Hearing Hearings — Hearing Record ✉
← All hearings

Vision Zero: Evaluating NYC's Street Safety Strategy

Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure

Chair: Shaun Abreu

Meeting overview

The City Council's Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure held an oversight hearing on Vision Zero, the city's street safety program now in its twelfth year, alongside six pieces of legislation and one resolution. The hearing drew testimony from DOT Commissioner Mike Flynn, NYPD officials including Chief Obey and Deputy Chief Thomas Alpes, the Business Integrity Commission, and Public Advocate Jumaane Williams. The session was substantive and at times pointed, covering enforcement trends, crash investigation procedures, infrastructure rollouts, new technology, and the legislative proposals on the table.

DOT Commissioner Flynn testified under Mayor Mamdani's direction, presenting Vision Zero Reimagined, a ten-year action plan released in September 2026. He cited record-low traffic fatalities in 2025 and strong year-to-date figures for 2026, including all-time-low pedestrian deaths. The plan commits to safety improvements at all of the city's most dangerous corridors within three years, daylighting or equivalent treatments at 1,000 intersections per year, neighborhood-wide 20 mph slow zones, and the creation of a public Vision Zero dashboard. Flynn said DOT is hiring roughly 200 new staff, with about half already in the pipeline, and described a new Office of Curb Management being stood up. The administration generally supported the Council's legislative agenda but consistently pushed back on specific mandates, arguing that flexibility is critical to effective implementation. That tension between Council wanting binding commitments and DOT wanting discretion ran through most of the hearing.

On enforcement, Chair Abreu pressed NYPD hard on the decline in moving summonses from roughly 700,000 annually before the pandemic to just over 413,000 in fiscal year 2026, a 41% drop. NYPD representatives declined to commit to returning to pre-pandemic levels, arguing that enforcement quality and data-driven targeting matter more than raw numbers, and that the landscape has changed significantly with the explosion in micro-mobility. Chief Obey pointed to dramatic increases in motorcycle and moped seizures and summonses as partly explaining the reallocation of enforcement resources. Chair Abreu was visibly skeptical, noting that camera enforcement and micro-mobility cannot fully explain a drop that predates the camera rollout. The committee also dug into the NYPD's Collision Investigation Squad, which handles roughly 200 cases per year and focuses on fatalities and critical injuries. A specific case was raised involving a cyclist struck in Midtown in June 2026 who was unable to walk for six weeks but whose case was apparently closed at precinct level and not escalated to CIS, prompting sharp questions about what qualifies as a critical injury and whether the thresholds are appropriate. NYPD acknowledged it would follow up. On drag racing, CM Santosuosso described ongoing street racing on the Belt Parkway the night after three teenagers were killed, and Deputy Chief Alpes reported a 161% increase in arrests for street takeovers year to date but acknowledged the problem persists.

Several bills received substantive discussion. Int 1153, the Stop Super Speeders Act, targeting drivers with 16 or more speed camera violations in 12 months and requiring installation of intelligent speed assistance devices, received the clearest administration support. DOT confirmed the state budget already authorizes a pilot program, and the city bill would provide required local authorization. Implementation complexity, particularly around out-of-state registered vehicles and back-end software, was flagged as a challenge. Int 1070, Chair Abreu's low-traffic neighborhood pilot bill, was welcomed by DOT with some requests to refine definitions; Flynn described learning from London's model and confirmed direct engagement with TfL. Int 613, requiring 100 miles of protected bike lanes annually for six years, was supported in principle but opposed as a rigid mandate. Int 113, CM Brooks-Powers' dangerous driving study bill, was supported with requests for minor amendments around data access issues, notably the difficulty of obtaining insurance data. Int 46, the autism warning plaques bill, faced DOT resistance on grounds of sign clutter and lack of evidence for behavior change, drawing a sharp response from the bill's sponsor. Resolution 687, calling on Albany to pass the Drag Racing and Speeding Enforcement Act, was presented without significant controversy.

The hearing surfaced several operational frustrations. CM Dinowitz described DOT failing to acknowledge receipt of constituent requests for stop signs and speed humps, suggesting a cultural problem within the agency around responsiveness to Council members outside of high-profile projects. CM Restler raised the fact that NYPD crash data on the city's open data portal had not been updated in five months, receiving a non-committal answer about timing. CM Pierina Sanchez raised streetlights out for nine to ten months at a time in the Bronx under a contractor called Highland, and the average streetlight repair time having ballooned from under three days to 8.5 or 28.5 days depending on which figure from the transcript is correct. On truck safety, the Business Integrity Commission was questioned closely about its side guard waiver program following the death of a teenager struck by a hydro-excavation truck in the East Village in September 2026. BIC defended the waiver granted in that case on the grounds that the vehicle had equipment filling the undercarriage gap, but acknowledged it did not have data on how often waivered trucks have been involved in pedestrian and cyclist collisions, which the Chair found disappointing.

The record

Numbers
  • In 2025, New York City recorded 205 traffic fatalities, a 31% reduction from 2014 levels.
  • In fiscal years 2018 and 2019, NYPD issued approximately 700,000 Vision Zero-related moving summonses annually.
  • In fiscal year 2021, NYPD moving summonses fell to approximately 300,000, the post-pandemic low.
  • In fiscal year 2026, NYPD issued just over 413,000 Vision Zero-related moving summonses, approximately 41% below pre-pandemic levels.
  • NYPD motorcycle seizures in 2025 totalled 5,567, compared to 2,169 in 2019.
  • NYPD moped seizures in 2025 totalled 14,421, compared to 1,610 in 2019.
  • As of September 2026, NYPD recorded 10,001 e-bike and 468 standard scooter moving violations in 2026 year to date.
  • 81.2% of NYPD moving enforcement in 2026 year to date was accounted for by cars and SUVs.
  • The city has more than 2,200 speed cameras across 750 school speed zones, operating 24/7 since August 2022, and red light cameras at 600 intersections.
  • A 2024 City Comptroller report found that over 1 million speed camera violations between an unspecified period ending June 2023 were voided due to obscured or ghost plates, representing 22% of all camera-based violations over that period.
  • In 2026, through October 18, NYPD conducted 31 joint ghost plate operations resulting in 440 arrests, 18,805 summonses, and 1,937 vehicle seizures.
  • In 2025, NYPD issued 430,058 obstructed plate parking summonses.
  • CIS handled 212 cases in 2026 year to date: 167 fatalities and 45 critical injuries. Of these, 77 (36%) were deemed criminal. 40 of 63 fatal criminal cases are closed. 75% of hit-and-run cases where a vehicle was identified led to an arrest; roughly two-thirds of those led to arrest overall.
  • NYPD responded to 271 documented street takeovers or car meetups citywide from January 1 to October 18, 2026, an 11% increase year on year, with 170 arrests (up 161%), 157 summonses (up 246%), and 291 vehicle seizures (up 104%).
  • DOT plans to deliver daylighting or equivalent safety treatments at 1,000 intersections per year under Vision Zero Reimagined.
  • Over 6,000 leading pedestrian intervals have been installed citywide to date; the Council's data team found LPIs reduce pedestrian casualties by 12.7%.
  • DOT has completed over 200 school 15 mph slow zones in 2026 and expects to reach approximately 800 by year end, with all 2,300 eligible school locations to be completed by the end of the current mayoral term.
  • DOT is hiring approximately 200 new staff, with about half already in the pipeline, funded by historic new capital commitments beginning in fiscal year 2027.
  • The average number of days to repair a streetlight has increased from under three days historically to between 8.5 and 28.5 days per the MMR (figures quoted inconsistently in testimony).
  • BIC has jurisdiction over approximately 7,000 licensed trade waste trucks. Fewer than 80 side guard violations have been issued since the side guard rule took effect in 2023, representing a claimed 99% compliance rate.
  • Transportation Alternatives identified 50 Boulevards of Death comprising 4% of the city's street miles but accounting for over 20% of traffic fatalities.
  • 63 elected officials and 17 community boards have formally requested Sammy's Law neighborhood slow zones.
  • Reckless driving arrests (VTL 1192) are up to 1,218 in 2026 year to date from 784 in full-year 2025. VTL 511 arrests for driving with a suspended or revoked license are up 9% year to date to 22,063 versus 20,709 at full-year 2025.
Action Points
  • NYPD to provide Chair Abreu with data on trends in hit-and-run identification rates over the past five years.
  • NYPD to investigate the June 2026 Midtown cyclist hit-and-run case specifically and report back to the Chair on why it was not escalated to CIS.
  • NYPD to provide a breakdown of CIS cases where no arrest was made, distinguishing between cases where criminality was found but no arrest achieved versus cases where no criminality was identified.
  • NYPD to follow up with Chair Abreu's office on specific precinct-level issues in his district, including illegal parking near precincts.
  • NYPD to brief CM Gale Brewer's office on the 104th Precinct collision report involving the 12-year-old struck at 75th Avenue and 60th Lane, including how the report was amended and what further corrections are needed.
  • NYPD to bring CM Santosuosso's concerns about Belt Parkway drag racing in Bay Ridge and Coney Island to the attention of the relevant Highway District commanders.
  • DOT to follow up with CM Restler on a timeline for restoring NYPD crash data to the city's open data portal, with a written response expected within the week.
  • DOT to provide a briefing to CM Restler on compliance readiness and resource levels for Local Law 178 of 2025, which requires installation of pedestrian sidewalk lighting on 300 commercial quarter-blocks per year starting January 1, 2027.
  • DOT to respond formally to Community Board 8's October 21, 2026 letter to the Comptroller regarding the Highland streetlight contract and provide CM Pierina Sanchez with specifics on when outages will be resolved.
  • DOT to provide the Committee with a decision tree or process map explaining how it determines what safety treatments to apply at individual intersections under Vision Zero Reimagined.
  • DOT to share data on how many intersections have received full versus approach-only daylighting treatments, and the number of additional intersections daylit since the Vision Zero Reimagined plan was released.
  • DOT to huddle internally and report back to the Committee on plans for accelerating the expansion of leading pedestrian intervals and provide a quantified target.
  • DOT to get back to CM Dinowitz's office on outstanding requests for stop signs and speed humps, including the Richardson Avenue speed hump request, and confirm acknowledgment of receipt.
  • DOT to discuss Empire Wind One container placement in relation to daylighting requirements with CM Justin Sanchez and brief on the status of enforcement in active daylighting zones.
  • DOT to brief CM Pierina Sanchez separately on specific intersection redesign options at the I-87 and Major Deegan ramp interfaces at Burnside, Fordham Road, and 230th Street, including engagement with state DOT.
  • DOT to connect with CM Haneef regarding formalizing a micro-hub pilot location on Wyckoff Street between Bond and Hoyt, coordinating with Brooklyn Borough Commissioner Bray.
  • DOT to discuss with CM Justin Sanchez the possibility of commissioning a neighborhood study of the Hub in the South Bronx covering pedestrian mobility, busway viability, and street safety.
  • BIC to provide the Committee with data on how many waivered trucks have been involved in collisions with pedestrians or cyclists since 2023, and how that compares to trucks with side guards.
  • BIC to provide data on the number of trucks currently operating under a side guard waiver out of its 7,000 licensed vehicles.
  • DOT to provide Chair Abreu with a breakdown of spending to date from the Sammy's Law school zone signage budget allocation.
  • DOT to share Streets Plan details, including new priority investment area maps and neighborhood slow zone criteria, with the Committee when published in approximately two months.
Download .txt
Full Transcript

(00:00:17)

Thank you. Good morning, and welcome to today's New York City Council hearing for the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure. At this time, please silence all cell phones and electronic devices. If you are here today, please fill out an appearance card with the Sergeant at Arms. Moving forward, no one is to approach the dais. Jerry, we are ready to begin.

Good morning, and welcome to today's hearing. I am CM Shaun Abreu, Majority Leader and Chair of the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure. Since its launch in 2014, Vision Zero has fundamentally changed how New York City approaches street safety.

The central principle is simple. Traffic deaths and serious injuries are preventable, and every New Yorker deserves to travel safely, whether they are walking, cycling, driving, or using another form of transportation. Over the years, we have made meaningful progress toward this goal. In 2025, New York City recorded 205 traffic fatalities, a 31% reduction compared to 2014. However, any life lost on our streets is one too many, and recent tragedies remind us that there is still considerable work ahead.

Last month, the administration released a re-imagined action plan aimed at eliminating traffic deaths and serious injuries. I support the goal outlined in this plan and welcomed the administration's renewed commitment to street safety.

However, ambitious goals must be accompanied by clear strategies, realistic timelines, and measurable outcomes. Today, we want to better understand how the administration intends to turn these commitments into meaningful improvements on our streets. What specific actions will be prioritized? When can New Yorkers expect to see results? And how will we measure whether the City is making sufficient progress toward its goals?

In part, that discussion is about enforcement. In fiscal years 2018 and 2019, the NYPD issued nearly 700,000 Vision Zero-related moving summonses annually. By fiscal year 2021, that number had fallen to approximately 300,000. While enforcement has since increased, with the NYPD issuing just over 413,000 summonses in fiscal year 2026, this is still approximately 40% below pre-pandemic levels. These numbers raise serious questions about the City's enforcement strategy. Why has enforcement remained substantially below previous levels, and what will it take to restore a consistent and effective enforcement presence?

We need to ensure that dangerous behavior is addressed across all modes of transportation, including cars, motorcycles, e-bikes, mopeds, and other micro-mobility devices. Street safety requires fair, consistent enforcement that prioritizes the behaviors posing the greatest risk to New Yorkers.

Beyond enforcement, we must continue investing in infrastructure improvements, including daylighting, safer intersections, protected bicycle infrastructure, and lower speed limits. We also want to examine new approaches, such as low-traffic neighborhoods and intelligent speed assistance technology, while ensuring that these initiatives are practical, effective, and responsive to community needs.

The legislation before us today provides an opportunity to advance these conversations and consider additional tools to prevent dangerous driving and protect vulnerable road users. We will be hearing the following legislation:

Introduction Number 46, sponsored by CM Arreola, in relation to installing child with autism warning plaques on the streets.

Introduction Number 113, sponsored by CM Brooks-Powers, in relation to requiring a study of dangerous driving.

Introduction Number 613, sponsored by CM Joseph, in relation to the installation of protected bicycle lanes.

Introduction Number 1070, sponsored by myself, in relation to establishing a low-traffic neighborhood pilot program.

Introduction Number 1153, sponsored by CM Abreu and Ossé, in relation to establishing a demonstration program for the installation and maintenance of intelligent speed assistance devices.

And Resolution 687, sponsored by myself, calling on the New York State Legislature to pass and the New York State Governor to sign S.1768/A.2585, the Drag Racing and Speeding Enforcement Act, which would impose five points on the driver's license for being convicted of participating in speed contests or races.

I will let the other sponsors discuss their bills, but I am particularly excited about my bill related to low-traffic neighborhoods. Low-traffic neighborhoods use a range of traffic-calming measures to reduce through traffic on residential streets. Studies suggest that these approaches can reduce traffic volumes without significantly impacting surrounding roads or emergency response times. Introduction Number 1070 would establish a two-year pilot program in five neighborhoods across at least three boroughs and evaluate impacts on street safety, noise, and surrounding streets. We want to better understand where these measures would be most effective and how they can help create safer, more livable neighborhoods.

In addition, my resolution calls on the State to pass S.1768 and A.2585, known as the Drag Racing and Speeding Enforcement Act, which would work to combat illegal drag and speed racing.

Ultimately, the goal of this hearing is to hold the administration accountable to new commitments, and to ensure that those commitments translate into safer streets. We look forward to working constructively with the administration, advocates, and communities to identify what is working, where improvements are needed, and what additional steps must be taken.

I want to thank my staff and Committee staff for their hard work in preparing for today's hearing: Julissa Quigley, my Deputy Chief of Staff; Boeri, my Senior Adviser; Sierra Townsend, Senior Legislative Counsel; Theodore Miller, Legislative Counsel; Kevin Katawsky, Senior Policy Analyst; John Bazell, Senior Policy Analyst; and Yates Wong, Finance Analyst. I look forward to today's testimony and discussion. I will now turn it over to the bill sponsors, beginning first with CM Brooks-Powers, followed by CM Santosuosso.

(00:07:03)

Thank you, Majority Leader and Chair Abreu, and members of the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure for hearing Intro 113 today. As we evaluate the administration's Vision Zero plan, I remain committed to the principle that our streets should be governed by data and that progress should be measured transparently and consistently. The work of this Committee, including during my time as Chair, has shown that safety and fairness go together. That work has included citywide daylighting, enforcement, and overhauling City truck routes.

Enforcement should be focused on the behavior that is injuring and killing New Yorkers. To do that, the City must know that behavior better. My bill, Intro 113, would require the Department of Transportation, working with the NYPD and other agencies, to study driving behavior and identify the patterns that signal dangerous driving before it ends in a crash.

The City already collects data but does not look at it in this way. Head-and-run reports, reckless driving convictions, crash reports, and the driving activity of vehicles registered to people with a suspended license, and where feasible, insurance information. Every year, the Department of Transportation would report to this Council and the public on what it found, what it recommends, what agencies have done about it, and whether dangerous driving is going up or down. I look forward to working with the Chair and the Committee to move Intro 113 forward.

I also want to take a moment to voice my support for Intro 46. As a proud aunt of an autistic nephew, it is a very important piece of legislation that I hope to see voted on as well.

(00:09:01)

As for Intro 1070, of which I am a proud co-prime sponsor with Majority Leader Abreu, we are looking to bring the low-traffic neighborhood pilot program to the City of New York. I look forward to working with my colleagues on these important pieces of legislation, and thank the advocates for the work that they have done around this issue and for our combined effort to make New York safer. Thank you, Chair.

(00:09:29)

Thank you, Council Member. I would like to recognize that we have been joined by CM Louis, Brooks-Powers, Justin Sanchez, and Wong, and Council Members who also are in the room. The Public Advocate.

(00:09:30)

CM Santosuosso, who also followed by Public Advocate Jumaane Williams.

(00:09:41)

CM Santosuosso, who also followed by Public Advocate Jumaane Williams.

(00:09:42)

Thank you, Majority Leader. Today we will hear my bill, Intro 1153, otherwise known as the Stop Super Speeders Act, which would require that drivers who are chronic speeders install a speed-limiting device in any vehicle that is registered to them. This legislation aims to crack down on our absolute worst offenders. It would target drivers who incur speeding tickets, speeding in school zones, 16 or more of those violations in the span of 12 months. It is tempting to think that there aren't enough drivers that would actually qualify for that speed-limiting device, but it turns out that there are thousands of them, and they are the worst danger to us on the streets. It is time for us to limit their ability to navigate their own vehicles, which they have proven they are unable to do safely.

I come to this bill as a pedestrian, as a cyclist, and as a driver, and I understand that this is not aimed at one or the other. It is not aimed at the drivers who have one or two speeding tickets, but at the absolute worst offenders. I am so grateful that we have been able to get a swift hearing, with the support of Chair Abreu and so many of the advocates that have pushed this forward. I look forward to hearing from DOT on the implementation of this bill: what kind of challenges it proposes, and what you need in order to implement it.

As you all know, this was started on the State level through State Senator Kennedy and Assembly Member Emily Gallagher and many others, and we look forward to finishing the job here on the City level. We want to see it passed as swiftly as possible, so I look forward to hearing how we can make that happen by partnering with this administration. I want to thank you for your efforts in focusing on this issue. Finally, thanks to the advocates, thanks to the drafters who have turned this around quite quickly, and thank you again to the Chair for hearing this bill.

(00:09:43)

Of course. Thank you.

(00:09:46)

Public Advocate Jumaane Williams. Hi, my name is Jumaane Williams, Public Advocate for the City of New York. Thank you, Chair Abreu, as well as members of the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure, for holding this important hearing and for the opportunity to share testimony.

The City's road crisis still remains a little limited, partly because crash statistics on the City's open data portal have not been updated since 2026. Directly outside the Dinkins Municipal Building on Centre Street, a fatal collision occurred on July 29 involving a driver and an individual riding an illegal bike. In August 2026, hit-and-run drivers took the lives of three cyclists within three days, bringing the total number of people killed by hit-and-run drivers to nine by the end of the month. Just early this month, on Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn, an unmarked NYPD vehicle ran a red light and struck a cyclist. Nine pedestrians were injured on October 9 when a driver barreled through a busy Bronx intersection.

According to the Vision Zero Imagine report, the DOT plans to use hardened daylighting or better treatments, such as traffic signals, all-way stops, crosswalks, and leading pedestrian intervals. As the DOT moves forward with the lighting measures, we must emphasize that compromised visibility poses a direct threat to pedestrians, cyclists, livery workers, and motorists alike. To keep expenses minimal relative to their overall budget, the City can integrate more daylighting into planned milling and repaving work, executed by City staff rather than outside contractors.

To regulate micro-mobility and e-bikes effectively, we must expand protected bike lanes and infrastructure and penalize retailers who sell non-compliant e-bikes engineered to exceed legal speeds, especially with the increased ICE presence across the City under this federal administration. We want to make sure that if there is particularly aggressive enforcement, it is not on delivery workers and cyclists in everyday life, but on the owners and regulators, rather than on individuals, since the systems contributing to most of the harm are not individuals. That doesn't mean we have to eliminate enforcement altogether.

To further enhance safety, the City must expand the implementation of Sammy's Law, lowering speed limits beyond schools to include other designated areas. I don't yet know that I support this across the entire City, but definitely some other areas outside of school zones. Furthermore, advocates are calling for immediate local programming of another State law, the Super Speed Initiative, sponsored by CM Santosuosso. So I say that, oh, praise God, which mandates speed-limiting devices for chronic reckless drivers. I just want to make sure that will be applied equitably to everyone in the City.

As noted by the Mayor, reckless drivers account for nearly 40% of traffic fatalities, and these drivers pose a significantly higher risk of causing severe collisions. Repeatedly building on the City's initiatives, we should, prior to legislative action, prevent driving motor vehicle crashes, which people have to remember. We talk about cycling and even horses, but crashes by vehicles remain a significantly greater hazard than anything else in the City, and every time we try to move on it, we get a particularly vociferous response. Specifically, I urge the Council to consider and also pass CM Brooks-Powers' bill, Intro 113, to implement universal daylighting and strengthen accountability on the streets. The daylighting proposal is supported by over 200 civic, street safety, and community organizations. Additionally, 23 community boards have passed resolutions endorsing intersection daylighting as a key measure to enhance street safety. Enacting this bill and others will ensure that compliance is legally required and formally codified: no standing or parking within 20 feet of any crosswalk, while establishing mandatory annual benchmarks for the DOT, including targeted intersections. Thank you. This is a very important hearing, and I want to thank the Chair again. Thank you.

(00:11:47)

Thank you, Public Advocate. I would like to recognize that we have been joined by CM Marte. I will now move to administration testimony and turn over to the Committee Counsel to give the oath. Please raise your right hand.

(00:15:36)

For the record, thank you. Good morning, Chair Abreu and members of the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure. I am Mike Flynn, Commissioner of the New York City Department of Transportation.

