Supporting Multi-Language Learners in Early Childhood Education Programs
Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education
Meeting overview
The Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education, chaired by Jennifer Gutierrez, held an oversight hearing on two items: T2026-2404, examining how the City supports multilingual learners in early childhood education, and T2026-2581 (Res 0650-2026), a resolution opposing the federal proposed rule titled "Reducing Federal Burden for Head Start Programs," which would among other things require all Head Start instruction to be conducted solely in English. The hearing came against the backdrop of the Trump administration's executive order designating English as the official language of the United States and a notice of proposed rulemaking on English instruction requirements in Head Start programs, with a public comment deadline of October 6.
The Mamdani administration sent Emmy List from the Mayor's Office of Child Care and Early Childhood Education and Eric Phillips, the newly appointed Deputy Chancellor for Early Childhood Education at NYC Public Schools, along with several senior officials. Their testimony was thorough and generally positive in tone, describing a system with 99 verified dual language bilingual education sites across the city, covering Spanish, Mandarin, Russian, French, Italian, Polish, Korean and Arabic. They described the identification process for emergent multilingual learners in early childhood, which relies on family self-reporting via the state's Emergent Multilingual Learner Language Profile rather than the formal NYSITELL assessment used in K-12. The administration emphasized culturally and linguistically responsive instruction across all programs, job-embedded coaching for educators, and the aspiration to expand dual language offerings into 3-K, noting two newly opened 3-K dual language programs this year in Districts 15 and 31. They were notably candid that there are no additional state mandates requiring multilingual supports in early childhood settings -- the Division of Early Childhood Education has made this a policy commitment of its own rather than a legal requirement. On funding, the administration confirmed there is no dedicated funding stream specifically for dual language pre-K programs beyond per-seat allocations, with a supplemental bilingual revitalization school allocation memorandum distributing around $1.3 million to 193 schools for professional learning, family engagement and supplemental materials.
The Independent Budget Office, represented by Emma Gossett, provided useful quantitative context, noting that 34% of pre-K students enrolled in NYC Public Schools operated or contracted programs spoke a language other than English at home, across more than 140 languages, and that 73% of New York City's 18,000 Head Start students in 2024-2025 were dual language learners who speak Spanish at home. The IBO flagged that if the proposed federal rule takes effect, families currently served by Head Start's multilingual programming will look to NYC Public Schools and private providers to fill the gap -- a system that, as the hearing made clear, is already under-resourced relative to demand. Applications for dual language pre-K slots showed 1,574 for Spanish alone, dwarfing available supply.
Community advocates and service providers added important texture. Advocates for Children flagged a serious compliance failure: of roughly 4,000 preschoolers entitled to bilingual special education programs and services in 2024-2025, 65% did not receive them -- a legal obligation, not a policy aspiration. Joanne Derwin of One World Project, the Spanish immersion CBO in Windsor Terrace that Gutierrez had visited, described running a universal pre-K program at a $120,000 annual deficit because the DOE per-seat rate does not cover costs, and noted she had turned down a 3-K contract for the same reason. Early Starters described working with newly arrived families in shelters who face not only language barriers but fears about sharing basic information like zip codes with city systems. City's First Readers and Literacy in Community Link emphasized the importance of home language as the foundation for literacy and called for investment in family-centered early literacy programs and educator professional development. The hearing generated real energy around expansion of dual language into 3-K and 2-K and better alignment between community-based providers and the public system, but no formal votes were taken and no legislation was passed.
The record
Numbers
- Approximately 45% of children ages zero to five in New York State identify as multilingual learners, above the national average of 32%.
- NYC Public Schools currently operates 99 verified dual language bilingual education program sites.
- Total emergent multilingual learners across the early childhood portfolio (pre-K, 3-K, 2-K and infant programs) as of current enrollment: 30,058.
- Breakdown: 12,725 in pre-K; 6,737 in 3-K; 581 in 2-K; 15 in infant programs.
- 34% of pre-K students enrolled in NYC Public Schools operated or contracted programs spoke a language other than English at home.
- Families served across 3-K and pre-K programs speak over 140 different languages.
- The five most common home languages across 3-K and pre-K: Spanish (18% of all enrolled students), followed by Chinese languages, Bengali, Russian and Arabic.
- Pre-K dual language programs received the following applications by language: 1,574 Spanish, 129 Chinese, 100 French, 60 Russian, 47 Italian, 24 Korean, 17 Arabic, 3 Polish.
- 3-K dual language programs received 60 applications for Spanish and 28 for Russian.
- Over 80% of families were able to get one of their top school choices for dual language programs.
- Dual language programs target a 50/50 split between native speakers of the partner language and English-speaking families opting in.
- 108 teachers are certified as lead teachers in dual language classrooms; 183 pre-K dual language licensed teachers hold a birth-to-two certificate or are on a pathway to it.
- New York State requires 15% of all continuing teacher and leader professional learning to be focused on multilingual learners; bilingual-certified teachers must devote 50% of their professional learning to multilingual learners.
- Funding for programs offering dual language learning in early childhood is approximately $30 million.
- A bilingual revitalization school allocation memorandum distributed approximately $1.3 million to 193 schools for professional learning, family engagement and supplemental materials; new programs received $1,000 each.
- NYC Head Start programs in 2024-2025 served 18,000 children across 150 programs, including 900 homeless students, over 600 students with IEPs, approximately 30 foster children and over 580 pregnant women.
- 73% of New York City's enrolled Head Start students -- approximately 14,000 children -- were dual language learners who speak Spanish at home.
- About 25% of Head Start staff spoke Spanish; 35% of staff were proficient in a language other than English; over 400 families participated in ESL training over the course of the year.
- Over 800 parent volunteers participated in Head Start programs in 2024-2025.
- Of approximately 4,000 preschoolers entitled to bilingual special education programs and services in 2024-2025, 65% did not receive them.
- One World Project's universal pre-K contract generates an annual deficit of approximately $120,000; the DOE rate leaves teachers earning roughly $25,000 less per year than their public school counterparts.
- NYC Public Schools previously served as grant recipient for approximately 30% of Head Start programs in the city; their grant was not renewed and they no longer oversee Head Start programs.
Action Points
- NYC Public Schools to provide the committee with the locations of the two new 3-K dual language programs (confirmed as District 15 for Spanish and District 31 for Russian, but formal follow-up on full details requested).
- NYC Public Schools to provide the committee with data on how many existing kindergarten dual language programs also have a pre-K dual language component.
- NYC Public Schools to provide the committee with annual data on how many dual language programs have been closed in recent years.
- NYC Public Schools officials to visit One World Project in Windsor Terrace, as encouraged by Chair Gutierrez.
- NYC Public Schools to follow up with Advocates for Children regarding a specific family waiting for a special education evaluation in Bengali to determine current status and expedite resolution.
- Administration to improve information in MySchools directories so families can clearly understand what enhanced language supports are available at each program and what they entail, per advocacy community recommendation.
- Administration to conduct more robust and targeted multilingual outreach to immigrant communities about Two-K, Three-K and Pre-K programs and provide hands-on support through the application and registration process.
- Administration to examine data on which kindergarten dual language programs lack a corresponding pre-K dual language program and develop a plan to address continuity gaps.
- Administration to accelerate the classroom conversion strategy to open new dual language classrooms in schools already operating dual language programs.
- Administration to develop and disseminate clearer, family-facing communications about dual language and multilingual programming options to improve public awareness, as urged by CM Brewer.
- NYC Public Schools to share data with the committee on progress of the bilingual educator pipeline and pathways for educators to obtain bilingual extensions.
- Chair Gutierrez to encourage members of the public to submit comments to the Federal Register on the proposed Head Start rule changes before the October 6 deadline.
- Administration to follow up with the committee on how schools are supported when considering opening a new pre-K dual language program within an existing kindergarten dual language school.
- Early Starters to continue workforce development collaboration with CUNY and Bank Street College of Education and to pursue expanded apprenticeship slots beyond the current five.
- City's First Readers to continue outreach to nontraditional settings including clinics, hospitals and WIC centers, and to pursue technology investment to allow smaller partners to update the program directory without manual intervention.
Full Transcript
Good afternoon and welcome to today's hearing of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education. At this time I would like to remind everyone to silence all electronic devices. Also, going forward, no one is to approach the dais. If you would like to sign up for in-person testimony, please see one of the sergeants at arms. Thank you.
Thank you and good afternoon everyone. I am CM Jennifer Gutiérrez, Chair of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education, and welcome to today's hearing. A special welcome to the incoming learners and early childhood education programs joining us today.
New York City is widely recognized as the most linguistically diverse city in the world — shout out to Queens. In New York State, the proportion of multilingual young children is higher than the national average of 32%, with approximately 45% of young children ages zero to five in New York identifying as multilingual learners. Access to multilingual early childhood education serves as a critical cornerstone for both cognitive development and social equity. Nurturing children's home languages develops their positive sense of self and cultural identity. It also maintains strong ties with family and community and supports young children's social and emotional regulation. Research shows a clear relationship between the age of exposure to a language and a child's success in learning that language. Yet a 2025 study of New York City's pre-kindergarten program found that there are not nearly enough designated bilingual pre-K programs available to support the growing number of multilingual learners.
Last year, President Trump issued an executive order designating English as the official language of the United States, and about a month ago his administration released a notice of proposed rulemaking on English instruction requirements in all Head Start programs. With the persistent federal attacks on multilingual services, now is the time for the City to step up its commitment to all of its residents in providing these services, including to our youngest learners. So today we will ask the administration: how are you supporting multilingual early childhood education students across our City? Are you planning to expand multilingual support as the early childhood education system grows? How are you informing multilingual families about their early childhood education options?
We will also hear Res 0650-2026, sponsored by myself, opposing the federally proposed rule change titled Reducing Federal Burden for Head Start Programs and calling on the Federal Government to prioritize protecting and growing access to high quality education for young children.
I want to thank the members of our Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education who have joined us today: CM Rita C. Joseph, CM Simcha Felder and, online, CM Kayla Santosuosso — shout out to Brooklyn. Thank you all for being here today. I also want to thank the staff of our committee: Julia Goldsmith, Katie Selina, Grace Amato and Julin Lawless and Margaret Barnsley, as well as my own staff, for their work on today's hearing. And finally, thank you to everyone who has signed up to testify. We look forward to hearing from you.
Good afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education. My name is Emmy List and I am the Executive Director of the Mayor's Office of Child Care and Early Childhood Education. I am joined today by my colleagues from New York City Public Schools and we would like to thank you for convening this important hearing and giving us the opportunity to testify before you.
The Mamdani Administration is committed to a vision of universal child care — a City in which every child under five has access to free, high quality early care and education offered in a range of culturally competent settings with caregivers and educators who are trained, respected and fairly compensated. Supporting multilingual learners is a critical component of the Mayor's goal, because we know that child care cannot be universal in one of the most diverse cities in the world unless we support multilingual learners and providers. All children deserve access to rich early learning environments that honor and celebrate their heritage and support their growth, no matter what language they speak at home. We are also blessed as a City with thousands of early childhood educators who speak languages other than English in their classrooms and programs, allowing children of all backgrounds to feel a sense of belonging and to thrive.
