can extend the pool season. I look forward to all of us working together to achieve that goal, because the reality is this isn't a luxury. The cost of not doing this is far too great to bear, more than simply dollars and cents. We're talking about lives at stake.

The other piece of legislation I have as well is about the Parks Department exploring the ways in which it can partner with nonprofits when it comes to swimming and some programs. I would also mention, and urge the Parks Department, as you all know, there is a phenomenal number of excellent nonprofit organizations across the City that are really filling the gaps for students, like in my own district, who don't have access to swim and water safety classes otherwise. It would be great to find ways for the Parks Department to continue to partner with and grow that collaboration between City government and the nonprofit organizations, many of whom are present today to testify.

Well, I look forward to a robust discussion on this piece of legislation as well, and to the ways in which the Parks Department can work with nonprofits on the ground to expand the pool of resources available to help children learn how to swim. Thank you all so much. I unfortunately can't stay too long at this hearing, it has been quite a day, but I will make sure that I review the testimony of both the Parks Department and the members of the public and nonprofit organizations who are here. Thank you, Chair.

(00:08:12)

Thank you. I'm going to read the testimony. I'm sorry, this statement is from CM Brooks-Powers regarding her bill.

(00:08:44)

Thank you. Sure. Chair Hankerson and members of the Committee on Parks and Recreation, thank you for including Intro 957 in this critical hearing on water safety. Intro 957 requires the Parks Department to post signs with safety information about rip currents at all bathing beaches under the Department. These signs will include information in at least four languages about the danger posed by rip currents and what to do if caught in one, as well as visual imagery.

In the Rockaways, the ocean is our front yard. Our beachfront is a beloved summer destination, seeing visitors in 2024, but that beachfront also presents a recognized danger. Every summer, our community is too often brought together to mourn those we lose. Two drownings in the most recent year. The Parks Department reported data that a lifeguard responded to 73 emergencies on Rockaway Beach, more than a third of the 203 water-related emergencies in New York City pools and beaches over that period. Our lifeguards are under a tremendous burden each summer to keep us safe, and informing beachgoers about the risk of rip currents is a common-sense preventative measure across the City. We must do more to increase safety on our waterfront. While mitigating the risk the ocean presents, Intro 957 takes a meaningful step in preventing tragedies and water-based emergencies, as rip current signage targets one of the greatest risks to beachgoers. The United States Lifesaving Association found that there are over 100 deaths each year in the U.S. attributed to rip currents, and rip currents account for over 80% of rescues performed by surf beach lifeguards. Residents of the Rockaways and the millions of beachgoers across the City each year need this potentially life-saving information at every beach entrance, lifeguard chair, and jetty.

Thank you to the advocates who continue to fight for this legislation and for water safety across New York City, including the Water Safety Coalition, Rising Tide Effect, Swim Strong Foundation, and many others. I also want to thank our local organizations advocating for increased surfing access, like Rockaway Surfers Collective and Black Surfing Rockaway, who are teaching young people in our community to enjoy our beaches safely. Thank you as well to my colleagues and the Chair for their work on this issue. I look forward to advancing this legislation. CM Brooks-Powers.

(00:09:26)

And you may begin when ready. Thank you. Good afternoon, Chair Hankerson, members of the Parks Committee, and other members of Council. My name is Mark Folk. I'm the First Deputy Commissioner and Chief Operating Officer for New York City Parks. Joining me today on my left is Chief Bonnie Williams, Chief of Special Programs, and on my right, Mattori, the Chief of Citywide Legislative Affairs.

We are pleased to be here to offer an update regarding a very successful and safe 2026 summer beach and pool season. Parks has long been committed to improving New Yorkers' quality of life through aquatic recreation, promoting health, fitness, and safety awareness at both our beaches and pools. Whether cooling off or getting fit, we know New Yorkers love to take a refreshing swim, and City beaches and pools are the primary getaway destinations for New Yorkers. Due to the timing of Memorial Day and Labor Day this year, the summer 2026 beach season was the longest in a decade. It was 114 days, which is 16 weeks, which is four full months, and New Yorkers came out in droves and took advantage of that. Four months, a record. Patrons visited our beaches and pools this year in record numbers, and we are exceedingly proud that our guests enjoyed a fun, family-friendly, clean, and safe experience at both our beaches and pools. It takes an incredibly hard-working team to make this a reality, including our maintenance and operations staff, aquatic staff, our Parks Enforcement Patrol colleagues, and most notably, our lifeguards. We are pleased to report that we certified 1,174 lifeguards this summer, the highest staffing level in four years and a close to 50% increase since 2022. Our lifeguards rose to the occasion, performing over 200 rescues, and we are extraordinarily proud to report that there were zero fatalities or drownings.

Lifeguards were on duty at their chairs at all of our beaches and pools this past summer.

Looking ahead, as the Council Member mentioned, we remain committed to returning to our pre-pandemic levels of lifeguard staffing at roughly 1,400 lifeguards, and we are diligently working to achieve that goal. We have already launched the lifeguard recruitment campaign for the summer of 2026 with the tagline "Your Strength, Their Safety, Our Team." For everyone, I'm holding up a poster which has been delivered to Council Member offices, and we welcome you to help us distribute the information about our new lifeguard recruitment campaign. We are proud that this

(00:09:32)

THE HOLES WHERE IT COMES TO STUDENTS LIKE IN MY OWN DISTRICT THAT DON'T HAVE ACCESS TO SWIM IN WATER SAFETY CLASSES OTHERWISE. IT WOULD BE GREAT TO FIND WAYS FOR THE PARKS DEPARTMENT TO CONTINUE TO PARTNER WITH AND GROW THAT COLLABORATION BETWEEN CITY GOVERNMENT AND SOME ORGANIZATIONS. MANY WHO ARE PRESENT TODAY TO TESTIFY AS

(00:09:49)

WELL, I LOOK FORWARD TO A

(00:09:52)

ROBUST DISCUSSION ON THIS PIECE OF LEGISLATION AS WELL AND TO THE WAYS IN WHICH THE PARKS DEPARTMENT CAN WORK WITH NONPROFITS ON THE GROUND TO EXPAND THE POOL OF RESOURCES AVAILABLE TO HELP CHILDREN LEARN HOW TO SWIM. THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH. I UNFORTUNATELY CAN'T STAY TOO LONG AT THIS HEARING. IT HAS BEEN QUITE A DAY, BUT I WILL MAKE SURE THAT I GET TO REVIEW THE TESTIMONY OF BOTH THE PARKS DEPARTMENT AND THE MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC AND NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS WHO ARE HERE. THANK YOU, CHAIR.

