The Business of Child Care Committee on Small Business | Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education · October 29, 2026 · 3hrs 23m Source: https://hearinghearings.nyc/hearings/committee-on-small-business-the-business-of-child-care-2026-10-29/ Video: https://councilnyc.viebit.com/vod/?s=true&v=NYCC-250-8-1_261029-130608.mp4 ================================================================ (00:00:23) THE DAIS. Oh, good, good. Good afternoon. Welcome to the New York City Council hearing for the Committee on Small Business jointly with the Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education. At this time we're going to ask everyone in the room to silence all cell phones and electronic devices. If you wish to testify you need to fill out an appearance card. If you haven't done so yet, see the Sergeant at Arms in the back of the room and we'll get you signed up. Most importantly, at this time no one is allowed to approach the dais. Are you ready to begin? (00:00:59) Good afternoon, everyone. I am CM Shanel Thomas-Henry, Chair of the Committee on Small Business. Thank you for joining us for today's joint hearing between the Committee on Small Business and Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education, examining the business of child care. I'd like to begin by thanking my co-chair CM Jennifer Gutiérrez. I'd also like to thank the representatives from the Administration, members of the public, and my Council colleagues who have joined us here today, including CM Felder, Brewer, and Hanif. We have CM Maloney. (00:01:42) In the last couple of years we've seen conversation grow significantly around child care in New York City. This year, the Mayor, the Governor, and the Council have focused their efforts on examining the landscape of child care and improving its affordability and accessibility for New York City families. Part of this examination is considering who would provide child care, and that is why today's hearing is so important. New York City small businesses are significant providers of child care, and that they have the resources and guidance to conduct their business is crucial to meeting the affordability needs of New York City families. According to a 2024 report from the U.S. Small Business Administration, nearly all firms in the child care industry are small businesses, but most of the child care firms that have exited the market have been small businesses. The growing cost of the industry has been an overwhelming burden for small businesses, and this 2024 report further noted that the price of child care grew by 230% from 1992 to 2022. Small businesses have the unique ability to be deeply connected to their communities. Many serve as unofficial community centers, or were started by someone who was born and raised in the neighborhood. Businesses can begin because of a deep need to give back to the community or to share a passion. But starting a small child care business takes a unique amount of work. There are many complex requirements that a child care provider must meet, in addition to rules and regulations that all small businesses must follow in New York City. The costs and the complexity of starting and sustaining a child care business can be understated, and we must find ways to appropriately streamline the business of child care if we truly want to make child care affordable. (00:03:51) The committee is also hearing Introduction 445, from CM Stevens, which requires the Department of Small Business Services to expand the Business Pathways program to include creative fields, retail, and cosmetology. (00:04:06) The programs would assist NYCHA residents in formalizing their businesses, including via professional business education courses, mentorship and professional coaching support in obtaining business licenses, guidance on business operations, marketing, and financial structures, funding to complete required health and safety trainings, support in completing provider applications, and help for certain businesses to secure a commercial space. The Business Pathways program currently in place was for entrepreneurs who reside in NYCHA housing to start and grow businesses in food and child care, the latter of which we plan to focus on for this hearing. (00:04:48) Public information about this program is limited, including who is presently responsible for running the program. We look forward to hearing from the Administration about this program and their thoughts on CM Stevens' bill. (00:05:00) I would like to thank Tyler Walls and Rebecca Beryllium from Speaker Thomas-Henry's staff for putting this hearing together, as well as my own staff, Derek Slaughter, Franklin Richards, and Sierra Smith, and everyone working in the background to help make this hearing possible. I'd like to recognize CM Murano. Okay, he's here somewhere. All right, we'll find CM Murano shortly. In the meantime, I will turn it over to my co-chair, CM Gutiérrez. (00:05:39) Thank you, Chair. Good afternoon, everyone. CM Gutiérrez, Chair of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education, and we're so excited to join the Committee on Small Business and their chair, CM Thomas-Henry, for today's oversight hearing on the business of child care. Over the last several months as chair of the subcommittee, I have had the privilege of hearing directly from families about how reliable, affordable child care plays an integral role in their lives. Yet the people who run child care programs are caught in an impossible squeeze. Child care providers are asked to deliver a high-quality, safe, and nurturing environment on razor-thin margins. They are competing in a market where the service is expensive for families to buy, and the wages they can afford to pay their staff remain far too low. Former Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen described the child care industry as the textbook example of a broken market. The majority of child care businesses are small businesses, and are owned and operated largely by women, and often women of color. Most are working hard and following the rules to keep their child care business open, but this can often feel impossible. National data shows that most for-profit child care facilities operate on a profit margin of less than 1%, well below the recommended healthy margin of 15% seen across most industries. This means that an unexpected cost pops up, like a broken fridge, plumbing backups, or water heater failures. It can be devastating to the financial stability of that child care program. This year, Mayor Adams and Governor Hochul made a big investment in expanding the child care system, but improving child care access for families is not just about making child care more affordable. The underlying infrastructure needs investment too. This means increasing contracted rates for child care and setting reimbursement rates for child care vouchers at the true cost of care. Without sufficient public funding, child care programs will continue to struggle. So today we'll ask the Mayor's Office of Child Care and Early Childhood Education and the Department of Small Business Services: how are you supporting child care businesses as small businesses, and how are you ensuring the financial viability of child care programs? Thank you to the members of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood who joined us today. I also want to thank the staff, Julia Goes-Pinkham, Katie Selena Great Tomato, Julian Lawless, and Margaret Barnsley, as well as my own staff, Franco LCA, Angela Angelica Colon, and Madeline McGillivray, for their work on today's hearing. And my legislative fellow. Thank you, Chair. Turn it back over to you. (00:08:04) Thank you, CM Gutiérrez. I will now turn it over to the Committee Counsel to administer the oath before we hear from the Administration. (00:08:54) CHILDHOOD EDUCATION, MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS AND ALL OTHER CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS. MY NAME IS EMILY LIST AND I AM THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE MAYOR'S OFFICE OF CHILD CARE AND EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION. I AM JOINED TODAY BY MY COLLEAGUES AT THE DEPARTMENT OF SMALL BUSINESS SERVICES AND NEW YORK CITY HOUSING AUTHORITY. THANK YOU FOR ORGANIZING THIS HEARING AND GIVING US THE OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY ABOUT THE BUSINESS OF CHILD CARE. I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO ACKNOWLEDGE AND RECOGNIZE THE EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATORS AND PROVIDERS WHO HAVE JOINED US FOR THIS HEARING TODAY AS WELL AS THE ADVOCACY GROUPS AND ORGANIZATIONS WHO SUPPORT THIS CRITICAL WORKFORCE. WE ARE GRATEFUL FOR THE WORK YOU DO EVERY DAY IN OUR CITY'S EARLY CHILDHOOD PROGRAMS AND APPRECIATE YOU BEING HERE TO SHARE YOUR STORIES AND EXPERIENCES. (00:09:32) Universal child care is a critical pillar for the Mamdani Administration and a key component in making New York City more affordable for everyone to raise a family. This administration has been working diligently toward a city where every child under five has access to free, high-quality early care and education, offered in a range of culturally competent settings, with caregivers and educators who are trained, respected, and fairly compensated. On just day eight of this administration, the Mayor and the Governor committed over $1.2 billion in New York City to put us more firmly on the path to universal child care here in New York City. We are lucky to have a rich ecosystem of early childhood education providers. (00:10:10) Many of the city's community-based child care providers have been in operation for decades, or more than a century in some cases, and they have educated and cared for thousands and thousands of children. We appreciate that today's hearing recognizes child care providers as the small businesses that they are. According to state licensing data, there are more than 10,000 unique licensed child care programs in New York City: over 2,200 licensed daycare centers, more than 1,500 licensed school-aged child care centers, close to 5,600 group family day cares, and around 740 family day cares. Child care businesses in New York City are typically very small. Small family child care programs may not have any staff other than the owner, and larger family child care programs have just one or two additional staff members. According to data from the U.S. Census, more than half of child care programs operating in New York City employ fewer than five people. Just 3% of child care businesses employ more than 50. (00:10:27) DATA. THERE ARE MORE THAN 10,000 UNIQUE LICENSED CHILD CARE PROGRAMS IN NEW YORK CITY. OVER 2,200 LICENSED DAYCARE CENTERS, MORE THAN 1,500 LICENSED SCHOOL-AGED CHILD CARE CENTERS, CLOSE TO 5,600 GROUP FAMILY DAY CARES, AND AROUND 740 FAMILY DAY CARES. CHILD CARE BUSINESSES IN NEW YORK CITY ARE TYPICALLY VERY SMALL. SMALL FAMILY CHILD CARE PROGRAMS DO NOT HAVE ANY STAFF OTHER THAN THE OWNER, AND LARGER FAMILY CHILD CARE PROGRAMS HAVE JUST ONE OR TWO ADDITIONAL STAFF MEMBERS. ACCORDING TO DATA FROM THE U.S. CENSUS, MORE THAN HALF OF CHILD CARE PROGRAMS OPERATING IN NEW YORK CITY EMPLOY FEWER THAN FIVE PEOPLE. JUST 3% OF CHILD CARE BUSINESSES EMPLOY MORE THAN 50. (00:11:05) As small businesses, New York City's child care leaders, a majority of whom are women of color, often wear many hats. New York City's regulatory landscape for child care providers, while important for health and safety, can make life very challenging for our child care business owners. Close to half of all child care workers have their own children at home. In total, over 5,000 child care workers have a child under the age of five at home, meaning they are likely making use of early childhood education themselves. The Mayor's Office of Child Care and Early Childhood Education sees its mandate simply to make it easier for families to find access to care, and to make it easier for child care providers to open, operate, and sustain their businesses. We do this by setting the Administration's strategy to deliver on universal child care, coordinating and aligning policy and programmatic activity across agencies involved in early care and education work, engaging deeply with the community to ensure parent and child care provider voices are represented in policy, and partnering with business, philanthropy, and the nonprofit sector to accelerate innovation and impact. Over the past 10 months, we have spent time listening to child care providers to try to better understand what they need and how the City can better support their work, which is essential to delivering our vision of universal child care. We consolidated application requirements, simplified communication with the Health Department, and provide real-time updates on application status, removing barriers that have long made it difficult for providers to open their doors. We are pleased to have demoed that permitting portal for the Council earlier this year. In May, Mayor Mamdani issued a proclamation declaring Child Care Provider Appreciation Month and coordinated a series of visits to child care providers across the City, intended to bring more visibility to the work that our providers do every day. (00:11:34) EDUCATION SEES ITS MANDATE SIMPLY TO MAKE IT EASIER FOR FAMILIES TO FIND ACCESS TO CARE AND TO MAKE IT EASIER FOR CHILD CARE PROVIDERS TO OPEN, OPERATE, AND SUSTAIN THEIR BUSINESSES. WE DO THIS BY SETTING THE ADMINISTRATION'S STRATEGY TO DELIVER ON UNIVERSAL CHILD CARE, COORDINATING AND ALIGNING POLICY AND PROGRAMMATIC ACTIVITY ACROSS AGENCIES INVOLVED IN EARLY CARE AND EDUCATION WORK, ENGAGING DEEPLY WITH THE COMMUNITY TO ENSURE PARENT AND CHILD CARE PROVIDER VOICES ARE REPRESENTED IN POLICY, AND PARTNERING WITH BUSINESS, PHILANTHROPY, AND THE NONPROFIT SECTOR TO ACCELERATE INNOVATION AND IMPACT. OVER THE PAST 10 MONTHS, WE HAVE SPENT TIME LISTENING TO CHILD CARE PROVIDERS TO BETTER UNDERSTAND WHAT THEY NEED AND HOW THE CITY CAN BETTER SUPPORT THEIR WORK, WHICH IS ESSENTIAL TO DELIVERING OUR VISION OF UNIVERSAL CHILD CARE. CONSOLIDATED APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS SIMPLIFY COMMUNICATION WITH THE HEALTH DEPARTMENT AND PROVIDE REAL-TIME UPDATES ON APPLICATION STATUS, REMOVING BARRIERS THAT HAVE LONG MADE IT DIFFICULT FOR PROVIDERS TO OPEN THEIR DOORS. WE ARE PLEASED TO DEMONSTRATE THAT PERMITTING PORTAL FOR THE COUNCIL EARLIER THIS YEAR. MAYOR MAMDANI ISSUED A PROCLAMATION DECLARING CHILD CARE PROVIDER APPRECIATION MONTH AND COORDINATED A SERIES OF VISITS TO CHILD CARE PROVIDERS ACROSS THE CITY, INTENDED TO BRING MORE VISIBILITY TO THE WORK THAT OUR PROVIDERS DO EVERY DAY. (00:12:53) Additionally, my office is partnered with providers organized for power, or POP, to lead a listening tour with home-based child care programs focused on fostering honest conversations with educators, as part of our commitment to supporting the educators who make child care possible for working families across New York City. In March, Schools Chancellor Mark Samuels announced a comprehensive overhaul of the City's child care procurement processes to ensure providers working with New York City Public Schools can open their doors, and to work to accelerate contract registration. This overhaul included a $43 million investment to transform the New York City Public Schools Division of Early Childhood Education, to ensure the staffing capacity necessary to implement reforms designed to prevent future contracting and payment delays. Later, our team in the Mayor's Office is helping to coordinate a Provider Leads Steering Committee to design a shared services cooperative for home-based providers, to reduce costs, drive up revenue, and help providers build power together. This co-op would serve as a tool to empower our small family child care businesses to compete with larger chains that threaten the business model of our essential small business providers. (00:14:04) Lastly, we know that our small child care businesses face a crisis of rapidly growing costs, especially liability insurance, and they lack the negotiating leverage to resolve those. We believe we should use the levers of government to support our small businesses and reduce costs like these. Looking ahead, the City is bringing together partners within and outside government to develop a comprehensive strategy to grow, sustain, and support the child care workforce, including addressing wage disparities, operating costs, and the long-term investments needed to support competitive compensation and high-quality care. As the Administration works with urgency to implement universal child care, we know