Creating early childhood education environments that support and encourage multilingual learning benefits from research and evidence. I also share this from experience. Last year my son was enrolled in one of the City's pre-K dual language programs. As a child coming from an English-speaking home, he had a chance to learn with and from his peers who came from Spanish-speaking homes. I saw the ways in which the children learned from each other and saw each other's language skills as an asset and a strength. All of the parents in the classroom were able to engage with the educators and with the day-to-day lessons regardless of which language we spoke at home. I know the benefits that I saw are not unique to my son's experience alone and represent what many families and educators experience every day.
Together with our partners at the New York City Public Schools Division of Early Childhood Education, the Mayor's Office of Child Care and Early Childhood Education has been working closely on a number of initiatives and programs toward the goal of delivering free, high quality care and education for every child under five in New York City. I am thrilled to introduce my newest colleague, who recently joined the Division as the new Deputy Chancellor for Early Childhood Education. Deputy Chancellor Phillips brings decades of experience in early childhood education and has worked closely with child care providers who are serving multilingual children. She will now share more background on the work that the Division of Early Childhood Education is doing to support multilingual
learners, and we look forward to then taking your questions.
Thank you and good afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education. My name is Eric Phillips and I serve as the Deputy Chancellor for Early Childhood Education at New York City Public Schools. I am joined today by Dr. Georgette Branch, Chief of Learning and Partnerships; Dr. Brenda Garcia, Chief of the Office of Multilingual Learners; and Dr. Arabella Pembroke, Senior Director of Inclusion and Support for Emergent Multilingual Learners. Thank you for the opportunity to be here and for your continued partnership in supporting New York City's youngest learners.
I come to this role with more than 20 years of experience across early childhood and K through 12 education, business and nonprofit leadership. Much of my career has been focused on building systems that support young children and families while assisting the educators and caregivers who serve them. Before joining New York City Public Schools, I served as the Executive Director of the National Association for Family Child Care, where I worked at the federal level to strengthen early learning programs, advance child care policies and elevate the voices of the early educators and providers who have served as the backbone of the early childhood system. Previously I spent eight years at an early childhood organization focused on supporting home-based child care providers, where I helped to bring its family network to New York City. This work is deeply personal to me as the daughter and granddaughter of early educators and caregivers.
I am honored to bring those experiences to New York City Public Schools and to lead our work to strengthen early care and education for children and families across New York City. Thank you for the opportunity to discuss how we support emergent multilingual children and families across early childhood programs in New York City, as well as our early childhood dual language bilingual education program.
New York City's children enter our early childhood programs with tremendous linguistic and cultural assets. Across our early childhood system, children are learning English while also developing one of the many other languages spoken by New York City families. Our responsibility is to build an early childhood system that recognizes those languages as strengths, provides children with developmentally appropriate opportunities to learn across languages and ensures that families have meaningful access to their children's education.
The process for identifying emergent multilingual learners in early childhood differs from the process used to identify English language learners in K through 12 schools under Commissioner's Regulation Part 150. For K through 12 schools, a formal process for identifying English language learners is followed, including the home language questionnaire, an individual interview when appropriate and the New York State Identification Test for English Language Proficiency assessment.
Those requirements do not apply in the same way in early childhood settings, where children are identified as emergent multilingual learners based on information families provide about their child's language background and experiences. New York State uses the Emergent Multilingual Learner Language Profile, a family-completed survey available in 24 languages, that asks which languages are spoken by parents and caregivers, which languages the child understands and uses and the family's preferred language for program communication.
The purpose is not to measure English proficiency but to identify children whose home or primary language is other than English, to help programs plan linguistically responsive instruction and supports across early childhood settings. Multilingualism is treated as an asset. All programs are required to support multilingual learners by using developmentally appropriate practices such as visual aids, modeling, intentional vocabulary development, home language connections, family partnerships and culturally and linguistically responsive instruction. The goal is to enable all children to fully participate in learning while also developing English.
Emergent multilingual learners across early childhood settings experience culturally and linguistically responsive learning experiences. Our emergent multilingual guidance as well as ongoing professional learning supports educators with instructional strategies. Those include using children's home languages and linguistic strengths, visuals and real objects, gestures, intentional vocabulary development, repeated readings, family knowledge and developmentally appropriate observation across languages and communication modalities.
As reflected in the New York State Education Department's Blueprint for Multilingual Learner Success, we believe all teachers are teachers of multilingual learners. Every educator can create an environment in which children's languages are visible, valued and incorporated meaningfully into learning. These distinctions matter because while dual language bilingual education is a specific program model, the responsibility for supporting emergent multilingual learners belongs to the entire early childhood ecosystem. The Department of Early Childhood Education works in partnership with the Office of Multilingual Learners to align this work within the broader New York City Public Schools guidance and resources for multilingual learners, while ensuring that supports reflect the particular needs of young children in early childhood settings.
Multilingualism intersects with other areas of a child's development. A child can be an emergent multilingual learner and also have a disability. Supporting that child requires educators and families to consider language development, communication, learning and disability together. Language differences should not be mistaken for disability, nor should a disability result in a child's linguistic strengths being overlooked. That is why our work to support inclusion and emergent multilingual learners must remain connected, supporting family partnership and multiple sources of information to understand how a child communicates and learns across languages and settings.
In practice, this means providing multiple ways for children to access instruction and demonstrate understanding. Educators can pair spoken language with visuals, gestures, modeling, objects and assistive technology; intentionally build vocabulary in both English and the child's home language; break directions into smaller steps; provide repetition and additional processing time and use predictable routines that reduce linguistic and cognitive demands. Small group instruction, peer modeling and opportunities to respond through speech, movement, pictures or other communication systems can also support participation. For children with IEPs, accommodations and specialized supports should be integrated with culturally and linguistically responsive instruction. Families are critical partners in identifying how children communicate, what they understand in their home language and what strategies are most effective across settings.
Families are essential partners in the education of emergent multilingual learners across the diverse early childhood settings that we support, including our dual language bilingual education programs. During enrollment, families have access to translated information and programs use multilingual staff, interpretation resources and appropriate translation technology to communicate with families. New York City Public Schools also provides broader language access supports including written translation and in-person, virtual and over-the-phone interpretation services. Families can access interpretation in many languages and early childhood
communications and enrollment resources are available in multiple languages. Additionally, center-based settings and family child care networks have access to over-the-phone interpretation services and translation templates to support direct communication with families, whether in person or by phone. For family child care providers, the affiliated family child care network is responsible for ensuring providers can communicate with families and connect them to interpretation and translation resources.
Our work is to strengthen consistency across the system so that a family's ability to communicate with their child's program does not depend solely on the language skills of individual staff members. Technology can support that work but it should not replace high quality human translation and interpretation, particularly when families are making important decisions
about enrollment, instruction, special education or other services. The early childhood dual language bilingual education program model provides instruction in English and a partner language across district schools, pre-K centers and contracted community-based early childhood programs. We have 99 verified dual language bilingual education program sites across New York City. Partner languages represented across these programs include Spanish, Mandarin Chinese, Russian, French, Italian, Polish, Korean and Arabic.
Dual language programming is an important component of how New York City Public Schools support multilingual learners across our early childhood system. Programs provide language supports that include bilingual or multilingual staff, translated family communications, interpretation at family meetings and instructional practices that support the continued development of both English and a child's home language.
An early childhood dual language bilingual education program is not automatically established when a particular number of children who speak one language are enrolled. The linguistic profile of enrolled and prospective families, parental interest, staffing and bilingual educator capacity, program quality, geography, enrollment sustainability and opportunities for continuity into elementary school are all considered when determining where dual language bilingual education programs can be established and sustained.
The strength of any dual language program depends heavily on its educators. Early childhood dual language bilingual education programs require appropriately credentialed bilingual educators, and we recognize that the available pool of bilingual certified early childhood teachers is more limited than the general early childhood workforce. New York State and NYC support pathways for educators to obtain bilingual extensions, and strengthening that pipeline remains important as we consider future expansion.
Furthermore, across all early childhood settings, we believe every educator can create environments that support emergent multilingual learners. Instructional coordinators, education administrators and other members of DECE's instructional support structure work within programs on curriculum, instructional practice, professional learning and implementation. DECE has access to several important sources of information, including home language information, enrollment data, the early childhood emergent multilingual learner profile, My Schools information, Teaching Strategies GOLD provider information, current dual language bilingual education program locations and languages, and K-12 bilingual education program data. These data provide an increasingly strong foundation for planning.
Our goal is to continue strengthening our data infrastructure so we can better understand where emergent multilingual learners are being served, what languages are being represented, where opportunities may be limited and how program quality and access can improve over time.
Looking ahead, our work to support emergent multilingual learners is focused on several priorities. First is using data to identify potential gaps in professional learning cycles and build educator capacity. The second is strengthening the bilingual educator pipeline while continuing to build the capacity of all early childhood educators to support multilingual children. The third is to strengthen implementation support to enhance the quality of children's learning experiences. The fourth is to ensure families have meaningful language access and a clear voice in determining which programs best meet the needs of their children.
Our goal this year is to build sustainable, high quality programs in the communities where children and families need them, while ensuring that every multilingual learner across our early childhood system is supported whether or not that child attends a designated dual language bilingual education program. We appreciate the Subcommittee's attention to this work and the Council's continued partnership on behalf of New York City's youngest learners and families. Thank you for the opportunity to testify today.
And I look forward to your questions. Thank you, Deputy Chancellor. I also want to acknowledge CM Kevin Riley who joined us. Thank you both for your very thoughtful testimonies. I just want to start by saying my child is also in a dual language program and was able to participate in the pre-K classes as an introduction, and that is what really kind of exposed me to understanding the value of this program as early as four and even younger. So thank you for this testimony.
I wanted to ask just to start... you have something for me? No, I am sorry to interrupt, but they have scheduled you to go. Of course, that is okay. Okay, thank you. Councilmember, in the interest of transparency, thank you. Can you just start... can you define... I graduated from public schools here. I think when I went to school it was... what was it? ESL class? It was just like the entry level. And I know that the vocabulary and the language classifications have changed, so can you just share...
...with me how... yes, so we are thinking very expansively about how we are supporting multilingual learners. To frame it the way that we view that for early childhood is a little bit different than how we view English language learners in K through 12. So I am going to ask my colleague Dr. Branch to provide some detail on how we define our multilingual learners for early childhood, and then Dr. Garcia can share what it looks like in K through 12. Thank you.
Good morning. Good morning, Chair. So in early childhood education, the way that we define our emergent multilingual learners is students who come from a home that speaks a language other than English. So essentially families self-identify and they tell us that their little one speaks Spanish, or is learning to speak Spanish, or another language in addition to English. So that is the definition.
Thank you, that seems easy enough. What is the definition? How is it different from then...
K through 12, or one through 12? Ah, hungry? Yes.
Good afternoon, Chair. Thank you for the question. So the state introduced the term "multilingual learner" and it is an umbrella term. Multilingual learner includes...
...English language learners, which I will define in a minute, former English language learners — so those are kids who were ELLs at some point — and it also includes any student who is learning a new language, so that virtually could be any student in our system taking a world language course or heritage language...
...course. English language learners are the students who actually are entitled, as per Part 154, to English language acquisition instruction. So it used to be called English as a Second Language. Now it is called English as a New Language, or transitional bilingual education programs, or dual...
...language bilingual education programs. Those are the three program models. Wow, thank you. Excellent. And I know it is nuanced, but what you shared seems simple on one level and more nuanced on another. Is there any plan... does this feel like the appropriate definition for early childhood for the foreseeable future?