(00:10:21)

THANK YOU. I'M GOING TO READ THE TESTIMONY. I'M SORRY, THIS STATEMENT IS FROM COUNCIL MEMBER BROOKS-POWERS REGARDING HER BILL.

(00:10:28)

THANK YOU. SURE. HANKERSON

(00:10:29)

AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE ON PARKS AND RECREATION, THANK YOU FOR INCLUDING INT 0957-2026 IN THIS CRITICAL HEARING ON WATER SAFETY. THIS BILL REQUIRES THE PARKS DEPARTMENT TO POST SIGNS WITH SAFETY INFORMATION ABOUT RIP CURRENTS AT ALL BATHING BEACHES UNDER THE DEPARTMENT. THESE SIGNS WILL INCLUDE INFORMATION IN AT LEAST FOUR LANGUAGES ABOUT THE DANGER POSED BY RIP CURRENTS AND WHAT TO DO IF CAUGHT IN ONE, AS WELL AS VISUAL IMAGERY. IN THE ROCKAWAYS, THE OCEAN IS OUR FRONT YARD. OUR BEACHFRONT IS A BELOVED SUMMER DESTINATION, SEEING VISITORS IN 2024, BUT THAT BEACHFRONT ALSO PRESENTS A RECOGNIZED DANGER. EVERY SUMMER, OUR COMMUNITY IS TOO OFTEN BROUGHT TOGETHER TO MOURN THOSE WE LOSE. TWO DROWNINGS IN THE MOST RECENT YEAR. THE PARKS DEPARTMENT REPORTED DATA THAT A LIFEGUARD RESPONDED TO 73 EMERGENCIES ON ROCKAWAY BEACH, MORE THAN A THIRD OF THE 203 WATER EMERGENCIES IN NEW YORK CITY POOLS AND BEACHES OVER THAT PERIOD. LIFEGUARDS ARE UNDER A TREMENDOUS BURDEN EACH SUMMER TO KEEP US SAFE, AND INFORMING BEACHGOERS ABOUT THE RISK OF RIP CURRENTS IS A COMMON SENSE PREVENTATIVE MEASURE. ACROSS THE CITY, WE MUST DO MORE TO INCREASE SAFETY

(00:11:35)

ON OUR WATERFRONT. WHILE

(00:11:36)

MITIGATING THE RISK THE OCEAN PRESENTS, INT 0957-2026 TAKES A MEANINGFUL STEP IN PREVENTING TRAGEDIES AND WATER-BASED EMERGENCIES. RIP CURRENT SIGNAGE TARGETS ONE OF THE GREATEST RISKS TO BEACHGOERS. THE UNITED STATES LIFESAVING ASSOCIATION FOUND THAT THERE ARE OVER 100 DEATHS EACH YEAR IN THE U.S. ATTRIBUTED TO RIP CURRENTS, AND RIP CURRENTS ACCOUNT FOR OVER 80% OF RESCUES PERFORMED BY SURF BEACH LIFEGUARDS. RESIDENTS OF THE ROCKAWAYS AND THE MILLIONS OF BEACHGOERS ACROSS THE CITY EACH YEAR NEED THIS POTENTIALLY LIFE-SAVING INFORMATION AT EVERY BEACH ENTRANCE, LIFEGUARD CHAIR, AND JETTY.

(00:12:11)

ENTRANCE, ENTRANCE, LIFEGUARD CHAIR AND JETTY.

(00:12:14)

THANK YOU TO THE ADVOCATES WHO CONTINUE TO FIGHT FOR THIS LEGISLATION AND FOR WATER SAFETY ACROSS NEW YORK CITY, INCLUDING THE WATER SAFETY COALITION, RISING TIDE EFFECT, SWIM STRONG FOUNDATION, AND MANY OTHERS. I ALSO WANT TO THANK OUR LOCAL ORGANIZATIONS ADVOCATING FOR INCREASED SURFING ACCESS, LA RUE BE A COLLECTIVE AND BLACK SURFING ROCKAWAY, WHO ARE TEACHING YOUNG PEOPLE IN OUR COMMUNITY TO ENJOY OUR BEACHES SAFELY. THANK YOU AS WELL TO MY COLLEAGUES AND THE CHAIR FOR THEIR WORK ON THIS ISSUE. I LOOK FORWARD TO ADVANCING THIS LEGISLATION. COUNCIL MEMBER BROOKS-POWERS.

(00:13:12)

AND YOU BEGIN WHEN READY. THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR HANKERSON AND MEMBERS OF THE PARKS COMMITTEE AND OTHER MEMBERS OF COUNCIL. MY NAME IS MARK FOLK. I AM THE FIRST DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER FOR NEW YORK CITY PARKS. JOINING ME TODAY ON MY LEFT IS CHIEF BONNIE WILLIAMS, CHIEF OF SPECIAL PROGRAMS, AND ON MY RIGHT IS MATORI, THE CHIEF OF CITYWIDE LEGISLATIVE AFFAIRS. WE ARE PLEASED TO BE HERE TO OFFER AN UPDATE REGARDING A VERY SUCCESSFUL AND SAFE 2026 SUMMER BEACH AND POOL SEASON. PARKS HAS LONG BEEN COMMITTED TO IMPROVING NEW YORKERS' QUALITY OF LIFE THROUGH AQUATIC RECREATION, PROMOTING HEALTH, FITNESS, AND SAFETY AWARENESS AT BOTH OUR BEACHES AND POOLS. WHETHER COOLING OFF OR GETTING FIT, WE KNOW NEW YORKERS LOVE TO TAKE A REFRESHING SWIM. CITY BEACHES AND POOLS ARE THE PRIMARY GETAWAY DESTINATIONS FOR NEW YORKERS. DUE TO THE TIMING OF MEMORIAL DAY AND LABOR DAY THIS YEAR, THE SUMMER 2026 BEACH SEASON WAS THE LONGEST IN A DECADE. IT WAS 114 DAYS, WHICH IS 16 WEEKS, WHICH IS FOUR FULL MONTHS. NEW YORKERS CAME OUT IN DROVES AND TOOK ADVANTAGE OF THAT. A RECORD NUMBER OF PATRONS VISITED OUR BEACHES AND POOLS THIS YEAR, AND WE ARE EXCEEDINGLY PROUD THAT OUR GUESTS ENJOYED A FUN, FAMILY-FRIENDLY, CLEAN, AND SAFE EXPERIENCE AT BOTH OUR BEACHES AND POOLS. IT TAKES AN INCREDIBLY HARD-WORKING TEAM TO MAKE THIS A REALITY, INCLUDING OUR MAINTENANCE AND OPERATIONS STAFF, AQUATIC STAFF, OUR PARKS ENFORCEMENT PATROL COLLEAGUES, AND MOST NOTABLY OUR LIFEGUARDS.

