2k in New York City Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education · October 7, 2026 · 3hrs 1m Source: https://hearinghearings.nyc/hearings/subcommittee-on-early-childhood-education-2k-in-new-york-city-2026-10-07/ Video: https://councilnyc.viebit.com/vod/?s=true&v=NYCC-250-8-1_261007-130650.mp4 ================================================================ (00:00:18) Thank you. Hello. Good afternoon. Welcome to today's New York City Council hearing of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education. At this time, please silence cell phones. If you wish to speak in today's hearing, please fill out a witness card with one of the sergeants. (00:00:37) Moving forward, no one is to approach the chair. You may begin. (00:05:16) Good afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez, Education Chair, members of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education and other Council Members. My name is Emily List and I am the Executive Director of the Mayor's Office of Child Care and Early Childhood Education. I am joined today by my colleagues from New York City Public Schools. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to testify about the City's new 2K program, a critical component of our vision for universal childcare. Mayor Mamdani ran for office on a vision of universal childcare — a city in which every child under five has access to free, full-day, high-quality early care and education in a range of culturally competent settings, with caregivers and educators who are trained, respected and fairly compensated. On just day eight of this administration, the Mayor stood with the Governor as she committed over $1.2 billion to New York City to put us on a path to universal childcare. Within that $1.2 billion commitment was the funding to launch 2K, the City's first universal early care and education program for two-year-olds. The Governor committed $73 million for the program for the first year, with a goal of serving at least 2,000 children this fall, and $425 million for the second year, with a goal of expanding by 10,000 seats to serve a total of 12,000 children in fall 2027. The Mayor and Governor have made the shared commitment that we will reach every two-year-old in New York City that wants to participate by the end of the Mayor's first term in the fall of 2029. We are committed to delivering 2K to all New Yorkers because of the tremendous benefit it will bring to children, families and educators in our city. Children experience 90% of brain development before age five, and a majority of it in their first few years of life. Providing more children with high-quality early learning opportunities will set them up for a lifetime of academic and social-emotional success. Parents currently spend an average of $26,000 for full-time childcare for a two-year-old. Many families pay even more. For parents, this can make it impossible to stay at a job they love and need to provide for their family, because the math simply does not work. For many, this leads to debt, tough tradeoffs and ultimately the decision to leave New York City. Free 2K will make it easier for families to stay and raise their children here. Because it will be offered in partnership with community-based childcare programs and home-based providers, the program will bring resources to the work our educators and (00:07:31) caregivers are already doing. We have an opportunity, if we roll this program out in the right way, to support early childhood programs and educators as we do. Ultimately, we believe 2K will bring significant economic return to our city, with more parents able to join the workforce, more families able to use their hard-earned resources in our local economy and more households with children able to stay in the city. Despite the good return on investment, we are not doing this just for economic reasons, but more so because we believe that childcare is a right. 2K is our first step toward delivering on that vision. We made the decision to expand 2K geographically so that when we bring 2K to a new area, we can work to meet full demand from the outset. This aligns to our value that care should be universal. In selecting where to place the first 2,000 seats for fall 2026, we looked at a multitude of factors, including economic need among families and areas where lower-income families have less access to free or subsidized care already. We also considered licensed childcare provider capacity. Given the short timeline for implementation, we wanted to ensure that whichever neighborhoods we selected would have the capacity to serve children. Lastly, we considered geography to spread 2K across as many boroughs as possible. The areas we selected for 2K for fall 2026 included School District 6 in Manhattan, which includes Washington Heights, Hamilton Heights and Inwood; School District 10 in the Bronx, which includes Fordham, Belmont, Norwood, North Morris Heights, Van Cortlandt Village and Kingsbridge; Districts 18 and 23 in Brooklyn, which includes Canarsie, Remsen Village, Brownsville and Ocean Hill; and District 27 in Queens, which includes Ozone Park, South Park, Richmond Hill, Woodhaven, Howard Beach and the Rockaways. (00:09:15) While we have not finalized yet where 2K will be offered in fall 2027, we have committed that the 10,000-seat expansion will include School District 31, which encompasses all of Staten Island. (00:09:26) After the first five districts were announced, the team at New York City Public Schools worked tirelessly to bring early care and education providers into the 2K program. 2K is offered in community-based childcare centers and licensed family child care programs. There is no 2K in public school buildings. The 2K sites are inclusive of providers who already contracted with the City to offer 3K and pre-K services, as well as new providers who applied to a request for information and were awarded new contracts to offer 2K. The default model for 2K is full-day, full-year, recognizing that working families need full-time childcare that maps to their schedules. We also recognize that not all families have the same schedules or care needs, and so there are some 2K programs that operate on a school-day, school-year calendar. Families were able to apply for the first 2,002K seats, and we mounted an all-of-government effort to ensure that families knew about how to apply and had the support to do so if needed. The City and community partners were on the ground in communities providing application assistance to families. We advertised in local and ethnic media, leveraged social and new media, posted ads in multiple languages on LinkNYC terminals and in high-traffic small businesses. We hosted a 2K jingle contest with celebrity judges Daddy Yankee and Lin-Manuel Miranda to bring attention to the program, and we ran a 2K for 2K race in Inwood. (00:10:44) We are grateful to the many Council Members who partnered with us on events and helped spread the word to their communities. (00:10:52) In total, we received more than 5,700 applications for the first 2,002K seats. This overwhelming demand demonstrates why we need to move with urgency to continue expanding access to care. We made just over 2,002K offers to families who had applied. The majority of families who received a 2K offer were given an offer to one of their top choices. 99% of families received an offer to a program choice that they had listed on their application. Among applicants who received offers, 82% received an offer to one of their top three choices and 59% received an offer to their top choice. Families who did not receive an offer were automatically placed on waitlists for any programs they applied to and were also encouraged to explore other program options and add themselves to those waitlists as well. We have also seen hundreds of additional families who did not originally apply to 2K add themselves to program waitlists. On September 10, the whole city was watching as our first 2,002-year-olds walked into their classrooms and programs to begin a year of learning, play and growth. There is much to learn from this first cohort of 2K children and providers. We know that we will take valuable lessons from year one and apply them as we continue to expand and strengthen the program. I will now turn it to my colleague and partner, Deputy Chancellor for Early Childhood Education, Eric Philips, who will speak to how 2K is working on the ground and what is next. (00:12:13) Good afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez and Education Chair, and members of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today about New York City Public Schools' implementation of 2K and our work to expand access to high-quality, affordable early care and education for children and families across New York City. Early childhood education is deeply personal to me. I am the daughter and granddaughter of early educators and caregivers, and I have spent more than 20 years working to expand opportunities for young children, support families and strengthen early childhood systems. Before joining New York City Public Schools, I served as the Executive Director of the National Association for Family Child Care, and before that I spent eight years at All Our Kin, working closely with family child care educators here in New York City. I bring those experiences with me to New York City Public Schools, along with the belief that has guided my work throughout my career: expanding access and ensuring quality must go hand in hand. Families need affordable care they can count on. Children deserve environments tailored to the ways that they learn and develop, and our educators and providers need strong support systems behind them. My focus is on building on the work already underway, enhancing the systems and partnerships that will continue to support the growth of 2K while improving our early childhood system more broadly. 2K expands access to affordable childcare while providing young children with nurturing, engaging environments during a critical period of their development. For families, that means greater access to high-quality, affordable care that supports their two-year-olds' learning and development, while giving families care that they can rely on. Two-year-olds learn through play, exploration, relationships and routines that support their development. They build language through books, songs and conversations. They develop early problem-solving skills through hands-on experiences and learn to communicate their needs, build relationships with other children and become increasingly independent. Learning happens throughout the day, including through everyday routines that help children feel secure, build confidence and develop strong relationships with the adults who care for them. New York City's mixed delivery system is central to how we are approaching the expansion of 2K. It allows us to build on the capacity and expertise that already exists across community-based organizations and family child care programs, while offering families meaningful choices in how and where their children receive care. Family child (00:14:52) care is a significant part of our 2K strategy, with approximately 60% of 2K seats offered in home-based settings through our family child care networks. Family child care can offer continuity, close and consistent relationships with caregivers, mixed-age experience and care that is responsive to the needs of both children and families. (00:15:16) I have spent much of my career working with family child care educators in New York City and nationally, and I know both the value they bring to an early childhood system and what it takes to support them. Our family child care networks play an important role in that work, connecting providers with instructional support, coaching, family services and operational assistance, while preserving the strength of home-based care. As we plan for the continued growth, we want to build on the strength of our mixed delivery system and ensure that family child care and our community-based organizations remain a meaningful part of that growth. That means continuing to engage with providers and family child care networks as partners, while ensuring that the additional supporting efforts we engage in reflect the realities of delivering high-quality care in home-based settings. Launching two-K on an accelerated timeline required significant coordination across New York City Public Schools, City agencies and our provider partners. In the months leading up to the start of the school year, teams worked closely with programs to address site and program readiness, enrollment, contracting, budgets and other operational requirements involved in bringing new two-K seats online. We also know that contracting and payment delays created real challenges for some providers as they prepared to begin services. The City took steps to help programs manage those immediate pressures while contracts and payments moved forward, including providing access to interest-free bridge financing through the returnable grant fund. Teams across New York City Public Schools and City government have continued to work to address outstanding contracting and payment issues. We have made significant progress and we will continue to prioritize those efforts until all two-K contracts have been registered. We are also focused on supporting strong and consistent implementation across the mixed delivery system. Our teams are in close contact with our programs and our family child care networks, providing ongoing support and responding quickly when financial, operational or programmatic needs arise. That close engagement allows us to identify challenges early, connect programs to the support that they need and coordinate across New York City Public Schools and City agencies when issues require a broader response. As we support implementation this year, we are also preparing for the next phase. The program launched this fall with 2,000 seats across five school districts and will grow to serve 12,000 children across all five boroughs in fall of 2027. Expansion at this scale requires the capacity and infrastructure to support it. That means improving how we enroll and connect families to programs, how we support providers and educators and how we manage critical operational functions such as contracting, procurement and payments. Some of this work is specific to two-K. Much of this is about strengthening the systems that support early childhood programs more broadly. To support that work, New York City Public Schools is hiring an additional 200 employees across early childhood and other agency offices. Many of the systems our programs depend on go beyond the division, and building this capacity will allow us to deepen our coordination, address longstanding operational challenges and better support a growing early childhood system. As we prepare for continued expansion, we need to make sure the systems behind the program grow along with it. We are not only preparing to serve more children. We are building the capacity to connect families to those opportunities and support quality consistently across a much larger system. That work is closely connected to provider sustainability. Our ability to expand depends on a strong network of community-based organizations and family child care programs that can continue to deliver high-quality care for children and families. The challenges with contracting and payments this year reinforced the importance of improving systems that providers rely on. Timely and predictable funding is critical. But so are clear communication, early planning, consistent guidance and operational processes that providers can navigate effectively. We know there is work to do in these areas and these efforts will be an important part of enhancing our early childhood system as we continue to grow. Partnerships with providers will be critical as we move forward. They bring deep knowledge of the children and families they serve and have firsthand experience with how our policies and processes operate in practice. I have begun visiting programs and speaking directly with providers, and that engagement will be an important part of my work as we continue to strengthen our early childhood system. As we expand, we also need to be thoughtful about where new capacity is needed and how it fits within the early childhood landscape already serving families across the City. Continued growth should broaden access for families while strengthening a strong and sustainable provider network that will undergird the early childhood system as a whole. The launch of two-K represents a significant expansion of early care and education in New York City, and it is an important step towards the City's broader vision for universal child care. As we grow from 2,000 seats this year to 12,000 next fall, our responsibility is to ensure that expansion is matched by the quality, capacity, trusting relationships and infrastructure needed to support it. For families, that means access to high-quality, affordable care that they can count on. For providers, it means stronger and more reliable systems that allow them to focus on serving children and families. For New York City Public Schools, it means continuing to strengthen how we support a large and diverse early childhood system while maintaining a clear focus on quality and children's needs. As we continue this work, I am excited about what two-K can mean for New York City's children and families, and I am deeply committed to ensuring that we build the systems and partnerships needed to deliver on that promise. I look forward to working with our providers, families, City partners and the Council as we prepare for the next phase of expansion. Thank you for the opportunity to testify and I look forward to answering your questions. (00:21:51) Thank you both. Good to see you all. A few of us were celebrating the Mayor's announcement on child care. I want to just start by kind of setting the scene. A few months ago, when you all started with the application process, you mentioned 5,700 — you all received 5,700... (00:22:18) Applications — how many of these applications came after the main round? (00:22:25) All 5,700 applications were received in the month when applications were open, and that is the pool of families from whom we made offers. We have seen hundreds of families in addition to those 5,700 add themselves to wait lists since then, and we will have a rolling waitlist process for two-K so that as seats become available during the year — we know that with our youngest kids that can often be mobility as families are making other changes in their lives — we will continue to fill two-K seats if they become available. And you all continue to also receive applications from families, even if they are not from the designated... (00:23:06) Neighborhoods — correct. So among the 5,700 applications, we received them from every corner of the City. The families who live in the five districts had priority for the program, but the overwhelming interest we saw is really just representative again of how significant the demand is for a program like this and why we are committed to expanding with such urgency. Can you share what was the distribution of applications by neighborhood, including applications after the main round? We do not have the by-neighborhood breakdown today. I am happy to share that data with the Council in the future, but again we did see applications from every part of the City. (00:23:43) Okay. Did you find any correlation between two-K applications and the amount of three-K applications submitted in the same school district? (00:23:52) I think we are still looking at some of those patterns, and certainly what we see from year one will inform how we think about what demand might look like in year two. In general, when we look across all of our early childhood programs, our highest application rates are among four-year-olds for pre-K, followed by three-K, followed by two-K, which generally maps to what we understand about families' preferences for formal child care. We also know that this was just the first year of