Hearing Hearings — Hearing Record ✉
← All hearings

Appointments to the City Planning Commission

Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics

Chair: Sandra Ung

Meeting overview

The Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics held a confirmation hearing on November 9, 2026 for six nominees: Martha King for a Council appointment to the New York City Board of Correction, and five nominees for the City Planning Commission — reappointments of Anthony Crowell and Kenneth Knuckles (the latter as Vice-Chair), and new appointments of Julie Stein, Margaret Anadu, and Meenakshi Srinivasan. No votes were taken at the hearing itself; the session was purely investigative.

Martha King, a former Executive Director of the Board of Correction (2015-2019) and current Chair of the Correctional Association of New York's board, made a strong case for reappointment grounded in institutional knowledge. She would serve the remainder of a term ending February 1, 2029. Questioning ranged across deaths in custody (15 in 2025, 7 so far in 2026), the ongoing transition to borough-based jails, solitary confinement under Local Law 42, the Department of Correction's catastrophically outdated paper-based information systems, compliance with sanctuary city laws, and the severe mental health crisis on Rikers (20% of detainees now classified as seriously mentally ill). King was candid about the limits of oversight, emphasised the need to look at systemic patterns across deaths rather than individual incidents, and strongly supported the solitary confinement ban while acknowledging it is insufficient on its own to reduce violence. The most substantive political friction came from Minority Leader Carr, who pressed King on whether the Department should cooperate with ICE detainer requests beyond what local law requires. King held firm that she would not advocate changing local law to permit ICE cooperation, and declined to support cooperation even for people with prior convictions absent a judicial warrant. The exchange was pointed but inconclusive, reflecting an ongoing legal and political battle rather than anything the Board of Correction directly controls.

The five City Planning Commission nominees appeared together and faced questions dominated by one structural concern: the 2025 Charter revisions that created a fast-track affordable housing ULURP process and reduced the City Council's formal role in land use approvals. All five nominees acknowledged the political sensitivity of the moment and pledged to compensate for the Council's diminished formal role through early and sustained informal engagement, including outreach to Council Members and community boards well before applications are filed. The nominees were broadly aligned on the housing crisis as the central challenge, supportive of transit-oriented development and infrastructure-matched density, and careful to frame the Charter changes as imposing greater responsibilities on the Commission rather than reducing accountability. Anthony Crowell, the most experienced voice on the panel, noted that no one on the Commission had been lobbied by City Hall on how to vote in his four years of service, and committed to continued independence. Kenneth Knuckles offered the most nuanced caution about the limits of what the Commission can do without community consent, noting that you cannot go forward in the face of fervent opposition.

Council Members pressed the nominees hard on infrastructure adequacy, particularly water, sewer, schools, and open space, with CM Lee raising a specific flooding crisis in her low-density Queens district and CM Williams flagging that the Department of Education told her during a neighborhood plan that no new school seats would be needed despite every nearby school being at or above capacity. CM Brewer raised the genuinely difficult problem of her Upper West Side district, which is designated as one of the 12 lowest-producing community districts under the new Charter but has almost no undeveloped land, sits largely within historic districts, and faces developers who prefer luxury condos. The nominees acknowledged the tension but offered only partial answers, essentially conceding that the economics of affordable development in high-cost, fully built-out areas are extremely difficult and that the fast-track process is unlikely to yield much in such districts. Julie Stein disclosed two pending waiver requests to the Conflicts of Interest Board related to her role as Executive Director of Union Square Partnership; the Chair asked whether she would withdraw if the waivers were denied, and Stein agreed she would.

Numbers
  • 15 people died in custody in New York City jails in 2025.
  • 7 people have died in custody in New York City jails so far in 2026.
  • 20% of people detained on Rikers Island are currently classified as seriously mentally ill, up significantly from approximately a decade ago.
  • Approximately 500 people have been detained on Rikers for more than two years awaiting case resolution.
  • The planned borough-based jails are currently approximately 220 people below the capacity needed to accommodate the existing jail population at the time of transition.
  • Martha King, as Executive Director of the Board of Correction from 2015 to 2019, oversaw more than a doubling of the agency's budget and staff.
  • Martha King would serve the remainder of a Board of Correction term ending February 1, 2029 if appointed.
  • Approximately 75% of people detained on Rikers are returned directly to their communities without a conviction.
  • Approximately 50% of seriously mentally ill detainees are homeless upon entry to the jail system.
  • The City of Yes zoning changes allowed modest increases in housing density in lower-density neighborhoods across the city.
  • The 2025 Charter revisions identified 12 community districts with the lowest housing production over the previous five years as targets for a fast-track affordable housing ULURP process.
  • The fast-track ULURP process is intended to reduce project review timelines from roughly two to three years to approximately six months.
  • CM Williams cited a neighborhood plan that produced between 12,000 and 14,000 units, with one variant projecting up to 40,600 units.
  • Mandatory Inclusionary Housing Level 1 requires that 25% of a building's floor area be affordable to households earning up to 60% of Area Median Income.
  • The Creedmoor redevelopment project in Queens covers approximately 50 acres and will include veterans housing, senior affordable housing, and affordable homeownership units.
  • One flooding mitigation project in CM Lee's district involved a $20 million underground tank that did not resolve the flooding problem.
  • Kenneth Knuckles has served on the City Planning Commission across five mayoral administrations.
  • Meenakshi Srinivasan served as Chair of the Board of Standards and Appeals for 10 years and as Chair of the Landmarks Preservation Commission for 4 years.
  • Anthony Crowell has served as Dean and President of New York Law School; CM Williams cited a dissertation examining 159 deaths in New York City jails over a five-year period (attributed in context to Deputy Speaker Williams's own research).
  • Higher death rates were observed in Monroe, Suffolk, Nassau, and Erie counties compared to New York City during the period studied by the Deputy Speaker's dissertation research.
Action Points
  • Martha King to send Deputy Speaker Williams updated comparative death-rate data across New York State county jails if appointed.
  • Martha King to visit jails regularly and work with other Board members to set oversight priorities if appointed to the Board of Correction.
  • Martha King to conduct retrospective, comprehensive audits of deaths in custody to identify systemic patterns rather than reviewing only individual cases if appointed.
  • Martha King to attend Department of Correction staff trainings and audit compliance with sanctuary city law protocols at Rikers if appointed.
  • Martha King to review the Board of Correction's current digital record-keeping and inter-agency information-sharing systems and report findings to Council if appointed, particularly regarding communication between NYPD, Department of Correction, Correctional Health Services, and community providers.
  • City Planning Commission nominees to engage proactively with Council Members and community boards at the earliest stages of ULURP and fast-track applications, prior to any formal filing.
  • City Planning Commission to establish clear communication protocols with Council Members in affected districts as the new Charter-mandated processes take effect.
  • Department of City Planning to be encouraged by commissioners to require or strengthen pre-application outreach by private developers to community boards and Council Members, not merely encourage it.
  • City Planning Commission to use available tools including conditions, project modifications, and agency partner assessments to address infrastructure adequacy concerns in lieu of formal community benefits agreements where those are unavailable.
  • Julie Stein to withdraw her candidacy for the City Planning Commission if the Conflicts of Interest Board declines to grant the two pending waivers related to her Union Square Partnership role.
  • Julie Stein to recuse herself from any City Planning Commission matter involving a Union Square Partnership BID expansion application.
  • Kenneth Knuckles offered to meet directly with CM Brewer to review potential affordable housing sites on the Upper West Side; Anthony Crowell and Margaret Anadu indicated interest in joining that meeting.
  • City Planning Commission to scrutinise and independently interrogate Department of Education school seat assessments submitted as part of environmental review, rather than accepting them at face value, following CM Williams's experience with inaccurate projections during her neighborhood plan.
  • City Planning Commission to utilise social media, remote participation options, and borough office outreach more aggressively to improve public engagement in land use hearings, particularly for communities without established civic infrastructure.
  • Department of City Planning to be pressed by commissioners to deploy staff redeployed from streamlined environmental review processes toward faster and more thorough pre-application community engagement.
Download .txt
Full Transcript

(00:00:15)

Good morning and welcome to today's New York City Council hearing from the Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics. At this time, silence all electronic devices, and at no point should anyone approach the dais. Additionally, please do not approach the witness table unless invited to testify. If you would like to sign up for in-person testimony but have not done so already, please feel free to sign up with a white slip located outside the reception desk. We are ready to begin.

Good morning and welcome to this meeting of the Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics. Before we begin, I would like to recognize the other member of this committee, Minority Leader David Carr. I would also like to acknowledge the Counsel to the Committee, Mandate Grasso, and the Committee staff. Directing today's hearing is the Director of Public Integrity, Alicia Gazelle, Chief of Council and Director of the Public Integrity Unit. Per the compliance associates and the public unit, and the additional attorneys in the Office of General Counsel, will help prepare this hearing.

Today we will be holding a public hearing on six nominations for appointments. We will be considering Martha King for appointment to New York City's Board of Corrections, and Anthony Crowell, Margaret Anadu, Kenneth Knuckles, Julie Stein, and Meenakshi Srinivasan for City Planning Commission. Each candidate will be invited to make an opening statement before we proceed. Questions will follow after all candidates have appeared. We will hear public testimony.

Up first will be the City Council's nomination of Martha King for appointment as a Council member of the New York City Board of Corrections. I invite Ms. King to come to the witness table. Good morning.

(00:02:11)

Good morning. The Board of Corrections is established under Section 626 of the City Charter and is responsible for the inspection of all institutions and facilities under the jurisdiction of the Department of Correction, and of all records relating to that work. In addition, the Board of Corrections is responsible for the evaluation of the Department of Correction's performance against minimum standards. The Board promulgates such minimum standards and rules and regulations for the care, custody, correction, treatment, supervision, and discipline of all persons held or confined under the jurisdiction of the Department. It promulgates such minimum standards and rules and regulations after giving the Mayor, the Commissioner, and an opportunity to review and comment on the proposed standards, and it conducts audits related to such standards.

The Board has nine members, appointed equally by the Mayor, the Council, and the Mayor from judicial nominations. Members serve six-year terms, and vacancies are filled for the remainder of the term. The Board is required to establish procedures for the hearing of grievances, complaints, and all requests for assistance made on behalf of any persons confined under the jurisdiction of the Department, or by any employee of the Department. The Board must issue, at least every three years, a report on the Department's grievance process, incorporating feedback from incarcerated individuals and recommendations for improvement, including for vulnerable populations. This report must be submitted to the Council and posted on the Board's website.

The Board is also, in most instances, obligated to investigate and prepare a report about the death of any individual in custody. The report must include any recommendations about the measures or correctional health services that could be implemented in the future to prevent the circumstances that contributed to the individual's death. The report should be posted on the Board's website, along with any response from the Department of Correction and Correctional Health Services. If appointed, Martha King would serve the remainder of the six-year term that ends on February 1, 2029.

(00:05:22)

Thank you. Good morning, Chair Louis and members of the Committee. It is an honor to be here today and to be considered for appointment to the New York City Board of Correction. My connection to New York City, and in an unusual way to Rikers Island, began when I was a few months old and my parents moved our family from Chicago to New York so that my father could run the Montefiore Health Services at Rikers Island. This move made me a New Yorker and created a lifelong commitment to public service and to improving the institutions, particularly those of the criminal justice system, that shape life in the City.

I am now a philanthropic advisor and strategist with 25 years of experience working across the foundation, government, and nonprofit sectors. I have spent my career seeking to better New York City and have familiarity with diverse policy areas. From 2015 through 2019, I had the privilege of serving as Executive Director of the Board of Correction. During that period, with support from the Council and the Mayor's Office, we increased the agency's staff and budget by more than double, and significantly expanded its monitoring, investigations, research, regulations, and public reporting.

Since that time, I have remained involved in oversight of jails and prisons through my research, public engagements, and serving as Chair of the Correctional Association of New York's Board of Directors. This experience gives me deep appreciation for what independent oversight can accomplish and an awareness of its limitations. I have a firsthand understanding of the obligations and responsibilities of a Board member, and I would welcome the opportunity to uphold them.

At a time of intensive court oversight and the significant transition to borough-based jails, the institutional knowledge on the ground, real-time insights, and commitment to transparency are especially important. The Board has a remarkable history of reforming the City's jails and establishing the elements of safer conditions, including access to the courts and legal services, visits, daily showers, the practice of religion, and health and mental health care. In 1977, future Mayor David Dinkins testified before the Board of Correction, encouraging its regulations. He noted, "We have abandoned the presumption of innocence when we allow such demeaning and debasing conditions in our jails to exist." The regulations remain vital work against demeaning and debasing conditions, even as those conditions shift in nature. Mayor Dinkins's statement holds true today, and improving conditions in City jails and upholding the presumption of innocence must be a priority for our City. Three quarters of the people detained on Rikers are returned directly to our communities.

(00:08:18)

If appointed, I would bring deep knowledge of the City's jail system and a strong commitment to New York City to the Board. I would also advance the work with an open mind, digging into current conditions and evaluating the evidence before the Board. Today, I would visit the jails regularly, work with other Board members and staff to set priorities, follow the facts, and exercise independent judgment. The Council has a long history of appointing dedicated, independent members of the Board and partnering with them to implement reforms. It would be an honor and privilege to further that legacy. Thank you for the opportunity to appear and for your consideration. I look forward to your questions.

(00:08:58)

Thank you for your testimony. We have also been joined by a Council Member.

(00:09:02)

First, I'm going to kick it off with some questions, and then I'm going to pass it off to my Council Members. I'll probably come back. So, first, why do you want to serve on the Board of Corrections?

(00:09:14)

Well, I think we have an especially promising moment to create fundamental reform in the jails, considering the current leadership of the Department of Correction, considering the federal court's intervention, and considering the move to borough-based jails. The Board's standards and regulations, its institutional and historical knowledge, and its memory are crucial to that process. Additionally, the Board is the one agency among all of those involved in reform of the jails that is formally committed to transparency and to speaking with all parties, combining real-time data and conversations with people on staff and people in custody.

(00:09:59)

Thank you. You previously served as Executive Director. What were the most significant reforms you led during your service, and what impacts did they have?

(00:10:00)

I'm very proud that when I was Executive Director, working with the Council and the Mayor's Office, we were able to more than double the budget and the staff. That translated to more investigations, more public reporting, additional regulations, and much more transparency in our City's jail system. One or two examples of which I'm particularly proud are the Board's work to evaluate the Department of Correction's complaint and grievance system. We issued the first comprehensive evaluations of the grievance system when I was Executive Director, and those evaluations led to a package of City Council legislation. It also led to an entirely new digital, centralized complaint system run by the Department of Correction. It allowed them to streamline all of their complaints and grievances with other mechanisms for getting complaints. It also led to staffing and policy changes that improved the grievance system.

Based on your experience overseeing the City jails, what role do you believe incarceration should play in the criminal justice system?

Well, I believe incarceration has a necessary but limited role. It should be used when it is necessary to protect public safety and to protect the integrity of the legal process. I think we have a history of overusing incarceration to try to solve problems that cannot be solved with a jail or with a prison.

(00:11:46)

We also have a record in New York City over the past 30 years, since Mayor Dinkins, of reducing the number of people who are incarcerated, while we've also reduced crime and made the City safer. So I hope that we can continue to build on that trajectory. You currently serve as Chair of the Correctional Association of New York. What lessons from that role will you bring to the Board of Correction?

(00:12:09)

[Continuation of prior response is not present in source.]

(00:12:10)

Just to clarify, so in case anyone is confused: the Correctional Association monitors and oversees the State prison system, an entirely different jurisdiction. I did talk to the Conflicts of Interest Board, and I will be cognizant of any potential conflicts if I were to be appointed. I was not advised, if any, by the Board of any conflicts.

(00:12:35)

Quick. So I think, with my experience at the Correctional Association and my experience at the Board of Correction, one of the key lessons is using data to inform our conversations about potential policy changes, and also paying attention to the actual implementation of reforms. Prisons and jails have many, many policies and regulations that they're supposed to be following. The problem lies in the implementation and integrity of those policies and regulations on the ground. So I believe that my lessons from the Correctional Association and the Board previously are to really be persistent and consistent in looking at implementation and conditions in real time, and using data from all sides, as much data as can be gathered through information systems, and data that comes from people working in the system or detained in the system. Those bring important perspectives. How would you adapt the oversight approaches you used at the Correctional Association to the unique challenges of the New York City jail system? I think they are very parallel. The experience of sharing with the Correctional Association and the Board, and the experience of what we've seen in the New York State prison system, directly relate to what we need in the New York City jails, which I believe is fundamental reform.

I think we've been trying to fix some of the problems around the edges, when I think we really need fundamental management, staffing, training, and information systems change that would ultimately reform the culture of the organization.

(00:14:35)

Thank you. We've been joined by Deputy Speaker Williams, and I'm going to pass it off to my Minority Council Member. Thank you.

(00:14:45)

Thank you. Thank you, Chair. Good morning. Thank you for being here today. I wanted to talk to you a little bit about what's commonly called sanctuary city policies. Do you believe that the Department of Correction should continue to refuse to cooperate with ICE detainer requests?

I believe that the Department should follow the laws that are set out by the City Council and the Mayor. So if the law was changed, would you advocate a change in local law in order to allow the Department of Correction to cooperate with ICE? I would not. Could you explain that, please? I don't believe that cooperation prior to someone's conviction of a crime furthers public safety or justice. So if someone was incarcerated at Rikers and had prior convictions, would you support cooperating with ICE under those conditions? If they were convicted of a felony, I believe that they are required to communicate with the federal government about that, but not for a misdemeanor offense.

I must say I'm not a lawyer. I'm asking your opinion. I'm not asking about what's legally required. Do you believe that someone who has prior convictions should, notwithstanding local law, be handed over to ICE if there's a detainer request issued by that federal agency?

No, I don't think they should be handed over. I think that's sort of a difficult position to maintain, right? We have people who have been incarcerated previously and have been convicted of crimes. These are people who have already violated our immigration laws, either by entry or by remaining, or both. What public safety interest is really served by allowing these individuals to remain in the United States and to not cooperate with federal immigration law enforcement? I think that we have good laws currently about people who pose public risks after they've been released, after they've been convicted. There is communication between local, state, and federal authorities to follow our current immigration laws. But there's currently a local law that the Department of Correction is following, right, that's being litigated in court? That precludes anything other than a judicial warrant from being acted upon by the Department. Now, most ICE detainer requests on their face are virtually all administratively issued. So we have a federal law enforcement agency that's trying to do its job, and we have a municipal agency that's refusing to cooperate with it. You think that's good public safety policy?

I don't see it that way. I don't see it as non-cooperation and not following the law. I think the City is following the law.

(00:17:24)

I think when an agency issues a request or an order and it's not cooperated with, that's non-cooperation.

(00:17:45)

You said they needed a judicial...?

No, well, that's what the local law says, right? But I'm just asking you substantively.

(00:17:53)

Why you think that it's not cooperation? It's not non-cooperation when it's a ICE detainer request. I mean, it's the very definition of non-cooperation. I don't know what to say about that, sir. I don't know what to say about that either. Thank you, Chair.

(00:17:57)

Now, I'd like to pass it all to CM Hanif, and we've also been joined by CM Banks. Thank you. Good morning. How are you doing today? I just wanted to focus on my questions on the borough-based jails, and I appreciate you taking your time today. In your response to the pre-hearing questions, you noted that there are long organizational and cultural problems with the agency. Can you please expand on those problems and explain where you feel the Board can play a role in addressing the new jail system?

(00:18:00)

(00:18:23)

(00:18:29)

(00:18:55)

Thank you. I believe strongly that the borough-based jails and bringing people who are detained pretrial closer there, their families and friends, into the courts, is absolutely essential. I do not think it is a magic bullet, and it will not solve all of the problems in the jails. I think the Board's role is not only to monitor the development and transition into the new jails, but really it is to focus on whether or not those new jails deliver on the promise of more safety and better conditions for staff and people who are in custody. To your question about what kinds of changes we need, I think, based upon the Board of Corrections reports and the reports from the federal monitor, we know that there are significantly dysfunctional supervision and support systems for staff. We have a recruitment problem, and we have a training problem for staff. We also have information systems based on paper that are very illegible and hard to translate into knowing what is going on. So one of the major findings of the federal court has been that the management of the Department of Correction does not actually know where their staff is deployed at any given time. Solving that problem could be huge for solving many other problems.

(00:20:20)

Thank you. Assuming the relevant stakeholders are not able to sufficiently draw down the jail population in time

(00:20:27)

Arm from the transition to the borough-based jail system. How do you propose the Board and the agencies respond to that? That is a huge concern. We are obviously concerned about delayed or escalating costs, and it is about 220 people above the current capacity of the borough-planned jails. I think we should start planning now, and we need to have a number of contingency plans for whether or not we can meet that goal. I believe that the City needs to work very closely with the court system on speeding up case processing. We have many people, 500 people, there for more than two years. These are people languishing there. The court should move faster, and that would significantly reduce the number of people. We have 20% of the people in jail who are seriously mentally ill. That is unprecedented, and the numbers have just been going up, so we need a focused plan with the courts to have other options for people with serious mental illness who are not

(00:21:41)

Being served well by being in jail. That is where I would focus.

(00:21:47)

I think of anything, Ransom.

(00:21:48)

I guess one more question. Following up on the chair and your pre-hearing question response, you know that continuing delays and escalating costs are creating the risks of our borough jail projects itself, which you just mentioned in your answer. Can you please expand on those risks and what role, if any, the Board can play in either managing them directly or reporting them for the benefit of policymakers to make the right decisions with policies?

