Waste Equity and Environmental Justice
Committee on Sanitation and Solid Waste Management
Meeting overview
The Committee on Sanitation and Solid Waste Management held an oversight hearing on the City's implementation of the Waste Equity Law (Local Law 152 of 2018), together with five bills covering containerization, battery disposal, composting, and litter basket policy. Chair Justin Sanchez (Bronx) opened with a pointed summary of the law's status: while citywide waste transfer volume has fallen 15% since passage, none of the four designated environmental justice community districts (Brooklyn CD1, Queens CD12, Bronx CD1, Bronx CD2) have achieved their mandated capacity reductions of 50% and 33% respectively. Brooklyn CD1 is at 35.8% reduction against a 50% target; Bronx CD1 at 14.8% against 33%; Queens CD12 at 23.9% against 33%. Bronx CD2 data was not specified. Despite this, 74% of citywide solid waste throughput remains concentrated in those four districts.
DSNY Commissioner Gregory Anderson testified that the department considers itself in full legal compliance, arguing that the law's exemption framework, which carved out capacity for recyclables processing, organics, construction and demolition recycling, and barge or rail export before applying percentage reductions, accounts for the gap between headline targets and actual numbers. Two Waste Management facilities in Bronx CD1 received no capacity reduction at all because they export nearly all waste by rail, which the law explicitly exempts. One facility, the Metropolitan Transfer Station, actually received a capacity increase in 2025 after adding organics processing infrastructure, a one-time credit permitted under the law. Chair Sanchez challenged this framing directly, noting that from the community's perspective the law's goals plainly have not been met, and pressed for the underlying exemption data to be provided to the Committee. Anderson also pointed to the commercial waste zones program (Local Law 199 of 2019), now live in six zones, as the most effective ongoing tool for reducing truck traffic in overburdened neighborhoods, projecting an 18 million vehicle-mile reduction annually once all 20 zones are operational by end of 2027.
On the five bills, the department's positions ranged from supportive-in-principle-but-not-quite to outright opposition. On Int 0030-2026 (containerization for City-owned buildings), DSNY argued all City buildings are already required to containerize and that mandating Empire Bins across every City facility would divert trucks and resources from the residential containerization rollout targeting large apartment buildings, which remains the priority through 2031. On Int 0987-2026 (allowing block associations to request shared containers), DSNY noted it already has a pilot application process in Brooklyn CD2 and welcomed further discussion. On Int 0352-2026 (battery disposal plan for micro-mobility devices), DSNY expressed broad agreement with the goal but flagged resource constraints, the limits of its special waste drop-off network (one site per borough), and ongoing negotiations with the Battery Network producer responsibility organisation whose plan has not yet been approved by DEP. On Int 0401-2026 (25 public organic waste receptacles per community district), DSNY flatly opposed it, citing a 42% drop in smart compost bin utilisation since mandatory curbside composting enforcement began, and arguing the money would be better spent on education and outreach. CM Restler pushed back, noting persistent demand at green market composting drop-offs and access problems for residents of large buildings with trash chutes. On Int 1041-2026 (restricting litter basket removals), Commissioner Anderson said the practice of removing baskets for illegal dumping had effectively ended before he took office in March 2026, and that he has not removed a single basket since becoming Commissioner, but resisted codification into law as removing the option of absolute last resort. CM Hankerson argued forcefully that the protection should be in statute regardless of who leads the agency, and that 3,300 approved litter basket locations across the city are currently missing a basket.
The hearing also surfaced several operational tensions. CM Hankerson pressed DSNY on why the four designated EJ districts were not prioritised first in the containerisation rollout; Commissioner Anderson gave a multi-factor answer involving borough diversity and geographic variety, and when Hankerson asked for a commitment that the next cohort after the current six districts would be the remaining three EJ districts, Anderson said only "we will certainly take a look at it," which Chair Sanchez immediately called a sidestep. Discussion of barge-based waste transfer and possible use of marine transfer stations for commercial waste, and even Rikers Island as an organic waste processing facility, rounded out the hearing's more speculative territory. The session closed with a reminder from Chair Sanchez that 311, not social media, is the correct channel for litter basket complaints.
The record
- T2026-2585 Hearing on waste equity and sanitation bills (hearing held)
- Int 0030-2026 Law to require on-street trash bins at city buildings (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 0352-2026 Law to require a battery disposal plan for e-bikes and scooters (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 0401-2026 Law to require public compost bins citywide (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 0987-2026 Law to let groups request shared street waste bins (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 1041-2026 Law to require notice before removing public trash cans (heard; awaiting a vote)
Numbers
- Citywide waste transfer volume has decreased 15% since Local Law 152 passed in 2018, to approximately 16,083 tons per day.
- 74% of citywide solid waste throughput remains concentrated in the four designated EJ community districts.
- Brooklyn CD1 has achieved a 35.8% reduction in transfer station capacity against a 50% statutory target.
- Bronx CD1 has achieved a 14.8% reduction against a 33% statutory target.
- Queens CD12 has achieved a 23.9% reduction against a 33% statutory target.
- The Metropolitan Transfer Station on Alex Street in the Bronx had its capacity reduced from 825 to 553 tons per day under LL152, then increased by 111 tons per day to 664 after adding organics processing infrastructure.
- The Action Environmental (now US Transportation) facility in Bronx CD1 had its permitted capacity reduced from 29.9 to 21.01 tons per day, with the gap from a straight 33% cut explained by a recycling exemption.
- There are approximately 16 putrescible and 21 non-putrescible private waste transfer stations in New York City.
- Commercial waste zones are projected to reduce truck traffic by 63%, equivalent to more than 18 million vehicle trips per year once all 20 zones are operational.
- As of the end of Fiscal Year 2026, six commercial waste zones are fully operational; full implementation of all 20 zones is expected by end of 2027.
- DSNY conducted 192,000 outreach activities and carriers conducted 2,581 individual employee trainings under the commercial waste zones programme.
- DSNY has approximately 400 smart compost bins installed citywide; utilisation fell 42% in the year following mandatory curbside composting enforcement.
- There are approximately 25,049 approved litter basket locations in New York City.
- Approximately 3,300 approved litter basket locations are currently missing a basket.
- DSNY now updates its litter basket Open Data inventory monthly rather than quarterly.
- The newer Better Bin litter basket costs approximately $1,200 each; DSNY can purchase only a few hundred per year with its own funding.
- DSNY currently offers special waste drop-off sites in one location per borough, open five days per week, accepting rechargeable batteries from mobility devices.
- DSNY holds one SAFE disposal event per borough per year; a recent event during a nor'easter still drew over 800 attendees.
- The illegal dumping fine for disposing of a substantial amount of waste from a vehicle is $4,000; improper disposal of household or commercial waste at a litter basket carries a $75 fine.
- Full citywide residential containerisation is targeted for completion by 2031.
- Community composting baseline funds were eliminated from the City budget in November 2023.
Action Points
- DSNY to provide the Committee with a copy of all exemptions granted to waste transfer stations in the four designated EJ community districts under Local Law 152.
- DSNY to investigate whether throughput at any solid waste transfer station has at any point since 2019 exceeded 90% of that station's permitted capacity, and whether any such instances were reported to the Mayor and Council as required by law.
- DSNY to analyse 311 complaint volume from EJ communities versus non-EJ communities and provide that breakdown to the Committee.
- DSNY to dig into the Chair's assertion that throughput decreased primarily in non-designated areas while remaining flat in the four designated districts, and reconcile the data with the Committee.
- DSNY to review whether the remaining three EJ community districts not yet scheduled for containerisation (Brooklyn CD1, Queens CD12, Bronx CD1) can be prioritised in the next cohort following the current six-district rollout.
- DSNY Commissioner to respond to CM Wilson's letter regarding litter basket placement gaps in his district, with a draft response already prepared.
- DSNY to investigate and address the absence of litter baskets at the Archer Avenue and Parsons Boulevard transit hub in Southeast Queens (Deputy Speaker Williams' district), with replacement of identified missing baskets already initiated.
- DSNY to schedule a district walk-through with CM Wilson to assess litter basket needs and placement.
- DSNY to continue working with the Battery Network producer responsibility organisation to ensure DEP approves a plan providing safe and convenient battery collection for New York City residents, including funding for City-operated collection sites.
- DSNY to keep the Council informed of progress on the Battery Network plan and DEP approval process.
- DSNY to explore feasibility of accepting commercial office paper, and potentially university recycling streams, at the 59th Street marine transfer station, pending sufficient data from commercial waste zones implementation.
- DSNY to look into the feasibility of moving DSNY trucks currently parked on side streets near the Manhattan CD9 garage back to the underutilised parking facility near that garage, and continue discussions with relevant Council Members.
- DSNY to develop a cost estimate for transitioning all City-owned buildings to stationary on-street containerisation, using desktop modelling by building type as a starting point.