With me today is Eric Beaton, Director of Transportation Planning and Management, and Madeleine Labadie, my Chief of Staff. Thank you for the opportunity to testify on behalf of Mayor Zohran Mamdani about Vision Zero and the administration's street safety strategy. It has been an exciting and busy month as the City ramps up our re-imagined Vision Zero approach. Vision Zero is a comprehensive, multi-agency priority initiative to build multiple layers of protection, both to prevent crashes in the first place and to minimize severity when they do occur. Our strategy is working.

(00:15:45)

Counsel to give the oath. Please raise your right hand.

(00:16:03)

For the record, thank you. Good morning, Chair Brewer and members of the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure. I am Mike Flynn, Commissioner of the New York City Department of Transportation. With me today is Eric Beaton, Transportation Planning and Management, and Madeleine Labadie, my Chief of Staff. Thank you for the opportunity to testify on behalf of Mayor Zahran Mamdani about Vision Zero and the administration's street safety strategy. It has been an exciting and busy month as the city ramps up our reimagined Vision Zero approach. Vision Zero is a comprehensive, multi-agency priority initiative to build multiple layers of protection to both prevent crashes in the first place and minimize severity when they do occur. Our strategy is working.

(00:16:46)

Earlier this month we announced that traffic deaths have reached historic lows over the first three quarters of 2026, with the second fewest traffic deaths since the city started tracking data in 1910. Pedestrian fatalities are at an all-time low, and 2025 is the safest year on record for our streets. This is one too many on top of the tremendous progress to date. The Mamdani administration is committing to Vision Zero through the new Vision Zero Reimagined action plan, a citywide strategy for the next decade, because there is more work to be done. Our decades-long initiative has shown that building safer streets works to keep more New Yorkers safe while traveling, and our newly released action plan continues the administration's commitment to expanding the deployment of proven safety interventions. While Vision Zero is a citywide effort, DOT is highlighting a variety of goals to support Vision Zero, which include implementing safety improvements for all of the city's most dangerous streets within three years, by the end of the mayor's current term in office. Other goals include removing dangerous drivers and devices from our streets, encouraging safe travel modes while discouraging oversized vehicles, cultivating a safety culture of accountability through education and enforcement, and leveraging emerging data technology and analysis for smarter interventions.

Altogether, these efforts support a holistic citywide strategy with our sister agencies to eliminate traffic deaths and serious injuries by targeting behaviors, vehicles, and street conditions that inflict the most damage. The progress we've made under Vision Zero is remarkable, but we aren't satisfied, not when New Yorkers are still losing their lives on our streets. When Mayor Mamdani announced my appointment, he made clear our bold ambition to make our streetscape the envy of the world, and that starts with safety. In just nine and a half months, we've reinvigorated the work at our agency. We've advanced long-delayed street redesigns, we have ambitious new projects in the pipeline, and we're scaling up all the foundational resources we need to do more and do it faster: hiring additional staff, expanding work capacity with contractors, investing in new facilities and equipment, and so much more. I expect that this year we'll see record output at DOT, both quantity and quality, and will set a new high-water mark each and every year. We have a clear roadmap for where we're headed, and we're laser-focused on delivering. We want to keep our eye on the ball by following the data, prioritizing the projects that will have the greatest impact, and directing resources toward where they are needed. We see the Council as a vital partner in this work. We share your commitment to street safety and welcome ideas and oversight. However, discretion and flexibility are critical to our success.

In order to keep improving safety outcomes on our streets, we've seen in the past that well-intentioned mandates can curb our ability to adapt to the changing needs of the city's streetscapes. We're excited to work with Council to strike that balance and implement the most impactful projects possible. My ambition for DOT, and it's shared throughout the organization, is simple: to execute with purpose and urgency, because lives truly depend on it. Turning to the legislation before the Council today.

(00:20:13)

First, Intro 46, sponsored by Council Member... This bill would require DOT to install, at the request of a child's parent or legal guardian, warning signs with plaques to warn a motorist of the presence of a child with autism. Being an attentive and safe driver, cyclist, or pedestrian is extremely important for everyone sharing the street in any neighborhood. We support the intent of protecting vulnerable road users, and doing so is core to our agency's mission. However, guided by the federal Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices, or MUTCD, we use signage carefully. Both the manual and independent studies demonstrate that too many signs create visual clutter, which increases the chances that drivers will actually ignore signs with critical information. It's also important to acknowledge that research shows these specific types of signs don't make streets safer or change driver behavior. Finally, the system proposed would require substantial new staffing and funding. Without an effective removal process, we would be concerned to see these signs up on every block. We're happy to have further discussions with the Council about this bill and our rigorous process for street safety design interventions. Next, Intro 613, sponsored by Council Member...

(00:21:28)

Brooks-Powers. This bill would require DOT, in coordination with the Police Department and other appropriate agencies, to conduct an annual study of driving behavior to determine what behaviors are associated with traffic crashes, injuries, and fatalities. Our priority is enhancing street safety, which is driven by comprehensive data collection to inform the thoughtful implementation of new initiatives. By examining our streets, we're able to build safer streets that work to keep more New Yorkers safe while traveling. We support studies that help the city better understand equitable and targeted safety strategies, and we look forward to working with Council on a few suggested amendments to ensure comprehensive reporting. Next, Intro 613, sponsored by CM Joseph. This bill would require DOT to install 100 miles of protected bike lane per year for the next six years. Biking in New York City is safe and getting safer. The rate of cyclist deaths is trending down, but of course we have more to do. As part of the mayoral administration, we're excited to build up our in-house capacity and to deliver more transformative and ambitious street redesign projects. As demand for safe and comfortable bike routes increases, we're responding by expanding opportunities beyond just protected bike lanes, ensuring the tools we use are appropriate for each respective corridor.

We share the Council's goal to enhance safety by delivering protected bike lanes citywide, and we look forward to conversations with the Council on how to best implement these designs in an efficient and equitable way. As I said earlier in my testimony, mandates don't always adapt to our evolving city. You have an administration and a DOT that is committed to achieving shared goals, so let's work together to deliver the greatest possible impact on street safety while preserving the flexibility needed to do so. As always, we're happy to meet to address specific corridors in your district that need closer attention as well. Next, Intro 1070, sponsored by Chair Abreu. This bill would require DOT to establish a two-year low-traffic neighborhood pilot program to direct traffic away from residential areas, with 6,300 miles of streets and 12,000 miles of sidewalk. DOT is responsible for a vast and vital portion of the city's public space. Safety is our top priority when determining design treatments, and reclaiming roadway into vibrant public spaces increases safety by enhancing pedestrian comfort and flow. We're always thinking creatively about how we can reimagine and transform our streets into public space open to all. We support the goals of this bill, which would expand upon proven initiatives like Open Streets, pedestrian plazas, and even Trick or Streets, coming up this weekend, to ensure that our streets continue to be a valuable local asset across neighborhoods citywide.

We have thoughts on how best to define or structure low-traffic neighborhoods, and we're excited for future conversations on this subject. Next, Intro 1153, sponsored by CM Santos. This bill would require the city to establish a demonstration program for the installation and maintenance of intelligent speed assistance devices. The administration was proud to support the inclusion of intelligent speed

(00:24:37)

assistance, or ISA, in the state budget, which authorizes the city to implement a Stop Super Speeders pilot program. This would require a vehicle owner who racks up 16 or more adjudicated speed camera tickets in 12 months to install a speed limiter device. New York City has been a national leader in combating traffic violence, and our automated traffic enforcement cameras have been an effective intervention. But a small group of recidivist speeders continues to flagrantly endanger themselves and others. Technology like ISA can target and preempt these super speeders' dangerous behavior, as it prevents a vehicle from traveling fast enough to break the speed limit in the first place. Since local authorization is required under state law to stand up a program, we support this bill and look forward to future conversations to ensure the success of the pilot program. In conclusion, I'd like to thank the Council for the opportunity to testify before you today. We would now be happy to answer any questions.

(00:25:39)

We've been joined by Counselor Perino Sanchez. And Counselor Mariola, do you want to give your opening now? You can. Thank you so much.

(00:25:57)

Thank you, Chair, Majority Leader Abreu, and the Transportation Committee for hearing Intro 46. Intro 46 would allow parents and guardians of children with autism to request the warning signs from the Department of Transportation to make motorists aware that there are autistic children living nearby. For some children with autism, busy streets and traffic can present unique safety challenges, and these signs would serve as an additional reminder for motorists to slow down and be alert. This simple, common-sense measure can give parents some added peace of mind, and while doing so, help them to keep their children safe. This passage would be another step forward in protecting the most vulnerable among us. For the Commissioner of the Department of Transportation, I want to send a message to the families raising a child or children with autism: New York City does not see you, does not understand the challenges you face, and is not willing to take reasonable steps to help their children stay safe. I do not believe that there should be a cost put on the safety of children, especially children with autism. Thank you for your consideration and the time to speak about my bill.

(00:27:17)

Thank you, Council Member. All right.

(00:27:18)

Let's head to some questions now. This should have some questions on Vision Zero Reimagined. In September 2026, the administration released Vision Zero Reimagined, the 10-year action plan outlining strategies, including strong enforcement, safer street designs, and expanding the use of technology. While the goals set forth in this new plan are laudable, the devil is in the details, and we must make sure that they are implemented effectively, transparently, and in a timely manner. Commissioner, what specific measurable benchmarks would you use to evaluate progress under Vision Zero Reimagined, and how do these benchmarks differ from previous Vision Zero initiatives? Thank you, Chair.

(00:28:06)

Absolutely. We agree that we can only measure success if we're tracking these kinds of things, and that's why the plan includes a number of commitments that include numerical targets, whether it's implementing a thousand intersections with daylighting or better, or addressing the roughly 200 Vision Zero priority corridors. It also includes a commitment to creating a Vision Zero dashboard, which would be a place where you can find a whole lot of different kinds of information about the program and the results. Likewise, we'll have an update to the Streets Plan coming out in the next couple months, and that will include some additional targets and metrics that will be measuring other ideas as well. Thank you.

(00:28:59)

Commissioner, we'll get into those specific benchmarks, like

(00:29:04)

daylighting, later. For instance, what funding and staffing levels are necessary to implement the Vision Zero Reimagined plan? Ah, yes. We're really excited that the mayor made a historic level of commitment to our safety and multimodal programs earlier this year, and we have the resources to move ahead with the bulk of the Vision Zero plan. It is a 10-year strategy, so if there are additional resources needed, we will certainly be in constant communication with City Hall, and we'll be on that.

(00:29:40)

And are these resources currently available? We are ramping up. Yes, the new resources have kicked in as of 2027, so we've been in that process basically of staffing up, of expanding capacity, of different mechanisms for implementing things that we need to do, and that's all pretty far along in progress. That's great, and it's part

(00:30:05)

of the ramping up. Can you give examples of certain positions you're hiring for? Division... Where are you expanding that capacity? Sure. It's a mix of the folks who developed the projects, the folks who implement them, and the folks who have to maintain them, because you need all of that. But to give an order of magnitude, there's roughly 200 new headcount, about a little over a hundred of which is already pretty far along in the pipeline, and others are in progress. It takes time, obviously, to put out postings and hire, but we're moving quickly, and yes, those are distributed. It could be, we have different groups focused on different aspects, but that gives you an idea. Thank you. How frequently will DOT

(00:30:53)

publicly report on implementation of Vision Zero Reimagined initiatives? I think, okay, yeah. So I think, like I mentioned, we'll be setting up

(00:31:06)

the dashboard, and that's going to be, I think, the most frequently updated in terms of other things we can get back to. And are you envisioning that dashboard to provide updates regularly on your agency's ability to meet these benchmarks? Yeah, that's the idea, and of course at hearings you can share a lot

(00:31:26)

as well, right? Yes. How will the forthcoming Streets Plan incorporate or build upon the Vision Zero Reimagine initiatives?

(00:31:37)

Yes, so probably the biggest jumping-off point in the Streets Plan from the Vision Zero plan will be around those priority corridors. We were flushing those out basically, and we've been crunching the data. So the Streets Plan will include the new set of priority corridors that we're committing to redesigning and upgrading. It will also add specificity to some of the ideas that are in the Vision Zero action plan. I know the action plan is an action plan, right? So it has a series of different things. Some of them are further along in development than others, so some of them will be able to share more in the Streets Plan.

(00:32:22)

As a policy matter, how do you see the actualization of the Streets Plan? How does that impact Vision Zero initiatives? The Streets Plan, you can see it kind of as an umbrella for multiple plans. So it's one mechanism for flushing out and implementing elements of the Streets Plan, but it also, you know, the same could be said for our Bus Plan, Next Stop, Fast Buses. And, yeah, I guess in terms more

(00:32:57)

of the street design-related aspects, the Vision Zero plan would be more articulated in the Streets Plan. Thank you.

(00:33:06)

Vision Zero is incorporated into the operations of all the agencies on the Vision Zero Task Force, which is a coalition of agencies including the NYPD and the Business Integrity Commission, which I refer to as BIC for the remainder of the hearing, that meets every other week to review upcoming and ongoing projects, study progress on key measures, and share agency updates. Could you give us an overview of how the various agencies that are part of the Vision Zero Task Force worked

(00:33:36)

together? What happens in these meetings? Happy to, Chair.

(00:33:42)

My name is Madeline. Get closer to the mic. Sure thing. Madeline Laverty, Chief of Staff at DOT. The biweekly meetings have all of the agencies under this administration, including the Fire Department, the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities, and formerly the Department of Education, New York City Public Schools. It is a coalition where every piece of the toolkit is employed when it comes to addressing the trends that all of us are seeing from the data of collisions on the street, our enforcement trends, novel policy discussions, really everything driven by what we are seeing and novel ways that we can address it. So I imagine it's the full sort of kit and caboodle of government all working together. These meetings really do look at the fatality numbers. DOT provides a monthly fatalities dashboard, and the Mayor's Office of Operations, which convenes the Vision Zero Task Force, tracks metrics for all agencies to ensure that we are on track for the commitments we have made publicly, as well as our general MMR-level metrics. It is a highly collaborative group of staff members from each agency, well-positioned to work across agency and across the city in order to drive fatalities down.

(00:35:04)

So it's fair to say there's a lot of data sharing happening, a ton of data sharing and other updates regularly on project updates that you have.

(00:35:12)

Yes, absolutely. So, as there are large programs, for example from DOT, perhaps a large street re-engineering project, one might say Queens Boulevard, a legacy capital project, updates on things like that, as well as discussions on novel issues such as crashes. You know, the one that has been discussed a lot lately, I believe, in them, that public advocates' testimony and in hearings that occurred, as well as the one in where there are notable trends, even small numbers. That is when the Vision Zero team gets together to really figure out how to address it and discuss the best path forward.

(00:35:49)

And have you, in this past year, have you seen these meetings lead to policy changes?

(00:35:58)

Yeah, a great example is actually the cease and desist work that the Mayor announced recently. That work was really driven by the task force monitoring the illegal device trends that we have seen, both in enforcement and in collisions. We are really looking at working together to see what additional tools can be brought to the fore, bringing in the Law Department to really expand the pie when it comes to ways that we can get at reducing traffic fatalities.

(00:36:25)

Thank you. I am now going to turn over to some questions on enforcement for NYPD and LTE.

(00:36:34)

Vision Zero related moving summonses issued by NYPD have significantly fallen in recent years.

(00:36:39)

Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, in fiscal years 2018 and 2019, NYPD routinely issued nearly 700,000 Vision Zero related moving summonses annually. However, according to data from the Mayor's Management Reports, NYPD summons issuance has fallen every year since fiscal year 2019's level and is currently at just over 413,000 summonses in fiscal year 2026, a decline of about 41% from pre-pandemic levels.

(00:37:13)

Why has NYPD enforcement remained substantially below pre-pandemic levels? Is this attributed to staffing, deployment priorities, or a change in enforcement strategy?

(00:37:32)

Another Mike, thanks. Thanks very much, Chair.

(00:37:35)

So, of course, the pandemic had enormous disruptions in a variety of areas, and our traffic enforcement was no exception. That did result in decreases both in 2020 and then into a low in 2021. The pandemic did create a number of disruptions, and that led to decreases across a lot of areas, and one of those areas was traffic enforcement. That led to a low in 2021. Since that time, we have been issuing more summonses every year. We are up over 40% from that low in 2021. The other thing I would note is that we are not just writing tickets. We are focusing our enforcement where it is going to have the most impact and the most material benefits, and we are seeing those increases year over year. I think the results we are seeing, with fatalities being down, reflect on the quality of that work, the quality of the work being done.

(00:38:30)

A decline of 41% is

(00:38:33)

kind of astronomical. Is

(00:38:36)

the NYPD going to

(00:38:37)

get back to the pre-pandemic numbers?

(00:38:39)

We don't set a specific number of summonses we are going to be issuing. We are driven by the circumstances. We are driven by what officers see on the ground. What we focus on is deploying our resources where they have the most impact. We follow the data, we identify those areas where that impact is going to have the most benefit, so our enforcement is following from that data.

(00:39:02)

So what I am hearing is a lack of a commitment to get back to pre-pandemic enforcement.

(00:39:09)

I think what I would say is that the number of tickets being written is not the end goal. Here, enforcement is going to follow the data. We are going to look to where we need to go to deploy those resources to keep our streets

(00:39:20)

safe. I mean, I think there is clearly an enforcement strategy that is changing here, because we see enforcement in some areas go up, but it is going dramatically down in this area. There is a change in enforcement strategy here. Well,

(00:39:38)

we're following the data. When it comes to issuing summonses, what we look at is the areas where that is going to have the most impact. So we look at our high-visibility corridors and we deploy our resources there, and our enforcement follows from that. We work at the precinct level, in areas that are going to have the highest risk, and that's based on fatality data, collision data, traffic data. We are deploying resources there, so our overall enforcement strategy is following that data.

(00:40:02)

So you're talking about following the data, right? Is your data showing that folks are not flouting traffic laws as much as they used to? Well, I think what, please answer the question. Thank you.

(00:40:14)

Thanks, Chair. Our enforcement data is what you've seen, and what's in front of you. Officers are writing tickets where they see violations. When they see

(00:40:22)

violations, are they not seeing them?

(00:40:23)

They're seeing violations. Are they seeing violations at the same levels as pre-pandemic, or more? Well, as I said, I'm just talking about the data here. What are you... I want to know what the data is telling you.

(00:40:34)

The data is telling us that we're up over 40% since 2021, and we're increasing every year. But you're not committing to doing pre-pandemic numbers. So I understand you're going up since 2021, but there is no commitment to get to pre-pandemic

(00:40:45)

levels. We don't think that writing tickets for tickets' sake is the answer. It's not the number of tickets, it's the quality of enforcement. If the data warranted 700,000 tickets a year...

(00:40:57)

Well, I'll let Chief Obey speak.

(00:40:59)

To our eyes, my expectation would be that, yes, the data you're seeing on the ground would warrant more than 700,000 tickets a year. Good morning, sorry, good morning. We do acknowledge the decline in Vision Zero summonses. I do want to mention that our commitment to Vision Zero remains unchanged. The traffic landscape in 2019 changed significantly from what we see in 2025, and what we are currently seeing in 2026. As things change, we have to pivot and address traffic safety outcomes, a change in travel patterns, new technology, and the department's wide enforcement responsibilities. As we heard earlier in the testimony, I just want to highlight a few things. First,

(00:41:47)

traffic fatalities and pedestrian safety will always be our goal. As you heard, in 2025 we reported 110 traffic fatalities, compared to 152 in 2024 and 2019. When you look at pedestrian fatalities, we are at a rate through 2018, and that also dropped to 73 versus 86. Who is concerned about our seniors? That also shows a significant decline, 26 versus 41. This year, 2026, is amongst the lower year-to-date totals in the department's historical trends. Again, when it comes to Vision Zero, our efforts are always centered around what we call the three E's: enforcement, engineering, and education. Another pivot we had to do was with the growth from 2019 to what we saw in 2025 and 2026. We talked about this a little at the last hearing: the growth of two-wheeled motorized devices. The landscape is totally different. Post-pandemic growth in e-bikes, stand-up mopeds, motorcycles, and

(00:42:51)

motorcycles, enough road

(00:42:53)

vehicles, required us to devote more attention to illegal vehicles and dangerous riding behavior. This, of course, is on enforcement, seizures, and inspections of retailers. We talked about this a little. Retailers selling non-compliant devices. Just very quickly, with data, when you look

(00:43:09)

at our two-wheeled device enforcement, motorcycle

(00:43:13)

seizures. Again, comparing 2025 to 2019: motorcycle seizures in 2025 were 5,567, versus 2,169 in 2019. Moped seizures in 2025 were 14,421, versus 1,610 in 2019. Okay, one says

(00:43:48)

motorcycle moving summonses, 57,009 versus 23,942 in 2019.

(00:43:55)

Moving summonses 20,054 versus 11,000 in 2019. Traffic enforcement is

(00:44:03)

focused overwhelmingly on cars

(00:44:05)

and SUVs, as they are the biggest category in causing serious injuries and fatalities. Year-to-date 2026, 81.2% of our moving enforcement is accounted for by cars and SUVs. When you look at 2025 micro-mobility

(00:44:20)

enforcement, again, I mentioned

(00:44:21)

at the last hearing, accounted for 10,001 e-bikes and 468 standard scooter moving violations through September 2026. This is the

(00:44:33)

point-of-sale initiative. 63 stores inspected, 57 summonses issued. We work closely with our partners in DOT in identifying and preventing illegal devices from entering streets. Another way in which we pivoted is automated enforcement. Enforcement emphasis on reckless behavior, including

(00:44:37)

ghost plates. You talk about

(00:44:51)

automated enforcement. Now it supplements enforcement around the clock on city streets. New York City speed cameras began operating 24/7 in August 2022, and the network includes more than 2,200 cameras and 750 school speed zones. As of this year, red light cameras were expanded to 600 intersections. These systems support consistent enforcement at locations where our officers can focus on driver behavior, such as reckless driving, suspended or revoked driving privileges, and fraudulent identification. Data for reckless behavior. Again, we're going to compare 2025 to... I know you're going to cut

(00:44:54)

me off. Yeah, I don't. Okay. You are saying that

(00:45:30)

part of the decline in enforcement is due to an increase in micro-mobility enforcement. But are many micro-mobility tickets considered Vision Zero summonses? For example, a motorcycle moving violation is a Vision Zero summons. So I just, the point here is to

(00:45:36)

because your question is why the drop. As we saw, changes. Micro-mobility wasn't a big thing in 2019. It's huge now, 2025 and 2026. Okay. So it's a combination of micro-mobility enforcement, automated enforcement, and ghost plates. We've seen a huge increase in those. Also, we've paid attention to pedestrian right-of-way collision injuries, in writing right-away summonses, and also, old Simon says. So it's a combination of factors, high-visibility corridors.