And I believe it is the most appropriate because all of our students are emergent learners — they are emergent language learners. Some of our students come in with very little language initially. They are coming in as early as six months, so we are really looking to the families to share information in terms of what they see as the best approach, and we utilize that to also honor that. For the foreseeable future, that will continue to be how we define our emergent language learners in early childhood education.
Thank you. Does the framing of the question change for the parent of a six-month-old, two-year-old or three-year-old versus a pre-K student where maybe they have more language? At six months or two years old versus the four-year-old, does that framing change?
It is consistent because at home, whatever language is introduced at home — whether it is the parents' language, or maybe grandma comes over and speaks an additional language — we are really using that information to determine how to best support the child in the classroom. So it may not even just be that it is a French-speaking household, but maybe there are grandparents or individuals who come over who speak Spanish as well. If the family shares that information with us, and the hope and desire is that language acquisition is advanced across all of those languages, then we support that.
Okay, excellent. Thank you. My next question is just regarding data for early childhood. I know that may be a little bit more complicated, but does DECE or the Mayor's Office of Child Care have an estimated number of multilingual learners in early childhood education programs? Yes, we do. Currently we have...
...across the entire portfolio — so across all of our pre-K centers, 3-K, our 2-K expansion and our infant programs — multilingual learners. I can give you the breakdown if you want in terms of pre-K versus 3-K versus 2-K. Would you like that? Yes. Can you repeat that? You said the total is 30...? 30,058. Okay, wow. It is precise. Yes, sometimes you break it down. So in pre-K we have 12,725. 3-K: 6,737. In our 2-K programs: 581. And our infant programs: 15...
...currently. Okay, excellent. Thank you. And then how do you all keep track of this? How often are you being informed of a new family who has been identified as a multilingual learner?
Right, so initially families can actually share that information even when they apply — when they are applying through the My Schools account. But that information is also maintained at the school or at the program, and that information is shared with the division. We are able to keep track of that because in addition to just the numbers and knowing that we have them, we do a lot of coaching. The Division of Early Childhood Education — that is really what I am most proud of — is in terms of how we are really able to support programs and provide support to teachers so that they can better support our multilingual learners. That information is captured and sent over to the division quite often. We have people on the ground who are also able to keep track of that information as well.
Do you find that it will change in the middle of the school year? Maybe a family who just did not respond in the same way for whatever reason — do you find that that happens often, where maybe in the...
...there... actually, yes. It is not typically that it changes for the families, but we get new students, so we have additional multilingual learners in the program. But it is not usually the case that we have a family who says little Johnny is a multilingual learner, he speaks French at home, and now that is no longer the...
...case. No. I think of the reverse, where the way that you defined it earlier could be like maybe abuela comes over once in a while and now they are being exposed in a way that maybe the parents did not anticipate. That is not typical. I would say that it happens from time to time but I think it is inconsequential. Sometimes we take a trip and we absorb a whole lot. Absolutely. Okay, I am going to ask one more question, then pass it to CM Riley for a couple of questions.
Oh sure. And I am sorry, can you just clarify the numbers that you just shared for multilingual learners — is that the current enrollment for 2026-2027 or for last year?
That is our current enrollment. Yep. As of September 2025.
Okay, well thank you. My next question before I pass it off to CM Riley: have you all found that if a family wants a seat in 3-K, pre-K or 2-K, and they want a seat in a particular program, and it is a family whose primary language is a language other than English — have you found that that raises any limitations for what schools they attend or even apply to? Or is that...
...is that a question that you pose to families? That is a great question. So we are very actively looking at what families need, both based on the language of the family and really the demand around all of the programs. We have been monitoring quite a bit. There is really strong demand for the dual language program from families who speak a language other than English and also from families who want to expose their child to another language.
So yes, we do have a lot of interest, and we are focused on making sure that we are prioritizing. Our goal for classes is for them to be 50% native speakers of the language of that program and 50% families who speak another language. We are able to meet families' needs. I think over 80% of families were able to get one of their top schools that they prioritized. There are options and ways that we need to continue to monitor what the demand is, but we are able to prioritize families who need that dual language program.
And is the strong demand that you mentioned particularly for pre-K, or is it a mix? Like, families are in 3-K and...
...what year? The strong demand that I was talking about was for our dual language program specifically. It could be 3-K and it could be pre-K, but specifically thinking about pre-K — and we just for the first time opened up two 3-K dual language programs this year.
Oh great. Where are those programs?
We will have to get back to you on that. All right, I will pass it to CM Riley first.
Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the panel that came out here today for testifying. We truly appreciate it. My question is going to be surrounding our program models and access. So DECE offers dual language and enhanced language support programs. The dual language programs teach English and target languages. So does DECE, in contracted early childhood programs — how many, excuse me, how many DECE contracted early childhood programs currently offer dual language or enhanced language support? And do you have that by borough, language and count? Thank you for that question.
First I will talk a little bit about what we have been discussing — the dual language piece and the enhanced language — and...
...how we think about that, and then I will turn it over to Dr. Branch to provide some of the detail about the specific programs that we have. So dual language: we have 99 of those and they cover a variety of different languages. The enhanced language support is a designation within My Schools that indicates that a school is able to offer resources, but in reality on the ground we actually expect all schools to be able to do that. So the enhanced language support designation — we believe that all of the schools have the resources and the expectations to be able to meet any multilingual child that comes into the program. So I will turn it over...
...to Dr. Branch. You are going to take that question, not me.
I just wanted to also offer a little bit more in terms of the explanation of the enhanced language supports, because we see it on My Schools. I saw it even before I came to the division and always wondered what it really meant. What it truly means is that a family can go to a program and there is someone there who speaks their home language. That person could be a lead teacher, a teacher's assistant, a custodial staff member or a secretary — any individual. It is not an instructional program. That is what is important to note. It is not similar to or on the same continuum as dual language. It is literally about language access.
What I am sharing, in terms of what was shared earlier, is that that is the expectation of all of our programs. So not only enhanced language programs, but the expectation is that supports are being provided in a family's home language at each and every one of our programs. That is actually expanded beyond the enhanced language designation. In terms of the breakdown, I do not have it by district, but I can give you specifically how many programs in pre-K and 3-K and what the languages...
...are. Okay, that is helpful.
Okay, so in terms of pre-K programs, we have five programs that support Mandarin Chinese exclusively. We have one program that supports Mandarin Chinese and Arabic, so you will find both languages in that program. We have two programs that support Mandarin Chinese and Spanish — again you will find both in those programs. We have two French dual language programs, one Italian, one Korean, one Polish, two Russian, one program that has Russian and Spanish, and 77 Spanish dual language programs in pre-K.
Is this all early childhood? Yes, for the early childhood. For 3-K, we are very excited about the two new 3-K programs that we opened this year. Right now the 3-K programs: one supports Russian and one supports Spanish.
And how does the City determine which languages to prioritize when creating or expanding multilingual programs? Good...
...afternoon. So we want to make it accessible to all families. We prioritize based on community demand, we prioritize based on seat availability and we also consider the geographic location of the needs. When we consider opening a dual language program we take a look at those different factors to make a decision, but ultimately our goal is always to expand the dual language classrooms so that all families have access to that type of model for their multilingual learners.
And could you share any barriers that prevent families from accessing these programs that you have seen? What we want to make sure that we consider is simplifying families' access to language and language support. What we currently have in place are opportunities for support to be available in the 13 languages that support the 99% of students who speak them at home. In addition to that, we consider what would be critical for family-facing communications. We have our internal unit that supports that work. Our translation unit helps to subsidize some of those resources for us, and we also have partner vendors that take care of that work for our community-based and family childcare networks.
Chair, may I ask a few more? Thank you. I just wanted to go into workforce, if that is possible.
And so we all know that educators are needed within these specific departments so they can help educate our children. How many early childhood educators in the division do we have who are contracted and qualified to teach in or support each language used by enrolled children? In the Division of Early Childhood Education, all of our teachers are equipped to support multilingual learners because all of our kids are emerging language learners. But specifically for dual language, we have 108 teachers who are certified, and they are lead teachers in classrooms across our City. So 183 pre-K dual language licensed teachers with the birth-to-two certificate, or they are on a pathway and very close to receiving that certification.
OK, and then lastly, you said everyone is equipped, so can you just explain that a little bit more? Is there professional development? Is there compensation for educators if they want to get a little bit more training? Can you just explain that a little bit?
Absolutely. So in early childhood education we have a robust ecosystem of support, specifically in learning and partnerships, and that is one of the verticals, as well as capacity building and family engagement. We have what we call instructional coordinators, and they are actually coaches that go into programs and work with teachers side by side, so they are able to provide them specific feedback on the spot that they can utilize today — not next week, but actually today.
They are providing supports around literacy but also around really utilizing the home language and how to have that come alive in the classroom on a day-to-day basis. We also have social workers who go into programs. Again, our staff are field-based and they support the social-emotional learning aspect and help teachers to ensure that they are taking culturally and linguistically responsive approaches each and every day in the classroom.
We also have inclusion specialists, and their job — on top of the layers of support that I just named — is, if we have programs where individuals are saying they need a little bit more support, they are certified teachers who are certified in special education or bilingual education and they go in to ensure that there are inclusive practices so that everyone — when we say all, we mean all — has and will have access to the curriculum and access to the learning environment.
Across our programs, we of course offer ongoing professional learning in person. We offer some sessions in hybrid format and some sessions online, but what I am most proud of is really that job-embedded, on-the-ground support where you can get feedback and improve your practice the very next day.
OK, thank you. Thank you, Chair.
Thank you, CM...
Sorry, I was just going to add another piece to the requirement of professional learning based on multilingual learners. New York State requires 15% of all continuing teacher and leader professional learning to be focused on multilingual learners for any teacher or leader to maintain their certifications. So that is one way in which we ensure every person who is certified to teach in the system has at least 15% of their professional learning going to that. And then any teacher who is either English as a New Language or bilingual certified, they are required to have 50% of that be specific to multilingual learners. So that is just another way for us to ensure that teachers are supported to support our really diverse — linguistically and culturally — student population.
Thank you. Thank you. I also want to acknowledge you have been
joined by committee member CM Gale Brewer and CM Julie Won online. I am going to ask a couple more questions and then pass it over.
Oh no, not a lantern fly! CM Brewer, save us!
Goodness. OK, I had a question about... somebody will save us. I had a question about families who want to enroll in an existing pre-K dual language program. I guess, is there a designated number of seats in the lottery for children for these programs whose primary language is a language other than English?
Is there a certain amount of seats? So by design, dual language programs — those that are specifically teaching in that format — are meant to have 50% of children coming from a household that speaks the target language and 50% of children who are coming from a household that does not speak the target language. So in the admissions process, essentially 50% of the seats are held for each group. A family does indicate when they apply on MySchools whether or not they speak that language at home. OK, and do you
have a sense — are there instances where there are waiting lists for the 50% of those families who speak that language versus the 50% who do not?
Just as with any early childhood program, there can be waiting lists. When a family applies for 3-K or pre-K, they can list
essentially an unlimited number of programs on their application, and any program that they ranked higher than the program they are ultimately offered a spot at, they are automatically placed on the wait list. So a family may have ranked five dual language programs, for example, and gotten into their fourth choice, so they would then be on the wait list for the three that they ranked higher. Or similarly, a parent who ranked a mix of dual language and non-dual language programs — if they have any of the programs ranked higher than their admitted choice, they would automatically be placed on a wait list. Got it, and
do you all have a sense — is there an exact number of kindergarten-through-five seats, or maybe kindergarten seats, for dual language? For example, if there are 22 slots in dual language pre-K, is it expected that there will be 22 slots in kindergarten, or
potentially more but not less?
