Meeting of October 6, 2026 Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises · October 6, 2026 · 1hr 57m Source: https://hearinghearings.nyc/hearings/subcommittee-on-zoning-and-franchises-2026-10-06/ Video: https://councilnyc.viebit.com/vod/?s=true&v=NYCC-250-8-3_261006-111034.mp4 ================================================================ (00:11:30) Good morning and welcome to today's New York City Council hearing for the Committee on Zoning and Franchises. Ladies and gentlemen, at this time we ask that you silence your electronic devices. If you would like to fill out a speaker card, please see one of the sergeants at arms. Approaching the front desk is strictly prohibited. Please do not approach the front desk before the chair begins. 33. LU 0134-2026 Application number N 240219 ZRK (Park Avenue Brooklyn 33. LU 0140-2026 Application number N 260088 ZRK (289 Kent Avenue (00:15:41) Good morning and welcome to a meeting of the Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises. I am CM Farah Louis, chair of the Subcommittee. This morning we are joined by Council Members Farías, Schulman, Salaam, Felder, Minority Leader Carr and J. Sanchez. Today we are voting on five proposals and holding three hearings. The five proposals that we will vote on are: Fort Hamilton Mews mixed use residential rezoning in CM Santosuosso's district; Park Avenue Brooklyn mixed use residential rezoning in CM Restler's district; 289 Kent Avenue mixed use rezoning in CM Restler's district; Sojourner Truth – Mapes mixed use residential rezoning in CM Feliz's district; and 69-67 108th Street rezoning mixed use residential rezoning in CM Schulman's district. We will then hold hearings on the following proposals: 108-05 68th Road residential rezoning in CM Schulman's district; 100-12 Queens Boulevard mixed use in CM Schulman's district; and the South Richmond Designated Open Space Amendment in CM Morano's district. This meeting is being held in hybrid format. Members of the public who wish to testify may do so in person or via Zoom. Members of the public wishing to testify remotely may register by visiting the Council's website at www.council.nyc.gov/landuse to sign up. For those in person, please see one of the sergeants at arms to prepare and submit a speaker card. Members of the public may also view the livestream broadcast of the meeting at the Council's website. When you are called to testify before the Subcommittee and recognized by myself to speak, your microphone will be unmuted. We will limit public testimony to two minutes per witness. If you have additional testimony that you would like the Subcommittee to consider, or if you have written testimony, please email it to landusetestimony@council.nyc.gov. Written testimony must be submitted up to three days after the hearing is closed. Please indicate the LU number and project in the subject line of your email. Those joining us remotely should remain in the meeting until excused by the chair, as Council Members may have questions. Lastly, for everyone attending today's meeting, this is a government proceeding and decorum must be observed at all times. Members of the public are asked not to speak during the meeting unless you are testifying. The witness table is reserved for people who are called to testify and no video recording or photography is allowed at the witness table. Further, members of the public may not present audio or video recordings as testimony but may submit transcripts of such recordings to the sergeant at arms for inclusion into the record. We will now proceed with the five votes. The first vote concerns LU 0131-2026 and LU 0132-2026 regarding the Fort Hamilton Mews proposal in CM Santosuosso's district. The applicant is seeking to develop a mixed use residential project in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn that would have approximately 292 apartments, of which up to 88 apartments would be permanently affordable. The proposal involves two actions. The first is a zoning map amendment to change the existing residential R5B and R6B district with a C2-3 commercial overlay to a residential R7X district with a C2-4 overlay. The second action is a zoning text amendment to map a Mandatory Inclusionary Housing Area. We are recommending two modifications to this proposal. The R7X district does not provide a sufficient transition from the lower one-to-two-family homes and the four-story buildings behind the proposed development site along Glasson Avenue. Therefore we recommend that the proposed rezoning be limited to an R7D district. The second is to add MIH Option one, which will provide the ability to include more deeply affordable apartments. CM Santosuosso also supports this project as modified and we have been joined by CM Encarnación. The second vote concerns LU 0133-2026 and LU 0134-2026 regarding the Park Avenue Brooklyn Rezoning proposal in CM Restler's district. The applicants consist of multiple private property owners seeking to facilitate the development of 391 apartments, community facilities space and four private schools across 10 development sites. Among the new housing to be built, up to 101 of the apartments will be permanently affordable. The proposal involves two actions. The first is a zoning map amendment to change the existing manufacturing M1-1 and M1-2 district to a new Special Mixed Use District consisting of a paired MX-4 district with a residential R6-1 district. The second action is a zoning text amendment to map a Mandatory Inclusionary Housing Area. We are recommending one modification to remove Option two, which will ensure the affordable apartments are provided at lower rents affordable to families with household incomes at an average of either 40% or 60% AMI. The Council Member supports this application as modified. The third vote concerns LU 0139-2026 and LU 0140-2026 regarding the 289 Kent Avenue Rezoning proposal in CM Restler's district. The applicant is seeking to develop a mixed use residential project in Williamsburg, Brooklyn that would have approximately 270 apartments, of which up to 83 units would be permanently affordable. The proposal involves two actions. The first is a zoning map amendment to change the existing manufacturing M3-1 district partially to a Special Mixed Use District consisting of a paired MX-8 district with a residential R7X district and the remainder to an M1-2A district. The second action is a zoning text amendment to map a Mandatory Inclusionary Housing Area. We are recommending one modification to remove Option two and add Option three, which will ensure the affordable apartments are provided at lower rents affordable to families with household incomes at an average of either 40% or 60% AMI. CM Restler supports this application as modified. The fourth vote concerns LU 0135-2026 and LU 0136-2026 regarding the Sojourner Truth – Mapes mixed use rezoning proposal in CM Feliz's district. The applicant is seeking to develop two affordable housing buildings in the Crotona neighborhood of the Bronx. The development is proposed to be 100% affordable and would have a total of 457 income-restricted apartments. The proposal involves two actions. The first is a zoning map amendment to change the residential R7-2 district and C1-4 commercial overlay to a residential R8 district and C2-4 commercial overlay. The second action is a zoning text amendment to map a Mandatory Inclusionary Housing Area. CM Feliz supports this project. The fifth and final vote concerns LU 0137-2026 and LU 0138-2026 regarding the 69-67 108th Street Rezoning proposal in CM Schulman's district. The applicant is seeking to develop a mixed use residential project in Forest Hills, Queens that would have approximately 59 apartments with up to 18 permanently affordable apartments. The proposal involves two actions. The first is a zoning map amendment to change the existing residential R1-2A district to a residential (00:23:50) R7D district with a C2-4 commercial overlay. The second action is a zoning text amendment to map a Mandatory Inclusionary Housing Area. We are recommending one modification to remove MIH Option two and add Option three, which will ensure the affordable apartments are provided at lower rents affordable to families with household incomes at an average of either 40% or 60% AMI. (00:24:19) CM Schulman supports this application as modified. Council, are there any members with questions or remarks at this time? No, Chair. I now call for a vote to approve LU 0135-2026 and LU 0136-2026 related to the Sojourner Truth – Mapes Rezoning; LU 0131-2026 and LU 0132-2026 related to the Fort Hamilton Mews Rezoning proposal; LU 0133-2026 and LU 0134-2026 related to the Park Avenue Brooklyn Rezoning proposal; LU 0137-2026 and LU 0138-2026 related to the 69-67 108th Street Rezoning proposal; and LU 0139-2026 and LU 0140-2026 related to the 289 Kent Avenue Rezoning proposal. Council, please call the roll. (00:25:04) Chair Louis. Aye. CM Farías. (00:25:08) Permission to explain my vote. Thank you, Chair. I just wanted to say, in terms of the Sojourner Truth – Mapes Rezoning, LU 0135-2026 and LU 0136-2026 application today, just in recognition of member deference and the prerogative of the Council Member whose district the project is located in, I want to recognize that the community board and local union have deep concerns about the negotiation and deal made. Those perspectives deserve to be heard and respected and I hope conversations continue as the Council moves towards a larger vote in the Land Use Committee and to the Stated Meeting. My role in this committee is to consider the full land use record before us, including the proposed use, the broader needs of the community and the position of the member representing the district. So in this case I will be voting aye and supporting the request coming from CM Feliz. Aye on all. Thank you, Council Member. (00:26:11) CM Schulman. (00:26:15) Permission to explain my vote. (00:26:16) So on the 108th Street project, I support it. The applicant has also made promises to work with me and the community board around issues of community space and all of that, which we very much appreciate. With that I vote aye on all. (00:26:36) CM Salaam. Aye. CM Felder. (00:26:46) Aye. (00:26:47) CM Encarnación. Aye. CM Sanchez. (00:26:53) Aye on all, with the exception of LU 0135-2026 and LU 0136-2026, for which I am a no. Minority Leader Carr. (00:27:07) Permission to explain my vote. (00:27:09) Sure, thank you. Excuse me, thank you, Chair. (00:27:15) I just want to say a few words about the Fort Hamilton Mews project. To CM Santosuosso, she spoke at the last hearing about how hamstrung she felt given the Council's increasingly limited options when it comes to negotiating land use decisions. I represent a portion of Brooklyn just on the other side of the Verrazano Bridge from this project. I hear from many constituents who have concerns about it and I think this is just the sad place where we have come to, where a local member does not