(00:46:37)

So let me ask you, is the suggestion that there's lower enforcement because of increased camera enforcement? For

(00:46:45)

example, it's a combination. This is surprising to hear, because while enforcement cameras like red light and speed cameras have slowly come online over the past few years, the moving summonses quickly dropped in 2020 and then plateaued. How do you explain this timing difference between when summonses dropped and when cameras became more widely used? So again, it's not just the cameras. It's a combination of things. We just had to address these changes as we saw the traffic landscape change. So with some

(00:47:16)

Oh, okay. Yeah, Jerry, I think one

(00:47:19)

additional point: when we're looking at moving violations in our Vision Zero summonses that are most responsible for injuries, especially for pedestrian injuries, we're seeing enforcement up there. We're targeting enforcement there. So things like disobeying traffic signs, signs were up almost 13%. For improper turns, up 8.6%. For failure to yield the right-of-way to pedestrians, an extremely important aspect for pedestrian safety, we're up 4.4 percent. I appreciate that

(00:47:46)

progress, but I have to get back to your point from earlier, where you said higher summonses are not a goal. Then why is it in the

(00:47:52)

desired direction of being up? I think that's calculated differently from the way we do it. I think that's counter year-over-year to date. So maybe a little difference

(00:48:04)

there. All right, all right. How does

(00:48:09)

NYPD determine where to prioritize enforcement of speeding, failure to yield, and other dangerous moving violations? We're looking at... we work in collaboration with our partners at DOT to identify those areas where the risk is highest. That's looking at the data. As I said, we're looking at fatalities, we look at collisions, we look at injuries, and using that information, we collaborate to identify the areas where enforcement is the most important. And do you need more officers to adequately enforce dangerous moving violations? I understand this past year there was, you know, the request for 5,000 additional officers that were made. I'm asking because if you need more resources, I want to make sure you get them.

(00:48:48)

Especially as we are approaching budget season next

(00:48:51)

year. In a perfect world, we would want more officers. Of course, in a perfect world, unconstrained by resources, we would have everything that we could have. But based on the number of officers we have now, based on our current headcount, we're certain we're able to do our best in terms of the enforcement we have.

(00:49:05)

And with an additional 5,000 officers, you think you'll be able to reach 700,000 summonses a

(00:49:11)

year? I mean, with an extra 10,000 officers, 20,000 officers, and the more resources we have available, the more we're going to be able to do.

(00:49:16)

But we obviously understand that we don't live in a world where we can simply have whatever, an unlimited number. We live in a resource-constrained world. You would like more officers, that's right, of course.

(00:49:27)

All right, I'm going to go ask questions of coordination now, between the agencies.

(00:49:32)

NYPD remains primarily responsible for enforcing moving violations, while DOT oversees street design and much of the city's automated enforcement infrastructure.

(00:49:43)

Has the administration considered expanding DOT's

(00:49:44)

authority to enforce certain traffic violations or investigate serious crashes? I think hopefully it's evident in the Vision Zero Reimagined plan that we're always trying to think creatively about all aspects of Vision Zero enforcement, being one of them. We're really proud of the impact of the automated enforcement program, and we're giving a lot of thought to that as well, with the state legislative session ahead of us. And on manual enforcement, we collaborate really closely and really well with, as you just heard... What about towing capacity to enforce parking laws? Does the OTS, your NYPD, need increased capacity? I can say, maybe not specifically your parking lots, but just for the... it's worth. When we're redesigning a

(00:50:37)

street or repaving a street, we do have the capability of DOT to tow vehicles out of the way. I would defer to my colleagues at DOT. Do you need more towing capacity to get cars off the road? The towing capacity right now is sufficient for our enforcement goals. As you know, Chair, we had a tow pound in Manhattan that we lost several years ago because of a change in state law. We've been working to try to find a replacement location. That's a difficult thing to do in Manhattan real estate. It's something we're working actively towards, but with what we have now, we're able to do the work.

(00:51:11)

Are there any responsibilities that could be transferred from DOT to towing capacity that we all have spoken about? I can't say we've had those conversations.

(00:51:31)

All right, I have questions on what is the coordination. Right, actually, what is the coordination between DOT and the NYPD? How do you coordinate on crash investigations, for instance?

(00:51:47)

And how does the DOT's relationship with NYPD inform implementable safety improvements? Sure, happy to discuss our collaboration. One of the great parts about our Vision Zero partnership with the NYPD is that we're co-located at our Traffic Management Center in Queens, and so when information comes in that there has been a collision, we are there together and receive that information at the same time. NYPD obviously responds to do its investigations. DOT also responds in person in the

(00:51:49)

field to assess the conditions on the ground, assess if there

(00:51:58)

is immediate fixes required to make the locations safe, such as a down sign or other sorts of issues that can be immediately repaired. And then, of course, we continue. As NYPD collects more information, we receive that information, and in the stream of our data work, we use NYPD's crash data to analyze and find those trends, and to assess individual crashes. DOT then works on any sort of redesign plans or other sort of policy and implementation after the fact for a given crash. But we work very closely, both in the immediate and in the near term, as well as in the overall holistic work, when we respond and how we share data and how we collaborate on how we respond, both from a policy perspective as well as from a response perspective.

(00:52:19)

On the enforcement end, great partners. DOT, as you heard, is co-located in the shared space Traffic Management Center. We share the data. We have the multi-agency Vision Zero meetings. On the education end, which is one of the three E's, every season brings its own challenges. We worked with DOT to inform the public about traffic safety initiatives. So far in 2026, 21 education initiatives were scheduled, of which 18 of the 21 have been completed. Right now we're working with them, and we have the wonderful... thanks to DOT. We have a Halloween traffic safety campaign. We're working hand in hand on this. I think about 30,000 flyers were created. So there's a work with... we're working with you, and we appreciate the work.

(00:52:23)

Thank you, Chief Obey. You mentioned monthly meetings. Are you referring to the task force?

(00:53:11)

Yes, the task force is on those biweekly meetings. If I can add, in addition to the Vision Zero task force meetings, we have a specific DOT-NYPD monthly meeting where we also go through the dashboard in detail.

(00:53:53)

And look at whether there are specific location additions. So it's in addition. We must have lots of different groups. Yes.

(00:53:58)

All right. The NYPD's Collision Investigation Squad only investigates critical injuries, meaning only a very small percentage of total collisions are directed to the CIS, Collision Investigation Squad.

(00:54:13)

What is the difference between how an instance of criminal road violence would be investigated by the CIS versus by a traditional precinct? The CIS, as you said, is an elite unit that's focused on... Sorry, please be

(00:54:22)

(00:54:40)

(00:54:53)

That's focused specifically on this issue of these collisions that result in fatalities or the most serious injuries, and that work that they do is very specific. When a case comes into them, it is going to involve freezing the street, gathering every piece of evidence off the street that they can. Gathering every piece of video. It is a very intensive process, an extensive process, and it delivers fantastic results. Last year, 75% of hit-and-run cases where the vehicle was identified were able to do all that work, because we dedicate tremendous resources to that. It is such a resource-intensive process. It is a process that we are going to be using in those fatality cases and those most serious injuries. In the case of other investigations, those will be referred to the precincts. Those will go to the detective squads, and those cases will move forward under the detective squads.

(00:55:54)

And what would you say qualifies as a serious injury?

(00:56:00)

Chief... the determination has become more... but this is a case where there is a fatality, where there is a likely fatality or there is a critical injury. Those determinations that are made are generally made by a hospital. In August 2026, there was a string of deadly road violence in New York City that brought renewed scrutiny to the City's Vision Zero efforts. Tragically, hit-and-run drivers killed nine people in the month, including three cyclists in just three days. And just this past week, a man riding an e-bike was hit and gravely injured by a hit-and-run driver in Crown Heights. How many of these recent hit-and-run cases have been fully investigated and resolved by NYPD?

(00:56:37)

Um, so, Chairman, as I said, these cases are very

(00:56:42)

extensively investigated. Those investigations can take up to six months or longer, so looking at those timelines, those investigations are likely to be ongoing. I can't speak to any specific investigation, but I can say that we do thorough investigations of all of those cases and deliver the results they find. So, I cannot speak to the ones currently being investigated. What I can do is we can look into those and come back to you with that information.

(00:57:06)

What is the procedure for closing a case, a serious injury or fatality? What is done regarding a case being

(00:57:16)

investigated by CIS? Okay, so, with what Director Ropa Chino mentioned, critical injury, likely to die, or fatal, where we actually have someone that has actually passed away, I would say there is extensive work that involves conferring with the DA's office. When that's all wrapped up at some point, then it's closed.

(00:57:46)

From start to finish. Essentially, what, of the 75%

(00:57:54)

of those that were identified as part of the CIS investigations,

(00:58:00)

what percent of those resulted in an arrest? I think it's about two-thirds of those cases are resulting in arrest.

(00:58:06)

And I saw two-thirds of the 75%. And I don't want to highlight that in some cases, the fact that there is no arrest is because there might not actually have been criminality there. Leaving the scene charges are going to be brought when somebody knows that they've struck another individual, that there is an injury, and then they have left the scene. In some instances, our investigation will reveal that the driver didn't have knowledge of the collision, so that accounts for some percent of those. So, what's the breakdown of the percent of folks who engage in criminality versus those who didn't? I don't think that we have those numbers here, but we'll get those for you and share and follow up.

(00:58:50)

That would be great. And then, so, what happened with the other 25% that weren't identified? Why do you think that happened? These are difficult cases. I mean, by definition, the perpetrator, the person who caused the collision, is not on the scene. That presents significant challenges. We use every tool at our disposal in order to try to identify those individuals, in order to identify those vehicles. And as I said, that's a really extensive process. We throw everything we possibly can at it. Chief, okay, I don't know if you want to add anything more to that.

(00:58:59)

The perpetrator is the person who caused the collision. That person is not on the scene, which presents significant challenges. We use every tool at our disposal in order to try to identify those individuals.

(00:59:13)

So I'll go with the numbers: year to date through 2026, 212 CIS cases. As we mentioned, the fatalities, 167 of the 200 fatal, and 45 of the 212 non-fatal. So this is just strictly cases, 212 total, 2026 year to date. Year-to-date total criminal cases: 77 of the 212, about 36%. Again, confirmed with the DA's office, deemed to be criminal. Total fatal criminal cases, the status is 63 of the 77, accounting for 80 to 81% of all criminal cases. 40 of the 63 are closed. A total of non-criminal, 14 of the 77, 91% are close to arrest.

(00:59:21)

So I'll go with the numbers. The year to date through 2018, there were 212 cases. As we mentioned, the fatalities, 167 of the 200 fatal, and 45 of the 212 nonfatal. So this is just strictly cases, 212 for 2026 year to date.

Year to date total criminal cases, 77 of the 212. Again, confirmed with the DA's office, deemed to be criminal. The total fatal criminal cases, the status is 63 of the 77, which account for 80 to 81% of all criminal cases. 40 of the 63 are closed, and a total of 14 of the 77 are non-criminal, which are close to...

(01:00:11)

What have the trends been in identifying those drivers involved in hit-and-runs over the past five years? I can speak right off the top of my head, just speaking to the extensive work our Director Pacino mentioned. Without saying too much about this particular fatality, in some cases, I'll speak very generally, some of these operators flee out of the country. In this one case, this particular operator fled to a particular country. After six or seven months, again working with partners, he was brought back to the country to face justice. And recently we had one, this was published, we had Ocean Parkway, was apprehended. So this is the type of work that goes into the cases. My question is, what are the trends right now, broadly, with respect to the Police Department identifying hit-and-run drivers? I know you say it's 75%. Has it been trending upwards or downwards over the past five years in identifying the drivers involved in hit-and-runs? Okay, so.

(01:00:12)

With hit-and-runs in general,

(01:01:19)

where we have our injuries, the policy itself is: officer gets there, assesses the scene. If there's an injury, you call. If it is a serious injury, then that case is referred to a precinct detective squad. If it is critical, likely to die, is determined by then. Last year, so identified as percent of drivers involved ahead of

(01:01:23)

runs. What was the rate the year before that, and the year before?

(01:01:49)

What was the... what was the...

(01:01:51)

That, I'm just trying to see what the trend has been. We can get that to you. We don't have

(01:01:53)

collisions to help the NYPD close more cases. So when the gets a case, because of the intensive investigative resources that are put into that case, those rates are going to be higher. We again live in a world of not infinite resources. There are limits on everything that we can do. And so we identify those cases that are highest priority for us: those fatalities, those most serious injuries.

(01:01:56)

And those are the ones that CIS is taking on. So on June 23, 2026, a bike advocate was struck in Midtown by a turning vehicle. The driver fled the scene and was unable to walk for six weeks after being struck and run over. Crash, unlike many hit-and-runs, was caught on video. However, despite this evidence, the case was closed by a local precinct and not escalated to CIS. Why was this case not escalated to CIS? To say that that circumstance and what that individual suffered was horrible. Um, I second want to say that I can't speak to the individual details about the investigation in that case. What I can say generally is that we are committed to using all of the resources available to try to capture, to understand what happened in the case of a collision when there's a hit-and-run driver, to identify the individual responsible, and to bring justice and enforcement where it's appropriate. I mean, this sounds like a perfect case for CIS. I mean, serious injury, there's a hit-and-run, looks likely, some of that means leaving the scene of a crime, so there's a criminal implication there. Would you agree that this is a perfect case for CIS to be covering under our current procedures? CIS is going to be taking cases overwhelmingly, unless there's a fatality. Thankfully, it's a fatality, thankfully. Likely fatality, luckily this was not, he wasn't to walk for six

(01:02:26)

And those are the ones that the department is taking on. So on June 23, 2026, a V-BAR advocate was struck in Midtown by a turning vehicle. The driver fled the scene and was unable to walk for six weeks after being struck.

And run over the... crash. Unlike many hit-and-runs, this was caught on video. However, despite this evidence, the case was closed by a local precinct and not escalated. Why was this case not escalated to the... to say that that circumstance, and what that individual suffered, was horrible?

I second want to say that I can't speak to the individual details about the investigation in that case. What I can say generally is that we are committed to using all of the resources available to try to capture, to understand what happened in the case of a collision when there is a hit-and-run driver, to identify the individual responsible and to bring justice and enforcement where it is appropriate.

I mean, this sounds like a perfect case for SIS. I mean, serious injury. There is a hit-and-run, it looks likely. That means, leaving the scene of a crime. So there is a criminal implication there. Would you agree that this is a perfect case for us to be covering under our current procedures? Our SIS is going to be taking cases overwhelmingly, unless there is a fatality. Thankfully, likely fatality, luckily this was not what he... wasn't to walk for six

(01:02:33)

matter will be informed by the hospital, or that an individual is fatal. It is likely to be fatal, and that's the case. The incidence in this specific instance, are you aware of the hospital indicating that this individual had a serious injury?

(01:03:54)

weeks. Yeah, so those

(01:03:56)

determinations you were talking about earlier. I was trying to ask you about what a serious injury would be. This sounds to me like a very serious

(01:04:02)

injury. So under our current

(01:04:03)

procedures, that's generally defined as being a critical injury, and that's the determination that we make. That's a determination that's made by or by a hospital. And do you know how the hospital made a determination that was a critical injury? Are you saying it was a hospital decision to label it a critical injury, and therefore you didn't get involved? I'm not trying to make a strong man, I'm trying to standardize the implications. So I can't speak to the specifics of this investigation, this case. We can look into that and get back

(01:04:28)

to you. So how do

(01:04:29)

does NYPD know when there's a serious injury or not?

(01:04:31)

So, as a general matter, it will be informed by the hospital, or that an individual is fatal, it's likely to be fatal. And that's the case. The incidence in this specific instance, are you aware of the hospital indicating that this individual had a serious injury?

(01:04:33)

A general matter. If it's critical injury, that's something, injury that's something that we would... this is something that is being done that is transported to you in real time, in real time, via the telephone. Is there some receipt we can probably try to obtain to get more information on this? Chief, you know, the form in which those are coming over. I'm sorry, can you just... my question is, I'm trying to understand how, when the NYPD learns in real time whether or not an injury is critical.

Okay, and I'm trying to understand if there were some communication from EMS or from the hospital transported to you guys that made it such that this individual wasn't being perceived as having a serious...

(01:04:49)

I can't speak to the specific instance, but we can look into that and certainly get back to you. I would say, as a general matter, if it's critical injury, that's something, injury that's something that we would... this is something that is being done, that is transported to you in real time. In real time, via the telephone, is there some receipt we can probably try to obtain to get more information on this? Chief, you know, the form in which those are coming over. I'm sorry, can you just... my question is, I'm trying to understand how, when the NYPD learns in real time whether or not an injury is critical. Okay, and I'm trying to understand if there were some communication from EMS or from the hospital transported to you guys that made it such that this individual wasn't being perceived as having a serious

(01:04:52)

The city, at the state level, how can we, you know, do something in lockstep on this that you guys deeply care about? If any of you have any ideas, please. Well, Charite, as Chief said, this is an issue that we take very seriously. We dedicate substantial enforcement resources to it.

We would welcome innovations in the law that could address these problems. I don't have anything to propose for you here today, but it's something we're very eager to engage on, to try to solve this.

(01:05:31)

injury. Okay, so because of

(01:05:32)

that, that way we can try to obtain the facts. Like Director Pacino said, we can't speak to this particular case, but I will tell you, at the scene of the incident, the initial scene when this collision happens, our officers respond. Also, if it is called, they respond. If the injuries are serious enough, where it is determined that this particular person is critical, likely to die, the person is dead or critical, that a responding unit will call, they will respond. We also have situations where people are conscious and alert and they die at the hospital. In that case, also, it is called.

(01:06:11)

So we will handle all critical, likely to die, all fatalities, serious injuries. We can't speak to this particular case, or reach out to your office to speak to you a little more about it. But

(01:06:21)

to your question with criticality, we respond and CIS handles it. But this case, we're going to have to get back to you on that. So, CIS investigates about 150 to 200 crashes per year. Despite there being many more crashes in our city that result in death and serious injury, why is this number so low, and do the CIS requires more resources? So, the criteria again for CIS is: there are some critical injuries, seriously likely to die. Those are the cases that we will handle. So, what's the second half of the question? Despite there being many more crashes in our city that result in death and serious injury, why is this number so low?

(01:07:16)

Chair, I think, again, what I would point to is that there isn't the space, perhaps, between a serious injury and what is designated as a critical injury. I don't want it in any way to take away from how life-affecting a crash can be and how serious injuries can be in those instances. But the procedures that we have in place are for when that injury crosses over to being a critical injury, based on

(01:07:41)

determinations that are made by or at a hospital, and those critical injuries are those instances, or those fatalities, or likely to be fatal, where we're going to have an investigation. Do you believe that all hit-and-run cases should be placed under investigation?

(01:07:57)

As I, as I said earlier, Chair, and you might get sick of me saying it, but we are aware of the fact that we don't live in an instance where we have unlimited resources all the time, and it's not necessarily just resources that we're talking about here. Investigations are really intensive, extensive investigations that have widespread impact. We use those resources in the most serious cases. That's the process that we have, and that's not to take away from the investigation that goes on. When CIS is not involved, those cases are going to a detective squad, and they are thoroughly investigated.

(01:08:31)

And as I said earlier, this is, I'm asking all these questions.

(01:08:33)

Because I want to make sure

(01:08:35)

that CIS has the resources. Do you need more officers for CIS? I mean, we want to make sure that the head of our spiking, and we want to increase the identification rates. We want to increase the arrest rates. What do you need from us?

(01:08:50)

What should we, what should we advocate for? So, Sharon, the first instance, I want to say three things here. I think first of all, I just reiterate, obviously we would take respect to decisions about how to allocate resources, how to do assignments in the departments. That's something that we're constantly looking at, re-evaluating and making new determinations on, to shift resources where they are needed. And then third, with respect to the upcoming budget going forward, the Commissioner will be looking forward to being in touch with Council about that process as we move into that.

(01:09:21)

Process, and as we move into that process, I'm going to be looking for, you know, more enforcement on moving violations. CIS, if you need more resources to beef up the pursuit of these hit-and-run drivers, consider me a partner. A few more questions, and then I'll turn over to my

(01:09:38)

colleagues. Ghost plates, obscured license plates, and ghost plates are unfortunately frequently seen in New York City, allowing drivers to evade tolls and camera-based enforcement.

(01:09:48)

In a 2024 report, the City Comptroller found that between and June 2023, over a million speed camera violations had to be thrown out due to obscured or ghost plates, which represented 22% of all camera-based violations over that period. What of targeted

(01:10:07)

enforcement action does NYPD take against obscured or ghost license plates? Okay, so, um, I'll address the ghost plate operations that we conduct across bridges and tunnels in the City. We work closely with other partners, New York State Police. In 2026 operations, through 10/18, we've had 31 joint operations resulting in 440 arrests, 18,805 summonses, 1,937 vehicle seizures, and 64 motorcycle and more ATV seizures. More generally, locally on the ground, we have addressed this reckless behavior with obstructed plate moving summonses. In 2025, I don't have the 2026 numbers, 430,058 obstructed plate parking summonses, mostly by our agents. We also address reckless driving criminal summonses, reckless driving arrests, and fraudulent tag arrests. So it's something that we take seriously, and we have great data to support the work. If I

(01:11:23)

could just add, please, I think also going back to an earlier point, this is an area that we recognize is very critical path, addressing ghost plates. That's why it was included in the Vision Zero Reimagined as one of the initiatives. It's also an example where expanded use of automated enforcement can free up NYPD resources to be able to focus on the things that really benefit from more manual enforcement, ghost plates being one of them.

(01:11:54)

Commissioner, thank you for that. So what further changes in regulation or laws should the City seek in order to combat ghost plates? Should we pursue increased penalties, more frequent impoundment, greater towing capacity? What should we, at the City and at the State level, how can we, you know, do something in lockstep on this that you all deeply care about? If any of you have any ideas, please. Well, Chair, as Chief said, this is an issue that we take very seriously. We dedicate substantial enforcement resources to it. We would welcome innovations in the law that could address these problems. I don't have anything to propose for you here today, but it's something we're very eager to engage on to try to solve this

(01:12:12)

The City at the state level — how can we do something in lockstep on this that you guys deeply care about? If any of you guys have any ideas... Well, Chair, as the chief said, this is an issue that we take very seriously. We dedicate substantial enforcement resources to it. We would welcome innovations in the law that could address these problems. I do not have anything to propose for you here today but it is something we are very eager to engage on to try to solve this.

(01:12:41)

problem. And in terms of location, how does NYPD determine

(01:12:44)

where to conduct target and license plate enforcement actions? Um, like I mentioned, we work with other partners. The City, locally, also local streets, stemming from complaints we have, are also involved too. So, it just, we kind of go all over for the most part.

(01:13:05)

Thank you. And I have to say that, you know, you're, you're Chief, Obey, your team has been incredible within target enforcement actions in my district, and we have been seeing results. So I would like to recognize, when joined by CM Haneef on Zoom, CM Restler, for questions, we begin with CM Long, followed by Santosuosso. So, um, thank you, thank you.

(01:13:31)

Chair, my questions are to Chief Obey and Chief O'Brien. Chief, sir, thank you both for your help with the traffic enforcement in my district and for the collision investigation in the Glendale case. You have both been responsive and I really appreciate it. But I am very concerned and frustrated with the 104th Precinct. As you know, two weeks ago a 12-year-old child was severely injured at the corner of 75th Avenue and 60th Lane. He was hit by a motor vehicle speeding. From the videos my office collected, not the precinct, the driver was at best running a yellow light, or worse, going through a red light. Basic police work was not done. The report was completed incorrectly with omissions and errors, and has since been amended, and still needs to be corrected.