I will just say, as a value — I know the deputy chancellor mentioned this — when planning, we do look for opportunities to create continuity so that children can have an experience in K-through-12 education that builds on their early childhood. But I will defer to Dr. Garcia for that. Thank you for asking that. That is something that is really important to us. 44% of all students in K-12 report a home language other than English, and so we do believe that when kids are exposed to dual language and multilingual education in the early years, being able to establish that foundation and continuing into kindergarten is fundamental. So we work really closely
with the Division of Early Childhood Education and the community on ensuring that we have a pathway to be able to grow the students who are in kindergarten. And are there scenarios where families are not enrolled in a pre-K program but in some kind of dual language or immersion program, and then they do not have a slot in kindergarten just because you are preserving those for the pre-K students?
I just want to clarify — they are not explicitly reserved, for exactly the reason you just said. Every school has a different student population for pre-K versus kindergarten. There will be families who change schools between pre-K and kindergarten. There will be families who were in pre-K community-based programming and are coming in for kindergarten. But the goal is to have sufficient capacity in kindergarten to be able to support children who are articulating from pre-K to K, as well as children who are coming from within the community and similarly have a language need. Got it.
And I think the other piece is that once a child comes into kindergarten and goes through the formal identification process, if they are an English language learner, the parent comes in for a parent orientation and they are entitled to choose between English as a New Language, dual language or transitional bilingual education starting in kindergarten. So if the school does not offer it, they can request a transfer to a nearby school
that offers the program model that they prefer. OK, is that communicated to the families any sooner?
It is communicated once the orientation happens, so it is within the first 10 days of school generally. OK, that is a little tough. I mean, the
idea that parents are engaging with school leadership well before orientation is ideal, but I feel like there are scenarios where parents kind of walk into this and do not realize it until they have already made arrangements for their kid to go to that school.
Well, what is distinct for the pre-K students is that a school can start the identification process on June 1 of the year before. So if a parent comes in and they register, they can start the orientation process. All K-to-12 schools are trained to administer the Home Language Identification Survey to begin with, and then if a home language other than English is reported, they administer the NYSITELL, and then automatically from there they get the orientation and can choose. OK, and you
will have a way of checking in with individual schools and school districts to make sure that that is happening as early as possible?
Yeah, we have many ways. We do announce that weekly — when the window is open so they can begin identification — and then we have systems and processes in place. Every school has a Comprehensive Education Plan, and within that plan there is a Language Allocation Policy. There we request that schools have a plan on how they are going to ensure the identification of students, including students who are coming from pre-K and entering kindergarten beginning June 1.
OK, thank you. Thank you for that. I am going to pass it to CM Brewer for her questions.
Thank you very much. I have been listening online so I heard all of this great discussion. My question is — I have seen some programs manage to get from early childhood all the way through middle school in French, but not Russian. In other words, they will have early childhood Russian, then elementary, but not beyond that. So how is it really possible to continue the language, because it is not possible in school three? So how do you make that happen for Russian or other languages?
I could speak to that. So that is something that
we are really committed to — ensuring that there is continuity from pre-K to 12 and that students graduate with a New York State Seal of Biliteracy. Ultimately, we work really closely with superintendents in the communities. So for example, in a situation where we have a school community that is looking for a feeder to go to high school, we work closely with superintendents and principals in the community. Our office specifically has been able to provide a school allocation memorandum over the past four years for the revitalization of bilingual programs, which includes a planning year for schools opening up a bilingual program, and we use the data to inform that. So that has been a very specific focus of ours. For example, we have been able to expand in District 15 this year — it is a continuity for Italian — so we can now say we have pre-K Italian, we have elementary Italian, and this year we will have middle school Italian. That is just one example, and so it is something that we
look at the data, we look at
the patterns, we take in community input, and then we work with superintendents and principals and have them participate in our bilingual revitalization efforts, which means that the school gets professional learning for a year on how to plan for the program, how to hire teachers, curriculum, and all of the pieces that will lead to a sustainable program.
Because that is a key piece — a program that is going to open and stand the test of time, not close within a year or two. OK, we will keep working on the Russian then. My question also is — do you have enough teachers in these different languages, or is there a shortage? Is that something that is able to be addressed, or do you have so many different languages that...
I will just say broadly, and then turn to my colleagues to speak to some of the particulars. We know that as we continue to expand access to early childhood education broadly, and specifically to support more and more of our multilingual learners, we cannot do that without investing in the workforce. So as we continue to invest in workforce development for early childhood education, we need to continue both bringing multilingual educators into the pipeline and supporting those who are already in our system to get their bilingual extension or otherwise develop the skills to support multilingual learners.
But I will pass to my colleagues. Are you calling the United Nations? That would be wonderful! No, I am serious. I think at a high level, as we think about how we promote jobs in early childhood education, doing outreach to diverse communities in New York City — we have so many multilingual speakers in New York City — and making sure that we are reaching them in the communities where they are, partnering with institutions of higher education who are serving a multilingual student population, as well as working with those in the K-12 system who want to go back to school and earn their bilingual extensions so that they can teach in a formally designated class. We also, as my colleagues have mentioned, provide on-site coaching and professional development so that all teachers are equipped to support multilingual learners whatever their own language
skills might be. OK. And I will just add on to that — the intentional strategy, as we are expanding and working with community-based providers and also family childcare providers, is bringing in educators who have very different linguistic assets and who are able to match their communities. So that is a very intentional way of trying to ensure that we have educators who understand the multilingual backgrounds that our children are coming in with.
OK, I am always trying to get more parents to send their children to public schools. One of the things that you are great at is what you are talking about. What you are horrible at is telling people what you do — horrible, horrible, horrible. So my suggestion would be, again, thinking of ways — I am not a charter school supporter, I will be honest with you — and so I am trying to get more students to go to your schools. So maybe you could put some information together, nicely laid out, and be able to tell people, because all Americans should speak
two languages, every single one.
But the question is, you have to tell people that you are teaching two languages. Because I have to tell you, if you ask the general public who does not have a child in the public schools, they are always going to say we do not have dual language or anything like that. So when you have that material, could you let me know? Thank you.
Thank you, CM. Agreed. I wanted to ask very quickly about the dual language model. I know that you shared it is 50/50. Are there other models of dual language implementation that you all are looking at, or does this seem tried and true to you?
Thank you for that question. Within the early childhood program portfolio, our current model is dual language, but we are always thinking about ways that we expand language access to families under the umbrella term of bilingual education and thinking about how that would look for our littlest learners.
I am glad you are open to that. I know we have got some folks here in the room that might have thoughts, so I hope you can stick around for the testimony. Are there any requirements from New York State about language instruction for early childhood? Are there specific requirements?
When thinking about what we value — oh, I am sorry, go ahead.
When we are thinking about what we value most, it is ensuring that our teachers are equipped and prepared to support multilingual learners in the classroom. So specifically for early childhood education, all teachers are provided with professional learning cycles around supporting that type of language instruction. That language instruction is embedded in the day-to-day instructional core — so from the minute the child enters the classroom to the minute they leave, the instructional time that the teachers spend with the children is pretty much overloaded with language
strategies such as repeated read-alouds, translanguaging, supporting the home language and embedding it into the instructional academic outcomes of the child for that day. Other strategies that our teachers
employ — just to name a couple — would include gestures and thinking about how we could accelerate vocabulary acquisition by labeling some of the discovery centers or areas in the child's home language or partner language if it is a dual language setting. For a monolingual setting, those same strategies transfer over to support the students who are multilingual and sitting in those programs too. Did you have anything to add?
Thank you. Regarding requirements in early childhood education — so in 3-K programs and pre-K programs, unlike K-12 where we do have state mandates, those mandates do not exist in early childhood education. However, in the Division of Early Childhood Education, it is a commitment of ours. In our policy handbooks for our 3-K centers, all of the policy handbooks speak to ensuring that we are culturally responsive, that we are honoring home language, and that there is a responsibility to ensure that all multilingual learners are supported. So the state does not mandate it, but the Division does.
HAVE ANYTHING TO SAY THANK YOU E REQUIREMENT IN EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION SO IN THREE K PROGRAMS PRE K PROGRAMS UNLIKE THE K 12 WHERE WE DO HAVE STATE MANDATES THEY DO NOT EXIST IN EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION HOWEVER IN THE DIVISION OF EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION IT IS A COMMITMENT OF OUR WE IN OUR POLICY HANDBOOKS FOR OUR C K SENSORS ALL OF THE POLICY HANDBOOKS IT SPEAKS TO ENSURE AND THAT WE ARE CULTURALLY RESPONSIVE THAT WE ARE HONORING HOME LANGUAGE LANGUAGE AND THAT RESPONSIBILITIES TO REALLY T OENSURE THAT ALL MULTILINGUAL LEARNERS ARE SUPPORTED SO THE STATE NOT BUT THE DIVISION
Absolutely. Thank you. Your flowers... and is there, just considering the Federal Government's decisions, kind of like reigning in executive orders, making English the primary language, which just sounds insane to me — what can we tell parents that want to enroll? And like Gale says, as a supporter, we want more of our students to enroll in public education. What can we tell them that feels like more than just a commitment in our handbooks? I know that you are proving it right day to day in schools, but what can we do to codify that more? How can we really lean into that in a more concrete way?
For parents, I will just start by saying that no matter what stance our Federal Government takes, multilingual children will always be honored and valued in our early childhood system and our entire education system. We will always prioritize ensuring that they can show up and learn in both their home language and in whatever other languages they might be learning in school, and that we see multilingualism as an asset and a strength. I think there are many ways in which we can codify this in the ways that we as an administration talk about early childhood education and our goal of providing culturally competent settings.
For every child, whatever that means to their family, as we continue to expand access to specific programming, really emphasizing and making clear to families as we do today when they browse their options for programs that they can learn in a variety of languages, continuing to support families when they apply for early childhood education programs to do so in whatever language they speak — there are over 200 languages — and receive the support to do so today. I think, to CM Brewer's point, we absolutely can continue to talk about multilingualism as an asset and to promote that, of course, to families whose children speak another language at home and would therefore really benefit from that model of instruction, but also to families like mine who do not and are opting in to dual language because we see it as a value for our children to learn another language in a city like New York. So in both policy and in the ways we continue to talk about our programs, the way we engage with families and the way we speak as a City about our work, to emphasize the asset that multilingualism is. Yes, absolutely. Thank you. We agree we will continue to make sure that teachers are supported in having linguistically representative programs, and we will continue to expand options. To answer your question earlier about those two three-K programs, one is in District 15, which is a Spanish-speaking program, and the other is in District 31, which is Russian-speaking.
Oh, wonderful. Thank you. I have a follow-up there, but I want to just ask — does every existing elementary K through five dual language program, if they have a pre-K, also offer dual language pre-K?
Not every single one. I will say, not to again generalize from my own experience, but my children go to an elementary school that has dual language Spanish beginning in kindergarten, though there is no formal dual language in the three-K and pre-K. Different school than I was at last year. The school is emphasizing language exposure in the early childhood years, so there are ways in which children can be exposed in early childhood even if it is not...
...a formal dual language program. Is there a plan — if they have these dual language programs existing, is there a plan, and if we cannot get there given the challenges, is there a plan to extend and to reach even into three-K?
