Examining the Restructure of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety
Committee on Women and Gender Equity
Meeting overview
The Committee on Women and Gender Equity held an oversight hearing on September 30, 2026, examining the restructuring of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence (MODGBV) under the newly created Office of Community Safety (OCS), established by Executive Order 15 in March 2026. The committee also considered several pieces of legislation: a proposed local law requiring the MODGBV to report aggregate data on calls to its survivor hotline; a resolution declaring November 25 as the International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women in honor of the Mirabal sisters; Proposed Int. No. 295-A requiring the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene to establish a menstrual health screening program for endometriosis and polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS); and a resolution calling on New York State to require insurers to cover lactation consultation and counseling services without restrictions. No votes were taken on any legislation.
The administration was represented by OCS Commissioner Dr. Aisha Delaney-Brumsey and a second commissioner identified as Sethi. They argued that the merger elevates rather than diminishes the MODGBV's work, pointing to a $15.7 million budget increase in FY2027, the largest since 2018, bringing the total MODGBV budget to $89.1 million. They described coordination benefits across gun violence, mental health, hate crime prevention and domestic violence, and noted that the MODGBV retains its distinct identity, staff and programs within OCS. They acknowledged missteps in failing to consult the advisory council before the announcement but said they have since responded to the council's letter and met with stakeholders. Council Speaker Julie Menin pressed the administration on whether downgrading the commissioner title to executive director sent the wrong signal to survivors, expressed her view that the MODGBV should remain a freestanding office with a dedicated commissioner, and raised concerns about a 25 percent vacancy rate across the office's 79 staff lines, with 59 positions currently filled. Chair Farías questioned the administration on data reporting continuity, contracting infrastructure, the Crime Victims Assistance Program (CVAP) RFP, budget transparency and the coordination of gender-based violence work with housing, homelessness and gun violence programs.
A large and substantive panel of providers and survivors testified in opposition to the restructuring, almost uniformly calling for the MODGBV to be restored as a standalone office with a commissioner-level leader reporting directly to the mayor. Testifiers included representatives from Sanctuary for Families, Safe Horizon, Urban Resource Institute, Womankind, New Destiny Housing, SAKHI for South Asian Survivors, KAFSC, the Violence and Abuse Prevention Program, Girls for Gender Equity, Sisters in Purple, the Legal Aid Society, the Coalition Against Trafficking in Women and individual survivors. Common themes included: the restructuring announcement was made without survivor or provider consultation, which was particularly damaging for a field built on trauma-informed, transparent practice; the MODGBV's 25-year track record as a public health-focused, survivor-centered coordinator is structurally distinct from general community safety work and cannot simply be absorbed into it; the mayor has not publicly condemned domestic violence despite at least six high-profile domestic violence homicides in his first eight months; adding bureaucratic layers between the office and City Hall will impair the office's ability to coordinate across agencies; small culturally specific organizations face particular risks from contracting disruptions during the transition; and prevention, especially work with young people, perpetrators and communities, remains chronically underfunded. One notable exception was KAFSC, which offered a cautiously supportive view of the broader community safety framework, arguing it could improve coordination for immigrant survivors.
Safe Horizon's CEO raised a specific concern about the CVAP RFP, arguing that it reduces precinct-based funding while adding new requirements, with the program already having been cut from serving 53,000 survivors annually to 40,000 under the Adams administration, and warning it will fall further under the new RFP. New Destiny Housing flagged an urgent housing crisis: approximately 2,000 Emergency Housing Voucher households, many of them domestic violence survivors, face loss of their vouchers with no alternative matched, and called on the City to designate these households as qualifying referrals under CityFHEPS to prevent shelter entry. Survivors testifying in person described concrete failures in case management, court systems, housing and emergency response, illustrating the human cost of fragmented systems. The hearing, while producing no votes or formal decisions, generated a clear legislative and oversight record that the Council chair intends to use in budget negotiations and ongoing engagement with the administration.
The record
- T2026-2461 Hearing on moving domestic violence office under community safety agency (hearing held)
- Int 0295-2026 Law to screen for endometriosis and PCOS (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Int 1079-2026 Law to require yearly reporting on domestic violence hotline calls (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Res 0441-2026 Resolution marking November 25 against violence toward women (heard; awaiting a vote)
- Res 0637-2026 Resolution urging Albany to require full insurance coverage for lactation care (heard; awaiting a vote)
Numbers
- There were over 249,000 domestic violence incident reports in New York City in 2024.
- The MODGBV received a $15.7 million budget increase in FY2027, the largest increase since the office's mission was expanded in 2018.
- The total MODGBV budget for FY2027 is $89.1 million.
- Approximately $7 to $8 million of the $89.1 million budget is allocated to staff; the remainder goes to contracted programming and discretionary Council contracts.
- The MODGBV has 79 staff lines, of which 59 are currently filled, representing approximately a 25 percent vacancy rate.
- There are approximately 100 staff total across all OCS offices.
- The MODGBV currently manages 90 contracts.
- The Home Plus program was expanded to $4.3 million in FY2027 to help survivors remain safely housed.
- Funding for immigration and family law services at the Family Justice Centers increased by 20 percent.
- Mental health and case management services at the Family Justice Centers increased by 20 percent.
- Youth-focused prevention through the Relationship Abuse Prevention Program increased by 20 percent.
- $3 million annually in new community-based, culturally specific services for survivors of gender-based violence was invested in FY2027.
- The Family Justice Centers receive approximately 63,000 visits annually.
- The CVAP previously reached 53,000 survivors annually when fully funded; this fell to 40,000 following Adams-era budget cuts and is expected to fall further under the new RFP.
- The MODGBV hotline receives nearly 100,000 calls annually.
- More than one in five families in the New York City shelter system identify domestic violence as the reason they entered shelter.
- Approximately 60 New Yorkers per year are killed in domestic violence incidents, with roughly half killed by a partner.
- On any given day across New York State, over 1,000 survivors are turned away from services due to lack of capacity.
- The City administers close to 4,800 Emergency Housing Vouchers, including more than 1,000 survivor-led households; approximately 2,000 households have not yet been matched to any alternatives as funding runs out.
- Federal data shows 6.2 percent of women aged 22 to 49 have been diagnosed with endometriosis and 8.7 percent with PCOS in 2022 and 2023.
- Among South Asian American New Yorkers, 85 percent of women aged 18 to 34 report experiencing sexual assault at least once in their lifetime; 48 percent report experiencing domestic violence.
- SAKHI reported a 14 percent increase in survivors served, a 50 percent increase in its food justice program and a 1,000 percent increase in its legal justice program year over year.
- The Domestic Violence Project at the Urban Justice Center opened 2,069 new cases in the first eight months of the Mamdani administration and answered 12,267 warm line calls, more than all calls received in 2025.
- Safe Horizon's CVAP clients reported a 95 percent satisfaction rate with services in the program's current form.
- At least six high-profile domestic violence homicides occurred in New York City in the first eight months of the Mamdani administration.
- A Staten Island Family Justice Center director of community programs position had been vacant for three years before being recently filled.
Action Points
- Administration to provide the committee with a detailed budget breakdown distinguishing MODGBV-specific funding from broader OCS funding within the $89.1 million total.
- Administration to provide the committee with a breakdown of what portion of the $15.7 million increase went to MODGBV programs and contracted services versus other OCS offices.
- OCS to follow up with the committee on whether 311 call center staff have been updated on the MODGBV restructuring so that survivor access is not delayed.
- OCS to report back to CM Gutiérrez on whether survivors and callers are experiencing any difficulties reaching the MODGBV following restructuring.
- OCS to continue filling remaining 20 vacancies across the MODGBV's 79 staff lines and to report on progress.
- Administration to share details of planned community-based service programs funded by the new $3 million culturally specific services investment before year end, and to invite stakeholder feedback.
- Administration to ensure no gaps in contract payments during the transition of MODGBV contracts to OCS, with particular attention to smaller organizations that cannot float delayed payments.
- OCS Commissioner Sethi to continue leading the interagency working group on building out internal contracting infrastructure and to communicate transition steps to providers proactively.
- Administration to assess and clarify title and salary structures across the combined OCS offices in an equitable manner and to keep the committee informed as decisions are made.
- Administration to respond to concerns about the CVAP RFP reducing precinct-based funding while adding requirements, and to consider whether the RFP should be revised.
- Administration to engage with New Destiny Housing and the committee on using CityFHEPS to prevent shelter entry for approximately 2,000 Emergency Housing Voucher households that have not been matched to alternatives.
- Administration to designate HRA domestic violence program households as qualifying referrals under CityFHEPS to address the shelter history eligibility gap identified by New Destiny Housing.
- Chair Farías to elevate survivor concerns about statute of limitations on rape cases and family court custodial issues to relevant state officials and district attorneys.
- Chair Farías to share information with the Speaker's finance team about expanded DOVE fund flexibility to support advocacy for sustained funding.
- Providers and community-based organizations to submit details of successful programs and funding requests to the chair's office ahead of budget season.
- Administration to ensure the MODGBV advisory council's quarterly meetings continue with Deputy Mayor Francois in attendance and that recommendations from the advisory council are responded to in a timely and transparent manner.
- Administration to include survivor and provider voices in future structural or policy decisions affecting the MODGBV from the outset, not after announcement.
- Chair Farías to pursue work with schools and providers on consent awareness legislation and programming in the new year.
- Legal Aid Society testimony to be considered by committee in assessing whether the City Charter's classification of domestic violence as a public health issue is being respected under the OCS restructuring.
Full Transcript
Good morning and welcome to the New York City Council hearing on Women and Gender Equity. At this time we are asking everyone to silence all electronic devices. If at any point you wish to testify at this hearing and have not yet filled out an appearance card, please see the sergeant at the back for assistance.
Please begin.
Good morning everyone. I am CM Amanda Farías, Chair of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity. Welcome to today's oversight hearing examining the restructuring of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety. Council Members present are CM Aldebol and CM Santosuosso, who have joined us this morning.
I want to begin by acknowledging the moment we are in. Just this week, New Yorkers and women have once again been confronted with the painful realities of sexual violence through the allegations surrounding former Cornell University students and the decision by the Tompkins County District Attorney to reopen the criminal investigation into the 2024 assault and rapes.
This case has raised renewed public questions about consent and how systems respond when women report violence, and whether our laws and institutions are adequately equipped to protect survivors. While that case is outside the jurisdiction of New York City, it is a reminder that gender-based violence does not exist in isolation. It exists in our homes, on our campuses, in our workplaces, in our communities and within the systems that are supposed to protect us.
As a City we are in a pivotal moment. We have an opportunity and a responsibility to ensure that preventing and responding to gender-based violence remains a central priority for our government, and that survivors can access meaningful support, and that our systems are coordinated, accountable and equipped to respond to the realities women and gender-expansive people face.
The Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence was created to tackle domestic and gender-based violence as a systemic problem and recognize it as an important issue impacting people across New York City. Since its establishment it has been a leader in efforts across the City to assess and respond to domestic and gender-based violence. These efforts include chairing the Domestic Violence Fatality Review Committee, co-leading the Mayor's Domestic Violence Task Force and collaboration with the Mayor's Office of Criminal Justice, and operating the City's five Family Justice Centers, just to name a few.
So today, as we examine the proposed restructuring of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety, I want us to focus on a fundamental question: how do we ensure that this restructuring strengthens, not diminishes, the City's ability to prevent gender-based violence, support survivors and hold our systems accountable?
The Committee will also consider the following legislation. Int 0295-2026, sponsored by myself, in relation to reporting on a hotline for survivors of gender-based violence. The Bill would require the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence to report anonymous high-level information about calls received by the hotline for survivors of domestic and gender-based violence.
We will also hear Res 0441-2026, also sponsored by me, declaring November 25 as the International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women in honor of the Mirabal sisters.
Additionally, we will hear Proposed Int. No. 295-A, sponsored by CM Louis, in relation to establishing a screening program for endometriosis and polycystic ovarian syndrome. I will now read a statement from CM Louis.
Thank you, Chair Farías, for your leadership and for moving Proposed Int. No. 295-A forward today. Proposed Int. No. 295-A would require the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene to establish a menstrual health program providing screening, referrals, education and support for endometriosis and polycystic ovarian syndrome, or PCOS. It would also expand sexual and reproductive health outreach to include these conditions. The need is significant.
Federal data shows that among women ages 22 to 49, 6.2% have been diagnosed with endometriosis and 8.7% with PCOS in 2022 and 2023. Among women diagnosed with either condition, rates of current fertility problems are substantially higher than among women without these diagnoses. Here in New York City, our own Department of Health recognizes that both conditions can cause significant symptoms including painful or irregular periods, infertility, fatigue and other health complications. Yet too many women continue to face gaps in awareness, diagnosis and access to appropriate care.
That is why the amendment to recognize PCOS is so important. In 2026 the medical community adopted polycystic ovarian syndrome as the updated name for the condition. The change reflects a broader understanding that this is a complex endocrine and metabolic condition that affects much more than just the ovaries. For too long, women's health needs have been shut out of conversations, research, education and public health systems that determine whether people receive care. We have an opportunity to change that by making accurate information and pathways to care part of our City's public health infrastructure.
I urge my colleagues to support Proposed Int. No. 295-A and I look forward to continuing the work to ensure that every New Yorker has access to the information, screening, referrals and support they need to take control of their health. Thank you.
Thank you to CM Louis for sending in that statement in support of her Bill. Finally, the Committee will hear Res 0637-2026, sponsored by CM Kayla Santosuosso and me, calling on the New York State Legislature to pass and the Governor to sign legislation requiring insurers to cover all lactation consultation and counseling services without restrictions and reimburse providers accordingly. I would like to invite CM Santosuosso to make some remarks about this resolution.
Thank you, Chair. There is overwhelming evidence that breastfeeding provides a multitude of health benefits to babies and their caregivers. Difficulties early on often force people to discontinue breastfeeding, many times without seeking professional advice or support. Research suggests that many of the disparities are further rooted in systemic racism, which further perpetuates health disparities later in life. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has reaffirmed that International Board Certified Lactation Consultants and other professionals are equipped to help parents navigate their challenges with breastfeeding. This greatly improves the chance that families will reach their infant feeding goals.