That is unacceptable. My office had to call your office to get additional help with the precinct, and this should have been handled by the precinct itself. Frankly, I find it unacceptable, the actions or lack of response from the 104th Precinct. I appreciate being able to reach both of you, but families should not need Council Members to call a chief to get the precinct to do the job. My question to Chief Obey: could you speak directly with precinct commanding officers about what is expected when someone is seriously injured, nearly killed, in this case, especially a 12-year-old child? Gathering evidence, preparing accurate reports, and knowing when to request highway assistance would be helpful. Please answer them.

(01:15:30)

Thank you. I cannot speak to the particular case you referenced, but I can tell you that we do have a forum called TrafficStat, where we address concerns like this. I have also spoken to Chief Green, and you worked very closely with the borough, so it is something that we take seriously and will continue to address. Okay. I will get to TrafficStat in a minute, but I appreciate that. Highway has the 104th Precinct and handles collision reports. Generally, could you reveal how those reports are prepared or checked by supervisors and corrected when errors are identified? How does that system work when you see errors?

(01:16:08)

So there are audits in place that trip traffic safety teams within precincts. In this particular case, it seems you are saying there is a discrepancy in how the report was written. I think it has been handled again by Highway, and I think it is prudent that we wait until they come to some resolution.

(01:16:32)

Okay. As a follow-up question, since you mentioned TrafficStat meetings, I do not see any public records that I could review. Are these like minutes or records available? Did anybody know, yes, that those TrafficStat meetings, like CompStat meetings, are internal Police Department meetings? We need to have confidentiality in order to have truly frank and honest conversations about exactly what needs to be done. That is an important part of our operational procedure. But the results that are coming out of those are things that will be communicated out as appropriate. Okay. My follow-up question would be: when we identify dangerous intersections like in this case where a child was hit, community boards were notified, my office has been notified, and what is the process that gets escalated to the traffic priority list at an intersection? How would I know, or how would we know, that it made it to your priority list?

(01:17:50)

So it would take a look at data. I have not personally looked at that location, but we could certainly get back to your office. We will speak to the borough itself, from Queens North, who will speak to the local precinct, and get a number of operations in place, and will support the initiatives. But typically we would go where the data takes us, where we see spikes in fatalities, injuries, or collisions.

(01:18:14)

So I cannot speak to this particular intersection where the collision happened, but that is typically our response.

(01:18:22)

Okay, okay. Thank you, thank you. Charles, I have a round two. Questions later. That sounds great. CM Santos will...

(01:18:29)

Also followed by CM Justin Sanchez.

(01:18:32)

Thank you, Chair. Commissioner Flynn, thank you. First of all, again, thank you for the Seventeenth Avenue bridge. I am going to keep thanking you because I am thrilled. And thank you for being of the same mind on the Super Speeders Act. At this point, advocates are mostly concerned about the timeline for implementation of the state bill that was passed. Is it possible, and if not, what barriers are there to timely implementation? Thank you, Council Member, and thank you for being such a great partner on this legislation. We are very proud to have championed the state legislation and appreciate the Council's partnership to move it forward. We are very eager to stand the program up as quickly as humanly possible. It is a very new program. This is going to be among the first in the nation, and probably the largest at this scale, so there is a lot of complexity there. There is software and back-end work. There are also things that are dependent on partners we need to work with, and generally the coordination, for example, with the Department of Finance, the State Department of Motor Vehicles. So there will be some aspects of the schedule that are more under our control than others. Our commitment is to do it as quickly as possible.

I could talk a little more specifically about some of the other schedule aspects, but one thing we would like to do in any scenario is, if there are things that are maybe out of our control for the full program rollout, at least get some early elements and testing going in the meantime. Okay, understood.

(01:18:52)

The other question I have is a practicality question, and it goes back to the chair's question about ghost plates. Unfortunately, a large number of these super speeders have vehicles that are registered in another state. If I understand it, can we at least ensure that the escalated fine that results from failing to install a device... well, first of all, can we order the installation of a device for a vehicle registered in another state? Correct. Correct. Okay. And then the escalating fine that would be incurred if they failed to install such a device could also be issued? Correct.

(01:20:21)

Yes. Okay, but otherwise, the piece of this that is missing is that clearly we cannot withdraw the driver's ability to register a vehicle from another state.

(01:21:00)

That is right. I think we can suspend their privilege to drive in New York State. Okay.

(01:21:04)

Okay, so it could be a license suspension. In other words, as far as I understand, the legislation does not call for a license suspension. It calls for a failure to register if you are registered in the state. It is a violation.

(01:21:11)

Okay. Well, I am not sure about that.

(01:21:18)

So the violations are sort of returnable too, TVBs. So there is the ability to have an accountability measure. But to your point, obviously these vehicles and their drivers are not registered with New York. So if they are found in New York State, there is the potential for a violation and to go to traffic court. Got it. Okay. And so a true sort of interstate cooperation in terms of a failure, I am sorry, a prohibition on the re-registration of a vehicle within another state is not possible at this point, I do not believe so. Okay. I know that there is some language in the law that allows us to basically account for the possibility of multiple vehicle registrations in New York State, right? Interstate, right? That is more complex. Yeah, and it just makes cracking down on the ghost plates an even more critical piece of this. I think, as we already spoke about.

(01:21:33)

I do want to turn the remainder of my time to the NYPD on a separate matter, which is the issue of drag racing. Drag racing and street racing. I represent Southern Brooklyn. It is a hotbed of drag racing and street racing, particularly along the Belt Parkway. Notably, at the end of, there were three teenagers who were killed in an extremely high-speed crash. One of the vehicles was shocking to someone who does not live next to the Belt Parkway, as I do. But what was even more shocking and distressing is that the night after three teenagers were killed in an act of street racing on the Belt Parkway, I could still hear the high-speed street racing taking place on the Belt Parkway the following night. So my office and Senator Kennard wrote a letter to the Highway Inspection, or the Highway Unit, asking what kind of enforcement was going to be going on, because this is a constant problem, and I am begging for help. If I could have 20 more seconds, Chair. The inspector responded with a letter detailing some enforcement efforts. It is one of those scenarios where I do not mean to question that work is being done, but I might be questioning that this work is not in fact solving the problem, because if I can hear it every single day from my window, something is wrong. So I am both begging for help and also asking for some kind of change in what we are doing, because it is clearly not working. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Good morning, Deputy Chief Thomas Alpes.

I am the Executive Officer of the Patrol Services Bureau. What you are talking about, car meets and street takeovers, is a high priority for NYPD. We understand that it is a danger to public safety and traffic safety overall. And you...

(01:22:33)

Cameras, or for intelligence gathering and prosecution on the back end, to help us identify these individuals engaged in this illegal behavior. So we also coordinate with our adjacent law enforcement agencies in Nassau County and Westchester County. That is seamless, because they are having similar problems that transcend and come into the city. We have multiple bureaus that are attacking this issue, to include Patrol Services Bureau, our Community Response Teams, the Intelligence Bureau, who are heavily involved in it as well, as...

(01:22:40)

We have tow trucks. We have drone teams. We have aviation, and we have our Highway District. So it is a multi-bureau approach within NYPD addressing this. What are the results? You look at January 1, 2026 to April 18, 2026. NYPD responded to 2,271 documented street or car meetups.

(01:24:32)

Sorry, was that citywide? Citywide. Two hundred seventy-one? In what period of time? From January 1 to October 18 of this year, so 271 total responses.

(01:25:09)

That is an 11% increase from last year. We made 170 arrests. We issued 157 summonses, and we seized 291 vehicles. That is a 161% increase in arrests, a 246% increase in summonses, and a 104% increase in vehicle seizures. While, again, I said that the number of car meetups and street takeovers has increased by about 11%, so this is a high priority for us. We do have dedicated teams that will go across borough boundaries and precinct boundaries. We can move throughout, and we can surge anywhere between 60 and 80 cars at a moment's notice to take these over. They are very dangerous to the police department. We have had many instances, not a couple, many instances, where these individuals ram our cars, physically assault our officers, and ram our officers. We have had shots-fired incidents. So we understand the danger of it, and the police commissioner has sent a directive. This will be addressed. Okay. And, all right, and again, I see that the effort is taking place, but for some reason the Belt Parkway, at least in the Bay Ridge section, I can tell you by my ears, every single night it is not being solved. So I appreciate the efforts, but again, I am not questioning whether work is happening. I am saying, is it working for where I am from, my district? And I am telling you it is not. So I do not know what further actions we can take, but it really is a dire need. I am sure. Let us bring attention to Bay Ridge and to the Council Members, please. Thank you.

And to Coney Island as well, wherever the place is, please help out the Council Member, please.

(01:25:45)

All right, we are now going to move to CM Justin Sanchez, followed by Wittes. Thank you, Chair. I want to go back to towing capacity. First, you said the DOT's towing capacity is sufficient. At what figures is DOT relying on when it says capacity is enough? Can you list the number of tow requests last year, how many were completed, and the average response times by borough?

(01:26:01)

Thank you, Council Member. Yes, so just to clarify again, we tow vehicles out of the way when we need to work on a street for more enforcement-type towing. I would defer to P.S. about the towing, DOT, I believe, is a family, but we could circle back. Oh, P.D., same. I am sorry, what is the question?

(01:26:19)

Ah, it was stated that the towing capacity is sufficient. So what figures, enough capacity? Can the agency give the Council the number of tow requests it had, how many were completed, and the average response times by borough?

(01:26:44)

Okay. So the second half will get to you after this. But I do want to say, as was mentioned earlier, we do not have a Manhattan tow pound, but we do have three tow pounds around the city: Brooklyn, Bronx, and 300 in D-92. That is the vehicle capacity. Bronx, two pound, through 50. Queens, top pounds 200. And it is sufficient. If we are over, typically in my experience, maybe about 60-plus vehicles. But again, I have testified to this. For the most part, these vehicles are in and out. So when we are talking about sufficiency, there is a rampant and growing unlicensed towing industry. Gothamist found that there are 700 unlicensed tow trucks in the city. Would you agree that the size of this illegal fleet suggests that capacity is not where it needs to be? We do not handle that in the NYPD. That does not fall under our...

(01:26:54)

Yeah, what we do not do is the licensing of tow companies. What I would say is what Chief Obey said, which is that when a summons is written and a vehicle needs to be towed in those circumstances, we are able to tell the vehicle owner. We would love to be able to replace that Manhattan facility. It is something we are working hard to do, but it presents challenges, some of which are very obvious. So if I am understanding correctly, the towing that we need in the borough, all of the cars that need to be towed, that have just sat there for time, we do not need to do anything about that? I do not know if you want to speak to something specifically about it. It just seems like one of the biggest issues that all New Yorkers complain about, and I think the Chair also brought it up, was that we just have cars that need to be towed, but they never seem like they are towed. And now we are hearing that we have the complete capacity. And I know when I am dealing with trucks that need to be towed and I am calling my station, I am told that we do not have this efficient capacity to tow all of these vehicles, to do all of this work. So I am just confused on what is sufficient. What is sufficient? The number of cars that we have in the tow pounds is sufficient. The number of cars that we actually need to be towing, what is sufficiency to the...

(01:27:28)

Sure. So two things I will say. First, we will come visit you and take a look, walk through your precinct, your district, just to get a sense of what is happening there, and we will help you with some of the towing issues. The second thing is we do not tow just to tow. We tow for violations for the most part. So I talked about ghost plate enforcement. Auto operators will go out there, respond to community complaints, and then we prioritize towing. If you have a vehicle that is parked in front of a fire hydrant that needs to go, rather than a vehicle that is parked in front of a park that has expired, we prioritize it. But we do not talk just to talk. We also cannot tow our way out of the towing problem, but we can certainly meet with you, and we would visit your district and...

(01:27:39)

The Police Department, we've had many instances, not a couple, many instances where these individuals ram our cars and ram our... and physically assault our officers and ram our officers. We had shots fired incidents, so we understand the danger of it, and the Police Commissioner has sent a directive. This will be dressed... OK. And again, I see that the effort is taking place, but for some reason the Belt Parkway, at least in the Bay Ridge section, I can tell you by my ears every single night, it's not being solved. So I appreciate the efforts, but again, I'm not questioning whether work is happening. I'm saying, is it working for where I'm from, my district? And I'm telling you it's not. So I don't know what further actions we can take, but it really is a dire need. I'm sure. Let's bring attention to Bay Ridge, and to the Council Members, please, thank you, and to Coney Island as well, wherever it is. Please, please help out the Council Member, please.

(01:27:59)

I'm sorry, what's the question? Ah, is it a... It was stated that the towing capacity is sufficient, so what figures? Enough capacity. Can the agency give the Council the number of tow requests it had, how many were completed, and the average response times by borough?

(01:28:38)

All right, we're now going to move to CM Justin Sanchez, followed by Wittes. Thank you, Chair. I want to go back to towing, towing capacity. First, you said the DOT's towing capacity is sufficient. At what figures is DOT relying on when it says capacity is enough? Can you tell us the number of tow requests last year, how many were completed, and the average response times by borough? Ah.

(01:29:07)

Thank you, Council Member. Yes. So just to clarify again, we tow vehicles out of the way when we need to work on a street for more enforcement-type towing. I would defer to the P.D. about the towing. Dottie does... I believe it's a family, but we could circle back. Oh, P.D., same.

(01:29:32)

I'm sorry, what's the question? Ah, it was stated that the towing capacity is sufficient, so what figures enough capacity? Can the agency give the Council the number of tow requests it had, how many were completed, and the average response times by borough?

(01:29:52)

OK, so the second half will get to you after this, but I do want to say, as was mentioned earlier, we don't have a Manhattan tow pound, but we do have three tow pounds around the city: Brooklyn, Bronx, and 300 in... Dar 92. That's the vehicle capacity. Bronx, two pound through 50. Queens, top pounds 200. And it is sufficient. If we're over, typically in my experience, maybe about 60-plus vehicles, but again, I've testified to this. For the most part, these vehicles are in and out.

So when we're talking about sufficiency, there is a rampant and growing unlicensed towing industry. Gothamist found that there are 700 unlicensed tow trucks in the city. Would you agree that the size of this illegal fleet suggests that capacity isn't where it needs to be? We don't handle that in the NYPD. That doesn't fall under a...

(01:30:51)

Yeah, what we don't do is the licensing of tow companies. What I would say is what Chief Obey said, which is that when a summons is written and a vehicle needs to be towed, in those circumstances we're able to tell the vehicle. We would love to be able to replace that Manhattan facility. It's something we're working hard to do, but it presents challenges, some of which are very obvious. So if I'm understanding correctly, the towing that we need in the borough, all of the cars that need to be towed, that have, you know, kind of just sat there for time, we don't need to do anything about that? I don't know if you want to speak to something specifically about it. It just seems like one of the biggest issues that all New Yorkers complain about, and I think the Chair also brought it up, was that we just have cars that need to be towed but they never seem like they are towed. And now we're hearing that we have the complete capacity. And I know when I'm dealing with trucks that need to be towed and I'm calling my station, I'm told that we don't have this efficient capacity to tow all of these vehicles, to do all of this work. So I'm just confused on what is sufficient. Like, what is sufficient? The number of cars that we have in the tow pounds is sufficient. The number of cars that we actually need to be towing, what is sufficiency to the...

(01:32:11)

Sure. So two things I'll say first. We'll come visit you and take a look, walk through your district, just to get a sense of what's happening there, and we'll help you with some towing issues. The second thing is we don't tow just to tow. We tow for violations for the most part. So I talked about ghost-rate enforcement. Auto operators will go out there, respond to community complaints, and then we prioritize towing. If you have a vehicle that's parked in front of a fire hydrant that needs to go, rather than a vehicle that's parked in front of a park that has expired, we prioritize it. But we don't talk just to talk. We also can't tow our way out of the towing problem, but we can certainly meet with you and visit your district.

(01:32:57)

Thank you, I'd appreciate that. I want to move on. I won't need round two. Containerization and Vision Zero: how does DOT triangulate Empire Wind One with the Vision Zero framework? For example, a stationary container looks like it could be in the daylight in areas. Have we, or are we considering that? What is happening there? Also, can you talk to us about what is happening with daylighting and parking? How are we holding drivers accountable who are parking in these daylighting zones, and what can we do? Because you have put up these plastic little things, but they drive over them. Thank you.

(01:33:57)

There's so much happening at our curbside, and that's why we're excited to be creating this Office of Curb Management, which we're currently putting together. We're going to have more to share there. Its job is really to look holistically at all these different dimensions, which in the past would have been handled at different parts of DOT. For containerization specifically, that's something we're communicating with DSNY pretty constantly. It's one of the bigger efforts going on right now that impacts us on the curb, and I'd say we have a great collaboration with them. Some of the bins may be too high to actually put to use for daylighting, because they would impede visibility. So it depends on the situation, but we definitely want to be thinking creatively every time we're putting something on the curb: can it also serve a safety function or provide some other benefit? Absolutely. Can he just speak a little bit about what's happening to hold the cars accountable that are in the daylighting zones right now?

(01:34:58)

Yeah. This is one of those things that we're always continually trying to build upon. We want to roll out safety improvements citywide, and to do that it means building things quickly. But when we build things quickly, they have some of the issues you mentioned. Over the long run, we want to keep moving toward both a higher quantity and higher quality, and that's sometimes why I talk about this in the context of our discussions around different kinds of targets. We want quantity and quality. In this situation, we're always evaluating how it is being used and how we can continue to improve upon it. In the case of these painted curb extensions with the flex posts, is it an enforcement thing we can work on, or maybe there's a design solution we can keep innovating? It depends on the situation. Is there any enforcement right now? We'll continually collaborate with NYPD on enforcement. So is there a method for enforcement right now, like our cars getting tickets, with that?

(01:36:04)

That seems like a question for NYPD. For cars that are parking in the daylighting areas, what is the enforcement looking like? Okay, so.

(01:36:15)

Are they getting tickets, or what? I can't speak to daylighting specifically, and I can speak to enforcement generally, so I don't know that we track it as it pertains to daylighting, but just in general.

(01:36:28)

That conversation should be had with NYPD, but I think the Council Member raises a good point, especially as the administration is expanding daylighting. We are also, in terms of increasing summonses and violations, accounting for ticketing for cars in daylighting zones.

(01:36:44)

I'll now move it over to CM Dinowitz, followed by Restler.

(01:36:48)

Thank you, Chair. This is a very interesting hearing, because the testimony today is extremely different from what I am experiencing in my community and what my constituents are experiencing. So it is interesting to hear that you have towing capacity, because Webster Avenue, Goulden Avenue, and the service road have no capacity for towing or heavy towing. I would love to continue that conversation with you further, and with Chief Obey, about why we are getting different reports from different people about what is and isn't feasible to clean up our neighborhoods. I appreciate the testimony and look forward to speaking with you soon. But I do want to ask DOT: you testified that you're concerned about certain legislation, that you want the flexibility to be able to meet the needs of the city. I appreciate that, and under normal circumstances that would be normal testimony. But if these ballot proposals pass, you will be given more authority. In my view, that ignores the community, which is actually the experience we have now, and it is deeply frustrating. We want simple things. We're not asking for hundreds of miles of bike lanes or bus lanes. We want some stop signs and we want some speed humps. We requested a speed hump on Richardson Avenue over a month ago. No response from the Department of Transportation. We requested stop signs on the service road in Henriettes and Parkway about a month ago. Not even an acknowledgment of receipt.

And, as I've mentioned at this hearing before, stop signs in North Rueda were rejected at a hearing just like this one. It was committed to me that we would get data associated with that, including velocity, the speed of the cars.

(01:38:24)

As to why those life-saving signs were rejected, we received no information despite follow-up. I am simply wondering if there is an affirmative policy to ignore Council Member and community requests, or if that is a problem with the culture within the DOT.

(01:38:36)

Thank you, Council Member. I apologize if there have been any gaps in communication. We recognize how critical community input and feedback is to the work we do, because we know the work we do is so tangible and really does impact people's day-to-day lives. So we take, and I personally take, that responsibility very seriously. That said, I know there's always room for improvement, so we are going to definitely take this feedback back. I think some of the specific traffic control requests you mentioned, I know there are criteria we have to use, so that we can be objective.

(01:38:48)

I believe I want to be clear. I'm not talking about the criteria, although in one case I am. In the cover letter, this was two years ago, we were... this report, I know, before you. The cover letter said we considered velocity. The report itself did not list velocity. I asked for that data from this administration and did not receive it. I'm not talking about what the data say in the other cases. I'm talking about acknowledging receipt and continuing a conversation despite follow-ups from my office.

(01:38:51)

We should absolutely be acknowledging receipt, so I'll certainly look into that.

(01:39:03)

It's a weird bare minimum to be asking, just to acknowledge receipt. And as I've mentioned at this hearing before, it is unfortunate that the only time DOT seems to act with urgency is when they want to do a project like a bike lane or a bus lane. And by the way, they do not take community input into consideration, or if there is a crime like a woman getting run over by a bus, or a rape, which are the two instances I can remember them being responsive. It shouldn't take that for the duty to be responsive to a community. And in my community, we are at our wits' end trying to get just a few safety measures, or at least start the conversation about that.

(01:39:35)

I want to go back to enforcement. I would just like to note here that at 231st Street, we've had meetings with DOT and NYPD about enforcement on 231 regarding cars parked or standing in the bus stop, contributing to a significant amount of traffic slowing the buses down, which I know is a big priority of this administration and of my community members. The response we got was, well, we'll do some enforcement, but we have automated bus enforcement, so we don't really need to. That was sort of the message I got every time I go by there. There is at least one car, or truck, or cart in the bus lane. I'm requesting enforcement here at this hearing. I'm also requesting enforcement on Gun Hill Road, where you installed a new bus lane and we warned you people would be parking, double parking, clogging up traffic. The DOT told us it wouldn't happen. Of course it's happening. We were requesting enforcement on Gun Hill Road to make sure traffic runs smoothly. Especially, if I can just finish the thought, Chair, especially as we are considering a rezoning on Gun Hill Road to provide much-needed housing to our city and to our community. One of the big holdups is the traffic. When there is no enforcement, it makes traffic worse, and it disincentivizes our community from getting on board to building additional housing in a denser neighborhood. So I cannot impress upon you how important it is for you all to be responsive to our community, to take our needs into consideration. Thank you, Chair.

(01:39:36)

Thank you, Council Member.

(01:40:06)

We have CM Restler, followed by one, thank you. Chair Brewer, you've been doing a terrific job with this committee and I really appreciate your leadership. Before I shift to DOT, I do just want to say, when we reach out to NYPD's Transportation Division, thank you, Chief Obey, for that. You've come out to my district several times, and I especially want to thank your XO, Chief O'Sullivan, who is one of the most superb public servants I've had a chance to work with. I really just want to thank you for everything you do and for being such a great partner.