two-K and so there is more work to do in future years to continue building awareness. That is something we saw with the historic rollout of three-K — that over time applications grew as more and more families both learned about the program and gained comfort with it. (00:24:33) Thank you. How many students are currently enrolled in two-K seats for the 2026-2027 school year? (00:24:39) At this moment we have over 2,000 children in our two-K program. We will release preliminary two-K enrollment data alongside our broader enrollment reporting when we release three-K through 12 enrollment data. (00:24:54) And can you share how many two-K students you expect to be enrolled by the end of the calendar year? Because kids turn two throughout the year, so they are not all enrolled at once. But do you have a sense of how many you anticipate to be enrolled by... (00:25:08) The end of the year? Our goal has always been to serve at least 2,000 children this year, and again we will have the data available by the end of the year. For children who are not yet two, I will note that families who applied and received an offer were able to enroll as long as their child is turning two in 2026. For center-based care, families have to wait until their child's second birthday to start. That is because of the health code — they have to be 24 months to be in that class — and so those children were given a delayed start date. So if your birthday was November 15, you can start services immediately thereafter. Children can start services in family child care settings prior to turning two, so for children with fourth-quarter birthdays who received an offer to a family child care setting, they could begin even prior to their second birthday. (00:26:00) How many emergent multilingual children are enrolled in... (00:26:04) That is not data we have yet, again as we do not yet have enrollment data finalized, but that will be among the many things we look at to understand who is participating in two-K. And I think you have heard this at... (00:26:15) Our hearing last week. But can you just remind us what are the languages available for instruction at the two-K sites? (00:26:25) We do not have any formal dual language programs, particularly among our home-based providers. There are many educators serving in two-K programs who serve in a language other than English. I am particularly thinking about neighborhoods like Washington Heights — we know there are many Spanish-speaking providers there — and in other communities, reflecting the languages that families in those communities speak. So that is something during the process when families were exploring programs: they were able to connect with providers and understand what their options might be. Thank you. (00:26:59) Curious on the priority taken for families — you mentioned obviously kids that lived in those five districts had a priority. Was there any other level of priority, if they had... (00:27:12) Siblings that already attended the center or the space, or any other? Yes. So among the children who applied to two-K, similar to our other enrollment processes, families could list many programs on their application. Then for each individual program, families are sorted into priority groups based on whether they are a continuing student in that program — so if they had been attending day care at that site previously — if they have an older sibling enrolled in the program and if they live in the district. So we worked through those different priority structures and all of that was made publicly available to families so that they could understand whether they fit into one of those priority categories for a specific program. (00:27:57) Thank you. Do you have data... just two questions. Curious — in the same way that we ask about parents' first choice, can you share what percent of families received their first choice of a two-K program? So 59% of families... (00:28:10) Received their top, number one choice. 83% received one of their top three choices and 99% of families received a program that was somewhere on their application. Okay. (00:28:24) How many two-K seats are extended day and how many are school... (00:28:29) Day? The majority of our two-K seats are extended day and year, and we will have those final numbers when we have our enrollment figures. (00:28:37) Okay. I am going to ask a few more questions and I know we have a number of colleagues with questions, so then I will come back. I wanted to ask a little bit about the budget. Can you share the total budget for two-K in fiscal year 2027? (00:28:57) Not including the smaller... the birthday... (00:29:00) Okay. The total budget for fiscal year 2027 is $73 million. (00:29:10) That is the total, and that is the exact amount that has been allocated for the current program. Yes. (00:29:14) Is that for fiscal year 2027 or 2028? (00:29:16) That $73 million is for this fiscal year, which also obviously maps to this school year. That is the funding we received from the State to support the year one two-K launch. Okay. (00:29:31) And we are projecting that... (00:29:33) Two-K for the 2027-2028 school year, fiscal year 2028, that budget will grow to $425 million, which has similarly been committed by the Governor. And that is with the proposed expansion of seats included. (00:29:51) Yes, the $425 million will... (00:29:53) Allow us to serve 12,000 children next year. So our 2,000 two-K seats that we will have continuity on and an additional 10,000 seats that we plan to expand to next year. (00:30:05) Okay. Do you all anticipate needing additional funding for this current fiscal year to... (00:30:12) Fulfill... to keep the program? We anticipate that we will fully... (00:30:17) Expend all of the funds for... (00:30:19) The budget — the $73 million — for the current year. (00:30:22) Okay, so there is no anticipated increase in the plan for the current year. No. Okay. Can you quickly — and then I will pass it to my colleagues — can you share a little bit about how you all determine the cost for each provider, essentially how you were able to distribute those dollars? (00:30:34) Yes, absolutely. And so... (00:30:45) Every provider receives essentially a cost per child times the number of children who are in their program. The two-K funding structure — those cost-per-child amounts — were developed based on an analysis of program operating costs, our existing early childhood program models, staffing requirements, program hours, facility costs and administrative costs. We also looked at how two-K compares to... (00:30:47) Three-K and pre-K in terms of the structural funding costs. So, for example, a two-K classroom is smaller in terms of the number of children than a three-K or pre-K classroom, in order to maintain healthy and safe ratios, and so therefore the cost per child is higher because your fixed costs of staff and facilities are the same. We offered this year two flat rates to providers. There are four of them. There is a rate for center-based providers offering an extended day and year program, a rate for center-based providers offering a school day and year program, a rate for family child care providers and a fourth rate for family child care providers offering a school day and year program. We also did allow providers who have demonstrably higher rent or significant other fixed costs that exceed that flat rate to bring that, with evidence, to New York City Public Schools. Overall, this funding structure is really intended to support providers, strengthen the early childhood program across the City and allow us to expand in a sustainable way. Thank you. (00:31:09) And the flat rates — it sounds like they are broken up into kind of four categories, and then depending on, like, the cost of rent, for example. Are the flat rates based on — what is the determining factor besides the per-student amount? Is there anything else? Like, is it a different flat rate for a provider in Inwood doing extended day in her home versus someone in the Bronx doing extended day? There... (00:32:13) Is no variation by geography. The extended day and year rate is higher than the school day and year rate, reflecting that those programs offer 10 hours a day, 260 days a year, versus our school day and year programs which are 180 days, six hours and 20 minutes. Okay. (00:32:37) And then how are those rates communicated to the providers? Do they feel like this is fair compensation? Can you share a little about that? (00:32:54) .AND THEN THE KIND OF HOW, WHERE ARE THOSE RATES COMMUNICATED TO THE TO THE PROVIDERS, I GUESS DO THEY FEEL LIKE THIS IS FAIR COMPENSATION. I'M WHAT? CAN YOU? SURE ABOUT THOSE LIKE THAT (00:33:04) So at the time that providers — so for existing providers who already contracted with the City for 3-K and Pre-K, they were able to express interest in offering 2-K through a survey where they demonstrated that they had the capacity to add two-year-olds to their program. New providers who did not previously contract with the City completed a request for information and went through multiple phases to demonstrate their readiness to offer 2-K. And then at the time that the City was ready to move forward with providers, they communicated the number of seats that that provider would be awarded based on their capacity and demand in their area, and then the rate that the City was offering for those seats. The team at New York City Public Schools has worked with providers to complete their detailed budgets, make sure that they have costs allocated in all the right places, and that is an area where the team continues to work closely with providers and make sure that they have what they need to be able to invoice for services over the course of the year. Before I pass it over to CM Brewer, can you share what the flat rate for home-based for extended day and school day are? I do not have the rates right in front of me, but we will get those to you. (00:34:12) Okay, all right. I look forward to that. All right, next up is CM Gale Brewer, followed by CM Riley and then CM Joseph. (00:34:18) Council members, just — well, so thank... (00:34:19) You very much. First of all, emails — I was very impressed. I do not know you, but all of a sudden I think she answers emails at all hours of the day and night. I like that. I went recently to something in East Harlem. I happened to just pop in — I am known for showing up everywhere. I did not know what the event was. It said something about child care. It was phenomenal. It was Robin Hood paying for an unbelievable development for providers. So my question is, are some of these individuals who are providing part of that program? It was phenomenal. So I just was wondering that. My question is, what are your goals for the development of this program? You have got early language about literacy, school readiness — so how are you going to know if you are achieving these goals? Obviously, with training like that it would help a lot. So I am wondering about the training for the teachers and Robin Hood in particular. (00:35:23) Thank you for that question and for witnessing that. Yes, we are working on a lot of different professional development for our teachers and for our staff within the division, for our educational leaders, as we are expanding into 2-K caring for and serving toddlers. It is a skill set that we want to make sure that all of our educators have. So we have worked with Robin Hood. We have a new partnership with Bank Street, which might have been that event that you went to — they are awesome, right? They are providing professional development on social-emotional learning. Coaches are working directly with our educators. In terms of the assessment and how we are looking at this, we are using an authentic assessment tool called Teaching Strategies Gold and we will be using that to assess how that classroom is being run and the type of experiences that the young children are receiving. (00:36:33) So the ones who are working now with two-year-olds in those districts — they already, as teachers, have had some kind of training that would mirror what I saw, or not? (00:36:44) Yes, like who they picked, maybe because they had the training. Absolutely, absolutely yes. So there are qualifications, including experience working with young children, for all of the staff. And we know that there are a lot more opportunities and places where we can provide support, particularly around working with children who might have developmental delays and supporting family engagement. So it is a bit of both. (00:37:10) Okay, and then one more question — the Chair asked about it also, but when you are in 2-K, can you get into the same program with 3-K? How does that work? And then, you know, will the next round have public school spaces or will it still continue to be the nonprofits? (00:37:26) So children who are attending 2-K — if that program also offers 3-K, then yes, they would receive a continuing student priority to stay at... (00:37:35) That program. Or if not, many have that — or are they supposed to have to reapply somewhere else? We do not know yet. (00:37:41) We have not yet confirmed all of the different programming and seats that everyone will be offering for next year, but certainly that is something we will look at. Continuity of care is an important value we know for families and for providers, and we will be looking at that as we work with programs to confirm capacity for next year. Our intention for the long foreseeable future is that 2-K will be offered only in community-based settings and family child care homes. We are not looking to place in public school spaces. And one more... (00:38:10) Question — where are those 200 people going to go? The ones you mentioned. It is a great question. So for the... (00:38:17) Additional staff, that includes many of our field staff who are working directly with the child care... (00:38:24) Care programs — they have started, or they are going to something? (00:38:26) Yes, some have started. So we have additional staff and we are continuing to actively recruit and hire for those positions. But we have our instructional coaches, our social workers, our inclusion specialists. Additionally, on the contracting and payment side we are bringing in additional analysts so that we can facilitate these payments going through in a faster... (00:38:50) Manner. Last question — the 225. Does that include... (00:38:54) Just state money, or next year do you need City... (00:38:55) Money? You mentioned this year it is just state — the 420 million is just the state... (00:39:01) Money, and that is the funding for us to operationalize the program. So that is the per-child cost to run the program. The cost that the City has incurred and will continue to support — for example, the 228 staff we are bringing on — those were funded through the preliminary and executive budget last year. So the City is making investments to make sure we have the infrastructure to support the program, and then the program itself is fully funded by those state dollars. Thank you. (00:39:33) Great. Next we have — did I skip someone? Oh no. CM Riley and then CM Santosuosso and then CM Joseph. (00:39:40) Thank you, Chair. Thank you so much for testifying, and as a dad I am really, really excited about this program. I think within our office we get a lot of families that are looking for child care providers. Child care is causing a lot of unintentional consequences for families who are trying to take care of their families and stay in an affordable New York. So with that being said, I just want to ask questions. You mentioned 200 additional employees to support the expansion — can you name how many of those positions are specifically dedicated to the 2-K program and how many are dedicated to contracting and procurement or even provider payments? Great. (00:40:27) The breakdown — so we are looking at across all of those areas. We have more positions that are on the instructional side: the instructional coaches, the social workers, inclusion specialists, and a relatively smaller proportion but still a significant investment in our operations and our finance staff. Okay, do... (00:40:51) We currently have enough qualified family child care providers and community-based organizations to support an expansion from 2,000 to 12,000? (00:41:01) So we are working with our family child care networks and working with them to figure out what providers are in their network and what their ability is to expand to care for more children. Those are active conversations we are having, and as we have more details in terms of where the seats will be needed and what the family needs are, we do feel confident that in the community there are providers and seats that we are able to accommodate the expansion. (00:41:30) Okay. Proposing going from 2,000 seats to 12,000 seats for fiscal year 2027 — what gives you the confidence that the systems currently experiencing contracting and payment challenges will be able to successfully handle a six-fold increase in enrollment? (00:41:49) I am happy to start and then I will pass to my colleague. I think some of the payment and contracting delays that we saw this year — as the Mayor has said publicly — are unacceptable and do not represent the way that we as a City believe that we should be working hand in hand with our providers. So our focus over the last couple of months has been both to ensure that every provider had what they needed, that we were working quickly to register contracts and issue interest-free loans for providers who needed funding in the interim, and at the same time we are building new systems, rebuilding the sort of human capital and systems infrastructure to support this growth. The administration has committed to significant procurement reform, increased transparency for providers and increased timeliness in the processing. Many of the staff that Deputy Chancellor Phillips has referenced who are coming on board will allow us to ensure more timely contracting and payment actions. And so with all of that and... (00:42:46) The administration's laser focus on expanding — but expanding in a way that supports providers — we do feel confident about reaching the 12,000 seats. Okay, and lastly, the transition from in-home care to in-school care can be a little bit challenging for parents. I can attest — my son just went through that transition and every time she is dropping him off... So can you just explain the thought process in not having 2-K inside of a traditional school setting, just for the record? (00:43:26) And so when we look at where families with two-year-olds often choose to send their children for care, where we see the environments that educators are trained and ready to welcome toddlers — those are our community-based centers and our family child care programs. Those are spaces that environmentally are right for two-year-olds, where we have educators who have been working with toddlers for years and years and have gone through the training and experience to be able to serve them well. So we have really focused on expanding 2-K in those settings because that is where toddlers in New York City are cared for today. What we are doing essentially is saying, rather than families paying out of pocket for that care, the City is stepping in to cover the cost of care. But we want to honor the expertise in those early childhood settings. (00:44:14) She said the state is covering it now. I would just add that as we are approaching the end of the year we will be very intentional about having either Pre-K or kindergarten information sessions so that families are able to get exposure to what the new program looks like. We are working very closely with our school-based colleagues to really support... (00:44:36) The transition. Yeah, I think that is a great idea — just having some form of a blueprint for a parent so that after the child has been in the home care provider system, transitioning them into a traditional school setting will be extremely helpful. Great work. I am looking forward to this expansion. Thank you. Thank you. (00:44:54) CM Riley. Okay, thank you for your questions. Next up we have CM Santosuosso, CM Joseph and CM