We can get you the data on exactly how many of the existing kindergarten dual language programs have pre-K dual language. The next piece that we have been collaborating really closely on with the Division of Early Childhood Education is examining the places that have kindergarten dual language and do not have pre-K dual language. If there is community interest, we are looking at how we can increase continuity in that way. So it is something that we are actively looking at in the data and using that to inform where new programs may be needed. I am really encouraged by the three-K dual language programs that you just shared. I think as a parent who does speak more than one language at home, it is incredibly attractive to me to ensure that my child is...
...exposed. I think the transition — I will just give you the example of my older daughter, where we spoke Spanish at home. She enrolled in a New York PS three-K program and it was wonderful for vocabulary, but nothing went on in Spanish. She really felt like she had lost a lot of that, and so then we intentionally kept her there so that we could enroll her in pre-K, and it just felt like that was not happening across the district — District 32, for example, but really in all of my Council district.
So I am really interested in wanting to ensure that yes, we expand and get all the things we need. I think the concern is obviously the pipeline for all things early childhood education, but especially if we are talking about immersion programs in dual language, there is a shortage. I think it is really important for us to spread the word that this is a direction the City is moving in. I do not know any parent who has enrolled their kid in a language program and regretted it, to be honest. So I think there is so much value there, and I hope that we can do it and I hope that we can really talk about investment to be able to expand. How are you all looking at expansion for dual language...
...programs? I know that you shared the specific rubric, but equity-wise, are there school districts in New York City right now that do not have a single dual language program? And if there are, how do you plan to expand? How are you all looking to continue to expand it? What do you need?
First, I want to just say one thing in response to what you were just talking about in terms of the path for children to be able to articulate from program to program. My colleague will talk a little about expansion, but I just want to highlight that obviously we are talking about schools and the continuity opportunity within schools. We also know that so many of our community based organizations and family childcare homes provide an incredibly rich multilingual experience for children, and for many families that may be where they are comfortable with their child attending early childhood education, for a variety of reasons including language access. We certainly want to help families understand those pathways as well — that they can learn in their home language in a community based program or a family childcare setting and then articulate into kindergarten at their local elementary school. So for families, the pathway does not necessarily mean staying in the same building, but certainly we want to make sure we are talking about all of our early childhood settings and the language opportunities within them. I will pass to my colleagues to talk a bit more about future expansion.
All right, thank you. So thinking about ways that we could again provide our families with more access, one of our current strategies is to convert certain classrooms into dual language programs. What we are working towards with school leaders and districts is thinking about ways that we can invite schools that already have a dual language program to open up additional classrooms.
But like my colleague Dr. Garcia suggested, our offices work closely together so that there is a more intentional focus and look at what the data is and what we can do to now meet those gaps. Specifically around making sure that if there is going to be an elementary school down the street that has a dual language program in Italian, thinking about ways that the local preschools and pre-K family networks can offer those programs too, so that when the child continues through their education career they have that solid continuity and foundation around their partner language that they have been engaging in since they were smaller.
What is the... I guess just to your point about encouraging schools to open up new classrooms for potential dual language — what does that look like? Because I feel like my experience with the department regarding early childhood education is that the data and the seat allotment do not match, in my opinion, in some of these districts. So how are you all looking at what data you are using? How are you able to justify that and rectify that? And in these scenarios, are you potentially thinking about additional seats, or having those schools potentially move seats from existing programs and switch them over to dual...
...language? So we look at that data and think about — this is a good problem to have — the demand, the seat numbers are what they are, and then the family demands are another sort of data set. So again, thinking about ways that we can intentionally support and expand those programs. But at the core of that work is always going to be family need and family requests, and then thinking about what the impact would be for that particular school, if there are going to be any needs around getting a certified bilingual teacher to teach that program. Those are the things that we are considering, and again it is just...
...more around factoring all of these different elements to make sure that when we do expand, it is intentional. We do not want to expand for the sake of expanding. We want to make sure it is done well and done right and then sustained for years to come. I mean, I understand it has to sort of feel like the perfect storm to have all of those things in motion. Has that garnered any success in opening up new classrooms?
The current strategy right now is to convert classrooms, and there are leaders who are 100% excited about it. My team and I have been in the field getting the interest, ideas and surveys around what schools and communities are already asking for. To answer your question, yes, leaders are completely open to that strategy. We have not opened up a new classroom yet.
OK. So you referenced some of these local providers that might be able to provide potential two-year-old and three-year-old multilanguage experiences. I know that we have Joanne here from One World Project. I think I visited her site — if you have not, you should. It is a thoughtful and wonderful program. As you are thinking about credential expansion, how are you all working with a group like that that is already doing this work? And is there communication when, for example, a parent goes to a school where a program just does not exist or they really wanted one, or they are just not equipped — are there referrals to some of these providers in those instances?
That is a good question. What I love about bilingual education is it is an umbrella with different models. One of the models that I know of that One World has is a Spanish immersion model. That is one model. Then we have the dual language model. Then we have transitional bilingual. Those are different types of ways that we support students' home language. But to answer your question, if we are thinking about expansion, then that also includes thinking about expanding the different types of models that we offer to our families too.
And just to confirm, the only model right now is the existing one that we have been talking about for dual language? Yes. OK. With the exception of One World's immersion model? Well, yes. OK. And...
On that — this will be my last question related to this topic. I know that for example in my district there are a number of schools that offer immersion as well in other languages, but in every instance parents are paying for this. I know that there is an interest for many parents of all different sorts of incomes — they want to enroll their child but they just cannot afford it. How are you all thinking about expansion and equitable access to multilingual education in early childhood for all families? Because I feel like in some neighborhoods this is where you will see immersion programs that are usually not Spanish — it is like French or Japanese. How can we ensure equity? Because I think parents want that more than anything. They want to be able to ensure that their child is learning another language, because like Gale said, we should already be doing that.
I think this is connected to just the focus on expanding child care options and affordability broadly, but also making sure that we are providing programs that families want. So we are intentional in working with community based programs and looking for opportunities where, if we are able to expand, we are able to work with more that might offer different types of dual language settings for young children. But I will just say we know that there is a lot of demand and interest for different types of multilingual programming. As you can hear from many of our responses, this is a priority for the Chancellor and for the Mayor, and making sure that we are working together across as many different options — and principals and schools and superintendents, if they hear of a need, that we are working together to offer programs that families are looking for.
If I could just add — we are also very intentionally understanding that the purpose of bilingual education programs is to support the multilingual learner. If we are thinking about expansion and what the community needs are, at the end of the day it is what that community needs for the multilingual learner that lives in that community. So if there is a significant population of students whose home language is Russian, then we are going to think about that when we are considering expansion. While monolingual learners benefit from those programs, multilingual learners depend on those programs. So that is definitely one of the driving markers around what we are looking for when we are thinking about expansion. I want to make that clear.
Excellent. Thank you. How does a successful transition of a multilanguage learner from pre-K to kindergarten work, making sure there are no gaps in services?
So I spoke a little bit about this before. It does begin with the identification process, and the fact that Part First is really a game changer — that was not always the case — because it opens that window to be able to bring in the family, do the home language survey, get to know the student, identify them, and for the parent to make their decision, to understand what they have at the school. Given that in kindergarten we have the NYSITELL, which does provide the language proficiency in English of the student, that is a good foundational start to know where the child is in English proficiency. We have a Spanish assessment for all students who come in with a home language of Spanish to get a sense of their Spanish language skills, and then we have additional assessments that are done at the school level to get to know students, along with parent questionnaires to get to know the parents. Thank you.
If a multilanguage child is also identified as disabled and in need of special education services, how does child care ensure that they are meeting both those needs? And is it different when the child is three years old and eligible for services compared to when the child is over three years old and eligible for pre-K...
...education services? I could speak to what that looks like for early childhood. New York City Public Schools never wants to have a family make the decision between having their child choose between language support and supports for their special education needs. So what we have for our early childhood students is, if a child is referred for special education services, our Committee for Preschool Special Education team would then administer the assessment or the questionnaire in that child's home language. The rationale behind that is to ensure that if there is going to be an evaluation that comes out of that, that evaluation does not necessarily need to be in that child's home language — so let us assume it is. If there is a cause for evaluation or a case for...
...evaluation, the child's evaluation is done in that home language. What happens is we have our own internal staff that go out and administer the evaluation, or sometimes we partner with outside agencies to support that work. If the designation is that the child will now have an individualized education plan, then those bilingual services are embedded into that child's plan. What the Committee for Preschool Special Education does now is work to ensure that those programs and services are rendered, and they work around the clock to make sure that there is continuity in those services too. Great, thank you.
Thank you. I want to ask a question about — I think we kind of touched on this — but how many applications does NYC Public Schools receive for dual language programs, and do you have a breakdown of those applications by target language? So we do have a breakdown. For three K, we received 28 applicants for Russian language and 60 for Spanish. Those are for the two three K through eight programs that we opened this year. In terms of pre-K: 17 Arabic, 129 Chinese, 100 French, 47 Italian, 24 Korean, 3 Polish, 60 Russian and 1,574 Spanish. Wow, that is a lot of demand. What are we doing? We are not moving fast enough.
We are doing something right, right? For a dozen three K — yes, yeah. In terms of three K, well, yes, we are starting and we are looking at the data to see where and when we can expand three K, but the demand is there.
Yeah, I mean, clearly families trust us and want their children in these programs, so we are excited about that. How long have these pre-K dual language programs been in existence? I mean, it might all be different, but...
It has been like in the last five years or so where there are different programs that have been developed more recently, but the majority of them were definitely during the last expansion under the de Blasio administration.
OK, and are there instances where in some of these dual language early childhood programs — I think of putting myself in my parents' shoes — I want my daughter to be in a dual language Spanish program, I apply to a pre-K program, and for some reason in the third or fourth grade it feels like it is falling apart. That is not what is happening — I am giving you an example. What does NYC Public Schools do to support schools when maybe enrollment is dwindling? A school in my district had a Japanese dual language program and it stopped. The enrollment was very low. I do not know if the support was fully there, but how often does that happen where these schools at some point find that the dual language program is not really a fit, and what do you do beforehand to support those schools so that they do keep it?
Yeah, you bring up a really important point. One of the reasons we called our efforts over the past few years "bilingual revitalization" was because we needed to take stock of what existed, how they were being supported, and making sure that we did not have a revolving door of programs opening and closing. So we invested in that. Programs closed for various reasons. We have...
...protocols in the K-12 space in which if a program is going to close — if a principal either says we do not have the certified teacher, or parents are not interested, or we do not have enough students — they complete a protocol that is then submitted to the superintendent and the local director, who first review and sign off, and ultimately it comes to the Office of Multilingual Learners. We do everything to try to save a program before closing it. Do you have evidence of how many you have had to close?
We have annual data. I do not have it right now, but we can get...
...it for you. What I can say is that over the past few years, because of bilingual revitalization, we have been able to have net increases in programs. There were programs closing as well, but now we are at a place where we are really having a net increase. Programs are being sustained — the existing ones — because we have been able to increase the professional learning, we have been able to ensure that if a teacher resigns or retires, we have a pipeline and we are connecting principals with the right resources to get the teacher. At the Office of Multilingual Learners, we have been really ramping up our efforts to increase access to home language arts materials, which is really critical to be able to deliver high quality instruction. So now I can say that we are moving from a bilingual revitalization effort to boldly reimagining multilingual education, because we are at a place where we are increasing programs and we have the mechanisms in place to really support schools in being able to sustain.