(01:40:10)

And Commissioner, good to see you and the team from DOT. I just want to highlight a few areas that have been of particular concern to me. This is both a DOT question: we've been trying to get an answer on the NYPD crash data on Open Data. It hasn't been updated since, I don't believe, unless there was an update in the last week. There is a note on the page saying there was an automation in progress and it was expected to be completed in... does anybody at the dais have a timeline on when we're going to have that data back online? I'd love the answer to be today.

(01:40:53)

We'll get back to you as soon as we can on that.

(01:41:55)

Okay, it hasn't been updated in five months.

(01:42:25)

Yeah, we'll look at that and get back to you as soon as we can.

(01:42:29)

How soon? As soon as we can.

(01:43:19)

Council Member.

(01:43:20)

Do you think you'll send me an email this week with an update about what that timeline looks like this week? Guessing.

(01:43:52)

Shift to DOT stuff. Pedestrian space. The Vision Zero plan included some minor references to pedestrian space, subways, bus stations, busy sidewalks. It is essential to making sure pedestrians have the space to move around safely in our community. More than half of New Yorkers do not own a car, myself included, but 75% of our streets are devoted to storing and moving vehicles. This DOT supports expanding pedestrian space by a million square feet per year. Commissioner.

(01:43:54)

Thank you, Council Member. As you noted, this is something we've been really prioritizing and working hard on the last few years, expanding pedestrian space, both actual full-time pedestrian space, but also open streets and other creative use of space that may be more based on events or different parts of the year. That's why we included it in the Vision Zero plan. One of the initiatives is to, for the first time, have an actual coordinated program around pedestrian districts and pedestrian priority zones. So we're very supportive of the idea of continuing to expand pedestrian space. Okay, I didn't hear a yes or no on the million square feet, but I heard enthusiasm for pedestrian space, so we will keep working together on that.

(01:43:56)

On lighting, this has been one of the areas that I will admit I have been most frustrated with the Department of Transportation. The Vision Zero plan includes some references to improving lighting. Last year we passed Local Law 178 of 2025, which requires DOT to install pedestrian sidewalk lighting on 300 commercial quarter-blocks per year, places like Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn. The law takes effect January 1, 2027. Is DOT prepared to start installing lighting in compliance with this new law, and do you have the resources to do so? Thank you, Council Member. You know, I can say, since I started in this role, it has become very clear to me just how much lighting affects the daily lives of New Yorkers. It has come up in almost all of my conversations with elected officials and partners. What I can say is that a lot of the infrastructure out there is showing its age, and some fixes can be done very quickly, and others are more complex. Sometimes it's aging cables and bases to the lights. Some of them are just so old that they need a full replacement of the light. So we've been working to expand our contract capacity, and this has been a big area of focus for me and our team, just being able to be more nimble and expand our ability to fix the streetlights. I am happy to hear that it's been a priority for you.

I will say I think it's one of the areas that undermines goodwill and confidence in DOT when lights don't get fixed in a timely manner, and when we have lights that are dark, it undermines our safety. We like the streets, and not the sidewalks, when most of us walk. So I really think this is an area we need to prioritize. We have not yet heard whether DOT has the resources they need to comply with this new local law. A briefing on that, and on how you're improving lighting.

(01:43:57)

Similarly, we have significant challenges around streetlights on the streets, but the lights at the intersections. If I made that distinction clear in the MMR: the average number of days to repair a streetlight increased from 5.3 to 8.5 days. For years, it was under three days. What's the reason behind this unacceptable delay, and does DOT have a plan to bring that time back down? It's still a requirement that our contractors evaluate repairs within 10 days at each location, but like I said, some are more complex. We were having some challenges with some of our contracts and the ways that it affects streetlights. I think what you said is spot on. If I may paraphrase, something the Mayor says a lot: we need to show that we can address the small things to earn trust to do the big things right. We take that very seriously, and that's why, yes, the answer to your question is yes, this is a focus area and where we're very hard at work to improve. But if the Chair allows, I'll come back for round two. I'll just say and conclude: we're thrilled about many of the street safety projects that are happening across our district. Work started on Adams Street yesterday. McGinnis is just about completed, making the area in eastern Greenpoint around PS 100 safer with the new innovative diverter that you all are installing. These are transformational projects that will save lives, dramatically improve safety across our communities, and I am deeply grateful for the leadership of DOT.

For the first time in years, there's no political resistance at City Hall. You guys are able to just plow ahead and do the work and make the improvements happen that we all need to see around our districts. I do want to continue to harp on these operational issues: streetlighting, and the intersection streetlights, which are really important issues that I don't think have gotten the attention they deserve from DOT over an extended period of time. Fixing the stuff is hard, but it's really important, and I'm eager to see progress. The MMR did not yet show that progress, so we're eager to get some updates from the agency on how we can turn things around. I'm going to come back for round two, but thank you so much again, Chair.

(01:44:02)

Thank you so much, Council Member. These are conversations I've had with the Commissioner regarding streetlights and the needs, and the eagerness on our part to see a change. We will be having a hearing on public realm in the next few months that will include streetlights. I'll just tell you, for your awareness, like we advocate for years to finally get to study an intersection, to analyze it, they'll approve it, and then it's another 8, 12, 15 months before the streetlight gets installed. It took me a few years to get a streetlight placed in front of a dog run, literally for like three years. And we will get to this. This is one of those big issues. It's related to crime, it's related to street safety, it's related to a host of other issues. You're right, Commissioner: getting the small things done restores our faith, and our constituents' faith, in government, that we can also get the big things done. So more on that to come in the next few months. I will have some questions now for BIC, for big.

(01:44:02)

I'd like to turn over. Before I do that, actually, CM Number One, my apologies, Council Member.

(01:44:09)

Shift to D OT stuff. Aery pedestrian space. The visions here plan included some minor references to pedestrian space, D subways, bus stations, busy sidewalks. Is essential to making sure pedestrians have the space to move around community our streets safely. More than half of New Yorkers do not own a car, myself included, but 75% of our streets are devoted to storing and moving vehicles. This DOT supports expanding pedestrian space by a million square feet per year. Commissioner.

(01:44:42)

Thank you, Council Member.

(01:44:45)

As you noted, this is something we have been really prioritizing and working hard on the last few years, expanding pedestrian space, both actual full-time pedestrian space but also open streets and other creative use of space that may be more based on events or different parts of the year. That is why we included it in the Vision Zero plan. One of the initiatives is to really, for the first time, have an actual coordinated program around pedestrian districts and pedestrian priority zones. So we are very supportive of the idea of continuing to expand pedestrian space. Okay, I did not hear a yes or no on the million square feet, but I heard an enthusiasm for pedestrian space, so we will keep working together on that.

(01:45:28)

On lighting, this has been one of the areas that I will admit I have been most frustrated with the Department of Transportation. The Vision Zero plan includes some references to improving lighting. Last year we passed Local Law 178 of 2025, which requires DOT to install pedestrian sidewalk lighting on 300 commercial quarter blocks per year. Places like Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn. The law takes effect January 1, 2027. Is DOT prepared to start installing lighting in compliance with this new law, and do you have the resources to do so? Thank you, Council Member.

(01:45:35)

You know, I can say, since I started in this role it has become very clear to me just how much lighting affects the daily lives of New Yorkers. It has come up in almost all of my conversations with elected officials and partners. What I can say is that what we are seeing is that a lot of the infrastructure out there is showing its age, and some fixes can be done very quickly, and others are more complex. Sometimes it is aging cables and bases to the lights. Some of them are just so old that they need a full replacement of the light. So we have been working to expand our contract capacity, and this has been a big area of focus for me and our team, is just being able to be more nimble and expand our ability to fix the streetlights. I am happy to hear that it has been a priority for you. I will say I think it is one of the areas that undermines goodwill and confidence in DOT when lights do not get fixed in a timely manner, and when we have lights that are dark, it undermines our safety. We like for the streets and not the sidewalks, when most of us walk. So I really think this is an area we need to prioritize. We have not yet heard whether DOT has the resources they need to comply with this new local law. A briefing on that, and how you are improving lighting.

(01:46:05)

Similarly, we have significant challenges around streetlights on the streets, but the lights at the intersections. If I made that distinction clear in the MMR, the average number of days to repair a streetlight increased from 5.3 to 28.5 days. For years, it was under three days. What is the reason behind this unacceptable delay, and does DOT have a plan to bring that time back down? It is still a requirement that our contractors need to evaluate repairs within 10 days at each location, but like I said, some are more complex. We were having some challenges with some of our contracts and the ways that it affects streetlights. I think what you said is spot on. If I would paraphrase, I think something the Mayor says a lot: the City needs to see that we can address the small things to trust us to do the big things right, and we take that very seriously. That is why, yes, the answer to your question is yes, this is a focus area, and where we are very hard to improve here. But if the Chair allows, I will come back for round two. I will just say and conclude, I will just say, we are thrilled about many of the street safety projects that are happening across our district. Work started on Adams Street yesterday. McGinnis is just about completed, making the area in eastern Greenpoint around PS 100 safer with the new innovative diverter that you all are installing.

These are transformational projects that will save lives, dramatically improve safety across our communities, and I am deeply grateful for the leadership of DOT. For the first time in years there is no political resistance at City Hall. You all are able to just plow ahead and do the work and make the improvements happen that we all need to see around our districts. I do want to continue to harp on these operational issues, streetlighting, and the intersection streetlights are really important issues that I do not think have gotten the attention they deserve at DOT over an extended period of time. Fixing the stuff is hard, but it is really important, and I am eager to see progress. The MMR did not yet show that progress, and so we are eager to get some updates from the agency on how we can turn things around. I am going to come back for round two, but thank you so much again, Chair.

(01:46:07)

Since I started in this role it has become very clear to me just how much lighting affects the daily lives of New Yorkers. It has come up in almost all of my conversations with elected officials and partners. I think what I can say is that what we are seeing is that a lot of the infrastructure out there is showing its age. Some fixes can be done very quickly and then others are more complex. Sometimes it is aging cables and bases to the lights. Some of them are just so old that they need a full replacement of the light. So we have been working to expand our contract capacity and this has been a big area of focus for me and our team, just really being able to be more nimble and expand our ability to fix the streetlights.

I am happy to hear that it has been a priority for you. I will say I think it is one of the areas that undermines goodwill and confidence in DOT when lights do not get fixed in a timely manner and when we have lights that are dark. It undermines our safety on the streets and the sidewalks when most of us walk. So I really think this is an area we need to prioritize. We have not yet heard whether DOT has the resources they need to comply with this new local law.

(01:47:20)

...briefing on that and how you are improving lighting.

(01:47:23)

Similarly, we have significant challenges around streetlights on the streets, but the lights at the intersections — if I made that distinction clear — in the MMR, the average number of days to repair a streetlight increased from 5.3 to 28.5 days. For years it was under three days. What is the reason behind this unacceptable delay and does DOT have a plan to bring that time back down?

So it is still a requirement that our contractors need to evaluate repairs within 10 days at each location, but like I said, some are more complex. We were having some challenges with some of our contracts and the ways that affects streetlights. I think what you said is spot on. If I would paraphrase, I think something the Mayor says a lot: the City needs to see that we can address the small things to trust us to do the big things right. We take that very seriously. That is why, yes, the answer to your question is yes, this is a focus area and we are working very hard to improve here. But if the Chair...

(01:48:23)

...allows, I will come back for...

(01:48:24)

Round two. I will just say in conclusion, we are thrilled about many of the street safety projects that are happening across our district. Work started on Adams Street yesterday. McGinnis is just about completed, making the area in eastern Greenpoint around PS 100 safer with the new innovative diverter that you all are installing. These are transformational projects that will save lives and dramatically improve safety across our communities. I am deeply grateful for the leadership of DOT. For the first time in years there is no political resistance at City Hall. You are able to just plow ahead and do the work and make the improvements happen that we all need to see around our districts.

I do want to continue to harp on these operational issues. Street lighting and the intersection streetlights are really important issues that I do not think have gotten the attention they deserve at DOT over an extended period of time. Fixing this stuff is hard but it is really important and I am eager to see progress. The MMR did not yet show that progress and so we are eager to get some updates from the agency on how we can turn things around. I am going to come back for round two.

(01:49:27)

Thank you so much.

(01:49:27)

Thank you so much, Council Member. You know, these are conversations I have had with the Commissioner regarding streetlights and the needs, and the eagerness on our part to see a change. We will be having a hearing on public realm in the next few months that will include streetlights, and I will just tell you, for your awareness, like we advocate for years, you know, to finally get to study an intersection to analyze it. They will approve it, and then it is another 8, 12, 15 months before the streetlight gets installed. It took me a few years to get a streetlight to be placed in front of a dog run, literally for like three years. And we will get to this. This is one of those big errors. It is related to crime, it is related to street safety, it is related to a host of other issues. You are right, Commissioner. Getting the small things done restores our faith, and our constituents' faith in government, that we can also get the big things done. So more on that to come in the next few months. I will have some questions now for B.I.C. for big.

(01:49:29)

CM, these are conversations I have had with the Commissioner regarding streetlights and the needs and the eagerness on our part to see a change. We will be having a hearing on public realm in the next few months that will include streetlights. I will just tell you, for your awareness, we advocate for years to finally get to study an intersection, to analyze it. They will approve it and then it is another 8, 12, 15 months before the streetlight gets installed. It took me a few years to get a streetlight placed in front of a dog run, literally for like three years.

We will get to this. This is one of those big issues that is related to crime, is related to street safety, is related to a host of other issues. You are right, Commissioner, getting the small things done restores our faith and our constituents' faith in government that we can also get the big things done. So more on that to come in the next few months. I will have some questions now for...

(01:50:28)

I would like to turn over. Before I do that, actually, Counselor number one. My apologies, Council Member.

(01:50:34)

Thank you so much, Mr. Abreu. I want to bring back to the visions of your reimagined plan that our Mayor Mamdani revealed on September 15, 2026. The advocates and I are still extremely disappointed that the Mayor has walked back on his campaign commitment to support universal daylighting, and I know that we are going to have the bill heard at another hearing. But for the Vision Zero reimagined plan, it commits to daylighting or better, in air quotes, verbatim, at a thousand intersections per year. Can you please define what better means and quantify it, or qualify it, and what metrics you used to define that as daylighting? For example, would solely a leading pedestrian interval count? And does that 1000 intersections mean safety treatments at all crossing locations within those 1000 intersections? Thank you.

(01:51:28)

Council Member, I think the starting point to answering that is really about the outcomes, and that's really what we're after here. With daylighting or better, it's the actual analysis we've done on how these treatments can reduce crashes, or reduce the severity of crashes. A lot of that depends on the context of each location. If it's a narrow street, a wide street, one-way, two-way, we see that. Basically, the other things we're including there as "or better" in certain situations could deliver even better crash reduction than daylighting, and that's why we're defining it that way.

(01:52:05)

Can you give us a clear example of what qualifies as better than daylighting? There's a longer list, but it could be a new traffic signal. It could be pedestrianization of a street. There's a very wide range of things we've studied, and the commissioner has said that in the right circumstances they can provide better outcomes than hardened daylighting.

(01:52:29)

So we absolutely have a strong commitment to doing more hardened daylighting and setting new highs for how much hardened daylighting we're going to do. We just want to be clear that it's not the only safety treatment that we have in our toolbox, and we want to make sure that we're doing the right thing in the right places to get the maximum safety benefit.

(01:52:45)

And the 1000 intersections, are all crossing locations within those 1000 intersections... a thousand. So we would do a safety improvement at the intersection, and when we do that, we look at where it is needed most. So that still doesn't answer my question. How are you quantifying a thousand? If we do safety improvements at that intersection, then it counts toward the thousand intersections. But what we're asking is, there's a thousand intersection means safety treatments at all crossing locations.

(01:53:17)

I think it's going to depend on the intersection. As Deputy Commissioner Beaton said, we approach each location individually because we want to maximize the safety benefit. We look at the crash history, the crash data, what kinds of crashes are happening. Is it turning issues? Is it T-bone type issues? That's going to suggest what the right treatments could be. So at some intersections it might be all the corners or all the approaches, and at other intersections, say a major road intersecting with a minor street, that might look different.

(01:53:55)

So could DOT provide us with a process map or a decision tree on how you determine what is better and what should be treated per intersection for this new Vision Zero plan?

(01:54:05)

I'm happy to talk to the team. Okay, great. Concrete curb extensions are one of the most effective tools to reduce pedestrian crashes, slowing turns, daylighting corners, and shortening crossing distances. They are extremely common in most cities, but in New York City, installation has been extremely slow. How does the Vision Zero reimagined plan intend to speed up these vital concrete curb extensions?

(01:54:26)

That's a great question. Thank you, Council Member. We do curb extensions as well, because they really do deliver multiple benefits, from safety to public space, potentially for greening and trees. You're right that they are more challenging. When we talk about our quick-build toolkit, it often doesn't include that, and that's because by the nature of being at the curb, they affect drainage along the gutter, and often the catch basins would need to be relocated. So that's something I've talked about, and I think we'll have more to say about it in the forthcoming streets plan. We want to be able to do more, both quantity and quality, and part of that is how do we do more permanent-type infrastructure with our in-house resources. That's something we're examining closely. We're having great conversations, and that's an area of focus for us.

(01:55:18)

Under Vision Zero Reimagined, will DOT prohibit vehicles from blocking curb cuts on unmarked crossings at intersections? If not, why not? That's specifically not in the Vision Zero reimagined plan. It's something I know was brought up in the last administration, but the rule was not fully adopted, so it's something we can talk a little more about going forward.

(01:55:46)

So yes or no? To be honest, I think I need to check with my team and understand the history, and I'm happy to take a closer look at it. Okay, we'll follow up. Thank you, thank you, thank you.

(01:56:02)

Council Member, I will soon have to go to BIC, but since we are on the topic of daylighting, I want to stay there for a second. Can you walk me through the anticipated timeline for meeting the administration's daylighting commitments, and by that I mean the annual commitments? All right. So the thousand intersections are better. While technically it would apply starting next year, we are meeting it this year as well. This is something we want to do every year going forward, and as the commissioner said, do more, do it better. We think that this intersection is delivering Vision Zero. So we want to make sure that we're meeting or exceeding that target. Just making sure Vision Zero reimagined, those target goals, are set out beginning in 2027, not as of the announcement date?

(01:56:04)

Yes. Each goal might be a little bit different, but typical for a report that came out in the fall of 2026, it mostly looks ahead to future years, but we have been working on it.

(01:56:59)

And wherever we can, including on the thousand intersection number, we do want to meet it this year too, and we are working towards that. Since the report was released, how many additional intersections have been daylit? We would have to get back to you on that specific number and timeline, but we do all of this, and we hope that it's happening.

(01:57:09)

How many intersections have received daylighting at the entire intersection, and how many have received daylighting on approach? What are the benefits of installing daylighting on approach, and when does DOT determine to use daylighting on approach? It always depends on the details of the intersection, but in general, what we see the value of hardened daylighting is, does tend to be on the approach, at intersections, because that's where the visibility is usually most limited. So as we think about where we can best use our resources to provide safety, that is one of the places that we focus on with hardened daylighting. Six months from now, how many... I guess it will be sort of through the winter and early spring, so that's not typically when we're implementing as much. We tend to look at the year, but so it's not prorated necessarily, and I think it's hard to break it down that way because it's sort of like that over the course of the year. But we're fully committed to this commitment that we've made, so we're expecting a thousand next summer, correct?

(01:57:18)

I don't want to hold you to that over the full year. Okay, all right. Yeah.

(01:57:32)

Construction timeline is between about and early, and so absolutely, through the entire construction. Okay.

(01:57:54)

Initial investments in daylighting, we focused on particular geographic areas, and how did DOT ensure that daylighting interventions are being distributed equitably throughout the city? So, it's based on a combination. It's based on the data fundamentally, and we want to put these treatments where they can have the biggest benefit. But the other core driver of our work program is what we call our Priority Investment Areas, which is our equity framework. We'll have a new map, basically, as part of the new streets plan, and we really prioritized the lion's share of our investments in there. There are three tiers, and in the first two tiers in particular, that's basically what's driving those investments. So it's a combination of the data telling us where they can be most effective,

(01:58:41)

but also which neighborhoods have really been historically disadvantaged. Other cities throughout the country have implemented daylighting to increase visibility, including ones with similar population density as New York, such as Hoboken, New Jersey. As the city begins to increase daylighting commitments, has DOT been in communication with other cities that have had successful daylighting rollouts?

(01:58:45)

Yes, we're always talking to our industry peers, and we're always trying to learn from them. I think Hoboken's done a lot of great things. They have some unique context that is a bit different from us, but that doesn't mean we can't learn from them, and we are. Thank you. On enforcement, some questions on enforcement for BIC. I'd like to turn to truck side guards.

(01:58:48)

Side guards are lateral panels that cover the space between truck's front and rear wheels to protect pedestrians and cyclists from being swept into the truck after a side-impact collision. Side guards are proven to keep vulnerable road users safe, and since 2023 they have been required on all trade waste vehicles in New York City with a gross vehicle weight rating over 10,000 pounds. On September 18 of this year, a teenager was killed and another was injured after they were hit by a hydro-excavation truck while biking in the East Village. We later learned that the truck that had hit them did not have the required side guards, because it had been granted a waiver from BIC. If side guards are such critical safety issues as we know them to be, can you help me understand why BIC would waive that requirement for any truck under its jurisdiction?

(01:58:54)

Thank you, Chair. I'm happy to take the question. It was a horrible tragedy, this accident, and my heart goes out to the family of the young girl. We don't want any collisions like that to happen on New York City streets, and along with our Vision Zero partners, we are doing all that we can to bring that idea of Vision Zero into reality. As you said, side guards are rails or panels that you affix to a vehicle to help close that gap between the front axle and the rear axle.

(01:59:00)

Side guards were not really a thing in the United States. New York is one of the pioneer cities to introduce side guards to various vehicle fleets, including the ones that BIC regulates. The national standards around side guards are just one of several tools to help ensure safety for these large, heavy vehicles. There are requirements that BIC has which complement side guards. Side guards can't prevent collisions; they can only mitigate the damage when a collision takes place. In this particular instance, a waiver was granted, and that's because the national standards around side guards recognized that while you want a side guard on a vehicle that does have that gap between the front and the rear axle, there are some vehicles that cannot support side guards, and there are some vehicles that already have infrastructure on the vehicle such that there is no gap between the front and the rear axle. In this particular case, the company that was involved in that collision had applied for a side guard waiver with BIC, and it had submitted information. We review each application individually because every vehicle is different, and we confirmed that vehicle did have incorporated features between the front and the rear axle, so that there was not that same type of gap between the wheels and under the vehicle that we're usually concerned about with side guards. So that was an appropriate application of the waiver process.

(01:59:46)

So in this instance, they had a different feature. You're saying that made that justified the exemption, and this was not a vehicle that had a huge open space between the front and the rear axle. Underneath, this was a vehicle that had devices, a fuel tank, a toolbox, that closed that space between the wheels, and according to national best practices and industry standards, it was an appropriate candidate for a waiver of a side guard.