that we must invest in child care operators and ensure they can sustain their businesses. In the past several months, we have taken some initial steps to address the financial and operational challenges facing providers and the educators who make these programs possible, though we know there is still much more work to do. In the Executive Budget, the Mayor invested $40 million in increased rates for contracted early childhood providers, including a 5% rate increase for family child care providers and a 2% increase for family child care networks and center-based providers. (00:15:13) Providers. The Administration also launched a $3 million emergency micro-grant fund to provide financial assistance to license home-based child care facing urgent challenges that threaten their ability to remain open. And with the City's recent announcement of where, geographically, we will offer 2K and fall 2027, we have open procurement opportunities for child care providers who wish to offer two-K services. There is a survey open now to existing early childhood contracted providers, which they must complete by November 9, and a request for information for potential new partners with New York City Public Schools, which will be open until November 12. (00:15:50) I will now turn it over to my colleague, Chief of Staff of the Department of Small Business Services, who will speak to how the Department supports the critical work that our child care providers do as small businesses in New York City. We look forward to your questions today and your partnership in this work. (00:15:52) Good afternoon, Chair Thomas-Henry, CM Gutiérrez, and members of the New York City Council Committee on Small Business and Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education. My name is Harris Con. I serve as Chief of Staff at the City's Department of Small Business Services. Thank you. (00:16:08) Our mission is to unlock economic potential and create economic security for all New Yorkers by connecting New Yorkers to good jobs, creating stronger businesses, and building thriving neighborhoods across the five boroughs. Small businesses are the backbone of our economy, and the City's independently owned child care providers play a dual role: they help sustain our economy and serve as an essential support system for thousands of families. SBS is committed to supporting all small businesses, including child care providers, by offering educational resources on topics such as opening a storefront business, forming a worker cooperative, securing financing, and accessing free commercial lease assistance and legal services. We are grateful for our ongoing partnership with the Mayor's Office of Child Care and Early Childhood Education and the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene in supporting these operators. (00:16:23) In addition to our direct services, SBS is involved in the development and implementation of the Open for Small Business reform agenda, which includes more than 50 reforms, with four specifically focused on child care. These reforms include expanding the child care permitting portal and streamlining the background check request portal. (00:17:09) In this process, the Administration gathered insights from industry leaders and direct feedback from some business operators, including a child care operators roundtable led by Deputy Mayor Sutton, an executive director of this. Additionally, we partner with the Office of Child Care and Early Childhood Education in our public events and webinars to help educate small businesses. Our New York City Business Express service also works with child care providers through the requirements, connecting them to the full suite of services that we offer. (00:17:28) IN THIS PROCESS, THE ADMINISTRATION GATHERED INSIGHTS FROM INDUSTRY LEADERS AND DIRECT FEEDBACK FROM SOME BUSINESS OPERATORS, INCLUDING A CHILD CARE OPERATORS ROUNDTABLE LED BY DEPUTY MAYOR SU, AN EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THIS. ADDITIONALLY, WE PARTNER WITH THE OFFICE OF CHILD CARE AND EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION IN OUR PUBLIC EVENTS AND WEBINARS TO HELP EDUCATE SMALL BUSINESSES. OUR NEW YORK CITY BUSINESS EXPRESS SERVICE ALSO WORKS WITH CHILD CARE PROVIDERS THROUGH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE PROGRAM, CONNECTING THEM TO THE FULL SUITE OF SERVICES. (00:17:59) Additionally, I'd like to briefly speak on the Business Pathways Program. Reference and introduction, for CM Shanel Thomas-Henry, sponsored by... The Business Pathways Program is operated by the Mayor's Office of President and Economic Resident Economic Empowerment and Sustainability, according to notes since 2014. The program has enrolled 448 residents in 12 boards of the food business pathways to start or grow their food businesses, and 189 residents across nine courses of the child care pathways to start and formalize their child business. We're joined today by my colleague Castillo, President of Partnerships and Initiatives at Nature, who can answer further questions on this program. (00:18:47) We're also grateful for the partnership of the New York City Council as a critical partner in all of our work, and thank you for this opportunity to testify. We will answer any questions that you have. (00:18:55) Thank you both for your testimony. I'd like to announce that we have Counsel Memo Morano has joined us. We've also been joined by CM Reilly and CM Maloney on Zoom. I will now turn it over to CM Joseph to ask questions. (00:19:15) Thank you so much, Chair. For this, allow me to go before. So there are a little over 7,000 families. Child care providers in a network that leaves about 5,000 providers locked out of the contract seats. What are the specific steps to bring them in, and when do you plan, and why do they get paid less than for the same seat? Also, in the paper, they have to pay a network fee. How do you expect to see them joining, if it is worth it? (00:19:44) Thanks so much for your question, Councilmember. New York City Public Schools contracts with networks, as you reference. These are intermediary organizations, very often community-based organizations with deep roots in child care and in their community, and we leverage networks as the vehicle to support home-based providers, because administratively it is, as we all know, onerous to contract with the City, and something that can be really challenging for a small child care provider. So the network takes on a lot of that administrative business work, and then can provide support to the provider when it comes to business enrollment and other administrative functions. Our family child care networks are also equipped to provide coaching and support to family child care in languages that providers speak, other than English. So we believe that when they are operating at their best, our family child care networks are really strong bridges to support providers participating in the City's initiatives. We also recognize that not all family child care providers have historically wanted to participate in networks, and so we've spent a lot of the past 10 months in conversation with providers and advocates who work with providers to understand what some of their challenges have been, and working with them to identify areas for strengthening our networks so that those can be more compelling opportunities for providers. We've really brought them the question of what would it take for you to be excited about joining a network, and we are working to incorporate the feedback we hear from them. I know you just referenced fees, and I know this came up at our last hearing. Family child care networks should not be charging providers a fee for participating, and so if that's something you're hearing, we would love to follow up with your office and get more specifics, because that should not be part of the model. New York City Public Schools pays a flat rate to family child care networks. A portion of that rate is to cover their administrative costs, and the vast majority of that rate goes directly to the provider to cover services. If the goal is universal, you're leaving almost 5,000 providers out of that network. I know you said you're encouraging them to come in. Do you know what the problem is as to why there's a hesitation to join your network? In conversation, yeah, that's a big part of the conversation, to say we are growing the capacity of our networks as we expand. So as we expand to K, we are looking to bring families and child care providers into the program in a significant way. We know that many families prefer home-based care for their toddlers, and that is a model we want to really lean on. So with the expansion of 2K, we are expanding network capacity, and again, really engaging providers to understand where there have been past hesitance, misconceptions, and real challenges that we are working to address. (00:22:44) Thank you, Chair. I'm just going to thank you. Nearly 30,000 families, one wait list this month. Of the 10,000 children that have been promised to move off, how many have actually been moved? Who got priority, and how many families are still waiting once all the 10,000 are moved? I'm hearing from providers who are losing income while these seats remain empty. (00:23:05) Yes. As the administration announced earlier this month, we are beginning to take families off of the voucher wait list. We recognize that this wait list has been an incredible hardship for the families waiting for care and for the providers who are willing, ready, and able to serve those families. Some portion of those 30,000 families may already be in other publicly funded care, but they absolutely have the right, if they would prefer a voucher, to remain on the wait list. We are inviting families to submit the paperwork to come off the wait list, so that we can provide support. (00:23:43) About 3,000 invitations went out to children on the wait list earlier this month, and we will continue to move families off the wait list on a monthly basis until we maximize our funding. 10,000 is the number we shared at that announcement, but our hope is that we can continue to move even more families off the wait list. How do... (00:24:03) ...you prioritize the families you move off the list? (00:24:07) That is a process very tightly regulated by state and federal guidelines. Families come off the wait list in the order they went on to the wait list, and families who come off the wait list must be in one of three priority groups: under 300% of the federal poverty line, unhoused, or the child has a disability. But we move through the wait list in the order that families have been waiting. (00:24:31) Thank you. Most of the child care workers are women, women of color, immigrants. Are you actively walking them through certifications? And are you providing training for them? Is it provided in their language of choice? (00:24:49) I can speak to you broadly. I think we can certainly get back to you with more information about how our colleagues in the DOE team talk about that. But do you have anything you want to add? (00:25:00) The New York City Public Schools also has a DOE team that works with their providers, but there are regular conversations between our team and their team. They do their own outreach, but we also have joined them, and vice versa. So there's a partnership between the teams that work on certification. We encourage any New Yorker, they don't have to go to public schools, that could also come to help them with their DOE certification. For sure. Labor is the biggest cost for these programs, and turnover hurts children the most. How will the new cuts, the pay gap for early childhood educators, and is the current rate structure pushing small providers to keep wages low just to stay open? We know that wages and benefits are one of the biggest challenges facing child care providers and their workforce, and this is something we are committed to addressing over time. The City has not yet released a new rate for early childhood services. That's something that will come, and we will be working with our partners in the Council and partners in labor to look at wages within that. We are continuing to look at other pathways to support early childhood workers. In the meantime, right now... (00:25:27) Will the new clothes, the pay gap for early childhood educators, and is the current rate structure pushing small providers to keep wages low just to stay open? And so we know that wages and benefits are one of the biggest challenges that are facing child care providers and their workforce, and this is something we are committed to addressing over time. The city has not yet released a new rate for early childhood services. That is something that will come, and we will be working with our partners in the Council and our partners in labor to look at wages within that. We are continuing to look at other pathways to support early childhood workers in the meantime. Right now. (00:26:19) Okay, CM Joseph, I have a couple of questions, and I'll turn it over to... Of child businesses in New York City, do you have an account of how many of those businesses are nonprofit versus for-profit entities? That is not a piece of data, but the state or the City collects it. We know there is a healthy mix of nonprofit and for-profit, and even among many of our for-profit businesses, they are very small businesses, and as referenced, we are operating on various thin margins. Okay. (00:27:06) Okay. (00:27:07) Committee staff and subcommittee staff have heard that liability insurance continues to be an issue for child care small business owners, with 80% of child care owners nationwide reporting increased costs. Is the Mayor's Office of Child Care aware of this issue, and are you offering any guidance to business owners in assessing affordable liability insurance? We are very aware of this issue, as we've gone across the city and met with child care providers of all sizes. This is something we hear as a really pressing concern, and as you noted, we know this is not just a New York City problem. When I talked to child care leaders in other cities, it's something that folks are hearing broadly, and we have been over the past couple of months looking at where the City can leverage our scale and our power as City government to try and address this crisis, because we know that it is really hurting our providers. So that's something we are actively working toward solutions on. Okay. Have you been talking to any providers in particular that would be interested in focusing on providing more affordable rates to child care? At this point, there are very few insurance companies operating in New York City that will insure child care providers. We want to make sure those who are in the business don't leave, but we also do need to look at alternatives to support providers. And again, this is something we see happening all across the country, where the number of insurers who are willing to back child care providers is dwindling. Aren't you? Thank you. Next question. (00:28:37) In family child care homes, business owners often wear multiple hats, as both the early childhood educator and the business operations coordinator. Is the Mayor's Office of Child Care providing any specific trainings for family child care home providers on how to operate a child business as a sole proprietor? For family child care providers who are part of our family child care networks, they do receive access to coaching and support through their network. There are also many, many wonderful organizations operating here in the City that are incredibly skilled at the business of family child care, who work with our family child care educators, and we are in close conversation with many of them about that. As I referenced in the testimony, we are also working with a group of family child care educators who are interested in building a cooperative, which, when stood up, would be a vehicle to really support the participating members with all aspects of running their business. (00:29:39) What services do family child care networks offer to alleviate some of the business administration burden from these home providers? (00:29:47) Family child care networks serve essentially as the intermediary between New York City Public Schools and our family child care providers. So they take on the burden of contracting with the City and all the paperwork that is required in order to be a contractor with the City. They bear the financial risk that comes with that as well, and so in that sense they are essentially providing greater stability for the providers, than they might have if they were working