have the institutional authority that they once had to negotiate projects on behalf of their communities, particularly at a time when Council Members are in conversation with the community about the larger zoning and planning issues facing Bay Ridge. This project preempts that, as she articulated at the last hearing. I think now that we have had the publication officially of the so-called bottom 12, which is going to result in a fast-tracking, as they call it, of a number of community districts — which is really just another way of saying selective disenfranchisement, where some communities are no longer going to have the voice that they once had and that others retain — I think it really shows that there is a clear legal issue that I fervently hope and believe will be explored moving forward. But that being said, this is the choice that we have before us and I respect the Council Member in having a clear view with respect to what is possible at this given time. So with that said, with great frustration, I vote yes on the Fort Hamilton Mews project and I vote yes on the others. Thank you. (00:29:02) At this time, for all items announced except for Sojourner Truth, which are LU 0135-2026 and LU 0136-2026, we have eight votes in the affirmative, zero in opposition and zero abstentions. Regarding Sojourner Truth, LU 0135-2026 and LU 0136-2026, we have seven votes in the affirmative, one opposing and zero abstentions. We are going to keep the vote open and proceed to the hearings. I will now open the hearing on Preconsidered LU regarding T2026-2620, 108-05 68th Road, a mixed use residential rezoning proposal in Forest Hills, Queens in CM Schulman's district. The applicant is seeking to develop a mixed use residential building that would have approximately 33 apartments. Mandatory Inclusionary Housing would be mapped as part of this application, which would require that approximately eight of the apartments be permanently affordable. For anyone wishing to testify regarding this proposal remotely, if you have not already done so, you must register online by visiting the Council's website at council.nyc.gov/landuse. For anyone with us in person, please see one of the sergeants at arms to submit a speaker card. If you would prefer to submit written testimony, you can always do so by emailing it to landusetestimony@council.nyc.gov. I now recognize CM Schulman for remarks. (00:30:34) Thank you, Chair. I would like to thank the applicant team for presenting their proposal at today's hearing. I look forward to working with them to ensure that the community's needs for affordable housing and quality of public services are well served by the land use process. To elaborate a little bit on CM Carr's remarks: what he meant is that the City Council, because of proposals that were done last year that were voted on in the City Charter and that are up for a vote, will be excluded from having any input on certain projects. I just want folks to be aware of that. We are trying to negotiate as much as we can but it is going to be less and less, so I just want that to be known. Thank you. (00:31:25) I now recognize a Council Member. Good morning, Council Member. How would you (00:31:36) like for my remarks to be reflected? As the Council Member said, due to member deference, and understanding that the Bronx project still has a way to go considering the union's perspective and the community board, with that I do vote (00:31:56) aye. OK. So at this time, for all items discussed except Sojourner Truth, which are LU 0135-2026 and LU 0136-2026, we have nine votes in the affirmative, zero in opposition and zero abstentions. Regarding Sojourner Truth, LU 0135-2026 and LU 0136-2026, we have eight votes in the affirmative, one in opposition and zero abstentions. These items are now referred to the Land Use Committee and we resume our hearings. Thank you, Council. I will now call the applicant (00:32:30) panel for this proposal, which consists of Richard Lobel, Rebecca Dovody, Jacqueline Diaz, Kevin Cortez and... Council, could you please administer the oath? Good morning. Can you please raise your right hand? As an order of business, we have four people but we called up six, so we have two online. Um, yeah, one of them is not (00:33:01) speaking. OK. (00:33:02) So can you please state your name for the record? Who is at the table? Kevin Cortez. Richard Lobel. Devon Murray. (00:33:17) You will be giving your testimony, which is limited to 10 minutes. You should start to conclude your presentation at eight minutes. When you begin your presentation, please restate your name and the name of your (00:33:27) organization. Thank you. (00:33:31) Richard Lobel of Sheldon Lobel, for All My Children Daycare and Nursery School. We are here today to discuss the 108-05 68th Road Rezoning. I will take us through the land use rationale for the proposed rezoning, and Murray will then discuss some of the architectural aspects, and then we are happy to answer any questions. So why are we here? Next slide. This is a project summary. 108-05 68th Road, which is Block 2179X, would be rezoned pursuant to this application from an existing R1-2A zoning to an R7A zoning district, which at the site would facilitate a new seven-story plus cellar mixed use community facility and residential building with roughly 38,100 square feet, of which roughly 11,000 square feet is community facility and the remainder residential. This would allow for a nonprofit nursery school on the ground floor as well as an existing youth center facility to operate on the second story. In addition to this, as with all such rezonings, there would be a Mandatory Inclusionary Housing text amendment to require affordability at the site, here penciled out at Option One. The next slide has the numbers behind the proposed development, which as stated would be a seven-story plus cellar building at roughly a 5.0 FAR pursuant to R7A guidelines. 11,000 square feet would be community facility use, with 5,000 square feet for All My Children Daycare and Nursery and 6,000 square feet for the youth center. 27,900 square feet plus or minus on floors three through seven would be occupied by residential use. The height is the same at 75 feet, seven stories, with a side setback at 65 feet, six stories. Parking is provided in the cellar. The number of units broken down as you see: 9 one-bedrooms, 23 two-bedrooms and 1 three-bedroom, allowing for generous unit sizes of close to two bedrooms each. There would be eight affordable units within that with the same ratios as the larger breakdown of units. Transportation would be drop-off. Most of the children would walk to the site escorted by a parent or guardian. The next slide is the zoning map, which tells some of the story in terms of the existing zone. You can see this is an R1-2A district, so zoned in 2009 pursuant to the Cord Meyer Forest Hills Rezoning. Prior to that it was an R1-2, so this property has been zoned R1-2 or R1-2A since 1961. The community board recognized that and saw that when you look at the area map and the surrounding buildings, many of these buildings reflect larger floor areas than would be permitted in the R1-2A, which is one of the reasons I think they supported this. Immediately to the west of the site across 108th Street is an R7-1 district, a pre-existing district, so you have a larger building along that side. But also on our side of the street you have existing grandfathered or non-compliant buildings as well. There is C4-5X and C4-4A zoning allowing for R7A and R7X closer to Queens Boulevard, as well as an R8X rezoning within a block and a half of the property that was approved in May 2025. The next slide is the tax map, which just breaks down the rezoning itself. Again you can see our lot, roughly 7,800 square feet, Lot One, and the adjacent lot, Lot Six. The next slide I think tells the story well in terms of why this is a meritorious rezoning. 108th Street here is a wide street per zoning at 80 feet wide. We are within 600 feet of a subway station, within half a mile of five subway lines as well as the Long Island Rail Road. So when the Commission approved this, they noted the fact that this was a transit-rich area, that the site itself would have no residential displacement, and indeed would allow for greater and more robust community facility uses at the site. This is also recognized by Queens Community Board 6, which notes that there is a shortage of indoor recreation space both for nursery and pre-K kids as well as for teenagers, which would be served by the existing site. So they were very happy to comply with our request and approve this rezoning. I think the vote was 35 to 4 in favor. It was a very strong vote. In addition to this, the site has good access, is on a corner lot, and is within a block of Yellowstone Park. All these things are hallmarks of what we think lead to a good rezoning. If you can just forward through the next several slides with photographs just to show the area of the site as well as the surrounding six and seven-story buildings, I would hand the microphone over to Murray, who can briefly discuss the architectural plans, and then we would be happy to answer any questions. (00:38:16) Questions. Okay, thank you. Can you just please restate your name before you start your talk? Oh, sorry — Devon Murray. (00:38:23) Thank you. This is the proposed rendering of the project. Next slide please. This is a breakdown of what we just went through. As we said, there are 33 total apartments. Eight are proposed. Zoning would allow an 11-story building, but with the FAR we can fit all of that within seven stories. Next slide. We have laid out here again where the project is in relationship to the immediate neighborhood. Next slide please. For the project, starting in the cellar, we are not required to provide parking but we have provided 12 spaces here to keep as much of the residential parking off of the streets as possible. Next slide. The first floor would have much of the community facility that we spoke about, with a small residential lobby and parking off of 68th Road. Next slide. The second floor is the community facility with an outdoor play terrace in the inner court. The next slide shows the typical residential floor plan with a mix of one and two bedrooms. Next slide. This is where we set back on the seventh floor plan, where we have our single three-bedroom and outdoor recreation space. The next slide shows the building section outlining the setback on the seventh floor. We have a total building height of 75 feet. The next slide shows a rough massing model of the proposed build-out. The red is the community facility, the blue is the residential. On the next slide we have a rendering of the proposed building in the neighborhood context. The next slide is another rendering, and the next slide shows 3D massing models of the proposed building. Next slide, you can see this massing against the existing buildings. Next slide. The next few slides are also just the