(02:00:09)

Despite the way that the truck was constructed, it was a side guard not compatible for this particular vehicle. Each vehicle needs to be looked at individually. For this particular vehicle, the vehicle would not support a side guard.

(02:00:25)

It would not support a side guard. Is it BIC's position that a truck without a side guard in this specific instance is safe to operate in New York City? I can't speak to that particular incident. Collisions that happen on the road that end in fatalities, as we talked about earlier in this hearing, are investigated by the Police Department. But our view is that any vehicle, as you said, over that particular weight, that's a trade waste vehicle, should have a side guard, because side guards help promote safety. But if the vehicle cannot support a side guard, then a waiver may be appropriate. We want to make sure that all vehicles, whether they have a side guard or whether a waiver is appropriate, are also engaged in other safe practices, so that coverage, clearance, and the windshield... BIC has requirements that drivers do a daily safety inspection of the vehicle before they go out on route, every single day, and they keep a copy of that report in the cab. So we have a full wrapper of requirements to help get us closer to the Vision Zero goal.

(02:00:31)

Thank you for that. What would make a truck that has a side guard be safer than the truck involved in this situation? Again, not appropriate for me to comment on that particular incident. But you could have a vehicle that has a wide-open gap underneath it, and if there's nothing there, and if the vehicles can support a side guard, a side guard should be installed. That's the harm that we're trying to prevent. But if you have a vehicle where the design of the vehicle can't support a side guard, and/or where the vehicle has equipment, it could be an additional axle or two or three additional axles, it could be a toolbox, it could be a fuel tank, if it's eliminating that gap, if it's that space, that is safer than a vehicle that has a wide-open space underneath it.

(02:01:25)

Right, but is it safer than a truck with just a side guard? I'm sorry, can you repeat the question? But is it safer than a truck with a traditional side guard? I think if what you're asking is if a truck with a traditional side guard is safer than a truck that has other equipment in that same zone, I couldn't comment on that. It's truck-to-truck specific and incident-to-incident specific. We just want to make sure that there's as much coverage there as is possible to promote safety. So you are going into the bases for which BIC would issue side guard waivers, and this example is one of them.

(02:01:26)

Are there other examples where a side guard exemption would be appropriate? Sure. Many of the trucks that fall under BIC's regulation are used to remove construction and debris. We're talking about heavy-duty construction debris, and those are dump trucks. We regulate a large number of dump trucks, and if you look at the average dump truck, it doesn't just have a front axle, a rear axle, and lots of space in between. It usually has additional wheels, including something that's called a third axle, a tri-axle, which is a wheel that is used to help the vehicle navigate uneven terrain. So there's a series of these wheels, and in a tri-axle vehicle, the vehicle moves in such a way that if you install a side guard, it would break when the vehicle wheel turns, or the wheel could get damaged. When we receive an application for a waiver, if we don't feel like we have enough information, we will ask the company for more. They send us a mechanic's letter that explains just what I explained to you, that the vehicle, the dump truck for example, can't support a side guard.

(02:01:29)

So that's one example of a type of vehicle that's different from the one involved at Fourteenth Street. Does BIC ever revisit or re-evaluate a waiver after it has been issued, and has it ever been rescinded at any moment? We have revisited waivers that have been granted, and what it's allowed us to do is have iterative, ongoing conversation with the company, so we take another look at where we've given a waiver and said, you know what, there is still a one-foot space, for example, between the step to the cab and that gas tank, and can you install a modified side guard in that limited space? We will keep working with the company until they do so, and we've had success in that regard.

(02:01:58)

Sounds like you know a lot about side guards. How many trucks under BIC currently have a waiver? Okay, so we have about 7,000 trucks under our jurisdiction that we have licensed, that we've granted plates to. As I mentioned, the largest share of that are not traditional trash trucks that you'd throw a garbage bag into. The largest share are C and D construction and demolition, what we call Class 2 vehicles. These are the heavy-duty vehicles, and most of those Class 2 vehicles are dump trucks, and those dump trucks, like I said, often have additional axles. So about half the vehicles that we regulate, of those, are these dump trucks.

(02:02:31)

In this particular instance, a waiver was granted, and that is because the national standards around side guards recognized that while you want side guards on a vehicle, some vehicles have a gap between the front and rear axle. There are some vehicles that cannot support side guards, and there are some vehicles that already have infrastructure on the vehicle such that there is no gap between the front and rear axle.

(02:02:43)

In this particular case, the company involved in that collision had applied for a side guard waiver with BIC and had submitted information. We review each application individually because every vehicle is different, and we confirmed that vehicle did have incorporated features between the front and the rear axle, so that there was not that same type of gap between the wheels and under the vehicle that we're usually concerned about with side guards. So that was an appropriate application of the waiver process.

(02:03:28)

So in this instance, they had a different feature. You're saying that made that justified the exemption, and this was not a vehicle that had a huge open space between the front and rear axle. Underneath, this was a vehicle that had devices, a fuel tank, a tool box that eliminated that space between the wheels. According to national best practices and industry standards, it was an appropriate candidate for a waiver of a side guard. Despite the way the truck was constructed, it was not compatible with a side guard for this particular vehicle. Each vehicle needs to be looked at individually. For this particular vehicle, the vehicle would not support a side guard.

(02:03:33)

It would not support a side guard. Is it your position that a truck without a side guard in this specific instance is safe? It's safe to operate in New York City. I can't speak to that particular incident. Collisions that happen on the road that end in fatalities, as we talked about earlier in this hearing, are investigated by the Police Department. But our view is that any vehicle, as you said, over that particular weight, that's a trade waste vehicle, should have a side guard because side guards help promote safety. But if the vehicle cannot support a side guard, then a waiver may be appropriate. We want to make sure that all vehicles, whether they have a side guard or whether a waiver is appropriate, are also engaged in other safe practices. So cover clearance in the windshield, BIC has requirements that drivers do a daily safety inspection of the vehicle before they go out on route every single day, and they keep a copy of that report in the cab. So we have a full wrapper of requirements to help get us closer to the Vision Zero goal.

(02:04:05)

Thank you for that. Would a truck that has a side guard be safer than the truck involved in this situation? Again, not appropriate for me to comment on that particular incident. But you could have a vehicle that has a wide open gap underneath it, and if there's nothing there and if the vehicles can support a side guard, a side guard should be installed. That's the harm that we're trying to prevent. But if you have a vehicle where the design of the vehicle can't support a side guard, and/or where the vehicle has equipment, it could be an additional axle or two or three additional axles, it could be a toolbox, it could be a fuel tank, if it's eliminating that gap, if it's that space, that is safer than a vehicle that has a wide open space underneath it.

(02:04:09)

Right, but is it safer than a truck with just a side guard? I'm sorry, can you repeat the question? But is it safer than a truck with a traditional side guard? I think if what you're asking is if a truck with a traditional side guard is safer than a truck that has other equipment in that same zone, I couldn't comment on that. It's truck-to-truck specific and incident-specific. We just want to make sure that there's as much coverage there as is possible to promote safety. So you are going into the bases for which BIC would issue side guard waivers, and this example is one of them.

(02:04:25)

Are there other examples where a side guard exemption would be appropriate?

(02:04:35)

Sure. Many of the trucks that fall under BIC's regulation are used to remove construction and debris. We're talking about heavy duty construction debris, and those are dump trucks. We regulate a large number of dump trucks. If you look at the average dump truck, it doesn't just have a front axle, a rear axle, and lots of space in between. It usually has additional wheels, including something that's called a third axle, a tri-axle, which is a wheel that is used to help the vehicle navigate uneven terrain. So there's a series of these wheels, and on a tri-axle vehicle, the vehicle moves in such a way that if you install a side guard, it would break when the vehicle wheel turns, or the wheel could get damaged. When we receive an application for a waiver, if we don't feel like we have enough information, we will ask the company for more. They send us a mechanic's letter that explains just what I explained to you, that the vehicle, the dump truck for example, can't support a side guard.

(02:05:37)

So that's one example of a type of vehicle that's different from the one involved at 14th Street. Does BIC ever revisit or re-evaluate a waiver after it has been issued? Has it ever been rescinded at any moment?

(02:05:39)

We have revisited waivers that have been granted, and what it's allowed us to do is have an iterative, ongoing conversation with the company, so we take another look at where we've given a waiver and said, you know what, there is still a one-foot space, for example, between the step to the cab and that gas tank. Can you install a modified side guard in that limited space? We will keep working with the company until they do so, and we've had success in that regard.

(02:06:28)

Sounds like you know a lot about side guards. How many trucks under BIC currently have a waiver? Okay, so we have about 7,000 trucks under our jurisdiction that we have licensed, that we've granted plates to. As I mentioned, the largest share of that are not traditional trash trucks that you'd throw a garbage bag into. The largest share are C&D, construction and demolition, what we call class two vehicles. These are the heavy duty vehicles, and most of those class two vehicles are dump trucks, and those dump trucks, like I said, often have additional axles. So about half the vehicles that we regulate, those are these dump.

(02:07:03)

Are there other examples where a side guard exemption would be...

(02:07:09)

Appropriate. Sure. Many of the trucks that fall under BIC regulation that are used to remove construction debris — we are talking about heavy duty construction debris — and those are dump trucks. We regulate a large number of dump trucks and if you look at the average dump truck, it does not just have a front axle, a rear axle and lots of space in between. It usually has additional wheels, including something that is called a third axle, a tri-axle, which is a wheel that is used to help the vehicle navigate uneven terrain. So there is a series of these wheels, and in a tri-axle vehicle the vehicle moves in such a way that if you install a side guard, the side guard would break when the vehicle wheel turns, or the wheel could get damaged. What we require when we receive an application for a waiver — if we do not feel like we have enough information — we will ask the company for more. They send us a mechanic's letter that explains just what I explained to you: that the vehicle, the dump truck for example, cannot support a side guard.

(02:08:16)

So that is one example of a type of vehicle that is different from the one involved at 14th Street. Does BIC ever revisit...

(02:08:24)

...or re-evaluate a waiver after it has been issued, and has it ever been rescinded at any point? We have revisited waivers that have been granted, and what it has allowed us to do is have iterative, ongoing conversations with the company. So we take another look at where we have given a waiver and said, you know what, there is still a one-foot space for example between a step to the cab and that gas tank — can you install a modified side guard in that limited space? We will keep working with the company until they do so, and we have had success in that regard.

(02:09:03)

Sounds like you know a lot about side guards. How many trucks under BIC currently have a waiver? OK, so we have...

(02:09:12)

...about 7,000 trucks under our — sorry, say it again. We have about 7,000 trucks that are under our jurisdiction that we have licensed, that we have given plates to. As I mentioned, the largest share of that are not traditional trash trucks that you would throw a garbage bag into. The largest share are C and D — construction and demolition — what we call Class 2 vehicles. These are the heavy duty vehicles, and most of those Class 2 vehicles are dump trucks. Those dump trucks, like I said, often have additional axles. So about half the vehicles that we regulate, those are these dump...

(02:09:53)

Trucks. All right, so you're saying of the waivers given, most of them are dump trucks?

(02:10:01)

Of the waivers given, and the larger share of what some other...

(02:10:05)

Type of exemptions given for non-dump trucks. So right?

(02:10:10)

So the vehicle that was involved in the Fourteenth Street incident, for example, was not a dump truck. It was a truck that had a high-powered vacuum that is used. It is kind of a clean-up truck when there is construction or tearing up of the street. It had a toolbox and it had a tank in that area, and that's why I couldn't support a side guard. There are many different designs of trucks. I don't want to give you broad categories. Dump truck is the easiest category because many of them do have those features I mentioned, but there can be a host of types of vehicles on the road where the manufacturer who builds the vehicle decides to put things underneath the truck, and those spaces. Do you know how many of those trucks that were granted waivers have been involved in collisions with pedestrians or cyclists since 2023? I do not have that information. How does it compare with those not being granted a waiver?

(02:11:12)

Um, it's a good question, Chair. We'll see if we have the data that allows us to break it down that way with respect to collision involvement and whether they had a side guard or a waiver. We will have to get back to you.

(02:11:28)

I think it's slightly disappointing to not have that information. Very disappointing. Ah, to not have that information. Please get it to us as soon as you can.

(02:11:39)

Um, and how does BIC enforce the side guard requirement for trucks that do not have a waiver?

(02:11:42)

We are regularly engaging in a variety of enforcement measures. We regularly visit the yards and garages of companies that we regulate, and if we see a vehicle that looks like it should have a side guard and it does not, we will review and see was there an appropriate waiver. If there was not, then that can result in a violation. We do joint operations with NYPD, city operations we call Safe Drive, where we will pick a high-traffic corridor and pull over trucks and do a full vehicle inspection to see: do they have a side guard, if they need one? Do they have a convex mirror? Are they filling out their daily inspection safety reports? So there is a lot of in-the-field work that we do to check: is this truck following all the safety regulations it is supposed to?

(02:12:47)

Have you found, do you know what the number is, for those who do not have a waiver and were found to not have a side guard? That's data I would have to get back to you on.

(02:13:03)

I would also need that information. Do you know how many licenses have been revoked for those not having a side guard? I could be wrong, Chair.

(02:13:15)

But my understanding is, one second, we have 99% compliance with the side guard waiver, so it would be very few where there have been violations of non-compliance with the side guard rule. It's been less than 80 over the past several years. We're talking about against 7,000 vehicles in the entire fleets that we oversee. Since the side guard rule went into effect, there have been less than 80 violations. So this demonstrates that the companies are either following the side guard rules, and we are working with them when they need an alternative like a modified side guard or a waiver. Thank you, thank you.

(02:14:00)

And I'll turn it over for questions. On for Lt.

(02:14:05)

This administration has touted its Vision Zero progress, citing record lows in overall traffic fatalities. However, traffic fatalities are up 86% for cyclists. How does the administration explain this discrepancy? Our streets are getting safer for car drivers but more dangerous for cyclists?

(02:14:17)

Thank you, Chair. Um, so I guess just to be clear, we're seeing an overall downward trend for traditional cyclists, where we've seen that growth this year is for e-bikes and stand-up scooters, and that, as you know from the last hearing, is a big area of focus for us. Generally speaking, what we've been seeing is crashes and fatalities from what you might call traditional users have been trending in the right direction. And then as the industry evolves and things change, we have to keep evolving in response to those new challenges. Recent trends in vehicles, such as larger hood sizes and heavier overall weight, make cars safer for those driving them but more deadly for other road users.

(02:15:12)

What is DOT doing in terms of advocacy, education, or other investments to address this issue? I know we can't regulate the size of vehicles in the city, but the harm to folks on our streets is outstanding.

(02:15:26)

It's a pretty big, it's really alarming, Chair. Yes. I know the New York Times, for example, did a really good article on this topic a few months back where they visualize the growth in the average vehicle size over the last few decades. This is very much on our radar. As you mentioned, it's something we have a little less control over, but we want to use our position to advocate and to see where we do have some policy levers to really incentivize safer vehicles, which in general are smaller vehicles. And just to add, in terms of what's under DOT's control, obviously we're concerned about the role of wear and tear on our assets as it relates to milling and paving and other repairs that need to be done. So we're thinking a lot about truck usage. We have a freight unit, and we are investing their work to help shift freight from large, heavy vehicles to other, safer modes such as cargo bikes, rail, and waterways, through initiatives like the Blue Highways, and working with organizations such as IIHS to develop federal safety standards for freight vehicles as well, to prioritize vulnerable road users.

(02:16:40)

Transportation Alternatives recently identified a list of 50 Boulevards of Death, streets that make up just 4% of the city's street miles but that account for more than 20% of traffic fatalities. Have you studied these Boulevards of Death, and do you have an understanding of why these particular streets are so deadly?

(02:17:02)

Absolutely. Looking at the highest crash corridors and locations is really at the core of our Vision Zero work. Obviously, it's always a moving target, right? If we address one of the top most dangerous corridors, then you'll just keep going down the list. I think Queens Boulevard is a really interesting example, where it was the original, I guess, Boulevard of Death. Right? Effort, both through quicker changes and then long-term capital projects, to improve it, and we've seen a plus-percent drop in fatalities on Queens Boulevard. Streets like that will continue, though, to be a challenge just by their nature, and we'll come back and make more fixes. But the short answer to your question is yes, and that's really the purpose of the Vision Zero priority corridors.

(02:17:52)

Corridors. Can you speak to what DOT is doing to prioritize investments in the Boulevards of Death to make them safer for pedestrians and cyclists?

(02:17:53)

Sure. This speaks to exactly why we put out an update to our Vision Zero priority corridors, because it allows us to focus our work in those places where crashes are most frequent. We bring the whole toolbox to those streets. Those include physical redesigns. It includes working with NYPD on enforcement, and includes automated enforcement, includes looking at traffic signal timing.

(02:18:23)

When we have a street that has been identified as unsafe, we don't want to leave that untouched. We want to make sure that we are always looking at those most crash-prone streets and doing everything we can to bring it down. And if we bring it down, then there's another most crash-prone street, and we're going to go after that one.

(02:18:41)

I mean, look, 20% is big. It's pretty big for only 4% of the city's street miles. So it sounds like a worthy focus and where the investment for our city should go. So I hope that this administration remains committed to addressing the 50 Boulevards of Death, leading pedestrian intervals, or LPIs.

(02:19:00)

Or when the crosswalk signal allows pedestrians to begin crossing before vehicles get a green light.

(02:19:05)

This seems like a relatively

(02:19:07)

straightforward and quick improvement. The Council's data team found it reduces pedestrian casualties by 12.7%. Intersections have received the more effective and lower-cost treatments in our toolbox, and we're really proud of how rapidly we've been able to roll them out across the city. What I will say is that, just like any tool, the effectiveness will depend in part on the context, that location. LPIs are really a tool that helps with turning conflicts more than anything, and so places where we have heavy turns, LPIs can have the greatest sort of bang for the buck. And of course, there is also a finite number of intersections in the city, so eventually you start to bump up against it. So I don't know, we could talk a little more about the specific numbers, but what I can say is, to date we've done over 6,000 LPIs, and we continue to see that as an important tool and maximize our use of it.

(02:20:17)

Thank you. I'd like to note that we were joined by CM Given. Given the speed at which LPIs can be implemented,

(02:20:25)

their effectiveness, and that, no physical infrastructure changes are needed, um, why haven't LPIs been implemented at more intersections?

(02:20:32)

Well, part of the answer is we are continuously installing more, but part of the answer is also that we want to make sure we're focused on the most dangerous locations. To a little bit your question, not every intersection in the city, not even every signalized intersection, has the same crash rate. There are parts of the city with fewer pedestrians and fewer turning conflicts, places where the LPI would not provide nearly as much benefit. So we want to make sure that our signal timing engineers are spending their effort on places that need LPIs, but they're also doing things like looking at how to make a correct progression so that cars aren't speeding. There are other things that signal engineers do, and we want to keep them focused on the places that really have the most crashes. I understand that is where it's being done, at the most dangerous intersections. How many are there in terms of your body of work? What have you determined to be the dangerous intersections, and how many more should we be expecting to address the outstanding dangerous corners? And then I have a separate question, which is, aren't LPIs better regardless of the benefit being low, being less? I mean

(02:21:21)

Crashes. I understand that is being done at the most dangerous intersections. How many are in terms of your body of work? What have you determined to be the dangerous intersections, and how many more should we be expecting to address the outstanding dangerous corners? And then I have a separate question, which is: are LPs better regardless of the benefit being low, being less? I mean...

(02:21:48)

You know what, I'll say, I guess maybe this is the overall theme: right, in theory we can do everything everywhere all at the same time. In reality, we need to focus our resources where we think they can have the greatest bang. I think you can be everywhere, at any commissioner. I wish, I wish. So that's the short answer. I mean, you mentioned also these high-crash corridors, or Boulevards of Death. That's another thing, right? So we're always trying to balance and figure out how we can have the greatest possible impact and save the greatest number of

(02:22:24)

lives. And given that it's low cost, I would like to see a more rapid expansion of LPIs at these intersections.

(02:22:31)

These intersections, and I understand that, you know, we're talking about resources, and this is one of those things that

(02:22:36)

doesn't require that much resource. So I think it's more of a question on, like, the operationalizing of it: when can we get it done, and by when? So if you could just please keep us in the loop on that expansion and where they're going to be implemented. We would love to see more. Yeah, I'll absolutely huddle with my team on that. Thank you.

(02:22:40)

Lanes keep riders safe for the length of a block, but then at the end, but then end at the intersection

(02:22:56)

With protected intersections, on the other hand, the bike lane is extended around the intersection, which offers a significant benefit for cyclist safety.

(02:23:03)

Other cities in the United States, like Seattle, Chicago, and San Francisco, implement these types of protections. Given a majority of crashes occurring at intersections, why do we not have protected bike intersections in New York City? More of that. Ah, thank you. Yes, we certainly see the value of

(02:23:12)

protected intersections. It is something that we've started to incorporate into our toolbox, and you can see examples of that around the city. I would say that we're increasing our use of it. I know it's a new thing, and I understand that it's all about a resource question, but, you know, let us know where that is on the agenda when you do have that. If you can maybe answer it now, Reverend.

(02:23:32)

Beeton, that'd be great. Sure, and I like pronouncing your name. Thank you.

(02:23:59)

I remember earlier this year I had a fun pronouncing your name. I like it too. Thank you. A bit, but I would say there's two different things.

(02:24:03)

At first, when we do new bike lanes, we typically use the so-called protected intersection or Dutch-style intersection design, and the places we don't use it are places that might have a very high number of turns, where something like a split phase for traffic might make sense. We want to make sure we're using the right thing at the right place. We also are going back to many of the bike lanes that have older designs, and we go back and add the protected-style intersection. For example, when we repave a street that has a bike lane, we don't just put back exactly what was there. We go and make sure we're upgrading it to the latest designs. That takes work. We don't get mileage credit for that kind of work, but we still think it's really important in delivering the safest bike network possible moving forward.

(02:24:11)

When you are constructing protected bike lanes and shovels are already on the ground, is it fair to say that protected intersections could just be added as part of those projects without being a significant cost? That's right. When we're doing new lanes, we always want to do the safest thing possible at the intersection, which in many cases is that protected intersection. And can we see that in future projects? I think you see that in a lot of the projects going in right now. Really, all the projects going in right now incorporate it into the work that we do.

(02:25:01)

Yes. And then retroactively, there are protected bike lanes where they were not being implemented. Was the agency's realistic ability here to

(02:25:04)

go back and add these back, protected intersections? So we certainly go back and add them any time we're redoing the markings on the corridor, such as after resurfacing, or if we're seeing crash-related issues on a corridor, we'll go back and redesign as well.

(02:25:34)

All right. So as more of the streets get milled and repaved and otherwise implemented, we'll ask about that at the annual hearing we do next year.

(02:25:43)

Regarding Sammy's Law. Sammy's Law expanded New York City's authority to lower speed limits on certain streets.

(02:26:00)

Lower speed limits are a central component of Vision Zero. Representing nearly New Yorkers, 63 elected officials have now formally demanded Sammy's slow zones in their districts.

(02:26:12)

The Vision Zero reimagined commits to expanding 20 mph speed limits with entire neighborhoods or other defined zones.