Felder. (00:45:05) CM Santosuosso. So I am 2-K's future number one fan, hopefully. Thank you both for your testimony and for your work. I hope I have quick questions. First, for future 2-K seats — so starting next year and beyond, is the plan still full day, full year? (00:45:24) Our plan is to continue with full day, full year as the default model, but with the option for providers, based on their community need, to opt into a school day, school year program if that better fits their community. (00:45:33) I am sorry if you said this and I did not write it down — what percentage was full day, full year, and what percentage was school day? The majority are full day, full year. We will have those final figures. Okay, I did not catch that. I am sorry about that. Let me ask — is... (00:45:47) The plan to make it available to all two-year-olds in the years after next year? Or rather, how many two-year-olds do you anticipate... (00:45:57) Not this coming next year — we have stated the 12,000 for next year, with the goal of by 2029 having access for all two-year-olds. We are in the process of studying the specific targets. Okay. When will you announce the... (00:46:14) Neighborhoods for next year? Very soon. We are working towards finalizing that information because we know that families and providers are eager to be able to plan, and we will of course brief the Council Subcommittee before that information is... (00:46:28) Public. That was not a selfish question, by the way. She will not be eligible until the following year, so it is — you know, I am just saying it is not just me. You mentioned... (00:46:38) You mentioned that there was a wait list, I believe. So how are you going to roll the wait list into next year's applications? What is the plan there? So families who applied to 2-K were added to the wait list under a few different circumstances. There are program-specific wait lists, similar to 3-K and Pre-K. So if you are a family who applied and you got your fourth choice on your application, you were automatically placed on the wait list for your first, second and third choices. If you applied to 2-K and you did not get an offer at all, unfortunately you were... (00:47:11) Wait-listed for every program you applied to. Additionally, families who subsequently expressed interest in 2-K can do so by adding themselves to program wait lists. Those wait lists will remain open year-round, so as a program has a vacancy they go to that wait list and they can call through families in the order they are on the wait list to offer them a spot. For next year, the children who were eligible for 2-K this year will all be eligible for 3-K next year, and 3-K is a full universal program. We can accommodate all children who apply, so all of those families will be able to get a 3-K seat next... (00:47:51) Year. Okay. I am curious about the size of the providers that were contracted this year. Do you have data around how many are single-location providers versus a larger provider that might have multiple locations? (00:48:07) I do not know that we have that data yet available, but we do have a really diverse mix of providers. We have, as you heard, many, many home-based providers who are serving just a couple of 2-K children alongside their other mixed-age enrollments. Then we have single-site providers, independent organizations who are serving a classroom or two of 2-K. And then we do have larger providers who have multiple locations across the City who are serving 2-K children in the locations within the districts. (00:48:34) Okay, and so do you have the data around how many had existing contracts with the City versus... (00:48:42) Brand new providers via the 2-K program? The majority of providers were previously working with the City to offer 3-K and Pre-K, and we did see a smaller number of providers who came through the 2-K program as newly contracted with the City. (00:48:53) Okay, I would love to see data as far as how many seats were in multiple-network providers, home-based, center-based, et cetera, as a breakdown when possible. But I know you said November for... (00:49:07) That, right? Yes, that is going to have preliminary enrollment data to... (00:49:09) Share. Okay. Can you speak to the decision this year to not include Staten Island? We were obviously limited with only 2,000 seats as to where we could go. When selecting districts, our goal was to be able to serve as many children as possible in each of those districts so that we could really fully meet demand. With Staten Island being one school district for the entire borough and with our relatively limited timeline to roll out 2-K this year, we wanted to make sure that we had sufficient provider readiness and felt we needed more time to be able to roll out to Staten Island in a way where we could really serve all families. We also saw this year that we had continued unmet 3-K demand on Staten Island, and that had been a real persistent challenge for families in certain parts of the island. So in addition to our 2-K expansion for this fall, we also added more than 2,000 new 3-K seats across certain priority zip codes, which included significant parts of Staten Island. With that additional capacity, we are more ready for next year there. I just have one more question and then I will get out of your hair. Okay, I guess when we are talking about additional staff — and I do not know if you share this perspective — it does feel like some of the payments and the permitting get held up at agencies that are not, for instance, within this division. So I am wondering if there is a plan moving forward to not only boost the capacity to process these payments and administer these contracts effectively, but also within the organizations that are part of the permitting process. (00:50:46) Yes. So a big part of the function of my office, the Mayor's Office of Child Care, is to make sure that we are coordinating across all of the different agencies that touch child care so that we can ensure a more seamless experience for providers. So a big part of our focus this year has been on just enhancing that coordination and making processes easier for providers, including with the launch of our permitting portal earlier this year, which we had the chance to demo for the subcommittee. We did meet with the Department of Health and made sure they had sufficient capacity to inspect sites and complete background checks for staff. We had a relatively small number of programs coming into two-K that had new permits this year, just because, given the short timeline, we primarily focused on bringing in providers who were already permitted to serve two-year-olds. As we expand further, we do anticipate bringing in programs that are opening for the first time or doing some sort of permanent amendment to add two-K capacity, and so we will be closely monitoring the Department of Health capacity as well as our other agency partners. (00:51:50) I only say it because I had to. They were not two-K programs. Obviously they were preschools, but I had two preschools that were completely held up by the Department of Health with re-permitting and reinspection issues, and ultimately they could not get their payments because they were not cleared. I felt that the department was doing what they could, but was really lagging behind, and as we talk about an expansion, I just feel like that is... (00:52:15) Probably going to happen over and over again if it is not addressed. (00:52:17) Yes, and I think for us it is both a matter of ensuring the agencies have sufficient capacity and ensuring that the agencies are properly coordinating, which is work that we have been doing over the past couple of months and we will start even earlier next year ahead of the launch of school, given that we will have many new seats coming online. Understood. Thank you both. Thanks for your work. (00:52:38) Thank you, Council Member. Next we have a Council Member, followed by CM Felder. Thank you. (00:52:46) Chair, thank you both for your testimony. I have a couple of questions around workforce. Workforce must double for universal child care. How is the administration approaching workforce development and... (00:53:00) Expansion. So first we must recognize there is no universal child care without the child care workforce, and this has to be an area of focus for us as we grow access to care in the City. So we will be taking a multi-pronged approach, looking at ways to bring new people into the early childhood field, working with our partners in higher education to make it easier for folks who want to be in early childhood to get the necessary training and credentials, and then supporting our incumbent educators who may be interested in going back to school or gaining the skills and credentials to move from an assistant teacher to a lead teacher, or just to be able to build their practice. Last week, the administration announced, along with CUNY, an expansion of early childhood apprenticeship programs, which is one of many strategies we will need to take in order to grow the workforce. (00:53:50) Now we are going to talk about the real thing, right? What are the plans to address pay inequities between home-based educators? We want to expand the workforce — that is beautiful. We want to sustain that workforce — that is great. But how do you keep folks working in this City when we talk about affordability? Ah, yes, absolutely. And... (00:54:11) We know this is a big priority for us. We know that wage equity is something we must address in the early childhood sector in order to support our early childhood educators and ensure they can raise their families and live and thrive here in the City. We have seen these inequities in place for many, many decades, so this is not a new problem, but it is a problem we know we must address head on. I know we have discussed this with you as a subcommittee and it is something we will be actively working to address, and we... (00:54:39) Want to be a partner in that work, right? We want to be a partner in how we stabilize that workforce and allow folks to work here. (00:54:47) My next question... (00:54:51) Chair touched on it. How are you coordinating with students who have special needs in the two-K program? You know, early intervention — because that falls on you wherever the gap of service does not happen, it falls on you. So where are we? How many providers do you have in related services? How are you letting parents know? And if a child does not come in with that, I asked: are you also helping parents get them services? (00:55:22) That is a great question, and we were prepared for the expansion. That was a place where the team spent a considerable amount of time, because it is different for two-year-olds than it is for how we support three-year-olds and their families. So every program received training in how to provide resources and referrals to families who might be experiencing some questions or wanting to look at their child's development. We made sure that we worked with the Department of Health — and that is another partnership that we have to have with them — to make sure that all of our programs understood what that process would be and how they can support a child who might be receiving early intervention services or who might be a candidate for that. We have inclusion specialists who are certified special education teachers who go out to all of the programs and are available to push in to provide consultation to teachers and programs who want support with families. In terms of the specific information that is confidential between the family and the early intervention providers, we are letting them know that our team is there to provide support if they have any families who are saying that they need that. So far this year, it is very early. We have not received any requests for specific children, but it was training and information that we really front-loaded as we went into the... (00:57:00) Year. And parents know that this is available to them, because the system is not seamless. It is... (00:57:07) Usually when we pass them off from early intervention, there is a dark hole sometimes. Our children — nearly 12,000 students at home — did not have a seat. So we need to clear that backlog and that waitlist for students. Is there a system in place for school-based when you do the health forms? You know, the health form when you go into a regular public school — is that available to providers as well, also to capture that language data that Chair was talking about? (00:57:40) So we do conduct family surveys where we are asking for their home language and other information that the program would need in order to best meet the needs of their children, and that is information that we will be collecting as we go through our enrollment process. And you will be able to have captured that data and share it with the committee. Chair, I have — go for it. Thank you. (00:58:03) What role is early childhood teacher education programs playing in the workforce or the credential pathways, tuition support, apprenticeships for current assistants who want to become lead teachers? You talked about that briefly. But what does that partnership really look like? As I am the Chair of the Higher Education Committee, I have not seen any of you come before me and ask how we can partner with the Council to make this... (00:58:24) Happen? Yes, we are in very active conversation with many parts of CUNY, with the CUNY Professional Development Institute, with individual campuses that have early childhood programs, and looking at different models they already offer. We are looking at how we can make those more affordable — we know that fees can often be an issue for prospective students. We are looking at ways we can offer coursework at different times of day, in different languages, in ways that better meet the needs of the prospective and current early childhood workforce. We have already made a commitment to expand apprenticeships and we will continue to look at that. So I think this is something where in the coming months, over the course of this next budget season, you will hear from... (00:59:06) Us. But we did put $2.5 million into that pot to make sure that this is happening, so we would love to further that. Are student parents included in the two-K outreach? Because sometimes child care is a barrier to why some mothers do not go back to college or higher education. Yes, and the City does partner with many of the CUNY child care programs to offer three-K and two-K, so that was a population that we absolutely worked with when we were doing outreach in the months when applications were open. We did work with CUNY to get the word out to their students about the availability of two-K in the community. Thank you. And two-K for students in shelters and students in foster care — talk to me about that. (00:59:52) And so those are areas where we again, during our outreach in the months when applications were open, partnered with our agency partners who work closely with children in shelter and children in foster care to make sure that they knew about two-K. This is an area where we can always do more, and so it is going to be a focus for us as we continue to expand, building out those partnerships with shelter providers and others so that these children are finding their way to two-K programs. Thank you. (01:00:20) Thank you. Thank you, Chair. CM Felder is up next. Thank you. It is going to be quick. I do not have a question for you here, but I wanted to second CM Brewer's statement about sending emails and getting responses. Any questions that I have had have been answered, and that is wonderful. I just wanted to say that the last time I can remember that there was any form of communication — it does not mean that we get what we want all the time, but that somebody is going to answer, even if somebody says no. That is also appreciated. The last time I can remember it was during the Bloomberg administration, and that was a story. I mean, we just could not get an answer. So I am delighted and really appreciate it very, very much. We should not have to appreciate getting an answer, but it is really a wonderful change and I look forward to continued communication. Thank you. (01:01:50) And we thank you for your partnership as well. (01:01:52) Also, I just want to make sure I recognize on the record Council Member... I called on her but I did not recognize her. My apologies. Hello. (01:01:59) Can I just ask you to clarify on the students living in temporary housing? I know that CM Joseph had raised that question. Do you have a sense of how many of the children enrolled in the two-K program are in temporary housing right now? Similarly, that will be data that we will be able to share when we share enrollment numbers with the other grades. (01:02:26) Okay. And then I... (01:02:27) Guess, are you all thinking about transportation challenges for any of these families? Is there a thought or a conversation around MetroCards for families in two-K? (01:02:39) Obviously, yes, but also for three-K and pre-K as well for access. So if a child has a special reason for transportation, then we are working very closely with our transportation division to make sure that the child and the family are getting the resources that they need. I know that we have been prioritizing families who are unhoused and making sure that they are receiving the support that they need from a transportation perspective. (01:03:15) Thank you. And is there information available for families about their ability to access the transportation team? How readily available and how easy... (01:03:23) Is that for families who are for the first time going through the MySchools process and who have this need but are not really sure how to navigate or where to put this information? We do try to make sure that that information is available in multiple languages that families speak. Additionally, we are in communication with the programs to make sure that they also can answer the questions, because they are often the first point of contact the family will go to. So the information is available and, especially as this expansion is happening, we are looking for ways that we can make sure that information is even clearer. (01:04:04) Thank you. Back on the provider designation — were there any providers that were initially offered a contract and then are not currently contracted? There are some providers who initially expressed interest in two-K and then subsequently decided not to participate, often because of their own planning for the year and whether they had changed their minds essentially about whether their offering was the right thing for them this year. I will acknowledge it was a really short turnaround time, given that we announced and began working with providers in the spring, and so for some providers that was just too quick a turnaround time to be able to be ready to offer two-K this fall, and we hope to come back to many of those folks in the future. Thank you. Okay. During the initial round of offers — just offers, not enrollment to families — for two-K, I believe we sent out a little over 2,100 offers to families. (01:05:10) Can you speak to... is it the Council's understanding that beyond the 2,000-and-some offers that were sent out in the first round, there are additional two-K seats for the current school year? Can you all speak to those additional two-K seats? (01:05:23) There were 2,018 offers made on offer day, and we have continued to add two-K seats, particularly among family child care providers who were still in the process of affiliating with a network and so had not yet come in by the time the application launched. We will have those final seat count numbers as part of the enrollment reporting later this fall. Okay. And so those additional seats... (01:05:47) Because I think for the longest time we have been hearing, when the application process started, that there were 2,000 two-K seats for two-K, right. These are additional seats. The $73 million that we discussed at the top — did those cover those additional seats? (01:06:00) There were no additional dollars needed for these additional seats. So