elevations, so you can go through these as well. Great. (00:41:25) So we can stop there. Just to reiterate, the community board was very pleased with this application, as evidenced by the vote. They had limited comments. The building itself they saw as contextual with the surrounding area. They appreciated that the height was comparable to buildings to the north and south of the property — it is six stories — despite the fact that those buildings are also within an R1-2A district. We appreciate and thank CM Schulman for her guidance during this process. We have had some very open conversations with her office, her, and the community. This is a valued nonprofit which serves the entire community in terms of child care and care of teenagers after school. So we are happy and hopefully we will have the support of the Council, and with that we have not answered any questions yet. (00:42:19) Thank you so much. I have a few questions and I will hand it over to CM Schulman. Given that the number of required parking spaces is below the waiver threshold, as a result you do not have to provide parking. How did you determine 12 spaces was the correct number of parking spots to provide? Could you provide more information? I will start, and if the remainder of the applicant team has any comments they can add those. We have a rezoning which was approved by the subcommittee — 69-67 108th Street — as a matter of public record, a building several... (00:42:56) ...blocks away which did not provide parking. The community board here was happy that we were providing some parking. (00:43:04) And it is always kind of a push and pull in terms of the availability of mass transit and the demands of the site. Here I think the fact that there are going to be nonprofits operating here which are going to have some pick-up and drop-offs — it was useful to have some parking on the site, as well as some employees in terms of the nonprofit and the childcare. So 12 spaces was a chance to bring a limited amount of cars off the street and provides some flexibility in that regard. The community board was appreciative. They did not really condition the application on that, but it would seem like just a minimal number of spots we can provide. (00:43:41) All right. And did you consider including a commercial overlay, and if so, why did you choose not to map one? (00:43:48) Sure. So again, in comparison to 69-67 108th Street, which does have a commercial overlay, conversations with City Planning were around the fact that that project is marginally closer to Queens Boulevard. There is a commercial overlay within a block to two blocks of that property, and so it was just felt to be more appropriate here to encourage residential and community facility uses that would be permitted under the existing zoning, rather than to bring the commercial all the way up to the site. So that was the reason and the rationale. We are happy to proceed without a commercial overlay, and I think that was appreciated by all the stakeholders as well. (00:44:26) Thank you. And now I recognize CM Schulman for questions. (00:44:30) Thank you, Chair. Which option do you intend to use? Option One. Is the ground floor tenant going to be the daycare facility the applicant runs? It is. How many seats do you project the facility would have? (00:44:46) I would defer to Diaz if she can address that. About 120 children. (00:44:54) The community board made a recommendation to include vehicle charging facilities for the parking garage. Is that something you are considering? (00:45:01) It is. I have talked to Murray about that. It is something that this architectural team has put in other buildings similarly situated, and we would be happy to do that. Also, with every development that is coming into the district — with all the storms that we have had, Forest Hills was never really, is not a flood zone, but that said there is a lot of flooding that occurs, especially with these unusual storms that we are having and everything else. So has any thought been given to how, when you are building it, to ameliorate that? (00:45:35) I would probably defer to Murray as well as Cortez. Yes, so we would on the roof of the building retain water and slowly disperse that back into the sewer drains. Great. Do you have any other questions? (00:45:56) Your Council... and invite my colleagues to ask questions. All good, Counsel. Are there any members of the public who wish to testify remotely or in person regarding this proposal? (00:46:09) Yes, we have one member of the public who would like to testify in person, but we do not have anybody online. (00:46:16) All right. This panel is now excused. Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you. (00:46:26) For members of the public here to testify, please note that witnesses will generally be called in panels of three. If you are a member of the public signed up to testify, please stand by when you hear your name being called and prepare to speak when I indicate that you may begin. Please also know that once all panelists in your group have completed their testimony, if testifying remotely you will be removed from the meeting as a group and the next group of speakers will be introduced. Once removed, participants may continue to view the live stream broadcast of the hearing on the Council website. Members of the public will be given two minutes to speak. Please do not begin until the Sergeant at Arms has started the clock. The following individuals have signed up to testify and should now come to the witness table. Sure Hands Shalom... oh, this is a different... (00:47:23) Yeah, that is for the next project. So do you want to testify regarding which project? Regarding 68th... (00:47:34) ...Road or Queens Boulevard? That is the next one. Actually, we do not have anybody signed up for 68th Road. Let us just make — if we can do a last call to make sure that we are not missing anybody. Last call: if there are any members of the public who wish to testify regarding this proposal remotely, please press the raise hand button now, or if you are in person please identify yourself to one of the Sergeants at Arms. This is the last call. 30 seconds. Being that there are no members of the public who wish to testify regarding the Preconsidered Land Use relating to the 108-05 68th Road residential mixed use rezoning proposal, the public hearing is now closed and items are now laid over. I will now open the hearing on the Preconsidered Land Use regarding 100-12 Queens Boulevard mixed use residential rezoning proposal in Forest Hills, Queens, in CM Schulman's district. The applicant is seeking to develop a mixed use residential building that would have approximately 389... (00:48:46) ...apartments. Mandatory Inclusionary Housing would be mapped as part of this application, which would require approximately 97 of the apartments to be permanently affordable. For anyone wishing to testify regarding this proposal remotely, if you have not already done so, you must register online by visiting the Council's website at council.nyc.gov. For anyone with us in person, please see one of the Sergeants at Arms to submit a speaker card. If you would prefer to submit written testimony, you can always do so by emailing it to landuse.testimony@council.nyc.gov. I now recognize CM Schulman. Thank you. (00:49:19) Good morning. I would like to thank the applicant team for their presentation on the proposal before the subcommittee. The community has a number of concerns about this project, especially about the proposed density, the displacement of small businesses and local businesses that are there now, including a drugstore. There is a concern from the building behind it, the Fontaine, and I want to — I have a constituent here — I want to apologize. I know some members of the Fontaine have reached out to me because the co-op has retained a lawyer. I cannot meet with you personally about this or discuss it, so please work through the attorney. Also, the area is vulnerable to stormwater flooding. That is another concern. While they share these concerns and continue to work with the development team to address them, I want to express my continuing support for bringing more affordable housing to Forest Hills. Thank you. Thank you, CM. (00:50:52) You may begin your testimony. Please start wrapping it up at eight minutes if possible. When you begin your presentation please restate your name and the name of your organization. You may all begin. (00:51:01) Thank you. I was going to say good morning but now I am going to say good afternoon. Chairwoman Louis, CM Schulman, all the members of the subcommittee, thank you for letting us speak today. My name is Ed Wallace, and together with my partner Jay Siegel at Greenberg Traurig, we are the lawyers for Benenson Capital Partners. With me to my left is Rachel Loeb, who represents Benenson, as well as Chris Fogarty, who is the architect. I am particularly honored to appear before the City Council because I was... (00:51:34) ...once privileged to serve in this body, so it is a real treat. Council Member Lynn Schulman, from the early days we have listened to the community, and I am pleased to preview that we have — I do not want to overstate it — we have an agreement in principle, a documented agreement, with the neighbors at the Fontaine. They are here today and they can speak for themselves, and I do not want to put words in their mouth. But thanks candidly to their good counsel and another former member of the Council, Dominick Rakia, we have had a very open line of communication and I think that has served everybody well. Finally, you are going to hear more about our response to community concerns, including efforts to preserve the current retail uses and to accommodate post-development those tenants as well as the labor unions who are here to testify as well. With that I am going to turn it over to Rachel Loeb. (00:52:32) Good afternoon. I am Rachel Loeb and I represent the Benenson family. I have worked with them for the last four years since I left EDC, where I was President before this, so I am really honored to be here. Several years ago the Benenson family started looking at this property, which they developed and have cared for for the last 70 years. It has always been the intention at the right time to redevelop this and bring housing as the current zoning allows. But at that moment in time we looked at the opportunity to bring not only more housing but a better building to the neighborhood, as well as affordable housing, and really continue that legacy of the retail tenants. So Jay is going to walk us through the details and the architecture, and then we will talk about the community benefits. Thank you. (00:53:19) Thank you. Rachel, could you go to the next slide please? So this is the property on the south side of Queens Boulevard between 67th Avenue and 67th Road. It occupies the entire block front. It is currently zoned R7-1 with a C1 overlay. This is an application to change the zoning to