(00:22:08)

In either managing them directly or reporting them for the benefit of policymakers to make the right decisions with policies? Absolutely. I think the Board, because of its unfettered access and because of its sole focus on the New York City jails, has the ability to identify problems earlier than many other stakeholders, and they can do that by talking with the management, with staff, and with people who are in custody,

(00:22:40)

and bringing to light, and to the Council, as much data as possible that the jails have. I think we have a risk of planning too much as if the borough-based jails won't happen. So we don't want to fall into a place where we make that prophecy fulfill itself.

(00:23:03)

Ourselves, but I think we also need to be cognizant that we need a Plan B also. Yeah.

(00:23:11)

Okay. Totally understood. Thank you, Miss King. Thank you.

(00:23:16)

Thank you. And now I am going to pass it off to our Deputy Speaker. Thank you.

(00:23:20)

Hi. I have just a few questions on deaths in custody. Fifteen people have died in custody in 2025, and seven have died so far this year. If confirmed, how would you approach reviewing those deaths, and what changes would you advocate to improve safety in jails? Thank you for the question. As you know, the Board of Correction is required to investigate each of those deaths, and I think the Board has been issuing very important and illuminating reports about each of those deaths. Additionally, what I hope the Board would do if I were appointed is look back on a regular basis, not just at one death, but at the patterns we see across all of those deaths, because we see recurrent failures and recurrent actions that make people unsafe, and a lack of prevention and a lack of urgency in addressing deaths. While it is very important to look at each individual death, we have to look across the deaths and highlight those patterns for the management, for the Council, and for the public.

(00:24:29)

Thank you. At the Correctional Association, you helped improve transparency around prison deaths. What steps would you take to make information about deaths in custody more timely and accessible to the public? Thank you. The Board's reports currently are the most timely and transparent. Of the different death investigations that are out there, what we don't always have is a retrospective, comprehensive accounting of the number of deaths, who is dying, and why. We need that alongside investigations, the basic data landscape, and in addition to the investigations, which is what the Correctional Association is issuing as well. Thank you.

(00:25:17)

And this is research, which I guess we should be calling a

(00:25:20)

King. Oh, I just passed last year. Yeah. Oh, congratulations. So wait, so you graduate. Whenever you walked. Oh,

(00:25:34)

Kenny Grant and John from John Jay. Most of my committee grad. Huge. Um, Silberman.

(00:25:47)

Okay, well, no dissertation.

(00:25:49)

Research examined 159 deaths in New York County, in New York City jails, over a five-year period. You identify recurring patterns preceding many deaths, including inadequate screenings, insufficient supervision, medical and mental health care, substance use treatment, communication, and record keeping. How have those findings shaped your view on the Board's role in investigating deaths in custody, and what changes, if any, would you advocate for the Board's approach to investigating deaths in custody? Ah, thank you. And

(00:26:21)

So it has. I think it would bring my experience from that

(00:26:25)

research looking at all of the county jails in New York. And as much attention as we put into Rikers Island, and as we should, I will say that the problems are pretty consistent across different jail settings. And that is actually the period I was looking at, the rate of deaths was higher outside of New York City than here. Not being said, I think, part of what I learned from that research, again, was really not just looking at one death, but looking across deaths so that one can take a systemic look

(00:27:08)

At what? What is failing in

(00:27:09)

terms of the delivery of services? The delivery of care. What is failing in terms of accountability? That is a large problem with the deaths: staff, for instance, who are not following the policies of supervision or not following the policies of screening, which is so important when people come in to identify any dangers or concerns, and that those people need to be addressed. That issue needs to be pointed out by management, and those people need either to be counseled, disciplined, or retrained. And it is not just that person. All of the staff need to learn from each of those individual deaths and the patterns we see across them. You said New York City

(00:27:58)

In comparison, the deaths are significantly, I would just say significantly lower. Like what? What are the averages versus New York? I would just love, comparatively, to see how it compares in the other counties.

(00:28:10)

Death rates are subject to a lot of change year to year in a jail. It was really Monroe, Suffolk, Nassau, and Erie counties, the ones that had higher death rates in New York City, and also this follows national patterns that smaller jails tend to have higher rates of death than much larger jails, which could be related to the resources we have, more research on the resources we have in health care and mental health care in larger systems.

(00:28:40)

So like we've had 15 deaths. Yeah. Um, do you know how many they've had in a year versus, I'm just very interested in the number.

(00:28:54)

One of the problems with dissertation research is that it is a little dated now, but I would happily send you updated numbers. Okay. All right. Thanks. Miss Prickau, my research, because COVID altered the patterns of death so drastically and chance.

(00:29:08)

Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. And we have been joined by Councilman Burlie and Felder, and now I would like to pass it off to CM Banks.

(00:29:16)

Thank you, Chair. I have seen that you, as the Executive Director, versus a Board Member, your resume shows you led the Board of Corrections as the Executive Director from 2015 to 2019. How is serving as a Board Member different, and what will you do differently in this role? So thank you for the question. The Board Members versus the staff and the Executive Director have very different roles, and I am much more cognizant of those differences, having served as Executive Director previously. Board Members really serve a public-facing role. So, leading public hearings, following the evidence produced by staff, voting on regulations and resolutions publicly, coordinating at high levels with the management of the Department, and really the Board Members work together to set priorities and set an agenda that then staff implement. Thank you for that.

(00:30:22)

Let me go into Local Law 42. I was actually proud to be a part of the Council that passed Local Law 42 to restrict solitary confinement and strengthen protections for incarcerated people. Do you believe solitary confinement should be banned in City jails, and what role should the Board play in implementing this law? I do believe that solitary should be prohibited, and the ban should remain. I think there is extensive evidence that shows the serious physical and psychological harm caused by solitary. At the same time, we don't have evidence that solitary deterred violence or made the jail safer. At the same time, it is not a sufficient condition to create safety in the jails. I think it is necessary, but not sufficient. The Department of Correction really needs a comprehensive and focused approach to violence prevention and responses to violence, and that goes well beyond solitary. It is about incentives and behavior management and following the data about why violence is occurring. On the role, when I was Executive Director, there were early reforms to solitary in terms of preventing young people from going in and people with serious mental illness, and the Board's consistent release of data and of monitoring how those changes were implemented helped further the reductions that we saw then. I think the Board's monitoring can help further the better implementation of that Local Law. I know within the confines of the federal courts

(00:32:12)

Position. Thank you. Thank you for that. What specific all tactics should the Board pursue to reduce violence while maintaining safety for both the staff and people in custody? So I think we get caught in a very bad cycle that is not productive of thinking about only responses to violence. It is very important that we think before violence happens, in all of those, which is about programming and keeping people occupied. It is about reliably delivering on our obligations as a City: if we say you have access to recreation, you should get recreation. So all of that has to happen, but then responding to violence, the actual separation of people who have committed acts of violence, is critical. De-escalation among anyone involved in violence is critical, and the existence of solitary didn't mean that that actually happened. So I think the focus needs to be on immediate de-escalation and separation of people who have committed violence.

(00:34:05)

And how should the Board monitor whether people in custody are receiving good due process protections required under Local Law 42? That is a good question. One of the privileges of the Board of Correction is to go into and access any part of the jail, including hearing rooms, and the Board has observed hearings in the past, and I think there could be a very important, focused look at all of the due process hearings that would be very illuminating for the Department of Correction, for New Yorkers, and for the Council. All right.

(00:34:13)

Thank you. Thank you, Chair. Thank you. And now I would pass it all to CM Lee. Hi. Good morning. Good morning, and apologies if you went through this. I was a little late. But as a social worker myself, former chair of a mental health committee, we worked on the mental health roadmap, and one of the things I didn't in my earlier years on the Council was work on the mental health roadmap, and one of the things we focused on once the pillar was the intersectionality between criminal justice and mental health, which is a big thing. I have learned a lot about it. I went on a visit and saw the facilities at Rikers after Health and Hospitals took over, and I really wanted to hear your feedback from your perspective: what are things that are working well, what are things we need to improve on, because Rikers is now the third largest mental health institution in the country. How can we better utilize treatment courts, what is needed with staffing? If you could give us a little bit more of the landscape and what you think could be worked on and improved? Thank you. We touched on it only a second before you were here. So you know, I think the numbers of people who are seriously mentally ill have continued to rise. It is quite shocking, I think, from where we were when I was Executive Director 10 years ago to where we are today, with 20% of people having a serious mental illness.

So I think we need all hands on deck from the State: state investment in hospital beds and psychiatric inpatient and outpatient treatment, as well as the court system's involvement, expanding treatment court options. We need the judges and the court system to think about the variety of custodial options for people with mental illness, as jail is not a place that can only worsen someone's mental illness. It doesn't get people better. And obviously we have a revolving door between the State and the City. I will say to the credit of the City health system running the health care in the jails, there are some very small innovations that do reduce harm, such as the intensive units that are much more highly staffed by health care staff for people with serious mental illness. Those are very important. Could those be in a hospital?

(00:35:30)

Executive Director, ten years ago to where we are today, with 20% of people having a serious mental illness. So I think we need all hands on deck from the state. A state investment in hospital beds and psychiatric inpatient and outpatient treatment, as well as the court systems involvement. As you said, expanding treatment court options. We need the judges and the court system to think about the variety of custodial options for people with mental illness, as jail is not a jail. Jail can only worsen someone's mental illness. It doesn't get people better. And obviously we have a revolving door between the state and the city. I will say to the credit of the city health system running the health care and the jails, there are some very small innovations that do reduce harm, such as the intensive units that are much more highly staffed by health care staff for people with serious mental illness. Those are very important. Could those be in a hospital?

(00:35:50)

(00:36:43)

Perhaps. Right. And as you

(00:36:44)

alluded to, though, the number of beds is a real issue, and I know that on the Council we really tried hard to expand the types of beds available for folks with severe mental illness. But in terms of

(00:36:45)

the referrals: if you deem someone who has severe mental illness, what does that look like in terms of the referral and the handoff for them to receive treatment versus being in the jail system? So that's

(00:36:55)

a good question. I'm not sure I'm the best position to answer it. I mean, if the courts are involved, right? We would need the judges' involvement in making that disposition about where that person would be held. Does that answer your question?

(00:37:08)

Yeah, yes. I know it's not obviously something we're going to solve here in this moment, but just to let us know and keep us updated in terms of where we are, the Council can help, because I know there are several members that are very invested in this issue.

(00:37:23)

So if we can push both. There are several pieces right before they get to the point where they land in Rikers, and then also after that point, what does the care look like and what does that system look like in terms of how we can uplift those folks. So anyway, I just wanted to put that out there. Yes, I would be remiss if I didn't mention supportive housing, and that we know that is the most cost-effective way to keep people out of jail. I think it's like 50% of the seriously mentally ill are homeless. Yes, and we did put more funding in for that, but I feel like it's not enough. So thank you. Thank you so much.

(00:37:37)

Thank you. I would like now to pass it off to CM Felder. Thank you. Good morning. I just want to follow up on the Banks discussion about solitary. So when I was in the Senate, I visited a number of jails in New York State,

(00:38:16)

I mean, they forgot about solitary confinement. Are you regular, you know, jail as solitary confinement,

(00:38:40)

(00:38:53)

I understood what you said, but I don't know if there is an answer. I'm not sure I understood what your proposal was to the actual solitary confinement that they have today. Yes, I'd like to pick up on two points you made. I think that much of what jail looks like is solitary, so that should be changed. That means that when people are not punished or under some kind of punitive sanctions, they shouldn't look the same. There should be programming and ways to keep people occupied and to move through the court process, so that should look very different. I think that's one of the problems: we can't just focus on solitary. We have to focus on the conditions outside of it. What I was trying to say about reform and keeping the prohibition on solitary is that it's very important that we respond to violence seriously and make sure that people are kept separate and that situations are addressed. But then also, there is a comprehensive disciplinary system that involves incentives and sanctions and is reliable. They have to implement it for all people, all the time, and that has not been the case historically. Thank you. I just have a few more questions about oversight, compliance. How well do you think the Department of Corrections is complying with the standards? The board standards are extensive, and clearly the department has the rules and policies in place that are reflective of the board standards. There becomes an issue in implementation and the consistent following of those standards.

The bigger problem, I believe, is that the department lacks information systems to actually know, for instance, how many people are going to recreation, and when people are going to programs or not. It lacks the ability to know where their staff is. So there are certainly problems with compliance with the standards, but we first and foremost need better information to accurately monitor compliance with the standards. Thank you. We were also joined by Counsel Krishnan. In your pre-hearing questions and responses, you noted that outdated record keeping makes compliance difficult to track. Why are improvements needed to improve communication between the department and the board? Good question. Right now, the board has restored unfettered access to the department. That hasn't always been the case under the last administration. There were a variety of ways that the board was obstructed by the administration and the Department of Correction. As long as management, staff, and the systems are communicating, that's the best we could hope for.

(00:40:48)

In your pre-hearing questions and responses, you said that compliance can look stronger on paper than in practice. What additional tools, if any, should the board have to hold agencies accountable when violations persist?

(00:41:02)

The board does have a variety of tools that are not always used, or not consistently used. That starts with audits and public reporting, moves on to resolutions and corrective action plans, and then moves on to notices of public violation. At that point, it is up to the court of public opinion and elected officials to back the Department and the Board of Correction's findings of issues within the jails. Thank you. I'd like to pass it off to Counsel Christian.

(00:41:50)

Thank you so much. It's good to see you. I had a few questions, building on some of the themes that have already been addressed. As you know, the 2025 Nunes report pointed to persistent staffing and operational failures at Rikers. How can the BOC help to address those problems and ensure that all the recommendations are put in place to improve conditions and overall oversight at our jails? Thank you. So I think the board's value lies within its ability to identify the cause of a problem by speaking with all the different stakeholders impacted by a problem, and then developing the information to accurately audit over time how that problem is manifesting in the jails. Then, developing solutions based upon practices from outside of New York City, but also with conversation and management about how to address those. As I was just mentioning, the board has a toolkit of escalating responses to non-compliance that it needs to use consistently, which I think will further the department's implementation of its policies.

(00:42:09)

Well, I appreciate that, and I appreciate your perspective on how to implement the findings and recommendations from the Nunes report, too. I think now we have a real opportunity with the new administration that shares, finally, the same values that I certainly do and many others: ultimately closing Rikers Island as quickly as possible, litigating the federal litigation, and making sure the consent decrees are actually implemented. I know that you will have a critical role in doing so, and I appreciate your approach to it. My other question is: when basic security failures continue despite years of oversight, what accountability measures should the BOC use to ensure supervisors are enforcing established protocols? We have Rikers, which is probably known for its failed accountability and discipline of its staff. We know that investigations into staff misconduct have dragged on and never been resolved. Like you said, I think we have a moment of opportunity to really address that problem. But until staff are held accountable and told what cannot be done, management can't tell staff what to do. In other words, you have to be able to say no, this cannot be done, if you're going to actually tell staff what can be done. I'm sure the administration is focused on improving accountability for staff, and I think that should be a priority. It's at the center of the Nunes consent decree, and I think it's also something the board should continue to look at.

(00:42:41)

And related, how could the board determine the underlying causes of staffing and supervision failures, rather than simply responding to individual incidents? Sorry, I didn't understand. How can the board determine or look at more causes of staffing and supervision failures rather than simply responding to individual incidents? In other words, as you just pointed out as well, we need to get beyond these individual issues and failures and understand the larger systemic reasons behind them. How do you see the board being able to do so?

(00:42:57)

Well, there's probably a couple of ways. One: the department, some years ago, developed an early intervention system for staff. In other words, if you see staff doing the smaller things wrong, how do you counsel, supervise, and support that staff to really learn the job and follow the rules and regulations? That has fallen away, I believe. I think the board could push that idea further. The board's audits of using video to actually follow whether or not staff's records are reflective of reality is another way that the board helps the department and the public understand where staff are meeting their obligations and where they are falling short. Thank you. And my final question combines those two together and applies it to our sanctuary situation. We have our sanctuary laws in New York City, as you well know. Earlier this year, my community oversight committee held a hearing about ensuring that the sanctuary laws were being enforced and implemented in reality. As I always say, our laws are not worth more than the paper they're written on if we don't actually enforce them and follow them in reality. We put out a very critical report about the last administration and the way in which information was being impermissibly shared within Corrections at Rikers, also then NYPD, and issued a series of recommendations.

(00:43:26)

To ensure that this instance is adhering to our sanctuary law policies and ensure that there are no violations of them, whether intentional or not: we had a very productive hearing earlier in the year. Leadership, under this administration, as opposed to the last one, has a real commitment to making sure that the findings and recommendations are implemented. The sanctuary laws are being taken much more seriously by this administration than the last one. As a follow-up to that, my question is: given that there can be individual failures that result in violations of our sanctuary laws, and such a crucial moment when there's so much fear and presence of ICE across our communities and neighborhoods like mine, there are individual instances, but they can also reveal larger, systemic problems. One of the things we talked about at the hearing was instituting trainings in place to make sure that employees at Rikers Island know what the sanctuary laws are, what is impermissible cooperation with ICE and city and federal government. That's really important. I also think there are other measures that can be taken to really protect our sanctuary laws in this moment, because ICE does not care about them. I've seen those instances over and over again in my own district, and we've all seen them across the city.

My question is, in particular: how do we ensure that, from an individual level and a systemic level, the Department of Corrections is both implementing the applicable protocols and doing all it can do to ensure our sanctuary laws are carefully followed in every instance at Rikers Island?

(00:43:31)

That's a great example of how, if the board identifies a priority, and when we as a city have identified a problem, the board can effectuate unique, ongoing investigations and audits of how the law is being followed. The board can attend trainings for Department of Correction staff and make assessments about whether or not that training is in compliance with the law and as effective as it should be for staff. It can talk to staff about whether or not they know the law and how to follow policy in their jobs. We also could look at the paperwork for each individual, like taking an audit of a series of individuals, and look at whether or not anything has changed since the Department investigation report.

(00:44:49)

Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Chuck. I believe CM Lee has a follow-up question. Sorry. Hi. I just wanted to go on a little bit of a deeper dive to follow up on the chair's question about the oversight and compliance and the outdated record keeping, because one of the things I saw frustrated on the social service provider side when I was on that end of it was the different silos in government and how the systems don't necessarily talk to each other. I'm just wondering, from your perspective, what systems are you currently using for record keeping, as well as communicating internally? How do those systems then communicate out to other agencies that you partner with a lot and that you communicate with a lot? And how could that also help with oversight, of course, while keeping privacy? I'll give one small example: a lot of times what we hear on the ground, in a totally different setting with the housing folks as well as the food providers, is that if they could simply put the housing questionnaire and the SNAP benefit questionnaire on the same application, it would tremendously help with streamlining. So are there things like that you see within your work that would be helpful in the staff's day-to-day, in helping them do the work that they're doing?

(00:45:23)

Since I haven't been at the board for a little bit of time, I'm not totally sure of their current access or how up to date they are on their systems. From my past experience, what I know from the outside is that the department and the board have had very outdated digital systems, and it makes it very difficult to understand what's happening or to track patterns. I think you're raising a really important idea, which is actually having the board look at all of those points where there are opportunities for better communication. I can think of, from the Police Department to the Department of Correction, for instance, at the beginning or between health services and correction while people are in custody, and then, of course, when people are returning to the community. There should be better communication and shared systems for community providers, as well as that the... So if you're in that position too, take a look at that. That'd be great. It probably happens, hasn't changed since you started. Even in our conversations with the day's offices, for example, I know that is something that is preventing them from being more efficient with both the cases they're working on, as well as getting people in and out of the system faster. So if you could keep us updated, that'd be great.

(00:46:31)

Thank you. That's great. Jim. Thank you. Seeing no other members have questions, Mr. King, you're excused. I want to thank the candidates for your patience, because I just need to take a thank-you break.

(00:47:01)

Next, we will consider the five nomination to the City Planning Commission candidates. Witness table.

(00:47:08)

Well, there's probably a couple of ways. The department, some years ago, did development of an early intervention system for staff. In other words, if you see staff with bad... not doing the smaller things, how do you counsel and supervise and support that staff to really learn the job and follow the rules and regulations?

(00:47:30)

That has fallen away, I believe. I think the board could push that idea further.

(00:47:37)

The board's audits of using video to actually follow whether or not staff's records are reflective of reality is another way that the board helps the department and the public understand where staff are meeting their obligations and where they are falling short. Thank you, and my final question.

(00:48:03)

That kind of combines those two together and applies it to the recent situation. We have our sanctuary laws in New York City, as you well know. Earlier this year, my Community Oversight Committee had done a hearing about ensuring that the sanctuary laws were being enforced and implemented in reality. As I always say, our laws are not worth more than the paper they are written on if we do not actually enforce them and follow them in reality. We put out a very critical report about the last administration and the way in which information was being impermissibly shared within Corrections at Rikers, also then NYPD, and issued a series of recommendations.

(00:48:45)

To ensure that this instance is adhering to our sanctuary law policies and ensure that there are no violations of them, whether intentional or not?

(00:48:53)

We had a very productive hearing earlier in the year. Leadership, confirmed under this administration as opposed to the last one, has a real commitment to making sure that the findings and recommendations are implemented. The sanctuary laws are being taken much more seriously by this administration than the last one. As a follow-up to that, my question is:

(00:49:20)

Given that there can be individual failures that result in violations of our sanctuary laws, at such a crucial moment when there is so much fear and presence of ICE across our communities and neighborhoods like mine, there are individual instances, but they can also reveal larger, systemic problems. One of the things we talked about at the hearing was instituting trainings in place to make sure that employees at Rikers Island know what the sanctuary laws are, what is impermissible cooperation with ICE and city and federal government. That is really important, and I think the other measures that can be taken to really protect our sanctuary laws in this moment, because ICE does not care about them. I have seen those instances over and over again in my own district, and we have all seen across the city. So my question is, in particular, how do we ensure that from an individual level and a systemic level, the Department of Corrections is both implementing the ally protocols and doing all that it can do to ensure our sanctuary laws are carefully followed in every instance in Rikers Island?