there were no additional dollars needed, but the slight nuance is that we, in addition to the seats that we added for two-K, had previously existing capacity for toddlers in some of these communities — seats that had been means-tested, that had been paid for by the child care block grant, or seats that had been previously funded by our Head Start grant and had been converted to City transitional dollars as part of expanding two-K. We looked at the existing two-year-old capacity that the City already had contracted in these districts and converted those from having been means-tested to now being fully free as well, and so that is how we have ended up with just above 2,000 seats. The 2,000 that we had committed to is what we were able to create newly with the $73 million. (01:06:47) So the budget was still... yeah, no budget change. Okay. I had a question about how... (01:06:55) Providers were able to enroll. I know in earlier iterations of child care programs, providers were able to enroll on site. Can you all speak to the decision for a centralized enrollment and application process for two-K? So the centralized application process, which we have had in place for three-K and pre-K for many, many years, is something that we value because it allows families to apply to all their programs in one place as opposed to families having to navigate multiple different processes. It is also a mechanism for providers to be able to access perhaps a larger pool of students, because families who may not have known about them are able to find them through the application process. Given that that is the system we have in place for three-K and pre-K, we built the two-K application on top of that into the same MySchools interface. We are continuing to look at how families, particularly for their youngest children, interact with this system and how it works for providers and where there may be systemic challenges we need to address in the future, knowing that families are used to different kinds of processes for a two-year-old versus a kindergartner. So it is something we will continue to look at to make sure that families and providers are supported through the process. But we do believe that a centralized enrollment system is a mechanism for us to be able to meet the maximum amount of family need and to support all providers in finding and accessing enrollment. I have heard from a lot of... (01:08:21) Providers and some parents who like being able to walk in and apply on site. I know that there is debate on what constitutes applying on site using the site. I think we are clear that when providers are saying that, they mean that they have the ability to do the application process and select. But there has been a good amount of advocacy for on-site enrollment. Is that something that you are all... (01:08:45) Potential, like looking up for the continued expansion of universal... I think there is a lot of merit to a lot of these providers being able to register and to do the application process for folks on site. As you said, obviously, families, if they walk into a program, the program can absolutely help them complete the application. We see that as a really strong way for families to be able to get the support they need. And to your question about on-site enrollment, I think there are many, many sort of points during this year where we will be gathering feedback from providers and families about how the system is working for them, and we want to make sure that family and provider input certainly informs our future decision making. So we will continue to gather that feedback about how the enrollment process is and is not working. Were there any known challenges in the application or the enrollment selection, like in the enrollment process, that you heard from providers? I think, you know, we continue to see families who express interest in 2K after the application process is closed, which is where our wait lists come in. And we made a different decision for 2K than for our older grades as it pertains to wait lists. So for 3K, pre-K and kindergarten, the waitlist process is only open in September. For 2K, we are keeping the waitlist open year-round to support the fact that enrollment looks different for two-year-olds. Okay. And then I... (01:10:05) I just wanted to ask a data question on the additional 2K seats, because you mentioned that you somehow need to transition because of the block grants, for example. Do you have those numbers of how many of the additional seats were from some of these programs? (01:10:26) And we will have the final seat count numbers when we have the enrollment data ready to report. (01:10:31) Okay, so just to be clear, I am asking for the additional seats. How many of them were from formerly means-tested, now converted to universal? (01:10:38) Okay, yes, and that data we will be able to provide once we have the final enrollment counts. Okay. Next I want... (01:10:47) To ask... This is kind of a big one and we spent some time on it in the past. I think a little bit of it CM Felder had raised the concern that I have had and shared with the City about expanding a program. Right now the 2K 2,000 seats, as I am clear, are both home-based and center-based, but only for network providers, right. So that is... I am Jennifer and I am Kayla's network. Right, that is exclusively how the system is working today. We have a good population of providers who are running their own business that I think, based on feedback, have had mixed experiences with networks. Either they have called networks up themselves saying they are interested and networks have said we cannot take on a new provider, or they made the determination that it just does not work for their model. Some networks charge them, right, and then some providers like the flexibility. And I truly do not think that we can get to a universal system, or let alone a 2K expansion system, if we are not including those providers. They are in boroughs like Brooklyn and Queens. We depend on those in areas where there are legitimate deserts. We depend on these providers. How are you all looking at these providers, these individual businesses, and including them in this, too, in the universal process? I just do not think that there is a universal, successful system without these providers. (01:12:22) Right. So, you know, the first thing is the importance of family child care to the system and that we have to bring our family child care providers along with us. And I do just want to take a step back and share the importance of the networks as they were envisioned, as they were designed. They are supposed to be a support system for family child care providers, to provide community support with working with children and, you know, in mixed settings, some of the administrative support pieces. And we know that the networks have different services, different ways, and inconsistency in how they are working with providers. One thing I will say: they should not be charging providers for affiliating in order to participate in the early childhood programs. We are really pushing to ramp up our support for the family child care networks and opening up lines of communication directly with the family child care providers, who have a lot of feedback to help us understand what options will work. How can we look at our system? How do we continue to really support this idea of networks so they are a benefit? But we also do know that we need to see where there are areas for flexibility. So we will continue to talk with both the networks and providers as we are planning for the expansion. (01:13:57) Have you heard from any networks that you are all contracted with about a surge in interest from providers wanting to be a part of the network, and what has their capacity been to start that process? (01:14:08) Yes, yes, we have. And so they want to work with us to figure out what expansion will look like, and we are having ongoing conversations with them about that. I think this is a place where they are asking for additional support, additional guidance, and what type of expansion would look like and how they could bring in additional providers who have expressed interest. So that is a place where we think that we can provide support as we are continuing to expand. (01:14:43) How do you have a sense of how many networks are contracted right now with 2K, 3K and pre-K? With how many networks we have right now... so we have over 40 networks that we are working with right now across all of the 2K, 3K and pre-K. That includes Staten Island. Does include Staten Island? Yes. I am just... what kind of support... I know you are unless the preliminary, right, but what kind of support, let us say, for the pre-K expansion, the 3K expansion, what kind of support existed for networks and what are you all looking at for 2K? So the support, I would say, are there and you... (01:15:24) Know two pockets. We are providing professional development to the educational directors of the family child care networks. And so, you know, there is usage of the Creative Curriculum and other curriculum pathways programs to make sure that they understand what programs are available and how to best coach and support family child care providers. In addition to that, we are also providing clarification around policies and connection to resources for the networks, who are then sharing this with their providers. They have access to a translation hotline through the network that the provider is able to access, and our team is working with them around their budgets and what flexibility there is to make sure that if there are additional resources that they need, that we have those. I also think there is just a community that other network directors are, you know, able to support, so that they are learning from each other as well as our team is providing that support. (01:16:37) Is the idea or the hope in this kind of continued rollout that more home-based providers, for example, will be a part of the network, or that there will just be more networks online? The hope is... (01:16:55) That more providers are part of the networks. I think some of those details in terms of how many networks and how many providers per network are things that we are going to be projecting out once we have more clarity on where the expansion is going to be and what the need... (01:17:12) Is. Okay. Well, I look forward to this continued conversation. I think it is something that is very important. We have heard from a number of advocates and so we want to make sure that we are kind of collaborating on this and making sure that we are including them. My next series of questions... sorry. Can you... I think you all shared at the top the kind of consideration for the five districts. I am clear on the Staten Island one, although I will re-ask the question. But can you give us a little bit more on how you all calculated need or priority in these five school districts? (01:17:55) We have looked at economic need based on the Economic Need Index, which is the measure that New York City Public Schools uses to look at a composite measure of child poverty in each area. We also looked at where communities did and did not already have access to free or subsidized care for toddlers, recognizing that in some communities families did already have some access and in others the gap was more significant. Those were the only... that was how we looked at economic need as a factor. And then we also looked closely at provider readiness, because again, given the short timeline for expansion, we wanted to go to communities where we felt there would be sufficient already-licensed child care capacity to meet demand. It was not a perfect science. I think there were many ways we could have gone about this, but you have to start somewhere, with the goal of then obviously expanding as quickly as we can to more and more communities. (01:18:49) And can you share, would you be able to share how many seats were offered in each district? I am just trying to figure out how you all made a difficult decision considering there were 5,700 applicants and how many seats will be accepted? (01:19:06) The seat allocation by district was based on our anticipation of demand in each of those districts, looking at the number of two-year-olds, just how many kids were born in 2024 and other data we have on the number of two-year-olds. We also looked at historic application and enrollment patterns in 3K and pre-K in each of the communities, and then again looked at provider capacity. So it was not an even split between the five districts. These districts are of very different sort of physical and population scale from each other. District 23 is... (01:19:40) Significantly smaller, for example, than the other four districts that we expanded to, just physically. And the number of seats by district was based on that assessment of anticipated demand and capacity. And then for the next, the 2027-2028 school year, how are you again... what steps are we taking now for 2K expansion into Staten Island? So on Staten Island, we prioritized for school year 2026-27 bringing more capacity online for 3K, which has allowed us to bring additional providers into the contracted system. Similar to what the team did this past year to expand, we will both look to existing contracted providers who already work with the City as well as new providers to bring them into the program, and particularly will be working with our family child care networks to bring family child care providers on Staten Island into the program. Okay. (01:20:35) Thank you. And then just a question on networks: how are networks funded? If there is no cost... we provide the funding for the networks for both their administrative costs as well as the child care costs, so that is baked into the... (01:20:58) Contract, that is right. And right, they are not charging the providers. They should not be charging the providers to participate. Okay. (01:21:08) Okay, enough. Okay, got it. (01:21:15) Can I... I think CM Brewer had raised this question about how... how do I say this... the amount of 2K seats per provider having an established 3K or pre-K. Right? I think you all said that those were the qualifications essentially that you looked at for 2K designations, that they were kind of an existing contract already with the City and that maybe some of them already had 3K or... it was a mix. We brought... so the 2K folks who are offering 2K, that includes providers who already were working with the City to serve 3K or pre-K, and it also includes providers who contracted with the City for the first time. Okay? (01:21:59) And I am certainly encouraged, and as a parent I am excited that so many of these 2K seats are extended day or extended year, non-means-tested. I think that is amazing. Do you all know if there will be available 3K extended day, extended year for that family in that same program? Currently, while our default model for 2K is extended day and year, our 3K and pre-K program is still, for the majority of seats, aligned to the school calendar. We do have some extended day and year seats in 3K. We know this is something that many families are looking for and it is something we will continue to look at as we grow the program. I think... (01:22:39) It is really hard to give somebody something and then take it away next year, and I think for families it is almost impossible to make work arrangements to pick up your child at 2:15, or you know what I mean, or kind of what to do with the summer. I know CM Riley and I spoke about this a lot, where there is not a lot of early childhood education programs for the summer. We were both bringing our kids up often and so I think it is a challenge. I would really love to understand a little bit deeper how you all are looking at that, or the conversations with the providers or the conversations with the parents, many of whom have extended day and it is going to be a rude awakening when they learn at the beginning of the next school year that they are going to have to pick their kids up in the middle of the day. (01:23:26) So I would love to continue that conversation. Can I pass it over to CM Joseph so I can get my notes together for questions? Thank you. (01:23:41) Thank you. Thank you so much. I noticed that you partnered with New York at the University of Chicago on the parent survey. Was CUNY ever considered for this research, and will CUNY be involved? Since the workforce you are building will be coming from CUNY, is CUNY being considered for that survey? (01:24:01) And so the particular survey that you are referencing was actually done by external partners. So that survey was funded by Robin Hood with a grant to New America, who then partnered with New York at the University of Chicago to administer that survey. So we are very excited for the forthcoming release of the data from that survey, which will give us for the first time really clear information about families' child care needs and preferences. But that survey was fielded and funded outside of the City. As we think about our future research agenda and the important questions we need to look at around the workforce and around 2K more broadly, we will look to a wide variety of research partners and we work very closely with many folks at CUNY as we are thinking about those questions. Thank you. As you continue... (01:24:45) To capture data to kind of move this system along, I hear a lot of expansion, but are we looking at the system as a whole to assess where we have gaps, where we have made mistakes, and how do we correct it before we expand? Expansion is great. I know parents need these seats. But as an agency, how are you assessing: do I have enough educators, enough providers, enough related services, enough of everything to meet the needs of this moment? Are you looking at the system as a whole and evaluating? As an educator, that is what I did. You have... (01:25:18) Policy, funding will come into play. Talk to me about what you are thinking. Yeah, absolutely. I think as a City we are trying to balance a few competing factors. From the family perspective, as you said, we cannot do this fast enough. Families are struggling mightily and we know that the lack of affordable child care is driving families out of the City and driving them to make impossible choices every day. So from a family affordability point of view, we cannot go fast enough. But we know that we have real challenges in the system today. We know that we need as a City to do more to support our early childhood providers and educators. We need to address longstanding gaps in wages and pay and some of the systems issues that you and the other Council members have brought up today. So our goal is to do both in parallel. We are looking closely at systems. We are, as the Deputy Chancellor referenced, trying to spend more time talking with providers and making sure we are bringing them into these conversations sooner, so that their perspective is informing the ways in which we go about this expansion. (01:26:26) In terms of vacancies, would you be able to send us a breakdown as to where the vacancies exist so we know? (01:26:33) Do you mean in terms of... (01:26:35) To support your early childhood division. At one point it was a skeleton, at one point, until we built it up. And then where are we now and what is the plan to scale it up, so that providers are not calling my office to say I am not getting paid, I am going to close the doors, my staff missed payroll? And that is something that has been going on for four years. So we have to figure out how do we fix that. (01:26:59) Absolutely. That is something that we can share. We are working actively to hire additional staff and address many of the payment issues as well as making sure that they feel supported in the field working with children. (01:27:13) What is the turnaround time when someone applies for a position and how long does it take for them to get... (01:27:17) It. Thank you. (01:27:21) Chair, thank you. I cut you off, sorry. Go ahead. Well, I will say I will follow up on that. We are moving as quickly as possible through our hiring processes and so I will follow up with