(02:26:17)

What is the expected scale of this rollout? How large will the zones be, and how many neighborhoods will get a slow zone each year? I'm excited about this one.

(02:26:33)

You know, we, as we all know, speeding is one of the largest contributors to fatal traffic crashes, so we certainly support the goal of bringing speeds down across the city. Something we've learned through experience is that generally lowering the speed limits is most effective when it's paired with traffic-calming improvements, and that's why we've kind of positioned it that way in Vision Zero Reimagined. As you know, we took the big step of announcing that we will do these lower-speed zones outside of essentially all New York City schools by the end of the term of this administration, the first term of this administration, and we're excited to build on that. And so, yeah, Envision, your Reimagine, we talk about doing it at a neighborhood in terms of the actual, I guess, magnitude of that. It's something that's in development. This is an entirely new program, basically, the details. But I think we want to do it at a scale that makes sense, and we want to learn from some of our global peers as well. In terms of it should be a large enough scale that you get that area-wide effect, but it should also be contained enough that we can put in the traffic calming effectively. And yeah, I mean, I guess I would just, I didn't mention it, but it's been really wonderful for us to see this groundswell of support from community boards, and to hear that this is something that so many New Yorkers want to see in their neighborhood, and we want to

(02:26:42)

absolutely have that be a part of our decision-making process. We also want to follow the data and make sure that every neighborhood can benefit, and that we're focusing these where they can have the greatest safety impact. So it's both. I have to ask, if the agency loves the community board's support and the community support more broadly, why is the stepping applications for the creation of noose labor?

(02:26:56)

We know speeding is one of the largest contributors to fatal traffic crashes. We certainly support the goal of bringing speeds down across the city. Something we have learned through experience is that generally lowering the speed limits is most effective when it is paired with traffic calming improvements, and that is why we have positioned it that way in Vision Zero Reimagined. We took the big step of announcing that we will do these lower speed zones outside of essentially all New York City schools by the end of the term of this administration, the first term of this administration, and we are excited to build on that. So, yes, envision, re-imagine, we talk about doing it at a neighborhood scale. In terms of the actual magnitude of that, it is something that is in development. This is an entirely new program, basically, and those details are still being worked out, but we want to do it at a scale that makes sense. We want to learn from some of our global peers as well. It should be a large enough scale that you get that area-wide effect, but it should also be contained enough that we can put in the traffic calming effectively. I guess I would just add, I did not mention it, but it has been really wonderful for us to see this groundswell of support from community boards, and to hear that this is something that so many New Yorkers want to see in their neighborhood, and we want to...

(02:28:30)

Absolutely. We have that be a part of our decision-making process. We also want to follow the data and make sure that every neighborhood can benefit, and that we are focusing these where they can have the greatest safety impact. So it is both. I have to ask: if the agency loves the community board's support, and the community support more broadly, why is the stepping applications for the creation of "noose labor"...

(02:28:53)

Of a new neighborhood slow zones, do you have any plans to reopen applications? Well, the neighborhood slow zones, I think that's a program that was phased out maybe around 10 years ago. I guess you could see it in some ways as an early precursor to this support to these neighborhood slow zones. I think the key difference, like I mentioned, is the more intensive design treatment that complements the lower speed limit. We would like to... it's always a balancing act, right? We want to be responsive to where the demand is. We also want to make sure we're following the data, and we want to make sure that all neighborhoods, even those we always... we don't hear from as much, can benefit from these types of things. So it's all in the mix.

Yeah, your data on neighborhood slow zones showed that this was actually incredibly effective. So should we reopen applications for these? I know that a lot of folks have been asking for it. I'm beating a dead horse, I understand. It's something we can look at. I think we should go back and look, and the team has. But I get a little more up to speed in terms of what the lessons learned were from the earlier program, and I'm sure that it's directly informing what we're developing, right?

(02:30:15)

Speaking of Sammy's Law, how many streets have had their speed limits reduced under Sammy's Law? I can say, at least for the schools, and we have more detail here, this year we've done over 200 of the 15-mile-an-hour slow zones. I'm expecting to hit roughly 800 by the end of the year. In terms of the school ones, I know we've done it on other corridors, a few dozen other corridors. And these are... these other quarterly... these are based on Sammy's Law zones. I think it's a...

(02:30:53)

Yeah, yeah. A lot of the other uses have been in places where we have things like open streets or shared streets, where there's some of that natural traffic coming built in already. So we are doing, as I said, both.

(02:31:07)

We're doing all the schools, and that's something we've already committed to. We're also doing it in these other areas where we compare it with traffic calming.

(02:31:17)

And sometimes that's on a street basis, sometimes that will be on a neighborhood basis. But we want to really put those together. We're not just putting up signs. We're really delivering a street designed for slower traffic. You mentioned that you've done 800 so far this year, 800 by the end of the year.

(02:31:31)

What about next year? How much do you do by then? Where is our commitment to do all eligible schools, which is the vast majority, or almost all? It's 2,300 school locations, which has about 3,200 schools, and some are co-located. By the end of this term, got it. So 800 by the end of this year, no number commitment for next year so far, but you're committing to doing all schools by the end of the term. Are you finding barriers to broader implementation of reduced speed areas? I mean, yeah, and I think it's part of the same overall... it's kind of what Deputy Commissioner and others we've been talking about. We were always trying to calibrate and target our investments to have the greatest impact. So again, I don't know that there's any specific barriers. I think it's more just about how do we balance that program, the approaches that we take to improve safety. Certainly, you were sort of getting into the criteria that DOT uses to prioritize Sammy's Law locations, like shared streets, open streets. Can you speak to any other factors that the department considers when prioritizing locations?

Sure. One of them is related to the barriers that you're talking about. One of which is the law itself does have specific... roads on which we are not allowed to do them, right? It's roads over three lanes outside of Manhattan. And those are often the most dangerous roads in those neighborhoods, so we do want to make sure that we are... which are just, you know, we're not included. We were specifically exempted from the state law. Beyond that, I think it's really we do want to look at the places where we're also doing the traffic calming at the same time. I think what we've seen over time is that just putting up signs has pretty limited effect. We're lucky when New Yorkers see signs at all. If there's something on a couple of blocks, most people just don't notice it. But we wanted to be reinforcing with the street design itself. So places where we want to do traffic calming, places where there's been crashes or neighborhood-wide issues, we want to do the speed limit changes, and we want to pair it with the traffic calming that really makes it real.

(02:39:56)

Thank you. The budget for Sammy's Law implementation around school zones was increased by 300... 370, 70,527, with more in the out years to install signage and hire planners to assess sign impacts on the streets.

How much of this has the department already spent, and can you give us a breakdown of where the funds have gone? Yes, so I can get you a breakdown of what has been spent. But what it goes to, two main things: it goes to hiring staff. You can call it planning, we call it inspections, where they just go in and say this is the pole we need to put the sign on. And then there's a crew, in the shop, that we buy the aluminum, we buy the retroreflective sheeting material. We would love to take you on a tour of the shop sometime if you want. There's a whole process where we produce the signs, and we have fabulous, dedicated staff who are so proud of the work that they do on signs. It's really amazing.

That would be... I would actually love to do that. That sounds great. But we find the places for the signs, we produce the sign, then we have a crew that goes out in the truck and goes up in a bucket and installs the sign. So it's not a huge amount of money, but it's all the steps along the way that get funded.

I have questions on low-traffic neighborhoods, and then after this set of questions I'll turn it over to my colleague for round two questioning. Now I'll turn it over to my colleague. Throughout the Vision Zero Reimagined report, the administration makes a range of commitments regarding the future of traffic management planning in the city, and particularly with respect to pedestrian-focused street design. For example, the administration states that it wants to establish pedestrian priority districts. Quote, "Pedestrian priority districts," quote, "shift New York City streets towards people rather than cars," and quote, "expand and innovate the city's toolkit of transformative corridor and neighborhood designs," for example, like boulevards, slow zones, and other speed management and volume reduction tools. Like with most aspects of the visions that we imagine, the report, these commitments sound great, but the devil's in the details.

So, to start with respect to the administration's commitment to exploring, quote, "other speed management and volume reduction tools," can you please describe what these tools are, and do they include low-traffic neighborhoods?

Thank you, Chair. I think there's a family of treatments that are on a spectrum, from things that are really about reducing through traffic on local streets, to things that are about reducing speed, which is similar but also separate, potentially, and then things that are about creating more space for pedestrians. It depends on the neighborhood. If you're looking at a dense commercial retail district where pedestrians are literally or figuratively spilling off the sidewalk, you want to look at treatments that actually create more space for pedestrians or give them more use of the entire roadway. In a lower-traffic, quieter area, it might be more of a concern from the community around cut-through traffic.

So there's a range of treatments that are related here, whether it's pedestrian-only zones, pedestrian priority zones, or low-traffic neighborhoods. We absolutely see the potential of these as an important tool for keeping New Yorkers safe. We certainly are looking at and learning from our peers, in particular London, but also other places around the world that are employing these kinds of tools. And we're really excited, to be honest. Some of these ideas are still in development, so it'd be hard to provide specifics, but we're excited to share more and to talk more.

I look forward to anything you have to share on this. This is really exciting. I know in your testimony you mentioned you're excited for future conversations on this subject, and that you support the goals of the bill, which we really welcome. You also mentioned in your testimony that you have thought on how best to define or structure low-traffic neighborhoods. Can you speak to that?

Yeah, I think it's just, to my last point, it's helpful to be a little more precise around what we mean by that and what it includes. Does it include how much of it is the speed management component, the through-traffic management? I think that way it'll be helpful to us, especially if we're going to be reporting out on our progress, or have certain targets. Look, we work with the administration on this. What we do want to make clear is this will be the first true low-traffic neighborhood in the country. We want a true neighborhood approach, not just... we want a true neighborhood approach. As long as we share that goal on a true neighborhood approach, I think we can land the plane on this.

DOT recently announced the first permanent school street with swing gates to block vehicle traffic during the school day. Thank you for the invitation to that. Sorry I couldn't make it. I thought it was very cool looking at the photos. Does DOT have plans to expand the use of this infrastructure, and could these gates be a viable option for low-traffic neighborhoods throughout the city?

I think it has a lot of potential. What we've seen when we're starting programs, and as we're evolving our toolkit... it's a big, complex city, and so things need to be battle-tested on the ground, because New York does put a lot of demands on infrastructure in terms of withstanding things. In the case of school streets and other open streets, we've seen historically the use of what we call French barricades, these movable fences. Those have some advantages, but they also have some challenges. I think a swing gate has a lot of potential. We want to evaluate this first use, see how it works, and if it works, then it would be great to scale it up.

(02:40:37)

Low-traffic neighborhoods have many benefits. They prevent cut-through traffic in residential areas. While cut-through traffic is a problem all over the city, it is worse in certain communities. What data does the department use to analyze cut-through traffic?

(02:40:54)

And how is that data used to inform street design interventions? Yeah, that's a really good question, Chair, because it is one of the things that...

(02:41:03)

Other cities have used to really choose what they're doing, things like low-traffic neighborhoods. We don't have knowledge of where every vehicle is in the city at all times, but what we're trying to do now is use some of the bigger data sources that use things like anonymized cell phone data to figure out where there are areas where a vehicle starts or ends in an area, which is kind of a description of cut-through traffic.

(02:41:29)

Is there any way you can get data from Waze or these companies to help you study that?

(02:41:30)

(continued)

(02:41:34)

Yeah, yeah. Without naming all the companies...

(02:41:35)

Like that. The kind of things...

(02:41:39)

Something I'll just add: I thought was pretty eye-opening is that a large chunk of our automated camera violations actually go to vehicles registered out of the city. So it does seem like if some New Yorkers or some neighborhoods are perceiving that there's folks cutting through their neighborhood, the data suggests that that is the case. So that just underscores the potential here.

(02:42:05)

Are there any street design tools currently used by DOT that are primarily aimed at reducing cut-through traffic in residential areas that don't include a LTN?

(02:42:15)

Yes, so I mean, just CM Restler actually mentioned one that we implemented just a few weeks ago in his district, where we used what we call a diverter, where traffic is allowed on every street in the intersection, but traffic from certain streets is forced to make a left or a right onto another street, so they can't just drive straight through. That's an example of a thing that we've learned from places like London as being very effective. It's designed so that if you're on a bike or you're walking, you can of course continue going straight, but for traffic, you cannot take a direct route.

(02:42:51)

Have you all been in

(02:42:52)

conversation with London folks or government leaders there?

Yeah, absolutely. In fact, I got to see some of these in person not too long ago, and we've even had them come and exchange knowledge with our team. So we're trying to soak up as much information as we can.

(02:43:11)

Great. A critical piece of

(02:43:12)

this legislation is reporting on the impacts of the LTN pilot areas.

(02:43:16)

What would a before-and-after data report look like, and what data do you think would be important for understanding success?

Sure. We can talk about everything that might go into a report, but of course it starts with safety. I think everyone expects that if there's less traffic in an area, it's likely to lead to safety, so that's kind of a minimum level. But we also want to look at things like making sure that we're not affecting emergency response times. We want to make sure that as traffic is diverted to other streets, it's not affecting bus speed on those other streets. We want to make sure that we're not benefiting one area at the cost of another. And again, some of the lessons from London are that you don't see those spillover effects. But as we measure it in New York, we want to know for ourselves and be able to tell, not just what's happening

(02:43:25)

in the immediate neighborhood, but also in any surrounding areas. What we saw in London was that the surrounding neighborhood traffic did not increase significantly, and so...

(02:44:05)

All right, there's this variation from place to place, but generally it did not. And that's a positive. What we also found was that emergency response times also didn't significantly increase, and partly because you have less traffic, so it's easier, of course, to get around. Something we saw over there, and hopefully it happens here.

(02:44:15)

I'm going to ask my last question of this hearing before I turn over to my colleagues, and that's for...

(02:44:16)

For years there has been consistent photographic evidence that streets surrounding NYPD precincts are inundated with illegally parked cars. This parking behavior has cascading impacts on the surrounding community: for pedestrians, residents, and local businesses. These problems have been so longstanding that there are now academic studies looking into the street safety issues surrounding our police precincts.

(02:44:29)

Unfortunately, but unsurprisingly, there are finding evidence that pedestrian safety is worse near police precincts. In my district, on a hundred street, there's... you know, there is a sign in spray paint to block the days of alternate-side parking for the cars to be gone, and it signs off DS and DY...

(02:44:46)

I don't know if it's true that the DY, let another government agency that needs to move its cars on certain dates, but this is an issue that is pervasive in our city.

(02:44:48)

What is the agency's position on it? Does the department recognize that it is a problem? I'll start there. Parking, obviously, in the city and around our precincts can be challenging, and it is something that we absolutely do recognize and take efforts to address. Our standards and assessment section is conducting daily command visits. We're evaluating our parking compliance, and we're evaluating that at department facilities. So it's something we look into, and we're trying to make sure that we meet all of our guidelines. Where we don't meet those guidelines, the standards assessment section is going to be documenting those findings and they are reported to department leadership. What's

(02:45:11)

being done to... I mean, do you recognize that it is a problem? Challenge to park in these areas? I mean, there's just a limited amount of space. It's a real issue.

(02:45:32)

So when you say challenging, is that a justification for the illegal parking?

(02:45:33)

No. As I said, it's something we take seriously. And as I just walked through, there are steps that we take to try to make sure that we're in compliance. And when there are indications of misuse of parking permits, those parking permits can be revoked. There could be other discipline as well.

(02:45:43)

What are you doing to address these

(02:45:46)

issues? So, I mentioned the standards assessment section is conducting those on a daily basis. All of that information they're collecting is going to be reported up to department leadership. So we're looking at this command by command. Those are coming on a daily basis. We're looking at our parking and making sure they are in compliance with our guidelines, and whether it departs from that. Something that gets escalated.

(02:45:53)

Why wasn't this issue

(02:46:24)

Being done to... I mean, do you recognize that it is a problem? Challenge to park in these areas. I mean, there's just a limited amount of space. It's a real issue.

(02:46:34)

So when you say challenging, is that a justification for the illegal parking?

(02:46:40)

No, and as I said, it's something we take seriously.

(02:46:42)

As I just walked through, there are steps that we take to try to make sure that we're in compliance. When there are indications of misuse of parking permits, those parking permits can be revoked. There could be other discipline as well. What are you doing to address these issues?

(02:46:57)

Uh, so I mentioned the Standards Assessment Section.

(02:46:59)

They are conducting those on a daily basis. All of that information they're collecting is going to be reported up to the department leadership. So we're looking at this command by command. Those are coming on a daily basis. We're looking at our parking and making sure they comply with our guidelines, and whether it departs from that. Something gets escalated.

(02:47:17)

Why wasn't this issue...

(02:47:18)

Mentioned and Vision Zero re-imagined. Are there any action items you're committed to pursuing to help address these problems going forward? Well, so as I said, it is something that we do look at every day. We document issues when we find them, we take action to correct them when we can. So it's something we absolutely take seriously. We want to move forward on it and would welcome any suggestions from the Council about what we could be doing better. And you know, Council Members, and two, so souls earlier...

(02:47:35)

Them when we can. So it's something we absolutely take seriously. We want to move forward on it and would welcome any suggestions from the Council about what we could be doing better. And you know, Council Members, and two, so souls earlier...

(02:47:48)

Like, I'm not doubting that network isn't happening or that work is happening, but it's clearly not enough.

(02:47:55)

Because the behavior on every police precinct in my district, the two sixes is better than the others, but every other police precinct in my district, and the 3-3, it was pretty bad.

(02:48:13)

Councilman Chairman, would be happy to discuss with you about those specific instances you're seeing in your district.

(02:48:18)

Ah, with questions, we're going to begin with Council...

(02:48:21)

Member Purina Sanchez, followed by Wang. Thank you so much, Majority Leader, and thank you for this very important hearing. So I have two sets of questions. The first one, and apologies if this topic has been touched on, but Vision Zero, Vision Zero Reimagined and the Streets Plan all charged the agency with redesigning streets to improve pedestrian safety, as we've been talking about today, including consideration of hardened daylighting. In my neck of the woods, DOT has made significant changes to Bailey Avenue and Sedgwick Avenue in recent years, including this year. Yet the most dangerous intersections of all, where the street grid collides with the entrance and exit ramps of the I-87 or Major Deegan Expressway at Burnside, Fordham Road, and 230th Street, have remained largely unchanged. How do I explain to my constituents why no changes were made at the most dangerous intersections of all, where there were significant redesigns? And part two is, help me. What interventions exist to make these specific kinds of high-conflict locations, like highway entrances, more safe, and what should I be advocating that you do at these locations?

(02:49:32)

Oh, thank you so much, Council Member. And I've got to say, I had the pleasure of breaking down barely just a couple weekends ago and seeing the new extension there. And also seeing, came by and said, I lived right, yeah, next time. I happen to be coming back from something in Marble Hill, but, so you know, but I also saw some of the challenges that you mentioned. I know that something we were pretty proud of at the northern end by Van Cortlandt Park, there's some ramps right from the highway there, and we were able to make some pretty significant changes. I am not sure if you want to speak about some of the others.

(02:50:11)

Yeah, and like these...

(02:50:13)

Interfaces. Between the highway and...

(02:50:14)

Streets have been, an, an...

(02:50:16)

Increased. They tend to be complicated intersections.

(02:50:19)

They also are a little bit...

(02:50:19)

More complicated because they also involve people beyond us, like, you know, the Fordham Road exit off the Deegan is really controlled by a state entity. And so we've been in touch with them and expressed that that is a priority for us. At the end of it, it's their bridge and their highway, so we need them to come to the table. Them, and we have very creative designers, but part of the reason those sometimes take longer is because it's not as much in our control as some.

(02:50:48)

Of the. Sorry, just because I'm limited on time, I have another question. What changes should I be advocating for when we do get State DOT at the table?

(02:50:55)

Sure. And it varies location by location, but essentially what we want to do is make sure we're protecting pedestrians and providing safe time for pedestrians to cross. And then make sure that the turning vehicles are properly managed. You know, we can talk to you separately in great detail, but obviously at Fordham and the Deegan, the problem is that the left turns overlap tremendously, so that people go around and make double and triple left turns. That's the thing. The intersection design causes the bad behavior, and so there are different intersection designs that have happened since the 1950s that do better at that sort of thing.

(02:51:32)

Thank you. And then my second question, and more to come on that, because these areas are very dangerous. Highland, the lighting contract. I have before me a letter that my community board, number eight, sent over to the Comptroller, cc the Bronx Commissioner and other DOT staff, regarding lights that have been out for nine months, ten months a year at a time. I also myself have reported lights around the Jerome Park Reservoir that have been out for months and months and months. And we understand that the agency is not able to hold Highland accountable. That is the interpretation we have in the community, because reports are made, it's not the exact address, then the light complaints, the lighting complaints, are closed. Inspections are only happening in the daylight. How does the company know that the lights are still off? And so much more: an update on the status of your contract with Highland, how many light complaints are in backlog, and when can we expect to have our lights back and functioning in these communities, because it's creating dangerous conditions? So, I can say, you know, I'm not sure if we're equipped to address this specific contract today, but I can say, and I mentioned this earlier, lighting is something I've definitely heard a lot about in my time in this role. And, you know, it's clear communities, it really affects people's lives day to day. And I'll be honest, it's an area where we've had some challenges.

As happens sometimes when you've got large operations, in this case we're working to really expand our contract capacity and be able to be more nimble and address some of these lighting things quicker going forward. So, my point is, it's very much on my radar and our radar, and it's something we're really focused on. Our Street Lighting Division is actively working to remediate some of these challenges. You can ask a follow-up, yes.

(02:52:42)

I'm not sure if we're equipped to address this specific contract today, but I can say, and I mentioned this earlier, you have been outlighting is something I've definitely heard a lot about in my time in this role. It's clear communities... it really affects people's lives day to day. I'll be honest, it's an area where we've had some challenges. As happens sometimes when you've got large operations, in this case we're working to really expand our contract capacity and be able to be more nimble and address some of these lighting things quicker going forward. So, my point is, it's very much on my radar and our radar, and it's something we're really focused on. Our Street Lighting Division is actively working to remediate some of these challenges. You can ask a

(02:53:34)

Follow-up, yes.

(02:53:35)

Just very quickly. This letter was sent last week. I hope that you all can send us a formal response. It was sent on October 21, and so we'd really appreciate the specifics on when our lights are going to... Yeah, happy to check with our traffic operations team and connect with you.

(02:53:51)

Thank you, Counselor Sanchez. We are going to have a hearing in the new year on public realm and streetlights, where we're going to go into the details on that even more. As mentioned before by Councilman Restler, as an issue, I just got an email from Councilor Morano about this. It's an issue in every borough, and so we're going to take a close look at that. CM Wong, followed by Justin Sanchez.