(00:50:21)

That's a great example. If the board identifies a priority, and when we as a city have identified a problem, the board can effectuate really unique ongoing investigations and audits of how the law is being followed. The board can attend trainings for Department of Corrections staff and make assessments about whether or not that training is in compliance with the law and as effective as it should be for staff. It can talk to staff about whether or not they know the law and how to follow policy in their jobs. We also could look at the paperwork for each individual, like a taken audit of a series of individuals, and look at whether or not anything has changed since the department investigation report.

(00:51:20)

Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Chuck. I believe CM Lee has a follow-up question. Sorry. Hi.

(00:51:25)

I just wanted to ask a little bit of a deeper dive to follow up on the chair's question around the oversight and compliance and the outdated record keeping, because just out of curiosity, one of the things I saw frustrated with on the social service providers' side when I was on that end of it was the different silos in government and how the systems don't necessarily talk to each other. I am just wondering from your perspective: what systems are you currently using for record keeping, as well as communicating internally, and how do those systems then communicate out to other agencies that you partner with a lot and that you communicate with a lot? And then how could that also help with oversight, of course, while keeping privacy? One small example is that a lot of the times what we hear on the ground, in a totally different setting with the housing folks as well as the food providers, is that if they could just simply put the housing questionnaire and the food SNAP benefit questionnaire on the same application, it would tremendously help with streamlining. So are there things like that you see that would be helpful in the staff during the day-to-day and helping them to do the work that they are

(00:52:45)

Doing so. Since I haven't been at the board for a little bit of time, I'm not totally sure of their current access or how up to date they are on their systems. From my past experience, what I know from the outside, the department and the board have had very outdated digital systems, and it makes it very difficult to understand what is happening or to track patterns. I think

(00:53:15)

You're raising a really important idea, which is actually having the board look at all of those points where there are opportunities for better communication. I can think about, from the Police Department to the Department of Correction, for instance,

(00:53:31)

at the beginning or between health services and correction while people are in custody, and then, of course, when

(00:53:38)

people are returning to the community. There should be better communication and shared systems for community providers, as well as that the

(00:53:47)

So if you're in that position, too, take a look at that. That'd be great. It probably happens. It hasn't changed since you started. Even in our conversations with the day's offices, for example, I know that is something that is preventing them from being more efficient with both

(00:54:10)

the cases that they're working on, as well as getting people in and out of the system faster. So if you could keep us updated, that'd be great.

(00:54:17)

Thank you. That's great. Jim, thank you. Seeing no other members have questions. King, you're excused. I want to thank the candidates for your patience, because I just take a thank-you break.

(01:01:28)

Next, we will consider the five nomination to the City Planning Commission. Candidates, witness table. Said the

(01:09:03)

And good morning. Now we will start with the left-most candidate and proceed down the line for opening statements, and then you'll follow the questions. I'm happy to go. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair and Deputy Speaker, members of the Committee, for this opportunity to appear before you today to discuss my nomination for reappointment to the City Planning Commission. I'm Anthony Crowell. I want to thank those Council Members who met with me during the pre-hearing process and who took the time to share their questions, perspectives, and concerns regarding the future of land use planning in our City.

After four years of service on the Commission, my desire to continue serving remains strong. My entire career as a lawyer and organizational leader has been dedicated to public service, building institutions, communities, and systems that better serve human needs and advance justice, whether in local government, higher education, community development, or civic leadership. I have always believed that effective public service begins with listening, collaboration, and a commitment to improving people's lives.

I care deeply about making New York City affordable and accessible to those who need homes and jobs. I care deeply about making our City more equitable, sustainable, safe, healthy, and economically vibrant. I believe that thoughtful planning and responsible growth are essential to achieving those goals.

Today, New York faces extraordinary challenges, particularly the continuing shortage of affordable housing. Addressing that challenge requires cooperation across every level of government and a recognition that both citywide and neighborhood needs matter. We must continue to identify opportunities to expand housing, support businesses, strengthen infrastructure, reduce environmental impacts, and improve quality of life for current and future New Yorkers.

Over the last 40 years, I have approached my work on the Commission with independence, objectivity, and respect for the facts before the Commission. I have sought to understand both the benefits and burdens of proposed actions, recognizing that our decisions affect both individual neighborhoods and the broader future of our City. Those principles would continue to guide my service if I am reappointed.

As this Committee knows, the City's land use framework has recently undergone significant change following the 2025 Charter revisions approved by the voters. As a Commissioner, I am committed to faithfully carrying out those responsibilities while ensuring that the Commission remains highly attentive to the voices of Council Members, as well as community boards and the residents they represent.

Throughout my nearly 30 years of service to New York City, I have always greatly respected and valued the role of the Council and viewed the relationship between the Council and the Commission as an essential one. I continue to believe that robust communication and collaboration with Council Members strengthens land use decision-making. The recent changes make that commitment even more important. While certain formal roles in the process have evolved, the need to hear and understand local concerns has not diminished. I have expressed my view that the Commission should continue to benefit from clear and meaningful input from elected officials, community boards, and community members, and I will continue working with Commission leadership to ensure that those perspectives inform our deliberations.

New Yorkers deserve a planning process that is both efficient and inclusive, one that advances urgently needed housing and economic opportunity while respecting democratic participation and engagement. My perspective on these issues is shaped by both my professional and personal experiences. I come from a working-class family and was the first in my family to attend college, and I attended law school at night while working full time during the day. My mother's family came to Brooklyn in the early twentieth century seeking opportunity, and like countless other New Yorkers, they relied on the promise that this City could create a better future for the next generation. That belief continues to guide me today.

I studied urban policy and planning as an undergraduate because I wanted to help make cities more just and effective. I worked on housing, land use, environmental, and community development issues before and during my service to the City, which started in 1997, when I was an entry-level lawyer at the City Law Department. Following that service, for more than a decade, I worked in City Hall in the Bloomberg administration on a broad range of matters affecting neighborhoods throughout the City, including 9/11 recovery, economic development and small businesses, and government reform. Those experiences reinforced my belief that planning and implementation are inseparable and that good policy succeeds only when government remains accountable to the people it serves.

Today, as Dean and President of New York Law School, I continue to work closely with students whose lives reflect the diversity, aspirations, and challenges of New York City. Many are first-generation college and professional students. Many work while attending school, and many struggle with housing affordability. Their experiences remind me every day that land use decisions have real-life, on-the-ground impacts and are not simply policy abstractions, whether people can afford to live, work, and build their futures in our City. That is why, during my tenure at New York Law School, we have built one of the strongest public interest housing law and policy programs among the nation's law schools.

Throughout my career, whether in government, leading academic institutions, or serving on public boards, I have relied on four principles that I often describe as the pillars of democratic good government: integrity, transparency, accountability, and independence. Those principles have guided my service on the Commission and will continue to guide my work moving forward, collaboratively with my fellow members of the Commission, the Council, the Administration, community boards, civic stakeholders, and New Yorkers from every neighborhood. Our City's future depends on our ability to find common ground and build solutions that serve both today's needs and tomorrow's generations. Thank you for your consideration.

(01:15:19)

Your consideration.

(01:15:28)

Good morning. Chair Menin, Deputy Speaker, and members of the Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics. It is an honor to be considered for reappointment to the City Planning Commission. I am grateful to Mayor Mamdani, Deputy Mayor Posner, and Chief of Staff Sherman for their support.

I appreciate the opportunity to testify before you today. The City Planning Commission plays a vital role in the long-term growth and development of the City and is paramount to ensuring that it is livable, affordable, equitable, and sustainable, and that it continues to thrive now and in the future. Given the significance of this position, I deeply appreciate this Committee's work in evaluating and deciding on this nomination. Thank you. Chair, Council Members, thank you for your service to the City.

I have worked for 36 years as an urban planner in New York, and my career has focused on land use, zoning, development, and preservation. I've held senior positions in both the public and private sectors.

(01:16:26)

GIVING ME A BROAD UNDERSTANDING OF AND APPRECIATION FOR HOW LONG DECISIONS ARE DEVELOPED, EVALUATED AND IMPLEMENTED. MOREOVER, I BELIEVE MY DECADES OF LEADERSHIP EXPERIENCE AT THREE OF THE CITY'S LAND USE AGENCIES QUALIFIED ME TO SERVE ON THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION.

I BEGAN MY CAREER IN NEW YORK IN CITY PLANNING AS AN URBAN PLANNER AND THEN AS A TEAM LEADER FOR COMMUNITY BOARD FIVE, SUBSEQUENTLY FOR MIDTOWN, THE UPPER EAST SIDE AND WEST SIDE COMMUNITIES, AND THEN AS DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF THE MANHATTAN BOROUGH OFFICE. I DIRECTED SEVERAL MAJOR PLANNING INITIATIVES AND AGENCY PRIORITIES. I ALSO WORKED ON COLLABORATING WITH COMMUNITY GROUPS AND LOCAL CIVIC GROUPS ON NEIGHBORHOOD PLANS, INCLUDING THOSE FOR EAST HARLEM WITH COMMUNITY BOARD 11 AND CENTRAL HARLEM WITH COMMUNITY BOARD 10, AND THE MANHATTAN BOROUGH PRESIDENT'S OFFICE.

I THEN SERVED FOR 10 YEARS AS CHAIR OF THE BOARD OF STANDARDS AND APPEALS, OVERSEEING ZONING VARIANCES, SPECIAL PERMITS AND APPEALS APPLICATIONS. MY TENURE FOCUSED ON STRENGTHENING PROFESSIONALISM, EQUITY, EFFICIENCY AND ENHANCING TRANSPARENCY IN THE BOARD'S OPERATIONS. THIS INCLUDED SETTING HIGHER STANDARDS FOR APPLICATIONS, BRINGING GREATER RIGOR AND ANALYTICAL DEPTH TO THEIR REVIEW, AND CREATING A MORE USER-FRIENDLY WEBSITE. FOR THE FIRST TIME, WE PROVIDED ACCESS TO THE BOARD'S DECISIONS. I ALSO SERVED AS THE CHAIR OF THE LANDMARKS PRESERVATION COMMISSION FOR FOUR YEARS. DURING MY TENURE, WE ADVANCED A VISION CENTERED ON GOOD GOVERNMENT, EQUITY, EFFICIENCY AND ACCESS. WE UNDERTOOK AN 18-MONTH PUBLIC PROCESS, RESOLVING A BACKLOG OF PROPERTIES ON THE COMMISSION'S CALENDAR, WHICH RESULTED IN DESIGNATIONS ACROSS ALL FIVE BOROUGHS. WE ALSO IMPLEMENTED PRESERVATION PRIORITIES IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE ADMINISTRATION'S REZONING PLANS, INCLUDING IN EAST NEW YORK, MIDTOWN AND EAST HARLEM, DEMONSTRATING THAT PLANNING AND PRESERVATION CAN GO HAND IN HAND. WE INITIATED REFORMS TO THE AGENCY'S REGULATORY PROCESSES AND INTRODUCED ONLINE RESOURCES, INCLUDING INTERACTIVE MAPS, APPLICANT PRESENTATIONS, COMMISSION DECISIONS, SEARCHABLE PERMIT DATABASES AND DIGITAL EDUCATIONAL TOOLS.

MORE RECENTLY, I WORKED IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR FOR PROMINENT LAW FIRMS AS A SENIOR ADVISER ON LAND USE MATTERS WITHIN THEIR PUBLIC STRATEGIES AND LAND USE PRACTICES. THIS EXPERIENCE DEEPENED MY UNDERSTANDING OF THE PERSPECTIVE OF A PROPERTY OWNER, SMALL BUSINESS AND NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE CHALLENGES THEY FACE IN PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT, FINANCING AND ENTITLEMENTS. THROUGHOUT MY CAREER, I HAVE WORKED WITH COMMUNITY BOARDS AND ELECTED OFFICIALS, BUSINESS ORGANIZATIONS, COMMUNITY GROUPS AND BOROUGH PRESIDENTS ON PROPOSALS AND A RANGE OF NEIGHBORHOOD PLANS. I HAVE DEVOTED EXTENSIVE OUTREACH TO COMMUNITY GROUPS TO EDUCATE THEM ON THE BOARDS' MANDATE AND PROVIDE GUIDANCE REGARDING THE PUBLIC PROCESS OF INDEPENDENT COMMISSIONS. I BELIEVE IT IS NOT ONLY IMPORTANT FOR COMMUNITY BOARDS, ELECTED OFFICIALS AND ALL STAKEHOLDERS TO ENGAGE IN THE PROCESS, BUT THEIR INPUT IS INVALUABLE TO A ROBUST PUBLIC REVIEW AND CRITICAL IN SHAPING DECISIONS.

I AM PARTICULARLY INTERESTED IN THE OPPORTUNITY TO CONTRIBUTE AT THIS POINT IN THE CITY'S HISTORY. NEW YORK FACES SIGNIFICANT CHALLENGES, INCLUDING THE URGENT NEED FOR HOUSING, ESPECIALLY AFFORDABLE HOUSING, AS WELL AS NEIGHBORHOOD INVESTMENT AND RESPONSIBLE, SUSTAINABLE GROWTH. IF APPOINTED, I WOULD WELCOME THE OPPORTUNITY TO HELP REVIEW APPLICATIONS THAT ADVANCE THE CITY'S OVERARCHING GOALS OF ADDRESSING HOUSING CRISIS, ENGAGING IN RIGOROUS PUBLIC REVIEW PROCESSES AND EMBRACING THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE COMMISSION. I BELIEVE THAT THE VOICES OF COMMUNITY BOARDS AND COUNCIL MEMBERS ARE INTEGRAL TO THE PUBLIC REVIEW PROCESS, AND I WOULD APPROACH THIS RESPONSIBILITY WITH GREAT RESPECT FOR THEIR RECOMMENDATIONS, WHILE ALSO RECOGNIZING THAT THE COMMISSION HAS BEEN ENTRUSTED WITH AN INDEPENDENT CITYWIDE MANDATE.

IN SUMMARY, IF I AM APPOINTED, I WOULD BRING MY LEADERSHIP AND DECISION-MAKING EXPERIENCE, SUBSTANTIVE AND TECHNICAL EXPERTISE IN PLANNING, AND MY UNDERSTANDING OF GOVERNMENT PROCESSES, AND MY EXPERIENCE WORKING WITH COMMUNITIES AND OTHER STAKEHOLDERS. I WOULD ALSO BRING MY ABILITY TO REMAIN INDEPENDENT, UNDERSTAND DIFFERENT POINTS OF VIEW, CONSIDER A RANGE OF CHANGES AND MODIFICATIONS TO ADDRESS CONCERNS, AND MAKE FAIR AND BALANCED DECISIONS.

NEW YORK'S LAND USE AND PLANNING ISSUES HAVE BEEN THE FOCUS OF MY PROFESSIONAL LIFE, AND I WELCOME THE PROSPECT OF TURNING TO PUBLIC SERVICE AND CONTRIBUTING TO THE BETTERMENT OF THE CITY. MY COMMITMENT TO SERVE ON THE COMMISSION IS NOT ONLY PROFESSIONAL BUT DEEPLY PERSONAL. AFTER MANY YEARS, RETURNING FULL CIRCLE TO WHERE I BEGAN MY CAREER WOULD INDEED BE LIKE COMING HOME. THANK YOU, CHAIR, AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE, FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION, AND I HOPE TO HAVE YOUR SUPPORT. I APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO APPEAR BEFORE YOU TODAY AS YOU CONSIDER MY NOMINATION TO THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION. I CARE DEEPLY ABOUT NEW YORK CITY, OUR NEIGHBORHOODS AND OUR SHARED FUTURE.

MY FAMILY HAS BEEN IN NEW YORK AS LONG AS WE HAVE BEEN IN THIS COUNTRY. MY GRANDMOTHER, WHO TURNS 98 THIS MONTH, STILL LIVES IN THE QUEENS APARTMENT THAT MY DAD GREW UP IN, AND TODAY I AM A PROUD NEW YORK CITY PUBLIC SCHOOL PARENT IN BROOKLYN. MY INTEREST IN URBAN PLANNING BEGAN DURING MY UNDERGRADUATE STUDIES, WHERE I BECAME FASCINATED WITH THE SPATIAL IMPACT OF PUBLIC POLICY DECISIONS, IN PARTICULAR THE FUNDAMENTAL ROLE THAT HOUSING POLICY PLAYED IN TWENTIETH-CENTURY AMERICA'S DEVELOPMENT PATTERNS AND THE INFLUENCE THAT HOUSING HAD ON SOCIAL OUTCOMES. THAT FOCUS LED ME TO PURSUE MY MASTER'S IN CITY PLANNING WITH A FOCUS ON HOUSING, COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, COMPLETING AN URBAN DESIGN CERTIFICATE AND WRITING MY MASTER'S THESIS ON FAIR HOUSING. I OBTAINED MY AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF CERTIFIED PLANNERS CERTIFICATION SHORTLY AFTER GRADUATE SCHOOL, COMMITTING TO ONGOING PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION TO STAY AT THE LEADING EDGE OF THE PRACTICE.

I HAVE SPENT NEARLY 20 YEARS IN AND AROUND NEW YORK CITY GOVERNMENT. I STARTED MY CAREER AT CITY HALL AND HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, AND THEN SPENT OVER 12 YEARS AT THE NEW YORK CITY ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, WORKING ON NEIGHBORHOOD PLANNING AND MANAGING PUBLIC REAL ESTATE ASSETS ON BEHALF OF THE CITY. I THEN SERVED AS THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF MAYOR ADAMS AND GOVERNOR HOCHUL'S JOINT BLUE RIBBON PANEL ON BUSINESS DISTRICT RECOVERY COMING OUT OF THE PANDEMIC, AND I NOW SERVE AS THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF UNION SQUARE PARTNERSHIP, THE BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT AND PLACE MANAGER FOR THE ORGANIZATION ON FOURTEENTH STREET.

THROUGHOUT MY CAREER, I HAVE LEARNED THAT PLANNING IN NEW YORK IS NEVER JUST A TECHNICAL EXERCISE. IT IS AN INTENSIVE COLLABORATIVE PROCESS WHERE STAKEHOLDERS BALANCE CITYWIDE IMPERATIVES WITH LOCAL PRIORITIES. I HAVE SEEN THE MOST DURABLE PLANNING OUTCOMES HAPPEN ALONGSIDE COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION, WHETHER PARTNERING WITH MANHATTAN COMMUNITY BOARD THREE TO OVERCOME FOUR TO FIVE YEARS OF DEADLOCK ON THE SEWARD PARK URBAN RENEWAL AREA, ALIGNING WITH BRONX COMMUNITY BOARD ON THE HUNTS POINT VISION PLAN, OR STEERING WATERFRONT INDUSTRIAL PLANNING IN SUNSET PARK WITH THE SUNSET PARK TASK FORCE AND FORMER COUNCIL MEMBER CARLOS MENCHACA. WORKING CLOSELY WITH THESE NEIGHBORHOODS AND STAKEHOLDERS YIELDED BETTER, MORE IMPLEMENTABLE PROJECTS. RUNNING A COMMUNITY ORGANIZATION MYSELF, I NOW BRING THAT GROUND-LEVEL EXPERIENCE TO MANAGING OUR WORK EVERY DAY. OUR CITY FACES A DIRE AFFORDABLE HOUSING CRISIS.

(01:24:24)

CRISIS. WE MUST ALSO SUPPORT THRIVING COMMERCIAL CORRIDORS AND PROTECT OUR INDUSTRIAL BASE SO NEW YORKERS HAVE ACCESS TO GOOD JOBS IN CENTRAL SERVICES. WE MUST ALSO THINK ABOUT HOW CLIMATE CHANGE WILL IMPACT OUR CITY AND HOW TO PURSUE SUSTAINABILITY AND RESILIENCY MEASURES TO PREPARE US FOR THE FUTURE. THE ROLE OF A CITY PLANNING COMMISSIONER IS TO EVALUATE PROPOSALS WITH INDEPENDENCE, OBJECTIVITY AND A DEEP RESPECT FOR PUBLIC PROCESS. AS THE COMMISSION FULFILLS ITS CHARTER-MANDATED DUTIES, I BELIEVE AUTHENTIC PUBLIC INPUT REMAINS INDISPENSABLE. COMMUNITY BOARDS, COUNCIL MEMBERS AND RESIDENTS PROVIDE ESSENTIAL LOCAL CONTEXT, AND MY OBLIGATION WILL BE TO CAREFULLY WEIGH THAT INPUT ALONGSIDE TECHNICAL DOCUMENTS SUCH AS ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEWS, TO ENSURE THAT DENSITY IS ALWAYS MATCHED WITH APPROPRIATE INFRASTRUCTURE. IF CONFIRMED, I COMMIT TO BRINGING AN ANALYTICAL, TRANSPARENT AND GROUNDED PERSPECTIVE TO EVERY APPLICATION BEFORE US. I LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING CONSTRUCTIVELY WITH THE COUNCIL AND COMMUNITIES ACROSS ALL FIVE BOROUGHS.