WE ARE PLEASED TO REPORT THAT WE CERTIFIED 1,174 LIFEGUARDS THIS SUMMER, THE HIGHEST STAFFING LEVEL IN FOUR YEARS, AND A CLOSE TO 50% INCREASE SINCE 2022. OUR LIFEGUARDS ROSE TO THE OCCASION, PERFORMING OVER 200 RESCUES, AND WE ARE EXTRAORDINARILY PROUD TO REPORT THAT THERE WERE ZERO FATALITIES OR DROWNINGS. LIFEGUARDS WERE ON DUTY AT THEIR CHAIRS AT ALL OF OUR BEACHES AND POOLS THIS PAST SUMMER. LOOKING AHEAD, THOUGH, AS THE COUNCILMAN MENTIONED, WE REMAIN COMMITTED TO RETURNING TO OUR PRE-PANDEMIC LEVELS OF LIFEGUARD STAFFING, AT ROUGHLY 1,400 LIFEGUARDS, AND ARE DILIGENTLY WORKING TO ACHIEVE THAT GOAL. WE HAVE ALREADY LAUNCHED THE LIFEGUARD RECRUITMENT CAMPAIGN FOR THE SUMMER OF 2026 WITH THE TAGLINE "YOUR STRENGTH, THEIR SAFETY, OUR TEAM." FOR EVERYONE, I'M HOLDING UP A POSTER WHICH HAS BEEN DELIVERED TO COUNCIL MEMBERS' OFFICES, AND WE WELCOME YOU TO HELP US DISTRIBUTE THE INFORMATION ABOUT OUR NEW LIFEGUARD RECRUITMENT CAMPAIGN. WE ARE PROUD THAT THIS

(00:16:12)

Public awareness campaign produced entirely in-house by Parks staff. Campaign materials are being distributed, and we again appreciate support from Council Members and all of our partners in the swim community to get them aware of it and help amplify our message.

The registration portal actually opens this Sunday, November 15, and the first qualifying tests will be held on December 1, so we are getting very close to beginning to qualify lifeguards for next summer. Already, with the help of agency partners, most noticeably public schools, we will again qualify, train, and certify lifeguards in all five boroughs, so no candidates have to travel far from their home.

Turning to the legislation being formally heard today. Introduction 262 would extend the operational season for beaches and outdoor pools and would increase the daily operating hours for beaches, outdoor pools, and indoor pools.

We share the Council's desire to expand New Yorkers' access to swimming, but the legislation as drafted presents significant budgetary, operational, and safety concerns. Beaches are currently open for swimming from the Saturday of Memorial Day weekend and close the Sunday after Labor Day. Outdoor pool season is generally patterned on the school calendar, opening after schools end in late June and closing again this Sunday after Labor Day.

As currently drafted, the legislation would require that both beaches and outdoor pools open in mid-April and remain open until mid-October, times of the year when air and water temperatures often range in the 52 to 60 degree range, leading us to expect that visitation would be exceedingly minimal.

Also, summer beach and pool operation entails hiring thousands of seasonal staff to serve as lifeguards, maintenance, and security personnel. The vast majority of our seasonal workforce consists of teachers, college students, and high school students, all of whom would be unavailable during the proposed extensions, as they are occupied with their primary academic or professional pursuits. We are proud of our extensive staff recruitment efforts, but the stark reality is that employees required to maintain and safeguard our beaches and pools would simply not be available during the proposed extension.

Additionally, the bill would require beaches and pools to remain open each day until eight p.m. Setting aside staffing challenges, lifeguards need to be able to see patrons in the water at either a beach or pool in order to safeguard them. Swimming is currently prohibited after sunset at beaches, with dusk occurring between 6:37 and 7:30 p.m., and lifeguards would not be able to see patrons in the water to respond to emergencies.

It is worth noting that the current operational hours and duration of our beach and pool season are comparable to other municipalities, including our neighbors on Long Island and New Jersey, and offer New Yorkers the ability to stay cool when they need it most.

Introduction 957 would require the installation of informational signage related to the dangers of rip currents at every beach entrance, lifeguard chair, and jetty under Parks' jurisdiction. Introduction 1163 would require the installation of digital signage at beach entrances regarding the danger of rip currents.

Keeping our beachgoers safe is a top priority, and we agree patrons need to be informed.

Due to the geographic configuration of our beaches, only Rockaway Beach experiences rip current occurrence. It is classified as a true ocean beach, and it is our only beach classified as a true ocean beach. However, because of our strong dedication to swim safety, we display the official NOAA advisory posters about the danger of rip currents in public restrooms at all eight beaches. I am just holding up one of these, which looks like the standard NOAA poster for rip currents, again posted at all beaches. In addition, we post large vinyl banners with such dangers on the exterior restroom buildings at Rockaway in accordance with New York State and local health code requirements.