I want to just pick up on what my colleague said and think about what I mentioned earlier. When it comes down to how we expand the program, one of those factors is the geographic makeup. So if we were going to, based on your example, have a robust Japanese dual language program and now it is feeling like it is dwindling — if the family need or the demand is not there, we have to consider that our wonderful city neighborhoods change. If what was predominantly a Japanese neighborhood has now evolved into something else, then we have to be responsive to that community and consider a dual language program that supports those families. It really does come down to the individual school. Thank you. Is there a demand...
...for early childhood educators that can provide instruction in a particular language that the City is currently unable to meet?
Of the many languages that you highlighted — what I think are the three K and the pre-K programs — is there a shortage of teachers that can speak those languages...
...or instruct, excuse me, in those languages across our current portfolio of dual language programs? No.
OK, and the same applies for early childhood specifically? Well, specifically for early childhood education, so we are talking about our two K, three K and pre-K programs.
Wonderful. OK, there is no shortage. And how do you feel about — not specific to a specific language — we do know that we have more demand than the classes that we have. However, it is not that there is a language that is being requested that we do not have. Is there — OK, all right, that is good.
Do schools — and I want to spend some time on this — sharing with us how schools are supported when they take on a dual language program. Do schools receive any additional funding specifically, and if so, how much has been directly allocated to schools in this fiscal year, and more or less what is the average per school?
Language learners — our emergent multilingual learners — we believe that is a core responsibility for any of our programs. So what they are using is their per-seat allocation, and they have the flexibility to design their programs in the way that best meets the children and the families in their program. For early childhood, there is no designated or specific funding for additional things for dual language learners. We are able to look at what the funding allocation is, so for the dual language learning programs it is about $30 million. That is for the programs that are offering dual language learning. I do believe there is additional funding on the K-12 side, and Dr. Garcia, can you talk a little bit about that?
So — I am so sorry — before Dr. Garcia, just to clarify: there is no additional funding specific for a pre-K program or the three K dual language? No, it is based on the classrooms and their...
...enrollment, not something specifically around the language.
And have you — OK, and have you found that schools need more funding for the dual language pre-K? We find that the schools are using the flexibility they have to support their instruction and their staffing, and it is something that we are continuing to monitor so we can be responsive.
And a K through five dual language school that wants a pre-K dual language — what is the response from NYC Public Schools? Do you currently already have a teacher that can do this, or are there scenarios where the school wants it and they do not have it and they need more funding? Dr. Branch, do you want to take that?
Yeah, I can speak a little bit to that. So we have a school allocation memorandum for bilingual revitalization. We just disseminated the one this year — about $1.3 million went to 193 schools, schools that are in the planning year and the first five years of program existence, so that we continue to provide some funding for them to be able to sustain. With that said, this is supplemental — it is not going to completely help a school stand up a whole program. It is for professional learning for teachers and for administrators, for parental engagement to get parents in and informed about the program, and for supplemental materials like home language libraries and home language supplies. We do include our pre-K programs in that school allocation memorandum, so if a pre-K dual language program were to open, we would include it in this bilingual revitalization school allocation memorandum. So this year, for example, any new program got a thousand dollars.
To support — again, for any school, not just new dual language — for K-12 it is any bilingual program, so dual language or transitional bilingual, and specific to pre-K, any new pre-K dual language bilingual education program. OK. I might have some follow-ups on that. And beyond dual language programs, do schools receive any additional funding for pre-K and the question of whether you receive any additional support for the multilingual language program?
Right, so no. Pre-K and three K programs are able to use the funding that they receive based on the enrollment and the age of the children, however they deem appropriate, in order to meet the needs of their multilingual children. So they can use funding for translation and interpretation, for paying for staff who will be able to support the multilingual students' instruction, and so we work with them to provide those resources and support.
OK, and does the same apply to enhanced language support programs? Do CBOs receive any additional funding to support multilingual learners? So there would not be additional support for those programs because technically enhanced language support is literally about language access for families — it is not an instructional model. It is about ensuring that someone in the building — anyone in the building — correct? OK. And there would be no additional support in the event where a parent is there and no one speaks that language? You are saying you do not need additional support because they can use a language line or something? Correct. There is an interpretation line that they can call to provide that additional support. OK, and do you...
...have you found that there are any asks from schools, maybe for additional support or different support? Is there anything — and I know you have outlined specifically what those existing supports look like — but have there been any schools that have engaged with you all and said this is not working, this is the way that we would want to be supported? So not necessarily more funding, but... We do get requests for additional support in terms of instructional support, in terms of additional strategies to help support multilingual learners. We are on the ground so we are tailoring our coaching model to provide the right supports to those programs. Yes, and we are able to adjust and ensure that programs get the right support.
OK, thank you. I think we are almost done with the questions and I am excited to hear from the public. Just maybe two more questions. I think I touched on some of the family childcare networks — the majority of them speak another language. In some of these surveys I see that Spanish is the majority, for example. How will the Mayor's Office tap into this resource to provide two K, three K and pre-K multilingual education in Spanish as we expand? And are we going to compensate these people for this extra gift of exposure and...
...immersion to other languages? Yes. So as we expand access to early care and education in the City, we see our family childcare educators as absolutely essential to that expansion, because we know it is a setting that families often choose and prefer, especially for their youngest children. We know families often prefer family childcare for a range of reasons — whether that is the intimacy of the program, the mixed ages, the flexibility — and often it is for cultural and linguistic reasons. We know many parents feel comfortable knowing their child is in an environment that looks and feels like their home, whether that is the language exposure, the meals they are eating, or just the cultures and customs that are practiced in that program. So as we continue to expand access to two K, family childcare educators are an absolutely critical part of that. We were thrilled this year with our first two K seats to include a large number of family childcare homes in that expansion. I will turn to my colleagues but will say that as we do that expansion work and as we do outreach to family childcare educators to make sure they know about the opportunity to participate, it is critical — and we have been doing that outreach always with translation services directly in the languages that we know family childcare educators are speaking, and by partnering with networks who themselves have staff who speak the languages of the family childcare providers in their communities.
I would just add on to that: it is incredibly important to our strategy to make sure that family childcare providers are a part of our early childhood system. We know that their superpower is being able to reflect the children and the communities around them. It was a very large part of our two K plans. They are also offering three K from their family childcare homes, so that will continue to be a significant part of our strategy as we move forward.
Thank you. I know folks in my community who intentionally enroll their child in a family childcare network because they want to expose their children to Spanish, for example. So I think we are all saying the words that say we value them, and I just hope that we can make tangible efforts to really show them that and to include them in the further expansion process, because I think they deserve to really feel that value. My last question — and I know you responded on the City's commitment to doing what we do best, which is continuing to really push for diversity and not necessarily what the Federal Government wants us to do — but just lastly on that: are there any special efforts that NYC Public Schools is making around multilingual students and family data, especially efforts to protect their data from any kind of federal oversight? I will just again reiterate the broad value statement and then turn to my colleagues to talk about the particular data. Whether it is this latest policy proposal from the Federal Government around Head Start or some of the other...
...policy statements the Federal Government has made around English and the stance towards immigrant students, we in New York City will always protect our immigrant students and our multilingual students. That speaks to both their ability to be themselves, to speak their language, to learn in the language that they speak at home, and to their information being protected and kept safe. But I will turn to my colleagues on the specific policies. Thank you.
So in my previous role as principal, what you just described is a very real situation — it does happen.
But I do want to emphasize that what New York City Public Schools educators — from the crossing guard to the Chancellor — our priority is to ensure that our students' privacy is protected and that we support the families that they come from. What New York City Public Schools has offered is specific guidance for what to do in that very real situation, clearly outlined in terms of what the protocols are when dealing with non-local law enforcement or something like that. In addition to that, a lot of the language data that we collect for the purpose of instruction and meeting those instructional needs is not correlated with or used for identifying a child's immigration status, with the understanding that a multilingual learner may not be an immigrant and an immigrant may not be a multilingual learner.
Right. So thinking about the whole ethos of what that means for immigrant families, what also governs our day-to-day practices is the idea of making sure that we are honoring and following the relevant laws to the letter. Those different things that we consider when we are protecting our students are what guide our day-to-day practice, and if for some reason there is some kind of back-and-forth engagement, we are advised and directed to deal with it or get our next steps from legal counsel. OK, all right.
Thank you all so much. I am done with my questions. I just want to make a final plug to really let us know how we can help collaborate. I think it is such a value, as I think we have all emphasized here today. We want to make sure that not only are we emphasizing this day to day for the existing programs, but sending a message to parents and all interested parents of NYC Public Schools that this is something that is in their local school district, that we are investing in and that we do want to expand. I think it makes it very attractive to parents and obviously our goal is to make sure that parents are sending their kids to our public schools.
So thank you all so much. Now I want to open the hearing for public testimony. I remind members of the public that this is a government proceeding and that decorum shall be observed at all times. The public shall remain silent at all times. The witness table is reserved for people who wish to testify. No video recording or photography is allowed from the witness table. Further, members of the public may not present audio or video recordings as testimony but may submit transcripts of such recordings to the Sergeant at Arms for inclusion in the hearing record. If you wish to speak at today's hearing, please fill out an appearance slip with the Sergeant at Arms and wait to be recognized. When recognized, you will have two minutes to speak on today's oversight topic and or legislation. If you have a written statement or additional written testimony you wish to submit for the record, please provide a copy of that testimony to the Sergeant at Arms. You may also email written testimony to testimony at council dot NYC within 72 hours of this hearing. Audio and video recordings will not be accepted.
For the first panel, by themselves, we have Emma Gossett from the Independent Budget Office. Whenever you are ready.
Good morning, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education. I am Emma Gossett, Lead Budget and Policy Analyst at the New York City Independent Budget Office. The Independent Budget Office is a nonpartisan independent government agency mandated by the New York City Charter whose mission is to enhance public understanding of New York City's budget, public policy and economy through independent analysis. Thank you for the opportunity to testify at this hearing on public comment to the Federal Government on proposed rule changes to Head Start programs. In my testimony I will discuss potential impacts of these proposed changes as well as share information on multi-language learners in early childhood education programs operated or contracted by New York City Public Schools.
Head Start is a federally funded early childhood education program. It serves children birth through five as well as pregnant people. Families are eligible if their income is at or below the federal poverty guidelines, or if they are experiencing homelessness, or in foster care, or receiving public benefits. Our comment to the Federal Register expresses serious concerns and urges the withdrawal of the proposal. We are concerned that the proposed regulation would introduce uncertainty and undermine implementation of Head Start programs that are critical to New York City families. In addition to providing child care, these programs increase families' access to resources that are crucial to their ability to afford and remain in New York City, including alleviation from food insecurity and increased access to dental, physical and mental health care as well as job training programs.
Over the past few years, New York City's Head Start programs have withstood major changes, including the closure of the regional office in New York. Prior to 2025, New York City Public Schools served as the grant recipient for approximately 30% of Head Start programs in the City, but their grant was not renewed and they will no longer oversee Head Start programs. In the 2024-2025 school year, the 150 New York City Head Start programs served 18,000 children, including 900 homeless students, over 600 students with IEPs and approximately 30 foster children, as well as over 580 pregnant women. These programs are run by highly trained staff and volunteers who include over 400 staff members and over 800 parent volunteers. There are also other positions that employ New York City residents, which include home visitors and evaluators.