REGARDING MY NOMINATION AND MY ONGOING ROLE AT THE UNION SQUARE PARTNERSHIP, TWO WAIVER REQUESTS HAVE BEEN SUBMITTED TO THE CONFLICT OF INTEREST BOARD. THE FIRST WAIVER REQUEST SEEKS PERMISSION TO ALLOW ME TO CONTINUE TO APPEAR BEFORE CERTAIN CITY AGENCIES AND OFFICIALS IN MY ROLE AS EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF UNION SQUARE PARTNERSHIP, WHICH ROUTINELY REQUIRES COMMUNICATION WITH ENTITIES NAMED IN RULE 1.09, INCLUDING COMMUNITY BOARDS, COUNCIL MEMBERS AND CITY AGENCIES. THE SECOND WAIVER REQUEST IS TO ALLOW ME TO APPEAR BEFORE THE SAME NAMED ENTITIES IN MY ROLE AS UNION SQUARE PARTNERSHIP DIRECTOR IN RELATION TO THE PROCESS FOR POTENTIAL EXPANSION OF THE FOURTEENTH STREET UNION SQUARE BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT. I WOULD NOT APPEAR BEFORE THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION IF THE DEPARTMENT OF CITY PLANNING IS PART OF THIS PROCESS, AND I WOULD RECUSE MYSELF FROM ANY MATTER INVOLVING UNION SQUARE PARTNERSHIP'S BID EXPANSION IN MY ROLE AS CITY PLANNING COMMISSIONER. BOTH REQUESTS ARE CURRENTLY WORKING THEIR WAY THROUGH THE FORMAL REVIEW PROCESS. I ANTICIPATE THAT THEY WILL BE APPROVED, AND I FULLY COMMIT TO ABIDING BY ANY AND ALL GUIDANCE THAT PROVIDED. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR TIME, AND I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER QUESTIONS.

(01:26:22)

GOOD MORNING, CHAIR, DEPUTY SPEAKER WILLIAMS AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE ON RULES, PRIVILEGES, ELECTIONS, STANDARDS AND ETHICS. THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME THIS MORNING AND FOR THIS CONSIDERATION, AND THANK YOU, TOO, MAYOR MAMDANI, FOR THE HONOR OF THIS NOMINATION. MY NAME IS MARGARET ANADU. I GREW UP BETWEEN LAGOS, NIGERIA, AND HOUSTON, TEXAS, AND I HAVE SPENT OVER TWO DECADES HERE IN NEW YORK, MORE THAN HALF MY LIFE. I LOVE BIG CITIES, AND I LOVE THIS ONE. I WANT TO SERVE ON THIS COMMISSION FOR ONE REASON ABOVE ALL: OUR NEED FOR HOUSING, ESPECIALLY AFFORDABLE HOUSING. DURING THIS CRISIS, IT IS THE FOCUS OF MY CAREER, AND SO MANY OF THE DECISIONS THAT DETERMINE WHETHER NEW YORKERS CAN AFFORD TO LIVE AND THRIVE ARE MADE AT THIS TABLE.

MY PASSION FOR THIS WORK AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT MORE BROADLY BEGAN IN HOUSTON. I WAS PROUD OF MY NEIGHBORHOOD, AND I LOVED MY COMMUNITY, BUT I WAS ALSO BUSSED ACROSS TOWN TO GET TO A GOOD SCHOOL. THE GOOD SCHOOL ACROSS TOWN WAS ALSO WHERE THE BETTER STORES AND AMENITIES WERE, AND EVEN BASICS LIKE SIDEWALKS. AS A TEENAGER, I DIDN'T UNDERSTAND ALL OF IT, BUT I UNDERSTOOD THAT WHERE YOU LIVE SHAPES WHAT YOU CAN REACH. FOR MORE THAN 20 YEARS I HAVE WORKED ON THAT PROBLEM AS AN INVESTOR AND FINANCIER IN HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ACROSS ALL FIVE BOROUGHS AND IN COMMUNITIES NATIONWIDE THAT DON'T HAVE ENOUGH AFFORDABLE HOMES. MOST OF THAT WORK HAS BEEN IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR AS A PARTNER AT GOLDMAN SACHS, AND NOW, WHEN I LOOK BACK AT THE FIRM, I FIND IT RECENTLY WORTHWHILE TO WORK ALONGSIDE NONPROFITS AND OTHERS TO GET HOUSING AND INFRASTRUCTURE BUILT. MY INVESTMENTS IN HUNDREDS OF PUBLIC-PRIVATE TRANSACTIONS AND MY PUBLIC ROLES AS BOARD CHAIR AND BRIEFLY WITH NEW JERSEY TRANSIT HAVE GIVEN ME GLIMPSES OF THE OTHER SIDE OF THE TABLE. I WOULD BE EXCITED TO SERVE IN A NEW CAPACITY AND TO BRING THAT PERSPECTIVE WITH ME.

I BELIEVE THIS IS A DEFINING MOMENT. OUR HOUSING CRISIS CONTINUES TO PUSH OUT THE WORKING FAMILIES WHO MAKE THE CITY RUN, AND THE COUNTRY MORE THAN EVER NOW RECOGNIZES HOUSING AS A NATIONAL CRISIS. IT CREATES A REAL OPPORTUNITY, AND AN IMPORTANT RESPONSIBILITY TO GET IT RIGHT. GETTING IT RIGHT MEANS GETTING MORE DONE, MORE HOUSING, FASTER, AND IN EVERY BOROUGH, BUILT WHERE THE INFRASTRUCTURE CAN SUPPORT IT. IT MAKES SENSE. I BELIEVE DEEPLY IN TRANSIT-ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT. PARTLY THAT'S PRINCIPLE, AND PARTLY IT'S THAT I'M THE RARE TEXAN WHO DOESN'T KNOW HOW TO DRIVE AND DOESN'T EVEN HAVE A LICENSE. IT ALSO MEANS THOUGHTFUL COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT ALONGSIDE THAT WORK, NOT IN CONFLICT WITH IT. I'D ALSO LIKE TO BE A BIT OF A BRIDGE, IF POSSIBLE, IN LAND USE. COMMUNITIES, DEVELOPERS, LENDERS AND GOVERNMENT OFTEN AREN'T WORKING FROM THE SAME INFORMATION, AND THAT CAN BREED MISTRUST. CAPITAL, ESPECIALLY, IS VIEWED WITH SKEPTICISM, SOMETIMES FOR GOOD REASON. MY PERSPECTIVE INCLUDES KNOWING WHY ONE PROJECT PENCILS AND ANOTHER STALLS, AND WHAT IT TAKES TO KEEP A BUILDING AFFORDABLE FROM A FINANCIAL PERSPECTIVE. I'M EXCITED TO LEARN FROM COMMUNITY BOARDS, BOROUGH PRESIDENTS, COUNCIL MEMBERS AND MY FELLOW COMMISSIONERS. I WILL JUDGE EVERY APPLICATION WITH INDEPENDENCE ON ITS MERITS. WHERE YOU LIVE SHAPES WHAT YOU CAN REACH. I WANT MORE NEW YORKERS TO FIND OPPORTUNITY RIGHT WHERE THEY LIVE, AND I'D BE HONORED TO HELP BUILD THAT CITY. THANK YOU, AND I LOOK FORWARD TO YOUR CONSIDERATION AND QUESTIONS.

(01:29:35)

...

GOOD MORNING, CHAIR, DEPUTY SPEAKER WILLIAMS AND MEMBERS OF THIS DISTINGUISHED COMMITTEE, AND THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY BEFORE YOU TODAY. I AM, OF COURSE, KENNETH KNUCKLES. I BELIEVE THAT PUBLIC SERVICE PERFORMED WITH BOTH COMPETENCE AND INTEGRITY IS THE HIGHEST OF ENDEAVORS. ACCORDINGLY, THAT GUIDING PRINCIPLE HAS BEEN MY NORTH STAR OVER SEVERAL DECADES OF EXPERIENCE IN NEW YORK CITY GOVERNMENT IN VARIOUS CAPACITIES: AS AN ATTORNEY, AS DEPUTY BOROUGH PRESIDENT, AS A CITY AGENCY HEAD, AND, MORE RECENTLY, AS A MEMBER OF THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION, A MEMBERSHIP THAT NOW SPANS FIVE MAYORAL ADMINISTRATIONS. MY CONTINUING INTEREST IN LAND USE AND CITY ZONING POLICY STEMS FROM MY FORMAL EDUCATION, AS WELL AS MY RECOGNITION THAT RULES AND CORRESPONDING DECISIONS THAT HELP SHAPE THE CITY HAVE A PROFOUND AND LASTING IMPACT ON THE LIVES OF ITS INHABITANTS. AS A DIVERSE MUNICIPALITY WITH BOTH HIGH AND LOW RISE COMMUNITIES, URBAN DENSITY AND SUBURBAN SPACE, THE ONGOING QUEST TO FIND GREATER OPPORTUNITIES TO BUILD AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS BOTH CHALLENGING AND COMPLEX. IT REQUIRES BALANCING DEMANDS FOR MORE EQUITABLE DEVELOPMENT WITH PRESERVATION OF NEIGHBORHOOD CHARACTER AND DISTINCTION, PRECIOUS TO ALL OF OUR COMMUNITIES. I BELIEVE THAT MY EXPERIENCE, PERSPECTIVE AND BOUNDLESS DEVOTION TO NEW YORK CITY STILL ENABLE ME TO MAKE A MEANINGFUL CONTRIBUTION TO DISCUSSION OF THE ABOVE-MENTIONED ISSUES. IF I SHOULD AGAIN HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY, I AM READY TO SERVE. THANK YOU.

(01:31:35)

THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. SO I'M GOING TO START OFF BY ASKING SOME QUESTIONS. I WANT TO ASK THE PANEL. WHEN A QUESTION IS ASKED, IT IS NOT DIRECTED TO ONE PERSON. ALL OF YOU COULD ANSWER IT. SOMETIMES WE DO HAVE QUESTIONS THAT ARE DIRECTED AT ONE PERSON. HAVE YOU ALSO BEEN JOINED BY COUNCIL MEMBER BREWER? SO I JUST WANT TO START OFF THE QUESTIONING BY DISCUSSING POINTS OF AGREEMENT. IN RECENT NEIGHBORHOOD REZONINGS, THE CITY COUNCIL HAS OFTEN NEGOTIATED POINTS OF AGREEMENT WITH THE ADMINISTRATION TO SECURE INFRASTRUCTURE AND CAPITAL INVESTMENTS ALONGSIDE INCREASED DENSITY. DO YOU SUPPORT THAT MODEL, COUPLING NEW HOUSING GROWTH WITH PUBLIC COMMITMENTS FOR INFRASTRUCTURE AND OTHER COMMUNITY INVESTMENTS? WHY OR WHY NOT? AND THEN THE SECOND QUESTION: NEW APPLICATIONS FOR REZONING WILL NO LONGER PLAY A FORMAL ROLE IN THIS PROCESS, SO SHOULD NOW THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION ATTEMPT TO SECURE POINTS OF AGREEMENT FOR LOCAL COMMUNITIES? IF NOT, WHAT STAKEHOLDER IS IN A POSITION TO DO THAT IMPORTANT WORK?

(01:32:10)

...

(01:32:42)

GO AS THE YOUNGEST MEMBER HERE. WELL, I BELIEVE IN COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING. I THINK COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING IS SOUND WHETHER IT IS SPARKED BY A CITY COUNCIL MEMBER, A COMMUNITY BOARD, OR WHATEVER ADVOCACY EMERGES FROM THE COMMUNITY. I THINK IT IS THE BEST VEHICLE TO BUILD CONSENSUS, QUICKLY OR GRADUALLY, WITHIN A GIVEN COMMUNITY. I DO APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT LARGER PROJECTS THAT COME BEFORE THE COMMISSION GENERALLY HAVE THE ABILITY TO LEVERAGE THOSE KINDS OF RESOURCES FROM THE MAYORAL ADMINISTRATION, AS OPPOSED TO SINGULAR HOUSING PROJECTS OR A MAJOR REZONING. BUT I DO BELIEVE IN IT, AND I HAVE SUPPORTED IT OVER MY TENURE ON THE COMMISSION. WITH REGARD TO THE SECOND PART OF YOUR QUESTION, I APPRECIATE THE CONCERNS ON THE PART OF THE CITY COUNCIL WITH REGARD TO THE EXISTING PROCESS. THE CITY PLANNING COMMISSION HAS THE FINAL WORD, BUT I KNOW THE CITY COUNCIL WELL ENOUGH TO UNDERSTAND THAT THAT IS THE JOB.

(01:34:27)

While your role has been diminished somewhat, your influence will still be substantial. I am sure in the process, certainly as it relates to both the community boards and the borough president. But I believe that it imposes a greater responsibility on the City Planning Commission members too, to ascertain and make sure, from our staff that justifies before us, that our environmental impacts, especially the issues that are raised by both the community boards as well as the borough presidents, are vetted and seriously considered and resolved. Because if they are not, then the entire process ultimately will not have credibility. Which is not good for land use in the City and not good for policy. So, I appreciate the fact that the process was voted upon and adopted by the citizenry, which imposes now the responsibility on the City Planning Commission to fulfill its mission. But that mission now will include, ah, of any project that comes before us in the ULURP process. Thank you for the question.

(01:36:15)

Thank you for the question. I concur with my colleague, and I will add that understanding the infrastructure needs of our communities is something I identified in my questionnaire to you as a key priority. I often look at in my work on the commission, not just what the planning goal is, but understanding what would make it effective in terms of its implementation. I think we all do about infrastructure and infrastructure needs, not just for today, but for tomorrow, and planning for that. It is critically important that we take steps as a department and as a commission to understand the fullness of that with whatever application is before us. Of course, environmental review plays a key role in that with regard to ULURP. The commission itself did not play any role in shaping the Charter Revision Commission's proposals, but now that they have become law, we have the weight of the responsibility of implementing them as effectively as possible and understanding their impacts in terms of the procedural changes and the changes in political accountability with regard to the Council. I am deeply committed, and I have spoken to my colleagues on the commission, including the chair, just about making sure that we have a process in place to engage with, as early as possible, Council Members in affected districts. I think that's critically important, to have that dialogue from the outset.

I would anticipate that the kinds of dialogue that take place at community board level will have an even greater level of Council Member inclusion, and an amplification in terms of their perspectives. I think we need to pay very close attention to that. Obviously, it is a critical moment. The test of whether our land use processes work well and ensure that community voices are included, particularly Council Members who represent broad communities, is this moment right now. So I think the commission has that responsibility, and it is my personal commitment, but also my commitment as a member of the body, that we will all work to ensure that those voices are understood and have a role in shaping the outcomes, including how infrastructure priorities are set.

(01:39:01)

Thank you for the question. I will not be repeating myself or what others have said, but I also concur. I absolutely believe that planning and rezoning should be paired with infrastructure improvements and investments in communities. That is a longstanding planning principle, and it is a practice the Council has followed over decades, and it has been very successful, for the better of both communities at the local level and for the City overall. So I support that proposition. In terms of the two types of applications the commission will entertain: one is the more modest projects, which have very small increases in density, and those typically do not create controversy or issues in communities. That is one type of application. But I think what we are talking about here is really the fast-track affordable housing process, which is aimed primarily at the twelve communities that have seen the lowest amount of housing production over the last five years. In those cases, I would make two points. One is that for rezonings in those areas, whether they are initiated by the department or by Council Members, which, by the way, I was very glad to hear that Council Members are proactively looking at rezonings of their neighborhoods, I anticipate there will be a lot of interaction and outreach to communities, as well as Council Members and other elected officials, even prior to any kind of filing or before it comes before the commission.

So I think there are a lot of opportunities for issues related to the impacts of a proposal on the neighborhood to be addressed, and already considering different options or different kinds of recommendations about how a proper proposal can move forward. In the case of the department's initiated rezonings, I would encourage the staff, and use whatever levers I have as commissioner to encourage them to continue to do that. The other thing is that if we think about larger rezonings in these neighborhoods, they would also include an environmental review that allows the public or the option to understand what kinds of impacts there are, and also will inform the commission in terms of what kinds of considerations should be given while deliberating on these proposals. So I think it would address issues related to transportation, sewers, schools, the public realm, equity, and of course housing affordability and access, and economic development and job opportunities. So I think that even though the process does not have a formal role for the Council and the community boards, I believe it will be, anyway, integrating the process, and definitely in terms of a public hearing process. I would really look forward to working with the community and the Council Members on their position, as well as taking their input into practice. I appreciate the question. I don't want to repeat a lot of what's been said, because I actually agree with literally everything that's been said.

I guess that's the one thing I'd like to add: I think, Anthony, you touched on the political climate of the moment. I don't think it's lost, hopefully, on anyone, that these changes come at a moment where all communities, I think, will be heightened to what it looks like to have some of these expedited processes in action, and still have their views and their concerns. Their voice is frankly heard. It's certainly something I know I'm really focused on, all five of us are. So I think that we will be going out of our way, despite what specific votes and points in the process don't exist, to be taken into account, all of the information we're getting about these neighborhoods and communities, the infrastructure that's needed, not specifically just in the moment of a particular application, but in all the discussions we're having across everything that comes before us. So I am both optimistic about how community engagement can continue to be, not just as important as it has been, but quite frankly, even more important. And I think that the changes, whether it's fast-track ULURP, et cetera, at least for me, make me more heightened to that importance, not less. In the interest of time, I'll say I affirm the importance of infrastructure investment that is commensurate with increased density, and that I concur with my colleagues.

(01:42:46)

Anyway, integrating the process, and definitely in terms of a public hearing process, I would really look forward to working with the community and the Council Members. Position is as well as taking there of the practice. CB Alund, I appreciate the question. I do not want to repeat a lot of what has been said, because I actually agree with literally everything that has been said. I guess that is the one thing I would like to add. I think, Anthony, you touched on the political climate of the moment. I do not think it is lost, hopefully, on anyone that these changes come at a moment where all communities, I think, will be heightened to what it looks like to have some of these expedited processes in action, and still have their views and their concerns. Their voice is frankly heard. It is certainly something that I know I am really focused on. All five of us are. So I think that we will be going out of our way, despite what specific votes and points in the process do not exist, to be taken into account. All of the information we are getting about these neighborhoods and communities, the infrastructure that is needed, not specifically just in the moment of a particular application, but in all the discussions we are having across everything that comes before us. So I am, both optimistic about how community engagement can continue to be, just not even just as important as it has been, but quite frankly, even more important.

I think that the changes, whether it is fast track, et cetera, at least for me, make me more heightened to that importance, not less. In the interest of time, I will say I affirm the importance of infrastructure investment that is commensurate with increased density, and that I concur with my colleagues.

(01:44:55)

Thank you. I will pass it up to CM Reilly.

(01:45:00)

Thank you. Thank you to the panel for taking the time to testify here today. I love what I heard, as you said. I think we're trying to do our best to be as proactive as we can, and we share that deep commitment to actually working together. I think that's where we want to focus. The notion is that there is no going to be working with Council, and that's something that we want to make sure that we're addressing. So I just wanted to put that out there. I love everything that you all said. Neighborhood rezonings are my favorite thing now. I'm doing one in my district, the White Plains Road neighborhood plan. The Council is working on a few neighborhood plans. What role do you see in neighborhood planning when you're talking about producing affordability within New York City right now? I would just add on to this: the issue that I share with the goal is that last year we had the deputy speaker, who heard they would have a plan, which we had 12,000 units of housing, a Cohen is 14,000, up to 40,600. So you see that we've achieved a lot of units from the neighborhood planning, but it doesn't seem like that is a focus right now with the administration. So I just wanted to get your perspective, and if I'm wrong, please correct me. You all don't have to go if you all share the same sentiment, as you call it. Just add in. But we'd love to hear your perspective on neighborhood planning, on how we could use it as a tool for addressing affordability. Maybe I can start, since I've finished the awesome.

I mean, as regards what the administration is thinking, obviously, I don't have access to a lot of what has not been publicly shared yet. But in my general perspective, I think that neighborhood planning is critical. When we talk about where we talk about what's in front of the City Planning Commission, it's really just a slice of what it looks like to do planning in New York City. There are urban planners who do work that's around couple investment, comedian, for that never actually touched the land use process. Having a comprehensive look at what a neighborhood needs, maybe up to and including land use, is really important. I think that the more leadership that we see on the ground, alongside individual actors as well as the public sector, are going to result in the best path forward for all of the collective stewardship of the neighborhood. I'm really in heart with what my colleagues said about the leadership that we see coming out of Council Members, and we know also coming from organizations across New York City thinking about what the future of their neighborhoods looks like. I think it's really important that that goes hand in hand with, whether it's private applications or applications led by the department, in order to come up with what our collective vision is. Ok, that's fine with me too. Okay, this question is directly to Kenneth. I have a few questions for you. Kind of apologize to put you on the spot.

When your pre-hearing response, you emphasized careful review of housing applications as a way to address the housing crisis.

(01:48:05)

What factors would lead you to vote against a housing proposal?

(01:48:14)

Well, at the end of the day, if I vote against a project, it's because I believe that it does not enhance the built environment in that immediate community. Symptomatic of that would be an insufficient number of units that are affordable housing, or an insufficient environmental impact analysis. Perhaps it could be the scale of the project in relation to the existing community, although I appreciate that all communities are going to have to look at greater scale if ultimately we're going to achieve the affordable housing that we need. But Councilman, if I reached the conclusion that the project does not enhance the community and would have an arguably less than positive effect on the community than I would, I would vote against it. Okay. Also, in your pre-hearing response, you say that every neighborhood should contribute to addressing the housing crisis. What factors determine whether a neighborhood is capable of accommodating more growth?