directly with the City. Okay. At this time, right before I turn it over to CM Gutierrez, I'd like to acknowledge that we've been joined by CM Brooks-Powers, Co-Chair. Thank you. (00:30:19) Thank you, Chair. Thank you both for your testimony. I wanted to ask the Mayor's Office of Child Care: I know you referenced in your testimony roughly the amount of providers. Do you have a sense of how many are nonprofit and how many are for-profit? That is not information that the City or State actively collects. Okay. Sorry. What? Oh, can you collect that information? I would have to get back to you on whether we can collect that. The City and State share the responsibility for licensing child care providers in the City. Our providers are licensed by the State, and our center-based child care providers are licensed by the Department of Health. So we have to get back to you on what business information we can collect. Okay. Thank you. Is the Mayor's Office of Child Care concerned about reports of increased interest from private equity in child care? We've heard from folks almost every single hearing testify about that. Yes, that is something we are keeping an eye on. Part of why we've been really excited about structures like this cooperative that we are discussing with child care providers is it's another way of providing business support and strength to providers, and can often also be a model of that support, succession planning. We've been really excited by some of the more innovative business models we've seen popping up in the City. For example, imagine Early Learning, which is the first fully employee-owned child care chain in the City. We are very much keeping an eye on the growth of private equity in child care. We know that the strength of New York City's child care ecosystem is that it is so deeply rooted in community, and we have providers who have been in their communities for decades, and we want to make sure that that small business framework, with those community connections, continues to operate. I think the concern is right. It's just comparatively, a private equity company has more funding for infrastructure. It's really difficult for a home-based provider two blocks away to compete. Are you all thinking through this co-op, and I will ask more about this co-op? Are you all thinking about guardrails around these private equity-backed businesses receiving public funds for child care? We're certainly going to look into that. Okay. (00:30:30) Chair. Thank you, Chair. Thank you both for your testimony. I wanted to ask the Mayor's Office of Child Care. I know you referenced me in your testimony, roughly the amount of providers. Do you have a sense of how many are nonprofit and how many are for profit? That is not information that the city or state actively collects. Okay. Sorry. Um, wait, what? Oh, do you? Can you collect that information? We would have to get back to you on whether we can collect that. The city and state share the responsibility for licensing child care providers in the city. Our providers are licensed by the state, and our center-based child care providers are licensed by the Department of Health. So we have to get back to you on what business information we can collect. Okay. Thank you. Is the Mayor's Office of Child Care, are you all concerned about reports of increased interest from private equity in child care? All we've heard from folks, almost every single hearing, testify about that. Yes, that is something that we are keeping an eye on. Part of why we've been really excited about structures like this cooperative that we are discussing with child care providers is it's another way of providing business support and strength to providers. It can often also be a model that supports succession planning, and we've been really excited by some of the more innovative business models we've seen (00:32:04) popping up in the city, for example. Imagine Early Learning, which is the first fully employee-owned child care chain in the city. We are very much keeping an eye on the growth of private equity in child care. We know that the strength of New York City's child care ecosystem is that it is so deeply rooted in community, and we have providers who have been in their communities for decades. We want to make sure that small business framework that we continue to see, providers with those community connections, keeps operating. I think the concern is right. It's just comparatively, a private equity company has more funding for infrastructure. It's really difficult for a home-based provider two blocks away to compete. Are you all thinking through this co-op? I will ask more about this co-op. Are you all thinking about guardrails around these private equity-backed businesses receiving public funds for child care? We're certainly going to look into that. Okay. (00:33:13) Okay, I wanted to ask about the micro grant program, which I think is great. You referenced it in your remarks. Can you share the current status of this program? Yes. (00:33:25) So we announced a procurement for an administrator to actually run the program, so we are in the final stages of contracting with that administrator. We are also deep in the work of planning for the micro grants program, all of the details of it, and we've had child care providers at the table driving that planning, thinking about questions like what kinds of emergency expenses will be eligible, what scale of grants, and in what ways should priority providers be prioritized as they apply for the funding. We plan to, with the administrator and with our advisory group of providers, launch the program later this year. (00:34:09) Okay. And when would it be? I know that you're in that procurement process. When would it be available for providers, potentially, too? Our goal is to launch the provider-facing part of this program by the end of the year, and then we anticipate making grants on a rolling basis as providers experience emergencies and apply for those funds. Okay. (00:34:32) As the early childhood system expands, not every family will immediately have access to public options, and child care small businesses will continue to play a critical role in providing child care. How will you ensure child care small businesses remain viable as the universal system is set up, so that the City doesn't lose our child care capacity? It is absolutely a priority for us to make sure that child care providers, regardless of their relationship with the City, are able to continue opening, operating, and sustaining their businesses. We want to make it easier for them to open in the first place, which is why we've invested in things like the permitting portal to smooth the pathway to opening. We are also working to streamline the various processes and regulations where multiple agencies are involved, so that providers are not caught in the crosshairs between different agencies and conflicting guidance. So our office plays a role there. We want to make it easier for families to find child care providers through tools like nyc.gov/care, which is a map of every licensed child care program in the City, and tools to help families find their way to those programs. And as we continue to expand access to care, make sure we are prioritizing our community-based child care providers and home-based providers, which is why, with the expansion of 2K, we are working 100% with... (00:35:55) ...with providers. There's no... (00:35:57) 2K in schools. This is a program entirely built in partnership with community-based child care providers and home-based providers. Okay, okay. (00:36:04) Thank you. I'm not sure if my colleague, CM Joseph, remembers. She was talking about the vouchers, but are you aware of any child care business closing due to lack of access, families having access to vouchers? It's a concern we've heard from providers. I don't have any specific examples of closures that have happened because of this. Certainly there are any you're hearing about, either. Yeah, I have one from elsewhere. Yeah, you would love to talk about that, but we know that with... (00:36:31) THE VOUCHER WAITLIST. Obviously, it has placed a huge burden on families, but providers as well, particularly providers operating in lower income communities where families have historically relied on vouchers for care. Yeah, so we know that reopening the waitlist is something that will support families, certainly, but our providers as well. But so, okay. And you haven't heard. I'll make sure (00:36:49) to give you the name of the provider that's so they close because Nichols in okay. Because of the vouchers in the 10,000 or 10,000 plus, I think is amazing, but I think it's not a system that families or even providers really know to depend on year after year, right? It's not something that's funded in the out years. The 10,000 is really just for through the end of this fiscal year, current. Know the 10,000 families who receive vouchers as they come off the waitlist, they will have—haven't seen about your for as long as they remain eligible, which is why we sort of waited to begin taking families off the waitlist until we have that certainty, and we did not want to give families and providers access to care only to then have to take it away. So any family who receives a voucher, so long as they remain eligible, they will be able to maintain that voucher, okay. And then what new families who are adding themselves to the waitlist (00:37:41) Yes, Sam, new families can continue to apply, and I'm sad. Funding to support to get those families off newer families off the waitlist, we're not sure about, and the NY you in the next. Year. So the Child Care Assistance Program, making vouchers is a state-funded program, and so we are able to take families off the waitlist now as we leveraged the funding we received from the governor earlier this year, and certainly that's something we'll continue to talk about with what the state (00:38:08) But there is no, and I'm not trying to take away. I think the 10,000 is great, I think it's worthy of the announcement, but I just want to be clear for New Yorkers who are hearing, like, oh, there's 10,000 vouchers available now. It's 10,000 vouchers really working its way through the waitlist. But if you are having a baby in the new year and you're in need of this voucher, that doesn't mean that there's money for this voucher for you. That's correct. That—I just want to be clear: the 10,000 or more vouchers that we are able to give out at this point, we'll go to the families who have been on the waitlist the longest. So we do expect there will still be families waiting for vouchers, and it's just leveraging with the state for their budget. Yes. (00:38:44) We also want to make sure that, for families who may be waiting for a voucher but also be eligible for other forms of care, whether that's 2K, 3K, pre-K, or any of the city's Head Start and Early Head Start programs that families know about and are taking advantage of, those care options—even if they elect to remain on the waitlist for a voucher—they'll be able to receive other care in the meantime? Yeah. (00:39:09) And is there any conversation with the state about increasing the reimbursement rate for these vouchers? So the voucher reimbursement rate is set by the state through a process called the market rate, and the state has recently issued their market rate survey to child care providers across the city, which is a chance for (00:39:29) providers to inform the state about the cost of providing care. The state will use that data to set the market rate, and they are set to update their market rates in 2027. Thank you. I have a couple more, if we can. We've got a number of members. Okay. In the administration testified that there was going to be a new payment and data management system rolled out by the—for contracted providers. Is that system still on track to be launched by now, the end of the year? They're working on the development of this system called the Early Childhood Management System, or MS, and would really differ from my colleagues at New York City Public Schools. To give an update, which we're happy to provide to you in the subcommittee. Okay. Um, (00:40:15) Thank you. Think you answered (00:40:17) this before? Um, have—besides what you—I think your references in your testimony about the 2% increase, just referencing contracts, the process when these rates were awarded, and of course, I'm referencing the original bid in 2021 when they were awarded, did it include an opportunity to negotiate a reimbursement for fixed costs such as rent or insurance? (00:40:48) So the contract, the rates that providers have in their contracts, which as you said were negotiated for many providers in 2021 when their contracts for first set providers went through a great negotiation process with New York City Public Schools. There was not one single rate. Providers, there is in between those rates, and providers were able to demonstrate, for example, their rent costs as a way of informing their rate. Okay. And is there—it is— (00:41:18) Is that locked in, or is there an opportunity for a provider to ask for higher reimbursement rates, such as increasing rent or labor costs? There are—so providers' rates (00:41:28) are set at the time of the contract and based on a budget that they develop every year. Providers submit an updated budget to New York City Public Schools. If there are providers experiencing some significant shift in costs, we would encourage them to connect with their operations analyst at New York City Public Schools to look at their budget. But there is—and, you know, in some moments where, for example, in 2024, when there was a new labor agreement between 30 and the Daycare Council, providers with staff in the union received increased funding to support that collective bargaining agreement. Okay. Um, (00:42:14) does the current contract only reimburse programs for the minimum legal classroom ratio? (00:42:22) Providers' budgets are set based on the classroom ratios that are dictated by the DOE, which is 18 children and two teachers for pre-K, 15 children and two teachers for 3K, and 12 children, two teachers for 2K. (00:42:39) Okay, so it's only—but it's only, it's for the amount of that that is set across the board, or that set individual, like contract by contract. (00:42:47) That is the standard classroom group size and ratio for all 2K, 3K, and pre-K providers. There are some exceptions, for example, for integrated classrooms where there are children with disabilities learning alongside children without (00:43:05) Okay. Um, I have one more question, and I think you'll hear a lot about this from some of the folks who are testifying, but obviously I want to, once again, raise dignified wages, pay parity, and I know we're rather early, but I want to make sure that folks are encouraged to bring this to your attention. Do you—how will the administration address pay parity and low wages for these early child care workers? (00:43:33) Increasing wages and addressing some of the significant equity issues is absolutely a priority for the administration, and we are looking at ways we can work to address that, and we're going to partner with Council as we think about this in the coming year and years. (00:43:49) Okay. Um, I have one more question, just about networks, and I'll pick it back up after members. But can you just tell me: from the—that was sent out earlier this year, were any new networks established as a result? There were, and it would have to work with my colleagues in the—to the schools to get back to you on the specific numbers. (00:44:10) Okay. Okay, great. Thank you. (00:44:12) Thank you. And now I'll turn it over to counsel. CM Felder for questions. (00:44:20) Thank you. First of all, I wanted to thank you, and thank the administration for giving the attention to this area. To my knowledge, this has been an area that I, you know, has certainly had my attention for quite some time. And at least beginning with the de Blasio administration, we didn't have—I never got a straight answer about, you know, the questions. Through there, like, they are being raised morning, and the answers that have been given. So despite the problems of not being able to get it done, you know, immediately, I think I appreciate at least that they're being addressed. Having said that, the issue of payment to the providers is something that I hear over and over and over again. It's an issue that you inherited, and you need a SWAT team to really address, because I think there are so many providers that, you know, I just haven't been paid for a long time, irrespective of what they should be getting