that answer on that one. My question is... okay, you all, sorry about that. I wanted to ask: you mentioned in one of your responses "high quality programming." How can you (01:27:53) define high quality pre-K programming, and what are the standards and indicators you are looking at across school-based, center-based and family child care networks? (01:28:04) So when we think about quality for our youngest learners, we are approaching that in a really holistic manner. The first is thinking about the environment and the educators who are working with young children. What qualifications and what experience do they have helps to inform their relationships. They are developing secure attachment and strong social-emotional development of the child, and so that is one of the first things that we are looking at. Additionally, we do have a robust plan where we are coupling the Teaching Strategies GOLD authentic assessments, which aligns with the curriculum that we are using in our two-K programs. Finally, with our Ages and Stages Developmental Questionnaire, to make sure that we are identifying any delays and referring children for supports as soon as we are able to connect with the families and the children. So it is a really holistic approach to thinking about quality, and we can report out, as the year progresses, what we are learning from our two-K sites and how the classrooms, as well as our division, are using that to strengthen our support. (01:29:27) Was there any professional development for any of the two-K providers in this pilot? Absolutely, yes. And was the cost for that included in the $73 million? (01:29:38) Yes. So the professional development that our team is providing — there is some that is included in our budget. In addition, Robin Hood has also worked directly with some of their partners in order to supplement the training and coaching that we are (01:30:00) providing. Okay. So I know I had asked earlier about the contract rates. I do have some of the numbers that were shared in the executive plan. I just want to understand — for the two-K school day, the contract rate was a little over $19,000, and for two-K extended day it was a little over $29,000. Do these numbers also include the payment that the network would be receiving from the DOE? Yes, and the way the rates work for a family child care network is a portion of the rate — the vast majority of it — is for the provider. They cannot alter that rate; that is the standard rate for the provider. And then a smaller portion on a per-child basis is what funds the network costs. Okay. And does that present... is that not a flat percentage for the network, or is it? Yes, and we can get those numbers — the exact percentage for you. Okay, wonderful. And I am so sorry, I think CM Joseph had asked this. Can you just re-share the vacancy rate in the early childhood division as of today? So there are 228 positions that we are currently hiring for. We can share the specific vacancy rate as a follow-up to the Council. Okay. And this — I am going to ask this and may have to follow up — but for the contracts and procurement division, are there vacancies? They were a part of that 228 positions. So we are working across the agency to bring in additional staff who are needed. So the contracting is a place where we can share some detail on that too. Okay. And then just quickly on the City's response to the contract registration — I want to give you your flowers. I think everyone took it seriously, everyone was urgent, everyone wanted to get these contracts registered and payments made. So I want to thank you all. And I think CM Joseph also mentioned that this is an unfortunate issue that we also want to avoid. Of the staff that was moved from other agencies into the department for the purpose of contract registration, are they still working on contracts at this point? The staff who temporarily came over to support the New York City Public Schools team have all returned to their home agencies. Okay. Though within New York City Public Schools, a large number of staff remain focused wholly on making sure that all early childhood provider contracts are registered and that all providers received their contract advances as soon as those contracts do register. Okay. And then, front of the vacancy rate — 228 — that includes contracts and procurement. What is the... is there a certain amount from the 228 that will be dedicated to contracts and procurement? Yes, we have identified that and we can follow up. I can get you the specific numbers. Okay, for that. And what is the head count currently for your division? The current head count for my division — we will get that number. Okay. How is the Mayor's Office? How are we looking? What is the head count over there? We have a team of 12 and we are fully staffed, with two people starting in the next month. Okay, all right, excellent. Okay. And then I just wanted to expand a little bit more on the pipeline. I think there have been a lot of exciting investments, significantly from the administration and more recently a smaller investment from the Council. Can you explain a little bit more what the expectation is on the additional dollars for CUNY's apprenticeship, for example? It is a two-to-three year program, I believe — correct me if I am wrong — but what are we looking at in four years? What do we think the investment in this apprenticeship will provide? So the expansion of the apprenticeship program will provide more educators, and we can get those exact figures for you. That alone will not build the workforce out to what we know we need in order to expand childcare, so it is one of multiple levers we know we need to pull. This is an area we are focused on and excited to preview with the subcommittee in coming weeks about some of the initiatives and plans we have for the future and that we hope to continue to invest in. Okay. And how soon — and obviously some of that money was allocated in the signing of the budget — how soon are those dollars going to work for this program? The apprenticeship program dollars are getting to work right away in expanding the number of apprentices. The New York City talent... I noticed the Office of Talent and Workforce Development is partnering with CUNY on the number of apprentices that are at CUNY and working within community programs, and then they also work closely with the Kennedy's Children Center, which is a program that supports primarily children with developmental delays and disabilities, and they have been the host of early childhood apprenticeships. That program is growing as well. Okay. And is there anything else that you all are doing with regards to recruitment, or that the City is doing, or any of the other agencies, really focusing on early childhood education? And obviously there is a whole teacher shortage, but what are some of those examples? So we are broadly working on a workforce recruitment strategy as part of this overall workforce development strategy. Again, I look forward to sharing more with you in the coming weeks. There is work that has been underway for many years in New York City Public Schools through the teacher recruitment unit to support early childhood educators specifically, both in placing them in school-based programs but also in our community-based organizations. They do hiring fairs, they collect resumes, they share those with providers to help support job placement. Thank you. And then for the current two-K providers, what is the cadence of communication with them? It is very early on, but are you checking in on them? How is it going for these providers? And I just want to plug that CM Riley said he would love to do a site visit, if allowed, to one of these two-K sites. Absolutely, absolutely. We would invite anybody on a site visit. So yes, we are in regular communication with our providers. In the two weeks since the school has started, they have received visits from our team. We have had our social workers and our instructional coordinators and inclusion specialists at every one of our two-K sites to check on them and see how they are doing and what else they need. I have been to several two-K sites since I joined and they are excited to be able to welcome families in this way. It is really a game changer for families. There is feedback on ways that we can partner with them in a better way, and so we are collecting all of that feedback and we will continue to do that. Thank you. (01:37:48) Related to Early Head Start and means-tested infant-toddler seats: how many City-funded, formerly Early Head Start seats are there currently, and what is the breakdown by age? That is data we can get back to you. The formerly — now what are called City transitional contracts. Okay. And do these seats have any requirements? For the City transitional seats, we prioritize families who are low income, but there is not a specific restriction. Okay. And is there any long-term plan for these transitional seats, given the launch and the upcoming expansion of two- (01:38:26) K? So we were thrilled earlier this year to be able to provide the funding to ensure continuity for these seats. We know that many of these providers are really, really strong providers in their communities who have been serving particularly our lowest-income families for many years, and so we want to make sure we continue to find ways to create continuity for their services. (01:38:46) Okay, great. And then I just have one more question if no one else has any. I just wanted to ask: I know that we have had testimony from providers — from network providers, individual providers and then some of the larger franchise-model providers. There is concern about their level of resources and infrastructure, but I think they have also expressed interest in wanting to be a part of this program. I know one of the two-K sites is one of these programs. How are you all thinking about, early on, the balance of — you have said to me that we need these families, we need these home-based providers — but how are you all thinking about the equity piece, similar to the folks that are not in a network, but some of these larger networks? How are you all thinking about where they currently are and where I think they want to expand? (01:39:44) What can you share with me about how you are thinking about it? I think with a mixed delivery system like we have, one of the really important values for us is that we have a really diverse mix of providers, because that both represents the diversity of our early childhood educators in New York City and it also meets families' really diverse preferences. We know that families are interested in really different types of settings for all sorts of reasons and we want to value that. So as we continue to expand, we will look at both the providers who already work with the City, who already offer three-K and pre-K, to bring them into the two-K program so we can have that continuity for families. And then we will create opportunities for new providers to come in as well in order to deliver universal two-K and ultimately universal child care. We need everyone, and so we want to create on-ramps for all of our providers to participate. Thank you. And I encourage (01:40:38) providers and parents to come and testify, because I am also hopeful that a lot of their feedback will be taken in as you all think about the next phase. And I think there is a lot riding on this design. Can you share anything about, just initially at this stage, what you all have been hearing as far as pressure points for providers? Not asking you to share anything confidential, but what is some of the feedback that you are hearing from providers — like, we would really love to see this in the next iteration? (01:41:16) We will be doing a lot of engagement because it is important for the continuity of the birth-to-five system. Some of the things that we have heard — conversations we have had about compensation and making sure that rates are reflecting the costs that providers are sharing with us. Additionally, there are questions about how we can be flexible as we think about continuity of care in the mix of seats and ages that are needed. How can we be responsive? How can we build in responsiveness to families' needs as those might change over the years? We are also looking at flexibility. We talked about the family child care piece of it, and so that is another place where we have received feedback and we will be looking at that. Overall, our goal is to be planning ahead, to be in conversation with providers and with families, so that as we think about what the next phase of this system looks like, we can have the conversations that we need to have in order to build a stronger system. And I also wanted to share — they have the number on the current head count. So as of October 4, we had 590 positions, or staff. (01:42:47) Do you have a sense of... so the 590 plus the 228 — what is that? Was that an existing total from administrations before, or is that an (01:42:59) increase? So it is not an increase, and all of the 228 positions are not all for our division — that is across NYC Public Schools. Oh, okay. It is... we are still rebuilding and it is hard to have an apples-to-apples comparison because the division over time has had different responsibilities and scopes of area. So this is an initial investment. We are looking forward to being able to bring in these additional staff in order to have things move smoother and support the providers and children. (01:43:39) And so is the 590 number that you just shared — is that the entire... that is okay. Okay. And would you be able to share maybe later what the vacancy rate is for that? Yes. Okay. Thank you. (01:44:01) I think we did it for now. I am (01:44:02) great. I also wanted to make sure that we are being mindful of people's time. I believe there is a baby here, so I want to make sure that she gets to testify. Thank you all so much for your answers. I look forward to the remaining answers and certainly the report and then, of course, the visit. Give me one second. Yes, Sergeant. We are just going to give the Sergeant a second to move all this. Thank you. Okay, okay. Thank you. I now open the hearing for public testimony. I remind members of the public that this is a government proceeding and that decorum shall be observed at all times. As such, members of the public shall remain silent at all times. The witness table is reserved for people who wish to testify. No video recording or photography is allowed from the witness table. Further, members of the public may not present audio or video recordings as testimony, but may submit transcripts of such recordings to the Sergeant at Arms for inclusion in the hearing record. If you wish to speak at today's hearing, please fill out a sign-in slip with the Sergeant at Arms and wait to (01:46:06) be recognized. When recognized, you will have two minutes to speak on today's oversight topic and our legislation. If you have written a statement or additional written testimony you wish to submit for the record, please provide a copy of that testimony to the Sergeant at Arms. You may also email written testimony to testimony@council.nyc.gov within 72 hours to be accepted. I am going to call up the first panel. We have... okay. I would like to call up, if I can read it: Alison Lou, Kayleigh Jac from New Yorkers United for Children, Nora Moran, Karen Rogel, Tara Gardner and Robert Cordero. Can we have the mom start? Okay. Thank you. Whenever you are ready. (01:47:36) Good afternoon. My name is Carrie R. I am a parent leader with New Yorkers United for Child Care. My family and I live in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn, and joining me here today is my three-month-old daughter, as of today. I have lived in New York for 18 years and I work as a theater and audio producer. I am currently on parental leave, and once my leave is over, my partner — who works nights as a general manager at a restaurant — and I are going to put together a patchwork of solutions so that we only have to pay for two days a week of daycare. Even for those two days a week, we anticipate spending more than $12,000 a year on child care. Five days a week, we looked into it — it would cost at least $36,000 a year in our neighborhood, which is unaffordable for my family. So three days a week, my partner will be taking care of her while I am at work 9 to 5, and then I will get home and he will go to work and I will be solo parenting at (01:48:31) night. Like many New Yorkers, we are getting creative to figure out how to make it work. But (01:48:35) the solution means we will not spend any time together, the three of us as a family. When I am anxious about (01:48:42) That the toll it will take on us, but we have been telling ourselves that we just have to do it and figure it out for a year and a half before, hopefully, 2K is expanded as promised, and then we can have more flexibility with our schedules and our careers. (01:48:58) Having free universal 2K for prima would allow us to take a breath. It will mean being able to save up for her future education and extracurricular activities and maybe even dream to save up for a down payment. When I found out that I was pregnant, basically around this time last year, we were so excited. But also worry set in about how to make the math work for our finances. And when we heard Mayor Mamdani announce that 2K free child care for all of New York City's two year olds was starting, we were able to breathe a huge sigh of relief. The tens of thousands of dollars that we would have spent on child care can now go towards building our future. Many people have mentioned the demand for 2K shows how much New York City families are desperate for this. I am proud to be one of the thousands of parents across New York City organizing and speaking up about the cost of child care over the past few years, but we need to make sure the 2K stays and expands and that all the child care workers caring for our two year olds are paid fairly. There is no reason that New York families should be struggling and oftentimes going into debt to pay for child care. Meanwhile, the child care workers are also struggling to afford to live here. I am committed to creating a society for my daughter that prioritizes care and education, where our taxes go towards services that benefit working families and the general public. It is my hope that the program becomes so ubiquitous and successful that when my daughter and her friends grow up, they cannot imagine a New York where great quality universal child care is not a fact of life, just like public schools or public libraries. The cost of child care is a nationwide crisis, but New York City has so often been a beacon of courage and innovation for the rest of the country, and I hope we can continue to be an example and lead the way on this issue, starting with expanding 2K for all. Thank you for your time. (01:50:50) Thank you, Kaylie, and shout out to the best baby. Thank you for being here. (01:50:57) Good afternoon. My name is Allison Lou and I am a senior organizer for New Yorkers United for Child Care and a Brooklyn mom to a five year old who was a proud grad of universal pre-K. New Yorkers United for Child Care organizes parents and would-be parents across the city to fight for free universal child care from birth to five, full day, full year, in every neighborhood. Watching the landscape of child care in New York City over the last few years has been absolutely amazing. Two years ago, I and other parents were fighting to protect 3K and pre-K from cuts. Now, New York City has become a pioneering city offering free universal child care from the age of two upwards. I am so grateful to the members of the City Council, Mayor Mamdani and Governor Hochul for partnering with us to make New York City a place where families with young kids can thrive. While we have made big strides in providing access to free child care for parents across the city, child care costs are still a crisis for too many New Yorkers, especially folks with kids under the age of three. That is when it is hardest for families to find care. Full time care for a two year