We also display advisory signage in multiple languages at every beach entrance, which notes that patrons need to be aware of strong currents and some drop-offs. Safety signage is installed at each beach or groin. Additionally, we already display signs on the back of every lifeguard chair reminding beach visitors that swimming is only permitted when lifeguards are on duty. In recent years, we have arranged with Parks' lifeguards to visit local public schools and teach students about water safety, focusing specifically on the danger of rip currents and the importance of swimming only when a lifeguard is on duty.

As all of this illustrates, we are always open to exploring new avenues to better educate New Yorkers about the importance of swim safety, but we have concerns that these two bills as currently drafted impose significant operational concerns and inadvertently lead to confusion for the public. Specifically regarding Introduction 1163, we believe the digital signage would be extremely challenging and expensive to install and maintain in a beach environment, given the exposure to sand, wind, and salt spray, as well as the potential for vandalism. I would like to note that across our eight beaches we have over 200 individual entrances to our beaches.

Lastly, Introduction 1164 would require Parks to consult with other city agencies that have jurisdiction over swimming pools regarding the feasibility of engaging with not-for-profit organizations to offer swimming and water safety programming at such pools, and to make related information available on an interactive map of swimming pools posted on our agency's website. We very much appreciate Council support for swim safety, and we are proud to offer free swim education and aquatic programs for thousands of New Yorkers every year, provided by Parks employees working at our rec centers, outdoor pools, and select public school indoor pools. However, the agency does not have the expertise or resources to assess the appropriate use of city property that is not under our jurisdiction or to advise when those facilities should be made available to non-city entities to provide additional programming.

Additionally, we believe that displaying information regarding non-Parks facilities on a map that is meant to inform regarding Parks facilities would lead to public confusion. Of course, we very much share the Council's goal of increasing awareness about the importance of water safety, and we would be happy to take further conversation with the Council and fellow city agencies to identify potential alternatives to achieve this important objective. We look forward to further discussing the legislation being heard here today and very much appreciate the opportunity to testify.

I would, though, however, close by restating four numbers which defined a successful and safe summer 2026 beach and full season: 114, the number of days in the beach season, 16 weeks, four months, the longest beach season in a decade; 1,174 certified lifeguards, the highest staffing since the pandemic, and a 50% increase in the last four years; and the number of patrons that we saw and hosted at our beaches and pools this summer, again a record.

And I would close with zero being the number of drownings or fatalities while lifeguards were on duty in their chairs during the longest, hottest, and busiest beach season in over a decade. We look forward to building on this success and having an even greater beach and pool season in 2027. Thank you for your continued advocacy and support for New York City Parks, and we would be happy to answer any questions you have. Thank you so much. Commissioner.

(00:24:37)

We are going to jump right in so that I can turn it over to my colleagues. I want to make sure there's enough time to hear from the public and advocates as well, so let's

(00:24:51)

start here. What's the

(00:24:52)

breakdown for lifeguards at beaches versus

(00:24:55)

pools in the 2026 season?

(00:24:58)

We deployed 480 beach lifeguards and about 680 pool lifeguards.

(00:25:11)

What is the current starting pay for first-time lifeguards, and what is the pay scale for more experienced lifeguards, respectively?

(00:25:18)

So, the starting salary is just below $23 an hour, which is competitive and higher than almost all of our peer beaches in New Jersey and on Long Island, and then it escalates with years of experience. In addition, if you come into your training program and you successfully go through the 16-week training program, you are also paid for the time you've spent training, and after your first year as a lifeguard, if you stay with us through Labor Day, you get a $1,000 retention bonus. I would want to note that all of this is part of the collective bargaining agreement, so it's not simply on Parks to bargain that agreement.

(00:25:59)

Do lifeguards at beaches

(00:26:00)

receive the same pay as lifeguards at pools? Yes. And are you currently engaged in any efforts to recruit and train students who may be interested in working as lifeguards?

(00:26:11)

Sure, I'll turn it over to Chief Williams.

(00:26:13)

Thank you, Council Member, for that question. Yes, we are engaged with New York City Public Schools. We are currently set up to host qualifiers for the upcoming season at New York City Public Schools in all five boroughs. We have distributed over 350 banners with our new marketing campaign that are going up at the schools, the high schools and intermediate schools. We also work very closely with the DOE. We have our staff at DOE athletic events, swim meets, football events, anything that DOE wants us to engage in. We also have an email blast that goes out with our digital toolkit to all parents and students in the New York City public school system, as many as possible.

(00:26:18)

Is this across all public high schools, or select schools?

(00:27:11)

Yes, Council Member. This is

(00:27:12)

across all public high schools. We work very closely. We also sit on the Lifeguard Aquatic Safety Task Force with many non-profits and city public schools, so we get the information out, not only about the qualifiers, but also about swim safety. We worked very closely with New York City Public Schools' digital media team to get information about the qualifiers, recruitment, and water safety out on social media. Thank you.

(00:27:48)

How many qualifying tests were hosted this year by Parks for potential lifeguards, and what were the test locations, sites? I'm asking about the 2025 to the 2026 season. We also had qualifiers across all five boroughs in a combination of New York City Parks recreation centers and New York City public high schools. During what months did the qualifying tests get held?

(00:28:13)

Thank you, Council Member. Remember, last year we started qualifiers in, and we ran into this year. We are starting qualifiers December 1 and running until. We wanted to give the swim teams a little more time to get up and get conditioning to get those kids ready to take the qualifier. Can you provide a breakdown of

(00:28:15)

what standards need to be met to qualify to be a lifeguard during the season?

(00:28:36)

Sure, that's a great question. So, it starts with them signing up for a qualifier. In addition to signing up for the qualifier, if participants feel they need to get ready to take that, our Aquatics Division also has the Swim Improvement Program that's offered at different Parks facilities and is available online, so they can train for a while. Once they take the qualifier and pass the qualifier, they can register for one of our 16-week training programs that we currently offer in all five boroughs. If they successfully pass and complete the training program, which consists of lifeguard skills, first aid skills, and passing the final written and practical exam, then they will be assigned to a pool or beach facility. If they are assigned to a beach facility, when they get out to their beach, there is an additional swim test that they have to take, because we want to make sure that they are ready. Thank you.

(00:28:42)

Can you describe the department's efforts to recruit lifeguards and what changes have occurred over the years in the recruiting process?