- DSNY to continue conversations with the Council on how to tailor any approach to City-building containerisation under Int 0030-2026.
- DSNY to look into the breakdown of litter basket locations by approved type and share data on why baskets have been removed, as part of discussions on Int 1041-2026 transparency requirements.
Full Transcript
Good afternoon and welcome to today's New York City Council hearing on the Committee on Sanitation and Solid Waste Management. During today's hearing, no one should approach the dais, please. Silence your devices if you might have them.
Thank you, Roman. Good afternoon, everyone. I think this is the latest start time that we have ever had for this committee. Good afternoon, everyone and welcome to today's Committee on Sanitation and Solid Waste Management. I want to give all of you who are actually in here a round of applause. Thank you for joining us. Thank you for caring about waste equity in our City.
Having said that, my name is Justin Sanchez. I am a Council Member and proud Chair of this Committee. I want to thank all the members of the Committee and the representatives of DSNY for joining us today. The Council Members who are present with us are CM Louis and CM Hankerson. I see no one on Zoom.
Thank you everyone for your attendance. The purpose of today's oversight hearing is to learn more about the City's implementation of the Waste Equity Law. This was passed as Local Law 152 in 2018 to assess our progress on reducing the negative impacts of the City's waste collection, recycling and transfer industry on vulnerable New Yorkers — New York City's most economically disadvantaged communities and communities of color. My district tends to face disproportionate health hazards associated with waste transfer infrastructure, specifically Bronx Community Districts one and two.
High exposure to heavy truck traffic and the accompanying noise, air pollution and odor have been linked to various negative health and developmental outcomes, including but not limited to reduced intellectual development in children, increased incidence of asthma and heightened risk of heart defects and low birth weights in babies when birthing parents are exposed to truck emissions during pregnancies.
I would also like to note that we have been welcomed by CM Louis, and a truck sounded just on that note. If you can hear that — the Waste Equity Law's mandated reduction in private transfer station capacity is meant to help alleviate some of these harms experienced by environmental justice communities, also commonly referred to during this hearing as EJ communities, and to encourage means of transferring waste that avoid diesel trucks.
Every waste transfer station located in four of the City's most burdened community districts — that includes Brooklyn Community District one, Queens Community District 12 and Bronx Community Districts one and two, with none in Manhattan — was required to comply with waste capacity reductions. In order to ensure effective oversight, the Waste Equity Law imposed reporting and notification requirements on the Department of Sanitation to track the permitted capacity in different waste transfer stations, track any impacts on employment from these reductions, alert the Mayor and the Council in the event that a waste transfer station approaches or exceeds their total permitted capacity, and report on the feasibility of reducing truck traffic in residential neighborhoods through means other than capacity reductions.
Since 2019, DSNY has complied with the law's reporting requirements by publishing annual implementation reports and providing the relevant data for that year. The most recent Waste Equity Law implementation annual report for calendar year 2025 was just released last month. We are pleased that DSNY data shows that overall the waste transfer station volume is approximately 16,083 tons per day, which represents a 15% decrease in the waste transfer volume citywide. I want to underscore that — citywide — since the law's passage.
However, that being said, we are concerned that none — zero — of the four designated community districts slated for the mandated reductions in permitted private transportation capacity have achieved full compliance with the reduction requirements of the Waste Equity Law. Additionally, we are worried that the permitted capacity reductions we have seen targeted mostly unused capacity at waste transfer stations, and that two stations appear to have not undergone any reduction whatsoever.
Just so that everyone is on the same page: out of the four community districts that we talked about — Brooklyn one, Queens 12, Bronx one and Bronx two — Brooklyn one was supposed to have a 50% reduction in capacity, whereas Queens 12, Bronx one and Bronx two were supposed to have a 33% reduction in capacity, and none of those targets have been hit.
So having said that, despite progress on the Waste Equity Law, we want to be clear that we have seen a 15% reduction citywide, so there has been progress. Despite that progress, the City is far from achieving its goal. The burdens of waste transfer infrastructure citywide — to date, approximately 74% of citywide throughput, the average daily amount of solid waste delivered to a solid waste transfer station — remains concentrated in the four designated community districts.
We look forward to hearing from DSNY and advocates about the implementation challenges and the shortcomings of the Waste Equity Law and the City's plans to fulfill the law's requirements as soon as possible. We also look forward to discussing proposals to improve waste infrastructure inequity borne by these communities.
In addition to the oversight, we will be hearing five bills today. First, Int 0030-2026, sponsored by the Majority Leader and CM Louis, would require the City to create a program that would mandate City-owned nonresidential buildings to dispose of their waste in stationary containers. Int 0987-2026, sponsored by the Majority Leader and CM Restler, would allow block associations and nonprofit associations to request stationary on-street waste containers for the storage and collection of waste. Next, Int 0352-2026, sponsored by CM Nurse, which would require DSNY to develop a plan for ensuring proper disposal of rechargeable batteries used for powered mobility devices such as motorized bicycles and scooters. We are also hearing Int 0401-2026, sponsored by CM Restler, which would require DSNY to install a minimum number of public organic waste receptacles in every community district. Finally, Int 1041-2026 — this bill would bar DSNY from removing public litter baskets solely on the basis that they were used for illegal dumping, requiring notification to Council Members and community boards when a removal is proposed and publishing data around why baskets were removed.
I now pass the floor and the mic to CM Hankerson to discuss this bill. Thank you, Chair.
Good afternoon, everyone. For years, New Yorkers have been calling for cleaner streets and better sanitation services to improve the quality of life in their neighborhoods. Residents have continuously pushed for more public litter baskets and Council Members have even allocated funding to DSNY to bring more baskets into their districts. Yet despite these efforts, there never seemed to be enough. Part of the reason is a shameful practice by DSNY — at least, I think it is shameful — of routinely removing public litter baskets in response to illegal dumping or the disposal of household garbage, which the Department categorizes as improper use of these baskets. In doing so, entire neighborhoods of thousands of residents are being punished for the actions of a few bad actors, and instead of addressing the
people responsible for the dumping, we are taking away a service that the rest of the community is in such desperate need of. In Southeast Queens, where I represent, we have spent a great deal of time fighting to get our streets clean and to keep them clean. I understand the frustration that comes with repeatedly cleaning the same location, only to return the next morning and find it covered in improper waste again. But removing a litter basket does very little to address the behavior. Now, DSNY has stated that it no longer engages in this practice and I welcome that change. Thank you.
But I believe it is in our best interest, Chair, for our communities to codify that protection into law so that it remains the standard regardless of who is leading the agency or the City. Under Int 1041-2026, DSNY would no longer be permitted to remove a public litter basket solely on the grounds of illegal dumping. The bill would require the Department to notify the local Council Member and community board before removing the basket and give them ten business days to respond.
Local community boards and elected officials hear directly from residents about the sanitation conditions in their neighborhoods. They should have an opportunity to weigh in before service is taken away from the very people that they represent. This legislation will require reporting on basket removal and subsequent litter complaints, giving us a better understanding of whether these decisions are actually improving the conditions of the neighborhoods that we represent and live in day after day. New Yorkers pay taxes for sanitation services and they have every right to expect those services to be maintained. If someone is abusing a litter basket, then our attention should be directed to the person responsible. We should be increasing enforcement against illegal dumping and working with communities to address these problem locations, rather than reducing the very services residents have fought to receive. I am proud to sponsor this legislation and look forward to working with my colleagues to get it passed.
Thank you, Chair. Thank you so much, CM Hankerson. I look forward to the dialogue regarding these bills today. I would also like to thank everyone on my team, especially my Legislative Director River Alexander for all of the work in getting this together, and the Sanitation Committee staff, especially Samia — last time we shouted out Samia, but this time I really want to make sure that we are shouting out Natasha Bynum, who is also our co-counsel on this Committee, and we are so excited by the work.
I want to make sure before we continue that we have also been joined by the amazing CM Hanif via Zoom. Thank you, CM Hanif. And with that, I want to make sure I am not forgetting anything. We will start by hearing testimony from the Department of Sanitation, followed by some questions to the agency, and then we will hear testimony from the public. I will now turn it over to Committee Counsel to
Good afternoon, Chair Sanchez and members of the City Council Committee on Sanitation and Solid Waste Management. I am Gregory Anderson, Commissioner of the New York City Department of Sanitation, and I am joined by Jen McDonnell, our Deputy Commissioner for Solid Waste Management.
The Department of Sanitation has equity baked into our functions at the deepest structural level, in that we provide a free, unlimited service to all New Yorkers. There is no sign up, there is no opt in, there is no fee for collection or limit on how much you can set out. Just put your waste at the curb, properly sorted and in a container, and we will get it. Sanitation serves everyone without question and is committed to fairness.