Given the clear health benefits to children and child caregivers, there is no reason that lactation consultation should not be covered by health insurance companies in the State of New York. This resolution calls on the Governor and State Legislature to pass legislation ensuring that families can access these critical services without having to pay out of pocket.
As a new mom who is nursing, I will just say that nursing can be very difficult. It requires a lot of support. It requires those around you who can help you make sure that it is done effectively. It is a shame that all too often these resources are not covered by insurance, and that is one of the reasons that would-be nursing moms are not able to nurse. So this resolution is important to me and I hope that we can get it passed, calling on the State to make sure that insurance is not a reason why a mom cannot choose breastfeeding for herself and for her child. Thank you so much.
Thank you, CM Santosuosso. I would also
like to thank Committee staff Julia Goldsmith Pinkham, Katie Selina and Ali Stafford, as well as my own staff Dan Curtain and Josina Cars for their work on today's hearing. I would like to remind everyone who wishes to testify in person today that you must fill out a witness slip, which you can find on the desk of the sergeant at arms near the entrance of this room. Please fill out a slip even if you have already registered in advance. If you are testifying in person today you will need that slip. If you wish to testify on any of the legislation, please indicate that on the witness slip whether you are here to testify in favor of or in opposition to the legislation. I also want to point out that we will not be voting on any of the legislation listed today.
To allow as many people to testify as possible, testimony will be limited to two minutes per person whether you are testifying in person or on Zoom. I am also going to ask my colleagues to limit their questions and comments to five minutes. Please note that witnesses who are here in person will testify before those who are signed on to the webinar. I will now turn it over to the Women and Gender Equity Committee counsel to administer the oath and call folks up from the administration to come testify.
Good morning, Chair Farías and members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity. My name is Dr. Aisha Delaney-Brumsey and I am the Commissioner of the Office of Community Safety and Commissioner of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence. Thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today and provide an update on the ongoing transition of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety.
The Office of Community Safety advances a coordinated, whole-of-government approach to preventing violence and promoting safety across New York City. Established by Executive Order 15 in March 2026, it brings together efforts to prevent gun violence and hate crimes, strengthen crisis response, support victims and survivors and prevent domestic and gender-based violence. Central to this approach is the recognition that community safety includes safety in our homes and relationships and protection from gender-based violence in all its forms.
Bringing the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence into the Office of Community Safety allows us to strengthen coordination across government while continuing to build on existing expertise, programs and partnerships. The Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence serves victims and survivors of domestic and gender-based violence and other crimes, as well as their families and communities, through collaboration with government agencies, community partners, survivors and philanthropy. The team works to reduce barriers, address gaps in services and create pathways to safety through program development, legislative and policy advocacy, research and capacity building. The Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence also oversees a range of prevention and intervention services including the City's five borough-based Family Justice Centers.
The Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence has continued to advance this mission, strengthen services and deliver critical support to victims and survivors across New York City. The Mamdani Administration allocated new funding to the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence's fiscal year 2027 budget — the largest such increase since the office's mission was expanded in 2018 to include all forms of gender-based violence. This is reflective of the administration's commitment to this work. This funding will support programs and services including legal services, mental health, prevention and community-based services.
In the fiscal year 2027 budget we expanded Home Plus to $4.3 million to help survivors remain safely housed through security improvements and flexible funding, while also providing flexible funding at the Family Justice Centers to help survivors meet immediate and essential needs. Together these programs help survivors maintain housing stability by addressing immediate safety and financial needs. We have also strengthened access to legal services. Funding for immigration and family law services at the Family Justice Centers increased by 20%, bringing the City's annual investment up significantly. We also secured funding in fiscal year 2027 and out for the Domestic Violence Matrimonial Right to Counsel pilot program, helping ensure that survivors continue to have access to critical legal representation in matrimonial proceedings.
At the same time, this administration continues to prioritize investments that respond to needs identified by survivors, providers, advocates and community partners. Many of these investments also reflect years of advocacy from those working directly with survivors who have helped identify service gaps and inform the City's response. This includes an annual investment in mental health services at the Family Justice Centers, allowing added capacity throughout the program including services for children impacted by domestic violence, a 20% increase for case management, navigation and children's services at the Family Justice Centers and a 20% increase for youth-focused prevention throughout the Relationship Abuse Prevention Program. We also invested $3 million annually in new community-based, culturally specific services for survivors of gender-based violence. We expect to share programs outlined by year's end and invite feedback from stakeholders.
The Crime Victims Assistance Program provides critical advocacy and support to victims and survivors of domestic violence and other crimes through NYPD precincts. Advocates play an important role in supporting survivors. We also know that many victims of crime never engage with law enforcement. The Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence's recently released solicitation provides funding annually for the Crime Victims Assistance Program and further strengthens community-based responses for New Yorkers impacted by crime and abuse by creating community-based access points so that the critical support the Crime Victims Assistance Program provides can extend beyond precinct-based settings. Through these new access points in each borough, survivors who do not feel comfortable reporting to law enforcement will be able to receive advocacy and support, including in-person accompaniment for those who choose to report with the help of an advocate, in community-based settings, strengthening connections between law enforcement and local providers.
As this transition moves forward, some organizational structures and leadership titles will change but the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence's mission and the critical programs and services it oversees will not. The Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence will remain a distinct entity within the Office of Community Safety with dedicated leadership and a clear mandate. The expertise of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence team, as well as all the teams that have been incorporated, will continue to inform decision making with direct and regular access to myself as the Commissioner, Office of Community Safety leadership and the Deputy Mayor of Community Safety. Bringing the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence into the Office of Community Safety also creates opportunities for stronger coordination across the City's community safety work. Domestic and gender-based violence intersects with many of the challenges the Office of Community Safety is charged with addressing, including gun violence, mental health, crisis response and support for victims and survivors of crime and violence. The Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence's research on the relationship between domestic violence and shooting incidents in New York City found that communities with high rates of gun
Violence also experience high rates of domestic violence. We know that access to firearms can increase the risk of serious injury or death in abusive relationships, and firearms also can be used to threaten, intimidate and control survivors. Moreover, young people exposed to violence in the home are more likely to both experience and perpetrate violence, including gun violence, as they grow up.
Children exposed to domestic violence are almost three times more likely to experience domestic violence as adults, and childhood exposure to family violence is also a strong predictor of domestic violence perpetration later in life. Bringing this work together creates opportunities to strengthen prevention and intervention efforts. Further, survivors with mental health needs face unique barriers to accessing both the domestic violence and mental health systems, particularly when navigating multiple systems that do not fully address their needs. At the same time, domestic and gender-based violence can have significant and lasting impact on survivors' mental health.
Further, connecting with mental health and crisis response can help align services, provide more responsive and trauma-informed care, and address survivors' needs more holistically. These connections reflect our vision for the Office of Community Safety: a public health approach to safety that recognizes both the immediate and long-term impacts of violence. Coordination across prevention, intervention, victim and survivor services, and crisis response will help us make effective use of the City's expertise and resources while helping keep domestic and gender-based violence central to our community safety work.
Another important part of this work is maintaining direct communication with survivors, advocates, service providers and City Hall. The Deputy Mayor will participate in the advisory council's quarterly meeting alongside the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence. This provides a regular opportunity to hear directly from stakeholders, assess progress and discuss needs and priorities. Staff, providers, advocates and other stakeholders will continue to be engaged throughout the transition and implementation process.
We appreciate the opportunity to provide positions on the legislation under consideration today. We support the Bill on reporting on hotline survivors for gender-based violence, with some adjustments to reflect that New York City's whole pipeline supports survivors of gender-based violence and other crimes. We would be happy to discuss those adjustments with the Council following the hearing. We look forward to continued collaboration with the Council, survivors, advocates, service providers and community-based partners as we move this work forward together. We will continue to strengthen services, address gaps, improve coordination across systems and ensure that victims and survivors have access to the support they need. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today, and we welcome any questions you might have.
Thank you so much for testifying. I would like to acknowledge that we have been joined by Speaker Julie Menin. I will kick it over to you for questions.
First, thank you so much, Chair Farías. I want to thank you for holding this very important hearing and for all of the advocates and groups who are here today. I know this is a very difficult topic and so we really appreciate you being here. My first question really has to do with the Office of Community Safety having communicated that one reason for moving the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety is that the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence will have access to more resources and be part of a coordinated citywide community safety strategy. What specific additional resources will the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence have access to under the Office of Community Safety that they did not have before?
Absolutely. One of the resources that I can point to — and thank you for that question — is that in this current fiscal year we increased the budget for the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence by $15.7 million, which is the largest increase that office has received since 2018. That is one significant type of resource that the office will have access to. In addition, the creation of the Office of Community Safety more generally is part of the administration's focus on ensuring that we are providing a comprehensive approach to public safety, so that the people and places at the most risk for harm and the types of violence that are most intractable have access to a coordinated approach. We know, as I testified, that people who are experiencing domestic and gender-based violence often live in neighborhoods with higher rates of gun violence. We also understand the significant relationship between domestic violence, its impacts on behavioral health needs and the relationship between substance use and domestic violence.
So combining the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence and the Office of Community Safety to work in a more coordinated way to build out a strategy that supports all survivors even more effectively... Do you not agree, Commissioner, that by no longer having a dedicated commissioner for this important topic, and having now put it under a new entity, that sends the wrong signal to survivors and to all the groups on the ground who are doing this important work?
The signal that I hope it sends is that this is an administration effort that is extremely committed to this work. The Office of Community Safety is a high priority for this administration and the work within it is...
The incorporation of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence is the administration's effort not to diminish but to elevate and escalate the work of that office. I can jump in — I think even with this transition the role of the office very much remains. For me, for the leadership team, for the staff, most of us are all still here. The entire leadership team is still here, and we are still here because what we know is our role is to make sure that as we work with the Office of Community Safety and work with our partners, we are continuing to elevate issues that are meaningful and important to survivors and to our providers. We think that so far we have been doing a pretty good job of that, and that is reflected in the funding and in our ongoing work.
And how many staff are currently hired by the Office of Community Safety and currently working right now?
There are approximately a hundred staff total across all of our offices. We have 79 staff lines and currently 59 of those positions are filled.
I am sorry, could you repeat that? So the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence has 79 staff lines and currently 59 of those positions are filled, so it is about a 25% vacancy rate. And what are the efforts to...
...fill those vacancies? We have actually been doing really well. The vacancy rates stem from historically higher increases that the City has been under for many many years. We have actually been working with Commissioner Aisha and the Deputy Mayor for Community Safety's team to move these vacancies forward as quickly as possible. One thing I want to highlight is that one of the positions we filled recently was on Staten Island — the Director of Community Programs and Partnerships — and that role had been vacant for three years. But that is the reality in which we were living in terms of City hiring freezes and processes, and so we are doing our best to work through that backlog with support from the Office of Community Safety team.
We have heard from many of the gender-based violence groups as well as survivors, concerns that the administration is minimizing the gender-based violence work by this move. So what would...
...you say to those concerns? I definitely want to ensure that our partners, advocates, providers and survivors know that we are not minimizing the importance of this work. As you...
...heard, the incorporation of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence into the Office of Community Safety is an effort to escalate and elevate this work. We are working very closely across the entire Office of Community Safety team and with the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence to ensure that we continue to engage very closely with our partners. I have attended the advisory council, the Deputy Mayor has as well, and we will continue to do that. We have held dozens of conversations with providers, advocates and survivors. We have conducted site visits. We are going to continue to work very closely with our partners to ensure that the work of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence — the focus that has been built over the past 25 years — remains not only intact but is strengthened as we build together. Anything you would like to add?
No, I mean I think all of that makes sense and I think again what I would invite all of our survivor community, our advocacy community and our provider community to do is to keep reaching out. We are here. My email has not changed, my number has not changed, so please reach out and we will do our best to make sure that we are continuing to connect, because I truly believe the work is going to be stronger if we move forward together.
Okay, that is the end of my questions. I just do want to say I frankly do believe there should be a commissioner of this entity and I think it should be freestanding. I think that is really important. I understand there is disagreement with that, but I am going to turn it over to the Chair.
Thank you, Speaker, for joining us and for the questions. I have similar sentiments about the way we are restructuring and some of our other commissioners, and I actually have a specific question to that as well. But primarily I would like to start by noting that gender-based violence remains a significant issue in New York City, with over 249,000 domestic violence incident reports in 2024 alone. Where does the Office of Community Safety place gender-based violence in terms of priorities to be addressed in this administration?
Gender-based violence is a top priority for this administration and for the Office of Community Safety. It is impossible to improve safety without addressing the impact of domestic and gender-based violence across New York. As Commissioner, I am working very closely with Commissioner Sethi to ensure that as we are developing the ongoing strategy for the office, domestic and gender-based violence remains a significant priority — not only as a focus of our work, but built in such a way that it will continue to be strengthened, that the office itself can benefit from the other offices, and that the office can also lend its expertise to the other offices that are part of it. So that in the years to come, New Yorkers who are experiencing gender-based violence, who may also be experiencing hate crimes or have a mental health need, will have access to a much more comprehensive and holistic approach to this work. It is a recognition that the work that the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence has done over the past 25 years is strong, needs to continue to be strong and needs to continue to be elevated.
I can only point to the early signs of the administration's commitment to this work — the investments that have been made, the continued and ongoing connection between myself, the Deputy Mayor and the supporters, advocates and providers — to demonstrate how much this remains a continued priority. And then, similarly to what the Speaker was asking about: the Commissioner's title will change to Executive Director once the office officially moves to the Office of Community Safety. According to some reports, there are approximately six Executive Director titles across the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence that are now reporting to the Commissioner. Will the existing Executive Director titles change as a result of the Commissioner becoming an Executive Director? And additionally, there are four Deputy Commissioners within the office — are those titles also going to...