(00:29:43)

Thank you, Council Member. That's a great question, and we're very excited to discuss the things that have happened, especially over the past three or four years. Number one, our marketing campaign: every year we have done over 700 mailings, actual snail mail and digital media, to kids that have been turned out to over 500 key stakeholders. We work closely with the elected officials, with the non-profits, with New York City public schools, to get the word out about the marketing campaign and recruiting for lifeguards. Our team goes out to swim meets and any event where we can get that word out that we are looking for lifeguards, for them to sign up to get our email blasts on how to register for qualifiers. So that's one aspect. We also sit on the Aquatic Lifeguard and Safety Task Force that I mentioned before, with a lot of the non-profits around New York City, and we all work collectively, not only for Parks, but for our constituents that are out there, on how we can reach these lifeguard numbers. So it's about communication. It's about having our lifeguards themselves actually go out and explain what an amazing job it is, how proud they are to be lifeguards, and to show the young kids that are out there that anyone can be a lifeguard as long as they put the work in and they can pass the qualifier and the training.

Council Member, I would also add that we've mentioned it several times, but it is worth repeating that in the last several years we expanded both the recruitment, the certification, and the training to all five boroughs. That has not been the case in years past, even leading into the pandemic. Most training and certification happened in Manhattan, so people had to travel some distance. We're very proud to offer it in all five boroughs.

(00:29:49)

I'm going to acknowledge that we have been joined by, I know, he

(00:31:41)

had to step out. CM Krishnan, CM Restler, CM Narcisse, CM Ossé, CM Morano. All right, a couple more questions for me, and I'll turn over to

(00:31:47)

my colleagues. What's the typical turnover rate for lifeguards, from year to year? Thank you, Council Member, for the question. We prefer to think of it as the retention rate, so the number of lifeguards

(00:31:59)

that stay with us. Sure. The retention rate this past year was 79%, so that's 865 lifeguards that worked for us in the summer of 2025 and came back in the summer of 2026. That's almost a 10% increase in the last four years. We've traditionally been running about a 70% retention rate, and we're now at 79%. So we like to think that's a reflection of many things, including the salary, the bonus, the work environment, many different things. But yes, the retention rate is 79%. I'm going to turn

(00:32:08)

it over to my colleagues, starting with CM Narcisse. Thank you, Chair. I wish that the safety part, like they love God, was on in the chair. So having said that,

(00:32:43)

while the lifeguard is in the chair there are zero, but we still have our young folks who are dying in the water. To your knowledge, what kind of recommendations can you give us? At least we can do something about it, because I want zero, even after hours. What can we actually do, in your vision? Thank you, very much, Council Member, for the question. The message is, the actions that can be taken are to help amplify our message, which is that you only swim when a lifeguard is in the chair. That is our constant message. It's everywhere we have it. We are now doing it on digital ads, with the A train, written Rockaways. So our messages are constant, whether you're at a beach or pool, you only swim when a lifeguard is in the chair. That is the way to ensure that we're providing the oversight that's needed to keep the public safe. I love that, but another way I'm thinking, please, in schools, in junior highs, in college, we can have that partnership to make sure that the message is loud and clear, because most of the young folks who are dying are usually from the high school age or early college. I want to impress upon their children. I mean, they're friends, you know that. I think that can be very helpful.

(00:33:05)

If I, I'd like to have the

(00:33:26)

Chief address that we've had great programming in high schools, and it's really great to see the young people interact with the lifeguards, many of whom are their peers. Thirty percent of the lifeguards we hired this past year are 16 to 18. But Chief Williams.

(00:34:26)

Thank you, Commissioner.

(00:34:27)

Thank you, Council Member. So in the past three years, our lifeguards themselves have gone out to high schools and intermediate schools in the five boroughs and have done water safety assemblies, especially focusing on rip currents and not swimming when a lifeguard is not on duty. This is something that, as I've stated before, we're part of the Aquatic Lifeguard and Safety Task Force, and other groups are doing this as well, because we know how important it is to get that word out, especially to that targeted group of teenagers that are going to go there when the beaches are not open. Our lifeguards are one of the most diverse groups.

(00:34:44)

Can identify with a lot of

(00:34:44)

those kids that are out there. Those kids can see themselves in the lifeguards, and they're getting that message out about how important and critical it is to only swim when a lifeguard is on duty. With the drone videos that we show during these water safety presentations, it really sends that message across. And don't forget the non-profits.

(00:34:45)

Um, what percentage of people who take the lifeguard qualifying test pass it, and which part do most people fail? Is there any free prep for people who almost pass it?

(00:35:24)

I can identify with a lot of

(00:35:25)

Those kids that are out there, those kids can see themselves in the lifeguards and they are getting that message out about how important and critical it is to only swim when on duty, and with the drone videos that we show during these water safety presentations. It really sends that message across, and don't forget the nonprofit as.

(00:35:45)

Um, what percentage of people who take the lifeguard qualifying test pass it, and which part do most people fail? Is there any free prep for people who almost pass it?

(00:36:02)

Thank you. Howdy, Member, for the question. So, to answer about the program on our (?) website, they call it the swim improvement program. That is free. They can find it on the Parks' website and register for that program to help them get ready to take the qualifier. The qualifier itself is a 50-yard swim that they have to pass in 45 seconds.

(00:36:27)

Is the qualifier to get into the program?

(00:36:30)

Um, last year we had 605 participants pass our qualifiers. We offered in all five boroughs. Thank you.

(00:36:40)

My last one. Residents often use the Jamaica-based shoreline in my district. Even those swimming is not allowed there. What does Parks do about signs, patrols, and outreach in places like that where people swim anyway?

(00:37:00)

Thank you, Council Member. Place that we're aware of that has a history of swimming or gathering, we do post signs that say swimming is prohibited. They're generally the international symbol of no swimming. Um, they're red with white text. And then we do have our Parks Enforcement Patrol officers... excuse me, uh, periodically stopped by, particularly on a weekend or hotter day during the summer when they know there'll be gatherings there. So we approach it both with signage and patrols.