We also acknowledge that our waste management and export system reflects longstanding injustices and inequities. To begin to correct these, we have implemented the City's landmark 2006 Solid Waste Management Plan, which called for a move away from truck export of solid waste from New York City to more sustainable and equitable rail and barge export. The facilities and system built as a result of that plan represent billions of dollars in investment, both public and private, in equitable, sustainable waste management systems and have reduced truck traffic in historically overburdened communities by hundreds of trips per day.
We did not stop there. Local Law 152 of 2018, which DSNY spent more than a decade working toward enactment of, required a reduction in the permitted capacity of putrescible and non-putrescible transfer stations in four historically overburdened community districts — by 50% in Brooklyn District one and by 33% in Queens District 12 and Bronx Districts one and two. The law also allowed for certain exemptions to those reductions in permitted capacity for activities consistent with the City's sustainability goals, including the processing of recyclables and organic waste, for diverting construction and demolition debris to beneficial use and for facilities that export waste by barge or by rail.
Local Law 152 represented the culmination of years of advocacy and organizing that began decades ago as the City began to close its own disposal facilities. Today, the law has been fully implemented and we have reduced not only permitted capacity but also actual throughput and actual truck traffic in these historically overburdened communities. The ongoing implementation of commercial waste zones will continue to reduce truck traffic in these neighborhoods. The commercial waste zone program is being implemented under Local Law 199 of 2019 to reform the commercial waste hauling system by establishing new safety standards for workers in the industry, improving service for businesses, increasing diversion rates, reducing vehicle miles traveled as well as the harmful emissions that come from waste hauling trucks. When fully implemented, we expect that commercial waste zones will result in a 63% reduction in truck traffic associated with commercial waste collection — more than 18 million trips per year.
The Fiscal Year 2026 commercial waste zones annual report was released just two weeks ago, covering the expansion from just one initial zone to six fully operational zones as of the end of this year. DSNY has continued to strengthen the oversight framework, including monitoring compliance, collecting and reviewing required operational data, conducting enforcement activities, supporting worker safety initiatives and engaging businesses and other stakeholders throughout every phase of implementation.
There is a substantial amount of data and information in that report, including information on the 192,000 outreach activities we have conducted by Sanitation and our partners, 2,581 individual employee trainings conducted by carriers, collection tonnage by zone and by stream, enforcement actions and much, much more. I will note that that data is all available in machine-readable, manipulable format, not just as a PDF.
When Local Law 199 was enacted, some opponents projected that the program would cause massive disruption for businesses, drive up costs and reduce the quality of service. To date, the opposite has been true. Pricing and service quality have both improved and the City's streets are both cleaner and safer as a result. We are proud of our implementation of this
Historic program and look forward to celebrating its full implementation at the end of next year. Also proud to have contributed to New York City's first citywide racial equity plan, mandated by voters in a 2022 ballot initiative. In this plan, we acknowledge that our operations are deeply connected with structural issues that affect New Yorkers of color, and that our mission includes a responsibility to address inequities in service levels and neighborhood cleanliness. As we work to strengthen our efforts, we are committed to ensuring that our sanitation programs promote equity and serve all New Yorkers, especially those in historically underserved communities. In this report we commit to continuously improving programs and service delivery to New Yorkers through ongoing evaluation of data analytics, stakeholder feedback and operational enhancements that are responsive to community needs. In the coming years, we will publish neighborhood-level data sets to measure key outcomes around diversion, containerization and commercial waste reform at the neighborhood level. These will include measures such as commercial and residential diversion rates, rat sightings, vehicle miles traveled, diversion participation, and we will use those to identify disparities and target improvements in our services. We will also use this data to inform outreach, enforcement and resource allocation.
Turning now to the legislation on today's agenda. Int 0030-2026, sponsored by a Council member, would require DSNY, in consultation with DCAS and DOHMH, to create a program requiring City-owned buildings to dispose of waste in stationary containers. DSNY agrees that we should move aggressively to containerize the City's trash, and in fact trash containerization has been required for all City agencies for nearly two years. Trash containerization is imperative for New York City, but we must take a thoughtful and strategic approach that accounts for density and efficiency. This Bill would require all City agency facilities, including small schools and offices, to use Empire Bins, which may not be appropriate in all cases. Moreover, all City buildings, as I said before, are already required to use some form of trash containerization, whether through tilt trucks, bins or off-street containerized collection. In developing the plan for the citywide rollout of Empire Bins, we have focused on residential properties with ten or more units not currently covered by our containerization requirements, to maximize the impact of our investments in getting trash bags off the sidewalk. Empire Bins now serve large residential buildings in West Harlem and are rolling out this fall in Brooklyn community districts, including Downtown Brooklyn and Fort Greene.
As the Mayor announced this spring, we are on an aggressive timeline to achieve full trash containerization by 2031, faster than ever previously envisioned. Adding Empire Bins at every City facility as we roll out that program will divert resources from that important focus on residential trash and delay the full rollout. There are certainly some municipal buildings for which Empire Bin service is appropriate, and we will pursue installation at the appropriate time. We would be happy to continue conversations with the Council as we expand our revolutionary trash containerization programs.
Int 0352-2026, sponsored by Council Member Nurse, would require DSNY to develop a plan for disposal of rechargeable batteries from powered mobility devices. These batteries represent a major problem for sanitation and our partners, causing fires in our trucks and our facilities when they are improperly disposed of. DSNY currently offers services aligned with the spirit of this legislation. We recently expanded the operating hours of our special waste drop-off sites and now have one location in every borough that accepts these batteries, from 10 AM to 3 PM. Adding a second site in each borough and further expanding those hours would require substantial additional resources. The proposed Bill also calls for accepting these items at any disposal or collection event organized by the Department. While we do collect them at our SAFE events, one per borough per year, including one coming up this weekend on Staten Island, it would be impractical to collect them at all Department-sponsored events without additional funding or material support from the rechargeable battery industry. We do believe that battery manufacturers should be primarily responsible for the cost of collecting unwanted batteries and educating the public on safe use and disposal.
Many rechargeable batteries, but importantly excluding those in mobility devices, are already covered by a New York State extended producer responsibility and retailer take-back program. This law requires that all stores that sell rechargeable batteries or items that contain them must also collect them for recycling, and the cost of that program is borne by battery manufacturers. The State recently enacted legislation to expand this producer responsibility program to include mobility batteries, but retailer take-back and recycling of those items remains voluntary in the updated State law. We are currently working with DSNY's producer responsibility organization, the Battery Network, to ensure that the producer responsibility program implemented pursuant to this law provides for sufficiently safe and convenient collection options for New York City residents, including by providing funding for City-operated collection sites and events. We appreciate the Council's strong interest in this topic and will keep the Council informed as these discussions progress.
Int 0401-2026, sponsored by CM Restler, would require DSNY to install 25 public organic waste receptacles in every community district. We currently have a network of approximately 400 smart compost bins installed citywide, and that program was established before the implementation of our nation-leading mandatory universal curbside composting program, which is our primary approach for providing composting service for New Yorkers. Since the mandatory program has been fully implemented and we have actually been enforcing it, utilization of the smart compost bins has declined significantly. Given this fact and the added cost to install and service the additional organic waste receptacles this Bill would require, we cannot support this Bill at this time.
Int 0987-2026, sponsored by CM Abreu, would require DSNY to establish a process for block associations and nonprofits to request shared stationary on-street containers. We have already established an application process for shared Empire Bins for small, one-to-nine-unit, and medium, ten-to-thirty-unit, buildings located in Brooklyn District 2 as we roll out this fall, and we are actively seeking applicants to test that approach. We look forward to further discussions with the Council about this legislation as we continue to implement our containerization program.
Lastly, Int 1041-2026, sponsored by CM Hankerson, would change how the Department considers litter basket removals. We understand that the Department's past practice of removing chronically misused litter baskets was frustrating to elected officials and New Yorkers alike, and today several factors make such removal rare and, when exercised, the last possible resort. First, the Department has the highest level of baseline litter basket service in recorded history, meaning that we are able to service every basket currently on the street more frequently all across the City. Second, the Department adjusts service levels more thoughtfully and
proactively than in the past, changing the frequency and time of day of collection to optimize service to a neighborhood's needs. Third, our network of community partners has grown in both size and scope, including BIDs, local mutual aid groups and supplemental service providers. Finally, thanks to action by the City Council several years ago, we have stronger enforcement tools to hold those who misuse our litter baskets for disposal of household and commercial waste accountable. In rare cases of clear, recurring misuse that leads to consistent, unmanageable overflow, DSNY may determine that a basket must be removed or relocated. Any such removals are subject to my own personal review, and it is an action that I do not take lightly. In fact, we have not yet removed a litter basket since I have been Commissioner. But it is critical that we retain this tool as an option of last resort to address chronic misuse and improper disposal that affects our City's neighborhoods.
On reporting, I am happy to say that we recently began updating the litter basket inventory posted on Open Data on a monthly rather than quarterly basis. I would be happy to discuss with you further regarding trend reporting, transparency and accountability with the Council. Thank you for the opportunity to testify on these topics today and we are happy to answer your questions.