R9X with a C2 overlay and to seek a Mandatory Inclusionary Housing Option one. Next slide please. It is well suited for housing. It has a subway station right in front of it for the M, E and R, and it has a bus stop as well. Next slide please. This is just depicting what I said a moment ago. It is currently a 26,000 square foot site, currently zoned R7-1 with the C1 overlay, and we are seeking to rezone to the R9X with C2. Next slide please. So on the left hand side is the building that could be constructed under the current zoning. Because of sky exposure plane obligations from all three street fronts, the building, to achieve the height of a little over 200 feet, would have to be set back from all three streets, pushed against our rear lot line, and would be a little less than 20 feet from a neighbor. What we are proposing, which is on the right hand side, is an R9 building which would be on Queens Boulevard, set back almost 50 feet from the neighbor. Normally the purpose of sky exposure planes is to provide light and air from streets, and you can see that Queens Boulevard being about 200 feet wide here is not a reason to provide light near to Queens Boulevard. Next slide please. This is a depiction — you have heard a lot about the Fontaine and we will hear more from them directly — but what I showed you before on the zoning, our building would be to the left of that loading berth area, just a little under 20 feet from the Fontaine. This is not exactly precise, but the building I showed you would be basically in line with the blue garbage container against the wall. So we would be set back almost 50 feet from the building. Next slide please. (00:55:38) Mr. Jones, let us go to the next slide. This is the floor area comparisons. As a result of the rezoning there would be an increase of about 267 units, from 130 to 309. The 132 market rate units now carry an affordable obligation. Of the 267 increase, approximately 100 would be affordable. So while the increase is 267, the affordable increase is a significant portion of that. The height of the building, although it is certainly a lot taller than the adjacent building, is comparable at 215 feet to 209 feet. Next slide please. This is a depiction of the heights of buildings in the area. It shows us at our proposed height of 215 feet. It shows that there are larger buildings just a few blocks away. They were able to do something like what I showed you that we could do as of right under the current zoning by setting back from different streets. The Vista is 40 feet higher than us, and there are other buildings on or near Queens Boulevard that are comparable height or higher than we are. I think at this point Rachel, thank you. (00:56:55) As we started to conceive this project and think about what the benefits would be to the community, one is creating housing. We know we are in a housing crisis. But not only that — delivering approximately 100 affordable units, and we are proposing that we would do them at option one, really meeting the needs of the community. That is something we heard from the community board and from the Councilwoman. As I mentioned, we developed this 70 years ago. We have curated it, we understand our retailers, and we have always brought what we felt are the retailers that meet the moment in the community. We are committed to that as well. We are in communication with all of our tenants. Many of them have leases that have already expired, but we really want to make sure that we bring back that neighborhood-serving retail. It will not only benefit our neighbors but benefit the future residents of our building. There will be improved higher ceilings, energy efficient systems and things like that. This also gives us an opportunity with the new building to widen the sidewalk, put in street trees, address the public realm and be a better neighbor. I would like Chris to answer more questions. We will not only be meeting but exceeding code around sustainability. It will be an all-electric building. We really looked at it and he will show you contextual materials. This came out of conversations with the community board as well. So we have been there for 70 years and we are going to be there for another 70 years. We want this building to feel part of the community. And then finally there will be bike rooms, electric bikes, 38 parking spaces — none are required, but having some in the basement — as well as charging for FDNY-approved micro-mobility, and so we are including that as well. Next slide please. Oh, I am sorry, that was not changed. So I just reviewed that. And finally, next slide please. I went through this but we really listened and tried to incorporate the community board's requests. As a result of their vote we can go through questions and talk more about that, but I want to make sure Chris has time to go through the design. (00:59:04) Thank you. Next slide please. My name is Chris Fogarty from Fogarty Finger Architects. We are very excited to present our proposal today. We are proposing a 21-storey masonry building on the south side of Queens Boulevard, listening and learning from the community. Next slide please. We also walked the neighborhood and drew on some of the beautiful precedents of Tudor language — red brick and masonry — and the way they play with the street wall and the height and setback. We wondered how we could incorporate that into our building, so we used some facade and street-facing set walls to try and recreate that. We also pushed the building as far north as we could, away from our neighbors to the south. We are lucky because the sun is always casting shadows on Queens Boulevard and not on our neighbors, so that was a fortunate circumstance rather than a design choice, but we are very excited about that. And then next slide. And then finally we spent a lot of time thinking about how it works at the street level. As Rachel mentioned, we want to recreate that ability for (01:00:21) retail of all shapes and sizes to come back, especially smaller retail. So there is an individual, smaller bay every 20 or 30 feet to allow different retail units to come in. Again, widening the sidewalk and increasing the number of street trees, and working with the local community as they work through their cycling lanes and everything else. (01:00:44) So thank you for letting me talk. That is it. Leslie, we will give our 13 seconds. (01:00:54) Right on time. Thank you. I have a couple of questions and then I will hand it over to Council Members. How many of the affordable units are expected to be family-sized apartments with two or more bedrooms? (01:01:07) Thank you so much for your question. We have not completed the design so I cannot give you the exact count, but we have included in our plan a significant number of two- and three-bedroom units because we actually think there is a demand for it. By the rules it will be proportional, so the number of twos... I think approximately our last plan was 25 to 30%, but that will be finalized once the design is complete. (01:01:40) Finalized. OK. And although parking is not required, the proposal includes 38 accessory parking spaces. How did you determine this amount? So it is one level of parking. There is currently surface parking there — it is not a manned garage. (01:01:55) And so in the basement of our site we need to have a variety of mechanical spaces and storage and bike rooms, and so we allocated the rest of the space to parking. (01:02:06) All right. And did you consider a subway improvement density bonus? We looked at it but not really — we are very far from there and we did not pursue it. (01:02:17) Do you want to answer that? OK. (01:02:20) Yeah, the zoning required us to offer an easement on the site and they sent us a letter declining it. They apparently have other plans for how to make this station accessible that do not include our building. OK. When we were... (01:02:39) ...to talk a little bit about the Fontaine. So my understanding from your testimony is that if you had built it as of right — in other words, you did not have to come to the City Council, you would have had permission to build — you would have been right on top of the Fontaine. Is that correct? And basically under what you are proposing you would be farther away. Is that right? Correct. (01:03:07) We could not be right on top — we would be 20 feet away from them because they have a 19 foot 7 inch gap between their building and their property line. But I am just asking so that people know what the as-of-right situation is and what you guys are proposing. (01:03:28) And I am hoping that you guys come to an agreement, because before anybody votes on this that has to happen. Now, the small businesses — you said you have reached out to... (01:03:45) ...them. Yes. I got a full briefing and I actually have a list of all the square footages for the various tenants, including all of what I would call the smaller mom-and-pops. I think you know it better than we know it. There was support at the community board subcommittee and in our discussions even with the Fontaine. This is a business-to-business transaction — we cannot sort of spill their beans — but what I think is primary is that we have an ongoing dialogue. We are now talking to them not only about their national presence but also about the possibility that they would have a temporary pharmacy nearby during construction. Let me state a sad fact: you cannot build a building without demolishing what is there. No, that is just... (01:04:32) ...reality. But we are very hopeful that they will come back full swing after that, and that during the construction they will at least maintain a presence. I do not want to get into trouble with them by telling their story, but that is the approach we have taken. In terms of the new building, we do not think there will be an economic barrier for that, or frankly for the kind of retail that Benenson — everybody came to us to say, well, you know, you are kicking out the... No. Benenson has worked with all of these tenants, has put them there, has made the accommodation mutually beneficial. If they want to stay after their lease expired, stay until we build — we are not going to build probably for another year or so, so there is time. In terms of the other, smaller ones, the question is: do you want to come back? Let us work on that plan. We have reached out to them. If you do not want to come back, can we replicate a similar kind of tenancy so that the neighborhood does not feel like... if they want to come back, there will be a space during the... (01:05:37) ...construction. I know that is a particular concern to you. I will just say this: having done relocations, the people who decide whether it is residential or commercial, where they want to be, are those people. The best we can do is say stay a little longer, maybe here is a little idea for you. But we have a client who really understands having been in the neighborhood. So yes, and frankly happy to keep your... (01:06:02) ...office