...change? Yeah, thank you for that question. The combination of the offices under the Office of Community Safety means that there are a variety of different titles because each office had its own title structure. The title differences are not unique to the Office of Community Safety. We are engaged in a process right now to look across our team to see what makes sense in terms of ensuring we have titles that reflect the seniority, the expertise and that allow people to do the work they continue to do. We have not made any decisions because we are making...
...sure that we are doing this carefully and assessing how titles will continue to reflect the seniority, expertise and influence that both the leadership and the rest of the team have. Okay.
So we will just stay in communication as this continues to move forward. While there is restructuring and changing of titles, the amount of work conducted by the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence will remain the same or increase. Do you expect all appointees and employees to keep a salary next year that is equivalent to this year?
So again, as you can imagine, combining four offices means there are also different pay scales. There is a lot of work to be done to ensure that we are being equitable. We have not made any significant decisions at this moment because we are trying to work very closely with the office as well as our City partners to ensure that any changes that we make are equitable. However, the goal is to ensure that we have appropriate staffing to do this work. As the work continues and builds, we will need additional staff and additional funding, and that is the work of myself and the leadership team — to work with the administration to ensure that the work is appropriately staffed. As you heard from Commissioner Sethi, we have actually been able to fill some vacancies that have not been filled in the past, and so we are working towards ensuring that we have the robust staffing that we need to do the growing and important work.
Okay, thank you. How regularly will the Deputy Mayor for Community Safety be meeting with the Mayor about the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence and gender-based violence issues in New York City, and how often do we anticipate the Deputy Mayor meeting with the office about gender-based violence?
So we have a structure and a strategy. The Deputy Mayor meets regularly with the Mayor around the Office of Community Safety, including focusing on the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence. The Deputy Mayor and myself meet regularly — weekly, sometimes significantly more than weekly. Myself and the Commissioner meet absolutely more than weekly. We have ongoing communication and coordination with the Deputy Mayor's team that includes project meetings, strategic planning meetings and other coordination. So we have a significant amount of coordination happening at all levels across the office.
The advisory council sent a media request to the administration and a list of community-informed recommendations but did not receive a response before the announcement of Executive Order 15. How will the Office of Community Safety engage with recommendations from the advisory council in the future? Absolutely.
We acknowledged some missteps in some of the early communication. However, the administration has been working very hard to correct that. We did respond to that letter. We also met directly — myself, the Deputy Mayor and the team — with the advisory council and are continuing to do that, to have those meetings. We are continuing to have site visits, and in that letter we responded with how some of the feedback from the advocates and advisory council had influenced some of the work that the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence did, including some of the recent investments. I can turn to the Commissioner for some additional details there. Yeah, I mean I think when you look at the new funding that we received, some of those...
...asks really came directly from the advisory council letter, in an effort to be responsive to what our advocates were asking for — including the funding for culturally specific services, including the funding for grassroots and survivor-led organizations, and including funding for existing programs. I think what we came up with in that $15.7 million was reflective of new things as well as an understanding that our existing programs also need more, because they are doing a lot with very little and have been for some time. So we need to continue to address that, and we are continuing to see people...
...in need. In addition to the ongoing partnership with the advisory council, we are also working on site visits and listening sessions that we will continue to do, and we hosted one just yesterday in the Bronx with the Deputy Mayor and her team, which was really nice. Great, thank you.
Also, apologies — we have been joined by CM Jennifer Gutiérrez as well. I just want to talk a little bit about data and reporting. The Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence is in compliance with the open data law and regularly uploads reports to open data on time. Will the move potentially slow that down, and how will you ensure that it does not?
Yeah, absolutely, that is a great question. All of our offices have a variety of reports that they are required to submit. As part of our efforts to consolidate the office, we are ensuring that we have the systems and processes in place so that we do not slow that down and that we are continuing to meet our obligations, and we have continued to do that to date. Yeah, our data team is the same — it is a small team but it is the same — and so we are working through those same channels to provide reports as requested, as usual.
And then in terms of the several key reports, as you even mentioned, around gender-based violence — including the annual fact sheet, Family Justice Center client satisfaction surveys, the fatality review committee reports, among many others — what is the approval process for publishing these reports under the new structure? Will there be any changes?
The approval process will remain largely the same. We have an expert team that understands this work and understands how to create and draft highly accurate and effective reports. We will continue with the approval process largely the same. The only changes are that both of us will be reviewing, but so far that has been totally not a problem.
Thanks, folks. I would like to talk a little bit about contracting. The Council has frequently heard that mayoral agencies can struggle to manage procurement processes because they lack the staffing infrastructure to manage contracts. Currently manages $30 million of Council discretionary funding and has support from HR staff to do so. How many contracts has the office managing in the portfolio?
If you must say the total number of contracts — sure. We have a total of 90 contracts currently. 90. It is a lot. For context, that will continue to support the office as it builds out our own internal contracting.
We are building out a contracting function not just to support the office but to support the entire office, which has even more than the 90 contracts. We are doing that work in partnership with the relevant agencies as well as the other agencies that currently support our contracting work, in combination with other mayoral offices and City agencies that support contracting, so that we can ensure we are building out a contracting shop that has the staffing and the capacity and the structures in place to do this work well.
We know that contracting well is both about meeting City obligations but it is also about ensuring that the providers that we work with — our contractors — are able to do the good work that we are paying them for. That is great. You answered my next
question. So on contracting, what is the goal of the new RFP regarding the Crime Victims Assistance Program?
Absolutely. I will turn this to Commissioner Sethi for the details, but one thing that I will say is that we are really excited to have the Crime Victims Assistance Program RFP out. We really encourage people to apply. The Crime Victims Assistance Program ensures that we are embedding victims advocates in every single precinct across New York City. It is also focused on ensuring that we have crime victims advocates and community-based partners so that we can ensure that for victims who are not comfortable reporting to the police, they have a place where they can receive victim services. We know that it is essential that there is universal access to victim services within NYPD precincts. That is a core tenet of this work. We intend to continue that going forward because we want to make sure that we are meeting victims wherever they are. We are really excited to be able to expand that work so that we have additional access points in the community, because unfortunately we know that so often victims do not report.
And those victims advocates will be there whether or not someone does report. If they are interested in reporting, they will accompany that person to the police precinct to help them report if they wish.
Yeah, I agree. I think for me, this work and all of the work we do are really quite consistent and similar. One thing is always about increasing access and reducing barriers.
Increasing access to resources for survivors. I think this does that by keeping the precinct-based services but also adding community-based touch points for these services, for advocacy, for potentially support for survivors who may be afraid to walk into a precinct. Accompaniment with a peer navigator — that is a huge shift, and I think an important one that is about
increasing access for survivors. The other thing that I know our office thinks about all the time is that survivors' experiences are diverse. There are a million different experiences of survivorship and our provider community reflects that diversity and should continue to reflect that diversity. We should have different providers for different survivors with different needs. Not just in, but with our contracting we have done over the years — adding borough-based options allows us to diversify providers as
well, with different providers doing the same work, which again is about allowing survivors to access what they need where they need it.
And with an organization they feel most comfortable with.
Thank you for the response. I would agree that most of us appreciate a borough-based response when it comes to an RFP. We do not always get that opportunity to have coverage that can address the multitude of needs across the City and making sure everyone has a provider that is appropriate. I am going to reserve the rest of my time to get to some Council member questions and I will turn it over to CM Aldebol, followed by Gutiérrez, then Santosuosso.
Thank you, Chair. I do not have a lot of follow-up questions. Both Speaker Menin and a Council member asked about restructuring and staffing. You said that there were 79 lines currently, 59 filled. You attributed the vacancy rate to a backlog of hiring. How much of that is attributed to turnover?
So honestly, our office has had some turnover but not very much. What I am always personally really surprised by is how many folks in our office have been with the office for 10 plus years, including some folks that have been there before it became what it is now. I think it really does speak to people coming
to this because it is passion work and the sort of meaning that they find in the work.
Do you foresee reductions in staffing as roles are changed and the office gets put under
the Office of Community Safety? It is too soon to be able to say what our literal structure will look like. However, what I can say is that we know that the charge we have been given is to build a more comprehensive approach to community safety, and that includes ensuring that we are appropriately staffing the work around domestic and gender-based violence. Our work is to really expand and to ensure that we are building out our staffing. While it is too soon to know exactly how far we will be able to expand, that is the charge that has been put forward.
Do you foresee a restructuring or a dramatic change in staff roles given the move to the Office of Community Safety? I do not anticipate a dramatic change in the way that the office is staffing their programs at this point. What we will be doing is ensuring that we have the appropriate staffing across our entire team and that as we are building out our survivor and victim services we will continue to do that work with the other offices. We will be restructuring, but it is too soon to know exactly what that will look like.
The purpose of the restructuring will be to ensure that we have all of the necessary expertise to do the work of domestic and gender-based violence prevention, all of the necessary expertise to do the work of hate crime prevention, to building out behavioral health services, of preventing gun and community-based violence. That is the north star for that kind of restructuring, and that all of those offices have the kind of operational support that they need to do their work, whether that is contracting, budgets or administrative support.
All of that is really necessary as you grow an office from what it is today to what we will hopefully be in the future, which is significantly larger. All the core functions of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence are critical to what the Office of Community Safety is going to do, which includes services, advocacy, research, evaluation and training. Those are things that are always going to be part of whatever we are doing. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. I will hand it over to CM Gutiérrez.
Thank you, Chair. Thank you all so much. I had just a couple of questions. One, logistically, under the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety, does that affect the way that anyone would maybe call 311 for more information related to this office? Is there another person or another... is there a delay because it is now not its own standalone office — it is under this bigger and larger umbrella?
So, just logistics. No, that is a great question. I was just thinking about how to respond to that. I think it is a great question. I do not anticipate that there will be an extra layer of access. For example, we will continue to have the office's website. As we build out our web presence, people will still be able to find it. The website will link to the office's website. Our goal will be to ensure, as we are building this out, that people have very easy, very quick access to community safety work. That is a north star for all of the work that we are doing. I would want to ensure that as we are building this we are continuing to work very closely with the leadership across the office and our other offices to ask how are New Yorkers finding out about our work and how do we ensure that even more New Yorkers find out about our work, that we are easier and easier to find no matter what.
Thank you. I would love to circle back at some point to see if that is the case. I think that sometimes for someone who is calling 311 — and again, if it is online it is a little different — but just speaking with some of the folks at the call center, sometimes they are not necessarily privy to some of the changes that are happening, either that we legislate or even that City Hall does. So it would just be helpful to maybe connect with them and ensure that
they are up to date. Again, I do not want to delay an emergency. I think that is great. One thing that we would love to do is circle back on that. If you are hearing about ways in which people are not finding out about us or cannot reach us, let us know, because we would love to try to address that. Whenever we do hear about a concern we want to make sure we work to address it. So if you are hearing things, please let us know. We would love
to. Absolutely. I have not heard anything but I just want to make sure we are ahead of it because I think it is difficult to restructure this. My last question — I am just curious: pre-pandemic, my district, which houses some of the higher rates of domestic violence incidents, and I am familiar with some of the folks on the ground. Under the various divisions of the Office of Community Safety, is there anything specific that your office is being asked to do in partnership with some of these divisions in public housing specifically? Is this merger going to allow us to have more resources to do more, and specifically in public housing?
Yeah, that is a great question. We recently ran a set of meetings to address some key safety issues in locations across the City, public housing locations and other locations. One of the things that we noticed early on is that we needed to have someone within those meetings who had domestic and gender-based violence expertise. So we included one of the staff members from the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence in those meetings, in addition to staff members from the Office of Neighborhood Safety who do a lot of our work in NYCHA developments. That is just one example of how we are trying to get these teams to work even more closely together, so that we can say for our team that is supporting NYCHA developments around reducing violence, we know that so often some of that violence has a root in domestic and gender-based violence. How do we ensure that we are both bringing resources as well as expertise? One of the things that I noticed when I first came on as Commissioner is that some of that work was already happening. These offices, while separate, were doing some work together. They have some joint providers. We are really just building on that foundation and trying to make it stronger and stronger.
There are no additional dollars or resources under this new Office of Community Safety for your office?
For the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence, we absolutely did have additional funding. We had $15.7 million in additional funding just this year, which is the largest increase that we have seen since 2018. Absolutely.
Wonderful. Thank you, Chair. Over to CM Santosuosso. Thank you so much, Chair, and thank you so much for being here. I want to start by just acknowledging that we recently lost a constituent in our district to murder in an extreme act of domestic violence — Maria Inez Granda. In her honor I just want to thank all the advocates that are doing this work and thank you to the office for what you do. With that, I have just a few questions, just to follow up on CM Gutiérrez's question. I think what I was hearing is that with that $15 million plus in additional resources — I know in your testimony you said it looks like it will support programs and services, legal services, et cetera — I guess I am curious how much of that will actually flow to CBOs and the providers and the Family
Justice Centers versus sort of administrative and centralized costs. All of it is for contracted programs. I love to hear that. I believe you said this in your testimony and I believe it was asked in questions, but I just want to flush it out entirely. For providers who are concerned that maybe this merger would lead to a decrease in their funding — if a contractor or a provider is currently funded by the office, will they see any decrease in their funding as a result of this merger directly?
We are not currently decreasing any funding. We are only in the space of increasing funding. Love to hear
it. I just wanted to flush it out for folks. Then for providers and for CBOs, again, if the merger would lead to sort of confusion about who to reach out to, or that would lead to a lack of access to the office's staff and the support that they have provided in the past — can you... they will have just as easy access to the office as they have had in the past. The front-line leadership continues to work directly with their providers. I would encourage everyone to continue to reach out to the people that they have been working with. They are also welcome to reach out to myself should they wish. We are just an additional point of access. We work extremely closely with each other. We sit 25 feet from each other. We are operating and continuing to build a real office. Absolutely, we want to assure everyone that they will have the access. To the earlier point, if there are any issues with access that are being raised, please let us know. We would love to address them.