Thank you so much. Let us start with some general oversight. How many private waste transfer stations are there in New York City?
It looks like about 16 waste transfer stations and another, I would say roughly 21, non-putrescible waste transfer stations.
Okay, and how many municipal waste transfer stations are there in New York City? Can you also give us the breakdown?
And can you walk us through how the required permitted capacity reductions of the Waste Equity Law were implemented by DSNY in each of the four designated districts between 2019 and 2020?
Yeah, so the permanent capacity reductions — we started with the existing permitted capacity, we took out any exempted material, so that was a certain amount that could be set aside for organic waste processing. This was all laid out in Local Law 52. There was credit for demonstrated recyclables processing, so if you were taking in, let us say, a hundred tons a day of single-stream recycling or paper recycling, that got set aside as an exemption. For construction and demolition we set aside any actual demonstrated recycling that they were doing. Whatever permitted capacity was left got reduced by the Waste Equity Law.
Data shows that none of the four designated community districts have achieved 100% compliance with the law's reductions. Specifically, looking at the Waste Equity data, one district required 50% but is only at 35.8% overall reduction, including both stations. Similarly, the 33% reduction in Bronx one is only down to 14.8%, and Queens 12 is down to 23.9%. Were any required reductions exempted in any of the four community districts, and if so, which exemptions were used and for
which facilities? So the way that the exemptions are applied under Local Law 52 is that those are applied first, prior to the reduction in permanent capacity, and then the remaining amount after the exemptions is what is reduced by either 33% or 50% based on the community district. And have capacity reductions targeted mostly unused capacity at waste transfer stations? It is a mix of both. There are, as I said in my testimony, actual reductions in throughput as a result of the implementation of this law. So there was real, tangible capacity that had been used prior to the implementation of Local Law 52 that can no longer be used.
So can you explain to us what challenges the Department has faced implementing the law and the law's reduction requirements? What more challenges have been faced and what can be done to ensure that total compliance
is achieved? So we have achieved total compliance with the law as it was written and enacted by the City Council and as was laid out in the environmental review that we did ahead of the law's passage. From our perspective, we have implemented that law. That does not mean that we have stopped working toward additional waste equity. I think the commercial waste zones program is a great example of that. Not only will a commercial waste zones program reduce truck traffic citywide, but it will reduce truck traffic in particular in neighborhoods that host waste transfer stations, commercial carting hubs of operations and other waste-related facilities. We have seen and will continue to see truck traffic reducing in those neighborhoods as we implement that
program. So you said we have hit all of the reduction markers, but can you explain again — so first you took out all the exemptions. Can you talk to us about what these exemptions were and what that means to the actual number in reduction that we are talking about?
The law required us to go transfer station by transfer station and take the existing permitted capacity, then take any exemptions that were set forth in the law very explicitly, remove those from the existing permitted capacity, take the reduction on a percentage basis and then add back the exempted amount. So if you take — and I am just going to use an example here to make it more concrete — if you take, let us say, the Action Environmental, now part of US Transportation, in Bronx Community District one, their initial permitted capacity was 29.9. Their new permanent capacity was 21.01. The reason that that is not 19.99 or 20.00, depending on how you round, is because they had existing recyclable materials that they were processing through that facility, demonstrated in previous transportation reports to DSNY. Under Local Law 52, that amount of recycling — the average amount of recycling, I think over a one-year, maybe two-year look-back — was set aside prior to the 33% reduction being applied and then added back after the 33% reduction.
So when you go facility by facility, there are exemptions for many, not all, of the facilities that had reductions taken. So talking about those
facilities, I do want to highlight that Waste Management in Bronx one and... it does not look like, from the data that we have, that there have been any reductions whatsoever.
So can you help explain why these facilities did not go through any required capacity reductions, especially when there is no reported capacity reserved at these stations for organics? What other exemptions did they receive?
Yes, so there is an exemption in Local Law 52 for any facility that exports the majority of its waste by rail, and both of those Waste Management facilities export nearly all of their waste by rail.
Some facilities, like the Metropolitan Transfer Station, actually received capacity increases in 2025. Why
was that? Yes. Again, there was a provision in Local Law 52 that allows for facilities that want to add additional capacity for organics processing or for recyclable material processing to take a one-time credit for that investment in new processing infrastructure. So they applied for and received that one-time credit, and that process is all laid out in Local Law 52 as well.
And I have more questions, but I am going to make sure that we turn it over to my colleague really quickly. But I am just curious — you mentioned a lot of the additional work that you have been doing in terms of the
supplemental work to the Waste Equity Law. I am talking about containerization, talking about all these advancements, but the thing that I find really curious is that out of all of the districts that we mentioned, none of those districts outside of Bronx 2, the start of the containerization pilot, were any part of any of these programs. I am curious — why were these districts not prioritized over other districts that did not need it as much as we did?
Bronx 2 is first on the list for next year, so I think we are coming that way.
Yes, but my question is — is there a reason why the four districts that we outlined, that we understood were overburdened, were not the number one priorities for these containerization pilots or any of these pilots that are coming out, rather than other districts that are not at the top of this list, that have been dealing with these burdens that these other communities have?
But are getting the nice things first.
I would say the fact that one of those districts is one of the first three districts to receive Empire Bins is a sign that we are, in fact, doing exactly what you are saying.
Yes, but also I do not think we are answering the question — like, why were those other districts chosen? Also, it is one out of, I think, nine or ten outlined already, and so curiously only one is in. Why has there not been a bigger push for any of these other places to be put in as
The great news is that every district in New York City will have full containerization by the end of 2031, so we are coming for every district citywide. As we discussed in previous hearings, the methodology for selecting the next six districts after Manhattan Community District 9, West Harlem, and Brooklyn Community District was: one, we wanted to have districts in each of the five boroughs. So we are adding two districts in the Bronx, one in Manhattan, one in Queens, one in Brooklyn and one in Staten Island.
Second, we wanted to test this in a variety of different geographic and density use cases. So we are rolling out in Bronx 5, for example, which will be the hilliest district that we have ever put containerization in. We are coming to Bronx Community District 2, which, as you have highlighted, has many of the equity and socioeconomic concerns that we are trying to address through much of this work. We are going to Queens West 2, which is the fastest growing neighborhood in the United States at this moment. So I think we picked districts based on a bunch of different criteria. Equity was certainly one of them, and I think the fact that we are coming to Bronx districts is a marker of that.
Can we get a commitment from the administration that the next districts after these six will be the remaining three environmental justice community districts that are waiting to have some justice?
We will certainly take a look at it.
We will follow back up on that. You side-stepped that question. CM Hankerson...
And also, before we continue, we are also joined by CM Restler and CM Hanif.
Pleasure. Thank you. I am going to move relatively quickly through my questions. When did the Department halt the practice of removing trash bins on the basis of dumping?
I became Commissioner on March 30, 2026, and one of the first things I said to my team was absolutely not — we are not doing that anymore.
Does the agency — excuse me — does the agency still remove baskets, but for other reasons?
Aside from illegal dumping? In general, no. What we will sometimes do — and a lot of this happens in close collaboration with City Council members — is move baskets from, you know, if there are four corners at an intersection, we will move it from one corner to another based on a concern from a resident or a business owner, or the location of a bus stop that maybe gets moved, something like that. So we certainly do...
...relocate them, but we do not generally remove them. How often do you collaborate with Council members to make that decision?
All the time, on a daily basis. No one has called me, but you know how to get in touch with us. So if you want us to come out and talk about your litter baskets, we are happy to do so.
Any time. I would love for you to get in touch with me as well. So how does the agency determine where litter baskets are placed?
There are a number of factors that go into it. We look at things like bus routes. We look at things like subway stations. Litter baskets, because they are predominantly for the kind of trash that you have when you are walking around — a coffee cup, a water bottle, a sandwich wrapper — we predominantly place them in places along commercial corridors because that is where you have the most pedestrians and most people carrying that material. And then we look at other factors, like where there are BIDs. There are more litter baskets because the BIDs in some cases purchase those litter baskets themselves and, in addition, they service the litter baskets on a much more frequent basis. So in BID areas we have a much higher...
...concentration. Got it. I am glad you said that. So in Queens, the intersection of Metropolitan Avenue and Lefferts Boulevard, there are six litter baskets. But in Southeast Queens, Archer Avenue and Parsons Boulevard, which is the major hub — like the only transportation hub in Southeast Queens — there are zero. What is the reasoning for that?
I cannot speak to that specific intersection. I know my office has been trying to schedule some time for me to come out and do a walk-through with you, so I am happy to come out whenever you would like and we can chat about specific needs, and if we need to add more litter baskets, we will do that.