(01:48:21)

Well, I think that starts, of course, with the availability of parcels. I can remember years ago, and I'll borrow the Bronx, where we had too much redevelopment of the borough, which now some 30 years later, I think has seen a renaissance. But each neighborhood varies with regard to the availability of land, so we've got to look at where the opportunities are. We've got to look at areas that are zoned industrial and manufacturing, to see where housing can be accommodated without extinguishing manufacturing and industrial uses where it's appropriate. I think each neighborhood, obviously each community, has got to, I think, act in good faith about the need to find affordable housing opportunities where they can, and I think DCP and ultimately the commission, that bring technical assistance where it's appropriate to communities, and to help them frankly figure it out. But we've got to really forge a consensus with elected officials, because you can't really go forward in the face of fervent opposition. So I think it's a collaborative process. Yes, I definitely believe it's a clattering process. I think elected officials are trying to do their job right now. We're finding specific areas in the communities that make sense where you could produce as much density. It just does feel like there is conflict when you are talking to, regarding some of those parcels in our communities that we believe make a lot of sense to do density, opposed to where you guys believe.

There's tons of examples from me being the zone and chair, and land use for the last four years, where I've experienced that with specific members. And in your pre-hearing response, you indicated that balance in the development with neighborhood scale and context was the

(01:48:44)

sufficient number of units who are affordable housing, or an insufficient environmental impact analysis, perhaps. It could be scale of the project in

(01:48:58)

analysis, perhaps. It could be scale of the project in

(01:49:03)

relation to the existing community. Although I appreciate that all communities are going to have to look at greater scale if ultimately we are going to achieve the affordable housing that we need. But a Councilman, if I reached

(01:49:21)

the conclusion that the project does not enhance the community and would have an arguably less than positive effect on the community than I would, I would vote against it. Okay. Also, in your pre-hearing response, you say that every neighborhood should contribute to address the housing crisis. What factors determine whether a neighborhood is capable of accommodating more growth?

(01:49:50)

Well, I think that starts, of course, with the availability of parcels. I can remember years ago, and I will borrow the Bronx, where we hit too much

(01:50:03)

of the redevelopment of the borough, which now, some 30 years later, I think has seen a renaissance. But each neighborhood varies with regard to the availability of land, so we have got to look at where the opportunities are. We have got to look at areas that are apparently zoned industrial and manufacturing to see where housing can be accommodated without extinguishing manufacturing and industrial, where it is appropriate. I think each neighborhood, obviously each community, has got to, I think, acknowledge the need to find affordable housing opportunities where they can, where it can. And I think DCP and ultimately the

(01:50:27)

commission, that, bring technical assistance where it is appropriate to communities and to help them frankly figure it out. But we have got to really forge a consensus with elected officials, because you cannot really go forward in the face of fervent opposition. So I think it is a collaborative process. Yes, I definitely believe it is a clattering process. I think elected officials are trying to do their job right now. We are finding specific areas in the communities that make sense where you could produce as much density. It just does feel like there is conflict when you are talking to regarding some of those parcels in our communities that we believe make a lot of sense to do density, opposed to

(01:51:16)

where you guys believe. And there are tons of examples from being the zone and chair and land you share for the last four years where I have experienced that with specific members. And in your pre-hearing response, you indicated that balance in the development with neighborhood

(01:52:07)

commission of how do you determine when a project is out of scale with a neighborhood? Well, you look at the existing zoning. You look at the built character of the community. But as I said, there has to be, I think, participation on the part of every community in terms of doing appropriate zoning. Where there is, certainly, where there is mass

(01:52:25)

commission. How do you determine when a project is out of scale with a neighborhood? Well, you look at the existing zoning. You look at the built character of the community. But as I said, there has to be, I think, participation on the part of every community in terms of doing appropriate zoning where there is, certainly, where there is mass transit, which has certainly been the focus, I think, of the commission over the last few decades: transit-oriented development. We need to scale these projects appropriately as best we can. Now, a number of the projects, as you know, come from private developers who are not in it to lose money. We all know that. So my approach has been to understand. We all live in neighborhoods. I live in District 5, a neighborhood in Wakefield, and a proposal for, well, I was saying all, a building, but that would never happen, obviously. But we all are protective of our neighborhoods. But I think we all recognize, hopefully, that if we don't address the affordable housing need in this city, then our neighborhoods ultimately are going to suffer from it.

(01:52:26)

transit, which has certainly been the focus, I think, of the

(01:53:08)

commission over the last few decades, transit-oriented development. We need to scale these projects appropriately as best we can. Now, a number of the projects, as you know, come from are initiated by private developers who, you know, are not in it to lose money. We all know that. So, I think my approach has been to understand. I mean, we all live in neighborhoods. I live in Five B, a neighborhood in Wakefield, and you know, a proposal for, well, I was saying all, and I building, but that would never happen. Obviously. But I mean, we all are protective of our neighborhoods. But I think we all recognize, hopefully, that if we do not address the affordable housing need in this city, then our neighborhoods ultimately are going to suffer from

(01:53:11)

Question for you. I cannot

(01:54:27)

Thank you. And last question for you. I can't go far to the other arm. You discussed that there are challenges with mandatory inclusionary housing, even though it's been a major accomplishment. Because you just shared what you believe the most urgent challenges are with it. Well, it's a debate that Anthony and I have heard for the last several years, and what is affordable, and whether or not the... You don't have level one, which starts with 25% of the portion of the building, of the square footage of a building, being affordable to those with 60% of the area median income. That is the challenge: greater subsidies ultimately will yield fewer units. But the challenge for us is to find, I'm sorry, as a city we've got to find more resources, so more people are able to afford housing. Now, that comes from the coffers of the City. I would hope that in the coming days and years the federal government will play a greater role than it has played in recent years, because we all have our limitations in terms of resources. Obviously the state government is critical to that effort. But the challenge continues to be: how do we reach as many people as we can with the resources that we have? Thank you. The next question I have is for Margaret A. Morgan. In your pre-hearing response, you stated that zoning is one of the most powerful tools for addressing housing supply and affordability.

What zoning changes do you believe have the greatest impact on housing, and what citywide issues do you believe are the most underrepresented in the land use decisions today?

(01:54:28)

far to the other arm. Um, you discussed that there are challenges with mandatory inclusionary housing, even though it has been a major accomplishment, because you just shared what you believe the most urgent challenges are with it. Well, it is a debate that

(01:54:30)

Anthony and I have heard, you know, the last several years. And what is affordable, and you know, whether or not the HA, you do not level one, which starts with 25% of the portion of the building of the square footage of a building being affordable to those with a of 60% of the city level. Um, that is the challenge of a greater subsidies ultimately will yield fewer units. So, but the challenge for us is to find, I am the OSA, as we, as a city, we have got to find more resources, to have more people be able to afford housing. Now that comes from the coffers of the city. I would hope that in the coming days and years that the federal government will play a bigger role than it has played in recent years, because we all have our limitations in terms of resources. Obviously the state government is critical to that effort. So, but the challenge continues to be, how do we reach as many people as we can with the resources that we

(01:54:47)

have. Thank you. Um, the next question I have is for Margaret A. Morgan. Your pre-hearing response stated that zoning is one of the most powerful tools for addressing housing supply and affordability. Was it only changes, do you believe, we have the greatest impact on housing, and what citywide changes do you believe are the most underrepresented in the land use decision today?

(01:56:30)

Man cash, it is hard to pick one zoning change. Processing and timing. Um, you know, coming from the perspective of, you know, thinking there needs to be.

(01:56:53)

Hmm. Thank you, thank you so much for the question. I think... it's hard to pick one zoning change. Processing and timing. You know, coming from the perspective of, you know, thinking there needs to be...

(01:56:59)

Man, it is hard to pick one zoning change. Processing and timing... coming from the perspective of thinking there needs to be...

(01:57:14)

I am a pro-development person. I think we need to build a lot more housing. I think we need to invest a lot in our existing housing stock. That is just an incredibly capital-intensive endeavor by nature, and so I think that in some cases, the lack of predictability in our processes is a real problem. Time is money. Lack of certainty is risk, and I think the more expensive a project gets, the fewer units you get in total, and the less affordable they are. If anything, I would speak to efficiency and predictability and time, which I think some of the recent changes will certainly serve. But of course, it remains to be seen whether we can really continue to have the type of community engagement that is really important alongside that. And then, can you remind me of the second question?

(01:58:20)

What city, where it needs to be, do you believe are the most underrepresented in the land use decision?

(01:58:24)

Today. Oh, I guess this is... I don't know if this really gets touched on in the specificity of the land use process. I know it certainly can come through some of the community benefits agreements I've seen, but I would say that the need for supportive housing, in conjunction with our affordable housing, is...

(01:58:53)

Okay, thank you. You're pre-hearing response. You identify the four-bah in production as the commission's most pressing challenge. How should the commission measure success in addressing that housing crisis?

(01:59:08)

Thanks for the question, I appreciate it. I think over time we need to look at total housing project production and depth of affordability, which Kim was talking about. And with that depth, the permanence of affordability. And then, of course, really consider how we were successful while appreciating neighborhood context, ensuring that the proper infrastructure is there. As we move forward, use different project areas as models for how to have more effective city-building. I think it's critically important that we have some indicators that show the tools we're using are successful, but also I think we have to do constant innovation. I'm very committed to ensuring that the program is as successful as possible, and I can raise some issues I would like to do more research and understanding on. How effective, I'm not entirely sure. When I see certain levels, I'm like, that can't be... It doesn't make sense to you, and I'd like to understand that a little more. So that's on the other side, doing more, a greater understanding of the research and where that research is coming from. So it's a comprehensive suite of things, both performance indicators and innovation and research on a forward-looking basis.

(02:00:36)

Thank you. Two more questions for you, Anthony. In your pre-hearing response you stated many Bloomberg-era downzonings and reflected concerns at the time, while also acknowledging today's housing crisis. Looking back, do you believe any of those downzonings should be reconsidered? I think that we have a housing crisis right now, and that there should be a situation where nothing is off the table in terms of their review. But it's always interesting and important to understand the context and how initial decisions were made and how we progressed from them.

(02:00:37)

So I would look at any application, look at any neighborhood proposal, and want to understand its history, of course, but also what can be achieved in terms of the crisis that we're trying to manage going forward. So it's safe to say your views have evolved during your tenure on the commission? I am always open-minded, absolutely, in terms of what could be. When you're looking at land use, you have to make sure you're keeping that open mind and looking at everything objectively, with an eye towards understanding how to solve problems.

(02:01:12)

Okay, and the last question is for Manofsky. In your pre-hearing response you identified delays in certification and project review as one of the commission's biggest challenges. What do you believe is a reasonable time frame for certifying an application, and how should the commission measure whether recent process reforms are actually succeeding?

(02:01:50)

I'm, thank you, Councilmember, for the question. I need to think. What would be an ideal amount of time? I think there are two issues. One is that you want to ensure that the quality of applications and the information needed for an application to be filed and certified is not diminished. But based on the period of time of pre-application review, I think balancing that is that it doesn't go on extensively, to the point where it really frustrates both applicants and people in the community who are waiting for investments in their neighborhood. I think what we see now, that there have been changes to the charter, I think will allow the commission to reorganize and deploy staff differently in terms of the review process. I understand that the chair and the administration are looking at a speed and sprint and various mechanisms. But I think the intent, if I remember correctly, is something like six months, which otherwise would take two or two and a half to three years. So the delays were based on a couple of things. One is the number of applications that go through. I think the complexity of those applications. I think the environmental review was probably the biggest stumbling block. I worked on the other side with clients bringing applications before City Planning, and it was the environmental review that was really the issue. So some of the changes seek to streamline the process, and I think it will do two things.

It may not be exempt, but staff that worked on this or would have worked on these applications can be redeployed, which makes the pre-application process much more efficient.

(02:02:13)

Thank you for your answers. I just want to say, I love everything you all said. I'm looking forward to partnering with you. I just want to emphasize that investments always seem to be tied to unit count, and I think that's the issue we're seeing now, where we want to talk about not only having an affordable New York City, but a livable New York City. Kenneth lives in my district. I'm pretty sure he wouldn't want me to add density here without taking care of the infrastructure issues happening within the community as well, and I think that's what a lot of communities are seeing, and that's what members are seeing as well. Lastly, messaging. I live in a highly residential community. A lot of homeowners don't understand why we have to produce housing in our neighborhood right now, because we haven't done a great job with the messaging and letting people understand that the population changed and that there are needs we have to focus on. So I do think messaging is important. And lastly, waterfronts. I do think we have a tremendous opportunity to activate our waterfront, because that's where we're losing a lot of New Yorkers to New Jersey and parts of Connecticut. So those three points are just for you all. Thank you so much for the opportunity, Chair.

(02:04:24)

Thank you, Chair. Now to pass it up to the Council Member.

(02:05:49)

Banks. Thank you, Chair. I wanted to first discuss community benefits agreements. We know that via community benefits agreements, Council Members have been able to get deeper affordability and make major infrastructure investments or commitments. In our pre-hearing questions we asked all five candidates to explain under what circumstances, if any, are necessary to protect communities from the externalities of proposed developments. That can be a valuable tool in planning, but the necessity and what they look like depends on the individual project, and there is no cookie-cutter approach. Mr. Sunni, I hope I'm not butchering your name? Yeah. There may be circumstances where they are appropriate, but their use depends on the project itself. Margaret, your response, you answered them. Then maybe examples where private agreements have been productive, but private enforcement carries risk. So here, your preference is for key commitments to be made publicly and then enforced by the public sector. Mr. Stein, you answered that you are not under the purview of the... because the CPC applications are evaluated on land use rationale, and then the formal public record. And Knuckles answered that they are not within the jurisdiction of the... should they be? While

(02:05:51)

the underlying question is how the city can ensure that new development is accompanied by the infrastructure and investments necessary to support it. I'd like you all to expand on your answers. Under what circumstances, if any, would be necessary to protect communities from the external impacts of proposed development projects? If you can all expand on your answer.

(02:08:08)

Yeah, I'm happy to start. Thank you for the important question and for reminding us all what we said, so that we can be consistent. I think that any agreement between two bodies can be productive. My comment about a preference for the infrastructure that we think is crucial and necessary, and part of a set of circumstances, why we think a particular land use application makes sense. My thought was that as much as possible, those things should be enforced clearly by the public sector body that approved the circumstances under which the community benefits agreement is necessary. So my one comment in my remarks was just about heightened risk. I think in private agreements that can only be enforced privately, I just believe there's risk.

(02:08:41)

There. Okay. Thank you. Thank you for the question.

(02:08:59)

I'm happy you asked about this, because I've tried to educate myself a little bit since then. I submitted the questionnaire, and I think one of the things is, I would agree with the sentiment that there are certain projects that will be before the City Planning Commission and will not go to the City Council, and that's where the city comes to us often. Negotiated investments in their neighborhood for infrastructure, for schools, open space, tenant protections, conceptually, it really does fall on the commission to grapple with those issues as they consider land use applications. I would say that it is a sort of instrument that's used. Instead of commenting on that instrument, there may be another instrument that should be used. But I think your point, and what I feel the commission should ensure, is that in some form, we are committed to getting feedback from department heads for the capital plan. I believe the chair noted that there are tools available that the department intends to use, all these levers and tools, that can in fact address the issues of impacts and effects on the neighborhood and mitigate any added density or growth in the neighborhoods.

(02:09:49)

Knuckles. Yes, thank you for the question, sir. I certainly believe that where community benefits agreements can be negotiated and carved out, they're for the good of communities. My perspective in terms of the City Planning Commission's role was, or is, that we should more or less stay in our lane in terms of looking at a City Planning application. I think it's our role, obviously, to determine the merits of the project and critique the impact of a project on a community, and speak to whatever deficits we see. But in terms of community benefits agreements, I don't think it's necessarily the role of the City Planning Commission to negotiate with applicants about over and above what the project presents, because I think that creates issues that take us beyond what our role should be. And frankly, institutionally, I don't know that elected officials would look kindly upon the City Planning Commission causing... I think it could be.

(02:09:57)

Thank you for your response. Thank you so much for the question. I'll speak to both my pre-hearing response, but also to align my perspective on this, philosophically, with what I mentioned in my response to CM O'Reilly's question. I think the idea often comes with the assumption that a project is swooping in as an outside action, and that it is not of the community. So the idea is that there's some project that has a number of impacts, hostile impacts, that can only be mitigated through some sort of a process with the community, where they get some sort of commitments that counterbalance the impacts of the project. But philosophically, going back to what I mentioned to CM Reilly, I believe these projects are most successful when they're thought of comprehensively, in the sense of overall neighborhood stewardship. Whether it's a private application or work being brought from the department, these are projects that should be thought of as offensively good and well designed, integrated into the community from the get-go, as opposed to a project that has negative impacts that need to be mitigated. You'll see when you have information that comes back through an environmental review, thinking about potential impacts, those are not a give-and-take. Those are things that get integrated back into the project fundamentally, whether it's an infrastructure investment or otherwise. I take the same perspective here, from the work I did over many years on the public side. I'll give you an example.

The first project I worked on was the Seward Park Urban Renewal Area project, which became Essex Crossing. But for many years, for forty-five years, the city had come and said, we want to do this version of this project, we want to do this other version of this project, and they always got shut down because they were not of the community. The innovation that happened in 2010, or 2007-2008, and finally in 2010, was going through an intensive collaborative process with the community board, with the Council Member, with different groups of the community, saying, come up with a set of guidelines that will build a project around. And it turned what had been an incredibly controversial and really impossible roadblock into a project that was able to be built. My lesson from that is that there are ways to position projects so that they are comprehensively thoughtful about the way they experience the community, as opposed to something that flies in and has to be mitigated. Thank you for the question.

(02:11:39)

So I'll just say at the outset that I do want to acknowledge the jurisdictional boundaries between what the Commission does and the role that community benefits agreements play, and how they're negotiated on a moral, community, and political level. Let me just say that I think community benefits agreements play an important role. Sometimes without them, a project can't go forward, and that's a value we have to understand and appreciate, and understand how projects evolved from not having community support to ultimately having community support. We hear those perspectives, and that's important. So I think it's important that we recognize the value of them and understand that they do not arbitrate what is just or fair in a benefits agreement. We hear it's about justice and fairness, through the voices of those who testified before the Council Members in particular. So was it helpful?

(02:12:16)

Thank you for your responses. I guess this particular question is about two lines of questions. Well, anyone can choose to answer. When evaluating significant new housing development, how should the city determine whether supporting infrastructure investments are adequate?

(02:12:33)

I can start. Yeah, you can. I think it's critically important that we rely on both the work of the department staff, which of course is exceptional, and equally as important and exceptional, the work of the agency partners. Depending on the nature of the infrastructure in question, I think those are fundamental threshold analyses that we look to, of course, environmental review and the formal processes. But it all plays into that, so that's a really critical component.

(02:13:12)

Problem. Thank you. Um, did you want to have a...

(02:13:18)

Nice time with all that. To the extent that the commission has or is developing tools to protect local interests in what instances, with the news... Well, I'd like to think that in our evaluation of projects, and their suitability and their compliance of existing zoning, or in the case of zoning changes, that the various findings that we must make... I think that process, hopefully, is a protector of the community. I seek our diligence in looking at these.

(02:16:08)

So I'll just say at the outset that I do want to acknowledge the jurisdictional boundaries between what the Department does and the role that community benefits agreements play, and how they are negotiated on a moral, community, and political level. Let me just say that I think community benefits agreements play an important role, sometimes without them a project cannot go forward. That is a value that we have to understand and appreciate, and understand how projects evolved from not having community support to ultimately having community support. We hear those perspectives and that is important. So I think it is important that we understand, that we recognize the value of them and understand that they do not arbitrate what is just or fair in a benefits agreement. We hear it is justice and fairness through the voices of those who testified before the Council Members in particular.

(02:17:12)

Helpful. Thank you

(02:17:14)

For your responses. I guess this particular question begins two lines of questions. Well, anyone can choose to answer. When evaluating significant new housing development, how should the City determine whether supporting infrastructure investments are adequate?

(02:17:35)

I can start. Yes, you can. I think it is critically important that we rely on both the work of the Department staff, which is exceptional, and equally as important and exceptional, the work of the agency partners. Depending on the nature of the infrastructure in question, those are fundamental threshold analyses that we look to. Of course, there is environmental review and the formal processes. But it all plays into that, so that is a really critical component.

(02:18:06)

Thank you. Um, did you want to have a...

(02:18:09)

To the extent that the Department has, or is developing, tools to protect local interests in specific instances, I would like to think that in our evaluation of projects and their suitability and their compliance with existing zoning, or in the case of zoning changes, the various findings that we must make, that process hopefully serves as a protector of the community. I seek our diligence in looking at these.

(02:19:14)

Cases, but applications, patients. Oh, and using our best judgment, which encompasses, you know, of communities. Oh, and obviously the record before us is... and inquiries with... Our staff, which we hold to a high... And I'd also mentioned, you know, there are projects that don't make the cut by then the commission. I mean, in many cases, they're withdrawn based on critique of staff. I think performing our due diligence is hopefully protective of communities. But if there are ways of perspectives that need greater appreciation and you know, I am all for hearing them. Thank you.

(02:20:14)

And else want to chime in on that, I will. Okay. This is a

(02:20:19)

Specific question. Is it that, in your pre-hearing response, you identified infrastructure as a major concern? Which infrastructure systems concerned you most as housing production increases? Thank you. Water, sewer. Concerned about transportation, access to public transportation, that roadway capacity. Open space, obviously schools.

(02:20:52)

Okay. So those are a variety of types of infrastructure that should all be considered. And certainly as we look at certain areas that have had lower production, it was important to ask why. And there might be a... in that lies in some of the infrastructure. Okay. Thank you.