I will now highlight a couple of the proposed changes. First, HHS would require all Head Start programs going forward to be taught in English and only English. Head Start programs serve students who speak many languages and their staff reflect this language diversity. Additionally, families benefit from Head Start language programming. In 2024-2025, 73% — or 14,000 — of New York City's enrolled Head Start students were dual language learners who speak Spanish at home. About a quarter of Head Start staff spoke Spanish and 35% of staff were proficient in a language other than English, and over 400 New York City families participated in an ESL training over the course of the year. We support the continuation of student language access and urge reconsideration of rescinding these requirements.
Secondly, there are a set of proposed changes that would remove requirements for parent engagement and parent committees. Head Start programs rely heavily on parent volunteers. In the 2024-2025 school year, Head Start programs served over 4,000 families, and single-parent households represented just under half of those families. New York City programs also hosted over 800 parent volunteers. Parent volunteering serves as a crucial touch point not only to programs but to families, particularly those with limited supports. Parents who volunteer have opportunities for career development through
structured coaching. We support the continuation of parent committees and the continuation of strong parental engagement and urge reconsideration of rescinding these requirements. A third set of rules highlighted in our comment would impact data and reporting and potentially constrain researchers' abilities to study Head Start's impacts and compare data before and after those changes take place.
The Independent Budget Office strongly supports comprehensive, transparent data practices and supports the continued collection of data measurements. Lastly, I will speak about multi-language learners within New York City Public Schools early childhood programs. Of the approximately 4,000 3-K students and 60,000 pre-K students who were enrolled in a New York City Public Schools operated or contracted program, 34% of pre-K students spoke a language other than English at home. Families served by those programs spoke over 140 different languages. The five most common for both grades were Spanish, whose speakers made up 18% of all 3-K and pre-K programs, followed by Chinese languages, Bengali, Russian and Arabic. If proposed rule changes to Head Start are finalized, the families of New York City's multi-language learners will look to NYC Public Schools for programs that support language access. There is an opportunity now to ensure there are sufficient resources for enrolled multi-language learners as well as to build new supports for future students. Thank you for the opportunity to testify and I am happy to answer any questions.
Thank you so much, Emma. This is really thorough and thoughtful testimony. I guess what I... I do not know if we heard directly about specific Head Start changes, but do you know of any conversations or plans that are in motion potentially considering... I mean, this is the whole purpose of the hearing today, really, to understand the families, the student population and to identify how we can better serve them or identify gaps. Have these conversations started happening? I mean, I think the 2- and 3-K classrooms are great, but my God, they are 2- and 3-K classrooms, right. What can we be doing, or what has started?
Yeah, I think in terms of Head Start, the changes are not finalized, so the proposed rules' public comments are accepted until October 6 for anyone interested. I think once, if those are adopted and if those regulations come into effect, they would impact the number of students who are seeking dual language programs. But I do not think that there are any current changes because those changes are not in place yet.
Do you anticipate the same for multi-language learners, and if they do go into effect, where they might be leaning on an NYC Public Schools program?
Yeah, I think if Head Start programs stop using other languages, those families would look not only to NYC Public Schools but also to private programs if they can afford them, or family members who could care for them. I think language is certainly a strength of Head Start, as 73% of students speak another language in a Head Start program, which is even higher than NYC Public Schools. So I think it is definitely an important part of the program and there are certainly...
...concerns. Sure. And you mentioned the deadline for public comment is on the sixth. Is there a place on the record where people can share their public comments?
Absolutely. On the Federal Register — if you look up the proposed changes to Head Start, you will be able to find it.
I encourage everyone to submit testimony and thank you again so much for testifying today. Have a great day. You too.
For our next panel, I want to call up Abigail Leonard, Raquel Graham, Ila, Karen Rogel — my apologies if I am mispronouncing — Albania, Judy Blumenthal. You can start when you all are ready. Just work your way down. Thank you.
Thank you, Council Member Gutiérrez and colleagues, for convening this hearing. New York is a sanctuary city. Our streets are filled with people speaking many languages and so are our classrooms. But what happens before those children begin to receive formal instruction? I am Carol Gaelle and I am here representing City's First Readers. The 18 partners of City's First Readers deliver some of the most effective programs around to support multi-language learners during the critical period from birth to five. That is the same time frame when a child's brain grows to 90% of its adult capacity and that is the best time to engage a child with stimulation and experiences that lay the foundation for early literacy.
So how does City's First Readers support multi-language learners and their families on the path to school readiness? We focus on play and joy. We provide tools for parents to create safe, stable and nurturing relationships, and that is what the American Academy of Pediatrics calls relational health. We also deliver free, high quality, culturally relevant early learning programs. There are proposed changes at the federal level that would, if implemented, require instruction at Head Start programs to be provided only in English. We value the languages and cultures that multi-language learners bring to New York City and our programming supports them.
So in closing, I want to leave you with two thoughts. This is a real and powerful impact that comes from working together to support families where early childhood multi-language learners are served. City's First Readers operates in a truly collaborative fashion, so I invite you to come see this for yourself by attending our quarterly meetings or any programs that we have coming up. City's First Readers is reaching out to nontraditional settings and establishing relationships with partners who are not conventionally considered educational — clinics, hospitals, health care providers, WIC centers and WIC offices. Family early literacy supports must be a part of a holistic process supporting growth, especially for our multi-language learners. Thank you.
Good afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the Subcommittee. My name is Albania Jimenez and I am here on behalf of Literacy in Community, Link. We work with children birth to five, their families and the educators and community partners who support them. The Link is a facilitating agency for City's First Readers and Open Manhattan Early Childhood Connect.
A child's home language is a foundation for learning. When a caregiver sings to a baby, tells a story or talks through the day in the language they know best, that child is building language, connection and a sense of belonging. Families should never feel they must stop using their home language to help their child learn English. I just want to be specific on that. The Link plans to launch "Supporting Multilingual Homes," a workshop series designed to help families build on everyday interactions, share their home languages and share what they know about their children with educators.
Families cannot do this alone. Early childhood educators need practical training to learn about dual language learners, invite meaningful conversations about language development and intentionally build English skills. Families also need welcoming programs and resources they can use in the languages they speak. We ask the Council to invest in family-centered early literacy and professional learning for educators who serve multilingual children, so that learning starts before kindergarten and builds on the strengths children and families already bring. Thank you.
Okay. Good afternoon. Hello...
Chair Gutiérrez. I have seen you in the neighborhood. I am from Williamsburg. Yes. I am a member of the public, so this is... maybe I knew it. I have never done this before.
Welcome! Everyone, please clap for her. That does not go into her...
...time. Okay. I would like to address two topics: dual language daycare and music programs in daycare classes. I say music because music is also like a second language.
Daycare is a very necessary part of our community. In order for parents to work and provide for their families, they need a safe place for their children. Daycares provide enriched programs for children to play, socialize and learn. Our daycares should not have to struggle for funding. Staff members like the staff members at Esto en Niños, which is in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, which is a dual language daycare — they were not getting paid due to lack of funding, but still those teachers showed up. As a grandmother, I am grateful to know what they do for providing my granddaughter with a dual language program. As a former educator myself who also worked in bilingual early childhood with a bilingual extension — though I am now retired — I have been exposed to the research indicating that knowing two languages is not only helpful for learning about other cultures but is also beneficial to cognitive learning. In this day and age, anything that can improve overall learning is an asset. Dual language programs in our daycares give our children an advantage. Please maintain dual language programs in our daycares.
Also, I want to personally thank the staff from Williamsburg, Brooklyn, south of Fifth Street, for their dedication to our children, because these are teachers that came in when they were not getting paid. Hopefully that will be settled.
As far as music programs in the daycare classes, I understand many private daycare centers have a music program where a musician from a nonprofit company will come into the classes and do an activity with the children. It would be nice to see this for our children as well in these settings. It is not that costly and our children would enjoy and benefit from having a music program such as described. The program could be done routinely on a weekly, bi-weekly or monthly basis. Why should our children get less than those children attending expensive programs? Please maintain and increase funding for our daycares, fund our future and give our children as much advantage as possible. Thank you.
Thank you so much for testifying. You did great! And I did not pay her to come here and represent the West Side. It is so good that they hear it firsthand. You have always been very present. Thank you. And the gentleman right behind you helped us a lot in this last cycle, so thank you. Next.
Good afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the Subcommittee. My name is Judy Blumenthal and I am the Pedagogic Director of Early Starters. We run early childhood safe spaces in four of the five boroughs for young children and caregivers, including newly arrived families living in New York City shelters.
Through play, consistent relationships and trauma-informed care, our educators help children feel safe, learn and build resilience, supporting their school readiness. We also train mothers from the communities we serve to work in our spaces and pursue careers in early childhood education.
Many of the children in our spaces only speak Spanish at home. When a young child enters a new setting, hearing a familiar language helps them feel safe, connect with an educator and express what they need. But language carries more than words — it carries a family's stories and traditions. When we engage children and families in their home language, we learn what comforts a child, what they enjoy and what matters to their family. We can bring that understanding into our work and show the children that their culture and heritage are welcomed and respected. Parents can ask questions and take part in their child's learning with confidence in their home language while they begin to learn English.
Chair Gutiérrez, thank you for recognizing the importance of home language support and Res 0650-2026. We fully support the resolution's opposition to the proposed English-only requirement for Head Start. What you describe is what we see in our spaces — children learn best when their home languages are valued. We appreciate that none of this is new to you, Madam Chair, and that you emphasize and understand this issue better than most, being a bilingual mother yourself.
Programs need multilingual interpretation for families and training that helps staff support young children across languages and cultures. Community organizations that already have trusted relationships with families can help the City reach children who might otherwise be missed. We urge the Council and Mayor Mamdani to invest in community-based programs like ours that reach multilingual young children and their families, including families living in shelters. Every child deserves to be welcomed in a language they understand, with their culture and heritage respected. Every parent deserves to be a full partner in their child's early learning. Thank you.
Good afternoon, Chair Gutiérrez and members of the Subcommittee. My name is Abigail Leonard and I am a Policy and Communications Analyst at Children's Aid. Children's Aid operates a comprehensive early childhood system across nine sites in Harlem, Washington Heights, the Bronx and Staten Island, serving 800 children and families annually. Within that system, our Head Start and Early Head Start programs serve roughly 500 children and families through center-based and home-based services at eight of our sites.
As a Head Start provider, we know multilingual support is not an optional addition to early education — it is integral to the comprehensive, family-centered Head Start model. Children's Aid programs use a planned language approach to support dual language and bilingual learners. Our policy recognizes bilingualism and biliteracy as strengths, and supports English acquisition alongside continued development of a child's home language. When educators do not speak every language represented in a classroom, they use culturally and linguistically appropriate materials and evidence-based strategies to support learning. These practices are especially important in Head Start's family-centered model, but they also benefit children across the City's early childhood programs.
A child learning English may understand a concept but be unable to demonstrate that understanding in English. Supporting their home language helps children participate, communicate and build the foundation needed to acquire English. It also helps staff distinguish between language differences and developmental concerns so children can receive appropriate support.
For these reasons, Children's Aid strongly supports Res 0650-2026 and its comments on the proposed federal rule. The proposed rule would generally require Head Start education to be conducted solely in English. This would take essential tools away from Head Start educators and make it more difficult for providers to fulfill their statutory requirement under the Head Start Act to accommodate children learning English, prepare staff to meet their needs and communicate with parents in the language they understand. We urge the Council to adopt Res 0650-2026, call on the Federal Government to withdraw the English-only requirement and continue strengthening access to multilingual early childhood education across New York City. We would be happy to provide written comments to the Council.