If we can look into it before the walk-through — so that is not actually in my district, but that station is serviced and used by folks in my district. It is actually in Deputy Speaker Nantasha Williams' district. There was actually a community cleanup that happened and, you know, it is kind of going viral right now. I continue to see the video because the major question is: why are there no garbage bins in this corridor that sees thousands of people hour after hour? It just does not really make sense. How do you determine the type of litter basket that is placed on a corner?
There are a couple of different factors we take into account. One, some Council members tell us they prefer a certain type of litter basket, and if they do, we try to honor that preference. Some Council members fund a specific kind of litter basket. The newer Better Bin litter baskets cost about $1,200 each, and so we are only able to buy, with our funding, a few hundred of those a year. But if a City Council member says they would like to purchase 250 for their district, we honor that request — they give us the money, we purchase the baskets and we put them out.
Okay. But generally, you know, we are trying to achieve a consistent look and feel across a given corridor. So if a member allocates money towards the purchase of litter baskets, do they have more of a say, or is it still fully determined by...
Every Council member can provide input on where the litter baskets go. When they are buying litter baskets, sure, we have a conversation about where they would like them. Let us use the number 250, but it could be 10, 20, 30, 40. We have a conversation with that member's office around: where do you want these specific litter baskets to go? Do you want to replace older litter baskets...
...do you want to try to fill in gaps in the litter basket network? So we have that conversation...
...with everybody. A follow-up to that, but I am running out of time. I am going to try to get through these last two, if that is okay.
Are truck operators mandated to report if a litter basket is removed from their route?
Let me say — because I have been told by some of your chiefs that sometimes baskets are removed by residents or businesses and not actually the Department — is a truck operator mandated to report if a basket is not there that they typically see, or if a basket collection service should be reporting to...
...us? We also, on a quarterly basis, do a full litter basket inventory. So the list of litter basket locations that we have approved right now — I think it is like 25,049 — and we will send officers out and do a physical inventory of every single approved location and determine: is there a litter basket on...
...site? What kind of litter basket is it? Is it damaged? Is it broken? Does it need to be replaced? We go through that process on a quarterly basis. That is how, right now, we know there are about 3,300 missing litter baskets across New York City, and we are in the process right now of trying to replace every single one of those missing litter baskets.
Final question: what are the enforcement tools used by the agency to address illegal dumping?
Just as a point of clarification — when we talk about illegal dumping, we mean dumping from a vehicle. That is typically not the kind of issue we have around litter baskets. But that...
Well, I am going to have to disagree with you in my district. I have seen folks pull up to a litter basket in a vehicle, a van, and dump. And obviously, in talking with members of the Department, they will say, oh, it is household trash, but I am like, no, it is not always household trash. Sometimes it is someone just taking — whether it is debris from a construction site or whatever — and dumping it on a corner at a litter basket. So that is why I say it that way.
I think that is an important distinction and every situation is different. At the end of the day, it is a $4,000 ticket if you dump a substantial amount of material from a vehicle. It is a $75 ticket if you improperly dispose of household or commercial waste at a litter basket. So in general, when it is that kind of trash, we will...
...issue the $75 ticket. If we see any identifying information — if we have a corner store that has a security camera and can tell us it came from this house or it came from this other business — we can issue a ticket based on...
...that, because there is a presumption of responsibility there. Thank you.
Thank you so much, CM Hankerson. I want to note that we have also been joined by the amazing CM Maloney. I would now like to turn it over to CM Wilson. Thank you, Chair. My colleague from Queens asked a lot of my questions, so I will not use the whole time. Just on the replacements of the baskets — do you...
...said you buy a few hundred a year, and 200 of the Better Bins specifically — Better Bins?
Okay. So what is the wait time like on a replacement right now? If someone puts in a 311 call about a missing one, how long does it take for a new basket to go out to the corner?
The wait time, I would say, varies because we are trying to replace baskets pretty systematically. Right now, I actually just got an update from my team that CM Williams' baskets are in the process of being replaced, so some of those that have been missing and identified in that viral video are in the process of being replaced as we get litter baskets in from our vendor. If it is a 311 complaint, it might be a few weeks or even a month or two before they are replaced, if we had just done a big replacement cycle in that district. Because we want to try to sort of fill all the holes — our goal is by the end of this calendar year to have replaced every litter basket that we identified as an approved location that is missing.
And then have a sort of good baseline for being able to replace litter baskets on a more consistent basis going forward. The last administration, just to be frank, did not emphasize replacing missing litter baskets. They were much more focused on buying fewer of the nicer Better Bin litter baskets rather than many, many more of the utilitarian green wire litter basket that we all know and love. We are trying to balance those two things by buying more of the green wire litter baskets in order to be able to just fill the holes that we know are out there.
And on the Better Bins — how is the design working? Because I feel like I walk around my district and I see them in so many different states, you know, the doors ripped off, pieces missing off the top. Does that contribute to a removal? Is the design of the Better Bin...
...working out? I would say the Better Bins have more parts to them, so there are more things that could break. A standard green wire litter basket has exactly one part, and so it either works or it does not. But with the Better Bins, if the top is missing, the great news is it still functions as a litter basket. It just does not look whole. So we do try to replace individual parts rather than remove the entire basket just because the top is missing.
I will say they work well in some neighborhoods and they do not work well in others. They do not work well in places where you have a lot of graffiti and stickers, because they act as a magnet for graffiti and stickers. So we try to work with Council members to say: here are the pros and cons of this basket versus a green wire litter basket, and try to identify the best one for their neighborhood.
And in terms of when you are replacing — you mentioned a lot of the community partners that you have and work with, but I feel like — and I know this is sort of anecdotal — where I do not have a community partner is where I am missing a lot of my bins. So do you prioritize your replacements in those areas that do not have a partner? For instance, in Chelsea, south of Penn Station, there is tremendous foot traffic, but that is where I am missing a ton — that is where I get complaints a lot about baskets being missed, and there is no community partner there to report on that and to clean them so that they could really use them. So how does that factor into where you are looking to replace?
We target our replacements. Where there are BIDs that own and install their own litter baskets, those are obviously getting replaced by the BID, so there is much more attention to those baskets and they even have dozens of extra baskets in inventory, ready to go out if something gets damaged or stolen. Where there are baskets that are only serviced by us and only managed by us, again, it goes through this process of every quarter we do a full inventory of all of our litter baskets, and we are in the process now of replacing every single approved litter basket location that does not currently have a basket. There may be places in the area that you are talking about that are not currently approved for a litter basket, and so it is technically missing. There are places where you think there should be additional litter baskets — we are certainly happy to have that conversation.
I did send you a letter about those, so I would love to know which of those are...
...approved. I have a draft response to that letter sitting in my inbox right now. Thank you. That is all for me. Thank you, CM Wilson. And just sitting on this topic real quick — do we have an exact number of how many litter baskets the Department removed due to misuse, depositing household or commercial refuse, or overflowing waste baskets in 2025, as well as how many it removed in 2026 for those same reasons?
We do not have those numbers, and in large part this practice was in effect more than ten years ago. Sometime around the end of the de Blasio administration, the decision was made by previous commissioners to cease that practice. So if you go back in news reports, for example, there were a number of baskets removed in Central Harlem at one point — I think around 2017, 2018 — and that caused prior administrations to really rethink if this is the right approach. There were also, going back further to 2013 and 2014, in parts of Ridgewood along specifically Fresh Pond Road, a lot of concern around removed litter baskets. Sometime around the end of the de Blasio administration, the practice shifted from wide-scale removals to much more targeted removals, and the number of baskets removed has fallen off pretty substantially since then.
My final question about the litter basket: according to 311, it usually takes over a month to get a response as to fulfilling a trash basket request. Many of my constituents, and I know many of my colleagues, feel that if you post a viral social media video you get a response almost immediately. Can you explain to us why there is such a disparity in the response times from 311 complaints to social media complaints, and how you have been handling these social media complaints that seem to get fulfilled right away?
I would be interested to know which of the social media complaints you are referring to, because a lot of people tag us on social media and we treat every complaint the same. We tell them all to file a 311 complaint. Our standard response, if you send us something on Twitter or Instagram — I do not know that we actively monitor customer complaints on TikTok, but we do have a TikTok — if you send us a complaint, our first response is to give you the link to 311 and say please file a 311 complaint, so that is where we like all New Yorkers to go. Because then we can track how quickly our officers are responding, what their response is and the level of satisfaction that customers have with that response.
Well, you have heard it here first, ladies and gentlemen: social media is not 311. Please put in your 311 request for your trash bins, your litter basket request. We are begging you — 311 — and then send us your 311 complaint number. Thank you.
I will also add, if I...
...please.
I think sanitation is probably one of the only agencies that — and it is not universal, but in many cases — will call back the 311 caller or online request submitter, whatever you call that. So if you do provide your contact information, our officers will give you a call and follow up. It may not be the outcome that you want, but at least they will talk you through why the decision was made the way it...