Then, sorry, one more thing: with regard to the Crime Victims Assistance Program RFP, what work is going to be done to ensure that the folks who are placed in those precincts are working
with the NYPD and the precincts in a way that is productive and collaborative and actually integrative, versus a sort of outside, siloed worker?
Yeah, that is definitely part of what the office has been doing since we started administering the Crime Victims Assistance Program as a contract. We will continue to do that in terms of bridging and making sure the right relationships are in place. We have really close relationships with the folks that do the domestic and gender-based violence work and we are working on getting the civil advocates the support they need at the precinct level as well. We are here and we really hope to continue playing an active role in making sure that that relationship is working the way we think it should.
And that will not change as a result of the merger. No. Just even like a really, really small
example of a win recently: we got to put up posters that had the victims advocates in the precinct. The program had been operating for 10 years without posters saying "here is somebody you can talk to." I think that is a success that we were able to help coordinate with the contracted provider, with NYPD and with
staff to really make that happen. I think it is small things like that that sometimes make the
difference. Definitely. I appreciate your time. Thank you so much. Thanks.
Thank you, Council member. I am just going to jump in on a few more questions before we get to public testimony. In terms of contracting, what is the future of the Family Justice Centers currently operated by Safe Horizons? The ones which were operated by the office — Safe Horizons is a contracted provider at Manhattan for a few services and we have 10 different contracted providers. So far there is no change
in that service. I think our only hope is to continue expanding, because again what we continue to see is tens of thousands of visits a year — around 63,000 visits annually. The people that we are serving
have higher levels of need. I think when I think about
my role and the office's role, it is about how do we make sure our providers doing this work are better resourced to do this work, which is getting more and more challenging due to the circumstances that we find ourselves in federally especially. And how will the
Ensure that small community-based organizations that are often the only providers able to offer services in specific languages or a particular cultural community do not experience a lapse in any of their funding during the transition. This is a core concern of the transition that we are ensuring to address.
Address them. Working to...
Address. We want to make sure that when we do ultimately move contracts over, that we have the structures in place already and that that structure has been in place for weeks, months, building up, so that we can transition without any gaps in payment. We want to ensure that all of our providers — but we know what is especially crucial for our smaller providers who cannot float while there is a payment gap — that we are doing that work. That is crucial for the work of the Office of Neighborhood Safety, which works with very small providers. Office of Prevention of Hate Crimes, all of our offices really do attempt to work with both small, culturally specific organizations that are deeply embedded in their community as well as some of our larger service providers who can cover more ground. So we are very, very focused on ensuring that that does not become an issue.
And is that also connected to the work that you are doing to having an internal contracted database where we are hoping payments and that structure continue on for a smoother transition? Absolutely. That is part of the work of building out our own contracting function internally and we will do that. We are aiming to do that in such a way that we can have as effective a contracting shop as possible.
And I say this is another thing that we are sort of doing with agencies that are involved in this process, right, as we think about what this will take in launching a coordinated working group to really figure out what the steps are. I think for providers that are our providers, we will do our best to be in communication with you. Please reach out and ask questions, right, because I think that is also the other piece — as this happens, how are we communicating the steps over and over again?
And I will just add to that that Commissioner Seth is the person on the team who is managing the working group to build and support this build-out with other agencies.
So that focus on domestic and gender-based violence is front and center there. Great. I just wanted to go back to what CM Gutiérrez was tapping on with the budget. Can I get a better idea? I know in the testimony you provided you stated the budget is $15.7 million and that is larger than budgets we have received in the past. Do we know what the total...
The budget is... the total budget for FY27 is now $89 million, which is — yes — which is significantly increased since 2022. $89 million for FY27. You are saying it is over $89 million? $89.1 million, right. And we can provide a...
Breakdown. Yeah, I would...
Really appreciate that, just because I am looking through the testimony and I see the $15.7 million. I am not a mathematician. That is new funding, so that is right. I am seeing some parts of the budget in the testimony here that are like expanding Home Plus to $4.3 million, annual investment of $3.9 million at the Family Justice Centers. I am trying to differentiate — what are the differences between where some of these legal services or other services are not directly housed under either the Office of Community Safety or the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence's...
Budget specifically, and are they across different agencies? What is the breakdown? I would love to receive that after the fact so we can get a better idea.
Yeah, we can absolutely do the breakdown. We can definitely give a breakdown of what went entirely to the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence and to services...
Supported by or overseen by the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence, and that is part of the overall $89 million.
Yeah, and of our $89 million, I think just off the top of my head it is somewhere like seven or eight million in staff, and then the rest is all contracted programming and discretionary Council contracts. So the $15.7 million was an increase from...
Fiscal Year 2026, yes, in programmatic and contracting. Right.
Down. And then just a couple of additional questions. How will the Office of Community Safety facilitate relationships between domestic and gender-based violence organizations and other key partners, including violence interruption programs and gun violence prevention organizations?
That is a great question and that is something that we are doing now and that we intend to continue to build out in a variety of ways. I think it will happen in a number of ways. Part of it is as the team grows into a more cohesive team across the office and they are sharing best practices, sharing ways of working, they will naturally also be bringing their partners with them.
Other ways that we are doing that — we of course have existing advisory councils. I anticipate that as we continue to expand we will have existing ways to bring together our providers and other advisory bodies in meetings, and will work to include a range of different providers. We are also, as we build out new initiatives around public safety, one of the focuses of that work is to think about what are initiatives that address multiple different forms of violence and how do we do that in a comprehensive way. One of the lovely things about the Family Justice Center is that it is a comprehensive approach to addressing domestic and gender-based violence and has lots of different providers embedded within it. You can imagine models like that happening in different spaces across our work, including providers in the domestic and gender-based violence space, the gun violence space, the hate crimes prevention space. This is not me announcing a new program. This is just me saying how I imagine that as we build out we will continue to ensure that we are pulling in the right people to provide a more holistic approach to this really challenging issue.
No, and I will say thank you. One of the things we talk about all the time, right, is one of the beautiful things about even bringing the teams together and the organization together and doing cross-training work is really understanding what people do that is different in a way that you do not always see. I think even as Commissioner Delaney-Brahms and I talk, one of the things we want to avoid is trying to get everybody to be experts in everything. We do not actually need that. We need people to be good at the things that they do and then figure out how to refer and cross over.
And build together, which again, as the Commissioner mentioned, is really the model of the Family Justice Centers, right. It is like we have legal staff to do legal services and mental health services and they do not try and do the same thing. That is kind of what we want to try and build on — that true collaboration where people hold their own piece.
And understand and respect how they connect to the other work. Yeah, I appreciate that. I think a lot of the questions that have been raised for me during this process are like, how are we talking about this work with and that involves poverty and those structures that we have throughout our City, even the intersection of domestic violence and homelessness across New York? How will the Office of Community Safety address those issues in collaboration with or through the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence? Just wanting to make sure that...
We understand what the leading causes are, we understand we are trying to create a comprehensive approach, but how are we going to ensure that that is actually happening under this larger umbrella?
That is a great question. That is the work. Ensure that we are building an infrastructure that prevents harm, that responds to people in the aftermath of really terrible harm, that supports them in the long term.
That not focusing on the individual — it means focusing on the places they live, the social structures that they are embedded in, finding ways to ensure that we are addressing those underlying drivers, or the social determinants of health — the way I think about it — underlying drivers of violence. That is a core principle of how I approach this work. I think what has been nice is that feels like a very core principle for how the Commissioner approaches this work as well. So I cannot tell you the exact how, other than we do have some programs that acknowledge this — programs that focus on providing flexible funding to people, on getting them emergency housing. That is the work of this office. I appreciate that. I do not have...
Any other additional questions. You are now excused. Thank you. I am going to move and open up for public testimony. The room is packed so I want to remind members of the public that this is a government proceeding and that decorum shall be observed at all times. Please remain silent unless called upon to testify. All testimony must be relevant to today's hearing on examining the restructure of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety. Remarks straying from the subject matter — speakers will be reminded of the topic and asked to refocus their comments by me.
The witness table is reserved for people who wish to testify. No video recording or photography is allowed from the witness table. Further, members of the public may not present audio or video recordings as testimony but may submit transcripts of such recordings to the Sergeant at Arms for inclusion in the hearing record. If you wish to speak at today's hearing, please fill out the appearance slip with the Sergeant at Arms and wait to be recognized. When recognized, you will have two minutes to speak on today's oversight topic and or pieces of legislation.
If you have a written statement or additional written testimony you wish to submit for the record, please provide a copy of that testimony to the Sergeant at Arms. You may also email written testimony to testimony at council.nyc.gov within 72 hours of this hearing. Audio and video recordings will not be accepted.
I will now call the first panel: Alina Victor, Liz Roberts, Judy Kluger, Maritsa Rico, Rosanna Campuzano. Okay, you may begin.
When ready. I usually just prefer to go down the line. Chair Farías and members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, my name is Dr. Rosanna Campuzano and I am the Deputy Executive Director of Programs at the Violence and Abuse Prevention Program, also known as VAP. VAP is a member of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence advisory council and is the only organization in New York City led by and for Latina survivors of domestic and sexual violence. Our mission is to end abuse. Every year we field over 5,000 calls on our helpline and our culturally specific programs serve over 3,500 survivors and children. We serve single immigrant mothers of color, many living on less than $15,000 a year. Many survivors in our communities face economic and cultural barriers and distrust of law enforcement, making it harder for them to report gender-based violence. That is why we launched our Survivor Justice Program to offer a different...
Path for survivors — a path rooted in community accountability, healing and repair beyond the carceral system. For this reason we were thrilled to hear Mayor Mamdani's announcement of the Office of Community Safety, because his vision reflects what survivors and community organizations have long called for, which is the shift away from over-reliance on law enforcement as a primary response to interpersonal and community violence. We deeply believe that partnership with the Office of Community Safety can lead to innovative, community-led strategies and elevate survivor leadership. But survivors and the organizations they trust must help shape the work from the start. Communities cannot be made safe — they cannot be built for survivors without survivors at the table. So we urge the City Council and the administration to include the voices of organizations like ours in strategy and planning, and to give the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence the resources and supporting leadership role needed so that the Office of Community Safety can achieve its ambitious goals.
As Domestic Violence Awareness Month begins tomorrow, we invite Mayor Mamdani, Deputy Mayor Francois and the leadership at the Office of Community Safety to spotlight this issue. We ask the Mayor to use his significant media presence to showcase that the administration stands against gender-based violence and to uplift our mission. VAP is excited, ready and willing to partner with the administration and City Council to create the answers that survivors need and deserve. Thank you very much.
Good morning. My name is... you can move the microphone to you. Yep.
Good morning. My name is Judy Harris Kluger and I am the Executive Director of Sanctuary for Families, New York's largest provider of comprehensive services dedicated exclusively to survivors of domestic violence and related forms of gender-based violence. Thank you, Chair Farías and the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, for convening this hearing and for the opportunity to testify here.
Gender-based violence is not a secondary issue that can be absorbed into a broader public safety portfolio. It is a complex and distinct crisis that touches nearly every part of City government, including housing, homelessness, poverty, child care, public health, criminal justice, immigration and economic security. More than one in five families in the shelter system identify domestic violence as the reason they entered shelter. Addressing a crisis of this scope requires a dedicated office with the authority, expertise, visibility and accountability to coordinate the City's response and to ensure that survivors remain a clear priority.
For that reason, we are deeply concerned by the decision to place the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence within the Office of Community Safety, with diminishing status. Survivors were only belatedly included in the Mayor's transition committee and not at all in the subsequent planning discussions around this change, and the abrupt announcement came as a surprise to the field. Subsuming the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence within a larger office risks diluting its mission and obscuring responsibility for who in the administration is addressing the needs of survivors. A standalone office gives gender-based violence a visible place in City government and creates a clear point of leadership for survivors, service providers, agencies and the public. It can set a citywide strategy, coordinate directly with agencies whose policies affect survivors, identify gaps in services and elevate urgent funding needs, addressing gender-based violence through trauma-informed, culturally responsive policies shaped by survivors and experienced advocates. These issues intersect directly with public safety but they cannot be addressed solely through a general public safety framework.
Moving forward, we stand ready to work with Deputy Mayor Francois and Office of Community Safety Commissioner Delaney-Brahms. We appreciate the commitment that the Deputy Mayor will join quarterly advisory council meetings to hear from advocates and track progress. Tomorrow marks the beginning of Domestic Violence Awareness Month and I share with my colleague on the right that this is an opportunity for the Mayor to affirm that ending gender-based violence is a core City priority. We welcome the administration's recent investments and commitments but programs and funding require a durable governmental structure to coordinate implementation, measure progress and ensure accountability.
We therefore urge the administration to restore and maintain a standalone office with sufficient resources, authority and direct access to senior leadership, preserve the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence's specialized expertise and establish sustained partnership with survivors and advocates. The City's structure should reflect the scale and urgency of this crisis. Thank you for your time and for beginning this important discussion. We look forward to working with the Council and the administration to ensure that New York City maintains dedicated, accountable leadership on gender-based violence. Thank you.
Thank you. If we can just take a pause for one minute. Sergeant, can you come here? Thank you. Just a suggestion for folks that are going to be testifying — the clock is working but the sound for the buzzer is not, so the Sergeant is going to announce when time is expired. Okay. The buzzer is not that effective anyway, to be honest. Okay, you may continue. Thank you.
Chair Farías, Speaker Menin, my name is Liz Roberts. I am the CEO of Safe Horizon, where we are the nation's largest nonprofit victim assistance organization. We are grateful that the Council is examining this issue so carefully.
We will say that having met with both Deputy Mayor Francois and Commissioner Delaney-Brumsey, we have found them to be thoughtful leaders with a deep commitment to creating safer communities for all New Yorkers. We recognize the value of placing the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence within the Office of Community Safety, but we have many concerns about the way this decision was made and the impact it is having. We feel strongly that the leadership of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence should not have been downgraded from Commissioner to Director, and that the new organizational chart adds additional and unnecessary layers between the leadership of this critical office and Deputy Mayor Francois. I also have serious concerns, having listened to the testimony of the administration a few minutes ago, about what will happen to the staffing — the current staffing of experts — when their titles change and when their salaries potentially change, as was indicated was possible. I think it will be hard to recruit people with that level of expertise and experience at the lower titles that are envisioned for the office in the future. So while the work of the office has continued uninterrupted, that may not be the case going forward because of the plan to downgrade titles.