Thank you all so much. I have a couple of questions, and thank you all for consistently showing up to these hearings but also for doing the work that you highlighted in your testimony, which is providing joy and making that connection for families. I think everything about the way that you operate is welcoming and encourages families to speak in their language, whatever language they speak at home. It is just about getting kids excited about reading and speaking. I know the Council funds Cities First Readers, so shout out to the Council members before us and certainly Speaker Menin, who continues to support us in funding it.
What is a dream scenario for the providers? You are all doing things we applaud, but you are unfortunately not able to do it unilaterally across the City. What is the dream scenario and what do you need to make that happen?
So much. We would also like to invest in technology, because our website works very well — if you go in there and just put your child's age and the community they are from, it gives them programs. But a lot of the partners do not have the support to manually put it in.
Just very quickly, talk about the partners that you are referring to. So the libraries automatically get updated because of the system they have, and so...
We started an Airtable, but some of the smaller partners do not have access to that technology, so the website cannot be automatically updated — we would have to put it in manually. Another thing would be just more access to books and multilingual books. We work with four languages now, but as you know, New York City has one of the most diverse language communities. Right now the languages are Haitian Creole, Spanish, English, Bengali and Mandarin, and one of the partners is already working with Arabic and Russian. But there are so many other languages — African languages and others — that we would like to be able to provide materials and books in, and that alone is also expensive, the printing and the ordering of books.
To confirm, at this point you are not necessarily formal partners with NYC Public Schools?
Correct, no we are not. I know you have spoken to Cherie, so she is working with New York City... yeah, City Reads Together. I know they have an early childhood piece of it, so we are working with them. They are trying to work with the Cities First Readers model.
Excellent, well I support it. I think so many of our colleagues — we were joined briefly by Chair Dinowitz, who as well has been supporting this initiative for a long time. Miss Raquel, you said in your testimony that you are retired. There is nothing about you today that sounds retired in that testimony. But I do love that you highlighted music as a second language. Is there a specific program that you are speaking of, and did you work at Los Niños or do you just know them?
From the neighborhoods. 250 which is in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. No, I did not work there. My granddaughter goes to Los Niños, but she had gone to a private daycare and they used to have a music teacher come in and do a weekly, bi-weekly or monthly activity.
And you know, with the public sector you cannot do that — it is kind of expensive. Teachers are not even getting paid enough, so hopefully things are going to get resolved. OK, thank you. Well, thank you, and you are welcome back anytime.
Thank you so much. My question for you, Judy — thank you for your testimony. I guess my question to you, just hearing from the administration, was there anything that you did not hear that you feel like we are missing, based on the potential expansion or how we need to show up for families? Was there something that you did not hear that you wish you would have heard, or something...
...that you loved that you heard? I think that accessibility is certainly something that we run into. Our spaces are trauma-informed spaces for newly arrived families to the City. These families will stay with us until they feel that they and their child are ready to move into the New York City programs. But their understanding of the system — of how to apply and how to navigate those programs and get into those programs — is not very straightforward for them. And that is speaking for the general programs as well as Head Start.
In terms of other things... can I ask, when they feel like it is not accessible, is it specifically just a language barrier, or what does that mean?
Because obviously they are coming from different countries and they do not do things the same way. I think it is a language barrier. I think there is also a level of bureaucracy barrier. A lot of them are also, in the current political climate, feeling very hesitant to give information like their zip code and things like that. So those tend to be the things that we run into when we try to help them integrate into New York City spaces.
In terms of something else that we would love to see more of — we would love it if we could have more collaboration with the administration. We have begun a workforce development program with our mothers and with our staff to help them find work in early childhood. We are currently partnered with CUNY and with Bank Street College of Education. The mothers and the staff get a brief introduction into childhood development and then we have five slots with CUNY to have an apprenticeship with a program in the City.
That they can get additional training with. And we — yes, five...
Slots. So we would love to be able to help provide those. Is that one of the larger interests for people at your sites, wanting to pursue a career in early childhood education? We have seen a great interest from it. Yeah, we have seen a fair amount of mothers want to sign up, and our maestras, who are our staff, they tend to want to see how far they can go in early childhood. So yeah, that interest is there. And yes, they need multilingual learners in early childhood.
Please, repeat it — we absolutely need it. Yeah, it is really great. Well, the last budget the administration and the Council were able to fund, I think, close to three million — two and a half million — to support this community program and that connection. It would be great to really focus on that.
And then Abigail, thank you so much for your testimony. My only question to you is — and I thank you for the support of the resolution — is there something that you did not hear today that you wish you would have heard from the administration?
We greatly appreciate what the administration is doing for multilingual learners and greatly appreciate the Council making the point of where we can go further. As a Head Start provider, though, we currently — as was mentioned before — the City does not provide Head Start programs at this point because of the contract non-renewal. We want to make sure that Head Start programs are a partner in the expansion of early education, and especially as a program that is federally funded, there is a great incentive to being able to partner with our early educators in seeking universal child care expansion. So we want to make sure that that is considered when we are thinking about what expanding child care looks like.
I also think that the point made about being able to distinguish between developmental concerns and language barriers is a point that we really think a lot about. Head Start is a comprehensive services model. We want to make sure that there is prioritization for children with learning disabilities and other disabilities, but also that there is a big difference between a child unable to respond in a language that is not their native language and then struggling to be able to reach those developmental goals. So I think that that is a...
...point that we are very concerned about, for other provisions in the rule as well. But I think we want to make sure that that is a point that is...
...emphasized. Excellent. Yes, thank you. Well, thank you all so much for testifying today. I want to call up for our next panel Betty Byes and Joanne Derwin right now. Is anyone else here that has not signed up to testify? If you are, please approach the sergeant at arms. Yes, great, thank you.
Thank you for the chance to discuss the importance of supporting emergent multilingual learners and their families across the City's early childhood education programs. My name is Betty Byes Mello. I am an attorney and the Director of Early Childhood Education at Advocates for Children of New York. We appreciate that the City has committed to expanding early childhood care and education programs. As New York City Public Schools continues to grow Two-K and strengthen existing programs like Three-K and Pre-K, it is crucial to support the thousands of young children and families in New York City who speak a language other than English in their home.
Among other things, the City should conduct more robust and targeted outreach in multiple languages to immigrant communities to encourage families to apply to Two-K, Three-K and Pre-K, helping ensure that families get hands-on support through the complicated application and registration processes. The City should provide detailed information in MySchools directories for families looking for programs that offer instruction and support in their home language, including specifying what enhanced language supports are available at each program and what that entails. The City should increase efforts to ensure programs are using translation and interpretation tools to communicate with families in their preferred languages, and invest in additional dual language Pre-K programs and explore ways to extend them down in age so that more children can receive bilingual instruction.
The City must also ensure that it is meeting its legal obligation to evaluate and serve young children with developmental delays or disabilities who speak languages other than English. Only about a third of preschoolers with disabilities receive their mandated bilingual programs and services. According to data from New York City Public Schools, of about 4,000 preschoolers who had a right to instruction and services in a language other than English during the 2024-2025 school year, 65% did not receive the bilingual programs and services they had a right to receive.
So as the City continues to make investments in early childhood education and considers ways to expand the workforce to create an early childhood education pipeline, it is crucial to address the need for bilingual evaluators, special education teachers and service providers to meet the needs of emergent multilingual learners with disabilities.
Advocates for Children also supports Res 0650-2026. Any questions? Thank you. Thank you, Betty. Joanna, yeah.
Thanks so much for having me today. My name is Joanne Derwin and I am the Executive Director of One World Project. We are a Spanish immersion community center based in Windsor Terrace, Brooklyn, and we were founded in 2012. We really started because I could not find a Spanish immersion program for my daughter. I had just finished working at the Ford Foundation, where I started an organization that built collaboration between progressive business, labor and community, and I was able to use my knowledge in nonprofit development to start a school.
I just wanted to emphasize how important it is to support multilingual learners. At One World Project, the greatest challenge for us has been about funding. To respond to some of what the administration shared: our current universal pre-K contract every year leaves us with a deficit of $120,000. It is incredibly hard to offer a high quality universal pre-K program in New York City with the funding that is allocated by the Department of Education. The Department of Education does not provide our teachers with what they would earn at a public school — it is about $25,000 per teacher.
So we have to make up that difference by fundraising. In October, for example, we recycled musical instruments and have a big waffle breakfast, and everyone is making a donation to participate. That is how we are doing it, little by little, trying to build enough funds so that we can continue to offer a high quality universal pre-K.
So it is really frustrating to hear that those funds are not available. And just to close — we were offered a 3-K spot and we would have loved to be able to participate, but that happened a couple of years ago, and we could not sustain a school by signing another deficit contract. So I encourage the Department of Education to pay community based organizations what it costs to run a high quality program.
I really want to thank Advocates for Children, which has been incredibly important in working with our families to secure providers who offer services in Spanish. It is incredibly hard to find speech therapists, physical therapists or occupational therapists, for example, who are able to speak Spanish to the children who are participating in our program. Thank you.
Thank you, thank you Joanne. I do have a couple of questions. First, I want to thank you for coming because you left your business to come and testify. I do not know if you were in the room, but I encouraged our new Deputy Chancellor to visit and to meet. I think what I saw on my site visit was just the best example of a director who cares, teachers who care, educators who care, and parents who know a really good thing when they see it.
You had raised the challenge of wanting to be able to open it up to all kids who need it, and so I second so much of what you raised about what the City should be doing to really compensate folks who want to get into early childhood education. It is very hard to promote a universal child care program when we currently do not have enough early childhood education teachers to fill those roles, or to inspire people to want to pursue a career in this sector if they do not know that they are going to be compensated. So thank you so much.
I also just want to highlight for everybody — you operate a wonderful apprenticeship program as well. We should be investing more in that with our CBOs because I think it is really special. So no question, just my love. Thank you so much and I appreciate it.
I did have a question for you, Betty. Thank you for your testimony. It is disheartening to hear that there is still such a large population of families with preschoolers with disabilities that are just not receiving services, and I know that they exist. So I am having a hard time reconciling why the number is so large. What do you think we need to do? What needs to happen? What does outreach and communication need to look like for that to happen?
Yeah, I think the main recommendation we are making today, specific to children who need bilingual special education supports and services, is really growing that pipeline and identifying the providers. As we have heard, it is really challenging for families to get bilingual supports like speech therapy in Spanish, or for children who have more complex needs to get a special education classroom where they are learning in Spanish or their target language. So we really think that we need increased efforts across the board to get special education teachers and service providers, but especially ones that are able to provide bilingual support, including for evaluations. Unfortunately, we hear from families who have been waiting because their child needs to be evaluated for special education.
Special education evaluation, yes. And another language — in Bengali specifically. Can we follow up? Are they still waiting? We are in contact with the family. Oh no. Okay. Let me know. I think you are in the know. Okay, wonderful. Well, thank you both so much for your testimony. Thank you.
I want to have Rebecca Schneider Kaplan — are they signed up? Okay, I think...
We can close out. Once again I want to thank everybody. Thank you to the administration for staying. Welcome to your first hearing — it is a great vibe here, please come back. And thank you to the Mayor's Office of Child Care, and of course thank you to our awesome advocates for their testimony. We look forward to the next hearing this month, which is next week on the seventh. Okay, yeah.