(02:21:11)

Thank you for that response. Mr. Knuckles, in your pre-hearing response you identified affordable housing and infrastructure as key challenges. Which infrastructure systems concern you most as housing production increases, and how should the city prioritize infrastructure investments in growing neighborhoods? Well, there is... there is water and sewer. I mean, we're an old city. Where you bring thousands of units into a community, there's got to be strict attention paid to the capacity

(02:21:53)

of that community to sustain those units. There are schools. Obviously, the impact on school seats. And there is open space. Some communities too few, probably in New York City, but some communities have more than an abundance of open space and others don't have sufficient areas of open space. So it's comprehensive

(02:22:23)

planning. All right. Okay. Women, where... You can do it. That's necessary to really address all of the infrastructure impact. Okay.

(02:22:36)

Thank you. Thank you for your

(02:22:37)

response on that. And for Mrs. Germany in Europe pre-hearing response, you emphasize the importance of securing infrastructure investments alongside growth. What types of infrastructure investments do you feel are most critical when adding new housing? Water, sewer.

(02:22:41)

And it seemed like that. See what? Thank you for the question. With added density, I think there's a host of infrastructure that we should be looking at: school seats, look at open space, more on a capacity for transportation or transit, of the public realm as well. So I think identifying which infrastructure needs our importance, this related to the location, community, and the type of application proposal. That's before the commission. Parking is also one of those things. You look at two

(02:23:00)

as well, but then in my

(02:23:11)

district. Well, I personally wouldn't say parking infrastructure. I understand that their parking needs are met, incorporated and required, even with the new zoning taking place. They still require... I think as a more philosophical issue, I think the idea that communities should become more sustainable, so should have options that don't only use to drive a car, so we could invest in other ways, buses and other transport. Also leads to parking tonight.

(02:23:39)

We're driving a car is an option. Yes, it is. Thank you.

(02:23:43)

Thank you. Actually, I do have one follow-up question on this infrastructure, because I forgot someone did answer. Working with you on the other agencies in New York City.

(02:23:50)

So, for example, I'll give a sample, like the eight, right? Infrastructure in any development, and, you know, school seats right now, are, you know, important. How do you actually see that relationship working out? So in terms of, you know, saying, in this neighborhood, if we really do need to get more seats for the neighborhood because of the development, what would your response be? Does anyone need to answer this question? I think... I think... thank you for this specific question. In time, those things together, and I think it's consistent with what some of the comments you've been hearing. It's a part of a really important, comprehensive plan. So I think if there's a... so much of this exercise feels like how you get, efficiently, accurately, productively, all of the right information to make these really complex decisions. So in a scenario where

(02:24:29)

have been fairly specific about a geography and neighborhood where there are not enough seats, and that would just be something that requires really heightened attention in any land use applications relevant in that and that community. What would the response be

(02:24:32)

of, you know, sometimes, you know, I get it, you know, and feedback, saying that, but you know, have the ability to, you know, a developer in a situation or two. I'm a user of workforce, but to make a developer, you know, pay for a part of the... you know, of the project. What will your response be to that? Yeah. Manisha, should I... should I lean on the two guys who have been here? But I know, but I will say. I mean, I think that is one data point. If, if overwhelmingly there is a perspective that there are

(02:24:40)

you know, severely not enough seats relative to a proposal that is required, significant, or proposing significant additional density, then that would be a really important consideration amongst all the other factors. I don't... I don't

(02:25:25)

know that. I guess I wouldn't take it as we don't have the... you know, the appropriate... pretty to say you need to create more seats, but we have the not just pretty, but the obligation to take that factor into account and what's being proposed and respond appropriately. Oh, ah,

(02:25:48)

thank you for the question, and I agree with my colleague, my soon-to-be colleague, hopefully. So, um,

(02:26:04)

know if I am aware of an assessment that there's an inadequacy of seats in a given community and there's a project coming forward before us. And in most cases, developers, unless they're doing several thousand units, I don't think you can negotiate with the developer about school seats. So it's incumbent upon the city government to provide those schools. So, again, I think I said earlier in the earlier response, if there's an... if there's an environmental impact that states that there is a shortage of schools, and there's a project that's arguably going to exacerbate that shortage, then I think we're duty bound. Certainly, I would be... to not approve a project that would have such a negative impact. But I think the more positive approach would be to advocate for more seats on the part of the school system, so that we don't have to choose between seats and bedrooms.

(02:26:28)

Thank you. I'd like the passenger off now to our Deputy Speaker Williams. Thanks.

(02:26:58)

Share. I just want to sing for my neighborhood plan. They told me that we didn't have a need for new school seats, and when I asked them what criteria they used to present that information, they didn't really have anything substantive. So I also hope that as commissioners you questioned the validity of some of these recommendations from the agency, because I didn't really understand or believe or trust that the criteria they used to make a determination that we don't need additional school seats was accurate. So I just want to say that, because many of the schools that are within the neighborhood plans are all at capacity, like every single one. Either has been expanded or is currently under expansion. And so if you have schools right in the vicinity that are currently expanding because they're over capacity, how is it that when you think about building new units you say there's not going to be a need for a new school seat? So I just want to say that they told me I did not need new school seats, and I did not agree with that, and I did not agree with the criteria they used to make an assessment to say we don't think you'll need new school seats in 10 to 15 years. I know overall in New York City, school enrollment in New York City public schools is down, and I know that's a part of the calculation, but again, I hope that you question what is presented to you, truly, interrogate the validity of some of these

(02:27:20)

recommendations. I have a

(02:27:28)

random question, and then, like, real questions. So also, I'm chair of Cultural Affairs, and one of the things I've been talking to many of the culture institutions and advocates about is this idea of culture as infrastructure. When we talk about infrastructure, of course, what many people say is sewer, water, like that is what we think about, physical infrastructure. But it is my belief that culture and arts should be a part of how we plan for communities, and it should also be looked at with the same importance as physical infrastructure. So I just wanted to know if you agree with that, what you think about culture as infrastructure, because I do think it's important in terms of how we plan for our

(02:28:45)

communities. Oh, whoa! Oh, go ahead.

(02:28:49)

I would just say, believe it or not, I'm old enough to remember the rezoning of 120 Fifth Street, which was 2008, and as a part of that zoning legislation and code, if you build within certain boundaries of 120 Fifth Street, if you build a project that is at least 60,000 square feet, then 5% of it must be devoted to a cultural institution. That was in recognition of and in furtherance of the 120 Fifth Street, called Corrida, as a cultural car. I think that approach is inappropriate in scale, and should be looked at in other venues, in the community of Jamaica. Just to... it has a strong cultural heritage, and virtually every one of our boroughs, but that's one approach to zoning that I think enhances the cultural infrastructure within a given community.

(02:30:24)

Actually, spoke to you because he gave me a hard time. Will you get some money for some of the cultural institutions? But we really try to be creative with, like, air rights. Is there a way to leverage air rights and some of the cultural institutions to provide additional resources to them? But governments aren't creative, so I hope they struggle to understand how to do this. And I'm sure many of the people that were working on the Jamaica neighborhood plan probably didn't have the institutional knowledge of 120 Fifth Street, but I wish I was to you before. That's good to know. Hopefully, hopefully you'll be there Saturday morning when they open the new Civil Rights Museum, which is a benefit of that exact presenting.

(02:30:26)

One of my private sector favorite projects. But more comments on this question. If you have any? True, when we had that nice conversation a few weeks ago, I appreciated you bringing that up, and it's something that I fully support, along the same lines as CAN and reflecting what went on 125. I'll also say that there are lots of different projects that have opportunities for community uses, which could be promoted for cultural... to occupy. In addition, of course, when we look at infrastructure, libraries are a think of mine. I've been on the board of the Brooklyn Public Library for 23 years and chair for five years. That is a key, and for

(02:31:06)

key cultural infrastructure for all of Brooklyn, and adapting in real time to make sure library service is available, but also the kinds of programming that arts and cultural programs are essential. So it's, and it should be a clear part of our planning process. Thank you. And thanks for mentioning the libraries. There's also part of my committee. Don't want them to think about, though. No, no, they're in Dog, all packaged

(02:31:10)

it. Okay, so about the alert in our pre-hearing questions, we asked candidates about proposals that go through the expedited land use review process. Specifically, we asked what recourse a community board might have if the ignores their recommendations or concerns, and what role the commission has in nonbinding recommendations from the community board. Mister

(02:32:27)

Crowell, you answered that you were bound to uphold the law and following the language, processes are requirements from the charter, including considering the concerns of community towards council members and republic, a Miss Shereen of a Sin. Did I say that

(02:33:07)

correctly? Help me, shouldn't have often vasin. Okay, Miss

(02:33:52)

Sheen, you answered that alert be subject to legal recourse through Article 78 proceedings, and you believe that the liver allows for meaningful input and recommendations, and you're confident that the sharing department will engage with the community as standard

(02:34:15)

practice. Xanadu answered that community board recommendations should be a part of the record and that the commission should respond to them substantively, and that community boards have their voice through borough president's public hearings and council oversight roles,

(02:34:20)

and Miss Stein, you answered that community boards, maintaining, try to mandate advisor your roles under that community, where members will contain to provide testimony directly to the, and you believe that the has a responsibility to carefully consider public input during

(02:34:42)

review. And Knuckles, you answered that the must fulfill his try to mandate to work, including review of new applications. If you all can

(02:34:56)

expand on your answers and share what recourse a community board has if it disregards its recommendations, and what role does the commission have in addressing nonbinding recommendations from the community board? Um,

(02:35:00)

thank you for the question. I just want to clarify my answer. After the first question, what recourse, and I said Article 78. I think that was really sort of a legal answer to the fact that if the commission approved a project and the community wanted to appeal it somewhere, it would have to go to an Article 78. So that's just a legal answer.

(02:35:14)

But if your question is more so that the commission is moving in a particular direction, they're not listening to the voices that the community board has raised.

(02:35:29)

I think that's a different question, and if you would like, happy to answer that. I, I

(02:35:45)

feel that if I am appointed to the commission, I think it's absolutely imperative to, um, what? The concerns are during the process, deliberate with the commissioners, with the chair. I have led to it. Agency always heard different places from a state of stakeholders, and I think we often, in fact, more often than not, try to negotiate under a deliberate, let's say, an outcome that addresses those concerns. So we use the tools that are available, which is whether we should modify projects to address the concerns, whether we should impose conditions. So I believe that even in the commission, one can explore the tools that can try and address concerns that we hear from community boards and probably elected officials.

(02:35:52)

Well, and in my experience, even though the community board recommendations have always been advisory, they're always taken extremely seriously. And nothing about that changes. So you look at the process, you know, of course, while both council members and community boards are representing local community, and I've always seen the community board recommendations play out as an important thing of its own right, not necessarily tied later on in the council process. And so you know, I'm pleased that the community boards will retain that key opportunity for giving their

(02:36:13)

advice, your recommendation. And then, of course, part of having committee members and council members and representatives, you're going to be able to testify throughout the rest of the process, literally. Great word

(02:36:38)

for word with what you decide.

(02:36:55)

Oh, no, no, I would just say.

(02:36:57)

With regard to either, I think the impetus for alert was not to... certainly I don't perceive it to be to make it easier to get. As I said earlier, I think it places

(02:38:02)

an even greater burden on to make sure that environmental impacts and other issues that are raised by the community boards and the borough president or address, I mean, they're going to be substantive, and as they are, I think community boards in the City of New York are very, very sophisticated about land use, because, frankly, that's where they probably have the most impact. But when it comes to city services, those are the issues that frankly raised the ire of local communities, mostly. So they have to be taken seriously. They are, and I think it places a greater burden and responsibility on the Planning Commission to make sure what we evaluate and ultimately approve is really in the best interests of the community in a given instance. Thank you. Um, I appreciate that. I will say that from my experience, even being on the community board, the

(02:38:39)

(02:38:54)

(02:38:58)

(02:39:01)

(02:39:23)

(02:40:36)

(02:40:45)

Experience is layered, and I think some community boards, even when we get back... and I'm sure you see it with the community responses. Some community boards are very sophisticated and have very substantive recommendations that you can say, okay, maybe we can tweak things here and there. And then there are community boards that don't. I don't know if this is, maybe, boards need better education when these practices come to their community board. But that would just be my only flag. I do think the ways in which community members make their voices heard is not always equitable across community boards, in ways that allow for a true assessment from the... So just, just something to flag.

(02:41:32)

Consider for neighborhood projects that go through local Council Members, and I think we've been talking about this with my colleagues here. As you know, they often play a crucial role in securing project modifications, local investments, or other community benefits in order to ensure the proposal will not have adverse impacts on the local community. How can the Commission help ensure similar community benefits are achieved for projects reviewed through ULURP? And just one thing I wanted to add...

(02:42:05)

Idea of, what can the Commission do around community benefits? How can they ensure that there is outreach to the members? I'm thinking about my neighborhood plan. There was a decent amount of people that testified, honestly, but I felt like there could have been more people that testified on the neighborhood plan. My staff physically picked up the phone and asked people to call. We had been going through a process of a steering committee that informed the plan, so there was a lot of engagement along the way. But I just personally feel like a lot of people don't really come.

(02:42:47)

No, my conversations with you all, maybe saying like a lot of you know, you guys were happy to see me, but a lot of Council Members also don't come to the hearing. And so I feel like maybe it's on us, and maybe we need to talk to our landlord, sorry, our landing spokes. But also, just from your...

(02:43:04)

How are we ensuring that people actually engage at the right entry points, because the entry points are going to be significantly different for ULURP projects, sorry, later stage engagement? But like the engagement in terms of ensuring that these community concerns are being addressed. To me, you can't even really address community concerns if people don't even know that they have an opportunity to talk about the community concerns. So I'll, building off of what you mentioned about arts and culture being infrastructure, right? Civic engagement is also infrastructure, right? There's a lot of muscle memory that gets built over years before you're ever in front of this process. And so I think it is incumbent upon us, at the community level and at the city level, to be investing in community organizations and processes that frankly have nothing to do with land use, because it builds the networks and the ecosystems that allow us to engage people more thoroughly.

(02:44:01)

When something like this comes up. I started the day saying that planning is a lot more than a land use application, and I've worked over almost 20 years in this and only done a few land use applications. I think you will get the best type of engagement, like you're mentioning, when you have organizations who are further able to work with their people to bring them in, when they have elected officials who are hyper-engaged. And also, when we think about this as a long-term stewardship process that is outside of an application, I would just sort of like to piggyback on the idea of cultural protection, say civic engagement. When we do it right, across the board, benefits specific applicants, specific instances like land use, and also strengthens our city. I would just say, as it relates to the City Planning Commission, review sessions and public hearings on Mondays and Wednesdays happen in the morning and in the afternoon, when most of the people who are impacted by our decisions are working. That's not going to change. Obviously, community boards are where, at least presumably, that's where the neighborhoods can really come in and let their voices be heard. But I think, in this age of media, and I'm sure you're most sophisticated in this area than I, we have to do more. We have to do more.

(02:45:04)

More to, I think, use technology to communicate with our communities, as well as the community-based program in the local stations, our local stations. Bronx, what is it called? The Bronx. I forgot. Yeah, the community-based... I think they ought to be utilized to the maximum extent possible, and what the hearings are going to be about. And I would presume that the Department would facilitate that in any way, because at the end of the day, the more input we have, the better informed our decision-making processes.

(02:45:43)

Yeah, I just want to piggyback on what was said, and I'll just add. I do think there's an opportunity to think about using that new media to reach people, particularly social media. Media from elected officials can be a very powerful tool. It can present items in an objective way, but also in a way that is personal, because it affects where they live. And in addition, it can help shape the public's perception of projects that are being proposed, applications that are being made, and invite people to engage, and sometimes engage in the way that works best for them, but so that you, as a representative, can hear their voice and community boards can hear their voice. So I think there are some, it's hard to reach people, so using as many of these strategies as possible and being able to cut through the lots of different noise is really important, and in a way to engage people. But I find that if you don't engage people where they want to be engaged or willing to be engaged, it doesn't work.

(02:46:41)

Yeah, and I mean, that was a challenge for us during the neighborhood plan. So in your rules, do you have the authority to ensure that these forms of engagement do happen? And like even what you said about the timing for the hearings, does it have to be in the morning? Like, can there be proposed even those, like once a month, or ones that... I don't know how it really works there. Like, are there opportunities to make it more accessible for every single New Yorker to be engaged in the process, should they wish? So I will give huge props to the...

(02:46:45)

Department and the Commission for using social media, and what I think has been very effective ways to educate the public, using the website, directing people from social media to the website. Even recently created a little book for children on the land use process, which I found...

(02:47:27)

Really nice. So there's capacity to be creative and innovative in outreach. I also think that when it comes to access, we should note, even though some of those hearings are during the daytime, it is possible for people to participate via...

(02:47:53)

Remote links at lunchtime. There are times when people can come in, and there are no shortage of people who participate, particularly for very significant projects where there's a lot of public concern. Virtually, and we always appreciate that. It can be either on camera or even telephonically through the link, so it works nicely. And then those regards as far as the alternative time, I would have to... I'm not sure what the requirements are, but I know that there are a lot of individual outreach opportunities that the staff engages in through the borough offices for projects.

(02:48:33)

And so those are, again, sort of what I was saying: meeting people where they want to be met, or wherever they want to be. Those are some ways, and that could be a really good tool for Council Members too, to work with. I just hope your rules, in addition to us, because I do feel like it is also on us as Council Members, but hoping you all do that. You push the Department too, to better engage, because the process has changed, I think.

(02:48:51)

A lot of times, communities sort of wait to use their political capital for when these projects come to the Council. But because these projects are not going to come to the Council in the same way, that opportunity won't be there. And so I don't think it's coming upon all of us to figure out better ways to inform the community on how to best ensure that their voices are heard. I love the people in the Queens office, but maybe this is a new administration. But under Mayor Adams, they were under-resourced, and so I supplemented, doing robocalls using my campaign funds, just because I wanted the community to know about our meetings and opportunities to engage. I supplemented additional education to educate the community on the land use process, about working with...

(02:49:12)

Nonprofit organizations outside of you...

(02:49:48)

Know, I used my own funds to pay for food. That is an accessibility thing as well for people who are coming in the evening. And so again, I love, and I know that they, the Queens office, so much. Thank you. And of course, the end, but I do feel like...

(02:50:02)

You know, they have us on so many resources to do that type of work. Over the summer we did door knocking, the Council's community engagement unit.

(02:50:27)

Thanks to Aging Atoms, she allowed her community engagement unit to do it in the summer. But this is the Council, technically supplementing what the agency was supposed to do. But because I was passionate about making sure as many people as possible, to the best of my abilities, were aware, we did it. But it is expensive and it is hard. I just think sometimes we short-change the community engagement piece, and that's the real harm, not necessarily whether or not we do everything they say. But I feel like for certain communities...

(02:50:37)

Not communities, because for certain communities, they have already organized locally and they can quickly corral and have hundreds of people testify. But for other communities that don't have that built-in infrastructure or resources, it is extremely hard to get them to participate. And I think it is a disservice to us in government, and not truly hearing the voices of the community when we're making these...

(02:50:49)

Decisions. So I'm going to skip one question and say, what role, if any, should the Council continue to play in securing, you know, benefits? But to me, it's not always about benefits. It's also about modifications to some of these projects. You know, what role do you think we should play? You all had really good advice. Maybe we should talk off-line about figuring out how to make sure the Council still plays an important role, but we'd love to know on the record what role, if any, you think the Council should continue to play in securing modifications.

(02:51:21)

Question. I think the accounts, they that incredibly important, full and... I just want to talk about my experience before, when I chaired Landmarks, and both the boards had no foam, and the process had no formal role for the Council. But still, I think we were always open to hearing their position, and very often it was incorporated into the decisions that remained. So I think that even though we now have Housing Plus Track, I think the role of the Council is an imperative, and it can be implemented...

(02:51:25)

Either through, I think, the

(02:51:43)

Form of process, which is public hearings where the Commissioners will have a chance to hear your point of view and written testimony, but also just ongoing relationship with the Department. I think that's critical. I worked at City Planning. We always worked with the Council Members. And yes, it's possible over time, different administrations have had different approaches. But I think that for big projects, significant projects, there is a role that starts even before the application is filed, and I would encourage the Department to continue to do that.

(02:51:53)

I think in the case of private applications, I think the Department does encourage private applicants and their development team to meet with Community Boards, and I said yes, encourage and require two for things, right?

(02:52:23)

I don't know when they have to come to us, because they come to us, and that you do have those developers or a really smart lobby that are proactive in their approach. But that is not a requirement for them to do it. So it is very piecemeal, and it differs across projects, lobbyists, whatever other advisers they have with them. Because it's like you said, it's an encouragement, not a requirement.

(02:52:48)

Right, it is not a requirement. I don't believe there's any requirement that they have to do it, prior to an application being filed or before a hearing. But they are encouraged, and you're right, it varies. Projects also vary. Some are small and have a development team which is very modest. Another will have, as you noted, an incredible team of people, and some of those actually have the resources to meet with Community Boards in multiple venues. But just to go back to this general question, I think the role is, I would encourage Council Members and Community Boards to continue to express your opinions, and I think that the Commission has a duty to deliberate on that and consider modifications or other kinds of responses to those concerns. Okay, I know my own colleague wants to ask a question about the essentially the criterion, information you need to make a certain determination. So for the 12 community districts, adequacy of existing transportation, sewer, and other infrastructure before approval of a project. Let me...

(02:53:18)

So I'm going to let her follow up on that, but I just want to have... And unlike question, comment. Sorry, Chair, but I just wanted to comment on that. You can reserve your question

(02:54:09)

From when she asks, is that... with the Jamaican neighborhood plan, force to reduce the size of the map because of the sewer infrastructure. And it was a little bit of back and forth, and so on.