(00:37:29)

Thank you. And I'm going to leave it with... I don't have no swimming pool in my district. I'm still talking about it, and my kids cannot swim in the bucket, so help us. I hope you hear us. Thank you. Before I go to CM Morano, are doing to acknowledge that we are joined online by CM Avilés and Perino... Sanchez. Um, we're just really quickly. Can you provide an update as to which pools are currently closed or will be closed for major repairs and/or maintenance or capital work, and then their future status?

(00:38:01)

Certainly. Thank you for the question. Of our three outdoor pools, two are open this year. The only two that were closed were Tony Dapolito, which has been closed for a number of years. But the good news there is that we have full funding to do both a new recreation center with an Olympic indoor pool and a new outdoor aquatic center honoring the Keith Haring murals at that site. So that's both fully funded. And then the other pool that was closed this summer was Crotona Pool in the Bronx, which just closed for a 20-some-million-dollar renovation this summer. Thank you, Council Member.

(00:38:38)

Morano! Thank you, Deputy Commissioner. Thank you for your testimony. Thank you for the use of props. I really wish every witness would emulate that. Congratulations to you and your team. I think you said you had the longest beach season in a decade, more than 200 rescues, and most importantly, no fatalities while lifeguards were on duty in their chairs. So hats off to you. It's a tremendous accomplishment, and I don't think we should lose sight of that. But I do want to follow up on an issue that my colleague, Council Member, raised. You emphasized that there

(00:39:17)

were fatalities or drownings while lifeguards were on duty in their chairs, and I think that's great. But I think it raises another obvious question, aside from the one my colleague asked. How many drownings occurred at City beaches outside the hours when lifeguards were on duty? And of those incidents, how many occurred during the regular swimming season? Thank you, Council. I'm sure I'm impressed. Thank you for the props, and the props, by the way. Yeah. Um, so we at Parks do not track drownings outside or fatalities outside of the... um, that is tracked through NYPD and the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. There are two City agencies that track those kinds of incidences outside of the hours when New York City Parks are officially operating our beaches and pools. Um, so we would have to get you those numbers, but those are not numbers that rest within Parks. And again, I would appreciate if you could get them to us, understanding that it involves some interagency communication. Because you can understand, if someone drowns at 6:30 in the evening when a lifeguard went off duty at six, I'm not sure the family is going to take a great deal of comfort knowing that the Parks Department's official statistics say there were zero fatalities...

(00:40:42)

...during supervised hours. I know that's not your fault, and I'm not trying to imply that, but I am curious. I appreciated the candor in your testimony about extending the swimming season. You pointed out that a substantial portion of our workforce consists of teachers and students who simply won't be available during the proposed extended season, and I think that's actually a pretty compelling practical objection. But here's what I'd like to know: if the Council passes a law requiring longer hours, but the department doesn't have enough qualified lifeguards to staff those hours, what actually happens on a practical level? Do we close portions of the beach? Do we divert lifeguards from one community to another? Do we reduce service elsewhere? What actually happens if we pass this law and you don't have the staff?

(00:41:30)

Okay, thank you very much, Council. I really appreciate the questions. They do want to get into this detail about longer hours versus longer season. So right now, our beach and pool hours are eight hours for both beaches and pools, that our lifeguards can sit in the chairs. If we extend the hours, the legislation currently being considered or proposed is a 12-hour beach daily hours. That means we would almost have to double the number of lifeguards. We need to hire. Because we need full shifts, and as you know, again, we've talked a lot about, we're getting close to 1,101 to 1,200. We need to get to 1,400. But 1,400 provides one eight-hour shift at our beaches and pools. Lifeguards work six days a week already at both beaches and pools. So in order to extend to eight to... as the legislation proposes, we would need several hundred more lifeguards, and at the moment, I'm not sure where we would get them from. We will continue to... again, we're growing about a hundred a year, right, for the last four years. We've got to get to 1,400 before we can even consider going beyond 1,400 and expanding those hours. To get to the core of your question, what would we do if we don't have enough lifeguards to meet a mandate or legislated obligation? I frankly don't know what we would do, because we've never been in that position. Um, you know, first of all, we would have to get funding from OMB for both extending the hours and hiring all of those additional lifeguards.

I would like to note that it costs us about two and a half million dollars a week to operate our beaches and pools. That's our staffing numbers. It's about two and a half million dollars a week for beaches and pools. That's largely staff costs for the thousands of lifeguards, maintenance staff, PEP officers, and then, of course, there's some money in there for chlorine and toilet paper and trash bags and things like that. But both of those things, I wanted to offer in response to yours about the challenge of extending the hours and needing a whole other set of lifeguards to run a second shift, and the fact that we would get funding from OMB, would be an unfunded mandate at the rate of about two and a half million dollars a week. If I may, Chair, one procedural. No, just one procedure. No, just to add to the terms of the existing Admin Code. The Commissioner's obviously... right there is some flexibility in the current Admin Code that allows the Commissioner, Parks Commissioner, some discretion in terms of staffing level requirements, extreme weather, certain. So I suspect that, were this legislation to advance, I suspect we'd have discussions about making sure that those sorts of aspects

(00:41:54)

To be 2 hours, beaches, daily hours. That means we would almost have to double the number of lifeguards. We need to hire...

Because we need full shifts and...

As you know, again, we've talked a lot about. We're getting close to 1,101 to 200. We need to get to 1,400, but 1,400 provides one eight-hour shift at our beaches and pools.

Lifeguards work six days a week already at both beaches and pools. So in order to extend to 8 to 8, as the legislation proposes, we would need several hundred more lifeguards, and at the moment I'm not sure where we would get them from. We will continue, again, we're growing about a hundred a year, right, for the last four years. We've got to get to 1,400 before we can even consider going beyond 1,400 and expanding those hours.

To get to the core of your question, what would we do if we don't have enough lifeguards to meet a mandate or legislated obligation? I frankly don't know what we would do, because we've never been in that position. First of all, we would have to get funding from OMB for both extending the hours and hiring all of those additional lifeguards. I would like to note that it costs us about two and a half million dollars a week to operate our beaches and pools. That's our staffing numbers. It's about two and a half million dollars a week for beaches and pools. That's largely staff costs for the thousands of lifeguards, maintenance staff, PEP officers, and then, of course, there's some money in there for chlorine, toilet paper, trash bags, and things like that. But both of those things I wanted to offer in response to yours about the challenge of extending the hours and needing a whole other set of lifeguards to run a second shift, and the fact that we would get funding from OMB would be an unfunded mandate at the rate of about two and a half million dollars a week.