informed. That will help. Yeah, my office will — please, if you hear anything to the contrary. (01:06:08) We know. Absolutely. And how long will construction take? Sorry, I pushed the wrong button. This building will take approximately 32 to 36 months from start to full completion. After about two years it is fully enclosed and they are just finishing the interiors. In terms of the construction mitigation plan for the project — noise, dust, all of that... (01:06:41) Yeah, so there is a fully documented plan. I have to say, actually, there is a complete construction plan that has been worked out and negotiated with DOT, DEP and others. We have made some agreements around fencing that have actually been recorded against the property, and other staging to minimize impact on the neighbors. That has already been agreed to and recorded. We have also reached out to all of our neighbors around the block, and we will continue to have a point person — some kind of liaison — because when we built on the other side of Queens Boulevard we had some construction issues, and so we want to make sure that there is somebody... (01:07:32) ...there. Whether it is with the owner or the contractor, who we have not picked yet, yes, it will be a full part of the plan. (01:07:40) OK. And what are you doing in terms of stormwater and flooding, because it is a huge... (01:07:49) ...building. I am going to let Chris answer that question as the architect. My answer is similar to the last architect's, which is that the new rules mean that we retain all the water. Unlike today, the same amount of roof area exists but they do not retain it. We will retain it and then it drips back into the system over time. (01:08:10) Now, you said it will be an all-electric building. You are aware that when we have had these heat waves, Forest Hills is one of the first areas to have reduced power and everything else. So how would that be mitigated? I can answer... (01:08:28) ...that. Because of the new codes, and because of the new zoning codes especially, which help with additional sustainability requirements, the load of this building would be much less than a comparable building built five years ago, and certainly much less than one built 10 years ago. So it is not going to be perfect, but it is going to be a lot less than it could be. By achieving these new standards we are going to reduce the amount that it could have been. So that is not really a good answer, but it is... (01:08:59) No, I know, but I just want to be mindful of that. You also — I saw in what you presented that you said you were going to work with DOT around the bike lanes. Because I have been in touch — we should have a conversation — I have been in touch with DOT because the previous administration handled the bike lanes in a hit-or-miss way, and so... (01:09:26) ...there is no consistency in how they are done. To the point where, where you are building this building on Queens Boulevard, it is single lanes so that the express buses go down there, and then if somebody double-parks or stops or whatever, they go over the barriers. So we need to work on that. Let me see... when do you think you will have some agreement with the Fontaine? (01:09:59) We have an exchange of writing that is very enforceable. It has been worked out and I... (01:10:07) ...think before this Council votes on... (01:10:10) ...anything, we appreciate the encouragement to accomplish that and we will do our utmost to do that. OK, that is all the questions I have. Thank you. (01:10:18) Thank you, Chair. I want to make a quick comment regarding the number of units, because you did not have an affirmative number to share with us today. I just wanted to remind you, if you could follow up with the Council Members so that it is clear what the number of units... (01:10:36) ...of twos and threes will be. Yes. OK. (01:10:39) That is important. Do any of my colleagues have questions for this panel? All right, this panel is now excused. Thank you for being here today. Thank you very much. Council, are there any members of the public who wish to testify remotely or in person regarding this proposal? (01:10:55) Yes, Chair. We have seven people in person who have signed up to testify and no one online. (01:11:02) OK. For members of the public here to testify, please know that witnesses will generally be called in groups of three. If you are a member of the public signed up to testify, please stand by when you hear your name being called and be prepared to speak when I indicate that you may begin. Once all panelists in your group have completed their testimony, if you are appearing remotely you will be removed from the meeting as a group and the next group of speakers will be introduced. You may continue to view the live stream broadcast of the hearing on the Council's website. Members of the public will be given up to two minutes to speak. Please do not begin until the Sergeant at Arms has started the clock. The following individuals who have signed up to testify should come to the witness table now: Marilyn Soler, Lawrence Lowe, Kitty Woodman. Yes, and Shahrnaz... you may begin. (01:12:28) You may begin. Thank you. Thank you very much for your time and good afternoon everybody. My name is Janos Shalom and I live in the Fontaine building. First I would like to thank Miss Marnie Soler, our sponsor, for negotiating with Benenson Capital Partners in good faith on behalf of Fontaine residents. I admire her professional dedication and diligent effort to support and protect us. Thank you. I am a UFT retiree and my husband is also retired. We were looking forward to aging in place. Unfortunately for the past six months we have been going through very difficult times mentally, knowing a 21-storey building will be built in front of us. We are only six floors high and this new building will be only 50 feet away from our windows, blocking our ambient light and our view permanently. Besides that, there will be overcrowded schools, overburdened transportation, heavy traffic and the loss of businesses which provide necessary daily needs, especially for seniors and the disabled. It is noble that City officials feel responsible to provide housing for people who are in need, but how about protecting the group of people who have already established a decent place to live? Do they deserve to live in agony? I hope we the constituents of Forest Hills could be protected according to our needs by our elected officials as well. I appreciate your time. (01:14:48) You may begin. Yes, good afternoon. My... (01:14:51) My name is Kitty Ruderman. I am 80 years old and I am on a fixed income. I have been a resident of the Fontaine Gardens for the past 17 years and I have been so happy living there. It is a lovely building and I have a very lovely... but at this time we are all totally depressed. They are planning to... I am on the sixth floor, my windows face Queens Boulevard. You can imagine with a 21-story high rise right in front of my windows. I wake up in the morning and see the sky every morning. I will now have no light, no air. I will be completely entombed. I face... and I know no one cares, but what if it were your mother or your grandmother? I thank you all for your time. Thank you. (01:15:48) Kitty, you may begin. (01:15:55) Yeah, one second. Hi, my name is Lawrence Lau. I am a resident of the Fontaine, the building on lot one. It is most impacted by the proposed development and would also be impacted by the rezoning. In addition, I am on the corporation's working committee for the development and I am actually testifying for the rezoning, if there was some sort of agreement, conditional to some sort of written agreement. In short, the rezoning does allow the development to be built closer to Queens Boulevard and away from the Fontaine. This pushes many of the quality of life issues away from our building. And I can tell you, when residents were first made aware of this development, many of them were very much against it. Since then, as a member of the working committee, I have worked with the Fontaine board and the developers to put together some sort of massing that would be more acceptable to Fontaine residents. As it was communicated to us, what the proposed development looks like is much more favorable to residents than the as-of-right one proposed if the rezoning was rejected. Last week we held a town hall and I basically told residents they are going to build, and here are some options. Here is what it would look like if the rezoning was rejected. Here is what it would look like if accepted. Who wants it to be rejected? And nobody raised their hand. So I think we have made tremendous progress, and I think everyone in the room would agree with me that in the next few weeks I would like to come to some sort of binding agreement sooner rather than later. Thank you. (01:17:43) Thank you. You may begin. (01:17:47) Good morning. My name is Marilyn Soler. I am the managing agent, member of the board, and originally the sponsor of the Fontaine Apartment Owners Corp. The Fontaine is a six-story residential building with 155 units, originally built in the 1950s as a rental property and converted to co-op in the 1980s. Our building is adjacent to and directly behind the proposed project site. Many of our residents, some of whom are here today, are longtime shareholders with families and rent-stabilized stakeholders. The applicant reached out to us over the summer and recently we have been meeting with them weekly and engaging in direct conversation on how this project can move forward in a way that is acceptable to both parties. About two weeks ago the applicant came to us with a design revision to potentially soften the overwhelming and isolating aspect of their original plan, which when completed will be rather monolithic and run an entire city block long. We reviewed the applicant's revisions at the town hall meeting for residents last Monday and I am delighted to say that the plan was met, for the most part, with relief. But more than that, it is potentially an attractive, livable, breathable compromise that the board is comfortable with, and that with the proper aesthetics could be a win-win for our block and for the surrounding neighborhood. We are relieved, as I said, and also grateful to everyone who worked to bring this about. We met with the applicant again last week and we are finally able to turn to the many logistical details that go along with such a large construction project. Both sides are committed to reducing this agreement to writing before the City Council vote so the project can move forward in the spirit of cooperation and goodwill that has (01:19:59) developed over these past several weeks of working together. With the applicant, we are hopeful and expect that these remaining items will resolve themselves in a way that is comfortable for both sides. And having nothing to do with this, thank you very much for making us aware of that fast track and the disenfranchisement