I think our biggest concern has been that this new structure sends a message that addressing domestic violence, sexual assault, human trafficking and other forms of gender-based violence simply is not a priority for this administration, and the Mayor's silence has only added to that message. So I would be remiss if I failed to mention very quickly that the Crime Victim Assistance Program RFP issued at the beginning of this process is asking the organization that staffs the precincts to do more work with less funding. It will have a very serious impact on the level of staffing, coverage and responsiveness that the program can provide to people who have reached out to the police for assistance. We were reaching 50,000 people before the Adams administration's PEG. That went down to 40,000 because of the PEG. It will go down even more because of this RFP. It adds new requirements while reducing the funding for the precinct-based advocate in a very significant way. We think the administration should reconsider, and we think that the Council should look more closely at that issue as well. Thank you.
Hi, good morning. My name is Alina Victor. So sorry — good morning, Chair and members of
the committee. My name is Alina Victor. I am the Chief Program Officer at Womankind. Thank you for the opportunity to testify on the restructuring of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety. For more than 44 years, Womankind has supported survivors of gender-based violence, particularly immigrant survivors who are often excluded from mainstream services.
We served nearly 3,000 survivors annually in 18 languages. As the committee evaluates this restructuring, we urge you to begin with a simple standard: success should be measured by its impact on those most affected by violence. We recognize the opportunities when survivors do not experience violence in isolation.
Survivors' experiences are inherently intersectional. Many are navigating poverty, housing instability, mental health challenges, discrimination, immigration-related barriers and language access challenges, while also holding multiple identities that shape how they experience violence, access support and move forward towards safety and healing. A more coordinated approach to safety, healing and stability that truly sees and hears survivors' experiences is important.
Culturally specific organizations must remain central to this work. Led by and accountable to the communities they serve, they center the people historically excluded from mainstream spaces and build on cultural traditions, lived experiences and community strengths to help survivors heal and thrive. Organizations like Womankind bring trusted relationships built over decades. We serve as bridges between communities and systems, elevating the voices of survivors whose experiences are often absent from policy conversations. We exist to serve survivors, confront violence at its root and build a future free from violence in a way that honors, strengthens and uplifts cultures and the communities we call home.
As New York City develops a broader vision for community safety, culturally specific organizations should not be consulted at the end of the process. We should be engaged as meaningful partners from the beginning to help shape policies and solutions that reflect the realities of the most impacted communities. Thank you.
And members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, thank you for the opportunity. My name is Marita Rico and I am the Policy and Advocacy Manager at New Destiny Housing. New Destiny provides permanent housing for survivors of domestic violence to break the cycle of abuse and homelessness. We develop and operate supportive housing for survivors and their families, and we provide housing navigation and aftercare, helping survivors find an apartment and the services that keep them stable in it. We are also a proud member of the advisory council.
I want to begin with what the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence has meant for our work. Our staff are co-located in Family Justice Centers in all five boroughs, which are overseen by the office. There we connect survivors to housing resources every day. The daily working relationship has made countless connections to housing possible for New Yorkers who had nowhere else to turn. The office's leadership has also been an invaluable partner, fighting for housing subsidies, flexible funds and other resources that survivors tell them they need the most.
We understand the goal of a more coordinated approach to community safety and we want this restructuring to succeed. Earlier this year, New Destiny joined our fellow advisory council members in writing to the Mayor with our concerns, and we appreciate the administration's response, including Deputy Mayor Francois's commitment to attend our quarterly meetings and the recognition that the office and its network of partners are a model for the Office of Community Safety overall. We asked that this commitment extend to the design of the transition itself.
Two things matter most to us: one, that gender-based violence work retains dedicated senior leadership with real standing at City Hall — someone whose top priority is the tens of thousands of New Yorkers who become homeless each year because of abuse — and two, that the Family Justice Centers' role as a front door for survivors is preserved. New York City has a best-in-class model with impressive quality, coordination and breadth of trauma-informed services available to survivors and their families.
The administration's letter — please let me wrap up, I have one more paragraph. The administration's letter rightly acknowledged that more work remains at the intersection of gender-based violence and housing, and I want to close on an example of why we need this attention. I want to thank you and your staff — Dan in particular — for meeting with us about this. The city administers close to 4,800 Emergency Housing Vouchers, including more than 1,000 survivor-led households, and the funding runs out. City Hall and the office have done an extraordinary job with limited resources to find options for households losing this federally funded voucher, but about 2,000 households have not yet been matched to any alternatives and time is running out. We have been urging the City to use CityFHEPS as the solution of last resort, and that moment has arrived. Because survivors reached safety without passing through shelter — some from HRA domestic violence programs, others directly from fleeing their homes — they are not eligible for CityFHEPS. Inexplicably, eligibility requires a shelter history that an HRA shelter stay does not satisfy. The City can fix this administratively by designating these households as qualifying referrals under the existing category for preventing shelter entry. We would welcome the chance to work through the details with the office and with this committee. Thank you again for the opportunity to testify.
Thank you all so much. I just have two questions for anyone that would like to answer. What are some of the areas the City is not considering when it comes to preventing gender-based violence? That is my first question for anyone.
I think there should be a comprehensive prevention plan that is much more expansive and ambitious than what we have in place now. We should be doing primary prevention of gender-based violence at all ages and in all communities, and we simply have not invested as a City in that.
Okay. Any
other thoughts? Okay, I would like to add — and I am going to maybe be
repetitive in this — but I think a lot of the time when we are thinking about gender-based violence, we leave culturally specific work and silo it into language access, and that is not the only aspect of services that are needed for immigrant communities. We are living in a time where immigration services are extremely difficult for a lot of our survivors. Accessing that support — though I know there are limitations because the federal government is involved — it creates other opportunities for violence and concerns and contributors within our family dynamics, and those are things that we also have to look at a little bit
more closely. And if I may, one last thing: as I said already, the administration acknowledged that the intersection between housing and domestic violence needs to be addressed a little bit more, and we are always pushing for that. As we all here understand, the top reason for homelessness in New York City is domestic violence, and New Destiny has done an incredible job at sort of being our bridge to some of the housing agencies in the City, and we hope that that continues to happen.
I just want to add as well one thing I was not able to add the first time because I was trying to stay within two minutes. In truth, we were deeply concerned that gender justice has not been part of the administration's messaging on the Mayor's affordability agenda. We all know that domestic violence is the greatest driver of homelessness in New York City, that gender inequity is a key part of cyclical poverty
and that survivors often feel trapped in abusive relationships because they lack financial resources. So I just want to remind everyone that gender justice is economic justice, and New Yorkers deserve policies that recognize this.
I would just add one more thing: survivors need to hear from the administration that this is an important issue, and we have not heard that. Thank you.
I appreciate that, and I will elevate all of the messages given to me today. If there are programs that you have seen really great success with in your organization, can you share what those are and what it would take to expand or advance those programs?
Yeah, I will discuss our work with young boys and teens. When Liz talks about prevention, the need to send a message when kids are young — that resolving issues should not be done with the use of force or control — we have a program for young boys and adolescents, as well as a camp that we send kids to that is not funded by any government funding. Five days in upstate New York, it is called Camp Hope. It is a national model and it brings young people together to address their trauma but also
build resilience and hope. And briefly, New Destiny ran an aftercare program alongside our housing navigation services for Emergency Housing Vouchers. This was privately funded, but we found through this that survivors need a lot more support than is given right now by the City when they are given a housing voucher, because it is so much to juggle — the housing search, moving costs, childcare, everything that comes along with the housing. So we are big supporters of housing navigation, especially — we specialize in domestic violence survivors, but for everyone, and especially for survivors — whether that be through the MATCH pilot program. So we are big advocates of making that permanent.
One of the things I had mentioned in my testimony was about our restorative justice program. We developed that program because many of our survivors, as I had mentioned before, are afraid to go to the police and they do not really have a lot of trust in the authorities. So one of the things that we started to do was to survey clients and our survivors specifically on what would be an optional, alternative path. We talked a lot about restorative justice and what that would look like in terms of community circles, and many of our survivors were very interested. They really wanted to be able to come to some kind of resolution when it came to the person who is causing harm, and even just resolutions within their own family, because that is not just happening with the person causing harm. So we have been very successful in the past three years being able to do circles and be able to find a different way without necessarily having them become part of the system. Funding is a big issue as always, and we would love to be able to have the opportunity to expand that and do much more work around restorative justice. But funding is always a big
challenge. Thank you. Okay, I am going to go back to the Crime Victim Assistance Program for a moment since I ran out of time. Having advocates in the precinct is a critical way that the City engages survivors of all forms of violence, abuse and exploitation. It allows us to connect with folks who would not necessarily reach out to the hotline or reach out to a community-based provider, and we hear that all the time. Our clients have a 95% satisfaction rate with the services that they received from the program in its current form. So I want to reiterate that it is a mistake to pull resources out of the precincts. At Safe Horizon, we deeply support investments in community-based and culturally specific organizations, and I think what needs to happen is to expand the pie, not to damage a successful and effective program in order to make those investments. Because when it was fully funded, it was able to reach 53,000 survivors a year. It has already been reduced, and this RFP will reduce it further. So I will stop there. I appreciate the
responses today. Thank you so much. Seeing no other questions — yeah, you are happy to share? Sorry, sorry. I wanted to talk about our embodiment programming, so what we call our Pathways to Healing programming. A lot of the work around gender-based violence involves a lot of trauma work, and trauma work — working with individuals who either speak English or do not speak English — talking about experiences can be very, very difficult. A lot of the time, embodiment practices allow me to better understand what has happened in my life. Our Pathways to Healing program brings in practitioners from all over the country talking about different modalities that our communities have already historically and ancestrally used to help in healing practices, and we would love more funding to broaden the range of modalities we offer to really focus the energy on what healing looks like after experiencing any form of gender-based violence.
I appreciate the responses so much. Please share each of these programs and the requests with my office as we move forward towards budget season. This panel is now excused. I will call the next panel up.
And I will recall from the last panel, just in case it was not heard: Iman Garde — or Gourd — up to testify, as I have an appearance card in front of me. Stephanie Woodbine, Lauren — I am working with handwriting here, folks — Lauren Schuster, maybe... Lauren S., that is what it looks like. Angie Martinez, Tanisha Sanders and Angelina Rosado.
And apologies for any mispronunciations. Schuster? No? It is not... okay. Unless you are up here already. Again: Stephanie Woodbine, Lauren Schuster, Angie Martinez, Tanisha Sanders and Angelina Rosado. Okay, great. You can begin when ready.
Good morning, Chair Farías and members of the City Council Committee on Women and Gender Equity. Thank you for the opportunity to address the Council regarding the restructure of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety. My name is Stephanie Woodbine. I co-chair the Advisory Council at the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence, and I am a member of the Langone Housing and Health Lab Speakers Bureau and Peer Network Cohort Two, serving as a resource for researchers, health care providers and policymakers to better understand topics such as how people lose their housing, diverse experiences with homelessness and ways to improve systems of care for people facing housing challenges.
The Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence is a base where survivors receive inclusive services and support — not incident-based — in rebuilding their lives after fleeing abuse. With the stroke of a pen, 25 years of meaningful health and human services work was reduced, and a press conference was called to announce its demotion as a standalone mayoral office. There was no input from survivors. It is perceived as a blow to our safety and how we access culturally competent resources in trauma-informed settings.
A move to restructure the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence comes at a time when survivors across the United States continue to receive alarming directives from the federal government, and especially uneasy are federal cuts to the Emergency Housing Voucher program created to alleviate the surge in homelessness post-COVID. Many survivors received these vouchers and will be losing their homes very soon. Surely there will be some carve-out for them in the form of a CityFHEPS full expansion. But there is also a gap between traditional poverty measures and the actual cost of living in New York City. Robust investments must be made in proven paths of safety for survivors, such as direct cash and timely payments of contracts. That is imperative to the viability of said paths. Harmful social norms perpetuate gender-based and intimate partner violence. Survivorship is nuanced and society plays a huge role.
Through education and awareness, pervading narratives about survivors will change if the City leads the charge. We have yet to hear from our administration addressing the issue of domestic violence, despite it being a driver of much of the City's most urgent social issues. We do fear the demotion of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence will cut survivors and partner organizations' direct access to leadership. Invite survivors to the policymaking table. Have us in transparent partnership. Do not allow the diversion of specialized resources for survivors. And finally, gun violence and hate crimes are a survivor community issue. Reducing gun violence and increasing safety begins with safety in the home. Thank you.
Thank you so much. Just a reminder — you are okay. A reminder that testimony is two minutes, but also if you want to submit any additional testimony that is extended, we receive it and we read it. Submit testimony at Council's website. You have 72 hours after the hearing. Thank you.
Good morning, fellow advocates, Chair Farías and members of the Committee. My name is Imam God and I am the Manager of Policy and Advocacy at Girls for Gender Equity, an organization that works intergenerationally through a Black feminist lens to center the leadership of Black girls and gender-expansive young people of color. As part of our efforts to bring the voices of youth to the forefront of the City, we have members serving on the Street Harassment Prevention Advisory Board and the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence Advisory Council. I am testifying today on behalf of our organization, our Sisters in Strength youth survivors and in alignment with the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence Advisory Council, where our organization serves as a member.
While there is no denial that addressing gender-based violence is a vital part of community safety, we still hold the fear that the recent restructuring of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety will de-prioritize gender-based violence and ultimately survivors' needs. We hold this belief because, although we have had positive meetings and correspondence from this administration, there has not been enough public discourse surrounding the administration's positions and plans to eradicate gender-based violence across the City since assuming office.