If I may, Chair, one procedural. No, just one procedure. No, just add to the terms of the existing admin code. The commissioner's obviously... a hundred percent. Right there is some flexibility in the current admin code that allows the commissioner, parks commissioner, some discretion in terms of taking staffing level requirements, extreme weather, certain. So I suspect that, were this legislation to advance, I suspect we'd have discussions about making sure that those sort of aspects

(00:44:14)

Of marine corporal. I'm

(00:44:16)

wondering. And this is just a question, not a

(00:44:18)

proposal, but would it

(00:44:19)

make more sense to authorize a very carefully designed pilot program that selected beaches based on actual demand and available staffing before imposing a citywide mandate? Um, you don't like that either.

(00:44:34)

No, no, I can tell you I don't like it. Council Member, I wouldn't say that. I would just say again, it depends on whether or not we would get the funding to do it and whether we could have found the staff to do it, both lifeguards, maintenance staff, and PEP officers. And again, I don't know if you're necessarily referring to expanded hours or the expanded season. I think the expanded hours might be a little bit more feasible because it's within the season when we know that people are available to work. But I can't emphasize enough that we will simply not be able to hire the people prior to... you know, college students don't become available until the third week in... high school students and teachers don't become available until the very end of... we pick up our employment in the middle of... because by August 1, we're already losing the college students that are leaving us to go have a few weeks off before they have to go back to college, the third week in. And then, of course, all the public school teachers are leaving us, and the high school teachers are leaving us Labor Day weekend to go back to their jobs or school. So we will not be able to have the staff to operate beaches and pools outside of the Labor Day to Memorial Day. Approximately...

(00:44:58)

Because it's within the season when we know that people are available to work, but I can't emphasize enough that we will simply not be able to hire the people prior to... college students don't become available until the third week in... high school students and teachers don't become available until the very end of... we're in... employment in the middle of... because by August 1 we're already losing the college students that are leaving us to go have a few weeks off before they have to go back to college in the third week of... and then, of course, all the public school teachers are leaving us, and the high school teachers are leaving us Labor Day weekend to go back to their jobs or school. So we will not be able to have the staff to operate beaches and pools outside of Labor Day to Memorial Day. Approximate

(00:45:46)

Season. Two final questions for

(00:45:50)

me. Um, your testimony makes an interesting distinction. You point out that among the beaches operated by Parks, only Rockaway Beach is technically classified as a true ocean beach, and that its rip current conditions differ from those of the other City beaches. I think that's an important distinction. In my district, we have Wolfe's Pond Beach. Um, Staten Island has its own waterfront conditions and challenges. Shouldn't the City's water safety policies be tailored to the actual conditions at each beach, rather than imposing a one-size-fits-all approach? Um...

(00:46:00)

Beach and that it's ripped.

(00:46:02)

Current conditions differ from those of the other City beaches. I think that's an important distinction. In my district, we have Wolfe's Pond Beach. Um, Staten Island has its own waterfront conditions and challenges. Shouldn't the City's water safety policies be tailored to the actual conditions at each beach, rather than imposing a one-size-fits-all approach? Um...

(00:46:24)

Possible. Thank you. Council Member, I would say possibly. I think our approach at Parks has always been, as I mentioned, posting the rip current advisories in all

(00:46:34)

of the restrooms. Another thing we did was take the maximum worst condition, or the maximum saturation messaging, and put it everywhere, because truthfully, somebody could enjoy a day at Wolfe's Pond and then travel to the Rockaways, and they should know about the risks of the Rockaways, even though they're not going to encounter them at Sout or Midland or Cedar or...

(00:46:54)

Wolf, right? I mean, it would seem to me that location-specific risk signage might be more pertinent. And finally,

(00:47:00)

one o'clock, to get all these in for the multiple rounds. You describe digital signage at

(00:47:09)

beaches as exceptionally difficult and expensive to maintain because of sand, salt spray, wind, and vandalism. That sounds reasonable, but here's what troubles me. Have you actually calculated what it would cost to install, operate, maintain, and replace these signs over five or ten years, and have you provided that estimate to the Council? Thank you, Council Member, but we have not, because the most recent introduction was just made last week. So we've not had that time to talk to manufacturers and see what that cost might be. And certainly the long-term five- or ten-year operational costs would be somewhat speculation, because we have nothing like this. If I can... sorry, just quickly on a process note, we are in communication with OMB, which I believe is compiling and has already submitted a fiscal impact statement for this bill. Specifically, it presents a really unique challenge because of the factors that were mentioned here. There are no significant unknowns about the our beach entrances, you know, which would be, you know, electricity, you know, utility connections, et cetera. So it would be a challenge to get a highly detailed... but we have certainly, you know, working with OMB, can provide some sense of that. Put on its face, it's considerable, very, very considerable. Thanks very much.

(00:48:21)

CM Narcisse, how to follow up? I'm going to extend Council Member, since one of those times...

(00:48:27)

You can do the thing that I want you to clarify for me. It's about the dust we talked about. We're trying? No, it is starting to get dark. So if you can kind of highlight this for me, can clear, be clear in my mind.

(00:48:40)

Sure. Thank you very much.

(00:48:41)

Um, again, the paramount need to ensure public safety for swimmers is for the lifeguard to be able to see the swimmers in the water, and particularly at beaches where they are looking quite a distance out. So you simply need to look at any chart and you'll see when dusk is. And again, in late September, October, dusk is anywhere from 6:15 to 6:36 to 6:40, approximately that time. And then obviously it gets earlier and earlier and earlier as we get into... So again, the legislation would propose keeping the beaches open till eight PM until October 15.

(00:49:17)

It was simply setting aside

(00:49:18)

whether or not we would have the lifeguards. It simply would not be safe, because they could not see the swimmers in

(00:49:26)

the water. Thank you.