paid. Prospectively, if they haven't gotten paid and they're to pay the rent now and everything else, you know, it is inherently—when you talk about the closures or not closures, whatever it is, it's certainly making it impossible for them. (00:46:12) That's something that I hear repeatedly, and I'm not volunteering to give you a list, because I can if you want one. But there are—I would say, you know, they're not in my district, but I myself, I would say, have heard from about, from about (00:46:33) conservatively, at least 10. Providers that haven't gotten paid for the previous year. Not 20, and I'm not talking (00:46:43) about 25. Ending, they still haven't gotten paid for (00:46:47) previous year, and it's not as though somebody has said information that, in fact, one of them showed me the email with a compliment. You know, some sort of saying thank you very much for providing all the information needed, and they're still waiting for the money. So I'm not, again, I as the purpose is not to blame you, although I would love to, because that's a lot juicier than asking the question. But the fact is that, you know, I mean? And again, it's not something that started under this administration, and this administration, in effect, has a minimum—I would say at a minimum eight years. I think more like 12 years or something like that. So, that's the question. Are you aware of this problem? I'm sure you're aware of this, and I'm just would like to know whether there is anything—you had mentioned additional money or additional staff. You talked about additional staff, but in the end, then a different problem. Has additional staff been, you know, set aside or hired or whatever else to deal with providers getting paid? (00:48:21) Thank you so much, Council Member. First, I would say, do give us that list. If you have providers who told you they have not been paid, please do share that with our office, and we will follow up immediately with the relevant agencies to make sure that they have that—that is right away. Um, some of the staff I referenced in testimony, the new staff lines that have been funded at New York City Public Schools, all of which are currently in the hiring process right now, or who have already been hired on, many of those staff directly support operations and work closely with providers on things like invoicing and payment. And really, our goal in bolstering staff capacity is to make sure that we don't just accept that because payment has always been a slow process. It needs to continue to be one, and we want to make sure that folks are being (00:49:13) compensated for the work they are doing. And I know that there are also providers, including I know folks who are here to testify today who have concerns about the payment timelines for vouchers, which is something our colleagues at the Administration for Children's Services are, um, looking at really carefully and closely as well. Thank you. (00:49:36) CM Bureau. Thank you. (00:49:37) Very much, very articulate answers. I have a couple questions. First of all, what are you learning at three—kind of disparate question. What are you learning for One Centre Street, if anything? The second question is, with all of this great news, what kind of evaluation has been done to see if families are staying in New York? Obviously it's too early, but you've got to get started. The way evaluation works, because you start at the beginning. If you start in the middle, it's not good evaluation. Someone know if that's happening? And then third, for—you know how many folks you are working with, how many child businesses are existing in the private sector? And there's one that I'm really interested in, which is the 24-hour care for the folks at the airport and people who have lots of different kinds of jobs. So that's just the beginning of questions. Thank you so much. (00:50:33) So first, on One Centre Street, the Little Apple, which started earlier this year and is now serving about 40 children, employees of municipal staff who work at One Centre Street or elsewhere in the—as part of the—the facilities. It's gorgeous. I highly recommend it. It's a great way to brighten your day if you've not been there. And I think the feedback we're hearing from folks who have access to that is that it's been really wonderful. (00:51:02) So there—it is completely free for the employees, and it is child care for kids under three. Okay. Until the cost is something that would be replicable to others. (00:51:14) Under three, also basically. So it's a model. It's the first. It's sort of the first of its kind, and it's something we're looking at closely to see the impact it has on city workers and whether it's a model that could be replicated ultimately. Okay. Um, to your question? (00:51:28) Yeah, yeah. The biggest, yet next one is about evaluating? Yes. (00:51:33) So this is something very top of mind for us. I mean, as you referenced, in terms of families leaving the city, part of the reason why child care is such a focus for this administration is because we see that families with children under six are twice as likely to leave the city as other households. (00:51:49) Yes. Um, so we are working with a number of different outside research institutions (00:51:55) who are all interested in studying the effects of our investments on child care in New York. Are they going to do it, or are they getting funded to do it, or where there are a couple of institutions that have outside funding to do this? We are also within the city working with the Economic Development Corporation and others to look at and monitor the effects of our investments. There are a few external research reports that we know. I prefer external—I prefer external. Okay. We're doing both, and in the Mayor's Office of Child Care, we are really working to coordinate with all of the outside researchers who are studying this, to make sure that all the questions we have are being answered, and we'd be happy to share more about our nascent research agenda with you. (00:52:38) Then just 24-hour care, who's doing— (00:52:41) So right now, that is a big gap. We know that there are families who, because of their work schedules, need that kind of care. We know that there are not very many providers in the city who offer it. Those who do tend to be our family child care providers, because that's a model that is flexible. We're able to meet those needs for families. It's something we need to spend more time and energy on, for sure. Okay. Thank you. (00:53:06) Thank you. CM Santos also. (00:53:10) Thank you. Both chairs, and I want to turn to this, what I think is a really interesting idea about the cooperative, and ask you if there's any discussion on contemplating that model to solve the insurance problem. (00:53:28) Um, first I'd say, I think we know the insurance problem impacts every provider in the city, regardless of their scale. So it's something we're looking at across the whole sector. I think we see a child care cooperative as potentially serving many functions, but one of them would be sort of shared buying power and shared (00:53:44) services. How would that work? Would that work in conjunction with the centers, or do you see it solving different problems? And I should say, I think cooperatives are a structure that we know are being looked at across the sectors in New York City, so not just specific to child care, but it's a topic that's really on folks' minds in terms of how do we support small businesses. And we are specifically working with a group of home-based providers who are looking at this model and whether it could apply, particularly to support family child care. Okay, I'm (00:54:17) Turning to the two-K rollout. I think, if I remember correctly, I don't know if it was at the press conference or if it was one of these hearings, you were asked about the distribution of seats and how it would work, and I think your answer... I don't want to misrepresent you, but I think your answer was many providers in each neighborhood, or in each district, actually sign up and are interested in being part of the program, and that is a big part of that. So when looking at how many two-K slots should be essentially assigned to each of the districts, we'll have to look at how many two-year-olds there are. Right. So your district has a whole lot of two-year-olds versus some of our other districts that we are reaching next year, which are just geographically much smaller, and so we will look at anticipated demand. So we look at how many two-year-olds are in each community. We look at historic patterns of three-K and pre-K enrollment and other population factors, just to assess how many kids there are. And then we are also looking at provider capacity. Right now we have our seat survey, and it is available to providers to assess interest in offering two-K services. We are also looking closely at what other care exists in communities for two-year-olds. For example, we have many Early Head Start and Head Start providers across the city, and they provide incredible care to some of our lowest-income families, so we want to make sure that we are not cannibalizing services but making sure that we are offering enough care in every community to serve two-year-olds who could use it. (00:55:53) Okay, and so for the two-K rollout: if I were a home-based provider who was interested in being part of the two-K rollout, and it is going to be in one of the eligible districts, how would I know which of the networks the city contracts with? If I wanted to express interest in being part of this? (00:56:13) Well, I am happy to say, and we can share right after this hearing with all of you, we just posted a new fact sheet for family child care providers. If you are interested in two-K, what next? Okay, which does go through all of the different resources that providers have and the process by which they can identify networks that cover their area. Okay, great. And I know we already had the hearing on the dual language learners and the language capacity of some of these providers and the program more broadly. If I were, if I were someone who ran a home-based... if I were a home-based provider, and it was dual language, and I wanted (00:56:55) to be able to reach, you know, materials or outreach, or speak with someone in my native language, is that something I would be able to do as part of expressing my desire to be part of this program and this rollout? (00:57:08) Yes. Our networks broadly have multilingual staff, and based on the communities they operate in, the providers they work with... do you have staff who speak many different languages? We will also, New York City Public Schools will be hosting meet-and-greet sessions for networks and providers, which is something they did in the spring, and those sessions all will have translation support. (00:57:31) That's great. And, for if there were very nascent, early-stage providers, particularly home-based providers, I'm thinking largely of immigrant communities, language communities that wanted to get on, in this process of getting themselves ready to become a part of this eventual program, what could they do? What services could be provided for them? (00:57:55) For them, I think, Council Member. The vast majority, almost every single service that we offer through the General Business Services, they are all accessible to sole-proprietor home-based providers, to center-based providers, and all of them remain open. What we are really excited about, in this calendar year, with the mayor, is the expansion of our Business Express service team. And as we speak today, the new staff are getting trained on Department of Health licensing regulations related to child care. So the work is only expanding with the expansion we saw this year in the adopted budget. (00:58:28) Point taken. Could I ask one more question here? It's sort of a dual question about SUVs and child care, and this is half-baked, so bear with me. But you know the program, that is the sort of contractor fund where private equity loans are used to cover back payments for some city-based contracts. Do you know what I'm talking about? (00:58:41) So we run a contract financing loan fund for city contractors who want up-front money to get started on the work they would like to conduct. It is capped at 3% interest rates, so it is very competitive compared to market-rate interest rates, and it is a revolving fund that we operate in conjunction with the Economic Development (00:59:15) Corporation. Is there a world where a model of something like that could help, which could work to solve some of the problems that we are facing with late payments and non-payments in the child care sector for our child care providers? We saw this earlier this summer, as folks were going through the contracting process. Our child care providers are all eligible for interest-free bridge loans that are offered through a partnership between the Mayor's Office of Contract Services and the Fund for the City of New York. That fund is typically for nonprofits, but all of our child care providers are eligible for that. (00:59:51) But they won't. And I know this because of personal experience dealing with some of this in my district: they won't be eligible for a bridge loan if they are being held up by permitting issues that originate with OHH. So if the permit is still... and this is with not new providers, but those that are going through some kind of renewal, or there is a change in something, an entity name. But if they are stuck in the DOH part of that because they don't have the active permit, they can't get funds from, and therefore they still can't get paid. You see what I'm talking about? (01:00:25) Yes. There are... as we have been working with providers, we have been able to help and support folks to resolve issues that were holding them up from getting a contract moving forward. So we continue to work through these one by one. If there are specific providers in your district who are still caught in this loop, please let us know, and we can follow up on the particular cases. Okay. Thank you. (01:00:48) Thank you, Councilman Moran. (01:00:53) Thank you. Cheers. Thank you (01:00:54) both for your testimony, your testimony about the $43 million investment to overhaul the city's early childhood education operations, particularly the commitment to accelerate contract registration and prevent payment delays. A couple of my colleagues have alluded to this already, but according to the Independent Budget Office, the average early childhood education contract went from being registered 83 days after its start date in fiscal 2021 to 247 days after its start date in fiscal 2024. And again, I'm not blaming this history here, but that's eight months. When the city doesn't pay a child care provider on time, that provider still has to pay the rent, they still have to pay employees, they still have to buy supplies. If a child care provider has to borrow money because the city hasn't paid what it owes them, does the city reimburse that provider for the interest on the loan? (01:02:03) So first, I want to say that we have... we have this, as you said, not just in the most recent period, but over many, many years. Decades of a sort of acceptance that it is okay to pay providers late, and that is something that we fundamentally want to change. We do not believe that represents the way the city should partner with child care providers. (01:02:27) Particularly given the time period you referenced, where we saw contracting and payment timelines protract. We saw a disinvestment in our early childhood infrastructure under the last administration, nearly halving the staff who support activities like (01:02:45) contracting and payment, and that really drove a lot of the delays that we saw. We are continuing to see some of the impact of that. The investment you referenced, which this administration is making, is really targeted at addressing that, at making sure that we have the staff, resourcing, and support to pay providers on a timely basis. When a contractor, a child care provider, has their contract registration delayed, they are eligible for interest-free bridge loans, and we really try to steer all contractors toward those loans, because there is no additional cost they have to bear to take those out. If a provider takes out a loan on their own, we are continuing to look into whether there are resources to support folks, but that is not typically part of the reimbursable expenses. So the city is effectively making a small business pay for the city's own inefficiency, right? So of that $43 million that you're investing in reforms, how much is specifically