In order to combat the de-prioritization of survivors' needs, we pose five recommendations, of which I will read three due to time constraints. First, the Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence should commit to survivor-centered and survivor-led policymaking and programming, and follow this commitment by recruiting and consulting survivors, including youth survivors, to work on these issues. This framework is essential as the City has not made any significant progress towards reducing the prevalence of intimate partner violence since the pandemic. Secondly, the City must make timely contract payments to maintain program viability and the survivors' safety network. We also need increased funding to properly respond to more youth survivors and sustain that growth. Third, the Mayor should speak out publicly against gender-based violence and create public discourse surrounding the issue, especially as it pertains to community safety.
These recommendations stem from a recent short survey of our fellow gender-based violence colleagues following two specific communications with the administration. We share these recommendations to inform New York City's community safety plan, and they responded with their commitments to our original recommendations. Those original recommendations to the administration came from a more comprehensive December 2025 survey, which included addressing survivors' unmet needs for permanent housing, cash assistance and access to affordable immigration-related legal support, child care and services for the person causing harm, as well as culturally specific services. We hope this Council and the mayoral administration will consider these suggestions as we envision the future of the Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence, and see Girls for Gender Equity as a resource throughout this transition, especially when it comes to ensuring the perspectives of youth survivors. Thank you.
Good morning. I am sorry, y'all. Good morning, members of our Committee. My name is Angelina Rosado. I am not only speaking to you as the co-founder and executive director of Sisters in Purple, but I am speaking to you as a survivor — a survivor who knows what it feels like to need safety while being forced to navigate disconnected systems. Today I stand beside other survivors facing the same barriers. I know where the systems break because I lived it, and because survivors show us every day what these breaks are.
Domestic violence cannot be reorganized without public view, stripped of specialized leadership and treated as one issue among many without clear authority, staffing, funding and accountability. When the government changes the structure of the response for survivors' safety, survivors deserve more than just silence. What resources remain protected and how is this change going to make us feel safer?
As Sisters in Purple, we walk beside survivors daily. We walk beside survivors after they disclose everything — and that means including police precincts, family and criminal court, ACS, HRA, emergency shelters, mental health care, employment, education and long-term healing. We see survivors getting handed a list instead of a warm connection. We see agencies fail to communicate, eligibility rules that do not match the danger and trusted community organizations excluded when referrals are made. Fragmentation is not a minor inconvenience — it is fatal for survivors in danger.
I understand — we understand — that the promise of a whole-of-government approach means domestic violence is connected to housing and stability, poverty, child safety and welfare, mental health, gun violence and community violence. Coordinating this can save lives. I am sorry...
I am so nervous, y'all. Okay. Just asking for it not to buzz while you finish. I am so sorry, y'all. Do not be nervous — this is a safe space.
But coordination without specialized power can create invisibility. If the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence remains under the Office of Community Safety, it must be recognized, fully staffed and equipped with funding, and we must make sure that leaders are experts who continue to work with direct decision-makers and empower the agencies as a whole.
New York City must create a system where we are not just responding to domestic violence — we are actually making a pathway for prevention. Sisters in Purple does propose a 12-month domestic violence case management system pilot that is built around survivor-led community hubs. This way it is more than just avoiding police interaction, because we do understand that survivors do not always want to walk into precincts, and they also do not always want to go where the services are because those services are connected to where family courts and other court systems are, which can put fear in them while they are trying to receive services.
We are not asking the City to pick between domestic violence and community safety. Domestic violence is community safety. A restructure changes titles, but it should be judged by whether survivors are safe, help is easy to reach, agencies are accountable and fewer families experience devastating losses. I do not want us to wait for another homicide to happen, another public tragedy to happen or another oversight hearing for government to act.
You have the authority right now to demand transparency, protect specialized survivor leadership and invest in prevention now. Thank you.
I am a little nervous. Okay. Breathe. Okay. Peace and blessings and thank you so much to the Committee and...
...the Committee on Women and Gender Equity. Hi everyone. My name is Angie Martinez and I am the Director of Peer Engagement at Sisters in Purple. I am also a Voices member and also sitting on the Fatality Review Committee. And I say this with pride — I am a proud survivor of domestic violence. Back in 2012, I was kidnapped with my daughter. By the grace of God I am here today to tell my story. I still face challenges while navigating through the system, which shows how much support survivors like me need.
I am here today because I know personally what it means to need a system that does more than just respond after someone has been harmed. Survivors need a system that sees us, hears us, protects us and helps us rebuild our lives again.
The restructuring of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety makes oversight incredibly important. Under Executive Order 15, the Office of Community Safety is responsible for coordinating several offices, including the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence. While the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence continues to have responsibilities related to domestic violence services, policies, agency coordination and improving the City's responses, with that restructuring comes an important responsibility. We must make sure that survivors do not get lost in the structure.
Oversight must ask the questions that survivors and community organizations are asking every day. Are survivors actually receiving services when they really need them? Are our shelters, housing resources, legal services, financial assistance and safety planning accessible and responsive? Are survivors from every borough and every community being heard? Are community-based organizations being meaningfully included in decisions and sitting at the table? And most importantly, are we measuring success by what survivors experience, not simply by what government agencies report?
As a survivor, I understand that asking for help can be one of the hardest moments in a person's life. I was once there. I was once that person. When a survivor reaches out, that may be the moment that they have finally found the courage to say "I need help." We cannot afford for that courage to be met with confusion, delays, disconnection in the systems or even death.
I believe survivors must have a seat at the table — not just as people being served, but as partners in shaping the systems designed to serve us. As Sisters in Purple, we are committed to making sure survivors' voices remain part of this conversation, and this is why we are here today. We need transparency. We need accountability. We need meaningful community engagement. We need resources to follow the needs of survivors. Because restructuring an office is about more than just changing where an agency sits on an organizational chart. It is about whether a survivor feels safer when they reach out for help. I am here today to let you know that we are those survivors. Listen to survivors. Include survivors. Invest in survivors. And hold the systems accountable for survivors. Thank you all and have a blessed day.
Good morning. I am Lauren Shuster, the Chief External Affairs Officer at Urban Resource Institute. I just want to thank my fellow panelists for sharing and using your voices to uplift the survivors that we all serve. Thank you, Chair Farías, members of the Committee and staff for holding this important hearing. URI is the largest provider of domestic violence shelter services in the country. Every night we provide safe housing to 4,000 individuals, 65% of whom are children.
25 years after its creation, the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence remains an essential voice for survivors. That role matters today as much as it did back then. While other violent crime has dropped, domestic violence rates remain relatively unchanged, particularly in Black and Latina communities in parts of the Bronx and Brooklyn. The decision to move the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence into the Office of Community Safety and to change its leadership was announced without consultation — the kind of consultation that has really defined our partnership over the past two-plus decades. For a field that is built on trauma-informed practice with transparency at its very core, that absence of consultation was felt acutely by the providers and the survivor community that we all serve. Decisions of this magnitude should be made in the future with survivors and providers at the center.
I will say that since then, Deputy Mayor François and Commissioner Delaney-Brumsey have engaged with us in an incredibly collaborative manner. They visited URI's midtown office and just yesterday did a walk-through of the Bronx URI site as the contract holder there. We are encouraged to hear that they are planning a provider advisory council and that they are engaging in an inclusive strategic planning process.
We believe that the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence, regardless of where it sits on the org chart, must continue to play a pivotal role in coordinating the services and supports that survivors access when they are in crisis and in need of help. That is the role that they have played and must continue to play. At the same time, we are grateful for the investments that were made in this most recent budget. Funding was increased for the Office of Community Safety, for youth violence prevention and for immigrant legal services. These are all critical investments for survivors, the families that rely on them and the communities that they live in. We are really just looking for increased partnership on these and so many more issues.
I want to highlight just in closing — we speak so much about domestic violence after a horrible situation happens, after there is a story of a family annihilation in the headlines. We can and should be investing in prevention, because there are ways to stop violence before it starts, to identify and interrupt those cycles of violence both with youth intervention and also with people who have caused harm. And so that is my soapbox, and thank you so much.
Of course. Just a question for the providers on the previous panel — what are some areas the City is not considering when it comes to preventing gender-based violence? I know some folks have raised some things, but are there things that are hyper-specific to the work that you are doing? I would love to hear some of that. Yes.
I would love to echo the sentiment that was just shared — that prevention really does start with educating our young people. More programming across the board needs to be done, because as youth they are already disempowered. Sometimes the gender-based violence they are experiencing is at home and they are not empowered enough to even speak about it. There are no third spaces for them. For example, at Girls for Gender Equity we do serve as a third space for young people, and that is something that is rare in their lives. But from there they have to learn to speak about these experiences, learn about them and understand what is even going on — to be able to identify it as gender-based violence.
Through our model, which weaves together restorative justice, healing justice and a social work model, and also more recently investing in contributing to research that allows young people to dive into the issues they are seeing in their lives, be able to explore those issues themselves and understand what solutions they can come up with — that is a huge part of prevention.
Also, mental health support is a huge aspect of being able to provide young people with the resources they need to work through the gender-based violence that they are experiencing in their lives, seeing their families experience it, seeing their friends experience it. Immigration supports are also needed because that is adding many more barriers. And ultimately this issue needs sustainable funding, because this is not a...
...one-time issue. It needs real structural change. We need sustainable funding.
I just have a comment from a survivor perspective. Something that the City needs to invest in is helping the children of survivors, especially when they enter the child welfare system.
That is important. My son has just been sentenced to 25 years and I should have gotten just a little bit more. My family should have gotten a little bit more of what we needed. But that is definitely one place where we need coordination. And now there is this whole issue of domestic violence in community safety. It is gun violence related — why he is where he is at right now. I was forced to stay in New York because I was in custodial court for 13 years and that impacted my son's development. Me being in survival mode, my children were right there. Economic instability, homelessness, you name it — youth as a tool of control. And the court with their court-ordered surveillance and coercive control, that was legal. So these are certain conversations that survivors need to have out in the open.
Thank you. I appreciate that. My follow-up question to the survivors that are providing testimony today was what might be helpful experiences you have had in navigating this system, but also where the points of contention are, points where we have missteps and we are missing. So I appreciate you uplifting that. If anybody else wants to add as well, they can.
Yes, I think I want to add to your first question. When we are talking about what is missing and what is not really working, the reality is leaning in on prevention — making sure that we are just not always focused on survivors and putting burdens on survivors, but shifting that energy to the people that are actually causing the harm, actually getting them the proper support and intervention that they need from a holistic standpoint. So at Sisters in Purple we actually have an initiative called Brothers in Purple, and our brothers — you know, that comes from a space where people who have self-identified as people that have caused harm and are choosing, again self-voluntarily, are choosing to seek further support and assistance to no longer have the mentality of what they believed was normal. Hurt people hurt people, and that is the reality. People that cause harm are people that have had their own calls to the right. So when we talk about preventive measures, investing — we work a lot with our organizations, our gun violence prevention, and working within that system is also helping, training them. As a survivor-led organization we believe that we have the best training. We are the survivors. They learn domestic violence differently when it comes from a survivor-led organization, and that is what we have been proving. We have worked with and also our reentry programs.
We have also worked with them and training their staff on how to identify domestic violence, not just for the community that they are serving but that they are employing. You know, just as recently we just had a survivor of domestic violence who worked at a domestic violence shelter in Staten Island who was murdered, pregnant, in Queens. This happened, and yet it is still quiet and we have not heard anything. And to know that the person that caused the harm, who is in question, is a person who served as a gun violence preventer. The fact that staff is not trained properly, or do they have the supportive resources for them to deal with whatever they are leaving at the door when they enter that organization? People still go home and people still have their own traumas that they are also dealing with, on top of being asked to support and protect our community. They also are their own community and they also need that support there too.
That was on the whole time. I just wanted to uplift what you said: hurt people hurt people. You, I, and many of the other providers here in this room operate abusive partner intervention programs where we provide accountability-based, trauma-informed programming to people who have caused harm. For so long we have relied on survivors to be responsible for ending their own violence without engaging the person causing harm. Research that we have done shows that almost 80% of people who have caused harm have experienced some sort of trauma prior to that. Our APEP program was recently evaluated by the Urban Institute and it found that it was a promising practice and it had significant impact on recidivism rates over a 12-month period after successful program completion. So it is real. Investing in programs that work with people who cause harm has the potential to increase safety for survivors and reduce recidivism, so that the City's costs also go down in the long run. I cannot agree more with all of the points that you made. Thank you.
And in that same vein I would like to also relate how this pertains again to young people and the education that they receive in schools, because the disciplinary measures that they have to deal with within schools do reflect the carceral system and it all starts there. So sometimes teachers experience a young person who they write off as troubled — usually traumatized, maybe experiencing gender-based violence among a plethora of other issues. What happens is they are usually pushed out of school, suspended, taken out of the classroom, out of the safety of school, which should be a place where they can learn to understand themselves, the experiences that they are going through, and know how to navigate them. So restorative justice within schools is a huge part also of ending gender-based violence.
If I can just add about youth: at Sisters in Purple we have Future Purple Nation, which is our youth programming where we work with the schools. We come into schools and a lot of it is teachers themselves, guidance counselors, parent coordinators reaching out to us, as well as our youth organizations reaching out to us to not just talk about teen dating violence, but also a lot of these kids, like Stephanie said, have experienced domestic violence in their households. So going to the shelters and working with the young people who experienced domestic violence, helping them understand — I was 15 years old when I entered a domestic violence relationship and I had no idea that I was even in one. Understanding those signs, because the people that came before me in my generation were not allowed to talk about their domestic violence. Those stories were not allowed to be told. As we see how old the Violence Against Women Act is, my grandmother is in her 70s and she had no protection. So these conversations were not normalized.
When we come into the community we make sure that our young people are really engaged. I am really surprised how much they care to actually know the information and really absorb it and really implement it in their lives. I am a mother of two children. My daughter plays no games when it comes to understanding domestic violence, which also helped her really shape friendships in her life and how she created boundaries with people. These are the things that are very pivotal to help prevent domestic violence, to keep teen dating violence from escalating into domestic violence, and understanding that our kids are angry. They do not have real resources. When we talk about the reduction of gun violence, if we are not addressing domestic violence in these children's households, they are going to come outside and they are going to be very angry about things and they...