old in the city runs an average of $26,000 a year, which is a rent or a mortgage. A report from the Citizens Committee for Children earlier this year estimated that 90% of New York families with young kids cannot afford care without assistance, which is an increase from just two years ago. The New York City Comptroller has also estimated that a family needs to make $334,000 a year to afford child care for just one kid, putting the cost of this essential service out of reach for most families in New York. As an organizer, I talk with parents who are struggling with steep child care costs every day. Free universal child care for two year olds has been nothing short of life changing for the parents we are in touch with. I will share just one story of the many I heard. Before 2K, one of our Bushwick parent leaders, Nancy Keith, did not think she could afford to have a second child because of the high cost of child care. After 2K was announced, she and her family were so elated. She is now almost 30 weeks pregnant with her second child. Her dream family is coming true for her. My family also wants to have another kid here in New York City, but we do not know if we can afford it. Before my son turned three and got 3K, we had to go into debt to pay for his care. At one point we decided to forego our own health insurance to pay for his child care because no one should have to make a choice like this. We were able to get out of debt and pay for health insurance when my son turned three and we learned that we got free 3K. It was almost a physical feeling, the relief that we felt lifted off our... (01:53:46) ...shoulders. I want everyone to feel that relief earlier than year three. Thank you. The memory of that time... oh, sorry. You can wrap it up. I am sorry. The memory of that time... (01:53:56) ...has stayed with me. Saying, if we knew we could count on free 2K, it would make it easier for us to consider a second child, but we do not know if... it breaks my heart to show my son that I do not know if he gets to have the baby brother or sister he has been asking for every week. I hear from families who are making tough decisions just like this in order to raise kids. (01:54:22) Here are the questions we all ask ourselves: Can I afford both rent and child care bills this month? Will I be able to afford care for my toddler and my senior parents? Will I ever be able to pay off my credit card debt if my... (01:54:40) ...kid's summer care costs $3,000 a month? Many of these families are leaving the city because they just cannot make the child care costs math work. More families need to know they can depend on it. I would also like to add that our child care workers are absolutely essential and we want care workers to be paid a living wage. Let us make sure we can make this happen for all New York families as soon as we can, while also taking care of our workers. Thank you. (01:55:10) Thank you. Okay. Hi. (01:55:17) My name is Nora Moran and I am the Director of Policy and Advocacy at United Neighborhood Houses. Our members are New York City settlement houses who serve over 8,000 children in early childhood programs each year and have been providing child care services for almost a century in this city. Our written testimony goes into a lot more detail, but I wanted to say a couple of things. Overall, I think the 2K expansion has been desperately needed. We hear time and time again just how crushing child care costs are for families. Aging down to two year olds is also really positive for settlement houses who strive to create that continuity of care. They want to make sure that if they are serving a child at 3K, they can work with them at four and age five. So 2K is going to let them do that. It is also extremely positive that the default for this program is a full day, full year. We heard time and time again about how parents find that six hours and 20 minutes is not enough. Our members can sometimes struggle to fill those seats because that is not the hours of care that families need, and it is not in our members' mission to charge families for care. They are nonprofits. That is not what they do. We also know that we cannot waste this moment as an opportunity to reform the system — not just for 2K, but also for 3K and pre-K. That infrastructure is really closely linked, and when we are fixing things for 2K it is going to improve the whole system, and that is good for everybody. So some specifics about what that reform looks like — we all know these things, it is not surprising. First, pay parity, specifically for those center-based providers with their New York City public school counterparts, as well as significantly increased wages for family child care providers, taking into account their longevity and work experience. A great pay scale starts getting us towards that. We want the city and the state to start embracing, adopting and funding that. Second is improving staffing at New York City public schools. We know that the contracting and payment delays happen because there is not enough staff on the city's end to process that. That is going to make or break this program's success. Third, reimbursing for the true cost of care. A report showed about a $12,000 gap between what we think a program should be funded and what it actually is. The next phase is going to be a key chance to reform that. And finally, making sure we are striving toward quality. It was great to hear about how professional development is being taken into account. A two year old is different than a three year old, a three year old is different than a four year old, and making sure that we are providing the coaching and training for staff to serve two year olds in the most developmentally appropriate way. (01:57:46) Thank you. Thank you, Nora. (01:57:50) Okay. Thank you, CM Gutiérrez and the Subcommittee, for the opportunity to testify today. As the city builds 2K, we need to think beyond the number of seats that are created. We also need to ask: do families know about these opportunities? Do they understand what 2K can offer their child and can they successfully navigate the process to access it? My name is Karen Rogan. I am the Director of Community Programs at Literacy in Community, or LINC, and LINC is the backbone organization for Cities First Readers, New York City's only Council-funded early literacy initiative. We are based organizations working with children and families from birth through age five across all five boroughs. Our strength is our reach. Our partners have deep relationships in different communities, speak different languages and connect with families in places they already know and trust, such as libraries, health settings, community organizations, family programs and neighborhood events. Those relationships allow us to do more than hand a parent a flier or direct them to a website. We can help families understand what 2K is, what their child can gain from early learning and how to enroll. This is especially important for families who are new to New York City, speak languages other than English or may not routinely connect with traditional city outreach. So Cities First Readers is not asking the city to create another enrollment system. We are asking the city to leverage an infrastructure that already exists. We already have community presence and we have the trust. As 2K expands, we encourage the city to invest not only in seats, but in community infrastructure that connects families to them, because success will be measured not only by how many seats we create, but whether families know about them, understand their value and can access them. Our 18 partners are ready to help you. (01:59:44) Thank you. Thank you, Karen. (01:59:53) Thanks. Good afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the Subcommittee. Thank you for the opportunity to testify regarding the expansion of 2K in New York City this afternoon. I am Tara Gardner, a proud Head Start graduate and former family child care parent. I am the Executive Director of the Daycare Council of New York and we represent nearly 140 nonprofit organizations and 42 providers in Queens through... (02:02:08) ...our family child care network. They collectively operate publicly funded child care and early childhood education programs throughout the five boroughs for more than 13,000 children. Our members have decades of experience educating New York City's youngest children, supporting working families and responding to the needs of the neighborhoods they serve. We are committed to expanding access to high quality early childhood education, especially for families contending with significant needs. As the city expands the 2K program, we must ensure that organizations have the funding, workforce, contracts and program models necessary to sustain them. Community based organizations are ready to be partners in the expansion. In our 2026 conversations with providers earlier this year, 87% expressed interest in participating in 2K. At the same time, they have repeatedly cautioned that the existing system has to be stabilized. In our provider discussions, organizations raised meaningful concerns about their ability to staff their programs and receive on-time payments. Those concerns reflect conditions providers are already experiencing. 74% described recruiting staff as difficult or very difficult, and more than 80% cited issues with low compensation, longer days, year-round operations and competition from public schools. For 2K to grow successfully, the city must learn from seasoned program operators as it designs the next phase of implementation. That means ensuring that the expansion is supported by several core policy conditions. Contracts and reimbursement levels must reflect the true cost of serving two year olds. Contract advances and payments must be remitted early enough for providers to hire staff, prepare classrooms and make necessary investments before children arrive. Expansion must make use of existing provider capacity, including currently under-enrolled sites and available classrooms that can accommodate 2K programming. Workforce investments must be sufficient to support the existing workforce and staff new classrooms. And finally, programs must have adequate resources, staffing and supports to serve children with disabilities and developmental needs. The Daycare Council looks forward to working with the Council, the administration, New York City Public Schools and providers across the city to ensure that 2K evolves into a program that provides meaningful access for families, while creating sustainable infrastructure for the organizations and educators responsible for delivering it. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. (02:02:13) I want to personally thank CM Brewer for coming to our spring recital. She saw my children perform without knowing it. She was across the room. Thank you for investing in another great organization. (02:02:18) I said, if it is in Manhattan, she will make it. I was not making empty promises. (02:02:24) Good afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the Subcommittee. Thank you for the opportunity to testify regarding the expansion of 2K in New York City this afternoon. I am Tara Gardner, a proud Head Start graduate and former family child care parent. I am the Executive Director of the Daycare Council of New York and we represent nearly 140 nonprofit organizations and 42 providers in Queens through... (02:02:51) ...our family child care network. They collectively operate publicly funded child care and early childhood education programs throughout the five boroughs for more than 13,000 children. Our members have decades of experience educating New York City's youngest children, supporting working families and responding to the needs of the neighborhoods they serve. We are committed to expanding access to high quality early childhood education, especially for families contending with significant needs. As the city expands the 2K program, we must ensure that organizations have the funding, workforce, contracts and program models necessary to sustain them. Community based organizations are ready to be partners in the expansion. In our 2026 conversations with providers earlier this year, 87% expressed interest in participating in 2K. At the same time, they have repeatedly cautioned that the existing system has to be stabilized. In our provider discussions, organizations raised meaningful concerns about their ability to staff their programs and receive on-time payments. Those concerns reflect conditions providers are already experiencing. 74% described recruiting staff as difficult or very difficult, and more than 80% cited issues with low compensation, longer days, year-round operations and competition from public schools. For 2K to grow successfully, the city must learn from seasoned program operators as it designs the next phase of implementation. That means ensuring that the expansion is supported by several core policy conditions. Contracts and reimbursement levels must reflect the true cost of serving two year olds. Contract advances and payments must be remitted early enough for providers to hire staff, prepare classrooms and make necessary investments before children arrive. Expansion must make use of existing provider capacity, including currently under-enrolled sites and available classrooms that can accommodate 2K programming. Workforce investments must be sufficient to support the existing workforce and staff new classrooms. And finally, programs must have adequate resources, staffing and supports to serve children with disabilities and developmental needs. The Daycare Council looks forward to working with the Council, the administration, New York City Public Schools and providers across the city to ensure that 2K evolves into a program that provides meaningful access for families, while creating sustainable infrastructure for the organizations and educators responsible for delivering it. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. (02:05:46) Thank you. I have a couple of questions, but because I do want prima to just be safe and be home, I wanted to ask you, Kayleigh — thank you so much for your beautiful testimony. I think there are many New Yorkers who dream of having enough resources to put a down payment. For the provider that you mentioned, where you are doing the math maybe two days a week — can you share, is this a center-based or home-based or kind of an informal care situation? Center-based, okay. And is the two days because that is what works for your finances? Exactly. Yeah. When you looked into five days it was unaffordable. Okay. (02:06:29) Okay. And Alison, you have been... (02:06:32) ...organizing. You have been up in Albany as well. What are New Yorkers United for Child Care thinking about for a non-election year for the state budget and fighting for universal child care? What are those conversations like? (02:06:47) You are having with parents... well, they are so excited and so optimistic because of how much we have been able to do over the past few years. I mean, when we first got started, my family did not know if you were going to get it. We thought it was going to get cut and now we are looking at expansion to younger kids and the hope that it is bringing the families. It is amazing and truly it has been life-changing. Absolutely really excited to do more, not just for themselves. Some of our parents are getting... their kids are getting older, but they want their neighbors to stay and their families to stay, especially folks who are, you know, born and raised here in New York. They do not know if they can stay here because of the... (02:07:31) Thank you. And then specifically the networks... and of course the Daycare Council. Can you share what conversations you have had with your team internally about the growth of this program, aging down even, but particularly... obviously you heard some of the numbers, and the numbers for the next year I think are upwards of 1000 two-year-olds. How are we coaching... like what do you all feel is the level of support that the agencies and the administrations provide? How are you all thinking about or working to include more providers? What have those conversations been looking like? (02:08:22) All right, so just from a provider perspective, we are ready. The biggest impediments, especially for settlement houses and groups that have been doing this for a long time since the inception of the Head Start program and even before that, for many of us is bureaucratic issues, delays. Right now we had a visit and they already have... I have got to give them credit. They always stick around. The one-year-olds are in the classrooms, right? That is what we saw this summer and that is Early Head Start. We use a combination of federal direct Head Start funding with City funding, what they call the transitional money, and so I think there are many providers with capacity. The impediments for us have been a delayed wage or an inspection, or those that are in... like we are, for example. It is much easier for us honestly when we are in private facilities or we have a landlord, we negotiate a deal and we can build it out directly to code and get through things much more quickly. But I think partnerships with the big agencies, like the Department of Buildings, to really streamline this in an interagency way would be so beneficial to providers large and small. It is much, much worse for our home-based family child care providers. They are trying to navigate the bureaucracy. It is easier when they partner with a larger organization, not that we are better, but a larger one with a lot more experience navigating the bureaucracy and the resources to do that. So I think that is a problem that is solvable. That is a bureaucracy problem. Honestly, we have seen a dramatic improvement. We were not part of the first round of two-K because it just was not in the neighborhoods that we were in yet, but we are ready. Other than that, we have seen a dramatic improvement honestly with this administration and this version of the City Council in payment and procurement process. It is not perfect for everybody, but it has been a nightmare in the past two administrations at different times for us. So there is a focus on that that proves that this is a solvable problem that finally has the political will to do it. But from our perspective, anything to streamline the bureaucracy, let us get these children in. Their parents are desperate to get their kids in. We have space. We have capacity. We still have other issues we have to address like the workforce pipeline, but that is my plea from the community-based perspective. Thank you. (02:11:14) Just one thing I would add to that. It is a little hard to answer the question without knowing the target neighborhoods for the next... (02:11:19) ...expansion. I think once we know that, our providers know. We have some that certainly do have some center-based capacity and a lot of interest in affiliating new providers in their family child care network, but we do not know where the target areas are going to be. I think there is going to be a lot more preparation that will just be able to happen once we know. Build-out does need to happen for sure. Specifically as it relates to network staff, the compensation issue is not just with teachers in class. The network staff is underpaid as well. And speed to quality, being able to support providers in their homes, the quality of the staff that you can attract and retain is really, really important. I think, as Phillips mentioned earlier, building in flexibility to contracting is also really important. As communities change over the life of a contract, changing contract seats and where providers are is really, really important to the success of our extended-term grant, or whatever the contract is as well. (02:12:40) Thank you. And then my last question is for you. You also always come and testify and obviously I am a big fan of Cities First Readers. The Speaker, the Council... what is an ideal relationship for you, representing LINC of course, but what is the ideal kind of relationship with the Department as we continue to expand