(02:54:13)

Thank you, Majority Leader, and Chair. I requested a lot of traffic devices near intersections of schools, they carry some playground, and my question here is to DOT, DOT's studies, which can take four to seven months depending on the device under review. My question is, when the request involves a school, daycare, or a playground, how does the team make sure its observations capture the periods when kids are actually crossing, and are studies conducted during arrival and dismissal while a school is in session? Please answer that. Sure, and that's a great question, and something that we really do try to pay attention to. Most intersections around the city, you try to capture the morning and the evening rush hour, but we know near schools, sometimes near parks, you get a different peak of when kids might be crossing the street. Sometimes it's a Saturday afternoon right near a park. And so what we do is we put down counters that can give us a 24-hour count as a starting place, so that when we go and count pedestrians, we can make sure we're doing it outside of the hours for those locations. And then we look and we see, hey, there's a school right there. We need to make sure that we're capturing school dismissal. We do try to be very aware if sometimes there's something that we might not know about a neighborhood. You don't know that there's a special event that happens midday there. That's where we rely on input from local Council Members and other experts who can tell us.

Make sure you check this hour, and we will go and do that. It was a follow-up: what conditions qualify a location for an expedited review or interim protection while a longer study is underway? All right, so we know that we'll have to get back to you, because that's beyond my specific expertise. But one thing I will talk about is if there's been a recent history of crashes, right? In the end, we're responding to some very recent events, then that's something that we have to take into account and make sure we're being responsive to something newer going on.

(02:54:40)

Okay, thank you. Um, second question, also in... Um, in my district, I have parking spaces that have been taken over by Amazon delivery trucks, well, big trucks or packages, pulling in, and then walkers, people walk up with dollies, with hand trucks, with all sorts of devices, pick up their packages, and then they come back and they do it again. All right, the problem here is, these trucks are not in these loading or unloading zones. They are in residential streets. They take over parking spaces. And now let me tell you how I know about it, because they chose the intersection in front of my office, and they're there the whole day, like 8 o'clock all the way to six. And I see it as a citywide problem, because I see it in Jackson Heights, Corona, other parts of Queens. So my question to you is, are you allowing this to happen, or is something you need to address, because it's clearly a problem, because they're taking over residential streets and parking spaces?

(02:55:31)

Please answer. Thank you, Council Member. Yeah, I mean, I think what we're seeing is really these trends that have accelerated, especially since the pandemic, in online shopping and online delivery, and just a much higher delivery activity in residential areas than we saw historically. And I think that highlights the need for curb space and how we provide it. We are doing a lot of innovative work. We have a whole freight team devoted to this that's part of our new Curb Management Division, and we're trying a few different tools across the board. Because there's two things in tension: we want less trucks circling over the place to make deliveries, but if they're not doing that, then they're going to do what you described, which is basically what we would call micro-distribution, where they stop in one place and then use maybe hand trucks, or they just walk, or maybe use a cargo bike to make the final delivery. So we do have a micro hub pilot program. We're also looking at things like shared lockers, where the deliveries can be made by Amazon, for example, to one set of lockers, and then residents come and get it. That also helps with theft avoidance. So the short answer is, it's very much on our radar, and we're trying to explore a range of options to minimize all the trucks circling and have dedicated space for deliveries.

(02:56:28)

Yeah, and I want to point out that as soon as the truck is empty, you pull out, another one can't pull in, and so on. So a lot of online shopping.

(02:57:39)

Yeah, there, the whole day, and that's clearly a problem, and it's a citywide issue.

(02:58:57)

Please, I please look into it. This discussion and come up with ideas that would be great. A priority. Thank you, Brooks-Powers, followed by Justin Sanchez, then Hanif. Thank you, Chair, and thank you for the testimony today. I'm Ping Pong in a bit today. Regarding my bill, Intro 0113, I wanted to ask, the administration's new plan makes removing dangerous drivers its first goal, and says nearly half of traffic deaths involve a driver who was unlicensed, previously suspended, or had multiple convictions. Intro 113 asks that the study exactly those patterns and report on them every year. You have stated this before, so I apologize if it's redundant, because I was chairing another hearing. But I want to know what DOT's official position is, and will the plan, Vision Zero data warehouse, include conviction, license status, and insurance data, and when will it be up and running? Thank you, Council Member. So we very much support studies like this that help us better understand the trends that we're seeing out there and how we can be more equitable and targeted in enforcement and other safety strategies. This is, in many ways, that's sort of the bread and butter, right? And I think anything we can do to better understand what's driving safety challenges is helpful. So we're excited to work with the Council and yourself too, to ensure that, I guess, to kind of hone the legislation and how we can make it most effective.

In terms of the data warehouse, one of our concerns with the bill is data sources we don't have access to as the City or as DOT. And so that falls, I think, both the insurance data, which has been, I think, a longstanding issue. Insurance firms have not provided that data to the City in the past, despite our deep desire to be aware of it, as well as the victim data, obviously living outside the marital control. So I think we're happy to continue conversations and think about are there novel ways that we can look for that data, because the data warehouse is a huge project that we're really, crash locations are really talking to each other. When will it be up and running? We'll have to get back to you on that. I don't have it in

(02:59:06)

Front of me today. Okay. Intro 0113 also asked relevant agencies to report on the steps taken to reduce accidents caused by dangerous drivers. What steps are already in place to reduce those accidents, and what more do you feel can be done?

(02:59:11)

Thank you. Yeah, it's really, it's sort of all of the above approach. Infrastructure, you know, I think in our ideal world, all drivers would behave safely, right? And you wouldn't even necessarily need enforcement, and folks could spend their violation money on better things, right? So we like to start with infrastructure and engineering and redesigning our streets, because in many...

(02:59:22)

You, you for...

(02:59:29)

Of course. You know what I mean? That's the most sustainable, right? It's the most sort of legible and elegant in a way. And so that's always our starting point. And so that's obviously following the data and innovating with new approaches to street design. Sometimes that's not enough, and so that's where we start to look at some of the other tools. We think that automated enforcement has been really effective, and the stats are very compelling, and we could talk more about that, but that's certainly a key piece.

(02:59:33)

And then there's sort of, you know, the question of, well, what happens with really the folks for whom even that isn't a deterrent, right? The folks who are just racking up speeding tickets and red light violations. And that's where something like the Super Speeder program can be a great tool, and things like we talked about earlier, about looking at ghost plates, and some of the other more systemic challenges.

(03:00:03)

Yeah, I appreciate that. My last question is for NYPD. Hi, Chief Phobic. Two questions for you. How many vehicles registered to people with suspended or revoked licenses does NYPD each year, and how many are caught on camera? And in the past year, how many Leaving the Scene and Right-of-Way law arrests were made, and how many led to convictions? I don't have the whole universe of what you're talking about, but I do have VTL 511 arrests. We are up 9% year to date, 2026 through, 2018, 2006, 63, versus 2070, from a year-end 2025. Reckless driving arrests, which is VTL 1192, 18, 15 versus 784 from last year. And reckless driving, nine versus 52, 90. Thank you, thank you.

(03:01:39)

Chair, CM Justin Sanchez, followed by Haneef. So the Hub is the second largest most visited place in the State of New York after Times Square on a daily basis. Additionally, a study of collision data found that the Bronx and its residents are more likely to be in traffic crashes than New Yorkers that live in any other borough, with the Hub being a particular hotspot. Will DOT consider more of a Times Square-ification of the Hub, that is, pedestrianization of the area, and can the agency commit to conducting a neighborhood study to address pedestrian mobility, busway viability, and ultimately address street safety? Thank you, Council Member. You know, I know that in many ways the Hub is sort of like the downtown for the Bronx, and it has that, and it is a hub literally, right, where multiple modes come together. So, you know, I guess one thing I'll mention, on the safety side, something we're really proud of is we looked at the distribution of some of the safety gains we've seen in the last few years, and actually the Bronx and Queens have seen the greatest safety gains under our Vision Zero efforts in the last few years.

(03:01:53)

Thank you. Yeah, it's really all of the above approach: infrastructure. In an ideal world, all drivers would behave safely, and you wouldn't even necessarily need enforcement, and folks could spend their violation money on better things. So we like to start with infrastructure and engineering and redesigning our streets, because in many

(03:02:20)

You, you for

(03:02:21)

Of course, you know what I mean. That's the most sustainable. It's the most legible and elegant in a way, and so that's always our starting point. That's obviously following the data and innovating with new approaches to street design. Sometimes that's not enough, and so that's where we start to look at some of the other tools. We think that automated enforcement has been really effective, and the stats are very compelling, and we could talk more about that, but that's certainly a key piece.

(03:02:57)

And then there's the question of, well, what happens with the folks for whom even that isn't a deterrent? The folks who are just racking up speeding tickets and red light violations. That's where something like the Super Speeder Program can be a great tool. And things like we talked about earlier, about looking at ghost plates and some of the other more systemic challenges.

(03:03:19)

Yeah, I appreciate that. My last question is for NYPD. Hi, Chief Phobic. Two questions for you. How many vehicles registered to people with suspended or revoked licenses does NYPD each year, and how many are caught on camera? And in the past year, how many Right of Way law arrests were made, and how many led to convictions? I don't have the whole universe of what you're talking about, but I do have VTS 511 arrests. We are up 9% year to date, 2026 through 2018, 22,006 versus 20,709 from a

(03:04:02)

year end 2025. Reckless driving arrests, which is VTS 1121, 1218 versus 784 from last year, and reckless driving, 9 versus 52. Thank you. Thank

(03:04:19)

You. Chair CM Justin Sanchez, followed by Haneef. So the Hub is the

(03:04:27)

Second largest most visited place in the State of New York after Times Square on a daily basis. Additionally, a study of collision data found that the Bronx and its residents are more likely to be in traffic crashes than New Yorkers that live in any other borough, with the Hub being a particular hotspot.

(03:04:47)

Would DOT consider more of a Times Square-ification of the Hub, that is, pedestrianization of the area, and can the agency commit to conducting a neighborhood study to address pedestrian mobility, busway viability, and ultimately address street safety? Thank you, Council

(03:04:49)

Member. You know, I know that in many ways the Hub is sort of like the downtown for the Bronx, and it has that, and it is a hub literally where multiple modes come together. So, you know, I guess one thing I'll mention on the safety side is something we're really proud of. We looked at the distribution of some of the safety gains we've seen in the last few years, and actually the Bronx and Queens have seen the greatest safety gains under our Vision Zero efforts in the last few years.

(03:05:06)

I know that in many ways the Hub is sort of like the downtown for the Bronx, and it is a hub literally where multiple modes come together. One thing I will mention on the safety side — something we are really proud of is we looked at the distribution of some of the safety gains we have seen in the last few years, and actually the Bronx and Queens have seen the greatest safety gains under our Vision Zero efforts in the last few years.

(03:05:37)

But there's more to do. The hubs are busy place, so definitely happy to sit down and brainstorm with you and your team around what that kind of study could look like. I'm, oh, you asked also sort of about the public space aspect. So I know Roberto Clemente Plaza was a big investment at the time and was a big change to the hub, but in terms of further public space enhancements, we're definitely open to ideas. I think how it can really best support the community, support businesses, support commuters, it would be really exciting. I would really love to get this on the books sooner rather than later, because we know how long these studies take to get done, and I hate studies. I just like action. Studies just delay us from getting to work. So really just, would love to get that done. In terms of parking permits, has DOT studied how full the curbs are in the outer boroughs, particularly the Bronx, the South Bronx, and what share of parked cars don't belong to people or belong to people who don't actually live there? And if DOT does not collect that data, does the agency have the capacity to gather such data in a piloted area? So this is something that we've looked at over the years, and it was part of the congestion pricing, something we've looked at previously around places like Yankee Stadium that have had specific parking needs.

(03:07:05)

And you see two things, right.

(03:07:08)

Are the vehicles that you see parked on the street registered at the local address? You get a little bit of a mixed bag there. But when you look overnight, you see the same vehicles that tend to be parked there night after night after night, which suggests that even if the registration is elsewhere, they probably are actually belonging to someone who is spending their time in that district. And this is a pattern we actually see all over the city, that a very, very large percentage of the vehicles parked in the free residential spaces, yeah, I do show that pattern of being there for very long stretches of time. And we take that to mean are owned by local residents. So we know that this is something that comes up, especially in busy business areas, where there's entertainment around. So it is a challenge, where a lot of the problem is just that New Yorkers own a lot of cars, and that takes up a lot of the space on the street. Oh, and having said that, there are a lot of cars that belong to people that live around there, but a lot of the times they're not registered to New York. They are not New York plates, and so parking permits address that. And also, yes, they're parked, I think, to your point, they are parked for a very long period of time. They're not moving during alternate side parking. Hence we had to pass the green sticker bill once. Also encourage people to actually have to move their cars.

(03:08:39)

So I think yeah, there's

(03:08:40)

There's a range of tools that we could use that would really encourage, incentivize, or require folks to register their vehicle where they're supposed to register it. What if it's permits, or if it's sort of the way that you charge for a street space in areas that have paid parking? You could have discounts for

(03:09:05)

Local residents whose

(03:09:06)

vehicles are registered locally. There's different ways to look at that, I think, and that's exactly what our curb management group is going to be looking at, those kinds of ideas. Do you think residential parking permits are a good way to mitigate parking scarcity for resident New Yorkers? Does the agency plan to advocate for a permit system in the state legislative agenda? So

(03:09:31)

There's a range of things.

(03:09:32)

I think with residential parking permits, what we've seen is that in other cities, at least, they're not priced in a way that it ends up freeing up parking, because it's priced so cheaply on an annual basis that it's not actually managing the demand. So I

(03:09:48)

Think it can address, though.

(03:09:49)

I think you made this point, Councilmember. It can help with the issue of out-of-state registration. I think it could be helpful, like I said. I think there's also other ways to address that, but RPP, we haven't seen in other cities that they really made much of a dent in the actual demand for parking. Chair, do you

(03:10:07)

Mind if I ask one more question, please? Got it.

(03:10:09)

Um, ah, this is for... thank you. This is for BIC. So BIC was created to drive organized crime out of the commercial waste industry. Now, recent reporting on towing describes armed turf wars between towing companies, including a Bronx body shop owner just sentenced to 19 years for killing a rival. Does BIC see parallels to the industries that it already regulates? Has BIC considered expanding its jurisdictional authority over the towing industry, and could its model of integrity vetting and licensing work for towing?

(03:10:42)

Council Member.

(03:10:45)

As you noted, BIC's current jurisdiction covers the trade waste industry. It also covers the wholesale markets, which are in your district as well, as well as shipboard gambling, and that's our mandate by law. BIC's team is a talented, highly skilled team that is, with respect to identifying patterns of organized crime, and engaged in licensing for businesses where we have concerns about criminality and want to keep criminality out of those businesses. That model could be transposed into other industries. If the city believes that there is a risk of criminality in particular industries, and BIC should come in, we're ready to have those conversations. There could be any number of industries that could be candidates for that, but that's a longer policy discussion. That's going to have to include City Hall, that's going to involve some budgeting questions, and ultimately will require legislation, by City Hall... I'm sorry, legislation by City Council, to give us the authority to move into whatever those new spaces are.

(03:11:47)

Thank you so much, Councilor Rouhani. Followed by one. Thank

(03:11:51)

You, Chair. And hello, great to see everybody. Commissioner Flynn, this is for you. I wanted to come back to Sammy's Law. So 17 community boards representing nearly New Yorkers, along with 63 elected officials, have formally called for Sammy's Law slow zones in their neighborhoods, and I'm proud to be one of those elected officials. The city's own Vision Zero Reimagined plan commits to expanding 20-mile-per-hour speed limits across entire neighborhoods. Yet beyond the five existing Sammy's Law slow zones, speed reductions are to short stretches in front of schools, very short stretches, I would add. Why are we lowering speed limits in neighborhoods? Neighborhoods are demanding

(03:12:40)

Safer streets. And can you tell us what's stopping DOT from implementing neighborhood-wide slow zones, and when we can expect to see them?

(03:12:48)

Thank you, Council Member. And

(03:12:50)

Yeah, I mean, first, you know, I would reiterate that we've been thrilled to see that groundswell of demand, and requests from New York City neighborhoods for lower speeds. We certainly see the value from the safety standpoint in reduced speed limits. I guess your question around the school zones versus area ones, I think that there's room for both. They have somewhat different kinds of goals or targets in mind, but we are really excited about announcing and including in Vision Zero Reimagined rolling out these lower speed zones at more of a neighborhood timeline. For that, well, this is an action plan, so this is a new program we've just announced. We're developing the details of it now, but we'll be looking to roll it out starting next year, neighborhood-wide. Yes, yes. And could you share, like, what criteria, in order to share which neighborhoods would be prioritized?

(03:13:52)

Yeah, I mean, I think where

(03:13:54)

We're kind of neck-deep in developing this sizable program. I think, like I mentioned earlier, we want to strike a balance. It's really helpful for us to hear from communities that are asking for it, and at the same time we also want to use the data to make sure. That also you don't actually have to hear from neighborhoods to know that this needs to get done right.

(03:14:18)

Well, that's right, and we

(03:14:18)

Want to follow the data so that when we make these investments, it can have the greatest possible impact. So we might look at things like where we're seeing speeding, where we're seeing cut-through traffic. Anything you would add? Yeah, those are some of the factors. Crash data clearly is always kind of the baseline.

(03:14:39)

Yeah, I would just push for expedition on this issue. Of course, having slower speed limits by school zones is necessary, but once kids are leaving the school, they're leaving that 150-foot slow zone area, and it's certainly not a substitute for a neighborhood, and so I'd love to just know more details.

(03:15:03)

Yeah, I guess the one other thing I would add is that equity is a big component as well, right? So the new Streets Plan coming out in a couple of months, we'll have the new version of our priority investment areas, and we really try to focus a lot of our investments into the historically disadvantaged neighborhoods. So it's always a balancing act, but we're happy to talk more and share more when we can. And so when you say a couple of months, we're talking... in which, what's December 1? Streets... And then that plan will lay out the proposals for the neighborhood-wide slow zones. I think we're excited to share. It's going to have more details on a number of initiatives, some of which were in the Vision Zero plan, some maybe new, and yeah, we're excited to share more details.

(03:16:00)

Thank you, thank you. CM Number One.

(03:16:02)

Thank you so much, Chair Brewer.

(03:16:07)

What percentage of drivers

(03:16:08)

Yield to pedestrians at both

(03:16:10)

Marked and unmarked crosswalk

(03:16:11)

Walks, and what infrastructure improvements increase yield

(03:16:15)

Rates at pedestrian crossings, and have these infrastructure improvements been considered in the Vision Zero Reimagined plan? So I don't

(03:16:24)

Know that we have that specific data points, but we do know that yielding to pedestrians is an incredibly important thing, and that's something both we work on, from an enforcement perspective, but it's also something that we try to design into the street infrastructure. Just for example, we talked a little bit earlier about design of bike lanes, protected intersections, and one of the very specific ways that that improves safety is by using

(03:16:24)

The physical infrastructure to force drivers to turn more slowly, and to turn at an angle where they can better see both cyclists and pedestrians. So what we want to do is have people turning slowly, so that they can see pedestrians crossing, and therefore yield.

(03:16:49)

So can you just clarify, you don't have the percentage of drivers for yielding to pedestrians, marked and unmarked, or you don't have it with you right now? So that's not something we've measured on a citywide basis. No. Is that something that you could consider measuring with the Vision Zero Reimagined plan, so that we have that data? Let's talk about that and get back to you.

(03:17:04)

Okay. And the leading

(03:17:26)

Pedestrian intervals, LPIs, are the cheapest intersection improvement, given that they require no infrastructure changes. Is Vision Zero Reimagined aware that only half of the signalized intersections have LPIs? Yeah, we've seen great results from LPIs, and we've put in over 600 to date. We continue to roll them out. You're right, Council Member, that there's really a much more, I guess, easier on the wallet, I guess you could say they're easier to roll out that way than to using it. I think it's, again, it's one of the tools that we have, and so it's part of the mix of all the safety improvements that we're making.

(03:17:27)

So is there a hard

(03:18:13)

Commitment from the mayoral admin of how many LPIs would be installed going forward? What the Vision Zero Reimagined plan doesn't include is a commitment specifically around LPIs. Would you be willing to add them? I mean, I think it's a treatment that we remain committed to. As you mentioned, there are signalized intersections we prioritize, in those locations where we think they can have the greatest benefit, and that's places where we're seeing a lot of turn conflicts. The more intersections you put them at, the impact may be a little... that doesn't mean it's not a good idea. It just means, when we're balancing in a world of finite resources, where to focus, we find other things that will have a greater benefit. So I guess what I'm struggling with is, it's clear that we are aligned as a Council, and with what your vision is for safety and what the advocates want. But what I'm having a hard time understanding every single year is the decision tree, or the process, in which you make what safety measures are put into what intersections. So if you could share that after this hearing, as a follow-up to the Chair as well as the members of this committee, it would be really helpful for us to really concretely understand what it is that you're quantifying and qualifying these decisions on, because there's so many tools in the toolbox, and we want to see all of them implemented. Thank you.

(03:19:49)

Thank you, Council Member. I'll meet with the team on

(03:19:52)

That. CM Chris Marte wanted me to ask the question on his behalf. As part of the visions that were reimagined, there were pedestrian priority districts mentioned. Is the administration committing to pedestrian LPIs

(03:20:05)

Manhattan specifically? Ah, oui, we will have more details to share on that program. It's new. We're excited. We think there's a lot of potential in different neighborhoods where we're seeing high pedestrian volumes and lower vehicle volume. So there'll be more to share. The Council Member is very supportive of this project, and I just wanted to communicate that. And

(03:20:31)

I don't want to... I want to scoop your announcement, but regardless of the neighborhood being selected, by when should we expect this pedestrian-only area to be considered done?

(03:20:36)

What we'd like to move quickly on, any and all of the ideas in the Vision Zero Reimagine, sometime next year. I'm sure we'll see movement on just about every initiative in that plan in some way, shape, or form by next year.

(03:20:58)

All right. Well, CM Haneef has one more question, and then we'll close out. Thank you. So this is about the micro hubs. I'm

(03:21:09)

Really pleased to learn about this pilot in my district, and I don't know if this is official, but on Wyckoff between Bond and Hoyt, right near my district office, there has been a hub. I'm not sure if it's official. Would like to know what we can do to either make that a part of the pilot. But I'm getting a lot of constituent complaints, given that the truck... I mean, it seems like it's a subcontractor, parked double parked, and they're doing the deliveries, and it's caused a lot of pain in the obvious residential

(03:21:49)

Neighborhood. Sure, and I don't believe that that's officially part of the program. Let's talk to you about it.

(03:21:55)

And the idea behind it is that we offer something in terms of dedicated space at the curb to a company, and they have to commit that they are not to be double parking or driving around the neighborhood or doing these other bad behaviors. And if we see them doing that, the idea is we take that space away. So we've done a handful of places now. It's seemed to be effective in

(03:22:18)

Across the city. I'd love to bump us up to the top, because there's a ton of deliveries happening, and I've been in touch with the Brooklyn Borough Commissioner Bray on this, but it's still unclear to me what the process is, and I think we've requested to designate the... Sure. Yeah, well, what we and Commissioner Bray will talk to you more about that.

(03:22:45)

Okay, I appreciate it. Thank you.

AI-generated summaries and transcripts. Errors are possible.
Verify against the linked video and send corrections via email.