dedicated to making sure providers get paid on time, and what measurable reduction in payment delays are you expecting? (01:03:55) I can get back to you on the exact breakdown of how many staff are assigned to payment and contracting, but it is a meaningful number of the new staff who are being invested in. There are also systems reforms. CM Gutiérrez referenced the new data management system that the Department of Education is rolling out, so there are a number of investments specifically targeted, and we will look at things like contract payment timelines, how long from the time of invoicing to the time of payment. We do see that the process has improved meaningfully over the last number of years, from the time a provider submits a fully complete invoice to the time it is paid. But certainly this year, we saw that there is still much more we need to do on contracting. As a step, I'm not going to ask you any difficult questions. So. (01:04:46) I appreciated your acknowledgement that the city's regulatory landscape can make life very difficult for child care business owners. (01:04:57) You also mentioned the administration's Open for Small Business reform agenda, which includes more than 50 reforms, and specifically focused on child care. Here's what I'd like to know: has the city calculated how much money those child care reforms will actually save an individual child care provider? The reforms include publishing a plain-language guide, expanding the child care permitting portal, upgrading the background check request portal that is necessary for child care operators, as well as in the Office of Child Care, but at the Department of Health. (01:05:37) So some of them are structural investments in the city's infrastructure, and some of them are resources for the business community. We would have to work with the relevant agencies to determine if they've done the analysis of the cost savings. Looked forward to seeing next. (01:05:51) The reason I ask is because I think there's a real possibility we're spending taxpayer money subsidizing child care expenses that government bureaucracy helped create in the first place. But one more quick (01:06:05) question. Thank you too, Ms. Lists. I want to raise something that doesn't get nearly enough attention. Your testimony talks about the expansion of the child care, including additional two-K opportunities, but the committee report points out an unintended consequence of these government-funded pre-K programs: older children are generally less (01:06:29) expensive to care for, and the revenue from those children helps providers subsidize the more expensive infant and toddler care. When those older children move into publicly funded programs, the cost of infant care can actually go up. So before expanding government-funded child care into a neighborhood, (01:06:53) does the administration conduct any economic impact analysis on existing private child care businesses? So this is an unintended consequence that. (01:07:03) You know, we're very aware of it, and I think certainly we saw it play out in the city's expansion of pre-K, and it's something we are keeping very closely in mind as we design our continued expansion. So first, as we roll out two-K, we are not placing any two-K seats in public school buildings. We are only working with child care providers in communities, to make sure that they are able to maintain the care that they provide to toddlers, and that we are not creating any sort of unintended effect of families moving out of community child care settings. We also saw there was an unintended impact here, particularly on our family child care providers with the rollout of pre-K, because they were not at scale eligible to offer pre-K, which is tied to some state regulations, but it is certainly a consequence we saw at the city level. That is why we have been really intentionally focused on making sure that family child care providers have a seat at the table as we roll out two-K. I think we want to be very careful in this set of expansions to balance the urgency that families have and the desperate need families have for affordable or free care, but we need to make sure our providers remain sustainable. Thanks. (01:08:18) Very much. Thank you, sir. Thank you. I'd like to (01:08:23) acknowledge we've been joined by a council member. Um, I want to kind of piggyback on my colleague's question as regards to starting (01:08:33) universal child care essentially, because as a... in daycare at six weeks old, so from six weeks old to two years old, literally the cost of daycare is roughly, on the low end, $1,000 a month, roughly on the low end. So have you guys looked at, or run across analysis from, kind of going back to your point, council members... so right now we know what it costs to basically pay for a child from three years old, and in some instances two years old, through twelfth grade. (01:09:10) You know, what vouchers you are paying for now. Has there been a cost analysis to (01:09:15) determine what it would actually cost the city to take that six-week-old through twelfth grade, versus fighting the state every year for more money for vouchers and the like? Has that been done? So part of why we are, what we are ultimately building toward, is a fully publicly funded system that would care for all children, or provide for the care of children starting as young as six weeks. Because, as you said, the costs are unbearable for families, and we believe that child care is, and should be, treated as a public good and funded that way from the earliest age. Families need to take advantage of care, and we have some internal assessment of costs. That's something we're continuing to look at and to discuss with the state, and we think about what the true pathway to universal child (01:10:04) care would be. I don't have a specific figure to give you right now, but it's something that we have been closely looking at and measuring. But it seems like, literally, my head is about to explode. (01:10:15) Okay. From all the different nuances to how cost per child... this for that, and that and this? Yes, we have a number of... we're making a simple math problem in my mind way more complicated than it needs to be. (01:10:31) A mess, and it could be me. I could be wrong. But would it really be possible to see how we could simplify that? Because a lot of our parents are depending on that, and as you can imagine, as my colleague reminded me, a thousand dollars per month per child is the low end? (01:10:48) Absolutely. It. (01:10:48) I wanted to ask the question in regard to the bridge loans: which entity or entities are you currently working with for that bridge loan program, and how do child care providers get access to it? So that is a program available to providers who have a contract with the city, particularly providers who contracted with New York City Public Schools, and it was specifically available to cover the period before a provider's contract has been registered, so providers can work directly with New York City Public Schools to submit an application. That loan fund is managed by the Fund for the City of New York. So, not to belabor the point, but (01:11:23) we've heard time and time again that the city is late and it's causing a lot of programs to close. I literally got a phone call yesterday where some teachers aren't able to get paid because they're waiting on money from the city, and some of these entities have been in business for 20, 30 plus years. What is causing these bad loops? It seems like at this point in time, it should be like riding a bike. (01:11:51) Yeah. So again, first, if you're getting a call like that from a provider, please feel free to flag that for our office right away, and we can look into the particular situation. You know, we saw earlier in the summer that there was a delay in contract registration, as the city was renewing over a thousand early childhood contracts. That is not a process that happens every year, but it is a process that we had to go through this year, and we saw the legacy of this historic disinvestment in our early childhood system. We did not have sufficient staff capacity to address it, and that was part of what drove the process. We worked quickly to address it by more than tripling the number of people who were working on contract registration, working to make sure providers were aware of bridge loans and other supports to ensure they had what they needed, and to move through that process as quickly as we could. Got it. Um, for... offer any (01:12:51) Type of funding solution, separate and aside from the bridge loan program, too. Child care providers, when there is this backlog or absence of payment from the City. (01:13:03) Thank you. Sure. Thomas-Henry. So, we have the contract financing loan fund. But as I mentioned, there's the Mayor's Fund, and the Mayor's Office of Contract Services has an even more generous program, and it doesn't have an interest rate associated with it. The contract financing loan fund is one that has a 3% interest rate. Then also for us, through My City Business website, it indicates that we can help a business with hiring a team, and potential employers can request recruitment services. Is this different from the Workforce1 centers? (01:13:14) This is so. We have a system that is pretty integrated, in that if we're helping a business owner and a business owner indicates recruitment assistance, we would then connect them with our Workforce1 center closest to them. We ensure that we have more clarity on the types of roles that are hiring, so that we can find them qualified candidates across the City. Do you have an idea of how many child care positions are connected through Workforce1 centers? We can try to find that for you, Council Member. We have definitely served child care providers who have looked for support in hiring staff. If I don't have it on me, I'll get back to you with that. (01:13:40) Okay. I've also found that a lot of child care providers or child care entities often work with NYC Youth, do you track that as well, in terms of placement with Summer Youth Employment and where they're placed in child care facilities? (01:14:18) We can certainly follow up with our colleagues at DYCD and come back to you with that data. But we do know that many youth are in child care programs through that, and that's a great experience for both the youth and for the child care programs. Okay. (01:14:19) I've heard from a few people that the expense of insurance does direct people to a particular resource for selecting insurance for their child care business. Is that the case at all? (01:14:36) So, sure. We don't direct businesses to particular for-profit businesses for any professional service that they're looking for, including insurance. But we have definitely heard, really clearly, across the business community, especially the small business community, and something that Executive Director Liz mentioned is also prevalent in the child care industry, where the cost of insurance is skyrocketing. In ways, that is making it really difficult for folks to operate their businesses. I didn't have the number on Job Seekers, but roughly 50 job seekers in the child care sector. As we proceed with the Universal Child Care expansion, we love to serve. We have 18 centers located all across the five boroughs, and not too far away from neighborhoods. So please do reach out to us if you know of any providers that are looking to staff up. We're definitely interested in helping them. (01:14:36) Is that 50 people looking for jobs that have come through a Workforce1 site this year? (01:14:50) Or no, 50 placements. 50 placements, hundreds of New Yorkers. But it's 50 actual placements. Again, it's hard for us to require that the employers hire the individual. What we do is job matching, making sure that the business owner gets, and the providers get, qualified candidates that meet their needs. Would a home-based provider be eligible for the Commercial Lease Assistance Program? (01:15:05) A home-based provider looking to start child care? Yes, a home-based child care provider looking to negotiate a commercial lease. So if they're looking to move into a storefront, either to be a child care provider or for other types of business activities, they would definitely be eligible for Commercial Lease Assistance. (01:15:53) Oh, and we have definitely helped child care providers in accessing commercial lease assistance. I think the idea is, if I have a one-family home, and I dedicate half of that home strictly for child care, would that business be eligible for the lease program, or does it have to be an actual physical storefront? (01:16:02) It would have to be a commercial lease. It's not a residential lease. The laws are on residential leases. There's a lot of difference in the protections that the City and State have for residential leases as opposed to commercial leases. Okay. (01:16:24) Now, private equity has become a growing presence in the child care ecosystem, specifically large-scale firms, and small business child care providers are more likely to exit the child care market. What, if anything, has the administration been doing to ensure that small businesses are not pushed out of the market, especially by private equity? (01:16:43) I will start an open path to our Executive Director. But we do know that one of the pain points that businesses have, two major pain points that businesses have across the City, most common industries, including the care economy: one would be financing, just having the resources to expand and grow capital. And then second would be navigating the maze of regulations, and with this particular industry, we all have acknowledged at this hearing that there are more regulations than many other industries. To that end, our Financing Assistance team works to connect any New York entrepreneur to a set of affordable lending options. We mostly partner with CDFIs, Community Development Financial Institutions, that are not-for-profits, mission-driven, trying to help small businesses succeed in the City. Then we also have our Business Express Service team, the team that you met on October 2, that was their first day in office. The Mayor's Office, today was the day where they were trained on all of our major enforcement agencies and the rules and regulations associated. Today was the day where they were getting trained on child care as well. (01:16:45) Should have bought them down, anything to add to their training? I know. We just reiterate that, as we continue to expand publicly funded care in the City, our priority is making sure we are partnering with our community-based child care providers and small family child care providers, who are the backbones of their communities. We are really focused on making sure that as we are expanding public funding opportunities, we are working very closely with those providers. How are you currently tracking the number of those small providers that are opening and closing? Any child care provider who opens has to have a license or a permit. For family child care providers, that comes through the State Office of Children and Family Services. For center-based child care providers, that comes through the Department of Health. Both of those respective agencies are looking at some closures, and our office partners with both of them. But is that data reported in some centralized way so that you can easily...? It's not data that I have in front of me today, but it's something that we are trying to look at more systematically, and would be happy to share with the Council as we look at that data. (01:17:03) Look at that data at all to track the number of small businesses that are essentially opening and closing in the child care sector? (01:17:18) Just across the board, across industries, we look at that. We know that for home-based providers we don't have the kind of data sets that other agencies would have, but on storefront activations and closures, that's something we're looking at very closely across the City. Got it. I now turn it over to Council Member. Thank you, and thank you, Chair. For a few questions about closures, I'm curious if, in collecting the data, you are also, I guess, I know that you have readily available data. Totally fine, but just curious: when these providers have to close, where they are, I'm just talking about center-based primarily, that are more visible. Are you made aware, does the Mayor's Office get made aware, when they're closing? (01:17:39) Like, is there a systematic reason, or like, is it Council Members calling you frantically saying the center is closing? (01:18:42) There is no systematic