of your Council. Thank you. Glad to know that. Thank you so much. (01:20:22) CM Schulman has a question. So the two individuals, the two of you that are against this — if this gets rejected, they can build as-of-right, elected officials had nothing to do with it, right up against the Fontaine. You do realize that, correct? I am aware and I do not know what I am going to do. No, I am okay. We have all been aware. (01:21:01) So let me just also reiterate — aside from the fast track, I want to say I have been working with the applicant and your lawyer to make sure that this happens. (01:21:18) And that there is some kind of agreement. All right, that is number one. Number two is that in a Charter proposal that was voted on last... if I reject it, the Mayor and the Borough President can vote for it and it will still go forward. So I can use my limited opportunity to make it better, and I want to thank the applicant, who has been willing to do that with me, which they do not have to, by the way. So we are trying to do what we can. And those are the big issues — the Fontaine and the stores, because I use those also. You know, I live in the park, so... (01:22:04) So I go over there all the time — the fruit store, all of them. So we are trying. You are trying to do that. But like I said, I just want people to understand what the options are. They are limited at the moment. (01:22:22) And so we are going to try to do the best agreement that we can. Are there any Council members with questions? CM Thomas-Henry? (01:22:32) I am just thinking about the many shareholders on the back side of this building. So from a view perspective, what parts of their units are up against this? That is a very... (01:22:43) Good question, and I should have been better prepared for it. The building is shaped like a horseshoe and there is a large garden in the middle. So it is one leg of the horseshoe that faces the new development. On the other side they are facing Booth Street, and then on the other you have the... actually within the City... (01:23:06) Okay. But no idea approximately how many? I have not had that calculated and I am very sorry. No worries, I was just curious about that. And what — the two young ladies here, who are on that side — what part of your unit is obstructed by this development? (01:23:21) The bedroom, living room, everything. (01:23:24) Everything. You are all welcome to come... (01:23:30) And thank you. If I could estimate, less than a third, because it is three towers, and then that one tower — the side of that one tower is... (01:23:39) Facing — would be facing the new development. So the other two towers would not be, while all of their windows on this one side, so those... or they have... (01:23:47) Opposite that. I cannot tell you. I believe all the windows are on that side. (01:23:51) Okay. My windows face Queens Boulevard. Gotcha. Oh — kitchen, bedroom and living room. (01:23:57) Okay, thank you. (01:24:00) Are there any other Council members with questions? This panel is now excused. Thank you all for being here today and for your testimony. The next panel will hear from Sarah, Shane and Keats. You may begin. (01:24:42) My name is Sarah Penenberg and I am here today representing SEIU Local 32BJ. 32BJ is the largest union of property service workers in the country, representing over 175,000 members across 13 states. Tens of thousands of commercial property service workers, security officers and residential building staff in New York. 32BJ supports responsible developers who invest in communities where they build. The developer of this proposed project, Bennington Capital, has made a credible commitment to good jobs for workers who will permanently staff the building in the residential sector. Good jobs like these mean prevailing wage, meaningful benefits and a pathway to the middle class for local community members who tend to fill these positions. It is not just a job. We need more housing to be built in every neighborhood of New York City to ensure that working families are not displaced by dwindling supply and skyrocketing rents. The proposed development will include 398 residential units, roughly a hundred of which will be permanently affordable, restricted for low- to middle-income residents. As the cost of housing and living rises in New York, New Yorkers struggle to find their homes. It is important now more than ever to create affordable housing and good jobs and uphold industry standards in the City. For all of these reasons, 32BJ strongly supports the 112 Queens Boulevard project. Thank you for your time. (01:26:16) Thank you. You may begin. (01:26:19) Good afternoon everyone. My name is Dennis Seabridge. I am a Council representative with the New York City District Council of Carpenters. I am here today to express our support for the 112 Queens Boulevard proposal and to recognize the constructive dialog that has taken place throughout the process. This is the kind of responsible development we need in New York City. It will bring hundreds of new homes to Forest Hills, including permanent affordable housing, while revitalizing an underutilized site directly above the 67th Avenue subway station. It will also bring improvements to the surrounding streetscape and new opportunities for local retail. For us, responsible development is also about how a project is built and making sure that the people building it have the opportunity to earn good, family-sustaining careers. That is why I want to recognize Bennington Capital for the way they have engaged with us from the beginning. Our conversations have been open, respectful and productive. It has truly been a two-way street and there has been real progress working together towards responsible union carpentry on this project. We have made meaningful progress and we look forward to continuing those conversations and reaching an outcome that brings skilled union carpenters on the job. This is what responsible development should look like — investment in the community, quality housing and a commitment to the skilled workforce that helps make these projects possible. We appreciate Bennington Capital's willingness to work with us and we look forward to continuing this partnership and delivering a project that Forest Hills can be proud of. Thank you. (01:27:43) Thank you. You may begin. (01:27:44) Council members, my name is Shane Keats. I am a renter here in Queens and I am here to voice my support for this rezoning. When I moved to the City I could afford a one-bedroom on 18 bucks an hour. Yes, the bedroom was the size of a closet and maybe fit a single futon at best, but I did not need roommates. Fast forward to today — my daughter just put herself through carpentry school and I thought, this kid is a genius. A skilled trade that cannot be replaced by a computer or AI. But this summer she told me she is taking a job out of state. She loves what she does, she loves where she lives, but as a journeyman carpenter at not-union $25 an hour, she cannot afford to stay here and continue to build her life here. Look, as a kid I lived in New Jersey. I have seen what ugly looks like. I have seen a lot of strip malls. From what this development is going to look like, I see Queens, not New Jersey. And I get why some people oppose this — any change in a place that you love is hard. I love my neighborhood in part because it feels like I can touch the generations that have come before me. But I want my kid and her kid to be able to have that same experience. And along Queens Boulevard, the only way that can happen is if we let good apartment buildings go up where single-story retail exists today, even if that (01:29:12) means stores we love and have long relied upon have to relocate during construction. It seems a small price to pay to create new memories of cherished places for another generation of New Yorkers. Thanks for considering my comments. (01:29:26) Thank you. Are there any members that have questions for this panel? Being that there are no questions, this panel is excused. Thank you for being here. We also have Zach Miller online. Mr. Miller, you may begin. (01:29:49) Zach Miller, yeah. (01:29:55) You may begin, Zach. (01:30:00) Hi, my name is Zach Miller. I am a longtime Forest Hills resident. I grew up in Rego Park. I am raising my family in Forest Hills and I am very supportive of this project. I think this is the smart kind of development that the neighborhood needs to attract and maintain young families in Forest Hills, to be able to also live close to relatives and friends while also being cognizant of transportation needs and business concerns. This type of forward-thinking development... so just as a resident I wanted to come on and say that I am supportive of this. Thank you, Zach. (01:30:48) If there are any members of the public who wish to testify regarding this proposal remotely, please press the raised hand button now. If you are in person, please identify yourself to the Sergeant at Arms. This is the last call — 30 seconds. Being that there are no members of the public who wish to testify regarding the Preconsidered Land Use item relating to the 112 Queens Boulevard mixed-use residential rezoning proposal, that public hearing is now closed. Items are now laid over. On the Preconsidered hearing regarding the South Richmond Designated Open Space text amendment application by the administration — as the administration will explain, a special zoning district called the Special South Richmond Development District is mapped over the southern portion of Staten Island and is primarily located in Council District 51. In this special district, certain areas are designated as open space and cannot be developed. The present application is a corrective action stemming from the City of Yes text amendments, which adjusted the boundaries of these designated open spaces. For anyone wishing to testify regarding this proposal remotely, if you have not already done so, you must register online by visiting the Council's website at council.nyc.gov. Those with us in person, please see one of the Sergeants at Arms to submit a speaker card. If you would prefer to submit written testimony, you can do so by emailing landuse.testimony@council.nyc.gov. I will now call the applicant panel for this proposal, which consists of Carrie Bailey, Katie Ferreira and George Todorovic. Counsel, please administer the oath. (01:32:50) Thank you. Begin your testimony. You have 10 minutes but at eight minutes please start wrapping it up. Please restate your name and the name of the organization. You may begin. (01:33:00) Okay, great. My name is George Todorovic. I am the Deputy Director of the Staten Island Borough Office at the Department of City Planning and I am here with my colleagues. I am here because I was the project manager of the South Richmond zoning relief proposal that was adopted in 2023 by both the City Planning Commission and City Council. This project is an update to that proposal from 2023, specifically about designated