to two-K and then universal? Like I mentioned in my testimony, our biggest power is in reach, and because of the 18 partners we reach these families and their trusted relationships. So given the opportunity to possibly help with outreach, to let them know, to provide information... I always say families just do not know what they do not know. We do have a lot of immigrant families we support who are asking, partners are asking us, what is two-K, what is it about, do I really need to do it? So us being able to provide this information in hospital settings, in libraries and programs, we can support the system and their enrollment. Excellent. Thank you. And just for... actually, anybody can answer it, but has anyone been in contact with any of the two-K private providers that are in the pilot and received any feedback that they have shared about the rates they have been receiving, any of that stuff? (02:13:58) Maybe we can take that. We have a few providers in both our membership and our network who appreciate the increased funding that comes with the pilot. For our network it has been great. Our providers were probably... I think the other day it was 94% capacity, in large part because of conversion to two-K seats. The fact that they are extended-year by default is the best part, I think, for families. Excellent. All right... (02:14:27) Well, thank you all so much. (02:14:30) Oh, sorry. Feel good, just... very first of the New York Post. You should bottle it and send it to the New York... (02:14:38) Post, because I read it every morning and they do not like the Mayor. But if they hear you, they might change their... (02:14:43) Mind on the... here, that would have been so... (02:14:47) Helpful. I read it. My question, just the training of the staff. I asked it earlier. I assume that all of this, the goal is better outcomes come high school and elementary school and so on. So are the training of the staff... but in addition, some of you do this, some of you do not. What is the... I would like to know what the City is doing on outcomes. Are you doing any outcomes? How do we keep measuring to show how important early childhood is? Is anybody doing that or is that something that is just done by the City? And how does that connect with training for the teachers? (02:15:29) Love you and you are going to be a little bit more critical now... (02:15:33) No. Well, we are a Robin Hood grantee, we are just fortunate. Robin Hood funds evaluation and impact, so we have been a long-time grantee. We actually have a system built where all of our early childhood enrolled families, over 1000 of them, we follow them from the beginning all the way through. We have Early Head Start, so we are working with pregnant women who are going to enroll their children. We should probably talk about Head Start with you, but there are ways to do this. I do not know if it is throughout the whole City, so I think the point is that is really something I am glad the City is looking at, partnering with Robin Hood and CUNY. But there has to be a way with this new initiative of universal child care expansion to measure it from baseline, because many of us were not measuring things back when the War on Poverty started 61 years ago when we got a Head Start. We were just serving children that were in families in dire need. But the programs that have been measured, like Head Start, have incredible outcomes, and I hope that the City does that. It is really up to the government to do that in partnership with the providers. (02:16:46) It brings funding too, if you show them. Yes, thank you very... (02:16:48) Much. Thank you. Okay, this concludes this panel and I am just going to call up the next panel. Thank you all so much for your testimony. I have... Lara, my apologies, from All Our Kin. Amy, Amy Lee, Sarah Wilner, Joy Farina, Betty... Albany, do you want to start? (02:17:53) Come on, you are good for it. Thank you... (02:17:57) Hello. Thank you, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the Subcommittee. My name is Albany Jimenez and I am the Chief of Community Mobilization, Adult Literacy and Community at LINC. For 30 years, LINC has worked with families and educators during the years when the foundations for literacy are first built. We are incredibly excited about two-K, but today I want to ask the Council to look beyond one measure of success: the number of seats we create. A seat gives a family access. What happens in that seat determines its impact. Two-year-olds are building language, relationships, curiosity and foundations they will eventually need to read. Every conversation, song and story, every back-and-forth interaction with a trusted adult, helps build those foundations. So as two-K expands, early literacy should be part of how the City defines quality. That requires investing in the adults around them. Educators and family child care providers need ongoing professional learning and coursework in child development and literacy, not just one-time training. Families need to be part of that strategy. They are our children's first teachers. What happens in two-K should connect with what happens at home, with practical support that gives families the tools to continue learning through the day. Finally, LINC should leverage community organizations like us that already have expertise and trusted relationships with families to help provide these supports. Universal child care can make our City more affordable. Universal literacy can make opportunity more equitable. Two-K gives us the chance to advance both. The Council should ensure that we measure not only how many two-K seats we create, but the quality and opportunity we create within them. Let us get this right from the beginning. Thank you. (02:20:25) Just a gold star for enthusiasm. Thank you. And Kenya, thank you, Betty. (02:20:34) Thank you for the chance to talk about two-K and the opportunity for the City to build a truly inclusive and accessible program that meets the needs of all children and families. My name is Betty Baisamello. I am an attorney and the Director of Early Childhood Education at Advocates for Children of New York. We want to congratulate the City and New York City Public Schools on the launch of two-K. We know how meaningful the... (02:20:52) ...opportunity is for the 2000 toddlers and families who are benefiting from the program this year. As two-K expands in the coming years it is critical that the City create an inclusive program that meets the needs of all toddlers. So we are focusing our limited time today on the inclusion of children with disabilities. As in prior expansions of early childhood education we have seen them left behind, and a program cannot be universal unless it meets the needs of children with disabilities. For children ages three to five years, New York City Public Schools offers not just three-K and pre-K general education classes but also more specialized settings with smaller class ratios, more individualized attention and instruction provided by special education teachers. However, such models do not exist for two-year-olds. While many children with disabilities can be supported by program staff in coordination with Early Intervention, it is important to note that this is only for a fraction of the day and does not ensure that children get the support and accommodations they need to participate in the full-day two-K program. Therefore, while coordination with Early Intervention is critical, the City must also consider the resources and program models needed to support children with more significant disabilities and intensive needs who require specialized care. (02:22:03) We are pleased that the City has made clear that children with disabilities are welcome in all two-K programs and appreciate the work the City has done so far. As it expands, we encourage it to build on this work and take the following steps. Monitor and strengthen current efforts to serve children with disabilities, including processes for requesting evaluations, approving and requesting accommodations and supports, as well as coordination with Early Intervention. Set aside dedicated resources, including for accommodations and supports not covered by Early Intervention. Identify specialists or additional staff who need to be hired to ensure programs can serve children with disabilities. Leverage the expertise of CBOs that already serve children with disabilities by, for example, encouraging center-based preschool special education programs to apply for two-K contracts, or contracting with them to support existing providers. Ensure that families are properly matched with programs and that sites are physically accessible for them. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. I will be happy to answer questions. (02:23:05) Thanks, Betty. Hello, good... (02:23:07) Afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the esteemed Committee. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today. In my written testimony I will have more details on policy recommendations, including the importance of payment rates that reflect the true cost of care and the dire need for health insurance and retirement benefits for all family child care educators. (02:23:26) I am Lara Kyriakou, the Senior Director of Policy at All Our Kin, a national organization that provides educational, mentorship, professional development and systems-building expertise to family child care educators and stakeholders. In New York City we offer bilingual services including licensing coaching, business training and educational coaching. I would also like to thank CM Brewer for attending our graduation earlier this summer. That was the event that you mentioned earlier today, graciously funded by the Robin Hood Foundation. Families who prefer family child care programs often speak of a feeling as though their child has a home away from home and deeply value the long-term bonds and connections that educators develop with children and their families, often across multiple generations. We are encouraged by the historic commitments from Mayor Mamdani and the Governor to expand access and capacity, including this week's announcement of additional funding for 10,000 children from the wait list. As the City continues to roll out the two-K program it is critical to ensure that family child care educators are included in the solutions. Educators continue to have a lot of questions about two-K implementation and uncertainty about whether they have the opportunity to participate and whether they will be able to afford to run their program. At the moment only about 20% of all family child care programs are part of a network. Of the approximately 80% of family child care educators who are independent, many cite the desire to control their own enrollment as a key motivator for this decision. Others also cite concerns about contract transparency and consistency across networks and payment delays as further reasons to remain independent. City leaders have expressed a commitment to a more inclusive system and we look forward to continuing to work with them closely to support equitable engagement of these educators. I could just add one more sentence. I wanted to also highlight that child development research tells us that continuity of care is incredibly important for children, especially the youngest children. Rather than separate programs by single ages, funding streams must be prepared to support children's care in one setting throughout the early years of life. This allows children the opportunity to benefit from consistent and responsive relationships with early caregivers, which is one of the key markers of a high-quality learning environment. For parents who prefer family child care, they often speak of the close connections with educators that they and their children develop, and without a continuum of care built into funding models the system risks undermining one of the most unique and valuable qualities of family child care. We are greatly appreciative of today's opportunity and remain available to provide any additional information that you need. Thank you. (02:26:01) I am glad. I am glad you took your time. That was an excellent closing point. My daughters are my family. Now I tell them. Yes. Wonderful. Thank you. (02:26:11) Good afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez and distinguished Council Members. Thank you for the opportunity for speaking today. I am here on behalf of PECK, People's Early Childhood Coalition. We are an advocacy group composed of teachers and structural coordinators, academia, social workers and policymakers working across boundaries to really confront the inequitable policies and help transform the local early childhood system. (02:26:37) My name is Joy Farina Basket. I have been an educator for over 20 years. I am currently an adviser, so I work with CEOs — with 14 of them. I am also a professor for secondary education and I want to just say thank you for the opportunity. I really just want to highlight five key points that PECK would love to bring to your attention, and I reiterate the urgency of getting your support on it. We believe in expanding the access to high quality early childhood education, as it seems like everyone here does. We believe families should have greater access. The point here is that expansion has to include the stability of the CBOs, which I have also heard quite a bit today, and the educators who are already doing that work. When this system is unstable, this is not simply a provider problem. It is a system problem. That kind of goes to the first point of contracting and payments, which again we have heard quite a bit today. We ask the City Council to really look beyond solving just maybe this year's crisis and to put in a fix to the structure that creates this crisis in the first place. We are asking providers to open the doors, hire qualified teachers, meet payroll, maintain classrooms, comply with health and safety regulations, purchase supplies — I can go on and on — without the funds to do so. (02:28:11) So ensuring that they have the funds before we continue to expand, and having a system in place, is critical. The second point was pay parity or wage equity. As we have all discussed, that is critical, and I would ask that as we embrace that, we do not lose quality with the workforce. Enrollment creates pay based on seats, so there can be half-full classrooms and they are not getting their full funding, so that creates another problem. So stabilizing contracts and payments, establishing true pay parity, creating a sustainable enrollment model like we used to have in the past, and then building the next phase around sustainability from the beginning — that is another consistent theme I have heard today: from the beginning. All of this can only be done with trust and transparency. So I am going to end on the importance of trust and transparency, because there has been — because of the way it was rolled out, and understandably so, it was quick, it was robust and it was needed — we need to rebuild trust and transparency together so we can unify. Sometimes we have to slow down to speed up, and I will leave it on that. Thank you. (02:29:42) Good afternoon, Chair and members of the Council. Thank you so much for allowing me to speak today. My name is Sarah Wilner and I am the Executive Director of Early Starters. At Early Starters, we work closely with families who live in housing instability, the majority of whom are new New Yorkers who have recently arrived to New York City. We provide early childhood safe spaces and programming for these families who, up until recently, have had very little access to any sort of early childhood programming. We believe that it is the right of every child to have access to quality early childhood programming, and we are very encouraged and hopeful by the City's commitment to expand to 2K. I do want to make sure that there are three points that I would like to highlight. First, reaching families through trusted community relationships. As we have all spoken about, families experiencing housing instability need additional support to learn about programs and navigate enrollment. Community organizations working with these families can help the City reach them. As we spoke about in last week's discussion on multilingual learners, we highlighted the need for access to information in different languages as well as trained staff on culturally appropriate and trauma-informed care. Second, building the workforce. As many of the Council Members and panelists have spoken about, many... (02:31:05) ...people that we work with in our communities have the interest, the language skills and lived experience to become excellent early childhood educators, but I think that they do need a bridge before entering college or an apprenticeship, given the multitude of barriers that they are facing daily. We have a pre-apprenticeship partnership with Bank Street College of Education with 33 mothers who have already graduated the program on emotionally responsive practice and early childhood development. Five of those are now pursuing their credentials and we ourselves have hired 19 mothers from the participating group to facilitate our programs. Another 22 women have now just enrolled in our third cohort and are excited to be part of the future workforce. Third, ensuring the expansion means quality and not just more seats. Two-year-olds need developmentally appropriate, relationship-based programs with educators who understand early childhood, who understand their culture, their language, their individual needs. We would be glad to share what we have learned from creating responsive, trauma-informed early childhood spaces for very young children and families living in housing instability. Thank you very... (02:32:22) ...much. Thank you all. I had a question also. For those who have not submitted their testimony, if you can submit written testimony to the committee. You raise a really good point about the providers who just may have a bad taste in their mouth regarding on-time payments and flexibility. Based on what you heard today from the administration, where do you think providers will land? Do you think that based on the commitment to on-time payments and an ongoing conversation around wages, where do you think some of these providers will land in the next cycle? Where do you think... (02:33:04) ...their opinion will change about wanting to be a part of a network, or do they want to remain independent and figure out the best way to be included in this program? Thank you for the question. I think that especially in this year with our new administration, and I am sure now that Phillips is here, there will continue to be a lot of community engagement. There have been a lot of efforts to attend educator meetings in the evenings and on the weekends. I have seen them speaking at any and all events. So I do think that if that can continue and if additional information can be shared transparently and in a timely manner, I think that will help. I do think there are... (02:33:49) ...will continue to be some educators who will say, "This is my business. I started this from the ground up and I fear that I will lose control of my business or some of my agency if I participate with the network." So I think there will always be educators who are not open to that possibility, but I do think that many have appreciated the engagement so far and I think there is still tremendous ability to continue the conversation and the dialogue. Thank you. (02:34:16) Betty, a question for you. Thank you so much for your advocacy on behalf of families with special needs. I know at the last hearing you shared some of those concerns. Based on what you heard today on the proposed expansion to 10,000 seats for 2K, for example, is there an urgent list of programs or supports where you feel this is absolutely necessary if we are going to expand from 2,000 to 10,000? There is a lot. It is no longer a pilot. What is your list of urgent focus areas for families with special needs considering this vast expansion? (02:35:00) Yeah, so I think to highlight from the testimony would be ensuring that