mechanism. We hear from community members, we hear from elected officials, we hear from providers directly sometimes, but there is no systematic way that we are notified if a provider closes. That's an independent business decision they're making. We find out about it before, or after. And what about if they are contracted with the City and still closing? If they are contracted with the City, then that's something they discuss directly with New York City Public Schools, and we are notified when. (01:18:47) Have you heard of any instances where center-based providers contracted with the City are closing, or for any late payments, or any like, are you made aware of the reason why they're closing? And certainly, any time a provider comes forward and says that they have some operational concern and that it might lead them to close their doors, New York City Public Schools, or our office in any case, we will often try to support and see if there's a way we can support that provider. Not that I'm aware of, we have had any program closures because of payment issues in the last couple of months. And then my last question on closures: I know that some of the 3-K and Pre-K sites are in churches, for example, that takes a little bit of work through, maybe the diocese, I'm not sure. But in my district, the number of the Catholic schools that are closed and others, charter schools in those sites, many of the Catholic schools that had a 3-K or Pre-K program. Are you made aware of when that closure happens? Are you, as the administration, expanding because of it? So if there is a program closure in a community, we do look every year at what the capacity for Pre-K and 3-K is, not just in the community. With the seat survey that we have open right now to existing providers, we do ask about providers' interest in expanding their capacity. And certainly, we see in a community that there's been some shift. We will work to try and address if we suddenly have a large number of families who previously had access to care and no longer have access to care. And when an independent school chooses to close, there are many ways we might find out about that, whether that's because they tell us directly, or because we hear about it from the community. But we are constantly trying to assess what the need is in a community. And if there is a contracted provider who closes, certainly that's something New York City Public Schools would be able to factor into their planning. Is there a certain amount of time that they're required to alert if they're contracted with the City, and then the parents? I would have to get back to you on that. Okay. Okay. Okay, great. (01:19:55) I just want a couple more questions on the child provider permitting tool. Will the tool be available for permit renewals? And then, you're, yes, that's something we're actively working on. Okay. And I'm sorry, I missed, is this tool available now? Yes. So this is the tool we demoed for the subcommittee back in, and it is available for any center-based provider looking to newly open in the City. And we are working to add renewals for center-based providers into this program as well. (01:20:02) Okay. And do you have a sense of when you'll be able to integrate the rules? That development work is underway. We can provide the subcommittee with an update. Okay. (01:20:20) Next, I just had questions on some of the operational costs. AMMI, in their recent report on the true cost of the programming by UNH, highlighted food costs, especially for standard day care programs, as an issue, because federal funding through CACFP only covers income-eligible children. Has the administration considered supplementing this funding? As we look at future contract rates, we will look at things like the cost of food and how to address that in contract costs. We do know that providers are facing rising costs, which is why the administration invested $40 million this year to make that 2% increase in center-based contract rates. We know that's just a first step, and there's more that providers need. Okay. And... (01:20:25) In the same report, it highlighted that providers could use more coaching and training support. Is that something the administration has also considered increasing funding for? (01:20:52) The administration, as we look ahead to future procurements and future rate setting, we will look at all of the different cost categories that providers face. We also have New York City Public Schools providing significant coaching and support to programs. We have a team of instructional coordinators, as well as a team of social workers and inclusion specialists who go out and directly support programs. That's capacity we've continued to build up and grow to make sure that we are able to support all programs as the contracted capacity grows. Okay. (01:21:00) And then my last questions for you. We're just getting to the co-op you mentioned. I know this is in the beginning stages. So, is it? You said it's primarily home-based providers that are coming together for it? Yes, there's a group of home-based providers who are coming together to do some sort of exploratory work and planning for a co-op. Okay. And is this... these are, I'm assuming, these are home providers and not in a network, or a mixture? I believe it's a mixture. (01:21:33) Okay. As you know, and I always raise the deep concern that I have for continuing to expand this program without these independent business owners at the table. I'm curious if there is anything more that you can tell us right now. If I am someone who is looking to start my own home-based child care center, in a space in my home, but I don't want to be a part of a network today, do I have the support of the administration to still be able to thrive in a two-to-three-seat space? If I'm in District 32, for example, in Bushwick, that is getting too many seats, which is a great thing. But if I'm not already in the system, how can I still be successful? How can I still be a successful business owner? How can I do that in this climate? What are some of the things that you are all thinking about? I know early on, to kind of integrate these people, so these businesses don't have to close down. These primarily women don't have to figure out another career option. I'm very concerned for them. Yeah, I mean, we absolutely do not want our home-based child care providers to close. We know how important these providers are to the families they serve, and we know what their businesses mean to their communities, and we want to make sure that they can continue to thrive. I'm excited to come to Bushwick to sit with home-based providers with you, hopefully in the coming weeks, and we've been meeting very regularly with home-based providers across the City, and continuing to talk with folks about the concerns they have about what they need in order to be successful, and to really take their feedback to how we can continue to improve the structures and systems we have, including the networks, to make it a more appealing prospect, make it something that can really deliver for our providers. There are many providers who are serving families without vouchers, serving families who pay privately, and also working with the... We want to continue to support all of those pathways for our providers. Okay. Thank you, Emme. Thank you, George, for joining me. (01:22:12) Yes, thank you. A few more questions. Earlier this year, that law is intended to coordinate inspections for specific businesses, especially businesses within the child care industry. Has there been any updates on implementation of this bill from the Mayor's Office, and if so, are there any specifics that you can give in regards to how the program will operate? Thank you. (01:22:25) You. So the bill goes into effect in... of 2027. So we have four months until the effective date. We're currently scoping that. We would see from health care providers, and so that's where we're occurring yet, but we're excited for the expansion of our best demon. Today was the day that they were trained on child care. Also looking forward to this work. Give me one second. Do any child care providers have been assisted through the Commercial Lease Assistance Program? If so, how many, and what issues were addressed specifically? (01:22:35) So, Commercial Lease Assistance Program, since it's a legal service, there is some attorney-client privilege applied to some of those interactions, so we do not know fully the extent and the depth of the service-related issues that the child care providers raised. But we do know that child care providers have used that service, as well as other small businesses, since the pandemic. It's at least 35 businesses that we know have used the Commercial Lease Assistance Program. (01:23:47) You said 30, 35, 35 that have used the full legal services program focused on commercial lease. We know that with the expansion, this administration is looking to serve a lot more. (01:24:00) And that's 35. When? Since the beginning of the program, which was around the pandemic. Okay. And as... conduct any outreach specifically targeting child care providers, and what type of materials are shared with those providers during that outreach? (01:24:24) [index 32 not present in source] (01:24:35) [index 33 not present in source] (01:25:35) They, in the same report highlighted, and it is like the fact that providers could use more coaching and training for support, is that something that the administration has also considered increasing funding for, and so (01:25:48) The administration. As we look ahead to future procurements and future rate setting, we will look at all of the different cost categories that providers face. We do also. New York City Public Schools provide significant coaching and support to programs. So we have a team of instructional coordinators as well as a team of social workers and inclusion specialists who all go out and directly support programs. That is capacity we have continued to build and grow to make sure that we are able to support all programs as the contracted capacity grows. Okay. (01:26:24) And then my last questions for you. I mean, we are just tied to the co-op you mentioned. I know this is in the beginning stages. So is it? You said it is primarily home-based providers that are coming together for it. Yes, there is a group of home-based providers who are coming together to do some sort of exploratory work and planning for a co-op. Okay. And is this? (01:26:45) These are, I am assuming, these are home providers and not in a network or a mixture. I believe it is a mixture. (01:26:51) Okay. As you know, I (01:26:53) always raise the deep concern that I have for continuing to expand this program without these independent business owners at the table. (01:27:02) I am curious if there is any anymore (01:27:09) Is there anything more that (01:27:09) you can tell us right now if I am someone who is looking to (01:27:11) start my own home-based childcare center, which is a space in my home, but I do not want to be a part of a network? Today, August 2026, do I have the support of the administration to still be able to thrive in a two-to-space if I am in District 32, for example, in Bushwick, that is getting too seats, which is a great thing? But if I am not already in the system, how can I still be successful? How can I still be a successful business owner? How can I do that in this climate? Like, what are some of the things that you are all thinking about? I know early on to kind of integrate these people, so these businesses do not have to close down. So these, primarily women, do not have to look, do not have to kind of figure out another career option. I am very concerned for them. Yeah, I mean, we (01:27:59) absolutely do not want our home-based childcare providers to close. We know how important these providers are to the families they serve, and we know what their businesses mean to their communities, and we want to make sure that they can continue to thrive. I am excited to come to Bushwick to sit with home-based providers with you, hopefully in the coming weeks, and we have been since meeting very regularly with home-based providers across the city and continuing to talk with folks about the concerns they have about what they need in order to be successful, and to really take their feedback to how we can continue to improve the structures and systems we have, including the networks, to make it a more appealing prospect, make it something that can really deliver for our providers. There are many providers who are serving families without vouchers, serving families who pay privately, and also working with the, we want to continue to support all of those pathways for our providers. Okay. (01:29:00) Thank you, Emme. Thank you, George, for joining (01:29:02) me. Yes, thank you. A few more questions for, earlier this year, that law is intended to coordinate inspections for specific businesses, especially businesses within the childcare industry. (01:29:15) Has there been any updates on implementation of this bill from the mayor's office, and if so, are there any specifics that you can give in regards to how the program will operate? Thank you. (01:29:34) You. So the bill goes into effect in 2027. So we have four months until the effective date. We are currently scoping that we would see from healthcare providers, and that is where we are occurring yet, but we are excited for the expansion of our best demand. Today was the day that they were trained on childcare. Also looking forward to this work. We will give me one second. Do we have any childcare providers been assisted through the commercial lease program, assistance program? If so, how many, and what issues were addressed specifically? (01:30:22) Um, so are commercially (01:30:25) assistance program since it is a legal service? There is some attorney-client privilege applied to some of those interactions, so we do not know fully the extent and the depth of the service-related issues that the childcare providers raised, but we do know that childcare providers have used that service, as of other small businesses since the pandemic. It is at least 35 businesses that we know have used the commercial lease assistance program. You said 30, 35, 35 that have used the full legal services program focused on commercial lease. We know that with the expansion, but this administration is leading. We are looking forward to serving a lot more. (01:31:04) And that is 35. When? Since the beginning of the program, which was around the pandemic. Okay. And as SB (01:31:12) conduct any outreach specifically targeting childcare providers, and what type of materials are shared with those providers during that outreach? (01:31:18) Materials are shared with those providers during that outreach. (01:31:20) So we conduct ground outreach. Even as you're aware, October 1, when we did September 1, when we did the Business Owner Bill of Rights outreach, or the street vendor outreach that we've done in your district, when we go out, we're serving all types of small businesses, including street vendors, door-friend businesses, entrepreneurs, New Yorkers that show up to our tables and are mobile outreach unit to get connected with entrepreneurship services, even if they don't currently own a business. So our outreach work is one where we're focused on reaching neighborhoods that are far away from our business solution centers and even around their business solution centers. It's not one where we're targeting specific industries. We're trying to make sure the broad variety of New York's businesses and entrepreneurs are able to take advantage of these services, because most of our services are not limited to a particular industry. Any New Yorker could benefit from that. An entrepreneur could benefit from financing assistance, understanding what the affordable lending options on the market are. Could benefit from some licensing and permitting support. We're proud to help childcare providers and other businesses understand the rules and regulations and permitting that they would have to navigate, and that's the type of support we provide across the (01:32:35) Ecosystem. Do you currently track, like, the number of, say, restaurants versus child care and all the other industries, the different services that they provide to each? (01:32:48) Yes. It really varies depending on the service that we're providing. So we'll have disaggregated data for the deeper services, such as the Commercial Lease Assistance Program. We won't have that for some levels of our business consultation or networking events or workshops that we organize, where we just wanted to make sure