open space, and my colleague Carrie is going to explain those rules, the background and the three specific sites for this project. (01:33:36) Good afternoon everyone. My name is Carrie Bailey. I am a planner at the Department of City Planning, Staten Island office. This is a public application from the New York City Department of City Planning and we are seeking a zoning text amendment to modify designated open space boundaries at three sites in the Special South Richmond Development District. Next slide please. Here you can see the three sites that are outlined, from left to right on the map. The first site is 181 Bayview Avenue, the second site is 381 Otis Avenue and the third site is a group of zoning lots... (01:34:20) along Otis Avenue. (01:34:21) This proposed text amendment is, as George said, a follow-up from the South Richmond... (01:34:29) zoning relief from 2023, and that text... (01:34:34) amendment provided zoning relief for small properties, and this proposed action will align with the goals of the special district by balancing development with natural feature preservation. Next slide please. Here is a little background on the history of designated open space. Designated open space was created in 1975 as part of... it was primarily mapped over public land such as parks or blue belts, but designated open space was also mapped over private property, both vacant parcels and those with existing structures. (01:35:11) It was also mapped on unimproved streets that are established on the City map as part of the capital plan for improvement. (01:35:22) And today, any privately owned zoning lot that contains designated open space requires City Planning Commission review. And even if not being... (01:35:34) disturbed or modified, a City Planning Commission certification is required to ensure it remains in its natural state. (01:35:43) If there are any minor site alterations or landscaping proposed within a designated open space, then an authorization is required. If designated open space boundaries are proposed to be modified, then a text amendment is required, (01:35:59) such as this application that you see today. (01:36:03) And the scope of most designated open space projects is limited to low-density single-family homes, due to the areas in which it has been mapped. Projects in designated open space range from minor site alterations for rear yard amenities like pools or patios, to modest home enlargements such as kitchen additions, to new developments for one home or dozens of homes and a brand new residential community. Next... (01:36:32) Slide please. Sure. So as we said, the South Richmond Zoning Relief proposal was adopted in 2023. The intent of CAESER, as we call it, was to provide zoning flexibility for small properties while maintaining the district goal of natural feature preservation on large properties over one acre in size. (01:36:52) A majority of the proposal was cleaning up outdated zoning regulations from 1975. As Karrie noted, this was the update since it had not been changed since then in 50 years. As you can see in thumbnail number four, CAESER included updates that do, among many other things in that proposal, digitizing the text maps, removing conflicts, things of that nature. Next slide. (01:37:16) Here is detailed information on the methodology from back then. (01:37:20) Updating the designated open space maps and why this application today seeks a minor follow-up to those adjustments. In 2023, the amendment aimed to clean up the maps from 1975 to address inconsistencies and unclear dimensions. For decades this made it difficult for property owners who came to our office to determine their boundaries. Therefore the boundaries were measured from the nearest street line, tax block, and it was digitized using ArcGIS mapping software. Another important update was to remove conflicts between the designated open space and built conditions. As illustrated through the example on the slide, you can see that over the years several property owners have approached our office to remove these conflicts. So this text amendment starts to pull back the boundaries where it was mapped on top of homes in 1975. This would allow for homeowners to do minor enlargements — kitchen additions, things that they should not need to go through a full use application for. It is important to note that this methodology only targeted people that... (01:38:28) ...had homes built before 1975, vested in the zoning. We did not include any vacant lots. The methodology did not include homes built after 1975 and it did not include large parcels that are natural for the environment. So that being said, several months after the adoption of the South Richmond amendment we were contacted by some property owners letting us know that they had identified an error. This prompted our office to go back and fact-check our methodology, and that was because the mapping of designated open space on private property was not supposed to increase. Therefore this proposed action is adjusting the boundaries on three sites, as Karrie noted, and we will just zoom into those very quickly on the next slides. Karrie? (01:39:17) Yes. So the first designated open space site is 181 Bayview Avenue. It is an interior zoning lot located at the intersection of Bayview Avenue and Excelsior Avenue. A comparison of the existing boundaries in red and the proposed boundaries in green — the designated open space boundary would shift north to more closely align with the conditions that existed before CAESER was passed in 2023, since the intent and goals of that text amendment did not contemplate increasing designated open space on a vacant site. The designated open space boundary will be moved 60 feet north to its original location before CAESER. Next slide please. (01:40:02) And the second site is 301 Arbutus Avenue. It is located a few hundred feet south of Highland Boulevard. This zoning lot was previously improved with a single-family home which was vested and built before designated open space regulations were mapped on top of this home in 1975. However the home has since been destroyed due to a fire and the site is currently vacant. So taking this site history into account, the existing designated open space boundary is proposed to be modified to remove a 60-foot by 90-foot area, which is shown here in the green circle, to allow for the previously existing structure to be replaced in kind. Next slide please. And this is the third and last designated open space site. It is on Notce Avenue. It includes a block of existing built townhomes. As a result of CAESER, the designated open space boundary was moved five feet closer to the street, which is shown here in red, and it removed the ability for modest as-of-right enlargements or expansions for dozens of homes on this block. So therefore the Department is proposing to reset this designated open space boundary back to its previous location in green and align it with the goals of home zoning relief for small properties. Next slide. (01:41:25) So this proposed text amendment also includes minor editorial changes in a couple of discrete places of Article X, Chapter 7 of the Zoning Resolution. The first is to remove outdated text from the text maps, which you can see crossed out here in red. That section references maps that are available to view in person at the Department of City Planning Staten Island Borough Office, but due to changes in document retention policy and modernized digitization... The second editorial change is within Zoning Resolution Section 107-260, which is a City Planning Commission authorization for future subdivision of certain plan review sites. There are two instances of this section that would be amended to remove a reference to site plan requirements and retain a reference to a required area plan. There is also a reference to an area of no disturbance that would be included at the end of this first finding that you see highlighted here in yellow. Next slide please. (01:42:36) So in summary, this New York City Department of City Planning zoning text amendment is seeking to modify both text maps and zoning text in Article X, Chapter 7 of the Zoning Resolution. The text maps would be modified to adjust designated open space boundaries across three sites and remove outdated text related to document storage and retention. Zoning Resolution Section 107-264 would be modified to clarify submission requirements, materials and findings. Thank you. This concludes the presentation and we are happy to answer questions. (01:43:10) Thank you so much. I have questions and we have CM Morano on the line with us as well who has questions. I understand that the text amendment mainly seeks to correct outdated or incorrect information regarding designated open spaces. What would happen if these corrections were not... (01:43:31) ...made? If the corrections were not made, site one would not be able to build a compliant home and would most likely need to go to the board for relief, which would be even more onerous and against the goals of the intended 2023 plan for homeowner relief to build housing. Site two would be able to build but not in the same footprint as the home that was destroyed. So since that home was destroyed in a fire and it did not come up in our database — since the database said there was no home — we talked with our counsel and they said we can introduce this at this time to allow it to be vested so the home can be replaced in kind. And the third site is a smaller consequence, I guess, for lack of a better word. It would prevent them from doing minor home enlargements, but it is not our intent to increase a restriction five feet into somebody's home. That was not the intent. So that is a minor cleanup. They might still be able to do some work on the front of the house, but still we want to correct the incorrect error we made in the 2023 proposal. (01:44:40) OK. And can you speak further as to how these corrective actions are consistent with the recently enacted South Richmond Zoning Relief text amendment? (01:44:49) Yes. So the text amendment from 2023 focused on homes that were built before 1975, because in 1975 any home that existed had this designated open space rule mapped upon it. For the past 50 years — I have only been there 10 years, but 40 before me and 10 while I have been there — our office has been asked, "Why do I have this map on my site?" And we said, well, now we have software to accurately map this, so we will clean this up. We got very close and there are three sites that we missed. Karrie sent a flyer with a QR code to the community board. We sent an interactive map. We said this is the last time we are going to do this — one more time to clean it up — and we found three sites out of, I think, 700. So I think it is pretty good, but I am not perfect and that is why we are fixing these last three. The connection to 1975 again is to help all the vested homes that were already existing that asked, "Why is this happening