Pursuant to Council Rule Section 10.60
Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics
Meeting overview
The Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics Committee met in near-total secrecy to vote on an unspecified matter, producing perhaps the least informative public record imaginable.
The Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics convened on September 29, 2026, under Chair Sandra Ung, with a full complement of members including Speaker Nantasha Williams, Majority Leader Shaun Abreu, Minority Leader David Carr, Deputy Majority Leader Chris Banks, and Council Members Encarnacion, Krishnan, Lee, and Riley. The stated purpose was to discuss confidential business pursuant to Section 10.60 of the Council Rules, which authorizes closed proceedings for certain sensitive matters — typically involving member conduct, ethics complaints, or personnel issues.
Within minutes of opening, the Committee voted unanimously to move into executive session under Article Seven of the New York State Public Officers Law, cleared the room of non-committee staff, and disappeared behind closed doors for roughly an hour and a half. When they returned, the public summary consisted of a single sentence: the Committee voted to work towards resolving an issue. No issue was named. No timeline was given. No further detail was offered. The meeting was then adjourned.
That is, in its entirety, what the public learned. Whatever the underlying matter is — an ethics complaint, a conduct dispute, an internal Council conflict — it remains entirely opaque. The Council is legally entitled to conduct this kind of business in private, but the outcome statement here is so vague as to be essentially meaningless. Whether anything of consequence actually happened today is genuinely unknowable from the public record.
The record
Numbers
- 1 vote taken during executive session, the outcome of which was described only as a decision to work towards resolving an issue.
- Approximately 88 minutes elapsed between the opening of the public session and the return from executive session.
- 8 committee members listed on the agenda; 7 named as present when the Committee returned to open session.
Action Points
- Committee to work towards resolving an unspecified issue, as voted during executive session — no owner, timeline, or subject matter made public.
Full Transcript
C. Riley and Nantasha M. Williams
Good morning. Good morning and welcome to today's New York City Council hearing for the Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics. At this time I would like to remind everyone to silence electronic devices. Good morning. I am Sandra Ung, Chair of the Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics. I am joined by my colleagues: Speaker Nantasha Williams, Majority Leader Abreu, Minority Leader David Carr, Deputy Majority Leader
and Council Members Elsie Encarnación, Shekar Krishnan, Linda Lee and Kevin Riley. The Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics is meeting today regarding Council Rule Section 10.60 for the Committee to discuss confidential business pursuant to Section 10.60 of the Rules of the Council. Therefore, I am making a motion for the Committee to move into executive session pursuant to Section 105 of the New York State Public Officers Law. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Noting that the ayes have it. I am now going to close this portion of the meeting and we will open in executive session. I ask that all non-committee staff clear the room. I also ask the Sergeant at Arms to staff this portion of the meeting. If executive session results in a decision to consider further actions and reconvene, we will not return. We will simply let the Sergeant at Arms know we are not returning. If executive session results in a vote, we will return to regular session to report the vote when executive session concludes. Please put up the notice. Thank you.
Good afternoon. I am Sandra Ung, Chair of the Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics. I am again joined by my colleagues: Speaker Nantasha Williams, Minority Leader David Carr, Majority Leader Shaun Abreu, Deputy Majority Leader Chris Banks and Council Members Elsie Encarnación and Shekar Krishnan. The Committee on Rules, Privileges, Elections, Standards and Ethics opened a meeting earlier today to discuss confidential business pursuant to Council Rule Section 10.60 of the Rules of the Council. Because it was necessary for the Committee to discuss confidential business, the Committee voted to move into executive session pursuant to Article Seven of the Public Officers Law. We are now returning to open session to make public the outcome of today's meeting.
During the executive session, the Committee voted to work towards resolving an issue.
This concludes the summary of the Committee's vote during today's meeting and this meeting is adjourned.