...was. I can confirm they will call you at any time to confirm — sometimes early in the morning.
Very early in the morning.
But again, New Yorkers, 311 is the way to get things done, not social media. Okay, going back to our questions before we turn it over to CM Restler. I want to go back to exemptions. Is there a way that we can get a copy of, or where we can access, the exemptions that have been given to companies in the EJ districts? Where would we be able to find that? In order to make sure that we have the best data as well, and so that we are not being like... you are not fulfilling your goals if we do not have the exemptions that they have been granted. To us, it looks like you have not been fulfilling goals. So is there a way that we can be provided a copy of that, or where can we find that?
Sure, we can provide you a copy of that. Great. Has the department allowed any capacity increases in any over-concentrated districts, and if so, what was the basis for each of the permitted increases? Yes. So the one increase that I can recall is the one that you referred to earlier, the Metropolitan Transfer Station at 207 Alex Street in the Bronx. That was an increase because they added 111 tons per day of capacity to process organic waste. So have
there been any incidents since... just a note: the law does prohibit them from increasing their permanent capacity over what their primary capacity was prior to the implementation of Local Law 152. So it was 825, it went to 553 and then came up to 664. Has there... I want to flag this also was in 2018. This has not even been 10 years ago. It seems like it was an entire lifetime. Having said that, have there been any incidents since this lifetime ago, where the law was implemented, where throughput at any of the solid waste transfer stations exceeded 90% of the total permitted capacity for such transfer stations, and if this had happened, were these instances reported to the Council and the Mayor?
Where throughput exceeded 90% of the permitted capacity? I am not aware of specific instances, but we can certainly take a look at that.
Overall City throughput has decreased since 2019. Can you help us understand what explains this trend?
Well, one, I think the implementation of Local Law 52 reduced overall citywide throughput because the majority of transfer stations were located in districts that were covered by Local Law 52. So when you reduce the permanent capacity citywide, you have to send that waste elsewhere, so more of that waste is going either up to Westchester County or into New Jersey, in places that, you know, are not regulated by the Department of Sanitation.
I think there is also a part of it that could be related to just waste reduction overall, I will say, because we have not fully implemented commercial waste zones yet, and so you know, that is speculation at this point. But once we have commercial licensing fully implemented at the end of 2027, we will have very robust data on where the waste is being generated, where it is going and what kind of waste it is. I encourage you to look at the full data set that we posted along with the commercial waste zones annual report, which has a lot of data in it.
Also, when looking at this data, we see that the throughput decreased primarily in non-designated areas while the throughput remained the same in the four designated areas since 2019. Could you also help us explain that trend?
I do not necessarily know that I am seeing the same trend, but we would be happy to dig into the data with you.
Okay, that would be great. We would really love to make sure that we are all on the same page there. What were the law's effects on truck traffic in the designated community districts, and did we see truck traffic decrease?
I know you spoke about it earlier, but if you could go into a bit more detail. I do not think we are able to measure the actual decrease in truck traffic because we do not have data on how many trucks there are and where, until commercial waste zones is fully implemented. We did quite a bit of modelling as part of the environmental
assessment that was done prior to the passage of Local Law 52, and what we anticipated as part of that environmental assessment was a substantial decrease in truck traffic in those districts. We have seen that, actually, throughput has decreased by about the amount we expected in that environmental review, so I would think that the truck traffic reduction has been approximately what we
expected. But even though we cannot answer about the waste equity law, I am curious if you have done any research into whether Local Law 199 of 2019 had any impact on truck traffic thus far, and what about Local Law 145 — if that had any impact on the waste equity law's implementation with truck emissions? Sure.
So for Local Law 145, which goes back to 2013, that was
the law that required emissions retrofits for all waste hauling vehicles. That law has been fully implemented. The last of the waivers under that law expired several years ago, so I think that has had a real impact on the particulate matter from those commercial waste hauling vehicles. I do not have a rigorous analysis of that in front of me, but you know, that is something that I think just the implementation of that law over several thousand vehicles has had a real impact.
For Local Law 199, we do publish to the decimal point the amount of vehicle miles traveled associated with commercial waste zones operations. Because we only have six zones fully implemented at the end of the fiscal year, and some of those commercial waste zones were implemented partially throughout the fiscal year, what we are able to do is model out, based on those first six zones, where we expect to be at the end of the full 20-zone implementation, and we are pretty much on track for that 18 million vehicle miles traveled reduction that we anticipated in 2018.
Particularly in the four designated community districts, has the department considered any other solutions to decrease truck traffic?
I think the implementation of commercial waste zones is the most effective tool that we can use to reduce truck traffic. You know, I think absent rezoning new parts of the City for industrial uses and opening new transfer stations in those rezoned places, I think it will be very difficult to meaningfully relocate transfer capacity out of those four districts and into other parts of the City. The best we could do is just shift the burden elsewhere onto environmental justice neighborhoods outside of New York City, and I do not know that that is necessarily a great outcome. But that is certainly what Local Law 52 has done.
Not the best outcome. Not everyone wants stuff in other EJ zones. But if it is not in the Bronx, it is good to me. I will actually turn it over to CM Restler.
Well, thanks so much, Chair Sanchez. I really appreciate your leadership in hosting this hearing today and hearing our legislation. Commissioner, it is always good to see you. I have to say I am very happy that we have commercial waste zones coming to Community Board one, we have Empire Bins coming to Community Board one. I just had a great meeting with Chief Ouattara, who is helping to make all the good things happen on the ground. We did work last week in Boerum Hill. There is just a lot of good stuff, and I consistently have a really positive experience with whoever I am dealing with at the Department of Sanitation. I really appreciate that.
We have just had, I think going back since the beginning of the de Blasio administration, really consistently great leadership from the agency, and I am thrilled that you are in this role and I am looking forward to continuing to work closely with you and your team. I see that you do not like my bill. Correct. Yeah. I said all the nice things
first. Might want to take back
those compliments. Yeah, well, we will see how the conversation goes. I appreciate that. The smart compost bins were kind of created in a different moment, before we had mandatory composting fully in place. Our legislation is, I think, rightly ambitious in trying to set a sizable number of compost receptacles around every community district, because there are times when you are having lunch in a park or having lunch in a City Council hearing and you need a compost receptacle for your excess food. Do you think that a smaller number of compost receptacles per community district could make sense if 25 is too big a number?
I think that... if you look at the utilization of our smart compost bins — and this is all in our zero waste report, which came out also on September 30, the same day as our commercial waste zones annual report. Big day for annual reports in Sanitation. There was a 42% reduction in utilization over that one year, and keep in mind we have only very recently been really focusing on enforcement for mandatory organics. I, for example, used to use a smart bin until my building got a ticket for not having a compost bin, and then they got a compost bin and now I just use my building's compost bin. So I just do not think that that is an investment that necessarily makes sense at this time. I think if there is a pot of money that we are going to invest in composting in New York City, it is probably better spent on education and outreach rather than providing additional bins for folks,
because we will come to every building in New York City once a week and pick it up from the front of your building. You know, our legislation — the idea was to make composting convenient on street corners for the times where it is not your household waste. But, you know, as I think during your brief sojourn up to Albany, we really struggled... you know, when we cut drop-offs at the farmers markets — at the farmers markets in my community, at McCarren Park and McGoldrick Park, with McCarren being a big reason... well, there is a big reason McCarren is taking over. That was a green market as an example. We still have huge numbers of people that come every single week to drop their compost off, and so I am concerned that we still need locations for people to be able to take their compost, whether it is household or otherwise.
We have gotten a lot of complaints from larger buildings that have trash chutes and where they are not having composting set up in the buildings. Maybe it is just the scale of the buildings that is challenging for the building management staff to handle the compost. Are you concerned about... I guess there are a couple of questions there. One, are you concerned about full adoption of composting, especially in larger buildings where the operations are a bit more involved? And then secondly, are you concerned about the stability of the compost drop-off sites we have across the City, and do you believe that they serve an essential role in kind of
achieving our composting goals? Thank you for those questions, and they are two very different questions. I fully agree with you on access to convenient composting for apartment building residents, particularly in larger buildings, and that is a place where we are doing a lot of enforcement already. If there are residents out there whose buildings do not have a brown bin and are not setting that brown bin out for collection, call 311. Let us know. We will do outreach first, and then we will write tickets and we will not stop on this. And that is where, in addition, I think the outreach and education is really valuable, to teach people how easy it is to compost in their own apartment. When my wife and I first started composting, she was not a fan, and she was just
like, why do we need four different trash cans? Now we were just at my in-laws' house in Pennsylvania, where they do not compost, and she literally was looking around my mother-in-law's kitchen for a place to put the egg shells. And we live in a high-rise apartment in Long Island City, so you know, it is easy for apartment residents to compost if you know how to do it and if you have some easy tips.