...do not know how to channel that. So leaving domestic violence out of the conversation is really detrimental to our children and our future. I appreciate all the comments shared. Thank you so much.
And it came to mind in your responses here — I have a couple of bills around consent and consent awareness. I would love to, as we approach the new year, kind of go to schools and continue the conversation with you folks on how we can talk about that in a real way. I am seeing no questions. The panel is excused. I will call the next panel. I am just going to make the executive decision here and move the time to three minutes for public testimony. I feel like I am allowing a lot of flexibility anyhow. Just so when the buzzer goes off you know your time is actually done. I am trying to be respectful of folks whose experiences and what folks are having the strength to come and share in front of the Council, and I want to be respectful of that, but also knowing that I have a clock and a hearing right after us at one o'clock with the folks that are present. So if the sergeants can change the clock to three minutes, that will be the cutoff time. I would appreciate that. I thank you, CM Gutiérrez. I would now like to call up Kelly, Madeleine Garcia Bigelow, Shari Yvette Barnett and Mildred. And I will give one last try at Tanisha Sanders if she is in the room and did not hear me.
Oh perfect. Chamara, you can come up. Kate, just press your time. Yeah, okay. Restart. Okay. Just fill some seats. Tiina Bien Aimé and Luce, if you can also come up. Because we have empty seats you can begin when ready.
Good afternoon. My name is Chamara Kelly. I am the co-founder of Sisters in Purple. I am here today as a community organizer with Voices of Women Organizing Project. The Voices of Women is a survivor-led organization that works on systemic change for survivors.
I want to speak to something that continues to be missing from the conversation about community safety: the lives of Black women survivors. Whether domestic violence is addressed through the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence, the Office of Community Safety, or both, Black women survivors tend to fall through the cracks. With regard to the restructure of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence, survivors and survivor-led organizations were not included in any conversation leading up to or during the restructuring. So we question what the difference is. What active actions is the Office of Community Safety going to take to protect Black women? Too often there is no public urgency, visibility or collective response.
The Office of Community Safety seems more focused on community violence. We cannot build domestic violence systems and community safety strategies that respond to some sorts of violence while remaining silent when violence happens within our homes, families, relationships and communities. Part of my concern is the lack of communication from the Office of Community Safety. We do not know what this restructure means for survivors or how they are addressing long-standing issues with the City's response to domestic violence. There has not been enough communication about what this new structure actually means for domestic violence survivors.
We are organizing for full survivor involvement in policies and procedures that impact survivors. We should not have to organize for this. It should be a given that this would happen. Survivors come to the table with solutions. We should be compensated for their time and certainly deserve more than a statement or condolences after a tragedy. Our communities deserve leadership, even when speaking is uncomfortable. As someone who works directly with survivors and communities, I know that silence does not make us safer. Survivors need to be protected and heard. Thank you.
Good afternoon, Chair and members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity. My name is Mildred Ramos. I am an executive leader in nonprofit operations and human services, coming forward today as a survivor and independent advocate to address systemic gaps in survivor protection and youth human trafficking oversight. Lived experience must lead policy.
In 1987, as a 16-year-old girl, I was abducted in Washington Heights, forced into two separate apartments inside a building, physically attacked, beaten and lost consciousness several times while being subjected to severe sexual violence by an adult Dominican man, an adult Jamaican man, a Colombian boy and a group of other boys forced to participate under their direction. I was examined at North Central Bronx Hospital and reported the crime to the 46th Precinct. Despite formal records, New York City, New York State and ACS failed to act. Case stalling permitted me to be trafficked to Arecibo, Puerto Rico without legal advocacy, tracking or state care, housed solely by a minor friend. Unaddressed catastrophic trauma permanently damaged my central nervous system, causing late-onset fibromyalgia with somatic pain.
Rather than protection, I faced decades of institutional lawfare. Systemic blackballing has left me completely without an income for six years. During a recent Newark emergency, first responders misidentified my trauma as noncompliance. I was forced into a hospital in an experience that deeply re-traumatized me. The second time I was forced to go, I do not recall everything that happened. I remember walking in, being put on an IV and later waking up to speak with a doctor on a screen. I was discharged alone to spend Thanksgiving dinner isolated in my home, ultimately resulting in the total loss of my family home and stability.
In Puerto Rico, one third of the population lives with fibromyalgia, as reported by Diario de Puerto Rico, amid severe medical shortages. I deeply worry that the people living there will face even worse conditions than what I have endured. These are the untold stories of Puerto Rico, where our children are sold into modern-day slavery and our people are left without health care while traffickers accelerate gentrification and politicians are silenced by corruption.
I demand five immediate actions: extradition and prosecution — locate, extradite and prosecute my abusers; closing jurisdictional loopholes; an independent oversight commission — establish a multi-agency body with permanent seats for people with lived experience; mandatory cross-border tracking — link New York City, New York State and Puerto Rico's Departamento de la Familia; first responders — require citywide training on central nervous system trauma so somatic pain is met with stabilization, not forced hospitalization or hostility; and housing and economic support — remove barriers to guarantee housing stability and economic recovery pathways. Without survivors leading oversight, institutions use blackballing and lawfare to protect themselves while perpetrators walk free. Establish this commission, open doors for housing and recovery, and extradite my abusers. Thank you for allowing me to testify today.
Good afternoon, Chair Farías and members of the Committee. Thank you so much for holding this hearing. My name is Madeleine Garcia Bigelow. I am the founder and managing director of the Domestic Violence Project housed at the Urban Justice Center. I have worked on behalf of survivors for 33 years, as a prosecutor in the Bronx and as a founder. In the eight months of this administration, at least six high-profile domestic violence deaths have occurred in New York City: Levi Williams, Angelique Apostle, Erika Caldwell, Yesenia Hall, Maria Inez Granda and Dana Foley. And yet we have not heard the Mayor condemn domestic violence clearly and unequivocally, even after each of these homicides. New York City has spent more...
...than a quarter century building a dedicated, survivor-centered system. In 2001, through City Charter, the Mayor's Office to Combat Domestic Violence was created, and then in 2018 the mission was expanded and it was renamed the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence. But these are not simply titles. They embody and symbolize years of advocacy, conversation and education led by survivors and providers. It was built with survivors and providers, and even though it collaborates really closely with law enforcement and the courts, it is decidedly distinct from that. Executive Order 15 folded that work into the Office of Community Safety. Consolidation in and of itself is not a disqualifier, but domestic violence is not interchangeable with gun violence interruption or general mental health response. Confidentiality protections and a justified wariness of anything that looks like general public safety...
...during July's quarterly crime stats press conference, Commissioner Tisch noted a 6% reduction in major crimes but pointed out that felony assaults remained flat, with 42% of those assaults being domestic violence related. Since the Executive Order, providers and survivors have not been included in any real conversation about what comes next.
So when restructuring happens in silence, survivors cannot tell whether a service still exists, advocates cannot make accurate referrals, and decades of expertise risk being deprioritized. The need is growing. In the eight months of this administration, my team of 23 has opened 2,069 new cases. Our warm line has answered 12,267 calls, more than all the calls received in 2025. Over 65% of our clients are immigrants and most of them are undocumented.
In the most recent issue of City and State, asked about the strong showing in the primaries, the Mayor said his most important goal is delivering for New Yorkers, that he is less interested in narrowing who he works with than in expanding who can sit across the table from him. So we take him at his word, Mayor Mamdani. We ask this Council to use its oversight authority to secure a commitment to a survivor-centered, survivor-led policymaking process with an actual seat at the table for the survivors and the providers.
Thank you again for holding this hearing. Good afternoon, Council. My name is Louis Qatari. I am chairwoman of Equal Power. I am a 40-year-old body, grandmother, survivor and advocate from Spanish Harbor. I come to you today as a mother, a survivor and a leader of families who depend on the very office you are reorganizing and moving.
You are making the decision about survivors without survivors in the room.
On paper, you call moving the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence into the larger Office of Community Safety coordination. To us, it feels like erasure. When you move a program, you do not just move an org chart — you move someone's lifeline. And that erasure is already happening. All the programs that were put in place to keep survivors and our families alive — flexible grants for rent, food, clothing and supplies for our children — on paper they exist, but when you actually need them, they feel nonexistent. They are being slowly removed, defunded or shuffled into other offices where no one is accountable. No one is asking what happens to a mother and her children when that lifeline disappears.
This is what that failure looks like in my life. I did everything we were told to do. I have photos of the abuse, police reports, real-time voicemails threatening my life saved on my phone. My lawyer would not present that evidence. The judge did not ask for it. Orders of protection were issued and they were not enforced. There were no consequences. And now four of my five children live with the person who hurt us fully.
When I sought emergency housing with priority because he was no longer in the home on paper, when I said I was still being threatened, I was told he seemed like he had calmed down. I claimed death threats out loud in real time for officers and was told to go home and call if he showed up. He did show up and nothing was done to him.
When I turned to the Family Justice Center, the revolving door continued. For almost a year I have been assigned and reassigned to multiple case managers. Each one promised help with the basics — food insecurity, clothing, supplies for my child and, most importantly, housing stability.
My emergency housing voucher is being removed from the Section 8 program. I need to transition to a new voucher to keep a roof over me and my 20-month-old daughter's head. For months I have asked for help applying. It took forever for someone to finally sit with me. Then at the last minute I was told there were steps I personally had to take — steps that could have cost me my eligibility and my spot, steps no one told me about until it was almost too late.
At the same time, Section 8 placed multiple rent abatements on my apartment. Management left that balance as my responsibility. I am now facing eviction for arrears that are not my fault. I begged to access the grants that the Family Justice Center advertises for exactly this. I emailed, texted and called every case manager they ever assigned me and their supervisors, and it was silent.
When someone finally called back, I was told the grants were gone and that I should have reached out for an update. The emails, the texts, the call logs prove I did — and prove everything the system did not answer. I am counted in those 60,677 visits that the Family Justice Center says they get. But my daughter and I are one step from losing our home. A referral slip is not a service.
We all know how bad it is out there. NYPD writes up a quarter million domestic incidents a year. We lose more than 60 New Yorkers a year to domestic violence — half killed by a partner. The hotline rings nearly a hundred thousand times. And on any given day across this state, over a thousand survivors are turned away because there is no capacity. But those numbers, which I have included on page for the record, do not show whether a mother actually got help or how long she waited.
So I am asking the Committee to do what survivors need you to do. Protect the programs we depend on. Stop quietly removing them. Track real outcomes, not just visits — how long to a lawyer, to therapy, to funds, to stable housing. Audit what you call a service. Preserve an independent office with its own trauma-informed staff who understand coercive control and family court. Fund consistent, accountable case management. And enforce the court orders you issue.
I am not a case number. I am the next family. Thank you.
Sorry, and just before you begin — part of the Bills that we are hearing today is exactly for that. On the hotline, we need to know the breakdown of the calls and if there is follow-up or not. So the Council, at least on our side, is trying to figure out different ways of getting that data and actually making it actionable, not just another data point that we reference.
Okay. Hello. Thank you, Chair, and members of the City Council, for this opportunity to testify today. My name is Tina Bien. I am the Executive Director of the Coalition Against Trafficking in Women, one of the oldest international organizations dedicated to preventing and ending the trafficking and sexual exploitation of women and girls worldwide. We do so through legal advocacy and working with a global survivor leadership network. We oppose the downgrading of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence commission, which is couched as a simple integration under the Office of Community Safety. Gender-based violence is not a simple subset of general crime or community safety. It is a pervasive and grave human rights violation, often perpetrated by members of the community, which requires highly specialized expertise, dedicated institutional infrastructure and targeted investments. The data in our...
...city reflects the critical need for a standalone and independent Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence commission and commissioner — whether in cases of intimate partner and domestic violence, sex crimes and rape, which are increasing in New York City, and specifically for our organization, the trafficking in human beings for sexual exploitation, an acute crisis in New York City that is being largely unaddressed and whose victims are overwhelmingly women.
I also would like to take a few seconds to thank the survivors on this panel and in this room for your courage and your leadership, and for sharing with the City your lived experiences that will hopefully help us develop a comprehensive response to prevent and end gender-based violence.
Just from the few searing testimonies we heard today from the brave survivors, it is clear that New York City cannot afford to address gender-based violence, sexual assault and commercial sexual exploitation as mere footnotes to public safety and municipal budgeting. Dismantling, weakening or merging this specialized commission would signal to survivors that their safety and rights are not front and center to the political will of our City.
We therefore urge the City of New York to maintain and strengthen the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence commission as a specialized entity headed by a commissioner. And please listen to survivors. Thank you.
Thank you all so much. I do not have any additional questions because I feel the testimony was very thorough. But if there is anything that anyone would like to raise about a service or experience that you found helpful, that the City could navigate into its resources, that is good for us to know. I also feel like all of you spoke really wonderfully on how your voice can be included in the decision-making process with the administration. But if there are any last notes, I am happy to allow some time to hear them. I just want to...
...advocate that the statute of limitations be removed, that there be no deadline on justice, and that when it comes to rape kits, that those are preserved. Thank you.
I do not have much because I gave a few recommendations, but it is just that anything that impacts survivors — they need to be included at all times. That is it.
Yes, I hear that. That is why we are having an oversight hearing. Literally just a couple of seconds — I think it has been about 15 people that have spoken, and when I was thinking through what it is that we are missing...
I think we will be missing a lot more if the Office of Community Safety continues the way that it has been discussed today through the commissioner, because these are all needs that are all diverse. Making it all one thing or another, or just really focusing on "we have given the biggest amount since 2018" — that is terrific, but...
...Liz Roberts saying the pie needs to be expanded — yes, all of it is important so that survivors can elect to move forward and have the privilege to decide who is going to help us, how we want to be helped. But the more we narrow things and make it...
...where we are actually almost in-fighting for a bucket of money that, the way it is defined, is through deliverables that do not really have anything to do with the work that is being done or comprehension of the complexity of it.