(00:49:27)

Council Member, Counselor, Senses as well. So.

(00:49:29)

Thank you. Chair, and thank you so much for being here. I am the proud representative of Coney Island, and so many of my questions today pertained to

(00:49:40)

our beaches and my district. Um, but first of all, I want to echo CM Morano's congratulations on the progress that we're making in terms of lifeguard recruitment and retention. I know it's not easy. I guess first, I'd like to just start by saying, what do you see as the main barriers to recruitment and retention to getting to that 1,400 number right now?

(00:50:02)

Yeah. Thank you, Council Member, and good to see you. Um, at this point, I would say there are not many major hurdles as we've encountered in the last several years. Again, I think we've addressed many of them with the increased salary, the retention bonus, the really aggressive marketing campaign, all of the partnerships, expanding to all five boroughs. It's really just awareness. And this is where you and your colleagues and all of our partners sitting in the audience can help us advertise. Again, we opened the portal this Sunday for people to register, and we start qualifiers December 1. So please, please, if you're interested in being a New York City lifeguard, sign up through the portal starting Sunday. Get your qualifying appointment and come out and swim for us. Yeah.

(00:50:48)

So, and I'm glad you mentioned that, because I believe in your testimony you mentioned partnerships with City agencies in order to get the word out. Can you detail any efforts in Nighthawk?

(00:51:05)

Thank you, Council Member. Thank you, Commissioner Folk. We haven't worked closely with NYCHA, Council Member, but that is something that we will. We do send them a digital mailing, and we do send them a snail mail, but we will reach out to them to see if there's something more extensively we can do.

(00:51:18)

Let me sign myself up to help. And, you know, the west end of Coney Island, of course, has something like nine or ten NYCHA developments, and I think it would be really advantageous to do some targeted recruitment in those developments, because as you said, you're doing an effort to sort of recruit lifeguards and place them near where they live. These are folks who live within walking distance to the beach, and I think it would be a really beautiful thing if we did some heightened recruitment within those NYCHA buildings in order to bring people out to lifeguard where they live.

(00:51:52)

But let's do that. Yeah.

(00:51:53)

Okay, great. We'll do that together. And I want to also just thank you for your efforts this past summer. About midway through the season, we realized that there was a real gap in lifeguard coverage on the west end, which, I think, um, is probably not an intentional thing, but does send the message to west end residents that that part of the beach is not as valued or prioritized as further east towards Brighton. And every year we do a little bit of catch-up to make sure that those are staffed. And I just want to say, going into this season, I would love a permanent plan to just make sure there's equity there, so that there is regular lifeguard staffing in the west end. This is one of those cases where we think of Coney Island, and we don't think of the west end, or further towards the amusement districts, but the folks that live near the west end, they are going to go swimming there where there's no lifeguards. And I think it would send a really strong message from the City if we would make sure, you know, that there was consistent lifeguard coverage there without a sort of scrambling midseason. But I will help you in hoping to do some of that recruitment with NYCHA. And then, I'm sorry if you said this while I was gone, but I would love to just hear a little bit more, again, I'm thinking Coney Island, of your efforts to recruit in partnership with public schools.

(00:53:10)

Counts, remember? Thank you. And I look forward to speaking with you about reaching out tonight. We work extensively with New York City Public Schools. Again, we sit on the Lifeguard Safety Task Force that they sit on, as well as a lot of the nonprofit set up here, not with us today. We have banners that go up at every high school. We have a digital marketing campaign that goes out through their social media, our social media, and email mailed to parents and students. We work with... we attend all the swim meets to recruit our lifeguards, go out and explain what an amazing job this is. And, you know, we just work very closely with them. We do qualifiers at the high schools and the other schools, and we also do training at public high...

(00:53:55)

Schools. Okay, thank you for all of your efforts, and I look forward to working together. Thank you. Well, okay, before we move to public testimony, I do have a couple of questions that are unrelated to the current topic. So if you can just indulge me for just three minutes, especially as we prepare for the snow season.

(00:54:25)

Other times when parks workers are assigned to clear public assets outside of parks, during snow storms. Thank you.

(00:54:34)

Councilmember, for the question. When you say public, I'm just pausing because I'm switching my mind from swimming in beaches. Sure. No.

(00:54:47)

No. All right. Excuse me.

(00:54:48)

Excuse me. So we have a longstanding commitment where during certain intense winter storms, we do commit a certain number of vehicles and drivers, took for two, who are deployed on 12-hour shifts to help clear residential streets. So it is a public asset, the residential street, but it's not a park asset, so that would be the only instance that I can think of where parks employees are employed in winter weather response, not on park's property.

(00:55:24)

Who gives them directives?

(00:55:29)

Midas gives me, gives them routes. Okay, are they oftentimes assigned to do the same work as the emergency snow shovelers, this Karen, bus stops, hydrants, sidewalks? No, this is vehicles. So this is pickup trucks with plows. Are you sure? Yes. Okay. Okay, I'm sure. Okay.

(00:55:45)

This is pickup trucks with plows on plowing residential, smaller-scale residential streets.

(00:55:53)

Okay. All right. I just wanted to get that on the record. You're sure about that? No. City parks workers are assigned to shovel outside of park's property areas that include bus stops, fire hydrants, sidewalks. So our park staff clear bus stops, fire hydrants, and crosswalks on sidewalks adjacent to park's property, because they're ours. So if you had, okay,

(00:56:15)

If you, Central Park, and you have Fifth Avenue, and you have a bus stop on Fifth Avenue, that bus stop will be cleared by park staff.

(00:56:17)

So we are clearing crosswalks, fire hydrants, and bus stops on perimeter sidewalks around all parks property, nothing else.

(00:56:24)

Nothing, nowhere else. Rather, nowhere else. Okay. Thank you for that. Thank you. All right, thank you for testifying today. I hope that you can stick around for the public testimony. If you can, please do, because I think it shouldn't just be the committee hearing, but also the agency hearing from the advocates. With that, I'm going to switch over, and then we'll call the names of those who will be testifying first.

AI-generated summaries and transcripts. Errors are possible.
Verify against the linked video and send corrections via email.