If we had more resources to be able to do that outreach and education, I think that is where the investment is really meaningful. If I can continue going, because I know his clock has run out. Okay, no one is saying no. On the drop-off side, I think that the kinds of drop-offs that you are talking about are very different than the organic waste receptacles that the Bill calls for. Those are drop-offs where you have a dedicated community composter standing next to the bin, helping people feel good about what they are doing and helping people understand that it is going to be turned into compost at a local community garden or at a community composting facility and go back to their local parks and gardens and whatever. I think that is all great stuff and I agree with you.
When the community composting baseline funds were eliminated from the budget in November 2023, that was a massive, massive change to the way that we approach composting in New York City, and I have said before I would love to have those baseline funds back in the budget so that we do not have to have this ongoing sort of tit for tat on whether composting is getting funded every year. I do not think that the people who are showing up at the green market looking to have that interaction with the community composter and have that sort of local, circular economy for their compost would necessarily feel the same way about using an organic waste receptacle like a smart bin that is collected by Sanitation and goes to one of our industrial-scale processing facilities, either a compost facility or an anaerobic digestion facility.
So I think he has made all very good points, and I still feel that in super high-traffic areas, in big parks like McCarren Park, or at Borough Hall, having a compost receptacle — having one of these smart bins — still has value. So I would love to continue the conversation. If there is a much more tailored approach that you think could make sense... it does not sound like you think it does, but I will push you anyway. And I will say lastly, I also take credit for converting my wife into a compost enthusiast as well.
I am sure our wives will be thrilled that we are discussing them here.
I was just going to say, blessings to both of your wives on behalf of the City of New York. Thank you.
On the topic of public composting, I am curious as to what the definition of education is, and just to piggyback off of what CM Restler was saying, having more of these public compost bins, especially in places like these parks — would that not be part of education, showing how easy composting is and getting more people to be able to compost? Especially when they are doing things in the park like barbecuing and bringing food — and I am Dominican, so we bring a lot of different food — and being able to compost all of that when it is not eaten or whatever. Would that not be a part of the education that would be able to show how easy it truly is to compost?
I think it could be, but as we have discussed before, we do not have very much in the way of baseline funding for education and outreach around our zero waste programs and our recycling and composting programs. So you know, I think that could contribute. But if we are not teaching people about why they should compost or how they can compost, I think giving them access to a bin is not necessarily the most effective thing that we can do. So again, to roll out the Bill as it has been introduced, we are looking at millions of dollars in expense money to purchase additional bins and install them, and I think that money could better be spent on, maybe, you know, the community composters going out into neighborhoods and teaching people about why they should
compost. So what you are saying is we need baseline funding in order to convert more wives and husbands to composting. I would love that.
Thank you. Okay, going back to our questions. So the Mayor's Racial Equity Plan highlights two strategies to address waste transfer infrastructure inequities borne by overburdened communities. Thank you. The first strategy would be to distribute waste transfer operations such that underutilized facilities become more utilized. The second would leverage solid waste management contracts as opportunities to produce more equitable distribution of waste transfer contracts. How does the Department plan to implement these strategies and where can the Council help?
So I think, in part, one of the things that we have long been talking about in these hearings is the use of our marine transfer stations for commercial waste, which, as I think we discussed, we are fully committed to, so long as we can overcome the real financial obstacles there, and are planning to do so following the complete implementation of commercial waste zones at the end of next calendar year. When we first started having these conversations that seemed very far away, but it is now 15 months, which is not that far.
So I think that is the most important thing we can do, by using excess capacity at specifically the 91st Street and Southwest Brooklyn marine transfer stations. As far as using our procurement process to reduce the capacity in overburdened districts, I think that is something that, as our current set of waste export contracts starts to expire — because these were all 20-year contracts — we certainly will look at as one of many goals that we want to try to achieve. The challenge again is there are not large waste transfer stations in other neighborhoods, and building a new waste transfer station in New York City is not possible at this moment, because of various zoning regulations and permitting requirements. So, just to be frank, unless we were to try to build a new municipal waste transfer station and go through the ULURP process for siting and land acquisition, I do not see a new large transfer station that services Department of Sanitation waste opening any time soon.
Have there been any conversations about trying to open a new municipal marine transfer station at all? There have not at this
time. I think the thing that we should be looking at as far as new infrastructure is additional composting infrastructure, as we have mentioned before.
Rikers Island. I was just going to ask — is that right? Has Rikers Island been spoken about or thought about as a potential place for a new municipal marine transfer station?
The challenge with Rikers Island as far as being a transfer station is that there is only one road in and one road out, and so you put a lot of trucks on that one road going to and from the island. I think the better option for Rikers Island is to be a receiving facility for organic waste that is collected and transferred at marine transfer stations all across the City, so that it can receive the material by water, not have the additional truck traffic, and then process it into
compost that can then be used beneficially.
Is there a way that everything could happen via water if it was at Rikers Island? Many things can happen by water. The thing that cannot happen via water is us picking up the trash at eight and a half million residents' homes, and once the trash is in the truck it has to go somewhere and be dumped. So that is the utility of the transfer station — to then move that material by other means
to its processing and disposal location. So the challenge we always have is we pick up the trash in the trucks and somehow the trash has to get out of those trucks, and where we do that and how, I think, is the focus of our efforts.
I think this is a worthy conversation that we should be continuing to explore. Having said that, are there any updates on increasing usage of marine transfer stations to move additional solid waste via barges in order to shift away from road-based transport? Is there any applicability of this program to private operators and has there been any discussion of this being scaled up for municipal waste transfer stations?
Yes, looking very seriously at doing this.
After the full implementation of commercial waste zones
next year. We have already started conversations with our 59th Street station, which we do not often talk about, which handles all of our paper that we collect in Manhattan, to see if there would be feasibility for accepting commercial paper — commercial office paper specifically — at that transfer station. At this moment we only have one zone, or I guess now two zones, fully rolled out in Manhattan. So we still need more data on how much commercial office paper is being collected separate from single-stream recycling collections, and as we have that data we can start to formulate what that would look
like. We also had a discussion about collecting all of the paper from the universities that we have on the island of Manhattan. We have not looked at universities specifically — many of them use private carters, so they would be covered by commercial waste zones. The challenge with the 59th Street station is that it only
takes paper. Many of the private carters are offering single-stream collection where it is
paper commingled with glass and plastic containers, and once that is commingled we can no longer take it at 59th Street because that goes straight to the paper mill on Staten Island. So we can certainly look into those universities and where their materials are
going. So is there a stream of flow we can track? We can certainly have conversations with the universities about how much material they are generating and what kinds of recycling programs they have.
We will definitely be having that conversation. Has the Department considered requiring that waste transfer stations located within the four designated
areas be enclosed? All putrescible transfer stations are required to be enclosed today. That is a requirement under the State regulatory scheme. Non-putrescible transfer stations are not required to be enclosed. I think
as we have talked a bit before about taking a more comprehensive look at the construction and demolition industry generally, and ways to improve recycling and ways to improve deconstruction rather than demolition, I think looking at those facilities and the impact that they have on the surrounding community is a great thing to add to that examination.
Does the Department monitor compliance with the waste equity law via the quarterly private transfer station reports that DSNY receives pursuant to Local Law 40 of 1990? Yes, we do.
Great. And then, in 2024, the Department released a chart detailing the percentage of existing lawfully operating transfer stations in New York City by borough. What is the breakdown citywide? Do we have
that? I do not have that specific report in front of me. We release that report every year.
And finally, 311 — please use it. Water or sewer runoff at private solid waste transfer stations: what about for things like open doors or gates, or for litter adjacent to waste transfer station properties?
Yes,
we do receive 311 complaints for all of those categories, and we investigate them quite promptly, usually on the same shift, so within eight hours. We also conduct most transfer station weekly inspections and even more frequent drive-by inspections, so we will drive by and look to see: are they tracking material out of the facility, are the doors open unnecessarily, are there odors or other fumes coming out? If any of those things are identified, we will take appropriate
action. Do you also have — and I know this is a large data set — could you help explain, if you have the data, the sanitation 311 volumes in environmental justice communities versus non-EJ communities and what that looks
like? Are EJ communities making 311 complaints relative to everyone else?
So yes, everyone makes 311 complaints — every neighborhood in New York City — to the Department of Sanitation, because we have an incredibly high volume of 311 complaints and service requests. It is not all just complaints; sometimes people are asking for something. So we do see high call volume from every sanitation district and section. I do not have specifically in front of me the breakdown between EJ communities and non-EJ communities, or between the racial equity communities that are identified in the Racial Equity Report and non-racial equity communities, but we can certainly do that analysis.
I would really appreciate that — that would be really great. I also want to mention, if I have not mentioned, we have been joined by the incomparable Council Members with their presence. I also want to give a huge plug and shout-out: Roosevelt Avenue needs more trash cans immediately. But do you have any questions of our great witnesses? Okay.