that they take advantage of the educational materials, and wouldn't want to create another wall where they have to go through an intake process before they get served. At this time, I want to ask (01:33:16) Shauna Castillo to join the panel. (01:33:24) I have a couple of questions as relates to my shed and the like. Um, how many businesses has or best work with that are part of the Business Pathways program, or our business, or our businesses owned by NYCHA residents? Thank you. (01:33:43) So, we will... the number of businesses that operate within the ZIP codes that have the most NYCHA developments where we do services. We have an incredibly strong working relationship and coordination with NYCHA's team, that Vice President Bacile runs, and our work is one where, through our best team and through all of our services, we're not necessarily tracking the residency of the New Yorker that we're serving, but we're tracking the business location. So it's hard to know if the New Yorker that we're serving is one who lives in public housing. But we are tracking the addresses of the businesses that we're helping, and so where they're located. (01:34:27) Is something that we do see, and it's around 4,000 businesses just this last fiscal year around public housing. Okay. (01:34:38) In what capacity has NYCHA provided any services to the Business Pathways program? (01:35:21) So the program was started in 2014, and at that time it was grant funded, and NYCHA worked together in delivering, administering, developing the program around the time of the pandemic. When grant funding expired, that's when NYCHA took over administration of the program, but we still coordinate as needed on the program, just as we do with all other sister agencies when they run programs related to business activation. How many NYCHA residents are in the Business Pathways program, and how many NYCHA entrepreneurs were assisted through this program this year? (01:35:34) Good afternoon, Sharon. Thank you for the question. Since 2014, we have had 365 graduates from our food business pathways program, since 2015, 49 graduates from child business pathways. This year we are administering one cohort of childcare business pathways that will enroll 25 residents. Are there any other programs aside from the food-based business and the child care provider through the program, the Business Pathways program, or currently provided through Business Pathways? But we are a resource for NYCHA residents that are interested in entrepreneurship and other sectors. So, for example, we host a monthly residents business development orientation, where we invite speakers and partners out that can engage with residents. And we do have a network of referral partners, including that we can refer residents, too, if they have a business interest or need outside of the two sectors that we currently serve under the Business Pathways program. We have a team that will flyer in NYCHA communities, and will also table at NYCHA-based events, and also external events. We have a biweekly newsletter that goes out to all NYCHA residents that have provided NYCHA with an email address, and we'll also lean on our community communications team for social media content. We know that word of mouth and really hearing real testimonies makes a world of difference, and so we leverage our digital newsletter, or NYCHA Journal, to make sure that we're working closely with the comms team and producing a variety of success stories every month for NYCHA residents that also then link to how they can learn more about the program. (01:37:43) Featured, and of all the NYCHA developments singing throughout the City of New York, what percentage of those actually participate, or do you advertise to? (01:37:53) Um, we're hitting every NYCHA development. Okay. (01:37:57) How many business owners do you have data in terms of by development? How many participants there are. (01:38:05) Um, we will maintain data on (01:38:06) how many participants have engaged in NYCHA's programming, specifically in Business Pathways. And so that will not only include who graduated, but also which businesses obtained their license in the case of child care, or registered their business in the case of food. And then NYCHA overall would obtain data through annual recertifications on the number of residents that are reporting. (01:38:33) Um, so, business income as part of that, your totals. Um, is there any assistance with these businesses? We certainly connect residents to our Part 215 team for registration as a Section 3 business concern, which is not to, um, but it is a sort of... that NYCHA, love, bridges. And then we will work with SBS on promotion around certification. In the past we've actually hosted sessions in our computer lab where residents can get hands-on support in the certification process. I'm (01:39:18) Not familiar with Section 3. What is that? (01:39:31) Oh, it is just a designation for low-income workers and NYCHA residents. Okay. So I'm (01:39:31) going to give you, for instance, currently there's a large infrastructure, a few large infrastructure programs in my backyard, and there are two major NYCHA facilities, the Bland and the Latimer, within a one-mile radius. Do you know offhand if any of these residents have access, be it to any of the employee opportunities, on-site work that's being done with the soccer stadium, or Willets Point? (01:39:51) I'm not familiar with those specific projects, but I can say that generally we are open to working with any company that wants to make sure that local residents are aware of their employment opportunities. Um, and we, on a regular basis, look... I... (01:40:23) And that, for instance, with so much infrastructure and development happening across the city, is there any current or future plans for training to prepare NYCHA residents for those opportunities, whether as entrepreneurs or... (01:40:38) On the workforce. Um, in our research department, we do offer a variety of job training initiatives through our partners. One that is popular, and one that we've offered, is a construction track through the NYCHA Resident Training Academy, and this is a pre-apprenticeship track, and so it can connect residents to union careers in the construction (01:41:02) industry. Ah, awesome. And how many staffers are in the Business Pathways program? The Department of NYCHA has 55 staff members total, and so staff members are across changes so that they can be supportive across functional units, specifically within our financial capability and business development team. We have one assistant director, two project managers, and temp staff. Currently, what is... (01:41:30) The fiscal cost of the program, and for the last three fiscal years. Um, for the last three fiscal years. Sorry. So... (01:41:43) The baseline costs for a child care and food business pathways is $100,000 for each cohort. And so that cost, the fiscal year costs, it depends on how many cohorts we operated in a particular year. How long is each cohort, and that $100K, a specific number of people that it can participate... (01:42:13) Um, so, I work... child care business pathways program is generally operating for 15 weeks. Food generally operating for 10 weeks, and so these meet about two times a week in the evening, for two to three hours each session. Um, and I'm (01:42:16) sorry, could you repeat the second part of that question? (01:42:36) Number of applicants who can participate for that hundred thousand dollars. So we generally enroll 25 a cohort in child care and 30 in food. Okay. And where is the actual training based... (01:42:44) Well, since COVID we actually switched to a hybrid method. So we're doing a lot of virtual training, and then place-based training, dependent on the topic and the need. So, for example, in child care there is one session that's done for food, where we go and take the aspiring entrepreneurs on a tour of a commercial kitchen, et cetera. So it could operate in a variety... (01:43:01) Of places, depending on the topic, but it's quite accessible now as a hybrid model, and we've really seen since COVID that that's been quite helpful for residents to keep to that. How does someone apply, and then... (01:43:02) How are those applicants promoted? Material, how residents can learn more. This typically starts within an information session, and so they call our hotline number, or they also utilize an online self-service platform, so authorized residents do have access to a self-service platform where they can register for an information session. Events. At the events we'll provide an overview of the program, take questions. From there there is an application process, and we have a score grid that will follow, and then a small committee that includes our staff plus partner staff that can evaluate applications. Now, an (01:43:29) Introduction 459 from CM Stevens would require the Department of Small Business Services to expand... the Business Pathways program. Is SBS involved in the Business Pathways program currently, and should they be, if not? We are very appreciative of his partnership. They've been alongside, standing partner, both on the workforce side and on the business development side, and we absolutely leverage them as a sort of partner. And what is your position (01:43:43) on this bill? Um, we appreciate the Council's interest in the Business Pathways program. We are very encouraged at what we see in continuing the program, and definitely have successes of resident graduates from there. We'd love to set up more in-depth conversations with the Council Members in order to really discuss the program as it currently operates. (01:44:42) Okay. How has the (01:45:12) resident feedback been thus far of the current Business Pathways program, and do you solicit feedback as part of the program? (01:45:37) We have taken feedback to make adjustments to the program. So an example of that would be the point in time in which we introduced the state application for licensing for child businesses. When we first started the series, we did that as a post-service, and the feedback was that it is very overwhelming, and it's really good to make use of classroom time in order to start that process and get hands-on support. (01:45:39) Particularly as the application has now become digital. We do have residents that have a digital literacy or digital access need. (01:45:47) So that's an example of how we'll incorporate feedback into the program. And if a home-based provider needs help with financing, where would you (01:46:17) direct them? So we do see that providers need help (01:46:25) with... um, financing, generally, specifically for child care. Our cohort will actually offer micro grants for a select number of graduates from the program that can help with things such as furnishing that they need, better specific to the child care business that they're intending to operate. So depending on the need, we'll make a referral to SBS, which other partners that can then provides further financial assistance and guidance. (01:46:38) And going back to Introduction 459, have you done a cost analysis or begun to think about what it would look like, the cost would be associated with expanding the program? Um, certainly, we know that depending on what we are considering for expansion. So, for example, new sectors would require a new cost analysis that we have not yet done. (01:46:42) Um, we're first led by resident interest and surveying residents. They are consistently interested, they maintain interest in starting a business, and identifying needs around business coaching and capital, as your previous stated as needs that they have to be successful, but they also consistently identify food and child care as being a (01:47:17) primary interest of theirs, and that's why we've really structured offering this program. Series. As stated previously, we know that a baseline cost for this particular industry of food or child care would be $100,000, and then, of course, that cost could potentially rise if we're discussing the expansion of micro grants in the program, like I previously mentioned. (01:47:44) Two final questions before being turned over to my colleague. How many of the businesses that you guys helped open... (01:48:06) Child care specifically, are still operating? So, data. Previously we've had 149 graduates of child care since 2015. Of those graduates, have moved on to opening their business... (01:48:34) And have you begun tracking or seeing of these business owners, how many continue to reside in NYCHA or are any who've moved out? So periodically we will survey business owners to reach out, see if they need continued support, confirm if they're still operating. You are right. (01:48:42) One of the reasons that we will see for a business to drop off from operating might be that they moved out of NYCHA. In that case, if they're still interested in business services, we would direct them to partners such as this. At this time I'll turn it over (01:49:04) to Council Members. Gutierrez. (01:49:28) Thank you, Chair, and thank you. (01:49:46) Cassie Jo. I ask a couple of questions that sound really (01:49:47) elementary, because I'm not (01:49:49) familiar with the Business Pathways program. Can you just (01:49:53) tell me, what are the (01:49:55) industries that you're able to train people for in this program? Our most common industries are food and child care, and that aligns with resident interests. And what's the... (01:49:57) Food industry? So food usually looks like catering, but not necessarily. And so we do have business operators that might sell their products in a retail market as opposed to catering. So that's why we call it food broadly, but it is a program that is not teaching you culinary skills, but it's a business development program for residents that are looking to (01:50:00) start or formalize their (01:50:14) food business, and for the child care portion, that is helping people start their business of child care in their homes and elsewhere, or formalizing their business. So it is recognizing that there could be some informal businesses that are happening, and this is also making sure, across the board, that residents begin to understand, while like babysitting or nannying, if you occasionally babysit, there's a way to really build on that and really formalize a business. Okay, but it is for specifically in... (01:50:17) In the other respect, it's (01:50:38) for them to be able to set up their home. (01:50:39) In their apartment. (01:50:53) Where? Okay, okay, let me. (01:50:56) Okay. I'm going to come back to you, but I just wanted to ask. I raised this to the Mayor's Office of Child Care before about private equity, and we do hear a lot. We hear them almost at every hearing, and some of those firms are contracted with the City, right? Some of them, they're part of the universal model. But in your effort to support small businesses, do you feel that there are... do you think that we should be creating more guidelines for the way that the City works with contracts with private equity, versus actual small, local community... (01:51:19) Businesses. Thank you. Um, I think we share on that, and I would have to defer to the Mayor's Office, the Contract Services and Chief Procurement Officer, Kim Yu, but on the topic of private equity and the impact it's having across the small business industries, something we're hearing, we're seeing, and we're working really hard to figure out ways to avoid, and come up with ways that the City could use its power, whether its purchasing power or some other intervention, programmatic interventions or protections that the City should consider to support small businesses. And so there's work underway. In the next couple of months, you'll hear more on how we could do better to protect small businesses. And okay, do you have any examples of, like, specific protections that you're thinking about? (01:51:20) It's a whole host of things. (01:51:22) In their apartment (01:51:23) Where? Okay, okay, let me. (01:51:27) Okay. I'm going to come back to you, but I just wanted to ask. I raised this to the Mayor's Office of Child Care before about private equity, and we do hear a lot. We hear them almost at every hearing, and some of those firms are contracted with the City. Right? Some of them, there. They're part of the universal model. But in your effort to support small businesses, do you feel that there are... Do you think that we should be creating more guidelines for the way that the City works with contracts with private equity, versus actual small, you know, local community (01:52:06) Businesses. Thank you. I think he shares that, and I