there is a process for providers to be able — when the provider itself cannot meet the needs of a child with a disability, and again many will be able to support students with disabilities in their program — but for children with more significant needs, really being able to have, for the provider and the parent, a mechanism to be able to request accommodations, request additional support, and to consider whether some of those models that we have for 3K and pre-K might be necessary for two-year-olds as well. Whether that be a more specialized setting, perhaps a smaller class ratio for children with disabilities with experienced staff, or programs that run preschool special education classes. This is really focusing on children with the most significant... (02:35:53) ...needs. And for parents of two-year-olds, potentially, how do they need to be prompted to engage in these conversations with their provider? I know that what I am most familiar with is 3K and pre-K, and as they said, it is different — it could be very different. What are some of those prompts that providers can be on the lookout for, or that we can just share with parents today, about what to do if their two-year-old is enrolled in a program or just in general... (02:36:21) ...what are some of those questions that we can pose so they can start those conversations with their providers? Some children come in already having been participating in early intervention, so those families have already been working with developmental providers and service providers, and having those providers be able to come serve their children is important. But for many families, this is going to be their first time having their child in any type of educational program. That is when developmental screenings become really important, and those conversations with families on understanding that children develop differently, understanding where their child is in their stage of development, and that there are additional resources and supports that can help their child meet specific milestones. Excellent. Thank you. (02:37:09) Thank you all so much for your testimony, appreciated. I want to call the next panel: Stephanie Crane, Sehgal Qatari — I deeply apologize for mispronouncing that — Joel Perry Stein, Carol Lazar Ritas, Camilla Farooqi and then Amy Lee. We did not have Amy Lee from the last panel. If Amy Lee is not here, I very quickly — as I see her escaping the room — I want to acknowledge Simone Hawkins, our former Deputy Chancellor. Thank you for being here. Bye, darling. Stephanie Crane, Sehgal Qatari, Joel Perry Stein, Carol Lazar Ritas — my apologies — Camilla Farooqi and Amy Lee, if we still have you. Wonderful. (02:38:12) Only three made it. Only three survived. (02:38:16) Thank you all. You can start whenever you are ready. Just push that button. (02:38:38) Yeah. Thank you. Good afternoon, Chair. I will be reading from my testimony, but before I do that I do want to thank Annie and Philip, because I am also getting those email responses back at sometimes midnight. So it is noted. Right now it is funny. I like that. That is great. That is beautiful. They are very helpful and we appreciate it. (02:39:09) So my name is Camilla Farooqi and I am founder of Manhattan School House. We serve about 200 children on the Upper East Side and Chelsea area. We have been raising the standards of early childhood education in New York City for 15 years. I came to this work as a working mother who struggled to find child care for my own son. We used a patchwork system as both my partner and I were full-time workers. I believe in universal child care with everything I have. I support the expansion to 2K. I am here today because the providers expected to deliver that expansion are being pushed to the edge of survival and the committee needs to hear what that looks like from the ground. Community-based programs are the providers who are providing about 60% of 3K and the 2K expansion cannot succeed without them. The issues have been repeated, and just like early childhood educators know that repetition creates deep learning and understanding, I will repeat them again. Payment delays: this fall, we nearly could not open because of those delays. Pay parity: we retrain the teachers and we lose them. Just this summer, we lost about five teachers to DOE because of pay parity. Frozen rates and a rising cost of hiring is impossible in this market, and that goes for teachers, assistant teachers, floaters and administrators. Regulations are written far from what the ground reality in the classrooms is. So here is what we recommend to have a successful expansion of 2K: register contracts before the fiscal year begins with advanced payments to providers. Pay parity in salary and benefits for educators doing the same work as their DOE counterparts. Annual cost of living adjustments. Timely invoice payments. Smart regulations, not more regulations. Coordination among agencies — providers are not go-betweens between these agencies. Real incentives for providers to open 2K classes, because without them small and minority- and women-owned businesses risk losing a permanent seat at the table. There are two things that did not come up today that I would like to mention. One is that as we talk about staffing for 2K and 3K, we are being hollowed out for infant-toddler programs, because many of the institutions are really focused on 3K and pre-K but not really infant-toddler, and that is the struggle we have if we are really talking about universal child care. Universal child care starts from birth, so we have to really think about that. Secondly, I will also mention one thing about regulations. I will give you one example: a director here in New York City needs to have a master's degree with certification. Just around the corner in Westchester, that is not a requirement. So why would many of our professionals be moving out of the city to get these jobs? (02:43:49) So thank you. Again, thank you. Can you submit that testimony by email? I have already done that and I will do it again. Okay, wonderful. Thank you. Next. (02:44:06) Good afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the Early Childhood Subcommittee. I am Sehgal Qatari, First Vice President. Thank you to the Council for holding this meeting and thank you to Mayor Mamdani and Chancellor Samuels for recognizing the financial pressure facing early childhood centers and taking action. The investment in additional staffing, faster contracting and emergency bridge loans represents meaningful support. We look forward to working together with all the stakeholders to ensure providers receive the funds they need. These problems predate this administration, but as we expand early childhood education we must change the conditions that keep producing these problems. Every new classroom adds contracting, budgeting and payment responsibilities. The City must ensure its administrative capacity grows alongside the programs it promises families. Providers need contracts completed before services begin, timely advanced payments, clear reimbursement schedules and reliable contacts who can resolve problems before payroll is threatened. Emergency loans can help centers through a crisis. However, our goal as a system must be one where centers no longer need emergency financing to perform work this City has already agreed to fund. We also need contracts that reflect the actual cost of operating these programs, which include annual cost adjustments and protect centers from destabilizing revenue losses when enrollment fluctuates modestly. Rent and staffing obligations do not disappear because a few seats are temporarily unfilled. Finally, reliable funding must support a stable workforce. Director and assistant director pay parity remains essential. These leaders supervise instruction, mentor educators, manage compliance and keep programs functioning through constant change. Expansion depends on retaining their experience. Again, we commend the administration's recent action. Let us build on it so that timely payments, sustainable funding and supported leadership become the foundation of the universal child care system in New York City. Thank you. (02:46:55) Thank you, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the Subcommittee for the opportunity to testify today. My name is Sehgal Qatari. I am a pediatrician and the Programme Director of Upper Manhattan Connect, SUMAC, which is a division of Literacy and... (02:47:08) A lot of literacy to meet me here today. Her family, in the years before kindergarten, brings many questions: is my child meeting their developmental milestones? Where can I find support? How does early intervention even work? How do I navigate to K, pre-K or 3-K? Families should not need to become experts in New York City early childhood systems to get the support that their children need, yet our City's early childhood landscape can be difficult to parse, particularly for families who are new to New York or speak a language other than English. Or unfamiliar with any of these processes. For many immigrant families, uncertainty surrounding public institutions creates an additional barrier. UMA builds a bridge caregivers can cross to get started. Our early childhood ambassadors help families build comfort and understanding in key areas of healthy development, from milestones and early learning resources to early intervention, childcare and K to kindergarten readiness. Ambassadors create a partnership with caregivers hand in hand. They make referrals, break down options, assist with complex paperwork and encourage families to self-advocate and ask key questions. As the City expands 2-K, this kind of support needs to be part of the investment. Families do not experience childcare and 2-K as separate programs. They experience it all as one journey — their child's journey. Our systems are obligated to foster that journey. We urge the City to invest in 2-K seats and the trusted family engagement that helps families find opportunities, access them effectively and connect to the array of available services in New York City. Success should be measured not only by how many seats are created, but by whether families can reach these seats and all of their benefits. (02:48:58) Thank you. Thank you all so much for your testimony. Now we are going to move on to our online panelists. We have Laurie... Laurie, can Zoe Sperrazza and Adrian Bond. Okay. Oh, my apologies. I want to call first Laurie Cangialosi. My apologies. Laurie, are you still on? I think it is... let us give it a moment. Okay, we can wait. Laurie, can you hear us? Okay. We can come back to Laurie. Is Zoe Sperrazza available on Zoom? You can unmute yourself. Hi. Can you hear me? Yes. Are you Zoe? (02:50:42) Yes. Yes, I am Zoe. Thank you so much. But if you will give me just one moment. Sorry about that. Zoe, please go ahead. Oh, can you hear me? I can totally hear you. Do you want to be off camera? That is allowed? Yes. Well, I am actually going to pull over right now. (02:51:02) Thank you. Yeah. No, I do not... and you are... okay, so... (02:51:17) Chair and members of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education, my name is Dr. Zoe Sperrazza and I am the Education Director at Kiddie Academy of Williamsburg, serving children and families in Brooklyn. I am also a lifelong educator. I hold a doctorate in education and leadership and, perhaps most importantly to the testimony I am going to give today, I am the mother of a two-year-old who is here in the back seat, and I am expecting our second child currently. I know the life of an elementary school teacher. Apparently, my child hack was to get my master's in early childhood and my certification for second grade, both of which are requirements as we mentioned earlier. I am in a demanding free care as part of my compensation. I am here to ask the City to make a commitment that is long overdue and to advocate for my staff: pay equity and meaningful salary increases for all educators serving New York City's youngest children, including 2-K, pre-K and pre-K educators working in community-based organizations. Our early childhood education is in crisis. As an education director, I see the consequences firsthand. We are expected to recruit and retain highly qualified, educated, experienced teachers to do extraordinarily important work, yet we are asking those teachers to accept compensation that does not reflect their education credentials, responsibilities or value. We are competing for educators in a city where qualified teachers have other opportunities — opportunities that often provide significantly better compensation, clear salary progression, benefits and greater long-term financial stability. This is not simply a staffing problem. It is a quality problem, an equity problem and ultimately a problem for New York City's children. A teacher should not become less valuable because she walks into a community-based classroom instead of a district school classroom. A degree does not become less valuable. A teaching certification does not become less valuable. Years of experience do not become less valuable. And most importantly, the children sitting in that classroom do not become less deserving of an exceptional teacher. As an administrator and a mother, I refuse to accept the idea that the solution is simply to lower our expectations. We should not be expected to diminish the quality of care and education we provide because we cannot afford to compete for highly qualified teachers. We should not lower hiring standards. We should not normalize constant turnover. We should not ask programs to somehow do more with less while simultaneously holding them accountable for increasingly rigorous educational outcomes. And we should certainly not accept a system where our youngest and most vulnerable children, who cannot advocate for themselves, experience the consequences of decisions made about how much the adults educating them are worth. Our teachers deserve a real salary scale comparable to other New York City educators. I am a big believer that you get what you pay for. New York City made an extraordinary commitment when it decided that early childhood education should be made available to its children, but access alone cannot be the finish line. Universal education must also mean high-quality education, and quality requires an investment in the people doing the teaching. We cannot expect programs to solve a workforce crisis that they did not create and cannot financially solve alone. We absolutely cannot accept less for our children. The City owes that to its educators. The City owes that to its families. And most of all, the City owes that to its children. Thank you very much. (02:55:08) Thank you, Zoe, and best of luck. When you are not mobile, please email the testimony if you have not already. Will do. Thank you so much. Thank you. That was a beautiful testimony. Okay, Lori is back. Lori Cangialosi, my apologies. You can unmute yourself. (02:55:38) Thank you. There you are. (02:55:40) Hey, as soon as I started to talk it shut down. I am like, oh my... (02:55:44) God. Go for it. Good Chair... (02:55:46) ...and members of the Committee on Early Childhood. My name is Laurie Cangelosi. I am the Director of the Play Group Experience, a NICEY in Staten Island and founder of the Five Boroughs NICEY Coalition. I know you hear this over and over and over again: NICEY teachers educate the same children, meet the same standards and provide the same publicly funded education as their DOE counterparts without the same compensation, benefits or protections. We know the problem is real. The struggle is real and, quite frankly, I am tired of constantly repeating ourselves. So today I do not want to just talk about the problem. I want to talk about a solution. NICEY educators should not have to come back every few years and renegotiate our worth. Create a NICEY compensation structure tied to comparable salary scales, recognize education and years of experience, include our assistant teachers, and fund seat compensation increases. When NICEY funding should increase with it. (02:56:54) Directors want to pay our educators what they deserve, but we cannot pay money the City has not funded. And this... (02:57:01) ...is not just about teachers. It is about children. When we lose teachers, young children lose familiar faces, trust, relationships and consistency. And as we discuss expanding 2-K, we cannot expand on an unequal system. Stop making NICEY educators repeatedly prove that equal work deserves equal value. Reform before expansion. You cannot build a strong early childhood system on an unequal foundation. Fix the foundation and then let us build. Thank you. (02:57:31) Thank you, Laurie. And our last panelist, Adrian Bond. Good afternoon. (02:57:47) Good afternoon, everyone, Council, Deputy Chancellor, and Speaker. Thank you for this time and for listening to us. I speak among so many voices — like everyone is saying the same thing repeatedly — but I speak for them when I say I have lived everything that everyone spoke about. By the way, my name is Adrian Bond and I am the Executive Director of Quick Start Daycare Center. We are located in Queens and we have lived everything that everyone spoke about today. We were that center that struggled to barely open up. We came from schools that were closing. We were holding on by a thread. We worked through the entire summer with no funding. We had to wait and we stuck it out, with the help of many emails, and I thank God that she listened and she insisted and we were able to open up. We serve over... by the way, we have all three programs here and it is just so unfair that we have these disparities. We have a problem with funding. We start with pre-K parity, but yet our staff show up to service these families and these children. We are providing a service and we should not be looked down upon. We should be part of building this foundation. We do not want to struggle every day. We are happy to service the kids, to educate them. We have a building full of certified educators. Even our assistant teachers are at the college level and we struggle. It is like we are begging for help with funding all the time and we should not have to, when we are supplying quality care for these children and parents. We just ask for a full partnership. We cannot build if we do not all work together in unison, and that covers everything from the salaries to supplying the everyday necessities to running the buildings. I heard someone say every month: do I pay my staff or do I pay for the building itself? Everything that it takes to function and run daily — it is a lot. I really hope to see positive change. I really hope the Deputy Chancellor coming in will help us. I would love... we welcome anyone to come in and see what we offer and what we do on a daily basis, and then you will understand why they say the struggle is real. It really is, because we are doing all of our part. Our voices come out and tell us we are doing such a great job, but why is it such a fight to manage every month — paying our staff and paying the household bills to continue functioning? Something needs to be done about the funding, about the invoices being paid in a timely manner, and about always working with us better and more clearly, all across the board. Something needs to be done in order for us to keep functioning. I thank you all and I look forward to an improvement. I see it. I know it is going to come, but we need it sooner... (03:00:53) ...rather than later. Yes, thank you. Thank you. Thank you for your testimony and you are a hundred percent right. I do feel they are committed to figuring this out. No one wants to close their doors or turn staff away. That is, I am sure, your worst-case scenario. Thank you so much. Thank you. All right. Thank you all so much. Thank you to the administration for staying. Once again, we heard a lot of praise today about your responsiveness and hopefully we will carry on this discussion. We will see many of you all at the end of our third hearing of the month. Thank you to everyone who testified and thanks to the team here. That concludes...