So I want to touch on CM Nurse's rechargeable battery disposal plan. What outreach and education has the Department engaged in to inform the public of the proper way to dispose of rechargeable batteries for micro-mobility devices?
Yeah, so we do quite a bit of education. This month in particular is Fire Safety Month and one of the areas of focus this Fire Safety Month is around rechargeable batteries — everything from buying approved batteries and making sure that you only have batteries that are safe to use, how to safely store and charge them in your home or business, and how to safely dispose of and recycle them at the end of life. So FDNY is doing a lot of education around that this month. We are working with them on that education. The Mayor's Office has put out some social media on that as well. Those are the kinds of things that we do.
When the plan from the battery network, which is the producer responsibility organization, is approved by DEP, there are also education components of that that will be undertaken by the producer responsibility organization. At this point DEP has not yet approved that plan. We are having ongoing conversations about the right balance between convenience and safety, because obviously we do not want to create drop-off opportunities that then create fire risk and are unsafe for either commercial establishments or for our communities. So that is an ongoing conversation. But as soon as that plan is approved, we expect that there will be funding there for education as well.
And have you — has the Department seen a lot of rechargeable batteries dropped off at the safe disposal events, and if not, what could the Department be doing to increase the traffic at safe
disposal events? So I would say the traffic at safe disposal events is never our problem. I think our capacity to be able to handle the amount of people that show up is our biggest challenge. We had a safe disposal event a couple of weeks ago during the nor'easter and, even though we did advise folks that if it is not safe, do not come out, we still had over 800 people come to the safe disposal event to try to dispose of paint, batteries, electronics, et cetera. So we would love to increase our capacity for those events. Right now we are only funded for one per borough per year and we get a lot of volume. As far as the batteries, do you have
anything to add there? I would say that we have seen a great increase in the amount of batteries returned both at the safe events that the Commissioner mentioned, but also at the special waste sites that the Commissioner mentioned earlier that are now open five days per week, which is very convenient for folks to come and bring their batteries. In addition to the safe events, which are only one time per year, the other point we would make about safety: those drop-off locations are for batteries that are not damaged. It is best to contact FDNY to come and address damaged batteries because there is a high risk of fire if a battery is damaged, leaking, swelling, or generating heat. But as long as the battery is not charging anymore or something like that, it is fine to bring to a safe event or to one of those special waste sites — one in each borough. Thank you.
And speaking of FDNY, we are curious: outside of FDNY, has DSNY partnered with any other agency or organization to host events for delivery workers, for example, looking to safely dispose of their micro-mobility batteries?
Yeah, so Sanitation is part of a micro-mobility working group that includes many agencies, including the Department of Transportation, Department of Consumer and Worker Protection and NYPD, focused on a range of issues around micro-mobility devices and third-party delivery. So yes, that conversation is certainly a part of that work, and I know DCWP is doing some of their outreach to the delivery worker community and to the third-party delivery apps, and they are raising the safety and safe disposal issues there as well.
And then we will talk about Int 0030-2026 and Int 0987-2026 quickly before I end with my last question. What is the most common method of waste collection for public buildings? Approximately what percentage of City-owned buildings receive off-street collection and what percentage of school buildings receive off-street collection?
The most common means of collection is standard curbside collection with a rear-loading collection truck. Almost every school in New York City, for example, receives a school truck collection. Those collections are done using dual-bin trucks, so we pick up a combination of paper recycling, metal, glass, plastic recycling and organics on various different days, and then the trash is collected on the neighborhood collection frequency, the same as the surrounding residents. As far as the percentage of City buildings that have off-street collection, I do not have that number specifically in front of me, but it is
a relatively low share as a percentage of all buildings. Do you have any idea how much it would cost to transition all of the City-owned buildings to stationary on-street containerization?
I think we are trying to work on that estimate as part of the discussion. Two things I will say: one, we do have to do a waste generation study on a building-by-building basis to determine how many bins each building would need, and so that is a time-consuming process that, if we were to do it for the whole City, would take several years. The second thing is — is there any other methodology that we could use in order to fast-track that timeline? Yeah, we are using a bunch of different approaches. We do desktop modeling based on — you can make estimates based on the number of students in a school, for example, or the number of units in a residential building, or the number of meals served. So we can start from that, but we do have to do the actual detailed waste generation study to make sure that we are putting enough bins there, because the last thing we want is to have one bin and then there is a pile of trash sitting next to it, because that makes the bin look like it does not work.
So we could certainly do that and we are trying to come up with a reasonable estimate of what that would be — what the number of bins would be and therefore the cost for all City buildings. The other thing I will say, which I mentioned in my testimony: City buildings are already required to containerize their trash. Every school sets their trash out in containers. If they do not have some other means of containerization already, other City buildings are using bins. We have a separate contract where City agencies can order directly from the vendor, and many City agencies have done so. Parks has designed custom waste enclosures that they are using at every park, so there are no longer just piles of bags sitting out by the fence. So every agency is sort of taking their own approach based on what works for them, and because we are
talking about schools, does that also apply to any of the charter schools as well, or is that solely for our public schools?
It depends on what kind of charter school and what kind of building they are in. If they are in a private building, then they receive commercial waste collection, so they are covered by commercial waste zones. If they are in a DOE building, they receive Sanitation collection. If they are in their own building, many of them do receive Sanitation collection, but some of them choose to go with a private carter. So it varies pretty widely based on the specifics of the school.
Great, thank you. And then, reports from the containerization pilot indicated record-breaking reductions in rat sightings and improved cleanliness at set-out locations. Do you believe that the containerization requirements in Int 0030-2026 would have a similar effect?
I think anything we can do to contain and reduce more waste would, as far as cleanliness and rats, the thing that we are focused on as we roll out our containerization program citywide by the end of 2031 is where there are still bags sitting on the sidewalk. That is large residential buildings. So the approach that we are taking is, because there is a limited number of trucks that we can purchase in any given year just because the factory that makes these trucks can only make so many, our plan right now takes all of those trucks and puts them toward solving the residential containerization challenge.
When we get to the end of 2031 and have purchased all the trucks we need for residential containerization, I think that is the right time to look around and say what are other things that we could use bins for, and start to look at lower density buildings that could use more shared containers, potentially requiring shared containers for some of those lower density buildings. But anything we do today that takes away from our ability to roll out as quickly as possible on the large residential buildings means we achieve that goal more slowly.
Thank you. And then my last question: on Majority Leader Brewer's inquiry, are there any other factors beyond the department's fleet and collection routes that the department needs to take into consideration when assessing the viability of an association's request for stationary on-street containers?
I think the other important factor is just whether there is enough material there to justify the size of the container. These containers generally are quite large. And if you had only a handful of single homes or a handful of units using one bin, that would be a waste of the City's money in terms of purchasing the bin and maintaining it. So we do want to try to get to at least a minimum number of 10 to 15 units sharing the same bin to sort of hit the minimum threshold, and then from there we look at waste generation and other factors to determine the right number of bins to assign.
And speaking of one of my favorite topics, waste equity: my last question is there has been movement of the trucks from Manhattan Community Board Nine because of the new opening of Success Academy Charter School. And now the trucks that were in front of the Manhattan Nine station are now just randomly on side streets, taking away all of the local residents' parking and just filling our streets with literally blocks of trucks, while the Nine truck storage facility underneath the bridges sits empty as of right now. So I am curious: has there been more discussion about being able to move the trucks that are just sitting on the streets back to the empty parking lot that gets only used for things like Harlem Pride?
I think there is a greater need for the trucks to be there. You can probably move them for events like Harlem Pride. I am not saying to cancel that. But has there been any discussion of being able to move the trucks that are just sitting on the streets back to the Manhattan Nine parking lot?
I am not familiar with the exact parking lot that you are referring to, but I am happy to take a look at it. We have made some adjustments to the parking around the Nine, which, as...
You have mentioned before, the Manhattan Nine garage is in the Bronx, along with Bronx 7 and 8 garages in Manhattan. It is sort of a weird...
But they have spaces. It is a much larger facility. It is very... if you were to go up to 215th Street, you would see sanitation trucks parked all over the place. But I will say we have tried to rearrange the way that we are parking trucks in the vicinity of the Manhattan Community Board Nine garage because of the additional pedestrian traffic going to and from the new school that opened. It is certainly something that we are having active conversations with many Council Members about. There are a few different districts that sort of cover that area. And we want to balance the residents' needs with safe pedestrian travel for the school kids, along with our operational needs to be able to provide service to New...
...Yorkers. Thank you so much. And you know how much I would love to make sure that the Nine trucks are back at Community Board Nine in Manhattan. So anything that we can do there would be much appreciated, and with that...
Thank you for surviving another day with us at the Committee on Sanitation and Solid Waste Management. I really appreciated it. We will be taking a brief five-minute break and then coming back for our... are we rested? Are we refreshed now? We could take another five.
But no, we would like this Committee hearing to end. So...