I will say that, in my experience, two buckets of funding that have been exceptionally helpful have been DOVE, because it does allow you to pivot in ways that other grants simply do not allow — they keep you begging, "Can I please use this money instead of MetroCards for this?" — and the flexible funding that came as a result of COVID that has been continued statewide. And I think that that is what...
...we need. We need a belief in what survivors are saying is their need, and that need is not stagnant. And privilege is, in many respects, the ability to choose what you want and not lose your foothold.
And I think that this administration, although I hope that they step up...
...they have made it really clear for eight months that it is all...
..."We got this." I mean, it is under the Office of Community Safety. They even recognize that mental health should be a separate division within the Office of Community Safety, but not so with these stories.
I said rarely in my tenure in the City Council have I, in the middle of a hearing, extended the time. That is probably the first time I have ever done that. This is a moment where I have an understanding, I think, beyond what I can vocalize, of the time that has been given to everyone here. I am trying to just really, in my duty, show respect. Showing up to testify for survivors means a lot to me, because it is the only way that I am going to have the tools that I need in my toolkit to fight for the things that we need — that are coming out of this hearing, that are within these Bills that we are hearing today, and that through numerous conversations I have had and site visits I have made, we are able to do the work together continuously. So I thank everyone. I do not have any additional questions for this...
...panel. Yes, of course you can add. I just wanted to add one last thing. About you saying about the bravery — another part of my situation that is going on that I do not think a lot of, maybe the Council or even just the organizations, know: there are certain situations where the unthinkable scenarios happen with survivors, and you would not think it is feasible, possible or whatever. But as of right now, I am going through child support, fighting my abuser, only because he wants to incarcerate me and continue his abuse with me even though I am unable to work at the moment due to his abuse. I have agoraphobia, anxiety, PTSD and palpitations, and because of that I cannot work. Because, as you saw earlier, I have to travel with someone all the time. My shakes are bad. I cannot stand for too long due to his abuse. I cannot be outside in public due to the abuse, because to this day he still stalks me.
I mentioned him stalking me in child support court, and when I brought it up to my attorney, my attorney told me it had nothing to do with child support. Situations like that are the problem — where they are still finding ways to abuse us, and when we bring it up in those certain areas, because it does not have to do with what we are there for, they do not care about it. I keep pushing the issue with my lawyer that because of his abuse I cannot work, so how does he expect me to pay child support for these children if he continues to abuse me? He literally just said he has seen me in the street. He is stalking my Instagram. He is stalking my Facebook, putting pictures to present as evidence of me. And yet nothing is being done about it. But yet I am supposed to sit here and let the same man that almost took my life now be the judge of whether I should go to jail or not.
And I think that is one thing we need to change — where in certain situations, yes, we should have the option to put people in jail, but not your abuser. Your abuser should never have the option in any scenario to put his victim in jail, no matter what is the...
...reasoning. I appreciate you sharing that with us. I do want to just offer my last two notes before I excuse you folks.
There are issues that are being elevated in this hearing that are out of the City's jurisdiction. You have my commitment to uplifting those to the State officials and to our district attorneys — the folks that are relevant on those jurisdictional matters, whether it is statute of limitations or some of our family court custodial issues. I will absolutely uplift those.
And I am really happy to hear about the expanded DOVE funds and the flexibility that it allows. I was a part of the team in my first four years in the Council to fight for those expanded DOVE dollars for Council members and the offices impacted. We created a tier system for those that are unfortunately most impacted, receiving more funds to allow our groups flexibility. So I appreciate hearing that and knowing that, and I will uplift that also to the Speaker's team in the finance division.
But thank you folks for testifying today. Thank you. Thank you, of course.
I would like to call up our next panel before we move on to virtual panelists. I will recall Shari Barnett, if you are in the room, Kavita Macron and Christopher Johnson. As you folks are coming up to testify, as a reminder, there are three minutes to testify and all testimony must be relevant to today's hearing on examining the restructure of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety. Speakers will be reminded of the topic and asked to refocus their comments. And if you want to submit any additional or longer testimony, you can do that within 72 hours at testimony@council.nyc.gov. You may begin when ready.
Good afternoon. Thank you, Chair, and members of the Committee on Women and Gender Equity, for this opportunity to testify. My name is Kavita Tamyra and I am the Executive Director of SAKHI for South Asian Survivors. I am here today to testify in opposition to the proposed restructuring of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence.
SAKHI has worked with South Asian and Indo-Caribbean survivors of gender-based violence in New York City since 1989, and through this work we have become acutely aware that gender-based violence is the defining crisis in our City. For survivors, it is not an issue that exists in isolation. It affects their ability to access safe housing, economic stability, food security, education, health care and community safety. That is why the City's response must be strong, coordinated and centered on survivors.
The urgency of this public health matter is reflected in the experience of the communities we serve. Among South Asian American New Yorkers, 85% of women between the ages of 18 and 34 report experiencing sexual assault at least once in their lifetime. 48% of South Asian Americans report experiencing domestic violence. 41% have witnessed domestic violence in their homes. And 25% have experienced child sexual abuse. Behind each of these numbers is a survivor, a family and a community.
That is why we are deeply concerned about the restructuring that could diminish the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence's standing and access to decision-making in City Hall, at a time when survivors and service providers are calling for stronger coordination and greater investment. We should not be creating additional barriers between survivors and the institutions responsible for serving them.
A meaningful gender justice movement must be led by survivors. Survivors must have a direct and meaningful voice in the policies and systems that affect their lives. They deserve to be seen, believed, heard and included in decisions about their communities. A reorganization that buries the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence deeper in bureaucracy with no consultation sends the opposite message.
SAKHI welcomed Mayor Mamdani to our Iftar, and we appreciated the opportunity to welcome him in our community. But meaningful engagement with survivors and advocates must extend beyond individual moments. It must be reflected in the structure, authority and resources of City government. We look forward to building on this engagement with Commissioner Sethi and working together to strengthen support for this important and often overlooked population.
For these reasons, SAKHI urges the City Council to oppose the proposed restructuring of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence, and to ensure that the office maintains a strong and meaningful position in City Hall with the authority and resources necessary to lead coordination citywide in response to gender-based violence. We also urge the City to strengthen its investment in community-based organizations and services provided directly to survivors every day. If we are committed to a safer, more equitable New York City, survivors must not only have their voice — they must also have a meaningful place in decisions that shape their lives. Thank you.
My name is Christopher Leon Johnson. I oppose this proposal, and I will tell you why. Because we have a Mayor, Mamdani, who — not only when he ran for mayor but to this day — has refused to really address the gun violence problem in the City. Second, he has refused to really address the domestic violence problem in the City.
And I think everybody knows why — you know why — because Mayor Mamdani is a Muslim, and I am going to tell you right now that the problem with you... I am going to keep you on topic. I am...
The... this is on topic. This is on topic. The problem... very, very closely being off topic. I...
Understand the problem with...
This mayor is that he surrounds himself with a lot of abusers that uphold that religion, so of course he has to cover it up by putting that division, making sure domestic violence against... that division. That is the truth. He has to make sure... that is the facts. Let me tell you right now, I think that the City Council needs to come and make a statement condemning... Islam in general, when it comes to the times. This is the facts. But I am going forward. I am going forward. A nonprofit that has walked out... you know, they got an abuser that abuses women in that nonprofit, Sisters in Purple. His name is Elvis Katori or something like that. People told you to remain on topic. I am saying right now, accusatory... this is the fact. I got the receipts on Instagram. I am... I could... but this is the facts. However, going forward, going forward, I am just saying this City needs to make a statement calling out, condemning the religion of Islam, calling out the domestic violence... your time is up and I am cutting you off because that is not true. The truth is we have gone forward for domestic organizations.
Please remove him from the chamber. Yo, this is crazy. I am leaving. Great, thank you. Got to stay on topic. I do not have any questions. If there is anything, as I had stated before, as a provider in the City of New York, if there are items that you think are working, that are helpful — I know you provided testimony — obviously we want you folks at the table when decisions like this are made. But if there is anything that the City could be doing more of, I know some folks mentioned prior funding is always more supportive. Any of the pots or funds, things like that, that we can take back would be helpful. Terrific.
I think one of the things that I did not hear through the course of this testimony is that this is ultimately the leading public health issue in our city and it needs to be addressed as such. Unfortunately it is not. When we put the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence in the scope of community safety, we are not examining the fact that it is a public health matter that is ultimately preventable and solvable, and that is really critical.
What we are seeing, particularly for a culturally responsive approach at this moment in time, is just a really critical need. The federal ecosystem that is impacting immigrant communities — 80% of the survivors that we work with at our organization identify as Muslim, 12% are undocumented. We are seeing a really challenging moment as a result of H.R. 1, the changes in VAWA and the expansion of public charge. We have seen a 14% increase in survivors served over the course of this year, a 50% increase in our food justice program, and a 1,000% increase in our legal justice program when we compare the same numbers from last year to this year.
Ultimately we are under-resourced. We are completely treading water. We are also seeing a diminishment of the impact of this issue across the city. So I think the framing of the matter ultimately needs to be examined, which is that it is a public health matter that needs to be examined across the city. I appreciate that response greatly.
I could not agree more. Thank you so much for testifying today. I will now move to our virtual testimony. I would like to call...
Horan Himmel? Hey... move it... sorry.
Apologize. That is okay. You can begin when ready. Okay.
Good afternoon. Thank you to Chair Farías and the Committee for the opportunity to speak. I am speaking today on behalf of the Legal Aid Society. The Legal Aid Society was founded here in New York City in 1876. We are the oldest and largest provider of legal services in the United States. We handle some 300,000 cases in legal matters per year for low-income New Yorkers with civil, criminal and juvenile rights problems.
I have been a staff attorney in our Family Law Domestic Violence Unit in our Civil Practice since 2019. The Family Unit represents survivors of domestic violence in both Supreme and Family Court. My fellow attorneys and I provide full representation to help survivors assert their rights to custody of their children, to child support and maintenance, to equitable distribution of property and their right to be safe and free from harm.
We urge the Mamdani Administration to keep the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence operating as its own office. It has existed for 25 years and has been successful. We strongly believe that independence was a key to that success and that making the office part of the Office of Community Safety will detract from its independence and by extension its mission. The Office of Community Safety seeks to address community violence with a community-centered model based in restoration and community accountability. This goal is commendable and needed, but domestic violence is not a community safety issue.
The New York City Charter itself, Section 19 — the section which established the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence in the first place — classifies domestic violence as a public health issue, not a community safety issue. The office was created and structured with the clear goal of making a focused and streamlined effort to address domestic violence, coordinated across City agencies. The director was appointed by and answered directly to the mayor to give the office access to quick decision-making and high authority when needed to facilitate intensive cross-disciplinary focus, which Section 19 of the City Charter envisioned.
Every layer of bureaucracy which is added between the office and the mayor lessens the perceived authority of the office and accordingly the ability of the office to work across agency lines. I can personally attest to the success of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence. I have been very familiar with that office through the Family Justice Center. Their dedicated and hard-working staff offers survivors of domestic violence a wide range of counseling and services including legal services. They send people to me to screen, to discuss their cases and give legal advice. They help other legal service providers also coordinate with agencies to better represent their clients.
On my own cases I have seen the ease with which agencies can communicate when facilitated by the Family Justice Center, and when they coordinate, how they can help provide a systemic answer to a devastating problem. I am concerned about anything which could take away that coordination and communication. Efforts to streamline city government and reduce bureaucracy are needed, but the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence represents just such an effort — a successful and long-running one. It already had access to resources and was empowered by the Charter to coordinate with other agencies, and I have personally seen that coordination in action to good effect.
Taking away the office's independence sends the wrong signal to survivors and those who advocate for survivors. The people of New York City voted to amend the City Charter to establish the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence in 2001 so that the City could have an office that would comprehensively address issues of domestic violence. The administration should listen to that mandate and keep the office independent from the Office of Community Safety and let it continue succeeding in its mission. Thank you for your time.
Thank you so much for providing testimony today. I would now like to call on Joann Kim.
Hello, good afternoon. My name is Joann Kim and I am the Assistant Director of Community Engagement of the Korean American Family Service Center, or KAFSC. For 37 years, KAFSC has supported survivors of domestic violence and gender-based violence, particularly immigrant survivors who face language, cultural, economic and immigration-related barriers. Thank you for holding this important hearing and for the opportunity to share a careful perspective on the restructuring of the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence under the Office of Community Safety.
KAFSC sees real value in a more connected approach to community safety. As a culturally specific organization, our work has never existed in just one category. The survivors and families we serve come to us because of domestic violence, but they are also navigating language barriers, immigration concerns, economic insecurity, hate incidents, community safety concerns and fear of engaging with systems that do not understand their cultural or language context. For organizations like KAFSC, bringing this work into a broader community safety framework makes sense. We have deep language capacity and long-standing trust within the communities we serve. We also know that domestic and gender-based violence is closely connected to preventing other forms of violence, addressing hate crimes, strengthening community trust and making sure people know where they can turn before a crisis escalates.
This structure creates an opportunity for greater coordination across these areas while still recognizing the specialized expertise that domestic and gender-based violence work requires. For immigrant communities in particular, trusted culturally specific organizations are often the first point of contact. Survivors may not initially identify what they are experiencing as domestic violence, or they may be hesitant to contact law enforcement or government agencies. They may come to us simply because they need someone who speaks their language and understands their cultural context. That is why we believe this broader community safety model has the potential to strengthen the City's response.
As the new structure continues to develop, we hope culturally specific organizations will remain strong partners in shaping how these systems work on the ground. Our organizations can help bridge the gap between City systems and communities that have historically been harder to reach. We look forward to working with the Office of Community Safety, the Mayor's Office to End Domestic and Gender-Based Violence, the City and our community partners to make this new model successful and to ensure that survivors and families receive coordinated, culturally responsive and accessible support. Thank you.
Thank you so much for testifying today. I do not have any questions for our virtual panel. If there is anyone either virtually or in person that would like to testify, use the raise hand function or come raise your hand here to get an appearance slip. Seeing none, this hearing is adjourned.