would have to defer to the Mayor's Office, the Contract Services and Chief Procurement Officer, Kim Yu, but on the topic of private equity and the impact it's having across the small business industries, it's something we're hearing and we're seeing, and we're working really hard to figure out ways to avoid that, and come up with ways that the City could use its power. It's either purchasing power or some other interventions, programmatic interventions or protections, that the City should consider to support small businesses. So there's work underway in the next couple of months. You'll hear more on how we could do better to protect small businesses. Okay, do you have any examples of, like, specific protections that you're thinking about? (01:52:53) It's a whole host of things. (01:52:55) That were currently exploring, and one thing we're also looking at, that briefly came up earlier in this conversation, was on Lisa's. There are differences in residential leases and commercial leases, and why have we accepted the norms on one set of leases on types of protections landlords are liable for? In the types of protections, let landlords be liable for commercial leases. So that's just one area of interest. There are other areas that we're looking at. Certainly the cost of insurance has come up significantly for so many small businesses. The cost of commercial rent has come up across the city, and so we're looking at how can the city government not just look at the things city government can do to reduce the cost drivers for them, which are things that you've heard, looking at fines, looking at the process, but also look at things that are beyond the direct control of city government. But is there all the city can play here? Our viewpoint is we should be as expensive as possible in delivering relief for small businesses, and that's what the commissioner and the administration is intending to do. (01:54:00) With regards to child care private equity, I've been meeting with them, speaking with them a lot. Many of them like to see themselves as these are being operated and owned by small business owners, just in this larger franchise as a franchisee. I'm curious. Do you all have data, or is this something that you can collect for in those instances where they... You know, I don't know why they are operating under a larger franchise, but do you all have data or a sense of why someone who's an independent business owner with a private equity firm is going with that? Just wanting to engage with the city, wanting to engage to be able to open up their own child care center on the dynamics of the industry. I defer to the opposite of health care, but I think we've heard there's so... (01:54:47) Much to give me a break. (01:54:53) Yeah, she's been here three times this month. Okay? Yeah, well, it's the... we just... (01:54:55) Not. Are you? But are you all engaging? Are you all working collaboratively with the mayor's office? I think it's interesting. A number of them are contracted with the city, right? You know, Bright Horizons, Learning Experiences. They have these three-K and pre-K programs. There are part of the universe, but the way that they approach me, it's like, no, we are business owners too, just under this. You keep smiling every time I say it, but under these, so I'm just curious. If we are collecting data, we're asking them, did you try to open up your own thing, and why are you? I'm just because there's a lot of concern. There's so much concern, but just private equity in general, and there's a serious impact on our small businesses. So just curious, if you all, how you think you will approach working with them. But I think the data we have is pretty anecdotal, I would say, and there are many different models for some of these bigger chains. Some of them do operate their sites directly, and some of them do, as you said, have a franchise model. We met with one recently who, for them, it is a really big selling point that their franchise owners are almost entirely women of color operating businesses in their communities, just right, you know. I think they would say that. They offer some greater level of support... (01:55:01) Or whatever it might be in terms of benefits, and others are connections to a bigger company. I mean, one of the reasons we continue to be excited about structures like co-ops or the employee ownership model, which we've seen kind of growing with child care, is because those are alternatives when it comes to being able to offer child care providers stability, succession planning, some sort of resources and scale. Child care, we know, can be an incredibly lonely and challenging business. And so I think there are other ways we were looking at to support providers who are looking for some of that through a broader support and sustainability. (01:55:03) Yeah, I'm wondering if there's like... marketing that says that makes it easier to just be able to work with the city directly to open up a business as opposed to having to turn to some of these bigger... (01:56:14) Private equity companies. (01:56:55) Yeah, we certainly are very interested in seeing more worker cooperatives across... (01:57:09) Yeah, yeah, industries. And I think something that many of us here would appreciate is that the services that child care providers come to, worker cooperative related services, are the TAP services thus far. (01:57:14) So there's this interest, and we do run a series of worker cooperative related services: legal assistance, how do you create the bylaws for governance, help you with financing assistance, and really excited to do even general shared service co-ops, which is an area of interest. Student that we're working with folks in City Hall, but also just expanding the possibilities for more new... It's a complicated thing to get your head around at the first go. If you mentioned, oh, you don't consider converting to a worker co-op? It's also something we're looking at, and it came up in one of the last Small Business Committee hearings on legacy businesses as a pathway for succession. If a business owner is retiring, has no other plan, a feasible pathway to hand the business over either in the family or to somebody that they would sell it to. One area that we're strongly exploring is to create incentives for more businesses to sell and convert it into worker co-ops, so that you retain the workforce that was certainly integral to the success of that legacy business. (01:57:27) Business. Thank you. And then I know that you mentioned earlier there's kind of your limitations, I guess, with it supporting just a child business. But is there something on... (01:58:30) If I guess, what is a direction for a New Yorker who wants to open up a child business? They just opened up their laptop, and are they using my city? Are they going to route, kind of, what is like that next step if someone's just blindly saying, like, I want to open up a child business in New York City? (01:58:44) I think there's no wrong door. If folks approach, we will help them, especially with storefront business openings. That's something where we've got resources, services, technical assistance, and we work very closely with the bureau at the Health Department that does the licensing. One thing that is interesting, that Sure, you're Thomas-Henry would appreciate it: unlike other industries, before the Health Department licenses a child care provider, for center-based operations they do a mandatory orientation with that entrepreneur. So before you even think of getting your lease or you get your license, you first learn a whole set of regulations. Another interesting aspect in this particular regulatory space is that the Health Department also offers a viability check of that center location. So before you sign, at least you could also learn, by having the Health Department, the same agency that does the enforcement, also tells you whether the space could be feasible for that type of an operation. (01:59:01) Oh, I love that. Okay. Okay, I'm thinking that I just have a couple more questions for Casino again. This is like brand new information to me. Can you share it for someone who is interested in pursuing the child care training program? What is the situation of that training program? 15 weeks, 50 things. Is that how it's facilitated, as virtual? It's mostly virtual and in the evenings. So how many hours a week? (01:59:43) It's two days a week, about six hours a week each. Oh, three and three. (01:59:54) Maybe. Okay. And what are for the majority, and you mentioned that this year's the current cohort, you have 25? Yes. How many of those are for the child care program? Oh, wonderful. Wonderful. I'm just curious on the... is there any limitation to a New York resident who is living in a studio, a two or three bedroom? How are you all kind of assessing the individual resident's circumstance and their viability of participating in, even successfully opening up a business? (02:00:21) That's a great question. So we work with a contract to provide New York Business Outreach Center Network, which are well known and well regarded in the industry, and so they're really experts in preparing the residents to enroll in child business pathways. They will conduct a walkthrough of the prospective applicant's apartment, and give them the information that they need, really begin to set the standard as to the size of the business that they could potentially do based on the space that they have. Also begin to give them tips around, you know, maybe there's too much furniture in the living room, and that's unintended space to use for the business. So that assistance will continue throughout the duration of the 15 weeks and really help to best prepare the eventual enrollee until the official inspection process of the program, and also in really deciding what type of business do they want to register. (02:00:28) For okay? And then how many cohorts a year, or is the Business Pathways Program able to do this year? We're doing one cohort. Typically we do one to two cohorts. (02:01:05) Okay. And then what happens after the 15 weeks? Are you in communication with them, or are you blocking communication with them, to see where they're able to open up a business? Kind of both, check in with them. Okay, both of us. Yes, okay. (02:02:06) And how regularly are you checking in with them, or for how long is the program checking in with the graduates of the program? I mean, we have for years. Really? Yes, we have graduates that are seven years in business now. We have others who will decide they want to pivot to something else, as I mentioned earlier, and we'll provide that support. So we really do want to be a base with them on a regular frequency to ensure that our stats are up to date and how the program is operating, so that we're there as a resource even post-graduation. (02:02:17) Okay. And how do you have a sense of what the success rate is for folks in the child care program wanting to open up their child business? Like for each cohort, how many of them are able to successfully do that? Yeah. So... (02:02:30) As stated earlier, we have 57 businesses that launched, and since the beginning of the program... (02:03:13) Since the beginning of the program, yes. (02:03:29) And we have 20 currently operating as of this year. Okay. (02:03:49) But you don't know what is the percentage of that versus the entire graduating class? I don't, I don't mean to... 189 graduates, okay, 2015. Okay. (02:04:02) Okay. And then I think it's wonderful again. This is brand new information. I was not aware of the secondary particular program, but I do have to share that. I think, knowing some of the home-based providers in my district and visiting with them that are in public housing, I mean, they have real challenges, because before opening up their business, before anything, they have residents, and it is really difficult to live in... (02:04:29) A night job for multiple reasons, but primarily just for repairs and dignified housing. In some of these instances, what are you hearing from cohort participants about their challenges in getting repairs, necessary repairs, that they need to have to be able to pass inspection and contract with the city? And how does the Business Pathways Program help in accelerating some of the ground much... (02:04:57) That's why it's really important that we start that pre-inspection and walk... (02:05:03) Through, really, even at the application stage of the program. And I spoke about some... (02:05:09) Of the items that are training partner Bach Net will review with the injury with the residents, what they are able to, like, to move ahead along on some of these things. Well, so what it's going to say is that we also, if there are repair needs, first we make sure that they have put in a ticket. So yes, we know that residents put in tickets, and we know what some of that feedback is. But there are also some issues that residents are dealing with, and they haven't yet formally put in a ticket. So we first make sure that they're educated in the repair ticket process, and then we make sure that they know that the Reese is a resource for them. And so we'll direct them on the standard guidance: go to the customer call, call the customer contact center, follow up with their property management office. If they're not getting the... (02:05:59) Resolution that they're (02:06:01) Expecting. Then they reach out to her office, and where there to serve as a resource the same way we would for business coaching, financing, any other support and referrals that they need. And then we'll work internally to try and address their repair concern. Um, I'm just curious, and I'll maybe pose this question for the admin at a later time. Just curious if of the home-based providers in Night, if any of them, you know, just have these extenuating circumstances with nature to be able to maintain their business open. So I'll pose that at a later time. I don't know. I just don't know if that's... I don't know if it's pervasive, but I feel like I represent nine nature developments in my district. The majority of the housing-related issues are coming from public housing tenants, so I can't imagine that they're also able to kind of operate their business from their home and not being a part of that population that is in constant need of repairs and attention from NYCHA. (02:07:00) I just have one more question. I don't know if you can answer it, but... (02:07:47) For the centers that are in NYCHA, do you know if they are on a different track for maintenance repairs for NYCHA? Um, so daycare operators on NYCHA grounds would also follow a customer contact center track as the first step to report a repair ticket, and then we do have a department called the Office of Public Private Partnerships that meets with schools on a biweekly basis, and they're there to support on a number of items, including any repair escalations that are needed. Okay, okay. I think I'm done. Thank you. (02:07:49) No worries. One more quick... (02:07:52) Question and a comment. I know you said you haven't started... (02:07:58) The cost analysis that controls for 545 would bring. But part of the bill would require professional business education, mentor support on licenses, et cetera. A few things that currently does too best and business solutions... (02:08:14) Programming would ideally have you given consideration to what it just be an expansion of your team providing these services, or are you guys thinking more something in a training for the Mitre business programmed to do these courses in-house? I can start with that answer. So currently our business pathway series does have in its curriculum many of the items that you mentioned. So it's really focused on business development, what it takes to be a successful business operator, including learning... (02:08:51) About financing, learning about regulatory requirements, and... (02:08:56) Then we currently do partner with CAN, continue to strengthen our partnership with them, particularly as they take on new pieces of this... (02:09:08) Work in the current administration. Yes, there's have anything to add? No, come, awesome! And... (02:09:16) The last thing was a comment. Emmy, you did so graciously offer to hear of any... (02:09:22) Programs that are having a problem. So I did what, like, within the last 24 hours, I have heard that African American parents' educational center in CM Hankerson's district... And not sure if you have time to stick around, but as of today, we did hear that we're going to have quite a few people testifying regarding the closure of Christ the King Community Daycare and Preschool. Thank you. And this panel is