to me?" and to provide homeowner relief for modest home construction. (01:45:58) Thank you for that. CM Morano, I am sorry — can you hear me? Yes. Hello, Council Member. Thank you everybody. Thank you for the presentation and the leadership of this committee. Council Member, do you have questions for this panel? I do, I do. OK. So, you know, for people listening, I am CM Morano and this application involves properties within my district in the Special South Richmond Development District. (01:46:30) As I understand it, the purpose of this amendment, as the folks mentioned, is largely corrective. It seeks to address mapping and recordkeeping discrepancies involving designated open space and I am generally supportive of correcting errors that have created unnecessary complications for homeowners. But I also want to make sure that a technical correction does not unintentionally create new development rights or other consequences that were never intended. So the community board raised concerns that some properties could potentially be treated as qualifying sites under this proposal. Can you explain whether this amendment would cause any property to obtain qualifying site status that it does not have today and, if so, what additional development rights would come with that designation? (01:47:23) That is a great question and to your point we did... (01:47:25) ...discuss this with the community. We do have to admit that during referral there was some confusion and we did clean that up after the community board referral was submitted. So you might see a little discrepancy in the community board's referral based on incorrect information we had provided. But after confirming with our zoning division and also with our other internal divisions, none of these sites are qualifying residential sites. They cannot obtain any zoning bonuses or zoning relief from the qualifying residential site text. This would simply allow for the designated open space area to be carved out — the 60-foot dimension for site one that Karrie noted, the 50-by-90-foot volume that Karrie noted for site two, and the small five-foot dimension for site three. That would just allow the reorientation of the building. No additional FAR, no additional typology or heights. They would need to be on a wide street. You can ask DOT whether or not they are going to widen the street, but that is something outside of this application. (01:48:43) Thank you for that. You know, a lot of my constituents are concerned about some of the new zoning rules and we do not have to get into the merits of the City of Yes or the fast track or anything like that, but I can tell you there is a lot of concern about what that might mean for development in our community. So related to this — would this amendment increase what can be built on any affected property, whether through additional floor area, greater height, increased density, additional dwelling units or any other zoning benefit? No. No increased height. It would simply allow for the reorientation of buildings because now the property owner has more space to work with, but they are still limited to the same lot coverage, the same height restrictions, the same FAR. None of those change. It is more of a lateral correction that we are doing to provide flexibility, not anything related to volume or intensity. With respect to 181 Bayview Avenue, the materials indicate that the property owner is separately seeking a zoning certification to facilitate construction of a new single-family home. Is the proposed home otherwise consistent with the existing R3X zoning and is this amendment necessary to allow that home to be built? (01:50:05) Yes, it is consistent and it is necessary. Because if we did not pursue this text amendment, the property would be cramped — like 20 feet wide. They would not be able to comply with yard requirements. It would be extremely narrow, funny-looking. They would need to go to the board for additional relief. So this was actually the site that first informed us of the change in the map and we acknowledge that this is something that we did not intend in 2023. Wholeheartedly did not intend this. This was not supposed to happen, so we are correcting it. (01:50:40) Has the environmental review identified any potential impact on wetlands, trees, natural features, open space, drainage or other environmentally sensitive resources and, if so, what protections or mitigation measures are being required? (01:50:57) I do not know any specific impacts that have been identified. There were not any. I do not know of any potential ones, but I will say that based on the methodology at a comprehensive level there were not any specific impacts, because most of the designated open space areas were already on disturbed areas such as over top of building footprints. Again, if a home was built in 1975 and designated open space was on top of it... (01:51:30) ...that does not really align, so we removed it. Any designated open space area that does remain does have sensitive natural features, so there will be some adjacency buffers. But we kept it in the places that do have wetlands, that do have trees. So again we could look to the specifics of the actual document, but the designated open space was moved where it was on top of existing structures or on top of other structures such as — we saw some basketball courts, gazebos and swimming pools in people's backyards. (01:52:04) I also want to ask about... Sorry. Oh yes, Karrie, do you have a follow-up? (01:52:08) Thank you. I just want to add a little further context to George's response. I am the Director of the Department of City Planning Staten Island office. I would just note that designated open space itself is a zoning regulation. I would not define it as an environmental regulation. So there are still layers of regulatory protection on any existing wetlands by the Department of Environmental Conservation and other agencies. Parkland that overlaps with designated open space will continue to be parkland. So just to note that all of these protections very much still stay in place and are considered and analyzed if and when a home or any development is proposed adjacent to or within that buffer area by multiple agencies. (01:52:52) I also want to ask about the practical impact on homeowners. For a property where the correction effectively adds usable backyard area back to the property, could that change the property's assessed value or property tax bill and, if so, has anyone analyzed how significant that impact would be? (01:53:14) I do not know that we can independently answer that at this time, but we are happy to consult our resources and get back to you if an answer is necessary. (01:53:23) Council Member, I am going to ask you to wrap up your questions. OK. Finally, if these mapping corrections were not made, what would the practical consequence be for the affected homeowners? Would they continue to face restrictions or approval requirements based on boundaries that everyone now agrees are inaccurate? And more broadly, how does this amendment advance the original goals of the South Richmond Zoning Relief without weakening environmental protections that were intended to remain in place? (01:53:55) If retained, the homes would not be able to be enlarged or built. Site number one — not built at all. Site number two — not built at all. Site number three — not enlarged. So they would not be able to utilize their full property rights or development rights. Site number one might need to go to the board. Site number two would need to do a complete reorientation. Site number three again would be modest, but they would not be allowed to do kitchen additions or enlargements in the rear yard. To that extent, even if and when this is approved and adopted, they still need City Planning Commission approval because there will still be designated open space on the site, just less of it. So they will have flexibility again — laterally — to reorient their site design to a better extent for a more superior, or as we sometimes say, a better site plan. But they will still need additional review and the community board will get that review if and when that reoriented building footprint is proposed and developed. (01:54:58) Thank you for your work on this. Madam Chair, thank you for your patience. Thank you. (01:55:03) Council Member, do any members of the committee have questions for the applicants? Seeing none, this panel is now excused. Thank you so much for being here today. We appreciate your testimony. Counsel, are there any members of the public who wish to testify remotely or in person regarding this proposal? No, Madam Chair, we do not have anybody signed up online or in person. If there are any members of the public who wish to testify regarding this proposal remotely, please press the raise hand button now. Or if you are in person, please identify yourself to one of the sergeants at arms. This is the last call. 30 seconds. Being that there are no members of the public who wish to testify regarding this, the Preconsidered LU relating to the South Richmond Designated Open Space text amendment, the public hearing is now closed and these items are now laid over. Before we conclude today I just want to make a quick comment on the record regarding the Sojourner Truth – Mapes Rezoning that we voted on today. Excuse me, I do not... (01:56:01) And achieving the project at the requirements appropriate for his district. However, it is clear that the developer has not adequately engaged with the union in developing this proposal and as a committee we are left uncertain on what labor guarantees can be expected as a result of the new development being considered today. The current commitment as presented was insufficient to ensure that workers will be prioritized in the new development with the new needs that the building will bring. As the Council, our priority must be supporting both our residents and the workers who are on the front lines every day keeping our housing safe, maintained and secured. I strongly encourage Fetner Houses to make a clear commitment to uphold a fair contract as negotiations begin next year and to ensure that the needs of these workers are reflected in an expanded agreement covering both their existing properties and the new properties created through this rezoning. (01:57:09) Thank you so much. (01:57:12) CM Schulman: I want to — I am not going to repeat everything, but I echo her sentiments. Every development that I have had in my district has had the support of both the residents, the community and 32BJ. The unions need to have a voice in this and there seems to have been some inconsistency in terms of the back and forth here. But in terms of member deference, I did vote for the project but I do have major concerns, so I wanted that on the record. (01:57:42) Thank you so much, CM Schulman. That concludes today's business. I would like to thank the members of the public, my colleagues, Subcommittee counsel and staff.