(02:54:10)

Just, I'm very interested in that question and how you all will make certain determinations around these projects that are not neighborhood plans. So it might be a lot to live, which looks a lot different than, you know, a whole, you know, 30, 40, 50 block.

(02:54:25)

But to just stay on theme about the Council's role, well-based, complete sense based off of our conversation that we had, but you repeatedly, which I love, the importance of Council input, particularly under ULURP and Fast Track. So what mechanisms would you like to see to ensure Council input reaches the Commission, and how should Commissioners weigh local Council Members' position when it conflicts with citywide housing goals? Yeah, I'm just very hopeful that the Council Members in these districts will be very active, and certainly, given the way the process has been restructured, that their voice is heard as early as possible, and the Community Board process, that they're dealing with applicants, and that the kind of impact that they historically had on the process. It just is coming in a different place, and its emphasis is there. Um,

(02:54:37)

I also believe that it's important for the Department to ensure they're having clear lines of communication with Council Members, of the Commission itself understands what is being said as a project makes its way to the Commission, and that the Council members testify before the Commission when projects are coming before us that pose specific problems for them.

(02:54:49)

Thank you so much. Thank you all, and congratulations on your nominations. Thank you, Pamela, pass it up to CM Lee. I was going to say

(02:55:02)

I don't know when they have to come to us, because they come to us. And you do have those developers, or a really smart lobby, that are proactive in their approach. But that is not a requirement for them to do it. It is very piecemeal and it differs across projects, lobbyists, and whatever other advisers they have with them. Because, like you said, it is an encouragement, not a requirement.

(02:55:28)

Right, it is not a requirement. I don't believe there is any requirement that they have to do it, prior to an application being filed or before a hearing. But they are encouraged, and you are right, it varies.

(02:55:45)

Some projects are very small and have a development team that is very modest. Another will have, as you noted, an incredible team of people, and some of those actually have the resources to meet with community boards in multiple venues. But just to go back to this general question, I think the role is that I would encourage Council Members and community boards to continue to express your opinions. I think the Commission has a duty to deliberate on that and consider modifications or other kinds of responses to those concerns.

(02:56:19)

Okay. I know my colleague wants to ask a question about the essentially criteria information you need to make certain determinations. So for the 12 community districts, adequacy of existing transportation, sewer, and other infrastructure before approval of a project. Let me, so I'm going to let her follow up on that, but I just want to have... and unlike question comment, sorry Chair, but I just wanted to comment on that. You can reserve your question.

(02:56:51)

From when she asks, is that, with the Jamaican neighborhood plan, force to reduce the size of the map because of the sewer infrastructure? It was a little bit of back and forth, and so on.

(02:57:00)

I'm very interested in that question and how you all will make certain determinations around these projects that are not neighborhood plans. So it might be a lot to live, which looks a lot different than a whole, 30, 40, 50-block area.

(02:57:19)

But to just stay on theme about the Council's role, based on our conversation that we had, which I love, the importance of Council input, particularly under ULURP and fast track. So what mechanisms would you like to see to ensure Council input reaches the Commission, and how should Commissioners weigh local Council Members' positions when they conflict with citywide housing goals? I'm just very hopeful that the Council Members in these districts will be very active, and certainly, given the way the process has been restructured, that their voice is heard as early as possible. The community board process, how they're dealing with applicants, and the kind of impact that they historically had on the process, it just is coming in a different place, and its emphasis is there. I also believe that it's important for the department to ensure they have clear lines of communication with Council Members, and the Commission itself understands what is being said as a project makes its way to the Commission, and that Council Members testify before the Commission when projects are coming before us that pose specific problems for them.

(02:57:39)

Thank you so much. Thank you all, and congratulations on your nominations. Thank you, Pamela. Pass it up to CM Lee. I was going to say

(02:57:58)

You like to see a way to ensure Council input reaches the Commission, and how should commissioners weigh a local Council member's position when it conflicts with citywide housing goals? I am just very hopeful that the Council members in these districts will be very active and, certainly given the way the process has been restructured, that their voice is heard as early as possible in the community board process, that they are dealing with applicants, and that the kind of impact that they historically had on the process is just coming in a different place. And its emphasis is there.

(02:58:44)

I also believe that it is important for the Department to ensure they are having clear lines of communication with Council members, that the Commission itself understands what is being said as a project makes its way to the Commission, and that the Council members testify before the Commission when projects are coming before us that pose specific problems for them.

(02:59:16)

Thank you so much. Thank you all and congratulations on your nominations. Thank you. I will pass it up to CM Lee.

(02:59:29)

Deputy Speaker, you should just ask, but she and I are very particularly interested in this answer because it impacts our areas of Queens pretty significantly. So, you know, I have four community boards in my district. It's very low density, laughing at because we've had so many of these conversations, and you know, it is different. So first I just want to recognize and appreciate the fact that you all are collectively saying that you want to really listen to the community board and Council Member voices, because I do believe, as you said, Nichols. Also, before every district is very different in terms of its characteristic neighborhood. What works for one may not work for another. Let me, but I think we've been experiencing, especially with a lot of the flooding, for example. I'll just use that as an example. Deputy Speaker and I, she used to have the part of Hollis before redistricting, where the family had passed away because of the basement apartment that got flooded. It is now in my district, and what happened recently is that because there's been so much flooding, one of the houses literally fell off of its foundation and had to be demolished. So now we're trying to work out a way to help the family so that they don't have to cover those costs. It's been very challenging. Just to give more context, I think a $20 million project put a tank underneath the ground to deal with this issue, and it clearly has not worked.

So, you know, the 12 community districts with the lowest production in the previous five years, it requires that the commission make a determination as to the adequacy of existing transportation, sewer and other infrastructure before approval of a project, and for projects reviewed through the fast-track affordable housing process. What information would you need to determine whether existing infrastructure can support new development? And lastly, before you answer that, just say I'm a transit desert. I have no trains, subways, nothing in my district. So infrastructure is a big concern.

[1] Not across the street in your district. I got it. Yeah.

[2] So, but yeah, we have a lot of challenges there in terms of infrastructure. So I just wanted to know what information you would need to determine whether the existing infrastructure can support new development. So I think it's important to sort of disaggregate the two types of projects we're talking about, because there could be more significant applications that come in through this process that would come along with a really comprehensive review. In those processes, those projects, you would have information about potential impacts and potential mitigations, and that is the information that we would rely on in order to evaluate the project comprehensively. I think there's this question. This came up as one of the questions that we had responded to, but there also is the potential for there to be more smaller projects that, incrementally or cumulatively, have impacts, but each individually do not. And this is the thing we've seen in New York City overall, like subway crowding, as an example, school crowding as an example. Each individual project doesn't have an impact on itself, but together they do. And I think this is going back to my earlier point, where the ULURP process is not the end-all-be-all of planning. These are places where the Council members, in conversation with the administration and the capital planning process,

[4] Outside of land use. Really?

[5] You have a lot of influence over, through the budget process, where investments can happen both in the short term and long term, to make sure that those incremental projects don't have a cumulatively negative impact.

[6] Or if they do, they're being thought through with more comprehensive neighborhood

[7] investments. Okay. Um, just out of curiosity, as I was listening to all of you answer the other questions, I wanted to flip it. Just ask: are there any city properties that the city would not build on, right? So how do you balance, you're sort of role too, your mandate to build, while also balancing that in terms of the neighborhood characteristics and some of the other questions that the Council members had? So certainly, hear, and thank you for the question. Are you asking whether there are any proposals that we would reject, or if there are any city properties that we believe nothing should be built on?

[8] I guess both, and I guess some. I mean, I know it's obviously a nuanced question in the sense that every project is different, right? Some, you know, will not go forward for environmental reasons, others not go forward because it's just not deemed possible to build there. But just wanting to get a little bit building off my previous question a little bit more, a sort of deeper dive into what the criteria is. Yeah. So I want to go back. Which Council member mentioned this? Someone was speaking before about livability. I think it was CM Riley, and how important it is not to just be building for affordability, but also for livability. I think there's the potential to misinterpret the mandate as "we just want to stack people on top of each other wherever we can house them," versus "we want to have orderly growth in New York City, where we're continuing to build a better collection of neighborhoods where people really want to live." And I think obviously, you know, it goes towards the latter, and that, you know, we're not just thinking about where can you warehouse people. It's how can we build neighborhoods that create attractive, affordable locations where individuals and families can thrive now and into the future. So it doesn't answer your question directly, but I think that is the philosophy, right? And

[12] I guess, I guess if I were to ask a jury. So when considering the proposals that increase housing, especially in lower-density neighborhoods like mine, because I have mostly, are one or two, some are three, almost little to none are four and above. So that just to give you a sense of how low density it is. My predecessor used to joke that on the subway map, the key legend of the subway map is right on top of my district, because there's literally nothing there in terms of trains and railroads and everything. So when you consider those types of lower-density neighborhoods, how would you balance the housing needs with the neighborhood concerns?

[13] I think a lot of it you have alluded to, which is hearing the community's responses and taking them into consideration. But what factors, at least for me, I would want you to know, and I would expect, frankly, that this kind of diligence would have been done by whoever is proposing a project. Where is the land that can be converted to residential? It's not currently zoned residential. Where are the properties, probably not many of them, but certainly that it should, some of them, are industrial properties, commercial

[14] strips that can accommodate appropriately scaled mixed use. I think those are realistically the opportunities in low-density areas, because, you know, I don't think anyone on the commission is insensitive to the nature and character of a given neighborhood.

[15] We all cherish our neighborhoods. But as part of everyone, every community playing its appropriate role, I think we've got to look at areas that historically have not been the source of residential development, but arguably can be in this new and enlightened era we're in. Yeah. No, and I appreciate that. Your answer before to CM Riley's question, alluding to that. So I appreciate that, and I sort of wanted to answer or ask a question more to Margaret, but want to open it up to everyone.

[16] So first of all, I appreciate your laughing emoji in your testimony tomorrow, which I appreciate because I do those all the time. But I am, to your point that you just brought up, where to look, right? For example, I do have a couple commercial corridors where it's just one floor of commercial space. So it is, I'm just one of the things I always used to talk to you about is that it's just so expensive to build lower numbers of units, and so I've always asked the question, because I can tell you certain places, even in my areas, where perhaps without disrupting the neighborhood makeup, you can still build maybe five units here, 10 units here, 20 here, and it adds up throughout the districts. And so I'm just wondering, if you know, especially Margaret, because I love how you talk about the public-private partnership, right, are there ways that we can partner so that it's not as expensive to build? Because I don't think a developer would go in saying, "Hey, we want to build five units of affordable housing here," because it's not financially viable for them. So how do we make it less expensive to build in areas where maybe we can add a little bit

[20] every right to address the crisis, the housing crisis. I love that question. Thank you. Thank you for

[21] asking it. I think one thing I'd say, and I hope this doesn't sound pessimistic, but I mean it just as framing: development in New York is expensive, big, small, inefficient, less. It just is. So you sort of start from a premise of hard, and kind of go with what makes it, quite frankly, less hard. I think they're actually, like really, really, around the city of rezoning. If you look at Myrtle Avenue in Northwest Brooklyn, which was a lot of, you know, single lots where there's now ability for increased density of housing above, and you had folks who put together four and five single lots, and then it makes more sense. It's still not going to be 300 and 400 units, but you start to get to a little bit more efficiency and still maintain a neighborhood scale and character. Also similar work you've seen on, you know, Bolt in the street through parts of Stuyvesant. So I think the idea that because something is not going to be a sky or hundreds of units, that it's not sort of worthwhile, and smaller projects over time, I think is false. I feel like one of the ideas that I'm excited about in terms of just housing lately is this idea of just

[22] sometimes it's a little bit everywhere, and I think there's a conversation that pushes that. So I think what you say, warehousing people, just stacking people everywhere, is not that. It's really sort of what additional housing is possible in context, in character, with the right infrastructure. And I think if that's, you know, five units over here and five over here, I think that's still incredibly worthwhile, even if it is, you know, potentially less efficient. Yeah, I just to piggyback on what you mentioned there, there is an opportunity for incremental

[25] growth, right? Growth in your neighborhood is going to look very different than in other neighborhoods. Right, the context is really important. But one of the opportunities through zoning is to create more value that makes these developments more attractive, and so I think one of the things to look at is where can we make appropriate changes that will both create more housing, but also housing opportunities for people who are in your neighborhood, who want to stay in your neighborhood, the children who grew up in the neighborhood who want to come back, people who are retiring and want to downsize. I think there's this sort of false dichotomy: the idea that if a neighborhood accommodates housing growth, it's only for citywide concerns. I think we also have a lot of people who wish they could stay where they grew up and actually have a lot of challenges finding housing. So a lot of the tools that come along, we are evaluating the opportunity to find a little bit of value in neighborhoods where a little bit more housing can become attractive. I just wanted to add that

[26] there are a couple of things in play which sort of changed the landscape. I think one is the City of Yes, which was "a little housing everywhere," that concept has been implemented, and we'll see. I know there are concerns, and people have different points of view, but what it basically did, particularly in lower-density neighborhoods, is allowed for a little more housing, and then also just increases in intensity, which were fairly modest. But the other thing is even the charter provisions, the amendments that were dropped in 2025, which also aimed at these modest increases, is also trying to address that: the incentives that allowed people to go into neighborhoods and propose rezonings for all this large and out-of-scale, and the smaller projects never really got off the ground. So I think it'll be interesting to see that with this change, what kind of applications come before the commission. I would also just say that, and I think all of us know this, that rezoning is not the same in one neighborhood versus another, and I think there's a lot of sensitivity to lower-density neighborhoods and how best to accommodate growth.

[28] Thank you. And to your point that you made earlier, Anthony, that's, you know, my area of Queens is where they really were fighting to sort of keep it. Because, you know, there's again, every area of the city is different, and in that particular area, because of the zoning in the neighborhood, of the housing that's there, it kept it lower density versus other areas.

[30] And so I appreciated you saying that. But just one final thing I'll say is that there is an example of a housing project in my district, which hasn't happened yet, but it's on state property, not city property, but you're too, all of your points: where can you look to build? It's on the property of Creed More, which is going to be a 50-acre project, which is huge. And this is an example of where I think really working hand in hand with a community paid off, in the sense that not everyone got exactly what they wanted on either side, but it came to a good middle ground, because I think that property had been discussed for 40 to 50 years, and the community board and the civic leaders and folks were okay with it in the end, because there really was a lot of listening that happened from the, you know, to

[31] the community's concerns and

[32] how do you adapt that into the project? So I'm actually, you know, glad that we were able to get it to a good place, and it's going to be everything from housing, veterans housing, senior affordable housing, affordable homeownership, which I feel like is not talked about enough, right, in certain communities. And, you know, the same thing that we talked about before: schools, probably, as you know, a firehouse that is going to be needed there. So it was a very well-thought-out process, and so I hope that's something we can continue to model in certain neighborhoods in particular. But yes, thank you.

[33] Thank you. Now I'd like to turn it over to CM Brewer. Thank you. I've done about over 200 town halls, and I have to say that in my experience, the City Council's role is incredibly important. I was able to get a whole park, a new school, and I could go on and on. Just recently, even with the community board, which is probably the most sophisticated community board in the city regarding affordable housing, we were able to get more affordable housing than the so-called. I am worried, I am, Board Seven is one of your 12, and I'm upset about it. I'd love to go to court about it, to be honest with you. I'm so angry, and we want affordable housing for years and years. No, no, Gail, we're going to go to the Bronx, land is cheaper. We're not going to give you a voucher. We're not going to do affordable housing, and nobody who is going to build wants affordable housing. They all want condos at $23 million a pop each. So it's a whole different world, and others here. So my question to you is, in situations like that, where we want affordable housing and we have buildings being converted, but that doesn't count because they're not new, only count new for the 12th. You have to have a new place. And with the second most dense neighborhood in the city, I assume in the country, I don't think there's one blade of grass available on the Upper West Side unless you tear down housing. My question is, how do you handle historic districts? Would you tear down housing in historic districts?

And how do you think affordable housing can be built in a district like ours that isn't convertible? I don't think so. I've got two vacant stores on Rose 57th Street and seven I stripped, and I can't get the city to make them and buy them or do something with a nonprofit, too expensive, can't do it, won't do it, et cetera. So I don't know. We're supposed to get affordable housing if to convert. I mean, to get around this 12. So my question is, historic district, and what do you do in a district like ours to change the situation? And also, we go against the mayor, even though you're appointed by him on some of these issues. That's my other question. Okay, but

(03:01:49)

Not across the street in your district. I got it. Yeah.

(03:01:53)

So, but yeah, we have a lot of challenges there in terms of infrastructure. So I just wanted to know what those are. What information would you need to determine whether the existing infrastructure can support new development? I think it's important to disaggregate two types of projects we're talking about, because there could be more significant applications that come in through this process that would come along with a really comprehensive review of those projects. You would have information about potential impacts and potential mitigations, and that is the information we would rely on in order to evaluate the project comprehensively. I think there's this question. This came up as one of the questions that we responded to, but there also is the potential for there to be more smaller projects that incrementally or cumulatively have impacts, but each individually do not. This is the thing we've seen in New York City overall, such as subway crowding, as an example, school crowding as an example. Each individual project doesn't have an impact on itself, but together they do. I think this is going back to my earlier point, where the ULURP process is not the end-all be-all of planning. These are places where the Council Members in conversation with the administration and the capital planning process

(03:02:12)

Outside of land use. Really?

(03:03:22)

You have a lot of influence through the budget process, where investments can happen both in the short term and long term to make sure that those incremental projects don't have a cumulatively negative impact.

(03:03:23)

Or if they do, they're being thought through with more comprehensive neighborhood investments. Okay. Just out of curiosity, as I was listening to all of you answer the other questions, I wanted to flip it. Are there any city properties that the city would not build on? So how do you balance your role, your mandate to build, while also balancing that in terms of neighborhood characteristics and some of the other questions the Council Members had?

(03:03:37)

Certainly. Thank you for the question. Are you asking whether there are any proposals that we would reject, or if there are any city properties that we believe nothing should be built on?

(03:03:42)

I guess both, and I guess some. I mean, I know it's obviously a nuanced question, in the sense that every project is different. Some do not go forward for environmental reasons, others do not go forward because it's just not possible to build there. But just wanting to get a little bit more, building off my previous question, a deeper dive into what the criteria is. Yeah. So I want to go back to something. Which Council Member mentioned this? Someone was speaking before about livability, I think. I have CM Riley, and how important it is not to just be building for affordability, but also for livability. I think there's the potential to misinterpret the mandate as "we just want to stack people on top of each other wherever we can house them," versus "we want to have orderly growth in New York City, where we're continuing to build a better collection of neighborhoods where people really want to live." I think obviously it goes toward the latter. We're not just thinking about where we can warehouse people. It's how we can build neighborhoods that create attractive, affordable locations where individuals and families can thrive now and into the future. So it doesn't answer your question directly, but I think that is the philosophy, right?

(03:03:56)

I guess, if I were to ask a jury, when considering the proposals that increase housing, especially in lower-density neighborhoods like mine, because I have mostly one- and two-family homes, some are three, and almost little to none are four and above. So that just gives you a sense of how low-density it is. My predecessor used to joke that the key legend of the subway map is right on top of my district, because there's literally nothing there in terms of trains and railroads. So when you consider those types of lower-density neighborhoods, how would you balance the housing needs with the neighborhood concerns?

(03:04:27)

I think a lot of it you have alluded to, which is hearing the community's responses and taking them into consideration. But what factors, at least for me? I would want you to know, and I would expect, frankly, that this kind of diligence would have been done by whoever is proposing a project. Where is the land that can be converted to residential? It's not currently zoned residential, you know? Where are the properties? Probably not many, but certainly some of them are industrial properties, commercial strips that can accommodate appropriately scaled mixed use. I think those are realistically the opportunities in lower-density areas, because I don't think anyone on the commission is insensitive to the nature and character of a given neighborhood.

(03:04:56)

We all cherish our neighborhoods. But as part of everyone, every community playing its appropriate role, I think we've got to look at areas that historically have not been the source of residential development, but arguably can be in this new and enlightened era we're in. Yeah. And I appreciate that, your answer before to CM Riley's question, alluding to that. So I appreciate that, and I sort of wanted to ask a question more to Margaret, but want to open it up to everyone. So first of all, I appreciate your laughing emoji in your test tomorrow, which I appreciate, because I do those all the time. But to your point that you just brought up, where to look, right? For example, I do have a couple commercial corridors where it's just one floor of commercial space. One of the things I always used to talk to you about is that it's just so expensive to build lower numbers of units. I've always asked this question, because I can tell you certain places, even in my areas, where perhaps without disrupting the neighborhood makeup, you can still build maybe five units here, 10 units here, 20 here, and it adds up throughout the district. So I'm wondering, especially Margaret, because I love how you talk about public-private partnership, are there ways that we can partner so that it's not as expensive to build? I don't think a developer would go in saying, "Hey, we want to build five units of affordable housing here," because it's not financially viable for them.

So how do we make it less expensive to build in areas where maybe we can add a little bit?

(03:05:44)

Every right to address the crisis, the housing crisis. I love that question. Thank you for asking it. I think one thing I'd say, and I hope this doesn't sound pessimistic, is just framing: development in New York is expensive, big, small, inefficient, less. You sort of start from a premise of hard, and kind of go with what makes it, frankly, less hard. I think there are actually really, really around the city examples of rezoning. If you look at Myrtle Avenue in Northwest Brooklyn, where there were a lot of single lots, and now there's ability for increased density of housing above, and you had folks who put together four and five single lots, then it makes more sense. It's still not going to be 300 and 400 units, but you start to get a little bit more efficiency and still maintain a neighborhood scale and character. Also similar work you've seen on, you know, Bolt in the street through parts of Stuyvesant. So I think the idea that because something is not going to be a skyscraper or hundreds of units, it's not worthwhile, and that smaller projects over time aren't worthwhile, I think is false. The idea I'm excited about in terms of housing lately is this idea of just sometimes it's a little bit everywhere, and I think there's a conversation that pushes that. So I think what you say about warehousing people, just stacking people everywhere, is not really what's happening. What additional housing is possible in context, in character, with the right infrastructure?

If that's five units over here and five over here, I think that's still incredibly worthwhile, even if it is potentially less efficient.

(03:05:45)

Yeah. I just want to piggyback on what you mentioned there. There is an opportunity for incremental growth. Growth in your neighborhood is going to look very different than in other neighborhoods. The context is really important. But one of the opportunities through zoning is to create more value that makes these developments more attractive. So I think one of the things to look at is where can we make appropriate changes that will both create more housing, but also housing opportunities for people who are in your neighborhood, who want to stay in your neighborhood. The children who grew up in the neighborhood who want to come back, people who are retiring and want to downsize. I think there's this sort of false dichotomy, the idea that if a neighborhood accommodates housing growth, it's only for citywide concerns. I think we also have a lot of people who wish they could stay where they grew up, and who actually have a lot of challenges finding housing. So a lot of the tools that come along, that we are evaluating, are opportunities to find a little bit of value in neighborhoods where a little more housing can suddenly become attractive. I just wanted to add that.

(03:06:23)

There are a couple of things in play which sort of changed the landscape. I think one is the City of Yes, which was a "little housing everywhere" concept. That has been implemented, and we'll see. I know there are concerns and people have different points of view, but what it basically did, particularly in lower-density neighborhoods, is allow for a little more housing, and also just increased intensity, which was fairly modest. But the other thing is, even the Charter provisions, the amendments that were dropped in 2025, which address these modest increases, are also trying to address the incentives that allowed people to go into neighborhoods and propose towers that were large and out of scale. The smaller projects never really got off the ground. So I think it'll be interesting to see, with this charter change, what kind of applications come before the commission. I would also just say, and I think all of us know this, that rezoning is not the same in one neighborhood versus another, and I think there's a lot of sensitivity to lower-density neighborhoods and how best to accommodate growth.

(03:07:06)

Thank you. And to your point that you made earlier, Anthony, that's my area of Queens, where they really were fighting to preserve it. Because there's, again, every area of the city is different, and in that particular area, because of the zoning and the neighborhood and the housing that's there, it kept it lower density versus other areas. I appreciated you saying that. But one final thing I'll say is that there is an example of a housing project in my district, which hasn't happened yet, but it's on state property, not city property. But to all of your points, where can you look to build? It's on the property of Creedmoor, which is going to be a 50-acre project, which is huge. This is an example of where I think really working hand in hand with a community paid off, in the sense that not everyone got exactly what they wanted on either side, but it came to a good middle-ground area. That property had been discussed for 40 or 50 years, and the community board, the civic leaders, and folks were okay with it in the end, because there really was a lot of listening that happened from the community's concerns, and how do you adapt that into the project? I'm actually glad that we were able to get it to a good place, and it's going to be everything from housing, veterans housing, senior affordable housing, affordable homeownership, which I feel like is not talked about enough in certain communities.

And the same thing we talked about before: schools, and probably a firehouse that is going to be needed there. So it was a very well-thought-out process, and I hope that's something we can continue to model in certain neighborhoods in particular. But yes, thank you.

(03:07:45)

Thank you. Now I'd like to turn it over to CM Brewer. Thank you. I've done about over 200 walks, and I have to say that in my experience, the City Council's role is incredibly important. I was able to get a whole park, a new school, and I could go on and on. Just recently, even with Community Board 7, which is probably the most sophisticated community board in the city, regarding affordable housing, we were able to get more affordable housing. I am worried, I am so angry, and we want affordable housing. Years and years. No, no, we're going to go to the Bronx, land is cheaper. We're not going to give you a voucher. We're not going to do affordable housing, and nobody who is going to build wants affordable housing. They all want condos at $23 million a pop, each condo. So it's a whole different world, and others here. So my question to you is, in situations like that, where we want affordable housing and we have buildings being converted, that doesn't count, because they're not new. Only new counts, for the 12th. You have to have a new place. And with the second most dense neighborhood in the city, I assume in the country, I don't think there's one blade of grass available on the Upper West Side unless you tear housing down. My question is, how do you handle historic districts? Would you tear down housing in historic districts? And how do you think affordable housing can be built in a district like ours that isn't convertible? I don't think so.

I've got two vacant sorrows, Rose 57th Street and Seven, I stripped, and I can't get the City to make them, buy them, or do something with a nonprofit. Too expensive, can't do it, won't do it, et cetera. So I don't know. We're supposed to get affordable housing if we convert. I mean, to get around this. So my question is, in a historic district, what do you do in a district like ours to change the situation? And also, we go against the Mayor, even though you're appointed by him on some of these issues. That's my other question. Okay, but

(03:08:13)

And I appreciate that. Your answer before to CM Riley's question, alluding to that. So I appreciate that, and I sort of wanted to answer or ask a question more to Margaret but want to open it up to everyone.

(03:08:25)

So first of all I appreciate your laughing emoji in your text tomorrow, which I appreciate because I do those

(03:08:30)

all the time. But to your point that you just brought up about where to look — for example, I do have a couple of commercial corridors where it is just one floor of commercial space. One of the things that I always used to talk to you about is that it is just so expensive to build lower numbers of units, and so I have always asked the question because I

(03:08:57)

can tell you certain places, even in my areas where perhaps without disrupting the neighborhood makeup, you can still build maybe five units here, ten units here, twenty here and it adds up throughout the districts. So I am just wondering, especially Margaret, because I love how you talk about the public-private partnership — are there ways that we can partner so that it is not as expensive to build, because I do not think a developer would go in saying they want to build five units of affordable housing here because it is not financially viable for them. So how do we make it less expensive to build in a way where maybe we can add a little bit?

(03:09:38)

Every right to address the housing crisis. I love that question. Thank you. Thank you for

(03:09:44)

asking it. I think one thing I would say, and I hope this does not sound pessimistic, but I mean it just as framing — development in New York is expensive, big, small, inefficient, less. It just is. So you sort of start from a premise of hard and kind of go with what makes it, quite frankly, less hard. I think there are actually some really interesting things around the City around rezoning. If you look at

(03:10:13)

Myrtle Avenue in northwest Brooklyn, which had a lot of single lots where there is now ability for increased density of housing above, and you had folks who put together four and five single lots and then it makes more sense. It is still not going to be three or four hundred units, but you start to get to a little bit more efficiency and still maintain a neighborhood scale and character. Also similar work you have seen on, you know, parts of Stuyvesant. So I think the idea that because something is not going to be hundreds of units it is not worthwhile — that smaller projects over time are not worth pursuing — I think that is false. I feel like one of the ideas that I am excited about in terms of housing lately is this idea of just...

(03:11:06)

Sometimes it is a little bit everywhere, and I think there is a conversation that pushes back on that. So what you are saying about warehousing people, just stacking people everywhere — it is not that. It is really about what additional housing is possible in context, in character, with the right infrastructure. And I think if that is five units over here and five over here, I think that is still incredibly worthwhile, even if it is potentially less

(03:11:32)

efficient. Yeah, I just wanted to piggyback on what you mentioned — there is an opportunity for incremental

(03:11:39)

growth. Growth in your neighborhood is going to look very different than in other neighborhoods. There are just different contexts and that context is really important. But one of the opportunities through zoning is to create more value that makes these developments more attractive. So I think one of the things to look at is where can we make appropriate changes that will both create more housing but also housing opportunities for people who are in your neighborhood who want to stay in your neighborhood — the children who grew up in the neighborhood who want to come back, people who are retiring and want to downsize. I think there is a false dichotomy in the idea that if a neighborhood accommodates housing growth it is only for citywide concerns. I think we really also have a lot of people who wish they could stay where they grew up and actually have a lot of challenge finding housing. So a lot of the tools that we are evaluating create an opportunity to find a little bit of value in neighborhoods where a little bit more housing all of a sudden becomes attractive. I just wanted to add that.

(03:12:44)

There are a couple of things that are in play which sort of change the landscape. I think one is that City of Yes, which was the "a little housing everywhere" concept, has been implemented and we will see. I know there are concerns and people have different points of view, but what it basically did, particularly in lower density neighborhoods, was allow for a little more housing. And then also just increases in intensity which were fairly modest. But the other thing is even the Charter provisions — the amendments that were adopted in 2025 — which talk about

(03:13:22)

these modest increases, are also trying to address that. The incentives that allowed people to go into neighborhoods and propose rezonings for large out-of-scale projects meant the smaller projects never really got off the ground. So I think it will be interesting to see, with this Charter change, what kind of applications come before the Commission. I would also just say that, and I think all of us know this, that

(03:13:52)

rezoning tailored to a particular community is not the same in one neighborhood versus another, and I think there is a lot of sensitivity to lower density neighborhoods and how best to accommodate growth.

(03:14:08)

Thank you. And to your point that you made earlier, Anthony — my area of Queens is where they really were fighting to, because every area of the City is different. In that particular area, because of the zoning and the nature of the housing that is there, it kept it lower density versus other areas.

(03:14:32)

And so I appreciated you saying that. But just one final thing I will say is that there is an example of a housing project in my district which has not happened yet, but it is on State property, not City property. To all of your points about where you can look to build — it is on the property of Creedmoor, which is going to be a fifty-acre project, which is huge. This is an example of where I think really working hand in hand with a community paid off, in the sense that everyone may not have gotten exactly what they wanted on either side, but it came to a good middle ground because that property had been discussed for forty or fifty years. The community board and the civic leaders and folks were okay with it in the end because there really was a lot of listening that happened from the

(03:15:28)

community's concerns and

(03:15:29)

how do you adapt that into the project. So I am actually glad that we were able to get it to a good place. It is going to be everything from housing — veterans housing, senior affordable housing, affordable homeownership, which I feel like is not talked about enough in certain communities — and just, you know, the same things we talked about before: schools, probably a firehouse that is going to be needed there. So it was a very well thought out process and I hope that is something we can continue to model in certain neighborhoods in particular. Thank you.

(03:16:08)

Thank you. Now I would like to turn it over to CM Brewer. Thank you. I have done about over 200 land use applications and I have to say that in my experience the City Council's role is incredibly important. I was able to get a whole park, a new school, and I could go on and on. And just recently, even with Community Board Four, which is probably the most sophisticated community board in the City regarding affordable housing, we were able to get more affordable housing than the minimum. So I am worried — Board Seven is one of your twelve and I am very upset about it. I would love to go to court about it, to be honest with you. I am so angry. We have wanted affordable housing for years and years. No — "Gail, we are going to go to the Bronx, land is cheaper. We are not going to give you a voucher. We are not going to do affordable housing." And nobody who is going to build wants affordable housing. They all want condos at twenty-three million dollars a pop each.

So it is a whole different world. My question to you is: in situations like that where we want affordable housing, we have conversions happening, but those do not count because they are not new. You have to have a new unit to count toward the twelve. And with the second most dense neighborhood in the City — I assume in the country — I do not think there is one blade of grass available on the Upper West Side unless you tear housing down. My question is: how do you handle historic districts? Would you tear down housing in historic districts? And how do you think affordable housing can be built in a district like ours that is not convertible? I have two vacant row houses on 57th Street and I cannot get the City to buy them or do something with a nonprofit — too expensive, cannot do it, will not do it, et cetera. So I do not know how we are supposed to get affordable housing. My question is about historic districts and what do you do in a district like ours to change the situation. And also: do you go against the Mayor, even though you are appointed by him, on some of these issues? That is my other question.

(03:18:29)

Thank you for that, and just all your service and passion. I think, I hope I am not speaking out of school here, but I feel like some of the designation of the lowest 12, that it almost feels like it is punitive, or that these districts have done something wrong or made a mistake. But one of the things you outlined, even talking about developers, talking about landing the Bronx, landing in your district, highlights one of the economic realities. You have seen a lot more affordable housing developed in parts of the city, especially private-on-private lots, where it is cheaper. So I just wanted to share two things. One

(03:19:11)

I hope it is a really just

(03:19:13)

healthy opportunity to talk in real terms around what are some of the reasons why some districts have produced less housing that seems like a really

(03:19:22)

Great practical one. It is

(03:19:24)

mostly developed. There are fewer lots, and it is more expensive to do so because it is in one of the most high-expense land parts of the city. So I view that as a positive too, highlight, and have people, stakeholders, commission members, community members, several people understand what it takes to create affordable housing and what are objectively some of the barriers. So I look at that positively. I think part of that, and I always think about the capitalization of these things and what makes it feasible, part of the fast track from my perspective. This comes with optimism that we can still have robust, significant, real and genuine community engagement. If you take that as a premise, which I do, then I view it as a way to make the process more efficient, and therefore less expensive, and therefore less risky, and therefore lower the cost of capital, which to me feels like it could be part of a solution to some of the things he highlighted. It is just more expensive than your district.

(03:20:29)

I am actually hopeful. As opposed to being perceived as this kind of punitive designation, it becomes one that both gets everyone more educated and hopeful. It actually just makes them. I do not think you could educate my district anymore. There is nobody in that district who needs education. Oh, your district? I am at the whole city. Okay, because we are, they are, people vote 20 times more than any other district in the city. Number one in the country, just assuming. So I just think it is a hard, I do not know what we are going to, we are not going to be able to accomplish what it is desired. And also, what do you think about historic districts? I feel strongly that they should not be torn down. But that seems to be what some people want to do. And do not rely on LPC, because there are no good, all this. So, Council Member, but I think protections that are in that you will find, my, a coal sale, I do not know. Demolition of the buildings, and buildings that are going to be out of scale to address the housing crisis. I do not think that is going to happen. 500 Columbus Avenue right now, that is what is happening. Well, I do not know that particular project, but I definitely take a look at it. But I think the idea of historic districts now sort of coming up against housing. Sometimes I think it does feel like the commission should think about this creatively, and there be new responses to how we deal with historic districts than in the past, because of this housing crisis.

I do not think that means that we should take away historic districts. I do not think it means we should tear down buildings, but I think there are ways that historic districts can produce housing, and I have seen that when I was the chair. There were housing projects in SoHo, and they are all too large in scale, and similarly in TriBeCa. So there is a way to allow development to take place in historic districts, actually taking with the historic... You and I disagree

(03:21:26)

on that one. Okay, we will. Anybody else? Hello, Council Member. Hello, sir. How are you? I know you very well.

(03:22:43)

Well, we are fellow Dinkins

(03:22:52)

alumni, among other things.

(03:22:57)

Yeah, does

(03:23:06)

it. Frankly speaking, I would hope that some contingent of the department and city government could sit down with you and look at and discuss where you think opportunities are for affordable housing that are not currently being focused upon. I looked at it, because I mean, you have laid it out. The Upper West Side is cheek by jowl. There are no large lots, except where certain developers are putting up super, super high buildings. So, Gail, if you do not mind me calling you Bail? Fine. You know the bricks and mortar as well as anybody. I would just like to, I just think, personally, I would like to sit with you and get your views on where there are opportunities. Maybe we agree, maybe we disagree, but all want affordable housing. There is no disagreement about the need

(03:24:16)

for affordable housing. So if there is a consensus on that issue, then I think we ought to be able to find some consensus around some site. Right now we have the site, 2.4 acres, and the developer wants to put up a building bigger than the Empire State Building, and

(03:24:30)

the 7% on and off site, and senior housing mostly, which we do not want. It is all tough, and you have

(03:24:39)

to do things differently, and the administration has to have. It is really easy to rack up a lot of apartments in other parts of the city. But when you have good schools, good transportation, and you want diversity, you have to do things differently. I have not seen anybody do that. Oh, Council Member, nice to see you.

(03:25:02)

Let me. I just want to concur with Cannon. I would love to be in that meeting. If I do not invite myself, because I think that is really valuable. I have questioned the what-ifs with the bottom 12, so I understand the concern. I certainly understand the contours of your district very well, and I think that suggestion is a prudent one, given the moment. You had asked another question about being independent on the commission, and I think it is imperative that all of us take in the, that we have before us, whatever our studies, the analyses, all the public testimony we hear, and make our determinations based on that, not on political influence, regardless of whether it is from the Mayor or anyone else.

(03:25:51)

And so I think that is the, it has not always happened in the past. It would be nice if it happened in the future. It is not. This is a fine mayor, but he does not know anything about housing or developments. He knows other things, nothing. And so you have to really be

(03:26:05)

independent and have to think about it differently. I understand that, the other things, but I can say, just for what it is worth, since I have been on the commission for four years, no one has ever called me to say, you should vote this way, you need to vote this way. I have always been given the space to do my independent analysis and to come down, based on the totality of what I have seen in the different evolutions of applications and projects that I have seen. What I will continue to do, that. Okay? Anybody else? No.

(03:26:40)

Okay, thank you. I have a few more questions, and we will be concluding today. So, environmental review and justice, right? Should environmental justice play in the commission's work? Not anyone, or more than one, to freak out. Okay.

(03:27:05)

Her understanding, well, projects that have undergone environmental review are now required, I believe, to look at environmental justice as a standalone analysis of sorts. So I think that takes care of it at one angle. And I think that, in terms of the commission otherwise, looking at projects which do not have an environmental review, then I think it is similar to other kinds of comments that we hear during the public, would be processed, and just to see if that is, if there was, to address it. I have had the opportunity. I think thank you so much for

(03:27:46)

this question. I think it is really critical. I have had the opportunity over my career to work in many environmental justice neighborhoods, and know very acutely the concerns that come along with them. And I think the other thing I would say, in addition to what a man actually mentioned, is that there also can be a relationship between sort of access

(03:28:55)

to process and environmental harm in a neighborhood. So I think it would be particularly important, when we are talking about a neighborhood that has had environmental harms in the past, to also make sure that enough is being done for public input, because maybe the most, some of the most disenfranchised, are living in environmental justice communities. I know that in these neighborhoods, but I think we would look in particular towards making sure we are hearing the perspectives of individuals who are impacted by a project, and whether it is through those organizations or making sure they are coming up, just fine.

(03:29:01)

As a follow-up to the commission, that is just an overseas implementation of the SEQRA. How do you see the purpose, and how do you see that as the purpose of the environmental review, and how should it inform the commission's decision making? I am sorry, Chief, would you repeat that question? The commissioner, overseas implementation of SEQRA. I hope I am saying this right. What do you see as the purpose of the environmental review, and how should it inform the commission's decision making? Well, I think the purpose is clear in terms of determining whether or not a project will unduly and unfavorably impact a community in terms of water, sewer, open space, environmental issues, air quality, et cetera. Those are issues that I believe are determinative of whether or not a project can and should proceed. That critique, of course, comes to us principally through the department staff, and where in those instances where it will not be required, and first of all, you know, the determination ultimately was based upon the fact that a large percentage of the projects that came before the commission did not have negative impacts as it relates to SEQRA. Now, one can always argue about that, but the fact that it is not required does not at all relieve us of the responsibility of assessing the environmental impact of a project on a given community.

That does not cease, and as I have said probably about 20 times, I think our role is heightened in those instances where SEQRA is not required, to nonetheless ensure that we are all judging, in our collective judgment, that environmental issues and questions are adequately addressed before the project proceeds.

(03:31:47)

Oh, thank you for the question. I just want to add to what was said, which I think SEQRA can be a very effective tool. I know that from a private applicant standpoint, when they are looking at their analysis, very often they incorporate certain aspects into the project to alleviate a concern. For example, open space. I think that is done a lot, and that allows them to screen open space, but because it is a large-scale site plan, that is part of the approval process. But it also allows or identifies not only impacts, but alternatives and mitigation, and I think that information can also be incorporated into any decision making. I think the commission, excuse me, has the light on it, and I can see that happening even in the future. And just one last point, for affordable housing projects, let us say they are not exempt from SEQRA, so they still have, the commission still has a responsibility to address the findings that it has, regarding good infrastructure and services, community in conjunction with any density. Thanks for the question. I am just going to add quickly that we have talked a lot about

(03:33:13)

the whole host of these questions about sufficient infrastructure alongside, and whether it is an individual application or broader rezoning, and SEQRA just feels like one, to be clear, tools, sets of information, et cetera, that we utilize to help address those questions, whether infrastructure is sufficient or not, which I feel like we got asked in many ways throughout the morning. Thank you, actually. So I am up to my last question, and they will be directed to Stein. So in your opening statement, you addressed this issue, that you were hoping to get a waiver from the Conflict of Interest Board. So do you agree that if they refused to give you a waiver, you should withdraw your candidacy? Great. Thank you. So thank you all for your testimony. I have

(03:34:03)

seeing no other members have questions, you all are excused. And now I am going to open up the floor to the public for comments.

(03:34:11)

Asked that you please limit your comments to two minutes, and if you wish to speak, please, for our parents, carved this lodge in arms, and be giving up to make your comment. Also, if you have a written statement, please provide a copy to the Sergeant at Arms, and those checking to make sure. We will also be hearing testimony for members of the public who are appearing in Zoom. So members of the public who are appearing via Zoom, please keep your microphones. Call. Is there anybody here in person or Zoomed to testify? Okay, great. Okay.

(03:34:30)

No other members of the public signed up to speak. This public hearing is now closed. I would

(03:34:53)

like to thank the candidates, the members of the committee, the committee staff, Sergeant at Arms, and the members of the public for their participation. Today's meeting, the meeting of the Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics, is now in

(03:34:57)

AI-generated summaries and transcripts. Errors are possible.
Verify against the linked video and send corrections via email.